Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Ensuring Family Connection: Effective Representation for Parents in Probate Guardianship
Transcript
- 0:03I am Ryan Wedeking, co -chair of Beverly Hill
- 0:05Bar Association's Family Law Section. I am delighted
- 0:09to introduce today's speaker, Natalie Garnica.
- 0:14Natalie Garnica is a staff attorney in the Child
- 0:18Youth and Family Advocacy Project at Public Council.
- 0:22She represents foster youth and low -income parents
- 0:25in family law, contested probate guardianships,
- 0:29DVROs and in other legal issues that threaten
- 0:32to destabilize families and push them towards
- 0:35the door of child welfare. A proud granddaughter
- 0:39of immigrants from, and Natalie, please. Thank
- 0:44you. Natalie is passionate about supporting our
- 0:48immigrant families. She leads community trainings
- 0:51on family preparedness and the unique custody
- 0:53issues facing parents at risk of deportation.
- 0:56She has trained nearly 2 ,000 people on the topic.
- 0:59Natalie is a graduate of UCLA and the Loyola
- 1:04School of Law. Before we get started, I just
- 1:09need to plug our... monthly family law section
- 1:12meeting which is happening today at 4 30 p .m.
- 1:15I will be giving a brief CLE no CLE credit will
- 1:22be given but it's a new thing that we're we're
- 1:25doing it's called a family law tidbit I will
- 1:27be speaking on community estate personal injury
- 1:30damages briefly if anyone is interested so please
- 1:35join our family section meetings we are increasingly
- 1:38trying to do a number of crossover topics that
- 1:43involve other sections, tax issues, entertainment
- 1:46issues, probate issues, certainly. So we welcome
- 1:51any probate attorneys who are interested in joining
- 1:54our family law section meetings as well. So with
- 1:57that, Natalie, I think we have a fantastic, very,
- 2:01very important and interesting topic today on
- 2:03probate guardianships. Please take it away. Thank
- 2:07you so much for that introduction Ryan. I'm gonna
- 2:10go ahead and share my screen now Let's see we
- 2:16go. Okay And I'll go ahead and get it Started
- 2:24okay. Thank you all for Coming today. I'm excited
- 2:29to talk about this area of law that is you know
- 2:36that I'm excited to talk about this today. So
- 2:38as Ryan said, my name is Natalie Gernica. The
- 2:42focus of my practice is the intersection of family
- 2:46probate and dependency and representing parents
- 2:50in contested probate guardianships. It takes
- 2:55up a decent amount of my time. So we'll hopefully
- 2:57have time for questions at the end. And then
- 3:01I also just want to mention that public council
- 3:03was actually founded by a past president of the
- 3:07BHBA back in the 1960s. So it's so fun to be
- 3:10able to present to you all. So we are going to
- 3:14cover a lot of ground today. We are briefly going
- 3:17to go over the guardianship of the person and
- 3:20that and the The focus today is representing
- 3:24parents in contested guardianship cases. I will
- 3:27not be talking about SIDGES cases, conservatorships,
- 3:31or guardianships for youth ages 18 to 21. I hope
- 3:35that by the end of our time together, you'll
- 3:37have learned something new or will have considered
- 3:39probate guardianships from a fresh perspective.
- 3:43So we'll also go through briefly some alternatives
- 3:47to guardianship, the guardianship process, and
- 3:51then some key points for representing parents,
- 3:54objecting to guardianships, terminating them,
- 3:57and getting visitation. California law allows
- 4:03for non -parents to petition the probate court
- 4:05for custody of a minor child when the child's
- 4:09parents are unable or unwilling to care for the
- 4:11child. If a petition for probate guardianship
- 4:16is granted, the parent's right to custody of
- 4:19the child is suspended, though not terminated,
- 4:22while the guardianship is in place. A person
- 4:28might seek a guardianship for a variety of reasons
- 4:31that are all very valid and it's truly in the
- 4:35minor's best interest for the guardianship to
- 4:37be granted. This could also occur when a child
- 4:41immigrates to the United States without their
- 4:43parents and lives with a non -parental caregiver.
- 4:46So again briefly those are just cases. A guardianship
- 4:50might also give the guardian The ability to make
- 4:54really critical to will would give the guardian
- 4:57the ability to make critical caregiving related
- 5:00decisions for a child that maybe they Didn't
- 5:04necessarily want to take custody rights away
- 5:07from the parent But if the parent isn't there
- 5:09and they don't have access to the child's vital
- 5:11records, for example Guardianship might be the
- 5:14only answer. So while guardianship is in place
- 5:18parents lose the ability to make decisions for
- 5:21their child It's distinct from adoption because
- 5:26their rights are suspended during the guardianship,
- 5:28not permanently terminated. And there is still
- 5:32a possibility for parents to regain custody of
- 5:36their child by filing a petition to terminate.
- 5:39But that is, it's very difficult to do. A guardianship
- 5:44appointment lasts until... It is terminated by
- 5:47the court or until the minor turns 18 or is emancipated,
- 5:51adopted, or married. In some cases, as I, you
- 5:55know, it can be obtained for older youth. And
- 5:58really any relative friend or relative or friend
- 6:05of the minor can petition to be their guardian.
