Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #221 - Minister Rob Fleming / City Councillor Christine Boyle / Dr. Gail Anderson
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Moameir and this is Van Color,
- 0:20British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight, we're asking
- 0:25why does this keep happening? We're going to look at the never ending cycle
- 0:29of encampments and decampments of unhoused people in Vancouver. We're going to look at
- 0:34why human feet keep washing up on BC shores. And of course we're going
- 0:39to look at commercial trucks hitting overpasses in BC, costing taxpayers millions, delaying
- 0:45commuters, impeding first responders and putting public safety at risk. Why does this
- 0:50keep happening? Here to explain is the BCNDP MLA for Victoria Swan Lake and
- 0:56BC's Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure, Minister Raw Fleming. Minister Fleming on and
- 1:02honor, thanks for being here tonight, Thanks for having me. So I
- 1:04feel like every British Columbian every time that they open up the newspaper or watch
- 1:08you know, the news hour, they see a story about a commercial truck
- 1:12hitting road infrastructure, usually overpasses, particularly in the Lower Mainland. So answer
- 1:19the big question, why does this keep happening? Well, if the question
- 1:23is what is the excuse. The answer is there isn't one, you know,
- 1:26not any good ones. It's never been easier, quite frankly, to
- 1:30get a permit for an overheight load that is being transported around our region,
- 1:36around our province. It's never been easier to measure that load with digital tools.
- 1:41Right, there's apps and there's GPS. They can map out their routes.
- 1:44Right. There are things today that didn't exist five ten years ago that
- 1:48make it immeasurably easier. You know, one explanation may be the volume of
- 1:53commercial traffic in British Columbia. Obviously that has gone up as the province says
- 2:00increased in population and as our supply chains have become even more important to the
- 2:05rest of Canada. You know, we have the busiest port here in Metro
- 2:07Vancouver. In fact, it's volumes are larger than all the other parts in
- 2:12Canada combined together. But again that doesn't explain it either. So we're looking
- 2:19for explanations through data. We're the only province that's keeping data on infrastructure collisions.
- 2:25But we're also working really closely with the BC Trucking Association and other industry
- 2:30partners because they're fed up with it just as much as you know, people
- 2:34trying to get home from a long day at work or trying to get to
- 2:37a show or wherever they're going to go. There's stock in congestion that should
- 2:39never have happened because you know, in an overpass so unique to British Columbia.
- 2:44Or are we seeing this in other places around the world or in North
- 2:46America. We're definitely seeing it in other parts of Canada, and in fact,
- 2:51we're leading a national discussion. Now we're number one, right, well,
- 2:54we could be. We're the only one that actually tracks it. So
- 2:57it's hard to say, but I mean, if you to surf the headlines
- 3:00and look at cities like Winnipeg and Saskatoon, they've had some high profile accidents
- 3:04recently that have done the same kind of damage that we've experienced in places like
- 3:08Delta and North Vancouver, and some of those high profile incidents recently in Metro
- 3:14Vancouver. We've got to be very surgical about this though. This is a
- 3:19small problem causing an outsized headache for everybody. Sure, there are about one
- 3:23hundred thousand truck movements every day in British Columbia. That's about three million a
- 3:27month, thirty six million a year if you want to do the math.
- 3:30And we've had thirty collisions of concern in the last two years. So it's
- 3:35a tiny fraction of the industry that is irresponsible, that is not measuring twice
- 3:39or deviating from roots that were approved based on the permit they have. Again,
- 3:45there's no excuses though, because it's never been easier to transport that cargo
- 3:49safely. So this is why the trucking industry wants to crack down too.
- 3:53I mean, normally you think they would stand together, but their drivers are
- 3:55losing money, their journees are losing business by being stuck in the same traffic
- 4:01that you and I are when something like this occurs. So we are working
- 4:05very collaboratively with again the VC Trucking Association, and we've said, look,
- 4:10we've got to come down hard on this. We've got to make it really,
- 4:12really expensive. We've got to you know, have the highest dis incentives
- 4:16possible. We now have the highest finds in Canada. And how big are
- 4:19those fines down They're not big enough or five and forty five dollars, So
- 4:24they've quintupled, you know, since a month ago. But we may take
- 4:30them higher. We're working on that. That will require amendments to legislation.
