Latest / Girl, Take the Lead! / 86. Book Discussion: Machiavelli for Women by Stacey Vanek Smith – 500 Years Later & What He Says About Leadership
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to episode 86. A Girl Take the Lead for Each
- 0:12week we explore womanhood and leadership.
- 0:15And I'm your host, yo Canny. So let me ask you, when you hear
- 0:20the name Machiavelli, what do you think?
- 0:25Maybe a historical figure. Maybe you've heard of his work
- 0:30The Prince, which offered pragmatic and often
- 0:34controversial advice to rules on how to gain and maintain power.
- 0:41Maybe you see him as an amoral realist who believed the end
- 0:47justified the means, and that rules should be ready to employ
- 0:52deceit and cruelty to achieve their goals.
- 0:56And if someone uses the adjective Machiavellian, it's
- 1:01done so to describe cunning and manipulative behavior.
- 1:08Maybe not a good thing, right? I know I thought some of these
- 1:12things too myself. So when my local bookstore
- 1:16recommended Stacey Vanek Smith's book Machiavelli for Women, I
- 1:21went what? Stacey Vanek Smith is a long
- 1:25time public radio reporter and host.
- 1:28She currently cohost NPR The Indicator from Planet Money, a
- 1:33daily podcast. She is also served as a
- 1:37correspondent for NPR's Planet Money and Marketplace.
- 1:41So she's no slouch when it comes to research, and this book is
- 1:46full of it. After reading Stacy's book, I
- 1:49learned a lot more about Machiavelli and came to
- 1:53appreciate the lessons he can offer all of us about leadership
- 1:57and power. And my hope after listening to
- 2:00this podcast, you will too. So I ask you to suspend any
- 2:05prior beliefs you may have about Machiavelli, and let's open
- 2:10ourselves to hearing about this man's writing done during the
- 2:15Renaissance period and their application to us today as
- 2:20proposed by the author. I hope you'll enjoy the listen.
- 2:24Here you go. Stacy presents the issue facing
- 2:32women today. Early in the book she says that
- 2:35while women are making real and substantial progress, hard won
- 2:40by generations of pioneering women, things are still a bit
- 2:44distressing. 80% of CE O's are men and within the Fortune 500
- 2:51more than 90%. Corporate boards are more than
- 2:5580%. Male women make about $0.80 for
- 3:00every male dollar. 2/3 of federal judges are male. 75% of
- 3:07elected representatives are men. Women start 40% of the
- 3:13businesses in the country, but 98% of venture capital goes to
- 3:19men. And she asks, why would this be?
- 3:25She states that popular explanations include women shy
- 3:28away from leadership positions. Women want more flexibility with
- 3:33their time, so they avoid the most demanding jobs.
- 3:37Women are more nurturing and collaborative.
- 3:40In other words, they lack the killer instinct you need in a
- 3:45leader or decision maker. And she states all of these
- 3:49explanations have seeds of truth in them.
- 3:52But she believes the real reason for the frustratingly slow
- 3:57progress of women in the workplace is something
- 4:00Machiavelli summed up quite well about 500 years ago.
- 4:05And here's the quote. Let it be noted that there is no
- 4:11more delicate matter to take in hand, nor more dangerous to
- 4:15conduct, nor more doubtful in its success, than to set up as a
- 4:22leader in the introduction of changes.
- 4:26For he who initiates will have for his enemies all those who
- 4:31were well off under the existing order of things, and only
- 4:37lukewarm supporters in those who might be better off under the
- 4:41new okay. So what did that quote mean, and
- 4:47what does it mean in today's English?
- 4:50Stacy says Changing the system is really hard, and you will
- 4:54probably fail. The old guard will freak out
- 4:57because they have so much to lose, and the people who would
- 5:02benefit from the change will waffle because they're scared
- 5:06and skeptical of how much they would really benefit even if
- 5:13they did manage to pull off this crazy hat trick.
- 5:16So for me personally, as I reflected on this, I wondered at
- 5:20my own career ambition and why didn't I go for being a CEO?
- 5:25I had friends who did, but why didn't I?
- 5:29I did become a Senior Vice President of Global Marketing
- 5:32and then again a Senior VP of Marketing and Sales.
- 5:36And being completely honest with you though, I think it was
- 5:40because I was fearful. I didn't think I was smart
- 5:44enough to break through the boys clubs.
- 5:47I could remember interviewing once with PepsiCo for a Pepsi
- 5:51brand management position and being asked in my interview what
- 5:56competitive sports I played like.
- 6:00None. I didn't get the job.
- 6:03No surprise there, right? But I did learn something about
- 6:07the game I was ill equipped to play.
- 6:11I wasn't competitive enough. Or could it have been something
- 6:16like I didn't know how to present myself in a competitive
- 6:21way? Interesting.
- 6:25And as I progressed in my career, I saw what CEO's did and
- 6:29thought, gosh, how did they learn about partnerships,
- 6:33mergers, investments in finance? And did I want to learn them?