- 6:10And actually minors who are 12 years old or older
- 6:13can also file on their own. behalf for a petition
- 6:18for the appointment of guardian. Guardianship
- 6:20of the person does not give a guardian control
- 6:23over a child's property or other assets. So that
- 6:27would be guardianship of the state. And again,
- 6:30this presentation will be just hyper -focused
- 6:32on guardianship of the person. Again, they're
- 6:35really important tools to provide for the care
- 6:38of children in situations where a parent parents
- 6:41have passed away, they're incarcerated, or where
- 6:45they're unable to care for their children for
- 6:47some other reason. And so briefly, the standards
- 6:52for appointment and probate. A California probate
- 6:57court will grant a guardianship if it is necessary
- 7:00or convenient as determined by the best interests
- 7:03of the child. So to assess best interests, it's,
- 7:08you know, the probate code directs probate courts
- 7:11to consider to use the family code for matters
- 7:15relating to custody and visitation and best interests
- 7:18as well is incorporated. And so the court is
- 7:21going to look at the child's health, safety and
- 7:24welfare, any history of abuse by one parent.
- 7:27or against the other or towards a child, the
- 7:31nature and amount of contact with both parents
- 7:34and their any history of drug abuse or continued
- 7:38alcohol abuse by a parent. And so the guardianship
- 7:44may be necessary or convenient because we don't
- 7:47want a child to be left without any provision
- 7:49for support and we want children that's in the
- 7:53best interest of children to be cared for. And
- 7:55so You know and then the burden of proof Assuming
- 8:00that there is no parent who objects is just a
- 8:04preponderance of the evidence that it is Necessary
- 8:08or convenient and in the best interest of the
- 8:10child for the guardianship to be granted So I
- 8:15mentioned it briefly earlier, but really anyone
- 8:18over 18 can petition or be nominated to be a
- 8:22child's guardian. There will be a background
- 8:24check, but it is not, depending on whether the
- 8:29family member is a relative or not, that background
- 8:33check is typically like a live scan and then
- 8:37an interview with a probate investigator, which
- 8:39we'll get into later. Legal status is not relevant
- 8:45to whether someone can apply to be a guardian
- 8:48although for families who are looking into guardianship
- 8:51and are concerned about Caring for their children
- 8:54if if they're facing Deportation we do recommend
- 8:58that you know folks talk about You know different
- 9:04options in case there is a if there is a real
- 9:07risk that their proposed guardian also would
- 9:09be deported So in any other requirements, guardians
- 9:14must fulfill their duties once they're appointed
- 9:17or their guardianship could be terminated for
- 9:20failure to fulfill those duties. We do have a
- 9:24full training on the details of the guardianship
- 9:28process because we're doing just a lightning
- 9:30speed overview of the actual guardianship process
- 9:35in this training. And that is more specific for
- 9:39caregivers who want to become guardians. And
- 9:42again, this is really focused on parents who
- 9:45would be opposing a guardianship. Briefly, I'll
- 9:50talk about joint guardianship and AB 495 because
- 9:55this is a new area of guardianship law that we're
- 9:58hopeful will be a really great tool for parents
- 10:01and guardians. So it was signed into law this
- 10:03year and is effective as of January 1st, 2026.
- 10:08And the major impact from AB 495 was an expansion
- 10:11of joint guardianship. So joint guardianship
- 10:14has existed and it under probate code 2105 f
- 10:21where a parent and a non -parent share custody
- 10:24with either having the ability to make decisions
- 10:26for the child but it is only applicable if the
- 10:30parent is terminally ill and that is defined
- 10:33as having an incurable and irreversible condition
- 10:37that results in death without life sustaining
- 10:40treatment and or life support and so in So that
- 10:45was really restricted. So what we, you know,
- 10:50we are hopeful that AB -495, which created probate
- 10:54code 2105G, it will allow for similar joint guardianship,
- 10:59but not just for terminally ill parents, also
- 11:02for parents who would be temporarily unavailable
- 11:05due to immigration, incarceration, military service,
- 11:09illness, or some other short -term absence. We
- 11:13hope that this creates, you know, gives parents
- 11:17an option of creating guardianship without really
- 11:21risking losing their custody for the long term.
- 11:24And it's so new that we don't really have an
- 11:28idea of how it's going to work in practice, but,
- 11:31you know, we're hoping to get a better sense
- 11:34of this over the coming year. So in another At
- 11:42another bird's -eye view that's really important
- 11:45for the rest of the presentation is that probate
- 11:48guardianship and guardianships probate and dependency
- 11:51are not the same Even though guardianships can
- 11:55also come out of dependency court They're really
- 12:00not going to be in the same They're there with
- 12:05if they have completely different goals and so
- 12:09In dependency or foster care, your local child
- 12:13protective services has investigated a parent,
- 12:17filed a petition against the parent under Welfare
- 12:20and Institutions Code 300, alleging that the
- 12:23parent has abused or neglected their child, and
- 12:26possibly removed the child from the parent's
- 12:28care. In probate proceedings, the government
- 12:31has not taken formal action and instead a private
- 12:35citizen is alleging that the parent is unable
- 12:37to care for their child. So, in dependency, we
- 12:42have a goal that is focused on making the parent
- 12:46making reasonable efforts to address the reason
- 12:49that the child was removed from the parent and
- 12:52to help the family reunify. There are services
- 12:55and timelines that the parent must meet and that
- 12:58is the goal of a dependency court case. So and
- 13:04in and in dependency, both parents and children
- 13:07have court appointed counsel and there's that
- 13:10plan of services. In probate, the goal of the
- 13:14proceeding is to make a custody order that is
- 13:17in the child's best interest and the court explicitly
- 13:20may not order reunification services. The court
- 13:24might appoint counsel for the child, but they
- 13:27don't in every case and the parent must retain
- 13:30counsel independently at their own expense. So
- 13:33in what we see at public council is that this
- 13:36results in indigent parents losing the right
- 13:39to care for their children because they don't
- 13:41have access to council or the ability to put
- 13:43a case on that shows it is in their child's best
- 13:46interest to remain in their custody. And so because
- 13:51of this. important difference and the fact that
- 13:55probate guardianship sort of stands apart and
- 13:57that it does not have, you know, it's a very
- 14:00similar end result and that a parent's rights
- 14:03are, even though it's suspended, they're suspended
- 14:06for so long and so permanently that it is very
- 14:12close to a termination. But unlike dependency,
- 14:17there is a completely different reunification
- 14:20is not a goal. And so This can create a risk
- 14:23of children entering what is known as hidden
- 14:27foster care. And it's essentially when child
- 14:32welfare agencies, either state, tribal, or county
- 14:36pressure parents into giving primary care and
- 14:39responsibility of their child to others, usually
- 14:42relatives, for I think reasons that folks, you
- 14:48know, feel is really helpful to the family a
- 14:51lot of times they're saying you know that this
- 14:55is much better appropriate guardianship you have
- 14:57so much more control over who becomes the guardian
- 15:00you keep your child out of the system and they
- 15:04often suggest it will be you know more advantageous
- 15:08to enter appropriate guardianship rather than
- 15:10the system and for some parents you know who
- 15:15really have very little chance of being able
- 15:19to satisfy the reunification requirements, that
- 15:25very well may be the case. But there are a couple
- 15:28big issues with this. One is that when families
- 15:32who maybe would otherwise enter dependency instead
- 15:35enter probate, there are no there is there's
- 15:39not any way to track those separations. So there
- 15:42are no we don't have numbers on how many families
- 15:44are separated outside of the court system. And
- 15:48without that data, we can't assess and improve
- 15:50avenues for ensuring child welfare. And then,
- 15:54you know, a second huge concern is the lack of
- 15:56due process. In dependency cases, as I said,
- 15:59they there is at least a goal of reunification.
