Latest / Wheel Takes / WoT on Prime (S2E3 "What Might Be"): Doors and Windows
Transcript
- 0:17Oh baby, I am so excited to talk about this episode. Hi.
- 0:24Hi, Welcome to Wheel Takes, a podcast that Allie's doing the intro to.
- 0:30Yes, oh yeah, that is the thing I'm doing. Hi.
- 0:33Hello, Hi, and welcome to wheel Takes a podcast about the Wheel of
- 0:38Time, both the TV show and the books, and then also sometimes other
- 0:44series as well. Yeah, but we're not here to talk it out to
- 0:47Grahams. But we're not here to talk about those. We're here to talk
- 0:51about the Wheel of Time TV show. I'm Ali, and I am a
- 0:54screenwriter and a first time reader of The Wheel of Time on book eleven.
- 0:59I am guy, I am an actor, and I have finished the Wheel
- 1:03of Time series of books. And this episode contains spoilers in a few different
- 1:08ways because it's broken into three parts. The first part is the longest part,
- 1:12and it is the part that is only show spoilers, so we're going
- 1:15to try very hard not to touch on anything that is not covered by the
- 1:19show. The second part is spoilers through what Ali has read that's going to
- 1:23be delineated by us Siren. You will know it when you hear it.
- 1:27That is going to be spoilers up through the end of Crossroads of Twilight,
- 1:32And then the third part is going to be full book spoilers, where somebody
- 1:37else, probably Bree, comes and joins me, Brie, who is a
- 1:41writer, and we discuss the full spoiler ramifications and foreshadowings and commentaries and things.
- 1:49And I strongly suggest that you not skip different sections because the first section
- 1:55is the longest and it's the one where we cover the most stuff. What
- 2:00is this? Who is this podcast for? Alli? This podcast is what
- 2:05do you mean for? Is it for people who have not watched The Wheel
- 2:08of Time show? Yet? It's definitely not for you. Go watch the
- 2:13show, come back and then talk to us. Then yeah, this is
- 2:16a show for anybody who has watched. Is watching is rewatching The Wheel of
- 2:22Time on Amazon Prime. As we both work in the entertainment industry, we
- 2:27like to think we know a couple things about the process of adaptation and the
- 2:30process of visual storytelling, so we are here to sort of discuss the craft
- 2:38as well as potentially shed some light into why certain changes may have been made
- 2:43from the book to the show. We also should tell you that we are
- 2:46not any in any way affiliated with the show, so it's true our best
- 2:51guesses they sent us a box of stuff. But that's it. Yeah,
- 2:54So all of those preliminary things out of the way. Generally, here's what
- 3:00you're gonna hear. First, we're gonna spend a really fucking long time breaking
- 3:02down what happened in the episode we are, oh are we? We are
- 3:07almost certainly going to divide that into a plot threads. Usually those delineate down
- 3:15to what we like to call a plot, B plot, and C plot.
- 3:17The A plot tends to be the story driven, more story driven plot,
- 3:23The B plot tends to be the more emotional plot, and the C
- 3:25plot tends to be a thing that was happening along the way. Because of
- 3:30how many characters and how many plots there are, we might add D plots
- 3:34or E plots, or we might combine a couple plots. This is just
- 3:36the way that we like to keep track of the relative significance. I suppose
- 3:40you could say of any given plot and perhaps the the purpose of that plot
- 3:46in the overall story of the episode, and therefore in the overall story of
- 3:50the season, and therefore in the overall story of the Wheel of Time on
- 3:52Amazon Prime. So, without too much further ado, what's the what's the
- 4:00what's the season, what's the what's the question of this episode? The question
- 4:06for this episode, Gus is essentially, will each of our characters assimilate to
- 4:13or reject their new worlds? I like it. Here's what we've got going
- 4:17on. We have in terms of new worlds. Nine Eve in the accepted
- 4:23test, very literally a new world, very literally a new world. Will
- 4:27she assimilate to it to her own demise or will she reject it and live?
- 4:33Okay? Will Rand be able to navigate the politics of Kyrian? Yeah,
- 4:39we could give a fun little look at that, don't we. We
- 4:41sure do. Will Paren be able to survive the Shawn cham Well, his
- 4:46whole party doesn't, not all of his party does? I should say,
- 4:49right, oh god, what a heartbreaker. This is why, you know,
- 4:54has been so funny. By the way, we're so bob to make
- 4:57it hurt more. I know, Guy Robert with Guy Roberts character, I
- 5:01mean, you're still alive, yes, thank goodness, But unfortunately Uno is
- 5:06not fun. Fun little behind the scenes fact we actually know the actor who
- 5:12plays who know. Haven't we said this on the podcast? Yes, but
- 5:15it was last season and he's wonderful. They've known him a long time.
- 5:18He's a great prison and sometimes listens to this. And no he didn't tell
- 5:24us anything. No, he's extremely good at that. And no we didn't
- 5:28ask. No. And in fact, what's funny is that Jess, his
- 5:32wife, plays the woman who commands Yeah, the voice Alwin who commands his
- 5:42execution. So we messaged him. We were like, and your own wife,
- 5:46brutal stuff, heartbreaker, Yeah, it's and he said some sweet things
- 5:50about loving being on the show. Yes. And in terms of the thematic
- 5:57kind of questions of it all, obviously we are still very much in the
- 6:01who's the real monster phase of the theme. That thematic dichotomy being of course
- 6:09good versus evil, and us realizing good doesn't necessarily mean great, uh,
- 6:15and evil isn't necessarily bad. It's like, it's all very gray. Yeah,
- 6:21there are good bad guys. It's actually evil and good are kind of
- 6:26a wheel, as it turns out. Wow, why are you telling me
- 6:29that? There are themes layers themes. We can go so bad, we're
- 6:33actually good, so good, we're actually bad unheard unheard of. Well,
- 6:39we could be doing bad things for good reasons. We could we could be
- 6:42doing what people might think are goodat things, but they're actually bad things.
- 6:46It's all very you know, interesting, But also who are we saving the
- 6:51world for? And how can we not become monsters in that pursuit and lose
- 6:56sight of it? I love it? And this is the this is the
- 7:00uh if we are using our the structure that we like to look at things
- 7:04with. This is the story turn, right, this is have I not
- 7:09talked about that? Not? This episode? Huh? Episode three is the
- 7:14story turn episode in which we learn new information that propels us to the midpoint,
- 7:18which is the mini climax of the season. In the mid season,
- 7:21it's to make sure that the middle doesn't get boring, so we get a
- 7:25little boop in the middle where we think maybe it could be the end and
- 7:29that it's not. So here we go, Ali, what's our a plot
- 7:32this week? So, because I know you and I discussed, we discussed
- 7:36this at length, and at first my instinct was tarv Allen because it takes
- 7:42it the most screen time does and it starts first, which you would go,
- 7:46oh, that's a typical A plot, right there, A typical A
- 7:51plot with typical A plot things. But it's more the emotional story beat.
- 7:58It is because that was you said to me, all it's got to be
- 8:00Tarvallen, and I went, that's very character development forward. So it's a
- 8:05little bit blurry. I think there's an argument to be made for Tarvallen in
- 8:09general, and there's an argument to be made for Rand and Selene being the
- 8:13A plot. I am firmly camp Rand, Selene and Kyriean are the A
- 8:18plot. I personally think, far and away the movement of the story,
- 8:26which is not to say the most important stuff, but the stuff that actively
- 8:30progresses things that are happening in the world, is Kyrie. Now here's the
- 8:37thing. My plot is bigger and in a lot of ways richer and has
- 8:41more time for the characters to grow and develop. But the plot related one
- 8:43I think is Kyrie. Here's what I do typically when I'm watching. First,
- 8:48I will watch it with you because we get them, and then we
- 8:50watch them immediately. Then I will watch them with like a friend or family
- 8:54member and just listen to their reactions. Right who has not seen it for
- 8:58you know this time, So I'll listen for their reactions to things they they
- 9:03thought and liked and all of that stuff. Then I watch it and just
- 9:05do a like, I'm gonna write just preliminary notes and then I watch it
- 9:11a fourth time to do my more in depth detailed notes, and that that
- 9:15viewing takes like six hours, and that viewing takes like, yeah, I
- 9:18do it while I'm on the bike so that I'm doing something else at the
- 9:22time, and that, yeah, that takes like forever. So because you
- 9:26keep pausing and they keep pausing and going, oh, look at that angle.
- 9:31I bet this is saying this and let it d D D and I
- 9:33just do like a literary analysis, but I guess film analysis of everything that
- 9:41happens in the episode. And we started talking about this and you started saying
- 9:48this, and I was like, fuck, I think he might be right
- 9:50actually, And then so I had to do a fifth watch of this episode,
- 9:56and on the fifth watch I agreed with you. Oh hey, so
- 10:00I switched them because I agree with you. I don't think that uh Tarvallen
- 10:07forwards the plot so much as it forwards the emotional storylines, and randon Selene
- 10:13is the plot forwarding plot. I think. Also, you know what we
- 10:16got to remember is that nine he was entire accepted test. The first two
- 10:22and a half arches are in the cold open, not in then I know,
- 10:26I know body, that's that's what fucked me. Yeah, a bit
- 10:30in the first watch was I forgot that all of that was just the fucking
- 10:35cold open, which was hilarious because I watched the second time this episode with
- 10:39my friend Jen who works in film and TV with me, and when the
- 10:46this is like how distinctive this episode was? Was we get to the end
- 10:52of the the fake third arch and the wheel of time logo comes up and
- 11:00yelled, was that just all the fucking cold open? It was a long
- 11:05and the two of us like cackled because we were like, what was it?
- 11:07Like, it was twenty minutes? Twenty minutes, Yeah, episode that
- 11:11isn't unprecedented, well not unprecedented, but that is a wildly long cold open.
- 11:16It's like common typically they're like five maybe no, not even like I
- 11:24mean half a pay the conventional wisdom when they're like talking to you about things,
- 11:28and of course you know they give you the conventional wisdom. You know
- 11:31what the rules are, and then you break them and if it works,
- 11:35it works. In the pirates of the Caribbean, it's a guideline. Yeah,
- 11:37it's like if it works, it works. And then if it's not
- 11:39working, then you know why because you broke the convention, and the convention
- 11:45is usually better, but not always, in this particular instance, not better.
- 11:50I think, oh, they did really good job breaking the rules here,
- 11:54but that was like a twenty minute cold open when typically, god,
- 11:56they're like two minutes max. I feel like Dark Friend's Social was three and
- 12:01a half, but that's also I guess the season's over. Well, here's
- 12:05the thing that the typical thing is like half a page to two pages.
- 12:11You can get away with three, but god, nowhere near five. Sure,
- 12:13okay what a lot of people say five, and then they're like five
- 12:18is an absolute maximum, but usually it's like three, silly thing. Yeah,
- 12:24there's no absolute rules in it, just like how people say a scene
- 12:28shouldn't be more than three pages. Then that's true most of the time.
- 12:33Yeah, that's true. That is true at the time, but it's some
- 12:37things like motivated. I mean it also in TV. We're talking TV,
- 12:41not movies. We're also talking movies no longer than three minutes. But that
- 12:46you can, like, if you're thinking battle scenes and stuff like that that
- 12:48are super long, you'll usually get like different locations and stuff and that counts
- 12:52as a scene. So like in one location, no more than three three
- 12:56pages? Does this make sense? I? Yeah, that's surprised. That's
- 13:01what people say for for what but not for every three minutes is long in
- 13:07film and television in one location, that's true, No, I suppose that's
- 13:09true. It's usually keep in mind every time you switch locations. Yeah,
- 13:15now that's the more I'm thinking. I'm trying to think of a good counter
- 13:16example, but I can't really pull one up. Yeah, like if you
- 13:20go back to command watching or something that's a scene, there are what about
- 13:24Like I'm thinking things like it like a few good men or or you know,
- 13:31like every rule I know. But I'm just thinking, like Aaron Sorkins
- 13:35started as a play, right, and it shows that's a good point.
- 13:37I just feel like most things that take place and now now you're right,
- 13:41I think it's usually it's usually three. And they're like for like long battle
- 13:45scenes they say three, Like typically they're like one or two max. Okay,
- 13:50yeah, a lot of time they say as fast as you can without
- 13:54like losing speed, But for those like character bildy breath scenes, they'll say
- 14:00three. So then as a first big action packed scene in the Battlestar Galactica
- 14:05mini series when you have a dama getting ready for the speech, going up
- 14:09to do the speech, doing the speech, and then discussing the speech after
- 14:13he sits down. Those are not all one scene. No, great,
- 14:18okay, because what would you what you would do is so for the getting
- 14:22ready, that would be like interior dressing room, right, yeah, so
- 14:24that because he's not out in the auditorium, and then you would do interieror
- 14:28stage because that's a different location. And then you would do interior audience.
- 14:33Sure, so so and I'm sorry, I'm just fixated on this, but
- 14:37now I want to I want to engage with this, I mean guideline depending
- 14:43because sometimes you would do just like interior auditorium and then you just do the
- 14:46whole scene that way. But like usually every time you kind of like move
- 14:50to a new area, you're gonna specifically say interior somewhere else or exterior or
- 14:56somewhere else there or interior exterior. There's that one the scene of the one
- 15:01episode of Haunting of Hillhouse where the first thirty minutes are one continuous shot,
- 15:07but even that is panning back and forth between different parts different rooms of the
- 15:11house, the funeral home, right, yeah, and different rooms of the
- 15:15house. Well, that also kind of pushes it. Now because they're in
- 15:18the they're not always in the same room. They're like they'll be in the
- 15:22lobby area, they'll be in the viewing area. There's they travel around.
- 15:28It's because TV is a visual medium, it relies on things to be constantly
- 15:33moving. Sure so even yeah, so even in like Rope, right,
- 15:37which is a Hitchcock film that's all done in one take, which if you
- 15:39haven't seen it you should just because it's a really interesting exercise, much like
- 15:45that Haunting of Hillhouse episode. Yeah, but like even then, it's like
- 15:50there are different locations in the whole thing. It's not all just like two
- 15:54people talking in one room never leaving to another area of that room. Sure
- 16:00or and at that that's yeah, it is theater And now I'm we just
- 16:04rewatched a bunch of Carsawa movies. There's a scene, there's a sequence in
- 16:08Seven Samurai where the farmers have gone to the city to try to hire samurai.
- 16:15They're like sitting outside, sat and dejected. When the first samurai they
- 16:22hire, who is played by oh god, what is his name? Takashi
- 16:27Shimura. He like comes out of the city and then he kneels down and
- 16:34he cuts off his top knot hair bun thing, and then he dresses up
- 16:40in robes and then he and then we learn that he's going to try to
- 16:42save a child from a bandit, and then he goes in to the city
- 16:47and then he goes up to the house and then he gives the guy food
- 16:51and then he dives through the door, and then the bandit comes out having
- 16:53been punched in the face by Shimura, and then he comes out with the
- 16:57kid. That's not one scene, even though that's one long, continuous event,
- 17:03it's different vignettes with it, okay, because like the job of the
- 17:07writer is not to direct. This is like the really hard part of writing.
- 17:14There's samariat really weird and blurry lines sometimes between writer and director, right,
- 17:19And a lot of the kind of conventional wisdom is like writers don't or
- 17:23the advice that you get is writers don't direct the director and don't make and
- 17:29don't act for the actor. Right, So you can say, like what
- 17:33are they doing? And of course obviously people fuck around with this also,
- 17:38but like you were not going to put the shot list in anymore in a
- 17:45movie that you write right, like, you wouldn't put in the transition,
- 17:48sure, and you wouldn't go like pan in on blank. The worst thing
- 17:53you can do done anymore, No, not at all. And it's like
- 17:57the considered a kind of bad thing to do because it's making the reader aware
- 18:03of the camera. And what you're trying to do is immerse the reader in
- 18:07the reading experience so that they like the script so that they want to make
- 18:10it. And then the director goes in and decides, like what the shots
- 18:12are going to look like. You can telegraph though, there's like a blurry
- 18:17line there where you can telegraph to the director what you want the shots to
- 18:22look like, because it depends on what you focus on. So I could
- 18:25say, like Gus reaches into his hand, Gus reaches into his pocket and
- 18:30pulls out a lighter, or I can say, m Gus pulls out a
- 18:36lighter, or you can say, Gus's hand goes into his pocket a few
- 18:38seconds later it comes out with holding a lighter. Right, and all three
- 18:41of those are different shots, yeah, right. The first one would be
- 18:45all of me, the second one would be me, and probably the surrounding
- 18:48third one would probably be close up on my pants pocket, right, But
- 18:52I would never say in a script extreme close up on Gus's hand because I
- 18:55know I've seen that before. But that's old fashioned. It's old fashioned.
- 19:00People don't do that anymore because what you're really trying to do now is like
- 19:03we guys. One, directors don't like it because they're like, let me
- 19:07direct my fucking movie, right, yeah, or my fuck an episode,
- 19:11don't tell me how to do it. I mean, certainly there are like
- 19:15writer directors who still do it because they're like, I'm going to direct it
- 19:18anyway, So why do I care whether or not I'm directing it, because
- 19:21I'm going to direct it. That happens, but it's now considered to be
- 19:25like the writer's overstepping. It's the same thing as like I would say what
- 19:30their reactions are, not like what the emotion is. So it'd be like
- 19:36she gets sad, I'd be like her face crumples, which, by the
- 19:40way, stage directions like angry sad like an arrow for an actor. But
- 19:45it doesn't really help. No, But like saying she gets sad, well,
- 19:49one, it's not that interesting, yeah, But two it's telling the
- 19:53it's telegraphing to the actor what kinds of like layers are going to put onto
- 19:57the scene and that's annoying to the actor. Yeah, well, the character
- 20:00doesn't know what kind of movie they're in exactly. The character doesn't know what
- 20:06scene they're in. The character is sensibly existing in their day to day life
- 20:10that happens to be a tragedy. Yeah, like I'm writing tactics in for
- 20:14the writers. Tactics is this thing, Gus, you want to explain you're
- 20:17an actor. Yeah, tactic is essentially in any scene when you are acting,
- 20:22as an actor, you need to be actively trying to do something.
- 20:26Hence actor, you are not a passive or you are an actor, so
- 20:30you are trying to accomplish something that something can be. I want to escape
- 20:34that something can be. I want to make this person stop talking to me.
- 20:38That that can also be I want to dominate this this social gathering.
- 20:45A tactic is essentially a verb that that an actor uses to help them figure
- 20:51out what track they're going to go on to try to to try to accomplish
- 20:56their goal. Because as an actor, you are not coming into a scene
- 21:00thinking, okay, I need to finish the scene. That's not if that
- 21:04is what is motivating the character in the scene. That's boring as shit.
- 21:10The character comes into the scene one from somewhere else. You you walk into
- 21:15a room, you walk on to stage. You are not coming from off
- 21:18stage. Yes, literally, you the actor, are coming from off stage.
- 21:19But you better know where your character's coming from because a moment before.
- 21:23Yeah, because you, as the character, you did not just spawn in,
- 21:29right, You came from somewhere, and then you have come to this
- 21:32place. And when you come to this place, there is a thing that
- 21:34you have to accomplish. And usually yes, you have to accomplish it.
- 21:38Why because the writer said so. But the writer said so. Therefore you
- 21:42need to figure out a good reason, and you need to figure out how
- 21:47you are going to reach that goal. It's not just going to be I'm
- 21:51going to say my lines and leave. It's gonna be I'm gonna say my
- 21:53lines which mean these things and mean these things to me, and I'm going
- 21:57to say them in such a way as to achieve my my stated objective within
- 22:03the scene. And I'm not going to say them sadly because I, as
- 22:10a human being, do not experience emotions, because that is the right thing
- 22:15to do. I experience emotions because a thing happened to me, and then
- 22:18I respond by having an emotion. Yeah, acting is reacting. Acting is
- 22:21reacting. And then more often than not, I am not going to be
- 22:23actively trying to be mad or trying to be sad as a human being because
- 22:29I don't like being sad or mad. I like to usually be kind of
- 22:33content, right, and so with with being one more thing. Yeah,
- 22:38so so really, you know, when you see the stage direction sadly,
- 22:42it really means fighting off sadness. When you see enraged, that's a little
- 22:49better, but it's it's there's got to be it's either got to be attempting
- 22:53to regain composure or or lashing out. It's it's got to be something you
- 23:00can actively do. It's not just an emotion that you're layering over top of
- 23:03your existence anyway. I mean rambling that acting for a while now, But
- 23:06no, no, no, I think it's important for people to think about.
- 23:08And then when I talk about you know, not acting for you,
- 23:15our job as writers is to think about as screenwriters because you're really just kind
- 23:19of like building the body for people to put life into. I mean that's
- 23:25a monumental task in itself, but like the big point of it is that
- 23:30you are in a collaborative a collaborative process. So you're building the body so
- 23:37that someone else can put the breath in and someone else can open the eyes.
- 23:41You can make that easier to do by thinking about tactics in advance and
- 23:48thinking about creating active characters with active wants and the tactics they may use to
- 23:57get those things, and why they may want that. Is there a backstory
- 24:03there that may you know, cause them to want this? La da da
- 24:07da dah, and all of that kind of informs then what Gus would layer
- 24:11in with his like real life human experience and his real life human personality,
- 24:15And that's kind of how that works. But I wouldn't telegraph to Gus,
- 24:21Gus, you're doing this sadly and be like Gus Gus's face crumbles yeah,
- 24:26and go on yeah, because that is something physical Gus can do, and
- 24:30then he can layer in his own reasons for reasons for why yeah, And
- 24:37that's what makes for interesting stuff. Anyway, we went on this whole tangent
- 24:41from saying a scene is usually three pages long, because I fully expect that
- 24:45everybody heard that and went, oh, no way, no fucking way.
- 24:48So I wanted to make sure that we went over some examples of things that
- 24:52seem like they are certainly longer that might not be. And again, if
- 24:56you're thinking of an exception, you're probably right, it probably is. Yeah,
- 24:59you probably that probably is an exception if there's this, and there are
- 25:02exceptions to everyone, right, They say this so that writers don't deliver a
- 25:07twenty page scene thinking that that's the standard. It's not the shorter usually the
- 25:14better, Like I know as an executive, and every executive I've talked to
- 25:18has said the same thing. When the maximum amount of pages usually that you
- 25:23want to see for a film is one hundred and twenty pages, which is
- 25:27like two ish hours. But if you open your movie like the a submitted
- 25:34script from a writer and it is actually one hundred and twenty pages, you
- 25:37want to die. Why is that? Because that's one hundred and twenty fucking
- 25:41pages. Yeah, that's a lot to read. What the fuck are they
- 25:44doing for one hundred and twenty pages? You know? Like I mean,
- 25:48I would say usually things like when if you're trying to get an indie made,
- 25:53one hundred and twenty pages is wild? Yeah, that's wild amount of
- 25:59pages. What are they doing for one hundred and twenty pages? Ninety ninety
- 26:03is the sweet spot Usually for like an indie or a kid's movie, it's
- 26:07like sixty oh yeah, yeah, and then you go, but what about
- 26:11Disney. Disney's a whole fucking thing. Disney's not a fucking indie mom and
- 26:15pop shop, right, Like, we're not. This is not Indi.
- 26:19Indye does not equal Disney. Disney might buy your indie if it's good,
- 26:23but Indy, but India's indies should not be one hundred and twenty pages.
- 26:27People do not want to sit through two hours of an Indian. Well,
- 26:30we're also discussing here, but that's general. We're also just gonna hear what
- 26:34what would commonly be referred to as a blind submission, right, we're not
- 26:38talking about like from an unknown writer. Yeah, we're not. No actors
- 26:41attached. Director Pixar had an idea and they went to their writers and they
- 26:47asked a writer to do a draft, or they commissioned a draft. That's
- 26:51that's different. Yeah, we're talking about like Gus wrote a script and he
- 26:56sent it to A twenty four and it was one hundred and twenty five pages
- 26:59long, and I would open that and go, why the fuck is this
- 27:03undred day twenty four? Doesn't want to read it? Well, now,
- 27:06it's not to say that you can't make it two hour long indie movie.
- 27:07It's just that I will still read it. And you know what, I've
- 27:11read one hundred and twenty page movies that do deserve to be one hundred and
- 27:15twenty pages. Absolutely, is that usually the case? No, so you
- 27:19better eat that one hundred and twenty. That better be the best one hundred
- 27:25and twenty ever, you know. But because it's it's it's a tough it's
- 27:30a tough industry. It's really tough. And yeah, and every executive that
- 27:33I've talked to where I go like, oh, I wrote a feature,
- 27:37it's ninety pages breathes a sigh of relief. Yes. Yeah, just because
- 27:42something can be this amount of pages doesn't mean it should be. And that's
- 27:45a really important distinction. But also then if it's too short, they're like,
- 27:48what the fuck? Why is it so short? Because there's just standards
- 27:52that exist for a reason. Okay, the dog's snoring, you might hear
- 27:56a little bit of that. Yeah, sorry about that. I know everyone
- 27:57minds so much hearing little Doggie snores. Yeah, but so how who are
- 28:03we saving the world for? What? What are we doing things for?
- 28:07That's gonna be important. So a plot in short is rand Selene and logan
- 28:14B plot when I think we can start to put this under the kyrie an
- 28:17umbrella. B plot is Tarva Allen or Tarvlon as the show says, whatever,
- 28:22whichever what out and plot is parent in the shop chain. So we
- 28:41get to the cold open for the stasis that kind of is also the stasis.
- 28:47Yeah, it's the test, yeah, which is a fucking banger.
- 28:49So we're gonna talk about the test before anything else because it's the cold open,
- 28:52yes, right, can we first? Yeah, because it informs everything
- 28:59else that happens pretty much, So niney prior to going into the accepted test.
- 29:03It's an unusually long cold open, as I said, So we get
- 29:07kind of this moment before the test where Leanna says that she couldn't go in
- 29:11the first time, which is straight out of the books. Yeah. I
- 29:15think like almost all of the dialogue is verbatim from the books. Yeah,
- 29:19which is great. There's a lot of verbatim ship there are books in this
- 29:23big chunks, Yeah, or homages too. Ninive's accepted test is its own
- 29:32chapter, possibly two. It's been a minute in the Great Hunt m hm.
- 29:37But Leana says, oh, I should say notably in the books,
- 29:41nine Eve spends no time as a novice. She is accepted in the Immediate
- 29:45Tower and immediately goes through the test because she's so strong and older than the
- 29:51typical novice. Yeah. It's one thing that I feel like the show hasn't
- 29:53really emphasized too much, is that the White Tower. And they might get
- 29:57into this later, but the White Tower in the books is extraordinarily strict about
- 30:03agists. Yes, very ageist. They really don't want to let in people
- 30:07over the age of like eighteen's pushing it, which is kind of strange to
- 30:11me. Yeah, that is kind of strange to me, because I mean,
- 30:15what about the kids whose parents like won't let them go, or the
- 30:18people who don't have the spark they don't start channeling right away they want to
- 30:25or not they can learn. But Leanna says she couldn't go in the first
- 30:30time. I think the inclusion of that detail may be important later in the
- 30:33development of her character. Could be I'm kind of interested in that because they
- 30:37spent a beat on it, because I wonder, you know what other things
- 30:42does she struggle to face. Also a rare moment of humanity and understanding from
- 30:47the Isidaya as an institution, considering how they act for the rest of this
- 30:52episode. Yeah, Leandron tells Ninety not to do this for anyone but herself.
