Latest / The Academic Boardroom Podcast / 7x Sports Emmy Award Winner: Navigating the Unpredictable Paradox in Sports Media
Transcript
- There are on air people who it's a crutch, like they will have the websites open in the league, websites that are awesome. They'll tell you the exit velocity and this and that. And there is reading off with, you know, you got to blend in. So just like making informed decisions in the front office, right? They're not usually getting hired because they can read off a computer screen when they're watching a baseball game. They're at the game. Their eyes, as a former player, should be seeing things that things that I can have the website open also, if I wanted to, I can. Sometimes I do, but I'm not sitting above home plate as a former major leaguer because I'm not. And seeing the game like, that's what I want you to be doing numbers there to help you, use them. I'm pro numbers, but don't make that like your calling card either. Theme Music Welcome to the table. You tuned in to the academic boardroom with doctor J and doctor E, pull up a chair. Higher learning, higher stakes. Welcome back to The Academic Boardroom, a podcast where we sit down with power brokers shaping the future of education. I'm your host, Dr. Eli Joseph, and joining me is my colleague and partner in crime, Dr. Janice Jassim Asare. Today we have a special guest, Jeff Bennett, who recently served as the Vice president of Talent Strategy and Research Data analytics at the FanDuel Sports Network. Prior to his work at the FanDuel Sports Network, Jeff Bennett spent over 30 years at ESPN, where he served as the vice president of ESPN Stats and Information Group. He founded ESPN analytics in 2010, and the team developed various metrics and tools that we know in sports today, such as total BR, also known as Quarterback Ratings, Football Power Index, Basketball Power Index, and Strength of Record. Jeff won seven Sports Emmy Awards for various contributions, including as a researcher on ESPN's Sports Center and Baseball Tonight. Studio shows. Jeff. Welcome to the boardroom. Dr. Eli, Dr. Janice, thank you for having me. I'm really honored. I'm really honored to be here because. And to be here with Jeff. Because it's a full circle moment. Rob King, who was also, I believe, was a senior vice president at ESPN. He connected us back in 2018, 2019 and interesting. Interesting enough. I applied to a sports betting analytics specialist role, and I didn't get the job. I was rejected, and I remember sending an email to Jeff, by the way. Jeff, thank you so much. But I was rejected and he was like, don't sweat it. I don't worry about it. And I'm glad that we were able to connect there again. I hope you didn't take that the wrong way. I don't mean to be flipping around. I don't sweat it and get a job you're looking for. But yeah, it's a it was competitive and I'm not. Like I said, I'm not even sure we've been filled that position as it was posted. We probably we probably evolved it, you know, because the sports betting industry was changing so much with the legislation and things. So interesting time for that. Yeah. It's all it's all good. It's all fine. Dr. Janice Gassam Asare I have a question that I was wondering, as I was looking more into you and reading more about your bio. Jeff. So, I know that most people fall into sports analytics from math backgrounds, or maybe people who are like really interested in statistics. But what I'm very curious about your origin story. Like, have you always been a numbers person or was that something that came for you later on? Yes. Great question. Always a numbers person from looking at the backs of baseball cards when I was six and memorizing statistics, you know, dating myself. If the 30 years ESPN didn't date myself enough, you know, scavenging newspaper box scores and memorizing statistics that way. I did go to a school called Worcester Polytechnic Institute in Massachusetts, and I was it's an engineering school. The nickname of the school was The engineers. So of course, I was a math major. Everyone else I knew was an engineer, but I survived that. What ESPN didn't have was other math majors. When I started there, they were. Everyone there went to like Syracuse, northwestern schools with journalism and communications. I felt very much like a fish out of water there, but I was able to hook on on my second role at ESPN with the research department, which I didn't really know what that was or meant, but I knew it meant sports history, which I was certainly qualified for, and they used calculators to figure out statistics. So I figure out if they use a calculator that's close to math. There's numbers unlike other people, just not just I don't mean that, but other most roles involved like tapes and in video. So to be able to use a calculator to help in numbers of tell a story, that's how I kind of gravitated through that track, through the span and then right place, right time. As the internet gained a footing and sports data became digitized and commoditized, where you can go on free websites like the reference sites, sports reference sites, and there's so many more where just the information age, sports analytics. When I went to college, I never heard of the word analytics. There were any sports analytics jobs. To my knowledge, people in the front offices were mostly former players. They weren't people who went to Ivy League schools or or came up to us, you know, scouting or some people in for officers now, you know, started with blogging and websites like in the 1990s. That was not how people got team front offices across any sport. But, you know, right place, right time. And Michael Lewis writing the ball money, Moneyball, you know, that opened a lot of people's eyes and some executive eyes at ESPN that we needed to have a more concentrated, higher level sports. They didn't even use word analytics. It was like a quantitative analysis team. And I got tabbed to lead that. And we made that. The sports analytics team in 2010 for I get those reasons later, but that's just kind of how it went as the that's the abridged version. But yeah, a lot of right place right time and just, you know, seeing some opportunities and surrounding myself with some really, really, really smart people. You know, I do I do not have a doctorate. I've often said there's not a lot of PhDs walking around the hallways in sports media, but the people that did have PhDs, I hired them and they worked for me. So great tip for any leaders. Hire some really, really smart people and surround yourself as many of them as possible. I wanted to jump in and ask you this question. Speaking of hiring PhDs as an executive. As a hiring manager, would you prefer a data scientist who loves sports or a sports expert who knows