- 16:03So even if a parent fails to complete the services
- 16:07and ultimately doesn't reunify with their child,
- 16:10they were provided with an attorney, given a
- 16:12list of services and given many opportunities
- 16:15to address those concerns. And in probate, you
- 16:19know, that just doesn't exist. And so, you know,
- 16:23we at public council care very much about child
- 16:26welfare and ensuring that families have the support
- 16:29they need to stay together whenever that is possible.
- 16:33And so we just want to bring this to light because
- 16:38it's really important for folks to understand
- 16:41that it is not as simple as, you know, probate
- 16:46guardianship is, you know, as dependency court
- 16:49always, you know, having such a negative connotation
- 16:52to it. And certainly, there are ways that can
- 16:54be improved, but there are also some really strong
- 16:57procedural protections for parents that just
- 16:59don't exist in guardianship, in probate guardianship.
- 17:04So Briefly, we'll talk about some alternatives
- 17:08to guardianship because that's a question that
- 17:10we get all the time. Well, if my child isn't
- 17:13in a guardianship and I can't care for them right
- 17:16now, what are the other options? And so informal
- 17:20caregiving is completely fine for many families.
- 17:25And in California, you do not need to have custody
- 17:28of a child. for someone to care for that child.
- 17:32If a parent isn't available, a child can live
- 17:35with someone else for extended periods of time
- 17:38if the parent agrees and that person's able to
- 17:41make basic decisions about a child's care. And
- 17:45so we see this. frequently and we encourage families
- 17:52who are at risk of deportation, for example,
- 17:54to make plans for who will care for their children
- 17:58if they are detained, for example. And if you
- 18:02are detained, you don't know whether or not you
- 18:06are going to be released back. Into the United
- 18:10States or whether or not you'll be deported and
- 18:12we don't want folks entering into premature Guardianships
- 18:15which are so permanent and in other circumstances
- 18:18Informal caregiving can be a really helpful tool.
- 18:23So We're gonna you know, I have a brief example
- 18:28So for you know, Elena is living in LA County
- 18:32with her three children. Her sister lives around
- 18:35the block and in July Elena calls Anita and says
- 18:40that she and her kids are in a DV shelter and
- 18:42it's not an environment that she wants to keep
- 18:45her children in. She has the opportunity to move
- 18:47to Las Vegas or it could be you know anywhere
- 18:50and a friend's offered to let her stay on the
- 18:53couch while she looks for work. There isn't enough
- 18:55room for the kids. Can Anita care for them over
- 18:58the summer while she gets settled? Sister agrees.
- 19:02So a lot of times folks would think well if she's
- 19:05caring for the kids she needs to be their guardian,
- 19:08but if And I'm sorry There's a typo here if Elena
- 19:12wants to take her children back anytime soon
- 19:15if she is planning on kind of no matter what
- 19:19happens them living together again in the near
- 19:21future a Guardianship would really get in the
- 19:24way of that and there are other tools that could
- 19:27be really helpful. So One of the primary tool
- 19:31is a caregiver affidavit and a caregivers authorization
- 19:36affidavit is created by family code section 6550
- 19:42and it allows most relative caregivers to enroll
- 19:46kids in school, make the same medical decisions
- 19:50as guardians for a child who is residing with
- 19:53them. It's not required but it can be helpful
- 19:56if applying for CalWORKs. And so the main thing
- 20:01is if and we see clients in these situations
- 20:04all the time, you know, especially, you know,
- 20:07homelessness is something that really pushes
- 20:09a person to like even though they would never
- 20:14want to be separated from their children, find
- 20:16somewhere that is safe for their child to live
- 20:20with the intention of reuniting once a parent
- 20:23gets back on their feet. And so a caregiver authorization
- 20:28affidavit can be really helpful in situations
- 20:30like this. And it can allow, you know, Allow
- 20:37the caregiver the authority that they need to
- 20:40do the basic things for a child But also once
- 20:44the parent is ready You know, their custody rights
- 20:47are not suspended And so there are some limitations
- 20:53I won't get to into the weeds on the limitations
- 20:57right now, but essentially those limitations
- 21:01are actually really helpful because it means
- 21:03that there is space for the parent to come and
- 21:07to be doing those things. So the parent should
- 21:10still be the one enrolling the child in daycare
- 21:13or preschool and getting vital documents. Those
- 21:16limitations are actually protective for parents.
