Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Boundaries
Transcript
- 0:00Hayes our listeners. So I thought I would read your emails and answer them
- 0:05today, and I came across one email from Famous Patron Lindon or FPL.
- 0:11He is a listener to the podcast that goes back I think maybe to like
- 0:15twenty thirteen or something. He was a big part of our lives because he
- 0:21would send in these questions that were just so smart and thought provoking. And
- 0:28he is still around and sent this really thought provoking email, and so I
- 0:32thought I would dedicate today's episode to answering it. He is asking about boundaries
- 0:38and systems theory and about the culture that will co opt certain words like boundaries,
- 0:46and it's pretty complicated. I think it'll give me a chance to talk
- 0:50about things that I don't normally get to talk about. This will get pretty
- 0:53technical, I think, because I think we're going to get into a lot
- 0:56of technical language, clinical language around systems and boundaries and differentiation Manuchen, Bowen,
- 1:03all that stuff. And I'm actually recording this intro after I recorded the
- 1:07whole response to his email. Maybe that'll help as a ford. So let's
- 1:11get into the beginning of the episode. When I stopped talking, Now it'll
- 1:15be going back in time when I first started reading his email, FPL says,
- 1:21I've been thinking about writing a few things. Oh first off, hi
- 1:23Kirk, A long time, No, right, I've been thinking about writing
- 1:26a few things recently. And I found this article and thought you might find
- 1:32it interesting. It's about boundaries, and the article mentions Manuchen, Bowen,
- 1:36et cetera. All right, so just chiming in here, So FBL sending
- 1:40this article in boundaries that mentions Mnuchen Bowen, So you know these are family
- 1:46therapist theorists who talked a lot of particularly Mnuchen talked about boundaries. Bowen did
- 1:52as well. So yeah, those are two good things to mention going on
- 1:55here. In a move not uncommon with writers and it sorry, in a
- 2:00move not uncommon with writers and edutainment, the article critiques the concept but actually
- 2:07gives some credit to it early on, So they're saying that the article critiques
- 2:14the concept of boundaries and gives credit to it. Okay, And then there's
- 2:19a quote here, most actual boundaries experts would agree that telling your partner who
- 2:24to spend time with is a symptom of terrible boundaries. End of quote.
- 2:30And then FPL goes on to say, I'm not sure what an actual boundaries
- 2:34expert is. I confess I somewhat took the idea of boundaries as a good
- 2:38thing at face value, but I still have some sympathy for the political and
- 2:43cultural arguments later and the piece. So just jumming in here. Yeah,
- 2:46So, first off, we have to define what boundaries are, and the
- 2:50typical usage among lay people is that, and really even therapists outside of marriages
- 2:58and family therapy, and really there's a lot of marriage family therapists who use
- 3:00the word boundary wrong. You know, wrong. I will say, yeah,
- 3:07I'll say wrong because they are family therapists that will say, well,
- 3:12as Minuchin said about boundaries, and then they head into this area. I'm
- 3:15like, you don't understand what boundaries are. It's kind of hard to understand,
- 3:19honestly, because but in a nutshell, what the family theorists would say
- 3:24about boundaries is that a boundary exists between two elements. Commonly, we might
- 3:30say that there's a boundary between you and another person, right, but there
- 3:37can also be boundaries around an entire family, or around a couple and the
- 3:42rest of the world, or between the hierarchy and the family You can have
- 3:46a boundary between the parents and the children, right. You can have a
- 3:51boundary between you and politics, or you and the internet. Right. So
- 3:55it's just a way of talking about how how permeable and how flexible that boundary
- 4:03is. Because in healthy systems, whether it's family systems or cellular systems,
- 4:11there has to be some boundary. A cell in the body can't have a
- 4:17like a shell to the cell that lets everything in, right, because then
- 4:25I don't know the wording for this, but it wouldn't function correctly. You
- 4:29also can't have a boundary around the cell that is completely impermeable, because I
- 4:34don't know if there's any cell in the body that doesn't absorb at least something.
- 4:39I'm guessing it always has to absorb something because there it has to process
- 4:43fuel or something. But so it has to be permeable but not too permeable.
- 4:47And it also depends on what this situation calls for, right, So
- 4:53you also have to have flexibility to how permeable and how impermeable the boundary is.
- 5:00So, for example, what Manuchin and Bowen and all these family theorists
- 5:04were getting at is that you know, if I was talking about me and
- 5:09my wife when like last night we were out to dinner and we were walking
- 5:16through the car I think, or you know, we got home and I
- 5:20was we were walking from the car to our front door, and I just
- 5:26had this upwelling of love for my wife, and so I, you know,
- 5:30said something like hey, come here, and she knows what that means.
- 5:33We have our ways of indicating like hey, I want some loving right
- 5:39now, or oh I have I have a warm feeling of love for you.
- 5:45Let's hug and kiss. And so that's what I did, and you
- 5:47know, she came in and pressed herself up together. This isn't anyway point
- 5:54is I wanted to say that because that's what happened, but then I started
- 6:00getting like pornographics. It wasn't. But so in that moment I wanted the
- 6:09boundary, or a more correct way of saying it, is that in order
- 6:15for the system to operate optimally, the system of me and my family and
- 6:21more specifically me and my wife, the Kirk and Stacey system, in order
- 6:29for that to work optimally in that moment, it was needed that the boundary
- 6:34between us needed to be flexible to open up a lot in that moment and
- 6:42have a lot of exchange. Really, I guess you could extend it for
- 6:45the whole night, right, because we were at dinner and we're just the
- 6:47two of us talking about all sorts of stuff and talking about personal things and
- 6:53things that are important to us, meaningful to us. Not the whole time,
- 6:56but some and it needed to be opened in that moment, right.
- 7:01It needs to be able to facilitate a lot of back and forth exchange and
- 7:08a lot of trust in the other person. And when we hugged and kissed,
- 7:13it even almost starts to feel like we're there is no boundary between us.
- 7:16It's just one person. If we go physically even further, then it
- 7:21really starts to feel like we're just one person. Not really like we're one
- 7:26person, but it's you know, physically and emotionally and spiritually, it's like
- 7:30you start to lose the boundary between between between the two people, right,
- 7:36And in order for it to function optimally, it calls for that because if
- 7:42we didn't have that permeability or that flexibility to become permeable, then we wouldn't
- 7:49be able to be close in that moment. We wouldn't be able to capitalize.
- 7:54Another dimension is how fast does it adjust right if we both or the
- 8:01system called for is a better way to put it. If the system called
- 8:05for the boundary to move from its normal state to a more permeable state,
- 8:11then it took too long for it to adjust, like it took the boundary,
- 8:20you know, the boundary takes three hours to eventually become permeable. Then
- 8:26we wouldn't be able to benefit from that because it would take too long to
- 8:31get there. You know, the whole time while we're at dinner, we're
- 8:33not really opening up. We're just talking about surface things, or we're triangulating
- 8:39a lot of things from the outside of the relationship, or we're just not
- 8:41even talking, or you know, we're not capitalizing on the moment. So
- 8:46it has to be it has to you know, there's a dimension of permeability,
- 8:50and there's a dimension of flexibility, and there's a dimension of how rapid
- 8:54the adjustment is. And so there's that now in contrast to that, if
- 9:01for example, Stacey is really upset about something like a common thing she'll be
- 9:11upset about is I mean not common, but that happens occasionally that she'll come
- 9:16home and she'll tell me about someone on the highway that almost ran her off
- 9:20the road, you know, just a bad driver, and it, you
- 9:24know, understandably freaks her out, and she has you know, some pent
- 9:31up kind of not only just rage about it, but also just unbridled fear
- 9:37around just like, oh my god. You know that it can be really
- 9:39unnerving to have that happen, right, Or if someone like road rages on
- 9:43her, which doesn't have very often, but if that ever happens, you
- 9:46know, that's pretty unnerving. And so she comes home and she's starting to
- 9:52tell me the story. Now, if I have a complete block up,
- 9:56then that's not going to work. Is if the is too rigid and impermeable,
- 10:01then I'm not there to listen or to absor to empathize. Right.
- 10:07So that's another aspect of this boundary crossing is that in order for me to
- 10:13empathize, I have to open up, or the boundary, I should say,
- 10:16has to open up. So that because you know, I keep trying
- 10:20to word it in a more systemic language instead of saying I'm opening the boundary,
- 10:24the system is calling for the boundary to be opened up, and the
- 10:28system is you know, being called upon to adjust so that everything operates optimally.
- 10:35That's the way systemic people think and talk, contrary to what the general
- 10:41public taught, you know, the way they talk and other counselors, you
- 10:46know, they'll use boundaries as something that is something that we have control of
- 10:50individually, and that's never true. Like I don't have complete control over the
- 10:56boundary between me and my wife. It's something that is created a lot of
- 11:01times subconsciously and through routines over time. Now this is different from limits,
- 11:07which I'll get into in a second, which is a different concept. Right.
