Latest / Murder Junction / Episode 127 - Jo Callaghan, artificial intelligence policing, and AI Armageddon
Transcript
- 0:00Former British Prime Minister Harold Wilson coined the phrase A week is a long time
- 0:05in politics. Well, ladies and gentlemen, it has been two weeks since
- 0:08we last met, and it feels like a very tumultuous year has passed.
- 0:12The current British PM, Rishi Sunac, has called a surprise general election a
- 0:16surprise because he's running so far behind in the polls. He's practically on another
- 0:20planet. And in the good old US of A we have the first ever
- 0:23conviction of a former president, a verdict that was hailed by mister Trump as
- 0:27the biggliest injustice ever inflicted in an American court room. Meanwhile, this podcast
- 0:32continues to serve as a beacon of sanity, with one notable exception. Abbit
- 0:37happy, my friend me. I'm very good. I'm very good. And
- 0:42we should point out that we are recording at a different time from the usual.
- 0:45We are recording first thing on Sunday morning, which means absolute my breakfast
- 0:51right now. Very nice, and dude, nobody needs to hear you chumping
- 0:55away on your what is it? What is it that you're eating? Well,
- 0:59you see, I'm glad, do you ask fast? See I have
- 1:02recently discovered a brand of cereal called Surreal su double r E A L.
- 1:07Right. My problem was most cereals are just like carbs and sugar, and
- 1:15that's not very healthy, right, So I found this brand of sugar which
- 1:18is high in protein, has no sugar. Sugar's replaced by something else,
- 1:23something probably will kill you in time, but it's not sugar and is low
- 1:26in carbs, and they do a whole range. They're an acquired taste,
- 1:30and not the first time, but after that once you get used to it.
- 1:36And I just now have it now and again when I'm in a rush.
- 1:41And because we have a very exalted guest on today, I thought I
- 1:44should eat breakfast beforehand rather than have my stomach gurgling, you know, obsessively
- 1:52incessantly in the background. Well, can you introduce us to our exalted guests
- 1:57and try not to you while you're while you're talking. Well, of course,
- 2:02of course I can. Our guest today is the author of the fabulous
- 2:07books Leave No Trace, Joe Callahan. And Joe, you are on already,
- 2:13aren't you. You're up with the lark, You really are. I
- 2:15mean, you're looking younger than the scene, which is difficult no or not.
- 2:19No, I don't see much. So, yeah, this is because
- 2:22you're you're you're a You're an AI hologram. That's true. That is do
- 2:27you say that? But everyone your first reaction to everyone is that there are
- 2:30AI hologram Why? But in Joe's case, it is very app so for
- 2:35for listeners who don't know Joe. Joe's debut, which came out in twenty
- 2:38twenty three, was one of the breakout crime novels in recent years. It's
- 2:44called In the Blink of an Eye and it featured Britain's first artificial intelligent policeman.
- 2:52Is this not correct, Joe? Yeah, that is correct, well
- 2:53done? Was I not justified? Instage? Actually is an AI holygram?
- 2:58There you go, Lock, Right, let's start at the beginning, Joe.
- 3:00Let's start with where you grew up and how you got into writing in
- 3:05the first place. Oh God, what did you do before you got into
- 3:08writing? Let's talk about that. But I'm still so I was still working
- 3:12now. My background is in sort of policy and strategy. So worked in
- 3:15the think tank as a civil servant for a national arms length bodies basically work
- 3:24in my director's strategy and yeah, for the workforce planning. So my background
- 3:30is very much policy and strategy. And when I'm fifty four now. When
- 3:34I was forty, I decided to try and write a novel, thinking I
- 3:38just need to find the time, a bit like you'veazzed, and I just
- 3:42I didn't realize how hard it would be, and so it took me thirteen
- 3:46years and five five rejected books until I got a book published in the UK,
- 3:50which's in the blink of an eye. So that's that's a very shortened
- 3:54version of my long journey. But you managed to skip out the whole bit
- 3:58about where you were, where you were born? Where you Yes, I
- 4:00was born in Birmingham. Sorry, you're a brummy, I'm a brummy.