- 21:20And then in a situation, kind of like the example
- 21:24I had described, when a parent is ready to pick
- 21:27up their child from an informal caregiving arrangement,
- 21:32parents should act on that readiness as soon
- 21:37as possible because, and that would be letting
- 21:41the caregiver know that they plan to pick up
- 21:43the child, actually showing up to pick up the
- 21:47child, documenting. all of their efforts. And
- 21:50then if the caregiver is really not releasing
- 21:52the child, consider getting law enforcement involved
- 21:55and bringing, you know, in LA, that would be
- 22:00calling the standby line, having certified copies
- 22:03of any court order showing they have custody
- 22:06of the child, the birth certificate, and getting
- 22:09support and facilitating that transfer. Because
- 22:13if the situation occurs where a parent is ready
- 22:18to pick up their child and the caregiver is resisting,
- 22:22that is a very clear sign that the caregiver
- 22:26will likely file for guardianship. And so even
- 22:32if the parent isn't successful in ultimately
- 22:35picking up their child. These efforts to try
- 22:38and pick up the child are extremely important
- 22:41for future objections and will be important down
- 22:44the line in an eventual guardianship case. Which
- 22:50brings us to guardianship. So we're going to
- 22:55talk about the life cycle of a pearl bait guardianship
- 22:59at the sort of bird's eye level. And things can
- 23:02move quite quickly so From the time a petition
- 23:06is filed if the caregiver is also requesting
- 23:10a temporary guardianship That is set for 10 to
- 23:1412 days after the filing and in most cases There
- 23:17are no orders between the filing and the temporary
- 23:19so in the really rare circumstance where a parent
- 23:23wants to pick up their kid and the guardian has
- 23:26filed only for permanent guardianship or the
- 23:31parent knows about the hearing on the temporary
- 23:33but it hasn't been issued. If the parent can
- 23:36get their child back in that time that is really
- 23:39important. Notice is required for the temporary
- 23:43guardianship hearing and then you know after
- 23:47the temporary guardianship hearing occurs there
- 23:50will be an investigation. And that report is
- 23:54typically published just three days before the
- 23:57formal appointment hearing. And we can see these
- 24:00things being pushed out a few times if there
- 24:03are delays in getting the investigation wrapped
- 24:05up. Then there is an appointment hearing, and
- 24:09that is where the court will decide whether or
- 24:11not to grant a permanent guardianship. And then
- 24:15finally, there is a trial, just a trial, not
- 24:19a trial Z. And so that is if the parent asks
- 24:24for a trial. A lot of times these do not go to
- 24:26trial. Parents don't know that they can ask.
- 24:28Sometimes it doesn't make sense to ask for a
- 24:31trial, but it is something that we have, you
- 24:35know, helped parents through in the past. And
- 24:39in some cases, you know, there might be an additional
- 24:43hearing in here. Like if, for example, an ex,
- 24:47you know, in some cases a parent might consider
- 24:49filing an ex parte. But that's pretty rare. It's
- 24:54so rare that the that an ex parte hearing would
- 24:56be granted. A lot of times that issue will just
- 24:58be folded into whatever the next hearing is.
- 25:02So I'm going to talk about temporary guardianship
- 25:07and how it is a bit of a misnomer and it can
- 25:09really get folks turned around, both caregivers
- 25:13and parents. So a temporary guardianship is temporary.
- 25:20Only and that it lasts from the date it is granted
- 25:24until the petition for permanent guardianship
- 25:27is granted or denied it is not temporary and
- 25:31that it can exist outside of a of a petition
- 25:37for permanent guardianship a caregiver in California
- 25:42cannot request the standalone temporary and because
- 25:47but because it's called a temporary honestly
- 25:49people think that it can exist outside of that
- 25:52and that once they have a temporary guardianship
- 25:55that it is going to end at some point or parents
- 25:59might hear oh that's a temporary guardian and
- 26:01they think that it can end for example when they
- 26:04get their own house or at some condition but
- 26:06that is just not the case it is I would say it's
- 26:11much more akin to an emergency guardianship because
- 26:14it's issued when a caregiver needs legal guardianship
- 26:17immediately and cannot wait until the hearing
- 26:19on the permanent. If it's issued, the temporary
- 26:24guardianship will be in effect pending the final
- 26:26determination. And so it is really important
- 26:30that if a parent opposes the guardianship generally,
- 26:34that they also appear and oppose a temporary
- 26:37guardianship as well. So both the temporary guardianship
- 26:45and the permanent appointment, uh, hearing for
- 26:48the permanent guardianship have specific notice
- 26:50requirements. Um, I'll just zoom backwards. So
- 26:54as, as we said, at least five days prior to the
- 26:57hearing, unless you get a waiver of notice for
- 26:59the temporary guardianship and then on the permanent,
- 27:03um, it can be, it's a little bit more difficult
- 27:06and I think it's much more rare to waive notice
- 27:09on the hearing for the permanent. but that's
- 27:12personal service at least 15 days prior to the
- 27:15hearing. And this is important in representing
- 27:17parents because we find that in practice, it
- 27:20is extremely common for potential guardians to
- 27:24inform the court at the temporary stage that
- 27:27they don't know how to contact the child's parent.
- 27:29even if they and the child's parent have been
- 27:31in touch very recently. It varies greatly between
- 27:35judicial officers, whether or not that is sufficient
- 27:38basis to form, to grant a good cause exception.
