Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / CAMELS Code 4 Reality: The Examination Burden No One Talks About
Transcript
- 0:02Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone. This is Mark with a special archive episode of With Flying Colors. I hope you enjoy. Also note, this is Mark on 10/09/2025. This podcast on code fours refer...
- 0:18Was recorded before NCUA changed their policy this year due to their downsizing by 23%. So they no longer require a hundred and twenty day contacts. You may have hundred and twenty day contacts, but you must at least have one follow-up. Other than that, this podcast is an evergreen topic with much good advice on what happens when you're a code for and what to do. Alright.
- 0:40Here we go.
- 0:45CREDIT UNION EXAM SOLUTIONS: Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA? Join Mark Trichol as he shares with you the insider's view on passing your exam with Flying Colors. The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel. If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time and money. Visit us at marktrichel.com to find out more.
- 1:17Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone. This is Mark Trichel with another episode of With Flying Colors. I'm excited today to be here with Steve Farr and Todd Miller. You've heard them here often. And, guys, how are doing today?
- 1:29Steve Farrar: Doing good. Doing good.
- 1:30Mark Treichel: Still doing good. Glad to hear it.
- 1:32Todd Miller: Doing well as well.
- 1:33Mark Treichel: Doing well. Alright. And so some listeners may have not heard. They may be new. But as a refresher for the old time listeners or the the new listeners, Steve, why don't you give a little bit of your background and what you did at NCUA before retiring from NCUA and then changing teams with Todd and I in helping credit unions?
- 1:54Okay.
- 1:55Steve Farrar: Yeah. I I can break my thirty year career at NCUA into to two separate pieces. The first fifteen years, I was in the field predominantly as a problem case officer working with credit unions primarily on the West Coast but got involved in projects throughout the nation. Then I spent the next basically fifteen years in the central office in the division of risk management, involved in multiple projects there that, you know, get me very interested and engaged in doing the enforcement manual, the corporate resolution, risk based capital, which I finished up right before I retired, and it took forever for that to come into place. Then in retirement, I did get called in and worked at a conservatorship for NCUA as a chief financial officer.
- 2:46That was a kind of my changing over from being an NCUA to being on the side of the... Working with the credit unions closely, and then I've been working with Mark since he started his agency.
- 2:56Mark Treichel: Very good. And, Todd?
- 2:58Todd Miller: So I spent right at thirty four years with NCUA. I can break my career into maybe three pieces as opposed to Steve's tube. I spent the first decade roughly as a examiner and problem case officer in the Western Region. That middle third of my career, I spent it as a regional capital market specialist in the Western Region. That also involved a lot of training of examiners on interest rate risk, liquidity, and investments, involved writing policies for NCUA's interest rate risk and liquidity reviews at that time.
- 3:32And then the last eleven years of my career, I spent it as a director of special actions in the Western Region, supervising problem case officers and supervising regional capital market specialists, that on more than a few committees during that time frame that were internal to NCUA, their supervisory review committee. All in all, it was an enjoyable thirty four years. I retired, and Mark gave me about three months off and called me and said, hey. Can you come back to work for the other side? I said, that sounds fun.
- 4:00I mean, it had
- 4:01Mark Treichel: to be. That's right. And we've been having fun ever since. Some of our best war stories, some of our greatest accomplishment, some of our proudest moments in credit unions was when a credit union would have to... Became troubled, right, and went into special actions or as a principal examiner.
- 4:19You work with a credit union. They have some issues. You get a good working relationship going. Credit union takes it serious, and lo and behold, they might come out stronger. But to get to that point, you have to have a setback first.
- 4:32So you code... You're a CAMEL code one, two forever. Some bad luck comes along or some bad decisions come along. NCUA gets a little bit more aggressive, codes you a three. We did a podcast on that we published last week on that.
- 4:46Now we're in a credit union that has transitioned from a three to a four or from a two to a four, which happens on occasions when stuff goes awry, and that's what this podcast is about. It's about becoming CAMELS code four, and I'll never say CAMELS. It's CAMEL to me. You... They added the s, but in my mind, it's CAMEL.
- 5:06CAMEL, you'll be... You're CAMEL code 4, and so you're CAMEL code 4. So now what does that mean for the credit union? What does it mean for NCUA? What should a credit union be expecting?
- 5:17What are your thoughts relative to... A downgrade just happened today. What does that mean?
- 5:23Todd Miller: From NCUA's perspective, once you become a CAMELS or they generally see you as a credit union that's exhibiting unsafe and unsound practices or conditions. They think risk management practices are unacceptable relative to the credit union size and complexity. They may even have some concerns whether management is willing and able to correct the nature of these problems, which they consider severe. And as such, it informs their entire supervision process and their administrative record process. At this point, they are building an administrative record.
