Latest / Deep Dive / Democracy: A Sacred Right or Just a Tool?
Transcript
- 0:00We all know the quote, right? The famous one.
- 0:04Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the
- 0:07others. Oh yeah, classic.
- 0:09Right. And you just, you picture
- 0:11Winston Churchill, you know, chomping on cigar, flashing the
- 0:14V for victory and just dropping this heavy, unassailable
- 0:18pragmatism on the world. Exactly.
- 0:21It's the ultimate mic drop. But here's the twist.
- 0:25Churchill didn't write it. No, he didn't at all.
- 0:28He. Was essentially just well, he
- 0:29was retweeting an anonymous source.
- 0:31It's entirely borrowed. And yet, I mean, that single
- 0:34line has become this, this ultimate rhetorical safety net
- 0:38for Western political thought. Yeah.
- 0:40Like whenever the system is gridlocked, or, you know, an
- 0:43election yields some completely baffling result, someone
- 0:46inevitably deploys that exact quote to just shut the
- 0:49conversation down. Right, because it implies that
- 0:52questioning the system itself is just.
- 0:54It's a fool's errand. Exactly.
- 0:56Which is exactly the taboo we are breaking today.
- 0:58So welcome to this deep dive. Because today, for you
- 1:00listening, we are taking the concept of democracy completely
- 1:03off its pedestal. Taking it right down.
- 1:05Yeah. We aren't going to treat it as
- 1:08a, you know, a sacred religion or some unquestionable moral
- 1:11absolute. We're going to put it on the
- 1:13surgical table and really examine it as a piece of social
- 1:16technology, like an actual mechanical tool.
- 1:18And we have to ask the hard question, is this tool actually
- 1:21working or is it secretly breaking the people who use it?
- 1:26And to do that, we are synthesizing a really
- 1:30fascinating stack of materials today.
- 1:32The wild stack. It really is.
- 1:34We have historical archives from Richard M Langworth.
- 1:36He's a senior fellow at the Hillsdale College Churchill
- 1:38Project, documenting what Churchill actually believed.
- 1:42We are also looking at a highly unusual letter from an academic
- 1:46medical journal that tries to apply democratic theory to
- 1:51hospital radiology departments of all things.
- 1:53Which is just bizarre, but so good.
- 1:55Oh, it's incredible. And then we have the minutes
- 1:56from a really contentious philosophical panel at the Lemon
- 1:59School of Economics. And anchoring our entire
- 2:02analysis is this paradigm shifting, deeply controversial
- 2:05book by a political philosopher named Jason Brennan, and it's
- 2:09called Against Democracy. So before we jump in, I want to
- 2:12clarify right up front for you listening.
- 2:14We are not taking sides on the modern political spectrum here.
- 2:18Absolutely not. We aren't championing the left
- 2:20or the right or the center. We are just looking impartially
- 2:23at the foundational machinery of voting itself.
- 2:27Just the mechanics. Exactly.
- 2:29And let's start with that Churchill myth, because the
- 2:32reality of what actually happened in the House of Commons
- 2:35on November 11, 1947? It perfectly sets up our
- 2:41cultural blindness to this topic.
- 2:43Yeah. So on that specific day,
- 2:45Churchill stood before the Commons and said, and this is
- 2:48straight from Langworth's archival research, right?
- 2:51He says indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form
- 2:54of government, except for all those other forms that have been
- 2:57tried from time to time. It has been said.
- 2:59Exactly. He explicitly prefaces it with
- 3:01that he was just amplifying an unsourced aphorism that was sort
- 3:04of floating around at the time. So he was acting as a publicist,
- 3:06just basically not a philosopher.
- 3:08Right, but because of his massive historical gravity, you
- 3:12know the phrase just permanently fused to his legacy.
- 3:14But Langworth points out that Churchill did actually have his
- 3:17own highly specific views on the mechanics of democracy.
- 3:21Right. He did.
- 3:22Back in 1944. He delivered a quote that is
- 3:26entirely his own and it paints a very, very different picture.
- 3:29What did he say? Well, he praised what he called
- 3:33the little man, walking into the little booth with a little
- 3:36pencil, making a little cross on a little bit of paper.
- 3:40Wow. Yeah, he argued that no amount
- 3:43of grand rhetoric could really diminish the overwhelming
- 3:46importance of that single, quiet act.
- 3:48I mean, that really strips away the massive state apparatus,
- 3:51doesn't it? It zooms all the way in on the
- 3:53micro mechanics. Totally.
- 3:54The individual citizen, the tiny pencil, the scrap of paper.
- 3:58It highly romanticizes the procedure itself.
- 4:01It does. And that micro focus leads us
- 4:03directly into our second source, which honestly is one of the
- 4:06most unexpected applications of this kind of democratic
- 4:09romanticism I've ever seen. Oh, it's so strange.
- 4:11Right, we are jumping from the fate of global empires to a
- 4:15hospital radiology department. Yeah.
- 4:17So this is a letter published in the Journal of the American
- 4:20College of Radiology by a doctor, Arnold C Friedman.
- 4:24OK. And what Friedman does is he
- 4:26takes that overarching cultural reference for democracy, that
- 4:30little pencil energy, and he attempts to use it as a
- 4:33diagnostic tool for his own highly specialized profession.
- 4:37So he's looking at his actual workplace.
- 4:39Right. He essentially looks around and
- 4:41asks, if democracy is the ultimate virtuous method of
- 4:45human organization, why are academic medical departments
- 4:49structured like absolute dictatorships?
- 4:51And he's not exaggerating, right?
- 4:52He describes these hospital departments as pure oligarchies.
- 4:55Pure oligarchies. You have a department chair who
- 4:58wields absolute, basically unchecked authority over the
- 5:01faculty. Wow.
- 5:02The chair dictates the clinical schedules.
- 5:04They allocate the research funding.
- 5:06Yeah, they decide who gets access to the best imaging
- 5:08equipment. They control tenure tracks.
- 5:10The decision making just flows entirely from the top.
- 5:13Down so the faculty are never actually asked what they think.
- 5:15Never. They are just told what to
- 5:17execute. Man, and you can trace the
- 5:20psychological fallout of that kind of structure pretty easily.
- 5:23Oh, absolutely. Like.
- 5:24When highly educated, highly specialized clinical faculty,
- 5:29the people who are actually reading the scans, diagnosing
- 5:31the tumors, grinding through that daily workload, when they
- 5:35are entirely stripped of agency, the result is just profound
- 5:40alienation. Friedman notes that they feel 0
- 5:43ownership over their own department.
- 5:45Right. They're localized ground level
- 5:48expertise is completely ignored by leadership and that just
- 5:52leads to inferior operational decisions.