- 11:11People often use the word boundaries as limits that is completely controlled by you.
- 11:16You can control your limits and your ground rules or your principles or your
- 11:22policies about things, you know. But anyway, so boundaries. So in
- 11:28that moment wife comes home, she's really upset if the boundary is too impermeable,
- 11:35if there's too much exchange going across from me and her, then I
- 11:41might become completely unglued emotionally, right, and that opt for the system.
- 11:48The health of the system depends on me not doing that, because if I,
- 11:54you know, like if that happened, and it does happen sometimes,
- 11:58then I might, I don't know, just start to say I'm going to
- 12:03find this guy and kill him or something. Or I might freak out and
- 12:07say, you can't drive anymore? Or what did you do? Did you
- 12:11drive bad? You know, I might start blaming her, right because I'm
- 12:13starting to lose perspective, right, I'm panicking. I can't do that,
- 12:18right, So I need to have some boundary up. There needs to be
- 12:22some impermeableness to the boundary, but I can't have it completely impermeable, because
- 12:28then I won't listen or know what she's feeling. I have to absorb some
- 12:33of it, right, And the optimal you know, the system, in
- 12:39order to be optimal, is calling for a boundary that is somewhat permeable but
- 12:43not completely perbable. Okay, And and the you know, situations can change
- 12:50all over the board. Right, if she wants to just be alone for
- 12:56a while, then I need to The system is calling for that boundary to
- 13:03be pretty closed off, and the system needs to be able to adjust to
- 13:09that. So there's flexibility, there's permeability, and then the speed of onset
- 13:16of optimal boundariness. Okay, that's what boundaries are. Now. What people
- 13:22tend to use the word boundaries is to say I have a boundary about this,
- 13:28And sure languages language and lay people and non marriage of family therapists can
- 13:33certainly use that language, so it's fine. But if you're a marriage of
- 13:39family therapist the very least to young, you need to understand when you're using
- 13:41that word of boundaries, it's not the systemic theory word of boundaries. Okay.
- 13:48So, and of course, you know, I could talk a long
- 13:50time time about what all the theorists we're also getting at about boundaries between the
- 13:56family system and the rest of the world, between extended family. Right,
- 14:01there's all these scenarios where the boundaries are in question or worthy of evaluating.
- 14:09Like a common example is that you have two people that are getting married or
- 14:16they're developing a stronger relationship, they're moving in together or something, and previous
- 14:24to that new relationship deepening, they were really involved with their parents, for
- 14:30example, or their friends or their work or something. Well, if the
- 14:35boundaries don't all adjust somehow, then this couple will have a hard time developing
- 14:43the intimacy that's required for them to feel together and bonded and attached. So
- 14:48that's another aspect of boundaries is that the routine of the boundary, the pattern
- 14:54of the boundary. The programming, if you will, the software that runs
- 15:00how the boundary operates needs to adjust over time, which is a kind of
- 15:07a global system change. Like for example, like when Stacy and I first
- 15:15met, I was, you know, my current social life for my relationships
- 15:22were such that I spent a lot of time and I had a lot more
- 15:28closeness with say friends and other people in my life. Right, But when
- 15:33Stacy and I started to become more serious, then the whole system and all
- 15:39the boundaries had to change their software there, they had to change their routine
- 15:45and meaning that if like I'm trying to this is kind of hard to explain,
- 15:52but the point is that the the like the way I described the boundaries
- 16:00between me and my wife and those two scenarios, if a system has to
- 16:03reinvent the rules of the boundaries every single time, it's too laborious and there's
- 16:08too much chaos. So with systems, with human systems, family systems,
- 16:14relationship systems, the idea is that we seek homeostasis, which is the it
- 16:21requires the least amount of work to sustain that routine where everyone basically understands their
- 16:26roles and how they're supposed to respond, and boundaries are included in that.
- 16:33Because boundaries are socially created, they're created collectively by everyone involved. And when
- 16:42there's a major shift like before Stacey and then after Stacy, all the routines
- 16:51have to change. All the rules of the game have to change at least
- 16:55slightly and operate on a different set of rules. And so that's another dimension
- 17:03to boundaries is that there are different states of boundaries that you know, like,
- 17:11for example, this is kind of a weird I don't want to say,
- 17:15being a sage. Let's say you take another couple and they they break
- 17:19up. Okay, Well, the boundary between you know, say the wife
- 17:27and the ex partner, that boundary has to change its routine, right,
- 17:33and this can there can be some weird such situations where you might divorce your
- 17:41partner and still reach out to them when important events happen to you even though
- 17:47you don't want to, because that's the routine. I could go on and
- 17:53on about this. I wish I had like a specific example to kind of
- 17:56get my hands into. But anyway, so that's what f FBL you know,
- 17:59is off and really interested in this kind of stuff. Lenin is very
- 18:03smart and as a non clinician really learns all this kind of stuff, and
- 18:07so that's that's what he's getting at. And so getting back to this article,
- 18:12you know, it says, quote, most actual boundaries experts would agree
- 18:18that telling your partner who to spend time with is a symptom of terrible boundaries.
- 18:22Okay, unquote. So that is not talking about boundaries, about the
- 18:27boundaries in family systems theory, because in the beginning of the article, apparently
- 18:34they're talking about munution Boen, mucial Bowen are talking about the boundaries I was
- 18:37just talking about. They're using the word boundaries to talk about limits or policies,
- 18:44personal preferences. That's all that is. Okay, So there's that the
- 18:51writer simply doesn't understand what they're talking about. And even if they went to
- 18:56other therapists, even family therapists, they wouldn't necessarily get good information. You
- 19:02know. The fact that I understand systems theory and boundaries and all this stuff
- 19:06to the degree that I do is not because it was easily understood by me.
- 19:10It took me maybe fifteen years of literally teaching this in my classes repeatedly
- 19:21for it to kind of start to gel. You know, and then to
- 19:26apply it to real situations is a whole other thing, right, because you
- 19:29can sort of get it, but it's like, how do you apply this?
- 19:32It's really hard. So, you know, I don't blame people,
- 19:34but from right off the bat, it looks like this writer doesn't know what
- 19:37they're talking about. I wish people just stuck to their lane, you know,
- 19:41just talk about, just talk about in your own language, right anyway,
- 19:45So there's that. Then the person just makes a claim without any sort
- 19:52of citation or anything, any sort of research. Most actual boundaries experts in
- 19:57Linden is smart saying, what's a boundaries expert? Yeah, it's not like
- 20:03a certification we have is that therap most actual even the word actual, like
- 20:07what do you mean? So there's like actual boundaries experts, and then there's
- 20:11like fake No, it's not a thing. Most actual boundaries experts would agree
- 20:15that telling your partner who to spend time with is a symptom of terrible boundaries.
- 20:19And even that word symptom, why would you anyway, it's a sign,
- 20:25just say a sign symptom implies that you're in this clinical world. You're
- 20:29not because you don't know what you're talking about. Anyway. So all right,
- 20:33so let's get at the core of this center. By the way,
- 20:36this emails really long, and I'm in the first little bit here. Most
- 20:42experts agree that telling your partner who to spend time with is bad. Essentially,
- 20:48it depends, right if your partner cheats on you and you're going through
- 20:56recovery, and you, as the victim, ask your partner, hey,
- 20:59I don't want you to hang out with the person that you were having sex
- 21:02with behind my back for the past three years. That's that's you know,
- 21:07it depends on the situation, of course. But you know it's like these
- 21:11these blanket statements right now, what they're getting out of course. Yeah,
- 21:15absolutely, if I were to tell Stacey that she can't hang out with one
- 21:19of her friends, then that's just to say that's bad. That's not even
- 21:25put a clinical word to it's unfair, right, is a symptom of terrible
- 21:29boundaries. I don't even know what they mean by that, you know,
- 21:32just I don't know. I just wish people stuck to it. Okay,
- 21:34Actually, let's take a break. So going on with the email here,
- 21:41Linden quotes from the article. Oh, Linden actually says, I think the
- 21:48central thesis of the article is stated less than halfway into the article, and
- 21:52then Linden quotes the article saying, I am not anti boundaries, but they
- 21:59are so rarely questioned because they have a seductive moral authority as the dominant metaphor
- 22:06for how human relationships should work. So let's break this down. I am
- 22:11not anti boundaries. Okay, I'm not entirely sure what you mean by even
- 22:15boundaries. I think what the author is meaning without reading the article and just
- 22:18reading it through Lindon's excerpts here this was I could have looked up to you
- 22:22the article. I'm pretty sure Linden actually even sent me the link. But
- 22:26I'm being lazy. But the quote, you know, I'm not so you
- 22:30know, boundaries, I think the author was defining as saying that you have
- 22:37and I think specifically limits on or requests on what you would request of your
- 22:44partner, like I would request that you not hang out with that person,
- 22:48or I would request that you don't go to that party. I'm guessing it's
- 22:56that kind of That's not a boundary. That's just it's weird to even say
- 22:59it that, you know, and I wonder if people are even using the
- 23:02word boundary to justify that kind of thing, right, because and this happens,
- 23:07I just see this more and more, or maybe it's always happening.
