Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 391:1-392:1

Transcript

Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 391:1-392:1 · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

0:04
OK, we are in healthless air then Shinpei.
0:14
No shinsadi Olive shinsadi alaf din bittl rishosla osan
0:30
shashakulla orev alaf kehol mishpate bittl lami shashakhalo,
0:37
er bahatseiro, kanehu bamavoy all bas that apply to doing
0:51
bitterol. So he's able to be in the vatel,
0:56
his resource in the hutzer to a specific person.
1:02
Kane hooba movoy that that same concept works in a movoy, except
1:06
now you're not dealing with an individual house, now you're
1:10
dealing with an entire hutzer the same way that a house works
1:14
within a hutzer okay. So house is to Hutzer, multiple
1:19
houses is to Hutzer as multiple hutzeros are to a Movoy, right?
1:24
So if there is a hat, and we're going to read Cain hoop the
1:26
Maboy Shah im Shakha Hatzer akhast solo nishtatva.
1:30
If one of the hatzeros within multiple hatzeros of a mavoy was
1:35
not mishtatis in the Shitu femavos mava tellos ri To that
1:53
hutzer that that forgot Awful P shame Robin, even though there's
1:57
multiple ones there. Shebne hutzer and it's going to
2:00
be the same rule. Shebne hutzer Gabi Mavoy hashun
2:04
kiya hutzer An entire hutzer regarding a mavoy, even though
2:08
the hutzer itself is made-up of multiple houses of multiple
2:10
people. And regarding the halahas of the
2:13
Mavoy, it's just one destination.
2:15
It counts as one person. So that that's the comparison
2:19
the hall Mishpateh Yesra of the Khatsar Imhaina Yudi.
2:22
And similarly regarding the the the rules of multiple Jews and A
2:29
and a guy within the same Khatsar or a single Jew and and
2:33
the guy in this in one Khatsar we say that there's with one Jew
2:37
we say there's no need to do a a a Rebekhatsar.
2:42
So it's the same thing if there's only one khatsar of a
2:44
Jew and one khatsar of a guy connected to a mob boy.
2:47
There's no need to do she took him with us.
2:49
The Holmes where you saw Bahasa in the NA hoodie Kane Ho Bamavoy
2:53
oh Bair that's that's the same rule with the movie And
2:56
similarly in an entire city Shane Islatata Bamavoy oh bair
3:02
Hanu kefas khoma. There's no is, Sir to carry
3:05
within a Movoy or within a city that was achy uchte hatsero
3:19
shall butt the isral be here until there's two different
3:22
hatzeros of the isral within the city.
3:25
But if there's only one and there's no need to do an error
3:28
at all. What we call yeah and meaning
3:32
what we're calling an error of meaning She took it with us
3:35
Avohatsa akhas low I feel in Harvey bottom show so ups from
3:39
the Soho like we've been saying if there's only one hats are if
3:47
multiple houses in that one so that huts accounts is just one
3:50
unit and therefore there's no need The Who should say hey yeah
3:54
mukas from ladira. But that's if the city was first
3:59
encircled by a wall for for residents.
4:04
Lustan Ares Hey Mukas Ladira your average city was originally
4:09
founded was originally encircled to to live in.
4:13
We stun with sarin as compared to a fortress.
4:18
I don't know about a castle, but a fortress, a Fort and a mukuff
4:22
and Ladera are generally not surrounded.
4:25
Are not originally built walls around them for for living space
4:31
for living within, but for defense.
4:36
OK shie shte hatzeer shall. But the Israel be here.
4:39
Now again we're just we're again just making the comparison
4:43
between multiple hatzeros and a Mavoy is similar to multiple
4:46
houses within a Hatzero Hatzero Shobati Solby there's two
4:51
different hatzeros each one that has Jews in it within the city
4:56
street from this car they call hats the Hatsa Shani Hudi then
4:59
they are required the aim Maspe gumaches could be misar here and
5:14
it is not enough that they should just rent en masse from
5:18
the mayor. Or sometimes modern days they
5:22
use the the fire marshal because the fire marshal has the right
5:26
to kick somebody out of their home if they deem the house to
5:31
be a fire hazard for example. And you need, you need that
5:33
power, you need to be able to the power to be able to kick
5:35
somebody out. So he's saying the the mission,
5:40
I'm sorry, the Mahaber is is is coming out with that.
5:43
You cannot just go to the to the Sarhat year to the mayor or fire
5:50
Marshall. But that's not so partial.
5:52
That is actually a a case that they do I go the ashram of the
5:56
doctor in in Lahoti la Hachnes Lucius Haeno Yehudi that that
6:00
would only be if you wanted to take Calem in or out of the non
6:05
Jews house through if you Jew wanted to take stuff out of the
6:09
non Jews house through the hutzer and into the mob boy then
6:13
the the son her ear is not enough you would actually have
6:17
to rent the the non Jews steak in the hutter and movoy.
6:25
I have a little talent about Movoy but just to be able to for
6:30
a Jew to to be Mitaltam and Movoy your Hollis Kerman Hassar.
