Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Morgan Housell: Smart People Are The Nicest
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to today's deep dive everyone.
- 0:02We are so glad you could join us.
- 0:03Yeah, really excited to get into this one.
- 0:05So our mission today is to unpack this really fascinating
- 0:09Q&A session from the financial and behavioral thinker, Morgan
- 0:12Housel. Great.
- 0:13And we're going to explore all these unexpected, kind of mind
- 0:18blowing intersections of human behavior, like how we accumulate
- 0:20wealth, parenting, and, you know, how we view the future.
- 0:25Exactly. I mean, the overarching theme
- 0:27here is really just recognizing our behavioral blind spots
- 0:30because we spend so much time trying to optimize our lives
- 0:34using pure logic, right? And we completely ignore the
- 0:38fact that we are these emotional, deeply flawed
- 0:41creatures playing a very complex game of human connection.
- 0:44Oh. Absolutely.
- 0:45It's it's wild how much we miss. But before we jump into the
- 0:48mechanics of those blind spots, I have a quick required focus
- 0:51note for you all. Go for it to access more
- 0:54advanced researches, applications and our latest
- 0:57published personal Intelligent Multi Agent Deep Value
- 1:00Intelligence. Welcome to explore and join Deep
- 1:03values dot AI community Track total market temperature.
- 1:07Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett Indicator from
- 1:11Apple App Store. And just a quick disclaimer, all
- 1:14analysis is based on publicly available sources and may be
- 1:17subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 1:20All contents from this channel is for information and research
- 1:22purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 1:26Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 1:28decisions. If you like to access wider
- 1:31topics, including life and investing philosophy, please
- 1:33subscribe to our sister channel, Deep Values.
- 1:36Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciate it.
- 1:38Awesome. With that covered, let's let's
- 1:40get into the actual behavioral mechanics.
- 1:42Yes, let's do it. So today we're going to cover
- 1:45why the smartest people in any given room are actually
- 1:47statistically the nicest. Yeah, that's a wild concept.
- 1:50Right. And also the fatal psychological
- 1:52flaw that's kind of baked into universal basic income and the
- 1:55true reason why bad news always goes viral.
- 1:57I mean that last one is so relevant right now.
- 2:00It really is. But let's start with this
- 2:02heuristic from the source material that just completely up
- 2:07ends how we evaluate people. The premise is basically this.
- 2:11If you want to find the smartest person in the room, find the
- 2:14nicest, right? And conversely, if you want to
- 2:16find the dumbest person in a given environment, you look for
- 2:19the cruelest. Which, you know, when you first
- 2:21hear that, it sounds like this cheesy platitude.
- 2:23Yeah, totally a pumper sticker. Exactly.
- 2:26But peeling back the layers of how our cognitive function
- 2:29actually works reveals this profound truth about human
- 2:34processing power. Oh wait, processing power?
- 2:37How so? Well, operating with cruelty or
- 2:39trying to dominate people is actually our default
- 2:42evolutionary setting. Really.
- 2:44Yeah, We have this deeply ingrained tribal urge to
- 2:48compete, to establish a hierarchy and basically suppress
- 2:52those around us to secure resources.
- 2:54I mean, I guess that makes sense from a survival standpoint.
- 2:56Right. And The thing is that requires
- 2:57almost zero processing power. It's just pure unadulterated
- 3:01instinct, but being genuinely kind, especially in like a high
- 3:05stakes competitive environment that requires a massive amount
- 3:09of cognitive overhead. OK, let's unpack this, because
- 3:12you're implying that kindness isn't just like a nice moral
- 3:17choice, but a computational one. Yes, like you are actively using
- 3:21your intelligence to override a baseline biological drive.
- 3:26It is entirely computational. I mean, highly intelligent
- 3:29people have the capacity to model out long term scenarios in
- 3:33their heads. Right, they see the big picture.
- 3:34Exactly. They understand that
- 3:36interactions in the modern world are almost never isolated
- 3:39events. Yeah.
- 3:40So if you're cruel just to secure some short term win,
- 3:44you're destroying trust, alienate potential
- 3:46collaborators, and you just create all this friction for
- 3:49your future self. It is so true.
