Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / How does Attachment Style Change Over Time?
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:20love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is Thursday, April 17th, 2025 at 7:36 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:27Time. And I was thought that I would
- 0:29talk about a question that we get quite a bit, which is does
- 0:35your attachment strategy just change on its own over time?
- 0:42So could, could you expect as as you get older, that your
- 0:46attachment strategy would just develop in a, in a, in a better
- 0:50way than it did when you were a kid?
- 0:53And what I like to say in a totally facetious and mean way
- 0:57is that at 50, you become invisible.
- 1:01And then it doesn't matter which is just the representation of
- 1:07ages in our culture, that tremendous focus on
- 1:12youthfulness. But the answer, I think is a no.
- 1:21There are a few things that might alter attachments your
- 1:26attachment strategy as you get older, and mainly that's whether
- 1:31or not you're able to form secure functioning relationships
- 1:34with people. So that in the literature
- 1:38anyway, preoccupied people sometimes form relationships
- 1:43with secure people and in being in relationship today tend to be
- 1:48able to form a more secure functioning.
- 1:53But it's a double edged sword because if the preoccupied
- 1:57person forms the relationship in pretend mode, then they're not
- 2:02actually forming an authentic attachment, they're forming a
- 2:07pretend attachment. And when that's discovered by
- 2:10the secure person, it actually can undermine the security of
- 2:14the secure person and pushing them more toward a preoccupied
- 2:19stance. Attachment.
- 2:25Your attachment strategy is transgenerationally stable.
- 2:28That is to say, you are likely to have the same attachment
- 2:32strategy as your great great as your great grandmother.
- 2:36So 70% of people, it's that stable.
- 2:40In family systems, you have that same attachment strategy.
- 2:45It's your great grandmother, 85% chance of having the same
- 2:50attachment strategy as your primary caregiver.
- 2:57Most mostly what we do in life is look for people that have the
- 3:04compatible skill set so that we can form a relationship with the
- 3:09existing attachment strategy that we have.
- 3:13So secure people tend to go with secure people, dismissing people
- 3:18tend to go with preoccupied people, and disorganized people
- 3:22tend to go with disorganized people.
- 3:27Dismissing people can go with other just dismissing people.
- 3:30It becomes a kind of mutual affirmation Society, or I think
- 3:39the colloquial term, is a power couple.
- 3:45But preoccupied people don't tend to go with other
- 3:50preoccupied people because neither is exploring and
- 3:53exploration, and the exchange of information about exploration is
- 3:57so central to enlivening relationships.
- 4:01When there's an absence of that, relationships get stale and
- 4:05people don't pursue them. Lucy's arguing with me about
- 4:14that. The dog, in case you can't hear
- 4:18it because of the software. Software in, you know, in the
- 4:28non mentalizing mode, psychic equivalents, teleological mode
- 4:31and pretend mode, it it's possible to form relationships
- 4:36primarily from that place. And so in pretend mode in
- 4:42particular, you don't make an authentic attachment.
- 4:46You pretend to make an authentic attachment, which means that
- 4:50it's very changeable depending on what you're doing in the
- 4:53moment. You can shift out of it into
- 4:57something else. And So what happens when you
- 5:01enter into a relationship with somebody who's in pretend mode?
- 5:04A lot of the time when they get a better offer, they just go off
- 5:07to the better offer. They abandon you.
- 5:10And because you considered it an authentic attachment, unless you
- 5:16also were in pretend mode, it's quite shocking and painful that
- 5:20they can move on with such rapidity.
- 5:22I mean, it's almost head snapping, the speed that some
- 5:30people can move on from a relationship where they've made
- 5:33all of the expressions of it being something that really was
- 5:37significant and mattered to them.
- 5:40I think that's one of the reasons why I'm always talking
- 5:43about slow dating in the schedule of how long it is you
- 5:48should get to know somebody before you make any significant
- 5:51commitments to them so they actually know whether they have
- 5:55the capacity to make that commitment or not.
- 5:59You know, there's a, there's a the glow period.
- 6:02We'd like to say when you meet somebody, if they glow for you,
- 6:05they light up and it is meant to get you over that rough few
- 6:11months of negotiating the first deals in a relationship.