- 30:56Even the last episode we saw her pressuring Ninety into going in the arches
- 31:00in order to learn from her. Yeah, and this is something Rave talks
- 31:03about them behind the scenes. M hmm, if you want to bring that
- 31:07up. Yeah. He says that the reason that niney fails is because she's
- 31:10his opinion, in his opinion is because she does it for Agwayne, not
- 31:14for herself. Yeah, which I agree with. I think that's going back
- 31:18to Maxim saying you need to find your reason for being here. Yeah,
- 31:22and Leandron basically says that's not going to cut it when it comes to the
- 31:30accepted test. You need to be doing this for yourself. You need to
- 31:33clearly know that you want to do this. You want it, you gotta
- 31:37want it, And Ninive doesn't fully want it. No, Ninive has kind
- 31:41of lost a little bit of her purpose because of what Agwayne said in the
- 31:45last episode, you know, and Ninieve had said when Leandron showed up at
- 31:49the door, Agwayne, I have nothing to say to you. But now
- 31:55she I think she's struggling to figure out why she's still there, which is
- 31:57I think why the test goes partially wrong. I think so yeah, yeah.
- 32:05This is also significant because Nini oh yeah, I already said that.
- 32:08Still, Ninive can't let go of her desire to protect Agwayne, this desire
- 32:12specifically being played on by the Arches each time she enters her desire to protect
- 32:16people she loves. Yes, I can't help but think about the stream metaphor
- 32:21that Niniev says about surrendering to the stream when she does the Woman's circle.
- 32:25Yeah, uh, ritual. That's a big principle that comes with meditation,
- 32:30is the surrendering of control, no attachment, no reactivity, and radically accepting
- 32:35the things that come and to a certain extent, separating her ego from the
- 32:37equation, something it seems necessary to do when becoming an isid eye and what
- 32:43the Arches are specifically designed to test. Yep, Ninive fighting to protect the
- 32:47people she loves when she really can't fully because things are going to happen to
- 32:52them in the apocalypse and she can't control that. Specifically revolving around both Agwayne
- 32:57and Land is the big reason she ultimately fails her test. She's too attached
- 33:00to her protector role and that would interfere with her abilities. Is nice to
- 33:05die? I think it's also that you need to you know, the future
- 33:08arch especially gives you the thing you want the most. It seems like,
- 33:14yeah, she wants for herself and I talk about this later but uh in
- 33:19my notes, but she wants for herself and her friends, for them all
- 33:22to go home and go back to their peaceful lives as planned, separate from
- 33:28all of the dramas of the world, and unfortunately, at the time that
- 33:30they're living in that is not possible. And the Arches do eventually show her
- 33:35that that Hobbiton is going to be touched by the battles to come right,
- 33:40and does Niiney really want to not be prepared for that? Right? The
- 33:45stakes introduced in linking adds maybe a subtle additional stake to this initial scene.
- 33:50Also considering I think, so, yeah, I get where you're going it.
- 33:52Every time they link, there is that element of risk. Regardless of
- 33:57whether or not it seems like it's going to be dangerous, there is just
- 34:00a little bit of an elevated risk. Sure, I don't think nothing could
- 34:05ever happen to you while doing this, That is true. That is a
- 34:07change of the metaphysics from the books that in the books it is literally impossible
- 34:10to burn out while you're linked, right, versus in this when they're when
- 34:15we're talking about the most powerful channeler ever, well in a thousand years,
- 34:21you know, things are a little bit more unprecedented, and obviously they become
- 34:24increasingly unprecedented as ninety ive goes through her test. So like, while we
- 34:29know nothing ultimately that that is not something to be concerned about. If you're
- 34:32a first time watcher and you don't know what about what's about to fucking happen,
- 34:37the stakes of linking ever are raised. Sure I'd buy that. Does
- 34:42that make sense? We're coming out this from a like, well, we
- 34:45know nothing happens to them in this, but I'm like first time watchers do
- 34:51not. So the steaks are always raised. The dog is wagging his tail,
- 34:54you might hear it. He's sleeping. Also, considering the last time
- 34:58ninety was involved, in a scene in which link happened. This could be
- 35:00loaded. Okay, maybe I don't think they're doing that on purpose. Well,
- 35:05I mean her block has come around because of the last time. That's
- 35:07true. That's true. Doorways in general are a motif we should be paying
- 35:12attention to this episode. Yeah, doorways and windows, I really track a
- 35:15lot of that. I like I put in all caps. She's standing at
- 35:20a door. A lot of thresholds this episode as niney, Matt, Parrin,
- 35:28Agwayne and Rant really really good timings considering this is the story turn episode
- 35:31that we have a lot of, like doorways, windows, thresholds, liminal
- 35:36spaces in general, not like what the Internet calls a liminal space, which
- 35:40is like ooh, a creepy looking fucking gymnasium with the chair in it,
- 35:45Like an actual liminal space, which is a transitory space between two things.
- 35:50Yeah, they all have dramatic moments in doorways. Liminal spaces represent choice or
- 35:54transition that they are walking through, shutting or forging for themselves. He's having
- 36:00a happy dream. The dog is wagging his tail in his sleep. All
- 36:04right, so we get arch one. Arch one nine. Eve is a
- 36:07little girl, which they immediately telegraph in the absence of her braid and the
- 36:10cut of her clothes. The silhouette is so girlish that I immediately said,
- 36:15it's her as a kid, and it's when her parents die. Yeah.
- 36:17Well, and as you point it out, there's something else that is very
- 36:22clear that she's a young two Rivers girl, not two Rivers near the two
- 36:25Rivers. I, yes, she's a young girl, is I said,
- 36:29the cut of her clothes, the absence of her brain. Yeah, her
- 36:31brain. Oh you already said that. Yeah, I just wanted to emphasize
- 36:34that that was a big thing that was like, h it's different. Yeah,
- 36:37but yeah, the cut of her clothes is very girlish. It's not
- 36:38accounting for boobs. You know, this is a formative memory for nine Eve
- 36:44that, in my mind, is a more impactful choice than the one in
- 36:46the books. Yes, so in the book, said respectfully at this point,
- 36:50and I'm standing up and trying to get my copy off the one second.
- 36:53But you know, last season there were some people who are like,
- 36:57why would they change nine Eve's backstory? I think this is a big reason
- 37:01why. Well, the first being her connection with Land, the second being
- 37:07so that she isn't an angry black woman for no reason, you know,
- 37:12so that it can be grounded. Considering they cast a black woman who is
- 37:15angry, who into a character who is angry, They need to give her
- 37:17a deeper reason otherwise she becomes a stereotype. And then the third reason I
- 37:22think is moments like this where we can really explore just how rough she's had
- 37:30it and why that might lead to her being so protective over her friends and
- 37:36family. This shape to niney viz. And how her personality formed from a
- 37:42young age. She tampered with herbs and abilities potentially way beyond her understanding.
- 37:46How interesting now that she is tampering with her own abilities here in the Tower,
- 37:52that and some of those powers may be way beyond her understanding. In
- 37:55what other ways could Ninie be tampering with things without realizing. The day her
- 38:00father washes her hands and teaches her about the dangers of the herb also pay
- 38:05off to the ninety backstory In this moment, likely folks who were paying attention
- 38:08feel the dread of what's going to happen. We get that dramatic irony,
- 38:12mirroring Niney's own internal knowledge of where this scene goes. But we are forced
- 38:16to experience the horror of it with her. It provides clarity as to why
- 38:20she's so angry without playing into the stereotypically angry black woman, because it grounds
- 38:22her anger is something real and painful. Airy said that we also get to
- 38:25understand in this moment why she's so devoted to the two rivers, which is
- 38:29about to get real painful in the second arch. Now in the book,
- 38:32I think it's supoortant we talk about this I'm not done. I'm not done
- 38:37with my sentence and to the found family that she has. She's already lost
- 38:39a family once and she won't do it again. So there's a couple of
- 38:44things which, like the whole first arch is completely different from what it is
- 38:47in the book, and all of the reasons that Alie just described are I
- 38:52think big reasons of why that is the case. In the book, she
- 38:55goes through the first arch and then she's in like a Hedge maze and she's
- 38:59being chased by one of the Forsaken who was around at the Eye of the
- 39:01World. It's not a shaw Mau's different guy. And she is also naked
- 39:07and that's it. And then she she ultimately channels in the arch, which
- 39:12she's not supposed to be able to do in either the book or the show,
- 39:16and she beats the ship out of this guy and she has to stop
- 39:21herself from murdering him to go through the arch. I believe that in the
- 39:28book, and I have the book in front of me and I'm kind of
- 39:30looking while we talk. I'm fairly sure that she is also just naked for
- 39:35the entire test, which is just kind of like at the she's at least
- 39:39not in the land one. I think because she's a queen, she is
- 39:45not naked in the test. What I what I should say, comes out
- 39:47naked each time I think, no, she goes in. She goes in
- 39:51naked for sure, and she's naked in the agon or one. I don't
- 39:54think she's the second or third sorry, let me uh agon or being a
- 40:00forsake. And I think they're cutting from the show, not worried about saying
- 40:02that. What I meant there was that she has to in the book.
- 40:06In the show, she just takes off her This is a change that I've
- 40:08noticed that has come up in a couple different ways. Is the show seems
- 40:14to be tending away from just sort of think people being naked just because or
- 40:19you know, spanking just because, which are both things that come up more
- 40:22often in the books, and I appreciate that I do too, But I
- 40:27also I also think that if we're going to have violence against women in that
- 40:34particular way, which like in the books it's a lot more like gendered violence
- 40:43if that makes sense sure, or sexual assault implications, I just don't think
- 40:47it's needed. And if it's not needed, I think it should be cut.
- 40:52If it is not something that like is a we are trying specifically to
- 40:59say something here with this, I think it shouldn't happen. I kind of
- 41:04feel that way also about murder in general on screen. I think there should
- 41:07be a purpose to it. Yeah, By and large, characters death should
- 41:10serve a purpose. Yeah. I think that we should be trying to especially
- 41:16violent death. I feel like we should be trying to say something with it.
- 41:22You talking about who know, Yeah, I think that was very purpose
- 41:29and we'll talk about it, you know, because I feel like I watch
- 41:32shows with a lot of gratuitous violence and I'm just kind of like, but
- 41:37why though, are we just doing it to do it? It feels like
- 41:39we're just doing it for the shock value, and after a while, I
- 41:43feel like that honestly gets boring. Yeah, I'm like, I will watch
- 41:47shows with a lot of violence, but I'm like, I want that violence
- 41:52to matter. Yeah, i want that violence to matter. I want any
- 41:57violence against women, especially in that particular, or any sexual violence to absolutely
- 42:02matter and has to be done carefully and thoughtfully and well, because it's just
- 42:07like we're past the point of I think I think we should be past the
- 42:13point of like, let's have it because it's shocking. Well, that's you
- 42:15know, that's the eighties, right, Eighties, eighties films, eighties TV,
- 42:20eighties movies were just a lot of them are very good, but they
- 42:22also tended to lean very hard into these tropes and trends of gratuitous nudity and
- 42:29you know, bystanders getting gunned down while the main guy runs away. I'm
- 42:34thinking of total recall, I think is the Arnold movie and you know,
- 42:38blood and guts and kind of like exhibitionism almost of violence and people getting assaulted
- 42:45just cause. I think there's a lot of that too though, just in
- 42:49like recent stuff. I agree, but I just go, why, I
- 42:52know, sorry, I totally agree with you. I just wanted to highlight
- 42:54that I think the eighties were like the heyday of that. I'm not at
- 42:57all suggesting that it's gone. I think I think Game of Thrones, as
- 43:00has often been brought up, leans really really hard into shock value, murder,
- 43:07shock value, assault, shock value, gore. You know, though,
- 43:12go ahead, I've liked House of the Dragon so far. Yes,
- 43:16I know, I know there was a lot of flak for that one scene
- 43:20in the pilot. Yeah, I think that while it was shocking and appalling
- 43:28and upsetting, I think that the extent to which it was upsetting was purposeful.
- 43:34Yeah, I think I think it was purposeful. And so I'm like,
- 43:37regardless of whether or not you agreed with the decision they were, they
- 43:39did have something to say with doing that. Whereas I think, like the
- 43:44stuff that I'm thinking of is like a guy comes home and finds his girlfriend
- 43:46chopped up in the freezer. Yeah, the literal fridging where it becomes almost
- 43:52funny. We're like, I mean, fucking why that's silliness? Like this
- 43:57stuff needs to have some kind of emotional weight. I mean, not funny.
- 44:00It's not funny funny, but it's like almost becomes cartoonish because you're like,
- 44:06none of this is going to have any consequence or matter or whatever.
- 44:08And I mean this with all due respect. I feel like the accepted test
- 44:16scene in the past for nine Eve I thought when I read it would have
- 44:22more of that level of impact, and I don't think ultimately it did in
- 44:28the book. Yeah, not in a spoilery way. I just think no,
- 44:31I thought that there would be more of an impact to that scene,
- 44:37and I think it just was there as a like, here's something scary that
- 44:40could happen. I think what was smart about what they did here was they
- 44:45showcased violence, but in a way that was directly impactful to the character.
- 44:51Yeah, it's under story in the book. That's not to say that what
- 44:55happens tonight, and even the book isn't scary at any it is scary.
- 44:59I just think that what was smart about the change is that this is a
- 45:02change that will we don't want to waste any precious seconds of TV, right,
- 45:07and so this is something that will continuously be relevant to the character,
- 45:13as opposed to this which isn't continuously relevant to the character. Not really does
- 45:17that make sense? Yeah, And I think by exploring Ninety's backstory more,
- 45:23it makes it more weighty. It makes it more relevant. I get more
- 45:28of a reason of why she might want to stay and make this different,
- 45:30whereas in the book she gets the upper hand on agon or she is like,
- 45:34I could find and kill him, which is a good reason to stick
- 45:37around to kill a forsaken, but it doesn't have the same level of it's
- 45:39not personalized as a well. And also the minute the arch appears, she
- 45:44realizes that he's not real. No she doesn't. Oh well, we as
- 45:47readers realize that it's not he. It's kind of hinted that he that it
- 45:52might be but probably isn't. Yeah, because when she starts channeling, he's
- 45:55like, that's supposed to be impossible. Oh sure, So it's like a
- 45:59non zero chance that he's real. But also spoilers for the end of book
- 46:02one, not really kind of he died, so he's dead. Yeah,
- 46:06So you know, I saw a bunch of people commenting about how much they
- 46:08loved that the father was seen taking care of his child, like washing her
- 46:13hands and knowing about herbs, while the mother was a badass with a bow.
- 46:15I tally loved that choice, and I think it was very much deliberate.
- 46:20We specifically find out Nine's mother is named el Nore, which becomes important
- 46:23later. Oh and I wept, and I wept, and I wept.
- 46:27It was beautiful. Wept and wepped and wept. We see them hide nine
- 46:30Eve in the basement. When she wants to do something for them to help
- 46:35and Beeren says the lines in the Old Tongue that Land once translated for nine
- 46:38Eve before shutting the trap door. Hey on her, I forgot which button
- 46:46did watch? Watch? Which I tried to say what? And which at
- 46:50the same time didn't work the door now symbolizing the two bad choices. A
- 46:55classic protagonist to Lemma that Ninive has to choose between you help her parents would
- 47:00probably die or stay hidden as they probably die. Even though Land is not
- 47:06present physically in this, he has an important part to play when it comes
- 47:08to those lines in the Old Tongue. This also introduces some further questions about
- 47:13nineties past questions always being good in a narrative because it makes us want to
- 47:19keep consuming said narrative. Why did these people attack her parents? Were they
- 47:24just general baddies or was there a bigger reason? Why were they Why were
- 47:30her parents seemingly skilled fighters? How did her father know old tongue. I
- 47:37think it's likely that these mysteries will be further explained or explored later. I
- 47:42think that's the thing is there are a lot of questions that are introduced,
- 47:45and people want the kind of like immediate satisfaction of knowing the answers, But
- 47:52the questions are being introduced so that you waffo watch and find out. Right,
- 47:58if they just explained every thing right off the bat, that's not going
- 48:01to make for a very interesting or compelling narrative. And they're trying to create
- 48:06that sense. Both for the people who have read the books, because I
- 48:10mean, you love the books, but if everything's going to be the same,
- 48:14you're not necessarily going to be that interested. Actually, well, it's
- 48:17just it's going to be a different You could just read the books again and
- 48:21have all the answers and spoil people online and all of that fun stuff.
- 48:28And also for the people who are reading the books without confusing the people who
- 48:32are have not read the books. Yep, sorry, I said people who
- 48:37are reading the books twice. What I mean is people who haven't read the
- 48:38books and people who have. One of Nineve's big wounds is a character,
- 48:43right, a lot of the time you'll think about when it comes to your
- 48:45character's past, like what is their emotional wound? What is something that is
- 48:51informing who they are? We all inside of us have at least one probably
- 48:55emotional wound that has informed us as a person. We're like, Oh,
- 49:00something has happened to me at some point that has changed my perspective and I
- 49:06never want to be this, or I want to be this because of this
- 49:09thing that happened or whatever. I mean. You know, if you witnessed
- 49:14your dog pass away when you were young, of something preventable, maybe that
- 49:17made you want to be a vet. It's your origin story. But for
- 49:22nine Eve, her big wound is that she is someone who likes to save
- 49:27people, yes, and protect people, but she was unable at one point
- 49:32to save her parents. I think also, and I think this is going
- 49:36to tie in with Nineve's character arc generally this season. I think, in
- 49:40addition to the linking, I think the fact that she believes Rand to be
- 49:47dead is probably informing her block more than a little bit. Hugely, absolutely
- 49:53hugely. She failed again. Yeah, yeah, it continuously dry her in
- 50:00every scene, and that's when you know it's a really good wound is because
- 50:02it continuously comes up in different ways, and it's not in these ways where
- 50:07it's like, oh, I have this wound, you know, or she's
- 50:13going to explain to us each time why this impacts her wound. We know
- 50:15enough about her wound, right, That's why, Like Paren's wife was a
- 50:20choice that was made so that each time he struggles with violence, you understand
- 50:24intuitively why without him having to go. This reminds me of my wife all
- 50:29right, same thing. Every time she is struggling because she wants to protect
- 50:32someone, or because she wants to save someone, or she is really fascinated
- 50:37by the fact that they're so easily able to save people. And when she
- 50:40goes and sees the Yellowaja healing people, I mean, all of that comes
- 50:45stems from this moment. I can't help but think of how it also connects
- 50:50her to Leandron, who has been pretty focused on what can happen to vulnerable
- 50:52little girls, which I swear is some kind of core wound for her since
- 50:57it keeps coming up sounds like yeah, gotta be nine even knows that too
- 51:00well. In this vision, for a moment, she as an adult is
- 51:05potentially given the chance to rectify what has probably haunted her her whole life.
- 51:08She sat there and listened as her parents died and did nothing. While it's
- 51:13traumatic to see niney of the adult experience hearing her mother's dying screams, shout
- 51:16out to actress Melissa James, because that was haunting, real good man,
- 51:21really shit. Imagine being a little kid sitting there hearing that and unable to
- 51:28do anything. Oh like that is fucked with me since seeing that that episode
- 51:34is like, we watched her as an adult experience that, but she was
- 51:38a child. Mm hmm. Well when her dad falls on the on the
- 51:42floor beam and it's just looking at her, I thought that was her mother.
- 51:45I'm pretty sure that was a dad, but I could be wrong.
- 51:46I thought it was her mother because I could hear her screaming. I'll have
- 51:51to watch it again. Yeah, but you watched it more than me.
- 51:52I've seen it like five times. Every time. I thought it was Eleanor
- 51:57but maybe it's beerin. But regardless, that freaked me the fuck out.
- 52:00I mean, this is scary in a whole different way. This is like
- 52:05emotionally scarring forever forever. Define you fucked up? Scary and like anyone who
- 52:14is an ounce empathetic and who has been a child before and also knows children
- 52:20would be like, holy fuck, I can't even imagine that. But Nineva
- 52:23is an adult could potentially change everything because now she has power, but the
- 52:28artists forced her to want the power, you know, not physically like her
- 52:31power powers. But she's an adult, like, she's able, she's more
- 52:36able to protect herself. She's been training. She you know, understands weaponry
- 52:39to a certain extent. Oh, you're absolutely right. I'm looking at it
- 52:42again. It's definitely her mom. Yeah, it's definitely her mom because she's
- 52:45also screaming. Yeah. I don't know why I thought that I was wrong.
- 52:49No, it's fine. I mean either way, it's fucking awful.
- 52:52Yeah. I can't watch it again. Sorry, Gus is looking at it
- 52:55over there. I can't watch it again because it's so traumatizing. I've watched
- 53:01it five times. It was traumatizing every time. Yes, as powerful as
- 53:06Ninive is now, however she might fear it, it can't undo what has
- 53:09already come to pass. And Ninive is not a person who can turn her
- 53:13back on people who need her. And yet this is the this is only
- 53:15the first time she's forced to do so in the Arches. The Arches understand
- 53:20her core wounds and will make her face them three times three times. This
- 53:27is because, yeah, the Arches understand what might be her reasons for turning
- 53:30her back on the tower, the suffering of others that she loves. Ninive
- 53:36would probably abandon everything related to the tower to go help one of her friends.
- 53:43Probably, Yeah, she's a great friend. The appearance of the Archway
- 53:45represents a new third bad choice that's introduced, abandoned. The entire scenario pretty
- 53:51horrific if you ask me. Ninive comes out physically wounded by the experience.
- 53:55It's healed by Leanna, alluding to how the Isida will fix the physical wounds
- 53:59of this is but their emotional wounds are theirs to bear and there and she's
- 54:02told that, yeah, man, you know, they could really use a
- 54:06therapy adda they really for a long time, really could. Ninive goes into
- 54:10the second Urgency's tamuth or dying. Now, this is almost exactly the same
- 54:15sites. This looks very similar. There's a new wisdom. Yeah, there's
- 54:20a sickness in the books. The wisdom is like deliberately poisoning people, I
- 54:25believe, whereas in this case it's like it is it is a plague of
- 54:30some kind. Right again, the herbs make an appearance. Yeah, same
- 54:37one, isn't it Crimson Thorne? Yeah, ninety third time? Yeah,
- 54:40nine sees Natty Coffin has replaced her. Natty is so getting a redemption arc
- 54:45because she comes up so often. Can we just say she has now?
- 54:49She she Well, she's come up. The actress is also amazing, Yeah
- 54:53she Yeah. I think. Yeah. Look, here's the thing. I
- 54:58have a whole theory about how this is going to go down that I will
- 55:00share in the spoiler section. We look, Yeah, we'll talk about it.
- 55:07Can't talk about it now because it's no spoilers for anything. Yeah,
- 55:10and I don't know because Natty is very different, Yes, both of parents,
- 55:15both Natty and Apple Cothin, are very different from how they are in
- 55:17the books, which we've discussed that like, because I think it gives Matt
- 55:24a lot more emotional depth, which we'll also talk about. But yeah,
- 55:30I think she's coming up a lot for a reason. I think the fact
- 55:34that she's stepped into the role as wisdom, whether or not it's true,
- 55:37is showcasing her desire to become a leader in the community and be a force
- 55:42for good I do. Nine Eve tells Natty that the eyesid Ie can heal
- 55:46this, hearkening back to her one big reason for wanting to be an isid
- 55:51eye Yep, but discovers they have not answered calls for help, likely because
- 55:53bigger world events are going on, the brutality of being powerful is that there's
- 55:58only so much that you can do. Niney's whole hostility toward the Tower,
- 56:01in part, revolves around the rejection of the village's old wisdom because of her
- 56:05background. The idea that the eyesid I could cruelly neglect Nineyev's home, the
- 56:09most important place to her because they took her in at a time she was
- 56:13an orphan and became her found family, is theoretically enough for ninety to abandon
- 56:17her post, and the Arches know this, which is why it's particularly challenging.
- 56:22Natty tells Nineve the one thing that would hurt ninety Eve most to hear
- 56:28I'm the one that stayed. This isn't your home anymore. Niney likely feels
- 56:31guilt at abandoning her position, something she was good at and had people who
- 56:36needed her in, and she abandoned those people and without her their suffering.
- 56:40The magnitude of Ninety's leadership in the Two Rivers was emphasized by the braiding ceremony.
- 56:46Niney was taken in by this village. They basically saved her, but
- 56:51she likely never forgot that she was an outsider and tried to work her way
- 56:53in as a in as a gesture in the hopes that them needing her would
- 56:59make them fully accept her as one of their own. To be told that
- 57:02in putting yourself first for once, that her sacrifices to this point for them
- 57:07weren't enough, and they in turn have abandoned her. After all she's done
- 57:10for them, The love she found was conditional once she failed. That's something
- 57:15that will cut ninety to the core. Yeah, she's losing her family twice.
- 57:22Really, you know, all three of these are just gonna make a
- 57:23block worse. I mean, all three of these are just just a bad
- 57:30time. Ninety has a bad time, that is the point. But nine
- 57:35still puts aside those feelings to comfort tam getting at who she really is as
- 57:38a character. Right, She's even though they said this isn't your home anymore,
- 57:45Niney's response isn't fuck you that I'm leaving. She's like, well,
- 57:46then I'm gonna do what I can. Still, Tam twists the knife by
- 57:51asking about Rand, another person ninety failed to protect. We talked about him
- 57:53a little bit earlier. She lies to him, not out of deceit or
- 57:59coward but because, as angry as she is, she's a nurturer at heart
- 58:02and wants to protect him in these last moments. What good does it do
- 58:07him to know that his son is dead as he's dying none? Yep.
- 58:10Tam tells Niny that her presence is a comfort to him as he dies,
- 58:14and there is that familial love that Nineve is looking for, And just in
- 58:17that moment, Ninive is forced to abandon that love once again in her and
- 58:23abandon once again her instinct to protect and comfort the people she loves. Yep,
- 58:28the archway symbolically giving her another too bad choices. That comfort is similarly
- 58:32not available to her once she's back in the room with the other ice to
- 58:37die. Yeah, they just dump more fucking water on her head and tell
- 58:39her to shut the hell like you're cleansed. Okay, stop talking about it.
- 58:43We don't want to know. We don't want to know, We don't
- 58:44want to know. Shut up, shut up, shut up. Yeah,
- 58:45we're gonna just wash it away as if it never happened. And this brings
- 58:49us to our inciting incident a third test. Yeah, yeah it is,
- 58:53Yeah, inciting incident happening also late, like twenty minutes in HM, give
- 59:00or take. But it still works because it's interesting in the third arch.