- 6:39By the time I could have gone in that direction, I started my
- 6:42family and frankly, being a CEO didn't sound very interesting
- 6:47and I could see the cost. And honestly, I was passionate
- 6:52about marketing and that became my lane.
- 6:56I thought I could handle that and balance my family.
- 7:00So I did hit the glass ceiling, didn't shatter it, but did get a
- 7:05little close to it and had a place at the table.
- 7:10So I guess I would say to you that just because there's a
- 7:14shortage of women representation at these senior levels, go for
- 7:19them if that's what you want and works for you, but it's okay if
- 7:24you don't. I started this podcast so we
- 7:28could all find our voices, breakthrough things that held us
- 7:33back, and become aware of ourselves.
- 7:36Someone else's success could be someone else's misery.
- 7:42So build your own version. What is success to you?
- 7:46Not everyone needs to be a CEO on a corporate board, be an
- 7:51elected official or federal judge.
- 7:55You just do you, No matter what. Our path, the principles and
- 8:00lessons Stacey Vanek Smith offers us in her book might be
- 8:04helpful to all of us along our journey.
- 8:08I pulled just a few of the many gems for you.
- 8:11The first is something she calls the Power Principle, and she
- 8:15says this quote. Power doesn't exactly have the
- 8:20best reputation. Say the word, and it conjures up
- 8:24images of men and expensive suits behind giant desks.
- 8:29End Quote. And she goes on to offer an
- 8:32alternative way to think about it, since most of us do have
- 8:36negative beliefs around power and the misuse of it.
- 8:40She says this, which is a more empowering way to look at power.
- 8:45Quote I think what women want in the workplace has a lot more to
- 8:50do with the original meaning of the word power, which means to
- 8:55be able. Power means being able to do
- 9:00things, to have agency and be the masters of our own fates.
- 9:06Women in the workplace want to be able End Quote, So what is
- 9:13standing between us and power? Stacy asks.
- 9:16And I love when she wrote this. Leaders are by definition high
- 9:21status. So when women are in leadership
- 9:25position, it often does not sit well with people, and it all
- 9:33comes down to stories, which can be formidable because they are
- 9:37woven into our identities. We use stories to make sense of
- 9:43things, and letting go of them can make the world seem
- 9:46frightening and chaotic. But the good news is we can
- 9:50change the stories throughout the book.
- 9:54Stacy includes lots of research. One example is Joan C Williams,
- 10:00who is a gender researcher and coauthor who is quoted to have
- 10:05said women can totally crush it at work so long as they're about
- 10:11twice as politically savvy as men.
- 10:15And Stacy adds to this, and I couldn't agree more that that's
- 10:20a lot of savvy. On top of a day job and a family
- 10:24and gas bills and getting in your 10,000 steps, I think we
- 10:28can all relay, no? Oh yeah, Stacy goes on to ask us
- 10:32to face the monster, a story that is big and insidious and
- 10:37ugly and entrenched and powerful and destructive and annoyingly
- 10:41hard to kill. So what could this monster be
- 10:44and how do we slay it? She starts this with an
- 10:47explanation of the Cinderella syndrome.
- 10:50We all know how the story goes. The stepmom tells Cinderella she
- 10:53can't go to the ball, only after she cleans the entryway.
- 10:57Mop the floors, Polish the silver, iron the napkins and the
- 11:00list goes on and on. Stacy says the stepmother is
- 11:04holding out the illusion of possibility to Cinderella, and
- 11:07Cinderella believes her. She states that women in the
- 11:10workplace get put in this position too all the time.
- 11:14Whereas men are typically promoted based on what they
- 11:16perceive their potential to be, women are typically promoted
- 11:20based on actual work they've done, usually again and again
- 11:24and again. This slows women down
- 11:26substantially in early and mid career.
- 11:29Women are told they can get that promotion or raise if they just
- 11:33do this one more thing. Meanwhile, Randy and Jerry
- 11:37saunter on into the ball without having so much as washed a dish.
- 11:44I thought that was really great, how she put that together, Stacy
- 11:48says. The perceived notions about what
- 11:51makes a good leader include qualities like being aggressive,
- 11:54assertive, logical, self confident, ambitious, visionary,
- 11:59brave, and demanding, and that these are 100% masculine traits.
- 12:06Now, she says that qualities people associate with an ideal
- 12:09woman are someone who is affectionate, helpful,
- 12:13sympathetic, sensitive, gentle, soft spoken, modest, and puts
- 12:18others 1st. And if a woman displays the
- 12:22masculine traits, others feel very uncomfortable because it
- 12:25goes against their stories or biases about what they think
- 12:30leadership is. And there's something else, you
- 12:32guys. She calls it the hot box and it
- 12:36often happens to women in mid career when they start getting
- 12:41close to leadership positions or positions of power.