- 4:08Yeah. So I was born in Birmingham, ran away eighteen to Glasgow and
- 4:12they went together where no one could understand a word I said. They thought
- 4:16I was from Australia, so calling the kettle black, oh dare you?
- 4:26People were very amused. I went to Glasog University just toudy English, but
- 4:29anyway, and then I when I moved to London for about ten years and
- 4:32had a fantastic time there, and then when we had children we moved back
- 4:35to them because I live in Birmingham again now, which is where said my
- 4:40book. It's a it's a police series, it's set in one in Warwickshire.
- 4:45Really been a lot of a lot of Midlands places feature in the novel.
- 4:48Right, So, think tank, tell us a bit about life.
- 4:53What were you thinking about? Oh, you had lots of great thoughts,
- 4:58so health policy mainly, but yeah, the idea. If you work in
- 5:00a think tank, you're sort of writing policy documents, trying to shape the
- 5:05climate of ideas future policy. So genomics was you know, wow, then
- 5:12back in the late nineteen nineties, which back there, you know, back
- 5:15then in the day I said, oh, in the next five years,
- 5:17it will transform their service. That was in nineteen ninety eight. So it
- 5:20just shows you forecasting, as you'll know as it's it's people always in the
- 5:25next five to ten years and sort of twenty twenty five years later it's you're
- 5:28still waiting for that big transformative change. So although in my day job,
- 5:32I'm quite skeptical about the pace of change that AI will or the scale of
- 5:36change it will have, in my book, I've taken the optimistic view in
- 5:42terms of saying so sort of you know, what if? What if it
- 5:44did make this breakthrough? You know what then? Because it is a questionable
- 5:47when it's not if. So that's why I'm just exploring sort of. So
- 5:51when you get a machine that's capable of deep deep deep learning, how much
- 5:56can it learn? And then what happens when it does? Yeah, we
- 5:59will talk a little bit more about AI because both you and I have probably
- 6:01done a lot of research on this on this topic for various reasons. I
- 6:06mean, I'm I'm a young and artificial and Joe is intelligent. Well,
- 6:12I was just I was just going to say that I'm young enough to remember
- 6:15when I when I got one of those fancy Cassio calculators. Do you remember
- 6:18that I had the specials on and suddenly you didn't have to use Abir's abacus
- 6:25ad tuplus two, which you can still did it in my headmate? All
- 6:28up here, mate, Okay, So so let's let's talk about writing in
- 6:34the blink of a night thirteen thirteen years to get this. But what initiated
- 6:41the idea of using an artificial intelligence policeman? That was because in my day
- 6:45jobs, I said that I proved a written middle grade children's books of ya
- 6:48they they too actually went on submission and didn't get picked up. So I'd
- 6:55already started to realize. I was read a lot of crime thrillers, and
- 6:58so I did in my head, I thought I'd like to write crime level,
- 7:00but I couldn't think of a different way in it's such a there's so
- 7:02many good books out there, I couldn't think of anything different to write.
- 7:05And then on my day job, I was researching the impact of AI and
- 7:09the workforce, and just that's just just that thought occurred and says, oh,
- 7:13gosh, I wond if you could have an AI detective. What then
- 7:15then the more I did research into that, or that the police are forced
- 7:19both here in the US were already looking at already using a part of the
- 7:23use of AI algorithms and policing and all the issues that raised in terms of
- 7:28some people arguing that would make policing more evidence based and therefore more fairer and
- 7:32more transparent, and then all the pilots that show actually because the training data
- 7:38is racist and misogynistic, and you are recycling back in all the prejudice of
- 7:42society, and just gosh, there's so much to explore there. And that's
- 7:46when it clicked, and that's what I thought. I'd try a partnering at
- 7:50a middle aged female detective like myself with an AI detective aid lock. Yeah,
- 7:56they did. I think they did a trial over in the States with
- 8:00court based data, and so they stimulated what would happen if they fed all
- 8:07this court based data into it and the AI turned out to be massively racist
- 8:11exactly, But it's their trending data, that's the pattern that they see that
- 8:13they recycle that back. That's not quite correct. Correct, correct, the
- 8:20AI was not racist, but because of the data was skewed towards in America,
- 8:26certainly African American people being convicted at higher rates than white people, it
- 8:33meant that when you then fed in notional cases, it tended to be biased
- 8:37against people of color in the States. So that was that was picked up
- 8:41early on. And yes, a lot of work has been going on in
- 8:45the AI background to try and correct some of those biases. But it was
- 8:48very difficult because you're working with, as you say, real life prejudices that
- 8:54that that exhibit in all forms of life, not just in the court arena.
