Latest / Decrypted: The UK Cyber Briefing / Apple goes back to court over the UK's iCloud backdoor
Transcript
- 0:03This is Decrypted. Friday, the seventh of August.
- 0:06Apple goes back to court over the UK's iCloud backdoor.
- 0:10Apple has gone back to a UK tribunal to fight, for the second time, a government order demanding access to e
- 0:18ncrypted iCloud backups. It's the kind of story that rarely gets a clean ending.
- 0:23The law behind it also forbids the people involved from saying exactly what was asked for.
- 0:29That's worth noting before we get into the detail.
- 0:32Whatever you think of the aim, a legal mechanism nobody can discuss in public is an odd foundation for public
- 0:39trust in security.
- 0:44In February 2025, the Home Office secretly ordered Apple to build a way into Advanced Data Protection.
- 0:52That's the optional end-to-end encryption Apple offers for iCloud backups.
- 0:57The order was a technical capability notice, issued through the Investigatory Powers Act.
- 1:03Apple withdrew A D P from new UK sign-ups that same month.
- 1:08It filed its first challenge at the Investigatory Powers Tribunal in March 2025.
- 1:15Then came pressure from Washington.
- 1:18In August 2025, the government dropped the demand for non-UK customers.
- 1:23But that October it reissued the order, narrowed to the encrypted backups of British users only.
- 1:29Apple filed a second complaint at the tribunal in July.
- 1:33That's according to reporting this week from TechCrunch, 9to5Mac and MacRumors.
- 1:38And there's a related case.
- 1:40Liberty and Privacy International have brought a challenge against the use of these notices.
- 1:45It's listed for a December hearing at the same tribunal.
- 1:49And finally. The Secure by Design problem with a backdoor.
- 1:53Advanced Data Protection is end-to-end encrypted so that Apple itself can't read it.
- 1:59That's what makes a "technical capability" order so awkward.
- 2:04There's no narrow door to build.
- 2:06There's only a general one.
- 2:07The design choice that keeps the service safe against everyone else is the same choice that makes it unreadab
- 2:13le to Apple.
- 2:16And it's the whole problem with legislating around it.
- 2:19A backdoor sized for UK law enforcement is a backdoor sized for whoever else finds it, government or not.
- 2:26So if your organisation builds or buys end-to-end encrypted products, treat this case as a live test.
- 2:33The question is whether "secure by design" and "lawful access by design" can coexist in British law.
- 2:41Right now, that question is being settled in a tribunal, not in a spec document.
- 2:47That was Decrypted. The written version and every source are linked in the show notes.
- 2:52Thanks for listening.