- 5:54And morale collapse. Completely collapses.
- 5:56So Friedman looks at this crisis of burnout, and he proposes what
- 6:01he views as this elegant, foolproof prescription.
- 6:04He says bring the ballot box to the hospital.
- 6:06Yes, he enthusiastically suggests that academic chairs
- 6:09should not be appointed from above anymore, but elected from
- 6:12below by the faculty. He wants term limits.
- 6:14He wants the faculty to hold recall power over their boss.
- 6:17It's a full political revolution in the MRI ward.
- 6:19Pretty much. He does throw in this really
- 6:21funny caveat, though. He insists there should be
- 6:24absolutely no campaigning allowed on the hospital floor.
- 6:26Right, He jokes that nobody wants to hear a radiologist
- 6:30giving a stump speech, saying read my lips.
- 6:33No 247 in house attending coverage.
- 6:36Which is a great line, but underneath the humor, Friedman
- 6:40is making a massive, totally unexamined philosophical
- 6:43assumption. What's the assumption?
- 6:45He's assuming that the mere introduction of democratic
- 6:48mechanics, you know, the little pencil and the little paper,
- 6:50will automatically cure the morale crisis and inherently
- 6:54produce better administrative outcomes.
- 6:56He assumes the tool itself possesses this kind of magic
- 7:00restorative property. But wait, hold on.
- 7:02Does simply giving a group of like, exhausted, frustrated
- 7:05doctors the ability to vote actually guarantee a better
- 7:09schedule or a fair distribution of equipment time?
- 7:13That's the question. Or does it just introduce, you
- 7:15know, office politics, factionalism, and popularity
- 7:17contests into a literal life or death medical environment?
- 7:20Exactly. But Friedman just takes it as a
- 7:22given that democracy always equals virtue.
- 7:25And that assumption, that unquestioned faith, is exactly
- 7:28what brings us to the London School of Economics.
- 7:31Because while Doctor Friedman represents the unquestioning
- 7:33faith in the mechanism, the LSE panel represents the
- 7:36intellectual rebellion against it.
- 7:38Right. So in October 2016, the LSE
- 7:40hosted this forum featuring political activists and
- 7:43theorists prominently, including Beatrix Campbell and Peter
- 7:47Hallward. OK.
- 7:48And the event was titled, very provocatively, The Worst Form of
- 7:52Government with a Question Mark. And just adding that question
- 7:55mark is treated like a major scandal in modern discourse.
- 7:58Oh, completely. The event notes reveal this
- 8:00really fascinating cultural tension.
- 8:03The panelists pointed out that in Western societies, we hold
- 8:07the sentiment of that fake Churchill quote so dogmatically
- 8:11that if you merely question the basic efficacy of the voting
- 8:13system, you are instantly marginalized.
- 8:16You're just branded and extremists.
- 8:17Immediately, the LSE panelists were highlighting a severe
- 8:20intellectual bottleneck. Beatrix Campbell, for instance,
- 8:23has spent her whole career analyzing how power structures
- 8:26operate right, And her critique at forms like this often centers
- 8:29on how the label of democracy is essentially used to launder
- 8:32systemic inequality. OK, let's drill into that.
- 8:35That's a strong phrase. How does the label launder the
- 8:38reality? Well, the argument goes like
- 8:40this. Western nations call themselves
- 8:43democracies, which implies that power rests equally with the
- 8:47people, right? Right.
- 8:48One person, one vote. Exactly.
- 8:50But Campbell and others point out that these systems have
- 8:53actually been entirely captured by massive concentrations of
- 8:56wealth, corporate lobbying and deeply entrenched patriarchal
- 9:00structures. So the little man in the little
- 9:02booth is an illusion. A total illusion.
- 9:05The actual policy outcomes are determined long before the
- 9:07citizen ever picks up the pencil.
- 9:09I see. So when the government enacts a
- 9:11policy that say devastates a working class community, the
- 9:15system just protects itself by saying, well, hey, you voted for
- 9:18this. This is the Democratic will.
- 9:20Exactly, it uses the mechanism of the vote to legitimize
- 9:24fundamentally unjust outcomes. Wow and Peter Hallwards work
- 9:28really echoes this. He frequently discusses the
- 9:30concept of the will of the people and how modern
- 9:33representative democracies are actually designed to actively
- 9:36suppress that will rather than express it.
- 9:38How so? He argues our current systems
- 9:40just offer the illusion of choice.
- 9:43You get to pick between two pre selected factions that
- 9:46ultimately serve the exact same broad economic interests.
- 9:50OK, so the LSE panel was basically trying to strip away
- 9:53all that Churchill romanticism. Yes, they were saying, look at
- 9:57the actual outcomes, look at the inequalities, look at the
- 10:00environmental degradation. If this system is producing
- 10:03catastrophic results, why are we treating the procedure itself as
- 10:07something holy? But the reaction to that kind of
- 10:10systemic critique is always the same, isn't it?
- 10:12Intense suspicion. Always you can hate the
- 10:15candidate who wins the election. You know, you can protest the
- 10:18policies, but you are never ever supposed to critique the
- 10:21mechanism of universal suffrage itself.
- 10:24Which perfectly Tees up Jason Brennan's entire philosophical
- 10:27project. It really does.
- 10:29In his book Against Democracy, Brennan takes that exact taboo,
- 10:32puts it under a microscope, and identifies it as this
- 10:34widespread, unquestioned belief system.
- 10:37And he calls it democratic triumphalism.
- 10:39Democratic triumphalism. It is the core target of
- 10:42Brennan's work. What does he mean by that?
- 10:44He says that in our culture, we basically give democracy 3
- 10:48distinct cheers. We believe it is successful on
- 10:52three separate fronts. OK, let's unpack these three.
- 10:55Cheers. What is the first one?
- 10:57The first cheer is epistemic or instrumental.
- 11:01This is just the belief that democracy is simply the most
- 11:03effective tool we have. We think it reliably produces
- 11:06just stable and prosperous outcomes compared to the
- 11:10alternatives. OK, so we cheer for it because
- 11:12we believe it actually works. Right, it gets the job done.
- 11:15What's the second cheer? The second is Artaic.
- 11:18Now this comes from the Greek word for virtue, OK.
- 11:20The Artaic cheer is the belief that participating in the
- 11:24democratic process intrinsically educates us.
- 11:27It enlightens the citizenry, it forces us to care about our
- 11:30neighbors, and it fundamentally makes us better, more virtuous
- 11:33people. Got it.
- 11:34And the third cheer. The third is intrinsic.
- 11:37This is the belief that regardless of the outcomes, even
- 11:40if the economy crashes and regardless of whether it
- 11:42educates us, the democratic process is an end in itself.