- 12:44It's being caught between two seats of expectations, feminine
- 12:48or leader. And it's a no win situation.
- 12:52And why people are likely to think of women as difficult,
- 12:56abrasive, and hard to get along with when leading.
- 12:59Or someone kind, generous, modest, advocate for others,
- 13:03smiling and supported behind the scenes, chronically underpaid
- 13:08and loaded down with work. Oh, in our episodes with Andrea
- 13:12Main DeWitt, we've come to see that we can mix our traits, and
- 13:16all of us are a combination of masculine and feminine traits,
- 13:21I'd add understanding that might help us navigate better.
- 13:26And what does Machiavelli have to say about this?
- 13:29He says the Prince cannot avoid giving offense to his new
- 13:33subjects, and however, it is essential that in entering a new
- 13:38province, you should have the goodwill of its inhabitants.
- 13:43Stacy offers us this translation.
- 13:46To win your new Kingdom, you have to do things that makes the
- 13:50locals hate you. To keep your new Kingdom, you
- 13:54need to get the logos to like you.
- 13:58To me that says mixing up our masculine and feminine traits
- 14:03and it can be your secret weapon you guys going into battle.
- 14:07Also throughout the book Stacy offers Machiavelli's lessons.
- 14:12The 1st is embrace the struggle. Your hardships are setting you
- 14:17up for success, not only to get what you want, but to keep it,
- 14:24Machiavelli wrote. Princess become great by
- 14:28vanishing difficulties and opposition.
- 14:32But before we all go Game of Thrones on this, which is where
- 14:36I went, let's take them all out, Stacy says.
- 14:40There's a Zen moment in The Prince where Machiavelli felt so
- 14:43strongly about the value of hardship, where he said
- 14:46something along the line of things happen for me, not to me.
- 14:54And the quote goes like this fortune Machiavelli wrote,
- 14:59especially when she desires to make a new Prince great causes
- 15:04enemies to arise and form designs against him in order
- 15:08that he may have the opportunity of overcoming them.
- 15:12His conclusion? Great leaders become great
- 15:16because of hardship and struggle.
- 15:19As we reflect on Machiavelli's conclusion, I'd like to weigh in
- 15:23and say yes. Overcoming hardships can make us
- 15:27more resilient, more empathetic and courageous, all great
- 15:32characteristics we'd love to have in our leaders.
- 15:36But it can go the other way too, and lead us to burn out, feel
- 15:40helpless, and a victim. Let's all do what we can to take
- 15:45a different path, a path that is right for us and works for us
- 15:50and doesn't burn us out. Stacy's hope with this book is
- 15:55that we all use these difficult circumstances to create a new
- 16:00kind of workplace. A workplace where everyone can
- 16:03experience the joys, challenges, rewards, and growth that come
- 16:09from doing the work you love. A workplace where everyone can
- 16:13grow into their very best personal and professional
- 16:18selves. A workplace where everyone can
- 16:22be able, and on that note, will end today's episode.
- 16:28Thank you for being here. Thank you for listening today
- 16:33and wish your hope you enjoyed this episode.
- 16:36If you did, please leave us a comment wherever you listen to
- 16:40your podcasts or join our public Facebook group Girl Take the
- 16:44Lead. And I'd like to welcome our
- 16:46newest members to the Facebook group Teresa and Rebecca.
- 16:50Thank you for joining us. You can also visit our website
- 16:54girltaketheleadpod.com and we have a YouTube channel where
- 16:58your subscription would be appreciated.
- 17:00Once you're on YouTube, search a girl, take the lead.
- 17:05So the three takeaways from this episode were one.
- 17:09No, you're not crazy. The Know when situation is real,
- 17:13but we can navigate all kinds of ways, and Machiavelli offers us
- 17:17insights into doing just that. 2.
- 17:21The Cinderella Syndrome and the Hot Box can be a disadvantage,
- 17:26but by being aware of them, we can open up new possibilities
- 17:29for changing the story. And three, facing the Bias
- 17:34monster will mean embracing our hardships and struggles.
- 17:40This episode, believe it or not, only covered chapter one, so I'm
- 17:45planning to do a sound bite on Thursday about some more gems
- 17:49from the book. I hope that you'll join us again
- 17:52to hear a bit more about Machiavelli for women.
- 17:55Thank you Stacey Vanek Smith for such a great book.
- 17:57Plus, we have lots of exciting guests lined up for August,
- 18:00including Nori Java, author of Keeping Your Seat at the Table,
- 18:04a return visit by Andrea Canny to talk about her insights about
- 18:10ageism. Courtney Lee, Founder, OYT
- 18:13Cosmetics, Bessie Graham, Awardwinning Entrepreneur and
- 18:18Maria Maruchian, an expert in diversity, equality and
- 18:22inclusion. Stay tuned to listen to these
- 18:25amazing women leaders and what they have to say about
- 18:28leadership. Thanks for being here.
- 18:31Talk to you soon. Bye.