- 59:05This is designed to feel violent and scary without a clear narrative. Yeah,
- 59:08this is a little different. Ninivas wearing bread potentially for the Red Ajia.
- 59:14Really only a little different, weirdly, only a little different because you will
- 59:16talk about it. But she's wearing red potentially maybe an allusion to the Red
- 59:22Aja. Yeah. I felt like Leandron was trying to fuck with it maybe,
- 59:25And it's clear that whatever she supposedly went through forced her to either let
- 59:30Land die or kill him. Yeah, the blood's not hers and all that.
- 59:34But of course this is a ploy to trick her and us into thinking
- 59:37she's out of the arches when she's still inside. It was hilarious because twice
- 59:42I watched this with a new person who was familiar with the Wheel of Time
- 59:45community, and it took both of them a second, like it took them
- 59:50a minute. It was different places both times where they were like, wait,
- 59:53that's this is fake. I okay, correct me if I'm wrong.
- 59:59I fel figured it out the second she was like I'm leaving. Yes,
- 1:00:02I believe, so I was like, oh, she's this is a fake.
- 1:00:06That was the point where I went, well, no, that won't
- 1:00:08work. It feel like even when she just walked out, I was like,
- 1:00:12this feels wrong. I was like, you're not gonna skip Arch three.
- 1:00:14It doesn't make sense unless there's some big reveal later. But both of
- 1:00:16the people I watched it with, not including me or not including you,
- 1:00:22both said oh, the community's going to have a lot to say about this.
- 1:00:24Because I was watching it and I was like, Okay, they're not
- 1:00:28doing this now because there there are changes, and then there are changes,
- 1:00:32yeah, and this is one that is changes that isn't gonna happen. There
- 1:00:37are changes where I'm like I can see the reason behind this, and I
- 1:00:39can understand where this might be going, and there are changes where I'm like,
- 1:00:44really, why don't and yeah, kind of like when I was watching
- 1:00:47The Last of Us behind the scenes and they were talking about We talked about
- 1:00:53changes, and it was like, if we can do it better, we'll
- 1:00:58do it, and if we can if it's worse or the same, we
- 1:01:00won't do it. Yeah. And of course that being the two people who
- 1:01:05worked on that, one of them Neil Druckman. Neil Druckman made the game,
- 1:01:09so he's kind of the authority. Well, yeah, their writer's room
- 1:01:13consisted of I believe two of them. Yeah. But had ninety Eves simply
- 1:01:20turned her back on the Isesida and left as a novice, that's one where
- 1:01:23I'd go like, why no, no, no, no, no,
- 1:01:27no, I don't see where you're going with this. Some of her hints
- 1:01:30maybe Leanna's coldness toward her when before Ninetyve went in, Leanna showed her some
- 1:01:36vulnerability by admitting she once couldn't go through, Like Leanna's not a cold is
- 1:01:40cold, but she's not cruel, And her little smile when she's like the
- 1:01:45blood's not hers to me was cruel. Yeah, So I was like,
- 1:01:50well, that doesn't feel like Leanna's callous even though we don't know Leanna.
- 1:01:53Well, she's not a cruel person. Because she showed that vulnerability by admitting
- 1:01:59she couldn't go through. It's a hint. Yeah, I need guess to
- 1:02:01verify that. The minute she says she couldn't remember what happened, I yelled
- 1:02:05that she was still in the arch. Just it's what I said. Nini
- 1:02:07seizes her own fate by walking out the door and abandoning her sisters, because
- 1:02:09when she went in, she wasn't really sure why she was there. Right.
- 1:02:15If she wanted to become an Isodi more than anything else, she would
- 1:02:19have taken the ring exactly to trick us and her Further, she gets a
- 1:02:22goodbye scene with Agwayne. She tells Agwayne that Isidai means servants of all,
- 1:02:28which is technically how Nini frequently behaves, so her leaving will be something she
- 1:02:31regrets. Nini's big fear is that she doesn't have what it takes to be
- 1:02:36an Isidie and what being one might do to her. Who will it turn
- 1:02:39her into? But the temptation to monsters, hey, But the temptation to
- 1:02:47return to what she was is ultimately too strong. Another hint at her being
- 1:02:52in the arches is the land's slow motion arrival without a God beautiful. I
- 1:02:57mean that's that it made everybody giggle, and there was a reason it seemed
- 1:03:02goofy, because it was meant to be goofy. Niniva's in her two,
- 1:03:07and there's a reason why when like the initial arch, the initial final arch
- 1:03:12happened, Everyone's like, what that was weird? Yeah, it was meant
- 1:03:16to be weird. Naniva's in her two rivers woolens. But she's still in
- 1:03:20yellow, with the color of a healer. So as much as she can
- 1:03:22try to run from who she is, she can't. Lana embraces her,
- 1:03:28by the way running from who you are also a matt thing, also apparent
- 1:03:31thing, also a ran thing, kind of everybody in this book except a
- 1:03:35gwayn a GWayne landambraces her just as the arch shows up, his face predatory.
- 1:03:42As the arch goes away, did you notice how weird his face is?
- 1:03:45No, watch it really quickly, Okay, watch how like his face
- 1:03:49does not seem loving in that moment? Really it feels victorious. Let me
- 1:03:53look it up. Hang on. Each time it's bothered me in a good
- 1:03:58way. Looks all loving and concerned. The arch comes, he looks concerned.
- 1:04:03He's like keeping her from going, and then he embraces her. Wait,
- 1:04:08wait for the embrace they hug. Look at his face. He looks
- 1:04:14like deeply contented And to me, that does not heart on disagree. It
- 1:04:21creeps me out every time I absolutely disagree with you. Not, No,
- 1:04:25I don't see it. It looks loving until he doesn't. He looks loving
- 1:04:28as shit. He closes his eyes and he rests his head on her head.
- 1:04:30Yeah, but to me it was more of a like, I have
- 1:04:32you now, I fully disagree with you, because also later in the Arch
- 1:04:36test landa is also a chill, dude, chill because if you weren't,
- 1:04:41it would be creepy. Yeah. I don't know. I don't know where
- 1:04:44you're coming from, but I respectfully disagree. I think it's predatory. But
- 1:04:48Ninety's choice is taken from her in part because she can't bring herself to abandoned
- 1:04:53Land now that she's left Agwayne. Her going into the archway for Agwayne is
- 1:04:57what leads to her downfall. Yes, Leandre, she tries to appear neutral
- 1:05:00to the way events transpire, though all of the Isidyes, standing there awkwardly
- 1:05:05was like kind of funny but also awful. It yes both, and Leandra
- 1:05:10tries to appear neutral to the way events transpired as Shiriam mourns the choice they
- 1:05:14made. This is the second time, it should be noted in two episodes
- 1:05:17we've seen Shariam deflect blame toward Leandron. Yeah, the first time being when
- 1:05:23she's talking to Alana and she's basically like, don't blame me, Leandron's making
- 1:05:27this choice happen, and this time where she's like, you better feel really
- 1:05:31bad about this. I know I will, which suggests to me this may
- 1:05:35be a dynamic to watch going forward, as is Shariam's kind of deflections of
- 1:05:41blame on herself. I see it. The isid ie are not as cold
- 1:05:44as they appear. Leandra throws the vase with the isid eye symbol an indication
- 1:05:48of her rage with herself and the tower as a whole. I also laughed
- 1:05:51to myself at the thought of constantly having to reset that shot. I even
- 1:05:55made the joke several times where she throws the vase and is like, cut
- 1:05:58all right, back to one set, where's the PA to clean up the
- 1:06:01vase? Back to one? Everybody? Back to one. That is what
- 1:06:05you say on a film set when you are taking a shot again from the
- 1:06:10top. You say, back to one or reset, yeah, cut,
- 1:06:13reset, and then the set pa with the broom comes out to sweep up
- 1:06:17the shards and props comes with a new vase. I always think about that
- 1:06:23shit when there's like broken stuff or things like that where I'm like, ugh,
- 1:06:27how many times did they do that shot? Oh? I bet they
- 1:06:29had a mark for where she had to throw it too. Yeah, but
- 1:06:32I bet they also had a mark that she had to throw it to per
- 1:06:35safety And uh yeah, that's the That's like a third of the episode right
- 1:06:40there, right there, and also the cold open, which is why I
- 1:06:43knew I got tricked to, like night, You've got tricked? Now?
- 1:06:45Should we talk about book third arch now? Or book third Arch later?
- 1:06:49We can talk about book third Let's talk about book third arch later. Okay,
- 1:06:55we're gonna talk about book third arch and what is different when we talk
- 1:06:58abouse. I feel like it'll be relevant later the button scene. Okay,
- 1:07:01so let's go to the A plot, but first we're gonna break for ads.
- 1:07:21Welcome back. Who wants to talk about a horny dragon named Rand who
- 1:07:27is actually mostly sad and trying his best. I'm excited to talk about this.
- 1:07:31I really liked Rand's stuff this episode. Yeah, I really liked everything
- 1:07:38he was doing. I liked everything that goes on between him and Selene.
- 1:07:42Yeah, it's just kind of cool. So Rand visits Logaine, who if
- 1:07:45we pick up right where we left off, yeah, who very quickly makes
- 1:07:50it clear he knows that Rand is there to learn from him. Is it
- 1:07:54right where we left I assumed it was like a bit later, because it's
- 1:07:58like, when are you going to ask me? It'd be a couple of
- 1:08:00days later. But for all intents and purposes, their relationship hasn't progressed because
- 1:08:02I feel like in Rand said, he's like, I'll get to know him,
- 1:08:05and then like, when the time is right, I'll slowly introduce the
- 1:08:09question. And Logan's like I knew who you were because you let them get
- 1:08:12it over with. You lit up like a fucking Christ the minute you walked
- 1:08:15in. Oh, let's do we want to talk about that? And generally
- 1:08:20the stuff about mechanics and being able to see things versus not being able to
- 1:08:24see things, Well, it's established a little gain can see. Yeah,
- 1:08:27they're they're being men. Who's off it? They're they're being picky with it,
- 1:08:30and I appreciate that, and it seems like the little sean Chan girl
- 1:08:38can see, which is why they use her to find people. Yeah,
- 1:08:42it seems like some of the some of the demani can can, which I
- 1:08:45kind of like in the books and where it was very briefly a metaphysics change
- 1:08:48in the books. All women can innately detect other women who can channel,
- 1:08:54and they can innately detect how strong they are, whether or not they're actively
- 1:08:58channeling. Men can only detect other men channeling when they are channeling. We
- 1:09:05have changed that. Yeah, it is different. How is it different?
- 1:09:09We will find out. So far, some certain people can detect the power
- 1:09:13in others and others can't. So far, it seems like what they call
- 1:09:16in the books a talent. Yeah, it's like a thing that you might
- 1:09:19be able to do that other people can't do. I'm assuming that that is
- 1:09:24to make it harder to spot people like the fores saken. Yeah, and
- 1:09:27without being too specific, there there are a lot of instances pretty soon in
- 1:09:32the books where channelers come up with a way to hide the ability to channel,
- 1:09:39which means, in my opinion, Robert Jordan wrote a rule and then
- 1:09:42he went, oh, I don't want that, and he found a way
- 1:09:44out of it. Yeah. So I think they're just the way out of
- 1:09:46it. Yeah, shortcutting the way out of it, which I think is
- 1:09:50a good idea. Yeah, Logan makes it very clear quickly that Rand is
- 1:09:56there to learn from him. We now get a look at Logan's continued rage
- 1:09:59towards the I said eye. And though he understood then that dragon, that
- 1:10:02Rand was likely the dragon reborn as he understood the power ninety wields, which
- 1:10:08compared to him, was like a blazing sun. Yes, he also seems
- 1:10:12a little bitter Ran just watched the procession when circumstances could have put him in
- 1:10:15his place. Logan is still a little deluded about being the dragon, either
- 1:10:20because it helps him deal with the things he's done, or because of the
- 1:10:24madness, or both, probably both. I also, by the way,
- 1:10:28this scene kind of parallels a throwaway conversation the thing that has discussed much much
- 1:10:35later in the books. Much later in the books, Logain references back to
- 1:10:41this event having happened in uh when he first saw Rand, and I like
- 1:10:45that they've put it here. Yeah. I also I think I think Rand
- 1:10:53showing up once again to break this illusion is devastating, So of course he
- 1:10:57taunts Rand and makes him get a special kind of wine in exchange for teaching
- 1:11:00him. Rand runs into an obstacle that perhaps Logan will not be able to
- 1:11:03or willing to teach him what he knows. So we get obstacles. We
- 1:11:10also get who are we doing this for? Mm hmm, Right, Logaine's
- 1:11:14putting himself in his feelings ahead of the greater good in this scene, right,
- 1:11:18yep? Yep? Important? Does that make him a monster? Perhaps?
- 1:11:24We get a glimpse of a gleaman who is essentially spreading what we later
- 1:11:28understand to be propaganda designed to send people to their deaths. Oh, and
- 1:11:31this guy has on the goofiest looking cloak. And this is also straight out
- 1:11:35of the books. Out of the book, right out of the books.
- 1:11:41Last year we saw last year, last season we saw Tom Marilyn. The
- 1:11:45inside of his cloak had some patches on it. This is this is a
- 1:11:48little more in line with how the gleam and cloak is described in the books.
- 1:11:51I am glad, and I think it makes sense that Tom Marilyn,
- 1:11:54down on his luck in Book one, did not have this code on.
- 1:11:57I also feel like it could be a visual separation between this Cleman, who
- 1:12:02seems very much into spreading this propaganda that is leading these people to their deaths
- 1:12:06and being part of this propaganda machine for the wealthy. And Tom who's playing
- 1:12:12in these taverns sad songs about men who can't forget yes and seems to be
- 1:12:17kind of rejecting a lot of this like Gleaman veneer and being part of this
- 1:12:25propaganda machine. Perhaps he's disillusioned with it makes sense to me. I mean,
- 1:12:30I don't know if I were like basically sent out to trick people into
- 1:12:35going to their deaths, I feel like I've become pretty deluded as well.
- 1:12:40That's what's dissillusion. Disillusion, Yeah, well that's what what is it?
- 1:12:45Selene says, they're all gonna go starve in the blight. Yeah, fucking
- 1:12:47rough. We get a low angle shot of this Gleaman, almost as if
- 1:12:50it's from a child's perspective. Oh that's a good point. Mm hm,
- 1:12:55oh I didn't think of that. That's cool. Yeah, it's like a
- 1:12:57low angle shot in the crowd makes some larger life, making him larger than
- 1:13:00life exactly. This is how the people see him as good. Mm hmm
- 1:13:05is good. And then we see things From Rand's perspective, this potentially gives
- 1:13:11Tom's Jada dis little context. Yep I said that this woman gets branded with
- 1:13:15a fucking horn. We glimpse the realities of what being the Hunter might mean
- 1:13:20when they're branded while screaming a glimpse into the fate awaiting them. We hear
- 1:13:27about the horn of a leer and understand better now what it is, and
- 1:13:30it's more app and after we've seen people looking for it and had it introduced,
- 1:13:36does Selene? Selene says right what it does calls dead heroes back from
- 1:13:41the grave. Selene is a woman with a sense of humor, one of
- 1:13:45the people. She's one of the people, a little sexy, and a
- 1:13:47shrewd businesswoman in the scene, all things that point to a woman we like
- 1:13:51and somebody that Rand should be learning from. Mm hmm. You know,
- 1:13:56I got to say this, this episode really makes me want them to get
- 1:14:02more into sort of I'm not gonna say anything book related. Don't worry how
- 1:14:06she can kind of cross class lines here, because it seems like that's very
- 1:14:13difficult to do in Kyrie in but she's able to wheedle her way, sneak
- 1:14:16her way into this party. She's able to get these fancy clothes and yet
- 1:14:19she lives in the foregate. Yeah, and we see how shrewd she is.
- 1:14:23I mean she says to this guy, give all the heroes a free
- 1:14:29round, yeah, and then charge them double when they start ordering for their
- 1:14:32mates. Yep, when they start buying rounds for their mates. She's a
- 1:14:36shrewd businesswoman. She's a woman of the world. And we've seen what happens
- 1:14:40when Rand is by himself. I mean, he's a sweet sheepherder baby.
- 1:14:45You know. I've seen people say like, oh, I like some first
- 1:14:49time watchers say like I like Rand's relationship with Celine because it feels more adult.
- 1:14:55It feels like he's She's a woman of the world. She's aware of
- 1:14:58what's going on. She can teach him the like street smarts essentially that like
- 1:15:03Agwayne, didn't you know? And there's nothing knocking Randon Agayne. It's just
- 1:15:08met there. They might not fix or maybe they do and they will come
- 1:15:13back together. We talked about how there were toxic elements to this relationship.
- 1:15:16Is it purely toxic? I don't think so. Oh, I don't think
- 1:15:19so either. I think there are elements to it that are concerning, But
- 1:15:23I don't think it is all bad. I think what you're bringing up is
- 1:15:26something important that I think we should clock, which is the flawed mentor.
- 1:15:29Yes, right, like Tom, Moraine, Leandrin, Shirium, Leanna,
- 1:15:36like the Alana Selene. There are all people who are Logane, oh my
- 1:15:43god, who are mentoring them. They might not be good people, but
- 1:15:46they might also just be flawed. Yeah, And what's great is it's hard
- 1:15:54to discern which is which, Like odds are some of these mentors might not
- 1:15:59be good people. We can't know for sure which not in the world that's
- 1:16:03as gray as this well Tom, and Tom introduces himself by robbing Matt exactly,
- 1:16:11and then he's given him sage advice. At the end of the episode,
- 1:16:14Leandron shoves Nineive against a wall, and in a scene that I am
- 1:16:16convinced is intentionally mirroring that scene, Logane shoves Rand against a wall. Moraine
- 1:16:23threatens to kill them. Yep. I mean nobody's like perfect in this and
- 1:16:30nobody's perfect amongst the friends. Mad abandoned his friends and is a thief.
- 1:16:34Paren killed his wife. I mean that was not his fault, but still
- 1:16:38and is a wolf boy rand might go mad. Ninive has baggage and is
- 1:16:46like super powerful in a way that scares her. And Agrain is hyper ambitious,
- 1:16:50which is not a bad thing. Which is not a bad thing.
- 1:16:53A Gwayne's fine, she just has ambitions that are beyond home. Well,
- 1:16:57I think a GWayne Gwen's flo us that she's jealous of ninety jealous. Yeah,
- 1:17:02Igwaine is jealous. It's not ambition that is being I think shown to
- 1:17:06be the issue with Agwaine. I think the issue is she gets jealous of
- 1:17:10other people. Yeah, comparative, an attitude where she compares herself too much,
- 1:17:15Like I feel like Agwayne is the person where Morain talked about the dragon
- 1:17:18and Agwaine was like, it's me and it should be me. Anything,
- 1:17:20it should be me, Yeah, which most people might feel that way.
- 1:17:25I think if it's special, it should be me. Some people would feel
- 1:17:28I would feel that way even though it might be a very bad thing.
- 1:17:31But I feel like it might be very bad, but it is special,
- 1:17:33but special. And I want a gold star. I want a gold star.
- 1:17:39I want to be told that I'm good at things. I want to
- 1:17:42be exceptional and everyone's favorite, and I want to be liked by everyone.
- 1:17:47Something that is possible to do is be liked by everyone? Did you know
- 1:17:50that it's definitely totally impossible? And to be the best all the time,
- 1:17:55And that is definitely not a trauma response, because you're like, if I
- 1:18:01can control being the best, and nothing bad could happen to me, right
- 1:18:05because I'm the best. No, that's not that you become quickly deluded.
- 1:18:12Aguaenne is me at twenty Aguenna Matt combined are me at twenty, which is
- 1:18:15a confusing combination. That's funny, and you go, what a self destructive
- 1:18:18sounding combination? And you would be correct. It is a self destructing sounding
- 1:18:23combination. We're at the Kyrie Noble party next with Rand and Selene. Selene's
- 1:18:32outfit in This is to Die For? Can I just give a shout out
- 1:18:36the costume designers? Fantastic, absolutely gorgeous. It feels like and the I
- 1:18:42think the costume designers encapsulated this and the set designers did too. Some Asian
- 1:18:46influences melded with pre revolutionary France, like there were the big there's the big
- 1:18:51hair and the wigs and the opulence. But also I felt like the textures
- 1:18:58of the designs felt out of Asian influence and the kind of like way that
- 1:19:01the dresses were built. Kyrie in in the books is kind of presented as
- 1:19:06a mid middling mash mishmash of elements of French culture and Chinese culture. And
- 1:19:15I feel like they nailed they really fucking nailed it with these costumes. They
- 1:19:18were gorge I was like a goog Rand getting letters from the nobles, which
- 1:19:27is directly a reference to the books. And Rand's coat. Oh yeah,
- 1:19:31and Selena is the one that gives him the coat, which to me,
- 1:19:35that is that is the that is sort of an iconic costume in the book
- 1:19:41at this point. That awesome is great. Really, this whole Rand hob
- 1:19:46nobbing bit is a nod to one of the major things going on with Rand
- 1:19:53in book two. And I'm going to get again fairly loose with how much
- 1:19:56I get into this, because Rand's journey plot wise in book two is very
- 1:20:00different from his plot wise journey in season two. His plot journey emotional emotional
- 1:20:09journey. His emotional journey in season two is a hybrid of his emotional journey
- 1:20:14in book two and book three. Sure, but some of the beats are
- 1:20:16very similar the inn catching on fire. Oh, a lot of people party
- 1:20:20the letters, Selene. No, No, many of the beats are similar.
- 1:20:25They're in different orders and sometimes they serve different explosit purposes. Sure,
- 1:20:28but the emotional journey, the emotional journey is very similar. I think more
- 1:20:31to book three than book two. But also there's a good deal of Book
- 1:20:36two. But Rand does spend a lot of time in Kyrine in the books
- 1:20:41in book two, and he actually, I would well, it's about the
- 1:20:45same amount of time I guess in Kyrie in book two. But there is
- 1:20:48this this thing with the letters is a nod to a much more lengthy series
- 1:20:59of letters he keeps getting and he keeps burning. Oh, and it stresses
- 1:21:02me out. It's so funny because the more letters he burns, the more
- 1:21:04letters he gets, which is exactly what the what Lady Alver says, Yeah,
- 1:21:09which is now you really have them talking, And I just I just
- 1:21:12thought this was such a clever way to sort of make reference to that.
- 1:21:17Yeah, it's so great. He just throws it out in the fire.
- 1:21:21Now, something something that I caught that I that I'm curious about. Okay,
- 1:21:27yes, tell me, unless you had something else you wanted to say,
- 1:21:29I have so much I want to say, so you get your thing
- 1:21:32in First, it looked to me like one of the people in the cold
- 1:21:38open of episode one was a little person. Yes, and Rand gets that
- 1:21:43invite from Lady so and so, Lady Dulaane. I only know that because
- 1:21:47I watched this yeah five times. Who is also a little person? If
- 1:21:51this show gets renewed for season four, it's because of me watching these episodes
- 1:21:58one thousand times apiece. So I just I thought it was I'm keeping my
- 1:22:02eye on that. Yes, I think here's the thing. I think if
- 1:22:06we are going to have a little person dark friend, which I am totally
- 1:22:10into, I'm always into little people being given acting opportunities. I think there
- 1:22:16just needs to be more diversity on screen in general. I think good actors
- 1:22:23are good actors, so we should just cast good actors. We can't have
- 1:22:27the only little person representation in the show. So I am expecting that we
- 1:22:30will have more little people, which I think is excellent. Yes, because
- 1:22:33here's the thing. We can have evil little people. We can have evil
- 1:22:38people of any race, any gender, any sexual orientation, whatever. But
- 1:22:44if that is your only representation of a marginalized group, I mean albinism,
- 1:22:49right, Like people in the albino community are like, please stop labeling us
- 1:22:53as vilains. It's not great. No, please stop making this thing we
- 1:23:00have into a commentary on who we are as people. It's fucked up.
- 1:23:05It's a pigment thing. That's fucked up. It's just a pigment thing.
- 1:23:09It doesn't mean anything about us. Yeah, can you have someone with albinism
- 1:23:15be an evil person? Yeah? You should probably not have that be your
- 1:23:18only representation, and you should probably make that super nuance. I brought this
- 1:23:24up only because I think that it seems as though that is a the who
- 1:23:29were these people? Thing is going to be something they will lean into.
- 1:23:32Oh yeah, and I that's like one of the best parts of the series
- 1:23:36in my opinion. Yeah, it's trying to puzzle things out. It's trying
- 1:23:40to puzzle stuff out. So yeah, I think definitely paying attention to who
- 1:23:44was in that circle is going to be massively important. So I think that
- 1:23:47this will not be the only little person that we see that I'm using the
- 1:23:51listen right, yes, it's little trying to be sure, listen, if
- 1:23:56we see more little people, I'm going to really start casting suspicions, at
- 1:23:59least diger Laine for sures E's I'm gonna be like hm hmm. And I
- 1:24:03believe a little person qualifies as just anyone under I think it's for eleven,
- 1:24:09like it's not very small. Like I knew people who technically, even though
- 1:24:14they didn't have like Dwarfism or anything like that, technically qualified as little people
- 1:24:17because they were just short. That's cool. So it could just also be
- 1:24:21a really short person, could I'm not wrong? I mean, who technically
- 1:24:28qualifies as a little And Verre is but on Ver is the one who kind
- 1:24:32of breaks everything down. We know that her name is Onvere because of the
- 1:24:36She says, that's right. Oh, and she says, I'm because Celine
- 1:24:41says, I don't believe I've made your acquaintance, lady there ah there,
- 1:24:45And I like how she says it very French sounded, very French sounding.
- 1:24:48There is an alvert in the books. Yes, I'm gonna I'm gonna hold
- 1:24:56off on saying who she is until the book spoiler section or until a spoiler
- 1:25:00spoiler section, until the book spoiler section. And also I want to see
- 1:25:04if they go anywhere with this Okay, yeah, so I'm gonna hold it
- 1:25:08off on that for now. On Ver is stepping in as another mentor figure.
- 1:25:13Rand stands in a corner. We should note the whole time he's out
- 1:25:16of the party, symbolizing his discomfort and that he doesn't feel like he belongs
- 1:25:20there. Onver informs him, amid shots of the Nobil nobility celebrating lavishly,
- 1:25:27that the rich don't want to feed any more poor mouths, and that the
- 1:25:30hunt for the horn is a ruse to get rid of peasants, something Rand
- 1:25:32was fooled by. Rand is still very much a boy from the Two Rivers
- 1:25:35and is not adept at spotting the political machinations going on around him because it's
- 1:25:41not what he knows. The experience with Dana last season that showed that just
- 1:25:44because something is a reminder of home doesn't mean it's safe has not fully translated
- 1:25:47to a world wise rant, which is why Selene might be good for him.
