Latest / Two Talking Fools Podcast / 15-Minute Deep Dive: What Really Happened at Three Mile Island
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome back to the late-night madness on W fool radio,
- 0:08You tune into the only show where chaos comes complimentary the only duo break.
- 0:38We are just two average, and I mean average girls, taking their phone calls to the podcast.
- 0:45Hey, guys, welcome back to Talking Fools. We've been doing this for about two
- 0:49years now, two years in July, close to 200 episodes, streaming all over the
- 0:54world, fans all over the world.
- 0:57It's pretty amazing. So welcome back. Got a lot of exciting things coming down
- 1:02the pipeline, both community projects and worldwide global things going on for
- 1:07our listeners out there.
- 1:08So we've slightly changed temporarily the podcast format and layout just in the sense that we're.
- 1:19Just trying we're testing we're testing shorter podcasts 15 minutes 13 minutes
- 1:2418 minutes 10 minutes and it seems like you guys love that and I understand
- 1:29why because we're the generation of we can't settle into something too, too long.
- 1:36Everything's busy. So it seems like the shorter form content's pretty great.
- 1:41So today, with everything I just said, I want to do a deep dive today into Three Mile Island, okay?
- 1:49One of the most famous nuclear incidents in our history, in American history.
- 1:55And I want to get into that today.
- 1:58Now, for the record, I'm not sure.
- 2:02When I was talking to my sister, the nuclear that was going to be coming potentially
- 2:06set to come to our town, that was back in the early 90s.
- 2:10And, you know, obviously Three Mile Island, that's going back even further.
- 2:15I'm not sure if there's any correlation or not.
- 2:17It's hard to do a lot of research when it's hard to get newspaper articles and such.
- 2:22But let's talk about Three Mile Island.
- 2:25Even people who know very little about nuclear energy have heard the name,
- 2:29and it has become almost symbolic of nuclear fear in the United States.
- 2:34But what is fascinating is that when you really look into the details,
- 2:38the story is so much more complicated than most people even realize.
- 2:43The accident involved mechanical failures, confusing control systems,
- 2:48human interpretation errors, and a massive wave of public fear fueled by the media.
- 2:54And today we're going to walk through the entire timeline, what nuclear power
- 2:58looked like in the 70s, exactly what happened on March 28, 1979,
- 3:05the statistics behind the accident, and what the site looks like today,
- 3:09more than four decades later.
- 3:12To understand Three Mile Island, we first need to understand the nuclear energy
- 3:17boom of the 1960s and the 1970s.
- 3:20At the time, nuclear power was widely considered the future of electricity.
- 3:24By 1979, the United States had more than 70 operating nuclear reactors and over
- 3:31100 additional reactors either plant or under construction.
- 3:37Nuclear plants produced enormous amounts of electricity used,
- 3:41using uranium fuel rods.
- 3:44A single uranium fuel pellet about the size of a fingertip contains the same
- 3:49amount of energy as roughly one ton of coal, or about 150 gallons of oil.
- 3:56Because nuclear plants produce electricity without burning fossil fuels,
- 4:01they were seen as a way to reduce air pollution and dependence on imported oil.
- 4:06By the late 1970s, nuclear plants were producing about 12% of America's electricity,
- 4:13and that number was expected to rise dramatically.
- 4:17Three Mile Island is located in the,
- 4:22Susquehanna River near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.
- 4:26The site had two reactors, Unit 1 and Unit 2. Unit 1 began operating in 1974.
- 4:34Unit 2 began operating in late 1978, just months before the accident.
- 4:40Each reactor produced roughly 900 megawatts of electricity, enough power for
- 4:47hundreds of thousands of homes.
- 4:50Like most nuclear reactors in the United States, the plant used what's called
- 4:55a pressurized water reactor design.
- 4:58This type of reactor relies on water both to cool the reactor core and to transfer
- 5:04heat to steam turbines that generate electricity.