- 8:58So tell us about the character the books are. You need to chose
- 9:01the plot and the characters. Yeah, so well in the first one to
- 9:05say, so that focuses on I was king to sort of show the different
- 9:09ways that we all make decisions. So dcs Catfrang, she's the middle aged
- 9:13being my detective, going back to work after the death of her husband,
- 9:16because that's why I wrote this two months after the death of my husband's I
- 9:20was literally just just I was just doing it to shut myself and I was
- 9:24just writing it to sort of yeah, I just just drew the mon experiences
- 9:28for that. And she makes decisions according to her gut and her instinct,
- 9:33whereas obviously aid Locke makes decisions according to algorithms, evidence, logic. So
- 9:37the vent she explored that sort of contrastween the two and how they make decisions.
- 9:39And in the first book, they work on a cold case because it's
- 9:43a pilot, so it's two missing boys that they have to find, and
- 9:46then they work out a kind of there's a lot of humor but also issues
- 9:50lost and grief in that one as they find a way to sort of work
- 9:54together. And then in book two, Leave No Trace, they get their
- 9:56first live case when a man is found crucified on top of man jud which
- 10:03is called Naneitan's Nipplean. It's a famous sort of industrial hill made of an
- 10:09old slag heap. It's a very famous landmark. Yeah, so man to
- 10:13find Christ crucified with his ears sliced seduff. So that's their first live case.
- 10:18And as more men become a found murder crucified, the young men of
- 10:22Naneitan advised not to go out alone, not to leave a pub drinking in
- 10:28pubs, or leave alone or let a friend know where they are. So
- 10:31for the first time it's men who are activised to change their behavior rather than
- 10:35women, which was really so it's a lot about gender, but also about
- 10:39what would drive someone to do such a terrible such a terrible murder. But
- 10:46yes, lots of issues in there I was asking to explore. That's really
- 10:48interesting just turning that that issue on its head. I think it's fascinating because
- 10:54two thirds, so a lot was two thirds of murder victims are males,
- 10:58you knowtually it's and yet most crime lobers deep center around women, as being
- 11:03in both of my books. The first book there's two missing boys, the
- 11:07second book there are two murdered men. The third book will involve the death
- 11:11of a woman. I'm trying to keep it sort of more statistically accurate,
- 11:15but yeah, just really key because lock is very logical. It happens at
- 11:18a press conferences. Because we've had two men now aged between eighteen berths both
- 11:22being crucified in a small area. What would be your advice to men of
- 11:26that age and lots of well, if it was happened to a woman,
- 11:30this is what you would say, you advise, you would advise young women
- 11:33to be careful to mine where you were. So he just literally regurgitates the
- 11:37advice it would be given. And and of course the men of Nanita known
- 11:41uproar. I dare you tell me not to go to the Purple too,
- 11:45because we're also used to army that I think that the ever Casey no more
- 11:52tripped to the pub for abbe. Wow, I'm outrage outraged, Joe.