- 1:25:51That will be an arc that will potentially take time, but he'll have
- 1:25:55to quickly get wise if he is to be the Dragon, because he will
- 1:25:58be having to deal with people like these. Rand standing out in red amidst
- 1:26:02the softer color scheme is also purposeful. He doesn't fit in very much.
- 1:26:08Not the color of the folks in the Foregate is somewhere he blends in.
- 1:26:12He wears the same colors, and it's a comforting color, the same dark
- 1:26:15blue that Morain often wears. Here, he stands uncomfortably out from the crowd,
- 1:26:19not fitting in visually as well as internally. Selene comes over and on
- 1:26:24Ver says, they haven't been introduced. Though Selene is a girl from the
- 1:26:28Foregate. She is comfortable in this environment and in going toe to toe with
- 1:26:31some of the someone of the upper classes, which seems odd. It is
- 1:26:35weird. You know, it stands out. It stands out. It's suggesting
- 1:26:41there might be more to her backstory. Yeah, it does seem. And
- 1:26:44she got these fancy fun but she had disgraced noble. What is she?
- 1:26:47What? You know? Morain talks about being from a fallen house, Yrien
- 1:26:51Alver doesn't recognize her. No, that seems significant, Yeah, especially considering
- 1:26:57she's older. So she probably, you know, has been around on the
- 1:27:00block a bit and knows people. She seems to know everybody else at this
- 1:27:03party. She says, we haven't been introduced, and Selene says, no,
- 1:27:08we have not, and then leads randaway rather than introducing herself. There's
- 1:27:12some subtext there that that should peak the audience's interest. Why doesn't she want
- 1:27:16to get to know on var. Is it to make sure they don't get
- 1:27:18discovered as people from the Foregate or something else? What might she be?
- 1:27:23What might she be protecting rand from, especially considering that she's more street wise
- 1:27:27than him. There are so many ways in which Selene seems to be filling
- 1:27:30Morain's role in the scene, right down to the fact that she wears blue,
- 1:27:33and she wears blue constantly in the Foregate, which is the color of
- 1:27:38the Foregate, but it's not the color of the nobility. She's still wearing
- 1:27:42blue. She's still a mentor figure. It's kind of white this stress,
- 1:27:45isn't it. It's light blue. Oh cool, So it's blending in with
- 1:27:50the Pastelli colors, but it's still blue. She's teaching him what he needs
- 1:27:54to survive in this world. But does that come with a callousness that could
- 1:27:58lead our boy who gives money to little boys in the street to becoming someone
- 1:28:01who chuckles at the at the outrage toward the evils of the wealthy time will
- 1:28:05tell. Selene gives Ran the wine that he needs. Rand is still in
- 1:28:10a corner in this scene. He's still not coming from most of the scene
- 1:28:13in a corp. He spends the whole scene in this or not his scene.
- 1:28:15He's solved. She's solving his problems without. Let me clarify, not
- 1:28:20this scene is not good for him. I mean this environment is not his
- 1:28:25preferred environment. No, she's solving his problems without needing to know what they
- 1:28:28are like because he doesn't explain to her. He says, like, flirtatiously,
- 1:28:32I thought you'd like a little mystery or something along those lines, which
- 1:28:36she seems to be okay with. Yeah, she shows her street smarts that
- 1:28:41Rand lack lacks when she chuckles at his outrage about the hunt for the horn.
- 1:28:45Selene has shown her own shrewd ability to take advantage of the hunt for
- 1:28:48the Horn for her own business in an earlier scene in which she tells someone
- 1:28:51to you know, do the free ale and then charge them double. But
- 1:28:55we've seen our members be shrewd before, Moraine, tom Land, Leandre and
- 1:28:59a lot Vren and Rand has seen the issues with not being able to keep
- 1:29:03up with that shrewdness in the world, Jana being a big example. Selene
- 1:29:08says that this is the most political city in the world. Everything everyone does
- 1:29:12is part of some scheme or some game, and she brings up that that's
- 1:29:15why Lady Anver wanted to talk to him again, She's protecting him from his
- 1:29:18own ignorance. Maybe just because someone looks like they're offering advice and help doesn't
- 1:29:24make them safe. Rand then questions why she associates with him then, and
- 1:29:29she says, don't ask questions. You know the answers to meaning she loves
- 1:29:31him, that's why, but also you know it begs the question. Rand
- 1:29:38says in response, I'm sorry I shouldn't have asked for your help and leaves.
- 1:29:42And her response is, but we're having fun. You're going to miss
- 1:29:45the fireworks. As she says this, she's out of the corner, in
- 1:29:47the middle of everything and speaking loudly enough for people to hear. She seems
- 1:29:53comfortable. She's comfortable here, yep, and in the world of politics.
- 1:29:57To Rand, what he's just learned was a big deal and made him sick
- 1:30:00of what he's seeing. To Selene, who is aware of the information already,
- 1:30:03the fact alone isn't enough to ruin her night. Her callousness is what
- 1:30:06turns Rand away, because despite all he has become, he can't bring himself
- 1:30:11to be this level of callous to other people suffering. He can't be this
- 1:30:15hard. No, and we know that because of how we've seen him with
- 1:30:18Errol and the people of the Foregate, Like we know that. That's why
- 1:30:21those scenes were there, so we could see sweet baby Rant. I really
- 1:30:26don't think you can understate the importance and not importance, but significance and relevance
- 1:30:30of Rand and Eryl. No, that was one of the most important scenes
- 1:30:34that they've ever added. I think, yeah, And I talk about this
- 1:30:36even more later again in the book. Very different arc that Rand is on.
- 1:30:45He is more closely connected to what Paren is doing. I think you
- 1:30:48could go ahead. I think it's so important that we are seeing one the
- 1:30:53emotional impact of the news that Rand is the dragon on him right, Yeah,
- 1:30:58and two who he is now so that we can set him up for
- 1:31:02where he needs to go. Yes, there's a lot of time for Rand
- 1:31:06to be having these big battles, these big action sequences, but right now
- 1:31:11we need to see Rand the person, not Ran the dragon. A shepherd
- 1:31:15named Randal Thor. Yes, it were. That's what we're seeing. And
- 1:31:18that's why he's so comfortable in the Foregate, and that's why he stays there,
- 1:31:21and he stays there in the books too, because he's more comfortable because
- 1:31:25these are his people. Oh he does, doesn't, Yeah he does.
- 1:31:27He stays in the Foregate both times. Yeah, I forgot about that.
- 1:31:30These are his kind of people. Errol and the people of the Foregate,
- 1:31:33and Selene being from the Foregate, should be more empathetic to how they're being
- 1:31:38taken advantage of. But as we've seen with one of the workers in the
- 1:31:42asylum, being poor doesn't make you automatically empathetic to the suffering of others.
- 1:31:45On the other hand, Dana was so empathetic she became a dark friend.
- 1:31:49Yep. So surely there's some balance to be struck between the two. I
- 1:31:53love that we keep going back to Dana. I will, at the end
- 1:31:58of this show, when the show is finally done, write an essay about
- 1:32:02why Dana wasn't the one of the most important additions to this show Dana and
- 1:32:08Errol. The question of Dana and Errol. I will just write an essay
- 1:32:12about why those two scenes were some of the most important new scenes, because
- 1:32:15sometimes people are like, oh, why are we wasting time on this when
- 1:32:19like there's all this other stuff that they could have put in instead because they're
- 1:32:23playing the long game. Well, h okay, fine, the question of
- 1:32:28Errol Steppin' and Dana why these characters were added, why they're important before we
- 1:32:32get into and then another about the transformation of Natty and Apple Coffin before we
- 1:32:38get into rand Loo Gain and the spillage of wine. We should probably take
- 1:32:44a quick at break welcome back. So Selene says, right in the middle
- 1:33:02of everything, right, she's out of the corner. She's not uncomfortable taking
- 1:33:05up space. You're going to miss the fireworks. And I fucking love a
- 1:33:09good transition, so I had to call this one out. This is a
- 1:33:12good one. This is such a good transition. Transitions are hard as shit,
- 1:33:16and you know when you write one and you're like, I fucking nailed
- 1:33:19that transition. So Selene says in the middle of everything, right, because
- 1:33:26she's obviously comfortable in the space. She's not in the corners, she's in
- 1:33:29the center, and she says, you're going to miss the fireworks. Cut
- 1:33:32to the fireworks, establishing shot of the fireworks right after she says that nice
- 1:33:39transition. In the books, the ruler of kyrie In sets off fireworks to
- 1:33:43distract the poor so that they don't rebell. Mm hmm. That's like a
- 1:33:46tactic that he uses. Yeah, they frequently, And there are these big
- 1:33:50parties in the fore gate, much like the one in episode two where the
- 1:33:57ruler just dumps money to basic let let the poor people get drunk and have
- 1:34:02fun so they don't rise up. So it feels very purposeful. Given the
- 1:34:06conversation Ran just had with Selene about distracting people with the horn and like trying
- 1:34:12to get rid of them, that they also have the fireworks going. That
- 1:34:15is very well handled yet Yeah, very clever. Close up on a tearful
- 1:34:19low Gain watching the fireworks. Likely Yah, this is great. Likely saddened
- 1:34:25because they remind him of the power he used to have that he can now
- 1:34:28only watch. I meant to go back and rewatch the scene between him and
- 1:34:32the King of Galdan when the two people are talking to him, the two
- 1:34:36like sworely, Yeah, people are talking to him, do you remember what
- 1:34:42that conversation was about? Because this isn't it implied that he like killed his
- 1:34:45sister or something. No, can you go back on your phone and see
- 1:34:51what they say? Because which episode of this episode? Four? Six?
- 1:34:56Right? Four? It's like a place. Let me pull it up.
- 1:35:00I meant to go back and watch it because I feel like that scene informs
- 1:35:04Logan's mental state now, in part because I was kind of thinking about,
- 1:35:09like, Logain probably had to do a lot of really shitty stuff in order
- 1:35:14to become who he became and to survive for that long, and then for
- 1:35:19all of that to be for nothing, which it is right now. I'm
- 1:35:24not saying whether or not it will be, but for all of that to
- 1:35:27theoretically be for nothing is rough as buck. Okay, I'm watching it reading
- 1:35:31the subtitles. He'll betray you, just like your parents, just like your
- 1:35:35sister. Okay, So it's kind of implied there that he maybe killed his
- 1:35:40family, Yeah, because they betrayed him, whether or not they actually betrayed
- 1:35:45him or not, or if that was the madness talking is also TBD.
- 1:35:49Right, I gotta watch season one again. Man, it's been too long.
- 1:35:54It's so funny to see the weaves without any coloration. Yeah, that's
- 1:35:58so different. Well, I mean, I think the weaves were in addition
- 1:36:01because we're learning more, you know, Like they wanted to introduce that as
- 1:36:05a concept when the girls were in the tower, so that we could be
- 1:36:10novices at the same time as their novices. So that's not too much information
- 1:36:14at once. So like they were giving us a look at what other people
- 1:36:17see and then showing us the weaves once they could see them. Yeah,
- 1:36:20I like that, or once they could actually experience them. Otherwise than we
- 1:36:26have to explain what weaves are, and we have, you know, and
- 1:36:29that's all stuff that is stuff that can be punted down the line to a
- 1:36:33place that's easier to you know, address it. Okay, But he's tearfully
- 1:36:40watching the fireworks, and I think he's likely saddened because they remind him of
- 1:36:43the power he used to have that he can now only watch, like the
- 1:36:46fact that he can see he still has the talent to see that people can
- 1:36:50channel even though he's cut off from the power. So that kind of implies
- 1:36:56that that talent is like men's talent. It's not like magic magic, it's
- 1:37:00not channeling, it's something else. But that's brutal am I wrong that he
- 1:37:04can still see that Rand can channel, yeah, but he can't touch it
- 1:37:10himself. Yeah, that's rough. Rough. He used to be able to
- 1:37:13shoot things like fireworks from his fingertips, and now he just can see them
- 1:37:17in the sky. Yeah, that's tough. A bit of a downgrade if
- 1:37:19you ask me. We hear other people reveling, a reminder of the world
- 1:37:24he can no longer participate in. Rand asked Logan, how do I stop
- 1:37:29it? That's his question that he immediately says. Also noteworthy, Rand is
- 1:37:32now in his asylum. Get up is like workout fit. Yeah, he
- 1:37:38changed out of that coat as fast as he could. He did not show
- 1:37:42up in his party outfit. He changed. Logan says it can't be contained
- 1:37:45and that it will spill out of him. The way this is worded feels
- 1:37:48very purposely coded to harken back again to what a Shamaiel said earlier this season
- 1:37:53about monsters. The monster within Rand can't be contained. Logan at the same
- 1:37:58time uses the wine that Rand got him a visual metaphor for this power spilling
- 1:38:01out of him, wasting what to other people would be appallingly expensive. They
- 1:38:06can't get that wine at the foregate. It's fancy yep, likely triggering Rand
- 1:38:12to considering likely triggering to Rand considering his moment before. Yeah, he walks
- 1:38:16into that having witnessed lavish bullshit while everyone's talking about how do we get rid
- 1:38:20of the poor people? Let's trick them into dying somewhere else. And now
- 1:38:25he's seeing like the wine that he works so hard to get being wasted by
- 1:38:30the sky and also showcasing that Logaine sent Rand on the errand just to mess
- 1:38:35with him. He's wasting time in the appending apocalypse for petty reasons. Rand
- 1:38:42says that Logine is mad in anger right. He throws that in his face.
- 1:38:45The way he's treating him is far different than his gentleness with Errol.
- 1:38:49Rand is back in his workman clothes. Oh, I said that even if
- 1:38:53it's after hours, because he got out of his stuff as quickly as he
- 1:38:55could to make him more comfortable. Logane says that the eyes that I made
- 1:38:59up the madness to poison the world against men so they can cast straight us.
- 1:39:03Yeah, interesting word choice. But they know that only and he says,
- 1:39:08but they know that only the dragon can defeat the dark one. Though
- 1:39:11we have seen the madness to be true. With our own eyes. We
- 1:39:14are getting a look at how Logan has talked himself into a different version of
- 1:39:16events, likely a combination of the madness and a response to the guilty feels
- 1:39:20at hurting so many people for nothing, including potentially his own family. Probably
- 1:39:25is I mean, I don't know how he's living with that, right,
- 1:39:28and he's not even the dragon, so it was all for nothing? Yep.
- 1:39:31Also, the verbiage on this feels super purposeful considering past critiques of the
- 1:39:35show. Oh yeah, they're cast trading the men on the show, well
- 1:39:41they wrote or samps whatever, But yeah, I think it is. It's
- 1:39:45interesting still. Also also people's general blame of women and feminism escapegoats at the
- 1:39:50moment, Yeah, and always Ran tells Logane, you're not the dragon.
- 1:39:56This has a double meat after this. This has a double meaning literal sense
- 1:40:00that yes, he's not the dragon because obviously literally not Yeah, but also
- 1:40:04in a larger sense, the thing the world needs is not this hot this
- 1:40:08dude, hyper masculine in cell person who disregards human life and precious things,
- 1:40:13is blind to reality and blames others for the hurt he caused. The world
- 1:40:16needs a man like Rand who feels empathy for the poor and the hurting.
- 1:40:19Who feels discomfort and lavish things and political dealings. That's the real dragon,
- 1:40:25provided he can survive the cruel world that he's sent to save. Logaine shoves
- 1:40:29Ran violently up against the wall, almost echoing what Leandron did tonight, even
- 1:40:32a teaching moment, but in this case he has to do it physically because
- 1:40:36his magic is gone. I think that's a purposeful mirror. I'd agree with
- 1:40:42that. Bell Gain says, I'm the only one who can teach you,
- 1:40:45and Rand says in response, you can't, you're sick. There's a lot
- 1:40:47of people getting pushed into walls. Rand pushes Selina into the wall too.
- 1:40:53Oh, I mean it's a typical. It's a tactic of like physically threatening
- 1:40:58somebody. Yeah. I mean, if you think about it just metaphorically,
- 1:41:01it's about like who has the power in that moment. But in the other
- 1:41:04two it was Leandron and Rand that had the power in those moments. Though
- 1:41:10Selene I think was kind of his like equal because she wasn't afraid of him
- 1:41:14when he did that to her. Versus this where Logan does that to Rand,
- 1:41:17and Rand is really the one with the power in the situation, because
- 1:41:21Logain does it out of desperation, because he says, you're going to get
- 1:41:25me out of here. I can feel it. Yeah, I'm the only
- 1:41:28one who can teach you, and Rand says you can't. You're sick.
- 1:41:30Sick. Rand is rejecting Logane's help because Logain is not going to really be
- 1:41:34able to teach him what Rand needs to be a good Dragon. Right.
- 1:41:38As we've established before, this is right on the heels of Rand rejecting Selene's
- 1:41:43mentorship as well, because become mean, this interested in playing political games and
- 1:41:46having power at the expense, at the expense of reality and real people is
- 1:41:50sick. It didn't bother This is really important. It didn't bother Rand that
- 1:41:57Logan is mad. No, that's well, here's why. Errol is mad.
- 1:42:01H Yeah, and was still a mentor to Rand. That's true.
- 1:42:04That's not the sickness Rand is talking about. That's true. The sickness is
- 1:42:09Logan's character. That's true. He's not he's yeah. Yeah, Rand's not
- 1:42:14bothered by madness. He's bothered by people, not people being shitty. Errol's
- 1:42:18not a shitty person. He's mad. He's not a shitty person. He's
- 1:42:21traumatized into madness. Yeah, it's Logan's character that is corrupted and that Rand
- 1:42:28rejects. Logane finishes with maybe but none of us can hide from what we
- 1:42:31are, meaning that Rand is just as much of a sick monster as he
- 1:42:35is m Who are the monster? Who are the monsters? Rand? Rand
- 1:42:42walks out the door, Hey, just like he walked out the door at
- 1:42:46the party in Kyrie in having shut out Logane's teachings. But it brings him
- 1:42:53right back to needing Selene as he exits through that door, and immediately when
- 1:42:58we next see him, enters the door to in in the next scene.
- 1:43:00So he's basically just like walking out one door right back to Selene because he
- 1:43:06rejected her teachings, but he still needs her at this time, but he
- 1:43:10is determined he doesn't maybe not need Logain. So we see Selene at the
- 1:43:15window looking out as Rand walked in. It's quite possible that Selene saw Rand
- 1:43:20coming as she was looking out, so she was aware that he was coming.
- 1:43:24Now this, this whole thing turns out to be a dream. I
- 1:43:27know, yeah, but I just wanted to say that, and we can
- 1:43:30talk about why that's significant. Later mm hmm, but Rand is wearing the
- 1:43:33coat from the party when he'd clearly taken it off at the asylum, our
- 1:43:36first hint that something maybe off. Rand walks toward her clearly to kiss her,
- 1:43:42but discordant notes are playing as he does so, which is an auditoryque
- 1:43:46that something is off. As he reaches her, she grabs his face and
- 1:43:49shoved him against the wall, holding him by his throat as he did to
- 1:43:53her in an earlier scene. The power dynamic between them has shifted, bringing
- 1:43:57back to mind something she said in the previous scene about how he can't hurt
- 1:44:00her. Maybe she wasn't just speaking metaphorically, and she then says, if
- 1:44:04you ever leave me again, like if you ever leave me like that again,
- 1:44:08I will kill you, as she tilts her head to the side and
- 1:44:11widens her eyes, a classic actor unhinged look. As the discordant notes crescendo.
- 1:44:16Something is wrong here, but that doesn't dissuade Rand. As the two
- 1:44:19become passionate, she tells him to leave on the coat, assuming like she
- 1:44:23does, seeming like she does appreciate the finer things. She then says,
- 1:44:28show me let go. I'm not afraid of you in reference to his power,
- 1:44:32and he complies, freeing himself in that moment and becoming the monster,
- 1:44:36surrendering to who he is, because Logaine says it will leak out of him
- 1:44:41eventually. But was this a dream? Yes? Yeah it was. But
- 1:44:46I think we're supposed to feel a little like is this real? Which means
- 1:44:50that we can still trust Selene because this Selene was Rand's dream version, so
- 1:44:57Selene's probably not related to this, and this is some kind of like weird
- 1:45:00Rand assumption land weird dream feelings. Rand wakes up at first almost it almost
- 1:45:08looks like he's post coital, it does. It does kind of feel like
- 1:45:14I'm calling this the dry dream. I like that because everything gets very dry
- 1:45:18and burnt, and he's still the result of it. He's still in the
- 1:45:21clothes from the night before, notably not wearing the coat which he told him
- 1:45:25to leave on. Oh yeah, so that's our hint that it's a dream.
- 1:45:29That's our first hint, well, one of many. He sees that
- 1:45:31the roof is on fire, and Selene enters yelling for him, clearly having
- 1:45:34slept in her own room based on her clothes. She's clearly on a nightgown
- 1:45:39and no robe. Yes, so she clearly slept in her own room and
- 1:45:42she's coming to save him. Rand I called it wet channeled or something.
- 1:45:49And now the roof is on fire. Perhaps the monster in him is leaking
- 1:45:53out. Like Lougaine said, outside everyone is screaming, giving Rand know that
- 1:46:00great feedback on how people are going to respond to him going forward with his
- 1:46:05powers. Yeah. Yeah, Selene strokes him and says, are you all
- 1:46:09right? But Ran just like says nothing and listens to people's screams. Yeah,
- 1:46:15burned out. He's caused suffering to the people that he cares about,
- 1:46:18which is exactly what he's trying to get away from. That's exactly what he
- 1:46:20fears. This is his greatest nightmare. This is one of his greatest nightmares
- 1:46:25happening. And I want to point out also, I think something that is
- 1:46:27not to mention that just because he even though he rejected Selene's mentorship in the
- 1:46:31last scene he was in with her other than the dream that he had,
- 1:46:35doesn't mean he doesn't care about her. He absolutely cares, Oh, he
- 1:46:39surely does. He's just upset because she is showing callousness toward other people.
- 1:46:44He cares about. Yes, I want to emphasize something I think the show
- 1:46:47does here very deliberately. Last season, when Igwaine was tied up with the
- 1:46:56White Cloaks, she has to work very very hard to channel enough to burn
- 1:47:02through parents ropes. Remember this, She's got her hands tied by her sides
- 1:47:08and she can just barely. Igwayne just barely is able to channel enough and
- 1:47:13sneakily enough to singe through parents ropes. Yeah. Rand burns down a building
- 1:47:19in his sleep? Yeah? Right, Igwayne this episode, after some training,
- 1:47:25is able to fill a doorway with flame, very clearly resulting from some
- 1:47:30effort. Rand burns down a building in his sleep. Yeah. Is something
- 1:47:35that I that I want to emphasize that is being shown by this is the
- 1:47:41man is quite literally overflowing with power. Well he yes, he and nine
- 1:47:46Eve. I mean we get to see we get to see Agwayne and how
- 1:47:49far she's come in this seat in this episode, but we also get to
- 1:47:54see more of like just how powerful Ran and nine Eve are. Yeah,
- 1:47:59because they do think that are unprecedented power. Yeah, And I think this
- 1:48:03lately, Rand in particular is extraordinarily strong. And I think this scene goes
- 1:48:10to show how extraordinarily strong he is while actively trying to avoid it. Yeah.
- 1:48:16Yeah, Oh, I also think it's significant that Logain says to rand
- 1:48:20I think does he say it in this episode? He says, you you're
- 1:48:24as powerful as me. Uh, I can't remember. It's either this episode
- 1:48:29or next episode. We'll save it for next episode. Yeah, but I'm
- 1:48:33like de Lulu. Okay, So that brings us back to the Tarvlon plot
- 1:48:42unless you have anything else to say about Randis Lane, because that's that's over.
- 1:48:45No, I'm I'm I'm good for that, and uh, I think
- 1:48:48we should take this opportunity to break for abs. Let's discuss the B plot.
- 1:49:10Y B plots a B plot, So then the B plot is the
- 1:49:14whole tower and also nine Eve's third test. Right. Yeah, so we
- 1:49:19get the B plot in the cold open. So obviously we've already talked about
- 1:49:24the cold open for an hour. Admittedly it was kind of a big deal.
- 1:49:29So we don't see the tower plot line again until the midpoint of the
- 1:49:33episode. So the midpoint, for those of you who don't remember, is
- 1:49:38pretty much exactly halfway through the episode. It's the point that is the mid
- 1:49:43it is the mid point. It is the middle point. Yeah, and
- 1:49:45just for those of you who don't remember, it's basically the mini climax in
- 1:49:49the overall episode. So this is the moment we're dreading for the episode's entirety.
- 1:49:56Igwayne finding out about nine Eve, Yes and Awayne are walking down the
- 1:50:00hall and Agwayne tells Elaine to weave them a hangover here. I just like
- 1:50:04this little detail. That's so funny, and Elaine says that as the innkeeper's
- 1:50:10daughter, she should know how to handle her liquor. It's so funny.
- 1:50:13Such a cute little moment between them. That's meant to showcase their friendship and
- 1:50:16expand their closeness, as is their similar hairstyles and clothing. So Agwaine has
- 1:50:21gotten rid of the braid at this point, and she and Elaine have very
- 1:50:27similar hairstyles. So that's showing a couple things. One that their closeness as
- 1:50:31friends, right they literally wear the same hairstyle, and two that she is
- 1:50:35moving away from nine Eve and the two rivers as a whole, becoming potentially
- 1:50:42more worldly, bumping elbows with the daughter era of and or becoming somebody who
- 1:50:46has left her small town behind in a way that Ninetyve hasn't right. Nineive
- 1:50:51is still very much braided and Ligwaine is not. So this is right before
- 1:50:58right, we're seeing this kind of moving away from nine Eve on Agwaine's part.
- 1:51:01Right before Awayne suffers the loss of her friend taking out taking it out
- 1:51:06on Alane, likely because she feels guilty for having prioritized her friendship with Alane
- 1:51:10lately over nine Eve, Agwayne knocks on Ninety's door to increase our dread for
- 1:51:14what she's about to find out. We see them walking down the hall and
- 1:51:16knocking on Ninety's door. A lot of the time that is stuff that would
- 1:51:19be skipped and we'd just jumped to them walking in. But this is put
- 1:51:26in specifically to highlight our dread of what's about to happen and emphasize the friendship
- 1:51:30of Elaine and Agwaine. Right before Agwayne basically rejects Elaine's friendship because of her
- 1:51:35guilt over Ninety's death. Yeah, and you know greed death in quotations.
