Latest / Chatter that Matters / Dr. Robert Sapolsky - Life Without Free Will
Transcript
- 0:00Here it is. Instructions to fit in, have everybody like you, and always
- 0:04be happy. Step 1. Where are we going? We know because we're being
- 0:08spontaneous. Somebody help me. We're
- 0:11being spontaneous. Like everyone else, you were born into bondage.
- 0:16Born into a prison that you cannot smell or taste or touch. A
- 0:19prison for your mind. Okay. So what if I'm not real? So
- 0:23what? Even if I'm not real, this moment
- 0:26is right here, right now.
- 0:33Imagine you're at your favorite coffee shop. You're ready to order.
- 0:38The barista asks, do you want a latte or black coffee?
- 0:41You pause, consider your options, and you confidently choose that
- 0:45latte. Now ask yourself, was that
- 0:49choice truly yours? We like to believe we're in control of our
- 0:52decisions, that we make choices freely.
- 0:56But what if I told you that my guest today believes that most of the
- 0:59decisions you've ever made, from what you ate this morning to your career
- 1:03path, were predetermined? What if the idea of free
- 1:07will was in fact an illusion? This is the belief of doctor
- 1:10Robert Sapolsky, a professor at Stanford University, where he
- 1:14holds positions in biology, neurology, and neurosurgery.
- 1:18He's also known for his work in primate behavior. He's the author of the book
- 1:22Determine, A Science of Life Without Free Will. By this
- 1:25point, we know enough about the science of how you
- 1:29came to be who you are that the owners of proof has
- 1:33switched. Sapolsky argues that all our actions are governed by biological
- 1:36and environmental factors, which leaves no room for true free
- 1:40will. Proof to us show us a mechanism by
- 1:44which a neuron, a brain, a person has
- 1:47done something, and it is completely freed
- 1:51from their biological history. And he has many fans.
- 1:55Bill Gates called Sapolsky's book, Behave, one of the best books he read in
- 1:592017, outlining how Sapolsky masterfully explains
- 2:03biology behind human behavior. Sam Harris, a neuroscientist and philosopher, refers to Sapolsky as
- 2:07one of the most interesting and eloquent scientists in the world. And Steve
- 2:10Pinker, who's been on my show, commended Sapolsky for his
- 2:14ability to merge biology and psychology,
- 2:19praising his work for offering deep insights into human behavior and
- 2:22decision making. Today, we'll unpack the question, do
- 2:26we really have free will? Are we really in the driver's seat?
- 2:30Is that steering wheel, our ability to accelerate or brake, even get out of the
- 2:34way just an illusion? Are you in fact
- 2:38meant to be? Hi.
- 2:42It's Tony Chapman. Thank you for listening to Chatter That Matters presented by
- 2:45RBC. If you can, please subscribe to the podcast. And
- 2:49ratings and reviews, well, they're always welcome, and they're always appreciated.
- 2:55Doctor Robert Sapolsky, welcome to Chatter That Matters. Well, thanks.
- 2:59Thanks for having me on. I'll begin by just talking about your journey
- 3:03into human behavior and the idea of free will. From what I
- 3:07understand, it really happened at an early age. It was kind of 14 where you
- 3:10started questioning what we're in charge of. So I'm I'm curious how
- 3:14somebody that young, instead of being out in a baseball field or or, you know,
- 3:17dealing with the hormones of puberty, had started having such big thinking.
- 3:21Well, first off, I was a horrendous athlete. I was brought up
- 3:25extremely religiously and believed all of it and was
- 3:29highly ritualistic. And circumstances were
- 3:33such, that I was having a religious crisis.
- 3:37It turned out to have transiently
- 3:41an illness for a few years, which turned out to be
- 3:45condemned in the old testament. Hey. Wait a
- 3:49second. God decrees that I have this
- 3:53medical problem, and yet my having this medical
- 3:56problem is viewed as some sort of insult, to
- 4:00god? What what's up with that? And this was causing a great
- 4:03deal of distress. One night, I woke up at 2
- 4:07in the morning, and it suddenly all made sense.
- 4:12There's no God. And as long as I was at it, just as
- 4:15an addendum, I added on that, oh, and there's no free will.
