Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / Public Health Grand Rounds Hosted by Dora Ann Mills with Guest Margie Skeer, Sc.D., MPH, MSW
Transcript
- 0:00This is Dr. Dora Ann Mills, Senior Advisor for Public Health at MaineHealth.
- 0:05Welcome to our Public Health Grand Rounds, where about every month we explore
- 0:10a relevant public health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 0:15These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on Podbean
- 0:20and at MaineHealth.org, where you can hear current and past episodes.
- 0:26Please note that guests' opinions are their own. Thank you.
- 0:30Thank you so much, everybody, for joining us on this bright, sunny day.
- 0:34I'm feeling a little fall today, a little chilly, but it is really a pleasure to introduce Dr.
- 0:40Margie Skeer, who's the professor and chair, who's a professor and the chair
- 0:46of the Department of Public Health and Community Medicine at Tufts University School of Medicine.
- 0:52Dr. Skeer brings together expertise in public health, social work,
- 0:57and social epidemiology.
- 0:59She earned her master's degree in public health and social work at Boston University,
- 1:04her doctorate at Harvard, and completed a postdoctoral fellowship at Brown Center
- 1:09for Alcohol and Addiction Studies.
- 1:12Her research focuses on preventing adolescent substance use through family engagement,
- 1:17communication, and shared meals.
- 1:20She leads the Supper Project, and as we call it in Maine, "suppah".
- 1:25It's S-U-P-P-E-R project, which explores how regular family meals can provide
- 1:31opportunities for children and parents to connect and talk about substance use.
- 1:36For those of us working in health care and public health, this work raises really
- 1:41an important issue of how can
- 1:43we help families turn everyday moments into opportunities for prevention
- 1:49and make those opportunities accessible to families facing completely.
- 1:54Competing demands and significant stress.
- 1:58Today, Dr. Skeer will help us explore the evidence and the practical implications
- 2:02in her presentation, Family Meals, Setting the Table for Adolescent Substance Use Prevention.
- 2:09Please join me in welcoming Dr. Margie Skeer. Thank you so much, Margie, for joining us.
- 2:15I know you are beaming into us from Boston, so we appreciate you joining us
- 2:21here up at MaineHealth Public Health Grand Rounds.
- 2:24And I'm going to toss the baton over to you. Thank you. Wonderful.
- 2:28Well, thank you so much for having me. I really appreciate the opportunity to
- 2:32be able to share some of the thinking around family meals and substance use
- 2:37and a little bit of my work as well.
- 2:40I'm going to share my screen. So thank you so much for that wonderful introduction.
- 2:47Just to reiterate, my name is Margie Skeer, and I have been at the Tufts University
- 2:52School of Medicine for 15 years.
- 2:54And you've heard my biography, but I did want to share a little bit about my
- 2:59background and how I got to doing the work that I do.
- 3:02So I started out, as you heard, with a dual degree in social work and public
- 3:10health, and I was really actually interested in being a clinical social worker.
- 3:16And so I was working in drug rehabilitation, both inpatient,
- 3:21outpatient. I was working with teenagers as well as people who were older.
- 3:25I was working with veterans.
- 3:26So I worked across the spectrum of substance use disorders.
- 3:31And it was during that time I was also very interested in public health.
- 3:35And because of that, I started thinking, I wonder if the work that I'm doing
- 3:40now in this field, which I knew was really where my passion lied.
- 3:44If my efforts could be more pervasive if I switched to the prevention side.
- 3:49And that's when I decided to get my doctorate in public health.
- 3:53And I focused on social epidemiology, but also on what we call planned social
- 3:59change or intervention design.
- 4:01And so I spent many years learning how to design interventions around behavior
- 4:05change with a focus on substance use disorders and substance use in general.
- 4:11And when I went to Brown for the Center for Alcohol and Addiction Studies for
- 4:15a postdoc, I realized I wanted to really focus on the prevention side and design
- 4:21interventions around prevention.
- 4:23And when I got to Brown, to the Center for Alcohol and Addiction Studies,
- 4:26I was very excited because I thought these are my people. I've been doing work
- 4:30at Harvard and it was wonderful, but not as many people were focusing on substance use.
- 4:35And I got to a center where everybody was doing this work.
- 4:38And I realized that people doing sort of more primary prevention,
- 4:42universal prevention, which is what I'm going to talk about,
- 4:45was a little bit few and far between.
- 4:47And so I sort of soldier on as in many ways a lone wolf doing prevention research.
- 4:54But even though it is harder to do in many ways because it's harder to sort
- 4:58of see the effects over time and it's harder to get it funded,
- 5:02it's so important because we in public health, we know that
- 5:06the more that we can do and the more that we can spend in the prevention realm,
- 5:09the less we have to do down the road.
- 5:12And I always say, and this is something that everybody who's taken a class with
- 5:17me or has heard me talk, that prevention is always easier than treatment.
- 5:21And so that's where I really spend my time.
- 5:24With respect to, you know, why we're here today, we're talking about adolescent substance use.
- 5:29And just to give a very brief primer about sort of where we are,
- 5:33current alcohol use is defined at the last 30 days.
- 5:36And we know that among high school students, about one in five is currently using alcohol.
- 5:44Now, that is down significantly. So, for example, in 1991, about 50 percent
- 5:50of high school students said that they were reported that they were using alcohol.
- 5:54So we've made tremendous strides, and yet it's still actually one in five is
- 5:59still too many because what we know about the effects.
- 6:03Additionally, not quite, but about 12% are currently using cannabis,
- 6:11and that's about 18% by 12th grade.
- 6:15So while we have seen declines generally, which is amazing, and I'm so proud
- 6:20to be part of a movement that is actually working to see,
- 6:24declines in adolescent substance use, it is still too high because we know that
- 6:29alcohol and cannabis are associated with various risk outcomes.
- 6:32And we know that there are still a significant number of young people who are
- 6:35using alcohol, cannabis, and other drugs every day.
- 6:39So the more that we can do to prevent it, the better it's going to be over time.
- 6:44So before I go into talking about prevention a little bit more,
- 6:49I wanted to spend a few minutes to talk about important developmental periods.