- 3:51Smart people use their mental horsepower to basically suppress
- 3:55the ego. Exactly because they recognize
- 3:57that cooperation and kindness yield significantly higher
- 4:00compound returns over a lifetime.
- 4:02And there's also, I think, this element of intellectual humility
- 4:05at play here, too. Or for sure.
- 4:07Like when I observe people who are demonstrably brilliant, they
- 4:10rarely react to opposing viewpoints with aggression.
- 4:13No, they don't. Yeah, if you challenge their
- 4:16thesis, they don't try to like, obliterate you.
- 4:19They usually pause and consider that their model of the world
- 4:22might just be incomplete. What's fascinating here is the
- 4:24underlying framework these different minds use to view the
- 4:27world. What do you mean well?
- 4:29Cruel or combative individuals typically operate in a strict 0
- 4:34sum framework. In their minds, success is this
- 4:37fixed quantity. So for them to experience a
- 4:41victory, you absolutely must experience a defeat.
- 4:45Right, it's like a pie, and if I take a slice, there's less for
- 4:47you. Exactly, but highly intelligent
- 4:50people recognize that modern societies are profoundly non 0
- 4:54sum. Meaning we can both win.
- 4:56Yeah, value can be created collaboratively.
- 4:58You can achieve your goals, I can achieve mine.
- 5:01And the overall system just becomes richer for it.
- 5:03The danger, of course, is that society really struggles to
- 5:06measure those collaborative trades.
- 5:08Oh, big time. We fall into this terrible
- 5:10psychological trap where we equate our net worth with our
- 5:14human worth. Yeah, which is so toxic.
- 5:17It is. It's like treating your entire
- 5:18existence as a purely mechanical arcade game.
- 5:21Oh, I like that analogy. Right, where the only valid
- 5:24metric of a life well lived is just the physical stack of
- 5:28tickets the machine spits out at the end.
- 5:30Yeah, and we default to that financial scoreboard because it
- 5:33requires no subjective judgement.
- 5:35Exactly. Money provides this universal
- 5:37tangible apples to apples metric trick.
- 5:40We can just compare two bank accounts instantaneously.
- 5:43It's just a math problem. But we cannot easily measure or
- 5:47rank subjective qualities, you know, like emotional
- 5:50intelligence, patience, or how someone supports their
- 5:53community. And because society can't
- 5:55efficiently count kindness or humor, we effectively round
- 5:59their value down to 0. Exactly.
- 6:01We just stare blindly at the scoreboard.
- 6:03But I want you to think about this in the context of your own
- 6:05life. Consider the extraordinarily
- 6:08wealthy people you might have encountered who operate with
- 6:10that 0 sum cruelty. We all know a few.
- 6:13Yeah, now contrast them with the foundational pillars of your
- 6:16local community. Like a dedicated teacher or a
- 6:19first responder. Exactly.
- 6:21Or a social worker. Their financial net worth might
- 6:24be pretty modest, but the structural value they inject
- 6:27into the world is just immense. And completely unquantifiable.
- 6:32Right. And the source material distills
- 6:34this into a really powerful maxim.
- 6:36The luckier you are, the nicer you should be.
- 6:39I love that decoupling yourself worth from your net worth is
- 6:43just incredibly liberating. It changes everything.
- 6:46It changes how you optimize your time, how you treat others,
- 6:49everything. And if we strip away that
- 6:51financial scoreboard from our identity, it forces a fairly
- 6:55uncomfortable look at how we treat the next generation.
- 6:57For sure, passing down wealth is a whole other issue.
- 7:00Yeah, we have to confront the mechanics of passing down
- 7:02resources without corrupting the character of our kids.
- 7:05Generational wealth transfers is perhaps the ultimate behavioral
- 7:08minefield. Absolutely, and the source
- 7:09material highlights this deep, revealing pattern observed by a
- 7:13hospital priest. Oh, I remember this.
- 7:15Yeah, this guy spent decades administering last rites, right?
- 7:19Sitting with people in their final hours, watching families
- 7:22say their goodbyes. That's heavy.
- 7:24It is. And the pattern, he noted, was
- 7:26stark. Right, because in families
- 7:29plagued by tension and strain dynamics, those final
- 7:32conversations were overwhelmingly transactional.