- 12:00He's just sitting in a pub right now, having is what did you call
- 12:01it? This is my house? Why not that the array of bottles in
- 12:09the background took them down, took them down. They were setting the wrong
- 12:13impression. So so your your protagon, your AI protagonist, lot I mean
- 12:18he's in some mention of a lot of the sci fi characters that I loved
- 12:24when I was was growing up, So mister Spock to a certain extent exactly,
- 12:30A lot of people don't spot that. Actually they think I've done like
- 12:31sort of acres of very technical research where it's actually a lot of it while
- 12:35was trying to draw and a lot of crime lovers have the have the other,
- 12:39the sort of body duo. But yes, doctor Spock from Star Trek
- 12:45Sherlock, which is where the name is a play on the Lock, you
- 12:48know, thinks very differently. He's super fast and super clever, but actually
- 12:52does not get a lot of human interaction. And both Spock and and Sherlock
- 12:58and Arnie in terminating. Quite often they'll do things and you'll start to think
- 13:03that they're developing some sort of human empathy, but actually just when you think
- 13:07they're developing, they'll do some of the materialized. No, no, no,
- 13:09there's still very a different machine. Because we're imposing our own human centricism,
- 13:15our own assumptions, and also that there's lots of our deepest assumption is
- 13:18that that human beings are the you know, the pinnacle of development, that
- 13:24they that they might they may be as good as to develop to be like
- 13:26us, as if that's the peak of progression. So again I'm felt quite
- 13:31keen to challenge that. Well, I mean, AI has been around for
- 13:33quite a while now, from the nineteen fifties in one form or another,
- 13:37and there have been landmarks which I'm sure you know about that some of our
- 13:43listeners might not, when the when the world chess champion was first beaten by
- 13:48I think it was Kasparov Orkarpov, I can't remember which one. And then
- 13:52Deep Blue, another massive computer that was able to win at a game called
- 13:58I think it's called, Oh it's a Chinese that's right, Yeah, that's
- 14:01right. It's more complex than than than chess, and idea that a computer
- 14:07could ever be human. The objective for both those games is to win,
- 14:11and they can carry on the same tasks. So in book three, which
- 14:13I'm just due to send to my editor tomorrow, I'm key to explore that
- 14:18in terms of if you ask a machine or AI to do one thing like
- 14:22save someone's life, they will ruthlessly go for that to the expense of anything,
- 14:24because they don't have the wider judgment. They're very good at doing the
- 14:28same thing over and over again. I think let's let's talk about that risk
- 14:31of AI then, because you've you've it's a nice sort of question to look
- 14:33at what are the risks here of this technology? Well, for the I
- 14:39mean I'm trying to sort of it in the book, I try and say
- 14:43neutrals are are lots of opportunities as well as risk, And for me,
- 14:46it's about agency that the risk now is that we're driven by supply side issues,
- 14:50So we're driven by what is technologically possible and where the profit is.
- 14:56So for most people labor costs that labor costs are the most expensive. So
- 14:58it's just by huge corporations who are not being too curious about you know,
- 15:03just because something's technology I possible, shouldn't be doing it and they're going for
- 15:07the profit rather than we should be looking for the demand lensed. And what
- 15:11do we as humans want AI to help us with? So you know,
- 15:16John Maynard Kane's talked about the art of the good life and the forties,
- 15:20how do we want to live our lives? And therefore, you know,
- 15:24what could AI do to help us do that? So we want to do
- 15:28the creative jobs. Human bees are creative beings. So I always say I
- 15:31want AI to do my bins, you know, to do my life admin.
- 15:35I don't want to the drudgery, the drudgery should be done to it,
- 15:37should you know? These are the things. This is what when people
- 15:39one hundred is what they imagined would happen, or we even going back to
- 15:43Aristotle or the automata, that is what people sort of imagined the world would
- 15:48be like. Instead, somehow we're allowing we're in danger of allowing AI to
- 15:52take up some of the best bits of being human because that is where a
- 15:56lot of the same that's where the profit incentive. As you say, yeah,
- 16:03it's certainly a debate in the world of of all of the creative arts,
- 16:08but particularly in the world of publishing at the moment. And I think
- 16:11there's a big class action lawsuit happening in the States with us. You're very
- 16:18famous writers who are taking chat gpt to court. Which is owned by is
- 16:25it Meta who owns chat gpt or Amazon? I can't remember Google, one
- 16:29one of the big tech companies own it. It's not taking them, they're
- 16:33taking them to court because when you put a question into chat gpt about an
- 16:37author's work, it's using information, it's scraping information of those books written by
- 16:47those authors without those authors permissions or any any payment being made to those authors,
- 16:51and of course that's that's not right, So that that whole debate will
- 16:55eventually shake itself out, there'll be a verdict and then hopefully because I'm a
- 17:00big believer in tech, right, so I work with it in my day
- 17:03job, and we did a piece at UCL where I helped manage projects.