- 6:16I know not everybody appreciates the language of deals in
- 6:23relationships, but when you're talking about a relationship
- 6:28with somebody, particularly an adult relationship, you're
- 6:31talking about somebody who you're enlisting to provide care
- 6:35for you. And you do need to know whether
- 6:40that person is capable of providing the care that you need
- 6:44before you commit too heavily to them.
- 6:46Because it is easily easy during the globe period to commit to
- 6:51somebody in a fairly substantial way that actually isn't capable
- 6:55of taking care of you in the way that you need.
- 6:58And you wouldn't know that if you rush in too quickly.
- 7:02And then it's very easy to get into a mind state of they could
- 7:06do it if they wanted to. So that they're intentionally
- 7:10withholding it from me rather than really recognizing the the
- 7:17limitations of the other person. Each of us, you know, is this
- 7:23human being which is makes us all very alike.
- 7:28It's astonishing, I think most of the time how alike we are.
- 7:32And at the same time, our conditioning is completely
- 7:35unique. And so we, we straddle this
- 7:38having such similarities to each other and then at the same time
- 7:43being completely unique. And so we can easily be
- 7:46persuaded by the the way in which we are all the same and
- 7:53enter into a relationship with somebody who isn't capable of
- 7:57responding or supporting your uniqueness.
- 8:00Right. And then what do you do?
- 8:04Well, abandoned your uniqueness. But then of course a little
- 8:09while later the creeping despair grabs you by the ankles and
- 8:14pulls you under and you can't do it anymore.
- 8:18And then you attempt to renegotiate the relationship.
- 8:23In the couples work I do, it's almost always one person is
- 8:27content in the relationship and the other person is drowning and
- 8:33the content person doesn't see the need to change anything
- 8:37about the relationship because it completely works for them and
- 8:40the drowning person is going under and can't do it anymore.
- 8:46Sometimes they show up and they've already drowned, they
- 8:49just don't know it and they literally can't do it anymore.
- 8:54So I always recommend you do your couple's work at the
- 8:58beginning of the relationship, not at the end of it, so that
- 9:01you set it up in a way that really can work.
- 9:05Christian, do you find that this kind of dynamic occurs when one
- 9:10of the partners is actually secure or, or like would it not
- 9:13really come to that? Like are there conditions under
- 9:16which there can be security in relationship, but that's still
- 9:19there? I wouldn't.
- 9:21I would say that you could be insecure and negotiate a secure
- 9:25functioning relationship and the main difference would be that
- 9:29both partners are unwilling to accept the other partner feeling
- 9:33like they're losing. But in the relationships I I, I
- 9:38don't typically see those relationships because they don't
- 9:40need counseling. People who where one person is
- 9:44winning in the relationship and they don't mind that the other
- 9:47person is losing is where they get into trouble.
- 9:55Your caregiver is, if you take excellent care of your
- 9:59caregiver, then they're in excellent shape to take care of
- 10:03you. And if you don't take excellent
- 10:05care of your caregiver, they burn out after a while and then
- 10:08they can't take care of you. And so the quality of your care
- 10:12is diminished by that. And so it really is in your
- 10:16interest to take care of them in the way that they need because
- 10:21what do you get out of that is somebody that who is able to
- 10:23take care of you over a long period of time.
- 10:28Why does that matter? Because in secure functioning
- 10:32relationships, if you negotiate a good deal for both people and
- 10:37it's supportive for both people, then all of that work that you
- 10:41do to come to those agreements, you don't have to do anymore
- 10:46because you've made enduring agreements.
- 10:50And all of that energy that might go to stabilizing a
- 10:53relationship goes is then available to go toward your
- 10:58exploration. And if you pick somebody whose
- 11:02exploration is has good synergy with your exploration, you can
- 11:06actually cut cover much more territory than you would be able
- 11:10to cover on your own. So it's very enriching in that
- 11:13way too. But you know, in in
- 11:17relationships where one person is cared for and the other one
- 11:20isn't, it's also likely that one person is exploring and the
- 11:24other person isn't. And so that synergy that really
- 11:28carries the relationship is also absent.