- 23:11I don't know. But where you have this concept drift, where in the
- 23:17beginning, this idea of boundaries is for a limited set of situations in our
- 23:22society. The word I have a boundary about this would be applied to I
- 23:27have a boundary about my workplace asking me to work on sunday. I have
- 23:33a boundary about that. So most people would say, yeah, that's a
- 23:37good thing to have as a boundary. And also it's maybe an appropriate use
- 23:42of the word boundary. You're saying, I'm not going to allow this other
- 23:47thing to encroach into my space, meaning work into my sunday. Okay.
- 23:52Then people start to realize that, ooh, there's this word called boundary that
- 23:59a lot of people get behind. You know, there's an audience that is
- 24:04watching this rhetoric around boundaries, and the audience is observing this, and ooh,
- 24:11you know, there's some power in the word boundaries because a lot of
- 24:14people get behind other people who claim they have boundaries. Well, some of
- 24:18the audience will use it appropriately, but there's a group in the audience that
- 24:25will pull the concept of boundaries far afield or at least a little bit of
- 24:30field from the meeting, and so they'll say, I have a boundary about
- 24:34you spending time with that person. Okay, in terms of the spirit of
- 24:41the definition, we're no longer talking about boundaries in the original sense. Now
- 24:48we're co opting the word boundaries because the individual wants to use something that they
- 24:53believe has power, that they believe will get support, maybe even on Twitter
- 24:59or something, I have boundaries. Like if someone just said on Twitter like
- 25:03my husband won't respect my boundaries, and be oh, that's not that's not
- 25:07okay. But then when you hear what they're using the word boundaries for,
- 25:12it's like I don't want my husband to have friends. I have a boundary
- 25:17about that. Well then we're well Jesus, you know, so then it
- 25:21dilutes it. Right then, the original people that are using boundaries in a
- 25:25helpful way, in an empowering way, it ruins it for them because now
- 25:30you know. And this is the same with narcissism and gas lighting and trauma
- 25:33bonding, and all these words get co opted and I could I could go
- 25:40on and on. You know, you get old, you start seeing these
- 25:41trends with words and and this element. I'm sure linguists and anthropologists have some
- 25:51kind of concept around this whole thing I'm talking about. I'm sure I'm not
- 25:55inventing this, but I've never heard anyone talk about it to my knowledge,
- 25:59and so I'm just kind of observing it and having this sort of lay person
- 26:03language around it. Anyway. So what this person, this author is doing,
- 26:10I think is reacting against people that are using the word boundaries as as
- 26:15as a way to make a bad request seem more justifiable. Okay, So
- 26:22then the other says, I'm I'm not anti boundaries. Okay, it's hard
- 26:26by the definition that you're using, but they are also so rarely questioned because
- 26:32they have a seductive moral authority. Yeah, so I think that's what actually
- 26:36I was talking about. So I guess I'm kind of agreeing with this person
- 26:41as the dominant metaphor for how human relationship should work. Yeah, yeah,
- 26:44I think that's that's coherent to me, depending on what we by boundaries of
- 26:49course going on. So just telling me out time, little tangent is that
- 26:56it's the same thing with trigger warnings. So I don't know the full history
- 27:03on trigger warnings. I used to know a lot more details about this,
- 27:06but I know enough to say this that in for a time, maybe in
- 27:11the beginning, but at the very least, there was a sizable group of
- 27:15people that were using the word trigger warning to refer to PTSD trigger in ways
- 27:22that make total sense to us. You would have a professor in a class
- 27:26with a bunch of freshmen in college, and the professor as a part of
- 27:32their teaching of a class. Let's say it's like film class, and the
- 27:37professor shows a scene in which a woman is raped, whether it's a girl
- 27:44with a dragon tattoo or it's the accused. I think that's a movie that
- 27:48called with Jodie Foster. These are graphic scenes and hard to watch. So
- 27:56for everyone it's going to be hard. But if people sign up for a
- 28:03class, well, so let me talk about trigger warning. Okay, So
- 28:06the original usage of trigger warning was for those people in the class who have
- 28:11actual PTSD because they had been raped. They have been raped, they're a
- 28:18student in the class and they have PTSD. Because not everyone who is sexually
- 28:23assaulted will develop PTSD, many do, understandably, right, and either they're
- 28:30in recovery and they have it fully recovered, or they don't even know what
- 28:33recovery is. They're just trying to survive and they're sitting in class and they're
- 28:37in the middle of the row, and under normal circumstances they can manage right,
- 28:45but they're forced to watch this scene and it'll skyrocket their distress. It's
- 28:52very very upsetting, not only just in the moment, but it could ruin
- 28:57their life for months. People can be triggered from their PTSD and it could
- 29:03be such an overload neurologically, and also it can be very disorienting consciously as
- 29:08well, because when you have all these symptoms, you start questioning is it
- 29:12safe to go to class, Is it safe to leave my house? Is
- 29:17there something wrong with me? Should I just turn off my emotions? Should
- 29:21I push everyone away from me? Because the person gets home and they're kind
- 29:25of short with their partner. So there's all these symptoms that generate from that
- 29:30triggering and that distress that pulls people away, causes people to be more isolating
- 29:37of themselves in their mind, and so it can really cause a lot of
- 29:41havoc. So there are these advocates saying hey, trigger warning. That's all
- 29:47you have to do is at the beginning of class, preferably at the beginning
- 29:51of the course, and before the class begins, you would send out an
- 29:56email to everyone. By the way, we're going to watch this clip.
- 29:59If that is a trigger for you, you are free to not come to
- 30:03class until the second hour or something like that, because you don't want to
- 30:08do a trigger warning when people are sitting in class, because then people have
- 30:12to self disclose that they have been assaulted by standing up and walking out.
- 30:18So there's all these principles around triggering. I don't think they're going to get
- 30:22a lot of people that are going to say that that's stupid, or that's
- 30:25coddling or something. Right. Well, under my understanding is that for people
- 30:34that were uncomfortable with things, they they saw this concept called trigger warnings and
- 30:41it was this powerful word that people this phrase that people tended to honor.
- 30:48And although these individual so you know, you have this audience of people that's
- 30:52that's watching this trigger warning exchange happen, right, and then a group in
- 31:00the audience will say, ooh, I have PTSD, I want that,
- 31:03or you have a group of people that doesn't have PTSD. That's like,
- 31:06oh, I get that, I understand what we're doing here with trigger warnings.
- 31:10You have another group in the audience that has an experience that has nothing
- 31:15to do with PTSD and maybe just has to do with their own preferences,
- 31:19and maybe they're a little narcissistic. They believe they're entitled to have the world
- 31:26conform to everything that they prefer, and they don't prefer to watch a rape
- 31:33scene. That's not what they choose to do. And when they watch a
- 31:37rape scene in class, they're not being harmed neurologically or psychologically or emotionally.
- 31:45They just don't like it. And maybe they do experience a little bit of
- 31:49harm because they're not used to experiencing things that are out of their control or
- 31:55out of their preference zone. They're used to catering everything around them to their
- 32:00they were spoiled or something okay, And so these individuals will co opt trigger
- 32:06warning and use it to you know, enact they're narcissistic and I'm not using
- 32:13it in the person disorder. You know, there's self centered notions that the
- 32:17world needs to conform to their preferences, and they'll claim they're being harmed but
- 32:22they're not actually being harmed, and then that starts to run away with itself,
- 32:30and that that's probably a larger group of people, or the very least
- 32:34a more noticeable group of people, because people with PTSD don't stand up and
- 32:37say, like, I have PTSD. It's not something that people are super
- 32:40proud of. They should be proud of it that they survived, but there's
- 32:45a lot of shame, so it's not common that people would be like just
- 32:51talking about it a lot. It's changing because of lack of stigma, but
- 32:53anyway, or reducing a stigma. Then you have this group people that are
- 32:58very reported at the very least. Journalists and conservatives particularly will will point to
- 33:05these snowflakes and college class that are like too sensitive and are constantly calling trigger
- 33:10warning. And then these the society starts to starts to question trigger warning,
- 33:15they start trigger warnings is just a way for people to be too soft.
