Latest / The Vegan Report / A Fork in the Road: The Future of Animal Protection.
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:02and today we're going deeper into two controversial
- 0:06topics, the ineffectiveness of cage -free campaigns,
- 0:11and the embrace of factory farming 2 .0 by so
- 0:15-called animal rights activists. As a reminder,
- 0:19we previously covered these topics in episodes
- 0:22120 and 125, links in the episode notes. To discuss
- 0:28all of this, I'm joined by Anita Krajnik. Anita
- 0:31is the co -founder of the Plant -Based Treaty
- 0:34and the founder and executive director of the
- 0:37SAVE movement. She is currently leading the Beyond
- 0:40Cage Free initiative, an open letter that, and
- 0:44I quote, is calling on effective altruists to
- 0:48pivot their focus area and the AI Windfall funding
- 0:53away from Welfare's reforms towards plant -based
- 0:57initiatives that create, multiply your benefits
- 1:00for animals, climate, health, food security and
- 1:04reduced pandemic risk. I invite you to sign the
- 1:08Beyond Cage Free open letter. I signed that letter,
- 1:12not because I don't believe in evidence -based
- 1:15activism, quite the opposite. There is evidence
- 1:19that those campaigns are not helping anyone.
- 1:22Enough evidence to warrant putting a break. on
- 1:26the stream of millions funding this style of
- 1:28activism. In addition to discussing KH3 campaigns,
- 1:33we also tried to understand what is going on
- 1:37in the minds of activists in this movement who
- 1:40have chosen to pursue operating advanced forms
- 1:43of factory farms. And to help us better understand
- 1:47their thinking, Anita and I looked at an article
- 1:51written by Aiden Kankyoku and published on his
- 1:55substack, Saint Castles, titled There is a Path
- 1:58to Meat without Misery. The article has generated
- 2:03quite a bit of controversy. Anita and I do a
- 2:06good job of breaking it down and explaining the
- 2:09rationale behind it. If you're curious, you'll
- 2:13find a link to the article in the episode notes.
- 2:17But be careful, it's pretty stomach -turning.
- 2:20As always, share this episode with the vegans
- 2:22you know and let's get more people to sign the
- 2:25Beyond Cage Free Open Letter. Follow or subscribe
- 2:30for more thought -provoking conversations. Thank
- 2:33you so much for listening and for leaving a good
- 2:36review. It's always appreciated. Anita, welcome
- 2:39to The Vegan Report. Thank you so much for having
- 2:42accepted my invitation. Nice to be here, Ryan.
- 2:46I was truly looking forward to talking with you.
- 2:49because we're going through some strange times.
- 2:52In general, if I look at the news, it's worrisome
- 2:57in a strange way. We have AI and the race for
- 3:02super intelligence. We have all of those wars
- 3:05going on. We have talks of alien disclosure.
- 3:11And now I look at the animal rights movement
- 3:15and Wow. We have some so -called animal rights
- 3:19activists who want to run factory farms. And
- 3:24I feel more and more strange from our reality.
- 3:29Like, is this the Twilight Zone? Do you feel
- 3:34the same way? I think there is a strong plant
- 3:39-based movement. There's a strong animal rights
- 3:42movement. There's a strong climate movement,
- 3:45health. healthy diet movement. So I work in that
- 3:50space, so I see a lot of this. I think what's
- 3:55changed is the rise of AI. There's concerns about
- 4:00safety across the board. There is a lot of money
- 4:04coming from AI, no entropic in particular. And
- 4:09I think it's really important that we take a
- 4:14holistic approach and look at helping animals,
- 4:19but at the same time, thinking about how to transition
- 4:23to plant -based food systems, because that will
- 4:26also help reverse the climate emergency, the
- 4:31health crises, pandemic risk, and food security.
- 4:36So I think it's really important to have a systems
- 4:40perspective in times like this. Because otherwise
- 4:43it's hard to make sense of it because like there's
- 4:45so much so much going on and It's like we have
- 4:50a fork in the road. We either go down a path
- 4:53That these are all separate crises and we just
- 4:57make them all worse or we go down a different
- 5:00path where there there are solutions there are
- 5:05pathways we can go and improve things across
- 5:09the board and Animals are key on this planet
- 5:16in terms of how we treat them. We'll decide the
- 5:20future of life on the planet. So in my lifetime,
- 5:27I was born in the late 60s. In the earlier part
- 5:32of the decade, in 1960s, there were under 10
- 5:35billion farmed animals that were killed each
- 5:37year. Now it's over 90 billion. That's in in
- 5:43my lifetime and that's unacceptable and and and
- 5:46the the numbers keep going up so for me the key
- 5:50metric is the number of farmed animals and As
- 5:57those numbers go up the number of wild animals
- 6:00goes down The climate crisis gets worse. There
- 6:05are more pandemic risks. There's more use of
- 6:08antibiotics You know the vast majority 70 % or
- 6:12so and we're gonna get antimicrobial resistance
- 6:15and that's gonna be the number one killer by
- 6:182050 more so than cancer so like there is a fork
- 6:21in the road and The only the way to understand
- 6:25that fork in the road is by putting a different
- 6:28lens on it's by having a different worldview
- 6:31which is holistic ecological and in that worldview
- 6:38there are particular ideas or philosophies, interests
- 6:43and institutions that we have to look at. And
- 6:45that sort of is my background, it's political
- 6:47science and it's called the three I's, interests,
- 6:51sorry, ideas, interests and institutions. And
- 6:55if we get them wrong, we're gonna go down a bad
- 6:57pathway. If we get them right, we can have paradise
- 7:03on earth. We're blessed with nature, with so
- 7:07many wonderful things on this planet. And it's
- 7:11up to us, basically. I want to get back to factory
- 7:18farming 2 .0 and what it means. But first, let's
- 7:22talk about cage -free campaigns and basically
- 7:26the animal welfare crowd inside the animal rights
- 7:31movement or inside the animal protection movement
- 7:33to use more inclusive language. I did an episode
- 7:37on that called I think the cage -free gaslight
- 7:41and I learned a lot from having that conversation
- 7:46that the cage -free narrative was not as truthful
- 7:51as you would think that there are lots of considerations
- 7:55that we're not thinking about when deciding to
- 8:00support this. What made you launch your open
- 8:05letter and take a public stand against this cage
- 8:10-free push inside our movement. So in September
- 8:15of 2026, we launched the Beyond Cage -Free open
- 8:19letter. And I've always had issues with welfare
- 8:25in general, not just cage -free, because I helped
- 8:29start a group called Toronto Pig Save in 2010
- 8:34with my dog Mr. Bean and local activists. We
- 8:39witnessed transport trucks going to a slaughterhouse
- 8:42and the pigs would look out. It was an epiphany
- 8:45because I saw the pigs as individuals looking
- 8:48out scared, sad, and pleading for help. The first
- 8:54pig I looked at up close when I walked up to
- 8:58the truck, I promised the pig three vigils a
- 9:01week. in front of the slaughterhouse. And we
- 9:03kept that promise until that slaughterhouse in
- 9:05downtown Toronto went bankrupt. And so when we
- 9:08were doing this vigils, it was so clear that
- 9:12those pigs, those cows, those lambs, those turkeys,
- 9:16those rabbits, they're all equal. They're all
- 9:18equal to you. They're equal to your family dog,
- 9:22family cat. They're equal. And so it was never
- 9:27our group, Toronto Pig Save, then became Animal
- 9:30Save, never said eat less meat. It was just,
- 9:34it's impossible to say that when you're in front
- 9:35of a truck and you know, every single individual
- 9:37is just like you and that they have, they deserve
- 9:41rights, animal rights. And so I've come from
- 9:44that tradition where, you know, we're always
- 9:47calling for people to do the optimum, which is
- 9:53go vegan basically. And then we started Plant
- 9:56Based Treaty five years ago and we didn't call
- 10:00it the vegan treaty. We called it Plant Based
- 10:01Treaty because It's something that is more sellable
- 10:08in terms of trying to talk to counselors and
- 10:13institutions and so forth. And the call again
- 10:17was calling for the optimum, which is like we
- 10:21need to transition from animal agriculture to
- 10:24a plant -based food system so that we can live
- 10:27in a safe and just world. It benefits the climate
- 10:34and other planetary boundaries, but also humanitarian
- 10:36issues like food justice, food security and so
- 10:41forth. And so coming from that tradition, like
- 10:44always asking for the optimum and using not just
- 10:49utilitarianism, but deontology or the philosophy
- 10:53of duty and doing the right thing in the present,
- 10:57not just calculating what is the Great is good
- 10:59for the greatest number, but doing the right
- 11:01thing in the present. So coming from that tradition,
- 11:04I've always been critical of, or not accepting
- 11:07really, of welfare. I didn't think it was necessary
- 11:11and it slows things down. A lot of people have
- 11:13said, oh, it's a stepping stone. It's incremental
- 11:15change. Obviously, I don't want to see animals
- 11:20suffering, but it's not just about suffering,
- 11:24as utilitarians would say, and animal welfare.
- 11:27It's about exploitation. And if you apply the
- 11:31golden rule, you wouldn't want to be in that
- 11:34truck and you wouldn't want to be used or bred
- 11:38and killed in a killing facility. So that's where
- 11:45I come from. And so I've always been critical.