- 1:51:39I also like that Igwaine uses a like a nickname for nine Eve. She
- 1:51:45knocks the door and goes, NA, it's me yeah, which the showcase
- 1:51:48they're close to me, yeah. Right before we see them, we see
- 1:51:53her having to deal with her friends supposed to death. She's also standing under
- 1:51:58the door's archway at the time, and that door archway doesn't look unlike the
- 1:52:02stone archways. I thought was interesting. Oh sure, yeah, all right
- 1:52:06yeah. Upon entering, she finds Cheerium, who does turn to look at
- 1:52:10her. Right, We've talked about the importance of turning to look at somebody
- 1:52:15versus not turning, and how back being turned to someone is a very powerful
- 1:52:17position to be in. So they purposely start her in a power position right,
- 1:52:23turned away from her dealing with Ninief's things, And then Agwayne enters,
- 1:52:29and she does turn to look at Awayne, but doesn't fully stop what she's
- 1:52:32doing to offer comfort, And that I think is really important in terms of
- 1:52:35the power structure that's happening here and the inability to provide comfort both to Nineve
- 1:52:44at the beginning that we've seen and to Agwayne now and kind of not even
- 1:52:48not only inability, but sort of unwillingness. Right, there's all the stuff
- 1:52:54when they're when she's doing her test of like your you know, your fears
- 1:52:57are your own, your troubles are your own. Yeah, she just goes
- 1:53:00like, Yep, she's gone cope, there is no therapy provided, goodbye.
- 1:53:03Yeah, cry about it if you want to, if that'll help.
- 1:53:06Yeah. And she wasn't being cruel she says even from the beginning that she
- 1:53:11respects Agwayne, so she's going to be blunt with her about what's going on
- 1:53:15and direct, but you know, it's still cruelty, And Jeeves says this,
- 1:53:18it wasn't how I intended for you to find out. So you know,
- 1:53:21clearly there had been a plan in place to address soften the blow a
- 1:53:26little bit, but it didn't pan out. Yeah, but there was no
- 1:53:30blow softening here at all. And I don't really imagine that the way they
- 1:53:34would have handled it would have been any better. No, I don't think
- 1:53:39so. I Yeah, I think probably we saw just about as warm as
- 1:53:43they're going to be towards somebody who's grieving. And it's not necessarily the fault
- 1:53:46of the institution, right, They're basically designed to be this way. They're
- 1:53:53supposed to be this way. So that's what makes relationships like Swan and Moraine
- 1:53:58so precious, is that they're in a place that's kind of designed to kill
- 1:54:01that kind of affection. I think this is also makes me think of something
- 1:54:08in the books, which is how I'll get to have This is relevant,
- 1:54:13But in the books when they talk about stilling and being stilled and having the
- 1:54:15power taken from you if you're an Isidi and that it happens to you,
- 1:54:19generally you never really talk to another isidie again, and the rest of the
- 1:54:23isid I pretend you don't exist because I said, I don't like to confront
- 1:54:27that. They don't like to address that that thing that can happen to you,
- 1:54:30and they don't like to think about it too much. And similarly in
- 1:54:35the prequel novel, there are instances where characters go through the arches and don't
- 1:54:40come out, and it's sort of like, yep, we're going to take
- 1:54:42one day off and cope deal with that, and then we're going to keep
- 1:54:45going. And I'm not saying that's necessarily, you know, the most emotionally
- 1:54:49healthy thing to do, but it does also I think tie in with that
- 1:54:53element of like, this is a shitty thing that happens, we don't want
- 1:54:57to think about it. We're just going to keep on moving through it.
- 1:54:59But I think it also a flex how historically we've dealt with as a culture
- 1:55:01in America, our collective traumas and our individual traumas. I don't think that
- 1:55:10there is a lot of space in our culture, and there's a lot of
- 1:55:13discomfort toward grief. Oh god. Yeah. I think Westerners are by and
- 1:55:18large pretty bad at grief. Yeah, we really are really bad at it.
- 1:55:24We're really bad at handling emotions. Well, I think that's starting to
- 1:55:29change culturally, you know. For all that you know, we studied in
- 1:55:35a couple different countries at different points. We have the opportunity and there was
- 1:55:39a lot of discussion with some folks about how Americans are very expressive when it
- 1:55:45comes to their emotions, and sometimes in a way that can be off putting.
- 1:55:49But I think that it's one of those things where we're like, okay,
- 1:55:55but you're going to express that, and then we're going to be like,
- 1:55:58all right, so you expressed it, so now we're just going to
- 1:56:00move on out. We're going to get attempted to happen. It's great if
- 1:56:02you need to have an emotion, go do it in a quiet, private
- 1:56:05dark room and tell everyone you're okay. Yeah. I think that's the other
- 1:56:10thing is is the only it seems that most of the time the only acceptable
- 1:56:14answer to oh my god, how are you doing is you know, I'm
- 1:56:17I'm doing okay, I'm working through it well. The reality is often like
- 1:56:20I'm I'm terrible, I'm shattered, I'm having a horrible time. But it
- 1:56:25seems like the accepted social contract thing is like, don't burden other people,
- 1:56:30burden in massive air quotes with what you're going through. Great. Well,
- 1:56:33I just had a conversation with a friend where she asked me a question about
- 1:56:39something and I was honest with her about something I was struggling with, and
- 1:56:43then I felt immediately like I had to apologize for doing that. You know
- 1:56:46that I unloaded on her, and she goes, we're friends. You're allowed
- 1:56:51to tell me things that you're struggling with. You know that, right,
- 1:56:56But you just don't feel that way all the time. Sometimes you're kind of
- 1:56:59like, I don't want to be especially when you are neurodivergent. You don't
- 1:57:02always really understand the rules sure of what is acceptable and what isn't in terms
- 1:57:08of expressing yourself with people, and so sometimes you're really worried, at least
- 1:57:13with me with ADHD about being too much, you know, and being too
- 1:57:17honest and too upfront about things, because some people do get really off put
- 1:57:23by that. And I want to point out by the way how well Elaine
- 1:57:27navigates Agwayne's grief. She does. She handles it like really, she recognizes
- 1:57:33this. It seems to me, Well, I'm not sure how much we
- 1:57:38can share about this. Part of this might be a spoiler conversation, so
- 1:57:44we come out. But yeah, the way that she handles a Gwayne's emotions
- 1:57:48is really strong, and I think we may be getting a sense that a
- 1:57:54GWayne, I mean Elaine, Sorry, I get them. And the meanest
- 1:58:00thing Robert Ranan ever did was put Elaine in Agwaine and plots together. Right,
- 1:58:04Elaine, we may be getting a sense that Elaine is a very emotionally
- 1:58:09intelligent person, yeah, and rather diplomatic person, because I think she likely
- 1:58:15understands that Agwaine is acting this way out of anger and grief. But for
- 1:58:23all the isid Ie profess to be sisters, there is certainly not a lot
- 1:58:26of sisterly warmth here. I think it's likely they picked Shirium to deliver this
- 1:58:29news to Awayne for two reasons. Oh well, they didn't pick her,
- 1:58:31but I think people overall they that the not the Isidie, the powers that
- 1:58:39be that made the show picks Serrium specifically to deliver this news for two reasons.
- 1:58:44First, because she's the mistress of novices, yes, so ostensibly it's
- 1:58:46her job. Makes sense that she would be the person cleaning up ninety things
- 1:58:51that she would be present there. And second because as a blue Ajia,
- 1:58:57the comforting color we associate with Moraine's protection is being used against us in this
- 1:59:00woman who provides no comfort to Agwayne. Yeah, Elaine does some great acting.
- 1:59:05Oh shout out to Kira Coveany for some amazing acting behind Agwayne in this
- 1:59:10scene because she understands quicker than Agwayne what Ninive not coming out of the arches
- 1:59:15means, but clearly doesn't want to be the one to elucidate matters. So
- 1:59:18you like watch care Coveany in the background so good. This is my favorite
- 1:59:23thing of the actors acting in the background because they're not necessarily meant to be
- 1:59:27watched. But sometimes you'll see somebody who is not the focus of a scene
- 1:59:30acting their ass off behind somebody who is the focus. She's killing it in
- 1:59:36the background because you see the moment she realizes what this means, and then
- 1:59:41the moment she decides not to say anything to make Agwayne understand that mcgwain needs
- 1:59:47to process this on her own. Agwaine grabs Niney's Wisdom belt from Scherium,
- 1:59:53which has been ninety's one connection to home beside her braid. Besides her braid
- 1:59:58over the shoulder, shots and close ups in the seen or used to make
- 2:00:00us feel simultaneously like voyeurs in this moment and also give us that discomfort of
- 2:00:03seeing pain out close and personal we don't really love. It's uncomfortable to be
- 2:00:10in someone's face when they're experiencing a big emotion. And they use a lot
- 2:00:14of close ups of Agwayn and this team to really trap us in this feeling
- 2:00:17of this inescapable grief, And that's coupled with Agwayne's protestations. Our inability to
- 2:00:27escape the situation is coupled with Gwayn Agwayne's protestations that that can't be true,
- 2:00:31right, so we are not escaping it, neither is she, despite her
- 2:00:34best efforts. Well, you know, it's also I don't know if I
- 2:00:38would call this dramatic irony, but we know that Ninive is gone but still
- 2:00:45existing, right, So like if the world that Ninive was in had faded
- 2:00:51away with the door, it'd be another matter. But we know that while
- 2:00:55there is no historical precedent for somebody returning, Ninety was clearly still alive in
- 2:01:01some sense. Right, So while Agwaine is being told there is no hope,
- 2:01:06give up, don't try, we know that they're be yeah, that
- 2:01:12they might be wrong, And so that's meant to kind of like heighten our
- 2:01:15one identifying with Agwayin, but two our desperation of like, there's nothing worse
- 2:01:21than that feeling of us knowing something that the characters don't. It's that dramatic
- 2:01:27irony that we have here that they're playing on, because one we felt the
- 2:01:30dramatic irony of her walking up to Ninety's door and us knowing that she was
- 2:01:34going to be getting this bad news, but two understanding that on top of
- 2:01:39everything else, her getting this bad news is preventing her potentially from saving Ninety
- 2:01:45from whatever situation that Ninety is in. Yeah, now, this is may
- 2:01:48or may not be a good time to discuss the fact that in the book,
- 2:01:51none of this happens. We don't see it. We don't, right,
- 2:01:57So the the the U nine in the book, and I'll be kind
- 2:02:03of vague. Ninety's third arch does involve her missing the boat, as it
- 2:02:13were, but then she just sort of summons the boat back, much like
- 2:02:16how she does at the end of the episode. She uses the power within
- 2:02:23the arches, which she is not supposed to be able to do. Notably,
- 2:02:25she also does that in her first arch, and then even though the
- 2:02:30arch appears and then disappears, she wills it back into place and leaves a
- 2:02:33different scenario where she's married to Land. But it's still a future scenario where
- 2:02:36she's married to Land. And there's none of this time spent with a GWayne
- 2:02:44in grief. There's no time spent Nobody believes that Ninive has gone missing at
- 2:02:46all. There is none of this sort of interim stuff. And I have
- 2:02:51seen complaints online that this is a I'm using air quotes, yet another fake
- 2:02:58out death, which I disagree with because she's notably not dead. Well we
- 2:03:03know she's not we know she's not dead. Yeah. I also don't really
- 2:03:09have an issue with the concept of a fake out death because I don't really
- 2:03:14consider this or many other things. One. I think for me, it's
- 2:03:19less about the device of a fake out death or a cliffhanger or you know,
- 2:03:24those things that I think have become irksome to people because they've been used
- 2:03:30to a point where it feels like a cheap trick, yeah, to get
- 2:03:35people to feel things. I think it's the why that matters to me more
- 2:03:40than anything. Why are they doing this? I don't necessarily think that discounce
- 2:03:45is a fake out it because we know she's alive, and so it's more
- 2:03:47about the dramatic irony of us knowing that she's alive and feeling stressed about the
- 2:03:51fact that nobody else seems to think so. Just like Julia in Romeo and
- 2:03:57Juliet, we know that she's still alive, but Romeo doesn't. Yeah,
- 2:04:00and then what happens as a result of Romeo not knowing that she's alive is
- 2:04:04the problem not the is she alive or not? It's the question of what
- 2:04:09is he going to do thinking that the woman that he loves is dead?
- 2:04:12Similar thing here with Agwayne, what is she going to do when we know
- 2:04:15that the person that she cares about needs rescuing potentially and could be in a
- 2:04:21really infarious situation. What is she going to do with this information? Is
- 2:04:25she going to believe them like everyone wants her to and cave into everybody's expectations,
- 2:04:30or is she going to do what we want her to do, which
- 2:04:31is try to save her front And this whole the idea that this plot line
- 2:04:38is superfluous or doesn't matter because will at the end of the day she's back
- 2:04:42anyway, ignores the journey the characters go on, right, And that's the
- 2:04:45why. It's the emotional ramifications of what this experience is going to do to
- 2:04:49her long term. Yeah. And that's another reason why this is the B
- 2:04:54plot and not the A plot is it's a deeply emotionally driven plot. At
- 2:04:58the end of the day, the what happened in this plot is she goes
- 2:05:00in, she doesn't come out, Agwayne has a bad time, she comes
- 2:05:03out. So in terms of plot advancement, yeah, it's not, you
- 2:05:06know, colossal, But in terms of what it does to the characters,
- 2:05:10Nineve lives an entire life, right, she has an entire child. Yeah,
- 2:05:14she has a whole ass child that she's now lost and is not real.
- 2:05:17Yeah, she once again fails to protect people, right, right,
- 2:05:21she once again sees what the eyes to Die are capable of inflicting on people
- 2:05:28and what the you know, kind of because this whole thing was also brought
- 2:05:30about by use of the power. In some ways, I see that this
- 2:05:33could also make her block worse. It pushes harder into Igwaine's relationship with nine
- 2:05:41Eve, which you know, kind of an important relationship between characters. In
- 2:05:45my opinion, it adds another dimension to Igwaine and Elaine's relationship, a significant
- 2:05:50dimension Alane's relationship because it's the first time their friendship is tested and like really
- 2:05:55quite brutally tested. I think because up until this point it's mostly fun and
- 2:06:00games. It's a fairly lighthearted relationship, and suddenly it's like, hey,
- 2:06:03well your friend's dead and you're yelling at me. But I'm going to come
- 2:06:08back to you, yeah, because I care about you and I'm going to
- 2:06:12give you the space that you need to grieve and deal with these things.
- 2:06:15Right, Like I don't I don't really consider a friend a friend with a
- 2:06:19capital F until we have gone through something together. I think it's very easy
- 2:06:27up until that point to love someone until you reach either a disagreement or go
- 2:06:32through a trial, and then I think that's when real friends reveal themselves and
- 2:06:38when you know, more fair weather friendships tend to fall apart. It just
- 2:06:44it tests your compatibility as people and your willingness to be there for them.
- 2:06:48Yeah, when there are other options available to you, you know. So
- 2:06:53I definitely feel like, yeah, that the measure of friendship comes when you
- 2:07:00face adversity and you get to see really who people are in those instances.
- 2:07:04And I think we get to see who Elaine is in this moment. We
- 2:07:06get to see that she is someone who is emotionally intelligent, mature, and
- 2:07:13wants to be there for Agwayne. Agwayne rejects her help right, which is
- 2:07:16her right to do, and that is largely because of the guilt that she
- 2:07:20feels that she has not replaced Ninive, of course, but grown a little
- 2:07:26bit apart from nine, even grown closer with Elaine in these moments because she
- 2:07:30is growing as a person. She's not as attached to her hometown as her
- 2:07:35friend, and so she's you know, exploring other options because she's growing up.
- 2:07:41They're growing a little bit apart because they need to. But in addition
- 2:07:45to that, it also showcases to ninety despite how much she may want to
- 2:07:48walk away from all of this and take everybody home and live that happy life
- 2:07:53in the country where she feels she belongs, she can't because Hobbiton is not
- 2:07:59going to stay safe when all of this is going down. And like Shiriam
- 2:08:03said in one or two episodes ago, don't we need her at our Don't
- 2:08:09we want her at our side when the shadow comes? Don't we want that
- 2:08:15woman who has all this power to be fighting with us. So that's I
- 2:08:20think why this moment, whether or not it worked for you, was there?
- 2:08:26Yeah, not to mention that. It also it deepens nine Eve's resentment
- 2:08:31to the Tower. Right, the Tower gave her this fantasy and then took
- 2:08:35it away. Well, I mean right, it deepens a Gwayne's relationship.
- 2:08:39Can I get the Tower? Yeah? Can I piggyback on that course?
- 2:08:41Not only it potentially gives her this furthered conflict with the Tower, but at
- 2:08:48the same time, she is now at a place where she cannot leave it.
- 2:08:50Yeah, now she's locked in. Now she has her reason for staying,
- 2:08:54which is if I don't stay, my hometown will be overrun and everyone
- 2:09:00when I leve will die. So I have to stay even though what they
- 2:09:03have done to me was deeply traumatic and something I don't ever want to inflict
- 2:09:09on other people in experience, because she's a person that's a caretaker, not
- 2:09:13someone who wants to put people through trauma. And I think also it's a
- 2:09:16moment for Agwayne. I mean, her thing at the beginning of this season
- 2:09:22was sort of you know, if I'd been there for rand maybe things would
- 2:09:26have gone differently. Lo and Behold. She spent the first two and a
- 2:09:28half two episodes with Elaine because she was and distancing herself because she was bitter
- 2:09:35at ninety for various reasons that are some are you know, Patty, and
- 2:09:37some are more understandable perhaps, not that they're not all understandable, but some
- 2:09:41are more sympathetic perhaps. And suddenly in ninety was also gone. So we're
- 2:09:45just gonna take that core wound that Agwaine picked up, and we're gonna just
- 2:09:48dig that spoon in there a little bit more exactly. It's those it's it's
- 2:09:52finding those moments of it's finding those bruises on your character and just poking at
- 2:09:58them. Yes, And it's funny to me because I feel like a lot
- 2:10:03of a lot of the moments that are not necessarily strictly from the books that
- 2:10:09are added that sometimes people go, why did we do this when we could
- 2:10:13have done X, Y and z other thing? They exist to deepen the
- 2:10:18existing facets of the character, I think, and in a book series that
- 2:10:22is four point four million words, many of which are spent with characters,
- 2:10:26among other things, going dress shopping and talking about the weather. And I'm
- 2:10:31not criticizing that in this breath. I'm saying, those are things that share
- 2:10:35their perspectives on the world and on life and help us get to know them
- 2:10:39better. If we can instead get to know them better while they're having a
- 2:10:43terrible fucking time and doing things that will very heavily emphasize their future actions and
- 2:10:50future behaviors and future lives. Why or not, Well, it's about making
- 2:10:54sure because in screenwriting, because you get so little time, it's about making
- 2:10:58sure that things are accomplishing multips at once, that scenes are giving us insight
- 2:11:03into a character while also forwarding the plot. And not every scene does have
- 2:11:07to be a plot forwarding moment, but it should at least be an emotionally
- 2:11:11forwarding moment. We have to make sure that scenes are accomplishing more than one
- 2:11:16thing as often as possible, though, because every word in screenwriting is precious.
- 2:11:22Yes, every second is precious. And if you want an example of
- 2:11:26what I would consider a fake out death, I'm not going to name the
- 2:11:28total specifics, but there is a zombie show where a character pretty explicitly dies
- 2:11:33on screen and is later shown to have actually hidden under a dumpster. That's
- 2:11:37a fake out death. Yeah, this is not yeah, because I don't
- 2:11:43think there's ever a moment where we actually believe that Nimieve could be dead.
- 2:11:46There are moments where we wonder, or is she not coming back? Yeah,
- 2:11:50but she's clearly she exists still, and we know that this is a
- 2:11:54world with reincarnation, so things always come back. But on the realm of
- 2:11:58like you know, we've talked about how in this episode we're discovering We're having
- 2:12:03characters discover new worlds and new identities in this episode, kind of finding out
- 2:12:09things about themselves that they didn't know. This is Agwayne having to face a
- 2:12:11world without ninety eating, which has never been something I mean, that's never
- 2:12:16been something that she's had to experience. Let's pop out for ads real quick,
- 2:12:22and then we'll keep her moving. Welcome back, Okay, keeping it
- 2:12:41rolling, Cherriam says, and I said this earlier, but I wrote down
- 2:12:46the line because I think this is a really important point. I will speak
- 2:12:48bluntly, not out of cruelty, but out of respect for you. Agwayne
- 2:12:52has wanted respect this whole time, and she's finally gotten it in the most
- 2:12:56terrific way. Oh that's good. The only reason she feels like she doesn't
- 2:13:01get the respect that she deserves right is nineyve. Ninive is an obstacle to
- 2:13:05her at this point and a frustration point. But now that Ninive has been
- 2:13:11removed as an obstacle and she's suddenly getting respect from Shiium. It's one of
- 2:13:16those be careful what you wish for moments. Yep, and Shirim says,
- 2:13:18the loss is going to shake you, perhaps more than anyone. Agwayne,
- 2:13:22in her mind, has lost both her boyfriend and best friend of one year.
- 2:13:24Oh we talked about this, and now there's no one there to comfort
- 2:13:28her like Ninie did over Rand's death. In quotations, Elaine tries. Yeah,
- 2:13:33Elaine tries to be that same support, but she's not close enough to
- 2:13:37Agwayne to earn that yet Agwayne says, I don't even know you. I
- 2:13:41don't want you here. This isn't something she means. It's pain talking,
- 2:13:43which we saw building in a close up on Agwayne's emotion as Elaine speaks off
- 2:13:48screen, because she in that moment is an intrusion, right, We see
- 2:13:54not Elaine speaking, but we are in a close up shot on a GWayne
- 2:13:58processing her emotions, and so Elaine's continued speaking, even though what she's saying
- 2:14:05is the comfort that Awayne deserves, the needs, is intrusive because Elaine's kind
- 2:14:13of a stranger. For as much as they have grown close, well,
- 2:14:15they've known each other for a month. Maybe right, Probably not even that.
- 2:14:20Elaine's hurt over Agwaine's rejection. Maybe think back to Elaine's comment about knowing
- 2:14:24what jealousy looks like. Is it possible the daughter air doesn't have many friends?
- 2:14:28Seems likely alone. Agwayne falls to the floor crying in the shadow of
- 2:14:33the door she just closed on Elane. Choices, choices everywhere. I forgot
- 2:14:37to talk about the window, Sheriam's window. Did you talk about Shiriam's window?
- 2:14:41What about Scheriam's window when we watched it, you paused and were a
- 2:14:45glog over the light streaming in through the windows versus the darkness, and oh
- 2:14:50yeah, I talk about that, yeah, oh yeah, right, I
- 2:14:54think I get at this a little bit right here. So we're on the
- 2:14:58same wavelength, I keep on. No, I love it, I love
- 2:15:01it. We're on the same way, like even though it's been a second
- 2:15:03we you know, talked about this episode. Yes, sweet, we did
- 2:15:07actually break mid recording. We Adore is a liminal space representing choice away and
- 2:15:13makes the choice to kick a lane out and deal with her suffering alone.
- 2:15:18Right, And we've talked about the emphasis on choices that keep happening. What
- 2:15:22our choices mean, what what we are in our choices do? Is that
- 2:15:26make us monsters? Does it not? And she cradles nine Eve's belt as
- 2:15:31she falls to the floor in the one speck of shadow that is in this
- 2:15:35brightly lit room, as if she's given up hope. Gorgeous, Right,
- 2:15:39we don't have to hear that she agrees that Nineve is dead. Necessarily,
- 2:15:43we don't have to see that. It's that fear that she has because she
- 2:15:48is in this shadow that's been that's overtaking her in an otherwise well lit room.
- 2:15:56So oh yes, And I talked about She's window because I thought it
- 2:16:01was really interesting that we get this character standing there looking out the window,
- 2:16:05right, this window that's you know, shining light on them, and then
- 2:16:09we immediately cut to Leandren in pretty much the same Yeah, it's pairing them
- 2:16:13together, which I think is really interesting, and we may want to clock
- 2:16:18going forward. I'm not sure what that means, but I think it's really
- 2:16:22interesting that the two of them are adapt adopting similar places in Matt versus Agwayne's
- 2:16:31lives. I would agree with a lot of that. Yeah. Yeah,
- 2:16:37and that's the next the next scene, right, but that's a transition because
- 2:16:41we're counting by location right now. And you know, I think it's really
- 2:16:45interesting to clock just light versus shadow when that is such an integral thematic thing
- 2:16:54in the in the series, the light versus the shadow, like who is
- 2:16:58in light, who is in shadow? And when? And I just think
- 2:17:01it's interesting that we see these two women who are both processing the fact that
- 2:17:05they basically set nine Eve up for failure in their minds, staring out the
- 2:17:11window at the light that is shining on them but is inaccessible and barred from
- 2:17:16them. I think that's a really interesting thing to think about, in addition
- 2:17:20to them just adopting power poses in these moments. Okay, a lot of
- 2:17:26Leandron will get to her. Oh wait, no, Leandron tower so with
- 2:17:30this is now So yeah, we moved to Leandron as Matt wakes up and
- 2:17:35makes a quip about her watching him sleep again. We love funny people.
- 2:17:37Oh guys, hilarious. Leandron's face is half in shadow again. I just
- 2:17:41want to say I love Donald Finn. I do too, He's great.
- 2:17:46But Leandron's face is half in shadow. There's a darkness that she feels that
- 2:17:50she's about to let out. Just as Awayne takes her guilt out on a
- 2:17:54lane, Leandron takes hers out on that. Neither of their griefs are their
- 2:17:56own. Unlike what Cherrium said, right, they are taking them out on
- 2:18:01other people. Leandron is wearing the belt that she wore that tied her to
- 2:18:07nine even a previous episode, visually, when Leandren informs Matt that they lost
- 2:18:11a sister, there's all kinds of dramatic irony in the scene because we know
- 2:18:13that Matt knows her, We know that Leandra knows that Matt knows her.
- 2:18:16We know that Leandron is making the conscious choice not to tell Matt that Nineve
- 2:18:20is the one who died, Yes, because I think if she told him
- 2:18:26it was nine Eve, he would go to Agwayne. Right. I don't
- 2:18:31think she wants them back together. Well, based on the end of this
- 2:18:35episode with her mysterious conversation with men, it seems as though she actively does
- 2:18:41not want that. Yeah, this was the plot. Matt assumes that the
- 2:18:45sister who died was very old. We know she tragically wasn't, which twists
- 2:18:48the knife for Leandren unintentionally as because of her and nine Eve will never grow
- 2:18:52old. Right, Matt, in his innocence and a misunderstanding of the situation
- 2:19:01hurts Leandron further. And I think that's something we also should clock, is
- 2:19:05how misinformation or misunderstandings cause characters to feel more pain and for things to get
- 2:19:11worse. Because I think part of Leandron's outburst toward Matt is these little twists
- 2:19:18of the knife that he's giving her that he's not even aware that he's doing.
- 2:19:20Yeah, because she is you know, fairly cruel, very very cruel
- 2:19:26at the end of this. Yeah, I mean, she basically takes advantage
- 2:19:30of everything that Matt has already been deeply insecure about and deeply concerned about.
- 2:19:37She says in his character even harder and just throws it in his face.
