Latest / Ryan's Journal / The Art of the Polite Complaint and the Fine Print

Transcript

The Art of the Polite Complaint and the Fine Print · Ryan's Journal

0:15
Okay, so here's the situation.
0:17
A man tries to upgrade his subscription.
0:19
The upgrade fails.
0:21
He tries again.
0:22
The upgrade fails again.
0:24
Two attempts, two failures, and what does Ryan do?
0:28
He doesn't throw the laptop.
0:29
He doesn't post a thousand word rant.
0:32
He writes a letter.
0:33
A polite letter.
0:35
In this economy!
0:36
That is discipline, folks.
0:38
That is a man who wants to win the long game.
0:42
That's the part that stuck with me too.
0:44
In the wrestling business, the guy who stays level when the finish goes wrong is the
0:49
guy who keeps getting booked.
0:51
Everybody loses their cool when the match goes sideways.
0:54
Ryan's match went sideways twice, and he reached for a pen.
0:58
I respect it.
0:59
I really do.
1:00
You don't see a lot of that anymore.
1:01
And think about what he asked for.
1:03
Three things.
1:05
A credit.
1:05
An extension.
1:07
An explanation.
1:08
Credit, extension, explanation.
1:11
It's a beautiful little package.
1:12
It's tidy.
1:13
He's not asking for a yacht.
1:15
He's not asking for the CEO's phone number.
1:18
He wants a little money back, a little more time, and somebody to tell him what
1:22
happened.
1:22
That's the most reasonable demand in the history of customer service,
1:27
and it's still going to end up in a queue.
1:30
Well, that's the thing about being reasonable.
1:32
It doesn't get you out of the line.
1:33
It just means you're polite while you stand in it.
1:36
And the source we're working from says Ryan did a few things right.
1:41
He described the problem.
1:43
He asked for specific remedies.
1:45
He stayed polite.
1:47
That's a good opening statement.
1:48
Clear, respectful, and not a single threat to leave a one star review.
1:53
Not one!
1:53
Which, let's be honest, is the real shock.
1:57
We live in a country where a late sandwich can trigger a social media campaign,
2:04
and this man is out here being a gentleman about a failed upgrade.
2:08
Twice failed.
2:10
The upgrade that wouldn't upgrade.
2:13
It's like a promotion where they hand you the badge and the badge says no.
2:18
Now, I'll say this.
2:20
We don't know who the company is.
2:21
The source keeps it anonymous on purpose, so I'm not going to pretend I know which
2:25
software or service we're talking about.
2:28
Could be anything.
2:29
All we know is there was a button, Ryan pushed it, and the button had other plans.
2:34
The button had a mind of its own.
2:36
Strong button.
2:37
Very independent.
2:39
I'm picturing a little spinner somewhere spinning and spinning,
2:43
and I'm making that part up, to be clear, the source never says it.
2:47
But you know it's what we all imagine.
2:50
The spinning.
2:51
The hope.
2:52
The nothing.
2:53
So let's talk about the letter, because this is where it gets interesting.
2:57
Ryan did the polite thing and he asked for specific remedies,
3:01
but the source points out a gap.
3:03
The letter never names the plan.
3:05
It never gives the dates.
3:07
And it never gives the exact error.
3:10
Never names the plan!
3:11
Never gives the dates!
3:13
Never says what the error said!
3:15
Come on, Ryan!
3:16
You wrote the whole letter, you got the tone perfect, and then you left out the
3:21
three things a support agent needs to find you.
3:24
It's like showing up to a rally and forgetting to say where the rally is.
3:28
Great speech.
3:29
Nobody knows what building they're in.
3:32
And here's what the source says that I think is the sharpest point in the whole
3:36
piece.
3:37
Without those details, the support agent has to guess.
3:42
And a guess makes a no more likely.
3:44
That's the whole mechanism.
3:46
It's not that the agent is a bad person.
3:49
It's that a guess is a risk, and when somebody has to guess,
3:53
the safe answer is the one that can't get them in trouble.
3:56
The safe answer is no.