- 6:54So some of you may have heard the terminology life course epidemiology,
- 7:00and I wanted to share that this is something that.
- 7:04It's part of epidemiology that really focuses on the study of long-term effects
- 7:09on later health or disease risk of physical or social exposures during lots
- 7:15of different points in the life course.
- 7:17So during gestation, childhood, adolescence, young adulthood, et cetera.
- 7:22And you have two major periods. The first is called a critical period and the
- 7:28second is called a sensitive period.
- 7:30A critical period is characterized by exposures that are happening
- 7:38during a specific time in development that really affects, quote,
- 7:42the structure or function of organs, tissues, or body systems that are not modified
- 7:47in any dramatic way by later experience, and that precipitates disease later in life.
- 7:53So, for example, attachment. if a baby isn't able to attach at a very specific
- 7:59period in their life, it may be very hard or impossible for them to do that later in life.
- 8:04That's a critical period. And we think it's really important as you think about
- 8:07exposures across a life course.
- 8:10Then we have sensitive periods. And sensitive periods are periods that are exposures
- 8:16during a critical period of development that,
- 8:19have effects on, quote, the structure or function of organs,
- 8:23tissues, or body systems that are not modified in any dramatic way by later
- 8:27experience and that precipitate disease later in life.
- 8:30So you might think, for example, a sensitive period with relationship to language acquisition.
- 8:36So you can certainly learn a new language as an adult, but if you learn a second
- 8:42or third language when you're a child, that it's much, much, much easier.
- 8:47And so this is an example, you know, language, but when we think about adolescent
- 8:53substance use and we think about the development of substance use disorders,
- 8:57it's really important to understand that adolescence is a sensitive period in the life course.
- 9:05So if we got people to 21, 25, 30 before they had their first drink,
- 9:11use of cannabis, et cetera, we would actually see that the rate of substance
- 9:15use disorder is almost zero.
- 9:17But because youth and the younger you start, the greater the risk of developing
- 9:22subsequent problems, we see adolescence as a sensitive period when it comes
- 9:27to substance use and related disorders.
- 9:30And so just to continue with understanding why prevention is so important,
- 9:35this is a picture of a time-lapse MRI images.
- 9:39And what we see is that between the ages of 5 and 20, there are differences in color.
- 9:47So at age 5, we see a brain that has lots of different colors with a little
- 9:53bit of blue progressing all the way to age 20 with mostly blue.
- 9:57And what the image shows is a gradual loss of gray matter, which consists of
- 10:02cells that process information.
- 10:04And the thinning of gray matter starts around puberty and corresponds to increasing cognitive abilities.
- 10:10And this is probably reflecting improved neural organization as the brain pairs
- 10:15redundant connections and increases in white matter to help brain cells communicate.
- 10:19But it's during that time. So it's really not until sort of the mid and even
- 10:24sometimes late 20s that the brain kind of has gone through a whole maturation process where the.
- 10:32Things that young people are
- 10:34doing over and over and over again actually stick and they get hardwired.
- 10:39And the things that they're not doing, there's something called neural pruning.
- 10:43So those connections kind of get lost.
- 10:45So if you know that about 6% of young people are using cannabis every day,
- 10:51what they're not doing is going to get sort of pruned away.
- 10:56And what they are doing using cannabis is going to be reinforced in the brains.
- 11:02So I show a slide. This slide is a picture of a giraffe.
- 11:07And my interpretation of the adolescent brain is a baby giraffe.
- 11:14So I don't know if anybody has ever seen a baby giraffe being born,
- 11:18but I'm going to stop sharing and I'll share another screen so that you can
- 11:22see my interpretation of a baby giraffe. So bear with me a minute.
- 11:29Great. Can you see my screen? Okay. So you'll see that we have a really cute image of a baby giraffe.
- 11:39And the baby giraffe, they're born and oops, trying to walk and it falls over.
- 11:45But they're born and they're basically required to start walking immediately.
- 11:49And for people who can see the video, you'll see that the baby giraffe is standing,
- 11:54but it's struggling to walk.
- 11:56And it's stumbling and it's kind of falling and it's trying to figure it out.
- 12:01So all the pieces are there and it can do it, but it takes a little time.
- 12:06And then after a little bit of patience, and as you see, as some of you can
- 12:11see on the video, prodding by the family and everybody around them,
- 12:18they make it. They're able to get there.
- 12:21But it takes a little bit of time. And that's actually how I see the adolescent brain.
- 12:27We all often think of adolescents as sort of small adults, but the truth is
- 12:34they're not, and their brains aren't quite there.
- 12:38So we have to truly understand when we as adults think, oh, it's fine if a young
- 12:44person is using something, is drinking or having a few drinks here and there,
- 12:49it's actually drastically affecting their brain.
- 12:52And we have to give them the time and space for their brains to really fully
- 12:57evolve before we move toward, you know, condoning substance use.
- 13:04So why is early prevention important? It's important for many reasons.
- 13:10One of the reasons that it's important is that 9 out of 10 people,
- 13:15so for those who can't see the screen, this is an image of 10 bodies and 9 of them are colored in.
- 13:239 out of 10 people who have substance-related problems as adults started using before the age of 18.
- 13:329 out of 10. That's almost everybody. So this shows that if we could actually
- 13:39sort of delay, we would be better off with respect to substance use disorder.
- 13:44And this next slide is a visual.
- 13:48Of a study. It's an older study, but it shows that,
- 13:52when people start using before the age of 13 or 14, their risk of ever using
- 13:59illicit drugs is almost 50 percent and their risk of developing a substance
- 14:04use disorder is almost 20 percent.
- 14:07But if you go across ages, every age that we can delay, we see a decreased risk,
- 14:15of illicit drug use and of dependency on substance use disorder.
- 14:21So this shows if we can get young people to about 21, which is the legal age
- 14:27of alcohol and of cannabis in the country, then we would have almost no substance use disorder.
- 14:35So that's why it's really important to focus on prevention.
- 14:40So what is prevention? This is an image of just a picture with the word prevention on a corkboard.
