Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Why Your Vote Feels Pointless – And How Nonpartisan Primaries Change That
Transcript
- 0:16Hey, everyone. My guest today is Chad Peace.
- 0:19Chad is the legal strategist for the Independent Voter Project,
- 0:22where he's challenged restrictive primary systems and
- 0:25advocated for reforms that bring more choices to the table.
- 0:30He recently joined ABC News to discuss a new Gallup poll
- 0:33showing a record number of young voters are choosing to identify
- 0:37as independent. Beyond his work with the
- 0:39Independent Voter Project, Chadda's founder and president
- 0:43of IVC Media LLC, the nonpartisan digital media firm
- 0:47behind award-winning voter education campaigns,
- 0:50record-breaking third party fundraising, and creative
- 0:53digital strategies that breakthrough partisan gridlock.
- 0:57He's managed major initiatives supporting open primaries and
- 1:00reaching unconventionally engaged voters nationwide.
- 1:04Welcome to the show, Chad. I want to thank you for being
- 1:06here today. Thanks for having me.
- 1:08Of course. Would you be able to tell the
- 1:11audience a little bit about yourself and what you're working
- 1:13on? Well, I'm a father of a three
- 1:17and a four year old, grew up in a family or one.
- 1:21My dad's side of the family was, you know, pretty defined
- 1:25themselves as Democrats in the right side of my mom's side of
- 1:28the family to define themselves as Republicans.
- 1:32I kind of vowed to stay out of politics, but got the bug in my
- 1:35early 20s or so, like a lot of folks.
- 1:38And then I had the opportunity to work on California's
- 1:43nonpartisan primary initiative, which converted.
- 1:47California is unique. Washington and Alaska always
- 1:51have also have nonpartisan primaries, but it's one of only
- 1:54three states that have a nonpartisan selection process
- 1:58for the candidates rather than partisan primaries.
- 2:02So at the time, I guess I really didn't understand the
- 2:07revolutionary nature of what we were doing.
- 2:10I was kind of like, well, this is interesting, this is a good
- 2:12initiative. And I was kind of, I was, I was
- 2:15tasked with communicating to independent voters that this was
- 2:20going to be on the ballot. You know, skip forward a couple
- 2:23of years, I started putting it within context.
- 2:26I, I was just finishing up law school and looking at it through
- 2:30the lens of voter rights and realizing that, you know, maybe
- 2:36there's a connection between the dissatisfaction and the, that we
- 2:39see in government and the hyper partisanship.
- 2:42And I, I, you know, whether I'm sitting out with people that
- 2:45think that themselves as liberal or conservative or whatever,
- 2:48like I feel like most people just a normal life, don't one,
- 2:52don't define themselves by that and two, just kind of have the
- 2:56same common grievances, right. And it's like, so if we're all,
- 2:59most of us are feeling this way, why do these representatives on
- 3:03both sides seem to be talking about stuff that like none of us
- 3:07really care about? And or it's like, we may care
- 3:12about it, but it's like, talk to me like a normal person and you
- 3:16look at the way our election process is designed, right?
- 3:20And how, how, what are the incentive process?
- 3:22All right. So if you take a traditional
- 3:25state like New Jersey where we filed A lawsuit, you know, the
- 3:29first stage before the general election, right?
- 3:33Candidates, how do they get on the ballot in the general
- 3:35election? Well, they first run in a party
- 3:38primary election. And what that means is only
- 3:42voters from that party can vote on the nominee, right?
- 3:47So our legal principle is that this is important stage of the
- 3:50public election process. Taxpayers are funding it.
- 3:53Our elected officials are administering it.
- 3:55But if I don't join a party, I'm not allowed to vote.
- 3:59It sounds like a violation of my right of association, right?
- 4:02So that's our legal principle. But that's how it's conducted in
- 4:05most places, right? And then you combine that with
- 4:07how many people actually vote in these primaries, right?
- 4:11And, you know, usually ranges from low states like New Jersey
- 4:15can be around 10%. And then, you know, some states
- 4:18may be as high as 50, but you just crunch the numbers and you
- 4:23realize it really only takes like 2% of the electorate to win
- 4:27that primary. And then some folks who've been
- 4:30paying attention to more recently, we had this big debate
- 4:33over gerrymandering and it wasn't a, you know, the none of
- 4:37the solutions were let's get rid of gerrymandering.
- 4:41It was the Republicans decided, well, we're going to do it in
- 4:44our states that we can control. And that what it means is we're
- 4:48going to draw the districts in such a way that make the general
- 4:51elections like meaningless, right?
- 4:55And then the Democrats do the exact same thing, right?
- 4:58And so, and then both of them tell their voters we're doing
- 5:01this because they're the bad ones.
- 5:03And then, you know, we just have to write.
- 5:04So it's a right self fulfilling prophecy that you know who gets
- 5:09left out voters, right. So that's why we focus on things
- 5:13like let's let's change the incentives of the process.
- 5:16Let's get rid of this, you know, first stage that divides the
- 5:20electorate and serves a private interest.
- 5:23We're not anti party. We're not anti, you know,
- 5:26doesn't mean you can't be a Republican or a Democrat.
- 5:28It doesn't mean you can't have a party doesn't do all these
- 5:31things. But the public election process
- 5:34and the incentive shouldn't give partisan voters an advantage
- 5:38over everyone else, which right now it's not just an advantage,
- 5:41it's frankly a monopoly. Yeah, yes.
