Latest / The So What? / Coalitions
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content on JP's website jplundmann.co.au.
- 0:21I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio.
- 0:36Hello and welcome to a recording to go with JP's latest newsletter.
- 0:41It's dated the 19th of May 2023 and the title is Coalitions.
- 0:48I suppose it's unnecessary to ask why this is such a hot topic at the moment.
- 0:54Well if Johannesburg elects its 8th mayor in about 7 or 8 years and you look at the
- 1:00dysfunctionality of municipalities all over the country, our experience of coalitions
- 1:06have not been a successful one, not at all.
- 1:10We've had coalitions since 2021, 2016 in Jo’burg but 2021 in other parts of the country and
- 1:16it hasn't been an epic experience.
- 1:18There's a lot of volatility, a lot of change in leadership all the time and the bottom
- 1:24line is that the argument goes about who, not about how.
- 1:29It is just the different digits giving us two very different words and two very different
- 1:35outcomes.
- 1:36It's about who occupies position of power and not about how we're going to exercise
- 1:41power.
- 1:42And now we've got to have a national election in the years time, in May 2024, 12 months
- 1:47from now if the election is not postponed and a lot of people are filled with the anxiety
- 1:53that one party will not get 50% of the vote and that we will then be forced into coalitions
- 1:59at the national level and that is why it's a pertinent issue.
- 2:02There's much excitement at the moment around the DA's moonshot pact and a series of small
- 2:11new parties starting up.
- 2:13If you look at the numbers what do they tell you?
- 2:17Well the numbers tell me that the DA will really have a hard time to get to 50% through
- 2:23a moonshot pact.
- 2:25There are 14 political parties currently in parliament, four parties of which the DA
- 2:30is one, command 92.5% of the vote.
- 2:34The other 10 parties share 7.5%.
- 2:37So it's not that we don't have small parties in the South African politics or parliament,
- 2:41we have them.
- 2:42They're just not that important.
- 2:44Now the premise of the moonshot pact is that the DA can replace the ANC as the biggest
- 2:49single party and that I think is wishful thinking.
- 2:53It is quite possible, it may happen, that the ANC drops below 50% but it's very far
- 2:58from probable that they will drop to a level lower than the democratic alliance.
- 3:03Now if you take the small parties in parliament, the parties making up that 7.5% plus the
- 3:10IFP that the DA is talking to, you can get to a maximum, really a big maximum of 40%
- 3:17and that is not going to be a game changer.
- 3:20So I'm not excited about the moonshot.
- 3:24When it comes to smaller political parties, just remember one statistic from the last
- 3:29election, the 2019 national elections.
- 3:3248 political parties registered to participate.
- 3:37They made it into parliament.
- 3:404 commanded 92.5% of the vote.
- 3:4348, 14, 4.
- 3:45So they are always in all elections in South African new parties, generating a lot of excitement
- 3:52and in the end they do not upset the apple card.
- 3:55And I think it will take quite a huge shift in our politics for the DA to become the biggest
- 4:00party and therefore for the moonshot to have a chance and for any of the smaller parties
- 4:05to come in and upset the apple card.
- 4:09They can do well, they can get 4, 5% of the vote, which is a good number for a party that's
- 4:13starting out.
- 4:14But it's not a number that determines power.
- 4:17What about the stay-away vote?
- 4:19That is the big uncertainty.
- 4:21You put your finger on it.
- 4:22The big question in our electoral politics is the millions of people who over the years
- 4:28have decided to withhold their vote and not to vote for any party.
- 4:32That is the big uncertainty.
- 4:35Will there this time in 2024 step up and vote?
- 4:39And if they step up and vote, who will they vote for?
- 4:42And we simply just know we'll have to wait for the votes to be counted.
- 4:47But you do believe that it is possible for the ANC to actually make it, to get 50 plus
- 4:54one or a bit more?
- 4:56Well I think we should not treat it as a forgotten conclusion that they will drop below 50.
- 5:01I think that would be as reckless as saying that they will get 50.
- 5:05Why do I feel they have a chance to get 50%?
- 5:08Two factors.
- 5:09The first one is that load shedding is probably the single most important factor now in our
- 5:15national political life.
- 5:17People are really angry about it.
- 5:19People are really upset about it.
- 5:21Now the research that we've done and which we've shared with clients, proprietary work
- 5:26we've done, indicate quite clearly that enough renewable power will be installed over the
- 5:31next 18 to 24 months to alleviate load shedding substantially.