- 4:35More important, though than fines, are a new tool that we've developed for
- 4:39ourselves that I announced in December, which is grounding an entire fleet where there's
- 4:44a significant safety concern based on one incident. So we have a couple of
- 4:47trucking companies right now that are under suspension. They cannot move a single thing
- 4:51in BC while a safety investigation is going on, which can take some weeks.
- 4:56And obviously that runs into you know, huge dollars of per day.
- 5:00Sure that sends out the strongest message, a lot stronger than fines could.
- 5:03But touching on fines, I mean, some of the damage that's costs that
- 5:08that that ends up being incurred is like millions of dollars. But then you're
- 5:11talking about, you know, a couple hundred dollars for a fine. Why
- 5:14can't there be a system where if a trucking company is responsible, they have
- 5:17to pay the cost of repair or their insurance has to pay the cost of
- 5:21repair. Why can't we have that because I think there are just a lot
- 5:25of British Clumbans that are really frustrated by being put at risk on the roads.
- 5:29British Columbians shouldn't be you know, paying for it, paying for it
- 5:32twice. They built the infrastructure and then paying to repair it. And we
- 5:36do go after aggressively recoveries from third party insurers for sure. So we've got
- 5:42files open on all the cases that you know that we that we've been discussing
- 5:45here, and you know, we do make recoveries. Having said that,
- 5:49it's still an economic cost to the reliability of our transportation network to you know,
- 5:55the cost of everyone's time. You know, I mentioned other trucks waiting
- 5:59and and commuters getting to and from work, but you know, think of
- 6:01contractors and workers getting to and from a job site, you know, lost
- 6:05time, all of that. So that's why it needs to stop. It's
- 6:10entirely preventable. Again, we've invested time, resources, money into creating tools
- 6:15that make it really simple. But we have some high profile incidents where you
- 6:18know, there's there's still a couple of outlier careless drivers causing havoc on the
- 6:25roads. When an incident like this happens, how does the investigation process start,
- 6:30Like do you go to the trucking company and say, hey, did
- 6:31you actually map out the routes that you were supposed to take. How did
- 6:34this end? Like? Is there an investigation that takes place? There are
- 6:38generally by two agencies. The Ministry Transportation has the Commercial Vehicle Safety Enforcement Unit,
- 6:44so they run all the truck truckway stations, they do mobile enforcement throughout
- 6:48the province, and of course the RCMP or a municipal police force who are
- 6:53usually first to attend the scene of an accident. The investigation looks at the
- 6:58vehicle, looks at the conditions, looks at the damage, and looks at
- 7:01the safety record of the carrier, looks at the driver's driving record. Those
- 7:05sorts of things may make arrests based on that. That was my next question.
- 7:11At what point does this negligence become criminal? That's based on the investigation.
- 7:15If there's a determination that the negligence was in fact criminal, then you
- 7:19know the RCMP will continue that investigation and forward to Crown Council potentially, And
- 7:26the CVS investigation is really around you know, is there a public safety concern
- 7:30from a company? Is there a pattern of a company or a particular driver
- 7:35being involved in multiple accidents and you know there are there consequences that flow from
- 7:43that either loss of license, suspension of the carrier's license, or even the
- 7:46entire safety certificate. You know, they it's a privileged to drive here.
- 7:50To get that safety certificate requires you to take on a number of obligations to
- 7:56protect each and every one of us that's on the roads, and if they've
- 7:59violated the terms of that safety certificate, it can be pulled, and we've
- 8:03said very clearly it will be pulled. Yeah, you said that your ministry
- 8:07does conduct these investigations. So is there a common thread in these truck accidents
- 8:13that we're seeing in terms of why they happened? The common thread right now
- 8:16is it's you know, there are thousands and thousands of commercial trucking companies in
- 8:20DC. There are perhaps a dozen or two dozen that are involved in this.