- 5:45So here in Iowa, we, we do the caucus and, and I have voted
- 5:51both ways, but like you said, you for the primaries, you have
- 5:54to be registered a certain way. And so I did my first caucus as
- 6:03like a captain and tried to recruit people to come.
- 6:06And not only is it only a small portion of the people that came,
- 6:11but there are, it's, it's a lot of retired people.
- 6:17And I'm, and I'm not trying to be offensive to them, but I will
- 6:19say me, like myself and the small group of like maybe four
- 6:26people that I could get to come to caucus were in our 30s.
- 6:31And we were the only ones in our 30s.
- 6:34And there was no one there younger than than my friend.
- 6:38That's like 2 years younger than me, 34.
- 6:40You know, so, so yeah, it's not a very fair representation of
- 6:47the people who will actually be voting in the general elections.
- 6:52Now that's on everyone else for not participating in the caucus
- 6:56or the primary. But the other thing about Iowa
- 6:59is we're split into 4 districts and it's just an even, you know,
- 7:04a plus sign. Now, if someone wanted to
- 7:06gerrymander, they would make a district right in the middle
- 7:10around the Capitol and you could get another Democrat seat.
- 7:14But now with California, can you explain how they do it a little
- 7:19bit more? Because I was just reading about
- 7:21how something to do with Eric Swalwell dropping out of the
- 7:26gubernatorial race actually benefited the Democrats more,
- 7:31and I really didn't understand it.
- 7:33It's just something I read yesterday.
- 7:35Can you explain this to me? Yeah, yeah.
- 7:37So, you know, there's a lot in the right we can talk about.
- 7:41I'd love to talk about Iowa. There's actually an effort right
- 7:44now going on to open the primary system there.
- 7:47But in terms of California, right, what confuses even the
- 7:50national pundits when they talk about it, they're so used to
- 7:53framing everything in this red, blue dynamic, right, is that we
- 7:57have, because we have nonpartisan primaries, it's not
- 8:01anti partisan. It's everyone participated.
- 8:04It's just agnostic, right? So everybody's on the same
- 8:07ballot, every voter gets the same ballot, every candidate's
- 8:11on the same ballot, right? And then the top 2 vote getters
- 8:15go to the general election. So that means you could have two
- 8:19Democrats, you could have two Republicans, you could have a
- 8:22Libertarian and a Green, right? It's party agnostic.
- 8:25That's the fundamental change I was talking about is where the
- 8:30purpose of every other primary is to elect a leader of those
- 8:34people who show up to a caucus in the party events, right?
- 8:37California doesn't function that way.
- 8:39It says we don't care about the party, right?
- 8:41We're not. You don't get disadvantaged for
- 8:43being a part of a party. You don't get advantage for
- 8:45being a part of party. So in a long field, when you
- 8:48have 10 Democrats and only two top ticket Republicans, right,
- 8:53you can understand how the top 2 Republicans could end up as the
- 8:57top 2 vote getters, right? Yeah.
- 8:59Now, once you crunch the numbers on the polling stuff, the
- 9:01chances, even when Swalwell was in, of that happening were
- 9:03almost nil. It was great news story, but
- 9:06it's almost nil. But Even so, now that Swalwell's
- 9:10out, there's probably going to be a Republican Democrat.
- 9:13But then you say, OK, that's a legitimate limitation of the top
- 9:192 nonpartisan primary, right? Yeah.
- 9:21So we've already seen leadership in this side on the left because
- 9:26they control most of the processes saying, see that we
- 9:29could have ended up with a disaster here.
- 9:31Therefore we should go back and close our primaries, right,
- 9:35because, you know, make sure we get a dip.
- 9:38What they don't say is that you don't have to do it one of those
- 9:42two ways, right? So just like I was saying, you
- 9:45got the left that wouldn't go for it here.
- 9:48That doesn't like it because they're in control, you know,
- 9:50and I'm not bagging on Trump. I think, you know, I'm, I'm not
- 9:53a, you know, I don't have a, a flag, his flag on the wall.
- 9:56And but I'm also like, not just everything he does is the worst
- 9:59thing in the world, but he just attacked Alaska's primary as a
- 10:03top four primary, right? It's a nonpartisan primary, but
- 10:07they advance four and then voters get to rank them.
- 10:11This is my first, second, third, 4th, right?
- 10:13So to win, candidates need to have people vote them second
- 10:18place and 3rd place, right? OK, so why does Trump attacking
- 10:23it? It's not because it's unfair or
- 10:25it's rigged or whatever. It's attacking it because it's
- 10:29more difficult to get the person the leadership wants elected
- 10:34because there's more competition for a broader set of voters,
- 10:37right? So in that context, that narrow
- 10:40context, Alaska would tend to be a red state, right?
- 10:44Our argument is all these states aren't red and blue.
- 10:47They're like marginally more Democrat than Republican, right?
- 10:50They just get exacerbated by the process.
- 10:53So in the case of Alaska, she's frustrated because of Murkowski
- 10:58is not a Trump Republican, but he can't primary her, right?