- 33:20Right. Meanwhile, you have people with actual PTSD that are being completely ignored
- 33:24and they don't have a phrase anymore. They need some other because they say
- 33:30trigger warning. You know, unless you spend hours educating everyone on what PTSD
- 33:37is and da da da, then you're not gonna You're gonna be associated with
- 33:43the the you know, the inaccurate or the disingenuous use of the phrase trigger
- 33:49warning, and so it it's harmful when these concepts creep away, you know,
- 33:58like with gas lighting, for example, there's a group of people that
- 34:01have been using the word gas lighting and gas lit, both clinicians and victims
- 34:08through recovery, as a way to understand and label and talk about the actual
- 34:15gas lighting that occurs within a long term high control abuse of relationship, whether
- 34:21it's in a culture, in a marriage, or at work or something.
- 34:24You actually start to lose trust in your ability to perceive reality and judge reality.
- 34:34You start to think, I don't know how to think, I don't
- 34:38know how to judge things. I'm stupid or I'm crazy, when you never
- 34:44were. And that is incredibly destructive and very useful to high control individuals because
- 34:52once they can get you to believe that they can do anything they want to
- 34:54you, because they can shape entire reality around whatever they want it to be.
- 35:00Because you have lost confidence in your ability to know anything that's real,
- 35:08that's gaslighting. So when someone is just in an argument with someone that like
- 35:15a friend and there's no abuse and there's no pattern here, and the person
- 35:22is like, you know, like an example that I'll see is someone will
- 35:24be like, what did I see online? As something like where one person
- 35:32is, you know, two people are, they're in a minor conflict.
- 35:35And I think it was Ethan and Tricia, right, I'll just I'll just
- 35:42say it was them. I don't know if it was them, but Ethan
- 35:45was telling Tricia, I think you were angry before, and Tricia was saying,
- 35:53no, I wasn't. I wasn't angry, and we don't know.
- 35:58Maybe she wasn't angry, but she did kind of look like she was angry,
- 36:00but we don't know. We're not inside of her. And then Ethan
- 36:04said, come on, you are angry something like that, and Tricia said,
- 36:07you're gaslighting me. Okay. People will call off that word because they've
- 36:16learned it's a respected word that when you drop that word, people listen and
- 36:22they have sympathy for you. So they just start dropping this word gaslighting around
- 36:29all because they feel like they're not being heard, I think, is what's
- 36:35happening, and they don't know what to grab onto, and so they grab
- 36:38onto these clinical words because they can and then it and when you use a
- 36:45word like that, the audience doesn't know enough about gas lighting or abusive relationships
- 36:50in general to counteract anything you're saying. You're like, Oh, I guess
- 36:53maybe you're right, because I don't know how to respond to that anyway.
- 36:58So with boundaries, I think it's a similar thing. Okay, So let's
- 37:02take a break, right getting back to FPL's quote of the article. The
- 37:12article says, quote, the story of boundaries, which i'll retrace here,
- 37:17took me back to the early nineteen nineties when boundaries erupted suddenly into the self
- 37:23help mass market, and then to the mid sixties when they cropped up on
- 37:30the fringes of egopsychology. Okay, well, if we're going to talk about
- 37:34boundaries within ego psychology, then we're really talking about a different sort of I'm
- 37:38chiming in here, then we're really talking about a different usage of that word,
- 37:43because that's far afield from family systems theory. And then FPL asks me,
- 37:49you were trained in the nineteen nineties, right, do you remember this
- 37:51happening? Is there any context missing? Just chiming in? Yeah, I
- 37:55feel like I've already been over that there's yeah, yeah, I was trained
- 38:00in the nineties and I feel like I've already been over the nuances on that.
- 38:06Now. I don't know the history of the use of boundaries within self
- 38:10help. I'm guessing that the first set of publications would be fair usage of
- 38:19the word boundaries where people are talking to people who are being imposed upon or
- 38:25abused, and the self help book is saying, you know, I imagine
- 38:30a lot of the boundary and I do remember a lot of talk along these
- 38:35lines of assertiveness. Right. You have a lot of people who have been
- 38:38socialized or harmed in a way that resulted in them defensively not being assertive.
- 38:45Defensively meaning as a defense against the pain and the fear. There's a defense
- 38:52mechanism that develops, and non assertiveness or allowing yourself to be trodden upon,
- 39:00is a defense against the It's a lesser of two evils anyway. So for
- 39:07the self help market, they were trying to appeal to a lot of people
- 39:12in that situation by saying, hey, you deserve boundaries, or you need
- 39:15to establish boundaries. If you don't establish boundaries, then you're at fault when
- 39:21or at least partially a fault when other people will just walk all over you.
- 39:24You can't just wait for people to respect your boundaries. You have to
- 39:30establish them, You have to react. I remember a lot of self help
- 39:34like that. And that's not the minuchen Boeen sense of the word at all,
- 39:39but not a bad usage of the word boundary, right, we could
- 39:43all kind of get behind that, right, going on with the article quoting
- 39:46it, and then the floodgates opened. In nineteen ninety one, a therapist's
- 39:52name and Catherine published a book called Boundaries, where you end and I begin,
- 39:58proclaiming the value of of diving up your emotional life. The next two
- 40:02years saw a parade of titles like Boundaries and Relationships, Da Da Da da,
- 40:07Yeah, I don't know. And then Lynnon asked me, are boundaries
- 40:13as a concept mostly the arbitrary result of self help books not in the clinical
- 40:20field, So, and that's a whole other thing. Like the self help
- 40:24realm is, to a large extent, if not the vast majority of the
- 40:30time, it's completely separate from the clinical world. A lot of people think
- 40:34they're related. Now, a lot of clinicians write self help books. But
- 40:40in my circle anyway, we will have no idea, what's happening with the
- 40:46general public. The general public can be reading this one book on this one
- 40:51thing, and everyone is talking about it, right, and we might not
- 40:55even hear about it because it's just not the sort of thing we talk about.
- 41:00It's not the kind of publishers we'd pay attention to. Even if we
- 41:04did hear about it, we'd be like, well, that's a self help
- 41:07book. It's not like below us. But it's probably too simplistic. It's
- 41:12not the sort of thing that we get into. So there could have been
- 41:15a time when there were even three definitions that were being used. You had
- 41:21the Minutch definition of boundaries, then you had the clinical usage of boundaries regarding
- 41:27assertiveness, and then you had this third definition that was being used by self
- 41:30help, and maybe a fourth definition that's kind of being used on Twitter anyway.
- 41:35Another quote here, boundaries do this by teaching us to relate to other
- 41:38people as if they are the one thing social systems are most determined to project,
- 41:45which is property. Most boundaries books of the early nineteen nineties un self
- 41:52consciously steal imagery from land ownership. So there's a quote or just as homeowners
- 42:00set physical boundary lines on their land. We need to set up mental,
- 42:05physical, emotional, and spiritual boundaries for our lives to help us to stingish.
- 42:09Yeah, just chime me in. Yeah, you know, it's just
- 42:13metaphors. And it is interesting and notable that in self help they would use
- 42:19that metaphor because that's the world we kind of live in. And yeah,
- 42:24well, let's see what point they're getting at here. But generally, boundaries
- 42:29came to psychoanalysis from the outside, as if slipping in through the service entrance.
- 42:36Two. Early family therapist Murray Bow and Salvador Remus borrow the term from
- 42:39the interdisciplinary science of systems there in the nineteen sixties. Yeah, this is
- 42:44all true, which was which which has vague associations with the with the US
- 42:49military, And I mean most of psychology had something to do with the military
- 42:55in the A lot of psychology in the Uni States actually was catalyzed by military
- 43:02funding and attention. There's a lot of money. A lot of things generate
- 43:09from money. I hope we understand that in our capitalistic society. And during
- 43:16World War Two, of course, there was a lot of money and taxes
- 43:22being poured into the effort of winning the war, and one of the wings
- 43:27of that effort had to do with psychology on a number of different levels,
- 43:30but one of them was evaluating soldiers at the beginning of their training as to
- 43:37their aptitudes or their even eligibility to become a soldier, but also evaluating them
- 43:45during war because of course people started to have reactivity to war, and then
- 43:52after the war, right, so you have all this money because you know,
- 43:55if psychologists and psychiatrists can make soldiers more effective and more effectively determine which
- 44:04soldiers should be doing what, then you can save a lot of money in
- 44:08other places if you pour money into this. And so there were a lot
- 44:12of clinical efforts but also research efforts going on, and so there was a
- 44:19lot of discovery and a lot of our major figures kind of emerged from that
- 44:23money and from that effort, and entire professions were created. I don't quote
- 44:30me on this, but I think psychologists kind of came into their own because
- 44:32before it was you know, a lot of psychoanalysts and a lot of psychiatrists
- 44:37psychoanalysts, and then at some point, you know, during World War two.
- 44:42I don't quote me on that anyway, point is is that a lot
- 44:45of things had to do with the US military am going on. It sees
- 44:47the world as a set of systems, which, so you know, this
- 44:52is talking about Bowen and Minusen. It sees the world as a set of
- 44:55systems. Sees the world as a set of systems, Yeah, which share
- 45:00the same principles, whether they are families, solar systems, or molecules.
