Latest / Film And Whiskey / Silence / The Wiseman Rye
Transcript
- 0:00In 2016, director Martin, Scorsese and star.
- 0:04Andrew Garfield gave the world, a prolonged examination of the
- 0:08role of suffering in faith in 2022.
- 0:12Kentucky, owl gives us the first of two new budget Expressions,
- 0:17the film is silence. The whiskey is the wise men ride
- 0:22and we'll review them both. This is the film and whiskey
- 0:26podcast. Welcome to the film and whiskey
- 0:46podcast, where each week, we review a classic movie and a
- 0:49glass of whiskey. I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and
- 0:56you're doing the accent of everyone in this movie Brad
- 1:00Because this week, we're looking at a 2013's silence, a movie
- 1:04full of terrible accents, just the worse.
- 1:08And to be clear, I think, as I said that, I might, I realized
- 1:13that I might have sounded like, I was imitating a Japanese
- 1:15accent. I was not trying to do that.
- 1:17I was trying to joke about the fact that Adam Driver and Liam
- 1:21Neeson and Andrew Garfield. Cannot do a Portuguese accent to
- 1:26save their lives. Nope, not at all, not at all.
- 1:29It's It's so bad. Hey, let's just get that out of
- 1:31the way now. So like, I like this movie a lot
- 1:35Brad. And obviously, I think, like,
- 1:37we've actually been talking about this movie for many years
- 1:39on the podcast, because when we first started the show episode 1
- 1:44of filmin, whiskey is Goodfellas, and you said on that
- 1:49correct, who directed that bigger?
- 1:50Right? You said on that podcast, that
- 1:52the only Scorsese movie you had seen up to that point was
- 1:56silence. So like yeah your introduction
- 1:59to Or say Z was perhaps the least stereotypically Scorsese
- 2:04film there is in terms of in terms of content and Rhythm.
- 2:09Well, it was really funny. So the reason I saw silence, one
- 2:13of my absolute best friends in the world.
- 2:15Matt Kalman. He lives out in St.
- 2:18Louis, he was visiting me while I was while we were both in
- 2:21seminary, and we were just like had a group of friends over,
- 2:26because I wanted my friends to meet my buddy that I lived with,
- 2:28in Philly. And we are hanging out, we had
- 2:31dinner, we, you know, had a few drinks.
- 2:33And we were like, let's watch a movie.
- 2:36And Matt was like, yeah, I heard about this movie called silence.
- 2:40It's about these like Jesuit missionaries to Japan.
- 2:43I'm really interested in it. I want to watch it.
- 2:46And so everybody in the group was like, well, you know, we're
- 2:48going to let the guest pick the movie X.
- 2:52I'll just say this, in a group of like 8 to 10 people silence
- 2:58is not necessarily the move. To watch Classic Party.
- 3:01Movie silence. Followed by a Maybe do like a
- 3:05back-to-back viewing and then just throw on like Schindler's
- 3:07List, right afterwards? Yeah, rip-roaring.
- 3:11Good times. We were like weeping halfway
- 3:14through the movie, so, yeah. That was my introduction to the
- 3:21illustrious world of Martin Scorsese.
- 3:24So, I also saw this movie while we were in seminary and you know
- 3:27of course I had been keeping tabs on it because Scorsese
- 3:30this, this project had been gestating in the mind of
- 3:34Scorsese for decades. He wanted to make it in the 80s.
- 3:37Didn't have the funding set. It aside came back to it, set it
- 3:39aside. Again you know, and then he
- 3:41makes the Wolf of Wall Street and he's like, you know, it's
- 3:44probably time for me to do silence.
- 3:45I think, I think the man needed a reset, he finally does silence
- 3:50and it comes out with just a thud.
- 3:52Like, I don't know what happened.
- 3:54I still I'm trying to figure out like, if the studio just
- 3:56decided, this is not really going to work.
- 3:58I know that he delivered it. At the very last minute.
- 4:01And so it wasn't really like an awards Contender.
- 4:03It does get nominated for best cinematography, but like that's
- 4:06it and you'd think that a Scorsese movie would have more
- 4:09like oomph behind it, but this movie kind of got dumped in
- 4:13theaters and it didn't come out, you know, wide until January and
- 4:18the closest it was playing to us.
- 4:19When we lived in, Kentucky was Cincinnati.
- 4:22And so I drove like an hour and a half, to go see this movie
- 4:25partially because there were like a number of people that
- 4:28went to Seminary with us. So that were also familiar with
- 4:31the fact that this movie was coming out and as Seminary Bros
- 4:36are want to do, they already had opinions on like the content of
- 4:40the movie having not seen it. And I was like for the love of
- 4:43God. Like I'm gonna at least go see
- 4:45this movie before, I formed my opinion on it.
- 4:47So like I knew I was the only person at Asbury Seminary that
- 4:51had driven an hour and a half to go see this movie that was
- 4:54released in like five theaters. So it was nice to at least know
- 4:57who was talking out of their butt and whoo.
- 4:59Not and that's my experience with silence.
- 5:03First off, I am okay with not being at Seminary anymore, Bob
- 5:07dude, me too that the life of Seminary Bros was was a little
- 5:11bit tiresome if I'm being honest.
- 5:16Secondly, I love your commitment to being right, you know?
- 5:22It's not even like that. I want to be, right?
- 5:24It's just that I want. I want to speak from an informed
- 5:27Place. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 5:29It clearly some that so many people in seminary, don't care
- 5:32about that. That's 100% the case.
- 5:35Yeah. Well in the spirit of being
- 5:39informed Brad and I have both seen silence now, multiple
- 5:41times. We're going to talk through the
- 5:43whole thing performances. The direction I want to talk
- 5:46about the pacing of the movie, a bit, because having seen it now,
- 5:49for a second time, Brad, I hadn't watched it since the
- 5:52theater. I do think this movie is a
- 5:53little slow. I do think this movie is not
- 5:55perfect, but we have a very particular Attachment to and
- 6:01lens to view this movie from. And so I think we're going to
- 6:04have a really good discussion on this today.
- 6:06But before we start all that, it's time for us to throw over
- 6:10to Brad explains, which is America's favorite segments.
- 6:15This is the part of the podcast where Brad breaks down the plot
- 6:17of the film that he has just seen often for the first time.
- 6:21This is not Brad's first time seeing silence, so let's just
- 6:24get that clear. However, it is a three hour long
- 6:26movie and we're only giving you 60 seconds to break.
- 6:29Take down the plot of it. Brad.
- 6:31Do you think you can do it? All right I think this movie
- 6:34comes in three parts. There's the opening when Andrew
- 6:39Garfield and Adam Driver are Jesuit priests, they find out
- 6:43that their Mentor has apostatize do, which you will probably hear
- 6:47that word. A lot means that they recanted
- 6:50their faith or basically said, I'm not a Christian anymore, so
- 6:54they go to Japan. Second part of the movie is them
- 6:59ministering. To basically an underground
- 7:02church that is being repressed by the Japanese government at
- 7:06the time. And then, the third part of the
- 7:08movie is when they are captured and it follows, Andrew Garfield,
- 7:11who eventually recants his faith and becomes a Christian router
- 7:18outer for the Japanese government and then he dies and
- 7:23he was still a Christian question, mark.
- 7:27Yeah, see what I did there. So this movie does a lot of
- 7:31things really well and it does a lot of things not so well, I'll
- 7:35say that now. Right, a couple days ago, Brad.
- 7:39I made a spreadsheet that I don't know what I'm going to do
- 7:41with yet but I put every movie we've ever reviewed on the
- 7:44podcast in one spreadsheet and it has our scores and it has the
- 7:48IMDb score and I am fairly certain that silence is either
- 7:53the lowest or the second lowest rated movie on IMDb that we have
- 7:56ever done on this podcast really.
- 7:59I think it was like Elizabethtown and then silence
- 8:02is not right above it. I was I was literally thinking.
- 8:05I was like, it beat Elizabethtown.
- 8:08This is a better movie than the little, for sure.
- 8:10It's a better movie than a lot of films we've done on this
- 8:11podcast, but it has a seven point one on IMDb with 112
- 8:16thousand reviews. So it's not like it's an unseen
- 8:20movie. I do think that a lot of that is
- 8:22that people have an idea in their mind of what a
- 8:24quote-unquote Scorsese film is. And then they go into this movie
- 8:28and it is very much a Scorsese film it has all the themes that
- 8:32his, you know, gangster movies have it's just not a gangster
- 8:36movie, and it's a very slow-paced examination of
- 8:39torture and, and like, spiritual anguish, but people probably
- 8:45went into this expecting something a little different
- 8:47than what they got. And I have to imagine that, at
- 8:49least part of this score is that they were just let down that
- 8:52there wasn't enough bloodletting in the movie.
- 8:55Yeah, I'd be curious if this movie was given a And like had
- 9:01an opportunity to re-examine its score with people who have sat
- 9:06with the movie for years. I wonder if it would get, you
- 9:08know, maybe like a 74 75. I will say when you said
- 9:12second-lowest, I wasn't expecting to 7.1.