6:35
Then you can just go to the mayor and and unlock just rent
6:41
all of the guy in that live in that city is just rent their
6:46
their rights within within the mobi within the city and that
6:50
would be enough Sherry deraha mobi.
6:51
Who shall hassar. Because the public the public
6:55
pathways do belong to or at least are under the control of
6:59
the local government the holists like Kulha Inum Yehuda Nishan
7:03
and they are allowed to kick them out again you these days
7:08
you have to look for which kind of government official has the
7:12
right to kick somebody else to kick somebody out so but what we
7:16
are ending up with that it's only if you want the the higher
7:19
form at least just reading the muhab and the Rama.
7:23
If you want the higher form to pull.
7:26
If you want to be able to take Calem.
7:28
If you Jew wants to go to take Calem from the guys Rashus into
7:31
the mud boy then he would have to rent his individual rights.
7:35
But just if you're not doing that just to be able to take
7:38
your own stuff out of your own house.
7:39
And into the mud boy and just not have the the guys rights
7:43
within the muddy ruin it for you.
7:45
Then it is enough to go to the sour that's that's the budget
7:47
reading of the Ramon the Mazdar Mamurin Bissar Shain Habattum
7:53
Shalo. And even this is talking about a
7:55
Sar a mayor where the he doesn't own the houses.
7:58
The guy named Lustre Shamish about to Beneha here at Klau.
8:01
He doesn't have the right to you know eminent domain.
8:03
He doesn't have the right to just go into anybody's house.
8:07
That was not necessarily true, let's say in Europe with the
8:12
parts I think was able to go into people's homes.
8:14
But nowadays the mayor of the city doesn't have the right to
8:17
go uninvited into your home. I feel a Vishach Mahama even
8:21
even at at war time, they don't have the right to to take over
8:26
your home. I've been welcome Shakulta hahir
8:28
enam nasam El Al pihasar. But in a place where everything
8:33
that goes on in the city, it, you know is there is absolute
8:38
rule of of the leader of the city of of let's say the mayor
8:42
or Hama Munishilo or some other appointee.
8:44
Vadesh Sheshirus mesar hahu oh Mishiro Luquita Mahani again.
8:50
If he acts like an owner then then you can just make a deal
8:57
with him on all the homes and and that would clearly be
9:00
enough. And again, if he is the absolute
9:04
owner and has rights to kick people out or or whatever, you
9:09
don't just have to go to the one that has that absolute pay.
9:12
You don't have to go to the mayor.
9:13
You can go to anybody that that is a permanent worker and and
9:19
and lives and lives with him again.
9:21
Doesn't have to be that person. We can go to his employees or
9:26
his seasonal workers, Mahani again, all this is very similar
9:31
to what we saw by Irula Hatzerras, Shari Ishla which
9:35
shows Lahosha Banasha, Uklein, Mohanto.
9:37
Because if this person has the right to Garrison his his armed
9:44
forces or even his weapons. The Vata Benehi here in the in
9:50
any home within the city, the Shahs Mohammad Shalami dattam
9:53
even you know if people don't want or or or without them
9:56
knowing if he has that right then it is considered his his
10:00
place and you can just make a deal with the Sara Hayeer, just
10:03
rent it from him and everything is done.
10:06
Base Shinsan of Alaf. Base Eustraeilim Hadarin the
10:14
Hatsa Yuhidi the ear sio if there are multiple Jews that are
10:20
living in one Khatsar Khatsar in a city of non Jews, Shahim
10:26
Mukefisoma which has a wall around it.
10:29
The other you who the Mafarem Derek, Shan Bishabas Ahsanu
10:33
Bihatsa a Faris. And now it just happens to be
10:35
that this Chavez there is some Jews let's say visiting the
10:39
Habad and they're and they're just they're just here for this
10:43
one Chaves Reinam OSA Millenium. That the fact that now that
10:47
there are there's more than one hutzer that has juice with it
10:50
but only one of the Hutzeras has permanent resident Jews.
10:54
The other one is just guests coming for the Shabbos, the Araa
10:58
Ano, OSA. Just having somebody that's
11:00
there as an araf is not going to answer on you.
11:03
That would require you now to make an araf from the term
11:07
matanta of the whole year and and both of them would be able
11:11
to carry throughout the whole city the iron else of cemention
11:16
iron. We've some OK cement iron.
11:21
Yeah. This is the situation where they
11:26
no, you wouldn't need to in this case.
11:28
And it's yeah, if there's only one hot syrup with twos in it,
11:33
right. If there's two then you do need
11:34
to run from the mayor. If the mayor has absolute
11:37
control yada yada shin Sonic bays, Vinay iruven, leir of I
11:42
see all of Irshaisa, Kenyon, Yochen let's say somebody this
11:47
one person owns the whole the whole city.
11:50
In other words he he founded it. He he he built it and it is
11:58
owned by him. A few analysis show Robin even
12:01
with later it becomes it becomes the public's.
12:06
We start from kulam sheet of effert via talta bahalha Medina.
12:09
So then they can just make this one sheetu femme vows over the
12:12
whole city Bahal Medina sounds like the whole area femme
12:16
heister shall Robin. I'm sorry.