Python? Well, they both have value. If I have to only choose one, I guess it probably depends on what the projects goal was, what type of project it is. You know, ideally you on the team, you have people with some overlapping complementary skills, but also very different skills. So you know, sports expertise at ESPN, super important. Maybe at another company in sports, the expertise doesn't have to be at the same threshold that ESPN is. But you still have to know, you know, a fair amount of sports to know what you're coding or what's meaningful in the results you're creating. Data scientists have tremendous value. Again, that wasn't even a term that existed when we started the sports analytics team. At least not. It wasn't very if it was if it was a term at all, it wasn't popular yet. So we were trying to figure out we're specialists. We're engineers like, what are what are we calling these positions? And then in a few years, data science was popping up everywhere. And, you know, people were studying data science and studying sports analytics and data science. And I wish we had that pool of people to hire when we started the team. No offense. I love the people we hired. But, you know, just again exploded so quickly. And we were such positioned well that when we started expanding the team, we were flooded with people who would, you know, went to school with to study sports analytics. I couldn't believe it. They didn't just exist a few years prior to us starting the team. So I'm dodging the question on how to answer that because I have I've had people who are sports experts who nobody thought and super valuable, and I've had people who are data scientists who like sports, maybe aren't as passionate. They both have value. But I'm going to be greedy and say I want both of them on my team. Okay, so I have a question for you that maybe some of the listeners who are in awe of, you know, your background and and want to do what you do. So I have a question. So if a college student told you that they wanted your job. What would you tell them is important to study and what would you tell them not to waste their time on? I probably would say, well, I don't currently have a job. I am a free agent right now, so watch what you wish for. I wouldn't say my path is is something that is, you know, anyone wanted to take the long, the long, slow journey? I'm not sure people wanted, you know, 20 years to become in sports analytics. You want to get there quicker. And I would say they probably should. You know, there's so many avenues at the core level. Find some products. If you're a student, find some projects or topics you're passionate about. Find ways to show your work. You know, have a blog. Just sometimes, you know, ten years ago, years ago, maybe in a different social media climate, people like Twitter was a really interesting place in the 2010 2011 for people to to make connections in the sports analytics industry and to to bounce ideas off each other. So I don't know if Xcom is that a more. I'm pretty sure it's not. But finding a place where you can you can show work, you can do some visualizations, you can get some feedback and get some peer review. I think it's really important we have candidates, you know, as at ESPN. And we were looking, you know, we were often hiring people that we already knew about because they had they had a really popular website that was interesting. And they've done the work. And, you know, we had rarely do we did someone cross our desk that we had never heard of before. And sometimes if that was the case, we would give them a side project as part of the interview process to see what kind of work they were doing. But the more reps you can get, you know, again, people who go to schools who can work in sports analytics and study that officially, which is amazing. I did just general math, applied statistics when I was at WPI. You know, now schools are getting awesome project work and partnering with teams or leagues. And as undergrads, they're getting great access. Usually, the biggest challenge is getting data is get, because then we had proprietary data or data we couldn't share because of our league rights and league agreements, which made it challenging to work with students who wanted to work with ESPN. And because we weren't allowed to share the data that we were getting as part of a larger agreement with the leagues in the conferences. But yeah, getting better, say best. If someone has a good project with the best available data, like, I'm not going to say, well, you know, your data is not good enough, like the data is what the data is. It's what you do with it. And, you know, and being open about, you know, the the results. People who would be like, you know, if I had this data, I would like to do this, but I don't. So this is the best that I can do. And, you know, that's I get that. I think that's a good outlook in your own work in what, you know, long as you're asking the questions and asking smart questions, you know, the data access would could take care of itself based on professional role in women to. As far as you know, given your extensive background. I've said this before, and I'll say this again, you have an eclectic background. It's incredible. But I was wondering the difference in terms of working at ESPN, you know, and building up the skill set that you need in the experience. And then you transition on over to FanDuel Sports Network. What was the difference in terms of the roles that you had and the responsibilities? And I'm pretty sure you have good experiences and bad experience with the differences. I love working for both places. For those who don't know sports, I think most people know what ESPN is to make that assumption. Right now, FanDuel Sports Network is is hit and miss. And some of it is depends on where you live in the country. It's a collection of regional sports networks in the northeast where we are right now and where I'm from, you can't get it. It's geo fenced, so it's very confusing to people. What I talk sometimes about FanDuel Sports Network, but we have the you know, the company has regional rights and most of it is Midwest South all the way out to Los Angeles. But northeast, think of the regional sports networks like the yes network or MSG or S and Y, Comcast, Philly and Nesn and Boston. Like we're like, that's what sports is. But they're like fatal sports. Midwest Ohio, Detroit, you know, West, South, Southern California. So they're everywhere else. Anyway. Yes. Has huge resources. Right. So I led a team of around 200 people at ESPN, at Sports Network. When I got there, I was a team of one. When I at the end of the at the end of it, I was thinking of 3 or 3 people below me. So way different amount of resources. And, you know, we did we had