- 11:03I don't care what you think about Murkowski or what you care
- 11:05about or think about Trump. The fact is Murkowski has
- 11:09broader appeal to voters outside of her party, including
- 11:12independents, right? And that's why she can get
- 11:15elected under that system. So my point bringing you back to
- 11:18California is if you say there's an unintended consequence of top
- 11:23two, it wouldn't be to go back to an even worse system where 2%
- 11:26of the voters matter. In New Jersey, they cut the the
- 11:30better thing to do would be to Look North to Alaska and say,
- 11:34wow, Alaska's actually on the leading edge of voting rights,
- 11:38and they actually have a system of representation that is pretty
- 11:43revolutionary. And that's exactly why they're
- 11:45going after it so hard, right? Yeah, yeah, I, I really like
- 11:51that because I've always thought, OK, I, I mean, I know a
- 11:57lot of people, they want their opponent to be terrible so that
- 12:01your guy has a or girl has a better chance of winning.
- 12:05But in my mind, I'm like, OK, but if if the person I vote for
- 12:09doesn't win, I want the person who does win to be a good
- 12:13candidate. And that's so to me that with
- 12:20Alaska, you could, you could rank them like, OK, well, if I
- 12:24have to choose, like I'd rather have this Democrat over this
- 12:28Democrat or, you know, even though I'd rather have a
- 12:31Republican when you can, that ranking seems to open that up.
- 12:35Yeah. And I mean, that's the danger of
- 12:37using examples, right, on certain outcomes, because then
- 12:40people go, well, you're getting example because you don't like,
- 12:42I know, I'm just saying forget about the what you think of the
- 12:46candidate, right? The first elect, right?
- 12:50When Sarah Palin ran, right, she got actually more first place
- 12:53votes. But then you have somebody like
- 12:55a Murkowski, right, that OK, nobody got a majority.
- 12:58And so the Democrat drops off and voted Murkowski higher than
- 13:03than Palin, right? And that's what I mean in terms
- 13:05of. So the point isn't to elect
- 13:07somebody that best represents the party, right?
- 13:11The point is to elect somebody that more voters are satisfied
- 13:16with, more voters preferred, right.
- 13:18And so yeah, to your point, it's like and it also going about
- 13:22incentives, right? The incentives right now are for
- 13:24division. That's there's the incentive of
- 13:26the process is make voters dislike one of the candidates so
- 13:31much that they'll vote for our candidate because they fear the
- 13:35other one, right, Even if even right.
- 13:37So even if they don't like our candidate, they're going to fear
- 13:40the other one even more, right, under a different systems and
- 13:44there's different ways to do rank choice voting, all that
- 13:46stuff. But the point is like if you,
- 13:48there are systems that allow people to have a different
- 13:53incentive structure and have candidates have a different
- 13:56incentive structure where, you know, candidates, I know in some
- 14:00places that have ranked choice voting, there's been candidates,
- 14:03they go out and they campaign together.
- 14:05They say vote for one of us first and one of us second and
- 14:08the other one second, right, if you like, blah, blah, blah.
- 14:10So, you know, that's really the the types of discussions I think
- 14:15that are happening more these days.
- 14:17And I think, you know, will continue and then you'll see,
- 14:21you know, for lack of better terms, the resistance from both
- 14:24sides of the aisle. If you're in California, the
- 14:26resistance will come from the left.
- 14:28If you're in Iowa or you're in, you know, Texas, it will come
- 14:32from the right for sure. But it's that's why at the end
- 14:35of the day, it's truly a nonpartisan voter.
- 14:38Small, you know, small I independent, right?
- 14:41Where? It divides both the parties too,
- 14:44right? There's independent minded
- 14:46Republicans, independent minded Democrats, and everywhere in
- 14:49between. Right, right.
- 14:52You know, also I think that there there are people who might
- 14:58not feel safe going to a primary for a particular party that
- 15:05where if it was all together it doesn't it eliminates that.
- 15:11I guess I don't know if there are problems with people
- 15:15protesting outside of primaries or caucus.
- 15:18Well, so like our state, we have the we have a lot of mail in
- 15:21ballot voting and stuff. But right.
- 15:23But to your point, I mean, it, it, it could be overt physical,
- 15:27or, you know, you could be scared of that, but you could
- 15:29also just be scared of the fact that when you go and you vote in
- 15:32one of the party primaries becomes publicly available
- 15:35information, right? Maybe not to the everyday, but
- 15:38but every consultant and everything they and people can
- 15:40look up. You know which party you voted,
- 15:43right? I think that there's a privacy
- 15:45issue, right? That's not the the first thing
- 15:47we talk about, but but to your point is the core principle
- 15:52we're talking about at the end of the day is that people your
- 15:56right to vote doesn't derive at the moment you join a political
- 16:00party, right? It derives by being a citizen of
- 16:04the United States, right? So our point was why do we have
- 16:09structures that literally disenfranchise you from a part
- 16:13of the process because you've chosen not to join a party,
- 16:17right? So that's the core argument.
- 16:20And we say like, that's a legal argument.
- 16:22But the practical consequence of not observing that legal
- 16:26principle is that we have extreme partisanship everywhere
- 16:30throughout the country. And it only perpetuates itself
- 16:32because when an issue that both sides are frustrated with
- 16:36mounts, the solution isn't to resolve it, it's to do it more
- 16:43on this side and more on this side and tell them on one side
- 16:46you're just a never ending fight.
- 16:49Yeah, yeah. And at some point, the
- 16:52politicians completely become disconnected with the people
- 16:56that they're supposed to represent.
