Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / PayPal Q3 2025 Financial Analysis: Valuation, Growth, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. OK, so today we are really
- 0:04getting under the skin of a major player in digital
- 0:08payments, PayPal. That's PYPL, of course.
- 0:12Yeah. And this one's interesting
- 0:13because it's not just another tech stock deep dive, is it?
- 0:16No, definitely not. It feels more like looking at a
- 0:18company that's kind of at a crossroads, hugely profitable,
- 0:23making tons of cash, but also facing some really big threats,
- 0:27especially from big tech. Exactly.
- 0:29That tension is precisely why we wanted to tackle this one.
- 0:32So the mission today really is to look past the noise, the
- 0:36headlines, right? We're going to apply a pretty
- 0:38rigorous value investor checklist.
- 0:40You know, the kind of framework someone like Buffett uses to
- 0:42figure out first. Is PayPal genuinely a great
- 0:45business? And second, the big question, is
- 0:48it trading at a fair price right now, a trice that gives you the
- 0:51investor some margin of safety? That's the goal.
- 0:54OK. And we've got some fresh numbers
- 0:55to work with, which is great. Their Q32025 results just came
- 0:59out. The market seemed to like them.
- 1:01Analysts were calling it a beat and raise.
- 1:03So what were the key numbers from the sources that jumped
- 1:05out? Well, the sources show some
- 1:07serious momentum. Actually.
- 1:08Revenue hit $8.417 billion. That's up about 7.3% compared to
- 1:14last year. Pretty solid.
- 1:16OK. 7.3% revenue growth. What about the volume going
- 1:19through the system TPV? Total payment volume, yeah, that
- 1:22grew 8% Year over year. It reached 458.1 billion,
- 1:26$10.00. So the platform is definitely
- 1:28seeing healthy activity. People are still using it a lot.
- 1:30But growth is one thing. The quality of that growth, the
- 1:33profitability, the cash, that's often where the real story is,
- 1:36right? What do the reports say there?
- 1:38Yeah, absolutely. And it tells us the business is
- 1:42pretty efficient at converting that volume into profit.
- 1:44Adjusted non GAAP EPS that's earnings per share came in at
- 1:48$1.34. And that beat estimates.
- 1:50See them by a good margin, yeah, analysts were expecting around
- 1:53$1.20 cent. Now non GAAP, remember that's
- 1:55sort of the company's preferred number stripping out someone off
- 1:58items. Right, focusing on core
- 1:59operation. Exactly.
- 2:00But the real eye opener, I think, was the cash flow.
- 2:03The cash. Tell me about the cash.
- 2:04Free cash flow FCF for just Q3, it was reported at $2.28
- 2:09billion. Wait, 2.28 billion in 1/4?
- 2:13In one quarter, it's a huge jump, up 48% from the same
- 2:16quarter last year. It really looks like the new
- 2:18management team is laser focused on, you know, turning those
- 2:22revenues into actual cash. 48% year over year FCF growth.
- 2:26Wow. Yeah.
- 2:27And on the back of that, management actually raised their
- 2:30guidance for the full year 2025 non GAAP EPS that kind of signal
- 2:35beating expectations and then raising the forecast.
- 2:39That's exactly what value investors look for when a
- 2:41stock's been, you know, beaten down a bit.
- 2:43OK. But hold on.
- 2:44If the cash generation is that strong, nearly $2.3 billion in
- 2:48FCF in three months, why is the stock price, you know, still
- 2:52sort of bumping along the bottom?
- 2:54Is the market just missing this, or is it really spooked by
- 2:57something else? I think they're definitely
- 2:58spooked. The stock price isn't ignoring
- 3:00the current cash flow. I don't think it reflects deep
- 3:04skepticism about whether that cash flow is durable,
- 3:06sustainable. OK, so it's about the future,
- 3:08not the present. Exactly.
- 3:10Before we dive head first into the competition though, we
- 3:12really need to understand what built this cash machine in the
- 3:151st place. What's the underlying advantage
- 3:18that's kept PayPal going since, what, 1998?
- 3:21It's been around a long time. Good point.
