Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Remembering Daniel Dennett
Transcript
- 0:01The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking feels so much more happiness. Truth, Fusian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast, hosted by Seth Andrews. He was
- 0:57known as one of the four horsemen of the New atheist movements. And already
- 1:03at that first sentence, I find myself shifting in my chair. You've heard
- 1:10me resist the term new atheists. I guess I understand it. We saw
- 1:17a resurgence in these conversations about the non belief in gods just after the turn
- 1:23of the millennium two thousand and six, two thousand and seven, two thousand
- 1:27and eight, Richard Dawkins had just released his book The God Delusion, A
- 1:33Book that Changed My life. Christopher Hitchins had the book God Is Not Great.
- 1:38He was traveling Bible Belt states, doing speaking engagements and debates. He
- 1:45was on television about every five minutes. Sam Harris released a few books,
- 1:49The End of Faith and Letter to a Christian Nation. And then rounding out
- 1:55the four we had Daniel Dennett. He was known as the nice one.
- 2:00He had the book Breaking the Spell Religion as natural phenomenon. He did a
- 2:06lot of examinations of the evolution of religion, why people's adherents to God belief
- 2:14and superstitions and superstitious rituals might be explained evolutionarily. These were the horsemen,
- 2:22the new atheists. But were they saying anything new? I mean, the
- 2:28science was certainly better in the new millennium as we began to understand belief in
- 2:34the brain, evolved tendencies toward this thinking or that thinking, conditioned response,
- 2:42cultural reinforcements, all of these other elements related to human psychology, brain chemistry.
- 2:49That information was certainly better than it was back in the days of Robert
- 2:53Ingersoll, George Bernard Shaw Bertrand Russell Mark Twain, etc. But as far
- 2:59as rejecting dogma and thinking freely to say, honestly, even courageously, I
- 3:06don't believe I am an atheist. I mean, that's that doesn't seem all
- 3:10that new to me. But four horsemen has always bothered me because it seems
- 3:20to anoint in a point these four men as the shepherds of a flock.
- 3:27You know, they were there, the horsemen, waving the standards, swords
- 3:31drawn at the front of the army, leading us toward battle, and we
- 3:36followed in lockstep. It just comes off that way to me, and it
- 3:39gives a little bit of ammo to some apologists who'd like to say that atheists
- 3:45have just traded one religion for another, the religion of atheism, and these
- 3:50are their preachers, these are their shepherds, And I just you know,
- 3:53it's different when I was part of a church and the pastor would preach something,
- 3:59I was conditioned to accept it. Ever, notice how pastors don't finish
- 4:03their sermons with a Q and a time. But if you go to a
- 4:08free thought event, there's a ton of Q and A And even those who
- 4:14have expertise and experience and take the stage, they are listening even as they
- 4:19are presenting. But this type of engagement is not new, and so I
- 4:26resist this clumsy framing of new atheism. But whatever. I'm totally digressing.
- 4:31We're talking today about one of the horsemen who just passed away on the nineteenth
- 4:38of April twenty twenty four, Daniel Dennett, the philosopher. He succumbed to
- 4:45lung disease. He's the second one of these four that we lost. Of
- 4:47course, we lost Christopher Hitchens to asofageal cancer back in December of twenty eleven.
- 4:54I actually did a ten year anniversary tribute for hitch It's in the podcast
- 4:59archive. You can just scroll back and find that show from twenty twenty one.
- 5:04Now, it's interesting that Daniel Dennett is a known name, but a
- 5:10lot of people don't know much about him. And here in the wake of
- 5:15his passing, I thought it might be a good opportunity to introduce you to
- 5:19some of what Daniel Dennett said and much of who he was. Daniel Dennett
- 5:27in Memoriam, including many recordings of his own voice, his own thoughts,
- 5:32in his own words. Daniel Dennett born the twenty eighth of March nineteen forty
- 5:38two, Boston, Massachusetts. His mother had a master's degree in English.
- 5:43She was an educator. His father had a doctorate in Islamic studies from Harvard
- 5:50and I am not kidding was a counter intelligence agent for the government. Daniel
- 5:58Dennett's dad was killed in a plane crash when Dan was only five, and
- 6:01after that they were living overseas in Lebanon. Dan's mother moved him back to
- 6:08Massachusetts before he was even a teenager. Though he was apparently just a natural
- 6:14philosopher. He just thought like a philosopher. A camp counselor told him when
- 6:19he was just eleven, He told him, you will be a philosopher.
- 6:25In nineteen sixty three, Daniel Dennett graduated with a BA in philosophy from Harvard.
- 6:31A doctorate from Oxford would soon follow. He became a professor at the
- 6:36University of California from nineteen sixty five to nineteen seventy one, and then he
- 6:42moved to Tuff's University in Massachusetts. A few other bullet points off the resume.