- 4:19And the universe is this huge empty,
- 4:23indifferent place with no meaning. How did that play at the
- 4:26dining room table with these? Not very well. And,
- 4:30just as a measure of it, my
- 4:34father went to his grave 20 years later
- 4:37having no idea that I had changed anything in my thinking. So
- 4:42And how did the whole animal fascination come in? Because the other thing that was
- 4:45really interesting is this, that you started really understanding that within the
- 4:49primate community, there was a lot of answers to that empty
- 4:53universe of yours. It, took the form oh, it was sort of
- 4:57the normal evolution in some ways. I I went
- 5:00from the predictable every play everyday
- 5:04obsession with dinosaurs to the
- 5:08mummies and that whole arc. And somehow, by the time
- 5:12I was about 10 or 11 and had settled down into primatology,
- 5:16the notion of hanging out with mountain gorillas, which I never got to do,
- 5:20unfortunately, but the notion of doing that seemed much preferable
- 5:23to any other option in life. And your the diversity of your academic
- 5:27background, maybe it made a lot of sense to you, but I read biology, anthropology,
- 5:31psychology. As you started moving through life, did any
- 5:35one triumph over the other? It's almost like rock, papers, and scissors, or was it
- 5:38just this fusion of all 3 that kinda just continued to lead you
- 5:42down this path? I was all set on primatology. I was
- 5:45writing fan letters to primatologists when I was in
- 5:49high school and stuff, and this one guy whose feet I
- 5:53was gonna study, I actually wound up being able
- 5:57to do that and was all set. I I studied
- 6:00Swahili in high school because I knew I was gonna do field work in East
- 6:03Africa someday. And I went off to college.
- 6:08He had a a minor heart attack my freshman year. He was
- 6:11fine. He lasted decades afterward, but he canceled his
- 6:15classes. So suddenly having an open slot somewhat
- 6:18arbitrarily, I took an intro neuroscience class
- 6:22and was blown away by that, and that started
- 6:26this, like, great divide. So am I a
- 6:30lab scientist, or I'm supposed to be wearing hiking shoes every day for the rest
- 6:34of my life? This lightning rod that you've attached to
- 6:37yourself, this concept of free will, and you've even described it as a
- 6:40lunatic fringe. How did that come about that you
- 6:44decided that you're gonna stand against a lot of people
- 6:48that would challenge you because you're just challenging the very essence of what humans think
- 6:52they are that we're in control? How did that come about, and how did you
- 6:55decide that you'd be, I mean, courageous enough to say, I'm gonna make this statement,
- 6:58and I'm gonna continue to defend it? Thank you for using the word courageous.
- 7:02It was just self evident. You look at enough
- 7:07biology factoids, and I think maybe the
- 7:10fact that I was straddling a number of different fields, the field
- 7:14primatology. I was So also getting ecology and
- 7:18physiological ecology and evolution stuff, and ultimately,
- 7:22some of the baboon work I was doing had me talking a lot
- 7:26to biological psychiatrists. Whereas the
- 7:29lab work was like with molecular people
- 7:33and eventually neurology types. And I think, sir, you collect
- 7:36enough factoids from enough different areas and your
- 7:4014 year old intuition that there's no free will, you you
- 7:44suddenly feel like you could back it up. We're biological machines.
- 7:48We're made of the same stuff as, like, squid are. We're
- 7:51just a fancier version and you throw enough pieces of that stuff
- 7:55together and out emerges some human attributes.
- 7:59So in your book Determine, one of the things I I really smiled at is
- 8:02you said focusing on intents, like reviewing a movie based on its final
- 8:06minutes. Why did you feel that one of the easiest ways for people to at
- 8:09least understand it is that they needed to consider the entire story
- 8:13versus just the, the happy ending? Because the ending, when
- 8:17you make one of those earth shattering choices as to whether or not you're gonna
- 8:21have tea or coffee or whether or not send your
- 8:24army over the border into the neighboring country. Like, in
- 8:28that moment, it is so intuitively just
- 8:32palpable that you there's a you in there.
- 8:36There's a you in there that's somehow separate of that biology
- 8:40yuck, and that you has formed an intent and is
- 8:43acting on it. And the problem is that it
- 8:47ignores the 99% of the book that
- 8:51preceded that, which is so how do you turn out to be the sort
- 8:54of person who would form that intent at that moment?
- 8:59How do you wind up being someone with
- 9:03your values, someone with your luxuries and privileges,
- 9:07someone with your attitude, someone with your traumas.
- 9:10So how do you wind up being that person? And when you
- 9:14look at the nuts and bolts of it, it's entirely made
- 9:18up of the biology that random luck handed
- 9:22you over which you had no control. And it's interactions with
- 9:25environment that random luck handed you. These paths you followed, at
- 9:29least when I started researching it, there's some there's some randomness in it.