- 17:10I don't do the research myself. We did a piece three or four years
- 17:12ago on the dangers of artificial intelligence and how it's used by organized criminal gangs.
- 17:18And you know, we were in a room full of people from law
- 17:22enforcement and industry, and everybody was brainstorming like one of your think tanks to
- 17:27figure out exactly what the main dangers would be because it's already being used to
- 17:33create far more complex phishing attacks. So the old email new letters used to
- 17:40get from Nigerian princes and planted by very sophisticated hang on, you're saying,
- 17:45it's no longer a real Nigerian prince, marry marry you a bit more million
- 17:55million pounds, which is why in the book I say that it's the home
- 17:57office, it's the it's a secular state there who actually initiates the pilot because
- 18:03they're conscious Actually criminals art have no qualms about using AI and all this technology
- 18:07to sort of the crime. But actually the police force is still very much
- 18:11locked in by procedures, processes, and we are you know, we've got
- 18:15four to two different police forces doing their own thing. So the idea of
- 18:18the pilot is to sort of say, actually, it's called the Feature Future
- 18:22Policing Unit, So they are supposed to be piloting different ways of working and
- 18:26accessing technology in a way that to try and identify what they could do if
- 18:30you liberated the police a bit in this way, here's a conscience. Here's
- 18:33a question can AI? Would AI develop a conscience at any point? Well,
- 18:38that's what I'm trying to explore the day. So Alan Turing said,
- 18:42once you create you know, a machine cape of deep learning, that is,
- 18:45that is, eventually it will become cleverer than us. And the professor
- 18:51Stewart Russell in his ref lectures says that as well. So he would say
- 18:52it is about when, not if. But then there's we don't actually full
- 18:57into some what human consciousness is any way. The reason why it's called in
- 19:00the Blink of an Eye is the book by Malcolm Gladwell called Blink, which
- 19:04is about how we all make decisions, and some of us, you know,
- 19:08make decisions very very quickly, literally the blink of an eye. That's
- 19:11not just instinct. That's you know, thousands of decisions that are happening so
- 19:17quickly, too fast for structurally process or recognize. We don't understand how the
- 19:21human brain works or what consciousness is. But so in the book I'm trying
- 19:26to explore, it's a four book series, I say, how much can
- 19:30a lot develop? And does he develop or is it that we think he
- 19:33is or we want him to and then what happens. That's a great example
- 19:37you use, because I read Blink years ago and there's a fantastic illustration of
- 19:42what he means at the beginning of that book. If I'm remembering correctly,
- 19:48that there's a statue that's been in a statue yes, which a Lot talks
- 19:51about in book one. Yeah, and and nobody realizes that this thing is
- 19:56fake. Yeah, Chappy comes in and within a second he's twins. Know
- 20:00exactly why you get it because there's no scratches of this is this it's a
- 20:04Greek statue, like there's thousands of years old and it's worth millions of them
- 20:08as mands, and they have all the experts in and everyone says, oh,
- 20:11yes, yes, yes it is. And then they said this.
- 20:14This one guy walks in and he goes, nah, that's a fake because
- 20:17there's no scratches on it. It's completely perfect. And he just looks at
- 20:19you as if your nose And that is because the other human beings wanted it
- 20:23to be true. You wanted this to be a genuine revelationary fined, whereas
- 20:30the guy just literally spent in a second. He just knew it was fake.
- 20:34But yeah, so it's a great example, isn't it. I do
- 20:37like that. I mean, not everyone sold on Gladwell's research, but I
- 20:41think that book was really really opening for me when I when I read it.