- 45:05Yeah. I've already been over that. Systems must maintain their boundaries, taking
- 45:09some things in and keeping others out in order to continue to exist. Yeah,
- 45:15that's all right. And Linen chimes in it says I don't know enough
- 45:19about systems theory to tackle this. The reference to the military application seems designed
- 45:22to resonate with the later comments about geopolitics and fighting communism, etc. Yeah.
- 45:28I mean, I don't know exactly what they're referring to. But Murray
- 45:32Bowen and salad Ar Mnuchen from my memory, I mean Murray Bowen from my
- 45:38memory. His one of his major early funding sources had to do with trying
- 45:47to find a cure for schizophrenia. And what he did was he looked at
- 45:54the family. So you know, he gets this huge amount of money him
- 45:57and his team, I believe, and instead of doing what a lot of
- 46:00other people were doing, like studying personality or psychiatry or something. He wanted
- 46:07to look at families. And so he, from my memories is all top
- 46:10top of my head, that he got a bunch of patients with schizophrenia and
- 46:15then he got their families to come in and actually they all stayed in these
- 46:22bungalows, I believe, and were provided with early versions of family therapy and
- 46:30early versions of Boynian therapy. And what Bowen was trying to demonstrate was that
- 46:37if you treat the system and the boundaries and the differentiation, all that kind
- 46:43of stuff, then the symptoms of the person with schizophrenia would not only reduce,
- 46:50but would stay reduced, you know, because what was happening was the
- 46:53observation, and this is, you know, true that if the person was
- 47:00schizophrenia suffering from schizophrenia, they live with their parents. Let's say they're twenty
- 47:05five, and you put them in the hospital and say they get better symptom
- 47:08wise, and you release them when their symptoms are mostly gone, they go
- 47:15back to their home and the symptoms, the symptoms come back. And so
- 47:21there was this confusion about that, like, well, what's happening because you
- 47:23know, if you cure someone's cancer and they go to live with their family,
- 47:28their cancer doesn't emerge just based on their social context. Right. But
- 47:31this observation of psychology, now you know, schizophrenia is a lot more complicated
- 47:37and more biological than I think they knew at the time because they didn't really
- 47:40have the technology to even ask those questions. Really, but research shows even
- 47:49today that stress level and systems operations can absolutely affect the symptoms and the severity
- 47:57for individuals with schizophrenia. Anyway, And so the idea as well, if
- 48:01we really want to help people schizphrenia, we have to actually zoom out and
- 48:05look at the system, right, And so Bowen and his team got a
- 48:08lot of money along those lines to look at schizophrenia and anyway, So going
- 48:15on with what Linin is saying. But the more I thought about it,
- 48:20like many things that are useful, systems theory may have been used in the
- 48:23military in many other fields, the comment starts to sound a bit like,
- 48:28aren't cooks kind of suspicious, don't they miss? Yeah? Right, I
- 48:34don't know that you know every detail of the history of systems theory and family
- 48:37therapy in the military, there from my memory off the top of my head,
- 48:42there's there's not a connection there, and even if there were, it
- 48:45wouldn't mean some sort of nefarious thing right now. Systems theory was used in
- 48:52the military, specifically with missiles guided missiles. There's this concept called called cybernetics,
- 49:00which is that when you know, we have these movie usages of cybernetics
- 49:07like it's terminator too, and all that kind of stuff, but the technical
- 49:13definition of cybernetics is or at least a portion of it from my understanding.
- 49:17I'm sure experts would be able to expand on this, But when you have
- 49:22cybernetics in terms of the way I was taught and the way I use it,
- 49:27in the way we use it in systems theory is that a cybernetics system
- 49:31adjusts to input so that a goal can be reached. So with a missile,
- 49:38if you're trying to hit a tank and you just shoot the missile at
- 49:43it and there's no guidance system, it might miss right, the tank might
- 49:47move, the wind might push it. But if you have a cybernetics system
- 49:52that can measure, you know what's happening, and so you point it at
- 50:00the tank and then the wind pushes it. Well, it has these fins
- 50:04that on the side of the missile that can sort of direct it back to
- 50:07in line with hitting the tank right or if the tank moves, then the
- 50:13missile is able to adjust to that right. So this has to do with
- 50:17like feedback and how systems operate, and understanding how systems operate, and understanding
- 50:24how cybernetics operate. You know, in the military they would use this obviously,
- 50:30and in family systems theory we would also use the general systems theory and
- 50:36cybernetics in that. Like when I was talking about me and my wife,
- 50:39when the two of us are let's say we have we go through let's say
- 50:47I'm working a lot. That's kind of easy to tell an analogy, but
- 50:52and it's causing distance between me and my wife because we're not spending a lot
- 50:57of time together. Well, our system has a cybernetic mechanism regarding feedback loops.
- 51:06I won't bore you with those details that will automatically kick in to adjust
- 51:13to help the system to operate optimally. And one of the mechanisms might be
- 51:20that Stacey might miss me, or I might have a longing to be with
- 51:25her or I when we are together, we both feel this urge to bond
- 51:35more with the time that we have available after I'm done with work or something.
- 51:40So those are those mechanisms. Now another there's all these other feedback loops
- 51:46and mechanisms that we can talk about, like me worrying about self employment and
- 51:52how at any moment my entire business could go belly up if, for example,
- 51:58you patrons just decide not to be patrons. I it would just completely
- 52:02throw my family into chaos. I mean not that we would not survive,
- 52:08but it would, you know. So I have that anxiety, and there's
- 52:14that that influence into that system of me and stacy that that reality is,
- 52:22you know, coming into our relationship. And if I don't have the ability
- 52:27to let that in, then I won't be able to adjust. But if
- 52:29I let it too much in, then it might cause too much anxiety or
- 52:32too much of my motivation will be around worries of my business going belly up,
- 52:39that it'll take me away from other things, you know. So there's
- 52:42all these mechanisms and self adjusting mechanisms that will kick in, and they're routines,
- 52:52they're not choices necessarily that we make be and Stacy being together a long
- 52:57time, so we don't have to reinvent the wheel every time. There are
- 53:00certain patterns that we fall into almost automatically, if not automatically, that help
- 53:07us to function well. And then of course the opposite can be true.
- 53:10If you have a system that's not functioning well, it's the same. The
- 53:15pattern is the problem, it's not the individuals. I hope this is all
- 53:19making sense. So getting back to the article here, the article made some
- 53:27good points. And even though it was published so this is all from Linen,
- 53:31and even though it was published in longer form in a psychoanalysis magazine,
- 53:37I started to think of your videos about the Sopranos image of therapy and its
- 53:40misinterpretation, at least of the West Coast therapy. Some of the commentary is
- 53:45definitely tempered, right, So what he's lit in a saying I think this
- 53:51article might be misrepresenting family systems and boundaries in the way that sometimes Lennon will
- 54:00see me point that out, Like when I was watching The Sopranos and reacting
- 54:07to it online, I was pointing out how the if I'm remembering right that
- 54:15I was saying, oh, this therapy is not representative of what a lot
- 54:20of therapists to do anyway, So going on, so am I usually stop
- 54:22in my usual style, I have a couple of summary questions. What use
- 54:28does the concept of boundaries have in modern therapy? Okay, just chiming in,
- 54:32good question. Again, your emails are always just brilliant and provoke me
- 54:38to talk about things I don't get a chance to talk about usually. But
- 54:44what does the concept of boundaries have in modern therapy? Well, it's not
- 54:46a common concept, although it is commonly talked about, it's not a formalized
- 54:54concept. It is a formalized concept within family therapy with that realm and even
- 55:01that even though, like I said earlier, a lot of family therapists anecdotally
- 55:07don't really understand the concept of boundaries because they don't understand the concept of systems
- 55:14in general. Because it's really fucking hard to understand and unless you had a
- 55:20really kick ass professor and you spent years of your life really trying to because
- 55:27it's a paradigm shift, you have to completely shift, because it's not just
- 55:31a clinical thing. Everything in our life, we especially in the United States,
- 55:37we think linearly. So that's the opposite of systems thinking is linear thinking.
- 55:42There's nothing wrong with linear in the family systems world. If you say,
- 55:46oh, that's linear thinking a lot of time, that's an insult.
