Latest / Seasons of Joy / How We Treat Others: Nice vs Kind
Transcript
- 0:00This is Jill Pack with the Seasons of Joy podcast. This is episode number 163,
- 0:06entitled How We Treat Others, Nice vs. Kind.
- 0:11Are you a woman of faith who is struggling to navigate your current season of life?
- 0:16Do you feel like life is just happening to you instead of for you?
- 0:20My name is Jill Pack, and I'm a certified faith-based life coach and a member
- 0:25of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
- 0:28I want you to know that no matter your season or your circumstance,
- 0:32it is possible to create a more
- 0:35joyful life, and I would love to show you how. Are you ready? Let's go.
- 0:45Hello, my friends. Welcome to this week's episode of the Seasons of Joy podcast.
- 0:50I'm your host, and today we're diving into something that has been on my mind
- 0:54and heart for quite some time.
- 0:56We are going to explore the subtle but
- 0:59powerful differences between being nice and
- 1:02being kind you've probably used these words interchangeably
- 1:06your whole life i know i have she's
- 1:09so nice he's so kind it sounds like the same thing right but i want you to think
- 1:16about this for a minute because what we're about to explore might completely
- 1:21change how you see your relationships your workplace interactions,
- 1:26and even how you parent or lead others.
- 1:29I recently had a wake-up call. I grew up believing that I needed to be a nice
- 1:36person. I shouldn't make people feel bad, right?
- 1:39I'm thinking that you probably received that message too.
- 1:42You might have also received a similar message that it was better to go along
- 1:47with others and just not ruffle any feathers. It was better to not have conflict, right?
- 1:53I believed that conflict was something that wasn't good and should be avoided at all costs.
- 2:01Peace has also always been important to me, and tension in my relationships has scared me.
- 2:09However, a few years ago, I had an experience where I was trying to keep the
- 2:14peace, right, in a contentious situation.
- 2:17I was trying to see both sides. I was trying to be neutral in order to make
- 2:23the contention and the conflict go away, and for peace and harmony to return.
- 2:29And that sounds nice, right?
- 2:31But the truth was, it wasn't neutral. I did have an opinion,
- 2:36but I was afraid to share it.
- 2:39Now, this belief and this fear prevented me from managing myself or showing
- 2:46up as the person that I wanted to be in that situation.
- 2:50Nice Jill was trying to manage and control others in order to remove the tension
- 2:56so she could feel better and honestly, so she could feel safer.
- 3:02It wasn't about being honest or kind.
- 3:05It was about trying to control the situation and
- 3:09it makes sense that I handled it the way that I did I'm not
- 3:12mad at myself for that because we often will
- 3:15respond in these certain ways these patterned ways these coping ways because
- 3:22we have been put into a fight or flight response right something that's activated
- 3:29in us in our nervous system and so we kind of go into that protective mode.
- 3:34And so no longer can we be intentional or purposeful, we're being reactionary.
- 3:41And that is where I was.
- 3:43But I also had entered that conversation and that situation with the patterned
- 3:50belief that I needed to be nice,
- 3:53which actually fueled my patterned behavior of shrinking,
- 3:57not sharing my honest opinion trying to
- 4:01manage other people's emotions and not having
- 4:04boundaries right so I entered it in with a false belief that also affected how
- 4:10I showed up yes I had kind of a fight-and-flight response but I also had added
- 4:17to it because of that belief that I needed to just be nice. And that was the better way.
- 4:23But as I have reflected on this situation, the last few years,
- 4:28I have a different perspective now. And it hit me.
- 4:33There was a time when it hit me that I might have this whole nice and kind thing wrong.
- 4:38And I think that's kind of a general rule for many of us.
- 4:43As I've talked to other women and
- 4:44other people, I think we have a similar experience around nice and kind.
- 4:50So what do these words actually mean? Let's start with the basics.
- 4:55When we look at the dictionary definitions, nice typically describes someone
- 5:01who's pleasant, polite, agreeable to others.
- 5:05It's about pleasing. It's being socially acceptable and appropriate.
- 5:10Kind, on the other hand, describes someone who performs good acts for others,
- 5:17someone with a benevolent nature who shows genuine care and consideration.