vendor assistance and I ran the vendor relationships at ESPN. But we had a team of people charting data, creating data, doing the sports analytics, doing the research, creating notes for talent broadcasts, putting things on the bottom line. Source network. We hired a company called Sport Radar, and they did 95% of the things that ESPN's full time staff and part time staff was doing. So it was being outsourced, just a smaller group of people. So yeah, it was just very different. Just know it was when I worked at FanDuel, it was much more about working with vendors relations because they were the ones in, I guess, embedded in helping the broadcast and then try to chart a path, which was the path was being charted for multiple years beyond 2026 to maybe, you know, move some stuff around or grow in different areas, maybe build up some internal team a little bit larger to take on some stuff. Just never got a chance to do that. You know, as we're taping this in April of 2026, FanDuel Sports Networks parent company Main Street Sports Group was in the news this week for their shuttering the business. The regional sports networks are very volatile, and the rights of the 29 teams are returning to the league's NBA, NHL and NBA. So that's a it's developing story. What happens to the 13 NBA teams that we just did our last broadcast on Sunday for? And then for the NHL, we have the coexist broadcast for the playoff teams that we have, which are three for the first round NHL playoffs. And then when our last team plays their last first round playoff game, then the network is sunsetting. So hence the free agency. But yeah, that's it's really balancing it. Just FanDuel had such a small top that when I got there I was able to do things beyond just research, data analytics and say just. But I got a role as the head of on air talent strategy, which wasn't in my background and that was trusted. Helpfully launch a show called Golden Golic with Michael senior Michael Junior in helping want to show with Stan from formerly of ESPN's Sportscenter called Countdown Live. So I was able to do a lot of really cool things in a short amount of time. At ESPN, I was the vice president of Stats Info, and this had so many more people there. So it was cool to kind of work at a place that felt a bit like a startup. Not as cool as when that startup fails, which happens to startups as well. But it was. It did feel like a startup that was, as I say, built upon the bones of what was at one time a thriving the Fox regionals, Fox Sport regionals across the country. And then they went into a real hard time in the early 2020s, changing names to Bally Sports and whatever. Bankruptcy got rebranded Sports Network. I came aboard soon afterwards and it lasted like less than two years, and that's that. So I have I have a follow up question that is kind of a pivot going back into the the academic realm. So do you think in your experiences that universities are actually preparing students for careers in sports analytics from what you've seen, or do you feel like a lot of the learning is like on the job? Well, I think they're more prepared than ever. Some really some people have are really bright, are getting good projects or thinking about sports and pretty when I when I speak to students. And I was certainly doing it a lot at ESPN, I also had a network of people that I was I would consider myself a mentor that I would check in on who anytime anyone reached out to someone at ESPN and said, hey, my son or daughter or neighbor is interested in sports analytics or is in the sports club at their high school, oh, let's reach out to Jeff Bennett. And I always was like, that's great, I love, I love speaking. 16 1718 1920 I still catch up with people who now work for the Chicago Cubs or wherever that I knew when they were maybe at a crossroads as a freshman, sophomore. So always been impressed in, in, I guess, the ecosystem because I didn't have that when I went to college. I wish I had sports data and I had the foresight to see what you could do with that. With that kind of career, and even knowing a career like that even existed. I didn't know that when I was 2021. So I'm always impressed when I talk to students. That said, there's no learning on the job. There's there's no way to replicate that. And I never went back to college after I graduated in May of 1994 with my B.S. in math. But I learned so much at ESPN. Both about how to be a researcher, how to tell stories, what is sports analytics? How can I build a team? I learned about being a prequel manager. I learned about being an executive. I learned about that business side things that when I was in my early 30s, I thought was like, oh, I never want to deal with contracts or legal or any of this. And then, you know, 12 years later, like, this is like every day of my life. And I found I enjoyed it. So there's no there's no substitute for getting a job that gives you opportunity to kind of stretch your boundaries and maybe ways you didn't even know that you'd even like, or you find out, hey, don't, I don't like this. I was right, but I had a chance to to sample it in some way. ESPN is an amazing place for that. There's just it's such a huge company with so much opportunity. And strangely FanDuel sports, which was so small. You know, there's also a lot of opportunity because they just need people to do a lot of different things or a lot of different hats. So I was extremely lucky to work in both places. Now as far as you know, ESPN, you were able to cultivate a new division, right? A new realm of ESP analytics. Right? I was wondering, how do you convince a legacy institution to stop trusting their gut or their opinions and then start trusting the data? Yeah. Wow. That was a rewarding and challenging time. It it was it is hard. It is hard, to introduce a whole new language of sports to people that were already at ESPN and considered themselves sports experts. And if they're on air, most people considered them to be sports. You know, those they were famous there or they were a former coach or player. And, you know, they got to where they got without sports analytics for the most part. So we saw some avenues. We focused very much on one product at a time and put the entire team was four people, the entire team's efforts on one project. And then we all pivoted to the second project, and that was what we lived and breathed 20 hours a day. So the first one, as you mentioned in the open, was NFL total quarterback rating. And kind of like our our North Star was to improve the NFL passer rating, which had been around since 1973. It was developed like it was a slide rule and maybe a napkin. It was it gave the people assumed it was really complicated because a quote unquote perfect score was 158 .33333. So that