Latest / Newcomer Pod / Dream of Semafornication (w/Reed Albergotti)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. Hey everybody, Welcome to Dead
- 0:14cat. We've got Eric newcomer here,
- 0:16Katie better and me, Tom, Dayton, joining us this week is
- 0:21our good friend. Read albergue, Audi read
- 0:24longtime business reporter. We work together at the
- 0:27information for a few years. Reed is also So a veteran of the
- 0:30journal and the post-launch, the sports section at the journal,
- 0:35write your part of the founding team there and it was that.
- 0:38Okay. I was okay, I'm so excited to be
- 0:40on here. I'm just a huge fan of your
- 0:43podcast. You guys are awesome.
- 0:45Not because I know you but I really enjoy it.
- 0:48I'm excited to have you read Because what I like about read
- 0:51reason that you're our friend, is that you're an interesting
- 0:54person to talk to like a lot of journalists are excellent.
- 0:57Like fact gatherers like that's the skill.
- 1:00I think you're an interesting thinker.
- 1:01Like I always want to hear your opinion on things and you're not
- 1:05as cynical. I think is a lot of me.
- 1:07You're not as cynical as I. Yeah.
- 1:09And it's a good topic to have you on today because we're going
- 1:12to talk about a story that you that you broke.
- 1:14As I believe the first official story for the new publication
- 1:18that you work for which is semaphore, you're the first 774,
- 1:24Indian myth and Justin Smith's new publication.
- 1:26That's started advertising on my Twitter feed.
- 1:30Incessantly and is preparing for a buzzy launch, this fall?
- 1:34Yeah. They have a real, some of, for
- 1:35Nia. I, we haven't actually decided
- 1:37on official an official term for, what is it semaphore?
- 1:40Ian or some of them, some of fornicators.
- 1:44Maybe we can maybe your listeners and right in because
- 1:47I'm a flurries, yeah, you guys should you guys should license
- 1:52Californication by the chili peppers and make that your like
- 1:55launch song. Sam Farr case, Yeah, we can't
- 2:02afford that sound drop right now.
- 2:05So some of our do you want to give us?
- 2:06I mean you know Eric said it's a it's the Smith and Smith Coast.
- 2:10Ben Smith has been a guest on our show but do you want to give
- 2:13us like the rundown on what semaphore is and why we should
- 2:15be excited about this is the newest beacon on the media
- 2:18landscape. Yeah.
- 2:19I mean, so it's a new, it's a new publication, and it has a
- 2:23couple of things that I think are different than what other
- 2:25people are doing. And one is, it has this
- 2:28International angle, so the The thesis is that there's this
- 2:31underserved English-speaking audience around the world that
- 2:35doesn't, you know, trust or want to read the local news they're
- 2:39looking for, you know, news from outside the country from trusted
- 2:44sources. But you know, the big
- 2:46Publications that they might read are not really writing for
- 2:50that audience, the writing for an audience back home where the
- 2:53publication is based, you know, we've already launched semaphore
- 2:56Africa. So we're going to hire people
- 2:58in. African countries who are based
- 3:02there and will write stories that, you know, we hope are
- 3:04interesting, not just to, you know, Western audiences but
- 3:07audiences in Africa and then the goal is to eventually expand to
- 3:12lots of different places and then, you know, I'm covering
- 3:15technology. So you know what I think is
- 3:19exciting for me is that we're also going to experiment with
- 3:22story forms. And so we're going to sort of
- 3:24separate out the facts, the news from the analysis and so each
- 3:29Each article will have you know the reporters Viewpoint and
- 3:33really the reporters Viewpoint in my might the reason that's
- 3:36valuable is not so much because I think people care what
- 3:39reporters think but because we want to be transparent and not
- 3:42have readers kind of guessing Okay.
- 3:44What is this person's angle you know based on who they decide to
- 3:47quote and how they frame you know certain you know sentences
- 3:52and then you know we'll offer other points of view to.
- 3:55So here's an opposing point of view or here's a here's a
- 3:57different way of looking at it, or here's a way.
- 4:00Looking at it from an international perspective.
- 4:01So the way I think of it, sort of like every story becomes kind
- 4:06of a discussion around the news that you broke rather than sort
- 4:09of. Here's, here's our Publications
- 4:11world view and this is the only way of looking at it.
- 4:15And, you know, Ben was actually in the Bay Area last week and we
- 4:18were doing a bunch of meetings and one of the people we met
- 4:21with reached out the next day and was all excited about this
- 4:24idea and referred to it as our talmud approach to news, which
- 4:29Tom, I know, You'll get just a, just a lot of chin stroking, as
- 4:33you read the article. I think the idea well read and
- 4:36you shiva's in New York. That's my long awaited
- 4:40excavation. Yeah, you guys are you guys are
- 4:42publishing some before an Aramaic now, so you can get,
- 4:44well, read all those Highly Educated Hasidic schools.
- 4:49Exactly. Here's the rabbinical view,
- 4:51yesterday's news like it. And, and so, it's because the
- 4:54article that you wrote, which I believe was the first official
- 4:57article. It didn't even log, right?
- 4:58You guys were like, fuck it. It's like we're going to publish
- 5:01before. We're even ready to go, which is
- 5:04always fun. I remember relation to that with
- 5:06the mirror, he was just getting so many scoops on Google and
- 5:08their cars that like we're just not be back when we were
- 5:11publishing. Jessica lessin.com.
- 5:14Yeah, Jessica lessons.com brought to you by Amira Friday,
- 5:17I think The Branding at the time and by the way, that is, what
- 5:20website is still up? I was looking at it the other
- 5:22day when I said, yeah, because I saw reads scoop and I was like,
- 5:25huh, I wonder what the story is with, you know, Jay elle.com but
- 5:29But so the story that you wrote though, like, does that reflect
- 5:32the semaphore style? I mean, are you guys still
- 5:36workshopping it? Like, did you, are you?
- 5:38Yeah, I mean, is that is that a preview of what's to come?
- 5:40Or just kind of like, you had to get the news out.
- 5:42I think there are some clues in that story for, for what the
- 5:45form is going to be. Like, we didn't really break it
- 5:47out into sections, and we're still experimenting with exactly
- 5:51how that's going to work. We're sort of writing articles,
- 5:53I mean writing real articles, but not publishing them, and
- 5:57sort of just kind of to test what?
- 5:59Like, you know, writing in this form.
- 6:02The, I think you'll notice that in the medium article, I did, I
- 6:06did sort of include more analysis with with the news.
- 6:10And so, in that way, it is kind of a, it is kind of a taste of
- 6:13what's to come. All right, let's not just have
- 6:15second order conversation. I think the actual story itself
- 6:18is, right? Right after the audience is
- 6:20screaming right now, be like, what the fuck is the story?
- 6:23The story itself is actually interesting, and hopefully the
- 6:26heart of this conversation, the story is about a Biden's, -
- 6:30order on China that basically puts the screws to the country
- 6:33and brings us closer to something that I would describe
- 6:37as basically a trade war between the US and China over Tech.
- 6:40And then so you have the scoop on the order, the order actually
- 6:43does come out a couple of days later but read, why don't you
- 6:46just tell us what you were hearing as you as you got the
- 6:50scoop and you know what? The nature of the conversation
- 6:52was on China? The u.s. yeah.
- 6:54I mean, I don't know if I would, if I would describe it exactly,
- 6:56like, putting the screws to China.
- 6:58I mean, I think with their what, I did ministration is trying to
- 7:01do is kind of walk, this tightrope between, you know,
- 7:05there's there's China Hawks, who kind of believe we should
- 7:08completely decouple with this country and have so that they
- 7:12have zero leverage. Because essentially, in their
- 7:14view, a war is coming and then there's, you know, the more
- 7:19moderates who kind of view that at War as, you know, somewhat of
- 7:22a possibility. But, you know, decoupling and
- 7:25and taking extreme, you know, measures We will essentially
- 7:30hurt us, business hurt us, interests in the short term, and
- 7:34maybe even increase the chances of war in the long term.
- 7:37So, what Biden is planning to do, and the order that came out
- 7:41is sort of related, but not exactly what I was writing
- 7:43about. They're planning to do is add
- 7:46more controls on investment that, you know, comes out of the
- 7:50US and goes to China. The order.
- 7:52The other day was sort of the opposite.
- 7:54It was expanding, you know, the cepheus, which regulates inbound
- 7:58investments from So, this and what was sort of interesting to
- 8:02me was that there was actually an article in the information,
- 8:05they broke the story on Sequoia China, which is the separate,
- 8:10but related to Sequoia in the US investment firm, one of the
- 8:14raising of teachers in the world at one point there were fears.
- 8:18The Sequoia China was almost like to good relative to Sequoia
- 8:21us, where it was like, should kneel shed and who runs that fun
- 8:24be in charge of Sequoia overall. Then of course, this whole
- 8:28geopolitical thing got much worse.
- 8:29So I think it was less much less likely that the US would lose
- 8:34its grip on Sequoia overall. And so we saw rule off, take
- 8:38take over. But but yeah a fascinating
- 8:40mini-drama instead of one of the most powerful or the most
- 8:44powerful Venture investor in the whole world.
- 8:46You know, us and China. That's right.
- 8:48I mean, yeah. Derek, you probably know more
- 8:49than anyone about that and I think what was interesting was
- 8:53in inside the National Security Council, when that story came
- 8:56out and got sort of passed around its Raised alarm Bells.
- 9:00It's like okay this story you know, hugely important
- 9:04investment firm in the u.s. is now like amid all the tensions
- 9:09with China. This is back in February is now
- 9:11doubling down on their Investments there.
- 9:13And I think it kind of lit a fire to push to push this agenda
- 9:17forward. Some of this was actually
- 9:19originally in the chips act or what became the chips act and
- 9:22then was removed. So this is kind of an attempt to
- 9:25do it with an executive order. And what I hear is they want to
- 9:28do it before the Midterms and there's a couple of other orders
- 9:31to that, we wrote about which is, you know, one is something
- 9:35related to really to tick. Tock, it won't these won't name
- 9:39Tick-Tock or even China, probably.