- 55:50It's not an insult in my book. It's just it's a particular mode of
- 55:53thinking. You know, if I'm walking down the street and someone comes up
- 55:59to me and punches me in the face and my face hurts, and I'm
- 56:00looking for an explanation as to why my face hurts, I don't have to
- 56:05think systemically. I can think linearly, someone punched me in the face,
- 56:08that's why my face hurts. I don't have to zoom out and understand the
- 56:13broader context, like someone just ran and came. You punched me. It's
- 56:15a linear reality. I could look at it systemically, but I don't have
- 56:21to define a satisfying solution or if satisfying conceptualization. And what defines satisfying conceptualization
- 56:28is you know, the concept drives the treatment, meaning that if someone punched
- 56:34me in the face and I evaluate it linearly, I say, that person
- 56:38punch me in the face. There to blame. I need to run away
- 56:42from that person. If I stop to think systemically, I might stay next
- 56:45to that person, they can see they can continue to punch me. So
- 56:46sometimes linear thinking is very helpful when you're when a spark plug goes wrong in
- 56:52your car, sometimes you just have to take out the spark plug and change
- 56:57it. It's it's just a linear situation. You don't have to figure out
- 57:00how the whole system works. Now, if your spark plug continues to go
- 57:05out in your car, then you got to think systemically because it could be
- 57:07part of the distributor cap or the power supply or something. You know,
- 57:12there's something going on in the overall system. And that's a very crude example
- 57:17because even that you consider as it could still be linear. But anyway,
- 57:21point is that systems thinking is so outside because all day long we are thinking
- 57:29linearly. We're taught linearly, we talk linearly. Our language is evidence of
- 57:35our linear thinking. Other cultures actually have an easier time with systems thinking because
- 57:38their language and their culture is at least somewhat more systemically oriented. They're not
- 57:45completely you know, it's still a tremendous amount of linear thinking within other cultures
- 57:50as well, but they have a little bit of easier time. People in
- 57:53Uned States have a really hard time, and so It requires you to think
- 58:00and observe and understand in a way that is divorced from everything that you're taught,
- 58:07everybody's language, everything, you know, the president said this, therefore
- 58:13this will happen, you know, linear, instead of like, well,
- 58:15what's the bigger picture? You have voters, and you have fears, and
- 58:20you have you know, segments of society. Like seeing seeing it zoomed out
- 58:28can also just be overwhelming. Right, It's so much easier just to hate
- 58:30one person or to blame one person, or attribute something, even if it's
- 58:36positive. Right, Attributing to one person is easier than wondering about all the
- 58:42factors that played into why something happened. Right, So you know, I
- 58:47don't I don't blame you anyway. So what does the concept of boundaries have
- 58:52in modern therapy. It's not in my anecdotal experience, it's not. It's
- 58:59not talked about clinically it's in it's not in the literature unless it's talking about
- 59:05Mnuchen and Bowen and stuff. Assertiveness has talked about limits, requests, having
- 59:15your own rights, you know, those are all things that are talked about
- 59:19clinically going on. But I will say that when you hear therapists that are
- 59:25consulting with each other, You will absolutely hear people talking about boundaries, Like
- 59:30if you know someone were consulting, if I were to consult about a client
- 59:36that was having issues with assertiveness, I would very likely hear from other therapists,
- 59:42even other family therapists, that would say it sounds like your client needs
- 59:45to establish boundaries that kind of thing. Okay, are there versions or interpretations
- 59:50of the concept you just like, yeah, I've already been over that.
- 59:52Does the idea make sense outside of family systems disciplines? Again, depends of
- 1:00:00what we mean by quote unquote the idea. Is there just a more general
- 1:00:04problem with good psychotherapy concepts being popularized? Yes, I've already been over that.
- 1:00:10Can we take on board the possible political, geopolitical origins or residences or
- 1:00:17concepts in family therapies but still hold on to their value as interventions and therapies.
- 1:00:25I think what Linin is talking about is that if you yeah, so,
- 1:00:30I don't know if this is what Lenin is talking about, But what
- 1:00:34I will say to this is that looked when we look at Bowen and others
- 1:00:40and the even though just the entire field of psychology, psychotherapy. What you
- 1:00:47see are a lot of Westerners, people from United States and mostly Western Europe
- 1:00:55as well. You have a small set of people, and also a small
- 1:01:01set of people. Within those people, it's a lot of white people and
- 1:01:04a lot of white men. So when we look at that, a lot
- 1:01:08of the assumptions and goals and givens and understandings emerge from white men in the
- 1:01:17Western world, and therefore we can critique it on that basis. And for
- 1:01:27some that would mean that they reject the whole enterprise, but for many,
- 1:01:30including me, it just means we have to understand it within that context and
- 1:01:36critique it. But don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. There is
- 1:01:39wisdom there potentially. You know, you have to decide for yourself if there's
- 1:01:44anything in there for you. So for me, for example, you know,
- 1:01:50it's not a black and white thing. It's not like I because you
- 1:01:53know, there's all sorts of valid critiques against Freud, and yet for me,
- 1:01:59there's a lot of things that Freud contributed, not only in a way
- 1:02:02that provokes a great amount of appreciation of him and his efforts, but also
- 1:02:09just flat out adhering to a lot of his theory and using it and liking
- 1:02:15it, you know, so all can be true there going on? Is
- 1:02:23defense a more useful idea than boundary or is it just a different focus?
- 1:02:31I think I've already been over that. Do you prefer differentiation and measurement,
- 1:02:36etc. To the idea of boundaries conceptualized at the individual level? Well,
- 1:02:43right, I haven't even gotten into differentiation. So everything that I've been saying
- 1:02:47about boundaries and systems applies to differentiation. And what I'll say in brief so
- 1:02:55that this hasn't going too long, is that the differentiation idea is another angle.
- 1:03:02And what I'll say briefly is that going back to that scenario where my
- 1:03:08wife comes home and she's unglued about someone that was horrible on the highway to
- 1:03:15her in that moment, I have to not only be differentiated enough from her,
- 1:03:22not separate. Differentiated. It's kind of a bad word because it sounds
- 1:03:25like it's more of a and it is reflective. I think of Murray Bowen's
- 1:03:30white maleness that it privileges individuation and standing alone. You know, the word
- 1:03:38differentiation. It's sort of a glass half empty way of looking at things.
- 1:03:44Because as a part of differentiation, and it's contemporary understanding is that differentiation is
- 1:03:51a balance and a flexibility between being very close to someone and being very separate
- 1:03:58from someone. So anyway, in that moment, my wife is talking about
- 1:04:04what happened to her, and I have to establish enough differentiation and enough separateness
- 1:04:12but not too much. So on one hand, I want to be together.
- 1:04:15So differentiation is the balance between togetherness and separateness. That's just one way
- 1:04:19of putting it, and that's the way he put it. And so I
- 1:04:21want to be together with Stacy because I want her to feel that I'm with
- 1:04:26her and I can feel bad for her and that I'm listening to her.
- 1:04:31And I also want to be together so that I can have empathy, because
- 1:04:34if I'm too separate, I won't know what she's feeling. I won't feel
- 1:04:39what she's feeling. I won't feel it, and it won't show in my
- 1:04:43facial expressions as I'm listening, right, Because when she's telling me about this,
- 1:04:46if I'm together with her enough, it will just provoke facial expressions for
- 1:04:53me of like oh my god. Right, And she can benefit from that
- 1:05:00that openness and that togetherness that I have with her in that moment, or
- 1:05:03you could say that's between the two of us. Differentiation is a more individual
- 1:05:11oriented. You could kind of hear it my language, you know. Earlier
- 1:05:13I would say the system would call for a boundary of this and this system
- 1:05:16some talking about the differentiation of me, you know, and that is,
- 1:05:23like I said, it's like a different angle. It's a slightly different way
- 1:05:26of conceptualizing and languaging the whole thing. And Bowen tended to work with individuals,
- 1:05:31whereas Mnucha intended to work with the whole family anyway. So I need
- 1:05:38to be together enough, but I also need to be separate enough so that
- 1:05:41I don't drown in her emotions such that it would lead to bad things of
- 1:05:47me rejecting her or trying to control the situation, or running out the door
- 1:05:51and trying to kill someone or whatever, you know, or being too worried
- 1:05:56of her leaving the house in the future. You know, that would be
- 1:05:59another lack of differentiation. Result would be that the next time she wants to
- 1:06:05go to the store, I'd be like, I'll go for you, and
- 1:06:08she's like why, and I just don't wry. I I'll just go for
- 1:06:11you, you know. I just don't want anything bad happen to you.
- 1:06:14You can see a lot of ill effects from that, and I'm absorbing too
- 1:06:18much of it, right, So I need to be separate and together.
- 1:06:25That's the differentiation Bowen contemporary language. You know, it's my language. It's
- 1:06:30not every Boeenian wouldn't word it that way, but that's the way I word
- 1:06:35it. So going on, PS, I heard about the trolling and abuse
- 1:06:43you received after the Depp Heard videos and it was deeply saddening and upsetting to
- 1:06:47hear. I hope you're doing well. Kind regards fpl oh, well things,
- 1:06:51that's great. Yeah, it's been two years. Like I said,
- 1:06:57I think said this email a long time ago, but it's been two years
- 1:07:01since that trial. Ish and I are almost two years and I feel ninety
- 1:07:11nine percent recovered. I had to put a lot of effort from various different
- 1:07:15angles to adjust emotionally, and I won't go over it again because I've already
- 1:07:23been over it. But but yeah, I feel pretty good. As a
- 1:07:30product of me feeling more recovered is that I feel like I can talk more
- 1:07:39safely on the podcast. I feel more safe. I didn't feel safe after
- 1:07:45all that, and I guess if I think about it, like me and
- 1:07:49Berto, you know, we did this whole deep dive on neo Nazis.