- 9:16I feel like there has to be more movies in like the sixth, the
- 9:20high 62 lo7 range, then then that that we've reviewed.
- 9:25Yeah. Surprisingly not man, that's
- 9:28that's impressive. Come on.
- 9:31All right, so let's talk the movie.
- 9:32I guess, I want to start with the performances.
- 9:35Andrew Garfield is in every scene or nearly every scene in
- 9:40this movie, and I actually think he's quite good.
- 9:43Andrew Garfield is one of my favorite actors working today.
- 9:46I thought he should have won the Oscar last year for his
- 9:48performance in the movie Tick. Tick.
- 9:50Boom. It was fantastic.
- 9:51He had a great year last year and he's really, really good
- 9:55here. Like I feel like people are
- 9:58finally coming. Around to Andrew Garfield as the
- 10:01incredible actor that he is. But from the time I first
- 10:04encountered him, which was in The Social Network in 2010, you
- 10:08know, by the time he gets here, it's 2016.
- 10:10He's in the midst of making all these terrible Spider-Man movies
- 10:13and he goes off and does this Scorsese film aside from the
- 10:17fact that his accent is really not good.
- 10:20I think the performance itself is pretty spectacular, it's it's
- 10:24an anguished internalized and then externalized, you know,
- 10:29Like putting them through the wringer kind of a performance
- 10:32and I think he really Nails. It Brad.
- 10:34Well, in this movie is one that relies a lot on narration and
- 10:39with Garfield as the primary narrator the there's a certain
- 10:43Beauty to voice acting where you are not on screen.
- 10:46But your voice is that a lot of people really don't appreciate.
- 10:51You know, like we've said it on the podcast before many times
- 10:54that Tom Hanks, talks about how acting for Toy Story.
- 10:58He's like, Stood at the end of the day you know he's in the
- 11:02booth giving it his all and I think that that can be the case
- 11:05here as well. I think you see Garfield really
- 11:08pouring his heart out on camera and you know just vocally and
- 11:14it's really noticeable Bob. Yeah for sure.
- 11:19I mean I want to press you a little bit though.
- 11:21Like what did you think about the performance itself?
- 11:24I think that he does a really great job of using his body.
- 11:30To express where he's at? That earlier in the film.
- 11:35He's a lot more open and he's a lot more.
- 11:37Like like his body. Physically is more open to The
- 11:41Peasants and as you get later in the film, he's a lot more
- 11:45hunched up curled in on his on himself like as he gets angry
- 11:50with Liam Neeson. You can see him like, physically
- 11:53wanting to lash out. And so I think the physicality
- 11:56of his performance is something that I really love.
- 11:59Ya. There's something about his
- 12:01character. And it's, I mean, it's pretty
- 12:03obvious, but there are moments in the movie where you can tell
- 12:07that Scorsese and the original author of The Silence novel are
- 12:12using the character of Rodriguez Garfield to kind of explore
- 12:16themes of like what Jesus went through, right?
- 12:19And Scorsese. Did this himself in his movie,
- 12:21The Last Temptation Of Christ, but it's not using the character
- 12:25of Jesus, to examine some of these things that's using
- 12:28somebody who acts as a. Tentative of Jesus, which gives
- 12:31it this other layer of kind of emotional torment because he
- 12:37knows what he's called to do. He also knows what he's taken a
- 12:41pledge to do in terms of like protecting his flock and and the
- 12:46pull between like staying faithful to confessing Jesus and
- 12:53preserving the life and well-being of the people that
- 12:56are in his care, I think, is this, it's this beautiful.
- 12:59And really tortuous kind of like interplay.
- 13:02But what I love, what I really like about what they do with his
- 13:05character, like I said is like they they do kind of make him
- 13:08an, what's the word like an analog for Jesus?
- 13:12And a lot of ways because as he gets closer to what, you know,
- 13:16is going to be the crisis point where he's going to have to
- 13:18either apostatize or confess, it's very similar to like what I
- 13:22would imagine the story of Jesus is like as he gets closer to the
- 13:25cross and you have this character, who is a very Judas
- 13:29like character who keeps coming in and keeps betraying him and
- 13:32then keeps crawling back and asking for forgiveness and you
- 13:35start to see the anger and the resentment rise up inside of
- 13:38Andrew Garfield towards this guy.
- 13:40And it's like, do I do, I do what I know is right, which is
- 13:43to forgive this guy repeatedly or do I let my sort of human
- 13:46emotions that are very real and very valid take over and I love
- 13:51that. They're kind of examining the
- 13:52story of Jesus through this guy, bro.
- 13:55I think that chi chi gyro is like the Crux of this.
- 13:59For sure. Like from the moment he comes on
- 14:02screen as this. Just absolutely.
- 14:05Drunken. I don't, I don't know what the
- 14:08right word to use like imbecille, like the way they
- 14:11portray him at the start is such a broken man that you see as he
- 14:17engages with his faith. He comes back to a renewal of
- 14:21Faith, but he has that line where he says, like, what am I
- 14:25supposed to do in a world like this, like why couldn't I have
- 14:28been born to a A different age where I could have lived my
- 14:31whole life as a happy old Christian and just died as an
- 14:34old. Man, why did I have to live in
- 14:36such a difficult time? And man if that is not like
- 14:41reflective of so many Christians existence, where whatever they
- 14:47are struggling with, they would ask that question.
- 14:49Like man, why, why am I having to struggle with this in this
- 14:53time? And the way that Andrew Garfield
- 14:56response to him throughout the movie?
- 14:58It's Just heart-wrenching and touching and sad and just all
- 15:05sorts of emotions. And I really think that that's
- 15:08where this movie works. The best for me as far as like
- 15:12causing a moral quandary and tension within my soul for sure.
- 15:17Like the whole, the whole point of this movie there's like four
- 15:19or five different subplots that are all designed to cause that
- 15:23tension and I think, well, I mean, we'll get into all of
- 15:26them, but I want to steer into the rest of of the cast real
- 15:30quick because I feel like Brad 75% of our show.
- 15:33Today is just going to be us talking about these moral
- 15:35quandaries. So ling, let's at least get the
- 15:38the camera work in the actors out of the way here.
- 15:40Let's drive in a New Direction. Hey, Adam Driver Place, father,
- 15:44Guru pay and again, this is Adam Driver coming off of HBO's girls
- 15:49when he's finally, like he's first starting to kind of blow
- 15:51up, this comes out, I think the year following the force awakens
- 15:54when the rest of the world became aware of who, Adam Driver
- 15:57was. He's so freaking good in this.
- 15:59Movie Brad. But even here, you can tell that
- 16:04people hadn't quite turned over the reins to him.
- 16:06The way that, you know, when we watch marriage story and he's
- 16:09like, clearly him and Scarlett, Johansson are the two main
- 16:11figures of that movie. I think he's good here, but he's
- 16:15really not in the movie that much.
- 16:17No, he's not. I think that Adam Driver should
- 16:21have been the lead and this o interest.
- 16:23I just I just genuinely think he is a better actor than Andrew.
- 16:29Our field just across the board, and I think he, he would have
- 16:33handled the introspective nature of it better that there's
- 16:37certain parts of the film, where Garfield, he just comes across
- 16:42as kind of corny and smell amazing.
- 16:46And I think that Adam Driver just has like this Panache.
- 16:51That would give him a little bit of an upper hand as father
- 16:56Rodriguez, instead of Guru pay. So, here's the thing.
- 16:59I think I disagree with you, and it's because and I don't know if
- 17:02it's because what you're saying is like, Andrew Garfield has
- 17:06some limitations as an actor, but I think if he does, it works
- 17:09in his favor here because you believe that he has a Zeal for
- 17:13what he's doing, but you never quite know if the character of
- 17:18Rodriguez totally believes what he's telling people.
- 17:21And I think that really helps play into the character as he
- 17:25goes along. You know, there's this one part
- 17:27of the movie where Garfield's character gets kind of Of
- 17:29rounded up with a bunch of other local Christians and they're
- 17:33kind of sitting around and one of them offers him something to
- 17:35drink or something to eat and he snaps at her.
- 17:37And it's the first time that as a priest, you see him just be a
- 17:39jerk to somebody and they all the other Christians around kind
- 17:43of realized like, oh this guy, this guy might not be exactly
- 17:47who he thinks he is or who he says he is and I wonder if what
- 17:51if you put driver in that role. I don't know if it works as well
- 17:55because he's so good at convincing you that he believes.
- 17:59What he's saying on screen and so I feel like having that kind
- 18:03of Da genus to him actually, like improves Garfield's
- 18:07character. I mean, maybe you're right man,
- 18:10I guess I just looked at it, plain and simple as like, I just
- 18:14think Adam Driver is the better actor, and in this film.
- 18:18And so from that level I'm like, yeah, sure.
- 18:20He probably pulled it off better, but but I man, you're
- 18:24the, you're the cinephile here. So, I'll Trust your opinion on
- 18:27it. No, I'm just saying like I Why I
- 18:30like where they're at in this movie?
- 18:31However there is somebody else we need to talk about here.