- 2:19:41But that's also got a sting that because of Leandra, ninetyve is dead,
- 2:19:46considering Leandron's chip on her shoulder about protecting little girls a little bit, though
- 2:19:52twenty five is obviously not a little girl to an Isodet pretty much is considering
- 2:19:56the longevity she could have had, oh hundreds of years. Leandren tells him
- 2:20:01the door is open and he's free to go right again, presenting choices through
- 2:20:03the form of a door, but goes immediately back to contemplating the window,
- 2:20:07as if there's some hope there that she's barred from. Leandren tells not to
- 2:20:11find Agwayne because if there's one thing she needs more than ever, it's a
- 2:20:15friend. We know that even though a GWayne has a lane, there isn't
- 2:20:18a replacement for the friends she's known from home, and so does Leandron.
- 2:20:22Leandren's guilt at depriving a GWayne of a friend makes her set not free.
- 2:20:26It's also what unleashes her cruelty, Just as it did in the scene with
- 2:20:31nine Eve last episode, Leandred had left the door open for Matt. He's
- 2:20:35free to go. This is a choice for both of them. We get
- 2:20:37to then hear Leandred's guilt set aloud that Nineve was ill prepared and needed Leandron's
- 2:20:41help again with the little girls in need of saving. But for the past
- 2:20:46five months I've been wasting my time with Morain's little secret. Morain might have
- 2:20:50seen something in you. Light darkness, verryo thematic things once again. Who
- 2:20:54is the monster? And she says importance, But I see nothing. You're
- 2:20:58not. You're an insidious coward who mistakes his own moral failings for cunning and
- 2:21:03wit, a stupid, desperate boy who wallows in self pity, blaming his
- 2:21:07friends for leaving him. I know you, Matt Coffin. I know you
- 2:21:11may not know though you may not know yourself. You left them, and
- 2:21:13you do it again. So go find Agwayne. If she'll see you,
- 2:21:16or run home, or starve in the blight, it doesn't matter to me.
- 2:21:20Just spare me the misery of your company. It's already cost too many
- 2:21:22people their lives, damn how to punch at two characters core wounds for five
- 2:21:28hundred Alex Starvin, The blade is such a cruel thing to tell someone to
- 2:21:33do. Let's clock how often people are telling Matt Coffin that they know him
- 2:21:37at a time when he's unsure if he's good or bad. It's playing on
- 2:21:39his fears. Yes, I just want to buy a cameo from Kate Fleetwood
- 2:21:43in which he accurately dresses me down and devastates my soul. It's just another
- 2:21:48So much of Twitter says they want that, says they want Kate Fleetwood to
- 2:21:52like to insult them, insult them brutally. Yeah. Okay. So there's
- 2:21:56a tricky thing about monologues like this is that they have to be earned to
- 2:22:00be compelling. So they should be done sparingly in film and television because not
- 2:22:05a lot tends to happen visually. It's just kind of highlighting the actor's ability
- 2:22:09to make words work. Yes, monologues are also usually not naturalistic. No,
- 2:22:16people don't tend to be able to monologue on very rarely. What's the
- 2:22:22unless unless what are the times in which people are able to talk without interruption
- 2:22:26for such a long time, especially if they're doing a dressing down like this.
- 2:22:31Moments of deep passion, what are you getting at, Yeah, moments
- 2:22:33of emotional passion and or moments in which the character is more powerful than the
- 2:22:39other character. Yes, yes, Notably, there are shows that you have
- 2:22:46significantly heavier use of monologues. Notably, Mike Flanagan has a series of Netflix
- 2:22:52shows which are very enjoyable that rely heavily on monologue Midnight Mass probably more than
- 2:22:56The Fall of the House of Usher or The Haunting of House or The Haunting
- 2:23:00of Blind manner that works for some people and does not work for others.
- 2:23:05And I mean that both in terms of the creative and also the audience may
- 2:23:09or may not find that works for them. You just have to be careful.
- 2:23:13I mean, I think that this is the thing, right, We
- 2:23:16set up the fact that there is a kind of general understanding and then and
- 2:23:20then it comes up to you always true, Well, it becomes up to
- 2:23:24you whether or not to break that rule. Mike planning and breaks it all
- 2:23:28the time. I mean, yeah, and I love my planning. Yeah,
- 2:23:31I very good would argue that he sets up those monologues to happen at
- 2:23:39periods of emotional and absolutely there's always This is the thing. Monologues are like
- 2:23:43songs in music. They're very much like some and I think I've said this
- 2:23:46before, but like, it's only for when you have something really to frickin
- 2:23:52say, you know, and both you as the author and the character.
- 2:23:56It's not going to be a long grocery list unless that grocery includes like arsenic
- 2:24:01you know, they're only effective at moments in which the character either has enormous
- 2:24:07power over the other or the scene is emotionally fraught. This one was both,
- 2:24:11so we get a lot of close ups again for this scene, another
- 2:24:13emotionally fraught scene in which characters are trapped. Then we get a wide frame
- 2:24:18pan in on Leandron at the Crucible to give us a sense of the magnitude
- 2:24:22and almost oppressive force of the tower. Right, it starts from a huge
- 2:24:26distance and then kind of zooms in very slowly. Leandrin is in shadow to
- 2:24:31emphasize her grief. Of course, Agwayne enters behind her, and Leandron does
- 2:24:37not turn around. Agwayne is not worth the respect of turning around in that
- 2:24:43moment. So she had respect from Shiriam, she does not get it from
- 2:24:46Leandron. A character making the decision to not turn around, symbolizes who has
- 2:24:50power in the scene, because the back turned again is a position of power.
- 2:24:54Leandron turns around as Agwayne says you wanted ninety dead because the words struck
- 2:24:58a nerve, but Leandron falls back on the old sister, leave you to
- 2:25:03your grief, and once again regains the power by turning her back on Agwayne
- 2:25:07to again walk away. Characters walking away from a character without looking at them
- 2:25:11is another emphasis of their power. It's funny because I was working on a
- 2:25:16scene in an acting class where I had to really go off on another character
- 2:25:20and I kind of got up in their face and started yelling, and my
- 2:25:24teacher stapped and said, don't do that. Go stay across the room and
- 2:25:28hit them from there. You're cutting your power. If you think you have
- 2:25:31to be right up close to someone looking at them in order to have power.
- 2:25:33It can give you power, but usually not if you're having an outburst
- 2:25:37that seems like a tantrum. More often than not. Yeah, if,
- 2:25:41for instance, Agwayne had run towards Leandrin Lyandrin Leandron before making this wall of
- 2:25:46flame, it would have been less powerful than her standing in place and just
- 2:25:50summoning a wall of fire. Admittedly, Leandron dispersed it with a wave of
- 2:25:54her hand, so clearly it was in and of itself a tantrum, but
- 2:25:58it was an impressive one at the moment, I mean, a deserved tantrum.
- 2:26:01Yeah. The dismissal makes Agwayne angry enough to break the rules and get
- 2:26:05out of her place for a moment. Agwaine fitting into the tower is a
- 2:26:09big thing for her, so this moment is a big character moment for her,
- 2:26:13being like I am going to tell a sister, I'm going to tell
- 2:26:16it like it is. I think that you killed my friend on purpose.
- 2:26:20So this is perhaps kind of a breaking of a block of Agwayne's this desire
- 2:26:24to please authority. Yeah, because they say that Agwaine needs to relax,
- 2:26:30she needs to let go, she needs to you know, do all of
- 2:26:31these things, which she can't because she is so eager to impress. But
- 2:26:37in this moment she lets that go. But for all Agwayne's power, and
- 2:26:39she's still not channeling with her hands. Yep, you said she dispelled it
- 2:26:43with a quick flick of the wrist. By the way, just want to
- 2:26:45point out again. The upper bound, it seems, or a high bound
- 2:26:50of Agwaine's abilities at this point, after several months of training are filled doorway
- 2:26:54with fire. Rand burned down a building while he was having a sex stream.
- 2:26:58Yeah, I think that we're showcasing Rand's abilities in relation to other people's
- 2:27:05pretty well. Yes, Leandren is dangerous to Awayne because she's still better trained,
- 2:27:11even though Awayne might be more powerful, is more powerful than she is.
- 2:27:16However, it does get her to turn around and look at Agwayne with
- 2:27:18a face that's almost oppressed, and she backs her up to the yeah we
- 2:27:24talk. Yeah, so leandrads still shows she had the power, because enacting,
- 2:27:28the person who backs up always has less power. In the scene,
- 2:27:31she backs her up right. We know that she's a threat because she's able
- 2:27:35to wave the cool thing Agwayne did. I mean that was pretty cools,
- 2:27:39very cool, and I think made all of us kind of go whoa yeah,
- 2:27:45waved it away and so we know. Okay, so Leandren is still
- 2:27:48very much a threat to Agwayne. She backs her up right to the end,
- 2:27:52very calmly, very calmly. Yeah, in in stark contrast to her
- 2:27:56slapping night even yelling at her to get out, which is a moment where
- 2:28:01it seemed like she did not have a great deal of power, that was
- 2:28:03had no control animal. Yeah, when you have when you lose control,
- 2:28:07you lose your power. Yes, right, and she was not all proximity
- 2:28:11lost control. Yeah, and she says you, I had to write this
- 2:28:15of her monologues this episode have fricking d real good. Yeah. I loved
- 2:28:22these, Okay, so I had to write this down. You were supposed
- 2:28:26to be the smart one, the girl who knew her place, the girl
- 2:28:28who knew how dangerous it is to overstep, which is in line with a
- 2:28:31gwayn nearly stepping over the edge. It's great timing on the hundred doesn't warn
- 2:28:37her that she's about to do that, right yep, doesn't seem to care.
- 2:28:39If she does, could probably catch her, yeah, which again would
- 2:28:43be a great power show of power from her. Wee. I said,
- 2:28:46I can only tell the truth, So here my words and know they are
- 2:28:50true. I didn't send ninety to her death. I sent her to the
- 2:28:52arches because I believed in her, but she disappointed me. It's not always
- 2:28:56the most powerful women who write history, it's the ones who survive. So
- 2:29:00you remember your place, and you just might. It's a threat. Oh
- 2:29:03yeah, one hundred percent, you might survive. Yes, that is absolutely
- 2:29:07a threat. It's also kind of the thesis for her, right, She's
- 2:29:11like, I might not be the most powerful, but I am the survivor,
- 2:29:13yep, and I do what it takes to make it. The wide
- 2:29:16angle shot showing Leandred backing a GWayne up is meant to maximize our dread as
- 2:29:20we watch a GWayne get closer and closer to the edge, A very different
- 2:29:24Leandron from the one who talked to Matt. But she's looking to place Blaine
- 2:29:26wherever she can at the moment. But it's a different story here. Is
- 2:29:30that inconsistency, grief or something deeper, perhaps being someone evil? We don't
- 2:29:35know, right There are a lot of people who have nefarious actions. But
- 2:29:39are they monsters again, Yes, we're wondering. Does someone who backs someone
- 2:29:43up to the edge of almost falling off and threatens them is that a monster?
- 2:29:48Unclear? We see Morain let someone die. Is she a monster?
- 2:29:52We don't know. The last two lines are a blatant threat to a GWayne.
- 2:29:56But we've seen threats from Morain, so that doesn't mean anything yep,
- 2:30:00necessarily about Leandred. A GWayne shows that maybe she has the ability to meet
- 2:30:03Leandred's power and even surpass it when she gets in Leandred's face and says,
- 2:30:07you have no idea what I'm capable of. It's a good rebuttal oop Allie
- 2:30:11dropped her phone, so now we're going to catch back up to where she
- 2:30:13was in her notes. Leandron notably doesn't yield any steps when Agwayne gets in
- 2:30:20her face, but this time it's a Gwayne's turn to turn her back on
- 2:30:22Leandred. So in this particular instance, Awayne getting in Leandred's face is powerful.
- 2:30:30Well again, it's calm, Yeah. If you step up to somebody
- 2:30:33calmly and get in their space, this is acting specifically, it reads as,
- 2:30:39oh, they're not afraid of them, whereas having a tantrum in someone's
- 2:30:43face is sort of like, okay, baby needs a nap. Yeah,
- 2:30:46And then she turns her back on her. So Leandred has threatened her and
- 2:30:50showcased how much more powerful she is than Agwayne at this point because she's well
- 2:30:54trained. But agwayn still turns her back on her, and then of course
- 2:30:58just as a GWayne is rejecting a mentor, right rejecting someone's advice. We
- 2:31:05then get to the Kyrie party, so that's an interesting cut because Rand then
- 2:31:09rejects Selene a lot with mentors. From Matt's POV, we see Agwainne crying
- 2:31:13and holding ninety Spelt in the garden, and she's clearly in need of a
- 2:31:16friend. Like Leandron said, people don't tend to cry and they open like
- 2:31:18that when they don't want someone to come and help them. I should know,
- 2:31:22and Matt has the opportunity. While Agwayne rejected Elaine's help because the friendship
- 2:31:26was too new, perhaps she does still want some comfort. Clearly she does.
- 2:31:30She's out in the open, but from something or someone closer to home.
- 2:31:33It's also a big condemnation of the ice to eye that this girl is
- 2:31:35crying alone in a public space and no one has come to help her,
- 2:31:39no trusted adult. That's true, that's a good point, but the shame
- 2:31:43of Matt abandoning his friends, not helped by the speech Leandren gave him is
- 2:31:48too much for Matt. And from a beautiful shot that focuses on Agwayne crying
- 2:31:50with Matt in the background, we see him slip away with Agwayne only looking
- 2:31:54up after he's gone, which is meant to frustrate the viewers over Matt missing
- 2:31:58an opportunity to help Agwayne in her hour of need, but it's necessary for
- 2:32:01his journey. When we watched this with a friend of ours and he did
- 2:32:07that, she went mad, like she got so frustrated, and it was
- 2:32:11great, pretty good. Matt goes back into his prison, both physically and
- 2:32:16metaphorically, to seek the help of someone who doesn't know what a problem he
- 2:32:18is in his mind Min So Unlike Agwayne, who rejected a new friend in
- 2:32:24her time of need, Matt specifically seeks out someone rather unfamiliar who cannot really
- 2:32:28know him. He doesn't tell her that he's free to go. A big
- 2:32:31hint that something may not be right with Min is the fact that she never
- 2:32:35has anything covering the hole in her wall. Yes, I was gonna say
- 2:32:39that, I didn't realize you put in your notes. If you think about
- 2:32:41it, anytime they went into the fucking Min's room, anybody would notice that
- 2:32:46there's a big goddamn hole. Yeah, And it's like a first to go
- 2:32:50like, well, that's a plot hole. No, it's not, it's
- 2:32:52not it's possibule. Min never fears being discovered by the isid eye, and
- 2:32:56that clue is there from the first time we meet her that all is not
- 2:32:58right with her. It's Matt's failure to banter with her after she jokingly accuses
- 2:33:01him of trying to seduce her that clues her and us into the fact that
- 2:33:05our guy is feeling badly. She enters his room and realizes the door is
- 2:33:09opened, telling him to go with her. He tells her, I don't
- 2:33:13know where to go. I've been here all these months and now I couldn't
- 2:33:16leave. I don't know where to go. Last season, all Matt wanted
- 2:33:18to do was go home to protect his sisters, But now he can't face
- 2:33:22them and the potential confirmation that he may be like his father After all,
- 2:33:24What protection can he offer them if that's the case. Matt feels that because
- 2:33:28he's abandoned his home and his friends, that it means they have abandoned him
- 2:33:31too. He's made a prison in his own mind, not being able to
- 2:33:35make a move because he has a certain decision paralysis, unable to go home
- 2:33:39and face his mistakes, but unable to picture a future without his friends and
- 2:33:43family. In the past, when Matt has been in a bind, he's
- 2:33:46had his friends to bail him out, But now who does he have when
- 2:33:48he needs them, since he abandoned them when they needed him. Min responds
- 2:33:52with all that matters is that the door's open. It's time to walk through
- 2:33:54it, because I'm definitely not waiting for you. Sometimes there's no way to
- 2:33:58fix the past or predict the future, so you just have to move forward.
- 2:34:01Any other things to add about that scene, I don't think so.
- 2:34:03It's lovely. I like it. It's great, it's fun Men's blast.
- 2:34:07I'm really glad we're getting more men in book two. In particular, around
- 2:34:13this point, there's not a lot. She's kind of at the tower hanging
- 2:34:16out and shows up for a couple of conversations. Yeah. I like that
- 2:34:20she's a little more directly intertwined. I like that they're putting her with Matt
- 2:34:24in the book. At this point, she's hanging out more with Elaine and
- 2:34:28GWayne. I saw some criticism about the decisions surrounding Parn's wife. Matt's dad
- 2:34:39means, you know, trauma with her viewing as you know. Oh,
- 2:34:43now the characters are just going to be about that one particular trauma. It's
- 2:34:46going to just follow them from thing to thing, and yeah, in part,
- 2:34:50but I think that's neglecting the fact that you know, people who are
- 2:34:54traumatized, you know, because they're like, there's no way they'll ever be
- 2:34:58able to get over it, and I go, well, no, there's
- 2:35:00no way for them to get over it necessarily, But people who are traumatized
- 2:35:03can also live really wonderful lives after their trauma. I think there's this weird
- 2:35:09idea what I'm just like that our culture has that we can't live a fulfilling
- 2:35:16life post trauma, and I think it's actually a really dangerous mindset. Well.
- 2:35:20Also, like the characters have things in the books that also are folkrum
- 2:35:28points for them, they're not the same things. Some of them are less
- 2:35:31dark. I think the show is darker than the books, but I don't
- 2:35:37even think that the show is darker than the books. I think that the
- 2:35:39show is definitely darker than the earlier book, yes, because I'm like,
- 2:35:43there are things that happen later that are really fucked up. So I just
- 2:35:48think that it's giving us fulfilling the promise of what the show becomes early.
- 2:35:54Yeah, no, I agree with that, and just deepening the characters that
- 2:35:56we get to know well the other yeah, I mean the characters and yeah,
- 2:36:01well yeah, I don't know, I understand the concern, but I'm
- 2:36:05also like, you can be a fully fleshed out character and have a core
- 2:36:09wound. That's why it's called a core wound. Yeah, it's core.
- 2:36:13It's not the only thing about you. It's just a thing that when it
- 2:36:16comes up, you know, ooh that's going to matter, that's going to
- 2:36:18influence this. Yeah, it's the thing that can be a motivator. But
- 2:36:22it's not the only thing about a character that makes a character tick. Yeah,
- 2:36:26it's like just something that they're particularly passionate about, usually from a place
- 2:36:30of response when yeah, I mean, I can't talk too much about this
- 2:36:35because you know, book spoilers, but like Rand has one particular trauma trauma
- 2:36:41is too actually that he keeps on going back to constantly throughout the books,
- 2:36:46at least two major traumas, and they do not define the character. They
- 2:36:50inform him, and they inform his decisions and things that happen to him reflect
- 2:36:56differently because of these traumas or respond is too trauma. But it doesn't.
- 2:37:03It just adds another dimension, doesn't take anything away. Right, That's how
- 2:37:07I feel too. Matt asks Men later at the horses, if she stole
- 2:37:11her things, it's like the things that she brings, and she responds,
- 2:37:15I prefer the term liberated. The two of them are connected because they don't
- 2:37:18have big moral issues with stealing to survive, right, They kind of seem
- 2:37:22to come from similar places. What I like that they're doing is they're kind
- 2:37:26of showcasing how these two people are alike. They're giving them kind of a
- 2:37:31shared sense of humor, a shared depth, which I think makes the fact
- 2:37:39that Min is probably betraying Matt. Yes, well is betraying Matt. It's
- 2:37:43clearly betraying that even more upsetting. Yes, because is she a monster?
- 2:37:48She doesn't really strike me as a bad person. No, mostly because she's
- 2:37:52funny and we love funny people. That's a big part of it. Yeah,
- 2:37:56she's funny and she reminds us of Matt. And just because she does
- 2:38:01things that are bad, like stealing, does not necessarily make her a bad
- 2:38:03person. This indicates Men perhaps came from a background familiar to Matt Yep and
- 2:38:09gives us hope that the door Matt went through might have led him to a
- 2:38:11friend who really understands him. Right as it's revealed Men is working with Leandron
- 2:38:16Bummer, the room is specifically given red lighting to hint at what's to come.
- 2:38:20There's a lot of like reddish coloring stuff this, Yeah, I do
- 2:38:24like the color. Leandron says that if Min succeeds, Morain won't have anything
- 2:38:30on either of us. Ever, again, we know Morain knows about and
- 2:38:33exploits Leandron's son and Min's powers, and that exploitation might have been a miscalculation
- 2:38:37as it's caused these two to unite against her at Matt's expense. Too much
- 2:38:41pressure, Yeah too. Perhaps Morain had overplayed. Min reaches for a flat
- 2:38:48bread and Leandron stops her in a visual medical metaphor for the obstacle Min faces.
- 2:38:52The future Min wants is being blocked by Leandron, and is that Leandre's
- 2:38:56discretion to provide, which Leandron demonstrat by letting the bread go after saying don't
- 2:39:01let me down, the implication being that it is only in doing that that
- 2:39:07Min can get what she wants. Leandron then watches Min go out the door
- 2:39:11as if Min is a puppet doing what she wants and that's it until uh,
- 2:39:16and then that transitions into Selene at the window watching for Rand, which
- 2:39:20is great transitions. I love them. They're very good. Before we check
- 2:39:24back in with a GWayne having a bad time, and then finally nine Eve
- 2:39:28and then eventually Paren we're going to take another quick ad break welcome back.
- 2:39:50So we get to a Gayne channeling at the arches. Ah. Yeah,
- 2:39:52And this is funny because I watched this once or I saw some commentary from
- 2:39:56somebody who's live watching it who was a little more critical than others, and
- 2:40:01are like, oh god, I can't wait for her to just beast mode
- 2:40:05the arches open, which is funny because that's kind of what you expect,
- 2:40:09right right. You kind of expect like, well, she's going to find
- 2:40:11out that she's special and she's gonna and she's good, and that's not what
- 2:40:16happens. No, she's unable to do it. She can't do it.
- 2:40:20She she she finds, she's she encounters limits, which also showcases just how
- 2:40:24powerful Nini it is. Yeah, yeah, we're setting up power levels.
- 2:40:30A GWayne is powerful right, obviously, but she's still kind of discovering that
- 2:40:37power. Meanwhile, did you know that nine unrealistic for her to be able
- 2:40:41to beast mode that open? Did you know that niney Valmira is the most
- 2:40:45powerful channeler they've seen in a thousand years. That's that's news to me.
- 2:40:50I liked that, Maxim goes as you keep saying, Yeah, it was
- 2:40:52really fucking funny. We did need a little bit of that well, because
- 2:40:56it had been like it's like they knew because it had become a meme the
- 2:41:00week before. Right, Yeah, they're gonna like this. Yeah, they're
- 2:41:03gonna like that. Each time she attempts and has the magic flow through her,
- 2:41:07we get wide shots as if we too can feel the magnitude of her
- 2:41:09power. Each time she fails, we get cuts to close ups on her
- 2:41:11face, letting us witness her react to her failure and giving us that trapped
- 2:41:16feeling that she must feel. Emphasizing the frustration, Elaine enters through the open
- 2:41:20door. Hey doors being open open doors, doors are open closed doors.
- 2:41:28The doors the arches that are doors and real fake doors, and Elaine tells
- 2:41:35Agwayne she's not the first to try opening the arches to save a friend or
- 2:41:39a lover. I love that we're leaning into that, the queerness of it
- 2:41:43all. They need more than one channel or to open the arches, which
- 2:41:46is going to give us an idea of how powerful Ninive is again in a
- 2:41:50show, don't tell way that's since that's always more impactful. Not only can
- 2:41:54she open it herself, she does so from within where you're not supposed to
- 2:41:58be able to all. I noticed that in this scene, unlike others,
- 2:42:01Awayne is channeling using her hands. Yeah, because her commitment to getting ninety
- 2:42:07back is more important than her pride. Elaine says that Agwayn could hurt herself,
- 2:42:11die, or be expelled from the tower. Awayne says, do you
- 2:42:13think I care about that now? Grief has a way of bringing clarity into
- 2:42:16what really matters, and to Awayne, Ninive is far more important than the
- 2:42:20goings on in the tower. But she's lost sight of that a very normal
- 2:42:24thing when she was feeling competitive. But Elaine responds, yes, of course
- 2:42:28you do. Even though grief has made Agwaine realize what's important, it doesn't
- 2:42:31mean that Awayne doesn't still want to be a powerful channeler. Elaine tells her
- 2:42:35that She's heard about the Trollic attack and that Nineve came to the tower for
- 2:42:37Agwayne, do you really think Nine would want you to throw away your life,
- 2:42:41your future because she's gone. That gets at this important thing about grief.
- 2:42:46You have to feel it and be transformed by it. But it doesn't
- 2:42:48mean that you stop living your life just because someone can't live theirs. It's
- 2:42:52not honoring the dead to throw yourself away. Elaine also shows that just because
- 2:42:56she's a new addition doesn't make her a less valuable member of the team.