- 20:45So let's talk a little bit more about this do mungering around AI,
- 20:48because morning I think personally, I think, yes, it's right to be
- 20:53concerned because there's lots of evil that can be can be done with AI.
- 20:57But at the same time, AI will try transform human society just as previous
- 21:02technological innovations. And we've now got a convergence of really amazing tech, so
- 21:07AI, the next generation of supercomputers, and then yeah, quantum computing because
- 21:12and also robotics because in Japan they're already and not just Japan, but Boston
- 21:18dynamics. But you've got a whole range of social robots now that are being
- 21:22created, that are having official intelligence embedded in them. And then they scares
- 21:27the life out of me that real elderly people like you, they generally feel
- 21:33bad lonely people like you. But what's the next generation if you can put
- 21:38AI into one of these things. I mean, that's just scares me.
- 21:44Right, these things are better than us, well, not necessarily, they
- 21:48will be right, they are, you know, improving, They will be
- 21:52better than us. Their bodies will be better than us, will be bigger
- 21:57than ours, gain to be amate. I think you've already lost on that
- 22:03front. You reckon, But do not. Does that not scare you?
- 22:06No, not at all. When you like, when you like a social
- 22:11robot. But it's not the social robot that I'm scared of. It's the
- 22:15social robots kids that come along or somebody who puts that's an anti social robot
- 22:19on the streets, right, that's smarter than ours and has a body made
- 22:25the titanium? Yeah? Where are we obsolete? Then? And again that's
- 22:30what times to one in the book in terms of where do humans add values?
- 22:33There are some things that aid Lock does. You know, you can
- 22:34watch a film in two seconds, you know you can. You can go
- 22:37for social media, but actually what what what aid Lot can't do? For
- 22:41example, his empathy? So he doesn't understand why cat would go and visit
- 22:47a mom. And that's even worse. You know, you've got a creature
- 22:49out there that doesn't understand empathy, but it's smarter than you would give him
- 22:56certain tasks, but you wouldn't say that. Actually someone who actually you're telling
- 23:00them that they soon may be dead or they've just had some top experience,
- 23:03they need human contact. They need to absolutely agree. So it doesn't make
- 23:07one that's good and one that's bad. It's realizing the range of different tasks
- 23:11and the connections between them, and where what happens you can help us.
- 23:18Yeah, but what happens when this technology says, well, actually, you
- 23:21know what, you are a hindrance to me. You are inefficient. All
- 23:25of these all these things like empathy are inefficient. There's no point in them.
- 23:30What do we do at that point when the technology becomes really important terms
- 23:33of how it develops, how it's regulated, and what tasks we set them.
- 23:37So again, Professor Stewart Russell gives an example in the Reef Lectures about
- 23:41if you set an AI, you know, a very clear task like sort
- 23:45of cleaning up the climate shape save the environment. You could literally do something
- 23:48that like boil the ocean that actually destroys all of human life in them because
- 23:52I think I've achieved the objective and the most efficient way of doing that is
- 23:56with moving humans for example. So that doesn't that skew you, that's scarce
- 24:00a life out, But that's about being aware and is therefore what you have
- 24:04to do is be incredibly care about how you develop these things, how you
- 24:07how you frame the question, and who gets to do that. But we're
- 24:11not. We're not being careful, as you said, possible for us to
- 24:17be careful. I think my issue is that we've seen to we lack agency
- 24:21at the moment, but it is perfectly possible for us to control it if
- 24:26we choose to. At the moment we have left it to you know,
- 24:30what's happening is developing through the aggregated acts of individual corporation. That is the
- 24:37risk, doesn't that you, Yes, it does. It's there is the
- 24:41potential for us to take agency and that's what we We're not doing its No,
- 24:48we are because there's a lot do mngering that happens in the media that
- 24:52doesn't talk about a lot of very sensible people behind the scenes who are debating
- 24:57this every single day. Who do they have power of these corporations. They
- 25:03are gradually getting enough political work regulations. Absolutely, no, I can,
- 25:07I can. I can tell you right now on this podcast that we are
- 25:11not going we are not heading towards a sky net tournament. But not all
- 25:15of these There are bad actors in the world. So with the best.