- 6:04So if things continue to go south, it enables them to take other actions. So they're starting that whole building block, formal administrative record. So the first thing as a code for what it means is you're gonna be under some form of administrative action. In most cases, that's an unpublished letter of understanding an agreement. If a board doesn't agree to that, they can end up with a preliminary warning letter.
- 6:30Generally, these are unpublished, although they may be published. There's reputation risk if they're published. For some of the state chartered credit unions, publication of these are required depending on state statutes. There's not a lot of states, but there is a few states out there that do require these administrative actions to be published. The next biggest thing that's gonna happen is you're going to see your examiners every hundred and twenty days.
- 6:56So they're gonna be doing an exam. They're gonna do follow ups a couple times a year. So you're going to get to know your examiner very well because you're going to be seeing them very frequently. They're probably gonna spend six to eight to twelve weeks a year with you. So that's a good chunk of the year that you're gonna have examiners involved with your Credit Union's operation, and it's a huge burden just to deal with that aspect of it.
- 7:22But from NCUA's perspective, that needs to occur. They need to know that you're resolving problems, and they're going to make themselves a be in your bonnet until problems are resolved or they know they have to take some other action. Other things that go with the code for when NCUA codes a credit union or the Federal Reserve is now on... Let known. And so, usually, you're gonna lose access to your daylight overdrafts.
- 7:48They may actually ask you to... If you're borrowing from the Fed or not borrowing agreements with the Federal Reserve, they may start asking you for more collateral, or they may ask you to put your collateral on-site. I've seen them in a number of different places with the Federal Reserve Bank. Most co poor credit unions are not borrowing from the Federal Reserve, but it does occur on occasion. If you're a larger credit union, you're likely to get assigned to the division of special actions.
- 8:16If you're one of the worst problems in the region, that can be a good or bad thing. Actually, a lot of troubled credit unions find it a good thing because those problem case officers have more experience than regular examiners, and they're... Tend to be a little bit more open minded and have a broader set of experiences as to what works and doesn't work. So in many cases, that turns out to be a good thing for the credit union. But the big thing for a credit union under a CAMELS four, you're going to be spending that twelve, eighteen, twenty weeks a year with your PCO examiner because they're gonna be doing exams or polyps every hundred and twenty days.
- 8:56Mark Treichel: And did you say... Did... I I don't know if I caught you. You talked about the Federal Reserve, but the Federal Home Loan Bank also, becomes aware of the CAMELS code.
- 9:04Todd Miller: Eventually, the Federal Home Loan Bank... With the Federal Reserve NCUA tells the Federal Reserve when we code a place of force so they know within a couple days, when the exam is completed. The Federal Federal Home Loan Bank, we don't actually tell them, but the Federal Home Loan Bank has their own credit reviews. Once a year, they typically ask NCUA for an exam report, and they pay us whatever they... NCUA charges them nowadays for that.
- 9:32They do charge the FHLB for those exam reports. So, eventually, the FHLB is going to find out because as part of their credit review processes, they tend to ask for those exam reports once a year or every eighteen months. And so eventually, they will find out, and it may affect how you deal with them. A lot of the FHLB credit processes are net worth driven, though, as opposed to CAMELS. I'm sure you get a higher risk rating when FHLB finds out you're a code four.
- 10:04But if you still have decent net worth, it doesn't seem in my history with... As a PCO and a DSA, it doesn't seem to impact your borrowing authority to getting a camel whore if your networks are still up at those regulatory levels. As soon as your network starts dropping down into PCA and stuff, then it can impact your borrowing ability with the FHLBs. They will start shortening the length of terms that you can borrow. So instead of long term advances, they're gonna cut you down to shorter term time periods.
- 10:38They may start asking you to... They'll put haircuts on your collateral. When network starts getting down under that 5% range. It's not unusual for the FHLB to say, haul those loan files over to our office or some other designated third party where we want them stored. And there's a huge operational expense involved in that too because now you don't have your original files when people refinance and things of that nature.
- 11:06You're checking them back out of the facility. It becomes burdensome. And, basically, if you get a co floor as a credit union for the board and management, your life is gonna become more burdensome.
- 11:18Mark Treichel: It's a little bit more problematic, which reminds me of a post I did when I first started taking a country western song that was called, how can I miss you if you won't go away? And and they don't go away. It seems like they're always there. You said ten, twelve, eighteen, twenty weeks. Your examiner has come visit for a long time.