- 7:35Exactly. The children would express
- 7:37gratitude for tangible financial things, like thanking the parent
- 7:41for covering a down payment or paying for college.
- 7:44It was basically an accounting of ledgers, yes.
- 7:47But in deeply connected, loving families, the financial aspects
- 7:51entirely vanished from the room. Yeah, the kids invariably
- 7:54expressed gratitude for validation.
- 7:56They usually said some variation of thank you for believing in
- 7:59me. That validation is the core
- 8:02psychological need, period, right?
- 8:04Yet parents who have accumulated resources still face this
- 8:08mechanical dilemma of what to do with the money.
- 8:10Yeah, they want to help, but they are paralyzed by the fear
- 8:14of ruining their kids ambition. Exactly.
- 8:16Charlie Munger famously captured this anxiety.
- 8:18Oh I love this quote. A wealthy peer asked him if
- 8:21leaving an inheritance would ruin his kids drive, and Munger
- 8:24replied of course, but you have to do it anyway or they will
- 8:27hate you. Classic Munger.
- 8:29Yeah, and while he was using his trademark hyperbole, it really
- 8:33gets to the heart of the deeply inefficient way we handle
- 8:36inheritances. How so?
- 8:38Well, we adhere to this antiquated tradition of hoarding
- 8:42capital until the absolute end of our biological lives.
- 8:46The economic utility of that is virtually 0.
- 8:49You have a 90 year old passing away and transferring massive
- 8:53capital to a 70 year old child who?
- 8:54Doesn't even need. It exactly that 70 year old is
- 8:57fully established, their mortgage is paid, they're
- 9:00lifestyle is locked in. It provides almost no functional
- 9:03utility to their daily existence, right?
- 9:06This is where the financier Lloyd Blankfein's philosophy
- 9:09becomes highly relevant. OK, tell us about that.
- 9:11He argued for the concept of the warm hand versus the cold hand.
- 9:15The warm and. Yeah, giving with a warm hand
- 9:18means deploying that capital when it can actually alter the
- 9:21trajectory of the recipient's life.
- 9:23So not at 70. Exactly.
- 9:25A person doesn't need a financial intervention at 70,
- 9:28they need it in their early 30s. Which is the decade defined by
- 9:32maximum friction. Exactly, They are trying to buy
- 9:35a house, paying staggering costs for early childcare, servicing
- 9:39student debt, and just grinding through the most demanding years
- 9:43of their career. So a strategic infusion of
- 9:45capital at that specific juncture provides immense life
- 9:49altering leverage. Exactly.
- 9:51OK let's unpack this. Doesn't giving a 30 year old a
- 9:55ton of money risk turning them into a spoiled brat?
- 9:59That is the universal anxiety. Because if they haven't
- 10:02developed the discipline to build that capital themselves,
- 10:05aren't we just accelerating their ruin?
- 10:07It's a fair question, but the behavioral theory presented in
- 10:10the source challenges that entirely.
- 10:12OK Money does not possess the alchemy to change a person score
- 10:15character. It merely acts as a frictionless
- 10:18amplifier. Wait, an amplifier?
- 10:20Yes, it exposes who they already were.
- 10:23If an error receives a windfall and devolves into a reckless,
- 10:26entitled jerk, the capital did not create that entitlement.
- 10:29So they were already like that. Fundamentally, yes.
- 10:32The lack of money was simply acting as a physical constraint
- 10:35on their behavior. Remove the friction and their
- 10:39true personality is broadcasted to the world.
- 10:42We see the empirical proof of this in family dynamics all the
- 10:45time. You can observe a family where
- 10:47three siblings are raised in the exact same environment,
- 10:50internalize the same values, receive the exact same
- 10:53inheritance on the same day, and one sibling might systematically
- 10:56destroy their life with the funds.
- 10:59The second might use it to launch a sustainable business.
- 11:02And the third. The third might quietly put it
- 11:05into broad market index funds and never change their
- 11:08lifestyle. Exactly the identical input of
- 11:10capital produced 3 radically different outcomes.