- 11:32And often in those kinds of relationships, the, the
- 11:35exploration that's shared is the secondary exploration, the
- 11:40gathering of time, energy and resources.
- 11:43And the primary exploration is not shared.
- 11:47And so it becomes a a dialogue around stuff and it becomes
- 11:53teleological in the sense that if you give, if you give the
- 11:59right stuff, if you're the one who's exploring, the other
- 12:02person feels cared for, and if you don't give the right stuff,
- 12:05they don't. But it's not intimate and it's
- 12:08often transactional. One of the things that happens
- 12:16that reinforces the stability of the attachment strategy that you
- 12:21have as you enter into the kinds of relationships that are like
- 12:25the relationships that you've witnessed as a child.
- 12:31We learn our conflict resolution strategies by observing how the
- 12:37adults in that in the households that we grow up and manage their
- 12:41conflicts. And then when we go to form our
- 12:45own relationships and start our own households, we often mimic
- 12:50those attachment strategies. And So what we need to do in
- 12:55order to get that to work is to find somebody who's compatible
- 12:59with our conflict resolution strategy.
- 13:03You know, you have the early phase of attachment zero to
- 13:06three, say, which really sets the the foundational attachment
- 13:11strategy. And then you operate from that.
- 13:14You go off to the playground into school and your attachment
- 13:23strategy is the foundation of relationships.
- 13:25So even in that early age, you are drawn toward relationships
- 13:31that will fit to the kind of attachment conditioning that you
- 13:35have because those relationships will work and relationships that
- 13:40are outside of that frame don't so much.
- 13:45So you're drawn and then each time you have an experience in a
- 13:48relationship that's in the pattern of your household, it
- 13:52reinforces the idea that that is how the world operates.
- 13:58And you know, children are not that cognitive.
- 14:00They don't have a way of reflecting on the world as
- 14:06different from their own family systems.
- 14:10Then when you get to be an adult really and you have a cognitive
- 14:14capacity to reflect on what happened in your homes, you'll
- 14:22come to this place of did my caregivers tell me the truth
- 14:29about what was happening and did what they tell what and what
- 14:33they told me was that meant to be helpful to me?
- 14:38And if it wasn't, of course, it reinforces an unwillingness to
- 14:44be intimate with people. So then you're looking for more
- 14:49transactional role based relationships.
- 14:53Now around here I talk almost exclusively about collaborative
- 14:58relationships and I don't talk much about role based
- 15:01relationships. But if you went to the bookstore
- 15:04and to the help self help section on relationships, 9 out
- 15:08of 10 books are going to be on transactional role based
- 15:13relationships. Men are from Mars, women are
- 15:18from Venus as well. You know, a popular title.
- 15:24We have the Manosphere now which is trying to adapt to feminism
- 15:33in a way which is also looking for role based relationships
- 15:38which are defined by certain teleological qualities.
- 15:50That meant really never made any sense to me.
- 15:53I guess my early longing was to feel seen by somebody, to be
- 15:58known by somebody, to be acceptable because I was.
- 16:05So I had a mother who didn't like me.
- 16:07I mean it it, it sounds not necessarily completely
- 16:13catastrophic, but whether you're a child, it feels pretty bad.
- 16:18Really don't like you and are constantly critical of who you
- 16:22are, wants you and and expresses very explicitly how you should
- 16:28be different than you are. It's very painful, tends to
- 16:32cause you to hide. And so really what I wanted was
- 16:39not to have to keep hiding because it was too exhausting
- 16:43and wanted people to see me not understanding the the, that you
- 16:56have to tell people who you are because they can't intuit it.
- 16:59You aren't Tele teleopathic in that sense.
- 17:05Even if we're autistic, we're not.
- 17:09I don't think so. You tell people who you are and
- 17:17then the people who like you come forward.
- 17:20The same thing is true if you, if you, if you present a false
- 17:25representation of who you are, the people who like the false
- 17:29representation come forward. The big problem with that, of
- 17:34course, is that it leads to a sense of deprivation because
- 17:40you're not seen, you're not known, and your authentic needs
- 17:43are not being met. Your pretend needs are being
- 17:46met. And after a while it it makes
- 17:50you mad and you're angry and critical.