- 25:19But if the North Koreans or the Chinese decide they're not going to play by
- 25:22your rules or the American military, right, Let's be honest, these rules
- 25:26don't apply to everybody. They never do. I had the same debate over
- 25:30nuclear proliferation where and it's not stopped the media. The world was going to
- 25:34be completely newe to death within five minutes. But we still have proliferations,
- 25:38we have roges. People have it run about to get them. We have
- 25:41plenty of people behind the scenes who know what they're doing. These discussions don't
- 25:45always happen in open forums, and I can promise you there is going to
- 25:49be absolutely no AI arm again anytime soon. Promise. That's a terrible promise.
- 26:02I'm sorry. Neither of you have convinced me that this isn't a risk,
- 26:06and I'm saying that I want to risk what I'm saying is not inevitable.
- 26:10It's not I don't want it to be inevitable, but it's a risk,
- 26:11right. Why would we do that to be alert to these I am
- 26:15hoping that these issues and these questions so that we can take more agency around
- 26:19it. I think is saying we have to have more faith in human beings
- 26:23that I have. I have a fear that the two of you, it's
- 26:26going back to what you said a little while about these these archaeologists who wanted
- 26:32it to be true. I think both of you want it to be benevolent
- 26:36and to work out for the best. I am not seeing that evidence already
- 26:41impacting your life in ways that you you Absolutely it's impacting my life. But
- 26:45I'm talking about the risks and the downsides of not being not being adequately policed.
- 26:52Let's put it this way. If AI is going to destroy the world,
- 26:55it would probably happen after you've passed. That's not the point. I
- 27:00was just trying to make you feel better. That's not that didn't help.
- 27:03I want to get back to Joe's books because so just before we finished it,
- 27:07tell us about the third in the series. If you can tell us
- 27:10anything but the second only, just like leave no trace, that's not a
- 27:12bit crucified. I can't really talk much about the third one because it's it's
- 27:15yea, it carries on that there's a story element that carries on in in
- 27:19in book three. But I say I see it as four books because the
- 27:23questions were debating. Now there has to be an answer with some sort of
- 27:27resolution to those issues. So I don't think I can carry on, you
- 27:30know, fifteen twenty book series in terms of a human an AI and will
- 27:34you know, well, they won't know what will have it developed? So
- 27:37it's like a TV series in the making. I mean it must be under
- 27:41option surely or if not, yes, it's it was optioned very early on,
- 27:45So it's been optioned for TV, whether or not that actually it gets
- 27:48to the screen. Who knows, let's hope. What I'm keen to do
- 27:52is exploring that one in terms of, you know what, what what will
- 27:56Locke do to to save people? In terms of, yeah, if you
- 28:00ask a machine to do something, they will they will do that and relentlessly,
- 28:06they will not stop until it is done. And this is the point
- 28:10earlier. Just to depress a beer again, I'm assuming both of you saw
- 28:17the Will Smith film I Robot based on the story. So there's a bit
- 28:22in there where the the robot has to dive in and save someone and it
- 28:26ends up instead of saving the kid, it saves grown grown up Will Smith.
- 28:36There's a tiny percentage more likelihood of him surviving this. This car that
- 28:40they will do very things and based on probability absolutely, rather than an emotional
- 28:45decision, which happens in book two as well. Yeah, so again,
- 28:48but then maybe there rises I'm just wanting to say it because also I don't
- 28:52want to re question that. But actually maybe some maybe some decisions just should
- 28:55be more rational. In all the books, there is somebody who makes a
- 28:57decision. Sometimes it's the sometimes it's it's the police. That's that some people.
- 29:03Sometimes the rational utilitarian, probability based decision. Maybe that is the better
- 29:08way. And I'm trying to generally stay neutral in terms of just make us
- 29:11all think about how do we make decisions. So what I'm trying to do
- 29:15is make sure hopefully the books are entertaining, hopefully that make people laugh sometimes
- 29:19that I do really want to make people think about all the things we've talked
- 29:22about today. I mean, you haven't thought you're writing some of the most
- 29:25interesting stuff in crime fiction at the moment, and more power to you.