- 8:26So, oh okay, the data is telling us that it's so these
- 8:28are repeat offenders, repeat offenders, to use the words of your opposition,
- 8:33Yeah, well yeah, Often it's the same company involved in multiple collisions with
- 8:39our infrastructure, and in some cases it may be the same driver, the
- 8:43same driver. We've we've we're looking for all those kinds of patterns because what
- 8:48we want to do is basically protect the pride and professionalism and reputation of the
- 8:54ninety nine point nine nine nine percent of drivers who you know, work safely,
- 9:00sure, proud of their work, go out each and every day,
- 9:01drive in very difficult conditions that you and I would probably be a little bit
- 9:05afraid to do. You know, they're absolutely yeah. There are people driving
- 9:09over the Cocahlla right now, you know, and putting it chaining up and
- 9:11doing it safely and working in adverse weather conditions. BC has incredible topography that
- 9:16makes for very difficult driving conditions. That's why we brought in the toughest licensing
- 9:22requirements in the country. We have a new mandatory entry level training program for
- 9:24all new entrance into the commercial driving industry. We've taken a couple of other
- 9:30steps too. We know that speed can be a contributing factor in these collisions.
- 9:33So starting in April, basically there's a factory installed speed limiter in every
- 9:39truck engine and the tops beedle max out one hundred and five plins. Well,
- 9:45minister, I know that this has caused you a lot of headaches,
- 9:46but I appreciate your efforts and hopefully reversing this trend of trucks hitting over passes.
- 9:52Thank you so much for your time tonight. I'd love to be back
- 9:54on his show and love to not be talking about this. Absolutely can't wait
- 9:56for it and keep working on that. We'll do that. Thank you so
- 9:58much, Thank you, folks. That's BC's Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure,
- 10:03Rob Fleming. Now after some business. Anytime the City of Vancouver DeCamps unhoused
- 10:07people from a park or street, a new encampment pops up somewhere else in
- 10:13the city, and this endless cycle has repeated itself for years? Why does
- 10:16this keep happening? Instead of looking for more permanent solutions? A Vancouver City
- 10:20Councilor will explain up next. Welcome back to this as Van Color, our
- 10:31featured guest tonight returns to the show to explain the City of Vancouver's inhumane cycle
- 10:37of decamping unhoused people, then decamping them again when they set up a new
- 10:41encampment somewhere else. As this whole cycle has been on repeat seemingly for years,
- 10:46why does this keep happening? Here to explain is Vancouver City councilor representing
- 10:50one city Vancouver. She is Christine Boyle, and this conversation is supported by
- 10:56shelter Point single Malt Whiskey, distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely shelter Point, So
- 11:05Christine. This month we saw Oppenheimer Park basically be decamped in a cold streak
- 11:11in the winter. Last year we saw Hastings Street be decamped, And there
- 11:16just seems to be this game of displacing unhoused people without any permanent solutions.
- 11:22They DeCamp them one place, and then they encamp somewhere else, and then
- 11:24they DeCamp them from there. So why does this keep happening now? The
- 11:28first thing to say is that it keeps happening because there aren't enough homes.
- 11:33There aren't enough homes across the whole spectrum, but especially for low income people.
- 11:39So people are living in tents and on the street because they don't have
- 11:45a safe, stable place to call home. So then why is the city
- 11:50displacing them if there's nowhere for them to go? Yeah, it's a great
- 11:54question. We know that people have nowhere else to go, and we keep
- 12:00shuffling them around. And one of the things we hear so clearly from advocates
- 12:05is that even though most of us think that it understand that an encampment is
- 12:11not an ideal living situation. It's still safer for a lot of people and
- 12:16for a lot of reasons than being shuffled into more secluded and isolated spaces in
- 12:22an encampment. There's still some community and people checking in with one another,
- 12:26an ability for health supports and social supports to make those connections that help move
- 12:31people into into housing or into recovery or the services and supports that they need.
- 12:39So encampments are not a long term solution. And also, if we
- 12:48keep just shuffling people around, we're making the situation worse and potentially fatal.