- 14:48And it's something that I bring up because I often ask people,
- 14:52what does prevention mean?
- 14:53And usually people will say something like, oh, it means we have to stop something
- 14:58bad from starting in the first place.
- 15:01And while that's true, I want to share a definition of prevention that I always
- 15:05go to when I think about designing interventions and the work that I do.
- 15:09So I'm going to share this definition. It actually comes from the Center for
- 15:13Substance Abuse Prevention.
- 15:18Which is part of the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.
- 15:22This is an old definition, and I'll read it and I'll sort of break it down,
- 15:27but I do want you to recognize that there's nothing in here that actually says
- 15:33substance use. So this is sort of a broad definition of prevention.
- 15:36But the CSAP defines prevention in this older model as a proactive process that
- 15:43empowers individuals and systems to meet the challenges of life events and transitions
- 15:49by creating and reinforcing conditions that promote healthy behaviors and lifestyles.
- 15:55So I'm going to break this down a little bit. Again, there's nothing that talks
- 15:59about stopping something bad from happening and also nothing about substance
- 16:04use. But let's break it down.
- 16:06So first, prevention is a proactive process.
- 16:11In working with parents and guardians and caregivers for many,
- 16:15many years, a lot of times I'll hear, well, I don't drink or we don't drink
- 16:19or we don't have alcohol in the house.
- 16:21Therefore, my kids will never be exposed to it. or we don't have to talk about it.
- 16:26And this idea of being passive when it comes to substance use prevention is
- 16:32really not something that we can do. We actually have to be very proactive about,
- 16:38working toward prevention.
- 16:40The second part of this is that it's a proactive process that empowers individuals and systems.
- 16:47So we're not talking just about the young person. We're talking about our larger
- 16:52structures that we all live within.
- 16:54And if we only focus on young people, we're actually missing a major,
- 17:00major opportunity to work to actually address the issue.
- 17:04Because we are individuals, and I'll talk about this in a few minutes,
- 17:08nested within our larger structures of our families, of our peers,
- 17:12of our work, our school, our communities, our neighborhoods,
- 17:18our religious institutions, and our policies, our states, and our country.
- 17:22So we live in these contexts, and if we do not actually work toward understanding
- 17:28how they impact the individuals, we're going to miss a lot and not be nearly as effective.
- 17:34The next is that we're talking about meeting the challenges of not just life
- 17:39events, but also transitions.
- 17:41And I bring this up because transitions are one of the greatest periods of risk
- 17:46throughout the entire life course.
- 17:47So you think about transitions anytime you go from one state to another.
- 17:52So, for example, you can imagine a kid starting school, maybe starting kindergarten
- 17:57if they hadn't been in daycare before, going from,
- 18:00elementary to middle school, middle school to high school, getting a license,
- 18:04leaving high school and either going to college or maybe getting a job,
- 18:08moving out, getting married, etc.
- 18:10Or even getting divorced, starting a new job, leaving a new job,
- 18:14retirement, all of these are talking about transition.
- 18:18And transitions tend to happen most frequently in childhood and adolescence.
- 18:24So we have to understand that even transitions that are considered positive,
- 18:29like getting married, like getting a license, like something that could be seen
- 18:33as very good, are still hard.
- 18:36And if we ignore that again, we're missing a piece of prevention.
- 18:41And then finally, prevention is talking about creating and reinforcing conditions
- 18:46that promote healthy behaviors and lifestyles.
- 18:49Again, there's nothing in this that says stop something from starting.
- 18:52It's if we started from a place of promotion, we'd be so much better off than
- 18:58where we often find ourselves when we're thinking about treatment.
- 19:02And so when we think about prevention, the Institute of Medicine was, in,
- 19:071994, focused on a continuum of care when prevention is thought of in this way
- 19:15of universal, selective, and indicated.
- 19:17When we think about prevention, we're often thinking about the medical model
- 19:22of primary, secondary, and tertiary.
- 19:25But in fact, that focus is on the stage of the disease. So you want to prevent
- 19:30the disease from starting and then from progressing and then the impact.
- 19:34This actually focuses on the target population of interest. So when we think
- 19:40about prevention, substance use prevention, we can think about these three different strategies.
- 19:46So universal selection prevention is aimed at groups or the general population
- 19:53without regard to individual risk.
- 19:55And this is an image of a population distribution, a normal distribution.
- 20:00And in universal prevention, you see that the benefits are really sort of at
- 20:07the high end of the distribution.
- 20:08So people who may have the higher risk and people in the middle,
- 20:13whereas you don't see any benefits, but in the lower end of the distribution.
- 20:19You actually see minimal benefits, but if it's universal and it can get to so
- 20:23many people, you can actually see a population benefit.
- 20:28And so you might see something, you know, anything, for example,
- 20:31that's delivered in the classroom for young people. And so D.A.R.E.,
- 20:34Drug Abuse Resistance Education, as an example.
- 20:39I'm not promoting D.A.R.E. This could be a whole other presentation on DARE
- 20:43and how it wasn't effective and in ways at the time when it was sort of being
- 20:48rolled out, increased certain substances.
- 20:51But it is an example of universal intervention that a lot of prevention that
- 20:55a lot of people may understand. So that's why I bring it up.
- 21:00The next is selective. And selective is aimed at those considered at heightened
- 21:03risk for problems due to membership in a particular risk group.
- 21:07And here we see an image of a normal distribution, and you see that the benefits
- 21:12are actually seen at the highest end of the distribution are the greatest,
- 21:17whereas you see a little bit in the middle and minimal benefits at the low end of the distribution.
- 21:22So, for example, this might be alcohol or drug programming that's given to members of a fraternity.
- 21:31Now, not every member of a fraternity will drink or use other drugs,
- 21:36and some may, in fact, never.
- 21:38But just because they are a member of this particular group,
- 21:41we know that their risk is higher and therefore they are targeted for prevention.
- 21:46Another example is children whose parents have a substance use disorder.
- 21:51Some may never use any substance and some may already be down the path or have
- 21:57substance use disorder, but because they are part of this group, they get targeted.