- 9:41But they're really, that's what they're really targeted for.
- 9:44It's an attempt to kind of reduce the data collection or
- 9:48sharing of foreign firms with, you know, that are their own by
- 9:53parent company's other countries.
- 9:55So it would essentially create some kind of firewall between
- 9:59the US Tick Tock and China, to take talk in terms of data
- 10:02collection. So it's kind of a, it's kind of
- 10:05a middle of the road approach. I mean, if you remember Trump
- 10:08actually banned Tick-Tock which turned out to be illegal and it
- 10:12wasn't, you know, the eventually it was going to be sold to
- 10:15Microsoft. And then, you know, the whole
- 10:17thing fell apart people. I think.
- 10:19Yeah. And Walmart think I was bidding
- 10:23on it for a second. Yeah, better appears this Dark
- 10:27Horse candidate. Really plummeted, I felt yeah,
- 10:33yeah, very interesting. Can sort.
- 10:34Listen, Katie ran our College radio station at one point,
- 10:38right? Aren't you're well-equipped to
- 10:40you know if you can DJ you can DJ video consumption for the
- 10:45Western Wall E. But yeah I mean that that never
- 10:48happened and you know I think what they're hoping, what binds
- 10:53hoping is that there's a way to do this legally and still
- 10:57accomplish to ban. Same things are Legally.
- 11:00No, not to ban it. They don't want to ban it from
- 11:02what I understand mainly because that's that's not legal.
- 11:05I mean there there there are Protections in place you know
- 11:08the first amendment is one of them but there's also this
- 11:11Berman Amendment which is sort of a cold war Relic that limits
- 11:18limits what the president can do in terms of blocking
- 11:22communication between countries. So, you know, while we were
- 11:27fighting this cold war with the Soviet Union, we wanted also to
- 11:30allow people to talk to people in the Soviet Union because that
- 11:33benefited us like, basically, you can't stop someone from
- 11:35sending like animals Animal Farm to the Soviet Union.
- 11:38Right away is the way I think of it.
- 11:40And so, you know, Tick-Tock is I think the idea is to Century
- 11:45essentially bifurcate the communication part of tick, tock
- 11:48from the data collection that doesn't exactly get around the
- 11:52fears of tick-tock being used. As a, you know, a weapon and
- 11:57information weapon like a propaganda tool.
- 12:00B, right? I mean, that's the fear.
- 12:02I'm not saying we know that it is so interesting.
- 12:04Because first of all, I think that Sophia's is a little bit
- 12:07misunderstood it's not a tool, meant to ban investment.
- 12:09It's just a tool meant to like, say, what are the laws and how
- 12:13do we make sure this investment complies with the laws and
- 12:15mitigates risk? It's not in its it wasn't
- 12:18created in order to prevent investment from happening.
- 12:20So this idea of tick-tocking in discussion to get this over, the
- 12:24finish line is simply like how do we make sure we're in
- 12:27compliance and everyone's comfortable.
- 12:29Its but reads talking about this bigger fear that China could use
- 12:32Tick-Tock as a propaganda tool to push information into the
- 12:36United States and then control the minds of tweens that I think
- 12:40is sort of the more interesting idea because some might argue
- 12:43that YouTube already does that and it is owned by a company in
- 12:49the United States of America. Well I think the US government
- 12:51wants wants their wants propaganda tools to be owned by
- 12:54US Congress right. Under slightly and more or less
- 12:57you know us media companies specific not Foreign countries,
- 13:00haven't been able to use things like YouTube and Facebook to
- 13:03push propaganda. Exactly, I want to argue about
- 13:06Tick-Tock but first I'm very happy Katie brought up cepheus
- 13:09because I feel like that's that's key to it and sort of the
- 13:11boar like, no one is ever been happy to anybody in the United
- 13:19States. Is that right?
- 13:20It's interagency. That's true.
- 13:21It's a committee. So, keep in mind, it's a when
- 13:24you think about the government, it's like a little, its nesting
- 13:26dolls. Inside the ultimate like deep
- 13:29state, Like, in a certain way, it's like the government
- 13:31decides, it stands for committee on foreign investment in the
- 13:35United States. That's literally it's a
- 13:36committee that looks at for Investments coming into the
- 13:40United States interagency it includes the Justice
- 13:43Department's National Security division.
- 13:45It includes the National Security Council, which is right
- 13:47in the White House. It includes National Security
- 13:49advisors and of course treasury because treasury their larger
- 13:53overarching. Desire is for investment, that
- 13:57will benefit the United States to For the longest time.
- 14:01Like SoftBank was very mindful of syphilis bizarre.
- 14:03All these worries about like artificial intelligence and
- 14:07they're just lots of sort of Chinese and Asian Investments.
- 14:11Very worried about sort of big steaks from from u.s. players
- 14:15over the years. Well, they also look at real
- 14:17estate and I think that Sophia's actually was much more active in
- 14:20the real estate space for a long time then in the tech space and
- 14:24it's only be not only but because since the 90s with our
- 14:29deepening relationships with countries like China and our
- 14:33extreme is read alluded to before our extreme dependence on
- 14:36China for like the the business dependence on China, in terms of
- 14:41intellectual property, just on things like supply chain and on
- 14:43things, like manufacturing has grown.
- 14:45This is even before you get to something like consumer app, you
- 14:49know, Sophia's became I think in the minds of people who even
- 14:52know about this ridiculous, Acura acronym, became really
- 14:56twinned with technology. And so in the most laymen terms,
- 14:59if he is The main, the main piece of it and correct me if
- 15:02I'm wrong has been sort of Defense related technology,
- 15:05right? You don't want.
- 15:06You know, a Russian Russian oligarchs.
- 15:08Buying bonds already taken. Lockheed Martin.
- 15:10Right. Exactly mr.
- 15:12Then, this executive order is expanding, syphilis has power.
- 15:16And some way, right? Or reader Katie do, what's,
- 15:20what's the new power that syphilis?
- 15:22Gets ya re-time. Not read the EO.
- 15:24So you'll you'll tell us how this has changed.
- 15:26Sophia's. No, I mean, the latest, the
- 15:28latest executive, Order. Okay.
- 15:30Well, the one that the one that came out a couple days ago which
- 15:33is not actually when I wrote about it.
- 15:35So it does. Okay.
- 15:37No mere does exist. One about a different executive
- 15:40order. Yeah.
- 15:40That's that came its it is related to surface and it
- 15:43basically expands the, you know, the Mandate like the types of
- 15:47things that Sophia's should look at.
- 15:49So it's kind of like a like a look at a broader.
- 15:53Look at a broader number of things here like like biotech
- 15:56for instance is something that now.
- 15:58Yeah, they should look at it. The way I think of it is like
- 16:01that executive order deals with inbound investment, what I was
- 16:04writing about deals with outbound investment which right
- 16:07now there's very few controls on.
- 16:10They would also expand export controls so like the types of
- 16:14things that us companies are not allowed to send to China and
- 16:18other, you know, countries problem countries, essentially
- 16:22would be expanded and then there's the data thing.
- 16:25So, I think what you're seeing is, there's their ideas for New
- 16:30types of like totally new categories of Regulation but
- 16:34also expansion of existing ones like cepheus if that makes
- 16:39sense. Read can just repeat that back
- 16:40you make sure I understand. So in the executive order does
- 16:43public cepheus, which is this review processing.
- 16:46What can a foreign company invest in in the United States?
- 16:49That is saying there should be more categories that Sophia's
- 16:52reviews. Simply because technology has
- 16:54changed so much. So maybe there was a time when
- 16:56the idea of a Chinese investment firm.
- 17:00Buying up shares of an agriculture business.
- 17:03Wouldn't be a big deal but now because of the role agriculture
- 17:05plays, National Security of seems like a bigger deal.
- 17:07So there should be more there or more in medicine and then what
- 17:10you wrote about was this idea of money flowing out of the United
- 17:15States and into foreign countries and companies is that
- 17:18right? Exactly.
- 17:19Yeah you got exactly what so what's the level of ban are they
- 17:23really going to ban the foreign investment or what sort of I
- 17:26don't think anyone will ever ban for ya.
- 17:27What's the restriction and What's what I would regulate
- 17:32like it's just going to be scrutinized and and it'll give
- 17:35the power to basically the White House and you know probably
- 17:39other agencies as well like the Chester Simon treasury Commerce.
- 17:43Yeah, to sort of look at these Investments.
- 17:46So basically they'd say okay so Sequoia has this, this Chinese
- 17:50arm like is that even? It's a separate entity.
- 17:53So can we even regulate that? Like let's take a look at it.
- 17:56See that's my question with the Sequoia thing because so far As
- 18:00I understand Sequoia China its Affiliated but the LPS and
- 18:04Sequoia China are in China. They're not US based and it's an
- 18:07RM be denominated fund. So you know there's obviously
- 18:11some sort of almost like licensing agreement between
- 18:13Sukhoi us and Sequoia China, but it doesn't strike me as like,
- 18:16you know, the the endowment funds and and hospitals.
- 18:19That are part of us. Venture Capital funds are going
- 18:22to be investing in, you know, the next byte dance in China,
- 18:24right? Yeah.
- 18:25Well, I think I think they're actually worried more about
- 18:27investments in things like, semiconductors, Yes, and
- 18:30artificial intelligence Quantum, Computing, they're worried that
- 18:34us money's going to help China, like, Advance their riff
- 18:37technological know-how and and it's not just, I think there's a
- 18:41fear that also with those investment dollars comes, you
- 18:44know, expertise, right. I mean Sequoia, would be able to
- 18:48lean on it. They have a huge network of
- 18:50people in these fields and could sort of help these portfolio
- 18:54companies and it really impacts joint ventures to.