- 9:33Do you think it's just this was just meant to unfold like dominoes that way?
- 9:36Basically, yeah. And where one gets mistaken
- 9:41as to thinking they're seeing free will is at some point you could reach in
- 9:45and mess with the dominoes a bit and bias them in one direction or
- 9:48another. And we confuse that with us just having had
- 9:52agency because that's much easier than seeing,
- 9:56oh, not only like have I become
- 10:00in effect in reality a biological machine, but a
- 10:04fancy one who has some insights into the buttons and
- 10:07the levers on the biological machine. Society seems to try
- 10:11to harness the masses by the give and take. You know, you go to a
- 10:15church and the sunshine's coming through the, the, the stained glass window, everything
- 10:19looks beautiful. You go over the other side, it's hell, risk and
- 10:22reward. It's always trying to set up these boundaries to kind of herd
- 10:26people like cattle. Is that a factor that factors into
- 10:29this whole concept of determine that really society is just an
- 10:33algorithm that's kind of set this up to streamline how we're born,
- 10:37what's our biology and science tells us what we're gonna do. Basically, but in
- 10:40a way where much of the time that's only one of
- 10:44the players and often a fairly minor one. Something that
- 10:48utterly fascinates me is the fact that different cultures
- 10:51developed into the being the cultures they are not by accident.
- 10:55What have been some of the ecological factors that influenced
- 10:59who becomes polygamists and who becomes
- 11:03polytheists and who becomes warrior class driven
- 11:06societies and all that kind and that then immediately
- 11:11determines what mom was doing with you within minutes of birth
- 11:15as a mechanism for replicating those values in the next
- 11:19generation. So, yeah, that's part of it, but, you know, there's lots of other
- 11:22levels of it. The reality is that when you're
- 11:26looking at when we carry out a behavior, one where
- 11:30we may mistakenly think that there was a me in there
- 11:34separate of of all the materialism and one that had
- 11:37just acted with free intent, you ask where that
- 11:41came from, and that came from whatever neurons hiccuped a
- 11:44millisecond ago, and it came from whatever environmental
- 11:48stimuli triggered those neurons in the previous minute.
- 11:52And it came from this morning's hormone levels, and it came
- 11:55from what trauma or stimulation or whatever changed the
- 11:59structure of your brain in the previous months, which came
- 12:03from your adolescence and your childhood and your fetal life and your
- 12:06genes and then the culture that got handed
- 12:10to you and you put all those pieces together, where'd that
- 12:14behavior come from? And it's from everything that came
- 12:17before. There's not a damn crack anywhere in that edifice that
- 12:21you could shoehorn in the notion that every now and
- 12:25then, your brain can do something completely free of
- 12:28its history. Talk to me about when you shuffle the deck. I mean, you
- 12:32talk about culture and how that certain cultures are wired a certain
- 12:36way. What happens now as a society as we start merging the
- 12:39tribes? Is that something that's gonna completely change the human race?
- 12:43Yeah. You have all sorts of residues of these mixtures.
- 12:47And by now, you know, walk around downtown
- 12:51Manhattan or Tokyo or London
- 12:54or Lagos, and you may perhaps be
- 12:58seeing what's an admixture by now, but go to the more isolated
- 13:01places, and you still see the very, very heavy imprint of the
- 13:05singular culture. But if nothing else, 60,
- 13:0970 percent of the humans on earth are believers in
- 13:13some version of a religion that emerged
- 13:16from the desert of the Middle East over the last
- 13:204000 years. How'd that turn out? Some
- 13:23illiterate shepherds came up with different views about, like, what the
- 13:27answers are to the unanswerable, and now most of
- 13:31Earth celebrates, like, Christmas. Do you see yourself as one
- 13:34of those shepherds, modern day shepherd that's just kinda trying to
- 13:38figure how things are? Yeah. You know, we're all trying to figure out how
- 13:42things work. And, my particular version I stumbled
- 13:45into is it looks undeniable to me that we work
- 13:49like biological machines. We're really
- 13:52weird ones because we could know that we're biological
- 13:56machines, and that generates all sorts of
- 13:59ripples of neurosis and anxiety
- 14:03and heroism and being part of
- 14:07something bigger than yourself and all that stuff. But it's just
- 14:10spin offs from the fact that, you know, you look at the building
- 14:14blocks of a sea snail and you look at us and a sea snail
- 14:18can learn how to do something. It could learn to retract
- 14:22its gill if you bop it on the head repeatedly, and it
- 14:25learns that that's like a scary thing so that each time
- 14:29you you couple the bopping with some random signal, it now
- 14:33retracts its gill. Oh, let's spend 30 years as
- 14:36probably the best living neuroscientist did, taking that apart down
- 14:40to the level of molecules. And it turns out it's the exact
- 14:44same molecules in us when we learn to
- 14:48be afraid of a type of people we never knew about
- 14:51before. We use the same molecule. You can you can do
- 14:54genetic engineering and stick some of our genes into a sea slug,
- 14:58and it works in the same exact networks. We're made of the same
- 15:02stuff. All that we've got going for us is quantity.