- 16:59I think there's a lot of truth to that and I think there's also
- 17:02a lot of truth that there's there's more people in the
- 17:05system. I always think the
- 17:07representatives, even if you don't agree with the
- 17:10meteorologically, most of them are pretty they're trying to do
- 17:14the right thing that I think voters maybe take out their
- 17:18grievance too much. I don't know, this might sound
- 17:20like counterintuitive or like a hypocritical, but I believe
- 17:24there's way more representatives that are in office or hanging on
- 17:29to an office or what that actually do want the system to
- 17:32change. It's not good for representation
- 17:34to go, I know the right thing to do.
- 17:36I mean, I sit down with my colleagues from the other side
- 17:39of the aisle. We both agree we know this is
- 17:41the right thing to do, But I got to run in a primary and I'm
- 17:44going to get my head topped off for doing the right thing
- 17:47because it's easy for my opponent to go and hyperbolize
- 17:51some ideological argument that doesn't isn't grounded in
- 17:54reality, right? And so the hope I think is that,
- 17:58you know, when the there's an opportunity, right, to jump on
- 18:02to, I think there's a lot more people that are ready to jump on
- 18:05that boat, but people aren't going to jump in the water until
- 18:10the boats there. Yeah, absolutely.
- 18:14You know, there is so much information to consume nowadays
- 18:18that I think that if someone who doesn't live in a state that
- 18:23does, like ranked choice voting, if someone reads about it,
- 18:28they're not going to know really what it is or how it works
- 18:33because there's just so much stuff to look look into.
- 18:39Right. And then you you know the
- 18:40information's fed by whose perspective it is, right?
- 18:44You know the irony on a lot of the Republican Subs.
- 18:46The Republican Party actually uses ranked choice voting in
- 18:49many of its states, right? They Yonkin the former governor
- 18:54of of Virginia. He was elected in a primary in
- 18:58the party Republican Party's internal processes endorsed him
- 19:04and nominated him through a ranked choice process, right?
- 19:07Like, so it's from, but the level of misinformation, right,
- 19:13of, you know, coming from the political operatives that, you
- 19:16know, have their agenda and stuff is a lot.
- 19:19And then I don't blame voters either.
- 19:20It's like, I got kids to take care of.
- 19:22I got to go to school, I got to go to work, I got to do all this
- 19:25stuff when I'm, I'm going to go and have to study how the the
- 19:29nuances of how an election process works.
- 19:32Like that's not a reasonable expectation for us to have.
- 19:36Yeah, it, you know, I also, I could see where by doing it that
- 19:42way you can get more, I, I guess a different variety.
- 19:48It's, it's not your cookie cutter Republican or Democrat.
- 19:52You can maybe get more candidates that are a little bit
- 19:55more in the middle. So I mean, that question hits on
- 19:59something that you know, is exactly right, which frustrates,
- 20:03you know, our independent voter project and stuff when you see.
- 20:06There's so many folks that'll say, look, California's system
- 20:09did nothing because there's just as many Democrats, if not more
- 20:12than there was before, right? And our position is, what does
- 20:16that have to do with it? If you go to California, if you
- 20:20spend a day in Sacramento and talk to the people around there
- 20:23and say, did California's nonpartisan primary do anything?
- 20:26I guarantee all the people who work in government up there will
- 20:31say, oh, yeah, it did because there's a huge there's, you
- 20:35know, your shows shades of Jay, there's many shades of blue that
- 20:40exist among those Democrats only because of the nonpartisan
- 20:45primary, right. And so whether you call them
- 20:47conservative Democrats or Liberal Democrats, right, like
- 20:51our point is that it's they're Democrats that should represent
- 20:54their district, right? If it's a Democrat district, but
- 20:57it has more conservative tendencies, well, guess what?
- 20:59There's probably, you can label it moderate, more conservative,
- 21:02you know, whatever kind of Democrat you want.
- 21:05But there's certainly big shades of of Democrat in California on
- 21:12a state level that you to a level you don't really see in
- 21:16Washington, DC. OK, Yeah, yeah, we're, I mean,
- 21:22it seems like it's more visible in the Republican Party right
- 21:25now because they're all fighting with each other so much, but.
- 21:29Well, I mean, there's that same things happening in the
- 21:32Democratic Party as well. And I don't think it's a it's a
- 21:34coincidence. And it's also, it's also a
- 21:37consequence of, of the system itself, right?
- 21:40I make the argument, you know, I'll say it, I'll say it again.
- 21:44Put it anybody from Democratic Party leader to Republican
- 21:48leader to, to, you know, here there's some folks in some of
- 21:52the special interests that really don't like what we're
- 21:54doing. I will to my dying day, tell
- 21:58them whether you disagree with me or not, I actually think what
- 22:02I'm saying is good for you, right?
- 22:04I think the the Democratic Party strengthens with the process
- 22:08like this, whether you're a labor or you're a business
- 22:10organization or you're probably everybody gets strengthened by a
- 22:14process like this because competition and inclusion,
- 22:19right? I think make all of us stronger
- 22:22and make all of us feel vested right now.
- 22:24We really have this winner takes all, you know, champion my
- 22:29ideology form of of of running for office and then and then
- 22:34governing that if you're not part of that segment that gets
- 22:40their issues championed for the short term of a, you know, of an
- 22:44election cycle, you're out, right?
- 22:48And it's hard to govern and it's hard to have, you know, it's
- 22:52hard to have credibility when people really thinking that you
- 22:55deserve to be their representative, right?