- 18:57So, for a long time, there were a lot of joint ventures between
- 19:00U.s. and Chinese automakers manufacturers companies like you
- 19:05know, Bechtel infrastructure companies and a lot of Ip gets
- 19:09passed and knowledge to reads Point.
- 19:11Like one of the reasons why there's this big like fear of
- 19:13Chinese Espionage and US corporations is because they
- 19:17want the fact that we have advanced knowledge in so many
- 19:19areas in order to benefit the greater Chinese government.
- 19:23Right. Yeah I think I think also just
- 19:25to take a step back. I mean Katie what, you know,
- 19:28your do a good job of sort of like Explaining the background
- 19:31and I think the other thing is just, you know, with the chip
- 19:34shortage with the supply chain problems that came out of the
- 19:37pandemic. I think that's just, it's so
- 19:39front of mine. Now how vulnerable we are to
- 19:43disruptions in the supply chain. You know, most of the advanced
- 19:47semiconductors come from tsmc and Taiwan which, you know, is
- 19:52being threatened by China. Now, so if trying to took over
- 19:55Taiwan, theoretically, I mean, they could cripple us industry
- 19:59right there. He's now fears that I think, you
- 20:02know, we're pretty are pretty drastic.
- 20:03So I think I think this is like these executive orders.
- 20:07When you think about, if you think of it from an extreme
- 20:09perspective like that, like they're not exact these
- 20:11Executives or like are very measured I would say mean
- 20:14there's there are people who really want even tougher
- 20:17restrictions, wouldn't you say K and the restrictions aren't
- 20:20going to help because I think I agree completely and I think one
- 20:23of the reasons why restrictions alone won't help is because
- 20:25we're looking at a geopolitical problem.
- 20:27So like if the issue is that Relationship that Taiwan has
- 20:31that, excuse me, China has with the greater China region Stark
- 20:34strict business restrictions, are not going to really do too
- 20:38much if China does attack Taiwan and that case, it's like what we
- 20:44should have been doing is investing in our own high-tech
- 20:48manufacturing change here in the United States.
- 20:51Exactly. Because it's not just
- 20:52manufacturing. You don't there a lot of
- 20:53companies that are not as impacted by the idea of
- 20:57instability in the in the greater China region.
- 21:00That is I say greater tiny China region.
- 21:02So as not to get a sense from the mainland, but we're huge
- 21:05value in mainland China. Thank you for that coffee and
- 21:08Mainland China. This podcast is adamant that
- 21:11Taiwan is an independent country.
- 21:13I don't know what you guys are gone.
- 21:14Yeah. Our affiliation with that, that
- 21:17sign is actually been a very successful joint pain, sir.
- 21:20It's really more of a brand-new garment manufacturing.
- 21:25Those those Supply chains and those manufacturing fact, those
- 21:29factories. That's work.
- 21:30That's like lower skilled labor and you can move it to Malaysia.
- 21:34You can use move it to pack. We can all go naked for a
- 21:36couple. Thanks for getting the but the
- 21:38manufacturing for something like chips is actually extremely high
- 21:42skilled labor for which nobody in the United States is trained.
- 21:45And I say this, you know, my dad used to work in high school in
- 21:47high Skilled Manufacturing. He worked in an industry that
- 21:51doesn't exist anymore. So you know our IP but there's
- 21:55no training to work on those Factory lines here in the United
- 21:58States was not just a matter of building them.
- 21:59Factories. It's big educational Challenge
- 22:02and so I think that you know again going back to reads Point.
- 22:05Why be super strict and restrictive when the bigger
- 22:09challenge actually is here in the United States and like
- 22:11filling in those both Supply chains in manufacturing, right?
- 22:15And let's be clear about what's happening here from the broader
- 22:18perspective with tech is that there's been kind of a hangover.
- 22:21There was this, like, ecstasy over the fact that we could
- 22:23export so much of our chip manufacturing to China, to our
- 22:26Hardware manufacturing to China, you know?
- 22:29It was very A lucrative seeming market for a while for US tech
- 22:32company and it was coincident with the idea that China was
- 22:34going to get to panaji. Become more democratic join the
- 22:38WTO and basically shed all of its Global Ambitions to take
- 22:41over the world that has had for centuries thousands of years
- 22:44anyway, keep going. Yeah it's so so yes certainly
- 22:47that didn't change over the course of a couple years of you
- 22:49know bringing a middle-class into China and having a bunch of
- 22:52manufacturing and you know, different provinces.
- 22:55But now I think there's just a huge what I'm just sensing
- 22:58talking to people in Tech is that there's a big, I said like
- 23:02hangover or regret almost in what we have empowered within
- 23:05China and the fact that yes it is allowed for cheap
- 23:08manufacturing for a lot of u.s. goods in the tech sector but
- 23:11there hasn't been a Level Playing Field.
- 23:13We can't use China as a market when I say we I mean like us
- 23:17tech companies can't use China's Market to release their their
- 23:19apps and services. It's been a disaster for most US
- 23:22tech companies that have expanded their you know, these
- 23:24be actually yeah Airbnb. Apple to imagine like when
- 23:28Russia invaded Ukraine and Apple's like we're not selling
- 23:30anything else in Russia. Fuck that.
- 23:32Can you imagine Tim Cook saying the same thing read.
- 23:34What is the like Revenue worse? North America still number one,
- 23:37but isn't China still number two for apples like, oh, you're 35
- 23:41percent of all of its Revenue. Definitely, I don't know if it's
- 23:4435, I have to look at the latest numbers, but like Tom said, I'm
- 23:47an ideas, man, not a facts, man. No, but it is no, it is huge and
- 23:53not it's not just their revenue though, right?
- 23:55I mean, if if they couldn't manufacture in China that would
- 23:58cripple All right, I'll cripple the company and the only thing
- 24:02that kind of just like everyone thinks of manufacturing, but
- 24:05like we sell a lot of shit to meddle class, Chinese people.
- 24:08So I to yeah, I think I think the thing Apple has in its favor
- 24:11is like it employs a lot of people there.
- 24:13So that's like the one I think that's the one thing that's sort
- 24:16of keeping oblongata have. It needs leverage to write.
- 24:20Sure the freight like a company that can actually have some
- 24:23leverage, you know, over a country.
- 24:25Obviously not a and obviously it's a beloved consumer product
- 24:28so there is Chinese. If people want to be able to buy
- 24:31it to it's a sign of their Global status.
- 24:34Right? But what leverage does Tim Cook
- 24:36have though if there is instability and or violence
- 24:40government-to-government violence in China.
- 24:42Like just because he employs a lot of people they're not going
- 24:44to do it totally know. I think if I think that's it, I
- 24:47mean, if that's the only leverage it's like, hey, if you,
- 24:50you know, if you heard us, you're hurting, you know, a
- 24:53bunch of jobs in China, and to the extent that, you know, the
- 24:57government there is willing to No, accept the loss of jobs,
- 25:01like, that's, that's kind of it. I mean, I agree to me, the core
- 25:05issue. Here is, yeah, the, the
- 25:07inability of American companies to compete fairly in China.
- 25:11And the need to sort of turn the screws to China.
- 25:15Until like, to me I'm less like, oh, we need to get rid of tick
- 25:18tock as we shouldn't have Tick-Tock as long as like, uber
- 25:22can't compete in China and the the failure of the American
- 25:25government to say, okay, if business is need To can operate
- 25:31here. Then our business is shop right
- 25:32there and I don't know I'm not a lawyer but I find it hard to
- 25:35believe. The US government doesn't have
- 25:37the tools to say like in a given industry.
- 25:39If we're not allowed to compete in that industry and your
- 25:42country, you can compete here. Like I would I be shocked if
- 25:47American law makes it impossible to say, like, I mean, on, like
- 25:51car manufacturing stuff, aren't there?
- 25:52All these sorts of like crop? Like, we get to look at how you
- 25:56treat our companies in order to decide how we treat yours.
- 25:59Like I just don't understand why social media and and China is
- 26:03the exemption here? Well, I think, yeah I mean I
- 26:05think you're taught. I don't think you're wrong, I
- 26:07actually don't know if you're wrong.
- 26:09I think that the the issue with Banning Tick-Tock is that
- 26:12they've done it using ayyappa that the international emergency
- 26:16economic Powers Act, which is the framework that Trump use and
- 26:20that is the framework that the B Administration will use in their
- 26:23executive orders as well. So they're not laughing about
- 26:26trade, fuck up the Chinese. In China, it's only fair like if
- 26:33we're going to have Tick-Tock, like I just have them both.
- 26:36In both countries, just sort of running rampant.
- 26:39Think if we got rid of tick, tock that we would no longer
- 26:41have political manipulation on social media.
- 26:43No. But it would be American
- 26:44companies. Doing it by foreign countries
- 26:46though. I mean like, yeah, exactly.
- 26:48Right. Countries can obviously use
- 26:50Facebook to manipulate citizens. I like the idea of Facebook
- 26:53coming to China. Now after they've been like to
- 26:57talk and whatever the version of tick tock, he's not called tick.
- 26:59In China but you know the you know, it's because it's such a
- 27:02it's such an give me my Tick. Tock is extremely restricted in
- 27:04China? Like they like, I think it's not
- 27:08just that we can't put Facebook and China.
- 27:10It's that we can track our troll armies, manipulate Tick-Tock so
- 27:15that Chinese people, see terrible things about their
- 27:18government and get mad. Whereas like, you know, troll
- 27:21armies in, you know, reister in Europe, can infiltrate Facebook,
- 27:24and make us see things that make a film.
- 27:26But I also think people make this Some big like foreign
- 27:31policy thing, which maybe there is, but just the fact that, on
- 27:34sort of the minutiae, The Tick Tock is a Chinese company that
- 27:38already has all these strong speech controls over how
- 27:42Creator, you know, they don't say suicide.