- 6:49Daniel Dennett was a Fellow of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry Humanist Laureates of
- 6:56the International Academy of Humanism. He was named two for Humanist of the Year
- 7:01by the American Humanist Association, and of course, he was a much sought
- 7:06after author and public speaker in my own journey. I think what I found
- 7:14most interesting and continue to find most interesting about Dennett's work is how he speaks
- 7:19to the evolution of religion. Because a lot of times we talk about religion
- 7:26as an idea. It's a bad idea if it's a superstition and all the
- 7:30harm that it propagates. But we don't often understand the evolutionary reasons that people
- 7:36may gravitate to the idea of gods or spirits or some sort of other worldly
- 7:43metaphysical agency. But Daniel Dennett this was totally his wheelhouse. Several years ago,
- 7:50he was on a broadcast called Closer to Truth, which was hosted by
- 7:55Robert Kohn. Here's a clip, It runs over five minutes, but I
- 8:00wanted to include the complete thought, what are some of the methodologies that we
- 8:05should begin to think about looking at a study of religion? Well, I
- 8:09think we have to think not just historically, but biologically. We have to
- 8:13realize that homeless sapiens us we descended from earlier Hamanids. We have a share
- 8:20a common ancestor with a chimpanzee. Going back about six million years, a
- 8:24lot has changed, and as Darcy Thompsone said, everything is the way it
- 8:30is is it got that way. So let's look at the history as best
- 8:33we can. We have to do a lot of extrapolation and some speculation and
- 8:37see what religion adds to the mix that makes us so different from all other
- 8:45animals. And I think we can do that. I think we can see
- 8:48both what its origins were in superstition, which grew out of an overactive adoption
- 8:56of the intentional stance when it's something. And this, by the way,
- 9:00is a mammalian feature we share with say dogs. If your dog here's the
- 9:05thud of snow falling off the roof, and jumps up and barks, the
- 9:09dog is in effect asking who's there, what's that? But who it's assuming
- 9:16there's an agent, might be a dangerous agent out there, This assumption that
- 9:18when something surprising, unexpected, puzzling happens, to treat it as an agent
- 9:24until you learn otherwise. That's the intentional the intentional stance, and it's it's
- 9:30an instinct, not just in us, an entirely appropriate instinct. I don't
- 9:35want to get eaten running around on the plane. It's on a hair trigger.
- 9:39And so that's right. You don't want to wait around it is you
- 9:43want to you want to to fire have a lot of false positives, a
- 9:48lot of false alarms right now in the dog. The dog just goes back
- 9:52to sleep after a minute. But we, because we've got language, we
- 9:56mull it over in our heads, and pretty soon we've conned up a hallucinated
- 10:01agent, a little forest god, or a talking tree, or an elf
- 10:05or something what made that noise? Now mostly those are just harmless little quirks
- 10:13that we have in our heads, and we soon forget them. Every now
- 10:16and then one comes along which has a little bit more staying power. It's
- 10:20sort of unforgettable, And so it grows and we share it with a neighbor,
- 10:24and the neighbor says, what do you mean a talking tree? Nah,
- 10:28there's no talking trees, you see. Oh yeah, I could have
- 10:31sworn that tree with talking. Pretty soon the whole village is talking about the
- 10:35talking tree. Maybe they're all saying it's crazy, all such thing as a
- 10:39talking tree, but they're all talking about the talking tree. The talking tree
- 10:43idea has entered the world. It has made multiple copies. Everybody in the
- 10:46village has a copy of the talking tree idea. What's it for. It's
- 10:50for itself. It's just it's just happened because it could. It's like a
- 10:54it's like a virus. And it may be from time to time that one
- 10:58of these little quirks gets randomly reinforced by I don't know, a good fishing
- 11:05catch or some animal, and then suddenly the good result is like an operant
- 11:09condition back to that little quirk, and it gets. In fact, the
- 11:13f Skinner did some experiments with pigeons on just that randomly reinforcing them, and
- 11:18pretty soon they were doing quite elaborate little dances. And and sure, these
- 11:22are these This isn't religion, This is just superstition, and it melds perfectly
- 11:26in with their lore, their physical law, their their natural lore. But
- 11:31sometimes they get the idea, well, if you if you say a little
- 11:35prayer to the to the talking tree before you go hunting, then then you
- 11:39do a little better on the hunt. And and and so it goes.
- 11:41And the line between good law, I mean, true accurate law about where
- 11:48where the food is and so forth, and the sort of embellishment they don't
- 11:52drive. They don't think of it as a religion. And gradually these ideas
- 11:56which naturally infiltrate into their community and get copies in all the heads locally,
- 12:03they sort themselves out. There's competition, there's there's only so much room in
- 12:07people's heads for these things, and the ones that are unforgettable, the ones
- 12:13that really are catchy, will get copied and passed on and passed on and
- 12:16passed on. These are the memes. Those are what Richard Dawkins would call
- 12:20memes. That's right. They're cultural items that reproduce in people's brains, and
- 12:24their only purpose is their own propagation. What are they for? They're for
- 12:28themselves. It's like when I first started studying religion, people said, oh,
- 12:33evolutionary account of religion, what do you think religions are good for?
- 12:37Dan, They've got to be good for something, after all, every every
- 12:39human group that's ever been studied has some kind of religion. And I said,
- 12:45well, yeah, every group that's ever been studied has the common cold
- 12:48too. What's it good for? It's good for self. And these ideas
- 12:52are just good for themselves. They're good at reproducing in minds, whether they're
- 12:58good habits or bad habits of mine. They're good at sem producing some one
- 13:03s. That's a neutral comment. It's not positive. Now those are if
- 13:07you like, the wild memes, because they don't really belong to people.
- 13:11People don't take care of them. They're they're not. Now they're going to
- 13:15get themselves domesticated. And now, just the way sheep acquired shepherds, and
- 13:20it was very much to their genetic benefit, millions, hundreds of millions of
- 13:28sheep. Now, so some of these wild ideas got shepherds as well.