- 1:07:51I'm pretty sure if I didn't feel safe, I wouldn't have even begun to
- 1:07:57do that topic. But I did at the whole the whole time I did.
- 1:08:01I did not feel unsafe heading into a very fraught area, right,
- 1:08:06and Berto and I went down a topic areas that were you know, pretty
- 1:08:14fraught politics Republicans, Democrats, and I feel like I have returned to the
- 1:08:24state that I maybe even before the pandemic. Really because you know, this
- 1:08:30is this really kind of has two layers. I won't go down this rabbit
- 1:08:32hole too far, but when you know, before the pandemic, I was
- 1:08:41somewhat you know, I had a I had an audience, but and it
- 1:08:46was, uh, it was big enough such that I was able to scale
- 1:08:51back a lot on my private practice, and I was seriously considering retiring from
- 1:08:59my job as a profess or early scaling back significantly. You know, I
- 1:09:01was making enough money on Patreon to be specific, to be able to do
- 1:09:06that financially, and I, you know, things were going you know,
- 1:09:14it'd been eleven years up until that point to get there, and obsessing about
- 1:09:18the podcast a little time to get there. And then when I and during
- 1:09:26that time, I was and I think when you need to listen to reruns
- 1:09:30from around that time, I'm not holding back really, I'm just I'm exhibiting
- 1:09:35that I feel safe enough to just talk off the cuff and maybe take some
- 1:09:40risks with topics or things that I was saying. You know, I wasn't,
- 1:09:43you know, completely unhinged or anything, but just fluid and comfortable.
- 1:09:49Then when the pandemic happened and I started making these reaction videos and suddenly a
- 1:09:55lot of new people, you know, I guess one way of putting it
- 1:10:00is, during that time, like midway through twenty twenty, the vast majority
- 1:10:05of people who were consuming my content had just discovered me, like a month
- 1:10:12or two earlier. And so when I would say something that was out of
- 1:10:18the boundaries that they thought using there were boundaries of what they thought was what
- 1:10:24I should be saying or what they were used to me saying, I would
- 1:10:28get this reaction from everyone. Even though I was saying things that I was
- 1:10:31saying a few months earlier, and there was there was no reactivity. And
- 1:10:35so that affected me too. I started to pull back on the reins because
- 1:10:43this whole new world started opening up to me. It's like, well,
- 1:10:45what can I say? And on the audio podcast I always felt more free
- 1:10:49because you know, the vast majority of you know, the new people weren't
- 1:10:54listening to audio podcasts. But anyway, so I would say that I came
- 1:11:00maybe ten to fifteen percent uncomfortable about the words that were coming out of my
- 1:11:06mouth when I was making content. And then when the trial happened midway through
- 1:11:13twenty twenty two, then like I became, it pushed me to probably like
- 1:11:19sixty to seventy percent uncomfortable, to the point where I would just be doing
- 1:11:25a casual episode with Emberto and I'd be second guessing everything that I was going
- 1:11:30to say. And the whole time, I did not feel like I was
- 1:11:35having fun or that I was enjoying the process. It wasn't fulfilling. It
- 1:11:41just felt like I was in constant danger. And you know, I literally
- 1:11:45had people that I mean, I won't go into details, but you know
- 1:11:48there was physical threat of well, i'll just say, you know, the
- 1:11:54kind of stuff that you hear other people experiencing. I experienced some of it.
- 1:12:00Know, the authorities were involved, government agencies were involved, out of
- 1:12:05my control. I mean, I won't go into details like so it was
- 1:12:09I did. I never called the authorities. The authorities just found out and
- 1:12:16again I won't go into details, but and still are involved. But anyway,
- 1:12:24so you know, it was scary. And through a joint systemic process
- 1:12:33of me and you and Stacy and Alina and all my friends and Umbardo and
- 1:12:43Bob and Rebecca and me and you and Stacy and everyone else, I you
- 1:12:51know, worked on how to create a place where we can all be safe
- 1:13:00and feel safe and good and comfortable while still pressing the envelope right, still
- 1:13:08pushing those boundaries if you will have comfortability, but taking care of each other
- 1:13:15and me taking care of myself, and me also reaching out. You know,
- 1:13:19a big part of me gaining safety is actually revealing to you what's going
- 1:13:27on for me, because without that you might just think, well, he's
- 1:13:33saying those things because he just doesn't care or whatever. But if you know,
- 1:13:36then you're more likely to if you do respond or provide feedback, take
- 1:13:44into account the reality of what I'm going through, not that you wouldn't give
- 1:13:47me negative feedback or something, but that you know, it's a different thing.
- 1:13:51Right. If you know what's going on with me and I'd say something
- 1:13:56that pisses you off, You're more likely to word it differently and understand it
- 1:14:01differently, Whereas if you didn't know that, you would just think I was
- 1:14:04just a drink face, and then you would feel you had license to just
- 1:14:10also at least be kind of a drink face back to me, you know
- 1:14:13what I mean. So you know it involved a lot of things, and
- 1:14:15it was you know, I worked on it, And it's reflective of what
- 1:14:19it's like to be a therapist when we as professionals go through moments like that,
- 1:14:25which happen a lot, especially when you focus on particular kinds of things
- 1:14:30like personal I SoRs. You're going to have those moments, and it's a
- 1:14:36healing process that involves a lot of different components, Right, Like there were
- 1:14:44times in my practice when I would have a really really bad experience with a
- 1:14:49personality disordered client, for example, and I would pull back on all my
- 1:14:56clients emotionally because I didn't feel safe in general. Right, And how do
- 1:15:01I pull out of that? What do I do? How do I get
- 1:15:05out do I even know what's happening? Do I have systems in place to
- 1:15:11react to that? Where's my vulnerability? Who am I vulnerable to? How
- 1:15:15do I notice when I feel safe again? How do I see the situation?
- 1:15:20What do I need to do to predict myself? But also still being
- 1:15:25open to clients, you know, it's that's what it's like to be a
- 1:15:28therapist. It's this constant awareness and effort and also acknowledgment of reality along those
- 1:15:34things. You know, That's why I love being a therapist because you know,
- 1:15:38other sort of disciplines jobs, they don't have that tradition. And so
- 1:15:44although you might have an individual that likes to do that, their colleagues might
- 1:15:47look at them like, why are you so introspective? Why are you staring
- 1:15:54at your navel all the time? Like get on with it, just move
- 1:15:57on, you know. So being a therapist to me really empowers me,
- 1:16:03you know, and all other therapists to be able to manage a lot of
- 1:16:06aspects of life, not just how to help people, you know what I
- 1:16:11mean. So let's adjourn there. I mean, I would think, and
- 1:16:18I always love hearing from you, Famous patron Linden. Your emails are kick
- 1:16:23ass. You might want to be careful on how many send me send me
- 1:16:29because there's so in depth that but anyway, I I uh, Linden goes
- 1:16:41way back on the part, and I always love hearing from people and staying
- 1:16:45connected to people who go back to the sort of not the beginning. I
- 1:16:49don't think anyone's with us, and I would I would put a lot of
- 1:16:55money down that there isn't a single person that consumes my content that was a
- 1:17:00fan in the first four years. If you are one of those people,
- 1:17:05please let me know. I'm talking, you know, nineteen, I'm talking
- 1:17:09two thousand and eight to twenty twelve. I'm imagining that none of you,
- 1:17:16I don't know, maybe like some of my former students, if you're still
- 1:17:19listening, because you would have anyway. So when I'm talking about old og
- 1:17:27fans, I'm talking about people that maybe started listening in twenty fourteen or something,
- 1:17:32which is a long ass time ago, but it's still like six years
- 1:17:36into the podcast. It's just kind of funny that, like, you have
- 1:17:41this thing that no one remembers that you'd spend all this time on for the
- 1:17:45first number of years. Anyway, which is fine, and I hope no
- 1:17:47one remembers it, because you know that content was at the very at least
- 1:17:53tonally. It's a lot different different, but it's also I didn't know what
- 1:17:57I was doing. I was just a therapist trying to be an internet content
- 1:18:01person, and there was no guide. You know. Now you go to
- 1:18:06YouTube and be like, how do I create a channel? And there's all
- 1:18:09this you know, this, all these guides and articles about Like back then,
- 1:18:14it's like, uh, I think you just point a camera at something
- 1:18:17or a mic and you just talk or something. I don't know anyway,
- 1:18:21So it's always great to hear from you, famous patron Linden and everyone out
- 1:18:27there. Please take care of yourself and think about your boundaries, meaning think
- 1:18:32about how you're how this, how the roots here? Okay, here's the
- 1:18:35thing. The next time you're in a fight or some bad experience with someone
- 1:18:42close to you, if you want, if you care to, thinking systemically
- 1:18:47requires thinking, Okay, what is the pattern if I were outside of that
- 1:18:56situation, what would happen. Another area you can look at is if you
- 1:18:59have kids or there's other people in your life who are fighting, is it's
- 1:19:03easier to kind of sit back and watch or you know, as objectively as
- 1:19:09possible, like tak an account of like the exact sequence. This is what
- 1:19:14I do with my with my students. I say, start with a sequence
- 1:19:16of behavior, what exactly it. Don't analyze it yet, because if you
- 1:19:23don't know what you're analyzing, you're just analyzing a random store in your head.