- 5:24But here's where it gets interesting. When we look at what the roots are of
- 5:29these words, that can also show us some insight.
- 5:33And so as I was studying this, the word nice actually comes from a Latin word, nesius.
- 5:42And it means ignorant. Isn't that interesting, right?
- 5:47And over time, nice has evolved through different meanings like timid,
- 5:52faint-hearted, before becoming our modern idea of pleasant and agreeable.
- 5:59Meanwhile, kind has roots in Middle English, meaning friendly or deliberately doing good to others.
- 6:07It is also connected to the dramatic word for kin, as in family.
- 6:13So kindness could be literally about treating others like family.
- 6:19So already, just looking at the meaning and the definition of those words,
- 6:25we can kind of begin to see they're actually not the same thing at all.
- 6:30And I would say, I would offer that the core distinction comes down to motivation and focus.
- 6:37Niceness is often self-centered. We're nice because we want to be liked,
- 6:42we want to avoid conflict, or we want to maintain our image as a good person.
- 6:49It's about us and how other people perceive us.
- 6:54Kindness, on the other hand, is focused on others. It's other-centered.
- 7:00It focuses on what the other person actually needs, even if that's uncomfortable,
- 7:06inconvenient, or doesn't make us look good at all.
- 7:09But I want you to think about it this way or just open your mind a little bit.
- 7:14What if niceness is expressed through words and gestures, right?
- 7:20If we think about it, can we see that?
- 7:23Like we say the right thing. We smile. We're polite, right? We can kind of see niceness that way.
- 7:30Where kindness is expressed through actions.
- 7:34It's doing what actually is.
- 7:38The best thing for you and the other person.
- 7:41It's doing what actually helps the other person, even when it's hard.
- 7:47So this is why we can be nice without being kind, and we can be kind without being nice.
- 7:54So when is nice, not kind?
- 7:58Let's look at some examples, and maybe you can see yourself in one of these scenarios.
- 8:03The first scenario is your colleague keeps missing deadlines,
- 8:07right and it's affecting your whole team and
- 8:10the nice response could look like you're
- 8:13covering for them you don't say anything to management and
- 8:17maybe you even do some of their work you're being pleasant and you're avoiding
- 8:22conflict sounds nice right but is it kind it isn't it's not really that kind
- 8:29because you're enabling behavior it's ultimately going to harm that colleague's ability to grow.
- 8:36It's going to harm your team's success and probably your own well-being, too.
- 8:41The kind response might be having an honest, direct, and probably uncomfortable
- 8:48conversation about the impact of that person's behavior.
- 8:53Scenario number two, let's say you're at dinner with friends and someone makes
- 8:57a poor taste joke, right?
- 9:00Something in poor taste, maybe be a racist joke.
- 9:03And the nice response could look like maybe you laugh a little nervously,
- 9:07you're not sure what to say, you change the subject, or you just sit in this
- 9:12uncomfortable silence, not knowing what to say, right?
- 9:17But you keep being pleasant, and you avoid a confrontation, right?
- 9:23We think we just need to push it away.
- 9:25Let's just pretend it didn't happen. That's the nice thing to do.
- 9:28But what would the kind response look like? It could look like speaking up.
- 9:33Might not feel nice in the moment, but it's the kinder thing to everyone involved,
- 9:40including the person making the joke.
- 9:42It actually gives them an opportunity to kind of reflect and think about what they said and grow.
- 9:48And again, it's not about calling them out or complaining.
- 9:51It could look like something like, ah, you know, I just didn't really feel comfortable with that joke.
- 9:56Did you mean for it to sound that way, right?
- 10:00And so you're not like angry. You're just speaking up.
- 10:05That is the kind thing to do.
- 10:07Let's look at another scenario. Let's say your friend is dating someone and
- 10:12they keep dating these people that don't treat them good.
- 10:15And she constantly comes to you and complains and looks for advice,
- 10:20but she never takes it, right?
- 10:22And you repeat this over and over the same scenario.
- 10:26The nice response is to keep listening sympathetically and you say supportive things.
- 10:32And there's nothing wrong with that.
- 10:34What you want to notice is how you feel after.