- 18:35My boy. He got he got taken by the
- 18:38Japanese. Got taken Liam's.
- 18:41Nice Liam Neeson. That that famous Portuguese man.
- 18:46Liam Neeson, Liam. Neeson was such a terrible.
- 18:51Casting Choice. Here's the thing though, he's
- 18:54really good. He just doesn't even attempt to
- 18:58be Portuguese in the Very first scene, he's kind of like doing a
- 19:02like mildly offensive, like Latino inflected accent and then
- 19:07with Tino adjacent, right? And then in the second, the
- 19:11second time, he shows up, he's like, hey, I'm Irish now and he
- 19:14just does Liam Neeson. And, yeah, it's I think the
- 19:18dialogue in that scene is so good and nice and does such a
- 19:21good job of presenting it. So matter-of-factly that I
- 19:25really loved his performance, but you're right man, like,
- 19:28literally Any actor from Portugal or Spain or surrounding
- 19:33regions, probably would have been a little bit of a better
- 19:35choice. Yeah, I think my issue is, it's
- 19:38kind of like an Interstellar. Matt, Damon reveal where I like,
- 19:44I know that you see Liam Neeson early in the film, so you know
- 19:48that he's in the movie. But like you have time with
- 19:52Andrew Garfield and with Adam Driver to get used to them
- 19:56being, you know, Portuguese priests that argh.
- 19:59Into Japan. You spend the whole movie with
- 20:02them. Whereas by the time you get back
- 20:04to Liam Neeson, he like, he's still Liam Neeson.
- 20:09You know what I mean? Like, it'd be like if Tom Hanks
- 20:11was in the role, he would still be Tom.
- 20:13Hanks, at that point of the movie.
- 20:15Like, anytime you have a famous actor in a role in my opinion,
- 20:19at least, they need to be in the entire movie, because I need a
- 20:23little bit of time to get used to them.
- 20:26Not just being Matthew McConaughey.
- 20:29Or Tom Cruise or, you know, whomever and so when Liam Neeson
- 20:33comes back on screen, I'm just like, oh, he has a special skill
- 20:37that set of skills and and he's also a Jedi master.
- 20:41And I, and he's also Aslan, he's a big lion.
- 20:45And so I just, I really struggled with the casting
- 20:48choice of Liam Neeson and all agree with you.
- 20:50Like he, he killed it in his scenes but but yeah, I think
- 20:55they could have gotten somebody a little less famous, all right?
- 20:57So this movie is I needed, like I said, for best cinematography
- 21:02the camera work in this movie is just spectacular, chef's kiss.
- 21:07I mean like like perfect Rodrigo update.
- 21:11So is the, is the cinematographer here.
- 21:13I mean, the color palette, the like the the mist and the fog,
- 21:18and then like the Striking kind of more warm and saturated tones
- 21:24when they get in that house. Where Liam Neeson is staying,
- 21:27just to kind of signify like, The luxury that he's living in.
- 21:31I mean, like, it's just it's really subtle but it is framed.
- 21:35So every frame in this movie could be like a painting that
- 21:38you hang. It's just beautiful.
- 21:39Yeah. And every single time they like
- 21:41are getting out of a boat and like fighting the shore to get
- 21:45onto land, they just have these beautiful wide like panoramic
- 21:50shots where you can see how little the priests are against
- 21:56this backdrop of Japan. And It serves to under
- 22:01undergird, the purpose of the movie, which is to show.
- 22:05Christianity, is so small in the face of Japanese power.
- 22:10And I and so, I think that the cinematography, like it lays the
- 22:14foundation for the message of the movie in such a beautiful
- 22:18way, and a lot of movies, just don't do that.
- 22:21Yeah. All right, before we go to
- 22:23break, Brad, I want to finish out talking about the qualities
- 22:26of the filmmaking and the film. As a film, right?
- 22:30Like we're going to get into the themes and we're going to
- 22:32Grapple. I think a little bit with how do
- 22:34you how do you separate out? The filmmaking from what the
- 22:38film is trying to say. And I'll say this, I'm not going
- 22:41to give this movie a 10 out of 10.
- 22:43I don't know if you are, but I do think this movie is flawed.
- 22:46I still really like it. And I think it gets at a lot of
- 22:48things that that many movies don't.
- 22:51But if I'm being frank here, it's a three hour long movie or
- 22:56actually, it's only like 2 hours and 40 minutes.
- 22:58It Longer than three hours. Yes, I don't know if I could
- 23:02actually pinpoint a scene or scenes that I think should be
- 23:06cut completely. Like it seems like everything
- 23:08has its place here. It's just it's really long and
- 23:12it feels really long and it's kind of repetitive like it's
- 23:17very cyclical the story that it tells.
- 23:19And so I feel like it needs to be shorter, but I can't
- 23:22necessarily offer. Here's what you should cut.
- 23:25You know what I mean? Here's the thing.
- 23:27Bob this movie, Feels really long and drawn-out and this is
- 23:34one of the only movies where I'm like, oh it's to emphasize the
- 23:40struggle and the pain than Andrew Garfield is going.
- 23:44Yeah. Absolute like you like you can't
- 23:46have this movie be like a tight, two hours and ten minutes,
- 23:49right? Like it needs.
- 23:52The amount of time it has to breathe life into the suffering
- 23:57and anguish that is On for Garfield that he experienced
- 24:01over a long period of time. And so I'm I'm with you, it's
- 24:06slow, there's moments that are boring.
- 24:09There's moments where you're just like, oh man, this is
- 24:12taking forever to get anywhere, but weirdly, I'm okay with it.
- 24:18Well, I mean, I'm, I'm not the person to normally say that, no,
- 24:21but I think weirdly this movie and Wolf of Wall Street, are
- 24:25actually really interesting companion films in scorsese's,
- 24:28catalog, Because he does the exact same thing with Wolf of
- 24:31Wall Street. Like that is a three hour long
- 24:33movie and it's three hours long for a reason.
- 24:36Like it is an exhausting movie to sit through mmm and it's
- 24:39because like it is, it is trying to have the effect on you that
- 24:44the drugs are having on Jordan Belfort in that movie and it is
- 24:48this like over-the-top maximal lized.
- 24:51You know, satire and it's very similar to like I don't know if
- 24:54in high school if you ever read any selections from the book Don
- 24:57Quixote but like Don. Say was written specifically to
- 25:01parody other really long and lengthy Hero Stories of the
- 25:05time. And like, you know, Miguel de
- 25:09Cervantes like wrote that book in the most long-winded way just
- 25:14to like on all the stupid stories, he didn't like it and
- 25:18it's really funny when you know that and I think that's what
- 25:20he's doing with Wolf of Wall Street and in another way that
- 25:23is like much more serious. He's doing that with silence.
- 25:26You're right. Like, this movie has to be
- 25:28Shaggy. And it has to be repetitive and
- 25:30it has to be cyclical and it has to kind of get annoying and get
- 25:34on your nerves a little bit. I think this is the best version
- 25:36of this story. I still don't think it's like a
- 25:39perfect, you know? I mean, like, I just don't know
- 25:41if this movie was ever going to be a 10 out of 10 even if it
- 25:44does everything it's supposed to do.
- 25:46Yeah. I mean, I don't think that
- 25:47Scorsese was worried about this being a 10/10, sure.
- 25:50Like, I think that he wanted to honor his Catholic faith with a
- 25:55really fascinating story in, you know, The the, I mean, the
- 26:00history of Catholicism goes back, 2,000 years, like the?
- 26:04It's really hard for Americans to understand because like the
- 26:07oldest things we have are on the East Coast from like the mid to
- 26:12late 1600s and and that's it and even you know, even that's like
- 26:16three hundred plus years ago with Catholicism, we're talking
- 26:19about 2,000 years of history and so for him to like take a small
- 26:26little piece of that and examine it with This near three hour
- 26:31movie like he, he wasn't trying to make a perfect movie.
- 26:35I think he just really was interested in these big life
- 26:40questions that that Catholicism deals with like, why do we
- 26:44suffer as humans? What is the point of suffering?
- 26:47Is there a place where suffering is not healthy?
- 26:54You know, like, we Christianity deals with all these questions
- 26:57about like suffering for your faith.
- 26:59At what point does it become worthless to suffer for your
- 27:02faith and your actually suffering for your own Pride?
- 27:05Like he's jumping into all these questions and I don't think he
- 27:09gave a riff that this, you know, flopped at the box-office, like
- 27:13he got to make it and he's happy, you know, yep.
- 27:17Yeah, totally agree, man. All right, well, it's going to
- 27:20fall down to us. Brad's answer the questions of
- 27:23why do we suffer and why are we here?
- 27:24But in order to answer these profound questions, we need
- 27:28whiskey, we need whiskey. Man, let's let's pivot into
- 27:31trying this Wiseman Rye. What do you say?
- 27:33Let's get to it. Bob lately, I've been finding
- 27:37myself pulling Whiskey's off the shelf that are consistently
- 27:40unique ones. That tell a good story.
- 27:42Every time I pop the Cork and I have to say the dock Swensons is
- 27:46absolutely top tier when it comes to a fascinating poor.