- 13:31They got stewards, They got people who would devote their lives to spreading these
- 13:37ideas, to protecting them, to teaching them, and so forth. Now
- 13:39we've begun the domestication of these wild memes. It's interesting how many people don't
- 13:46realize the word meme comes from that nineteen seventy six book I think it was
- 13:52seventy six, Richard Dawkins, The Selfish Gene. He was talking about genetics,
- 13:58the replication or imitation one to another. And now we talk about it
- 14:05in terms of things that are copied and spread rapidly, usually on the Internet,
- 14:11whether it's a picture, video, text, idea, whatever, the
- 14:15meme, but it has a scientific origin. Oh God, I guess we'll
- 14:22open up the free will Gan of worms and the thoughts, the perspectives,
- 14:28the opinion of Daniel Dennett coming up next. Thanks for listening and thanks for
- 14:39your support Patreon dot com, slash seth Andrews. You get the show two
- 14:46days early and totally commercial free, and your support is appreciated. Continuing to
- 14:54talk about Daniel Dennett, now I mentioned free will. This conversation makes my
- 15:01brain hurt. I'm not a philosopher. I don't think like philosophers. I'm
- 15:05still debating whether philosophy, which is this exploration of knowledge and life and purpose,
- 15:15you know, these existential conversations if philosophy is is it beneficial or is
- 15:20it just this sort of stuffy, snobby time wasting naval gazing. You know,
- 15:26should these be scientific questions? And then is philosophy actually rooted in science
- 15:33or is it something else? I mean I literally just stop, I just
- 15:37say quit it. I want to go and share memes, right, And
- 15:41I don't know if you feel the same way. There are some people who
- 15:43love to wade in or swim in the ocean of philosophy. Knock yourself out.
- 15:50But one of the big conversations I had to do with free will,
- 15:54does the brain automatically decide for us what we're going to do, what we're
- 16:00going to say, how we think the entirety of our being, and we
- 16:04just think we have agency, but it already happened, it was already predetermined.
- 16:10Or is there a choice? Do we really have free will? Daniel
- 16:17Denniz thought that we actually do have agency, we can choose, and that
- 16:23those who say free will does not exist may be harming the species. About
- 16:30a decade ago he sat down and shared his thoughts. This is probably a
- 16:34three or four minute clip. This is from the Big Think broadcast. Let
- 16:38me trot out one of my recent favorites, which I devised to jangle the
- 16:45nerves of neuroscientists who've been going around saying that neuroscience shows that we don't have
- 16:49free will. I think their reasons for saying that are ill considered, and
- 16:56moreover, that what they're doing is apt to be mischievous and doing some real
- 17:00arm. So I concocted a little thought experiment, a little intuition pump,
- 17:04to suggest that So this is the case of the nefarious neurosurgeon who treats a
- 17:11patient who has obsessive compulsive disorder by inserting a little microchip in his brain which
- 17:18controls the OCD, the obsessive compulsive disorder. Now there is such a chip.
- 17:22It's been developed in the Netherlands and it works really quite well. That's
- 17:26science fact. But now you've come to science fiction. So the neurosurgeon,
- 17:32after she's operated on the guy, sewed him all up. So, okay,
- 17:36you're OCD is under control. Now you'll be happy to learn. But
- 17:40moreover, our team here will be monitoring you twenty four to seven, and
- 17:45we're going to be controlling everything you do from now on. You'll think you
- 17:49have free will. You you'll think you're making your own decisions, but really
- 17:52you won't have free will at all. Free will is an illusion that we
- 17:56will maintain while controlling you. Goodbye, nice life, sends him out the
- 18:00door. Well, he believes her. He's had a shiny lab and you
- 18:07know, lots of degrees and diplomas and all that. So what does he
- 18:11do? Well, he thinking he doesn't have free will anymore, he gets
- 18:15a little self indulgent, a little bit aggressive, He a little negligent in
- 18:19how he decides what to do, and pretty soon, by indulging some of
- 18:23his worst features, he's got himself in trouble with the law, and he's
- 18:29arrested and he's put on trial. And at the trial he says, but
- 18:33your honor, I don't have free will. I'm under the control of the
- 18:37team at the neurosurgery clinic. I'd say, what's this and they call the
- 18:42neurosurgeon to the stand. I said, did you tell this man that you
- 18:47were controlling as every movie? He didn't have free will? He says,
- 18:49yeah, I did. Yeah, but I was just messing with his head.
- 18:52That was just a joke. I didn't think he'd believe me. Now
- 18:56right there, I think we can stop taking deep breath and say, well,
- 19:00she did something really bad. She really harmed that man. In fact,
- 19:03her little joke telling him that actually accomplished non surgically pretty much what she
- 19:10claimed accomplished surgically. She disabled him by telling him he didn't have free will.
- 19:17She pretty much turned his free will off and turned him into a morally
- 19:22incompetent person. Now, if we agree that she did a bad thing,
- 19:26if nobody recommends people play jokes like this, what are we to say about
- 19:30the neuroscientists who are telling the public every day. We've shown in our neuroscience
- 19:36labs that nobody has free will. I think if the neuroscientists recognize that what
- 19:42my imaginary neurosurgeon did was irresponsible, they should think Sarah seriously about whether it's
- 19:48irresponsible of them to make these claims about free will. You know, here,
- 19:55I am in my own life, and I've come to the conclusion that
- 19:57even if I don't have free will, even if my brain's going to do
- 20:03what it does automatically, I'm still operating as if, like I have an
- 20:08illusion of but I'm conducting myself with the idea the desire to do the right
- 20:15thing. So even if it's a foregone conclusion and I'm acting it out,
- 20:19even if it's make believe, it's it's something that should happen. And then
- 20:26I thought, well, if I'm pretending I have agency, was that make
- 20:30believe also a foregone conclusion in my brain? And I had no choice about
- 20:36choosing to make believe. You see what I'm talking about? All right?