- 23:00You know, a big concern with a lot of people, particularly
- 23:05those that don't vote, is they feel that they don't, that their
- 23:08vote doesn't mean anything. And this this directly addresses
- 23:14that issue. I mean, I think so I, I, people
- 23:19go, oh, there's low turn out. Let's just go spend a whole
- 23:22bunch of state money trying to drive turn out and tell students
- 23:25to go out and vote, right. But that doesn't solve the issue
- 23:28that they don't not going. I use, I use an example.
- 23:31Say you're a vegetarian, right? But I say you can eat dinner as
- 23:37long as it's a hot dog or a hamburger, right?
- 23:40Yeah. Try to get that vegetarian to
- 23:44eat dinner all they want. Maybe you cram it down their
- 23:46throats the only way you're going to get them to eat.
- 23:48That's our process, right? The Democrats have their process
- 23:52over here. They elect somebody Republicans
- 23:54over here and they say, OK, we, we nominated the hot dog.
- 23:58Oh, we nominated the hamburger. Then we go, why are these
- 24:01vegetarians not coming out to eat?
- 24:04And we're surprised, right? Right.
- 24:08Put a vegetarian on the ballot. Put it.
- 24:09Put a salad on the ballot. Right.
- 24:11And I bet you though some of them will come out and and vote.
- 24:14Yeah, that's funny. I was a vegetarian for 13 years
- 24:18and I still very much love salads.
- 24:20So I I liked that analogy. Well, I'm a meat eater, but you
- 24:24know, see. Oh yeah.
- 24:26No, Yeah, with a different process we could find something.
- 24:29Yeah, no, I I mean, I eat meat now and it's, I eat more, more.
- 24:35I don't know, I'm sounding weird right now.
- 24:37I, I eat more meat now than I ever did.
- 24:39I don't know what happened once I started eating it again.
- 24:41It was like my body was trying to make up for 13 years.
- 24:46Anyways, So another thing is again, is a lot of people are,
- 24:52they think, oh, I'm just voting for the lesser of two evils.
- 24:56So yeah, if you're exactly with the hamburger and the hot dog,
- 24:59it's why, why even vote? But sorry to interrupt, I just
- 25:04wanted to. Tell you about my sponsors real
- 25:06quick. Sometimes I get on a roll
- 25:10cleaning or gardening and I need a boost but don't have time for
- 25:13a meal. Big Fork Brands Pork Jerky is
- 25:15the perfect choice to keep my momentum, offering high protein
- 25:18snacks for on the Products come in a variety of delicious
- 25:30flavors, including Thai green Curry and Maple and brown sugar
- 25:33for the meat options and Gangster and Chicago Fire.
- 25:36For the sausage. I personally think the original
- 25:39flavor of the pork jerky hits just right after tackling a big
- 25:42chore. It's a little salty and very
- 25:44flavorful. My discount code gives you 20%
- 25:47off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 25:50available. Just visit bigforkbrands.com and
- 25:54enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 26:01Are you looking for a gift for a music lover?
- 26:03Or maybe some apparel to show off your quirky side.
- 26:05Old Glory has you covered. With over 300,000 officially
- 26:09licensed items covering music, sports, entertainment and pop
- 26:12culture, you're guaranteed to find the perfect item.
- 26:15They even have seasonal gear. My husband enjoys The Beatles
- 26:18and Led Zeppelin apparel and I love the Billy Idol apparel.
- 26:22I even found items for my fellow plant enthusiasts.
- 26:25This family owned superstore is known for their quality and
- 26:28customer service. Offers free standard shipping on
- 26:31all orders and orders are shipped the same day you
- 26:33purchase. My discount code gives you 15%
- 26:37off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 26:39available. Just visit oldglory.com and
- 26:42enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 26:48Looking for a game changing way to improve your health?
- 26:51Zevo Life is the world's most nutrient dense whole plant,
- 26:54packed with over 50% plant protein, essential amino acids,
- 26:58fiber and antioxidants. Harnessing the best nature has
- 27:02to offer, Zeva Life nourishes your body while driving your
- 27:05performance, vitality and overall well-being.
- 27:08Each serving is a concentrated source of clean, well balanced
- 27:12nutrition designed to support modern lifestyles.
- 27:15And just one teaspoon a day supports your gut, boosts energy
- 27:18and promotes healthier skin and hair.
- 27:20It's no wonder that it's receiving rave 5 star reviews.
- 27:24Step into a healthier future with a 30% discount and a 30 day
- 27:28risk free guarantee by visiting DIVO dot Life and using my promo
- 27:34code to support my show and to receive 30% off your entire
- 27:37order, enter in my promo code JADE.
- 27:39That's JADE at checkout. Can you tell me a little bit
- 27:44more about the Independent Voter Project?
- 27:47Yeah, I mean, I found it in about 15 years ago by former
- 27:52legislators, Full disclosure, one of them was my father,
- 27:55right, with some of his colleagues.
- 27:57And really, they saw California under its old open primary
- 28:02system, which the Democratic Party took to court.
- 28:05The Republican Party joined them, and they successfully won
- 28:08a lawsuit that closed the primary under the old system.
- 28:12They created Independent Voter Project to say, look, this isn't
- 28:14sustainable, it's not good for governance.
- 28:17And they drafted California's top 2 nonpartisan primary, which
- 28:22would survive legal scrutiny, right?
- 28:25And so we got by a stroke of luck and circumstance and
- 28:28everything, we got it on the ballot.
- 28:30The voters passed it. And now California is one of
- 28:33three states with nonpartisan primaries.