- 10:37If you notice some resentment coming up for you, then maybe that's a sign it's
- 10:43time to say something different or to do the kind thing instead of the nice thing.
- 10:50Because ultimately right they're
- 10:53stuck in this pattern and if you you
- 10:56have an opportunity to share something that might influence
- 10:59them so the kind response could look like saying i care too much about you to
- 11:06see your you continually hurt yourself this way i'm here when you're ready to
- 11:12do something different but i just can't continue to have the same conversation over and over.
- 11:20I love you, right? Like it's, you can share genuine care.
- 11:24But being honest. And now notice, in each one of these scenarios,
- 11:29the kind responses required a few things, right?
- 11:34It required courage, boundaries, and sometimes some short-term discomfort for long-term benefit.
- 11:42So why do we default to the niceness over kindness?
- 11:48It's often rooted in fear fear
- 11:52of rejection fear of conflict fear of not being liked niceness feels safe because
- 11:58it's predictable and it's socially rewarded right we want to be the nice person
- 12:04but what i discovered is research actually shows that when we act with genuine kindness,
- 12:11our brains release oxytocin.
- 12:14And it's a love hormone.
- 12:16And this hormone actually dampens the activity in our amygdala.
- 12:22And that's the region of your brain that's associated with fear and anxiety.
- 12:27So kindness literally makes us less afraid. It calms us down.
- 12:34Kindness can also release serotonin and dopamine, which boosts our mood and
- 12:39creates this natural reward cycle.
- 12:42It can even trigger endorphins, which can give us something like a helper's high.
- 12:48So while niceness might feel safer in the moment, kindness is actually better
- 12:55for our mental health and well-being, and it creates deeper,
- 12:59more authentic connections with the people in our life.
- 13:03When we consistently choose niceness over kindness, I believe we pay a price.
- 13:08And that couldn't look like enabling harmful behaviors in others, right?
- 13:14We build superficial rather than genuine relationships.
- 13:18We suppress our authentic selves and our values.
- 13:22We create resentment when our niceness isn't appreciated.
- 13:27And we miss opportunities to truly help the people we care about.
- 13:31If you are a people pleaser, I see you.
- 13:35I have had this tendency for most of my life.
- 13:39But it's exhausting, isn't it? We try so hard to manage everyone else's emotions
- 13:45and reactions, and we can be so focused on being nice that we've lost touch
- 13:51with what we genuinely care,
- 13:53with what genuine care actually looks like, right?
- 13:58What does that genuine care and kindness look like?
- 14:01Well, I think it has three elements.
- 14:05When we genuinely care for another person, we are aware and have empathy, right?
- 14:12Kind people pay attention.
- 14:15They try to understand what somebody actually needs, not just what would be
- 14:21pleasant to hear or receive, right? We are aware and we have empathy.
- 14:25The other thing is, is it, it needs courage, right?
- 14:29It has courage in it because kind people are willing to be uncomfortable,
- 14:34which requires courage.
- 14:37And, and we, we have to have courage to have that difficult conversation in
- 14:41order to set boundaries or to act even when it's inconvenient.
- 14:46And it requires genuine care.
- 14:49Kind people are motivated by the other person's well-being, not by our own self-image or comfort.
- 14:57This means that sometimes kindness looks gentle and supportive,
- 15:02and sometimes it looks firm and challenging.
- 15:06Sometimes it's bringing soup to a sick neighbor, and sometimes it's refusing
- 15:11to enable someone's destructive behavior, right?
- 15:15So how do we shift from this default niceness to intentional kindness?
- 15:21Here are some strategies One, ask better questions. Instead of asking,
- 15:27what's the polite thing to do?
- 15:28Ask, what does this person actually need?
- 15:31Instead of asking, how can I avoid conflict?
- 15:34What if you asked, what would be most helpful here? Or one of my favorites,
- 15:39the favorite question I have is, what does love look like right now?
- 15:45What does love look like right now? What would that look like?
- 15:48It also requires us to practice honest communication.
- 15:52This doesn't mean being brutal or insensitive, right? Sometimes it's like,
- 15:57we're going to be brutally honest.