- 27:51What separates doc Swensons from the rest of the pack is their
- 27:54unrelenting? Goal of always letting the
- 27:56whiskey shine. No matter what whiskey comes
- 27:58through. The front door, Doc's.
- 28:00Their team of tasters will blend and finish it into something
- 28:03that is deliciously. Memorable, the beautiful thing
- 28:06about a good blended whiskey is that often times with proper
- 28:10care and attention, they turn into a whiskey.
- 28:12That is truly greater than the sum of their parts.
- 28:15Whether you're trying their alter ego blenders cut or
- 28:18exploratory series, you are guaranteed to have a phenomenal
- 28:23experience with Doc's Woodson's, whiskey, you can find them
- 28:26online at Doc's, whisky.com, That's doccs whisky.com.
- 28:38Alright so today we are checking out the weizmann rye bread.
- 28:43Before we even get into that, I have to offer a quick correction
- 28:47to last week's episode, you know, every now and then we get
- 28:51on a little bit of a Spiel and we misspeak apparently I
- 28:54misspoke pretty heavily last week, on our Jack, Daniels
- 28:57bonded episode because I've had multiple people right into tell
- 29:00me like, hey, you're very wrong about this witch.
- 29:04Like no, like I seriously appreciate and I think the best
- 29:06distillation. If haha, distillation love.
- 29:09I see what you did that of what we got.
- 29:11Wrong comes from our friend, Zack Johnston at up rocks.
- 29:14He wrote to us today and he said, hey guys, I love love.
- 29:18Love what you're doing to Quick Corrections for the last
- 29:20episode. All Tennessee.
- 29:22Whiskey is bourbon. It's a subcategory both by
- 29:25definition and legally. So I know that we said, hey
- 29:28Tennessee, whiskey is not bourbon.
- 29:30I said that in part because like they tried to position In
- 29:34themselves as not bourbon but it's important to note legally
- 29:37like by every classification. It is bourbon, that has
- 29:41undergone this filtration process.
- 29:43That you know they talked about in Tennessee, Zach says the
- 29:46rules are literally copied from the bourbon ones and the legal
- 29:49trade category for Tennessee, whiskey is bourbon, it's the
- 29:52same thing. Except for that Lincoln County
- 29:54process of sugar maple charcoal filtering that said most bourbon
- 29:58is also filtered in one way or another.
- 30:00So the filtering of Tennessee. Whiskey doesn't disqualify it
- 30:03from being a bourbon Also, we said that Jack Daniels bonded
- 30:07was a completely new product that's also not entirely true.
- 30:10It was an international product that was kind of sold at like,
- 30:13duty-free stores or in airports. So it's just hitting us shelves
- 30:16for the first time but they, they launched it as a Jack,
- 30:21Daniels Travelers, exclusive bottled and bond which has been
- 30:25around since 2018. So Zach and others.
- 30:28Thank you for the correction. We really appreciate it.
- 30:31You're just such an arrogant American Bob to When whiskey
- 30:35hits the shelves here, it's the first time it's ever, hit the
- 30:38shelves, you know, I will say, I'll take the opportunity to
- 30:41say, part of what we do here on the show is we try to present
- 30:46things as the common person, right?
- 30:49And like, every once in a while, we'll hear from a PR person and
- 30:52they'll send us a sell sheet and a press release that goes really
- 30:56heavily heavily in detail on the Whiskey's that were drinking.
- 30:59So, we have all the information. A lot of times, though.
- 31:02What we do is what anybody at home would do is We pick
- 31:05something up at the liquor store, we type it into Google
- 31:07and we say, like, you know, the wise men ride review and we look
- 31:11up from these pretty reputable sources like what they have said
- 31:14about the whiskey and and in some cases we've gotten a few
- 31:18Corrections over the years that we only said what we saw in
- 31:23these reputable sources. And so sometimes it's just a
- 31:26breakdown of communication, we're like hey we didn't know
- 31:28this about the whiskey but that also reflects the fact that the
- 31:31average person wouldn't know this about this whiskey.
- 31:34Yeah. I was going to say Bob 100% as
- 31:37far as the first fact that we got wrong last week.
- 31:40I had no idea. I genuinely thought that
- 31:43Tennessee sour mash whiskey was not bourbon.
- 31:47So I that's news to me, man. Alright, so let's transition
- 31:50into this Wiseman Rye. This is a new brand from
- 31:54Kentucky owl. And I said at the top of the
- 31:57episode that it's a budget brand, it's not really a budget
- 31:59brand. It's still like, 50 plus
- 32:00dollars. I was about to say, right, but
- 32:03it's only budget. Paired to their normal to
- 32:05Kentucky owl. So this is a 95% rhyme Ash bill.
- 32:10But Brad, it is not an mg P product.
- 32:13This is not originating in Indiana.
- 32:14This is a Kentucky distilled 95/5 rhyme Ash bill.
- 32:21I thought that MGP had like the trademark on 95% ride like
- 32:25nobody else has to do it. Well, we shall see it.
- 32:30Clocks in at 100.8 proof and Brad.
- 32:34I got to say, man, it has a very pleasant nose.
- 32:37Yeah. It's a little bit Dusty.
- 32:39There's some brown sugar going on.
- 32:41It's buttery. And then like about halfway
- 32:44through the nosing experience. Boom, like all that strong ride
- 32:49that you're looking for. I'm pretty impressed with this
- 32:53Baba. I'm not going to go crazy high
- 32:55but I'll give it an 8 out of 10. Yeah, I'm The same Brad.
- 32:58Like this is a very wry heavy, right on the nose and really
- 33:02herbaceous, lots of mint. Lots of Dill on this one.
- 33:05There's a little bit of caramel kind of underlying it all and
- 33:08every once in a while you'll get like the barrel notes as well.
- 33:11But for the most part it smells like walking through a garden
- 33:14like it's really herbaceous. I like it a lot.
- 33:17I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10.
- 33:19Yeah, and I think as you get into the actual palette, it
- 33:23drops off a little bit from the nose, not too far but for me, I
- 33:27got like a little bit of a raisin flavor.
- 33:30A lot of the Rye spice and some of that brown sugar coming
- 33:34through and normally Whiskey's get Okie, kind of on the back
- 33:38end near the finish. This one for me, felt okey
- 33:40almost on the tip of my tongue, so there's definitely some of
- 33:44that wood character coming through here.
- 33:46Yeah, Brett. I'm with you the, the flavors
- 33:48interesting. There's Definitely, like,
- 33:51there's like a raisin. E note on this.
- 33:52And it's not a sweet one. It almost reminds me kind of
- 33:54like prune juice a little bit. Mmm.
- 33:57I like it, though. It gets a little bit thin on the
- 34:00mouth. Feel for me like the front half
- 34:02of the palate. It's there.
- 34:04It's a nice kind of honeyed sweetness.
- 34:06You get a lot of that kind of raw Rye grain.
- 34:09You get some of that raisin or prune and I'm gonna go to
- 34:11swallow, it makes itself known but it's just a very thin kind
- 34:15of back. End of the pallet into the
- 34:17finish. I'm going to give this This a 7
- 34:20out of 10 on the palate. Yeah, I'm actually right there
- 34:23with you about. I'm going to give it a 7 out of
- 34:2410 as well. I think that the Finnish picks
- 34:27up a little bit. There's a for me that honey
- 34:30really came through on the Finish after I had had drank it
- 34:34and swallowed it sat on my on my palette for little bit.
- 34:36I was like, oh there's a little bit of honey going on, but the
- 34:39other parts of the Finish, lots of Oak, lots of really nice
- 34:44complex rice spices. It almost has a little bit of a
- 34:46clove feel to it. I like Finish.
- 34:49I'll give it a seven and a half out of ten.
- 34:52I can't quite put my finger on which kind of herb, this reminds
- 34:55me of most it's not super minty, but it also doesn't really tip
- 34:58into that Dill side to heavily. But after you swallow, there is
- 35:02a lot of, I don't even want to call it graininess because it's
- 35:05not just Rye grain, but there's like an unknown
- 35:09undistinguishable. Like herb.
- 35:13Here are you, are you picking it up here?
- 35:14Like what? What is it that I'm getting on
- 35:16the finish here? I honestly don't know.
- 35:18Bob. I didn't get many herbs on this
- 35:21at all for me the most unique note throughout was that kind of
- 35:24Raisin prune juice. So I'm not really getting the
- 35:28herbaceous feel. It definitely doesn't tip into
- 35:31like a like a bitter oakiness but it kind of goes a little bit
- 35:35sour and I think that's why it's reminding me of some sort of
- 35:38herb or plant. I like this still But I think
- 35:43the Finish is where it kind of starts to go south a little bit
- 35:46for me. I think I'm only going to give
- 35:48it a six and a half on the Finish.
- 35:50Yeah, and that jumps us into balance, honestly.
- 35:53It's like a pretty well-balanced whiskey, like it all around.
- 35:58And has some interesting flavors.