- 15:06You put together, like, 80,000,000,000 neurons instead of, like,
- 15:10the 100,000 in the sea slug, and
- 15:13out pops theology and aesthetics
- 15:17and economic viewpoints, and
- 15:21who knows what else, an obsession with the Kardashians. How do you
- 15:24deal with the sense that can can somebody transform? Can they
- 15:28change their course in life? Can they become a better human being? Can they find
- 15:32empathy and compassion if their biology and environment
- 15:36hasn't set them up for that kind of success? You've touched on sort
- 15:39of the second of what I've used, the 3 ways in
- 15:43which people go off the rails and decide they're absolutely seeing
- 15:47free will in action. The first one is when you very consciously make
- 15:50a decision in that moment, it seems inconceivable that
- 15:54there's not a you in there that's separate of all those neurons.
- 15:59Second is when you look at somebody who's had lousy circumstances
- 16:03and yet through, like, some incredible display
- 16:06of tenacity and self discipline, they
- 16:10come out, woah. They made themselves a self
- 16:14made person. Pulling one up by one's bootstraps is
- 16:17inherently a belief that there's a me in there that's separate of the
- 16:21biology, and that one is really tempting. And the third one is
- 16:24the one you bring up, which is stuff changes.
- 16:28People change. Society's changed dramatically. I mean, there's
- 16:32there's at least a handful of ex white supremacists
- 16:36out there who pay money to painfully have their, like,
- 16:39tattoo swastikas. Remove people change.
- 16:44And where that seems to be free will
- 16:48out the wazoo is the fact that in those circumstances,
- 16:52people mistakenly believe that someone
- 16:55chooses to change, and that simply
- 16:59is not the case. What happens instead is we are
- 17:03changed. We are changed by circumstance, and
- 17:06the way in which we are changed by whatever circumstance gets thrown at
- 17:10us is entirely a function of who we turned out to
- 17:14be when we went in and experienced that change. In
- 17:17an interview you did with Michael Shermer, you mentioned the concept of useful
- 17:21fiction. Rather than there's no free will, that's how the world
- 17:25works, it's kind of a drag, suck it up. My view
- 17:29is actually rejecting free will is wonderfully liberating.
- 17:33And throughout history, every time we figure it
- 17:37out, here's a circumstance of human behavior
- 17:40where, woah, it turns out they had no
- 17:44control over it. It wasn't their fault that they were like this.
- 17:48Every time we've done that, the world's become a more
- 17:52humane place. For most people, jettisoning the
- 17:55notion of free will is enormously liberating
- 17:59because we got a world that works on the notion
- 18:03that it's okay, that some people get treated way better
- 18:07than average for stuff they had nothing to do with, and some people get treated
- 18:10way worse. And getting rid of the notion that there's
- 18:14anything other than just random stupid luck. I wouldn't
- 18:18say the world's in a great place right now. Is there anything from what you've
- 18:21studied that we can use as a society to
- 18:25change for the better? You know, this is a world of a huge amount
- 18:29of misery and inequality.
- 18:34The the most pernicious thing about inequality is
- 18:37when it's not only just permeating everywhere,
- 18:41corroding everywhere, but you've managed to get societal
- 18:45beliefs that there's somehow justice built
- 18:49around inequality. People get what they deserve.
- 18:53People wind up in a way that has to do with
- 18:57justice and entitlement and
- 19:00earning one's position in life and things of that sort. I would say
- 19:04if I have to reduce all of these science
- 19:08factoids, which collectively said we're just biological machines and that's
- 19:12where behavior comes from, if you think you
- 19:15understand why somebody just did what they did, the odds
- 19:19are pretty good that you're wrong because you don't
- 19:23really understand how it turned out that that's how they
- 19:26function. Or maybe another way of stating it is any time
- 19:30you're about to like judge someone, especially when it's harshly,
- 19:34especially when it's moralistically, stop instead and figure
- 19:38out how did they become that sort of machine.