- 27:44They say all these contorted things and maybe that's the
- 27:47right idea and maybe in America, but it but it's crazy.
- 27:50That one of the most important cultural apps in the United
- 27:52States, has the Norms set in China.
- 27:56Now, of course, I guess this is what ever European thinks every
- 27:58day. It's like why?
- 27:59Americans deciding like the terms of the speech debate here
- 28:04in Europe, but it's crazy crazy in America, that like such
- 28:07Nuance, speech codes are being set by chinese company.
- 28:10Well, I thought it was crazy during the Hong Kong protests.
- 28:14When you had people in the NBA, I mean, the NBA was being their
- 28:19speech, was being set by, you know, the Chinese government at
- 28:22that point. Remember that's Grudge.
- 28:23A legitimately believe that actually, I think he was
- 28:26speaking from the heart and he was like, yeah, let's let's
- 28:29talk. Look at it both sides here and
- 28:30these Hong Kong protests, okay? That's possible.
- 28:33Actually, I mean, you have a general manager from some NBA
- 28:36team, whose, you know, probably has no connection right to China
- 28:40whatsoever, who says, you know, I think democracy is a good
- 28:43thing, right? In Hong Kong and they caramelize
- 28:45it like a Robbie's out of China. I mean, if you do you remember,
- 28:49by the way, when John Cena was giving some press conference at
- 28:53a movie promotion and he mentioned Taiwan in a way, he
- 28:57shouldn't have, and then later had to release it.
- 28:59Apology for it, and did it in fucking Mandarin.
- 29:02Like they had him speak as close to as a whole, you know, a
- 29:05hostage video. I can get like China, China does
- 29:08not need tick tock in order to force people to report with its
- 29:12Norms around how you speak and yeah, like they think of the
- 29:15most powerful wrestlers and made them say, whatever the fuck they
- 29:18want them to their knees. I was covering Apple.
- 29:21When Apple pulled its at or pulled the app that was it was
- 29:24like the Hong Kong protests app that was allowing protesters to
- 29:27see where the police were and I get a call from Apple PR and
- 29:31they're like, briefing me on this and it's like basically
- 29:34Chinese propaganda, like we ban this app because, you know,
- 29:38these protesters were using it to hurry comply with the laws in
- 29:41the countries in which they operate.
- 29:43Yeah, they're like, we've been given like credible evidence is
- 29:47being used. Yeah, and I'm like, I cannot
- 29:49believe I'm on the phone with apple and like, they're just
- 29:52basically getting a Chinese propaganda and translator of all
- 29:55the supply chain is in China. And, you know, it's your second
- 29:58largest revenue generating. Better believe.
- 30:00That's the thing. This is what I find.
- 30:02So fascinating, you know, in the beginning, you said there are
- 30:05two competing Visions, you know, one is to be more hawkish and
- 30:08the other one is to believe that will just hurt business and it's
- 30:10like, well, can't these things both be true because I think
- 30:12that there's going to be a moment where what happens in
- 30:15that region? Just hurts business.
- 30:16Whether or not, we've been hawkish for sure just to make a
- 30:20zoom out, observation about the ideology that we're shaping on
- 30:23this podcast. I do think I do think there's a
- 30:26reality that like I'm a Warhawk. No, no.
- 30:30No, I think this is shared but I do think there's this growing
- 30:33question of whether we really want tech companies to be
- 30:37responsive to local governments right on the abortion issue in
- 30:40the United States. It's like how deferential do we
- 30:42want them to be do? We want tech companies to be
- 30:45differential in China? I think like the left and sort
- 30:49of the pro-government crowd has for the longest time.
- 30:52Hal. Das like a virtue that the
- 30:55government can bring companies under their thumb.
- 30:57But I think there's a rising question.
- 30:59Just who whether we want these independent tech companies to be
- 31:04sort of sovereigns to talk about apology or something and say,
- 31:07sorry. Screw you, we don't have to
- 31:09follow any one country's laws know, and I think another way to
- 31:12look at that because I think that's exactly right.
- 31:14I think another way to look at it is where are we right now,
- 31:16in, in, in history? Right.
- 31:19So, there was, I think, many people would say comply with the
- 31:22law, but then, if you look back and see your 1955, if you had
- 31:26companies stand up and say, you know what, though we actually We
- 31:29don't we don't agree with Jim Crow and we're not going to
- 31:32follow that law. We're going to break that local
- 31:34law. I think there are some people
- 31:36would have thought that was the right thing to do, in terms of
- 31:37history in the 80s, you know, we don't like apartheid we're not
- 31:40going to follow that local, or we're going to not do business
- 31:43with you. People would say, that's right.
- 31:44So, with questions like abortion, do you want any us
- 31:49company much like company or any other flouting a local state
- 31:53law, if they think that it's wrong, or do you want a large
- 31:56multinational company saying, you know what, we think that
- 31:59Happening right now in this other place in the world, keep
- 32:03in mind we have a lot of data points to show that you know
- 32:06imposing u.s. mores and morals on to another country.
- 32:09Doesn't always work Afghanistan. But do you know to say like
- 32:13should we be so upset by a human rights issue or whatever?
- 32:16That we're just not going to comply with this with this
- 32:19country's laws and I think that that's an open question now,
- 32:22because we're still figuring out what's going on, histórico lie.
- 32:25It's funny to me, there's so much press on what these
- 32:28companies do in these other countries.
- 32:29He's and the censorship that they're willing to go along with
- 32:31and places like Russia and China and yet it hasn't really changed
- 32:35anything and it's sort of like apartheid was a was a big public
- 32:40push, right at like a public pressure push and that's what
- 32:43really kind of turn the tide. I mean happened on University
- 32:46campuses and it spread to is consumer up.
- 32:48Yeah, yeah, consumer up. And like, it doesn't seem to be
- 32:51happening now and I'm not really sure why.
- 32:54But at the other thing I think about is and this is maybe
- 32:57taking it in a Direction, you don't want to go, but like, This
- 33:00to me is the biggest the best argument for something like a
- 33:03new internet. Like a decentralized internet
- 33:05that can't be that can't be censored because and also, I
- 33:08don't know what that would look like, and I don't know if it's
- 33:10technologically feasible but that this is like what I think
- 33:13about when I'm free tornado cash, you know, right Campana
- 33:17technology or whatever. It may be, what I think of when
- 33:19I think of you no censorship in the Internet.
- 33:22It's not like Facebook saying, you can't say Nazi or whatever.
- 33:26It's this stuff. It's it's these countries around
- 33:28the world that are Able to essentially manipulate, you
- 33:32know, the base, the pipes of the internet and these large
- 33:35corporations to, you know, to basically bolster their regimes.
- 33:39And I think it's something we should be talking about more.
- 33:41Totally, I'm curious. Like, could you expand on that
- 33:43more? Because that's something that I
- 33:45feel like I hear said on Twitter but then I scroll past it
- 33:48because it's not enough. It's I don't like, it's only 140
- 33:50characters. I keep going like what what how
- 33:52would that like just how would a decentralised internet for
- 33:56example, either free companies or prevent companies?
- 33:59From giving in to what say, the Chinese government wants.
- 34:02Well, I think I think the idea is that would get rid of those
- 34:04companies. It would supplant them.
- 34:07I mean, the turbulence answerable.
- 34:09I mean, because if you're like you, if you're the government
- 34:12has to go out to eat user instead of saying, hey Facebook,
- 34:15like Chase down this user on our behalf, you know, it's like if
- 34:18every node is sort of independent, then you have to go
- 34:22after the user, right? I mean, yeah, it will reminds me
- 34:25in a way of like, you know, music sharing at the, you know,
- 34:27at the beginning of the 21st century where it actually was
- 34:30fairly impossible for the record labels to stop Napster.
- 34:33They had to sue people individually, and what basically
- 34:36solved it for them, as that things got centralized again and
- 34:39music. Downloading was taken up by all
- 34:41the major tech companies, mostly apple, and suddenly, even, I
- 34:44mean it first of all, it, put it into like a legal space but also
- 34:46centralized it and it seems like what you're talking about read.
- 34:49What? Again, sort of decentralized
- 34:50things in a don't want to simplify it too much and say
- 34:53like it's peer-to-peer again but that's the idea, right?
- 34:55Is that it's kind of individually these, you know,
- 34:58the data and the Is transmitted across smaller groups of people.
- 35:02Yeah, it wouldn't, it wouldn't involve large centralized
- 35:04company and I think if you include things like satellite
- 35:06internet along with like decentralized protocols that
- 35:10wouldn't allow for control. I think you could see
- 35:13theoretically a world in which, you know, they're it's
- 35:16impossible to I mean and that would create other problems,
- 35:20too. I'm not saying that's a Utopia,
- 35:22right? I mean, there are certain types
- 35:23of speech that probably should be censored, right?
- 35:26Totally, you know, I don't know. I'm just, I'm throwing it out.
- 35:29It smashes speech is also like this larger question of like
- 35:32what makes us feel like we're part of a community.
- 35:34So I was like, for something else.
- 35:37I was just rereading this Liz burning op-ed the happened after
- 35:40you've all the, it was like the country that kills its children
- 35:43and has no hope or I just butchered the headline.
- 35:45But basically part of her thesis is that we do live in a society,
- 35:50in which we Face our future together.
- 35:53And I would argue that the more and more and more we live
- 35:56online, decentralized, allying, ourselves, Communities far away
- 36:00from one another and sometimes, not even the United States.
- 36:03I think it's an open question, whether or not we as Americans
- 36:06want to face the future together and figure it out together and
- 36:10feel like we have a shared stake and I think with the more
- 36:12important thing that even if you don't want to face the future
- 36:15together, you realize you have a shared stake with your
- 36:18neighbors. And I think that the more and
- 36:20more and more we are Road at that, the harder is to see
- 36:24country trying to solve anything together.