- 11:46Yeah, the idea is that it's a uniquely just form of social
- 11:49organization because it inherently honors human dignity
- 11:53and equality. Triumphalism claims that
- 11:56democracy deserves all three of these cheers simultaneously.
- 11:59See, I want to focus heavily on that distinction between the
- 12:03instrumental view, the first chair, and the intrinsic view,
- 12:05the third cheer because honestly, it changes everything
- 12:08about how we evaluate our government.
- 12:10It's the whole ball game. Let's use an analogy for you
- 12:13listening. Imagine you walk into a room and
- 12:16on one side, resting on a beautiful easel, is a priceless,
- 12:20exquisite painting, and on the other side of the room, resting
- 12:24on a dirt workbench, is a heavy steel hammer.
- 12:27Right. Is democracy the painting or is
- 12:30it the hammer? And this is the dividing line
- 12:32between two major camps and political philosophy,
- 12:34proceduralism versus instrumentalism.
- 12:38If you are a proceduralist, you view democracy as the painting.
- 12:41Because a painting doesn't have a job to do.
- 12:43Exactly. You don't ask a painting to fix
- 12:45a leaky pipe or, you know, build a house.
- 12:47It's mere presence is justification.
- 12:50Right. We value the painting simply
- 12:52because it exists, because it represents human expression and
- 12:55dignity. So proceduralists believe that
- 12:57the procedure of democracy, just giving every single adult an
- 13:01equal say, is inherently just completely regardless of the
- 13:05outcome. Yes, they believe the process
- 13:08itself is the moral good. But instrumentalists see it
- 13:11differently. Totally differently.
- 13:13Instrumentalists view democracy strictly as the hammer, and a
- 13:17hammer has 0 intrinsic value. Right, if you buy a hammer and
- 13:21the steelhead shatters the very first time you hit a piece of
- 13:24wood you don't like, frame it and hang it in your living room.
- 13:26No, you throw it in the garbage. Because it failed its
- 13:28instrumental purpose. Right instrumentalists argue
- 13:31that there are independent, objective standards of justice
- 13:34in the world, things like human rights, economic stability,
- 13:38public safety, and we should use whatever tool, whatever form of
- 13:42government, most reliably achieves those just outcomes.
- 13:47So if democracy builds the best society, we use it exactly.
- 13:50But if another system build a better society, we throw the
- 13:53Democratic hammer in the trash and use the new tool.
- 13:56Yes, and Brennan is an unapologetic instrumentalist.
- 13:59He thinks democracy is just a hammer, just a tool, right?
- 14:03And to expose the danger of being a pure proceduralist, he
- 14:07poses this philosophical hypothetical in the book.
- 14:10And I'll warn you, it is a very dark hypothetical.
- 14:13It's intense. It is, but it's surgically
- 14:16dismantles the idea that the procedure itself guarantees
- 14:19justice. Walk us through it.
- 14:21OK, so Brennan asks us to imagine a perfectly functioning
- 14:25democratic society. They have a flawless
- 14:28constitution. They hold massive, inclusive
- 14:30town halls. Every single person has an equal
- 14:33voice. The procedure is perfect.
- 14:35Right. The debate is robust and fair.
- 14:37They follow every democratic rule to the letter, and then at
- 14:40the end of this perfect process, the majority of the electorate
- 14:44votes to legalize the physical abuse of children.
- 14:46Oh wow. Yeah, and they passed a
- 14:48subsequent law ordering the police to sand down and just
- 14:51allow the abuse to happen. OK, so if you are a pure
- 14:53proceduralist, you are totally trapped here completely.
- 14:56Because if you truly believe that whatever the democracy
- 14:59decides is inherently just simply because the democracy
- 15:02followed the rules and decided it, then you are mathematically
- 15:05forced to concede that in the scenario child abuse is now
- 15:09morally acceptable. Which is an absolutely abhorrent
- 15:12conclusion. Obviously.
- 15:13Right, so the outcome matters deeply.
- 15:16You cannot use the cleanliness of the voting procedure to
- 15:20magically wash away the profound immorality of the decision.
- 15:23Wow, yeah. There are independent moral
- 15:26standards, and if a democracy violates them, the democracy is
- 15:30objectively wrong. The hammer missed the nail and
- 15:32smashed the window. You can't just stand amidst all
- 15:35the broken glass and say, well hey, the hammer swung with
- 15:37perfect form, so the shattered glass is actually a beautiful
- 15:39thing. No, the outcome is a disaster.
- 15:42And this brings us to a really critical inflection point in the
- 15:44analysis. If we accept the instrumentalist
- 15:47view, if we accept that democracy is just a hammer and
- 15:50it's only value is how well it drives the nail, then the
- 15:54success of the entire system depends entirely on the people
- 15:58swinging the tool. The voters.
- 15:59The voters which requires us to shift from philosophy straight
- 16:02into psychology. Because if democracy is a tool,
- 16:06what happens to the human mind when it actually picks up that
- 16:08political hammer? Does swinging it make us
- 16:10stronger or does it like tear our mental rotator cuff?
- 16:14Right. And to understand the ecological
- 16:16impact of voting, we have to look at the great historical
- 16:19debate between two radically different thinkers, the 19th
- 16:22century philosopher John Stuart Mill and the 20th century
- 16:26economist Joseph Schumpeter. Let's start in the 19th century
- 16:29with Mill, because Mill is essentially the godfather of
- 16:32that archaic cheer we talked about earlier, the idea that
- 16:35politics and nobles us right. He had this grand, sweeping,
- 16:38incredibly romantic hope for what mass democracy could
- 16:41achieve. You have to remember the
- 16:43context, though. Mill was writing at a time when
- 16:45the franchise was severely restricted.
- 16:48He was actively advocating for expanding the right to vote to
- 16:51the working class right, and his hypothesis was that
- 16:54participating in politics would act as a massive civilizing
- 16:57force. He thought that if you took a
- 17:00factory worker, you know, someone who spent 12 hours a day
- 17:03doing just repetitive mind numbing labor, and you handed
- 17:06him a ballot, you would essentially force his mind to
- 17:09expand. Exactly.
- 17:11Suddenly, this worker has to consider the national economy
- 17:15and foreign policy and the common good.
- 17:18So Milt explicitly theorized that political involvement would
- 17:21be an educational mechanism. He did.
- 17:24He thought it would harden our intellectual rigor, but soften
- 17:28our selfish He genuinely believed that forcing people to
- 17:32deliberate with their fellow citizens would make them
- 17:34smarter, broader minded, and fundamentally more virtuous.
- 17:37But, and this is a huge crucial caveat, Mill was operating on
- 17:41hope. Sure hope.