- 5:37You know there's research out not by us but by other people that if as little as 5,000
- 5:44megawatts of renewables are installed, you can cut load shedding by 60%.
- 5:49Now our numbers indicate that we're going to get 20,000 megawatts over the next two
- 5:54years.
- 5:55The election is going to be in a year's time, not two years so be aware of that.
- 5:59The point I'm trying to make is the more load shedding gets alleviated after this winter
- 6:04and the more it gets better, which in due course it will because new capacity is installed,
- 6:09the more the ANC will get the credit or there's a chance that the ANC will get the credit.
- 6:14They will also claim it I'm sure.
- 6:15They will also claim it.
- 6:17So that's the, now there's of course a big idea at play here.
- 6:21All these projects that I'm talking about are being driven by the private sector.
- 6:26They keen to get the job done.
- 6:28They keen to connect to the grid.
- 6:29They keen to get the show on the road so to speak.
- 6:33And the keener they are and the more successful they are, the more the ANC will get the credit.
- 6:38It's one of those ironies that play out in life.
- 6:41But I think that is something one must be aware of.
- 6:44The second thing is simply the social grant system.
- 6:46At a moment there are 10 million people in South Africa who receive 350 around a month
- 6:51from the government.
- 6:52It's a social distress relief grant, the so-called SDR.
- 6:57This grant goes as I've said to 10 million people.
- 7:00It was instituted during COVID, right?
- 7:02It was instituted during and just after COVID to try and alleviate COVID distress.
- 7:08It is scheduled to end at the end of March 2024.
- 7:13Now the chances of that grant being terminated in March, which is two months before the election,
- 7:18must be absolutely null.
- 7:20I can't see that happening.
- 7:22What I can see happening is that the grant will be renamed.
- 7:26It won't be called the social distress grant.
- 7:28It will be called the basic income grant or something.
- 7:31It will be made permanent.
- 7:32It will probably be increased a little bit within what the fiscus fines it can afford.
- 7:38And the government will say, look what we've done for you.
- 7:41We've given a permanent grant, permanent social relief to 10 million people.
- 7:46We've taken away the uncertainty that the grant may end and they even may increase the
- 7:50budget.
- 7:51I think they will increase it.
- 7:52So that will have a huge impact.
- 7:55Many of those people may be part of the stay away group, if I can call it that.
- 8:01Absolutely.
- 8:02And that move may encourage them to actually go out and stand up and vote and then vote
- 8:06for the ANC again.
- 8:07It'll also solidify ANC support.
- 8:09Many people are wavering.
- 8:11We'll then say, okay, you know what the party is looking after us.
- 8:14Let's give our vote to them again.
- 8:16So I think these two factors can add up to pushing the ANC over the line.
- 8:21But of course, against that, you've got a couple of factors.
- 8:24You've got the anger about load shedding, which may carry on and keep on damaging the
- 8:29ANC.
- 8:30The ANC itself admits that it's damaging them.
- 8:33Secondly, there's the utter dysfunctionality at the municipal level, which is getting worse
- 8:39by the day.
- 8:40Potholes, sanitation works, water supply, that sort of thing.
- 8:45And thirdly, there is just the ongoing reports on corruption that keeps on dropping, dropping,
- 8:52dropping like water dropping through the roof.
- 8:56And I think, so where is the balance?
- 8:59Where is the balance?
- 9:00Will it be over 50 or below 50?
- 9:02I honestly don't know.
- 9:03None of us know.
- 9:04We will have to wait for the votes to be counted again.
- 9:07Okay.
- 9:08So let's turn to the possibility that the ANC does not get 50 plus one.
- 9:15What do you think will happen?
- 9:17What do we know of the major parties and the attitude to coalitions?
- 9:23Well, in that sense, April was a very, very interesting month because the three big parties,
- 9:29the ANC, the DA and the IFP, three of the four big parties, have shown their hands.
- 9:36And if I can just take them in sort of cronological order.
- 9:40On the 2nd of April, John Steenhuizen made his acceptance speech when he was re-elected,
- 9:45his leader of the DA.
- 9:47It was a speech of 1,440 something words.
- 9:51He used the word values once.
- 9:55What he emphasized in the speech was not values, but who is excluded from his moonshot coalition.
- 10:01Not so much who is included, but who is excluded.
- 10:04And he made two points very strongly.
- 10:07The first was that he is absolutely against the EFF.
- 10:11Okay.
- 10:12Fine.
- 10:13There's no news there.
- 10:14But then secondly, he said that anybody, any organization, any political party who has
- 10:19tethered themselves to the ANC will also not be welcome.