- 3:22Let's unpack that core engine now.
- 3:24What's the fundamental structure of Paypal's business?
- 3:27At its heart, it's a classic 2 sided network built on just
- 3:30incredible scale. It operates this global platform
- 3:33right connects almost 438 million consumers with
- 3:38merchants. 438 million active accounts.
- 3:41Yeah, across something like 200 markets globally.
- 3:44Think of it like a massive worldwide tollbooth for buying
- 3:47stuff online. And the sheer size of that
- 3:49tollbooth. Yeah, the volume, it's hard to
- 3:52even wrap your head. Around it really is.
- 3:53Their total payment volume for the full year 2024 was $1.68
- 3:58trillion, almost $1.7 trillion flowing through their system.
- 4:02Wow. And for you, the average user,
- 4:04what that scale means is, well, two things.
- 4:07It's everywhere and it becomes a habit.
- 4:09The sources mentioned users averaged over 60 transactions
- 4:12per active account per year 60. Times a year.
- 4:15Yeah, that kind of repeat usage, that almost unconscious click on
- 4:19the PayPal button, that's the bedrock of their advantage.
- 4:22It's just easy. OK, I get the habit part, but
- 4:25with things like Apple Pay, Google Pay, instant bank
- 4:28transfers, does that habit still translate into a strong
- 4:33competitive Moat? I'd argue yes, but maybe the
- 4:37nature of the Moat is shifting. It might be less about the tech
- 4:40now and more about brand trust. Trust.
- 4:44Interesting. Yeah, the sources pointed out
- 4:46something like 75% of Europeans prefer PayPal for online
- 4:49payments. That says a lot about perceived
- 4:52security and just knowing the brand.
- 4:54And that two sided network effect is still powerful.
- 4:57Merchants feel they have to offer it because so many
- 4:59consumers want to use it, right? It's like everyone's going to
- 5:02the same party. Financially speaking, if you're
- 5:04a merchant and you're not there, you're missing out on a huge
- 5:06chunk of potential sales. And that stickiness, that
- 5:09network effect that feeds directly back into the cash
- 5:12generation you mentioned earlier, high efficiency in
- 5:15turning transactions into actual cash.
- 5:17Precisely, PayPal is just a phenomenal cash machine.
- 5:20They've generated positive, positive free cash flow every
- 5:23single year for the last decade and the margins on that cash
- 5:26flow usually in the mid teens to low 20% range.
- 5:30What was it in 2024? Around 21.3% FCF margin in 2024.
- 5:36For a value investor seeing a business that spits out that
- 5:39much cash relative to its revenue without needing tons of
- 5:43capital reinvestment, that's structurally very attractive.
- 5:46OK. That definitely sets a high
- 5:47standard for business quality. But as always, investing is
- 5:50about balancing that quality against the risks.
- 5:53Let's pit it to the headwinds. What are the big threats that
- 5:56could derail this cash flow story?
- 5:58We need to kind of separate things here.
- 5:59There's the short term noise and then there are the potentially
- 6:02permanent structural challenges. OK, what's the noise?
- 6:04Well, things like maybe consumers getting a bit more
- 6:06cautious with spending depending on the economy, currency
- 6:09fluctuations. They operate globally, so that
- 6:11always has an impact. And maybe some short term
- 6:14execution risk around the leadership change.
- 6:17New CEO Alex Chris came in during 2023.
- 6:20Turnarounds always have bumps in the road.
- 6:22Right. Those feel temporary.
- 6:23Now, what about the permanent challenges, the stuff that
- 6:26probably keeps the C-Suite up at night?
- 6:28What really threatens that mode? Competition.
- 6:31Specifically competition from big tech.
- 6:34That's the serious one, the looming risk, as the sources put
- 6:38it. Apple Pay.
- 6:38Google Pay. Exactly.
- 6:40They are becoming undeniably ubiquitous, especially on mobile
- 6:44phones. Apple Pay's growth, in
- 6:47particular, was flagged as a major threat.
- 6:50How does that threaten PayPal directly?