- 17:42He didn't have the data because mass universal suffrage didn't
- 17:45really exist yet. He was guessing what would
- 17:47happen, right? Jump forward to the mid 20th
- 17:49century and Joseph Schumpeter actually has the data.
- 17:52He is watching mass democracy operate in real time, and his
- 17:56observation is completely. Brutal.
- 17:58Devastating. Schumpeter argued that Mill had
- 18:01it exactly backward. Yeah.
- 18:03In his 1942 work Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy,
- 18:08Schumpeter observed that when a typical high functioning citizen
- 18:11enters the political arena, their cognitive performance
- 18:14doesn't elevate. It plummets.
- 18:16He said the citizen drops down to a lower level of mental
- 18:19performance. Yes, Shoppeter wrote, that the
- 18:21typical citizen argues and analyzes political information
- 18:25in a way they would readily recognize as infantile in their
- 18:28normal professional lives. Infantile.
- 18:31In his exact words, the citizen becomes a primitive again.
- 18:34Man, why does that happen though?
- 18:36How does a person who is, like, entirely rational when they're
- 18:40buying a car or managing a household budget suddenly become
- 18:43a primitive when deciding on national tax policy?
- 18:46The mechanism is actually quite simple.
- 18:48It's the cost of being wrong. OK, explain that well.
- 18:51When you are buying a car, if you ignore the data and buy a
- 18:54lemon, you suffer the consequences directly.
- 18:56You lose money, your car breaks down.
- 18:59The feedback loop is immediate and highly personal.
- 19:01Right, you feel the pain of the bad choice.
- 19:04It's exactly, but in a mass democracy, your individual vote
- 19:08has a mathematically microscopic chance of altering the outcome.
- 19:13I mean, the odds of my single vote deciding a national
- 19:15election are lower than me getting struck by lightning on
- 19:18the way to the polling place. Precisely because your
- 19:20individual vote doesn't change the outcome, the cost to you of
- 19:24holding irrational, unscientific, or purely
- 19:28emotional political beliefs is zero.
- 19:31You don't suffer any immediate penalty for being wrong, so the
- 19:35mind literally stops doing the hard work of rational analysis.
- 19:38It indulges in tribalism and emotional gratification instead.
- 19:42But this contradicts every single public service
- 19:44announcement I have ever seen completely.
- 19:46Every election cycle we are bombarded with the message that
- 19:49low voter turn out is a national tragedy.
- 19:52Apathy is always framed as a moral failure.
- 19:54We have, you know, celebrities on television telling us it
- 19:57doesn't matter who you vote for, just get out and participate.
- 19:59That is a dominant narrative. Yeah, Yeah.
- 20:02But Brennan takes Schumpeter's observation and makes a deeply
- 20:05counter intuitive claim. He says the decline in political
- 20:08engagement is actually a good thing.
- 20:10Wait, really? Yeah, we should stop demanding
- 20:12maximum participation. He argues that apathy is
- 20:15actually a virtue, which sounds insane until you hear his
- 20:19reasoning. His reasoning is that in a
- 20:22healthy society, politics should be operating quietly in the
- 20:26background, just managing the infrastructure.
- 20:29Citizens shouldn't have to obsess over the government.
- 20:32They should be utilizing their limited time and mental energy
- 20:35to actually live their lives. He gives this great, really
- 20:38grounded list in the book. He says people should be out
- 20:41studying, painting, enjoying poetry, listening to music, or
- 20:45even avoiding the highbrow stuff.
- 20:46He says they should be watching football, attending NASCAR
- 20:49races, reading celebrity gossip or just going to Applebee's with
- 20:53their friends. Yeah, his point is that all of
- 20:55those activities, even the really frivolous ones, are
- 20:57generally peaceful. They build social bonds.
- 21:00Obsessing over politics, on the other hand, actively makes us
- 21:04worse versions of ourselves. It stultifies.
- 21:06Us it does. It makes us aggressive, paranoid
- 21:09and mean. So to really prove why Brennan
- 21:11desperately wants us out of the voting booth and inside an
- 21:14Applebee's, we have to look at the actual sociological data.
- 21:18We do. Who are the people currently
- 21:20swinging the hammer? Brennan distills 60 years of
- 21:23political science and voter psychology into a taxonomy.
- 21:27He creates a bestiary of the electorate, dividing citizens
- 21:31into 3 distinct species, the Hobbits, the Hooligans and the
- 21:36Vulcans. Let's analyze the Hobbits first,
- 21:38OK? The Hobbit is the archetype of
- 21:41the politically apathetic citizen.
- 21:43They are largely ignorant of political mechanisms, they don't
- 21:46possess a strong fixed worldview, they lack basic
- 21:50social scientific knowledge, and they don't know much history.
- 21:53But they aren't malicious, right?
- 21:55Just like the hobbits and Tolkien Shire, they just want to
- 21:57tend their gardens, drink their ale, and hang out with their
- 21:59neighbors. Right, they don't want to think
- 22:01about the geopolitics of Middle Earth.
- 22:02Exactly. They're focused on their
- 22:04immediate daily reality. And they are peaceful.
- 22:08And the data shows a really striking demographic reality in
- 22:12the United States. The typical non voter is a
- 22:15Hobbit. OK, now contrast the peaceful
- 22:16Hobbit with the second species, the hooligan.
- 22:19Ah. The Hooligan.
- 22:21The hooligans are the rabid sports fans of politics.
- 22:25Unlike hobbits, hooligans have highly fixed, rigidly defined
- 22:29worldviews. Their political affiliation
- 22:32isn't just an opinion, it is deeply fused to their core
- 22:35identity, functioning much like a fundamentalist religion.
- 22:39I mean, we all interact with hooligans constantly every day.
- 22:42They are the relatives ruining Thanksgiving dinner.
- 22:44They are the people sharing 30 hyper partisan memes a day on
- 22:49social media. And here is the mechanical
- 22:51breakdown of how a hooligan processes information.
- 22:54OK, hooligans actively consume political news, but they do it
- 22:57through the lens of motivated reasoning and confirmation bias.
- 23:01They aggressively seek out data that validates their
- 23:04pre-existing identity, and they immediately reject, ignore, or
- 23:07attack any empirical evidence that contradicts them.
- 23:10It's called identity protective cognition.
- 23:12If a piece of data threatens the tribe, the brain literally
- 23:16treats it as a physical threat and blocks it out.
- 23:18Exactly, and the most dangerous trait of the hooligan is how
- 23:21they view the opposition. A hooligan cannot comprehend
- 23:24that someone might disagree with them in good faith.
- 23:27If you disagree with a hooligan, they automatically assume you
- 23:30are either intellectual deficient, morally evil, or
- 23:33entirely selfish. Wow.