sounds hard to figure out on your own. And also not not intuitive, but you realize it only took it was just four step process that took quarterback play using four inputs, which was pass completions, pass attempts, yards I guess five touchdowns interceptions. That's it. Touchdowns interception ratio. So that's that's fine. And that was it. And it had some sort of divide by three multiplied by four blah blah blah. And the end if you did the you know, hit the thresholds and divide by whatever the answer, if you were at a 250 passing yard game and you're 20 of 26 for four touchdowns and interceptions, you're perfect. So I had a, you know, a ceiling. It was upper bound. People don't understand it. It wasn't it was escalating every year because completion percentage game was changing completion percentage. And at that time when we were doing this in 2010, Michael Vick was a dynamic quarterback for the Philadelphia Eagles. He was a very strong passer and had some good passer rating games and seasons. But he was known for what running. Running. Right. So like quarterback play was not like just Dan Marino or Joe Montana. I mean those guys are great. But the game was changing in a way where like, so we're not we're just not counting that as a play. A guy, a quarterback is running for first down on third and seven and like, that doesn't count. It didn't count fumbles, which is really fumble. That's a disastrous play. It's behind the line of scrimmage. You know it's oftentimes picked up the defense sometimes even picks up the scores. It didn't account for sacks which is a huge it's not every sack is not on the offensive line when you study it like these are the score stick sacks all the time because they hold the ball too long or just a bunch of reasons like it's in sacked and the other guys would get rid of the ball fast and throw it away. The Mannings almost never took sacks. So again that's a negative play. So we just want to say what is everything a quarterback do? And then the biggest thing is NFL, QBR and NFL passer rating had no context. Like no context you throw for a garbage time touchdown and a blowout touchdown. It's like fantasy sports where you know we were like situational. Like if you have a 12 yard completion on third and ten, like that's a huge play in the game. NFL passer stats were context neutral. So we we created a bunch of frameworks. We created what was called expected points model. So we knew every point on the field and every down what a team's chance of scoring are. And then we took the before and after expected points added to the play. And that was the that was the credit. We were using the denominator, I guess the unit we were using to determine if the play was successful. Then we did a ton of analysis to say, okay, now, but how much of it was is there secret sauce? How much is the quarterback and how much is his ten teammates? So incredible amount of analysis on every type of play we could do to decide, because it's a difference. If a quarterback, I'll go to third and ten again. If a quarterback completes a pass on third and ten and he throws it 11 yards and the guy catches it and you know he's cross the line of scrimmage across the first down line and it gets tackled right away. First down a lot of credit to the quarterback. If it's also that same third and ten and he breaks down he's like I'm just fourth option. I'm going to throw it to my running back who's, you know two yards behind the line of scrimmage. And he scampers for 12 and gets third. Gets the ten yards. Like still a great play for the team. Same outcome for the team. But more credit for the running back and probably some blockers. The guy who just dumps the ball off three feet away is not the same as throwing the needle. So that's just an example. Obviously the NFL stat, which was designed to be also a box after and after the season and after the season, look at it to determine the pastor passing title as to was on individual level. So to do like situational, who are the best NFL passers on fourth or when trailing like media was using this archaic stat to tell stories and splits that it just wasn't useful and we knew we could do so much more. So anyway, long story short, dove into a project, put all efforts into it, try to teach people about why this was a better tool, make it more like a tool than a stat. And then once we got the trust, moved to a college basketball to beat Ben, and for the P, which the committee was using to select teams, and now they use all sorts of metrics, including two that we developed at ESPN as part of their the committee sheet. And now they're seeding teams better. And sometimes it's too well, there's fewer upsets because in the first round because teams are seated better but they have better data in college football's the same way. So we found the opportunities where we could make a big improvement. We didn't touch baseball because baseball was just more mature in that space. And yes, maybe there would be a couple ideas, but it just wasn't worth our time to go deep into, like making a baseball stat when that was just there was just so many people working on that. We're like a college football. Nobody was working on it, and ESPN had the best college football data in the world, and then we had the smartest people working on it. And then we came up with, you know, our resume metrics and our predictive metrics. So that's how we attack those. And then it was just I mean, my role was not to be the the data scientist. My role was to be someone who asked the questions, was curious, knew enough about it, could 17 pass the smell test to ask questions? Why? Or was taken there? Look at that. And then I was kind of when the evangelists internally for it. So I was I was meeting with show groups and we'd have preseason seminars by sport and, you know, going to the Sloan Conference every year and trying to roll it out and talk to people. I was just hitting the trail, talking people, communication. That was what I could do and finding new ways in trying to. I guess, iterate the message where knowing, knowing who I was speaking to and I was really trying to like, talk to people in their own words, they weren't frightened by the math. So, you know, if someone was, you know, putting everything into the realm of what sports terminology is and not coming out from a math perspective, that was if you came out from a math perspective as a huge turn off the TV, those people and also, you know, knew that knew I had a strong feeling that there were some pain points. There were people internally, ESPN, who were against it, like thought it was stupid or waste of time rooted to fail. If we predicted a team was going to win and they didn't, we were like, they talk about it on air like, ha ha! It was like such a weird