- 22:03And then finally, indicated, which is aimed at those who've already demonstrated
- 22:07early signs or consequences of problem behavior.
- 22:10And this is where we see the normal distribution, where the benefit is really
- 22:15only seen at the very high end.
- 22:18And this involves sort of direct intervention, but not formal treatment.
- 22:22And so one example might be people who go to an emergency department for an
- 22:28alcohol or drug-related injury.
- 22:30Maybe they have a broken wrist because they fell off a curb after being intoxicated.
- 22:35Or young people who are already partying and going to clubs or raves and they're
- 22:41already starting with substances. So they may not have a substance use disorder,
- 22:46but they're already going down a path.
- 22:48And so our approaches to prevention really need to be thoughtful about the target
- 22:53group, where they fall in this continuum.
- 22:56Because if we just, you know, if we're only focusing on universal,
- 22:59we're going to miss the higher risk.
- 23:01If we're only focusing on the higher risk, we're going to miss our opportunities
- 23:04to do prevention with the larger population.
- 23:08And so when we think about the social ecological model, this is,
- 23:13an image of the social ecological model, thinking of seeing how we are individuals,
- 23:19so with our own knowledge, attitudes, skills,
- 23:23and we are nested within our interpersonal, so family, friends, social networks,
- 23:30our organizational, so like I said, social institutions, our community, and our policy.
- 23:37And so the social ecological model gives us a framework for how we should be
- 23:41thinking about prevention.
- 23:43And in my work, I really focus on this next slide. We just see the one circle
- 23:50of the interpersonal with a highlight around family.
- 23:55And so that's where a lot of my work stems. So I'm going to spend the rest of
- 23:59my time talking about this in particular.
- 24:03So family this is my very very very adorable picture of a,
- 24:10of a penguin family with two adult penguins with their adorable little two ping little penguins.
- 24:19And so within the family context i just want to talk for a few minutes about
- 24:25sort of what works and what doesn't work and then we'll get to meals,
- 24:29So what we know does not work in the family context for substance use prevention.
- 24:35The first is authoritarian parenting. This is a picture of a parent or a guardian,
- 24:40sort of holding a small child's hand and waving their finger at them.
- 24:44We know authoritarian parenting is when there is very high structure in a family and very low support.
- 24:52And we know authoritarian parenting creates a high-risk environment for young
- 24:57people, Whereas in the family environment, high structure but high warmth and
- 25:02support is really protective.
- 25:04But authoritarian parenting we know is very high risk.
- 25:08We also know permissiveness with substances is a major risk for young people.
- 25:15And this is something that I hear a lot. People ask me, well,
- 25:19young people are going to drink anyway.
- 25:23As a parent, I should be giving them the tools to do it in a safe way.
- 25:26We sort of think about through a harm reduction lens.
- 25:29But what I always say is if we give young people expectations,
- 25:35they're more likely to meet them.
- 25:37And if our expectations are, so I'm raising my hand to my head,
- 25:41if my expectations are up here, maybe, and now I'm bringing my hand up,
- 25:47you know, maybe like half a foot below, maybe they meet those expectations.
- 25:52But, you know, maybe they don't quite get there, but they get somewhere.
- 25:56But now I'm bringing my hand down to my waist.
- 25:59If my expectations are down here, they're not going to typically go above those expectations.
- 26:05So if you sort of say my expectations are low, you're creating an opportunity
- 26:10for young people to not meet those expectations.
- 26:13And we know that they're more likely to meet higher expectations.
- 26:16So with permissiveness with substances, we need to be thinking about that.
- 26:20And that happens in the context of the family all the time.
- 26:25So what does work when it comes to substance use prevention?
- 26:29One thing is parental monitoring when caregivers know where their children are
- 26:35when they're not at home is very protective.
- 26:38We know open communication tends to be very effective. So when young people
- 26:42feel like they can talk to their caregivers or their caregivers talk to their
- 26:46kids, even if they don't think they're listening, they do. This we know is very protective.
- 26:53But now I'm going to get to family meals. So why family meals? What is it about meals?
- 26:59And you may have, and this is an image of just a fork and a spoon and,
- 27:05you know, just to show that we're talking about meals.
- 27:08And you may think, you know, when you looked at the title of this talk,
- 27:12you may have thought, how do family meals relate to substance use prevention in adolescence?
- 27:18And this is sort of an interesting area. So I'll take you back to how this sort of all began for me.
- 27:24So when in 2000 and I think it was actually the year 2000, so we're talking
- 27:30a long time ago, I have an image on the slide of an old school television with
- 27:36antennas and a remote control.
- 27:38And many of you on this call like me may remember when you actually had to watch
- 27:44television, like you might, you turn it on and whatever is on the screen is
- 27:49on the screen. And, you know, that's what you watch.
- 27:52So in the year 2000, I turned on my television that looked probably something like this.
- 27:58And I remember seeing a public service announcement.
- 28:02And the public service announcement was something like a coach walking through
- 28:07a house, walked to the kitchen and along the way said, you know,
- 28:12the number one way to prevent your kid from using drugs.
- 28:15And he goes and he opens up the oven and he pulls out a turkey and he puts it
- 28:19on the table and says, eat dinner with them.
- 28:22And so I was a public, a master's of public health student at the time.
- 28:26And I remember in the year 2000.
- 28:29Seeing that commercial and thinking to myself, could that actually be true? Is that real?
- 28:35And during that time, I was not in a position to really research that.
- 28:41But about nine years later, after I had finished my doctorate,
- 28:44when I became a researcher and I started thinking about how I wanted to work
- 28:49toward prevention and design interventions for adolescents, I was sitting in my office, and,
- 28:55my brain went back to that moment of the PSA.
- 28:58And then, so I thought, okay, well, now I know how to do research. I know what to look for.
- 29:03And what I found was that there was actually a lot of research.
- 29:07And in fact, the National Center for Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia
- 29:11University, which is now sort of Partnership to End Addiction, had.
- 29:17About a decade of research and reports called The Importance of Family Dinners.
- 29:22And they were of the first group to kind of to really shed light on this.