- 20:40Well, you free will debaters, I passed the baton to you. You
- 20:44just go off into your little room, find that basement, sit around the
- 20:48card table, and you can debate all night. Just don't invite me,
- 20:53Okay, I just don't have the bandwidth for it. But Daniel Dennett used
- 21:00to do a lot of speaking about purpose, generating purpose, being handed purpose,
- 21:07especially from a higher power. There was a speech that he did and
- 21:11this is one of the favorites that I found online. It was back in
- 21:15two thousand and seven at a TED conference. Now TED stands for Technology,
- 21:22Entertainment and Design, and these conferences are really slick. They've got like twenty
- 21:26minute speeches and they bring in thinkers and scientists, philosophers and just everyday people
- 21:30from all around the world to present. So this is a TED conference two
- 21:36thousand and seven with multiple presenters. Rick Warren was on the roster. Rick
- 21:41Warren is a world famous Baptist pastor. He founded the mega Church, one
- 21:48of the biggest churches in the United States. It's called Saddleback Church, Lake
- 21:52Forest, California, and Rick Warren really rose to fame. It's saddled Back
- 21:59by the way, he was excommunicated from his own church and from the Southern
- 22:03Baptist Convention entirely. They kicked him out. You want to know why he
- 22:11committed the sin of hiring a female pastor, because the Southern Baptist Convention apparently
- 22:21thinks it's the year eleven hundred. But Rick ain't hurting because he published in
- 22:27two thousand and two. He's got a lot of books, but the one
- 22:30that he's known for published twenty two years ago. It's called Purpose Driven Life,
- 22:37a book which is beloved by Christians. It exploded all of these years
- 22:44later. It's been translated into one hundred and thirty seven languages. It has
- 22:48sold fifty million copies. Imagine the Royalty checks on that. So Rick Warren
- 22:56is speaking at ted about his book, which makes several claims, and Daniel
- 23:02Dennett followed up with the rebuttal. But the claims go like this, Okay,
- 23:07people should obey God's word even when it doesn't make any sense. And
- 23:14he also said to have meaning in life, you have to deny natural selection.
- 23:23With Rick Warren sitting in the audience, Daniel Dennett took the stage to
- 23:29push back just a little bit. Here's a clip, Well, this from
- 23:33a Purpose Driven Life. The Bible must become the authoritative standard of it for
- 23:37my life. The compass I rely on for direction, the council I listen
- 23:41to for making wise decisions, and the benchmark I use for evaluating everything.
- 23:45Well maybe, okay, but what's going to follow from this? And here's
- 23:51one that does concern me. Well, remember I quoted him before with this
- 23:55one. Surrendered People obey God's word even if it doesn't make sense, and
- 24:00that's that's a problem. Don't ever argue with a double He's better at arguing
- 24:07than you are, having had thousands of years to practice. Now, Rick
- 24:12Warren didn't invent this clever move. It's an old move. It's a very
- 24:18clever adaptation of religions. It's a wild card for disarming any reasonable criticism.
- 24:25You don't like my interpretation, you've got a reasonable objection to it. Don't
- 24:29listen. Don't listen. That's the devil speaking. This discourages the sort of
- 24:36reasoning citizenship it seems to me that we want to have. Okay, So
- 24:41there's Dan Dennett and he's right there, face to face, eye to I
- 24:45taking Pastor Warren to task, and he issued an idea, a proposal for
- 24:52how we might better prepare or educate the next generations. This clip is along
- 24:57when it runs just over four minutes from that same Ted talk in two thousand
- 25:03and seven. Here's my proposal. I'm going to just take you a couple
- 25:07of minutes to explain it. That education in world religions, on world religions
- 25:11for all of our children, in primary school, in high school, in
- 25:15public schools, in private schools, and in homeschooling. So what I'm proposing
- 25:22is, just as we require reading, writing, arithmetic, American history,
- 25:27so we should have a curriculum on facts about all the religions of the world,
- 25:33about their history, about their creeds, about their texts, their music,
- 25:40their symbolisms, their prohibitions, their requirements. And that this should be
- 25:45presented factually, straightforwardly, with no particular spin, to all of the children
- 25:52in the country. And as long as you teach them that, you can
- 25:57teach them anything else you like. That I think is maximal tolerance for religious
- 26:03freedom. As long as you inform your children about other religions, then you
- 26:08may, and as early as you like it, whatever you like, teach
- 26:11them whatever creed you want them to learn, but also let them know about
- 26:18other religions. Now why do I say that, Because democracy depends on an
- 26:25informed citizenship. Informed consent is the very bedrock of our understanding of democracy.
- 26:33Misinformed consent is not worth it. It's like a coin flip it's just not
- 26:38it doesn't count. Really, democracy depends on informed consent. This is the
- 26:42way we treat people as responsible adults. Now, children below the age of
- 26:51consent are special case. Parents. I'm going to use a word that the
- 26:57pastor Rick just used. Parents are stewards of their children. They don't own
- 27:03them. You can't own your children. You have a responsibility to the world,
- 27:08to the state, to them to take care of them. Right,
- 27:15you may teach them whatever creed you think is most important, but I say
- 27:19you have a responsibility to let them be informed about all the other creeds in
- 27:23the world too. Now, the reason I've taken this time is I've been
- 27:29fascinated to hear some of the reactions to this. One reviewer for a Roman
- 27:34Catholic newspaper called it totalitarian. It strikes me as a practically libertarian. Is
- 27:41it totalitarian to require reading, writing, and arithmetic. I don't think so.
- 27:47All I'm saying is and facts facts only, no values, just facts
- 27:52about all the world's religions. Another reviewer called it hilarious. Well, I'm
- 28:00really bothered by the fact that anybody would think that was hilarious. It seems
- 28:04to me to be such a plausible natural extension of the democratic principles we already
- 28:11have that. I'm shocked to think anybody would find that just ridiculous. I
- 28:18know many religions are so anxious about preserving the purity of their faith among their
- 28:26children that they are intent on keeping their children ignorant of other faiths. I
- 28:33don't think that's defensible. I've got more Daniel Dennett clips, audio clips,
- 28:38and just a few, but first I want to cover some of his thoughts,
- 28:42written thoughts. These are his words my voice, from various books,
- 28:48publications, speeches, TV shows, etc. Nineteen ninety five from his book
- 28:55Darwin's Dangerous Idea. Then I was trying to say that you can't have science
- 29:00without philosophy. Quote. Whenever Darwinism is the topic, the temperature rises because
- 29:07more is at stake than just the empirical facts about how life on Earth evolved
- 29:14or the correct logic of the theory that accounts for those facts. One of
- 29:18the precious things that is at stake is a vision of what it means to
- 29:22ask and answer the question why. Darwin's new perspective turns several traditional assumptions upside
- 29:32down, undermining our standard ideas about what ought to count as satisfying answers to
- 29:38this ancient and inescapable question. Here, science and philosophy get completely intertwined.