- 17:55So you notice. You may have noticed quite a
- 17:58few, or at least I do, bickering.
- 18:03I think they have a name for the Bickersons.
- 18:05Wasn't there ATV show where the characters are called the
- 18:09Bickersons? And then you discover that
- 18:16you're an adult and you're living outside of the family
- 18:19influence and you think, oh, this is a great idea, I'll just
- 18:23be authentic. And then you try to just be
- 18:25authentic. And then you begin to understand
- 18:27the nature of your unique conditioning that prevents you
- 18:32from being able to do that because it's too frightening and
- 18:36you have to overcome that fearfulness in order to do it.
- 18:41So the original question, of course, does your attachment
- 18:45strategy change much over time? It certainly can.
- 18:47But in order to change it, you have to be willing to tell
- 18:52people who you are, which means you have to be able to express
- 18:56authentically who you are in In some cases, people even know who
- 19:04they are. But a lot of times when you've
- 19:07been pretending for a long time, you lose track of who you are,
- 19:10and so you don't even know who you are.
- 19:12So how do you tell other people who who you are when you don't
- 19:15even know that was my? Question George is like.
- 19:19People. Do you know who?
- 19:21You are like, do people often know who they are?
- 19:22But yeah, yeah, I have a. Sense of not knowing.
- 19:26Who I am. Relationships.
- 19:28Yeah. So then the discovery, then the
- 19:31beginning of course is the discovery of who you are and
- 19:35what your actual preferences are.
- 19:38In in the work that we do, particularly around IPF, this
- 19:43actually is one of the most important things that can happen
- 19:46is that somebody will actually admit that they don't know who
- 19:49they are and they will admit that they can't find out on
- 19:53their own. So that neither that that's the
- 19:57moment that they come out of pretend mode and you can
- 20:03actually begin to change things. And up until then, as long as
- 20:07you're pretending to know who you are, know what you want and
- 20:12try to convince somebody of that you you don't.
- 20:17But the conditioning is really hard around that because it's
- 20:20feels so threatening to have to admit that.
- 20:27Christian George, I'm curious if you see kind of a useful
- 20:34looseness around that, that like maybe maybe someone's idea is if
- 20:40they get to secure attachment, they'll know exactly who they
- 20:42are for real. But I, I wonder, I wonder, like
- 20:48what you think about a kind of pervading healthy doubt that
- 20:55come that can accompany secure attachment?
- 20:59Well, when I started seriously to practice meditation, I wanted
- 21:04to be enlightened because I thought enlightenment meant I
- 21:07would have no more problems. This didn't turn out to be even
- 21:11remotely true. And do you bring up a good point
- 21:16in the sense that we aren't one thing, We aren't fixed, we are
- 21:23this collection of conditions, conditioning, and each moment
- 21:31ignites different aspects of that conditioning.
- 21:34And so that each moment, the sense of self that arises is
- 21:38both completely unique to the moment that it's arising in and
- 21:43at the same time a representation of the
- 21:50conditioning that you have that makes sense.
- 21:54So one of the ways we talked about that is an organized
- 21:57attachment. People's conditioning is fairly
- 22:00stable. And so they tend to predict in
- 22:02reliable ways where you could actually make a calculation that
- 22:07if I say this to them in this way, they'll take it in.
- 22:10But if I say the same content in a different way, they won't take
- 22:15it in because of their reactivity.
- 22:16But disorganized people, it's such a chaotic or chaotic maybe
- 22:25has a negative connotation. It's such a complex, the setup,
- 22:31it's very hard to predict how somebody's going to respond to
- 22:35that. That's one of the hallmarks of
- 22:37secure function, that you know somebody well enough that you
- 22:40know how to express something to them so that they'll understand
- 22:44what you mean without going mad. And you know, the self
- 22:53experience is insubstantial and not really what's happening.
- 22:59What's happening is the the whole body mind conditioning,
- 23:02which then the self is a witness to.