- 11:49But what changed this year was the realization
- 11:53that Anthropic was funding the animal philanthropies
- 12:00with hundreds of millions of dollars and potentially
- 12:02billions next year or over the next few years
- 12:06and that the funding seemed to go mainly to cage
- 12:11-free and Sorry welfare technology or welfare
- 12:17tech Sorry and then But some of it was going
- 12:25to alternative protein as well as it hopefully
- 12:28some of it was going to some plant -based initiatives.
- 12:32So I've learned that and then I learned about
- 12:34that recently because there was this summit in
- 12:37Toronto, which you went to as well, Ryan, the
- 12:39ABBA summit, the Animal Vegan Advocates Summit,
- 12:42which was held in Toronto for the first time
- 12:44in May. Usually it's in Washington and LA, but
- 12:48because of Trump and making the U .S. a very
- 12:52unwelcome place for people abroad, they've now
- 12:55moved it to Toronto and it's going to be in Mexico
- 12:56City next year. So anyways, at that summit, Tracy
- 13:00Ryman, who's the new head of PETA, People for
- 13:05the Ethical Treatment of Animals, gave a talk
- 13:06on humane washing. And they also were distributing
- 13:13their white paper on the failure of cage -free
- 13:16housing systems to reduce overall hand suffering.
- 13:21So in this white paper, which is about 40 pages
- 13:25and has like almost 200 footnotes, PETA, which
- 13:31used to be supportive of various welfare approaches,
- 13:34including cage -free, changed its mind and is
- 13:37now opposed to it because they do not believe
- 13:39it reduces overall, hence suffering. That's even
- 13:41in the framework of utilitarianism, just talking
- 13:44about suffering, not exploitation. Because they
- 13:48found that on some level, nobody wants to be
- 13:51in a battered cage. And it does seem at first
- 13:54glance that it's much better to be cage -free.
- 14:00But it is on certain levels, like being able
- 14:03to turn around, spread your wings, nest. So you
- 14:06have some natural behaviors. But what PETA found
- 14:08was that in some areas, it's the same, like whether
- 14:11it's just forcing chickens' hands to lay that
- 14:16many eggs, like 300, it's completely unnatural.
- 14:19Like in wild, you'd be 20 eggs. It's the calling
- 14:24of the male, or the killing, rather, of the male
- 14:26chicks, of the... The forced malting and the
- 14:31lighting and there's just so many atrocities
- 14:33that happen But then in some ways it was worse
- 14:35such as the dust levels are 10 to 15 times large
- 14:38more more so and there's Injurious pecking there's
- 14:45cannibalism more cannibalism The keel bones the
- 14:49keel bone on hands tends to be fractured at 80
- 14:52% 85 % in the cage free so And there's more fungal
- 14:59disease. And these facilities are more likely
- 15:03to catch fire, in which case the entire barn
- 15:05burns down. So when you look at an overall welfare,
- 15:11it's not really improved. And then when you compare
- 15:16that to plant -based, there's no comparison.
- 15:18Why not just promote plant -based food transition,
- 15:22not just for the welfare of the hens? but for
- 15:26the rights of the hens, so they're not exploited,
- 15:28but also for the climate, for reducing pandemic
- 15:31risk, for improving people's health. People who
- 15:35eat an average of half an egg, it's in our report,
- 15:38each day they increase their chance of heart
- 15:41disease by six or eight percent, something like
- 15:44that. So we had a Dr. Zarka Sam contribute that
- 15:49part of it. She heads Plant -Based Canada. you
- 15:53know, there's food insecurity issues, there's
- 15:58issues of more fresh water use, greater greenhouse
- 16:02gas emissions, acidification, eutrophication.
- 16:05And on top of that, in our open letter, we note
- 16:09that in the UK egg industry study, which came
- 16:13out in July of 2026, they found that moving from
- 16:18battery cages to cage -free would require 1 .6
- 16:21million extra hens per year to produce the same
- 16:26number of eggs because the eggs get damaged and
- 16:29in the cage free. So you're actually introducing
- 16:33more hens into the system. So from our perspective,
- 16:37effective altruism and other sort of funding
- 16:46communities need to change the metric to the
- 16:49number of animals in the system because we got
- 16:51to stop breeding and killing and slaughtering
- 16:57farmed animals. And as I said at the start of
- 17:00this, it was below 10 billion land animals a
- 17:04year in the 1960s. And now it's over 90 billion
- 17:08in the 2020s. And we're seeing the consequences
- 17:14for the animals, for the environment, for health,
- 17:18for food insecurity, for pandemic risk. So that's
- 17:22why the starting point at this fork in the road
- 17:26needs to be worldview. We need a paradigm shift.
- 17:33For decades, people have been calling for this
- 17:35paradigm shift. There was this famous book called
- 17:37Turning Point by Fridjoff Capra, and it was made
- 17:41into a movie called Mind Walk with Liv Ullman,
- 17:45just a great actress, and Sam Waterston. So I
- 17:50strongly recommend this beautiful film called
- 17:52Mind Walk. but it's based on the book, you know,
- 17:55for Jeff Caffer's turning point. There've been
- 17:58so many thinkers like that in environmental studies,
- 18:02environmental thought. I used to be a teaching
- 18:04assistant for my favorite prof, Russ Holden.
- 18:07He taught a course on environmental thought.
- 18:09There were books like... Sorry, I'm just trying
- 18:17to think of this book that I really like, but
- 18:19basically it's about worldviews, like, you know,
- 18:21sort of like... Just sort of... Changing the
- 18:27worldview from Cartesian mechanistic reductionist
- 18:31thought to something that's more holistic and
- 18:37ecological systems thinking. So, you know, in
- 18:41environmental thought there is a long tradition
- 18:43of trying to encourage people to change that
- 18:47worldview. And yeah, the title of the book that
- 18:48I was wanting to get was called The Re -enchantment
- 18:52of the World. by Morris Berman. It's absolutely
- 18:55a beautiful book. I think he might be from Montreal,
- 18:57where you're from. I think he was a professor
- 18:59at McGill. But yeah. Yep, here it is. Morris
- 19:05Berman is assistant professor in the program
- 19:07in science and human affairs at Concordia University,
- 19:10Montreal. But it's just a beautiful book and
- 19:13environmental thought about how at one time in
- 19:16human history, it was Mother Earth. There were
- 19:20certain worldviews that sort of had a lot of
- 19:24deep respect for the role of women and men, like
- 19:30just it was much more egalitarian. It was respect
- 19:33for nature and not seeing humans as separate
- 19:38from nature and superior to nature. So there's
- 19:41this long tradition and stories saying that is
- 19:44one of the root causes of where we are. You know
- 19:47how there's a lot of thinking about, oh, let's
- 19:48do nudge strategies. It's not enough. Nudge is
- 19:51great. Plant -based by default is great, but
- 19:55it's not enough. We also have to change our worldview.
- 19:58And we need much bigger changes if we're going
- 20:02to get to where we need to go to stop the climate
- 20:05emergency and the other emergencies which we're
- 20:08facing this century. How do you think the animal
- 20:14welfareists, the effective altruist crowd has
- 20:18welcomed that white paper? Because I look at
- 20:21the timeline and I see when that presentation
- 20:24was given. There is now like millions of dollars
- 20:29worth grant from the Animal Welfare Fund looking
- 20:33for new cage -free campaign projects to fund.
- 20:40I look at various events, cage -free events where
- 20:44people proudly take pictures supporting this
- 20:49campaign. And it feels like those people are
- 20:53in complete denial of all of that discussion.
- 20:58And I wonder because I did not confront any of
- 21:02them. I know a few of them, but I did not confront
- 21:05them with what do you make of that white paper.
- 21:08But have you had that interaction? So I think,
- 21:13yes, I've been talking to a lot of people about
- 21:15the white paper because I went to the talk by
- 21:18Tracy Ryman of PETA. And I didn't know about
- 21:23the white paper until I went to the ABBA summit
- 21:26in Toronto. And I was very impressed by Tracy
- 21:29Ryman's talk. It was beautiful. It was like in
- 21:33terms of showing who hens are as individuals,
- 21:36as mothers in a natural setting, and then just
- 21:39showing their incredible suffering and exploitation
- 21:45in animal, sorry, whether they're cage or cage
- 21:50-free. And the paper came out in January 2026,
- 21:56and it's less than a year, and I think now there's
- 21:59more and more interest in it. So sometimes it
- 22:02takes a little bit of time, but I think we also
- 22:09have to make it simpler. Like I said, it's 40
- 22:11pages, 200 footnotes. So what we did in our...
- 22:15beyond cage -free open letter is we put it into
- 22:20a chart form to simplify it. And so you can read
- 22:22it in like less than a minute by just looking
- 22:24at the chart. So I think it needs more infographics.
- 22:30There needs to be more talks about it. I think
- 22:36like Tolstoy, one of my favorite authors, he
- 22:39would say for some big issues like this, you
- 22:42either get it or you don't. And I remember when
- 22:45I was an omnivore, I thought I was a good person.
- 22:50I liked animals, but for some reason I never
- 22:52thought about food. And it was only in university
- 22:57where when I saw a movie, the animals film, that
- 23:00I changed and I became vegetarian in the 90s.