thing. So we have a lot of battles we lost. But like, I just knew it. I knew I felt very strongly that people were going to start working at ESPN from teams, you know, 3 or 4 years down the road where analytics are a part of life for these teams. And this wouldn't be the first time they heard the word analytics when they came to spin, because they'd heard it for the when they were for the Cleveland Guardians or whatever, for Golden State Warriors. They had they had they've touched analytics or been part of their scouting or preparation or whatnot. So it looks at this point was growing everywhere, algorithms and how you stream videos and, you know, everything was, was, were a little bit scared of that. Like people maybe are scared of AI now, but people would just be scared of algorithms. So yeah, we try not to use that word because that would be a trigger for some people, even though that was was how we were writing the code. But, you know, in the background. Yeah. I'm curious. Your knowledge is so vast and, you know, you've been doing this for decades. So and you can be honest with this. Do people in sports analytics actually read like academic research, like how do you continue to stretch your knowledge? Because I'm sure from the the year you started when you graduated with your BS from Worcester, how things have evolved so much now with AI and all of that. Like so how do you continue, especially as like an odd in this space? How do you continue to stretch your knowledge? Do you read academic research? Do people in sports analytics actually read academic research? I'm just curious how you stay up to date on everything that's happening in the sports analytics world. Yeah, it's a lot to consume. I again, I think I use the term I know enough to be dangerous. Yes. I go to a conference, I'll look at the, you know, I'll try and carve out some time to look at the posters. You know, where the students are coming up in and learn something and ask questions around that. I try anyone who goes to a big conference as a whole, hallway full of posters or workshops, and they're ignoring that to go to the fancy, you know, A-lister panel. Probably not taking advantage of the opportunity. So I was I'm always trying to get that. Now there are people. Yes. The answer to your question, doctor, is certainly people. You know, people that were on our team were going to a joint statistical conferences. We would fly them out there. They make they present there, they would learn. Disney has a data analytics group meeting every year in August in Orlando. We would send people we present there as well. We learn there's tremendous published works that people were doing and learning from. And some of the early work we did, we we partnered with Doctor Benjamin Elmer because he did a study on who owns the plate in baseball. And we used that kind of vision of credit to help us with the examples I was saying about football with quarterbacks. So we hired him as a consultant to help with a slice of that, working on some academic work, building on some academic work he did for baseball, which is another part of sports. I love when you find something interesting. Cricket, whatever. So many of those, those building blocks can be ported over to a different sport. Not all sports are like that. There's some fundamental differences in how some sports are played. Some are more free flowing with like very, very few stops in the whistle. You know, like a soccer. Obviously baseball is very discreet, you know, batter, pitcher, match ups, pitch, pause, pitch, inning. Football has start and stops with the clock is very important. But there's there's aspects of these different sports that I love. And that's one of the great parts about being on that ESPN team is we did all these sports and we were aware of what was happening, all these sports. Maybe we weren't doing new baseball work, but we were very aware of what was happening. With the rise of all encompassing statistics like Wins Above Replacement and some of the more advanced stuff, and then we're like, okay, what's that? What's that look like in a different sport that we're trying to do? So having there is a real tight knit community of of a academia in sports analytics. I came from UConn Sports Symposium in stores. I was there on Sunday. Just popping in was in my state I'm in, and I had a bunch of friends who used to be on the team who won, works at Google, who flew, flew east to to be on the panel and was originally from Connecticut as well. So family trip in there. And you know, it was a great gathering to see a bunch of people. But you know, again, students, they're asking questions, having access to to real leaders in pioneers and people making difference right now. Two people were there for working on the, you know, who work for WNBA team the day before the giraffe. And they were at this conference like, how do you have time for this? Like, oh, he's got a, you know, conference call a half hour ago in the corner. But now we're on this panel. But like your drafts tomorrow is free agency. Like WNBA is huge right now. I can't believe you guys are here. But, yeah, I love when the community is still very tight knit and they are aware of what other people working on, and, you know, reputations matter. I just what I loved about ESPN is there's a lot of theoretical stuff out there, and we were able to like put it into practice, like making it public, people doubting that ESPN could do this. I get it because they think like the forward facing Stephen A's or now Pat McAfee. Like, of course they're not working on this like it's it is people who who have the chops. So you gotta trust us. And that actually, I have a follow up question to that because I've been thinking about this. So there are professors who are publishing papers in sports analytics that likely haven't worked a day in their life in the industry. How do you feel about that? Because I know in a lot of different fields and industries, there is this like scientist practitioner gap where people who are doing the research aren't necessarily in the field and vice versa. And there are there is a lot of really great research, but people who are doing the work aren't actually maybe reading it sometimes. So does that bother you that there are people, professors maybe, who are publishing research, who haven't worked in the industry? Or do you think that that adds value? Total some adds value? I'm sure. And I'm sure if there's some pieces, if I would read, I'd be like, oh, they only knew it's not so easy. Or they're limited by the data they have and that's that's all they can do. And I just have to be like, I get it. That's that's where you're at right now. There's, you know. Sure. Certainly. I even my own career, I was doing some stuff I say 