- 23:06So that whole body, mind conditioning can react in many
- 23:11ways given the circumstances, given the interpretation and the
- 23:19meaning. Disorganized people, of course,
- 23:23are dissociative, sort of also depends on what packet of
- 23:26memories that you hit in the forming of that moment.
- 23:34You know, in each moment, what opens up in front of you is all
- 23:38of the choices you could take, all of them, every single choice
- 23:41that you could take in the next moment.
- 23:44But what happens to a lot of us? We get into these very fixed
- 23:48views or these limiting beliefs about who we are and what's
- 23:52possible for us. And so we eliminate from our own
- 23:55awareness a vast quantity of the possibilities in front of us.
- 24:04And then we tend to pick over and over again the the more
- 24:08conditioned ones, they're more recognizable, they feel safer.
- 24:14And so over and over again, we choose to reinforce our
- 24:18responses in a way which, you know, enforces the attachment
- 24:26conditioning. We, we have an exercise where we
- 24:36touch back into the natural innocence of the child before
- 24:40anything bad happens. So that you can begin to get a
- 24:44sense of that childlike wonder of the for the world and for
- 24:49yourself. That that is often sequestered
- 24:54or hidden because of the things that happened in response to you
- 24:58expressing that. So that you can begin to use
- 25:03that kind of childlike energy in your exploration, that wonder at
- 25:10the way the world is, the way you are, which is a wonderful
- 25:19thing. Which is a really a question of
- 25:26beginning to shift into the view that some people are safe and
- 25:32some environments are safe. You can find those environments
- 25:37and those people and you can be really free to explore in the
- 25:45beginning. Though of course, when you, you,
- 25:47you admit that you can't explore because you're conditioning as
- 25:50such and that you always feel under pressure about having to
- 25:55come up with something. You can just sit in the not
- 26:03knowing and allow the whole body mind process to solve the
- 26:09problem if you have a sense of safety and a sense of
- 26:12encouragement. So that's what we're really in
- 26:15need of. We remove the pressure of
- 26:19performance, we remove the idea that it has to be acceptable to
- 26:26whoever was in charge of us when we were little, and to just let
- 26:30the mind fill in what it is that's important to us, what
- 26:34matters to us, and then begin this process of discovery.
- 26:43Resilience, of course, is one of the great necessities of
- 26:46exploration because most things don't turn out very well in
- 26:50terms of satisfying the the purpose of the exploration.
- 26:56And if you have resilience, of course, it's just all right sad
- 27:00next on to the next Ave. of exploration without too much lag
- 27:05time. And if you don't have resilience
- 27:07and you don't know what to do, each time you come up to that,
- 27:11that experience of it not turning out exactly how you
- 27:15wanted or as well as you might have wanted, you're thrown into
- 27:19the conundrum of what to do next.
- 27:23And that secure modeling of taking in the data, making a
- 27:28decision, taking an action, seeing what happens, collecting
- 27:33the data, making a decision for the next action, that flow of
- 27:37actions is really what represents security.
- 27:43That expectation that things will turn out well also eases
- 27:49that. But when you're in an insecure
- 27:53mind state where you're anticipating rejection, you're
- 27:57anticipating things not going well, it makes it much harder to
- 28:03explore when you feel or you're conditioned toward helplessness
- 28:11and, and you feel completely unable to make the decision for
- 28:16what direction to go in each time it doesn't work out
- 28:20perfectly. You're thrown into this
- 28:21conundrum of what to do next, which can be burdensome.
- 28:28And if you're disorganized, of course, it, it, it isn't that
- 28:31you think that you'll be rejected or humiliated or just
- 28:35have made a bad choice. It's that you're going to be
- 28:37killed if you make the wrong decision.
- 28:40And it just puts this enormous pressure on picking the perfect
- 28:45thing to do. Whereas at the other end of the
- 28:49scale is a secure scale. It's just gathering the data,
- 28:52making a decision, forming an intention, taking an action and
- 28:55see what happens, gathering the data, making a decision, forming
- 29:09an intention, taking an action, and then that cycle with the
- 29:15expectation that it's going to turn out well, we did.