- 12:52So you sit on city council, there didn't seem to be any indication to
- 12:58the public that this was going to happen. It wasn't explained why it's happening
- 13:01in this cold snap of the winter. I mean, we had sub zero
- 13:05temperatures. Why wasn't there any proactive communication even to the public as to the
- 13:09reasoning behind this latest encampment in Oppenheimer Park. So it's true, I got
- 13:15no advance noticed that this was happening. I heard about it when my phone
- 13:18started blowing up with messages from really from community leaders and housing advocates saying,
- 13:28you know, wtf is happening here and what are we going to do about
- 13:31it? I think the question that should be put to the mayor and the
- 13:35ABC majority again and again is what's the plan. You know, we've been
- 13:41in office a year and a bit and as you outlined, there have been
- 13:46two major decampments and people just keep coming back because they have nowhere to go.
- 13:52So what is Mayor sim what is ABC putting on the table that brings
- 13:58us out of this cycle? Just want to be clear, you're saying that
- 14:01even you're not aware of why this decampment happened when it happened, the Oppenheimer
- 14:07Park one that we saw this month. I'm not The bilog exists that allows
- 14:11park rangers to ask people to take down their tents during the day so that
- 14:16parks can be used by a whole range of park users. But the timing
- 14:22of this decampment in the midst of a horrible cold snap was rightly infuriating to
- 14:31so many people, myself included. I know the Mayor and I have gone
- 14:33back and forth in this. We've had the tie's Jen Saint Dennis talking about
- 14:37the Hastings Street decampment, and there seems to be this conflict about whether or
- 14:41not there was enough shelter space for these displaced folks to go to or at
- 14:45least to sleep at night, in the case of Oppenheimer Park. From your
- 14:48understanding, was there enough shelter space mixed reviews is what I hear. I've
- 14:52been asking for the numbers. We know a number of the warming centers were
- 14:56at capacity during this cold snap. We had additional shelter beds opening, but
- 15:03a number of them were full. And it also becomes a challenge of where
- 15:07people can get to and where they what fits their needs, whether they have
- 15:11a pet or they have some belongings they need to bring with them. The
- 15:16long term solution needs to have a lot more options that meet people's specific needs
- 15:20and allow them to get back on their feet, and that's what we're severely
- 15:26lacking. And I think the reason this is important is people die in these
- 15:28extreme weather events. Yeah, it's absolutely a question of life or death,
- 15:35particularly in the weather that we have been seeing, and there's no there.
- 15:39We can't keep this cycle up and expect something to change. We have to
- 15:43put those solutions on the table. We need to create that housing. We
- 15:48need options for people to move into, so let's talk solutions. I know
- 15:52you're not in the majority in Vancouver City Council, but if you had your
- 15:56way, what are the solutions that Vancouver City Council needs to work towards to
- 16:00make sure that this cycle stops. First of all, we need to stop
- 16:04making of worse and so last July, I brought a motion forward to counsel
- 16:08asking that we renew leases on temporary modular housing so that we don't see more
- 16:15people lose their housing and move into homelessness. It seemed like a bare minimum
- 16:22that we could do as a council, totally in our refection. Yeah,
- 16:25let's keep the housing that we have. Well, we work to build more
- 16:29housing. Mayor Simon and the ABC majority voted it down, which I truly
- 16:33cannot explain to you. I was shocked by that. They will say they
- 16:41want permanent housing, not temporary housing, but that permanent housing isn't immediate and
- 16:47in the meantime we need now, we need to keep the housing we have
- 16:52so that new housing adds to the units and we're not just shuffling people around.
- 16:56So that's one. I also have spent years fighting to make it faster
- 17:00and easier to build non market housing, including social and supportive housing. And
- 17:07there's so many examples that come up in the public realm where you hear on
- 17:11the North Shore or in Vancouver, days and days weeks of public hearings for
- 17:18badly needed affordable housing. It's a broken system, and we at the local
- 17:25government level can help fix it in preapproving that housing or dramatically speeding it up
- 17:32which brings those homes online faster. It also saves a lot of money that
- 17:36can go into deepening affordability in that housing. And so I have twice brought
- 17:41forward that motion to City Hall. Failed on the last council, it got
- 17:48passed, but slowed down on this council, and it clearly isn't a priority
- 17:52for ABC because we haven't seen any tangible Wow. Yeah, well, Mayor
- 17:56sim does say that he's a processed guy, he's a black belt and lean,
- 17:59so hopefully he reconsiders. Christine, thank you so much for your time
- 18:02tonight. Thanks for having me folks representing one city Vancouver. She is Vancouver
- 18:07City Councilor Christine Boyle. Thank you to Shelter Point, Single Malt Whiskey for
- 18:11supporting local conversations. Now, did you know that BC has a morbid history
- 18:15of human feet in shoes just washing up on beaches. Why does this keep
- 18:22happening? We'll talk about it up next. Welcome back to this is van
- 18:33color. Severed human feet keep washing up on British Columbian shores, so much
- 18:38so that it has garnered international attention from Vox, The Guardian, CNN,
- 18:44NPR, and many others. So why does this keep happening and what exactly
- 18:48is happening? Beaming in to explain is a forensic entomologist and a professor in
- 18:53the School of Criminology at my alma mater, Simon Fraser University. She is
- 18:59doctor Gail Anderson. Doctor Anderson, thank you so much for being here tonight.