- 15:58No, it means being truthful in a way that serves the other person's growth and well-being.
- 16:05So I want to give a few examples of what this could look like.
- 16:08Let's say your teenager has been coming home repeatedly pass curfew, right?
- 16:15And the nice response might sound like, oh, honey, I was so worried. Are you okay?
- 16:21Maybe next time just text me. And if that feels okay to you,
- 16:25I don't necessarily think that that's wrong, but does it provide them an opportunity
- 16:31to learn and grow, right?
- 16:34Maybe the kind response could look like, I'm so relieved you're home safe,
- 16:39and I'm concerned about this pattern that I'm seeing.
- 16:44This is the third time you've missed curfew this month. And so could you help
- 16:48me understand what's happening?
- 16:50Because this current arrangement just isn't working for either of us.
- 16:55Right? Help me understand.
- 16:58Second one, let's say your partner has been critical lately.
- 17:02And instead of just trying to be extra pleasant to compensate,
- 17:06what if you tried saying something like, I've noticed something that I would
- 17:11like to talk to you about.
- 17:13Over the past few weeks, our conversations have felt more tense.
- 17:18And I find myself walking on eggshells. And I don't think it's healthy for either one of us.
- 17:24And I'm wondering if there's something going on that we could and should address
- 17:30together. Would that be okay?
- 17:32Right? Again, we are, we're inviting them into the conversation,
- 17:38and so we're inviting them to collaborate.
- 17:41And here's another example. Let's say with a colleague who always misses deadlines.
- 17:47Instead of saying, hey, no big deal, maybe next time you can try to be on time,
- 17:51get them in a little earlier, right? We just kind of sweep it under the rug.
- 17:55We mention it. We feel like we're being nice.
- 17:57We've addressed it in our mind, but was it kind?
- 18:01What would the kind response look like? Well, it might look like saying.
- 18:06We would really want I really want to talk
- 18:09to you about project timelines when reports
- 18:12come in late it it creates this domino effect that actually is impacting our
- 18:18whole team's ability to meet our deadlines and I'm just wondering what kind
- 18:23of support do you need so we can kind of back get back on track how can I how can I support you.
- 18:31Okay, the next one. Let's say you have a friend that is always canceling last minute, right?
- 18:37And in the past, you've like, oh, it's no problem. We can reschedule anytime.
- 18:42And again, maybe that feels fine because you aren't feeling that resentment.
- 18:47Not a big deal to you. But maybe you're noticing that resentment come up for you.
- 18:53And so being nice isn't working anymore. And it's time to step into kindness.
- 19:00And it can look like saying, I care about our friendship, and I've got to be honest with you.
- 19:06This is the fourth time that you've canceled last minute, and it's starting
- 19:11to affect how I plan my time.
- 19:14Can we talk about what's going on here? What's happening?
- 19:18Right? So each one of these scenarios, there's a pattern, right?
- 19:23In these scripts, there's a pattern. they all start with care,
- 19:28right? How much you care about that person.
- 19:30And then you're stating an observation. You're not being critical.
- 19:33You're not being judgmental. You're stating an observation clearly.
- 19:37And then you're inviting that other person into a collaboration rather than
- 19:43just complaining or blaming.
- 19:46Okay. The next strategy is to set healthy boundaries.
- 19:50Kindness isn't limitless accommodation. Sometimes the kindest thing you can
- 19:57do is to say no or to establish clear limits, right?
- 20:02It's not an ultimatum. It's not manipulation.
- 20:05It's, this is what I will do in this situation, right?
- 20:09What's okay, what's not okay, and what will I do in those situations, right?
- 20:16It's not trying to manipulate another person, but a kind boundary actually shows
- 20:21kindness to you and the other person. They are put in place for both people
- 20:27so that your relationship can be healthy.
- 20:31The other strategy is accept discomfort. I think this is so important.
- 20:37When we can get comfortable with the fact that kind acts don't always feel good
- 20:42in the moment and aren't always appreciated immediately, the better we are able
- 20:48to kind of step into that courage, right?
- 20:52When we can know that it's not always going to feel good, but the long-term
- 20:57benefit is going to be more impactful than the short-term comfort, right?