- 23:36And Brennan notes that the vast majority of regular voters,
- 23:39active campaign volunteers, and the politicians themselves all
- 23:42fall squarely into the hooligan category.
- 23:45They do. I want you listening to think
- 23:47about the most toxic pop culture fandom you have ever witnessed.
- 23:51Like, think about the obsessive sports fans who literally riot
- 23:56in the streets, flip cars and set fires when their team loses.
- 24:00And sometimes they riot when their team wins.
- 24:01Right. It is a deeply irrational tribal
- 24:04frenzy. Totally irrational.
- 24:06Now imagine taking that exact same toxic, irrational reality
- 24:09denying frenzy and giving it direct authority over the
- 24:13national economy, the criminal justice system, and the
- 24:15military. It's terrifying.
- 24:17It really is. It's one thing to be a hooligan
- 24:19about a football game. It's another entirely to be a
- 24:22hooligan when deciding who gets taxed into poverty or who gets
- 24:25sent to war. Which brings us to the final and
- 24:27most elusive species in Brennan's bestiary, the Vulcans.
- 24:32The Vulcans, named after Spock from Star Trek, presumably.
- 24:36Exactly. The Vulcan represents the
- 24:38absolute pinnacle of rational political thought.
- 24:41A Vulcan processes information scientifically.
- 24:45Their policy preferences are strictly grounded in empirical
- 24:48social science and rigorous philosophy.
- 24:51They're intensely self aware of their own cognitive biases and
- 24:54they actively work to mitigate them.
- 24:56So they only hold a belief as confidently as the evidence
- 25:00permits. If the evidence changes, their
- 25:02belief changes instantly without any emotional distress.
- 25:05And the defining characteristic of a Vulcan is what's called the
- 25:08ideological Turing Test. What's that?
- 25:10It means a Vulcan can explain their opponent's political world
- 25:14view so perfectly and so fairly that the opponent would actually
- 25:17say yes. That is exactly what I believe.
- 25:20The Vulcan is completely dispassionate.
- 25:22They sound like the perfect voters.
- 25:23They would be, but there is a massive fatal catch to the
- 25:27Vulcan archetype. What is it?
- 25:29True Vulcans do not exist. They are a myth.
- 25:31They are conceptual ideal. No human being, not even the
- 25:34most rigorous political scientist, manages to be a
- 25:37perfect Vulcan. We all possess biases.
- 25:40We all have blind spots. Yeah, but the Vulcan represents
- 25:42the standard of cognitive hygiene we should be striving
- 25:46for if we're going to wield the coercive power of the political
- 25:49hammer. OK, so let's tie this entire
- 25:52psychological beast theory back to the debate between Mill and
- 25:55Schumpeter we talked about earlier.
- 25:56Mill's grand romantic hope was that the system of democracy
- 26:00would take peaceful, uninformed hobbits and systematic radically
- 26:03educate them, turning them into rational, enlightened Vulcans.
- 26:07But the. Sociological data proves Mill
- 26:09wrong. Completely wrong.
- 26:11The tragic pipeline of political participation does not lead to
- 26:14enlightenment. When you take an apathetic
- 26:17Hobbit and force them to pay attention to politics, the
- 26:20system does not turn them into a Vulcan.
- 26:22What does it do? It radicalizes them into a
- 26:25hooligan man. The procedure doesn't ennoble
- 26:29us, it corrupts us. It drafts us into a perpetual
- 26:32tribal war. So we have to confront a really
- 26:35serious dilemma here. If the majority of the
- 26:38electorate operates as deeply biased, irrational hooligans,
- 26:43what does that mean for the legitimacy of the decisions they
- 26:45make? OK, I have to interject here
- 26:47because I can hear the standard liberal defense forming in
- 26:51people's minds right now. Let's say I accept your premise.
- 26:54I accept that most voters are hooligans.
- 26:57I accept that they are irrational, tribal, and ignore
- 26:59the data. So what?
- 27:01So what? Yeah, yeah, Don't we have a
- 27:03civil right to be wrong? If I want to make a stupid
- 27:06decision, isn't that my fundamental right as a free
- 27:09citizen? Doesn't a democracy have the
- 27:11sovereign right to govern itself right off an economic Cliff if
- 27:14that's what it genuinely wants to do?
- 27:16That is the absolute bedrock of libertarian and classical
- 27:20liberal thought. We firmly believe that
- 27:23individuals should be allowed to make terrible, self-destructive
- 27:26choices, provided they are only harming themselves.
- 27:28Brendan uses a great analogy for this in the book.
- 27:31He introduces a character named. Izzy.
- 27:32Oh, Izzy. Yeah.
- 27:34Izzy is the 20 something single guy.
- 27:36No kids, no dependents. And Izzy makes terrible life
- 27:40choices. He eats a massive caloric
- 27:42surplus of junk food every day. He refuses to exercise.
- 27:45He blows his entire paycheck on frivolous gadgets instead of
- 27:48saving for the future. He's a mess.
- 27:50Izzy is acting completely irrationally.
- 27:53But society let's Izzy do this. The government does not kick
- 27:56down his door and legally force him to eat a salad or go for a
- 27:59jog. Right.
- 28:00Why? Because Izzy's incompetence is
- 28:02entirely localized. He is only hurting himself.
- 28:05He possesses the civil liberty to ruin his own life, yes.
- 28:09So my question is, why isn't voting just like Izzy eating a
- 28:12cheeseburger? Because the Izzy analogy
- 28:14collapses the moment you apply it to the ballot box.
- 28:17Oh, an electorate is not a single isolated person.
- 28:21A democracy is not Izzy. When a hooligan voter steps into
- 28:24the booth and makes an ignorant, biased, empirically disastrous
- 28:27decision, they're not just ruining their own life.
- 28:29They are generating massive negative externalities.
- 28:32Exactly. They are imposing their
- 28:34irrational will on innocent people when the hooligan
- 28:38majority votes for a terrible economic policy.
- 28:41They're imposing poverty on minority groups who are outvoted
- 28:45right. They are imposing massive debt
- 28:47on future generations who haven't even been born yet.
- 28:50They're imposing devastating trade policies on foreigners who
- 28:54have absolutely no say in our elections but suffer the
- 28:57fallout. So political decision making is
- 28:59fundamentally different from personal decision making because
- 29:02politics is coercive. It's force.
- 29:04You aren't just choosing a meal for yourself, you are holding a
- 29:07gun to your neighbor's head and forcing them to eat it too.
- 29:10And because political power is coercive, exercising it requires
- 29:13A massively higher moral justification than exercising a
- 29:17personal civil liberty right. If you want to destroy your own
- 29:20health, society permits it. But you do not possess the right
- 29:24to destroy my health simply because you want a tribal
- 29:27popularity contest. Wow.