- 5:09Cooling is absolutely critical. Without constant cooling, the water circulating
- 5:15through the system, temperatures in the reactor can rise extremely quickly.
- 5:20The morning of March 28, 1979, at approximately 4 a.m., a series of small mechanical
- 5:30problems began unfolding inside Unit 2.
- 5:34A pump responsible for supplying water to the steam generators shut down unexpectedly.
- 5:42The loss of that pump caused the reactor to automatically shut down in a process
- 5:47known as SCRAM, S-C-R-A-M.
- 5:52Control rods dropped into the reactor core and halted the nuclear chain reaction.
- 5:58That part of the safety system worked exactly as intended.
- 6:03However, shutting down the reactor caused pressure inside the system to rise.
- 6:09To relieve that pressure, a valve known as the pilot-operated relief valve opened.
- 6:16The problem was that the valve became stuck-opened, and the control room instruments
- 6:22incorrectly showed that it had closed.
- 6:25Because the valve remained opened, cooling water slowly escaped from the reactor system.
- 6:31But the operators in the control room believed the system was still sealed.
- 6:37Over the next several hours, coolant levels inside the reactor dropped.
- 6:43And as coolant levels fell, temperatures inside the reactor core began rising dramatically.
- 6:51At one point, the plant's emergency core cooling system automatically activated
- 6:56to restore water levels.
- 6:59However, because of confusing instrument readings, operators believed the reactor
- 7:04actually had too much water.
- 7:07So they manually reduced the emergency cooling flow, a decision that allowed
- 7:11the reactor core to overheat.
- 7:14Inside the reactor, temperatures eventually rose high enough to damage the nuclear fuel.
- 7:20Roughly half of their reactor core had melted.
- 7:24This event is known as a partial meltdown.
- 7:28Fortunately, the reactor was enclosed inside a massive contaminant building
- 7:33made of steel and concrete.
- 7:35These contaminant structures are designed specifically to prevent radioactive
- 7:40material from escaping into the environment.
- 7:43At Three Mile Island, the contaminant system performed exactly as designed and
- 7:49prevented a much larger disaster.
- 7:53During the accident, another unexpected problem appeared.
- 7:58Chemical reactions inside the overheated reactor produced hydrogen gas.
- 8:04A hydrogen bubble formed inside the reactor vessel.
- 8:08Hydrogen gas can be explosive, so scientists worried that the bubble might ignite
- 8:13and cause a catastrophic explosion.
- 8:16For several days, the entire country watched the news wondering if the plant might explode.
- 8:22Eventually, engineers determined the bubbles were stable and unlikely to ignite.
- 8:29Despite relatively low radiation releases, public fear spread quickly.
- 8:35Within days, approximately 140,000 people voluntarily evacuated the surrounding region.
- 8:42Schools closed and highways became crowded with people leaving the area.
- 8:47The governor of Pennsylvania recommended that pregnant women and young children
- 8:51temporarily evacuate as a precaution.
- 8:55Another factor amplified the panic. Just days before the accident,
- 8:59a movie called The China Syndrome had been released.
- 9:03The film told the fictional story of a nuclear reactor meltdown.
- 9:08The timing made the accident feel eerily similar to the movie.
- 9:14Now, despite the meltdown, the amount of radiation released was relatively small.
- 9:19The average radiation exposure for nearby residents was one millerum.
- 9:25For context, the average American receives about 300 millirem of radiation each
- 9:32year from natural background sources like cosmic rays, soil, and even certain foods.
- 9:39A chest x-ray exposes a person to about 10 millirem.
- 9:43In other words, the radiation exposed from the Three Mile Island accident was
- 9:49lower than many common medical procedures.
- 9:53Long-term studies conducted by federal and state health agencies found no clear
- 9:58increase in cancer rates in the surrounding population.
- 10:02The cleanup of Unit 2 became one of the most complex nuclear cleanup operations ever performed.
- 10:09The process lasted from 1979 until 1993, roughly 14 years.