- 36:00It's averagely complex, but like nothing about it really stands
- 36:05out. So I think I'm going to give it
- 36:06a 7 out of 10 on balance. I'm gonna go ahead and give it a
- 36:09seven point five. And I will say that this is my
- 36:12second time trying it, I tried it about two weeks ago, and it
- 36:15was really delicious. When I first popped the cork
- 36:18really sweet almost like a very Bourbon irae and I really really
- 36:22like that. Now that it's at for a couple
- 36:24weeks it has a completely different character to me and it
- 36:27may just be me, it may be that I ate something different today
- 36:30and that my palettes just thrown off.
- 36:32But this is a very different drinking experience today than
- 36:35it was two weeks ago for me. So, I'm gonna try to walk the
- 36:40line between those two extremes Variances.
- 36:43And I'm going to give it a seven and a half on balance.
- 36:46Yeah and that brings us to our value Robert.
- 36:48This is a fifty dollar bottle of whiskey.
- 36:52As we mentioned before, definitely a lot cheaper than
- 36:56other options from Kentucky owl. But fifty dollars is nothing to
- 37:01sneeze at man. Yeah, and I actually see that
- 37:04it's selling for like up to $60 in some places and I would not
- 37:07recommend it at that price but let's just say, 50 as SRP here.
- 37:12I don't think it's a terrible value and Rise are still kind of
- 37:16slept on in the marketplace and they're not making enough of
- 37:19them. I would love to see as much
- 37:22variance and and you know availability of different
- 37:26products in the Rye world as we do in the bourbon world.
- 37:29So I think I'm more willing to spend 50 bucks on a ride than I
- 37:32am on a bourbon just because there's not as many things to
- 37:35pick up that said, I mean, it's not a great value.
- 37:39If this was $35, I'd be like, oh yeah, good value.
- 37:42And fifty. I'm just going to give it a six
- 37:44out of ten. Yeah, I'm right there with you.
- 37:45Bob six out of ten on the value it.
- 37:49Hmm, I almost want to give it a 5.
- 37:51I'll stick with a 6. It's a decent value but
- 37:55honestly, it needs to be like a 38 dollar bottle of whiskey.
- 37:59All right, so Brad, what are you coming out to?
- 38:01I'm not a 35.5. I am at a thirty five point
- 38:06zero. So we're coming out to a
- 38:0835-point, 25 out of 50 or A 70 and a half out of 100.
- 38:15We are just at that point where we would normally start
- 38:18recommending to try or to buy. I would say, go ahead and give
- 38:22this a try at the bar. Like, I don't think about for
- 38:24would cost you that much. It's probably gonna be about 10
- 38:26bucks for a poor. It's decent, like it's pretty
- 38:29good. I just don't know if I would say
- 38:31pull the trigger on a 50 dollar bottle of it.
- 38:33Yeah, I think the thing for me is it's not unique enough to
- 38:37make me want to spend $50 or even 10 Yeah, I don't know.
- 38:43I don't think I'm going to recommend by or try.
- 38:46Wow. Yeah, I'll recommend try but not
- 38:48by. So we have another expression of
- 38:51this coming up next week. It is the wisemen bourbon.
- 38:54So we'll give that one a try as we kick off next week's
- 38:58miniseries. But Brad, let's get back into
- 39:00talking about silence. What do you say suffering?
- 39:07Today's sponsor is a little bit of a departure from our usual
- 39:10area of expertise. And man, oh, man, I was blown
- 39:13away by their product. Once we received it, I am
- 39:16talking about manscaped. Now, if you're like me at all,
- 39:20you probably seen the manscaped ads and kind of Wonder to
- 39:22yourself like, do I really need like some sort of specialty
- 39:25trimmer to take care of my downstairs business.
- 39:28And I've just got to be honest. I was absolutely wrong there
- 39:32trimmers called the lawn mower 4.0 and I got to say it is the
- 39:36Rolls-Royce of Tremors. It's got a ceramic blade.
- 39:39That reduces grooming mishaps, a wireless charging base and an
- 39:43awesome flashlight. That keeps things illuminated
- 39:45while you're working and beyond all that it's waterproof.
- 39:48This thing is really changing the game when it comes to below
- 39:51the belt hygiene. Now this is just me talking
- 39:53about my experience, but this trimmer really is Way Beyond
- 39:57anything I've ever used to keep things neat.
- 39:59And tidy, you can use our discount code film whiskey to
- 40:03get 20 percent off your order and free shipping head on over.
- 40:06To manscape.com and use code film whiskey, to get 20% off
- 40:10free shipping, and you will be well on your way to hygiene
- 40:13Heaven. All right, everybody, that was
- 40:20wise, man. Rio a whiskey.
- 40:22That was like, kind of, it was a solid expression of Rye, but
- 40:25didn't really have anything that stood out about it, Bob.
- 40:28Yeah, I feel it, man. Yeah.
- 40:30You know, what does have something that stands out Bob to
- 40:33fax in a faucet to fax it up? Also Canada's favorite segments?
- 40:38This is where Brad tries pretty successfully to stump me.
- 40:42I think I'm sitting at like two and four on the season.
- 40:45Right now, I have to go back and check my record but like, not
- 40:48off to a good start with this season.
- 40:50Brad for me. It yeah, it's a little rough for
- 40:53you, man. I'm I would say I'm feeling it
- 40:55for you but I'm just sitting happy man.
- 40:59Yeah you're succeeding over here you're winning at life right
- 41:01now. I feel great.
- 41:03All right Brad you're just know that your failure brings.
- 41:06Brings me. Great joy.
- 41:09You know that's a house that's like the theme of Silence that
- 41:13my failure gives you life. Yeah it does.
- 41:17Alright man hit me with these three supposed facts, one of
- 41:21which is false facts. Number one, this is the first
- 41:25film for Adam Driver since Midnight, Special also released
- 41:30in 2016 and he lost over 40 pounds for the role of Guru pay.
- 41:36Fact, number two, Daniel Day-Lewis and Liam Neeson
- 41:40replaced each other in projects that were both stuck in
- 41:44development for years. Nissan was supposed to play
- 41:46Abraham, Lincoln and Daniel Day-Lewis was supposed to play
- 41:51father Ferreira but when nice and dropped out of Lincoln,
- 41:54Daniel Day-Lewis replaced him and later Neeson was chosen as
- 41:59father, Ferreira fax number three, shinya tsukamoto who
- 42:04played mochi. Chi chi in the film is a huge
- 42:07fan of Martin Scorsese and like immediately applied for the role
- 42:11when the casting call went out. But Scorsese was like wildly
- 42:15confused. When the application like
- 42:17reached his desk because he was questioning, if this was really
- 42:21the director of tetsuo the Iron Man from 1989, that wanted to
- 42:26act in his film. Wow, I have no idea.
- 42:29Um, I am pretty sure that Adam Driver had like three or four
- 42:34movies come out in 2016 Midnight, Special, which is a
- 42:39pretty good movie and then he had one that was called
- 42:41Patterson and then he had this one.
- 42:43So I know he lost a ton of weight, I but I don't know if
- 42:48you're trying to trick me with like this is his first movie
- 42:50since midnight special, but unless you're trying to get me
- 42:54on a technicality, I'm going to say one is true too.
- 42:57I think is also true because I remember when they were We were
- 43:00developing the Lincoln project with Liam Neeson and then it,
- 43:04then it pivoted over to Daniel Day-Lewis.
- 43:07So three seems to me to be the falsehood, but I have no idea.
- 43:10Like, I don't know anything about what you're saying with
- 43:12number three. So you could be trying to trick
- 43:14me. I'm gonna hope that you're not
- 43:16being super nitpicky about number one and the and the
- 43:19movies that Adam Driver made in 2016, and I'm going to say three
- 43:24is the falsehood. Hmm.
- 43:26Yeah, I'm being a little bit nitpicky, Bob.
- 43:31Come on, man. He he lost over 60 pounds for
- 43:34the role and this was not his first movie since drivers.
- 43:37Not dude. I thought you said you were
- 43:40never gonna do it like this. When you when you when you draft
- 43:43it up, your questions. I wasn't.
- 43:47I guess I'll say this. As I was drafting this question.
- 43:50I didn't think I was being super nitpicky, but do we know the
- 43:54order they were filmed in like maybe this was his first movie
- 43:57since midnight. I don't know about order was
- 44:01filmed in order of release was driver since midnight, Patterson
- 44:06and then sigh. This seems very nitpicky.
- 44:07I will also say that if he lost over 60 pounds, that also means
- 44:12that he lost over 40 pounds. He still did lose over for.
- 44:15That's like that. Question of like how many you
- 44:18know like how many months have 28 days and it's all of them,
- 44:21all of them. Yeah, yeah yeah that's like
- 44:24somebody asked me the other day. How do you pronounce the capital
- 44:29of Kentucky is a low level or Louisville and I told them, it's
- 44:35frankly. Yeah.
- 44:36And and he was like, you're the first person who ever got that.
- 44:38Everybody else goes wrong. I, I don't know if I want to
- 44:42take the L on this man. Like I knew what the three
- 44:45movies were, I think we should arm wrestle.
- 44:48I think we should leave it up to our patrons, okay?