- 23:04And I think a topic like climate change, unfortunately
- 23:10it's not on the radar of Like the effect of altruism
- 23:15community at least as we see in the EA forum
- 23:18or coefficient giving because it wasn't one of
- 23:20the priority areas So it was like animal welfare
- 23:23health, you know might be might be some, you
- 23:25know, maybe it's security You know things like
- 23:28that AI security and things like that, but or
- 23:31safety rather But if climate change is not part
- 23:35of your sort of a daily Data or information that
- 23:41you're getting it's so easy It's so easy to treat
- 23:44it like an externality. And so we want to change
- 23:49that. And so we're calling for a holistic systems
- 23:53perspective where you do think of all these different
- 23:57items. And it is part of your daily concerns.
- 24:01And what's remarkable is they all have the same
- 24:04solution, which is switch from eating animals
- 24:08to a plant -based food system and diet change.
- 24:13So that's how I see it. I just see it as like,
- 24:17we'll get there. It's just like, just we need
- 24:20to do better at getting the information out.
- 24:22I think just a lot of people simply do not think
- 24:24about it. I mean, until PETA did this study,
- 24:28unless you were really deep into this issue,
- 24:31you wouldn't be thinking about, oh, this welfare
- 24:34is traded for this other welfare. You might improve
- 24:38one thing and make other things worse. I think
- 24:39most people never thought about that at all.
- 24:41And so PETA has introduced that in January. They
- 24:44published this. And it's a big contribution.
- 24:50I mean, there were some studies like that already
- 24:52suggesting it, but it wasn't popularized. But
- 24:54when one of the largest and oldest animal groups,
- 25:00in particular an animal rights group like PETA,
- 25:02takes a stand, it's really important for the
- 25:06movement. And I know the initial reaction was
- 25:10maybe ignore it, move on. But I think once people
- 25:14learn about it around the world, from India to
- 25:18Latin America to North America, I think once
- 25:21people learn about it, it's quite impressive.
- 25:28And some people will still try to argue that,
- 25:31oh, this one welfare measure, cage -free, is
- 25:35something really worth backing. But I don't agree.
- 25:39I think We need to pivot. We're facing an animal
- 25:43emergency, but we're also facing a climate emergency.
- 25:46And we really need to take a systems perspective
- 25:48and just go full on, make the main priority a
- 25:55plant -based food system. But I also see other
- 25:58barriers that we can talk about. I think it's
- 26:03a question of getting this information out, but
- 26:05I also see barriers with respect to In political
- 26:08science, we call it the three I's, you know,
- 26:10ideas, interests and institutions. And, you know,
- 26:13happy to talk about that as well, because I think
- 26:14that's a further reason why we're not seeing
- 26:19us just like race, you know, towards that pathway
- 26:26that is like plant -based food systems, which
- 26:29is like such a win -win across the board. It's
- 26:31like, why wouldn't we do it? I think the explanation
- 26:34has to do with the three I's. also bring up the
- 26:39ego question, because PETA was brave to publish
- 26:44that paper. They used to support the KH3 campaigns.
- 26:49And so by publishing this paper, they admit that
- 26:52they were wrong. And that's something humans
- 26:56don't like to do. And there are some activists
- 27:00who devoted their entire activism pushing to
- 27:06implement cage -free policies. So much money
- 27:11was spent on those campaigns from funders. Like
- 27:19those all of that big crowd needs to now confront
- 27:23the fact that those actions were kind of wrong
- 27:28and they should now admit that this was not effective
- 27:35at progressing the agenda. And so yeah, ego,
- 27:40I think, is playing a big role here, no? I think,
- 27:45again, like I said, the story about when I was
- 27:47an omnivore, I was worried about the Cold War.
- 27:50I thought I was a good person. But then I found
- 27:53out about how animals are treated. I couldn't
- 27:55believe it. So I think it's like, did I reflect?
- 27:58I regret that until my early 20s, I was an omnivore.
- 28:02I really regret that. I don't focus too much
- 28:06on that. I focus on, OK, what am I going to do
- 28:08now? What's the most I can do? And I think that's
- 28:11the same in this situation. Yes, there are some
- 28:15costs. People have been working hard on cage
- 28:18-free with good intentions. And OK, well, maybe
- 28:23if we take a holistic systems perspective, it's
- 28:27not helpful. And maybe it's not helpful if you
- 28:31Even in taking a utilitarian world philosophy,
- 28:35it's not helpful according to the PETA paper,
- 28:37which came out in January. And it's also not
- 28:39helpful if you take an animal rights perspective.
- 28:41You're talking about exploitation of animals.
- 28:44But then when you take the climate, health, food
- 28:46insecurity, pandemic risk, water use, acidification,
- 28:52eutrophication, all these different issues, it's
- 28:55not a winning solution. It's a lose, lose, lose,
- 28:57lose, lose approach. Um, but then again, you
- 29:02know, like I said, I was, you know, we all made
- 29:04mistakes in the past. And, uh, once we learned
- 29:08new information, how do we switch? We don't tend
- 29:11to focus too much. Okay. I was really, really
- 29:13made bad decisions, you know, for 20 odd, 22
- 29:17odd years in my case, being an omnivore. Um,
- 29:20you, I mean, I, I regret it. I deeply regret
- 29:23it. I'm remorseful that I've caused so much death
- 29:26and suffering. But my focus is just like, okay,
- 29:30what can I do now? How can I change things? And
- 29:34I think that's what we're asking for. When we
- 29:37launched this Beyond Cage Free open letter, that's
- 29:40what we're focusing on. We're saying, hey, pivot.
- 29:43Let's pivot now. If you take a holistic lens,
- 29:46and that's not easy. This is not just our movement,
- 29:50not just the animal protection movement. You
- 29:52can go to the environmental movement. They don't
- 29:53take a holistic perspective. That's why they
- 29:55don't focus on food enough. So, it's just across
- 29:58the board we have this tendency to not use complex
- 30:05systems perspective or thinking. But there's
- 30:13a history of that, as I said, and some current
- 30:15work on it that's really important. And there's
- 30:20a lot of academics and journalists who are trying
- 30:23to... get people to take a holistic perspective.
- 30:27I'll give you an example. Kate Raworth, she's
- 30:29an Oxford economist and she used to work for
- 30:33the UN development program and then Oxfam for
- 30:36more than a decade. And she wrote a famous book
- 30:39called Donut Economics in 2017. She's now vegan.
- 30:44She recently turned vegan. She says that you
- 30:48need to, in a donut, she's trying to challenge
- 30:52neoclassical economics, which is like endless
- 30:57growth. So she said, no, you need a donut, you
- 30:59need a circular economy. And on the outside,
- 31:02the ceiling is the planetary boundaries like
- 31:04climate change, biodiversity, land use, acidification,
- 31:10the ozone layer, phosphorus and nitrogen, like
- 31:16new chemicals, like, you know, plastics and micro
- 31:19things like that. And then also I think it's
- 31:22aerosols might be another one. But anyways, there's
- 31:24nine planetary boundaries. And that's basically
- 31:26Johan Rockström's work from Sweden. And he's
- 31:28currently at the Potsdam Institute. But on the
- 31:31inside, you have the UN Sustainable Development
- 31:32Goals. And then in the center of the donut is
- 31:34the green zone. That's like the safe and just
- 31:36zone. So she has a whole chapter in her book
- 31:39on systems thinking. And it's fascinating. It's
- 31:42about how do you balance this drive for efficiency
- 31:46with retaining diversity? And so, in the EA community,
- 31:54it's too simplistic. It's all about efficiency,
- 31:56but that's not how you have a resilient food
- 32:01system or ecosystem either. And then there's
- 32:05another book by George Monbiot called Regenesis.
- 32:11And chapter two is on systems. The first chapter
- 32:14is on soil and then the second chapter. It's
- 32:16a really beautiful book. The whole book is about
- 32:18changing our food system to plant -based. and
- 32:21he's also vegan. And he was the first person
- 32:24to, like in the special comments on the support
- 32:26for PETA's paper, he was the first, well, no,
- 32:29he's not the first person, it's Dr. Crystal Heath,
- 32:31but he's certainly listed here. He's at the bottom
- 32:33here of the first page. It says, there is simply
- 32:39no good way of supplying people with eggs. The
- 32:42welfare and environmental impacts are enormous.
- 32:45However, the chickens are housed. As this crucial
- 32:49report shows, We just need to stop. So that's
- 32:53his quote. But he writes for The Guardian. He's
- 32:57written many books. And he has a really beautiful
- 32:59book called Regenesis. And there's a whole chapter
- 33:02on systems thinking. And he talks about the standard
- 33:05American diet, SAD. The acronyms are SAD. And
- 33:10how there's the spread of the standard global
- 33:13farm, which is factory farming, spreading around
- 33:15the world, and how it's making our food system
- 33:17less resilient. And he says the population crisis
- 33:20is not humans, which apparently the growth rate
- 33:23now is 1 .05, whereas the population growth rate
- 33:29of farmed animals is over 2%. So he goes, that's
- 33:32the biggest part. That's why I started our conversation
- 33:36saying the key metric is the number of animals
- 33:38in the system. And it's not just growing because
- 33:42there are more people on the planet. Even per
- 33:44capita, it's growing. between the 1980s and 2020s,
- 33:50it grew 50 % from 30 kilograms per person per
- 33:54year to 45 kilograms per person per year. That's
- 33:57devastating for the animals. And for both farmed
- 34:02animals and wildlife, because the more farmed
- 34:05animals you have, the more land use there is
- 34:08for animal feed and the less wildlife you have.