- 27:43And a lot of times if parents are not, if they
- 27:46don't know about the temporary hearing, they
- 27:47don't know what is being said at the hearing
- 27:50about why they can't get in touch. And so, A
- 27:54lot of times cases involving parents who want
- 27:57to contest the guardianship, the temporary has
- 28:00already been granted and that is done. Notice
- 28:04on the hearing for permanent guardianship is
- 28:07not only required for parents, but also all relatives
- 28:12within the second degree and anyone with a valid
- 28:15visitation order or any other party. and again
- 28:19if the party can't be found petitioner has to
- 28:22submit a declaration of due diligence and that
- 28:24level varies in practice so parents will sometimes
- 28:28review that declaration of due diligence and
- 28:31say hey like you did have my phone number you
- 28:34did know we were texting you know few days before
- 28:37and you know in some cases we have found that
- 28:41there is you know it might be worth it to try
- 28:44and to file you know we've like an ex parte and
- 28:47this is in the manual um that is part of your
- 28:50materials an ex parte request to vacate the temporary
- 28:54guardianship for lack of notice. I honestly the
- 28:58chances of that actually happening are quite
- 29:01slim, but it could be an opportunity to put the
- 29:03court on notice as to whether if there are really
- 29:06strong facts to show that the guardianship was
- 29:08not being that the guardian was not being truthful
- 29:11in their ability to contact the parent. So after.
- 29:19After the hearing on the temporary guardianship,
- 29:22there will be an investigation. And this investigation
- 29:26is generally, if it is a relative requesting
- 29:32the guardianship, then it will be conducted by
- 29:35the probate court investigator. If it is a non
- 29:38-relative, the investigation will be completed
- 29:41by, in LA County, a DCFS social worker. And it's
- 29:46going to have the report is going to have some
- 29:48minimal, some minimum subjects that it covers
- 29:52the history of the proposed guardian, how they
- 29:54came in, you know, how they came to have the
- 29:57child in their care, their concerns and recommendations
- 30:01and assessment of the guardianship need. It is
- 30:04really crucial for the objecting parent to One,
- 30:08know about the investigation and contact the
- 30:11investigator and ask to be interviewed and make
- 30:13themselves available for an interview. If a parent
- 30:17hasn't yet filed an objection, the probate investigator
- 30:21only has the information that was provided in
- 30:24the guardianship in the petition. And so. It
- 30:29can be really critical for the parent to be able
- 30:32to tell their side of the story to the investigator
- 30:35and make it clear that this is not so cut and
- 30:39dry of a case and to provide especially positive
- 30:43facts about the parent's bond with their child
- 30:47and how they are able to care for the child and
- 30:50why it's not necessary or convenient for this
- 30:53guardianship to be granted. quirk of this investigation
- 30:59is if you are representing a parent in a probate
- 31:03guardianship proceeding, only minors council
- 31:06and the court get online access to the report.
- 31:09It will populate in the portal, but you still
- 31:12have to go in person and request it. pretty much
- 31:18every time and it will be available at the last
- 31:21minute essentially before the hearing. And this
- 31:24is because the report is very confidential and
- 31:27they want to make sure that only authorized parties
- 31:31are able to access it. But there is a weird quirk
- 31:35of being a parent's attorney in these. So the
- 31:41objecting to the guardianship. So your client
- 31:45has found out about this guardianship they intend
- 31:47to oppose it and hopefully they found out about
- 31:51it before the investigation has occurred and
- 31:53before ideally even before the temporary guardianship
- 31:57has been granted um but a lot of times that isn't
- 32:01necessary like that may not line up that way
- 32:04the process for a Formally objecting to the guardianship
- 32:09is to file a written objection. So there is a
- 32:12new ish form form GC 215 But we always recommend
- 32:19attaching a strong supporting declaration and
- 32:22points and authorities to also really beef up
- 32:27that objection and It's important for the parent
- 32:32in their declaration to not only lay out their
- 32:38bond with their child, the relationship with
- 32:40the child, to tell their side of the story as
- 32:43to how the child came to be in the guardian's
- 32:46care, but also to address any allegations within
- 32:51the petition. at the hearing, you know, sometimes
- 32:57it works out where you're able to get the written
- 33:00objection filed before you appear at that first
- 33:03hearing. Sometimes the timing doesn't and you
- 33:06end up having to appear and orally state the
- 33:09objection. You still need to file the written
- 33:11objection. It's really important. And parents,
- 33:18again, like those allegations that are made against
- 33:20the parent carry a really heavy weight because
- 33:24The child is with this other person for some
- 33:28reason and so Again, because reunification is
- 33:32not a goal in guardianship proceedings and is
- 33:36best interest of the child, the court is really
- 33:39going to be hesitant to disturb the status quo
- 33:42in order that the child be removed from, for
- 33:45example, the temporary guardianship's care. So
- 33:47it's really important for the parent to lay out
- 33:51all of their strongest facts because really in
- 33:54your objection, you're stating your reasons for
- 33:56why the guardianship should not be granted, but
- 33:58you're also hopeful. laying a strong, laying
- 34:03strong groundwork for asking for visits and for
- 34:07a petition for visitation. And yeah, it's really,
- 34:12I find it really important to frequently check
- 34:18in with clients and set expectations about where
- 34:22this is going to go because as you know, we'll
- 34:26discuss a little bit, it's. very difficult to
- 34:31prevent a guardianship from being issued and
- 34:33also even more difficult to terminate one. And
- 34:36so parents need to be aware of how permanent
- 34:39a guardianship is once issued and how long it
- 34:44might be until they are able to establish visits
- 34:48with their kid or even, you know, and really
- 34:51face the possibility they may never have custody
- 34:53of their child again. But if they are able to
- 34:58prevent the issuance of a temporary guardianship,
- 35:01that is really going to hugely change the odds
- 35:06for them. And so in a contested guardianship,
- 35:13so earlier we talked about the burden of proof
- 35:16for a guardianship just sort of at baseline being
- 35:19preponderance of the evidence showing that it's
- 35:23necessary or convenient and in the child's best
- 35:25interest. but if a parent objects family code
- 35:29section 3041 applies and this code section is
- 35:33not the um it is it is a beast of a section and
- 35:39I'm going to summarize it and then you'll see
- 35:42even the judicial council has a flowchart for
- 35:45the judges to apply when parents object. So with
- 35:49a parent objects, the burden is on the petitioner,
- 35:53so the proposed guardian, to establish by clear
- 35:55and convincing evidence that parental custody
- 35:58would be detrimental and the guardianship is
- 36:02required to serve the best interests of the child.