- 19:42And every time you think you deserve better treatment or
- 19:46entitled to something, ask the exact same question and nowhere
- 19:49in there is agency going to be the answer. But
- 19:53what's the answer? Somebody is wired to be a pedophile,
- 19:56that assaulting another human being is just within their DNA.
- 20:00How do we address that as a society if we have to have the compassion
- 20:04that that's just who they are, but at the same time, protect the rest of
- 20:08society from who they are. We do it exactly
- 20:11as we deal with 5 year olds with nose colds.
- 20:15300 years ago, illness and moral
- 20:19worth was intertwined in Europe and if you got sick
- 20:23it was God punishing you for, or if a kid got sick it was
- 20:26punishing the parents for their sins. And like, okay, we got a
- 20:30different view of illness now. If your 5
- 20:34year old gets a nose cold, that is not a moral failure on their part.
- 20:38You do not preach at them. But nonetheless, sometimes you gotta protect
- 20:41society from them, which is if your 5 year old is sneezing, you
- 20:45keep them home from kindergarten tomorrow because they're
- 20:48dangerous. They're a danger to society. And the kindergarten
- 20:52teachers say, you know, if your kid has a cold, please keep them home so
- 20:55they don't get everybody else sick, and you constrain their
- 20:59behavior. You impose what is literally
- 21:02a public health quarantine model, which is you make sure your
- 21:06kid can't hurt, harm anybody else, but you don't do
- 21:10an inch more than that. You don't tell them, and you can't play with your
- 21:14toys today because you're sneezing and you're rotten and you don't preach to
- 21:17them. And if that seems inconceivable to us that
- 21:21we do that with, like, a vicious, affectless,
- 21:25remorseless, sociopathic, and nightmare of a human,
- 21:30we've done it before. When people figured out that, oh,
- 21:34sociopathic, remorseless people don't control
- 21:38the weather. And when there's a sudden hailstorm and your medieval
- 21:41crops are destroyed, it's not the work of witches. And
- 21:45it's a better world when we don't burn people at the stake anymore. It's a
- 21:48better world when we figured out, you know,
- 21:52airplane pilots with hay fever who've taken
- 21:56an antihistamine and were drowsy. They can't
- 22:00be pilot for the next 3 days until there's all these
- 22:03ways in which you can impose, in
- 22:07a sense, public health models, figure out how to
- 22:11make this person not dangerous to people anymore,
- 22:14and constrain them in that way. And don't do it an inch
- 22:18beyond that, and don't moralize about it. And as long as
- 22:22you're at it, put a lot of effort into understanding how people like that
- 22:25turned out to be that way and get a root cause so that's less
- 22:29likely to happen in the future. But what if someone like your with your
- 22:32knowledge was in power instead of having the
- 22:36empathy that you do, they said, listen. This person's never gonna change.
- 22:40There's no redemption. Let's bring back the death penalty. Are we
- 22:43not concerned that this knowledge in the wrong hands could be
- 22:47abused beyond belief? It won't work or it sure as
- 22:51hell shouldn't work. They had nothing to do
- 22:55with how they turned out that way. And you know what? If they
- 22:58have an itchy back and someone scratches it, they
- 23:02feel better. It's a nicer life for them for 2 seconds
- 23:05there. If they are still capable of
- 23:09experiencing things and they do
- 23:13not deserve because there's no such thing as deserve. There's
- 23:16nothing earned. There's nothing entitled. They
- 23:20have no more or less claim to having their
- 23:23needs considered than that of any other random human who
- 23:27turned out to be who they are. When
- 23:31we return, more with doctor Robert Sapolsky, and we go
- 23:35back and forth in this conversation of free will or lack thereof. We
- 23:38even talk about how it could apply when raising a child,
- 23:42and, of course, my 3 takeaways.