- 34:11So we've had a devastating impact on this planet.
- 34:15See, that's why you need a holistic perspective.
- 34:18You can't just talk about, oh, the number of
- 34:19hens that are cage -free and you're sparing them
- 34:21from cages. No, you have to talk about how the
- 34:24Amazon is being cut down for animal feed to feed
- 34:29chickens in Europe and China. That's why you
- 34:33need a holistic perspective. You have to take
- 34:34all of that into account. And when you do, it's
- 34:39obvious that the right answer is let's fight
- 34:42really hard for a plant -based food chain. system
- 34:45transformation, let's have a just transition
- 34:48for workers because the fossil fuel campaigners,
- 34:53the anti -fossil fuel campaigners, they're already,
- 34:55they're way ahead of us, the animal movement.
- 34:58And that's why I think effective altruist community,
- 35:01coefficient giving, all these, they need to include
- 35:04climate change as one of their areas that they
- 35:09support action on and that they need to talk
- 35:12about food and climate. and food and health and
- 35:14food and pandemic risk. So anyway, so that's
- 35:17that's where I'm coming from. So I'm not I'm
- 35:19not that critical. I have no anger. I have no
- 35:21I just see this as, you know, it's not on people's
- 35:24radars for various reasons. And it's our job
- 35:27to get it on the radar. But then we also have
- 35:29to deal with these three eyes like we got to
- 35:32change the philosophy. It can't just be utilitarian.
- 35:35It has to be deontology and systems thinking.
- 35:37We have to change. We have to address the interests.
- 35:40You know, we're dealing with these big AI companies,
- 35:44and they have an interest in creating a worker
- 35:45-free workforce and to work with big egg like
- 35:49Cargill, which is already mechanizing the killing
- 35:54at slaughterhouses. So there is this interest
- 35:57there that we have to address and say, look,
- 35:59to anthropic and open AI, we have a bigger interest
- 36:02here, which is the survival of life on the planet,
- 36:07not killing animals, not destroying our climate,
- 36:11not using up our fresh water use for meat, dairy
- 36:14and eggs. So we have to sort of address those
- 36:17interests. And the way to address those interests
- 36:20is through organizing and bringing groups from
- 36:24different sectors together and creating a big
- 36:26tent. So of animal protection, climate groups,
- 36:29health groups, and that's what we're trying to
- 36:31do with this open letter. Let's talk about factory
- 36:36farming 2 .0 now. I did an episode on that with
- 36:41Sam Tucker Davis. He wrote a piece about it.
- 36:45You are on Substack now too. Is it recent? Yeah,
- 36:50I just got on it because of all this issue. Amazing.
- 36:54I need to subscribe. Your first post was first
- 36:56article was very interesting. But for him, this
- 37:00whole push for factory farming 2 .0 in this phenomenon
- 37:04of animal rights activists deciding to run factory
- 37:10farms is the product of defeatism in the animal
- 37:15protection movement. We don't believe that we
- 37:19can win, we don't believe that we can transition
- 37:22the food system to a plant -based model and so
- 37:27basically we joined the enemy in an effort to
- 37:31change the enemy from inside, incrementally of
- 37:35course, just on the margins. I guess my first
- 37:38question for you about that is what do you make
- 37:41of that defeatist attitude. I think it comes
- 37:48from the three I. So I'll give you an example.
- 37:51So it's in the interest of companies like Anthropic
- 37:55and OpenAI to work with Big Ag and try to create
- 38:04robots and machines that breed, confine, feed,
- 38:08and kill animals. It's a business and they could
- 38:13create a worker -free workforce in factory farms
- 38:17and slaughterhouses. And there's a lot of money
- 38:20coming from that industry. And there's also this
- 38:24ideology or philosophy of utilitarianism which
- 38:28focuses on welfare. So why not talk about welfare
- 38:32tech and cage -free and welfare measures in factory
- 38:39farms and slaughterhouses? Why not talk about
- 38:43shrimp welfare, better stunning methods and even
- 38:45pay for them, as you said, or fish stunning.
- 38:51It's coming from an industry where that's what
- 38:53they know and that's where the business is. There's
- 38:57these ideas that are limiting, like utilitarianism,
- 39:01these interests where we have an oligarchy, just
- 39:05a few companies that are massive. are working
- 39:11with other big industry. And then we have institutions
- 39:17that are separate, disaggregated. We don't have
- 39:21holistic thinking, you know, with cross -sectoral
- 39:24departments all concerned about, oh, let's talk
- 39:27about climate, animals, let's talk about everything.
- 39:30So we don't have that. So the three I's facilitate
- 39:34and enable that kind of defeatist thinking. If
- 39:41you took all those things away and the hundreds
- 39:46of millions and billions of dollars that's about
- 39:48to enter philanthropy came from a lentil company
- 39:51or a bean company or an avocado company or a
- 39:55bread company, it would be very easy to talk
- 40:00about plant -based food transition. So I always
- 40:05look at it as what's the most obvious and rational
- 40:08thing to do won't necessarily happen. until you
- 40:11address the barriers, the systems barriers, the
- 40:16thinking barriers, the institutional barriers.
- 40:19So in political science, we call those the three
- 40:21I's, ideas, interests, and institutions. Often,
- 40:24ideas are not enough. For a lot of us, ideas
- 40:27are enough. We might have strong ideas about
- 40:29animal rights, and that's enough to determine
- 40:30our attitudes and behavior. But for a lot of
- 40:34people, it might be interests. A lot of people
- 40:37think that's probably one of the most important
- 40:39things. But in the Western tradition, Institutions
- 40:42are important. For people that believe in democracy,
- 40:44the rule of law, those are institutions. For
- 40:46somebody like Trump, he's just very self -interested,
- 40:51where it's just very transactional. So that's
- 40:56in the worst. That's very psychopathic and sociopathic.
- 41:00But just generally, for most people, there's
- 41:04incentives that come from a system or interests.
- 41:09So I'm just trying to be... honest and open and
- 41:12having conversations with coefficient giving
- 41:14or, you know, not that I've had conversations
- 41:17with Anthropic yet, but I just would want a very
- 41:19open discussion saying, look, at the end of the
- 41:22day, the most important interest we have here
- 41:25is not money or gold or anything like that. It's,
- 41:29you know, a safe and just planet. And if you
- 41:37have a philosophy with that interest, that respects
- 41:42life or that respects rights, then that would
- 41:48also influence how they see things. And then
- 41:50there's also institutions, and I'm calling for
- 41:52cross -sectoral institutions where we bring together
- 41:56animal protection people, climate scientists,
- 41:59health professionals, pandemic experts, food
- 42:02security experts, and things like that. But most
- 42:05people have no idea how threatened we are by
- 42:08climate change. and food insecurity. And so I
- 42:13beg people to please go to our Beyond Cage Free
- 42:18website and not only read the open letter, which
- 42:22is very long, but we have much longer report.
- 42:27And it shows you in depth how threatened we are,
- 42:33like our climate niche, where we can live. that
- 42:37doesn't seem like the Sahara Desert, like average
- 42:41temperature above 28 degrees Celsius, is going
- 42:45to shrink as the climate warms. And there could
- 42:48be billions of climate refugees or migrants this
- 42:53century if we can continue this warming. And
- 42:56we could cross tipping points, like we could
- 42:59lose the Amazon rainforest. We're likely to lose
- 43:02coral reefs. How tragic is that? We're likely
- 43:06to use glaciers, the West Antarctic ice sheet,
- 43:10the Greenland ice sheet. It's just like, if we
- 43:14warm a lot, we're going to cross more and more
- 43:16tipping points. And so how do we make this part
- 43:19of the daily conversation? The only way to do
- 43:22it is to have a, you know, a, you know, a holistic
- 43:26systems thinking and bring people together and
- 43:29have this, this worldview. And so when you look
- 43:32at our beyond cage -free open letter, it's very
- 43:35ambitious. It looks at all these different factors
- 43:38and makes the case. And it's new for a lot of
- 43:41people. It might be a little uncomfortable for
- 43:43people to see. I posted on the EA forum, but
- 43:45I posted a lot about climate. So I talked about
- 43:48the animal and climate emergencies, because we're
- 43:50trying to introduce people to think about these
- 43:53things. Because if you don't, it's just simply
- 43:56not part of your reality. It's an externality.
- 43:58Like when I was an omnivore and thought I was
- 44:00a good person, I never ever thought about, oh,
- 44:03where's the chicken or what I thought back then
- 44:06was beef rather than cow flesh. I just thought,
- 44:08oh, I'm a good person because I'm making steak
- 44:10for my mom who's working at a warehouse. And
- 44:14I thought, oh, I'm such a good person. I'm making
- 44:16dinner for everyone. So it was completely not
- 44:20part of my thinking. And I think the same thing
- 44:23is happening here. People are just not It's just
- 44:28not part of it. They're not just not even thinking
- 44:30about it. It's completely outside the radar.