- 36:05at you know reading those first two subsections
- 36:09that seems like quite a high burden, a high hurdle
- 36:13for the petitioner to clear and it seems to be
- 36:17very consistent with over you know the fundamental
- 36:20right of the parent and child to be together.
- 36:23But it's incredibly important to note that detriment
- 36:27includes the harm of removal from a caregiver
- 36:30who has been acting as a de facto parent. And
- 36:34so this detriment can be shown by and de facto
- 36:42parent status can be established by showing for
- 36:44how long the caregiver was caring for the child.
- 36:48And if the caregiver can establish that they
- 36:51are the de facto parent, then the burden shifts
- 36:55back to the parent. And the parent is then going
- 36:59to have to essentially prove they are going to
- 37:02have to prove that Returning the child to their
- 37:05care to parental custody is not detrimental and
- 37:09that it is not in the best interest of the child
- 37:11for the guardianship to be granted and then that
- 37:15and that is done by a preponderance of the evidence
- 37:17standard so They can get you know, it's easy
- 37:21to get turned around You can see this decision
- 37:23tree and again it applies to non -equal cases.
- 37:26That's another little asterisk We're not talking
- 37:28about equal cases in this presentation But here,
- 37:34this is why, you know, in the objection in any
- 37:37of the filings, it is so clear and in talking
- 37:40with clients, it's really vital to get an understanding
- 37:43of exactly when the guardian began caring for
- 37:47the child and sometimes even weighing out well,
- 37:50how long if a child is four years old, have they
- 37:53been living with the guardian for more than half
- 37:56their life? Like that could be really something
- 37:58that would change the calculus of a case and
- 38:02what a parent's efforts would be best spent fighting
- 38:06for. And, you know, I think that the other thing
- 38:11is there is a lot. It's tricky here because we
- 38:16don't have the the guardrails essentially of
- 38:21dependency court and dependency court. You can.
- 38:26You can still get de facto parent status, but
- 38:31the goal is reunification. There's an understanding
- 38:35that parental custody is really important and
- 38:39vital for even imperfect parents who have had
- 38:44substantiated allegations of abuse or neglect.
- 38:48The court still sees that it is ideally if they
- 38:53can satisfy and meet the the re the different
- 38:58steps that they need in their case plan to reunify
- 39:01with their child and that is in the best interest
- 39:03of the child but that is not here present in
- 39:05guardianship probate guardianship and so you
- 39:08can get it's very common to get cases and in
- 39:12our line of work where um maybe the parent has
- 39:15never been accused of abuse or neglect there
- 39:19is no substantiated finding um really poverty
- 39:22and conflict between the guardian and the parent
- 39:26are at the heart of the issues and that parent
- 39:30has a worse chance in probate guardianship of
- 39:33reuniting with their child than they would in
- 39:36dependency court. So gathering evidence and evaluating
- 39:42a case for a parent, it's the most helpful thing
- 39:46is going to be the really having a significant
- 39:50time period that the parent and child live together
- 39:53and that the parent was the primary caregiver
- 39:56for the child. That evidence is going, you know,
- 40:00to look like, and how do you prove that other
- 40:03than, you know, the parents' memories? You can
- 40:07have, you know, pictures, evidence of who's enrolling
- 40:10the child in school, who's taking the child to
- 40:12the doctor, arranging for childcare, paying for
- 40:16childcare. those things while the parent and
- 40:19child live together and also while they lived
- 40:21apart are really important. And it's, you know,
- 40:25frequent, well -documented visits while the parent
- 40:28and child were not living together would also
- 40:31be strong evidence for a case. Factors that can
- 40:35really hurt a parent's case, any period of time
- 40:39without contact. Sometimes, you know, parents
- 40:44are going the parents in these cases are here
- 40:49for some kind of reason. Either they decided
- 40:55it was best for the child to live with a cousin
- 40:57while they were navigating homelessness, or they
- 41:01you know, are survivors of domestic violence
- 41:04and made arrangements for their child to live
- 41:07with someone else because they didn't want the
- 41:10child to experience living in a shelter. And
- 41:12frequently in my cases, I have my clients are
- 41:16often former foster youth who often just do not
- 41:20have the framework from which they know what
- 41:24is normal. or what is a healthy boundary to have
- 41:31with a family member who is offering to help
- 41:33them with their child. And so it's surprising.
- 41:39The periods of time without contact can be super
- 41:41harmful to a case. Failure to be the one making
- 41:44the medical appointments, enrolling a child in
- 41:46school, any history of abuse, instability, which
- 41:50can be homelessness, which can be moving homes.
- 41:55having frequent relationships that are bringing
- 41:59instability into the home. All of these things
- 42:02could hurt a parent's case, even though parental
- 42:05unfitness is not required to grant a guardianship.
- 42:08But it's inevitable that the proposed guardian
- 42:11is going to be bringing these things up and the
- 42:13court is going to look at it quite closely. it
- 42:20can be incredibly difficult to settle these cases.