- 36:27So I think that's not just like the matter of whether or Not
- 36:29some speech should be censored, which I would largely agreed
- 36:32exist. That's how to sort of teach
- 36:33exist, but like as we decentralize ourselves from our
- 36:36physical place, what impact does that have on our whatever it is
- 36:41on our community? It's pretty ironic to me that
- 36:45once you had the ability for anyone to communicate with
- 36:48anyone basically on social media, Etc.
- 36:51We actually became much which we were driven farther apart from
- 36:55each other. You know, well, because the tech
- 36:57itself is not really as See, when you look at Tick-Tock, it's
- 37:00not that much of a person-to-person communication.
- 37:03I mean, the idea of following is almost going out the window in
- 37:05favor of algorithms, because the way people prefer to use tick,
- 37:09tock is just like, showing their interests and then having the
- 37:12robots figure out for them as it goes on.
- 37:14I mean, we have, we have this really interesting conversation
- 37:16with Taylor Lorenz, a couple weeks back where she was
- 37:19bringing up this. I felt kind of amazing moment at
- 37:21VidCon, you know, like the influencer Comic Con, where all
- 37:25the Tick-Tock stars that were, there had basically no lines of
- 37:27people, they had no fans. People wanted to Line up and see
- 37:30them because people have no attachment to them, it's just
- 37:32sort of entertainment that shows up in their feed.
- 37:34That gives them a moment of dopamine hit joy and then they
- 37:38move on to the next thing. And, and I think I don't really
- 37:41know what the point to this is. Other than like, I don't think
- 37:43social media as it was conceived, maybe in Zuckerberg,
- 37:46's conception is that relevant anymore and we're moving away
- 37:50from connection as the main force of these platforms,
- 37:54because that's not what the platforms are optimized to do
- 37:56anymore, just optimized to to Watch time essentially and give
- 38:01us moments of entertainment but I so it's fundamentally.
- 38:03I'm cheering for the erosion of like local community over global
- 38:07Community. Like what?
- 38:09Yeah I'm I'm more aligned in ideology, probably with this
- 38:12driver Chinese Elite who are like doing business all over the
- 38:15world than the person who's like, happy staying in their
- 38:18Hometown in like Middle America, which totally is fine.
- 38:21I'm just saying that once you start, once you start saying,
- 38:23well, I just have more in common with these people.
- 38:25Do you, then have the community will whether it's in your town
- 38:28or your state to pass a Gun control law or you like fuck it.
- 38:30This is just the work. I live in right now the issue or
- 38:33not. I'm not saying that like of
- 38:34course you have more in common with people who aren't, I mean,
- 38:37I grew up in a small town in Vermont, you grew up in a small
- 38:38town, in Georgia, we probably have more in common with one
- 38:41another. Then we do with a lot of the
- 38:42people who grew up and we would leave.
- 38:44Right that we would leave is the key thing.
- 38:47There are still things that because I'm old I still feel
- 38:51very connected to a small, much more Blue Collar town in Vermont
- 38:58than I do in a lot of ways. Will the people?
- 39:00I spent a lot of time with in Washington DC or New York and I
- 39:03think it is that connection that makes me want to solve a problem
- 39:06like. Well I don't want kids in
- 39:08Vermont getting shot, I think that's bad but the more and more
- 39:12I don't have that connection then I'm like yeah, I keep a
- 39:16promise that we have these are the government is set up like we
- 39:19have a bunch of Californians upset about what's happening in
- 39:22like Alabama Mississippi and it's just like to some degree,
- 39:25the composition of our government doesn't really align
- 39:29Line with this Society, we better just if we just like had
- 39:32governments that were more reflective of the populace.
- 39:35I mean the the minority rule in the United States, being a being
- 39:38a key problem. And I had to solve that, I'd be
- 39:40more inclined to split it up, then to live under minority
- 39:43rule, you know. Yeah, and you're right, like, so
- 39:45if people like I think education is an interesting problem like
- 39:49very wealthy people in California, New York and stuff
- 39:52started trying to buy Local School Board elections in states
- 39:57where they thought they could make more of a difference than
- 39:58California. York but it's sort of like bolt.
- 40:01Maybe if you felt a little bit more attached to your community,
- 40:05you could just try to solve the problem of that state like state
- 40:08governments and sort of like what's going on in States has
- 40:11been really impacted by the phenomenon, just described.
- 40:13But I mean I think it's another version of well the more we see
- 40:17ourselves as detached from our communities and more you know
- 40:21like-minded with people who are not anywhere geographically near
- 40:24us and we want to affect change at that level.
- 40:27There is still some governance happening.
- 40:29Below. You just are not attachment and
- 40:31then you get kind of surprised when I work out, right?
- 40:34The back to how that related to tick.
- 40:36Tock and Tom's point about the line, you know, the note the the
- 40:39short, the short lines are no lines to see the TIC top
- 40:42celebrities. I mean, I think there is
- 40:45something about Tick Tock that's missing that kind of that that
- 40:48attachment. And I think that that's not that
- 40:50that's going to be their Achilles heel.
- 40:52But I think it's important to remember that, you know, there
- 40:56are all these new apps always coming up and you know, The
- 40:59youth, whatever the youth culture, isn't, I'm like
- 41:01gravitates toward these apps, right?
- 41:03And like I remember it was interesting at the code.
- 41:05Conferencing Evan, Spiegel up on stage, getting all these
- 41:09questions about Tick-Tock and I could almost see like him
- 41:13thinking, like, well that I was Tick-Tock, you know, like four
- 41:15years ago like everyone was like Snapchats going to take over the
- 41:19world and now it's sort of this also-ran and Facebook is still
- 41:23just as powerful as they were then.
- 41:25And you know I could totally see that happening with Tick-Tock.
- 41:29I mean it Eventually, like, I don't see that becoming the new
- 41:32Facebook. I see it becoming more like a
- 41:34Snapchat in the future. As some new thing comes out that
- 41:37attracts the young people. Yeah, I actually had a piece
- 41:41this week but showed that tick-tocks year-over-year growth
- 41:44is slowing. So, it's not like, you know, I
- 41:46think there is an expectation that it's going to continue on
- 41:49this Torrid Pace forever. But, you know, that's just not
- 41:52possible. In terms of the law of large
- 41:53numbers. And there probably is also going
- 41:55to be like a generational issue. At some point with the users.
- 41:58The there was a pretty Fascinating hearing that
- 42:00happened this last week. It was another one of those you
- 42:03know, Congress drags a bunch of social media Executives and brow
- 42:08beats them for like a couple of hours on C-Span to type
- 42:12hearings. But this one was interesting to
- 42:13me because Vanessa Pappas who is the CEO of tick-tock was there
- 42:17and she really got a grilling from a lot of the top lawmakers
- 42:21including including Josh Howley, who basically.
- 42:26I mean he went like toe-to-toe with her wasn't we can we go
- 42:28toe-to-toe with us Editor. Basically, he was trying to get
- 42:31her to answer the question of like, how many people in the CCP
- 42:34work for tick tock or work for B dance?
- 42:36Which, you know, she's like doing her best to avoid that
- 42:38question. Because, you know, we don't
- 42:40give, you know, whatever party affiliation test of people that
- 42:43joined the company was like, I don't know, all of them, but
- 42:46also their. Right?
- 42:47There's like not only gives you can be like, I'm trying to use
- 42:51it but I'm sort of like, not into the like, I I supported
- 42:55different. I supported different political
- 42:57party in China. I'm with the greens.
- 42:59The lot of greens over in B. This know there's a bunch of I'm
- 43:04sure the place is mostly full of, you know, CCP members and
- 43:07she's like doing the alternative is.
- 43:09There is no alternative. You are PCP member essentially a
- 43:12citizen in China. You don't want to be like, fuck
- 43:14it. I'm a Libertarian.
- 43:15It's obviously an insane Quest me.
- 43:17You're saying this Katie but I mean, it is the wrong question
- 43:19because total a, if you ask people, if you ask people in the
- 43:23US like at, you know, how many you know how often do you like
- 43:26comply with national National Security?
- 43:29Guests from the US government when it's like, like we'll all
- 43:31the time. Like, that's what we do.
- 43:33We're Americans, right, we're gonna support the American
- 43:36government. I think it's just like all these
- 43:39things about like, well, there are laws in China that Force
- 43:42these companies to share data. If they are asked and it's like,
- 43:45we basically have the same thing here, it's just the differences,
- 43:49you know, we're a country where a democracy, we have rule of
- 43:52law, you know, obviously there are flaws, but like, you know,
- 43:55we're not we trust our government because it's ours, I
- 43:57mean, to some degree, I think what we're saying, We don't need
- 43:59the questions. It's like it's obvious like
- 44:02yeah, China is a controlled country by a single party that's
- 44:06like hostile, the United States in a lot of ways.
- 44:08And like, why do we need to interview Tick-Tock about their
- 44:11policies to come to a decision? Like either?
- 44:13It's like we're okay, well, because they want the audio B,
- 44:16they want to break. Yeah.
- 44:17Video clip right? Let's just like do it or don't
- 44:19but like I don't know what information you're getting out
- 44:21of this laughs cause Josh Holly's going to probably run
- 44:23for president and so he's going to use that clip.
- 44:27It would be great if a republican had a, you know, A
- 44:29policy agenda. I'd love to see it, you know,
- 44:31Peter teal actually gave an interesting speech at a national
- 44:35conservative convention and he, well, of course, most of it was
- 44:38spent criticizing the left, which he basically described as
- 44:41like, the California ideology the sort of rallying Cry of this
- 44:45speech was that Republicans are fundamentally running on like
- 44:49nihilism. They don't have any real
- 44:51legenda. They need like a substantive
- 44:53policy agenda. So it was, it was sort of, I'm
- 44:56not the only one saying it, I'm saying, Peter teal is also
- 44:58critical. Of the lack of Republican agenda
- 45:02at the moment anyway, right? Yeah.