- 29:47Scientists sometimes deceive themselves into thinking that philosophical ideas are only, at best,
- 29:53decorations or parasitic commentaries on the hard, objective triumphs of science, and that
- 30:02they themselves are immune to the confusions that philosophers devote their lives to dissolving.
- 30:10But there is no such thing as philosophy free science. There is only science
- 30:15whose philosophical baggage is taken on board without examination. The Darwinian Revolution is both
- 30:22a scientific and a philosophical revolution, and neither revolution could have occurred without the
- 30:30other. As we shall see, it was the philosophical prejudices of the scientists,
- 30:37more than their lack of scientific evidence, that prevented them from seeing how
- 30:41the theory could actually work. But those philosophical prejudices that had to be overthrown
- 30:48were too deeply entrenched to be dislodged by mere philosophical brilliance. It took an
- 30:55irresistible parade of hard on scientific facts to force thinkers to take seriously the weird
- 31:03new outlook that Darwin proposed. Let me lay my cards on the table.
- 31:08If I were to give an award for the single best idea anyone has ever
- 31:14had, I'd give it to Darwin, ahead of Newton and Einstein and everyone
- 31:19else in a single stroke. The idea of evolution by natural selection unifies the
- 31:26realm of life, meaning and purpose with the realm of space and time,
- 31:32cause and effect, mechanism and physical law. But it's not just a wonderful
- 31:37scientific idea. It is a dangerous idea. My admiration for Darwin's magnificent idea
- 31:47is unbounded. But I too cherish many of the ideas and ideals that it
- 31:52seems to challenge, and want to protect them. The only good way to
- 31:57do this, the only way that has a chance in the long run,
- 32:01is to cut through the smoke screens and look at the idea as unflinchingly,
- 32:07as dispassionately as possible. Now, you put scientists in philosophers in a room
- 32:15and you read that quote to them, and then just watch chaos breakout.
- 32:21And I don't know the answer to this. I tend to think that scientific
- 32:28answers may not require philosophy. I mean, we're talking about hard data experimentation
- 32:36and coming up with hypotheses. It's not philosophy, is it. But again,
- 32:40this is above my pay grade. You tell me what you think.
- 32:45From television, on a show called The Genius of Charles Darwin, Dennett said
- 32:50that the earth has grown a nervous system and it's us. There's a line
- 32:59from Breaking the Spell that I really liked, a couple of paragraphs where we
- 33:02talked about the difference between you and I relying on authorities on a specific subject
- 33:09or in a field, right scientist to our legitimate, vetted, peer reviewed,
- 33:15credible experts. We have to at some point rely on that expertise because
- 33:22they are an authority. Well, what's the difference between that and religious believers
- 33:28saying that God is their authority, or a pastor or a member of the
- 33:34clergy or whatever is their authority. Isn't there a difference? Daniel Dennett thought,
- 33:38So, here's what he said. Quote. Surely just about everybody has
- 33:45faced a moral dilemma and secretly wished if only somebody, somebody I trusted,
- 33:51could just tell me what to do. Wouldn't this be morally inauthentic? Aren't
- 33:58we responsible for making our own moral decisions? Yes? But the virtues of
- 34:05do it yourself moral reasoning have their limits. And if you decide, after
- 34:09conscientious consideration, that your moral decision is to delegate further moral decisions in your
- 34:16life to a trusted expert, then you have made your own moral decision.
- 34:23You have decided to take advantage of the division of labor that civilization makes possible
- 34:30and get the help of experts specialists. We applaud the wisdom of this course
- 34:37in all other important areas of decision making. Don't try to be your own
- 34:43doctor, the lawyer who represents himself as a fool for a client, and
- 34:49so forth. Even in the case of political decisions like which way to vote,
- 34:54the policy of delegation can be defended. Is this a dereliction of one's
- 35:01duty as a citizen. I don't think so, but it does depend on
- 35:07my having good grounds for trusting the delegates judgment. That's why those who have
- 35:13an unquestioning faith in the correctness of the moral teachings of their religion are a
- 35:20problem if they themselves haven't conscientiously considered on their own whether their pastors or priests,
- 35:28or rabbis or immams are worthy of this delegated authority over their own lives,
- 35:34then they are in fact taking a personally immoral stand. This is perhaps
- 35:40the most shocking implication of my inquiry, and I do not shrink from it,
- 35:45even though it may offend many who think of themselves as deeply moral.
- 35:52It is commonly supposed that it is entirely exemplary to adopt the moral teachings of
- 35:58one's own religion without question, because, to put it simply, it is
- 36:04the word of God, as interpreted always by the specialists to whom one has
- 36:09delegated authority. I am urging, on the contrary, that anybody who professes
- 36:15that a particular point of moral conviction is not discussable, not debatable, not
- 36:22negotiable, simply because it is the word of God, or because the Bible
- 36:28says so, or because that is what all Muslims, Hindus, seeks etc.