- 11:36And I got a question for Steve as it relates to what Todd just said and the central liquidity facility. So let's say you downgraded to a... From a three to a four. There are some liquidity challenges. The Federal Home Loan Bank says, yeah.
- 11:52You know what? We're gonna give you more haircuts on this, or we're gonna cut your line because of capital. And then lo and behold, you've got a line... The last line that you can utilize is at the corporate, the local corporate. There's a thing called...
- 12:06A lot of credit unions don't know about it, but a guaranteed line of credit at the corporate, and the CLF gets involved in that. Can you share... Now this isn't directly linked to a four, but I would say there's a strong correlation that code fours, might end up at the doorstep of, their corporate, and then the corporate may make a phone call to NCUA. Could you expand upon what I just tiptoed into there, Steve?
- 12:29Steve Farrar: Yeah. And and there's always mistakes made on that. And then, yes, you do have the option of joining the central liquidity facility, but then the the central liquidity isn't really a lender of last resort in that it... You still
- 12:43Mark Treichel: have to be credit worthy to
- 12:44Steve Farrar: get a loan from the central liquidity facility. And then there's this whole... You have to do the deposit and all that kind of stuff. So it is a source of liquidity that's out there in addition to the other ones that are receiving the reports. Mark talked about a a guaranteed line of credit, which is a type of tool assistance under two...
- 13:04Section two zero eight of the Federal Credit Union Act, and the the insurance fund would basically be guaranteeing payment to the we usually work with the corporate credit union on doing guaranteed lines of credit. Now, it they used to be used more often when we had credit unions that were operating with lower levels of capital. But since PCA, they're really rare that we would do those. And, you might see it in terms of if you're in conservatorship. Now there...
- 13:34And another thing that I wanted to bring up, on that is is, as credit unions get to be a CAMELS four, and they're larger, it can start to have, some impact on the NCUSIF's equity ratio because the the math is there as the same as your credit unions. As your delinquency on your portfolio increases, you have to have more money set aside for the expected losses on that. So the same thing happens is that credit unions' CAMEL codes become worse and they're larger. You can start seeing that the insurance fund is starting to have to put more money in the reserve for losses, which reduces the equity of the insurance fund, which can lead to reduction in the equity level and, potential premiums, that have to be paid to recover from that. So that all plays into that equation on that, so I thought it would bring that up.
- 14:30Mark Treichel: That's a great point. And when we talked about, code threes in our code three podcast, we talked about trends of large code threes increasing and that the smaller code threes in number are the same adjusting for mergers, but that the growth seemed to be that the average size of a code three was going up because when a few big credit unions fall into that category, it can impact the numbers. And, of course, if they slip into code fours, as you're saying, that can increase the map on... Math on the calculation on what needs to be in the insurance fund. So far, the code three...
- 15:06Code four data doesn't seem to reveal too much. I don't know if you have that there in front of you, but are there any trends in code fours that you've seen, or is that maybe what's coming around the bend?
- 15:18Steve Farrar: On the short run, they're... They haven't increased the number. It's been a 125 CAMELS fours in December. And, again, in March, it was the same number that the assets... And they were increased from 5,500,000,000 to 7,000,000,000.
- 15:32But if you look at, like, FDIC sometimes runs a little bit ahead of recognizing potential problems a little bit faster than NCUA does. Yet, in the same time period, they went from 52 institutions that are the problem bank, which is four and five, at from 52 to 60, but their assets went from 66,000,000,000 in those institutions to 82,000,000,000, and that's what, you know, we're always concerned about is now that this... The delinquency is coming up and we're seeing more losses that are occurring on the credit side. And the credit side is where the insurance fund gets its losses. We can ride through liquidity and interest rate risk might cause an institution to fail.
- 16:15It doesn't generally cost the insurance fund money. Credit losses cost the insure... Insurance fund money. So that's that's why people get really concerned once you're at CAMELS four and that it needs to be fixed quickly so it doesn't turn out to be a loss to the insurance fund because I was always at NFL for the football league has protect the shield, and I was always out there. My job is to protect the fund.
- 16:40Todd Miller: I
- 16:40Steve Farrar: was a real cheerleader on that when I was in NCUA.
- 16:44Mark Treichel: And then at the end of the day, when all the people at NCUA gather at the bar, they would toast to the fund because the fund was paying their salary.
- 16:52Todd Miller: You hung out with different examiners than I did.
- 16:55Mark Treichel: That was an East Coast thing. That was... There's a... There's someone who may or may not be in the office of the National Examination Supervision who was... Who started...