- 44:32So that's what we're trying to do. So there's
- 44:34no judgment here. There's no anger. As I said,
- 44:38there's no pointing fingers. It's just like,
- 44:41we're just trying to help people do the right
- 44:44thing, which is in all of our ultimate interests
- 44:46and our deepest interests. And that's what our
- 44:50project is. When I try to understand what's going
- 44:55on in the minds of people who are pushing that
- 44:59new model. I can't help but think about the article
- 45:07that was written by the Sandcastle person. I
- 45:11think his name is Aidan. I don't remember the
- 45:14title exactly. I think it was Meet Without Misery,
- 45:18the title of that article. And he goes into basically
- 45:22the rationalization of that, of adopting those
- 45:26new Welfare is technologies at what degree? And
- 45:31he goes very far with that. And basically why
- 45:36we should call it a day as an animal rights activist
- 45:40and concede to the industry and just lean in
- 45:45into this new farming 2 .0 reality. And when
- 45:51I read the piece, I can't help but feel disgusted.
- 45:55I can't help but think those people went too
- 46:00far like they're off the wagon like it's over
- 46:04we can't really reach them anymore because they
- 46:09are very radical and ideologue in the way they
- 46:13have framed this issue and that's kind of a mind
- 46:17prison hard to get to escape that one reader
- 46:23of that article said this was a thought -provoking
- 46:26piece What's a euphemism? I think it's not thought
- 46:30provoking. I think it's confusing. And I think
- 46:33that's what it does. It confuses your sense of
- 46:38reality, your rational thinking, your moral compass.
- 46:44Yeah, it's hard to have another reaction than
- 46:48let's just excise that part of the movement.
- 46:55and let's just do things our own way, because
- 47:00we can't reach them. But do you still have hope
- 47:03to reach people like this Aiden fellow? Yeah,
- 47:09I do. I know Aiden. I've met him as part of the
- 47:13Direct Action Everywhere actions a few years
- 47:15ago. And he was part of... I think he's been
- 47:20in different movements. He's part of some large
- 47:25group now. or something. But anyway, I looked
- 47:30at that piece and I took it very seriously. I
- 47:33spent hours reading it and taking notes. And
- 47:38when I read it, I read it from a class perspective.
- 47:44So a lot of his calls to action were about helping
- 47:50AI companies do their business with Big Ag. So
- 47:55once you see it from that perspective it actually
- 47:57makes sense You know If you don't analyze it
- 48:04from say a class analysis It just it seems like
- 48:10oh is this person psychopathic is this person
- 48:12is this arbitrary? He's just saying shock things
- 48:15and just trying to mess with your mind or you
- 48:18know No, it actually made a lot of sense to me
- 48:20when I was reading it It was like there's a ton
- 48:24of money coming, and Anthropic is strongly connected
- 48:30to some of the biggest animal welfare philanthropies
- 48:35and started by some of the people that are now
- 48:38in Anthropic. So if you're in AI, you're trying
- 48:44to think, okay, look, this is the field I work
- 48:46in. We're working with Big Ag. How do we make
- 48:49it better? How do I apply what I know in AI?
- 48:53You know, what can I do? Oh, you know, maybe
- 48:54we can have welfare technology. Maybe we can,
- 49:00you know, improve the stunning methods. Why would
- 49:03you talk about plant -based food or farmers markets
- 49:06or, you know, societies that are mostly plant
- 49:10-based, but they're being, there's astroturf
- 49:13operations by Cargill. No, you in fact want to
- 49:16work with Cargill. The guy who started Mercy
- 49:17for Animals is now with the Spring Innovation
- 49:21Fund, heading that. And no, on his website, he
- 49:24puts Cargill. There's nowhere on the website
- 49:26that says plant -based food transformation, because
- 49:28there's loads of money there. And there's people
- 49:34in that group that also were part of alternative
- 49:38plant protein. But no, they don't think the money's
- 49:40there. They're making this decision saying, no,
- 49:42there's more money here. So they're going here.
- 49:45So if you look at it from a class perspective,
- 49:51Some people have made the decision like, let's
- 49:53just work with that. But if you take all that
- 49:58away and it was a bread company or a bean company
- 50:02that had the money, this would not be the conversation.
- 50:06Aidan would be writing a different paper. He
- 50:08would be writing a paper about, we really need
- 50:11to change our protein from meat, dairy and eggs
- 50:15to beans and lentils and seeds. He would write
- 50:18a completely different paper. But he's succumbed
- 50:23to this powerful force of interests. And it's
- 50:30also monopoly or even oligarchy interest. There's
- 50:34a lot of pressure on these companies. There might
- 50:37be amazing people working at these companies,
- 50:39but there's pressure on them to not go bankrupt,
- 50:43to understand how many hundreds of millions they
- 50:45have to invest in data centers. They need to
- 50:49prove themselves that they can create a worker
- 50:50-free workforce, which doesn't necessarily benefit
- 50:52us, but that's how they can argue that their
- 50:57companies are valuable. And where are you going
- 51:00to do it? Are animals going to resist and fight
- 51:05back when you create machines and robots? Which
- 51:11human being would want to be bred, confined,
- 51:15fed, and killed by... machines and robots. This
- 51:20is a total dystopia. And that's why we have to
- 51:24step back. And again, look at the three I's,
- 51:28look at interest, look at ideas, because ideas
- 51:30facilitate this. Utilitarianism makes it easier
- 51:34to have these bad ideas. And when you lack the
- 51:38institutions, like a systemic, holistic type
- 51:41of institution. So there's ways to respond to
- 51:45this. And it's always been, in the case of interests,
- 51:49It's always been organizing. So you organize
- 51:51people power against private interest or special
- 51:57interests. And at the end of the day, it helps
- 52:00everyone when you organize a five -day work weekends
- 52:05or you improve democracies. It just benefits
- 52:10everybody. And so that's our mission. That's
- 52:14why we're trying to get set up a big tent, have
- 52:19lots of different interests come together, and
- 52:23what can AI do to help us? Can it help us develop
- 52:28a systems calculator where we develop what Patrice
- 52:34Jones said was a holistic math for animals? Because
- 52:39right now, the way quantitative methods are used,
- 52:45they're not accurate. they're treating the most
- 52:49important things as externalities. That's not
- 52:52a real math. We have complex systems, and we
- 52:55need, even if you use quantitative methods, it
- 53:03would show that the best win -win approach is
- 53:07switching to a plant -based food system. So anyway,
- 53:09so that's how I see Aidan's piece. Like I just
- 53:11see it, when you look at it carefully, I took
- 53:13notes and was going, oh yeah, this would benefit
- 53:15the the business. I would constantly saw things
- 53:19that he was saying that would benefit business.
- 53:21He even celebrated. He said, you know, if robots
- 53:27took over workers, that would be a good thing
- 53:30because workers are angry and robots are going
- 53:32to be more gentle. But I would ask Aidan, why
- 53:37don't you replace one of those hens and put yourself
- 53:40in that situation or one of those cows and have
- 53:44live in that windowless warehouse and go to a
- 53:50slaughterhouse and be killed by a robot. If you
- 53:54follow the golden rule, none of us would want
- 53:57this. This is absolute nightmare. I understand
- 54:03where he's coming from. I read it really carefully.
- 54:08It took me hours because I was taking notes.
- 54:13I can see through it basically. And so I do think
- 54:20he can be persuaded because I could just simply
- 54:22point out to him, look, this is what you're doing.
- 54:25And if it was a bean company or a bread company,
- 54:27you would be writing a different paper. There
- 54:32is a part of this article substance that I could
- 54:37not make sense of, which was he invites the readers,
- 54:42animal rights activists to sacrifice our moral
- 54:48purity. And it's like we're some bourgeois class
- 54:51that is holding into this precious moral purity
- 54:56that is stopping us from making progress. And
- 55:00he wants us to bloody our hands. It's basically
- 55:03word for word what he's saying. I'm not inventing
- 55:06that. And I was thinking... If you're ready to
- 55:11go that far, sacrificing your moral principles,
- 55:15why are you not inviting us to murder every shareholder
- 55:21of Tizen and all of the other animal exploitation
- 55:26operations out there? If we're ready to sacrifice
- 55:30our moral principles, if the means justifies
- 55:34the end and so on, then why not go there? Why
- 55:38go into the field of let's turn animals into
- 55:44brainless creatures and do all of those experimental
- 55:48things to them? And I feel like it's a bit cowardly.
- 55:53It's the weak, you know, animals are weak. We
- 55:56can absolutely do that to them. But going against
- 56:02those oligarchs out there, becoming some kind
- 56:07of violent militia. That would mean sacrificing
- 56:12your comfort. That would mean standing up from
- 56:15your desk and having to purchase a gun or something
- 56:19and maybe sacrificing your freedom and so on.
- 56:23And I guess we're not ready to go there. It's
- 56:29deranging. It's a deranged way of thinking about
- 56:34the world. Yeah. What did you make of that? I
- 56:38thought that was one of the most interesting
- 56:40parts of it because I think both of us, Ryan,
- 56:42think a lot about philosophy and that really
- 56:44moves us, you know, and that sort of is central
- 56:46to us. And you said you were very influenced
- 56:49by Buddhism and that it's inconceivable to even,
- 56:53you know, think about what Aidan was saying.
- 56:57And I agree with you that sort of that passage
- 56:59sort of stuck out to me and I can read it here.