- 21:03So being willing to feel uncomfortable because that's where the growth happens.
- 21:08When we're willing to step into that discomfort of being kind,
- 21:12we grow and the other person has an opportunity to grow.
- 21:16So accepting discomfort is so important.
- 21:20And finally, focusing on the long-term impact, right?
- 21:24It's asking ourselves, what serves this person's highest good over time?
- 21:30Rather than what makes them happy right now, right?
- 21:33Nice is about ease and pushing away any tension or discomfort, right?
- 21:41But does it really benefit the other person and you in the long run?
- 21:45So it's paying attention what's going to be best in the long run here.
- 21:50When we choose kindness over niceness, we create a ripple effect.
- 21:55We are better able to model authentic care for others. We give people permission
- 22:01to be real rather than just pleasant.
- 22:05We build trust and deeper connections with the people in our life.
- 22:09And here's something beautiful that I want you to consider.
- 22:12You can often be both kind and nice.
- 22:16You can speak hard, difficult truth with gentleness.
- 22:21You can set a boundary with kindness and compassion. You can challenge someone
- 22:27while still being warm and respectful.
- 22:31Now, the goal isn't to become harsh or uncaring.
- 22:36It's to become more genuinely caring. Caring enough to do what actually helps
- 22:41rather than just feels safe.
- 22:43So I have a challenge for you this week. I want to challenge you to notice the
- 22:48difference between being nice and kind in your own relationships and your life this week.
- 22:54Pay attention to those moments when you're tempted to choose the pleasant option, right?
- 22:59The path of least resistance over the helpful one.
- 23:04Maybe it's giving honest feedback to a direct report instead of just saying, oh, good job.
- 23:10Maybe it's telling a friend you can't cover for them again instead of just grumbling
- 23:14about it later behind their back.
- 23:16Maybe it's speaking up when somebody says something harmful instead of just letting it slide.
- 23:22And again, it's not about being rude or calling them out.
- 23:25It's being honest and telling the whole truth, right? Which includes that you love this person.
- 23:33You love this person and this comment wasn't appropriate, right? We can do both.
- 23:41There's room for both. We want to start small.
- 23:44Practice kindness in low stakes situations so you can build that muscle for when it really matters.
- 23:52Start small and see how you feel. And each time you do it, that's what I've
- 23:59learned. Each time I've leaned into the kind response instead of the nice response, I have grown.
- 24:07And my ability to do it the next time improves. And that muscle is growing and growing.
- 24:13Am I perfect at it? No, but I've come so far and I can see the difference in
- 24:19my life and it feels so much better.
- 24:22The difference between nice and kind isn't just semantic. tick.
- 24:28It's transformational. When we
- 24:30understand that true kindness sometimes requires us to be uncomfortable,
- 24:34to speak truth, to set boundaries, and to act from genuine care rather than
- 24:41social conditioning, we become capable of having real impact on the people around us.
- 24:47The world, in all honesty, doesn't need more pleasant people.
- 24:52It needs more genuinely caring people. people who are willing to show up authentically,
- 24:59to have hard conversations, and to choose love over likability.
- 25:06I invite you to sit with this question, and it's this.
- 25:09In your most important relationships, are you choosing to be nice or are you choosing to be kind?
- 25:16And what might change if you leaned more toward the latter?
- 25:21If you want to talk about how to move from niceness to kindness in your life, let's chat.
- 25:28You can find a link in my show notes or on my website, www.seasons-coaching.com,
- 25:34to schedule a one-on-one complimentary clarity conversation.
- 25:39And if this episode resonated with you, please share it with someone who might
- 25:44benefit from thinking about this distinction.
- 25:47And I want you to always remember, it's not about being perfect.
- 25:52None of us will be totally perfect at this, but we can be more intentional.
- 25:58Thanks for being here and have a joyful week. Thank you for tuning in to the
- 26:03Seasons of Joy podcast. I hope you enjoyed today's episode.
- 26:06And if you like what you heard, don't forget to subscribe, leave a review,
- 26:11and share with your friends and family.
- 26:12If you want to learn more about me or how to work with me, just visit my website,
- 26:17www.seasons-coaching.com and have a joyful week.