- 19:03Hi, thank you for having me. So Since two thousand and seven,
- 19:07sixteen severed human feet have washed ashore BC beaches, including as lately as
- 19:14August twenty twenty three. Why does this keep happening? Well, actually it
- 19:18doesn't. They're not severed feet. Seven feet suggest they've been cut off.
- 19:22They haven't. They've just disarticulated naturally when the body decomposes. There's a lot
- 19:29of animals involve this decomposition, and the body completely disarticulates. But what happens
- 19:34when you've got running shoes, and remember all of these are in running shoes.
- 19:38The foot gets encased, usually in the sock and then the shoe and
- 19:42the rest of the body decomposes, disarticulates from the ankle and then becomes separated.
- 19:48A running shoe is a floating device, so it's washed ashore. So
- 19:52those scavenging animals then don't go after the foot because it's protected by the sock
- 19:56and the running shoe exactly that it's last bit they're going to get to because
- 20:00it's got quite a close sock on it and then a running shoe. And
- 20:03what happens to tissue when it's in a kind of a wet environment with a
- 20:07low oxygen is it becomes adapacia tissue. This is the adipose tissue changing over
- 20:12into almost like a soapy material and pretty much nothing eats that interesting. So
- 20:18are these feats identified? Are they missing people? Like? What is happening
- 20:22here? I think all of them have been identified, usually with DNA to
- 20:27people who are related to them and who have donated their DNA for that kind
- 20:32of identification. I believe all have been identified. Is it foul play,
- 20:37though, is it what is usually the case with these folks who are whose
- 20:41feet are being washed up on BC shores. My understanding from the Corner's reports
- 20:45is that none of them have been considered foul play. They're all either accidental,
- 20:49natural, or suicidal deaths. Is this a phenomenon that we see anywhere
- 20:56else in the world or is there something particular about the Pacific Northwest that we
- 20:59see this on a periodic basis. I gather it's found all over the world
- 21:03where you've got water. I remember when the first ones were washed ashore.
- 21:07I had a visiting scientist from I think it was New Zealand at the time,
- 21:11and they said, oh, yeah, we get those all the time.
- 21:14I think we get quite a lot because of the configuration of the island
- 21:17and the mainland and that waterway in there. So they're more likely to get
- 21:21washed ashore and found on a beach that somebody might be looking at, versus
- 21:26if they were you know, say, the other side of other side of
- 21:29Vancouver or island, or further down the coast peraps where there isn't such a
- 21:33sort of barrier. So, just to be clear, these are not like
- 21:37unsolved mysteries or things that don't really have an explanation. No, unfortunately,
- 21:41fortunately they're not mysteries, but unfortunately they are very sad cases in which people
- 21:47have died and been lost in the water. Doctor Anderson, I appreciate you
- 21:52explaining this very bizarre phenomenon and I guess it does make sense once you actually
- 21:56go through it. So thank you so much for your time tonight. You're
- 22:00welcome. Thank you folks, that's our show. Thank you so much to
- 22:03doctor Gail Anderson, Vancouver City Councilor Christine Boyle, and BC Minister of Transportation
- 22:10Rob Fleming for their time tonight. We will be back next week. In
- 22:12the meantime, please find me on x TikTok at Van Color. Of course,
- 22:18this is Van color, and I'm moamir telling you that in a province
- 22:22where you can be anything, be colorful. Peace.