- 57:02He said, I ask much more from you now. I ask
- 57:05you to let go of your moral purity, to take those
- 57:09pristine hands of yours and use them to make
- 57:12a difference in the lives of animals, letting
- 57:14them be stained with blood in the process. In
- 57:16fact, it's better to think of ourselves climbing
- 57:19down the ladder, leaving behind our moral, comfortable,
- 57:24sorry, leaving behind our comfortable moral high
- 57:26ground, like Orpheus descending into the underworld
- 57:29to negotiate with its ruler for the return of
- 57:31his lost love, even brings a love story into
- 57:34it and descending into hell. So I thought that
- 57:37passage, I really thought that passage was significant.
- 57:40And because I'm a big follower of Leo Tolstoy,
- 57:42so I don't believe in violence. I think violence
- 57:44is the worst thing that can happen to anyone.
- 57:47Nobody wants to be subject to violence. It's
- 57:49such a horrible thing. War is a horrible thing.
- 57:52You know, killing animals is horrible. And Leo
- 57:55Tolstoy was, you know, a big advocate of nonviolence.
- 57:58And he wrote he wrote an essay or an introductory
- 58:02essay called The First Step. It was for a British
- 58:07author, Howard Williams, who wrote a book called
- 58:09The Ethics of Diet, which looked at famous vegetarians
- 58:12in history. Leo Tolstoy was known as a psychological
- 58:19realist, one of the most famous realists, alongside
- 58:24Charles Dickens and others, Balzac. war and peace.
- 58:31He went to the battle sites in order to write
- 58:34the book. He did a lot of research. And so when
- 58:38he was invited to write this introductory essay,
- 58:41he said, well, I'm going to go to a slaughterhouse.
- 58:43So he took a train to Tula. And the first time
- 58:47it was closed when he went, then he went back.
- 58:50And the first thing that struck him was the smell.
- 58:55It was unbearable. He bore witness. That's sort
- 59:00of what our group did, Toronto Fakes, Save Animals,
- 59:02Save Women. It's about bearing witness and going
- 59:04there and being present. He bore witness inside
- 59:06the slaughterhouse. And then in the essay, the
- 59:10essay is called The First Step, because he said
- 59:13the first step to being a good person is not
- 59:17killing animals. And so in contrast to Aidan,
- 59:22he says, we need to take a step. up the ladder,
- 59:26or up the staircase, not descend down. And Aidan's
- 59:30essay is structured as rungs, like let's go down
- 59:33this step, then down this step, then let's sit
- 59:37beside the factory farm, like the Cargill and
- 59:40all these kinds of companies. He didn't name
- 59:42the companies, but that's what he's basically
- 59:43saying, which is what Spring Innovation Fund
- 59:45is doing with Milo heading it. So it's just saying,
- 59:51let's go down those rungs. and get our hands
- 59:54bloody. Whereas Tolstoy is saying, let's go to
- 59:58a plant -based food system. Let's not eat animals.
- 1:00:00Let's not kill animals. And that's what the first
- 1:00:03step was. And in it, he quotes, he says, all
- 1:00:07moral teachings set up a ladder, as Chinese wisdom
- 1:00:10puts it, reaching from earth to heaven, the ascent
- 1:00:14of which can only be accomplished by starting
- 1:00:16from the lowest step. As in the teaching of the
- 1:00:19Brahmins, Buddhists, Confucians, So also in the
- 1:00:23teaching of the Greek sages Steps were fixed
- 1:00:26and a higher step could not be tamed without
- 1:00:28the lower one having been taken being previously
- 1:00:31taken and in in it he calls for He says flesh
- 1:00:36eating is simply immoral as It involves the performance
- 1:00:40of an act which is contrary to moral feeling
- 1:00:43killing So so he's against violence and so as
- 1:00:46you can see the greatest thinkers are talking
- 1:00:49about how Do you become a good person? How do
- 1:00:52you walk up the ladder? Whereas Aidan is encouraging
- 1:00:56us to walk down the ladder. So he is minimizing
- 1:01:00philosophy or ideas for interests. He is so clouded
- 1:01:06by the enormous money that's out there for this
- 1:01:10short -term gain, which would harm animals, the
- 1:01:14climate, pandemic, all that. He's putting all
- 1:01:16of that aside, treating that as an externality
- 1:01:18because He's being overwhelmed by the amount
- 1:01:25of money that's possible. So yeah, so he's just
- 1:01:30throwing out ethics basically, or throwing out.
- 1:01:32But he's trying to sell it as though he's not
- 1:01:34really. He's saying, oh, get your hands bloodied
- 1:01:36so we can tweak welfare. But as we all know,
- 1:01:40he wouldn't replace the position of a hen or
- 1:01:43a cow with his own position, because there's
- 1:01:46a lot of money where what he's doing, and he's
- 1:01:48going to live a very comfortable life. And he's,
- 1:01:52you know, working with big ag. And it's a no
- 1:01:56-win prospect because the industry is fundamentally
- 1:02:02immoral, like it involves killing. And none of
- 1:02:06us would want to be on that other end. We wouldn't
- 1:02:08want to be the victims. So yeah, so again, so
- 1:02:12that's why I come back to these three I's. Ideas,
- 1:02:14interests, institutions. See how they interplay.
- 1:02:17You know, what's at play? You know, what's...
- 1:02:19What are the interest barriers? Because Aidan,
- 1:02:23there's a barrier. He's facing this big barrier,
- 1:02:27which is interests. So how do we help him? So
- 1:02:30I think it's perfectly possible to help all that,
- 1:02:33all these situations. It's not easy. That's why
- 1:02:39I'm thinking, how do we figure this out? How
- 1:02:41do we change the interest structure, the incentive
- 1:02:43structure? How do we broaden the ideas in the
- 1:02:47effective altruism community? So it's not just
- 1:02:49utilitarianism, very narrowly defined. How do
- 1:02:53we include deontology? How do we include systems
- 1:02:55thinking? How do we change the institutions and
- 1:02:58bring everyone together so that we can consider
- 1:03:02everything from all the different experts? And
- 1:03:05by experts, I mean, not just people with PhDs,
- 1:03:08but people who have worked in the field for a
- 1:03:10long time. Whether they're indigenous peoples
- 1:03:14or gardeners or, you know, Tim who's, you know,
- 1:03:19has done the UK VegFest for decades. Like we
- 1:03:22have all these amazing experts in our movement
- 1:03:24and we have to work with people in other movements
- 1:03:27and come together. So yeah, that's the way I
- 1:03:31see it. I see it as, you know, so how do we strengthen
- 1:03:35democracy? How do we, you know, they are these
- 1:03:38big questions. How do we change the interest
- 1:03:39structure in incentives? How do we consider all
- 1:03:43these different factors? Because at the end of
- 1:03:45the day, if we have tipping points and a climate
- 1:03:48catastrophe, there's no winner. And Al Gore in
- 1:03:52his film, An Inconvenient Truth, he said, there's
- 1:03:55a scale. On the one side, there's money, on gold,
- 1:03:59and on the other side, there's the earth. I mean,
- 1:04:01which one would you choose? You know what I mean?
- 1:04:05So there's a famous saying like, all the gold
- 1:04:10or all the money in the world will not buy you
- 1:04:12another minute, that famous song by this group.
- 1:04:15I forgot the name of the group, but there's a
- 1:04:16song about it, Dust in the Wind, I think it's
- 1:04:18called. We're all just dust in the wind. Al Gore
- 1:04:25said the same thing in Inconvenient Truth. It's
- 1:04:26a theme. At the end of the day, what matters
- 1:04:31It's like we have a precious earth, and we've
- 1:04:34got to protect the rainforest, the Amazon rainforest,
- 1:04:36and we've got to protect life on earth. We've
- 1:04:38got to protect wildlife. We should stop breeding
- 1:04:40farmed animals. We should have animals go to
- 1:04:43sanctuaries. We should support sanctuaries. There's
- 1:04:47so many. Like I said, there's a fork in the road.
- 1:04:49It's one path or another. You either go down
- 1:04:52the ladder, the ladder. That's another way to
- 1:04:54say the fork in the road. from an ideas perspective,
- 1:05:00up or down from an interest perspective, you
- 1:05:02know, from all those perspectives, how do we
- 1:05:03go to one pathway versus the other pathway? Yeah,
- 1:05:08it's again, I feel like if you cross certain
- 1:05:13moral lines, then we don't know what's the next
- 1:05:18thing you're going to think is a good idea, which
- 1:05:23is not a good idea. Like we talk a lot about
- 1:05:27how there are too many people out there. like
- 1:05:30humans overcrowd the earth and we are the consumption
- 1:05:34of resources is too intensive. And so many environmentalists
- 1:05:39like good hearted environmentalists have said
- 1:05:41that there is a problem of overpopulation on
- 1:05:44earth. The solution to that is not to go down
- 1:05:48the ladder and think about designing a virus
- 1:05:52to kill half of humanity. That's not where we
- 1:05:56want to go, but Following his logic, that's where
- 1:06:00we would go as activists. And no, yeah, I have
- 1:06:05to dissociate from that trend and from that perspective.
- 1:06:13Did you want to add something about this? I don't
- 1:06:16know. I just think there's a way to have a conversation.
- 1:06:20And I'd be more than happy to have a debate or
- 1:06:23discussion with Aidan or anyone. And I think
- 1:06:27there is a pathway. to doing the right things.