- 36:34Believe, and I am a Muslim, Hindu seekh should be seen to
- 36:38be making it impossible for the rest of us to take their views seriously,
- 36:45excusing themselves from the moral conversation, inadvertently acknowledging that their own views are not
- 36:52conscientiously maintained and deserve no further hearing Dennett said this. He said, there
- 37:00are no forces on this planet more dangerous to us all than the fanaticisms of
- 37:07fundamentalism of all species, Protestantism, Catholicism, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism and
- 37:15Buddhism, as well as countless smaller infections. Then I find it interesting that
- 37:21he used the word infections on the issue of the soul. From Dan Dennett.
- 37:28This is two thousand and four. In a BBC documentary called The Atheism
- 37:31Tapes. He said, I was once interviewed in Italy and the headline of
- 37:37the interview the next day was wonderful. I saved this for my collection.
- 37:42It was, Yes, we have a soul, but it's made of lots
- 37:45of tiny robots. And I thought, that's exactly right. Yes we do
- 37:52have a soul, but it's mechanical, but it's still a soul. It
- 37:57still does the work that the soul was supposed to do. It is the
- 38:01seat of reason, it is the seat of moral responsibility. It's why we
- 38:07are appropriate objects of punishment when we do evil things, why we deserve the
- 38:13praise when we do good things. It's just not a mysterious lump of wonder
- 38:20stuff that will outlive us. Here is an interesting one that I don't think
- 38:28I agree with. And again I've got more quotes coming up in Daniel's voice.
- 38:31This is from Dennett in Breaking the Spell. He said this. Since
- 38:37September eleventh, two thousand and one, I've often thought that perhaps it was
- 38:42fortunate for the world that the attackers targeted the World Trade Center instead of the
- 38:47Statue of Liberty, or if they had destroyed our sacred symbol of democracy,
- 38:55I fear we as Americans would have been unable to keep ourselves from indulging in
- 39:00paroxysms of revenge of a sort the world has never seen before. If that
- 39:07had happened, it would have befouled the meaning of the Statue of Liberty beyond
- 39:12any hope of subsequent redemption, if there were any people left to care.
- 39:17I have learned from my students that this upsetting thought of mine is subject to
- 39:22several unfortunate misconstrules. So let me expand on it to ward them off.
- 39:30The killing of thousands of innocence and the World Trade Center was a heinous crime,
- 39:35much more evil than the destruction of the Statue of Liberty would have been.
- 39:40And yes, the World Trade center was a much more appropriate symbol of
- 39:45al Kada's wrath than the statue of Liberty would have been. But for that
- 39:50very reason, it didn't mean as much as a symbol to us. It
- 39:54was mammon and plutocrats and globalization, not Lady Liberty. I do suspect that
- 40:04the fury with which Americans would have responded to the unspeakable defilement of our cherished
- 40:09national symbol, the purest image of our aspirations as a democracy, would have
- 40:15made a sane and measured response extraordinarily difficult. This is the great danger of
- 40:22symbols. They can become too sacred. An important task for religious people of
- 40:30all faiths in the twenty first century will be spreading the conviction that there are
- 40:36no acts more dishonorable than harming infidels of one stripe or another, for disrespecting
- 40:44a flag across a holy text. Now I get his meeting, and I
- 40:51do agree with eighty five percent of it. We are seeing in this country
- 40:58the deification of symbols. You must stand and salute and say the pledge toward
- 41:05the flag. It is mandated because you are free right. And if you
- 41:10desecrates, if you tear burn whatever the flag you have, become a heretic
- 41:15in a way, you should be burned at the stake. We are creatures
- 41:20who respond to symbols that we have imbued meaning to. Somebody sets a history
- 41:27book on fire, fine, somebody burns a Bible or the Koran, and
- 41:31it's chaos. So I do understand and agree with his position that symbols that
- 41:39we take personally will almost always produce an irrational and sometimes very dangerous response rooted
- 41:47in emotion much more over reason. What I don't necessarily buy is the idea
- 41:54that our response to the World Trade Center wasn't also an irrational emotional response.
- 42:02Remember when the towers fell, everybody was saying, drop the nuke, turn
- 42:07the Middle East to glass. Fuck those people. I mean, that's all
- 42:12we heard. And it was this weird reductive thing where it wasn't just the
- 42:17terrorist, it wasn't just Islamic extremists. We heard people a lot of people
- 42:22saying it's the Muslims, those people practicing idolatry in league with Lucifer who hate
- 42:31America want to burn us to the ground. Let's burn them to the ground
- 42:37first. And the World Trade Center and the Pentagon are symbols, symbols of
- 42:44America and American freedom that people do still take personally. I'll let you discuss
- 42:50this further, but I take as larger point. Maybe we're more in love
- 42:53with the Maybe I'm just jaded. Maybe that's it. I just don't get
- 43:00misty about the freedom icons anymore. Is that just cynicism that comes with age?
- 43:06I don't know. You know, whenever people stand up and put hand
- 43:09over heart and sing, oh beautiful, fool spacious guys right for amber ways
- 43:16of green, and everybody's starting to feel that vibration of America freedom and their
- 43:22bones, and I just tend to throw up a little bit in my mouth.
- 43:29It might just be a me problem. Then. The Statue of Liberty
- 43:32is remarkable, it's lovely, it's beautiful. I'm glad it is there.
- 43:37I hope it represents the best of us. But seeing it does not produce
- 43:42in me the emotional response that Dennett is talking about. Maybe I'm just projecting
- 43:46me instead of assessing correctly the culture itself. What do you think about that?
- 43:53Let me take a short break. I've got more in memoriam. Hang
- 43:59on. We're taking a few minutes this week to remember the late Daniel Dennets,
- 44:09supposedly one of the four horsemen of atheism, and we've talked a little
- 44:15bit about that already. He passed away on the nineteenth of this month.
- 44:20I think there are some who might be worried that we are deifying Daniel Dennet.