- 29:29Therefore, imposing an incompetent, hooligan driven
- 29:31decision on innocent people is not a civil right, it is a
- 29:35fundamental injustice. This philosophical point is
- 29:38perfectly mirrored in a comment we found on Langworth's
- 29:40Churchill blog. Actually, Oh, right.
- 29:43Underneath the article analyzing the quote, a physician named
- 29:46Doctor Michael Calm left a really profound observation.
- 29:50What was Doctor Calm's perspective?
- 29:52He viewed the political machinery through the lens of
- 29:54medical science. He pointed out that in medicine,
- 29:57true progress, what he refers to as secular humanism, proceeds
- 30:02agonizingly slowly. Yeah, it is highly cautious.
- 30:05It relies on rigorous peer review and it constantly
- 30:09questions its own evolving knowledge base.
- 30:12It is essentially Vulcan behavior.
- 30:14It respects the complexity of the biological system.
- 30:16Exactly. But Com warned that politics is
- 30:19often driven by ideology, which is the exact opposite of
- 30:22science. He noted that those who seek
- 30:24ideological shortcuts, the one-size-fits-all solutions that
- 30:28hooligans love, are the ones who inevitably wind up creating
- 30:31authoritarian regimes. That makes total sense.
- 30:33They try to force a complex society to fit their simple
- 30:36theory and it causes massive destruction.
- 30:38The hooligan voter is terrified of complexity.
- 30:41They want the shortcut. And when you grant millions of
- 30:44hooligans the unchecked power to impose their ideological
- 30:48shortcuts on the entire population, the results
- 30:51historically are catastrophic. Which brings us to the most
- 30:54uncomfortable, most provocative question of this entire deep
- 30:57dive. Here we go.
- 30:59We've established that democracy is an instrumental tool, a
- 31:01hammer. We've established that the
- 31:03people swinging the hammer are mostly irrational hooligans.
- 31:07And we've established that imposing an incompetent will on
- 31:09innocent people is unjust. Right.
- 31:12So what is the alternative? If universal suffrage is a
- 31:16flawed tool, does everyone actually deserve an equal vote?
- 31:19And to answer that, Brennan forces us to look past democracy
- 31:22to its modern, highly pragmatic and deeply controversial cousin,
- 31:27epistocracy. Epistocracy literally
- 31:29translating to the rule of the knowledgeable, yes.
- 31:32The concept traces its philosophical roots all the way
- 31:35back to ancient Greece, specifically to Plato's concept
- 31:38of the philosopher king. Plato argued that ruling a state
- 31:42is a specialized skill, like navigating a ship, and it should
- 31:45only be entrusted to those who have mastered the knowledge
- 31:48required. But even Aristotle pushed back
- 31:50on his teacher Plato. Aristotle basically said, look,
- 31:53a perfect philosopher king is a fantasy.
- 31:56And even if you found one, giving absolute power to a
- 31:58single human being will inevitably corrupt them.
- 32:01The ship will sink. And Aristotle's critique of the
- 32:05philosopher king is correct. Relying on a single dictator, no
- 32:09matter how brilliant they are, is a recipe for tyranny, right?
- 32:12But Brennan argues that modern epistocracy does not require a
- 32:15dictator. It doesn't rely on a single
- 32:17king. Modern episdocracy is about
- 32:20designing institutional structures that systematically
- 32:23favor knowledge within a broad voting system without
- 32:26centralizing power in one person's hands.
- 32:29So he isn't trying to abolish the voting booth, he's trying to
- 32:31upgrade the filters on it. Exactly.
- 32:33Brennan outlines 5 feasible real world models for an episdocracy,
- 32:38and we really need to break these down mechanics first
- 32:40because this is where the theory actually hits the pavement.
- 32:44Let's start with model #1 restricted suffrage.
- 32:46Restricted suffrage is the most direct approach.
- 32:49Under this system, you do not automatically acquire the legal
- 32:53right to vote simply by turning 18 or breathing oxygen OK.
- 32:57Instead, the right to vote must be earned by passing a basic
- 33:01competence process. Like a standardized test?
- 33:03Yes, an objective test covering basic political, economic, and
- 33:07historical facts. If you don't know the three
- 33:10branches of government, or you don't know the current
- 33:12unemployment rate within a reasonable margin, you are
- 33:15deemed incompetent to wield political power.
- 33:18It's treating the voting booth exactly like a driver's license.
- 33:21You have to prove you know what a stop sign is before the state
- 33:24hands you the keys to a two ton vehicle.
- 33:26Precisely. OK, model number 2 is slightly
- 33:28different. It's called plural voting.
- 33:31Plural voting was actually the system preferred by John Stuart
- 33:34Mill. In this model, you don't
- 33:36disenfranchise anyone completely.
- 33:38Every single citizen gets a baseline of one vote.
- 33:41So the Universal Foundation remains intact.
- 33:43Exactly however, citizens who are deemed to possess higher
- 33:47competence, perhaps through passing rigorous exams or
- 33:51holding specific educational degrees in economics or public
- 33:54policy, are granted additional votes.
- 33:57Extra votes. Right.
- 33:59Your baseline is 1, but a demonstrated expertise might
- 34:02earn you 3 votes or five votes. It tilts the electoral math
- 34:06toward knowledge without silencing the uninformed
- 34:09entirely. Model number 3 is wild.
- 34:11It's called the enfranchisement lottery.
- 34:13This one is fascinating. It draws heavy inspiration from
- 34:17the sortition systems of ancient Athens.
- 34:19How does it work? By default, no citizen has the
- 34:21right to vote. The general public is entirely
- 34:24disenfranchised. However, right before an
- 34:26election cycle begins, the state runs a massive lottery system,
- 34:30randomly selecting a cross section of thousands of
- 34:32citizens. These randomly selected people
- 34:35become what Brennan calls pre voters.
- 34:37Right. And to convert their pre voter
- 34:39status into an actual ballot, they're legally required to
- 34:42participate in rigorous state funded competence building
- 34:45exercises. Like a boot camp.
- 34:47Exactly. They have to attend deliberative
- 34:49forums, read extensive briefings from multiple perspectives,
- 34:52study the data. Only after completing this
- 34:55intensive civic boot camp do they earn the right to cast the
- 34:59deciding votes. It's brilliant because it
- 35:01acknowledges that the general public doesn't have the time to
- 35:04study policy. Most people are working 2 jobs
- 35:07so it selects a representative sample and literally pays them
- 35:12to do the homework. Yes, it ensures that the people
- 35:14making the final decision are hyper focused and highly
- 35:17educated on the specific nuances of that exact election.
- 35:21Right. OK, model number 4 is the
- 35:23epistocratic veto. This model leaves the
- 35:26traditional Democratic legislature entirely intact.