- 1:06:32And Tolstoy and Gandhi and Martin Luther King,
- 1:06:37they didn't dislike the individuals or the Southern
- 1:06:42white people or whoever, or the British or whoever
- 1:06:45it was. They recognized it's the system that
- 1:06:51sort of forces people to do things or incentivizes
- 1:06:55them or shapes their thinking. So, from my perspective,
- 1:07:03we really need to change the system. There was
- 1:07:06a Holocaust survivor that said, you know, to
- 1:07:09animals we're all Nazis. And certainly I behaved
- 1:07:12like that when I was like an omnivore. And I
- 1:07:14didn't even know, I didn't even think about it.
- 1:07:18So, from my perspective, I like Tolstoy's and
- 1:07:23Gandhi's and King's non -judgmentalism. It's
- 1:07:27challenging. because I know it's easy to be angry,
- 1:07:30you know, get upset. And certainly that, but
- 1:07:35we've all, most people have done horrible things,
- 1:07:40you know. And how do we, you know, just how do
- 1:07:46we move beyond and become better people? How
- 1:07:49do we go up that ladder? And the way we go up
- 1:07:52that ladder is we have to help other people get
- 1:07:54up that ladder. So I wouldn't dismiss. Any of
- 1:08:00these people like I I think it's you know, it's
- 1:08:02good to have a conversation So I think I think
- 1:08:08also I think it's useful to read they've got
- 1:08:11like I've read a lot of the Gandhi books told
- 1:08:13site Like it really helps me because I was doing
- 1:08:16vigils for like 15 years I don't do many now
- 1:08:21anymore, but I used to do a lot of them and it
- 1:08:23was very grounding to read their work Because
- 1:08:26it's very easy to get angry and hateful and at
- 1:08:31the injustice, but it's very self -defeating.
- 1:08:35Like it just makes you, I don't know, like disappointed
- 1:08:42and angry and tired and you know, it's just not
- 1:08:46very sustainable versus just trying to understand,
- 1:08:50you know, the systems, there's problems with
- 1:08:52our system, human design systems, the three I's,
- 1:08:55those are human systems and they often act as
- 1:08:58barriers and There is a way forward. And one
- 1:09:03of the things we have to aim at is a positive
- 1:09:07tipping point. And there's a book called Positive
- 1:09:10Tipping Point, which I'm reading right now by
- 1:09:12Professor Tim Lenton from the UK. And he talks
- 1:09:16about Greta Thunberg and other positive tipping
- 1:09:20points, just how you start with a couple of people,
- 1:09:23then it grows to more people, then eventually
- 1:09:25you have millions of people engaged in Fridays
- 1:09:28for Future. You know, she really had a big impact
- 1:09:31on the world as a child. Quite interesting. So
- 1:09:36that's what we got to focus on. I wouldn't focus
- 1:09:39on, okay, I hate this or that person. I don't.
- 1:09:44I just think of how are we going to get those
- 1:09:46positive tipping points? How do we persuade people?
- 1:09:48And you know, you and I were talking about Buddhism
- 1:09:50and Leo Tolstoy's short story called Three Questions.
- 1:09:54And the three questions are, who's the most important
- 1:09:57person? advisor, this king was asking because
- 1:10:01he had to solve a problem. So he was saying,
- 1:10:03oh, who's the most important person? And what's
- 1:10:06the most important time? What's the most important
- 1:10:08thing to do? And then the conclusion was the
- 1:10:11most important person is the person in front
- 1:10:12of you. So that's very deontological. So it could
- 1:10:15be the animal in front of you or the person.
- 1:10:18So if the adens are in front of me or the meat
- 1:10:21eaters in front of me, at that moment, they're
- 1:10:22the most important person. And the most important
- 1:10:24thing at the time is now. And the most important
- 1:10:26thing to do is to be kind or just. And so that's
- 1:10:31how I see it. And just, yeah, I just think there
- 1:10:38still is a small window as Johann Rockstrom,
- 1:10:42the Planetary Boundary Earth scientist says,
- 1:10:45for us to turn this around, to turn the Titanic
- 1:10:48around. So that has to be our focus, he said.
- 1:10:50We have to urgently change. And so we have to
- 1:10:54urgently change towards a plant -based food system.
- 1:10:56And how are we going to do that? That's the mission.
- 1:10:59That's my mission. We were inspired by Sappora
- 1:11:03Berman, who's the chair of the Fossil Fuel Non
- 1:11:05-Proliferation Treaty. So she's concerned about
- 1:11:07energy and fossil fuels. And then that's how
- 1:11:09we started the Plant Based Treaty. And so in
- 1:11:12our case, what we're really looking at is animals.
- 1:11:16And there's this famous quote from another short
- 1:11:19story by Leo Tolstoy, which I read to you before
- 1:11:21we got on air, which you basically said, you
- 1:11:24know, all life is one. And when men treat...
- 1:11:29when men want to harm others, they really do
- 1:11:32evil to themselves. And I think when we harm
- 1:11:35animals, it's going to bite us back. We're going
- 1:11:39to destroy the climate. There's going to be a
- 1:11:42tipping point for the Amazon rainforest. The
- 1:11:46climate niche is going to get smaller and smaller
- 1:11:48where we can actually live. More of the world
- 1:11:50will be like the Sahara Desert. There's going
- 1:11:53to be conflict. There's going to be fighting
- 1:11:55over water. It's going to be a hell. There's
- 1:11:59been books like The Road. It was on Oprah Winfrey's
- 1:12:03list of books to read. I read most a lot of those
- 1:12:05books, and that was one of them. And it's very
- 1:12:07dark in terms of, so like I said, there's a fork
- 1:12:09in the road. Where do we want to go? We have
- 1:12:13a choice. We don't have a lot of time. That's
- 1:12:16why I just want Coal Fish and Giving, ACE, Animal
- 1:12:19Charity Evaluators, Navigation Fund, Center for
- 1:12:22Effective Altruism. I really want them to really
- 1:12:25listen and put climate, animal rights, systems
- 1:12:31thinking, pandemic risk, all of that in a systems
- 1:12:35calculator and to fund that and move away from
- 1:12:39funding cage -free. The same is true for all
- 1:12:42the nonprofits, but a lot of these nonprofits
- 1:12:44are... you know, get dependent on these funds.
- 1:12:47And so all the nonprofits need to get together
- 1:12:50and say, look, we really need to focus on plant
- 1:12:55-based food systems as the main priority. So
- 1:12:58how do we convince all of these different actors?
- 1:13:01And that's the project. That's the focus. So
- 1:13:05I'm not discounting anyone. Like, I need Aidan's
- 1:13:08brilliance in campaigning because he's done a
- 1:13:10lot of good work, you know, against you know,
- 1:13:14foie gras or whatever it is. All these, you know,
- 1:13:17a lot of these, you know, they're wonderful people
- 1:13:19and campaigners. They're just like you can get
- 1:13:20on a wrong pathway if you get overwhelmed by
- 1:13:24interests and money. And we just have to put
- 1:13:27the money in the right place. That's all. Which
- 1:13:30is to speed up a transition to a plant -based
- 1:13:35food system and reduce and eliminate the number
- 1:13:38of animals in the food system. Like I said, I
- 1:13:44don't know Aidan and I actually never had read
- 1:13:48his substance before that piece. So that's not
- 1:13:51a very good first impression. But I think I'm
- 1:13:57thankful that he published that because it gives
- 1:14:00me an insight into the minds of the people who
- 1:14:05back this, what I think is an insanity. And I
- 1:14:08think there is space for criticizing and even
- 1:14:12criticizing harshly the ideas that people push
- 1:14:16while understanding that those are ideas and
- 1:14:21they're not what constitutes that person entirely.
- 1:14:28That person is much bigger than those few ideas.
- 1:14:31And I think it ties to my Buddhism because in
- 1:14:35Buddhism we don't believe that someone is their
- 1:14:38actions. that we can look at someone, look at
- 1:14:42their actions, look at the words and make some
- 1:14:46judgment on them. Anyway, let's not get into
- 1:14:49that. That would be this another one hour discussion.
- 1:14:54But I want to highlight as a last question what
- 1:14:59you said about how this is harming us too. Let
- 1:15:04me read one passage of that piece that also stuck
- 1:15:08with me and You also highlighted that passage
- 1:15:12in your first sub -stack piece. Let me see. Quote,
- 1:15:17we would be designing animals specifically to
- 1:15:20thrive inside factory farms, beings utterly devoid
- 1:15:24of negative effect, for whom every moment lying
- 1:15:28still in the ammonia -chocked air is pure bliss,
- 1:15:33for whom even the blade cutting into their throat
- 1:15:36feels like an orgasm. In the limit, maybe these
- 1:15:41animals would be happier in factory farms than
- 1:15:44they could be anywhere else. Now, you could have
- 1:15:52a multitude of reactions from reading that passage,
- 1:15:55but one of them is thinking, all of that technology
- 1:15:58you're going to develop into turning animals
- 1:16:01into this monstrosity, they can also be applied
- 1:16:06on humans. And this vision of factory farms and
- 1:16:14slaughterhouses and animal welfare that you're
- 1:16:18sharing could very well be translated into some
- 1:16:24kind of dystopian totalitarian vision of the
- 1:16:29world that awaits us with those new technologies.