- 11:14Because the money merely magnified 3 distinct underlying
- 11:16natures. Which means the actual labor of
- 11:19parenting, the installation of values, discipline and
- 11:22perspective has to be completed decades before any wealth
- 11:26transfer occurs. Yeah, that makes total sense.
- 11:28And the author of the source material actually formalizes
- 11:31this in a letter written to his own young children.
- 11:34How about the letter? Yeah.
- 11:35One of the stand out lines is incredibly jarring at first
- 11:39glance, He tells them. I hope at some point you are
- 11:42poor. Yeah, out of context it sounds
- 11:45almost vindictive, total. But the underlying mechanics of
- 11:48that wish are profound. He isn't wishing them structural
- 11:51poverty or destitution. No if not.
- 11:54He is hoping they experience the psychological weight of scarcity
- 11:58during their formative young adult years.
- 12:00Because you cannot mentally model the value of a dollar
- 12:04until you have experienced a deficit of dollars.
- 12:06Exactly. If resources are perpetually
- 12:08abundant, you never develop an awareness of the effort required
- 12:12to produce them. Right.
- 12:13Experiencing that friction in your 20s builds the
- 12:16psychological infrastructure necessary to handle that warm
- 12:19hand windfall in your 30s. Precisely, and preparing the
- 12:23next generation requires having some kind of thesis on what the
- 12:26future they are inheriting will actually look like.
- 12:28Which brings us to one of the most perplexing cognitive
- 12:31dissonance issues of our time. It really is.
- 12:34Because if you examine the objective historical arc of
- 12:37human civilization, it is undeniably pointed toward
- 12:41radical progress. Yet the collective psychological
- 12:44state is completely saturated in pessimism.
- 12:48It's a huge paradox. The data on human progress is
- 12:50staggering. Oh yeah.
- 12:51Over the last few centuries, global life expectancy has
- 12:54roughly doubled. We've eradicated ancient
- 12:57diseases. Right, the baseline comforts for
- 12:59a modern middle class citizen would be unrecognizable magic to
- 13:03royalty just a few 100 years ago.
- 13:05And yet, concurrently, our media, diets and casual
- 13:08conversations have grown increasingly apocalyptic.
- 13:11Why is that? Well, the economic historian
- 13:14Deirdre McCloskey captured this absurdity perfectly.
- 13:17She noted that people simply love to hear that the world is
- 13:20going to hell. It's true.
- 13:22And the author Matt Ridley pointed out the social asymmetry
- 13:24of this If you analyze data and publicly state the world is
- 13:28improving, you are dismissed as a naive Pollyanna.
- 13:32Right. Or a corporate shill or
- 13:33something. Exactly.
- 13:34If you project it will continue to improve, you're called
- 13:37embarrassingly mad. Wow.
- 13:39But if you author a paper predicting imminent
- 13:41civilizational collapse, you're lauded as a visionary and handed
- 13:45a MacArthur Genius award. There has to be a mechanical
- 13:48reason our brains prioritize the bad despite overwhelming data.
- 13:54Why is pessimism so intellectually seductive?
- 13:57It really comes down to the asymmetrical physics of how news
- 14:00actually happens. What do?
- 14:01You mean by physics? Well, bad news is instantaneous
- 14:05and violently disruptive. Think about major historical
- 14:08shocks. Pearl Harbor, the attacks of
- 14:10911, the sudden COVID lockdowns. Yeah, those happened in a flash.
- 14:15Right. They materialized in a matter of
- 14:17hours. The world genuinely became
- 14:18structurally worse in a single morning.
- 14:20And our brains are wired for. That exactly.
- 14:22Our evolutionary threat detection systems are
- 14:25hypercalibrated to react to sudden violent shifts because
- 14:28historically those shifts meant death.
- 14:30Whereas Good News entirely lacks that suddenness.
- 14:33Precisely. Good news is fundamentally about
- 14:36slow, agonizingly quiet compounding.
- 14:39Right, there's no positive equivalent to a sudden disaster.
- 14:42No, you never wake up to breaking news that the world
- 14:44miraculously improved by 30% overnight.
- 14:47Never mind it. Happens.
- 14:48Good news is the reality of that over the past several decades,
- 14:52the mortality rate from heart disease has declined by roughly
- 14:551% per year. Which is amazing.