- 10:16During the cleanup, more than 100 tons of damaged nuclear fuel was removed.
- 10:24Thousands of tons of contaminated water were filtered and treated.
- 10:30Radioactive waste was shipped to long-term storage facilities.
- 10:35The total cost of cleanup was approximately $1 billion.
- 10:40Even though the physical impact of the accident was limited,
- 10:44the political impact was enormous.
- 10:46Public trust in the nuclear power dropped sharply.
- 10:50Construction of nuclear plants slowed dramatically across the United States.
- 10:55Regulators introduced stricter safety requirements and new training programs for reactor operators.
- 11:05The accident also led to the creation of the Institute of Nuclear Power Operations,
- 11:09an organization dedicated to improving nuclear safety and oversight.
- 11:15Three-mile island today still sits quietly along the Suquhanna River.
- 11:23The damaged Unit 2 reactor remains sealed and permanently shut down.
- 11:28Unit 1 continued to produce electricity until 2019 when it closed due to economic
- 11:34pressures from cheaper natural gas energy.
- 11:37But most of the radioactive material from the accident has been removed.
- 11:42The site is monitored, but largely inactive.
- 11:47For more than 40 years later, the Three Mile Island accident remains one of
- 11:53the most studied industrial accidents in history.
- 11:56It demonstrated how complex technology, human decisions, and confusing information
- 12:01can combine to create a crisis, but it also proves something important.
- 12:06Nuclear containment systems can work.
- 12:10The lessons learned from Three Mile Island reshaped nuclear safety around the world.
- 12:16And so I want to bring it to you guys. What would you do or how do you feel about nuclear?
- 12:24And if you don't live near a nuclear plant or a nuclear containment facility, would you feel okay?
- 12:32Would you feel nervous living by one or would you feel totally, totally fine?
- 12:40It's funny, you don't hear so much about it today, except for the like Three
- 12:43Mile Island, you hear about Chernobyl, but you don't hear about things like
- 12:47this too, too much today.
- 12:50Just another interesting thing, right out of Pennsylvania, and the funny thing
- 12:54is, when we talk to people, a lot of people have never heard of Three Mile Island.
- 13:00But there's a documentary out that you can watch, and so now you know a little
- 13:04bit more, and if you see the documentary, let us know. I'd love to know your feedback on that.
- 13:09Every day, it amazes me. Every day, I know social media is going to be the demise
- 13:16of us all, but for as much negativity that comes out of it, don't you learn so much too?
- 13:22Like, I learn every day.
- 13:25It's my favorite thing to do. Learn about new things and then given the opportunity
- 13:30to bring it to the podcast is something special.
- 13:33And I just love learning about these different things together.
- 13:37Yesterday, we did a podcast on the American Mall.
- 13:41And I don't know, maybe that's not exciting to everybody, but like these are
- 13:47changes that are happening in our world.
- 13:49Sometimes I don't feel like we stay present enough so we don't hone in on these
- 13:53things that are going on.
- 13:54So maybe this is our 15 minutes of saying, hey, let's learn a little bit about what's around us.
- 14:00So now you know a little bit more about Three Mile Island.
- 14:04And that's all I got for you guys today. The sun is shining, like I said.
- 14:09Gonna go back and enjoy the rest of the day. We've got some exciting topics
- 14:13coming for you next. I've got some more to push out.
- 14:16Make sure you stay tuned. Right now, we're doing a giveaway.
- 14:19If you leave us a Google review between now and Sunday, you'll be entered in
- 14:23to win some merch if you're chosen.
- 14:25So there's that going on and much more.
- 14:28Two Talking Fools. You can find us at twotalkingfools.com.
- 14:32We're on all the social media platforms and
- 14:36we'll make you laugh and we'll make you think and we'll we'll be your best buds
- 14:41all right guys that's it for me and shabo have a blessed day take care of yourselves
- 14:47be nice to people be kind to people be kind to yourself be kind to yourself
- 14:51all right love you guys peace.