20 years ago that I'm like, oh, I can't believe I published that. Like, that's awful. But I didn't know any better. So embarrassing. I'm not saying that's what. That's what these examples are. Yeah. It's it's hard getting like even people who work professionally have awesome ideas and can be tuned out by the organization. A new general manager could come in, a new coach and manager could come in. And you know, there's new leadership. And maybe the owner who worked in finance is like, oh, we have to have an analytics person. But if they were just doing something in a corner, if it's good and could be impactful and they don't have the trust of the organization or the decision makers, they're going to be frustrated. They're going to leave. So even being in the field where you know, you're living and dying with every team victory, not not everyone has the same experience because some teams are some, you know, organizations are more committed to it than others. So maybe they go out and they just publish their work and that's how they get their outlet. I don't I don't know, but in general, you know, more people building on really good ideas, people passing around, interesting concept, people asking good questions if they can't get the answer because of a data limitation. You know, at least we're moving the ball in the right direction. I wanted to touch base on sports betting here. Now, obviously right now at this at this recording, we have MLB games going on right now as we speak, and we have students we passed by who may have place a bet. What are your thoughts on obviously legalized betting within, you know, an environment here like New York? And do you think there should be some form of a sports betting literacy course or program? There are all the institutions here. I mean, education is important. There's a lot around responsible gaming. You know, it's a huge topic, obviously, especially when it comes to young people. You know, I'm I'm glad it wasn't legal when I was 20 something and had no money and thought I knew everything about sports and thought I thought that was my, my, you know, my angle in life. I did thankfully, place a bet. I don't think I placed a bet until I was well into my 40s. So it's a little bit scary how accessible it is. But I get I get the appeal. But I do think overall more education is needed. You know, it's a very it's a it's not the Wild West like it was. And now it's actually pretty regulated. But you're seeing with prediction markets, right. The access to that. It's not sports betting, it's not legalized sports betting. But there's a lot of like if I want to bet on the play in basketball game so I can do it. On how she I don't have to be in a state that has, you know, legalized sports betting. So there's a reckoning to come around around this. So yes, I think there's I mean, it's an amazing tool for sports analytics because we're always measuring ourselves against the markets. We are always we're trying to create independent predictions without any sort of Vegas inputs. I'll say Vegas as a, you know, a broad term for and try to create power indices on our own without, you know, preconceived Vegas over unders. That gives you a sense of how much how good a team is expected to be. We are trying to get to those predictions on our own based on everything we could do, and then we compare ourselves to the Vegas lines all the time, and we still do. On the back, I say we this is awful, I do this, but ESPN is still on the back end, has a system that every day you can you can look at it. It's not exposed to the public and it's it's how close, you know, mean square error is on the predictions, the predicted scoring margin, you know, where the biases are, if any. And just kind of and how it stacks up against other public systems, how it stacks up against the closing line, the opening line for the, you know, for the books, there's a lot of information in sports betting that helps really fine tune predictive metrics. Even player props really do probably help you get a sense of like, I mean, you could probably you could fill out a baseball lineup with that information. It would help you or any sport lineup. But but yeah, there's a lot of when it comes to students, I get a little squirrely on that also. And we talked space on this prior to recording. What are your thoughts on prediction markets and how disruptive have the prediction market has been in relation to sports betting, like the traditional DraftKings and FanDuel? Yeah, I think it's a it's a moving target. I'm sure I don't I don't work for FanDuel proper or DraftKings. I'm sure there's a lot of internal conversation around prediction markets or some of the smaller betting companies who maybe having trouble penetrating the marketplace. That kind of do of FanDuel and DraftKings, the United States have. And they see well, maybe prediction markets are predictive. That's the that's the way to go. And of course, predictive markets are more than sports. So there's there's a lot of stuff there. I don't know how I mean it's something certainly worth keeping an eye on. And in following I don't know I don't know which direction this is going in. I don't know what I don't do not know what this means for the US sports betting companies, how concerned they are with this. If the concern at all, I assume they are. Yeah. I don't know how it's going to play out. I really don't I don't have a guess on that. I mean that's, that's that's the beauty of, you know, using analytics as well. You just don't know. You don't know until you know, something happens and it's like, okay, now we need some legislation or now we need a lot. Now we need to do something about it. We just never know. I'll just say something about that. It's not exactly what you're talking about, but I think some people were scared of. This is not your question. I know, but it made me think of this from earlier. People were people were resistant to sports analytics is because they felt territorial that this number was the authority or being as the authority, when most of these really is at 0% or 100%, there's usually a range of chances. Or even if someone's QBR was 80 doesn't mean like which is from A01 hundred scale. You know, it's a system of ranking. But it's there's a question like, why what what powers that like it's just a gateway and a tool. I get a little I think people get a little freaked out by analytics thinking like, oh, that's like a a sports conversation ender or argument ender. It's not. It just shouldn't. It's it's it's another data point. But it's about arming analytics, about arming people to make better decisions and using data, using data and other things to help inform but not be the sole. That's why the best organizations have analysts and scouts. This is not