- 29:29You haven't mentioned the fact that you do use humor between locks, sort of
- 29:33po faced logical interactions with the Kate so terrific because it is funny when someone
- 29:42doesn't understand how humans think and work in the way we think it. Hopefully,
- 29:47so trying to sit and also get going back to the research watching shows
- 29:51like I went back to because riginally I was a bit worried about it being
- 29:53too cheesy or I didn't want it to be silly luck with a robot.
- 29:57Why he's a holog I'm not a robot. I didn't want it to be
- 30:02to pull me up the narrative, And so we watched night Rider because I
- 30:06was trying to. Actually, it's a really good and it's full of so
- 30:10much joy. More again is someone who has why why do humans do these
- 30:17strange things? And there's a lot of third drop from the sun Watch.
- 30:25There's so many great shows. Then. I think these shows in the eighties
- 30:27they had very much their tongue in the cheap and they knew they were and
- 30:30there's a lot of joy in them. So I did sort of Actually,
- 30:33I'm going to put hum in this because some of it is it's not always
- 30:36depressing as a bed. Some it's really quite funny. Yeah, the half
- 30:41the half Star, it's really well made as well. It's it's it's worth
- 30:45a rewatch. I'd like to have a call nickname like the hoff you do.
- 30:52It's not it's not it's not repeatable early in the morning, but it's
- 30:56it's very cool. I assure you it's very cool. Last question for you,
- 31:00last question before we wind up. Are you enjoying Are you enjoying coming
- 31:03late into writing and being a writer and hanging with the crowd? I am.
- 31:08I feel incredibly privileged. That's all those years of rejection. I still
- 31:12quite can't quite believe it is why I say yes to things like doing a
- 31:15podcast at nine am a Sunday morning, because I just whose idea was that?
- 31:21Anyway? Sorry? Whose idea was that? Was it? Probably?
- 31:25That's why he has the nickname to go to Cricket As our listeners will know,
- 31:32it's all about it. It's all about you, verse, isn't it.
- 31:34It's not about our guess, it's about you. I love going to
- 31:37the crimes. That's that's a real privilege to be able to. Where can
- 31:41we see you this year? Jill? Tell us where we can see you?
- 31:44Oh, probably everywhere. I'll be a Harrogut So I'm doing Newark book
- 31:48and gives to her next week Newark the week after Harrogate and Bloody Scotland and
- 31:56quite I loved your book Hunted. You know so much us every word Jill.
- 32:04We are wonderful court and literally this at the top of the list because
- 32:07it's so wonderful. Vas hasn't said anything nice, but no, that's a
- 32:13lie. Visas said lovely things about it. I have to be, I
- 32:15have to admit. So that's what are you up to next? Well?
- 32:20I am now going to eat my breath, which will not be a bowl
- 32:23of surreal, be a proper breakfast, probably two eggs and toast. Now
- 32:30we'll go and play cricket, and if I get out very very early,
- 32:35I will be well. I don't really care if we win, as long
- 32:37as I make some runs. The question was more about what you're going to
- 32:39do in a literary sense. I'm not sure our listeners care for your daily
- 32:44schedule. Us just I need all of our listeners to pray, pray for
- 32:49my success today because it's not been a very good season so far. I've
- 32:52missed a lot sprise me, the ones that i'm the ones that I've played,
- 32:55I've not scored very many runs. Young mass bowler who really shouldn't be
- 32:59there. How old are they when you say young? Forty five fifty?
- 33:05Oh, it's been absolutely lovely having you. Thank you, Okay, well,
- 33:07good luck the cricket. And that brings us to the close of another
- 33:10episode. Once again. If you've liked the show, can we ask you
- 33:14to leave a review, sign up for regular episodes using your favorite podcast app,
- 33:19and do spread the word, ladies and gents, until the next episode.
- 33:22We have been your friends. The Red Hot Chili writers