- 45:04The Peter teal ideology, though is like getting lots of like
- 45:06German blood, infused and so, like our eldest smartest
- 45:09Americans that we can rejuvenate our thinking class.
- 45:12Okay. Okay.
- 45:15Yeah, I know. But anyway, just to finish it
- 45:21off with Tick-Tock. I mean, I feel a little bit for
- 45:23Vanessa, Papa's over a tick tock, because she's really just
- 45:25like a punching bag for these people at this point.
- 45:27And I don't think she has this. She's getting paid.
- 45:29Before. Well, it's also the role of
- 45:30anybody who goes before a congressional panel, right?
- 45:33But she in particular because she has no control over this app
- 45:36and what we've seen with with Tick-Tock is they've tried over
- 45:39and over again to put on all of these safeguards and
- 45:41transparencies and things that they claim can do to avoid like,
- 45:45some sort of, you know, some sort of incursion on American
- 45:48data. But when it comes down to it,
- 45:50this is a company that is owned by a massive Chinese.
- 45:55You know, a massive Chinese company whose like own CEO is
- 45:58sort of afraid of the CCP. And so there's just no way you
- 46:01can put any sort of Safeguard in there that's going to one pass
- 46:04muster in the US but also meaningfully change.
- 46:06The fundamentals of how this company works and so it's all
- 46:09kind of an insane. Kabuki theater that I mean, we
- 46:12sort of touched on this earlier but I just don't see how it
- 46:14doesn't end towards some sort of like amputation.
- 46:16Thank a tectonic. You read his piece is saying
- 46:20that he thought a band was coming or I did.
- 46:22He say it expressly or seems like it's getting bipartisan,
- 46:25right? I guess that's sort of the point
- 46:26is that you're seeing now, I guess, ban is a tricky word
- 46:28because it As you know, read and Katie point out earlier there
- 46:31are like First Amendment issues when it comes to that, but I
- 46:34just don't see how we're not going to end up revisiting the
- 46:36entire cycle that we had in summer of 2020, where it really
- 46:39looked like Tick-Tock was going to have to be amputated.
- 46:42It would have been funny if Trump did it.
- 46:43Like is classic Trump that it's like to try it.
- 46:46Do something, you know, I've complicated well, he couldn't do
- 46:49it. I mean, he tried, right?
- 46:50You actually have to be able to get the bureaucrats below you to
- 46:53do it, you know, he was basically going to lose.
- 46:55He actually had to work through the lovers or government to
- 46:58articulate an Right. Like he's like, he's like
- 47:00they're a threat. But then the people on this
- 47:03committee have to actually show where it as a threat he was
- 47:06going to lose in court but the bipartisan point is a good one.
- 47:09I mean if there are new laws created, right the right law
- 47:12could potentially indirectly or maybe directly result in a for
- 47:17all intents and purposes ban of tick-tock, right?
- 47:20I mean that could happen but I think any time you're talking
- 47:23about laws and bipartisan you know like high-profile balls
- 47:27being made like it's a big if right.
- 47:29Right, so I'm not holding my breath but I do think
- 47:32something's gonna happen. I also I wanted to ask you guys
- 47:36though what you think about this?
- 47:37Because I have this question all the time when it comes to data
- 47:41and Tick-Tock it's like well we we read all the time.
- 47:45You know, the New York Times as a great job of writing these
- 47:47stories about the data that you can just buy on the open market
- 47:51about people that's been collected from all these firms
- 47:54and then combined, and it's like, couldn't they just buy
- 47:57this data? I mean, I'm at data so they'll
- 48:00kind of don't need Tick-Tock for collection.
- 48:01That is the thing that like I think that no politician wants
- 48:05to say because everybody's trying to run on this issue but
- 48:08like China, it literally does not need to have any apps in the
- 48:12United States. It can just buy the data
- 48:14collected from all the other apps in the United States.
- 48:17That then bundle it and make a significant amount of their
- 48:19revenue just selling it and that is fine.
- 48:21That's an open Global Market because hackers buy it,
- 48:25criminals by it, why not the Chinese government.
- 48:27They're not restrictions I really My concern is, it's not
- 48:30about the data, it's the control to me.
- 48:32I mean not, I mean, I know people talk about the data but
- 48:35like if Tick Tock said, oh, we want Americans to think 20% more
- 48:39about sports and 20% less about politics because that's in our
- 48:42like that would have a huge impact on to do.
- 48:45You mean like, I just feel like there are a lot of subtle
- 48:48already do that. Like no.
- 48:49Yeah, Katie makes a good point. Yeah, but at least Facebook does
- 48:52it Facebook doesn't because of some like, you know, terrible
- 48:55corporate interests. That's when but to have faith to
- 48:58have Tick, Tock, do it? Where it's like, perhaps in the
- 49:01National interest in some subtle way.
- 49:03That's like, that's really our, that's the thing.
- 49:06That's what the CIA wants, you know, like that's has real power
- 49:09to and Samaritan, I mean, but it's America, but that doesn't
- 49:13mean it works in American interest.
- 49:14The idea that Facebook is working in American interest,
- 49:17has been disgraced so many times.
- 49:20Ben Shapiro, into your veins, like the video.
- 49:23I mean, just the amount of effort it took to get social
- 49:26media companies to not show all those beheadings.
- 49:29That were being used in Isis recruitment for months and
- 49:32months and months and they refused to take them down.
- 49:34It's like, anybody could tell you that, that would be in the
- 49:37National interest to not be used as a tool to recruit for Isis.
- 49:41And the tech companies were told that and they even agreed, but
- 49:44they were like there's a lot of traffic to these beheading
- 49:46videos. So I mean, I don't think that
- 49:48you're you could say that just because they're American
- 49:50companies are working in American interest, but I'm sure
- 49:53this argument that you two are having right now is the right
- 49:56argument to have. Because, if the, if Katie's Then
- 50:00there's really no point to doing any of this until like, any of
- 50:04this Tick-Tock stuff until you Shore up the whole market,
- 50:07right? Like you have to fix data
- 50:09collection, on the whole from any company and you have to fix
- 50:13the abuse and manipulation of social media, whether it's based
- 50:17here, or anywhere of my face is gonna get spy.
- 50:20Did I want to spite my own face? I don't want someone else biting
- 50:24my face, we could be in a really funny position where Tick-Tock
- 50:27is far more regulated and Farm. More safe than any American
- 50:30company, right? It's like, it's like you have a
- 50:36little tiny leak that you're plugging with your finger.
- 50:38And meanwhile, like there's just waves crashing over the side of
- 50:42the boat and like sinking you. It's like what's the point,
- 50:44right? I can see it.
- 50:46I want to see the moment in America.
- 50:47Let's just go down this road where they met somehow.
- 50:49Magically do decide the band Tick.
- 50:51Tock the like 24 to 72 hour period.
- 50:54Where the teens are like not allowed teams.
- 50:56That don't know. I gonna do, I'm gonna be like a
- 50:58lot of my thoughts. We're going to make a little
- 51:00Revolution. It's like, what are we supposed
- 51:02to do now? Well, if you're smart, you'll
- 51:03lead that Revolution. Because I think it is going to
- 51:05be tens of millions of people who are going to go through
- 51:07serious withdrawals that have no idea.
- 51:10You know, how to manage themselves on a, you know, an
- 51:12hour by hour bait minute, second-by-second basis, it'll be
- 51:16a crisis of its own. You know, it's like investment
- 51:19over here. Five minutes until right.
- 51:21Yeah. The rise of Yik Yak again, just
- 51:23wait it out. That's right.
- 51:26Right. Okay.
- 51:26So in our last couple of minutes here I thought we could Do a
- 51:29shark shark, swerve away from Tech and talk a little bit about
- 51:33philanthropy. Do you guys want to talk a
- 51:34little bit about Patagonia? Yeah, sure.
- 51:37Is it controversial article now, that's why I'm okay, why is it
- 51:40controversial explain that part to me.
- 51:42Okay, can we just quickly Define it before we get into the car?
- 51:51And you're arguing about it, hopefully somewhere some diem
- 51:53threader. Okay.
- 51:54So the CEO of Patagonia decided to sell his company.
- 51:59To a trust, a sort of trust and series of nonprofits, that will
- 52:03basically push all of the company's annual profits, which
- 52:07were like a hundred million dollars a year to go towards
- 52:10efforts that are to fight global warming just Pro environmental.
- 52:13Causes he still remained has voting control of the company,
- 52:16but it sort of has raised the question again of philanthropy.
- 52:20And whether or not, this was truly an altruistic way to take
- 52:25his largesse and fight global warming or he just wanted to do
- 52:28a giant tax. It's Dodge and avoid putting
- 52:31that money through the levers of public control that would have
- 52:35probably done just to be clear the extended to tax Dodge.
- 52:38It's that he didn't like sell his company.
- 52:40It's it's not like he's using this to hide taxes.
- 52:44It's that if he had exited in normal way.
- 52:47You would have had a big tax bill which to me is a pretty big
- 52:50intellectual contortion as a tax Dodge attacks judge to me, is
- 52:54normally, you have a tax bill and you pay less on it because
- 52:57you're using the Some not just like you're not selling
- 53:01something you're not making money off of it.
- 53:02Yeah, there's there's a complications around that in
- 53:05multiple ways. And also, I do think we can just
- 53:07add very quickly here that this is like a couple of weeks after
- 53:11Republican, or conservative billionaire.
- 53:13One of the bad guys. Yeah, one of the bad guys are
- 53:15basically the same thing donating his his company to us a
- 53:19501 C 4. Oh yes which all of that money
- 53:22is going to go towards, you know, fighting, you know,
- 53:24transgender bathrooms or some shit like that.
- 53:26We against voting rights against climate.
- 53:29Reform against what's the third pot?
- 53:31Helping helping the fucking the Federalist Society or whatever.