to replace the Scouts, which was a big post. Moneyball. Fear that teams are just like fired their scouting department and just have a bunch of people who never played the game. Like there's great value in playing the game or seeing the game or I mean, it's still played by humans last I checked, but humans make some really bad decisions and go on gut or go on certain use other biases where the data will least, you know, a good system sees all the plays in context, and even a good system is not perfect. So even knowing what the system doesn't have any of that data doesn't exist, because you have to keep updating the models that robustly as leagues. Now have, you know, ten years ago put chips and shoulder pads and now there's cameras everywhere. And like all this GPS data comes in. Someday maybe the biomedical will be part of it that's being captured by like catapult and stuff. Right now. It's not merged in a public way, but teams are using that for sure. Like you can always get better if you have just have to know like where the where are the holes? And humans can do a great job of filling those holes in. And, you know, just because a great model says a coach should go for on fourth and two because there's a 51% chance of being successful, there's a 49% chance like that is immeasurable to a human being. So maybe going for it is the right decision. But there are what's on your play sheet. What are you seeing from the defense like it's unless it's I mean there's some egregious ones obviously like that that, you know, some reads or chance of winning, but punting there is a bad idea or going for that sometimes could be a bad idea, but oftentimes it's a little more greater than it's maybe being shown on TV or on an app that says you should go for it. And it's like with the margins, super, super thin. So, anyway, I'm just a that's a tangent. But that's that got me thinking. Good. I also wanted to I also wanted to get your thoughts on sort of to laugh a little bit, because whenever I go on Twitter and Twitter west of my opinion, but I would go on Twitter and I would, I would visit and see the comments based on a game that I'm watching, and I would have people saying, this is rigged or, you know what's going on. This is a stupid play. And, you know, the draft Kings or FanDuel said that there is a six and a half point spread. But you know, the is getting blown out. What's going on? Do you think that some of some of the information or some of the things the reaction that we get from Twitter, is it like a misinformed or is it just out of just pure anger or someone who's losing their money or something like that? Thankfully I'm not really on Twitter, so. But I can put myself in that space mentally to to imagine what it must be like during a game. You know, fans are emotional fans. There's a wisdom in the crowd, for sure, but there's a lot that fans don't understand. You know, there's all humans don't understand probability. I don't know if you guys know that, but I will. That's a hill I will stand on till the end. One of the things that I really learned in starting the sports team, trying to rule out probabilistic, you know, predictions and things of that nature is like, if someone hears like 60% in their mind, it's 100% like, oh, you're wrong. Like three out of five versus two out of five. Like, do you understand, like how thin that margin is 55% versus 45%. Like it's that could go either way really, really fast. I feel bad for weatherman whether people. But yeah that's that is something that we really like. I think I just made some assumptions about my coworkers in the sports media space, because I was familiar with numbers and had a thought about thinking about my life. Should I cross the street or not? Was the chance I get hit by this car? You know I live that way all the time. Many people are not wired that way. And when we were rolling out, you know, this team is favored or has this percent chance and maybe, maybe one against Vegas or common conventional. There are usually slight favorites and people would freak out like it's crazy. And that happens sometimes with live betting odds. So if it in your example is still sick, maybe the better team at home falls in a hole and they're still favored. That's a hard concept to wrap your head around because you feel like, well, they don't have it today. They're not coming back. Come backs happen. You know, there's there's some when you're at home and you are the better team, you're going to have leeway in the other way. If you get out to a hot start, you're going to have a very high chance to win or that that in game scoring margin is going to be higher than the game started at. The people making these live markets are pretty strong, like they know what they're doing. So anyway, that questions that I guess I'm not sure why there's a long track record of the people who do this like winning. You know, but anyway, so yeah, but people have an emotional reaction, especially when it's their team. And for some sports, I know we rolled out college football like college football fans. Super passionate, very territorial, very parochial. And just that's a sport that never had data, just never. I mean, they crowned champions on writers polls when the games weren't even on TV. Like, I don't even know how guys were filling out. And women are filling out their top 25, but you couldn't watch more than one game at a time. And that's how you like national champions, two national champions, because the two split polls and then BCS came in 1998, and that was the computers. And everyone freaked out about that. And then they basically denuded the the systems to become just no, the black boxes that didn't use scoring margin and they weren't doing they didn't have a single job. And then that was, you know, that was derived and people hated the BCS era. So here comes the CFP, which was going to be humans. And they they went back. I was going at my notes not too long ago, and the committee was like leading in hard finally, humans, not computers. This is 2013, 2014. If you look now they the committee just it's the correlation between their top 25. And we tweet bases and their final rankings is almost exactly what the metrics have every every week. And they use they have so many they have these sheets that give them predictive numbers and then resume based numbers. And you know, our team at ESPN came up with this kind of dual way of approaching it where it can't be a one shop all metric. It has to be something that measures quality, which we came up with strength of record, which is the most deserving and some of which is the best, which is the predictive. If these teams play 100 times on neutral field, who wins more often? Well, that's a that's a way to describe where the better team is. Maybe