- 28:35And so since that time, Independent Voter Projects
- 28:39operated a news website, Ibn dot US, which covers this kind of
- 28:44stuff going on everywhere from California to Iowa to Maine.
- 28:50And we host conferences with legislative leaders and
- 28:54sponsors, right, where they come together to talk about their
- 28:58issues, but they also learn a little bit about the election
- 29:00reform. We, we always make sure there's
- 29:02folks from both sides of the aisle at those conferences.
- 29:07And we've passed a few other election reforms.
- 29:11We authored one in San Diego about, what, six years or so ago
- 29:15now that, you know, made it so that candidates couldn't get
- 29:18elected in a primary when half the people are voting, right.
- 29:21So we participate in a lot of that stuff.
- 29:25And, you know, we're a small but I think passionate crew of folks
- 29:32that, you know, we just believe that there's that there is going
- 29:36to be an opportunity for voters to come together and really fix
- 29:40the system. And we think it is.
- 29:43The fix isn't by getting a certain person elected or
- 29:46certainly on one side or the other.
- 29:48It's changing the incentives within our election process to
- 29:52incentivize, you know, good behavior and good governance.
- 29:55Right, right. You know, now I, I think now is
- 29:59the perfect time to, to get that word out.
- 30:03I, I just think people are more fed up than than ever with, I
- 30:09mean, I mean, finding out about the, what's going on in Congress
- 30:14in people's personal lives and on both sides of the aisle.
- 30:18I think people are just so tired of it.
- 30:21And I've, I've talked to other representatives about like why
- 30:29they're leaving, you know, why there are so many retiring.
- 30:32And aside from like the threats and the hate that they get from
- 30:36the other side, It's, it's the, I guess, feeling that they
- 30:42can't, that they're just stuck in a bubble.
- 30:45They can't make a difference. It's.
- 30:47Yeah, I, I don't speak for all of them, but I can imagine
- 30:50there's just a sense of futility of, you know, swimming against
- 30:53this ocean of just, you know, constant barrage of stuff that's
- 30:59like noise, right? It's just noise.
- 31:01It's political theater and this and that, right?
- 31:03And there's not any real opportunity to like, hey, let's
- 31:08fix this stuff, right? Every single thing is done from
- 31:13the perspective of, oh, how does this get crafted into a
- 31:16political campaign message, right?
- 31:20Both to trash to to convince people that the other side is
- 31:25set on lighting the whole world on fire and that our side is,
- 31:30you know, the Lord's Savior and, you know, can't do anything
- 31:34wrong under the sun. Yeah, yeah, that's it's, it's so
- 31:39frustrating to watch. So where, where are you the most
- 31:46active? You I I know you mentioned you
- 31:48work with other states. I mean, we're, we're based in
- 31:52California. We always say we're a California
- 31:54organization. We're not going to go into other
- 31:56places and tell them what to do. But we actually have some folks
- 31:59that are in Iowa who came to us who are working on, I'm working
- 32:03on it, opening up the Iowa's primary election process when it
- 32:08comes to state elections, right, Caucuses for presidential and
- 32:12stuff like that. But on the at least as it
- 32:14involves state elections to try to open them up and give
- 32:17independent voters an opportunity to at least cast a
- 32:20vote in one of the two primaries.
- 32:22So they approached us, asked for some advice, asked us how to,
- 32:26you know, how do we articulate this stuff?
- 32:28How do we message Full disclosure?
- 32:31I actually, I am not IVPIVP is a client of mine.
- 32:35I do digital communications inside and outside of, of
- 32:39politics, but I obviously have a passion for independent voter
- 32:43project. And so it's a large part of both
- 32:46my identity and the work that I do.
- 32:48And you know, increasingly there's people like those in
- 32:52Iowa who just found us online or connected to us.
- 32:54I forget exactly how they, they came into contact with us, but
- 32:57they're like, hey, we want to do this.
- 32:59We're we got this thing drafted. Can you help?
- 33:02And and, you know, so in that case, we were happy to play
- 33:05second chair and and give people advice, but in terms of, you
- 33:09know, we're not going to be the ones throwing the ball or
- 33:12pushing push in the direction unless it's in California
- 33:16because that's what we know and that's where we live.
- 33:18Yeah. Would you be able to tell me who
- 33:20that was in Iowa, if you know? It's called all Votes Iowa.
- 33:27OK. And if you go to open my
- 33:31primary, open myprimary.org, OK, you'll see that there's there's
- 33:38like their website. They also have their
- 33:41organizational website that's kind of like their lead
- 33:43generation website. And I don't think he'd have a
- 33:48problem with me telling you there's there's a group, there's
- 33:52a group with them. But you know, one of them's name
- 33:55is Brad Williams. And they're just, they're great
- 33:59group of people. They're not like super hyper
- 34:02political and stuff. They're just trying to do
- 34:04something to improve the process, right?
- 34:06Yeah, yeah, because I, I would like to help with that if
- 34:11there's a, a way to do so just. Send you an e-mail if you'd
- 34:16like. Oh yeah, that'd be great.
- 34:18Yeah, OK. They're really great group and
- 34:22been really fun working. They're just expanding their
- 34:24program right now and right really that's, that's their
- 34:27whole agenda. It's to give people more, you
- 34:30know, have more people be able to vote in the primary.
- 34:33Yeah. So what advice would you give to
- 34:37other states if they wanted to do something like this?
- 34:42I would say it starts by, you know, tell 1.