- 53:35Stack, the court with Republican judges.
- 53:37Like, it's like, it's like Godzilla and Camara of
- 53:40billionaires on the left of which is this is spoil my
- 53:43framing. If it's not obvious to me is the
- 53:45obvious like, good bad. What's the difference with
- 53:47journalists? Like I want to I want to cut to
- 53:49read on this point because you know, long time Outdoorsman
- 53:54there's a lot of Patagonia lives in Marin County, the Patagonia
- 53:57Capital. It is the only one Among Us.
- 53:59Actually enjoys nature on a regular basis.
- 54:02The rest of us to do disproportionately by from
- 54:04Patagonia, if you're Outdoors, where II don't think I own any
- 54:08Patagonia stuff, but I do look. I think I think Vaughn jernard
- 54:12is like the real deal. I think we kind of all agree on
- 54:15that, right? I mean we're not.
- 54:16The argument isn't whether he liked, but I have people who are
- 54:19like this is why I'm so curious. I'm like, what?
- 54:21The controversy again, but keep going to controversy.
- 54:23I think the controversy is frame.
- 54:25It's more like, it's more of a, the System is more immediate
- 54:30criticism, right? Because the New York Times
- 54:31article the tone of this, this article about jernard is like
- 54:35very different than the tone of the one about the Republican
- 54:38donor, and it, basically, the David jealous of the New York
- 54:41Times, who is like, what he his column was like columnist.
- 54:45So he has a voice. He's a professional way of
- 54:48writing, very positive things about billionaires.
- 54:51I think there's one. I think there's one question in
- 54:54the in the New York Times article and it was nice not
- 54:58enough. Not.
- 54:59Hired by the deer and times at this point.
- 55:02I know, I think that he is in describing the tax liabilities,
- 55:07he sort of described. I think the argument is that
- 55:10that I saw from some tax experts on Twitter.
- 55:14Is that for all intensive purposes, the tax liability
- 55:17issue around what, you know, the Patagonia situation and the one
- 55:21with the conservative company is basically the same and yet.
- 55:25Gals described it as you know, shoe nard basically.
- 55:29We paying all of his taxes and not trying to avoid any taxes
- 55:32whereas the other one was described.
- 55:34As, you know, a series of unusual Financial transactions
- 55:38to avoid taxes and dark money. I think there's a question there
- 55:42but see the dark money part of it.
- 55:44That criticism doesn't make any sense because they refer to the
- 55:47Republican as dark money and jernard as, you know, whatever
- 55:51philanthropist. And there's a very different,
- 55:54the big difference there because the times basically uncovered
- 55:57that whole His transaction was a dark.
- 56:01They were right? It's like you.
- 56:03If you give it away, if you give away your money, right?
- 56:09And you say it just gave it two years Max.
- 56:11It would be a totally different narrative.
- 56:13That's it. If you say I'm giving away my
- 56:16money thing, everybody likes. No, it's not that.
- 56:20It's like, if you say, I'm giving away my money and here's
- 56:23what I'm giving it away for and I'm going to do a press release
- 56:27in an interview about it and everyone can know.
- 56:29No, then is it really dark money?
- 56:31Whereas in the in the other situation where you have this
- 56:34Republican donor you know it had been secretly transferred to a
- 56:39501 c 3 and then secretly sold to another company.
- 56:43And then the proceeds were secretly transferred back to
- 56:46this charity, and it was like, it was all done in secret.
- 56:50And the only reason anyone knows about it is that there was some
- 56:53Insider who leaked the tax records.
- 56:56So to me that's the difference. Is it 501?
- 57:00C 3 or 501 C 4 5 and C 4? Which is the shrine art.
- 57:03I don't, I'm assuming. Yeah, it was the same thing with
- 57:05the resort both. They're not like nonprofits
- 57:08because they know it's little bits are able to give unlimited
- 57:12political donations to packs. Right.
- 57:14Which could be, you know, if you wanted to could be secret,
- 57:18right? But the difference is Patagonia,
- 57:20doesn't want it to be secret. So I think that's the I think
- 57:23that's a huge difference. It's like if your paperwork
- 57:25basically allows you to be dark money, but you don't, Want to be
- 57:29dark money, so you announce it and do a big article about York
- 57:32Times that you're not funny anymore.
- 57:34That's my, that's my opinion. And I, this is thinking, we told
- 57:39you, I actually did reporting on this for this podcast.
- 57:46I emailed Patagonia. And I asked like, do you know,
- 57:49are you going to basically be transparent and like, tell us if
- 57:52there are any other donors, you know, or if you give to Super
- 57:56Pacs and they basically were like, yeah, we're you know Tell
- 57:59you what we do, but they have no reason to not be right because
- 58:03their whole brand and their whole, you know, thing is like
- 58:06they want people to buy their stuff because they're doing this
- 58:09work. This particular work, whether
- 58:11you think it's good or bad whereas on the Republican side
- 58:14it's like there's a lot of obfuscation, a lot of because
- 58:17they don't really want their motives to be known, right?
- 58:20They want there's like all this astroturfing that goes on and so
- 58:23I think that's the I mean you might agree with what they're
- 58:25doing ideologically and that's fine, but like the it is all
- 58:29Done in secret and that is the dark part, right?
- 58:31I guess. Like my argument here, also, I
- 58:34mean, there's the other part of this, which is like are, you
- 58:37know, 501, C 4 S or trusts and other kind of nonprofits the
- 58:42best stewards of this capital in order to fight global climate
- 58:46change rather than just going to the tent.
- 58:48I'd rather than just having government, they will have
- 58:49companies aren't going to pay their fucking taxes and what the
- 58:51government distributed I guess, it is what we've got, right.
- 58:55But it seems, I mean it gets completed, just passed a huge
- 58:58climb. Built to be clear.
- 59:00I mean, are we? We're so used to nihilism about
- 59:03the federal rather than like it's not right?
- 59:05Yeah, we did. But we did do it, you know, like
- 59:10but like there's no question that the actual ability to fight
- 59:12climate change which is a global apocalyptic issue, you know,
- 59:15requires deals made between like, you know, India and China
- 59:19and like huge emitters of carbon into the atmosphere that know,
- 59:24you know, nonprofit or trust is actually going to be able to
- 59:26stop. So if your, if your true goal Is
- 59:29to stop this Global issue. I don't really think this is a
- 59:33matter of like billionaires, putting a little bit of, you
- 59:35know, or all of their money towards these private
- 59:37institutions that are going to be, you know, they're not going
- 59:39to go, she ate with the Indian government so like have them
- 59:42invest more in renewable but it's multi-pronged and like I
- 59:46mean multi you Tom I agree. Completely Patagonia is not
- 59:50going to solve climate change and they're probably not even
- 59:53going to make a dent in climate change.
- 59:55I think. Yeah, I think what it's really
- 59:56about is it's like come He's never have Happy Endings and I
- 1:00:01don't think shoe nard wanted to become Ben and Jerry's and have
- 1:00:04his company sold to Unilever. You know, which is what happened
- 1:00:07like against their will. And then, all of the things they
- 1:00:11stand for basically go out the window because, like,
- 1:00:13eventually, that's what would have happened.
- 1:00:15Like Patagonia would have been if you didn't do this, they
- 1:00:17would eventually just been bought by some private Equity
- 1:00:19Firm and they'd be sold in Target and like, you know, none
- 1:00:22of this stuff. He's what Sam look.
- 1:00:23Sam lesson Had A provocative argument that I think is correct
- 1:00:27that basically if they wanted Maximize the help for the
- 1:00:30environment. They would have sold the company
- 1:00:32taken the cash, and then do whatever they want and that
- 1:00:35paying out whatever like a hundred million dollars.
- 1:00:37A year is not the best way to help the environment.
- 1:00:40And like I said, what did he then?
- 1:00:42Just get a one-time payment. I'm not sure.
- 1:00:44Yeah. Yeah, but with the company, I
- 1:00:45think of it, like, a VC, you know, it's just like, oh, better
- 1:00:48exit. If you sell rather than if you
- 1:00:49go to like this, the company really going to be really well
- 1:00:52running this structure. I think a key piece of this,
- 1:00:54he's still running it, he still has voting control right?
- 1:00:56If the company's well-run or not, well, Ren who knows but
- 1:00:59Like that's like, saying the Harvard endowment should just be
- 1:01:02like a one-time thing and like shouldn't invest blowing, just
- 1:01:06get a giant pot of money and then just spend that money for
- 1:01:09the next hundred years. You know, it's cool, doesn't
- 1:01:12make any sense, but I think part of the issue is that Patagonia
- 1:01:14wants to run the business in a way that it's like a great deal.
- 1:01:16You know, employees get paid above market and treated better
- 1:01:19than they would expected another company.
- 1:01:21So, there's sort of two causes of Patagonia one that they think
- 1:01:25the company running as it is is a good thing in that like They
- 1:01:29have a community of people get treated well, and they believe
- 1:01:31in their products. And to this the environmental
- 1:01:34payoff which used to be with the family got paid.
- 1:01:37I mean, I think it's a pretty good.
- 1:01:38I think this makes sense. I mean, it's nice to have a
- 1:01:40company where people get bit, but I really like patagonia's
- 1:01:43goal, was to have happy employees.
- 1:01:46Yeah. They're one of the first
- 1:01:47companies to do that to write. Their goal was not to be Walmart
- 1:01:51right there and it was that bad. Like it's his company, it's his
- 1:01:55he wants to, he's like, this is my company, this is my goal.
- 1:01:58If we're So cynical, the reporters can't be like this is
- 1:02:01what being good in business. Looks like I just feel like we
- 1:02:04have both sides. Ours.
- 1:02:07We're just like part of Journalism is trying to clarify
- 1:02:10and if we're like so confused if we're like, oh, I don't know.