- 1:16:33We could be the animals in this story. We could
- 1:16:37be the victims of all of this. And I'm not sure
- 1:16:42he was conscious of that, writing all of that,
- 1:16:46that us and our children could become a version
- 1:16:49of that if those technologies fall into the wrong
- 1:16:53hands. Yeah, what do you make of that? Yeah,
- 1:16:57I mean, that passage, it's disgusting. It's like
- 1:17:00reading Hitler's Mein Kampf or something. It
- 1:17:02was very fascist. And it's disgusting. I mean,
- 1:17:06it's bottom of the barrel. It's just, yeah, you
- 1:17:11don't want to turn precious life into something
- 1:17:14meaningless like that. See, I understood his
- 1:17:19blog in general. but he just wrote in the most
- 1:17:22disgusting way. He just made it, you know, so
- 1:17:25one person I talked to said, oh, he was just
- 1:17:27trying to shift the Overton window so that he
- 1:17:30could write this disgustingly so that some of
- 1:17:32the other things would seem not as radical. But
- 1:17:35I didn't buy that either. I think this piece
- 1:17:37was very revealing and I'm sort of grateful for
- 1:17:40it because it, in the words of one really major
- 1:17:46animal organizer, or head of a group, he said,
- 1:17:52this piece by Aidan was a pivotal moment in the
- 1:17:57movement. And it was like a warning sign of where
- 1:18:02we're heading. So I actually think he did a big
- 1:18:04service. And particularly because I understand
- 1:18:08it from an interest perspective. He was working
- 1:18:12with the interests that be. but in a very myopic
- 1:18:16way. So I think it's in everyone's interest not
- 1:18:19to treat the environment and climate and animal
- 1:18:23rights as an externality. It's going to come
- 1:18:24back and bite us. And so I actually think he
- 1:18:28did us a huge favor. I do think it's part like
- 1:18:32he just went right to the bottom. He went to
- 1:18:35the most extreme fascist kind of position. But
- 1:18:41it was a warning. And if We move in the direction
- 1:18:46of robots and machines running factory farms,
- 1:18:51confining animals, feeding them, deciding how
- 1:18:56much water and food, which is where it's heading
- 1:18:58with the precision livestock farming, and then
- 1:19:03killing the animals. How is that not a fascist
- 1:19:06dystopia? Would any of us want to be in this
- 1:19:10situation? He did a service to us, so I'm actually
- 1:19:13quite grateful to him. But I hope he steps back
- 1:19:19and recognizes that he was writing in a fascist
- 1:19:21way. I hope that that, I think that's important.
- 1:19:23I agree with you in terms of being critical like
- 1:19:25that. We shouldn't just let people get away with
- 1:19:27like, it's okay to write that way. So I do think,
- 1:19:31I wouldn't say put him in prison. I wouldn't
- 1:19:33talk that way, as you mentioned earlier. I think
- 1:19:35there's a freedom of expression. I value that.
- 1:19:40There should be some boundaries like you should
- 1:19:42not be promoting hate or violence and certainly
- 1:19:47He was certainly veering into some dangerous
- 1:19:50territory for sure if you applied this to any
- 1:19:53group of humans It's just just utterly disgraceful
- 1:19:57So and there was a reaction like I talked to
- 1:20:00a number of people in the animal welfare and
- 1:20:02animal rights movement They were like horrified
- 1:20:05by this piece, but that's good because that's
- 1:20:08they were awakened to where this is heading.
- 1:20:11They might be receiving money for cage -free,
- 1:20:13but it's more than cage -free. We're moving towards
- 1:20:18welfare tech technology. We're moving towards
- 1:20:27precision livestock. I never used the word livestock.
- 1:20:30It's disgusting. Animals are not property, but
- 1:20:33it's called precision livestock farming and deciding
- 1:20:36how much food give broiler chickens because they
- 1:20:41will they will die if you just give them unlimited
- 1:20:43food because they get they get overweight so
- 1:20:45there's this you know decide how much water and
- 1:20:47food to give them and how to how much to starve
- 1:20:49them and so that that you know they can they
- 1:20:53don't they don't that you know 40 percent or
- 1:20:56whatever die from being you know overweight so
- 1:20:58like you know so AI is playing a role in this
- 1:21:00so this is very disturbing so he certainly opened
- 1:21:03so again again it's a fork in the road and he
- 1:21:07showed how bad it could get, which is a fascist
- 1:21:09dystopia, versus another pathway we could take
- 1:21:13by using holistic systems thinking and deontology
- 1:21:18and not just utilitarianism, which is limiting.
- 1:21:22Use those ideas, change the interest structure
- 1:21:26so that by organizing and putting pressure on
- 1:21:32AI companies with regard to data centers or with
- 1:21:36regard to what they invest in. They shouldn't
- 1:21:38be working with big ag and making factory farming
- 1:21:41more efficient. No, we should say no to that.
- 1:21:44They should be helping on a plant -based food
- 1:21:45transition. And we need to create institutions.
- 1:21:48And if we do all this, we all win. Who's going
- 1:21:53to benefit if we go down the fascist dystopia
- 1:21:56pathway? I mean, who benefits? There's that famous
- 1:22:00saying, first they came for this group, then
- 1:22:02they came for that group. There's a priest that
- 1:22:04said that about fascism. Because that's gonna
- 1:22:07happen. So like so yeah, it's a we live in a
- 1:22:11very important time and with respect to climate
- 1:22:14change we're heading to the 1 .5 limit within
- 1:22:17the next three to five years and that's a scientific
- 1:22:20target not a not a political one and that means
- 1:22:23that we're gonna hit some tipping points and
- 1:22:27these tipping points are Really serious. So we
- 1:22:31all of us have to work on positive tipping points.
- 1:22:33Like how do we do the right thing, you know,
- 1:22:36move to a plant -based food system. So I need,
- 1:22:38I need Anthropic. I need Cold Fish and Giving.
- 1:22:40I need all these groups. I need Aiden. I need
- 1:22:42all every, all the nonprofits, all the welfare.
- 1:22:45Like we need everybody to, you know, to do everything
- 1:22:51we need, everything we could possibly do to go
- 1:22:53as fast as we can to shift the food system so
- 1:22:58that it's safe and just for everyone. I'm so
- 1:23:04glad that you exist Anita. It's a team. It's
- 1:23:08a team. So I should make clear like I just a
- 1:23:10face of it, but you know, we, I, we assembled
- 1:23:12a huge team. I worked very closely with Robert
- 1:23:14Grillo free from harm and PETA and so many activists
- 1:23:18in plant -based treaty and animal safe movement.
- 1:23:20And so it's a team and, uh, yeah. So yeah, I'm
- 1:23:25so happy the team exists and our philosophy is
- 1:23:28expanding team leadership. Definitely. Yes. And
- 1:23:32people can, um, I think in a section of the Open
- 1:23:37Ladder website, you can see which organizations
- 1:23:40has signed into this. So yes, definitely it's
- 1:23:47a team and those are beautiful efforts. That's
- 1:23:50what we want to see after reading such piece
- 1:23:53and going down the rabbit hole of factory farming
- 1:23:562 .0 and all of that. We want to hear that some
- 1:23:59people are pushing back against that and we...
- 1:24:02want to join efforts to push back. And yeah,
- 1:24:07so it's admirable. And I'm so grateful that you're
- 1:24:10doing that. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you
- 1:24:13for your podcast. And yeah, I really appreciate
- 1:24:15you interviewing Sam Tucker Davis. That was very
- 1:24:18enlightening. And his Factory Farming 2 .0 was
- 1:24:21very, he published it a day before Aidan's substack,
- 1:24:25one day before. So he's played an incredible
- 1:24:29role. His life story is very interesting. Um,
- 1:24:32so we're very grateful to him, you know, and
- 1:24:34there's so many people that have been amazing
- 1:24:35and, uh, just wonderful people, you know, that,
- 1:24:40uh, this has lit a fire under a lot of people.
- 1:24:42Like, uh, you know, PETA is now signed onto the
- 1:24:46open letter and Captain Paul Watson Foundation
- 1:24:49and Plant -Based Health Professionals UK. And,
- 1:24:53um, there's so many groups and Jane Velez Mitchell
- 1:24:55on Chain TV. So we're trying to get... you know
- 1:24:59hundreds and thousands of groups and you know
- 1:25:02animal climate health and then more than a thousand
- 1:25:05experts as our goal and we already have over
- 1:25:091200 individuals who signed so you know we want
- 1:25:13to get we just want to have this positive solutions
- 1:25:16oriented conversation and organizing so that
- 1:25:22we choose the right the best pathway the optimal
- 1:25:25pathway for everyone. So, you know, we don't
- 1:25:29go down the route of the road, you know, that
- 1:25:31book, which is like a dystopia. You know, we
- 1:25:35can have paradise on earth or we can have a dystopia.
- 1:25:38It's up to us. It's up to us. Great parting words.
- 1:25:43Anita, thank you so much for having accepted
- 1:25:46my invitation and answered my questions. This
- 1:25:49was an amazing conversation. Thank you, Ryan.
- 1:25:52And I hope to see it in person sometime. We're
- 1:25:53not too far away. Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:25:56I kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 1:25:59the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 1:26:02to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 1:26:06caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a
- 1:26:09new episode.