they're not going to win that particular matchup, but we think that they are the better team. And then again, strength of record records, everything looking backwards. And we we blew the committee's mind. We got to actually speak to the committee and the head of the committee two different years for ESPN about like, no, it's actually you need two different metrics and it's not blending them like the BCS and averaging and throw out the higher, lower number and divide by six. Like, this is crazy. Like, no, it's like these are the metrics that tell you how good teams are, which works for seeding. These are the teams that tell you like how accomplished they are. And this is, you know, as they build their resume through challenging games and hopefully victories, they should be invited to the postseason. But to blend them together is where things get muddied. And then you're not telling a story at all, and then you can't unpack it when there's a weird, well, why is that? But if they beat him earlier in the year and now they're behind them, and if you mix them together, you'll never get an answer that's satisfactory. So I'm not sure how I got there on that answer, but that that is something that, you know, that I learned a lot. Working at ESPN is like splitting things into, like what problem we trying to solve, and then being very laser focused on getting a solution to that. I have one final question. That's it? Come on. One final question. If there's one particular skill that you would highlight that can help you navigate through, whether it's uncertainty or growth in your career, what would it be. You're saying, right, going forward or at what point in my career or anyone's career? I'll say, you know what I'd say starting going forward and and navigating through uncertainty, whether it's termination contract, you know, terminations, layoffs, things of that sort. Well, I mean, I guess I'll make this about the present. Like I'm in an uncertain time right now. I don't know what's next for me, but, you know, so you have some sort of experience where you are in your career, gave you the beginning of your career. You have experiences, hopefully from things you did when I started and was like, oh, here are the things I did in college here. The projects, here are the challenges they had overcome. You know, and here are the things I need to learn. And what are you doing to better yourself on your own? And there's more resources now than ever with YouTube videos and online classes. And there's so many things AI, we didn't talk about AI. It's a whole nother podcast. Obviously, AI in sports is in sports. Analytics is just a small slice of it. Uncertainty. There's, you know, you want to have a plan. Wherever you are in your career journey, you want to have a plan. You see yourself. I want to be X here and X and y years and prepare to to to. Don't hold yourself so rigorously to that plan, at least for me. I mean, I never would have dreamt when I was stocking the shelves and putting barcodes on tapes, that I would have a math job at a sports media company, and that would have a ability to to oversee people. I could barely oversee myself as a 22 year old at ESPN that have been entrusted with the lives of other young people someday. Professionally, not not. Those are the kind of lives I was overseeing. I'd be able to hire people, work with, you know, legal and contracts and all the things I thought was like, boring. Who wants to do that? You know, so be open to be open. Such a long answer I'm giving you just be open to new experiences and use your network of people. Use the people in the network might just be your professors. If you're 22 or peers who are finding ways or your parents, it's okay to listen to your parents, to occasionally use the people and help chart that journey and then stay in touch. Maybe you don't get that job in 2018 and that guy says, don't sweat it. Calm back up again. You never know. Come on a podcast, you know, and be there for people. And the times are good. I, I again, I love the fact that I was the person that everyone thought of at ESPN when they had someone who said they want to be in sports analytics. That usually freaked out the person who was, oh, you work at ESPN and they they would get onto my, my inbox. And some of the most rewarding conversations was learning from the kids. What are you studying these days? Which of course load what product were you doing? What internships are you doing? What do you want to do? Sometimes, like I won't be able to help them that much because what they want to do is in sports, not quite what I my background is, but oftentimes I would just give them some general advice. I think that would say it was helpful. And I'm still again, you never stop learning. I'm in my 50s now and I don't know what's next. Yeah, and I'm in New York City, in part to meet with people and get their opinion on what they think I could be doing, or how I could help their organization and keep my options open. You know, LinkedIn has been a great tool for me to connect with people, to see people that are out there. I go to conferences. I popped in, I said to to stores a couple of days ago, I wasn't able to make Sloan this year because I work commitment, but that was the first time I haven't gone to Sloan in 16, 17 years. So, you know, you take advantage of the opportunities that you have. But you should never stop learning, never stop learning you. When the great things about sports is. There's so much to learn, even if you just break it down to a single sport at one time. I was the Baseball Tonight lead researcher. Never in my life was I like. All right, got it. Baseball since 1876. Know everything. What's next? Never. You learn something every single day in sports especially. So be open to learning and continue to be curious. It'd be a good teammate. Doesn't matter where you are in your career spectrum. Be a good teammate. I want we used to say yes, we want all star teammates. That's like table stakes. If you're not a great teammate, I don't think you're going to be successful. You won't last long last at all. That was great advice, Jeff. It was so great to to chat with you and to hear about your extensive experience. I hope that this episode is really insightful for people who are studying sports analytics or people who just started in the field, but it was such a pleasure to meet you. Well, thank you very much. It was a pleasure, was all mine. Jeff, we appreciate you for joining the boardroom and we are signing out. Theme Music scholar and a business minded soul. We at the academic forum. Yeah, we keeping it 100. If you're looking for the truth. Well, you finally found it. Take a seat at the head. Let the dialog flow. It's a masterclass. Five. If you did it now you know.