- 23:47Hi. It's Tony Chapman. You know, I thought this would be the perfect episode to
- 23:51share some news about the RBC's foundation and their commitment to
- 23:55stronger communities. What they've done is launch a new community infrastructure
- 23:59fund. The end game is to make our community spaces more sustainable and
- 24:02accessible through retrofits, repairs, and upgrades. The best way to think
- 24:06about what they're doing is to think about a hospital that's easier to navigate, or
- 24:09a community center that's more energy efficient, or a
- 24:13vibrant cultural hub that's more welcoming. That's the future RBC
- 24:16Foundation's investing in, and it's all part of RBC Foundation's $2,000,000,000
- 24:20commitment to funding ideas for people and planet over the next 10 years. If
- 24:24you're a registered charity, and you want to apply for funding, head to rbc.com.
- 24:29Enhancing the sustainability and accessibility of buildings, well that
- 24:32matters to you, to me, and to RBC.
- 24:38You make a choice. You choose something. You're choosing
- 24:42flavor of ice cream. You're you form an intent, and you act on
- 24:45it. For most people, that is necessary and sufficient to
- 24:49decide you had free will. How did you turn out to
- 24:53be the sort of person who would have that intent?
- 24:57Where did that intent come from? My guest
- 25:00today is doctor Robert Sapolsky. He's a renowned neuroscientist
- 25:04at Stanford University. And we're talking about his book, Determined, A
- 25:08Science of Life Without Free Will, and his argument that our free will
- 25:11is just an illusion. It's shaped by biology and environment. And if
- 25:15that's the case, that challenges traditional views of moral responsibility.
- 25:19Be curious how you think at the end of this episode.
- 25:23I'd love to see you in a debate with somebody. What's the best debate you've
- 25:27been in, toe to toe, and at the end of it, you walked out
- 25:30smiling, going, we both held our own, and we both
- 25:34feel we've improved our position. What was the most
- 25:38interesting one was when I had during the fall with the philosopher
- 25:42Daniel Dennett. He was one of the most visible
- 25:45strident atheists out there, but was a total
- 25:49mess of a philosopher insofar as he
- 25:53somehow saw there was still free will out there. People
- 25:56turn out to be the way they are because there's a lot of
- 26:00things that you earn. And if the picture is good, it's
- 26:04because you're entitled to it and having
- 26:08ridiculous statements in all of his writing to the effect not even
- 26:12to the effect of this is, like, verbatim, luck evens
- 26:15out over time. Good luck and bad luck even out over
- 26:19time. And thus people shouldn't cite luck when complaining about
- 26:23how things turned out not so great for them. And the reality is
- 26:27that starting with like the most basic biology to the most basic
- 26:31sociology, good luck is likely to amplify
- 26:34over time, and bad luck is likely to amplify, and they diverge
- 26:38further and further over the course of their life. So we had
- 26:42a debate, which turned out to be remarkably
- 26:46frustrating, because I think all he
- 26:49was saying at the end is, damn. It just seems
- 26:53so intuitively obvious that there's free will.
- 26:56Wow. And when you dissected his arguments,
- 27:01intuition is a really lousy
- 27:04guideline for figuring out how things work because, consistently,
- 27:08intuition kinda takes you up dead ends. So we had a
- 27:12debate, and they did, like, the most, like, embarrassing
- 27:15thing that beforehand, the moderator asked the audience to
- 27:19vote on whether or not there was free will, and, like, 30% of
- 27:23people thought there was no free will. And then afterward, he asked him
- 27:26again, and now most of the people in the audience no longer believed in
- 27:30free will and, woah, what a triumph and all of that. You know, it
- 27:34was cool. It was very stimulating in the sense of seeing all the
- 27:37ways in which his stance did not have much
- 27:41more to it other than, damn, it's gonna be really
- 27:44uncomfortable to admit that there's no free will. Are you ever
- 27:49concerned that what you've uncovered, this gives
- 27:53people with the wrong intention, the ability to
- 27:56in fact manipulate society if they can in fact rewire
- 28:01where we're meant to be? One of those like comforting
- 28:04things is, you know, life is not only stranger than we
- 28:08imagine, it's stranger than we can imagine. Every time you
- 28:12answer a question, you generate 10 new ones, and it's
- 28:16a pretty complicated system. Nonetheless,
- 28:20we have ways of modifying behavior with interventions.
- 28:24We're not at the point of doing it with, like, CRISPR ing
- 28:28somebody's genome into being different, and it is beyond
- 28:31terrifying that that seems inevitable that that's gonna,
- 28:35like, fester in various outposts. There's been one case of
- 28:39it so far. But, you know, we do the same thing with
- 28:43propaganda. We do the same thing with advertising. We do the same thing
- 28:46when we convince people that they really need to change second
- 28:50messenger pathways in their brain in the morning by
- 28:54drinking coffee and having caffeine do that in order to be alert.