- 34:45You can tell your legislators and your representatives that's
- 34:48an issue you care about most. You know, most of them are going
- 34:52to be able to work within the system to do it because the
- 34:56institutional pressures will stop them.
- 34:58But it's important that they get involved.
- 34:59Some may be willing to say things publicly, but then just
- 35:03find folks like you just asked me, oh, there's a group that's
- 35:05doing there's get together and just start organizing and, and
- 35:10make people or tell your friends, hey, look, we actually
- 35:13can fix this. Every state is different.
- 35:17They have different rules. Some states have, you can do
- 35:20citizen initiative, some states you can't.
- 35:22But in any case, there's always a way to just advance the ball,
- 35:27whether through education or awareness.
- 35:30And then finding those folks who are, whether they're business
- 35:32leaders or political leaders who are are engaged and do want to
- 35:38improve. There's a lot of people in both
- 35:40business and government that are frustrated just like the rest of
- 35:43us, who, you know, if they know they have other folks there and
- 35:47there's something to work towards are are willing to do it
- 35:50and willing to, you know, put some of their own time and
- 35:54reputation behind. Right, Yeah, yeah, I think, I
- 35:59think that this could get more people involved in politics and
- 36:02make them feel like they have just gives them a more hands on
- 36:08opportunity, maybe makes them feel like they have a little bit
- 36:11more power in their vote. Well, I hope so that that's the
- 36:17goal on that. The difficulty though, is
- 36:21because you're not, you're not bounded by, you know, more like
- 36:25a party or, you know, more of a a tribe, so to speak, is that
- 36:30political things happen. And it's really easy for, you
- 36:34know, whether it's somebody leading an organization or it's
- 36:37just a groups within the organization to to split
- 36:42themselves because of the very partisan issues that they're
- 36:46trying to fight, right. And a lot where, you know, it's
- 36:50a group that starts out to do this.
- 36:51And then a couple years later, it becomes kind of like a group
- 36:55of Democrats or Republicans because of the way, you know,
- 37:00the political system really starts pushing people and
- 37:03dividing people. And it's that's why it takes so
- 37:06long. It's very hard.
- 37:07I think the more people who are interested in politics on the
- 37:12periphery, right, get involved, that's what's going to really
- 37:18catalyze it, right? Because the people like me who
- 37:20wake up thinking about politics and are watching what's going on
- 37:23all the time are too vested in the current status of the
- 37:28system. You need people on the outside
- 37:30have a very long term perspective and treat the noise
- 37:33as it should be treated. It's noise, right?
- 37:36Whether it's something about Trump or Swalwell or whatever.
- 37:40Like to me, I've just gotten to a place where, like, that
- 37:42stuff's just noise. Like, yeah, OK, I can't control
- 37:47what's gonna happen tomorrow or who's gonna do what tomorrow.
- 37:51Yeah, a lot of it. It doesn't really affect
- 37:57anything. You know, like Trump keeps
- 38:00getting in hot water for posting memes and stuff like that.
- 38:03And it's like, OK, so it's offensive.
- 38:06What did it do to you? Did it do anything to you?
- 38:09Did it affect geopolitics in any way, shape or form that he
- 38:13posted this? Just get over it.
- 38:15Like why are you saying? I probably will get in trouble
- 38:19just by saying my hair does not get caught on fire all the time
- 38:22and like, but that also. But that also doesn't mean I
- 38:25think that's what a president should be doing.
- 38:27Of course, but. That right.
- 38:30But like, to your point, it's like, you know what?
- 38:32That's who he is and, you know, he got elected and you know
- 38:35what, I go, what kind of system did we create that that kind of
- 38:40behavior gets elected and right. Maybe that, you know, he's the
- 38:44bull in the China shop that you say wake up, wake up, Yeah.
- 38:49Yeah, yes, it well, and yeah, it it's not like he changed.
- 38:55He he, I mean, he is who he is. You got to give him that, right?
- 38:59Yeah, that's the same guy, you know?
- 39:00Yeah, you got to give him that. And, you know, that's the and
- 39:04and really that is, that's the authenticity you don't really
- 39:09see anywhere else, right? And I think it's like some
- 39:12people you may not like that authenticity or like maybe like
- 39:15whatever. But to your point, it's like
- 39:19that's the only vegetarian meal on the cat, right?
- 39:21It's like alternative. And maybe I will, but what I
- 39:25don't like is this pole tested dribble where the I don't even
- 39:30know who's talking to me. Some candidate went to their
- 39:32consultant, told them what they should say, and then they're
- 39:35coming and just spewing a bunch of nonsense, right?
- 39:38That they don't even believe. And so, you know, that's the
- 39:42world we live in, right? But I think fortunately there
- 39:44are a lot more people that have something to say that are
- 39:47willing to be authentic if we just provide a pathway to do.
- 39:52It right, right. Yeah, I'm trying to imagine how
- 39:55much this could change things if more states adopted these
- 39:59practices. You know, there's a lot of of
- 40:05third party people out there that that.
- 40:11They're agnostic or they're within the parties right now and
- 40:14frustrated, right? And that's the point in it.
- 40:17It's competition. I think the bright, you know,
- 40:21the ray of optimism, right, is that the last time we had a lot
- 40:25of these big election reforms was the the turn of the great
- 40:28Progressive Era, right? Which is not the same as the
- 40:31progressive terminology we use now.
- 40:34But that's when primaries first came into the public sphere
- 40:39where we didn't have a nomination process.
- 40:41We had it was all private, right?