- 29:20George, you mentioned about insecurity, feeling helpless and
- 29:27and not knowing not to do not what to do next, feeling
- 29:30burdensome. This is still the case.
- 29:33It's secure people. It's just that they feel burden
- 29:37but also safe at the same time. Well, they don't.
- 29:44Most of the time in these series of mundane small things that we
- 29:48need to do, if it doesn't go the right way, they just make
- 29:53another decision based on the data to go to course correct,
- 29:59you know, to go correct so that there isn't a catastrophe
- 30:05waiting for them. They're not.
- 30:06There isn't a rejection waiting for them.
- 30:09It isn't. They're not going to be spinning
- 30:13helplessly wondering what to do next, and they're not going to
- 30:18be afraid of the of terrible consequences, so they're not
- 30:23inhibited that way. Because they make decisions
- 30:27quickly. Because they make they're
- 30:31confident in their decision making process, which is
- 30:36underpinned by. If it doesn't go exactly as I
- 30:39thought, I can course correct. So they're making decisions
- 30:43quickly, but with the hope that eventually we'll be OK.
- 30:49Yeah, that, that's their expectation is that will turn
- 30:51out well. The decision person expects to
- 30:54be rejected. A preoccupied person can't make
- 30:59the first decision because really what they're attempting
- 31:02to do is avoid being thrown back into not knowing what to do,
- 31:07which is the thing that's uncomfortable and disorganized
- 31:10people are afraid of terrible consequences.
- 31:15And the solution that you tell your people who are working on
- 31:19this is to consciously force yourself towards making any
- 31:22decision perfectionism right away.
- 31:25The force is bad. I don't I don't recommend force.
- 31:30What I recommend is that you remove the pressure of having to
- 31:34make a decision that any decision you make, well produce
- 31:40the results. And if it isn't the results you
- 31:41want, then you can just make another decision.
- 31:44It doesn't have to be perfect because you're not attempting to
- 31:47avoid these negative outcomes doing it.
- 31:51And you can't know what the outcome is going to be.
- 31:53It's too complex. We, we, we are pathetic
- 31:58processors of vast amounts of data.
- 32:01And so we never make a decision on vast amounts of data.
- 32:04We make decisions on a cherry picking of data because that's
- 32:08what our capacity is taking the data is you don't get that much
- 32:17make an intention for an action based on an outcome you're
- 32:21hoping for. But the to guarantee an outcome
- 32:25is so complex. I see your hand, Christian.
- 32:30I'll, I'll call you Damasio said that if you dropped a drop of
- 32:41red dye into a glass of water, you would have to transform all
- 32:45matter in the universe into computing machines and let them
- 32:49process for 1000 years to be able to predict the movement of
- 32:53one dye molecule through an inch of water.
- 32:58How is it that we expect as human beings to, to with a
- 33:02little bit of data that we gather in the decision making
- 33:05process? We have to reliably predict
- 33:08what's going to happen. We, we, we can't do it.
- 33:11It's just not reasonable. But you can get yourself caught
- 33:18up in this idea that you should be able to do that.
- 33:20You should be able to take an action that has a predictable
- 33:23outcome. And sometimes you do and
- 33:25sometimes you don't. So it reinforces that.
- 33:29Is that making sense? You did also say that your
- 33:32smartphone could probably reverse engineer the move the
- 33:37path of the one molecule of die through an inch of water.
- 33:41And you'll notice as human beings, we really like these
- 33:45narratives that explain what happened with super accuracy,
- 33:50right? Even though they're also
- 33:53made-up. Christian So I wonder if to to
- 34:02what Moody was saying, you might agree with this kind of
- 34:06formulation that an insecure person or a secure person might
- 34:10have all the same set of possibilities in front of them.
- 34:13And the insecure person might make a decision, might, might
- 34:16take some action and then it not work out.
- 34:19And instead of seeing that there's other possibilities,
- 34:23they kind of retreat back into the helplessness that didn't
- 34:25work. Oh, I'm helpless, right?
- 34:27That's what happened. And, and the secure person would
- 34:29just see, well, there's other possibilities here, but there
- 34:33was possibilities for both people.
- 34:35It's just one person had a different belief about them.