- 44:50Let's see what they say. Yeah, I'm in.
- 44:53All right. Answer is what are your
- 44:54thoughts? What do you think, did Brad?
- 44:56Did Brad get me or not? Did I do them dirty?
- 45:01All right, man, let's get back into talking about silence.
- 45:03I think it is time for us to kind of dive into some of the
- 45:05deeper themes here. Brad, I sent you an article
- 45:09before we recorded this, and it was in the New York Times a
- 45:11couple weeks ago, and it was really beautiful.
- 45:13It was, it was a podcast at the New York Times does and I was
- 45:17reading the transcript of this podcast and it was an interview
- 45:19with a pastor who had experienced like significant
- 45:23trauma and burn out as a result of pastoring through the
- 45:27pandemic and also Rule the polluted politicization of
- 45:32America, over the last five years, six years.
- 45:35And there's a quote in that article that I want to read.
- 45:38And I think it's going to kind of frame my take, on this movie
- 45:41for the rest of the episode. So in this story, The Pastor's
- 45:44talking about how they had gone through.
- 45:46This big vote for something as a church.
- 45:49And they had really done everything, they could to make
- 45:51it as transparent as possible and give people a voice and then
- 45:54the vote went one way and everybody who disagreed you know
- 45:58like gave the pastor of Each of crap they got on social media.
- 46:01They had like a whole group of people basically saying that
- 46:03like this pastor is a bad leader and bad-mouthing him publicly
- 46:07because you know the church decided democratically to do
- 46:11something and this is what he says.
- 46:14He says and I realized at that moment that being a pastor, is
- 46:18this really precarious little spot.
- 46:20You sit in that people project, all of their wants and needs and
- 46:24demands expectations. Unrealised hopes on to you.
- 46:29But when you don't meet them, they're posed with the response
- 46:33either. They're going to reject you or
- 46:36ruin, you or abandon you and Brad.
- 46:39I think we're at a really interesting place in the history
- 46:41of American Christianity, where you are seeing pastors, drop out
- 46:46of the ministry, like at an alarming rate, and it's a result
- 46:50of the tension of trying to. I don't say, please people but
- 46:56keep, you know, they're their flock for lack of a better term.
- 46:59Satisfied and engaged, and also experiencing the trauma and the
- 47:04burnout of losing people and having people burn you.
- 47:07And I watched this movie and that's not necessarily what's
- 47:11happening to Andrew, Garfield's character.
- 47:14But what really moved me this time around, wasn't the
- 47:18theological like is he doing the right thing?
- 47:21Is he actually listening to the doctrines of the church has
- 47:24historically held is he is he a heretic?
- 47:28The thing that really moved me. He was watching this through the
- 47:30lens of a pastor because I think that this movie might be the
- 47:33best depiction I've ever seen of what it means to be.
- 47:37A pastor, like, Andrew Garfield is wrestling on The Daily and
- 47:43this movie. Like, do I heed the words that I
- 47:48know to be true in scripture where Jesus says, like, if you
- 47:52reject me before people, I will reject you and do I hold people
- 47:56to that standard even if it means they're going to die.
- 47:59I make them go to their death and then when it's turned on him
- 48:02and he, he is confronted with. Like, if you don't do this
- 48:07thing, if you don't apostatize, we will kill all these other
- 48:11people who are in your care and they will be innocent victims of
- 48:15your stubbornness. That's kind of how its framed to
- 48:17him. And his question is like, how do
- 48:20I care for the people who are under my care, under my
- 48:24supervision, as a pastor? When you look at the movie
- 48:28through that lens, whether or not Not you agree with what
- 48:30Andrew Garfield did. I really think it helps people
- 48:34understand the position that clergy of all faiths.
- 48:39I would say in America and throughout the world are in.
- 48:43Yeah. I mean my first thought coming
- 48:45off of that Bob, is that like Being a pastor is really tough.
- 48:50Yeah, today's society. Like yes, I this might be
- 48:55facetious but like it makes me think about how it seems like
- 48:59every year at least. Once a year, some major news
- 49:03Outlet will like right along article about how evil the
- 49:07Catholic churches. And there's part of me that
- 49:10reads those things and I'm like do you not like understand the
- 49:15Catholic Church them, not changing their position.
- 49:18Isn't anything new right? And in the face of like moments,
- 49:22like that, I think about how hard it has to be to be a
- 49:26pastor, or a priest or, you know, some sort of minister in
- 49:30today's world where it's like, no, we've held these tenants for
- 49:34hundreds of years. And yet now, they are being
- 49:38completely castigated for them. And then in the midst of that,
- 49:42where the culture is castigating them.
- 49:45Their own flock has such wildly diverse opinions about how they
- 49:50ought to be pastoring and ministering to the congregation
- 49:55that it is just a recipe for burn out there.
- 49:58There is massive immense pressure from the outside facing
- 50:04gargantuan pressure from the inside as well.
- 50:07And you're right. Like you see that in Andrew
- 50:10Garfield man. The the way that the the
- 50:12Japanese villagers who are Christian Respond to them is
- 50:17like an overwhelming amount of pressure.
- 50:19Like we like we haven't been able to properly practice the
- 50:23faith in decades because no priests have been here.
- 50:27And now we're able to have our sins forgiven and now we're able
- 50:30to do all these things. And at first you see Garfield
- 50:33like he's like all about it and energized by it.
- 50:37But by the end of the film, he has gone from being energized by
- 50:40the cool parts of being a minister 20 like the Suffering
- 50:45is brutal and I don't know if I can handle this.
- 50:48Yeah. And I mean, like, Andrew
- 50:50Garfield doesn't have to worry about the, the kind of trivial
- 50:53things that we have to deal with in the American Church of like,
- 50:56am I satisfying people's kind of consumer mentality.
- 51:00But, but in his, you know, in what he's dealing with its
- 51:03Amplified, it's turned up to 11 because he is he's dealing with
- 51:08life and death literally. And like what is my job here?
- 51:11As a, pastor is my job to make sure people are following the
- 51:15but I don't see the letter of the law but like, you know,
- 51:18Orthodoxy and right beliefs or is my job to do, what I can to
- 51:24protect my flock and that's ultimately, like, what the
- 51:28ending of this movie is about when he is confronted with the
- 51:31fumi a with like this, very crudely carved image of Jesus
- 51:35and asked step on it as a way of like, stomping on Jesus and what
- 51:40Scorsese and what endow the the author of the book has happened
- 51:44at the Dove of the story is that he hears the voice of Jesus
- 51:48Calling to him and telling him to Stomp.
- 51:51Like This is what I came here for.
- 51:52I came to be stomped on by people like it's okay.
- 51:55Go ahead and do it. And again, I'm not saying I
- 51:58agree with that, but I think what Scorsese does.
- 52:02So brilliantly here is he doesn't just make the question
- 52:05of like, is it right? Or not to stomp on Jesus.
- 52:08A question, but he puts you in the emotional state of Andrew
- 52:12Garfield, where it's like. All right.
- 52:14Well, The alternative is like if I don't stop and I stand on my
- 52:17principles, then I really am responsible for the death of
- 52:20other people. And I love that there is,
- 52:24there's just no easy answer to any of these questions and they
- 52:27continued even after that climactic moment in the movie.
- 52:31No, there's really no easy answers to it.
- 52:34I will say to kind of jump away from the the moral quandary.
- 52:39We're talking about for a second.
- 52:41I actually think that this movie was not graphic enough Tough.
- 52:45Hmm, there's part of me that like from the time Andrew
- 52:50Garfield has captured. The most graphic thing that they
- 52:53show in the movie is when the waves are overtaking, the three
- 52:58Christians that they kill, you know, who were the leaders of
- 53:01the church in that in that town and outside of that, I like I
- 53:06don't know if this just sounds bad or not, but it doesn't feel
- 53:10like Garfield's crisis of faith is warranted by what you see.
- 53:15On screen. Hmm, and I don't know if that's
- 53:18just me. Maybe I'm desensitized by other
- 53:21more violent movies, but there's a part of me that feels like,
- 53:25Scorsese focused so much of the camera work simply on Garfield
- 53:30that you didn't get the sense of the torture that the Japanese
- 53:35were putting these Christians through one thing that I really
- 53:37did like though is that Scorsese allows the camera and the scenes
- 53:42in the pacing to be so patient that It kind of demonstrates
- 53:46that, you know, throughout church history, like we really
- 53:50valorize the martyrs, right? Like we really hold them up as
- 53:54like, wow, they got eaten by lions and like what an
- 53:56incredible thing to do for your faith.
- 53:58But like I think the question Scorsese asks, is all right,
- 54:01what would it look like to actually have to watch somebody
- 54:03to eaten by a lion? Like it's not, it's not a simple
- 54:06thing, it's not a quick thing. There is no there's no dignity
- 54:10to it and and Garfield's character talks about how that
- 54:13guy hung on that. That cross in the middle of the
- 54:17sea for like five days, until he basically just starve to death.