- 40:42You think it was even more private than caucuses.
- 40:44It was like the literally the leadership of the of the
- 40:47parties, you know, in the smoke filled rooms deciding that this
- 40:51was going to be the candidate, right.
- 40:53And so they brought in primaries in a couple states in the at the
- 40:57turn of the the previous century.
- 41:00And almost overnight, the rest of the country started adopting
- 41:04them, right. So when change happens, it can
- 41:08happen fast. And, you know, I'd like to think
- 41:11we're at an inflection point where, you know, we can get some
- 41:14things passed. Unfortunately, there's been some
- 41:17setbacks in the reform space the last couple election cycles.
- 41:20But I think there's opportunity now.
- 41:22And I think there's a lot to your point, I think there's a
- 41:24lot more people stepping back and going.
- 41:28This is a systemic problem. It's not one of the two parties,
- 41:31right? Yeah, yes.
- 41:33And it, you know, SO2 quick things is for me to be able to
- 41:41absorb all of this information on politics everyday.
- 41:46I think of it as a game. And I'm a competitive person.
- 41:49And I think that to a lot of these politicians, it is a game.
- 41:53You're playing your role, you know, and you've, whoever plays
- 41:56their role best wins. But it's sad to think that our,
- 42:02our country is like that. But I do think, as we've just
- 42:08been discussing, that people are tired of the game.
- 42:11And I do wonder if that's what's causing a lot of these
- 42:14influencers to kind of go off the rails now.
- 42:18Like, are they, are they realizing that people don't
- 42:21agree with everything they say? They're kind of turning their
- 42:24listeners away. Do you think that has something
- 42:27to do with it? You know, I don't, I don't, I
- 42:30don't know. And maybe each one has their own
- 42:32circumstances and stuff. But like, I think the certainly
- 42:35part of it is like finding your niche, right?
- 42:38It's like, Hey, where's my, you know, the people that will agree
- 42:41with with this thing and I'm the only one willing to say that,
- 42:44right? And so that that's the only
- 42:46place they can find it. Maybe they don't even agree.
- 42:48They just like, wow, somebody will say that or take that
- 42:51position. I don't know, but I do think
- 42:55that, you know, like I said it, there's the incentives are to
- 42:59have more tribal, right, tribal type views of the world and as
- 43:05it translates into political power, right.
- 43:08So if you have your tribe and you can utilize that tribe for
- 43:11political influence because it comes with this many votes and
- 43:15that many dollars and that's effective.
- 43:19So what I'm, you know, essentially what we're trying to
- 43:21do, realign the incentive to say, look, these tribes that are
- 43:24like kind of out there and not that many people, relatively
- 43:28speaking, agree or, you know, can understand what the heck
- 43:34they're saying, have less influence, not more influence.
- 43:39Yeah. Is there anything else that
- 43:42you'd like the audience to know? I think you know that there's
- 43:48other people out there. There's a lot of folks out there
- 43:50and you don't have to to be pushing for a reform.
- 43:54Like you don't have to be an independent voter, especially if
- 43:57you're engaged in the system. I mean, the most the, the folks
- 44:02that are really, really needed right now are the folks that are
- 44:05already in the Democratic Party, in the Republican Party and can
- 44:09help from within, convince enough people to say, look, this
- 44:13is not a sustainable path we're on.
- 44:15We need the, it's opening up. The process is actually good for
- 44:20us. That's how we open our tent and
- 44:22that's how we become stronger, whether you're Republican or
- 44:25Democrat. So I just say learn more visit
- 44:31at Ibn dot US if you want to know what's going on in the
- 44:34space and look, look around and find organizations like All
- 44:38Votes count Iowa. Reach out to them, say how can I
- 44:41get involved? Yeah, awesome.
- 44:44Yeah. And can you tell us a little bit
- 44:46more about Ibn dot US? Yeah, Ibn dot US.
- 44:50So the Independent Voter News, it's it's a publication of by
- 44:54Independent Voter Project and it's sister C3 organization.
- 44:58And we have we have a simple etiquette.
- 45:01It's you know, we always say we've been called liberals,
- 45:04conservatives, you know, anarchists and every, every
- 45:08pejorative you've heard, you know as well.
- 45:11And we say we're all on that, right?
- 45:14We're we're we're multi biased, like we're just, we're just
- 45:17saying what you think. And if you don't agree with
- 45:19something, then then write your own story.
- 45:22And that's kind of been our ethic.
- 45:24But at its core, what we focused on is, look, there's a reform
- 45:27effort going on in Iowa. Alaska passed a very
- 45:30revolutionary thing here, you know, did you know, how did, how
- 45:33did New York end up with ranked choice voting, but only in
- 45:36closed primaries? Things like that, that wake up
- 45:39thinking about, you know, we're, we're probably covering it.
- 45:44Awesome. I will be sure to put the link
- 45:46to both of those websites in the show notes, but I'll, I'll keep
- 45:51in touch with you and great. Yeah, and I'll find you on
- 45:54social media and stuff too so I can tag you in.
- 45:57Perfect. I wish I was more active, but
- 45:59I'm not as active as I should be.
- 46:01But yeah, I appreciate it very much.
- 46:04And also I can connect you with with the folks from Iowa.
- 46:08Oh, perfect. I'd love that.
- 46:09So all right, thank you for your.
- 46:12Time and appreciate you having me.
- 46:14Yep, thank you for being here. Reach out anytime.
- 46:17Will do.