- 1:19:27So you have to know what it is and what it is systemically,
- 1:19:30is the sequence this person said this, then this person did this, Then
- 1:19:34this person did that, then this person said that, then this person does
- 1:19:38that. A little deeper is inferring emotion. This person did this, which
- 1:19:44caused this person to feel this, which caused them to do this, which
- 1:19:46caused this other person to feel this, which caused them to do this.
- 1:19:49And it's a little deeper. You're inferring. You're not necessarily completely aware,
- 1:19:56of course, but it's a little but ver at least you're still in that
- 1:20:00sequence area. Then you can analyze it. You can start to look at
- 1:20:06things systemically once you have that understanding, because usually what people do linearly is
- 1:20:13like that person's jerk face, and that person is a victim of the jerk
- 1:20:16face. I see this when I watch reality TV, that the audience will
- 1:20:23tend to react to reality TV with this urge, this like desperation to figure
- 1:20:29out who's the bad guy and who's the good guy? Or I mean a
- 1:20:32lot of times they're like, everyone's a bad guy, but one person's less
- 1:20:35of a bad guy. And that can be a useful way of looking at
- 1:20:41it, and it might be a coherent way of looking at it, but
- 1:20:45it's only one way of looking at it. Another helpful coherent way of looking
- 1:20:48at things is, look, no one's a bad guy, everyone's a bad
- 1:20:51guy, whatever. But how does the system operate? What are the rules,
- 1:20:58what are the boundaries, How do the boundaries react? What are the
- 1:21:00boundaries around this relationship and the rest of the world. What's the pattern?
- 1:21:06What's the routine when this person does this? What does this person do?
- 1:21:12What are the needs of the system and how are they being met? Are
- 1:21:15the boundaries flexible enough and healthy enough and have enough reactivity such that everyone can
- 1:21:25get their needs met? That's in my line. I rarely, if ever,
- 1:21:29hear systems serious talk like this. Family systems serious talk like this.
- 1:21:32But unless you add this in, I feel like you're just floating in space.
- 1:21:38So the system, the family system, the system of me and Stacy.
- 1:21:42A big part of its purpose is to optimize our needs being met,
- 1:21:47which involve our individual needs and our needs as a couple. And so do
- 1:21:54our boundaries and our routines and our patterns do they facilitate our needs being met?
- 1:22:00So when I'm getting out of the car and I have this upwelling of
- 1:22:05love for my wife, I mean, part of it is like, how
- 1:22:09did we even get there? Because earlier in the day she came into my
- 1:22:13office and said, do you want to do something tonight? You want to
- 1:22:16go to dinner or something? So that's something that happened for it, And
- 1:22:20then we could go further back and enter her emotions. Where did that come
- 1:22:26from? Why? And also were what barriers weren't there for her? Because
- 1:22:33if she worried I was going to reject her, then she might not say
- 1:22:38that, right, Or if I had hurt her feelings earlier in the day,
- 1:22:43it would it would interfere with her enacting that urge or even having it
- 1:22:46in the first place, right. So when you start to really analyze systems,
- 1:22:51you start to see it in that way. No one's to blame,
- 1:22:58no one is responsible, so to speak, for the entirety of how a
- 1:23:02system operates, right, It just it's happening. And so anyway, as
- 1:23:10I had that upwelling of love, for as I'm getting in the car and
- 1:23:15I say, hey, come here, why did I do that? Why
- 1:23:19did I not feel afraid to do it? Why did I feel safe to
- 1:23:28do it? Why did stacy like within the blink of an eye slam into
- 1:23:34me? And then even the micro as we are standing there having some affection,
- 1:23:45what are the exact muscle movements really? Right? Because that's all safety
- 1:23:50based and routine based. We have a routine to the way we do that.
- 1:23:57We have a routine the way that we ask for that. And some
- 1:24:00systems don't have those routines. And so it's not like, hey, you're
- 1:24:04a jerk face. You never say you love me, or you never kiss
- 1:24:09me or hugby. It's the system doesn't have a routine to facilitate that.
- 1:24:13And in order to establish those routines, the homeostasis has to change. It
- 1:24:18has to sometimes it requires dismantling all the rules that are operating on a system.
- 1:24:25And of course our childhoods inform our tendencies regarding certain routines. You know,
- 1:24:32the routines and the patterns that were developed and we saw in our family
- 1:24:38of origin. We tend to repeat those, but we can absolutely establish new
- 1:24:43routines right And for some people, what family therapy is about is just introducing
- 1:24:48a new routine that they didn't even know was possible, that they had never
- 1:24:54seen before, and are their minds are blown like wait, so wait,
- 1:24:58we could be doing that. And so the way that family systems think is
- 1:25:02like, your relationship isn't broken or your spouse isn't broken. We just have
- 1:25:10to change your routine and we have to figure out what routines should be discarded
- 1:25:14and what routines need to be added. And it's not as easy as just
- 1:25:18saying, look, you just need to hug and kiss more. It's everything.
- 1:25:23It's safety, it's love, it's your emotions. It's how do you
- 1:25:30notice each other. It's the boundaries, it's outside things that are involved.
- 1:25:35It's how differentiated everybody is. You know, it's very complicated. It's not
- 1:25:42just like telling a client you need to create a new pattern of kissing and
- 1:25:46hugging. More like there's a reason why they're not doing it. Partially it's
- 1:25:50because of modeling, but partially it's because of some there's something going on that's
- 1:25:56interfering with their natural desire to hug and kiss. They naturally want to do
- 1:26:01that. What's getting in the way, How did it get in the way,
- 1:26:05How do we change that pattern? What pattern do we have to create
- 1:26:10to change the pattern? That's a whole other thing. It gets complicated anyway,
- 1:26:14So you can think about for yourself, either observing from the outside or
- 1:26:17yourself of you know, like a really easy thing is you have a fight
- 1:26:21with your partner and then at some point that's soon enough after that you remember
- 1:26:27enough of the details, but not so soon that you're still undifferentiated. So
- 1:26:32as soon as you establish enough differentiation and can look at it as objectively as
- 1:26:38possible, you want to try to recall, and sometimes, you know,
- 1:26:43you have to make stuff up, like well, I'm pretty sure this isn't
- 1:26:45exactly how things went down, but this is an approximation that this person did
- 1:26:48this, and that I did that, and then generally this my partner did
- 1:26:53this, and then I did this, and then you can start to see
- 1:26:56when you look at it in that way, and that stemic routine pattern from
- 1:27:01above zoomed out way different solutions emerge other than my partner needs to stop being
- 1:27:09an asshole, or I need to stop being an asshole. You start looking
- 1:27:12at Okay, how did the system start not in conflict but then eventually it
- 1:27:18was in the throes of conflict. What's going on with this couple, what's
- 1:27:24going on with the outside of the system and the broader system. You can
- 1:27:30understand why people avoid thinking this way because it's it introduces billions of factors.
- 1:27:36It's like trying to predict the weather, which is another system which is impossible
- 1:27:41to predict, and it gets hard, and you know, I understand why
- 1:27:47why people avoid it. I avoid it. It's too it hurts my brain.
- 1:27:56But the solutions and the accuracy that it provides is superior to a lot
- 1:28:03of linear ways of thinking, particularly when we're talking about relationships. And that's
- 1:28:09why family therapists, couple therapists originally back in the fifties and sixties were attracted
- 1:28:16to systems theory because that was a general systems theory, a theory for all
- 1:28:21systems, whether it's ecology, the weather, a sell a molecule, the
- 1:28:30solar system, a political system, you know, the system of the world,
- 1:28:35a societal system, an organization system, you know, the system of
- 1:28:40a company. Applying it to families really opened up a whole new landscape to
- 1:28:53explore, discover and help and everyone out there please stake care of yourself because
- 1:28:58you deserve it, You really really do it in