- 14:58Over a 50 year timeline, that quiet, boring statistic
- 15:02translates to 10s of millions of human lives saved.
- 15:06But it doesn't make a good headline.
- 15:08Exactly a headline reading. Heart disease deaths dropped by
- 15:11a fraction of a percent this month triggers absolutely 0
- 15:15evolutionary response in our brains.
- 15:17It's too slow. Here's where it gets really
- 15:19interesting. It's not just the speed of the
- 15:22events, it's how our cognitive systems process the tone of the
- 15:25messenger. Yes.
- 15:27I view it through the lens of a medical diagnosis.
- 15:30If you visit a doctor and they suddenly look concerned and say
- 15:32we found a lump, we need you in surgery tomorrow.
- 15:34You panic. Right.
- 15:36You experience extreme biological arousal, your
- 15:39adrenaline spikes, you drop every other priority, and you
- 15:41take immediate action. Because you respect the
- 15:43pessimism, it demands survival. Exactly.
- 15:46But if that same doctor says you look fine, keep doing what
- 15:49you're doing. You feel like you wasted your
- 15:51morning. Yeah, you feel mildly bored.
- 15:54Pessimism mimics the tone of a critical survival warning.
- 15:57Sell your stocks right. The market is a bubble.
- 16:00Liquidate immediately. It forces an action which our
- 16:04brains interpret as high value information.
- 16:07And optimism. Optimism often mimics the tone
- 16:10of a complacent sales pitch. Stay invested.
- 16:13Stay the course. It requires inaction, so our
- 16:16brains dismiss it as low value noise.
- 16:19So you really have to deliberately calibrate your own
- 16:21internal BS detector. Absolutely.
- 16:23You have to ask yourself if your skepticism is actually
- 16:26protecting you from a tangible threat, or if it is just
- 16:29accidentally filtering out positive facts just because they
- 16:32don't trigger an adrenaline response.
- 16:34And this raises an important question, because that threat
- 16:37detection system is currently flashing red for almost everyone
- 16:40right now. Oh, the ultimate modern trigger.
- 16:42Yes, the catalyst that feels genuinely apocalyptic to a huge
- 16:46portion of the population is the rapid acceleration of artificial
- 16:50intelligence. I mean, I look at the
- 16:51capabilities of these large language models and it genuinely
- 16:54feels unprecedented. It's definitely a shock.
- 16:57It feels like there won't be any fundamental knowledge work left
- 17:00for humans to do in a decade. Will the robots just take all
- 17:03the jobs? The panic is entirely real, but
- 17:07historically the existential dread surrounding new technology
- 17:11is remarkably consistent. We've been here before.
- 17:14We have We're experiencing the exact same psychological shock
- 17:18waves that accompanied the proliferation of steam engines
- 17:21in the 1800s, or the rise of mechanized assembly lines in the
- 17:25early 20th century and the explosion of the Internet in the
- 17:281990s. And what happened then?
- 17:30In each of those eras, the prevailing intellectual
- 17:33consensus was that the new technology would permanently
- 17:35eliminate the need for human labor.
- 17:37Massive, unsolvable unemployment.
- 17:40Exactly. It is the classic lump of Labor
- 17:42fallacy, the assumption that there's only a fixed amount of
- 17:45work to be done in the world, and if a machine does it, a
- 17:47human just sits idle forever. But that never materialized.
- 17:50Historically, displaced workers always found entirely new
- 17:54categories of work, or they became exponentially more
- 17:56productive. So why does the AI revolution
- 17:59feel so uniquely devastated, stating right now it is entirely
- 18:02about the demographics of the displaced.
- 18:05AI is not targeting physical labor, it is taking direct aim
- 18:09at cognitive white collar tasks. Right, college educated workers.
- 18:13Exactly. People sitting in comfortable
- 18:16air conditioned offices believed they had reached the pinnacle of
- 18:19economic security. Yeah, they spent the last 50
- 18:21years watching blue collar manufacturing go overseas
- 18:24thinking they were totally safe. Viewing it as the natural
- 18:28evolution of global economics. But now the disruption has
- 18:31arrived at their own cubicles. That's a huge shift.