- 54:21And it wasn't a quick thing and as much as he wanted it to be a
- 54:25quick thing, it wasn't. And I think because of that like
- 54:28no, there's not that much kind of sudden jarring violence in
- 54:32this movie but because you see how undignified some of these
- 54:38deaths are I do think it. It still has the impact that
- 54:42that Scorsese intends it to Well, that that kind of brings
- 54:46me to my second point. I feel like the big problem with
- 54:49that I have with this movie, is like, how hard Scorsese veers
- 54:54into the realm of gaslighting, where I like the way he
- 55:00portrays, the Japanese is that they are just so manipulative.
- 55:06And they literally just keep telling Andrew Garfield.
- 55:09Like this is your fault that they're dying.
- 55:12This is your fault that they're suffering.
- 55:14And the whole time, I'm just sitting there in as an audience,
- 55:17like saying like, no, no, you're the one hanging, these people
- 55:22upside down and cutting a little thing in their ears, so that
- 55:24they don't pass out too quickly, right?
- 55:26Right. You're the one, putting them out
- 55:28in the ocean to die, like, there's no suffering that Andrew
- 55:33Garfield is causing to these people like you are causing all
- 55:37the suffering. And for me, that's just, I don't
- 55:40know. It took away from the impact of
- 55:42the movie for me. Did you feel like there's
- 55:45anything there? No, not so much because I feel
- 55:47like every every time you can kind of come to a simplistic,
- 55:51not want to call what you're saying simplistic.
- 55:53But like to an easy answer, there's something else in the
- 55:56movie that counters it. You know what I mean?
- 55:57That that makes it more complicated.
- 55:59And for me that thing is when he has that face-to-face with Liam
- 56:02Neeson and Liam Neeson is basically saying, you know, you
- 56:06think, you think that I'm a heretic and you think that I'm a
- 56:09bad person but like how do you know that what you're trying to
- 56:13teach these people is even Taking root and he walks through
- 56:17kind of the like translational issues that from the very
- 56:20beginning. Like, we tried to teach people
- 56:22what the Son of God meant. And I thought we were talking
- 56:24about the Sun in the sky. And then he says, like, I think
- 56:27he'd goes into like, do you even know what their word for God
- 56:29really means, and it's something you remember what it is.
- 56:32Like I can't, I don't remember this, but it, yeah, but it's
- 56:35like something really trivial. And he's basically saying, like
- 56:38these people were never worshiping God.
- 56:40They were worshiping you if you want to do the right thing, as
- 56:43somebody, who is an Object of their devotion then protect them
- 56:48and that's where I'm like, oh my gosh, this is not even a
- 56:50question of right doctor in a wrong doctor and this is a
- 56:52question, like if Liam Neeson's character is actually right
- 56:56about this, what would I do in that situation?
- 56:59And I think that's like, that's the thing that that really, that
- 57:03I love about this movie, and Scorsese like, goes into in
- 57:06depth, in this, on, in interviews about the movie.
- 57:08He talks about how like, his faith has evolved quote-unquote.
- 57:12And a lot of times, I just means, like, I don't believe
- 57:14what I To believe I want to find something that matches, what I
- 57:17think should be the case. But for me at least what I will
- 57:21say is this, it is really easy to sit in a seminary classroom
- 57:26and learn about like what the right thing to believe is to
- 57:30make a system work because if one piece of the system falls
- 57:33apart the rest of the system doesn't work and so you know
- 57:37it's really really easy to be like oh my gosh that person's a
- 57:40heretic that person doesn't believe the right thing.
- 57:43I can't believe they're leading people astray.
- 57:44Tray with this this and this thought and then you get out
- 57:47into the real world of like ministering to people and you
- 57:50realize I have not necessarily cracked.
- 57:53Open my Systematic, Theology book in like five years because
- 57:58a no one is asking me questions that are specifically related to
- 58:02what my thoughts on like Martin Luther and the response to the
- 58:05Reformation is, but be like, when you start dealing with the
- 58:10intricacies and the complexities of the real world, it's just not
- 58:13as black and white. Eat as it is, when you're in
- 58:15college. And I think this is like a
- 58:17really good demonstration of me sitting in my like marble Tower,
- 58:23scoffing at all, the feet on the ground who aren't doing it the
- 58:27right way. And then me getting out in the
- 58:29real world and being like, Oh yeah, there's a lot tougher
- 58:31decision to play that. I wasn't factoring it.
- 58:34See I, I just, I really struggle with that because for me, the
- 58:39scene with Liam Neeson was One of the least convincing scenes
- 58:44of the movie, because he talks about how the faith hasn't taken
- 58:48Rouge that Japan is a swamp and it, you know, it, nothing grows
- 58:53here and I'm like, well, if that's the kind of the message
- 58:57that you're shooting for, then why did you show the
- 58:59faithfulness of the villagers and The outlying Villages of the
- 59:03country? Because in my opinion, they are
- 59:06clearly not worshiping group a and and Rodriguez Their faith
- 59:12would have dissipated long ago if they were just worshiping a
- 59:16preseason. Like I have every faith is real
- 59:20and genuine And so for me like the position of the Japanese
- 59:26government and of Liam Neeson, just feels patently wrong.
- 59:33Like it is not true. It feels like no they just
- 59:36didn't like Christianity so they are trying to stomp it out for
- 59:40me. I never once in the movie got a
- 59:43sense of moral quandary of like well maybe the Japanese are
- 59:48right and it's a swamp and it can't grow.
- 59:50It's like no it very obvious. Grew.
- 59:52Yeah, and you stomped it out. Oh, I agree.
- 59:55I think that. But what I, what I really like
- 59:58about it though. Is that do you remember when we
- 1:00:00did do the right thing? And a lot of what we said was
- 1:00:03like, nobody really does the right thing and that movie.
- 1:00:07Hmm, it's kind of the same way here, except almost the inverse,
- 1:00:10where I think everybody has some bit of Truth to what they're
- 1:00:15saying, but I don't completely, I can't trust anyone 100% in
- 1:00:21this movie. And when it comes to Garfield's
- 1:00:23character, like at the end of the movie, he apostatize has and
- 1:00:26you're like, oh man, he did it. And at first, you're like, well,
- 1:00:29at least I kind of understand why he did it and then they go
- 1:00:31into this really extended epilogue.
- 1:00:34And to your point about Scorsese, the dude knows how to
- 1:00:37do movie endings. The last 25 minutes of this
- 1:00:41movie or the best part. They're like the exact opposite
- 1:00:44of the Return of the King ending.
- 1:00:47It's like the same. It keeps going on and on and on,
- 1:00:50but it just gets more and more depressing.
- 1:00:52Yeah, and if more and more happy and more gray, like there's more
- 1:00:55questions that arise and the great thing about it is he
- 1:00:58doesn't dwell on any one of these scenes long enough for you
- 1:01:01to really like grapple with them, he's just like and then
- 1:01:03this happened and that complicates things, and then
- 1:01:05this happened and this complicates things and you find
- 1:01:08out that Andrew Garfield for, you know, decades and decades
- 1:01:11basically ends up working for the Japanese government.
- 1:01:14Alongside Liam Neeson in like, sniffing out Christian stuff and
- 1:01:20like, throwing other Christians. Under the bus.
- 1:01:23But then every once in a while, you'll see that, he kind of
- 1:01:25still believes this. And he's smuggling and artifact
- 1:01:28here, they're too kitschy, gyro or to the Japanese church.
- 1:01:33Is he still a Christian? Is he not still accretion it?
- 1:01:35Does he think that this is the best way to be a Christian by
- 1:01:38like publicly denying and then working in the background.
- 1:01:42But but then he'll do something that seems so egregious that
- 1:01:44you're like he can't really be a Christian.
- 1:01:46And man, I like, I don't agree with most of what Andrew
- 1:01:51Garfield doesn't. The end of this movie, but the
- 1:01:53questions still remain. Like, what is a Christian?
- 1:01:56Can you be a Christian while publicly denying that you're a
- 1:02:00Christian? It goes.
- 1:02:01It goes all the way back to the question of Peter denying Jesus,
- 1:02:04three times. Do you have to be reconciled?
- 1:02:07Do you have to be restored publicly?
- 1:02:09Can you with your final breath? Like Andrew Garfield, like still
- 1:02:13be clinging to that cross and be considered a Christian.
- 1:02:16It's just, it's such a good ending to this movie and it's Is
- 1:02:22that will never really be able to answer.
- 1:02:24Yeah, but even with Peter man, he said, like Satan has asked to
- 1:02:29sift, you like wheat? But when you have turned back,
- 1:02:31strengthen your brothers and like Peter spends the rest of
- 1:02:35his life. Strengthening the brother.
- 1:02:37Yeah. And I'm pretty sure he's the one
- 1:02:38that gets as it, is it him or John, that gets crucified upside
- 1:02:42down. That was John, no, no, John, no,
- 1:02:44that was Peter. John Dies of old age on Patmos
- 1:02:46that? That's right.
- 1:02:48Yeah. So like I don't know.
- 1:02:49I really struggle with the ending of this film.
- 1:02:52I, to me, it feels Feels like maybe that maybe this is putting
- 1:02:57something on Scorsese. That's not there.