- 2:43:00He's astute, a good study of people and learns quickly, though GWayne felt
- 2:43:03it was too early for Elaine's comfort. Elaine's ability to be impartial, much
- 2:43:07like Men, becomes a different sort of comfort in an episode that has everyone
- 2:43:11questioning who can be trusted. Elaine definitely seems like a good candidate, but
- 2:43:15we thought the same about men. No one knows what happens in the Arches,
- 2:43:18and then Awayne says I can't leave her, and Elaine responds, I'll
- 2:43:22get some blankets, will stay the night. Maybe what she faced offered her
- 2:43:26a better turning of the wheel. Elaine immediately makes herself a part of this
- 2:43:30on Awayine's terms here as a means of support. This is a woman who,
- 2:43:33it seems has some experience with grief of some kind, because most women
- 2:43:37in their early twenties don't really know how to handle someone else rocked by such
- 2:43:39a profound grief. Speaking generally yet broadly, Yeah, broadly, I think
- 2:43:46that sometimes deep grief is just something that you have to experience to really understand
- 2:43:50it. Hm. And they're not in a place that showcases very well how
- 2:43:54to support someone in deep grief. The mention of the better turning of the
- 2:43:58wheel the trend positions I love good transitions immediately transports us back to the two
- 2:44:03rivers, lots of emphasis on pastel color palettes and birds singing in the background
- 2:44:09saturation to give us this idealistic view in nineties had initially this would be a
- 2:44:15better turning of the wheel, herself and her friends safe at home or safe
- 2:44:18in general, with a GWayne doing great things at the tower, showcasing that
- 2:44:22she has let a Guayane go in a loving fashion to some extent and made
- 2:44:26her peace with the direction she's going in. But the rest of her boys,
- 2:44:28who she knows are alive, are largely home and around, and she
- 2:44:33has Land as well, who is free from Moraine's bond and can be with
- 2:44:35her without baggage. Yep, this is the future as she wants it,
- 2:44:41and it's an awesome look into how nine sees her boys as opposed to how
- 2:44:43they see themselves. Nine EE sees Parent as someone who has made peace with
- 2:44:48violence, scampering around happily with her young daughter in a game that looks really
- 2:44:50similar to a game my sister and I used to play with my dad and
- 2:44:54stepdad when we were little that we call Monster, in which the dad in
- 2:44:58question which has us around pretending to be monster and then catch us. Paren
- 2:45:01is looking like a monster, right, but it is a loving, tender
- 2:45:09hearted man. It's a game game, and he's not afraid to like make
- 2:45:13a little play sword for el Nore. And meanwhile, Matt's Matt's like a
- 2:45:18fucking world traveler with his fancy ass coat and shit. Yeah, Parent is
- 2:45:22questioning whether he's a monster in the show, but NINEI sees him as maybe
- 2:45:26someone who looks intimidating on the outside but has a soft heart, evidence by
- 2:45:30how he's playing with her daughter. Regardless of your feelings about kids, we
- 2:45:33tend to love seeing a man who can be sweet to kids, because it
- 2:45:35tends to evoke a sense of gentleness, and we get that from both Paren
- 2:45:37and Matt. Paren has in some way found his peace with violence as well,
- 2:45:41in ninety said because he gives. Oh yeah, I talked about this,
- 2:45:45But Ninive is unclear in her relationship to violence, because when el Noor
- 2:45:48says her father will teach her how to use the sword, ninety response will
- 2:45:50see, there's no mention. I think that could also be sort of a
- 2:45:54hey, maybe we won't need to. Yeah, I hope we won't need
- 2:45:58to, although then we get the thing about trols in right north. That's
- 2:46:01what I mean is that she's not seeing her daughter as someone who will need
- 2:46:05to use a sword because they're in such a peaceful place. But we know
- 2:46:09that that's not true. There's no mention of nine Need's own knowledge of how
- 2:46:13to use the sword, which she gleaned from the tower, likely because she's
- 2:46:16distanced herself from it, sees it as not a useful tid bit of information
- 2:46:20and grown, and also because yeah, Land is better at it, no
- 2:46:24question. But still I think that's intentional that she never mentions that she knows
- 2:46:26how to use one. Matt, like you said, who questions in the
- 2:46:30books whether he's a good person or a prick just like his dad, and
- 2:46:33who struggles with poverty, is a noble in more ways than one, as
- 2:46:35he comes writing up that was gentle with the sisters in the first episode of
- 2:46:39season one, and this assurance that though he's become a lord, he's not
- 2:46:43lost his sweetness, suld and that should be reassuring to us as well,
- 2:46:46that he's still that way despite the Dagger's influences and the suffering he's endured.
- 2:46:52We get another mention of a term we heard Errol use in the first episode
- 2:46:56of season two, Blade Master, when Matt sees Elinor. Because it's been
- 2:47:00brought up twice, it's likely that because this is something that this is because
- 2:47:03it's something they want us to remember. Yep. Usually the real magic is
- 2:47:09in saying it three times, So I'm assuming they're maybe an additional mention down
- 2:47:13the line. In the books, Niney sees herself as a queen with land
- 2:47:16in this part of the Arches. But I think that this was a smart
- 2:47:18departure because it gives us a chance to see what is driving nine Eve the
- 2:47:22chance for this future. That's why she's so protective in her ideal future.
- 2:47:26It's not just herself who is happy, but everyone, and they're all safe
- 2:47:30from the violence and their little two rivers bubble yep alas Serry goes inside and
- 2:47:37Land and that's when we get to see Land for the first time. What
- 2:47:43a what a look? Or this guy yet two rivers? Land insensible,
- 2:47:48It's fantastic. Matt and Perrin playfight with el Noor while Land and nine Eve
- 2:47:52talk. I think it's interesting. It kind of almost looks like the playing
- 2:48:00is almost kind of a foreshadowing of what's right about to happen. A little
- 2:48:03bit. Matt and Parrin play fire. Yeah, blah blah blah, Agwayne,
- 2:48:07is Land and Ninive talk about how Agwayne is fighting a trollic of invasion
- 2:48:13in Saldea, which Land says is far from here and Ninie says, not
- 2:48:16far enough. This reminds me a lot of dialogue from a very different scene.
- 2:48:24There are a number of moments in book two that involve like potential futures
- 2:48:28if you know what I'm talking about, You know what I'm talking about,
- 2:48:31that that have people talking about like, well, you know, we've been
- 2:48:35living here in two Rivers quite a while, but there's supposed to be trall
- 2:48:37excepting North. But that's a ways right. Yeah. So I think it's
- 2:48:43one of those things where it's like we're showcasing the consequences of Ninive not being
- 2:48:46part of everything. Yeah, and you know, her and her friends being
- 2:48:52taken out of the equation for what's about to happen. Yeah. Ninive calls
- 2:48:56Agwayne by just Agwayne. He's drops the Sadai, doesn't she Land calls her,
- 2:49:03showcasing neither has shaken their old habits despite the passage of time. Nine
- 2:49:09needs hope that she can go back to her little part of the world and
- 2:49:11that she and her friends could be insulated from the violence to come, and
- 2:49:13started to crack. Nine Eve's realizing, you know, things are coming.
- 2:49:18And then Lane asks Ninetyve as she regrets leaving the tower, and she says
- 2:49:22nothing, that's a yes, yeah, but also that she's happy, but
- 2:49:28also like, yeah, you know, but there's something there we can assume
- 2:49:33that means whatever answer she shouldn't say is probably the truth, or at least
- 2:49:37partially true. In abandoning the tower, Niny likely hoped that it meant her
- 2:49:41interaction with the hard choices of the apocalypse were over, but as events worsened,
- 2:49:46she likely realizes that what she's done is deprived the world of one of
- 2:49:50their most powerful beings and left her unable to fully defend her loved ones,
- 2:49:52and nine Hopes are fully shattered along with her door. Much like the wheeled,
- 2:50:00we get to see the cyclical nature of life when Ninive must protect el
- 2:50:03Noor like el Nora once protected nineveh Yep. This is the constant turning of
- 2:50:05the wheel that Dana wanted to stop in season one, and this is not
- 2:50:09the better turning that Ninie hoped it would be and that Elaine speculated about.
- 2:50:15The regret she likely feels at choosing what she wants over the fate of the
- 2:50:18world as reports of violence increase is likely what prevents her from doing the exact
- 2:50:22thing she did when she came out of the arches in a fake way again
- 2:50:24but for real. Ninefe has to live this imagined other life in order to
- 2:50:28realize it's not possible, and that she has to stay in the tower for
- 2:50:31the fade of the world. Like Chierriam said, they need her with them
- 2:50:33at the end. I said that, but bears repeating. Nineve is able
- 2:50:37to defend herself this time, as opposed to the initial attack when she was
- 2:50:41a child and the initial trollic attack, likely in part due to her worder
- 2:50:46training in her mind. Sure, yeah, you know she can construct the
- 2:50:48Yeah, of course, everybody else dies. But she gets to see for
- 2:50:52herself what Leandron has said about the uselessness of swords when compared to the tower.
- 2:50:56Yes, we also get to see what Morain mentions about how brave it
- 2:50:58is to face the dark with nothing but a sword. As we see all
- 2:51:01of our beloved people die one by one, it's rough. When ninety sees
- 2:51:05Land stabbed, She's able to do what we were told was impossible and channel
- 2:51:09in the arches always Land m M. Nine Eve is unprecedented, and unprecedented
- 2:51:15levels are powerful and this is another show don't tell of that. Elmore comes
- 2:51:18out to ask mummy, what's that? Oh my god, yes, the
- 2:51:22archers and realizes what all cry every time I watch this shit. But she
- 2:51:26can't, being who she is and who we know her to be, after
- 2:51:30all of these arches, bring herself this time to leave her child behind.
- 2:51:35Children represent hope, innocence and the future. Nine Eve. Other than also
- 2:51:39just the natural instinct to protect her child, is also protecting those things symbolically
- 2:51:43as well. So when she goes through the arches, all of those things
- 2:51:46are ripped from her, and though she remembers living a whole life with Land,
- 2:51:50it's all gone. It never was. Now the third arch in the
- 2:51:54book, again, it's much shorter, and it's just not it's her kind
- 2:52:01of in a field of flowers, Malkir has been rebuilt. Land rides out
- 2:52:05and she's like, I'm a queen. This is amazing. I'm with Land,
- 2:52:07whom I love. Everything is amazing. They talk about their children,
- 2:52:11and then the arch reappears. So this, this is significally more painful,
- 2:52:15I think in terms of long term pain. Yeah, and I think we'll
- 2:52:18have a lot of hard repercussions for nine Eve. I was also freaked.
- 2:52:24I also freaked a bit at the blood on nine Eve that is right where
- 2:52:26Elinor should be, as if it's this big wound now she has, as
- 2:52:31if the kid was hurt in some way, even though actually probably Land's blood
- 2:52:35probably, but like we get to see it coating her right where she was
- 2:52:41carrying her daughter By the way, we probably got the earlier scene in which
- 2:52:45Leanna remarks that the blood on Nineieve isn't hers, because in this scene they
- 2:52:48wanted us to know for sure the blood isn't hers. Nine gets out of
- 2:52:52the arches with empty arms of false to the ground, wailing. Agwayne rushes
- 2:52:56over to her to comfort her, and Nineve at last allows her to see
- 2:52:58how much she hurting. Because the pain is so profound she can't hold it
- 2:53:01in hell of an ending. So now from here she has to figure out
- 2:53:09how to have a relationship with the Tower because she must heavy heavy realizations for
- 2:53:16nine Eve. This, I you know, I like pretty much all episodes
- 2:53:22of this show by and large, but this, this was very, very
- 2:53:24strong one. This is one of the best episodes of the show. Yeah,
- 2:53:28I in my mind in turns devastated and buoyed and devastated and enjoyed it
- 2:53:35and was devastated at rinse and repeat. Speaking of devastation, Shall we move
- 2:53:41to the C plot? Oh right, there's a whole fucking another plot.
- 2:53:45Wow, I forgot and goddamn speaking of yeah, yep, okay, okay,
- 2:53:50I'm good, I forgot. Yeah, I totally forgot. We didn't
- 2:53:52talk about a parent because I was so wrapped up in the third arch.
- 2:53:56Yeah, it's pretty wild, right, Like, this episode is fucking packed.
- 2:54:01It is with stuff, like just stuff to unpack. It's amazing packed
- 2:54:05with stuff to unpack. Hey, there we go. So we got parent
- 2:54:24in the shon Chan. Oh yeah, so many smart choices in this initial
- 2:54:30scene. My god, as Reif has said, they're here to show that
- 2:54:35the shan Chan don't fuck around and as such terrified. They show fase how
- 2:54:41big the obstacles are that these characters are not facing. Right, this is
- 2:54:46the obstacles Season nine eds relationship with the tower obstacle, Parent and the shan
- 2:54:52Chan, and the shan Chan in general obstacle. Like, we are upping
- 2:54:56the threat levels constantly, which is why I'm very certain of what I think
- 2:55:03will be the and I will brag about it. I was very certain what
- 2:55:07the ending of this season would be, and I was fucking right. Yes,
- 2:55:13we are recording this part after having seen everything because it's much later now.
- 2:55:16Yeah, but don't worry when I gonna talk about it. Yeah,
- 2:55:18okay, but rape in my mind is saying I don't want to hear shit
- 2:55:24about how the Changian aren't that bad, which which sometimes people say about the
- 2:55:28Shanian In the books, the specific costuming choices are designed to make the characters
- 2:55:31look as inhuman as possible. It's playing on the fact that they have the
- 2:55:35bug helmets and the bug motif. In the books, they described as looking
- 2:55:39like giant bugs. Right, so we're playing on that. We're making them
- 2:55:43look as kind of inhuman and alien as possible, uh huh, Right,
- 2:55:46from their hairstyles to their weird kind of appendagy. It almost it looks alien,
- 2:55:54and they look like they have spines on the back of their armor.
- 2:55:56It's really cool, I mean, to me, looks they look a little
- 2:56:01bit like the Krogan from Mass Effect too. Really, they kind of remind
- 2:56:03me of Predator. Yeah yeah, well various aliens, yeah, various like
- 2:56:07the Holy Creatures. The women who control the Magic Women look like they have
- 2:56:13that look like the Krogan Mass Effect, specifically because of their back armor,
- 2:56:20the scary helmets, scary masks, Surroth wearing horns that make her look demonic,
- 2:56:26all with the purpose of making these characters feel like a hive collective getting
- 2:56:30at one of these One of the types of horror that I love machine horror,
- 2:56:33which represents our fear at a loss of autonomy. We place a lot
- 2:56:37of importance on the human face. When that is taken away, the person
- 2:56:41no longer feels human. How fitting for a group that enslaves people that they
- 2:56:46lose their humanity when they deprive others of theirs. The lower down the people
- 2:56:54are, the more of their faces we can see in this initial stage,
- 2:56:58and the more they have. Yes, those people are ponds in a larger
- 2:57:03game. Very purposefully. The people who are enslaved have way more of their
- 2:57:07faces showing than almost anyone else, giving them a look at their humanity.
- 2:57:11I thought it was also a great choice to have a blonde haired girl be
- 2:57:15presented as one of the first enslaved women we get to know. I mean,
- 2:57:18I think it's pretty clear that they are enslaved. Yeah, we yes,
- 2:57:24that's not a spoiler, yes, but yeah, I thought it was
- 2:57:28really smart in an initial scene showing an enslaved person to not have that be
- 2:57:35in some way evocative of something of a real world situation. Yeah, because
- 2:57:41about you talking about an American chattel slavery. I'm talking about American chattel slavery,
- 2:57:45and I think that it's really smart that they are distancing themselves from that
- 2:57:48well while also still like not not here, here's what I'm saying, not
- 2:57:56capitalizing on an existing groups trauma, yes, for entertainment, I think is
- 2:58:03a smart choice because notably, the shan Chen also have American accents, which
- 2:58:07is by the way true in the books. They have text and accents in
- 2:58:09the books. So it is it is clear to me that the parallels are
- 2:58:15deliberate. Yea, but that we are going and it's it's it's it's inspired
- 2:58:20by, but different from, it's based on, but different letting itself be
- 2:58:26it's Oh, here's the thing, it's letting itself be its own thing that
- 2:58:28is different then, but also fully exploring the stakes of what that is.
- 2:58:35Yes, I just think it's really smart to be like, we're not necessarily
- 2:58:39capitalizing for entertainment on the existing trauma of a well that would be fucked it
- 2:58:45would. But that happens, yes, I know, you know, no,
- 2:58:48I mean it happens like that is something that people do in entertainment historically,
- 2:58:54and I'm glad that they're being really here's the thing. I'm glad they're
- 2:58:58being really conscious about the justcisions that they're making. Yes, they're in that.
- 2:59:01They're like, we're going to showcase the full trauma of what this means.
- 2:59:05I'm like, not pussyfoot around about whether or not this is good or
- 2:59:09bad. Yeah, we're going to show that these people are fucking terrifying and
- 2:59:13should be feared and are you know, kind of shitty. Also, the
- 2:59:18girl is very clearly a child. Yes, it's ah god, I remember
- 2:59:22that picture first made the rounds on Twitter. Everybody was going, oh my
- 2:59:24god, it's a kid. Good. Good, because you know what,
- 2:59:28this is the thing. If we are going to have slavery in something,
- 2:59:31we need to fucking like do it. You know, Like, this is
- 2:59:35my thing is if we are going to explore this something this wrong and this
- 2:59:41traumatic, we can't just go like and there's slaves. They ain't house elves.
- 2:59:45There's oop olumpus. They're enslaved. But like in a cute way,
- 2:59:48there can't be doing this anymore. We cannot be. We shouldn't have ever
- 2:59:52been doing this, but we cannot do this anymore. Yeah, in entertainment
- 2:59:54where we're like, oh, but like they're happy this way, no,
- 2:59:58fuck you, I mean badly blonde girl seems to really be enjoying herself.
- 3:00:03That does not mean that she is happy. We'll get there. I have
- 3:00:05a lot of thoughts about this, a lot to talk about down the road
- 3:00:09about this that we can't necessarily cover right now the right scope of this.
- 3:00:11But I did see some people online refer to her as Braddy. Oh okay.
- 3:00:18I think this just shows how brainwashed she is. That this girl,
- 3:00:20who is a literal child is visibly delighting and subjugating people as she has been
- 3:00:26subjugated. Brainwashing is on the table. Also, let's keep in mind that
- 3:00:31she's in front of the people enslaving her, so she may need to put
- 3:00:35on a mask of face. Yeah, we'll see where it goes. I'm
- 3:00:39speculating that we will likely I said this at the time, I'm speculating that
- 3:00:43we will likely see more of her. By the way, going back to
- 3:00:46what you said earlier about visual parallels and other parallels to American chattel slavery,
- 3:00:52the GAG is an American chattel slavery thing, right, So it's not it
- 3:00:56is not it is it is. It is a where of what it's inspiration
- 3:01:01and parallel is. Yeah, I mean, here's the thing. I think
- 3:01:05it's a I want to be thoughtful about how I say this, because we're
- 3:01:07dealing with a really delicate subject. I think that they are walking the line
- 3:01:13of we're going to acknowledge what this is and the extent to which this is
- 3:01:20a traumatic, awful thing that we should not under sell without I think,
- 3:01:26necessarily making it feel like, oh, we're going to exploit the real world
- 3:01:31traumas of real people for entertainment. And I think they're walking that line very
- 3:01:37carefully, Yeah, which I appreciate. Well, it's very much in the
- 3:01:41in the line of just throwing traumatic imagery about Willy Nilly with full brunt or
- 3:01:48tempered or changed or in any other way to refer back to other fantasy shows
- 3:01:54that will just like have essay happen on screen because they know it's going to
- 3:01:58get a response, versus addressing a topic perhaps more carefully. Yeah. I
- 3:02:05think my thing has always been it's not that you can't explore these kinds of
- 3:02:09traumas on screen. And I do think to a certain extent people need to
- 3:02:15be made aware of the gravity of these things. It's how you do it
- 3:02:20that really matters to me. Yeah, and why Yeah, And I think
- 3:02:24that they are doing a good job to me of showcasing how monstrous this is.
- 3:02:28Yes, I also thought it was a smart choice to showcase the impact
- 3:02:31that the taking of these girls has. We hear about it happening in the
- 3:02:35books, and we see like scorched marks in the earth at these different towns.
- 3:02:41Yeah, we never actually see never see it happen. We only see
- 3:02:45the aftermath of this and the devastation that it inflicts on their families. We're
- 3:02:48getting a little outside of our spoiler scope with this because this is some later
- 3:02:52stuff in the book. So let's be very careful, all right, we'll
- 3:02:54talk about that later. Young girls, in our society, we pretty universally
- 3:03:01agree, is someone who needs to be protected, right right, Young children,
- 3:03:07young girls. To see these children ripped from the arms of their wailing
- 3:03:11loved ones is exactly how strongly we should be emphasizing how awful this is.
- 3:03:16It's not only children too, it's it's some older women. I believe in
- 3:03:20this episode, I think like youngish women. Sure, Okay, so of
- 3:03:26course, seeing this scene, Uno would want to protect these children. Yeah,
- 3:03:31because he is a protective person. He's funny and we like him,
- 3:03:37and he's enjoyable as a character, but he is also very much full of
- 3:03:41vinegar and very very principled. Notably, remember he found out that the Shinarin
- 3:03:50from earlier was a dark friend and was like fuck him, on him,
- 3:03:54leave him. He did spit on him. He has very strong feelings.
- 3:03:58Yeah, I think what happened is very much in line with who Uno is
- 3:04:01as a character, even though it doesn't happen in the books. Yes,
- 3:04:05that is a notable change. Uno doesn't die here. Uno wouldn't bow to
- 3:04:09them, who know would not bow to them? No, No, I
- 3:04:11do not believe he would. Notably, the soldom bows before the hook at
- 3:04:16the base of the palatequin before she walks away, Chekhov's hook. Chekhov's hook.
- 3:04:20So then they pick Uno to swear the oaths first. Well, yeah,
- 3:04:26I think that the soldier sees that he's trying something. Yeah, or
- 3:04:28sees that he's probably the one who would be the most resistant, And that
- 3:04:33is a very unfortunately clever thing that she does by going this guy's going to
- 3:04:37be a problem, So we should just stamp him out first and foremost,
- 3:04:41and if he goes down, everybody else will go down. This is a
- 3:04:43very story turney plot line. By the way, because we're learning about a
- 3:04:46whole new group, we also get another choice presented. There are choices all
- 3:04:52over this episode, but instead of Adore, it's a spike. I think
- 3:04:58this is likely something that they do. They pick someone they think will likely
- 3:05:01resist as an intimidation tactic when they kill him right to get people to be
- 3:05:07subservient. It feels like they specifically were looking around looking for the person who
- 3:05:11is most like this is bullshit to bring him forward first, because it accomplishes
- 3:05:16one of two things. If they kill him, it showcases that they're not
- 3:05:20fucking around. And if he capitulates, then it encourages everyone else to do
- 3:05:24so too, because they took their strongest person and made him capitulate. So
- 3:05:28it's going to either it's going to decrease resistance either way. It's a win
- 3:05:33either way. It just looked like they were looking for him and she's the
- 3:05:37woman who is. The soldier specifically came up when she was like, who's
- 3:05:39ready to swear the others? And he goes and she goes he is this
- 3:05:43man? Yeah fun. Oh. We mentioned earlier that the voice alway is
- 3:05:48the character's name who is speaking is Guy Roberts's real world wife. It was
- 3:05:54so funny. We messaged him like, end your own wife. Yeah,
- 3:05:58yeah, I think we said that earlier. Yeah, it was so fun
- 3:06:03The brutality of the killing is also a message to the characters and the fans
- 3:06:05the shan Chan do you not fucker talk around? The only time we hear
- 3:06:09Sarroth speak is to say, after UNA's death, all show bow. The
- 3:06:16less she says, the more weight she has when she does speak. Yep.
- 3:06:20There are other reasons that I think they chose to kill Uno that we
- 3:06:24can't talk about right now, though we can talk about in the spoiler scope
- 3:06:28section. Just I will say it establishes for the book fans, Hey,
- 3:06:33you think you know what's gonna happen. Maybe you don't, Maybe you don't.
- 3:06:37I like that. I like that too, and not in a senseless
- 3:06:41way. I would say, because UNA's death serves purpose. Yeah, you
- 3:06:43don't have to like it. That's okay, it it does serve It was
- 3:06:48done with narrative intent. Noah. Again, I think some shows kill characters
- 3:06:54solely to keep you on your toes. I think, and again it is
- 3:06:58not a criticism of this choice, but I think the walking dead in particular,
- 3:07:01will kill characters simply because they haven't in a minute, or did when
- 3:07:05that was on the air. Game of Thrones in its early years, I
- 3:07:09think killed characters because the plot demands it. Notably, I'm not going to
- 3:07:13be specific about Game of Thrones case you haven't watched it, but a lot
- 3:07:16of what kind of set that show apart in its early days was that major,
- 3:07:20major main characters would die seemingly at the before the end of their arcs.
- 3:07:26But those character deaths were done sort of in a way where it went,
- 3:07:30well, duh, how in a realistic scenario would you expect this person
- 3:07:33to get out of this? It doesn't make sense and it wouldn't happen.
- 3:07:37So therefore, expect that this is a world where actions have consequences and things
- 3:07:41may not happen according to narrative structure as you want it to. And in
- 3:07:46this UNO's death serves a narrative purpose, it does and world purpose. So
- 3:07:54we cut to a carriage and a bloody pair and shackled inside. Yes.
- 3:07:58Oh also, Shu you talk about how paren is the last one to go
- 3:08:01down? Yes, oh yeah, he wants to be Oh yeah, because
- 3:08:07Ktar tells them fucking no, I'm not worth it. And then Messima goes
- 3:08:11down, and then Paren goes down at the very end, and then he
- 3:08:13looks up and he makes eye contact with Ishamael. Yeah, I think that's
- 3:08:18going to be important, is Paren's unwillingness? Well, Paren realizing that perhaps
- 3:08:26violence is necessary sometimes in these particular instances, even though he watched Uno get
- 3:08:31killed. It's like, maybe it's better to go down for something that's right
- 3:08:37than to kneel before something that's wrong. Who is a monster? Is attacking
- 3:08:43these people a monstrous thing to do? Was Uno a monster? I don't
- 3:08:46think so. It was a futile effort, but perhaps to them Uno was
- 3:08:52interesting stuff. So yeah, we get a bloody parent shackled inside a carriage
- 3:08:56a liminal space. Ishama else sitting across from him and says that I am
- 3:09:03the man who is standing between you and the spike. It's a good line.
- 3:09:07We get a little casual threat in there. Don't play along, and
- 3:09:09who know might happen to you? You might be duo duo or dose or
- 3:09:16dose whatever. In introducing himself as someone who could keep parent alive? Again,
- 3:09:20who is a monster? Is somebody who could keep you alive a monster
- 3:09:24is the problem. We don't know necessarily, but we've heard a lot potentially
- 3:09:31about him and his bad works, so we're supposed to assume so. But
- 3:09:35we're kind of seeing how he gets at people. Notably, he has also
- 3:09:39already referred to himself by the moniker father of lies. So let's take what
- 3:09:45he says with a grain of salt here, right, But he thinks that
- 3:09:48those labels are unfair. He does who's right, but he says the parent
- 3:09:52is headed to fam He has this creepy ass moment where he gives par and
- 3:09:58water. He like insists on holding it and like pouring it down his throat.
- 3:10:03It's very rough. He has sexual chemistry. That's literally everyone everyone,
- 3:10:11literally everybody. This actor has sexual chemistry with everyone, just knocking it out
- 3:10:16of the just a walking maget sexual kid. He's grown ass. What am
- 3:10:22I talking about? But yeah, older than I am and not a little
- 3:10:26bit. But it's like it's almost this like fatherly thing to like give like
- 3:10:33pour water into somebody's mouth, and it's corrupted. It is, it's very
- 3:10:37corrupted. Like he tenderly takes his face. It's really really well and the
- 3:10:43high angles of the shots hint at Parent's vulnerability. Yep, and as Jean
- 3:10:48Mael says, you know you have something inside you, something that calls for
- 3:10:52blood, something that sets your eyes on fire. Show me, Paren,
- 3:10:56I want to meet the monster. Jean Mael. It's once again getting at
- 3:11:01the thesis of what is a monster. We know that Paren, the man
- 3:11:05is not a monster. We've seen that in nineties test right. He's a
- 3:11:11good hearted person both because of his but Paren fears that he might be,
- 3:11:16and a Shameel is playing off of that, both because of his wolf abilities
- 3:11:20and also because he killed Leilah. Paren then looks into a Shamel's eyes and
- 3:11:22sees the fire eyed man he and the boys all saw in their dreams.
- 3:11:28A Shameel is basically pairing them together, being like, this sets your eyes
- 3:11:31on fire. Your eyes changed because of this, My eyes have also changed.
- 3:11:35You've seen me before. We are connected. He's connecting them on purpose.