- 1:02:13We need to just like question everything, you can't be like,
- 1:02:16oh, not taking the money for yourself, giving it to a cause
- 1:02:19that most people think is good setting up a company.
- 1:02:22That's good for your employees being trapped, like, read
- 1:02:24saying, being transparent about what you're doing and proud of
- 1:02:27it and saying I don't want to be rich and It's sort of tacky to
- 1:02:29be so rich, like those are good things.
- 1:02:31We should praise those and if we can't do, that journalism is
- 1:02:35failing and we're just like, we believe in losers.
- 1:02:38Totally. Like I totally agree.
- 1:02:40It means that we've been watched especially as business
- 1:02:42journalists into believing that maximizing profits is an
- 1:02:44ultimate good, and that there can be no other good, right.
- 1:02:48If you think of it as like private Equity or just like,
- 1:02:50well, he left money on the table.
- 1:02:51That's effectively what that's saying, right?
- 1:02:53Exactly. And that's and I think that
- 1:02:55like, that, even that way of thinking it's funny, there's a
- 1:02:57book on Milton That came out. I think last year that before
- 1:03:01the year before that really attacked this idea of like of
- 1:03:04profits and virtue being the same thing.
- 1:03:07And I think there's another book that's coming out soon, that
- 1:03:09sort of from a different angle from like a more data-driven
- 1:03:12angle attacks the same thing. So I think I'm hoping that
- 1:03:15there's a cultural shift away from this idea that has had a
- 1:03:19Stranglehold on culture and on business reporting as I'm as
- 1:03:24guilty as anyone that maximizing profits.
- 1:03:29Smizing profits for shareholders is the ultimate good and your
- 1:03:31alternate Duty as a CEO. And if you're not doing that,
- 1:03:34you're doing something wrong. And I hope to God, that I did
- 1:03:36dies a fucking down. The company still needs to be
- 1:03:39well run and profitable to pay off.
- 1:03:42Absolutely. You can be well, Ben and
- 1:03:44Jerry's, a great example. It was a well-run company that
- 1:03:47made money interested in profit. Well, Max you can go round in
- 1:03:52circles about this. There is a great presentation at
- 1:03:54Kota re down of you washed it by NYU professor.
- 1:03:59Whose name I'm blanking on they just like the ESG shareholder
- 1:04:03capitalism movement. I think is somewhat manipulative
- 1:04:06and gives you as a lot of control to justify its G.
- 1:04:09Yes. G you know environmental social
- 1:04:11like like these sort of stocks that are picked based on how
- 1:04:14like good for the environment they are but like somehow
- 1:04:17Tesla's never on the list and like, like, gas oil, and gas
- 1:04:21companies are I mean, there's a lot of like, I don't know.
- 1:04:23Anyway, I still think I believe in profits, but I think this is
- 1:04:26aligned with like a profit. Well, in Orion, I don't I never
- 1:04:29said in anything. I just said that profits are
- 1:04:31bad, okay? I mean, I'm saying that we
- 1:04:34believe is business reporters, that maximizing profits above
- 1:04:38everything else, so paying your employees as little as possible,
- 1:04:41not giving them Health Care, not giving them content schedule, so
- 1:04:44they can rely on right there. We really the profitability it's
- 1:04:47because it makes the subjective. He has been squeezed out of
- 1:04:50their company and the to go from, you know, making like two
- 1:04:54dollars per share in earnings, versus a dollar eighty because
- 1:04:58you wanted your Employees, have health care.
- 1:05:00What the fuck I mean? Like I don't think most business
- 1:05:03reporters have this ideology, we went through this.
- 1:05:04What we have all these labor business reporters?
- 1:05:06We had all these. No no I think we do have the
- 1:05:11ideology, we don't intend to. That's not how we think about
- 1:05:13it. It's like when you're writing
- 1:05:14your average earnings report as a crime reporter, right?
- 1:05:17You're like Starbucks, you know, did x y and so it be earnings.
- 1:05:21And so you started getting this getting into this mindset that
- 1:05:24like, because they beat earnings by a penny, a share of the
- 1:05:26company's doing well and you're never incentivized to look.
- 1:05:28Under the hood and be like, what the fuck is Starbucks doing to
- 1:05:30its employees? Like, what is it nests?
- 1:05:33Would it be net? Would it be okay for them to not
- 1:05:35beat by a penny, a share? If they allowed people to have a
- 1:05:38regular schedule and and are they a good CEO, right?
- 1:05:41I mean, that's like the, the mark of whether or not they're a
- 1:05:42successful CEO is whether or not they are maximizing shareholder
- 1:05:45value and, you know, dividends and other aspects of their
- 1:05:49profit going to pay. You know, like that.
- 1:05:51That's the effectiveness of their of their job performance
- 1:05:53II. Think you're right.
- 1:05:54Katie, I think I would add though.
- 1:05:56There's another type of reporter who is also A problem, which is
- 1:06:00the one who is, sort of anti-capitalist right now, or,
- 1:06:04you know, doesn't believe in the in like, you know, profit as the
- 1:06:07ultimate motive and wants to see companies do altruistic things
- 1:06:11and then gets like sucked into these, like, total greenwashing
- 1:06:15like marketing. Ploys, by these big companies
- 1:06:18that, you know, and then write about like as if they are
- 1:06:21altruistic. It's like almost like an
- 1:06:23aspirational thing. And the sad thing is and this
- 1:06:27Eric you kind of made this point.
- 1:06:28It's like, Like somehow we have a hard time telling the
- 1:06:30difference between the green washing and then like genuine
- 1:06:33efforts like Patagonia here, like with somebody who I think
- 1:06:37is the real deal. You know, doing trying to do the
- 1:06:39right thing. It's just, you know, it's just
- 1:06:41it is kind of sad, right? The way I see it too.
- 1:06:44Is like, I think what you have to accept what chouinard is that
- 1:06:48he's a capitalist and he is going about this in the best
- 1:06:51possible way that capitalism will allow for, which is putting
- 1:06:54this company in the, you know, in the responsibility of or like
- 1:06:58with Stewart's, have someone whose sole goal is to further
- 1:07:02that initiative? Now if you don't believe that
- 1:07:03capitalism, what's the best version after that?
- 1:07:06Like, well, if you don't believe that capitalism is the right
- 1:07:09model. Okay.
- 1:07:10Well, that fighting global warming.
- 1:07:11I know I'm sick of this like I'm sick but so that's an argument.
- 1:07:15You can have though but I think I think the mistake people make
- 1:07:17is thinking that there's some better way within the system,
- 1:07:20right. He could have done it which I
- 1:07:21just don't agree with it was this magical new system.
- 1:07:24Like it's like the only thing I could have done is run for
- 1:07:27office. Become a senator And passed
- 1:07:29legislation. Other than that, he's using the
- 1:07:31tools he's given, like, I think he should be given more than
- 1:07:35just one Senator, right? He'd have to clone himself
- 1:07:38become 20th senators from Key swing state.
- 1:07:41And by the way, if their profit was being used towards that
- 1:07:44technology, I think you have something here.
- 1:07:46I think you'd be a real surprise if Patagonia was secretly
- 1:07:48working with, you know, crisper and and we bring on cloning a
- 1:07:53different Church. Yeah, but no.
- 1:07:55I think, yeah, I guess it's just more like accepting that the
- 1:07:58Them has this is the best possible outcome, it could have.
- 1:08:01And if you believe in it, then it deserves it serves accolades
- 1:08:04is sort of where I stand with it.
- 1:08:06All also, we should acknowledge, I won't do anything and global
- 1:08:08warming is inevitable, but that's a side point.
- 1:08:10I just think it would be so incredible to Patagonia just
- 1:08:12keeps on going forever. Like as this great, you know,
- 1:08:15employee-friendly company or people go surfing at lunch and
- 1:08:18Ventura and you know, they sell cool clothes that, you know, her
- 1:08:23high-end or whatever. And, you know, they try to do
- 1:08:25their best, they're not going to obviously save the world but
- 1:08:28they'll try to Do their best like that would be incredible.
- 1:08:30Like, that's a result. I never would it would, it would
- 1:08:32have expected. Yeah, in small businesses are,
- 1:08:34you know, like not it's not that small.
- 1:08:36What? It's like a three billion dollar
- 1:08:37company. But yeah, we want more companies
- 1:08:39of that size to succeed. I think that's, that's the
- 1:08:43dream. So, yeah, we have a moment of
- 1:08:46optimism here, too. I think is still scrambling to
- 1:08:49find some way to be cynical about it, but I'm not worried as
- 1:08:52I've said, if I'm gonna, if I'm gonna believe in the system,
- 1:08:55then this is the best possible outcome.
- 1:08:58Yeah. Nothing podcast to take down the
- 1:09:00system. Well, look, we got exactly what
- 1:09:02we wanted out of read, which was with some interesting thinking.
- 1:09:04We got some, some good thoughts. We got some optimism.
- 1:09:07Here's everything. You wouldn't get out of me but
- 1:09:09you got all the credit. Anyway, thanks, thanks so much
- 1:09:14for joining. Congrats on the launch of some
- 1:09:16of wins. It launched, we know is there a
- 1:09:17day? It's going to be next.
- 1:09:19We haven't announced an exact date but you know, you know,
- 1:09:22will say in the fall. Not exactly sure what I'm
- 1:09:24allowed to say right now. But this is so much fun.
- 1:09:27I you know it's great. Rate was like you know even
- 1:09:30better than a phone call catcher's mask and your kids are
- 1:09:34not like breaking down the door trying to get in.
- 1:09:36So I'm glad we gave you was actually kind of scary.
- 1:09:38Yeah. What's going on out there?
- 1:09:40I love to imagine that our phone call catch up, Sir.
- 1:09:42Just like let's argue about the substantive issues for like an
- 1:09:45hour and 20 minutes. All right, thanks, thank you.
- 1:09:52Bye. Goodbye.
- 1:10:06Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:10:09Goodbye.