- 29:28However, what I found was that most of the research had been observational,
- 29:33meaning that it was looking, you know, doing surveys or really observing people
- 29:39rather than intervening upon them.
- 29:42And so I started thinking about how could I actually incorporate family meals
- 29:45into an intervention? And I'll talk about that in a few minutes.
- 29:48But I also just want to talk for a few minutes about family meals.
- 29:52And what we have seen over many years is that the research that had been done
- 29:59initially by Casa Colombia, now Partnership to End Addiction,
- 30:03and many other researchers has actually been replicated and been translated into practice.
- 30:08So this is a picture of the Family Dinner Project dot org's logo.
- 30:14And this is an organization whose goal is to champion family dinner.
- 30:18So, quote, family dinner as an opportunity for family members to connect with
- 30:22each other through food, fun and conversation about things that matter.
- 30:26So it's being promoted as a sort of something that people should be doing.
- 30:32Another example, this is a picture that was posted on social media many, about a decade ago.
- 30:40Brandi Young, who is a second grade teacher at a school that the woman who posted the image.
- 30:47Whose child was in her classroom, she passed out a letter to every parent on.
- 30:54Parent-teacher night to say what their new homework policy was going to be.
- 31:00And she said, Dear Parents, this new homework policy, after much research this
- 31:04summer, I'm trying something new. Homework will only consist of work that your
- 31:07student did not finish during the day.
- 31:10Dot, dot, dot. Research has been unable to prove that homework improves student performance.
- 31:14Rather, I ask you spend your evenings doing things that are proven to correlate with student success.
- 31:20And the thing that she says at first is eat dinner as a family.
- 31:25So we're seeing this in the lay community. We're seeing this out,
- 31:30that this has been shown. Eating dinner as a family is something that's really
- 31:34important. And it's not just for substance use.
- 31:36There are lots of outcomes where we know that this is important.
- 31:41But why? So why are family meals important?
- 31:44Before I tell you, I do want to share something that came up last year.
- 31:48And so this is an image of New York Times. There's an opinion guest essay.
- 31:53This is just about a year ago.
- 31:55It came out and it's called Why I Had to Kill Family Dinner.
- 32:00And so if you read the article, which I read with great interest and in fact
- 32:05sent a follow-up, which did not get published, but that's OK,
- 32:09I'm going to read part of this editorial or this op-ed.
- 32:14So this is an author woman talked about, did not basically decided that she
- 32:20didn't want to have family dinner anymore.
- 32:22So it said, I didn't want to do it anymore, but I felt terrible about giving it up.
- 32:27The messaging on family dinner is intense. I'd like to get the PR machine behind
- 32:32family dinner working for the end of end of gun violence in America.
- 32:36Family dinner will make your children smart. It will keep your children off drugs.
- 32:40Your children will learn languages, turn away from vaping, and join Model UN
- 32:45if you just sit together at the table for 15 minutes every evening,
- 32:49a plate of food in front of you.
- 32:51So she goes on to sort of talk about how, you know, why she decided to not eat
- 32:57meals anymore together.
- 32:59And she says, quote, so the next image is about, you know, more from this op-ed.
- 33:06Quote, the best part of giving up family dinner is finding new traditions.
- 33:10So she talks about this might be a walk, you know, for people walk around the
- 33:13block, an evening bike ride.
- 33:15For our family and for so many families, I'm sure it's TV.
- 33:20Every evening we gather in the living room and decide to gather on a show to watch.
- 33:24And she says, and we talk. Oh, how we talk.
- 33:28So I concluded that this author doesn't want to cook anymore,
- 33:34which I certainly understand.
- 33:36And I think anybody who made it through the pandemic would also agree that deciding
- 33:41on a meal, sitting down, making anything may be so unappealing. Right.
- 33:47But the truth is what she came to the conclusion of is that she's finding different
- 33:54ways to connect with her family.
- 33:56And that's really what the family meal is about and why we see it as providing a protective effect.
- 34:04And so this is the next slide is an image of a saucepan.
- 34:09And so I just wanted to sort of share what we call like the secret sauce of family meals.
- 34:16So why family meals are found to be associated with adolescent substance use prevention.
- 34:22First of all, it provides consistency and structure.
- 34:27It helps create a natural, low-pressure space for everyday conversation and
- 34:33help strengthen communication.
- 34:36It can show children that they are prioritized because you are not doing something
- 34:42else. You are spending this time together.
- 34:45And that actually makes a difference. Even if they may not see it in the moment,
- 34:50it does say something to them that you are prioritizing spending time with them.
- 34:56And the frequency can also help if you see, it might help you notice changes
- 35:02in behavior, mood, friends, school performance.
- 35:05So if you're having that consistent way to touch base every single day,
- 35:11that actually helps with identifying problems if they start.
- 35:16So that's kind of what helps why family meals are important.
- 35:22And I want to just give talk for a minute about what is a family meal.
- 35:26So this is an image of a plate with silverware.
- 35:30And people say to me all the time, well, what if people can't have a meal with their children?
- 35:37Maybe there are activities that get in the way. Maybe they maybe there's food
- 35:42insecurity. Right. There are so many reasons why people may not be able to eat meals together.
- 35:47So I just want to say what a meal is in my personal research and work and how we define it.
- 35:54So this next image is a picture of, people may recognize this,
- 35:59and you see it's a picture of the Cleaver family, Leave it to Beaver.
- 36:03And often when people think about, and for those who can't see.
- 36:07It's almost like a Thanksgiving meal that June Cleaver sort of every day is
- 36:12wearing her dress and pearls and puts this meal on the table for her husband and three kids.
- 36:17And so people often think that this is what a family meal is.
- 36:22And we really have to break out of this in order to reduce the barrier to entry.
- 36:27And in my research, we define a meal as any time a parent, guardian,
- 36:32caregiver, or anyone who's raising a child is with them and one of them is with
- 36:37a child and one of them is eating.
- 36:40So that could look like...
- 36:42Lots of different things. So for example, this is an image of a caregiver and
- 36:47a child maybe standing at a counter and they have a snack in front of them.