- 6:52The risk is what they call disintermediation if users just
- 6:56start defaulting to the wallet built into their phone room,
- 6:59Apple Pay, Google Pay, without even thinking about clicking the
- 7:02PayPal button. So PayPal gets cut out of the
- 7:04decision process. Right.
- 7:06They potentially lose that direct customer relationship and
- 7:09crucially, they lose the data and the higher margin that comes
- 7:12with their branded checkout experience.
- 7:14OK. So if that competitive pressure
- 7:16is real and growing, how are we seeing it show up in Paypal's
- 7:20financials right now? We're seeing it in margin
- 7:22compression, specifically the average take rate.
- 7:25The take rate explain that. It's basically the percentage of
- 7:28the total payment volume that PayPal actually keeps as
- 7:31revenue, and that rate has been steadily declining by about 5%
- 7:35per year on average. 5% decline annually.
- 7:38Why are they just becoming less efficient?
- 7:40No, it's actually a consequence of their strategy and scale.
- 7:44They've been pushing more into processing payments for large
- 7:47enterprise merchants and also doing more unbranded processing
- 7:51through their Braintree service. OK.
- 7:52And those larger clients, they have the leverage to negotiate
- 7:56volume discounts. So as that part of the business
- 7:59grows, the overall average fee percentage gets dragged down.
- 8:03It's a structural pressure. They have to grow volume faster
- 8:06just to keep revenue growing at a decent clip.
- 8:09That makes sense. So lower average fees.
- 8:11Now what about their costs? When margins are pressured,
- 8:14companies look to cut costs. What's the biggest single
- 8:17expense line for PayPal just to make these transactions happen?
- 8:21That would be the transaction processing fees they have to pay
- 8:23out to others. Think Visa, MasterCard, the
- 8:26banks. The Kurd networks and partners.
- 8:28Exactly. In 2023, PayPal paid out over
- 8:31$14 billion in these kinds of expenses.
- 8:34That was something like 54% of their total operating expenses.
- 8:37Well over half their costs are just pass through fees.
- 8:40Pretty much. It shows you how tough the core
- 8:42business is. They have this huge cost base
- 8:45that's largely unavoidable because they rely on that
- 8:47existing payment infrastructure. It puts a ceiling on their
- 8:50ultimate profitability. OK, that paints a clear picture
- 8:53of the whisks. So let's move to that rigorous
- 8:55assessment, Segment 3, running PayPal through that value
- 8:58investor checklist. How does it score on things like
- 9:01consistency, financial safety, and returns on investment?
- 9:04All right, let's apply the checklist using the data from
- 9:06the sources. First up, consistency.
- 9:10Buffett famously likes to see earnings per share rising
- 9:12predictably year after year. And PayPal.
- 9:15Well, on that strict definition, it fails.
- 9:18EPS actually dropped in 2021 and then fell sharply in 2022.
- 9:21That was partly the hangover from the pandemic boom
- 9:24normalizing, so no smooth upward climb there.
- 9:27But overall growth has been good.
- 9:29Oh yeah, the longer term trend is strong.
- 9:31The 10 year compound annual growth rate for EPS is still
- 9:35impressive, around 16%, but that recent volatility those down
- 9:40years means it doesn't pass the strict consistency test.
- 9:43Why is that consistency metric so crucial for classic value
- 9:47investors, especially in a sector like tech that changes so
- 9:50fast? Because consistency implies
- 9:52predictability, and predictability reduces risk, if
- 9:56a company's earnings always go up, it suggests a strong,
- 9:59defensible Moat and makes forecasting the future, well,
- 10:02easier. And the volatility suggests
- 10:04disruption. Exactly.
- 10:06In tech, volatility can signal that competitive pressures are
- 10:09real and impacting pricing power or growth.
- 10:12Paypal's recent earnings dip confirms that the competitive
- 10:14landscape is affecting them, making the future inherently
- 10:17harder to model with confidence. OK.
- 10:20Consistency is a fail on the strict test.
- 10:22What about the balance sheet? Does it have the financial
- 10:24strength to weather these competitive storms?