- 17:05I'm not saying at what level and not at the top, not at the tippy top, but there was someone that that came up with toasting to the fund. And if they're I don't know if they're a listener, but they are. They're probably smiling right now. Alright. And so go ahead, Todd.
- 17:19Todd Miller: There's one more thing we didn't talk about that applies to CAMELS, they're officially a troubled credit union under section seven zero one fourteen of the regulations, and NCUA now gets a say in change of senior management officials and elected officials. So there's an approval process, and they have a right to veto various management changes or board changes.
- 17:45Mark Treichel: And that... That's just another administrative burden of putting the people in, putting their resume in, whether it's a board member or an official. Now refresh my memory. Some of
- 17:54Todd Miller: them can serve temporarily. Is it So if you have a board election, they can serve for thirty days without that approval. I'd have to go back and read the reg. I think you have to send notice into NCUA, like, by the third business day or something that, hey. Here...
- 18:11Here's a change in our election. And I don't know. You got till day seven or something or somewhere in there to actually send in the change in approval. You'd have to go look up the reg. I don't remember it exactly, but elected officials can serve for that thirty day period while NCUA processes that approval form.
- 18:30For senior executives, they need approval from NCUA before they can serve.
- 18:36Mark Treichel: And and, the reason there is there's risk to the fund. They wanna make sure it was ever put in place at an institution coded to four as the skill sets, to help reposition and reduce the risk to the credit union and then, of course, thereby reducing the risk to the insurance fund.
- 18:54Todd Miller: He already does say no to some of those.
- 18:56Mark Treichel: They do. They do indeed. I think we've all been involved in in a few of those. More often than not, if you've done a good search and there's no skeletons per se in the closet of who you've selected, you'll see approval, so you can get them on board and start dealing with the issues. Now code ones and twos can get document resolutions.
- 19:15Code threes, you're definitely gonna have a document resolution. So now you're a code four. You... I got... You're gonna have document resolutions, but those document resolutions might also then turn into what?
- 19:28Todd Miller: In most places, if NCUA's preferred path is they turn into an unpublished letter of understanding and agreement, that's the preferred, and the path happens most of the time. Some credit unions prefer not to enter into letters of understanding and agreement. So NCUA will issue you a preliminary warning letter if you refuse to sign that letter of understanding agreement. It will say essentially all of the same items, increasingly reserving the right to publish letters of understanding and agreement. Historically, they do that in only rare cases.
- 20:06And like we mentioned earlier in the podcast, there are sub states that have statutes that require them to publish those letters of understanding and agreement. Now, usually, they bury it on their web page. They don't issue a press release to the newspapers or anything because they would rather the public not know and create reputation risk for the credit union. But there are some states that will publish those letters of understanding agreement because they have no choice. Their statutes require it.
- 20:33If you're a state charter, just know what your state regulations require if you fall into this task. There's a special thing too. So we've talked about code fours in general, but there's code fours that start having challenges to capital. And once your net worth starts falling below those regulatory limits and you have that code four, there is other implications too. They start finding out all your lenders want collateral.
- 21:02If you're doing set mortgage... Selling mortgages on the secondary market, this gets very problematic and especially with Fannie Mae and choosing to not want to buy your mortgages. Mae will often take your servicing rights away from you. Fannie Mae will often make you post collateral to retain those servicing rights. So there are other implications that come into play if your capital starts falling at the same time you get that code four.
- 21:32Mark Treichel: Got it. Yeah. So it's not a good place to be. You might get assigned to special actions, generally speaking, after the shock and awe of getting signed... Assigned to special actions is over.
- 21:43Generally speaking, I think our history has been that the credit union likes the better stat... The the more educated longer term staff, the not so risk averse staff that are in special actions because sometimes they've seen so much more that they have a better context because of the journey that they've been on, at least a better resolution for the credit union. So any... Anything else on code fours before we, do a short chat about code fives?
- 22:09Todd Miller: We talked about this in our code three podcast too. There's a higher expectation on the board that they're gonna hold management accountable and monitor progress on these doors and administrative actions. There's an expectation that management's gonna keep their board informed as to progress on resolving these issues. In general, though, for board members, NCUA is gonna put more pressure on them to hold their management accountable and understand the nature of the problems and and what is needed for progress. There's gonna be some expectation that the board will authorize the resources necessary to address these problems.
- 22:49Because, generally, when you get down to the code board, involves additional people, additional third parties, lots of overtime. The expense levels will go up even though NCUA might give you a door that says reduce expenses. The corrective actions are gonna usually require you to spend a fair amount of money, and there's gonna be some expectations that board are gonna authorize the resources necessary to resolve these problems.