- 42:25Unless, you know, it'll be interesting to see
- 42:27how joint guardianship impacts, impacts these
- 42:31cases, but caregivers and parents cannot share
- 42:34custody permanently. And by the time it gets
- 42:36to this stage, the relationship between the parent
- 42:39and the guardian has likely deteriorated quite
- 42:41a bit. And so it can be, incredibly hard to settle
- 42:46and it's important for parents to know that they
- 42:50do have the right to go to trial about whether
- 42:54or not their child will be placed in a guardianship.
- 42:57Whether or not they have a good chance of success
- 43:00goes back to that kind of evidence and sometimes
- 43:05these cases can move at a speed where it just
- 43:10doesn't make sense to go to trial. Sometimes
- 43:13a parent has not seen their child for quite some
- 43:17time and the visit orders that you get, which
- 43:19we'll talk about, are really minimal, it is going
- 43:23to be highly unlikely to win it. at a trial if
- 43:27you have just Saturday afternoons with your kid.
- 43:32But in other cases, where parents have frequent
- 43:36overnight visits, where they've addressed the
- 43:40concerns in the petitioner's allegation, it could
- 43:42very well be worth it to go to trial. And those
- 43:45will be at 1 .30 p .m. and span across several
- 43:49afternoons. at the end, you know, there is an
- 43:55opportunity to make a closing statement. And
- 43:56then especially because these cases, if they
- 44:00get to trial are so fact specific, it's generally
- 44:04a good idea to request for a specific statement,
- 44:08request a statement of decision. So visitation
- 44:13is a really incredibly helpful tool in these
- 44:18cases. And sometimes it is best that a parent
- 44:22focus their efforts on visitation. As I said,
- 44:25they're not going to have a strong case if they
- 44:28do not have regular visits with their kid. And
- 44:31so in another here, in this example, Anita has
- 44:35overnight visits with her children from after
- 44:38school on Fridays to 5pm on Saturday. So great
- 44:41that it's overnight, not great that it's only
- 44:43one day a week. Excuse me. Her sister starts
- 44:48to cancel visitation. First saying the children
- 44:51are sick the day of the visit. Then she begins
- 44:54to reschedule the visits or shorten them. And
- 44:56then it escalates to several visits being canceled.
- 44:59So what can Anita do to enforce visits? And here
- 45:04I think it's important to think of a few things.
- 45:07One, are these just informal visits? Because
- 45:11while even in a temporary guardianship, visitation
- 45:15is at first at the discretion of the guardian.
- 45:18So a lot of times we have there are situations
- 45:21where the relationship is cordial enough to that.
- 45:25the guardian is allowing regular visits but there
- 45:28is no court order. So if there is no court order
- 45:31then seeking an order would be a first step.
- 45:34If there already is an order then Anita needs
- 45:37to bring the cancellations to the attention of
- 45:40the court and be very careful about how she is
- 45:43documenting and trying to go on visits. It is
- 45:48so important for clients to understand where
- 45:53their starting position and that, yes, they are
- 45:56their child's parent, but in a lot of cases,
- 45:58they are going to be starting out with just daytime
- 46:02visits. And they're going to have to be okay
- 46:05with that and show the court the benefit of increasing
- 46:09visits. That means being at 100%, you know, on
- 46:13time, making it to the visits. and so that they
- 46:17can justify asking for more. And once you can
- 46:22get visits in, whether they're informal or not,
- 46:26dealing with cancellations can be really tricky
- 46:28for clients as well, because sometimes they don't
- 46:32follow through on the visit, even though... I
- 46:35frequently tell clients like the guardian, it
- 46:38needs to be crystal clear that the guardian is
- 46:40the one canceling the visit and that you are
- 46:42not, it is not a joint decision or that you are
- 46:45just not following through. So when you, the
- 46:53way to formally request visitation is to file
- 46:56a petition for visitation. These are, there is
- 47:01no court form. It is a pleading and we have a
- 47:05sample in the manual that is part of your materials.
- 47:09Um, and it also should be, it should include
- 47:12a supporting declaration from the parents. Um,
- 47:16parents, yeah, they might have to start all the,
- 47:18like the, depending on the allegations and the
- 47:20petition, it's, it could be true that they start
- 47:23with supervised visits. Hopefully though, um,
- 47:26you can get Daytime visits to start and then
- 47:31ask for a return date to continue Increasing
- 47:34visitation and step up further. There are some
- 47:37judges I think that are really open to that and
- 47:41it can be really helpful to essentially continue
- 47:45getting more visits until you and and Essentially
- 47:49you go into trial with your client having, you
- 47:53know first third and fifth weekends and And then
- 47:57it's like, well, if the parent is able to have
- 48:00their child on these week, substantial weekend
- 48:03overnights, you know, it becomes harder to say
- 48:06that it's necessary and convenient for the guardianship
- 48:09to be granted. Because at the end of the day,
- 48:12California does have a preference for parental
- 48:15custody. And so this brings us to terminating
- 48:22a guardianship. If a guardianship has been ordered,
- 48:30again, it is tough to terminate these. Parents,
- 48:34it's essential that they reestablish or maintain
- 48:37contact with their child. If they don't have
- 48:41a visit order already, getting visits consistently
- 48:44and visiting under any conditions that the guardian
- 48:47allows, it can be really difficult to parents.