- 35:29Everyone votes, the politicians are elected, and the legislature
- 35:33passes laws exactly as they do right now.
- 35:35So where does the Episdocracy come in?
- 35:36Above the legislature. So it's a highly restricted,
- 35:39heavily vetted council of experts, economists, scientists,
- 35:42constitutional scholars. This expert panel cannot write
- 35:46legislation. They cannot proactively make
- 35:48laws. But they possess a supreme veto
- 35:51power. If the Democratic legislature
- 35:53passes a law that is objectively disastrous, empirically false,
- 35:57or violates basic economic reality, the expert panel can
- 36:01strike it down. So they act as an emergency
- 36:03brake on the hooligan majority. Exactly.
- 36:06They can't steer the car, but they can stop it from driving
- 36:08off a Cliff. Yeah.
- 36:09And finally, model number 5, weighted voting or what is often
- 36:13called the simulated Oracle. This is the most mathematically
- 36:16complex, but arguably the most equitable model.
- 36:20In the simulated Oracle. The voting process looks exactly
- 36:24like a normal democracy. Everyone goes to the polls.
- 36:27But there is a catch. A major catch?
- 36:29At the exact same time you cast your ballot for your preferred
- 36:31candidate, you must also take an objective political knowledge
- 36:35quiz right there in the booth. OK, let's drill into the
- 36:38mechanics of this algorithm. How does a quiz change the
- 36:41outcome? Once all the votes and quizzes
- 36:43are collected, A statistical algorithm goes to work.
- 36:47It possesses 3 dating points for every voter.
- 36:49Their demographic profile like race, income, gender, their vote
- 36:55in their objective knowledge score.
- 36:56The algorithm looks at the data and asks a specific question.
- 37:00How does a low income minority voter with low political
- 37:04knowledge vote compared to a low income minority voter with high
- 37:07political knowledge? Oh I see.
- 37:08It isolates the variable of information.
- 37:10Exactly. It's statistically controls for
- 37:12race, income, and gender to ensure that the system isn't
- 37:16just handing power to wealthy people who can afford better
- 37:19private schools. Right?
- 37:20Right. It maps the delta between what
- 37:22an uninformed demographic wants and what that the exact same
- 37:25demographic wants. When they are fully informed,
- 37:28the algorithm then mathematically weights the final
- 37:30election results to simulate what the entire public would
- 37:34have voted for if they all possess perfect Vulcan level
- 37:36knowledge. No, I guarantee you listening to
- 37:39this list of models is causing a visceral, almost defensive
- 37:42reaction for a lot of people. Oh, for sure.
- 37:44We have all been raised in a culture of democratic
- 37:46triumphalism. Hearing these models feels
- 37:50deeply, inherently wrong. It feels elitist.
- 37:53It feels incredibly elitist. I have to push back here on
- 37:57behalf of the listener. Just because someone passes an
- 38:00economics exam, why do they get extra votes?
- 38:02Just because someone is a certified expert?
- 38:05Why does that give them the moral authority to dictate the
- 38:08laws I have to live under? That is a completely fairpoint.
- 38:11This commits what philosopher David Essland calls the expert
- 38:15boss fallacy. The expert boss fallacy is the
- 38:17most powerful and common critique of epistocracy, and it
- 38:21is a completely valid concern. Eslin points out that possessing
- 38:25superior knowledge does not automatically grant you the
- 38:27moral authority to rule over someone else.
- 38:30Right. And to explain this, let's use
- 38:32Eslin's amazing real world analogy involving the fitness
- 38:35celebrity Shanti. The creator of the Insanity
- 38:38workout programs. Yes, Shanti.
- 38:41Now let's establish the facts here.
- 38:42Shanti is an absolute, unquestionable expert in
- 38:45physical fitness and kinesiology.
- 38:47He knows exactly on a molecular and biomechanical level how to
- 38:50get cut abdominal muscles. He possesses superior elite
- 38:53knowledge that I do not possess. He is a fitness Vulcan.
- 38:56He. Is the Shanti's superior
- 38:59knowledge. Give him the moral authority to
- 39:01kick down my front door at 5:00 AM, drag me out of bed, and
- 39:05physically force me to do burpees in my living room.
- 39:07No, that would be assault. I would call the police.
- 39:11Just because he knows what is best for my health does not give
- 39:14him the right to be my boss. Knowing better does not equal
- 39:17the right to rule. That is the expert boss fallacy.
- 39:20So doesn't this entirely destroy the case for epistocracy?
- 39:24It would, except for one critical pivot in Brennan's
- 39:27argument. Brennan agrees completely with
- 39:29the Shanti analogy. He agrees that experts do not
- 39:32possess a natural right to rule. Epistocracy, he argues, is not
- 39:36based on the idea that smart people should be our bosses.
- 39:39Wait, if it's not based on the authority of experts, what is it
- 39:42based? On it is not based on the
- 39:43authority tenant. It is based entirely on the anti
- 39:46authority tenant. Let's unpack the anti authority
- 39:48tenant because this is the crux of the whole philosophy.
- 39:50The anti authority tenant states that ignorant, incompetent and
- 39:54highly biased people should not be allowed to impose their will
- 39:58on the rest of us. Epistocracy isn't about
- 40:01rewarding smart people with power, it is about protecting.
- 40:04Innocent people from the catastrophic damage caused by
- 40:08incompetent people wielding power.
- 40:11It is a defensive mechanism, not an offensive one.
- 40:14Let me bring this home with the final mechanical analogy that
- 40:16clarifies the difference perfectly.
- 40:18Let's talk about the Department of Motor Vehicles.
- 40:21The DMV, the great bureaucratic equalizer.
- 40:24Right now, we all rightfully, universally agree that it would
- 40:29be profoundly evil and unjust to restrict someone from driving a
- 40:33car based on their identity. Of course, if the government
- 40:36announced you cannot have a driver's license because you are
- 40:38Catholic or because of your race or your gender, there would be
- 40:41riots in the streets. Because that is an arbitrary
- 40:43discriminatory restriction of liberty.
- 40:45Exactly. But we also universally agree
- 40:48that it is perfectly just, and in fact a moral imperative to
- 40:52restrict someone from driving if they are incompetent.
- 40:55If a person is legally blind, or if they suffer from severe
- 40:58seizures, or if they refuse to learn what a red light means, or
- 41:02if they choose to drive while intoxicated, the state revokes
- 41:06their license. We physically take their keys
- 41:08away. And no one screens elitism when
- 41:11the DMV denies a license to a blind person.
- 41:14No one claims the blind person's civil rights are being violated.
- 41:17Why? Because an incompetent driver
- 41:20puts the lives of other innocent drivers at risk.