- 28:58Every time scientists come up with something, there has
- 29:02tragically been ideologues who were willing to seize it and run
- 29:06with it. And some of the time, it's been scientists themselves who've decided
- 29:10this time to put on a brown shirt and start goosestepping.
- 29:14I think if the only
- 29:18logical outcomes of saying there's no free will is
- 29:21blame and punishment make no sense, praise and
- 29:25reward make no sense, Feeling as if you are
- 29:29more morally worthy than any other human makes no
- 29:32sense, and that you've earned nothing and are entitled to nothing more than
- 29:36anyone else. I don't know. I guess somebody could be
- 29:40creative and produce a truly miserable dystopian
- 29:44world out of that. But I think what it mostly does is
- 29:48it's gotta make you realize, like,
- 29:51you're nothing special. Nobody else is deserving of
- 29:55negative judgment, of condemnation, and hating
- 29:59someone makes as little sense as hating an earthquake. Dan
- 30:02Ariely was on my show, and obviously his passion is behavioral economics.
- 30:06You've gotta be violently opposed to the whole concept
- 30:10that we can change someone's behavior by, you know,
- 30:13nudges and, you know. Of course, he can. You know,
- 30:17the the danger there is deciding that the
- 30:20nudges and tools of behavior economics are
- 30:24more powerful than they actually are, that they explain everything
- 30:28because they don't, because neurochemistry doesn't explain
- 30:31everything and endocrinology doesn't and
- 30:35physiological ecology doesn't, and none of them do. You put all the pieces
- 30:39together, but you could change somebody's
- 30:42sociopolitical view by what the smell is
- 30:46in the room they're sitting in. You could change the likelihood
- 30:50of somebody being a conservative or liberal
- 30:53depending on the stress hormone levels they were exposed to when they were a
- 30:57fetus. You you know, all of these influences are
- 31:01coming in. The the infectious disease
- 31:05load that your ancestors were dealing with
- 31:08400 years ago is a significant predictor today of
- 31:12the levels of xenophobia in your culture. What
- 31:15scientists tend to do for a living is overinflate the
- 31:19importance of the particular sliver they've just spent their
- 31:22entire lifetime on, but you put all
- 31:26the pieces together. So, yeah, behavioral economics, that's
- 31:30great. We're not rational decision making machines optimizing
- 31:33whatever, and that's fascinating stuff. And that's great,
- 31:37but that's, you know, one part of the whole thing. There's a
- 31:41lot of parents that'll be listening to this and going, so how
- 31:45do I parent my children? Is there anything I can do? Do I have any,
- 31:48anything that I can impact or is in
- 31:52fact, who I gave birth to is really who they
- 31:55are? No, because you're influencing them
- 31:59enormously depending on what culture you're in
- 32:03within minutes of birth. Teach them if they
- 32:06wanna judge somebody else, they should stop and think how
- 32:10do they become that way and how do they become that way in ways that
- 32:14I've never experienced and can't even imagine. You teach them
- 32:17when they think that it's not fair, that they're not getting
- 32:21something, that fair is not a relevant concept, and they
- 32:25did not earn the good things they have. They're just damn
- 32:28lucky, and they should keep that in mind. It doesn't make any sense to
- 32:32hate anyone. And if someone comes up to you
- 32:36and says something like, woah. I'm so grateful that you just
- 32:40did that kind thing to me. They're not making any sense because what
- 32:44they should be saying is, I'm so grateful that you happen
- 32:47to turn out to be the sort of person who could be kind to me
- 32:50just now. And if that's said to you enough times,
- 32:54you no longer say, woah, I am so impressive that,
- 32:58you wind up saying, woah, I guess I'm kind of grateful that I turned out
- 33:02to be that sort of person also. If kids are brought
- 33:06up that their basic view is they see someone
- 33:09different and whatever the judgment is,
- 33:13if their first thought is how that person turned out to be like
- 33:17that, kids have to wind up being
- 33:20adults who are less judgmental and less
- 33:24entitled and all those good things. So Determines coming
- 33:28out in paperback, somebody was to buy this book
- 33:32and read it. If you could just say, there's one thing I'd love them to
- 33:35think about at the end of it, would it be just about the sense of
- 33:38judging and empathy, or would there be something even more than that?
- 33:42Basically, I'd be happy with just that. That's, that's plenty.