12:19
Medina's the city okay the femme haister Shall Robin age left we
12:32
start from Kunm sheet of effort they can all make one sheet two
12:35
thing evolves and and that will partner.
12:39
You don't have to you don't have to make.
12:42
I think he's trying to say you wouldn't have to make every the
12:44
hats errors in each of the different hats errors.
12:46
If it's if it's owned by one person or if there's only one
12:49
entrance then you can just make one what we call Arith and and
12:54
it would include the whole city other than hoister Shell Rob and
12:57
the Asian schnips often. But if it was owned it was
13:00
founded by the public and it has more than one opening has two
13:04
openings Shawn the custom bizarre.
13:06
The awesome bizarre. Even if it means they always
13:08
enter from 1:00 and they always exit from another I guess like a
13:12
two way St. I guess.
13:14
I don't know I feel nice as Shelly offed even if it was then
13:18
later one person bought everything up so now it's owned
13:21
by one person aim Arvind is Kula then he cannot make just one
13:25
error for everybody. Anita Newman I'm welcome.
13:28
Effed. I feel Hatso ahas uvayas Lesoha.
13:32
He has to leave one area, even if it's just one hatser and one
13:39
house in it. When Mishrasan Hashar and then
13:42
everybody else makes it, she's too famous.
13:45
Boss this this is actually I've heard that I heard from Roviosa
13:51
that we do this modern times when we make an area for the
13:55
whole neighbor for the whole city, we have to leave over an
13:58
area that's not included because then you can say we're all of
14:02
this area is included which means as opposed to this this
14:05
area as opposed to this one area that's not included And then it
14:09
works. But if you want to include the
14:11
whole city we were seeing in the Sith that that has to be owned
14:14
by one person. Do you Ayla Mashaf, including
14:17
Matam, the whole airports nurse in Malcolm Shashira And then the
14:22
people that want to use the Arab are mutta to carry in the whole
14:27
city except from that one place that they left out the EU, the
14:38
Osam Hanisha Mutanga Mucomam, Bashita Shosam Lazman.
14:42
Then that people that live in that one area that's left out,
14:46
they can make an area for just themselves and then the whole
14:50
city has one area and then this one area which was excluded from
14:54
the city area makes amongst themselves and they can just
14:56
carry for themselves in that one area.
14:58
Then Mahayana, Sham, Robin. But if there were a lot of
15:00
people that lived in that one hotser, assuming the top of the
15:05
shower color ear, they're not allowed to carry in the rest of
15:07
the city. But DOB is that Msham Hecker who
15:11
this whole reason for living, for living in an area that they
15:15
can't use, that's really just so that people realize that there
15:20
is such an idea as Eric Kadesha Idisha, Eric Hitler, him on top
15:23
of the ear, Zesha, Robin Bokenbo.
15:26
That's just so that people realize that it's the arrows
15:29
that enables them living in a city, that Robin Bokenbo, that a
15:34
lot of people come in and out. There's more than one entrance
15:38
so that they don't forget Torres Arab Sharieba welcome Shanish
15:41
Avalon is that if Imam Aimital from well Ella Elazman the
15:44
Elazman because they now know that there's an area that they
15:47
can't go into that they can't well they can't carry into.
15:50
And so the Taurus area of the the idea of of not being able to
15:56
carry wherever you want that that is that is satisfied for
16:02
most of the are mothering mothering mother in the
16:04
hospital. What if you have the city and
16:06
you could make an error for the whole city at once.
16:09
Although we saw that you would need to leave it open air that's
16:13
not included. But if they wanted they instead
16:15
of doing that they can just make an error for each motherly by
16:19
itself. Again, this is how they used to
16:21
do it in times of the tomorrow, not so popular now we don't do
16:24
that now. Koshkinda mahani that that would
16:27
work if you wanted to. Even if it wanted to make for
16:30
the whole city, that would work except for one era that would
16:33
work. If they wanted to make one
16:34
Mobley at a time, that would work.
16:36
Gauss Kinnahani, the Ainshire Goblem.
16:38
Is that because when you make for any one Mobley, you're
16:40
leaving over all the other Mobley's in the city.
16:42
So that that obviously works. Haga.
16:46
It's actually asked to the name shne possum shnei mashuliyan.
16:51
If you're going to go the route of molla then at the at the
16:57
entrance to each Movoy you should make the strips.
17:01
They can be a Masha who thick, but it has to be on either side
17:06
of the Movoy. We've seen, I think we've seen
17:09
that you can make a hacker for a Movoy with a Lathi with a Cora
17:14
or with two Marshalls or with a Circe Apasso.
17:20
But here he's he's advocating the two Marshalls on either
17:23
side. Shikoshkinda Mahani.
17:25
Sorry Shashank she didn't even. Who wrote Esther Ammos.
17:29
If if the mother is 10 almost wide will be Yes, Sir May Esther
17:35
Sir Sir Espesa. It's going to end up being more
17:37
than 10 almost wide. Then the only thing that would
17:39
work would be a eight source of pesa.
17:42
I think we're going to stop here.
17:46
Have a good day.