- 23:15Mark Treichel: Makes sense. Steve, any last thoughts on force?
- 23:18Steve Farrar: Yeah. Yeah. Those documents or resolutions for bores often become really voluminous, and it becomes a big project management issue. And what part of that project management is that reporting that Todd talked about.
- 23:30Mark Treichel: Very good. So the worst code is the functional equivalent of an f in school. Right? If a four is a d and a three is a c, and NCUA doesn't really look at it in that mind, but I always did when I was there because it's an easy translation. If you get an F in school, you might have to withdraw from the class, have to redo the class.
- 23:50Code fives are rare, but any thoughts on, and I can always remember, it's okay, it's a four, it's gonna be a five, you start coding at a five, we're thinking of further administrative action. And sometimes you think you're writing a code five, and before you deliver the report, you actually end up conserving the credit union because the risks are identified are so bad. But general thoughts on the death wish code, also known as a CAMELS code five. Yeah.
- 24:16Steve Farrar: Failure is usually imminent, and you're either gonna be... They're gonna be quickly trying to find a merger partner for you, but it'll be a merger partner with NCUA or in the state regular, highly involved in that process, and your choices will be very limited. They'll take the least cost option to resolve the credit union quickly. Excellent point. Todd?
- 24:40Todd Miller: In other words, what Steve is saying is the regulator's gonna pick your merger partner, not you.
- 24:45Mark Treichel: Self determination is out the window at that juncture.
- 24:49Todd Miller: At that point, as an NCUA employee, you're just trying to reduce the cost of the insurance fund to the lowest dollar possible by any means possible.
- 25:00Mark Treichel: Well said. Well said. Alright, guys. We'll we'll go ahead. We're gonna say something.
- 25:05Todd Miller: Not really for code fives, and you mentioned it already. You're getting ready to write a report to issue a code five, and quite often, it turns into a conservatorship, especially in recessionary area periods. That's very much a true statement. We talked about fun stuff that we've had as examiners, and probably the most gratifying thing is taking a conservatorship and actually fixing it and returning it to the members. Prior to the credit union membership app, there was lots of easy ways for NCUA to provide cash assistance for credit unions to keep them open.
- 25:40And I know Steve did a lot of that early in his career. I did a little bit of it. The Credit Union Membership Act took away NCUA's ability to provide assistance to keep a failing partying open. It came back to NCUA in twenty ten, twenty eleven, but it's very much limited to capital notes. No other form of assistance.
- 26:00And so they're done pretty rarely, although we did do a couple of them at the last recession. NCUA did save a couple conservator shifts by recapitalizing them. Those were always the most rewarding parts of the job, though, is when you take a troubled credit union and actually resolve those issues and see it return to the members.
- 26:18Mark Treichel: Yeah. That's a great point. It reminds me of an act... An old acronym. Right?
- 26:22The PUED, the prior undivided earnings deficit for... What Todd's alluding to is you... NCUA could guarantee a deficit. So where we have prompt corrective action now that says you have to do this at 7%, you have to do this at six, you have to do this at four, but you fall under four, NCUA is pushing you to merge and or having other corrective action and a plan for you to merge. At some point in time in there?
- 26:47Is it at two or four they have to conserve? We used to let credit unions run if they put a plan together to get back to zero within four... Within twenty four months, if I remember right?
- 27:00Todd Miller: That was the general time frame. I did two or three PUEDs. Steve probably did a dozen or more. It... I understand the public policy point of view of why they can no longer do that, but I can also just actually look around today and see at least five credit unions that we say that way that it would otherwise been closed in the early nineteen nineties that are still here today in 2024.
- 27:27They were successful ways to preserve a credit union. It's unfortunate that stat sheets by congress no longer give NCUA the option anymore.
- 27:38Mark Treichel: Agree. I agree. Those were good tools to be able to use in the right situations, and they took, flexibility out of staff's hands because public call... Policy, required that to happen. Alright, guys.
- 27:50Any last thoughts here before we wrap up today on fours and fives? Very good. As always, this was fun. Brings back... Triggers some synapses.
- 27:59I hadn't thought of the acronym PUED in in a few years. That's always fun to to make my brain think of a long lost acronyms. Thanks so much, guys.
- 28:11Todd Miller: Take care. Have a good day.
- 28:13Mark Treichel: You too. And listeners, as always, I appreciate you listening. I hope you'll listen again soon. Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 28:26CREDIT UNION EXAM SOLUTIONS: Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors. Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA. If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check out our services at marktrichl.com.