- 44:24I do not. I think we listen, we observe, we analyze,
- 44:30we assess, we agree, we disagree. And he said some problematic
- 44:34things. I remember think he went after feminists at one point, and I'm
- 44:38trying to remember exactly what was said. You can elaborate or correct me,
- 44:43but I just it just rang false with me. As we talk about equality
- 44:47for all, and in my own life, I embrace the word. I
- 44:52think the word feminism is just fine. You can call it egalitarianism. But
- 44:55this idea of trying to promote gender equality across the board, I don't think
- 45:00that fight is over. But it's not like I look at Dan and disagree
- 45:05and say screw that guy, because I feel like he brought a lot to
- 45:07the conversation. He was massively involved in something called the Clergy Project. I
- 45:15probably should have mentioned this earlier in the broadcast because it's such a big deal.
- 45:20You may have heard about it, but let me elaborate. This is
- 45:23the creation of a group of pastors secretly atheists, yet they remain in the
- 45:31pulpits wondering, what in the hell am I going to do now? Man?
- 45:37I know that feeling. I work for a job where I was producing
- 45:39videos for mostly churches. At midlife, I think I was pushing forty.
- 45:45What am I going to do if I shouldn't be promoting churches? Because I
- 45:49don't want to do this anymore. But this is my skill set. Where
- 45:52am I going to go? Well? The genesis of the Clergy project takes
- 45:55us back to nineteen eighty four. Now stick with me. I'll try to
- 45:59make this quick. Dan Barker he's the current co president of the Freedom From
- 46:05Religion Foundation, A former evangelical preacher and I mean hardcore Pentecostal speaking in tongue's
- 46:13Bible literalist pastor Dan Barker. But in nineteen eighty four he appeared on Oprah
- 46:20Winfrey's show called Am Chicago. This is before she went global, and Dan
- 46:27came out as an atheist right there on television, and right away he started
- 46:34to get mail from pastors all around the United States who were saying I saw
- 46:40your interview. I can't tell anybody I don't believe either, but I'm still
- 46:45a preacher. I don't know what to do next. I just had to
- 46:49tell somebody. Dan Barker started to compile their stories well. In two thousand
- 46:55and eight, Dan Barker was featured in an article in Psychology Today. It
- 47:00was called an Atheist in the Pulpit. After that went public, more and
- 47:06more mail started coming in. This whole time, Richard Dawkins had been speaking
- 47:13with Daniel Dennett about what might be done with all of this, with the
- 47:17letters, with these poor people, non believing clergy looking for a way out.
- 47:24Now we jumped to twenty ten, qualitative researcher Linda Lascola and Daniel Dennetz
- 47:31helped to fuel and operate a pilot study called Preachers who Are Not Believers.
- 47:37That study included many of the folks who had originally sent letters to Dan Barker.
- 47:44So it's all starting to come together. The full scope of this research
- 47:50project would culminate in a book released in twenty thirteen called Caught in the Pulpit,
- 47:55Leaving Belief Behind, and around that time, actually just a bit earlier,
- 48:01the Clergy Project was formed pastors who reached out and went through a strenuous
- 48:09vetting process to make sure they weren't fakes or moles trying to rat out their
- 48:15fellow pastors by pretending there was a very intensive background check. The Clergy Project
- 48:22that first had like fifty pastors involved, and today it has hundreds and hundreds
- 48:30and hundreds of people who are still preachers, and yet they are atheists desperate
- 48:37to find a way out. Clergyproject dot org, and don't be hard on
- 48:46these people. I know what it's like to feel like you're financially held hostage.
- 48:52Many of these pastors would talk about how their own sermons changed. Instead
- 48:57of Adam and Eve and Noah's Ark and Moses and the Exodus and the Nativity
- 49:02story and Jesus on the Cross and Heaven and Hell, they were preaching more
- 49:07about good people doing good things, embracing the moments, kind of a humanistic
- 49:14thing. They were preaching humanism, and they were slowly starting to take all
- 49:19of the magic and all of the literal Bible dogma, etc. And they
- 49:23were just sort of taking it and suddenly sweeping it out, hoping nobody else
- 49:28would notice. They became motivational speakers in a way, and their sermons reflected
- 49:32that, afraid to tell their peers what happens if you're a pastor and you
- 49:38go, hey, Bob, I don't think I buy any of this anymore.
- 49:44And then Bob tells the church board or the religious organization, which is
- 49:50the umbrella for the denomination, and you find yourself on the street with no
- 49:54options. Clergyproject dot org is a re for them, and Daniel Dennett was
- 50:02a big part of it. What about consciousness? There was a Google talk
- 50:09that Daniel Dennett did about ten years ago. We talked about things called intuition
- 50:15pumps and other tools for thinking, and these were his thoughts on consciousness.
- 50:22I think the consciousness is like reproduction and metabolism and self repair, healing,
- 50:30blood clotting. It's a very interestingly complex and deeply recursive biological phenomenon. It
- 50:37is not in the interesting sense. And there's many senses of consciousness, in
- 50:43the sense that we in this rumor consciousness, which is this sort of anchoring
- 50:47its home base from our own experience and our reading of literature. You know,
- 50:52we read novels and things like that. We have this sense of what
- 50:54a conscious life is like I think we're the only creatures that have that kind
- 51:00of conscious life. I don't think dogs have it. I don't think dolphins
- 51:02have it. They're sentient, they're awake, they feel pain, but they
- 51:07don't have most of what makes human consciousness so important. And I think that
- 51:14that phenomenon is in the end software, and I think it has to be
- 51:20installed. I think so it is an implication of my view. And don't
- 51:25try this at home, don't test this that if a human baby could be
- 51:30raised entirely without any interaction with other human beings, have cut off from language,
- 51:35if it could grow to adulthood without benefit of all the thinking tools that
- 51:38would normally be installed in the course of just growing up in a social community,
- 51:44I think that human being would have a mind so profoundly different from ours
- 51:49that we would all pretty well agree it wasn't he or she wasn't really conscious.