- 3:11:41Paren then does a like, I think, very purposefully animalistic. Who
- 3:11:46are you it is? Yeah, it's it's pretty intense. Who are you
- 3:11:50right? Yeah? I think it's meant to feel almost like what is he
- 3:11:54transitioning into a wolf? What's he doing? Is he a monster. We
- 3:11:58know he's not, but he does these things. Sometimes he's showing a more
- 3:12:03bestial side. Oh and then he says you're dead. Rand killed you,
- 3:12:07and A Shamael replies, is that what Morain told you? The Father of
- 3:12:13lies is sowing distrust in their ranks? Yes, Morain lied to them,
- 3:12:18has lied to them in the past. Can they trust her? I also
- 3:12:20like that as Shameel is outfitted like an oily businessman from the Mad Men era,
- 3:12:26It's cry love the fucking costuming in this show so much so, there's
- 3:12:31so much attention to this stuff. The wolves come and a Shamel says they're
- 3:12:35here in a taunting tone, almost if this plays into his plans, As
- 3:12:39Chamael tells him, the more wolf you are, the more your mind.
- 3:12:41I'll be watching your progress with great interest. It's fucking guy before calmly walking
- 3:12:46out into the chaos, Calm always being powerful. Calm is power again,
- 3:12:50making this seem like this plays into his plans. Everything is going according to
- 3:12:54plan, which we should be panicking about. Mm hmmm. Is Jameel's playing
- 3:12:58into parents suspicions of his powers? Are these a good thing? Or are
- 3:13:01they're negative reasons? Why Elias is such a mystery. Could Paren really be
- 3:13:05a monster like Matt? Paren has given an uncertain door to walk through as
- 3:13:09Elias enters, looking rather monstrous himself as his face drips blood. Yeah,
- 3:13:15it looks like he tore someone's fucking throat out. Oh eat, he definitely
- 3:13:18did. Like this man is biting people, but Parent isn't so dissuaded by
- 3:13:22Shamel that he doesn't follow Elias. Parent says that who wants to go get
- 3:13:26loyal and the others, and Elias responds, you can't help your friends from
- 3:13:28the back of a cage. Paren is not a beast meant to be chained,
- 3:13:31and he's useless to everyone if he is. It is go ahead,
- 3:13:35last thing, But is this boy stumbling into an even bigger trap? Only
- 3:13:39time will tell. Uh. It's interesting because I think that they are compared
- 3:13:43to the book, they're making Alias more more wolf like. He spends all
- 3:13:50his time with wolves in the books, but he's still very much a civil
- 3:13:54human. Yeah. You know, he's called long tooth by the wolves because
- 3:13:58he has a long knife. And it seems like this man bites people.
- 3:14:03Yeah, and I'm kind of into it. Seems like he does and I'm
- 3:14:05into it as well. You know what, fight, I kind of like
- 3:14:09it a lot. Carrie Beatle is doing an amazing job. I really just
- 3:14:13the actors in the show are really killing it. I'm pleased. I like
- 3:14:18that they're leaning into the mystery of Elias and the mystery of these powers and
- 3:14:24how uncertain Parent is about whether or not these are good things. Maybe not
- 3:14:28all gifts are good yep. And that's the end of Parent, And that's
- 3:14:33the end of the spoiler for the show section the show only. So we're
- 3:14:39going to say farewell, good night of Vitashan, goodbye to anybody who has
- 3:14:45only watched the show. Go away as soon as you can, because after
- 3:14:48these upcoming ads, we're going to get into the spoiler section. And you
- 3:14:52don't want that if you have not read for what Ali has read, which
- 3:14:56is through Knife of Dreams chapter three. Oh away, it's a spoiler.
- 3:15:03Babies, spoilers, spoilers, spoilers, spoilers, spoilers, spoilersoil Welcome to
- 3:15:11the spoiler section. I have to come up with it, all right,
- 3:15:15I'm trying to think of a thing. I got to make a bit,
- 3:15:18I got to do a joke, spoil ance Slandia. Nice where there are
- 3:15:24spoilers abounding like dinosaurs. All right, oh man, break down. We've
- 3:15:31got a couple two, three, four, five things to talk about here.
- 3:15:35Okay, so sorry yonder a little bit. It's totally fine. Uh
- 3:15:39oh, we've got nine Eve in the accept A Test as a little girl.
- 3:15:45The dad comes over when she's got the deadly herb. What's it called?
- 3:15:50Crimsn This is spoilers by the way through Knife of Dreams chapter three.
- 3:15:54Oh yeah, thank you for much spoilers through Knife of Dreams chapter three.
- 3:15:58I'm so glad that I know about Adelius's death for this season because now I
- 3:16:05get to pick up on all this other shit that I wouldn't have picked up
- 3:16:07on last season, you know what I mean. So, yeah, we're
- 3:16:11introducing this Deadly Herb again the third time we've seen Crimson Thorn yep, when
- 3:16:18Adelius has just been introduced frequently wearing red flowers. Giving Adelius this much focus
- 3:16:24and having her impact the plot as a whole means her death is going to
- 3:16:28be given I think a lot more importance, very possible. Oh my god,
- 3:16:33Natty in the Accepted Test. Yeah, she is so getting a redemption.
- 3:16:39God, intersection that you had a theory on how that redemption arc was
- 3:16:41going to happen. Oh do you remember what it was because we recorded that
- 3:16:45part weeks ago. Okay, you know the Battle of two rivs. Yes,
- 3:16:48she's going to be the first one stabbin for sure, I'll buy it.
- 3:16:52Yeah, it's going to be like, oh God, like the women
- 3:16:56are running away la da da da da. We get and we've seen Natty
- 3:17:00run away from danger even when her own children are threatened before. But now
- 3:17:05we're seeing in the accepted test. We are setting up this idea right that
- 3:17:09when the chips are down, Natty will step up. Mm hmm. Even
- 3:17:11if this is not the real Natty, even this is, yeah, it
- 3:17:15doesn't matter because we're seeing her in a position we're remind First of all,
- 3:17:18we're reminding ourselves, oh, Natty exists, which is important, just the
- 3:17:22idea of reminding people that Natty exists. Right, when they could have picked
- 3:17:28a couple other people to fill this role, they pick Natty, which I
- 3:17:31go, Okay, so we are supposed to be reminded that Natty is specifically
- 3:17:37kind of hamstringing Matt. Right. I just feel like we're going to be
- 3:17:43chips are down, the women and children are running to the are supposed to
- 3:17:48run to the forest, right, Natty Coughin comes out with a fucking frying
- 3:17:52Yeah, Natty with her fucking frying pan is going to be just fucking funny.
- 3:17:56So it's probably actually going to be like I think it's a pitch for
- 3:18:00such thing. Yeah, I'm visualizing like a pitchfork or something. But she
- 3:18:03just helps spears somebody. No, because we had the pitchforks on Winter Night.
- 3:18:07They had the women kill the trollic with the pitchforks on Winter Night.
- 3:18:09Yeah, maybe it does have to be something that. I think it has
- 3:18:11to be something different. I don't know if they're going to separate the women
- 3:18:16and children by the way, I'd like be like the women have to go
- 3:18:18into I don't know if that's going to happen. I do think though,
- 3:18:22that she's going to be like, maybe I shouldn't fight, right, Well,
- 3:18:26he's going to like maybe choose cowardice. At first, they might not
- 3:18:30because yeah, it might just be like a, hey, some people need
- 3:18:33to go with the kids because we might need to evacuate the children, you
- 3:18:37know. Yeah, So, but I think that she comes back like Oh
- 3:18:43yeah, there's going to be some kind of thing where it seems like she's
- 3:18:45going to flee from the danger, and then she doesn't, and then she
- 3:18:48really doesn't. Does Apple come back? Yeah? I think that Natty's redemption
- 3:18:56is seemingly being given more weight. Yeah. Yeah, the dog is gonna
- 3:19:03make some noise, dog noises. Yeah. So I just think it seems
- 3:19:07like they're giving Natty as a character a little more attention than they are able.
- 3:19:11That could that could change, right, We've got a lot of show
- 3:19:15until Battle of Two Ribs, but it seems like they're at least setting Natty
- 3:19:18up for redemption. Probably not that much if book if season four is Book
- 3:19:22three, season three is Book four, My god. Yeah, but that's
- 3:19:26still seven whole episode. I mean, I'm assuming Battle of Two Ribs is
- 3:19:28either seven or eight of three true. Okay, yeah, so that's still
- 3:19:33quite a bit. We'll see. Yeah, but they're reminding us that she
- 3:19:35exists specifically, which means to me, they're like, remember her, remember
- 3:19:41her, remember her. It's a command. The scenes between Leandren and Cheeriom
- 3:19:46are so fun to watch knowing they're both black Auja but may not know about
- 3:19:50that about each other well, to clarify for people, you have determined that
- 3:19:56Serrium is either black Aja or is involuntarily work for them because of the whole
- 3:20:01being beaten by apparently at forsaken in the tent that one time. Yeah,
- 3:20:07but they may not know about each other, which adds such a fun dynamic
- 3:20:09that I'm sure. I'm sure the two women know, the two actresses know,
- 3:20:15they know whether or not they are yes, yeah, and whether or
- 3:20:16not they know about each other, which I think no, probably not,
- 3:20:20but yeah, And then they must be having so much fun playing whatever that
- 3:20:24reality is without telegraphing it. I just think it's exciting as a dynamic.
- 3:20:30But then I'm also like, there's purposely put This is my other argument.
- 3:20:35They're purposely put in the same position facing a window back to the camera.
- 3:20:39It just feels like the two of them are being set up to be in
- 3:20:43a conversation with each other's characters. You also wanted to talk more about Elaine's
- 3:20:48grief or her understanding. Oh I'm getting there, Okay, Sorry, Aktar
- 3:20:52and Messima put themselves before protecting the innocent. Yes, something parent struggles to
- 3:20:58do. Foreshadowing at its finest, Yes, like we're showcasing that Mesma sucks.
- 3:21:03Am I right? And you know the ink tar dark friending stuff.
- 3:21:07Yeah. Land Feir is sitting under a sign that is her chapter logo from
- 3:21:11the books. Wait, that's this that's this episode, oh land Fair,
- 3:21:16Yeah she was. It's the fucking moon and stars. Oh god, that
- 3:21:18was great. She's also wearing black lace under her blue coat, which I'm
- 3:21:22feeling like is a hint yes, colorwise, hints of black, hints of
- 3:21:28white. The use of color and costuming is fucking great. Something to pay
- 3:21:33attention to Rand leaning into land Fear and saying that he thinks she prefers when
- 3:21:37there's a little bit of mystery, such dramatic irony for what's going on right
- 3:21:43now. Ugh, ay, they're having a lot of fun with the dramatic
- 3:21:46irony. I really love that. Yes they are, land Fear being the
- 3:21:50one who gets in the coat. I love that choice. It Yosha may
- 3:21:54have kept that coat, by the way, good for him getting him that
- 3:21:58coat dressed, seeing him like what she wants him to be. Oh,
- 3:22:03there's so much there about, just like her manipulating him into what she envisions
- 3:22:11loose there in being it's it is Matt questioning Leandre's integrity and accusing her of
- 3:22:16bullshit that makes her unleash her cruelty on him. That's that's what strikes close
- 3:22:22to home. Gee, I wonder why maybe because the one time she was
- 3:22:26trying to do something out of guilt, it gets questioned. Huhm. Starve
- 3:22:31in the blight is what Landfear says to hire Nobles. It's the same turn
- 3:22:35of phrase sat from each other. That's what she says. They're hoping the
- 3:22:39hunters of the Horn will do, and that link is the blight, which
- 3:22:46is why I'm saying that I think the links between Serium and Leandron might be
- 3:22:50on purpose. We'll see Landfear saying to Rand, I could get used to
- 3:22:54you looking like this when he's wearing the coat was something I just want to
- 3:22:58call out those things. Landfeir looks really comfortable in this environment. She looks
- 3:23:05really comfortable in every in liese. Yeah, but especially in the like Kyrienna
- 3:23:09Noble place, and Rand does not laying the groundwork for our audience that she
- 3:23:13seems too comfortable here for being a woman from a humble four Gate background,
- 3:23:18especially when she dismisses Lady Anvere the audacity. She also has no trouble with
- 3:23:24the fact that people are being sent off to die so that the nobility don't
- 3:23:26have to feed them, laughing at Rand's naivete is This could be dismissed by
- 3:23:33first time ors as someone who has seen a lot and is worldwide as jaded
- 3:23:37a potential good mentor for Rand, or if they're into romance tropes. Of
- 3:23:41the romance tropes of it all, they might catch on to the fact that
- 3:23:43something may be off with her. She might be a miss wrong. The
- 3:23:48writers cleverly disguise the Forsaken being out without tipping readers off that she could be
- 3:23:54forsaken, while still laying the breadcrumbs that she could be landfear by having mentioned
- 3:23:58of the Forsaken in the first season and having Moraine deduce that a Shawmiel is
- 3:24:01out and maybe planning on releasing the others. By making it seem like this
- 3:24:05is something he may do, the writers show simultaneously how much on the back
- 3:24:09foot even someone as powerful as Moraine is when compared to the Forsaken, because
- 3:24:13he's already done it h the right, but we think that it's going to
- 3:24:18be a future thing. But he that's like the first thing he did after
- 3:24:22he left the ide world. I bet she knows that at least one of
- 3:24:24them is out because of the moon dial. Yeah. Yeah, but like
- 3:24:28she's sang, may, yes, she's saying like that's what he's planning.
- 3:24:33Yes. Meanwhile, Landfair is very deeply intertwined with Rand right now, which
- 3:24:37is not what you want. The writers also successfully walk the tight rope of
- 3:24:41giving information without giving it all away. Yes. Really smart work there.
- 3:24:46I saw a mystery writer on TikTok because I've been following these mystery writers.
- 3:24:50I think I said this last episode say that one of the most important things
- 3:24:52you can do in mystery writing is messed with the order in which you give
- 3:24:54information, so that the breadcrumbs are there, but the trail isn't obvious.
- 3:24:58Yes, and by having the order of information changed around into different plot lines,
- 3:25:01the writers successfully give us the surprise. Yes, everything everyone says or
- 3:25:07does is part of some scheme or some game, is what land Fear says.
- 3:25:13Dramatic irony for the ones who know. That's the lean is Land Fear
- 3:25:16don't ask questions, you know the answers to is what she says to Rand.
- 3:25:22Yes, the obvious answer is because she loves him. Because he's like,
- 3:25:26why do you even waste your time with me? She says, don't
- 3:25:28ask questions, you know the answers too, So obviously she's saying like,
- 3:25:31because I care about you, because I love you. Right, But the
- 3:25:33dramatic irony here is that rand is not yet aware of how much she loves
- 3:25:37him. This reply has layers of subtext. Just a couple, just a
- 3:25:43couple. Not being paralyzed by his past mistakes feels very purposeful. His obsession
- 3:25:50with what he's done in the past, the past haunting him, bothering him.
- 3:25:54I feel like it's purposeful. Yeah right, yeah, yeah, okay,
- 3:25:56yeah yeah, Ma's obsession with his past actions feels true. Yeah yeah,
- 3:26:01making up Yeah okay. Sh I get where you're going with that.
- 3:26:05Yeah yeah, why wouldn't it. I mean, I know that they were
- 3:26:09basically kind of forced into this plot line by Yeah, they absolutely were,
- 3:26:16but I feel like they are taking advantage of it and emphasizing it further in
- 3:26:20part because it's like, sure, him having this like idea of himself as
- 3:26:24no hero and past things being like something that kind of bothers him is a
- 3:26:31constant thing. Yeah, here's the thing, because we know now because it's
- 3:26:35after the whole season has come out and they've been able to do interviews that
- 3:26:39they essentially had to do a page one rewrite because of Barney Harris's exit.
- 3:26:43And I really love what they have done me too. And I'm only talking
- 3:26:48about the first three episodes right now, whether it's worked for you or not,
- 3:26:52with the fact that they had to completely fucking overhaul everything and not have
- 3:26:56the boys be together, because that was actually the original plan was a lot
- 3:27:00closer to the page pages of book two of the boys are together hunting for
- 3:27:07the Horn. Uh. And I just love that we've been able to spend
- 3:27:09so much specific time with these characters still as themselves in spite of it.
- 3:27:16No, do we talk about Huno or do you have We're getting there.
- 3:27:20I'm sorry for Wait, what are we wanting to We talked about a couple
- 3:27:22of things we wanted to talk I wrote it all down. We already talked
- 3:27:24about all A Lane's grief. Yeah, grief, that's the other one.
- 3:27:28Grief with a Lane. Definitely, she's experienced that with her father. Yeah,
- 3:27:33that's what I was thinking of. Yeah, it's that being forced to
- 3:27:39grow up too soon. Yeah, and probably also with uh Tom getting forced
- 3:27:43out with different kinds of griefs, so you know, yeah, taring Gale's
- 3:27:48death for sure. Yeah, let's talk about you now, all right,
- 3:27:50we already talked about who know, Actually yeah we did, because we talked
- 3:27:54about Ingtar and Messina. Yeah I'm losing track, oh yeah, but I
- 3:27:58mean it just makes it why they caught him. I love Uno, man,
- 3:28:01and then you know, I love Guy Roberts. He did such a
- 3:28:03great job he was. He's so funny. He's such a fan, and
- 3:28:09you know, I'm as sad as anybody. But listen, y'all. Uno
- 3:28:13doesn't do anything after book three as far as we're gone along, Like in
- 3:28:18book six he starts teaching cavalry and that's kind of the last time we've seen
- 3:28:24him. Yeah. I love Uno. He's a fucking funny character. He
- 3:28:26has great moments with nine Eve, and yeah, we'll lose those character moments
- 3:28:31for him and nine Eve, and that that is sad. But I understand
- 3:28:35that if you've got to kill somebody, if you're choosing to kill somebody and
- 3:28:37you want to have minimal plot change from it, you can't kill Massima.
- 3:28:43No, and you can't really kill and it doesn't make sense for either of
- 3:28:46them to give up their lives for that. No, so, and if
- 3:28:50you bring in some random third person or fourth person and kill them, we
- 3:28:54won't care. It's not going to be as significant to the book people.
- 3:28:58It might still be significant to show only folks. However, this might seem
- 3:29:03like a bit of a stretch. By the way, this next thing go
- 3:29:07ahead, but it pricked my ears up when Paren and a Chamael are in
- 3:29:13the carriage, as Chamael says to Parent, I was starting to worry you
- 3:29:16might never wake up, and I was kind of like, dream shit.
- 3:29:18I think it was. I mean, maybe just seems like an interesting line
- 3:29:22to me. It is because she loves the dream is she loves the dreams
- 3:29:26Paren with the wolf dreams. I don't know. I might be a bit
- 3:29:28of a stretch, but I was kind of like, huh, I wonder
- 3:29:31if they're playing with that a little bit. Something that calls for blood and
- 3:29:35something that sets your eyes on fire has to be a reference to land Fair
- 3:29:37and a shameel. Oh yeah, those were that was very specifically worded.
- 3:29:43That's not a stretch. Who said that as Shamayel says the following line,
- 3:29:48Uh, hold on, you have something inside do something that calls for blood,
- 3:29:54something that sets your eyes on fire. Yeah, no, i'd buy
- 3:29:56that. Yeah, that's good, that's fun. Yeah no, that's definitely
- 3:29:58what happening. But those were such a specifically words. That's very specific.
- 3:30:03Yeah, so specifically. Yeah, that's land fear and a shamel right there.
- 3:30:07Paren giving a kid a sword huh rm vibes. Parent gives a kid
- 3:30:11a parent made a sword for el nore. Oh oh, like a little
- 3:30:18wooden one, right, yeah, like a little one. Oh yeah right,
- 3:30:22yeah, sure, just a thought. Sure, sure, parent with
- 3:30:26the sword giving why not whose parents are like, maybe you'll learn to use
- 3:30:33it? Yeah, good pick up. That's good. That's good. That's
- 3:30:37good. Matt bringing messages messenger Matt like he does in the books Oh and
- 3:30:43Bok book three, Matt brings messages like more than what or is sent on
- 3:30:48like retrieval or message sending off. Oh yeah. On book six, yeah,
- 3:30:52I just was like, go get a lane, go send this message
- 3:30:56to my mother, Go do this, go do that. It just reminded
- 3:30:58me stuff in the books. I worry about the potential foreshadowing of Parent dying
- 3:31:03twice in the scene, once in the play fight with el Nore and once
- 3:31:07in the fight with the Trolics when the axe hits him. I think that
- 3:31:09that's just the I mean, I think the play fighting was foreshadowing for what
- 3:31:15happened. Yeah, but I was just like, Man, parent dieses like
- 3:31:18a lot of time in the scene, and I was like, Eh,
- 3:31:22I hope that's not foreshadowing. But I have said for a while and I
- 3:31:26worry about parent dying because I don't think every comes back at and so I
- 3:31:35could see a world in which that happens. Matt has a slice across his
- 3:31:41eye. Gus, Uh, does he? It is the second time in
- 3:31:46the Yes, in the scene he has a slice across his eye. He
- 3:31:50had the same slice across his eye in episode one when Matt thought that he
- 3:31:54killed him. I was not really paying attention to that, but I will
- 3:31:56take your word for it, Gus. Yes, he has to lose half
- 3:32:00the light of the world to save the world. He's not going to lose
- 3:32:01an eye. Oh well, I know, go on, you know,
- 3:32:05I don't know. I'm also worried about Land getting killed because we've seen him
- 3:32:09in life threatening wounds with life threatening wounds twice now and Ninive is there to
- 3:32:13fix it. But what happens if she's not there? It's a good question.
- 3:32:18I'm worried about those things. From a book reader perspective who hasn't read
- 3:32:20everything. I don't really have anything else book related to say. Oh,
- 3:32:24we had one more thing to talk about. I thought we skipped something.
- 3:32:30Well, did I like how often they're bringing up I said I can't lie.
- 3:32:35I said I can't lie. I said I can't lie. As a
- 3:32:37reminder, I said, I can lie, but Leandron has lied. But
- 3:32:41that Leandron can lie, oh several times? Now, yeah, the oh
- 3:32:46there's Tarleck's in the north. It's the Flicker test. Oh yeah. This
- 3:32:50is definitely part of a parallel to Flicker Flicker more heavily than Yeah, you
- 3:32:56know, because here's the thing, and obviously I'm not going to talk about
- 3:32:58it anything later. There are a lot of different things in book two that
- 3:33:03are like, here are some visions of a future that could happen. And
- 3:33:05I appreciate that they that elements of Flicker Flicker appear to be incorporated into this,
- 3:33:11which is not to say that they're not incorporated into other things, or
- 3:33:13that we don't have it waffo. Yeah, I mean I definitely think there's
- 3:33:20a world in which things will get moved around a bit, you know,
- 3:33:24almost definitely. Yeah. Yeah, I think we covered I think we I
- 3:33:26mean, our part one was robust as fuck. So I feel content.
- 3:33:33Pour one out for Uno Roberts. You love you. Yeah, all right,
- 3:33:39Well I've got a little bit of full books stuff to talk about,
- 3:33:43not a ton, but a smidge. So Ali, if you don't mind
- 3:33:48stepping out, get the fuck out and I'll uh, I'll do that.
- 3:33:52So, if you ever read the whole Wheel of Time books series, skid
- 3:33:56daddle and unidentified full series has been detected. If you have not read the
- 3:34:03entire Wheel of Time series, this is your signal to disengage. What's up,
- 3:34:11everyone, It's just me today. Bree is under the weather and hopefully
- 3:34:15we'll be feeling better so soon, because it sucks to be sick. Incidentally,
- 3:34:20Consort of Fires out. That's Breez's book that Kit Rocha wrote. It's
- 3:34:24called Consort of Fire. It's also known as Ornie Dragon Book. It's real
- 3:34:28good and you should read it. Available at ebook retailers and some other retailers
- 3:34:33possibly near you. Hey, I don't have a time to talk about,
- 3:34:37but I do want to talk about how the fact that they basically did nine
- 3:34:41E sized eye test outro with her accepted test, where she says to the
- 3:34:48sisters like, fuck your shit, fuck your ring, fuck your tower,
- 3:34:52and fuck your coat of conduct. Fuck that I am who I am,
- 3:34:54fuck you, And I think it's quite interesting that they had to do that
- 3:35:01early. I don't think that that rules out more of that journey with her
- 3:35:05later, but I do think it will be different later if we do get
- 3:35:07the accepted test, the full raising test for ninety's later on. I also
- 3:35:13think we might not get that, because while I love it, there's gonna
- 3:35:16be a lot of shit to cover in the very end of the series.
- 3:35:18But everybody I've watched or talked about this episode with who has watched it in
- 3:35:24proximity to Ali, which is a couple of different people, were like,
- 3:35:26and I had to physically restrain myself from saying, oh wait, this is
- 3:35:30her is the dye test. Oh man, it's fun. That's really all
- 3:35:35I have. So, you know what, thanks for being here, and
- 3:35:39I'll cut it over to the outro. Oh yeah, the only other thing
- 3:35:41I'm gonna say, actually is I had said in the book spoiler section that
- 3:35:46Uno does nothing up until that point a Knife of Dreams. I love that
- 3:35:50Huno's a character from a plot perspective, he does not do anything after book
- 3:35:56two to three. Alas, pour one out. All right. For those
- 3:36:03of you who are still here, Ali's back, Hi, thanks for listening
- 3:36:05everybody. We have social media if you want to know what we have going
- 3:36:09on, it's linked below. We also have a Patreon if you want to
- 3:36:11support us that way, it's it's batreon dot com, slash wheel ficks,
- 3:36:16and you can always leave us a rating and interview, which helps a lot.
- 3:36:20Other than that. Do you want to do We started playing improv games
- 3:36:22and our ballot of song words the Snakes outro, and you really liked and
- 3:36:26I've liked it. Do you want to do that again? We all have
- 3:36:28time themed one? Yeah, okay, we do what's the game call that
- 3:36:30I was figured it's called that we did last time meld? Yeah? Okay,
- 3:36:33yeah, hold on, let me think of one this time okay,
- 3:36:37right, basically, okay, the rules, Yes, we're going to count
- 3:36:41down, We're each going to say a word and then the next time,
- 3:36:43we're going to do it again, and we're going to try to say the
- 3:36:46same word based on the first word we said. So if Ali, for
- 3:36:48instance, said camera and I said, uh, light bulb, then the
- 3:36:56next time we might both try to say flaplash yeah, And so we're trying
- 3:36:58to get to the same word yeah, okay, ready a right three two
- 3:37:03one except test okay great, three one two damn it? What have we
- 3:37:09done? Nine even two rivers, Oh yeah okay three two one wisdom,
- 3:37:13damn it, wisdom and great okay okay, okay, okay three two one
- 3:37:20circle okay three two one eventiation okay okay ready, yeah three two one seat
- 3:37:35raising God, damn it, okay okay, I said I on Olmerland.
- 3:37:37Seat rais okay ready three two one one Yes, Thanks losing everyone, Bye,