- 10:27I hear it scores very well, passes easily.
- 10:29The debt to equity ratio is low, around .5 X, which is right
- 10:32around a comfortable threshold. In cash.
- 10:34More importantly, yes, the cash position, PayPal is net cash
- 10:38positive. They have about $10.8 billion in
- 10:41cash and short term investments, which is more than their total
- 10:44debt. So they could pay off all their
- 10:45debt tomorrow if they wanted to. Pretty much, yeah.
- 10:48And interest covered, how easily they can cover interest payments
- 10:50from earnings is super high, around 14X.
- 10:53So financial stability not a concern.
- 10:56This company isn't going broke. It definitely has the resource
- 10:59to compete. OK.
- 11:00Solid balance sheet, last check profitability and efficiency.
- 11:05Do those decent gross margins we talked about translate into good
- 11:09returns for shareholders? Yes, generally it gets a passing
- 11:12grade here too. The average return on equity or
- 11:15Roe over the past 10 years is around 16%.
- 11:18That's slightly above the 15% benchmark often used as a sign
- 11:22of a high quality business. It doesn't need a lot of
- 11:24capital. Right, because it's primarily a
- 11:26tech platform. It's not capital intensive like
- 11:28say a manufacturer depreciation. The cost of wearing out assets
- 11:32is tiny compared to its gross profit.
- 11:34Only about about 3.9% in 2024. This means most of the profit
- 11:38turns into free cash flow they can actually use.
- 11:41OK. So summing up the quality check,
- 11:43we have a high quality cash generating machine with a strong
- 11:46balance sheet and historically good returns, but it fails the
- 11:51strict test for consistent uninterrupted earnings growth
- 11:54due to recent pressures. That's a fair summary all.
- 11:57Right. Let's move to the final piece,
- 11:59capital allocation and valuation.
- 12:02How has management actually used all that free cash flow?
- 12:05And crucially, what does the math suggest about the stock
- 12:09price today? Is it fair, cheap or still
- 12:13expensive? OK, capital allocation.
- 12:15First, PayPal doesn't pay a dividend, so their main way of
- 12:18returning cash to shareholders has been buying back their own
- 12:20stock. And management seems pretty keen
- 12:22to show they think the shares are undervalued.
- 12:24How so? How aggressive had the buybacks
- 12:26been? Very aggressive recently, they
- 12:27authorized a big $15 billion buyback program back in 2022 and
- 12:31these buybacks have added up. They've reduced the total number
- 12:34of shares outstanding by about 16% since 2015. 16% fewer
- 12:38shares. That helps boost EPS over time.
- 12:41Exactly. And importantly, look at when
- 12:43they were buying. In 2023, they spent $5 billion
- 12:46buying back stock at an average price of around $67.72 per
- 12:50share. So they were buying heavily when
- 12:52the price was. Low, right?
- 12:53That's a classic sign you want to see management using
- 12:56shareholder cash to buy shares when the market is pessimistic.
- 12:59It suggests alignment with long term value creation.
- 13:02OK. Good use of capital.
- 13:03Now the price tag itself. We know PayPal got caught up in
- 13:07the tech bubble, traded at crazy multiples.
- 13:10Where does it stand now versus, say, a reasonable valuation
- 13:14benchmark? Yeah, that market correction was
- 13:16definitely needed. Back in the boom times.
- 13:18PayPal easily failed any sensible valuation test.
- 13:21PE ratios were up in the 50s, even 60s, unsustainable.
- 13:25And today? Today it's a completely
- 13:27different picture. The forward PE ratio based on
- 13:30expected earnings has come all the way down to around 12X12.
- 13:33Times, forward earnings. Yep, that's comfortably below
- 13:35the sort of 15 xpe benchmark that many value investors use as
- 13:39a rough hurdle. It strongly suggests the market
- 13:41has already priced in a lot of negativity and worry about
- 13:44future growth. OK, 12 XPE sounds cheap,
- 13:47especially compared to its history.
- 13:49But PE is just one metric. What about intrinsic value based
- 13:53on future cash flows? What did the discounted cash
- 13:56flow DCF analysis show? Right.