- 36:53I would consider that a family meal. It could look like a dinner at a restaurant.
- 36:56It could be at a fast food place. I mean, you know, it could be anywhere. It could be,
- 37:01whatever you can, you are able to sort of figure out what this looks like for,
- 37:07your family, for your patients, for the people that, you know,
- 37:10that are in your life that you're trying to help connect.
- 37:14There's something about food that really bonds people. And even if it's a banana,
- 37:19it's a shared experience.
- 37:21And it also, if you're able to take that time without screens,
- 37:25without other things going on, that's where the magic happens.
- 37:28That's the secret sauce. It's the connection that really matters.
- 37:32And the truth is it doesn't have to be a meal, but that is where people often
- 37:36find that they are eating anyway.
- 37:38So can we actually all do it together or even one person with a child.
- 37:44So it could look like this. But what it's not is this is an image of two parents
- 37:52playing cards at the kitchen counter, glass of wine, bottle of beer.
- 37:57And in the background, you see the two kids eating dinner, watching TV.
- 38:03And I actually took this.
- 38:05This is a generated image, but I took this image from one of my research studies
- 38:09where we gave parents iPads and asked them to take in videos of their family
- 38:14dinners for us to analyze.
- 38:17And a family actually submitted this. And so this is how they defined family dinner.
- 38:23And I want to be able to say like, so this is not a family dinner because they're not together.
- 38:30So even though they're physically in the same space, it's nothing that allows
- 38:33for them to actually engage in any meaningful way. So,
- 38:39So that's the kind of work that, you know, we think about.
- 38:43And like I said, I always try to reduce the barrier to entry because people
- 38:47always sort of say, well, we can't possibly have a meal together.
- 38:50Well, we need to change the definition.
- 38:52And it's really about engagement at the end of the day.
- 38:55So I'm going to spend a couple minutes in my last couple minutes talking about
- 38:59some of our research projects that I've been engaged in.
- 39:02And kind of what this was look like over the past kind of couple of decades for me.
- 39:07And it's hard to distill it down to just one slide, but I'm going to try to
- 39:10do it so I can talk about it.
- 39:13So as in my introduction, we talked, you heard about what's called the SUPPER
- 39:18Project. So that's substance use prevention promoted by eating family meals
- 39:23regularly. That's what SUPPER stands for.
- 39:26And this is an intervention, a brief intervention, universal, so aimed at anybody.
- 39:33It's not for people at higher risk with the goal of increasing communication
- 39:40in general, engagement and communication about substances for young people.
- 39:46So caregivers and their fifth through seventh grade students.
- 39:49And this was the first intervention that actually tried to tap into meals as
- 39:53a conduit for education, for communication.
- 39:56And we worked with over 400 parent-child dyads and did a large randomized control trial.
- 40:04We first got a National Institute of Drug Abuse pilot trial,
- 40:08and then we were able to get funding to test this in a large-scale trial with 400 families,
- 40:15where we found that parents in the intervention were way more likely to talk
- 40:20to their kids about alcohol, cannabis, other substances.
- 40:23And the things that they were saying were much stronger. It was a higher quality.
- 40:27So not the kind of things such as, well, if you're going to drink,
- 40:31do it in this context to be safe.
- 40:33It was more aligned with the science, what we know the conversation should be
- 40:38to actually help prevent substance use.
- 40:41And so I developed that in 2009. We did qualitative work.
- 40:45We piloted it. We tested it. And our primary outcome paper around parent-child
- 40:49communication came out last year.
- 40:53Another research trajectory in 2013, our lab did a literature review looking
- 41:01at family meals and risk outcomes.
- 41:03And we looked at the literature around family meals, which has lots of definitions,
- 41:08by the way, not mine, but there are lots of them out there, and showing that
- 41:13there were very strong associations with reductions in risk of substance use, so alcohol,
- 41:19tobacco, et cetera, as well as sexual risk, academic problems,
- 41:25violence, and sort of across the board
- 41:28that kids are eating meals with their families were less likely to sort of be
- 41:32engaged in a lot of different risk factors, as well as having higher.
- 41:36Nutritional content in their meals.
- 41:40And we did that as a jumping off point and realized sort of during that literature
- 41:44review that the definition of what a meal was, was very condensed.
- 41:49And we felt like we actually focused, most of the literature at the time focused
- 41:55solely on frequency. So how often are you eating and duration?
- 42:01How long are you taking? And so during this time, we actually spent about a
- 42:04decade developing and testing what we call the family dinner index,
- 42:08which is I designed, we designed this,
- 42:12survey tool to be very brief so that it can be added in larger epidemiologic studies.
- 42:18So there are eight items covering sort of four different factors focusing on
- 42:24group enjoyment and things that people have to do at meals and found that,
- 42:29this measure was also associated with reductions in risk of substance use and alcohol,
- 42:37and lots of other substances.
- 42:40And then we are actually, we focused a lot on communication outcomes.
- 42:46So that's what I mentioned before about when we saw the supper project,
- 42:52that large trial, we focused on what are the outcomes of communication.
- 42:56And we have another paper that we're writing now focusing on not just if people
- 43:02in the intervention group had better communication outcomes, but was there,
- 43:08a relationship with how long they ate and how many meals they ate and,
- 43:13how much they talked about substances.
- 43:16And we're finding that that was, in fact, the case. So we're seeing more the
- 43:20effect of the intervention for people who were more engaged with meals.
- 43:24And then a recent study that just came out this year looking at the relationship.
- 43:31This is an observational study with over 2,000 parent-child diodes across the U.S.
- 43:36Where we took the family dinner index and we looked at the relationship between
- 43:40quality of family meals, which is what we saw through the family dinner index,
- 43:45and substance use, which we saw over and over again.
- 43:49But we looked at the relationship with, were there differences in kids who had
- 43:54been exposed to adverse childhood experiences?
- 43:57And kids who had zero or up to three adverse childhood experiences still derived
- 44:02the benefit of family meals when it came to substance use outcomes.
- 44:06But what we found was let kids who had higher ACE score, adverse childhood experience
- 44:11of four or more, they were not deriving the same benefits when it came to substance use outcomes.