- 10:23Now in my view, that is clearly painting the DA and himself into a corner.
- 10:29By emphasizing those who are excluded and not those who can be included, you're limiting
- 10:34your spatial vulnerability.
- 10:37So that was the DA.
- 10:38Not so much emphasis on values, a very strong emphasis on who's in and who's out.
- 10:44Then a few days later, on the 8th of April, and maybe it wasn't in response, I don't
- 10:49know, the IFP showed their hand.
- 10:51And Mr. Hlengwa, who was a chair of the parliamentary committee on public accounts,
- 10:56SCOPA, and a very strong IFP leader, came out with a clear statement with five succinct
- 11:03values, emphasizing the importance of values, saying that the IFP can't go with parties,
- 11:08that they do not agree basic values on.
- 11:10And those five values are very straightforward.
- 11:13It's democracy, it's social equity, it's ethical leadership, really things that most
- 11:20of Africans certainly will be able to relate to.
- 11:23But then he made a second point.
- 11:24And the second point was the way in which parties conduct themselves in a run up to
- 11:30the election in 12 months time.
- 11:32That's being such a way that you can include other people in a possible coalition.
- 11:37Should, and that's the way you put it, should it happen that the electorate doesn't give
- 11:41one party 50% plus one?
- 11:44So not only was it emphasizing values and talking about values, which I think is a critical
- 11:49foundation, but it was also talking process and our politics should be conducted.
- 11:56And I find those two pillars quite useful.
- 12:00A couple of days later, towards the end of April, the ANC at the National Executive Committee
- 12:06meeting adopted a framework on local government coalitions.
- 12:11It talks about local government coalitions.
- 12:13Presumably the framework will also apply to a national government coalition.
- 12:18And essentially they made the same point as the IFP.
- 12:21They must agree on basic values.
- 12:24Just as the IFP has said.
- 12:26They then listed 12 of those values and again it's stuff that everybody can agree with.
- 12:32There's nothing there which is objectionable.
- 12:35And they then listed a number of other principles as well.
- 12:38Important principles for a coalition.
- 12:40They've clearly given some thought to it.
- 12:43However, less than a week or so later, a new mayor was elected in Johannesburg, as I've
- 12:48said, the 8th mayor and the ANC just basically ignored all those guidelines.
- 12:54So yes, they do have a framework, but yes, they didn't apply the framework.
- 12:59And that tells us something about the ruling party.
- 13:02So all three parties, all three major parties have shown their hand.
- 13:07And if you look at it and you assume for the moment that most DA members can go along with
- 13:13the values as articulated by the IFP and as articulated by the ANC, then it seems to me
- 13:20values is not a stumbling block.
- 13:24And it's possible for the three main parties to come together.
- 13:27And that raises the very intriguing possibility that we can move into a politics where the
- 13:34three, what I want to call the three parties of the center, where they come together and
- 13:39form a grand coalition.
- 13:41At the end of the day, the differences between the DA, the IFP and the ANC are really not
- 13:47that fundamental.
- 13:48Yes, there are people in each party who hate people from another party.
- 13:53There are people in each party who are ideological about certain points and they wouldn't like
- 13:58to go with other parties.
- 13:59Surely that's more true of the ANC.
- 14:02If you say the ANC agree about most values with the DA and the IFP, I don't think so.
- 14:10Not the whole of the ANC.
- 14:12No, not the whole of the ANC, but certainly majority, certainly the majority.
- 14:17The ANC who accepted that framework and the values in that framework, the RET faction that
- 14:23supports the coalition of the EFF can be found in Gauteng and they can be found in KZN, but
- 14:28not necessarily in the rest of the party.
- 14:31So they are there, they are important, but I think you can undercut the KZN faction with
- 14:37the IFP coalition and in Gauteng, well, in the N numbers we'll talk and I doubt whether
- 14:43they can get the numbers.
- 14:45So I think it's possible for the three parties of the center to come together.
- 14:51This is a different kind of moonshot idea.
- 14:53I think that's a real moonshot.
- 14:56What do we know about South Africans?
- 14:58We know that the majority of South Africans, three quarters at least, 80%, are not radical
- 15:04in their outlook or the way they live and relate to other South Africans.
- 15:09They're not extremists.
- 15:11But our politics does not reflect that.
- 15:14Our political party makeup does not reflect that.
- 15:18So I think it's time for the central forces to come together.
- 15:25At the end of the day, the differences between the non-RET faction of the ANC, the IFP and
- 15:31the DA, the non-ideological part of the DA are not that big.