- 33:46You know, on a certain level, you study biology, and it has
- 33:50to ultimately be a mechanism of
- 33:54social justice. Because you see us and you
- 33:57see squid and you see how all of it works, and you gotta reach
- 34:01some conclusions, which taken to their logical extent has
- 34:05to make the world more humane. And if you thought about the
- 34:09human race, a 100 years, 500 years, a 1000 years from
- 34:13now, does it continue? Or is it is just the way we're
- 34:16wired that we have a certain life cycle on this planet like almost
- 34:20every other living creature? You know, I would have predicted we're gonna
- 34:24be a completely dystopian nightmare,
- 34:28fairly soon. We seem to be holding that at bay. Global warming may
- 34:31hand us that. Now if things work out,
- 34:36people in the future will look back at us and be as
- 34:39horrified at our ignorance and our
- 34:43societal assumptions than we are when
- 34:46we look back and see that, oh my god. People used to believe that
- 34:50old ladies with no teeth at the edge of the hamlet could control the
- 34:54weather. Hopefully, they're not gonna be too self congratulatory about the
- 34:58fact that they've, like, managed to crawl their way a little bit more in
- 35:01the direction of this being a more humane place to be a
- 35:05a human. But, you know, we're we're moving in that
- 35:09direction. If you ever found peace, whatever you were brought on this planet
- 35:12for seems to be this insatiable appetite for knowledge
- 35:16and curating and synthesizing and
- 35:20digesting and do you ever have a chance to just
- 35:23relax or is this constantly kind of being how you've been ordained?
- 35:27Is this is this is who I am until I leave the planet?
- 35:31I've got some pretty clear,
- 35:35things that explain how I turned out, how I am. If if
- 35:38nothing else, my my parents traumatized me to the
- 35:42exact perfect extent so that I would, like, wind up being
- 35:46able to be a successful academic, not an inch more or less.
- 35:49But, you know, I see where some of that stuff comes from. I don't know.
- 35:53I'm at the very least a lot mentally
- 35:56healthier and happier once I met my wife about
- 36:0035 years ago, and my life was transformed by that. And I
- 36:03decided that, like, living alone in a tent with a bunch of baboons in East
- 36:07Africa was no longer my model for sociality.
- 36:12Everything that I took out of the 14 year old
- 36:16conclusion about how things work was pretty grim.
- 36:20It has settled much better in me since then,
- 36:24focusing on the liberating aspects
- 36:28of all this depressing knowledge and focusing
- 36:31on, you know, we're biological machines, but
- 36:35we're totally weird ones and that we're capable of thinking, we're
- 36:39having emotions, and thus we're capable of having emotions.
- 36:44That softens the blow a little bit over the years.
- 36:48You know, Robert, I always end with my 3 takeaways and it's interesting
- 36:51enough that as you talked about at the end of how your parents traumatized you,
- 36:55but I think their their love and passion for religion that almost cost
- 36:58you your life was a great gift because it did fuel
- 37:02that brain at 14 to decide, you know, I I could let
- 37:06puberty take over my body, but I'm actually gonna just come to some conclusions
- 37:09that I think at a very early age, most of us wouldn't even factor
- 37:13in. The you chased this in so many different ways, with so many different degrees,
- 37:17in so many different parts of the world, is fascinating me because
- 37:21maybe it wasn't your free will and this is how you ordained, but I do
- 37:24believe that when somebody finds something in life, if they just
- 37:28continue to chase it, it's an interesting roller coaster between highs
- 37:31and lows. And it sounds like you've had many of those. But I think the
- 37:35thing that I celebrate the most is just the fact that you do
- 37:38believe in humans, that you do hope that
- 37:42there's a way that we can be less judgmental,
- 37:46less entitled, and much more empathetic about just
- 37:49realizing that everybody is all part of one race. And maybe if we can
- 37:53just think about it that way, we could have a better race to the future.
- 37:56It's absolutely ridiculous to think that something
- 38:00good or bad can never happen to a machine.
- 38:04But nonetheless, it's a good thing when, like, pain
- 38:07is lessened. Pain is painful even though we're
- 38:11machines. Happiness
- 38:15is fragile, is wonderful. Like, yeah, it's
- 38:19a better world if there's less pain. Thanks for having me
- 38:22on. Once again, a special thanks to RBC for
- 38:26supporting Chatter That Matters. It's Tony Chapman. Thanks for
- 38:29listening, and let's chat soon.