- 13:59The DCF tries to estimate the actual underlying value.
- 14:02We looked at a couple scenarios based on their trailing FCF of
- 14:05about $5.6 billion. OK.
- 14:07What's the base case? The nominal or base case assumes
- 14:10they kind of stabilize things and get back to, say, 10% free
- 14:14cash flow growth per year for the next 5 years.
- 14:17That's roughly in line with their historical average before
- 14:19things got choppy recently. They achieve that 10% growth.
- 14:23That scenario gives you an estimated intrinsic value of
- 14:26around $118 per share A. 118 dollars.
- 14:28OK, that sounds significantly higher than where the stock is
- 14:31trading now. But what if things go wrong?
- 14:34What if that competition really bites hard?
- 14:36That's where the conservative case comes in.
- 14:38This model assumes a much tougher environment.
- 14:41We model FCF actually declining by 5% for the next two years,
- 14:45followed by pretty sluggish growth after that, basically
- 14:47assuming the competition wins some significant battles.
- 14:49And the value in that pessimistic scenario?
- 14:51That yields an intrinsic value of approximately $73 per share.
- 14:55Wow. OK.
- 14:56So $118 if they get back to historical growth, but only $73
- 15:00if they stumble significantly due to competition.
- 15:03That's a huge spread, nearly $45 per share difference between
- 15:06those two outcomes. He has a big cap.
- 15:08And given the stock price has been hovering, you know, much
- 15:11closer to that $7273 range lately.
- 15:14Exactly. It tells you the market is
- 15:16essentially pricing PayPal for that conservative, low growth,
- 15:20maybe even temporarily declining FCF scenario.
- 15:22Right now, all the pessimism seems baked in.
- 15:25So if you believe that the $118 nominal case is actually
- 15:30achievable, if you think management can execute this turn
- 15:33around, then the stock looks potentially quite undervalued
- 15:36today. That's the implication, yes.
- 15:37It suggests a pretty significant margin of safety if they can
- 15:40return to something resembling their historical growth
- 15:43trajectory. This has been a really
- 15:44fascinating look into what seems like a classic value investing
- 15:48dilemma, a high quality business facing significant disruption.
- 15:52Yeah, the key take away really is that tension, isn't it?
- 15:54You've got this financially solid company, spits out cash,
- 15:57has this powerful network effect built on trust.
- 16:00It checks most of the financial quality boxes we looked.
- 16:03At the market is clearly worried the valuation is screaming that
- 16:06Big Tech might just win the battle for the checkout button,
- 16:09leading to permanently slower growth for PayPal.
- 16:12Precisely. And the entire investment case
- 16:14really the difference between getting a return closer to that
- 16:1773 priler conservative value versus the $118 nominal value,
- 16:23it hangs almost entirely on one thing.
- 16:25Management execution. Management execution.
- 16:28Can the new team successfully navigate this turn around?
- 16:31Can they defend their turf against Apple and Google?
- 16:33Can they stabilize or even improve that declining take
- 16:36rate? If they can't restore that
- 16:37consistency we talked about earlier, then maybe today's
- 16:40price is fair. But if they succeed, the
- 16:43potential reward looks substantial.
- 16:45Which leads us and you, the listener with a really
- 16:48interesting final tone to think about.
- 16:51PayPal fails that strict Buffett test of consistency, that smooth
- 16:55year after year earnings growth, largely because it's operating
- 16:58in this incredibly dynamic, competitive tech space.
- 17:01Right, the environment forces volatility.
- 17:03So the provocative thought is this.
- 17:05And in a sector like fintech, which changes so rapidly, is
- 17:08consistency actually the most important metric?
- 17:11Or does the current valuation, which seems to price in so much
- 17:14pessimism, offer a compelling opportunity?
- 17:17The math suggests a big reward if PayPal just gets back to its
- 17:20average historical growth. But you have to weigh that
- 17:23against the very real risk that the competitive landscape has
- 17:25fundamentally changed for the worse.
- 17:27Is that potential reward worth the risk?
- 17:29Something to Mull over.