- 41:23The state isn't trying to create an elite Society of race car
- 41:26drivers. The state is just trying to
- 41:28protect pedestrians from getting run over.
- 41:30And this is Brennan's ultimate devastating question.
- 41:33If an incompetent driver can kill a family of four in an
- 41:36intersection, an incompetent electorate can destroy the lives
- 41:40of millions across the globe. Yeah, why don't we treat the
- 41:43voting booth with the exact same gravity as a driver's license?
- 41:46It is a staggering contradiction when you frame it mechanically.
- 41:50We demand objective proof of competence to operate a Honda
- 41:53Civic, but we demand absolutely 0 proof of competence to operate
- 41:58the United States military, the nuclear arsenal, and the global
- 42:01economy. It's absurd when you put it like
- 42:03that. We tolerate a level of sheer,
- 42:05unmitigated incompetence in the boating booth that we would
- 42:08never, ever tolerate on the highway, or in a surgery room or
- 42:13in the cockpit of a commercial airliner.
- 42:15We let Izzy fly the plane simply because he showed up at the
- 42:18airport. So let's pull back and recap the
- 42:21incredible, deeply uncomfortable journey we have been on today.
- 42:25It's been a lot. We started by dismantling a
- 42:28historical myth, discovering that Winston Churchill's famous
- 42:31pragmatic defense of democracy was actually just a borrowed
- 42:35aphorism. Basically a tweet from 1947.
- 42:37From there, we zoomed in on the micro democracy of the hospital,
- 42:41looking at Doctor Friedman's sincere plea to replace
- 42:44dictatorial radiology chairs with elected officials.
- 42:47Right, which highlighted our deep, unexamined cultural
- 42:50assumption that the mere introduction of the ballot box
- 42:53magically fixes morale and guarantees better outcomes.
- 42:56But then we subjected that assumption to the Crucible of
- 42:58the LSC panel exploring Beatrix Campbell and Peter Hallwards
- 43:01frustration that critiquing the democratic mechanism is treated
- 43:05as ideological heresy. And we use Jason Brennans
- 43:08critique of democratic triumphalism to separate the
- 43:11proceduralists from the instrumentalists.
- 43:14We asked is democracy a beautiful painting that has
- 43:17intrinsic moral value just by existing?
- 43:20Or is it merely a hammer, a mechanical tool whose only value
- 43:23is its ability to build a just society?
- 43:26And once we recognize democracy as a hammer, we were forced to
- 43:30analyze the minds of the people swinging it.
- 43:32We contrasted John Stuart Mill's romantic 19th century hope that
- 43:36political participation ennobles us with Joseph Schumpetty's
- 43:40harsh, data-driven reality that participation actually
- 43:43stultifies us, returning us to a primitive state of tribal logic.
- 43:47Which led us into the psychological bestiary.
- 43:50We realized that forcing peaceful, apathetic hobbits to
- 43:52participate in politics doesn't magically transform them to
- 43:55rational, enlightened Vulcans. No, the tragic pipeline of mass
- 43:58democracy simply radicalizes them into tribal hooligans
- 44:01desperately seeking to impose their biased worldview on
- 44:04everyone else. And because political power is
- 44:07coercive. Because the electorate isn't
- 44:10just an isolated guy named Izzy making bad dietary choices, but
- 44:14a collective wielding a weapon over vulnerable populations, we
- 44:19examined the epistocratic alternatives.
- 44:22Not because we believe the expert boss fallacy, but because
- 44:25the anti authority tenet suggests we all have a
- 44:27fundamental moral right to be protected from incompetent
- 44:30decision makers. Exactly.
- 44:32I want to talk directly to you listening again after hearing
- 44:35all of this, after unpacking the mechanics and the psychology, I
- 44:38want you to conduct an honest audit of your own political
- 44:41engagement. Look at your daily media diet.
- 44:43Look at how you interact on social media.
- 44:46Is your political consumption making you a Vulcan?
- 44:49Is it making you more rigorous? More dispassionate?
- 44:51More capable of perfectly explaining the arguments of the
- 44:54people you vehemently disagree with?
- 44:56Or is it slowly turning you into a hooligan?
- 44:58Are you treating your political party like a sports team?
- 45:00Do you consume news just to get that hit of righteous
- 45:03indignation? Are you treating politics like a
- 45:05beautiful sacred painting, or are you willing to view it as
- 45:08just a hammer? It is a profoundly difficult
- 45:11mirror to look into because it demands that we abandoned the
- 45:14comforting illusion that participation equals virtue.
- 45:18It really does, and I want to leave you with one final
- 45:21provocative thought experiment to chew on as you go about your
- 45:23day. Something that builds on
- 45:25everything we have unpacked here but wasn't mentioned in the
- 45:28previous discussion. It pushes the instrumentalist
- 45:31logic to its absolute limit. If we truly accept the
- 45:36instrumentalist view. If we truly believe that
- 45:38democracy has 0 intrinsic value, that it is just a hammer and we
- 45:43only care about getting the most just, stable and prosperous
- 45:47outcomes, what happens when technology finally catches up to
- 45:51our philosophy? Imagine in the near future an
- 45:54impartial, highly advanced artificial intelligence system
- 45:57is developed. Let's call it the Oracle.
- 45:59The ultimate Vulcan algorithm. Yes, and let's say the Oracle
- 46:02can perfectly track the objective right ends of
- 46:05government. It can manage the global economy
- 46:07without causing inflation. It allocates resources with
- 46:10perfect efficiency, eliminating poverty.
- 46:13It manages the criminal justice system without a shred of racial
- 46:17or class bias. It performs the job of
- 46:19governance far, far better than any human electorate full of
- 46:22biased hobbits and tribal hooligans ever could.
- 46:25The ultimate epistocratic tool. It removes human error entirely.
- 46:29Exactly. The question is, would you hand
- 46:33over the keys? That is the question.
- 46:35If democracy is truly just a hammer, would you trade it in
- 46:38for a hyper efficient nail gun even if it meant you never ever
- 46:41got to cast a ballot again? Would you gladly sacrifice
- 46:45Churchill's romantic vision of the little man walking into the
- 46:48little booth if it absolutely guaranteed a perfectly just
- 46:52world? That is the ultimate test.
- 46:54It reveals whether you actually care about the house being built
- 46:57or if you just like the feeling of swinging the hammer.
- 46:59It brings us right back to the beginning.
- 47:01Are we willing to step into the Muddy Waters of our own biases
- 47:04and admit that maybe the X-ray machine of our political
- 47:06assumptions is broken? Maybe Churchill's borrowed quote
- 47:09wasn't a piece of undeniable pragmatic wisdom, but a
- 47:12comforting limitation we placed on our own imagination.
- 47:16Something to think about.