- 51:54Now that may be a very eccentric notion of consciousness, but if you're
- 52:00wanting to know do I think that if you look for a better notion of
- 52:04consciousness, or one that isn't so eccentric, and you start thinking about what
- 52:07it is, you know the capacity to experience color and flavor, and to
- 52:12have quality, as philosophers say, I think that's all pretty badly confused,
- 52:16and I've tried to say how and why over the years, But part of
- 52:21what makes it confusing is that people want consciousness to be, to use a
- 52:27technical term, super califragilistic xpialidocious. And if you're not talking about something that
- 52:35is super califragilistic xpialidocious, they think you're not talking about consciousness. And there's
- 52:42a quote my friend Lee Siegel is a philosopher and a magician, a very
- 52:45fine stage magician, wrote a wonderful book on Indian street magic called Net of
- 52:51Magic, and there's a passage in there I love to quote and he says,
- 52:54I tell my friends I'm writing a book on magic, and they ask,
- 52:58do you mean real magic? And by real magic they mean pharmaturgical acts
- 53:05and so forth, And he says, no, not real magic, sleight
- 53:08of hands, you know, stage magic. And then he goes out and
- 53:12says, in other words, the kind of magic you can actually do is
- 53:16not real magic. Real magic is the kind of doesn't exist. Interesting that
- 53:25Daniel Dennet would often talk about, and I agree with this, by the
- 53:30way that the majority of people who say they believe in God actually believe in
- 53:37belief. This is Daniel Dennett interviewed on the Science Network May fifteenth, two
- 53:43thousand and nine. I guess it's my favorite chapter in the book is about
- 53:46belief and belief. I began to notice that arguing against the existence of God
- 53:52is sort of pointless in most circumstances, because it's not so much that people
- 53:57believe in God as they believe in belief in God. And in fact,
- 54:00more people believe in belief in God than believe in God. How do I
- 54:05know that, Well, with very few exceptions, people who actually believe in
- 54:10God also believe and belief in God. That is, they think it's a
- 54:13good thing. They are all for it. They're proud of the fact that
- 54:15they believe in God. They think it's good. Once in a while you
- 54:21will encounter somebody who actually deeply, bitterly regrets the fact that they can't shake
- 54:25their belief in God. They wish they could, but they're just it's a
- 54:29weakness. That's a rare individual. So all those people believe in belief in
- 54:34God, and then the people who don't believe in God, they believe many
- 54:37of them just believe in belief in God. So there's more all told.
- 54:40And the more I thought about it, the more I explore this, I
- 54:44discovered how true that is. For instance, I would say, with few
- 54:47exceptions, the most hysterical and vitriolic criticisms of my book have been from people
- 54:55who themselves declare themselves not religious, they don't need them life, but they
- 55:00are the self appointed defenders of religion, and they believe in belief in God,
- 55:07and they view me as mounting an attack on this, and in a
- 55:12way that I am. I'm saying the belief and belief in God is what
- 55:15is really standing in the way. It's what's doing all the work today,
- 55:20and let's do one more to finish us off today. On the question of
- 55:23a universe that has no meaning, and I've heard this from apologists, So
- 55:28if you don't believe in God, how could you have any purpose? If
- 55:31the universe doesn't care? Why bother Daniel Dennett's thoughts on that. There's two
- 55:37ways of looking at it. There's the old fashioned way, which is the
- 55:40trickle down theory of meaning. Our lives can't have meaning unless we are the
- 55:45lesser products of something. Even more meaningful than we are God. We're God's
- 55:51creations, God's army, God's tools, God's toys, God's playthings. That's
- 55:57what gives us meaning. We inherit it from the big The other way of
- 56:01looking at it is the bubble up theory of meaning, which says the universe
- 56:06starts off without any meaning and there really is no point to it, but
- 56:09it's possible for life to evolve, and it does, and we eventually show
- 56:15up, and we are meaning makers and we care. Initially, we just
- 56:22care because that comes along with our instincts as part of our biology. But
- 56:28as we think and reflect and care, things being to matter more to us,
- 56:32and what could be more important than the things that matter the most to
- 56:37us? That's who we are. And we can meet in rational exploration and
- 56:45mutual persuasion and decide, here are the things that are really important? Do
- 56:50we all agree? Now, maybe there's always going to be a few outliers,
- 56:52people that just don't get the point of it or think go their own
- 56:57way, well, okay, as long as they don't hurt us. But
- 57:00pretty much there's agreement about what ought to be done, what a good life
- 57:04is, what a good life for others is there's always rooms for improvement once
- 57:07you've got that, and that's homegrown ethics. It's not an edict from on
- 57:15high. You don't have to be told by an eternal being what's right and
- 57:19wrong. You figure out what right and wrong is, then you're motivated to
- 57:23act on this. And I look around the world and see so many wonderful
- 57:29things that I love and enjoy and am the beneficiary of, whether it's art
- 57:32or music, or medicine or clothing and food and all the rest. I'd
- 57:37like to add a little to that. That's the way that rather than thanking
- 57:40God is non existent benefactor, the way to thank the human beings that created
- 57:47all this is to create a little bit more if I can, and add
- 57:52to the goodness in the world. Daniel Dannet born on the twenty eighth of
- 57:57March nineteen forty two, assed away on April the nineteenth, twenty twenty four,
- 58:04at the age of eighty two. Go out there and spread some goodness,
- 58:09make some meaning, and thank you for listening. Follow The Thinking Atheist
- 58:15on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos. Products like
- 58:21mugs and t shirts featuring The Thinking Atheist logo links to atheist pages and resources,
- 58:25and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 58:31Thethinkingatheist dot com.