- 18:34The speed at which their specialized cognitive skills are
- 18:36being commoditized is creating a massive psychological trauma for
- 18:40the chattering classes. And because the people
- 18:42experiencing this trauma are the ones who write the articles and
- 18:46shape the cultural narrative, we are seeing radical solutions
- 18:49proposed. Like universal basic income.
- 18:51Exactly. The proposed solution to say 20%
- 18:55AI induced unemployment is a Ubi of $5000 a month.
- 18:59From a purely mathematical perspective, it appears elegant.
- 19:03Tax the AI productivity gains, distribute the wealth.
- 19:06So what does this all mean? If the government cuts you a
- 19:09check to tend your garden and write poetry, isn't that a
- 19:12utopia? According to the behavioral
- 19:15insights in the source material, it would almost certainly
- 19:17trigger a societal dystopia. Wait, really?
- 19:20Why? Because it completely ignores
- 19:22the complex behavioral realities of humans.
- 19:25Humans are not biologically wired for perpetual, unearned
- 19:28leisure. No, we possess a deep structural
- 19:32need to engage with difficult problems.
- 19:35Overcoming friction, developing mastery, and bearing
- 19:38responsibility are how we generate dopamine.
- 19:42And a sense of self worth. Yes, we require the dignity of
- 19:45knowing that our actions matter, that we are contributing to a
- 19:48system larger than ourselves. So if you simply buy off a
- 19:51massive segment of the population.
- 19:52You invite a profound psychological crisis.
- 19:55The psychosis of aimlessness is incredibly destructive.
- 19:58Wow. Without the structured friction
- 20:00of work, people lose their anchoring.
- 20:02They become alienated and deeply neurotic.
- 20:04So paying people to just sit at home would unleash unprecedented
- 20:08societal psychosis. Exactly.
- 20:10A massive population endowed with free time, guaranteed
- 20:14capital, and absolutely 0 societal purpose is a recipe for
- 20:19catastrophic social instability. It completely reframes how we
- 20:23should be discussing the AI transition.
- 20:25It really does. We are entirely focused on the
- 20:27logistics of the economic replacement when we should be
- 20:30focused on the crisis of human utility.
- 20:31Spot on. Well, before we wrap up, the
- 20:34source material offered a really strong cultural recommendation
- 20:37for understanding these deeper aspects of human nature.
- 20:40Oh yes. The author highlighted a book
- 20:42titled London Falling by Patrick Radden Keefe, published around
- 20:462018. Fantastic book.
- 20:48It's described as a phenomenal, albeit deeply melancholy,
- 20:52exploration of grief and the complexities of the human soul.
- 20:56If you want to understand the emotional infrastructure that
- 20:58drives our behavior, it is highly recommended.
- 21:01Definitely check that out. And, you know, if we connect
- 21:04everything we've explored today, from the realization that
- 21:07intelligence is best expressed through kindness to
- 21:10understanding that wealth merely amplifies our baseline character
- 21:14to the evolutionary reasons we crave the friction of meaningful
- 21:18work, it leads to a rather profound final thought.
- 21:21What is the ultimate take away? We spend our lives terrified of
- 21:25scarcity. But perhaps the greatest
- 21:28challenge awaiting us in the AI driven future isn't a crisis of
- 21:31scarcity at all. If the technology truly
- 21:34unleashes boundless productivity, the ultimate
- 21:37challenge of the next century won't be figuring out how to
- 21:39distribute wealth in a world of abundance.
- 21:41Now what will it be? It will be figuring out how to
- 21:44distribute purpose. Wow.
- 21:46How to distribute purpose? Exactly.
- 21:48If we rely solely on the cold logic of a compass that only
- 21:51points toward financial optimization, we will end up
- 21:55wandering through life hoarding tickets, completely starved for
- 21:58meaning. Perfectly said.
- 22:00Build the cognitive strength to be kind in a 0 sum world, Give
- 22:03your wealth with a warm hand and never stop seeking out the
- 22:07friction of a hard problem. Absolutely.
- 22:09Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive.
- 22:11Everyone. Take that final thought, Mull it
- 22:13over, and we will see you next time.