3:57
Always the safe answer.
3:59
Nobody ever got written up for saying no.
4:01
Nobody got a plaque for saying maybe.
4:04
So the agent opens Ryan's letter, sees a nice man with a real problem,
4:09
and then sees fog.
4:11
Which plan?
4:12
Which day?
4:13
Which error?
4:14
And the agent thinks, I could dig through the logs for an hour,
4:18
or I could send a kind sentence and a closed ticket.
4:22
Momentum goes to the closed ticket.
4:25
Every time.
4:26
I think about it like a commentary table.
4:28
When Gorilla Monsoon and I were calling a match, and a lot of people remember him as
4:32
Gino, we had to describe what was actually happening in the ring.
4:37
If I'd just said something went wrong in there, folks, nobody learns anything.
4:41
You need the specifics.
4:42
The name, the move, the moment.
4:44
Specifics are what make the story land.
4:46
Ryan told the story.
4:47
He just skipped the names.
4:49
Names and dates win elections, Jesse.
4:52
Show me the precinct, show me the numbers, show me the timestamp.
4:56
This letter has feelings and requests, but the receipts are missing.
5:00
And I want to be fair, because I'm a fair person, very fair,
5:04
nobody's fairer.
5:05
Ryan may have had a perfectly good reason.
5:08
Maybe he wrote it fast.
5:09
Maybe he was frustrated.
5:11
But the lesson is the same either way.
5:13
Put the facts in the first paragraph.
5:16
And that's not me being hard on Ryan.
5:18
It's a small fix.
5:19
Plan name, dates of the attempts, the error message or code.
5:23
Three lines.
5:24
That's the difference between an agent who has to guess and an agent who can just
5:28
look it up.
5:29
And an agent who can look it up can actually say yes.
5:32
Now let's go to the fine print, because the show is called Read the Fine Print and I
5:37
take that seriously.
5:38
The source says most terms and conditions treat credits and refunds as at our
5:45
discretion.
5:46
At our discretion!
5:48
You hear that phrase and you know.
5:50
You know.
5:51
It's the three most powerful words in business.
5:54
Not you're welcome.
5:56
Not thank you.
5:57
At our discretion.
5:59
But the source makes a point I want to keep, because it's fair.
6:03
It says that's not cruelty.
6:05
It's a protective clause.
6:07
A company writes that language so it isn't forced to hand out money every time
6:12
something breaks.
6:13
So the customer looks at a failed upgrade and sees a broken promise,
6:17
and the company looks at the same failure and sees a policy.
6:21
And the source says neither side is wrong.
6:24
Neither side is wrong!
6:25
Which is the most annoying sentence in the English language,
6:29
by the way.
6:30
I want a winner.
6:31
I want a scoreboard.
6:33
But no, the source says the gap between those two views is where conflict starts.
6:39
Ryan sees a transaction that didn't work.
6:42
The company sees a clause that works perfectly.
6:46
Two people looking at one broken button and seeing two different worlds.
6:52
It's like a storyline where both guys think they're the good guy.
6:56
That's when it gets heated, because nobody thinks they're the villain.
6:59
Ryan figures, I paid, I tried, it failed, make it right.
7:03
The company figures, we wrote the rules clearly, the rules say discretion.
7:07
Both of them believe the script is on their side.
7:10
And I'll tell you what this tells me.
7:11
It tells me the no is probably coming before anybody opens the envelope.
7:17
I'm saying probably, because the source never tells us how Ryan's letter turned out.
7:24
We don't know if he got the extension.
7:26
We don't know if he got a form letter.
7:28
We don't know if the upgrade ever worked.
7:32
The ending is missing.
7:34
It's a cliffhanger by accident.
7:36
Which I think is actually useful, because it keeps us honest.
7:40
We're not here to say the company said no.
7:42
We're saying that under a discretion clause, a no is a very available answer.
7:46
The real question isn't whether it's allowed.
7:49
The real question is how it gets delivered, and how it gets received.
7:53
Delivery!
7:54
Now we're talking.