- 1:02:59But it feels like the last 20 minutes of this movie are where
- 1:03:03Scorsese feels like he's at in his life.
- 1:03:06I agree. It's against definitely like
- 1:03:08it's almost like wish fulfillment.
- 1:03:10Hmm. You know I mean and and I found
- 1:03:12out in researching it to that like that last moment of
- 1:03:16Rodriguez holding on to that cross in the barrel that's being
- 1:03:20burnt. That's a Scorsese insertion like
- 1:03:23that's not The original text at all.
- 1:03:25Yeah, and I think it's very telling that Scorsese still
- 1:03:29wants to be able to believe that Rodriguez is a Christian and
- 1:03:33that he can hold these things near and dear to his heart while
- 1:03:36publicly denying them and you're a hundred percent, right?
- 1:03:38I think it says more about Scorsese than it says about even
- 1:03:41the characters in the movie. Yeah.
- 1:03:44And that, that's the struggle I have with this film.
- 1:03:46I don't, I don't know. I've been reading c.s.
- 1:03:50Lewis lately and reading a set of his essays.
- 1:03:54In a book called the way to glory.
- 1:03:55And in this one essay. Well, I mean, it was a speech
- 1:04:00that he gave in the middle of World War Two.
- 1:04:03He talks about he's talking to a bunch of pacifists about why he
- 1:04:07see us Louis is not a pacifist and he talks about how in his
- 1:04:12opinion, like one of the biggest struggles with the pacifist
- 1:04:16position is that the greatest evil is suffering and death and
- 1:04:22he just can't find In proof that suffering and death are truly
- 1:04:27the greatest evil, a person can experience.
- 1:04:30And I feel like this movie is Holy is completely based on this
- 1:04:37question of like is suffering and death.
- 1:04:41The worst thing that can happen to a person actually it?
- 1:04:46Sorry, let me rephrase that it's not based around that question.
- 1:04:49It assumes that as the underlying principle that
- 1:04:53suffering and death is the worst thing that can happen to a
- 1:04:56person therefore you should apostatize to prevent suffering
- 1:05:00and death from happening to other people.
- 1:05:03And like, Louis would just disagree flat-out disagree with
- 1:05:06that. And I, you know, I am nowhere
- 1:05:09near the intellectual giant that CS Lewis's.
- 1:05:14So I don't know man. I like I think this movie is
- 1:05:17fascinating but I'm wondering if the very premise of the movie is
- 1:05:21a little bit flawed. I mean, I do think that it's
- 1:05:23important. And for us to acknowledge and
- 1:05:25like, obviously, if you've listened this long in the
- 1:05:27podcast, you know, that like Brad and I obviously went to
- 1:05:30Seminary, we are both in some capacity, like, pastoring people
- 1:05:33and we believe this stuff. Like, we are Christians reading
- 1:05:36reviews of this movie from atheists, is I think really
- 1:05:39enlightening to because like to them, they're like, this is a
- 1:05:42no-brainer. Why wouldn't you just step on
- 1:05:43the thing? And so, it really does kind of
- 1:05:46depend on the lens that you're looking at this movie from.
- 1:05:48And I would just ask that anyone who's hearing our take on it,
- 1:05:51understand that are the world view that We're coming from is
- 1:05:54like, hey, we believe this stuff we're actually in the same boat
- 1:05:57as the, the missionaries in this movie.
- 1:06:00And so, the struggle for us is the same struggle that they're
- 1:06:03going through and when you look at it as an outside Observer and
- 1:06:05you're like, oh yeah, this is a no-brainer, you know, I think it
- 1:06:08simplifies it a little bit too much, man.
- 1:06:11Bob, you know what we should have done, what's that?
- 1:06:13We should have found a token atheist to have on the podcast
- 1:06:17so can a man that's what we should have done to get the, get
- 1:06:23the opposed View on silence Brad.
- 1:06:25I think it's time for final scores, man.
- 1:06:28This is this is a hard movie to rate and it gets back to like
- 1:06:32the how do you capture Christianity on film discussion
- 1:06:35that we keep kind of circling and we still haven't done that
- 1:06:38bonus episode yet. But Hmm, this isn't like a God's
- 1:06:41Not Dead which is just a crap movie like but it's also very
- 1:06:45different to me than, like, Passion of the Christ.
- 1:06:47Which I think now, with almost 20 years of distance, I can look
- 1:06:51back on Passion of the Christ and be like, this was is used as
- 1:06:54a pretty important tool for people to see like violence and
- 1:06:58like what can happen to the human body?
- 1:07:00When it's tortured. And when you believe that,
- 1:07:02that's Jesus, it's a very effective tool but also like
- 1:07:05it's not really a great movie. And I think I'm like, okay
- 1:07:08saying that now, this is different than that because I
- 1:07:11think this is just a much better made film.
- 1:07:14And it asks more challenging questions than Passion of the
- 1:07:16Christ did, but it falls into that same boat, where it's like
- 1:07:21we do believe this stuff. So like me, Can you evaluate the
- 1:07:25movie as a film? And I think as a film I'm gonna
- 1:07:28give it an eight and a half out of ten.
- 1:07:30It's not a perfect movie but it has a lot going for it and
- 1:07:33obviously like we have been very affected by it.
- 1:07:36I'll just flat out say like as Mochi.
- 1:07:39She died in the waves. I was weeping.
- 1:07:42Hmm. Like I don't think I could watch
- 1:07:46this movie without weeping as I look at his sacrifice for, you
- 1:07:52know, our lord Jesus. Disgraced like that gets me but
- 1:07:57you're right. Bobbi gets me because I believe
- 1:07:59in this stuff right? Because I'm down with it.
- 1:08:01Yeah I found a really cool little tidbit that after
- 1:08:05watching this movie Terrence Malick the director of the tree
- 1:08:08of life also a very you know Christian heavy themed movie
- 1:08:12wrote a letter to Scorsese and he said this in his letter he
- 1:08:16said, one comes away, wondering what our task in life is what is
- 1:08:21it that Christ asks of us. And what Shapes.
- 1:08:24Will he assumed in these dark times?
- 1:08:26Like those of old, he might appear as you show.
- 1:08:30Even in those who opposed the faith or betray it, like, Judas
- 1:08:33or Pilot, his love seems to be wider for it and, you know, he's
- 1:08:38calling back to the character of key gyro, but I just love that.
- 1:08:41Malik. Is he even struggling with?
- 1:08:43Like I saw this movie, I don't know what to make, like, what is
- 1:08:47Jesus actually asking us to do? And that's, I mean, that's,
- 1:08:51that's the, the point of the movie.
- 1:08:53Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:08:54What would Christ have for us in this broken world?
- 1:08:58And that is that's a really hard question.
- 1:09:01Bob as you said like jumping into the real world of
- 1:09:06ministering to people and caring for them.
- 1:09:08And in times of struggle and darkness and Brokenness.
- 1:09:12The question, like, what does Jesus have for me in this?
- 1:09:15What would he have me? Do who, what kind of a person,
- 1:09:18would he have me? Be, that's a really hard
- 1:09:21question and it's a really important one.
- 1:09:23The With it for anyone who considers themselves a follower
- 1:09:28of Christ. I think, as far as the Movie
- 1:09:31silence goes, I think I'll give it an 8 out of 10 Bob.
- 1:09:36There's a lot of issues that I have with it Beyond, just the
- 1:09:40philosophical stuff going on. It is wildly slow-paced and I
- 1:09:46like that, it does that, but it's still slow and I'm gonna
- 1:09:48dock it a little bit for that. I wish Andrew, I wish that Adam
- 1:09:53Driver. Who was the lead?
- 1:09:56I wish that they had good accents, that there's
- 1:09:58definitely. There's definitely a few things
- 1:10:01going on here, but overall, it's still Scorsese, there's still,
- 1:10:06he just man. Scorsese is just like the master
- 1:10:09of the mic drop, like, he hits the end of his movie drops.
- 1:10:13The mic and is like, yeah, think about that, for the next three
- 1:10:17months, right? Like he does that with every
- 1:10:19movie, he does it with silence. So it's still an incredibly
- 1:10:23well, Film, just not, not my favorite Scorsese, but still
- 1:10:28really good. But we want to know what you
- 1:10:30think you've listened to us. Talk about it for over an hour
- 1:10:32now. So, if you've seen silence, we
- 1:10:34want to hear your opinion on it. You can find us on social media
- 1:10:38on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram at film whiskey, or
- 1:10:42you can jump on our Discord. We are on there.
- 1:10:44Every single day, talking about movies, whiskey cigars, all
- 1:10:49sorts of things you can join us by clicking the link at the end
- 1:10:53of Every one of our show notes. All right, next week we are like
- 1:10:57really steering out of this. Kind of conversation, and we're
- 1:10:59steering into the world of filmmaker Edgar Wright.
- 1:11:03We're going to do three movies by him kicking off with his
- 1:11:052004, classic Shaun of the Dead, Brad.
- 1:11:09I'm really excited for that. One, cannot wait to talk about
- 1:11:12that movie but until then, I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and we'll
- 1:11:16see you next time.