- 34:40Mudit, you were at my house for dinner once and I bought this
- 34:43big watermelon and I carved it open and we all sat there on the
- 34:48first bite. It was spoiled and then I took
- 34:53it away. Very disappointing because a
- 34:57great big watermelon in summer is, you know, like it's
- 35:00spectacular. And I just brought out a bowl of
- 35:03oranges and and you said something along the lines of you
- 35:08pivoted rather fast from the rotten watermelon to the sliced
- 35:14oranges. That's what I mean now.
- 35:18It could have been a catastrophe of the ruined dessert, or it
- 35:23could have been a bowl of oranges.
- 35:26Feel like this applies to like smaller things, yes, but I feel
- 35:31it's hard to talk with people where you know, money is
- 35:34involved or moving is involved like big life decisions.
- 35:39And it's very easy to get back in the helpless state or
- 35:42negative state. If you know you you move cross
- 35:47country and then you realize it didn't work out and it's it's
- 35:50hard to tell yourself there are many possibilities.
- 35:54Well, yes, there are all the possibilities that are then
- 35:57related to the moment that you're in.
- 36:02It's like saying it's like saying stay positive in some
- 36:05sense, like. Well, you, you cannot predict
- 36:11with any reasonable accuracy what is going to happen.
- 36:16That's why in Buddhism we say you make an intention.
- 36:19The action that you're going to take, not the action is going to
- 36:23produce the results that you want, because there's no way to
- 36:25know that. It's one of those aspects of
- 36:30standing on the ground, this ground.
- 36:35How do you navigate that, that you can't predict the outcome of
- 36:40even a very good intention necessarily, and that all
- 36:46actions that you might take has an unseen consequence, right?
- 36:57How do you, how do you make plans for all of that?
- 37:00It just isn't what we can do as human beings.
- 37:04We, we don't have the capacity to do that.
- 37:08And so really what we're talking about is an ethical framework
- 37:11for the way that you participate in the world and the way that
- 37:15you world meeting other people. Of course, the way that you
- 37:18participate with other people in the the way that you treat
- 37:22yourself is in an ethical framework.
- 37:26And then taking the actions based in this way, then
- 37:30addressing what happens in the outcome of all of that, which
- 37:36you you sometimes know pretty quickly and sometimes not for a
- 37:39while. People just having this belief
- 37:54that anything could happen. And frequently does is is a
- 38:05pretty. Good way to change your I mean
- 38:08just having this belief that what do you expect will happen
- 38:14will what happens just having that expect removing that
- 38:18expectation is is is a big belief I guess.
- 38:22You know, Dan Brown used to say when I would grumble about the
- 38:26outcome of things, you live an ethical life, don't you?
- 38:30And I would say, well, I tried to, well, I, I, I know you, I, I
- 38:34watch you, you, you try to live an ethical life.
- 38:37And the thing you need to understand is if you lead an
- 38:40ethical life, the thing that happens is the good karma.
- 38:44You may not want it, but it's still the good karma.
- 38:46And so that what you have to do is examine in what way that
- 38:50that's represented in the good calm.
- 38:54So we were going to open a meditation center in December of
- 39:02the year before COVID hit. And if we had done that, we
- 39:10would have opened just at the time that the, the lockdown of
- 39:13COVID happened and we would have been bankrupt at the end of the
- 39:17year. So that when it didn't, didn't
- 39:20open, while it was tremendously disappointing at the time, it
- 39:24became evident that the, the timing actually wasn't going to
- 39:29be good for it. And, and what actually happened
- 39:33was nobody lost all that money because we didn't do it.
- 39:38But we, but it, it was not apparent at the time that that
- 39:42was what was happening. So that's another investigation,
- 39:47which is quite interesting is if I'm living an ethical life and
- 39:50my actions in the world are in that ethical frame, then what's
- 39:55happening here is the good karma.
- 39:59How is this the good karma? Even if it's something that I
- 40:02didn't want? So it isn't even that it turns
- 40:06out the way that you want means that it's good and it doesn't
- 40:09turn out the way you want. It is bad.