7:55
Because a no can land like a punch or it can land like a handshake.
8:00
Same word.
8:01
Totally different crowd reaction.
8:03
And that's what the next part of this is all about.
8:06
The source lays out what it calls an SEL playbook for the company,
8:10
social emotional learning, applied to a support desk.
8:14
Which sounds funny until you read the steps and realize it's just basic respect with
8:18
a number next to each line.
8:20
Step one is empathize first.
8:23
The example is, I'm sorry the upgrade kept failing.
8:27
That cost you time.
8:28
That cost you time.
8:30
That's a great line.
8:31
Short.
8:32
Human.
8:32
It doesn't admit a lawsuit, it doesn't promise a pony, it just says,
8:37
I see you.
8:38
Because Ryan's real loss here might not even be money.
8:42
It's time.
8:43
Two attempts, one letter, probably more waiting.
8:46
The company can't always give back the dollars, but it can at least notice the
8:51
minutes.
8:52
Step two, stay calm.
8:54
No blame and no policy speak.
8:56
And I think that second part is the killer.
8:58
Policy speak is when someone reads you the rulebook like it's a hostage statement.
9:03
Per section whatever, we are unable to.
9:05
The source says skip that.
9:07
Stay steady and talk like a person.
9:09
Step three, explain briefly and honestly.
9:13
We can't issue credits for this, and here's why.
9:16
Brief!
9:17
Honest!
9:18
Two of my favorite words.
9:20
You don't need a forty paragraph defense.
9:23
Say the no, say the reason, move on.
9:26
People can handle a no.
9:27
What they can't handle is a no wrapped in six layers of fog.
9:32
Step four is my favorite, pair the no with a yes.
9:35
The example is, I can fix the upgrade today and extend your trial.
9:39
Now notice what happened there.
9:41
The credit got denied, but the functional problem got solved and Ryan still gets
9:45
more time.
9:46
That's a trade where nobody walks out empty handed.
9:49
That's a win!
9:50
That's a negotiated win!
9:52
The company protects its discretion clause, Ryan gets his upgrade,
9:56
and he gets extra time.
9:58
And step five, follow through.
10:01
I'll check back with you Friday.
10:03
Friday!
10:04
A date!
10:05
A promise with a calendar attached.
10:07
That's how you build trust, folks.
10:09
You say Friday, and then Friday actually shows up.
10:14
Now the source doesn't leave Ryan off the hook.
10:17
There's a playbook for the customer too.
10:20
Lead with facts.
10:21
Which, we've covered, plan, dates, error.
10:24
Ask for the fix first, before you ask for money.
10:27
Offer a flexible choice, so the agent has more than one way to say yes.
10:32
And if the answer is no, pause before replying.
10:35
Pause!
10:36
That's the hardest one.
10:38
Because the instinct is to fire back immediately, to win the exchange.
10:43
But the source says take a breath, then ask one question: what alternatives are
10:50
available?
10:51
That question is a masterpiece.
10:53
It's not a surrender.
10:55
It's not a fight.
10:56
It keeps the door open and puts the next move in the company's hands.
11:01
That's the thing I keep coming back to.
11:03
The closing line in the source says terms and conditions set the boundaries,
11:08
but tone decides whether people feel respected inside them.
11:13
The rules might not change.
11:15
The clause might stay exactly where it is.
11:18
But how you get treated inside those walls, that part is still up for grabs.
11:23
So here's the final scorecard.
11:25
Ryan, great tone, great asks, missing the plan, the dates, and the error.
11:31
Company, probably holding a discretion clause, and the right move is empathy,
11:36
honesty, and a yes next to the no.
11:39
We don't know how it ended.
11:41
But we know how it should be played.
11:43
Be specific.
11:44
Be calm.
11:45
Pair the no with a yes.
11:48
And when in doubt, ask what alternatives are available.
11:51
And if you've got a failed upgrade of your own sitting in your drafts,
11:55
go put the plan name, the dates, and the error at the top.
11:58
Three lines.
11:59
It might be the best edit you ever make.