- 15:37And if the Germans can work together in a grand coalition where there are very clear
- 15:41differences delineated between parties, I can't see why we can't do it.
- 15:47But if the ANC gets a 46 or 47% and the IFP gets what, 5?
- 15:544 or 5%.
- 15:554 or 5, then won't they just get together and run the country?
- 16:01Yes, I think that's what will happen.
- 16:02And then you can throw in a small party like Good and you can probably throw in a small
- 16:06party like Aljamar.
- 16:08They have consistently voted with ANC in the lifetime of this parliament, the current
- 16:13parliament.
- 16:14So those small parties will come together with the IFP and ANC in their life more than
- 16:1850%.
- 16:20But the question we have to ask is, can the big problems of South Africa really be solved
- 16:29by a government that is supported by only 50, 51, 52% of the people?
- 16:34Don't we have a better chance of solving the problems of the country with a government
- 16:40that's supported by 70% of the citizens?
- 16:42And what are the big problems of the country?
- 16:45Well, it's the issues we know.
- 16:48It's poverty.
- 16:49It's unemployment.
- 16:50It's our education system.
- 16:53It's housing.
- 16:54To summarise it in one sentence, it is to restore the dignity of all South Africans in their
- 17:01daily existence.
- 17:04Not just in theory, not just in terms of access to the right to vote or the right to mobilise
- 17:11all the rights that our constitution gives us, but it's to fulfil the promise of the
- 17:15constitution that the dignity of all South Africans in their daily existence will be
- 17:22restored or at least be installed.
- 17:26And I think that is a mammoth task.
- 17:28That is not something that one party can do in its own, not in a democracy.
- 17:32You can try to do it under the dictatorship, but that's not where we are.
- 17:36So I think it is better to have a democracy supported by 70% of the people that can have
- 17:41this national goal of let's uplift all South Africans.
- 17:46And that's why I think even if the ANC gets 51% of the vote, it may be better for everybody
- 17:53the ANC included to pursue a route of a 70-75% government with healthy differences and so
- 18:00on between them, but not so healthy that you can't govern.
- 18:05I think it's a possibility and you're quite right, that is the real moonshot.
- 18:10In summary, so what?
- 18:12Look I think if you look at the mess with loadshedding, you look at the stagnant economy, you look
- 18:17at the dysfunctionality of municipalities, you look at the potholes, you look at the
- 18:22general discontent of the population, then I think we run a real risk that the South
- 18:27African democracy will become delegitimised.
- 18:31And we see in several countries around the world where democracy is being delegitimised.
- 18:37We run that risk too if we cannot fulfil the promise of our constitution of a quarter
- 18:43of a century ago.
- 18:45And that's really what is at stake here.
- 18:47The failure not just of local government and particular departments and so on, but the
- 18:52failure to live up to the promise of our constitution can delegitimize our constitutional project,
- 19:00our democracy project.
- 19:02In other words, that people simply think it wasn't worth it?
- 19:06It wasn't worth it.
- 19:07It's time to turn to some kind of the data.
- 19:09It's time to yield power to a populace to make all kinds of warm promises.
- 19:15Developments that we see elsewhere in the world, that's the risk we run.
- 19:19And I think it's a risk that can be avoided by having a strong 70% government in charge.
- 19:26Also, I think the countries in many ways now, where it was in the 1980s, there are obvious
- 19:32lift differences.
- 19:33Of course, we then had a semi-civil war.
- 19:35We don't have that now.
- 19:36We then had apartheid.
- 19:38We don't have that now.
- 19:40We then had a huge degree of repression.
- 19:42We don't have that now.
- 19:43Yes, there are obvious differences.
- 19:46What are the similarities?
- 19:47Well, the similarities is a stagnant economy, huge poverty and deprivation, the politics
- 19:53that is stagnant and not bringing hope to people.
- 19:56Those are the similarities of the 80s.
- 19:58And what happened in the 80s?
- 20:00We now know that today we've got the benefit of hindsight.
- 20:04What we got was a political initiative that unlocked what we had in South Africa and we
- 20:11moved towards a democracy.
- 20:13And I think we need a similar kind of initiative that bring together the parties of the center
- 20:18to form a government that is supported by 70, 75% of the people.
- 20:24You're surely leaving us with much food for thought.
- 20:28Thank you very much.
- 20:29My pleasure.
- 20:35Thank you for listening to the So What podcast.
- 20:37If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating and please
- 20:42consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 20:46Also, tell your friends.
- 20:48Remember you can find a written version of all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.