- 40:13But then you're at that moment. And of course, in this moment,
- 40:16this is called conditionality. In this moment, what opens up
- 40:22are all of the possibilities for the next moment and the choices
- 40:28of the next moment are based in this moment, which was based on
- 40:32the moment before it. And so this series of actions
- 40:36that you take create this this possibility for the next moment
- 40:46so that you can get on to these virtuous Jags and you can get on
- 40:50to these vicious Jags cycles depending on your action.
- 40:59And you're free to pivot at any moment depending on what you
- 41:02pick. Sir, one last thing I was going
- 41:12to say is there's another way that I'm realizing is thought
- 41:15put too much weight into anything.
- 41:19There is a free flowing version in the meditation world that the
- 41:25emptiness view just sees everything as not significant.
- 41:31That is another way of living that I thought is actually quite
- 41:35freeing. Because you don't really.
- 41:37Put too much meaning in anything.
- 41:41It doesn't last very long because the next moment has its
- 41:46own set of meanings. Any objective thing, at least
- 41:53the non dual that it's not it's it's you know, it's
- 42:00insignificant in some sense. So you don't you're not bothered
- 42:03by it. It's it's it's a.
- 42:06Right. It still could be very
- 42:12significant and not last very long.
- 42:18So even the significant things you can't grasp onto can't grab
- 42:24because they don't last either. So I might go in the direction
- 42:29of taking in as fully as you can every moment, knowing that it
- 42:33won't last. So you don't grab on to.
- 42:36You can fully experience it. It can be quite profound, quite
- 42:40meaningful, and then it's gone into the next moment and you
- 42:45don't grab onto anything. Yeah, I realize the meditation
- 42:55has put me in a slightly The object objects of the world are
- 43:00losing its grab, it's losing excitement.
- 43:05So it really had to push back in the in the, oh, let me take
- 43:10this. It is a it's an effort that oh,
- 43:12let me take this intentionally or fake it that this is amazing,
- 43:18even though internally I know that's completely useless.
- 43:22Because, you know, fully engaged, there's no way to avoid
- 43:26the losing of everything, because everything is lost.
- 43:29There is only a way of avoiding having it the first place.
- 43:34We, we can easily get into this idea that if we don't take it,
- 43:38if we don't engage it, we, we'll save ourselves the, the agony of
- 43:43losing it, but you still lose it, except you haven't really
- 43:47had it. And so the idea then is to push
- 43:49as fully as you can into each moment, each expression, do your
- 43:54very best at every little thing, every mundane thing, and then
- 44:01don't hold on as it passes. So why don't we do a little
- 44:08practice? What do you what would you like
- 44:10to do today? IPF.
- 44:18IPF yeah, OK, so go ahead and settle in.
- 44:32How's that? Nice.
- 44:44So what's coming up? We have a level 2 starting on
- 44:48Friday at 10:30 AM Pacific Time for two hours the 1st and 3rd
- 44:56Friday of the month, and that should be good.
- 45:01Let's see what else we got in these uncertain times.
- 45:14And then in May, on the 10th, we're going, oops, no, that's
- 45:25something else. On the 17th of May, we're going
- 45:29to start a level 2A level one class for three Saturdays
- 45:45and then we're going to do 1/2 day exploration retreat on June
- 45:4921st. That's an intermediate one
- 45:52night. I like to do the intermediate
- 45:57advance mentalizing in 1/2 day chunk just to, to go over what
- 46:02that development is. Really what we're talking about
- 46:04there is the, the, once you complete the preliminary
- 46:09practice of, of the attachment work and you want to go into the
- 46:14deep inside work that comes from meditation, then that's what
- 46:18this really is about. And then we'll have a, an
- 46:22advanced mentalizing retreat. Maybe I'll do it the week after
- 46:28the 28th. Anyway, that takes us through
- 46:32the first half of the year. Ioffer the teaching freely, but
- 46:39I do hope that if you're resourced and you can make a
- 46:41donation, you will. There's a link on the website
- 46:44for that. Any amount is helpful, supports
- 46:48me and also the work Medigroup is doing.
- 46:50Really appreciate your practice. It's wonderful to see you and I
- 46:54hope to see you soon. Bye.