- 44:17So while family meals can absolutely be a very important aspect of the family
- 44:24environment and ability to connect with kids, if kids have higher other risk factors,
- 44:32we are seeing that it's not as strong of an intervention.
- 44:36So we have to be careful not to think of it as a complete panacea.
- 44:39So with that, I will leave you with another adorable family picture.
- 44:44These are ducks with their little ducklings.
- 44:47And I want to thank you so much. And if you have questions, I know we have about
- 44:5410 to 12 minutes. If people have questions, I'm happy to answer.
- 44:58And thank you so much. I'll stop sharing.
- 45:00Oh, my gosh, Margie. That was fabulous. Thank you so much.
- 45:04And thanks for giving us so much background before you dove into the family
- 45:11dinner. So I think Carol Zekman has her hand up. Hi, Carol. Haven't talked to you for a while. Hi.
- 45:18I just wanted to thank you for bringing up how high we set the bar around condoning substance use.
- 45:24Because one of the best things about working in public health was when my three, I do have three sons.
- 45:29So my three sons, whenever they were teenagers or early college and they would
- 45:33try and make us feel guilty that we had not condoned drinking in any way,
- 45:38you know, they would say, well, we might have, when we were in college, not gotten drunk.
- 45:42I said, nope, being in the public health world, I actually know that's false.
- 45:46So for all of you who may still have kids, it's great to have in your back pocket
- 45:50that you cannot be guilted that not condoning drinking was not setting your
- 45:57children up for success.
- 45:58So it was kind of good to just be able to be like, nope, facts,
- 46:01surveys, everything, research is all behind me. So it was handy.
- 46:06Thank you so much. And if I can use it as a jumping off point to say something
- 46:10else, and I really appreciate that comment.
- 46:13And one of the things that I hear a lot, because people will inevitably sort of ask me,
- 46:18particularly if I'm talking with younger people, maybe in the college age,
- 46:21they'll say, well, you know, my friend whose parent sort of,
- 46:25you know, said, I forbid you from drinking or doing any of this and partying.
- 46:29And then they got to college and they just let loose and they sort of,
- 46:33you know, went nuts because they didn't have the experience or they didn't have that experience.
- 46:38You know, any kind of boundaries. So they just went, you know, from zero to a hundred.
- 46:43And I said, well, you know, that does happen, but usually there's other context.
- 46:48And oftentimes we see that context
- 46:50in that more authoritarian parenting of you're, you cannot do this.
- 46:56And maybe sort of that finger wagging and, you know, not let's talk about it,
- 47:02but you can't do it. And I forbid you to do it. And that's the end of that.
- 47:06We're not going to talk any further.
- 47:08Usually, and we see this too, if you can start these conversations young and
- 47:12actually develop conversation skills around this, by the time people are teenagers,
- 47:18you can actually have dialogue about it.
- 47:20And so what are the questions you have? Tell me what you've heard about.
- 47:25If you say you want to, let's talk about why. What are the needs here? What is it going to do?
- 47:30Sometimes it's around like, oh, my friends are, you know, I live in a town where
- 47:33people go to what they call the woods and, you know, trying to have conversations
- 47:38with kids about not going.
- 47:40I have an 18-year-old and a 15-year-old. Like, I know, I mean,
- 47:44I'm literally in the thick of it with these conversations and all the things
- 47:47that we do in my household around this.
- 47:49But it's often, you know, people who sort of go from zero to 100,
- 47:54it's not just because they weren't allowed to.
- 47:58There's other stuff happening as well. And so,
- 48:01if people do want to continue to think, like, I want to provide expectations,
- 48:06or if you are clinicians working with parents and guardians,
- 48:10you know, providing them with the permission to have higher expectations,
- 48:14we know from the evidence that that's really effective.
- 48:17Well, that's great. Thank you. And thanks, Carol. Joe's got a great question
- 48:21about how some schools serve lunches with a teacher at each table and a round
- 48:25table otherwise filled with students.
- 48:28What sort of value would you associate with that? Is that somehow you think
- 48:33replicate the family meal or some of the benefits of it?
- 48:37So I think that that is a very interesting, I haven't heard that before having lunches with a teacher.
- 48:44I'm wondering if you're talking about maybe elementary versus high school,
- 48:47because I might have a different answer depending on that.
- 48:53I do think that there are lots of times where family meals are not actually a good thing.
- 49:03And any time, right, because if you're in an environment, in the home environment
- 49:07where there's actually adversity, that might actually create more problems.
- 49:12And so we should be thinking about, I mean, I advocate to think about,
- 49:17can we think of family meals as something broader?
- 49:20And, you know, you may not want to, if you're a teenager, you may not want to eat with your teacher.
- 49:25You may want to actually process your day with your friend. But maybe if you're
- 49:28a younger person, you know, maybe you're in elementary school,
- 49:31having an adult that you can sort of process some stuff with could be really important.
- 49:36I've been talking to somebody, a colleague who does work with young trans women who.
- 49:45You know, don't live at home and are living in sort of, you know,
- 49:48with like a done mother and talking about like whatever your family looks like,
- 49:53can you carve out time to be able to have connection, right?
- 49:58And again, it doesn't have to be a meal, but a meal sometimes allows that.
- 50:01So I think when people try to create it in other environments,
- 50:06like in the cafeteria, I think they're trying to do something good.
- 50:10And it's always important to sort of know, are we doing good or are we doing
- 50:15harm by, you know, putting this into play?
- 50:18So I can absolutely see benefits of it, but it would also be important to sort
- 50:23of check in to see if it's doing what they're expecting to do.
- 50:28That's great. And Elizabeth's got a question. She said, I was interested in
- 50:32terms of the university drinking culture, if there are examples of effective
- 50:37prevention strategies.
- 50:38For instance, a family member of mine attends an SEC university.
- 50:42So Elizabeth, I had to Google what that is. It said Southeastern Conference. Is that right?
- 50:48And their parents are completely fine with the drinking culture of the students.
- 50:52So, and Elizabeth, feel free to add, and I just saw you popped in on camera.