- 48:50for parents to realize that they are in the backseat
- 48:53and they don't get to choose where the visits
- 48:57take place for how long they are but it is just
- 48:59vital that the parent demonstrate to the court
- 49:02over and over again that their child is their
- 49:04number one priority and they will do whatever
- 49:06it takes to see their child. In a termination
- 49:11the parent is going to be examined very closely
- 49:15and again any allegations that were you know
- 49:21unresolved need to be resolved. And so if this
- 49:24is a case where the parent objected to the guardianship
- 49:28and lost, they are not going to be able to turn
- 49:32around and file a termination, a request to terminate
- 49:35it. And that's a frequent question, you know,
- 49:38that people have is there's this guardianship,
- 49:40you know, they come and they already have a guardianship
- 49:42granted. What can I do? It's like, well, there's
- 49:44a lot to do before you get to the termination
- 49:48stage. um and once you have plenty of evidence
- 49:55to show you've addressed all of those concerns
- 49:57and that there's contact with the child on a
- 50:00regular basis then you can file a petition to
- 50:03terminate termination is you have to show it's
- 50:06in the child's best interest and it's her parents
- 50:10burden to prove even if you're successful the
- 50:13former guardian may be allowed visits um and
- 50:16those visits visit order could be in effect until
- 50:19the children turn 18. And there is probate code
- 50:231611, which is designed to prevent really, you
- 50:27know, folks who are in denial that this guardianship
- 50:31is, is happening and it's going to be in place,
- 50:34you know, it is, it imposes penalties for parents,
- 50:40for litigants who continue to file meritless
- 50:43petitions to terminate. And so It can be, getting
- 50:48to the termination stage can be quite difficult,
- 50:51but it is possible. And that brings us to the
- 50:55end of our presentation. So we have a few minutes
- 50:59left for questions. I know that covered a lot
- 51:02of ground, but I hope that it brought in a fresh
- 51:06perspective for folks who maybe haven't seen
- 51:08these cases from a parent's perspective before.
- 51:15I'll go ahead and I think I can see the I'll
- 51:19check the Q &A I see Okay, so yeah, we talked
- 51:27briefly about the burden of proof of if a parent
- 51:29objects it gets quite Shifts back and forth depending
- 51:35on whether or not they can establish the guard
- 51:38whether or not the caregiver can establish that
- 51:39they're a de facto parent and so I really appreciate
- 51:46everyone's attention and You know, I am happy
- 51:50to I also just want to plug that public council
- 51:53does have a guardianship clinic we operate out
- 51:57of Stanley mosque and that is you know, they're
- 52:01public council serves thousands of litigants
- 52:04in preparing petitions or objections petitions
- 52:08of terminate all kinds of things and then The
- 52:12sub project that I'm a part of at Public Council,
- 52:15the Families Belong Together project, we do advise
- 52:21parents who are former foster youth and take
- 52:28some cases and represent them in contested guardianship
- 52:31proceedings. And then we also work with families
- 52:34who are sort of at the intersection of dependency
- 52:37and maybe are wondering whether or not they should
- 52:41consent to a guardianship. So yeah, I see that
- 52:47we have definitely we have clients who are considering
- 52:53how to plan for their family if because they're
- 52:56at risk of deportation. So we have support for
- 52:59those clients as well. Thank you all so much.
- 53:03Thank you, Natalie. It looks like we just have
- 53:05one question through our email service, if I
- 53:07could read that to you. It's regarding contested
- 53:10guardianships. In your experience, what facts
- 53:13most persuasively establish or defeat a finding
- 53:15of detriment? Ooh, so the detriment is going
- 53:21to be which facts most persuasively defeat a
- 53:24finding of detriment. I don't know if that's
- 53:28in the chat. I think that That one of the things
- 53:33that a parent can show is That consistent involvement
- 53:38in the child's life. I think that it's going
- 53:40to be much more difficult for a for the court
- 53:45and in and in the cases where we've had You know
- 53:52this the parents continued push and involvement
- 53:54through visitation in their child's life can
- 53:58really show that it is not detrimental for the
- 54:01child to be returned to their care. I think that
- 54:04especially if you have a situation where the
- 54:08potential guardian is not following the visit
- 54:12orders that might be in place during the pendency,
- 54:14that can really... that can really work to a
- 54:17parent's advantage. It's super painful for the
- 54:20parent while it's happening, but if they are
- 54:22following up on visits and the potential guardian
- 54:26is the or the temporary guardian is canceling
- 54:28the visits without cause, that can be one of
- 54:31the most persuasive things to show to also show
- 54:36the court that this potential guardian may not
- 54:38follow court orders, which is an essential duty
- 54:40of a guardian. So I would say time with the child
- 54:43in terms of really having Ideally, being able
- 54:47to show that the separation between parent and
- 54:50child was very brief, that even when they were
- 54:53separated, the parent stayed in touch, that the
- 54:56parent was still taking the lead on all of the
- 54:59care for the child. And then during the pendency
- 55:04of the case, really getting robust visitation
- 55:07so that it's not a big transition for the child.
- 55:10Because again, best interest. the court is not
- 55:13going to want to shock a child and move a child
- 55:17from the guardians home to the parents home without
- 55:20a ramp up. And so it can be very difficult, you
- 55:24know, inversely to convince the court that it
- 55:27would not be detrimental, even if there are no
- 55:29concerns about the parents in terms of no allegation.
- 55:34allegations of abuse or neglect or anything else.
- 55:37But if at the end of the day, the child has been
- 55:40used to living with the guardian for over a year,
- 55:43for example, and just seeing parent, you know,
- 55:46on, you know, one day a week, that's still going
- 55:50to be a huge transition. And the court could
- 55:52find that that would be detrimental and on that
- 55:54basis alone, award the guardianship. All right.
- 56:02Thank you, Natalie. All right, so this concludes
- 56:05today's presentation. Thank you again, Natalie,
- 56:07for an excellent presentation. And thank you
- 56:09so much to our audience for joining us today.
- 56:11Have a great day, everybody. Thank you. Bye bye.