- 50:56So feel free to add anything to that.
- 50:59Yeah, I was just curious once these kids leave the home, if there's any prevention strategies and,
- 51:06you know, it seems like the family is very permissive in their use of alcohol
- 51:11at home and almost like, well, they're supposed to go there and get it out of
- 51:15their system and learn how to drink.
- 51:17And these kids are 18 and 19. And that seems to be the thinking on many college
- 51:25campuses. But it almost surprised me that the parents thought that way.
- 51:29Yeah. So, you know, thank you. That's a really, really good and important question.
- 51:34I will say sort of that I'll answer kind of the flip of what you're asking first,
- 51:38and then I'll get to what you're asking.
- 51:40So what we also know from the evidence and research is that when parents and
- 51:45guardians continue to provide high expectations when their kids are off on their
- 51:50own, whether it's college or elsewhere,
- 51:53that those expectations still actually matter.
- 51:57And so if you are caregiver and say to your kid who's going off to college,
- 52:02my expectations are still this, right?
- 52:05Again, if their expectations are very high, maybe the kid is getting closer to that.
- 52:12But that still actually matters when they're off on their own.
- 52:17So the family environment still does make a very, very important impact on substance use behaviors.
- 52:25If parents say, well, this is your right, you're supposed to go off and do this,
- 52:30have fun, just try to be safe, that's what they're going to do. So.
- 52:37The drinking culture, if they're at school, the college environment is really
- 52:42conducive to that, and they're living in the family environment that's also
- 52:47promoting that, there may not be much that colleges can kind of do.
- 52:52But we do know that, you know, like I said before, the amount of the prevalence
- 52:58of drinking has gone way down.
- 53:00And we're seeing more and more, too. Like, even in college campuses,
- 53:04it's just not what it had been.
- 53:06And so the more that we can actually promote the sort of social norms of most
- 53:12people your age are not rather than most people your age are,
- 53:16that's actually better. And we can we see that on college campuses as being kind of effective.
- 53:21There are lots of different programs. It's not my age group,
- 53:23per se. So I'm sorry I can't give you as much. But I will share sort of a.
- 53:29Like an anecdote that happened with me and that idea of norms.
- 53:32My son two years ago was taking driver's ed and he came home and he said to
- 53:36me, mom, the driver was talking, the driver's ed instructor was talking about
- 53:42the, you know, how important it is that if we're, if we're drinking, we're not driving.
- 53:46And he said, look, I know most of you are drinking.
- 53:50And if your parents don't think you are, then they have something else coming.
- 53:53But I just want to impart to you how important is that you don't drive and,
- 53:58you know, just to be really safe.
- 54:00And so when he came home and told me that, I said, isn't that so interesting?
- 54:03Because the truth is, this is a group of maybe 40, 16-year-olds.
- 54:08I said, maybe, you know, four to six to eight of them are drinking, but not 40 of them.
- 54:17And so I called the instructor because this is what I do.
- 54:20I call the instructor. And I said, I just want you to know, when you say to
- 54:25this group of 16-year-olds, I know most of you are drinking,
- 54:28you are actually increasing the chances that they are, right?
- 54:32So the norming that we do on college campuses and high schools,
- 54:35you know, he was doing something because he thought he was doing something helpful,
- 54:40but in fact, he might have actually been creating harm.
- 54:42So I'll leave you with that. Sorry, I know I went on a tangent, Elizabeth, but.
- 54:48No, that's actually, it was great. Thank you. And thanks, Elizabeth,
- 54:50for bringing that question up.
- 54:52So one, I think one last question, unless I see any others.
- 54:55You know, clinicians are, most of the people on the call, many of them are clinicians.
- 54:59And, you know, they've just got a couple minutes to discuss a lot of things with parents.
- 55:05So, you know, if there's kind of one thing you could recommend that they talk
- 55:10about in terms of family dinners, is there one realistic first step in sort of how they can,
- 55:17articulate it to parents when you've only got, you know, a few seconds?
- 55:21So I would say that if it's possible to, you know, have a 30 second conversation
- 55:28about how conversations and open communication is so important and meals can provide that.
- 55:35Is, you know, that's one thing that you can say.
- 55:38And there are lots of resources and I'm happy to share with you,
- 55:41too, if you want to share out about how people can sort of start this conversation,
- 55:46because some people it's just not, you know, it's not easy.
- 55:49But I would also say that if you can get to people and say a meal does not have to be this,
- 55:55you know, this big to do, it can just be a snack, just find the time as many
- 55:59days as possible to have even five minutes to connect. And that will make a difference.
- 56:05That's great. Well, thank you very much.
- 56:08I feel like, you know, sometimes you discover the benefits of the past and this
- 56:12is sort of what this is happening because I'm of a generation where,
- 56:16I mean, family meals were the norm, you know, and so it is interesting to see that they went away.
- 56:22And then now we're, thanks to your research and others, we're rediscovering their benefits.
- 56:27So thank you so much, Dr. Margie Skier, for joining us.
- 56:32And you are not that far away in Boston at Tufts University.
- 56:35So anyway, maybe one day we can all meet in person too.
- 56:38So thank you so much for your research and your dedication to this.
- 56:42And we also, Ellen, our next Public Health Grant Rounds with Brian Kostucchi
- 56:50from the De Beaumont Foundation.
- 56:51He's a national public health figure, especially around communications on public
- 56:55health. And what day is that? Can you remind me?
- 56:58On the 27th, October.
- 57:01And I'll put that right here. Okay. October 27th at noontime.
- 57:07And again, he's a national figure on communication around public health.
- 57:10So, oh, there you go. And stop in the chat.
- 57:13Thank you so much, everybody. We'll see you then. Thank you,
- 57:16Martha. Bye-bye. Bye. Thank you.
- 57:19Thank you for listening, and we look forward to connecting with you again at
- 57:23MaineHealth's Public Health Grand Rounds, where we explore a timely public health
- 57:28topic with national and Maine experts.
- 57:31These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on Podbean,
- 57:36and at MaineHealth.org, where you can hear current and past episodes. See you next time.