Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Greenfield on The Fight For Legacy OEMs and Cheap Chinese EVs
Transcript
- 0:00[funky music] It is Tuesday, April 28th, roundin' the corner on April. We have Steve Greenfield on the show today. This is the Automotive State of the Union.
- 0:07We're gonna talk about the fight for legacy OEMs and Chinese cars and EVs and all the competition and all the things that we're hearing out there.
- 0:15The Beijing Auto Show has kind of lit another fire under the conversation. Steve, thank you so much for joining me today. Paul, it's great to be back, as always. Oh, my goodness.
- 0:24So there's so many things coming on, but first and foremost, let's talk about the fact that we have a SOTUCON coming in hot.
- 0:29Two weeks from today will be the welcome reception, and you are going to be delivering another one of your keynotes. Um- Cool. Well-... we never know what is, it is you're gonna bring. We don't ask in advance.
- 0:41Um, we just say, "What's important to you right now?" And then we're gonna listen to what you say. Do you have any idea what you're gonna talk about this year?
- 0:47Well, one, I'll say that that is, uh, very trusting of you guys. Um- I think we have- I, I- We have a bit of a track record to go on at this point. No, no, I, I, but, but you, you know how this f- goes.
- 0:56I mean, I, I have a chance to speak at a few of these different things over the, the, the, the course of the year, and I'm, I'm amazed at so- some folks are very, very controlling. Like, they wanna- Oh... see the slides.
- 1:05They wanna massage the message. They wanna cut the number of slides, et cetera. Uh, the people can remain nameless. Maybe they're tuning in today. [laughs] But I find that very interesting.
- 1:13You guys are the opposite end of the spectrum. And listen, as a presenter, I really appreciate the trust, et cetera. It actually, in some ways, imposes more pressure and a higher bar for me to, like, d- deliver up there.
- 1:22But, um, no, I, I think, I think this is gonna be fun. Like, for those that are gonna be there, I think we'll have some fun.
- 1:27I think, um, you know, I was telling, um, Nathan right before the segment here, I've got, like, six sticky notes up here that, um, a- as I'm sitting in, I've got a few minutes during the day, I'm thinking through what the story is that I wanna tell.
- 1:39[laughs] And I think we're gonna, we're gonna talk a little bit about the future- Mm-hmm... uh, of course, and, and look fi- five or 10 years from now, what the economics to a dealer might look like.
- 1:47You know, I'm, I'm inspired specifically, we were talking about this earlier kinda, like, in the green room, about the marathon this, this weekend.
- 1:54And not only did you have the, the winner beat the world record and do a sub-two-hour marathon, which has never been done before- Right...
- 2:01but the number two, who had never, ever run a marathon before, also broke the world record and came in under two hours. Unbelievable. There's something, there's something to be learned here.
- 2:10What I'm, what I'm gonna attempt to do to, to, to dissect is looking at the distribution of dealer performance. Mm.
- 2:17And we always talk about, you know, NADA metrics or NCM metrics and, like, talk about the average dealer does this and the average dealer does this. But what we know is there's deciles, right?
- 2:27There's the top, the, the lowest 10% of dealers are performing way below average.
- 2:31But more importantly, the top decile of dealers, we're gonna examine and say, like, what, what, you know, what, what, what does the performance look like for that top 10% of dealers?
- 2:40But more importantly, how are they doing it? And then is AI gonna be able to bridge the gap? Because like this marathoner, I do think that, you know, if you can examine your competition
- 2:52and understand the competition, how are they achieving it, you may never achieve exactly what they're achieving. Mm-hmm.
- 2:57But by examining the great, you know, uh, whatever, whatever you like, athletes, uh, business leaders, et cetera- Yeah. Excellent performers- Um-... yes... you, you, you c- you can become more like them, right?
- 3:08Start to adopt attributes of them, et cetera.
- 3:10And, and then I think most people would look, and I've heard this over and over, over the last, like, 20 years from dealers, yeah, but they're in a better market, or they've got better brands- Right...
- 3:18or I could never be an operator like their operators or whatever. Always. But we are on the cusp of, uh, AI enabling you to effectively operate like the top decile dealers out there.
- 3:28So that's what I wanna unpack is first examine that distribution.
- 3:32Um, understand, you know, what, what are the attributes of the most successful dealers, and then use AI, or, or, or look t- i- if we could potentially envision a future in the next five, 10 years where w- we're leaning on AI to ra- raise the tide for all dealers, but those dealers specifically that wanna kinda buy in and say, "Look, I, I, I need to perform more like those top-performing dealers.
- 3:53How, how can I bridge that gap?" And, and, and I think that it'll be very interesting. I, I don't know how successful. That's my goal. Yeah.
- 3:59How successful I'm gonna be laying this out will b- will be my challenge over the next two weeks.
- 4:03But I do think, if nothing else, uh, the folks in the audience, I'm gonna provoke some interesting thoughts that they may not agree with, as usual. But, um- [laughs]...
- 4:11hopefully, they walk away going, "Wow, very interesting."
- 4:13Like, I mean, if, if I'm, if I could identify the attributes of successful dealers, want to be more like them, and then AI is gonna uniquely allow me to potentially become more like them- Mm-hmm... then I, I, I'm all in.
- 4:26Like, l- let me be very open-minded to how that might progress over the next few years. So I have a couple thoughts because you already got my mind spinning and I just wanna, like- All right. I got my, I got my pad.
- 4:35I'm, I'm, I'm taking notes. No, the, the thoughts are this. Number one, this sounds like a book in the making. [laughs] Maybe. Maybe.
- 4:40Um, and maybe, maybe not, like, a super long book, but, like, a 100-page, read-it-on-a-short-flight kind of book- Mm-hmm...
- 4:47because I think the principles you're talking about are, are broadly applicable across any industry- Right... but I think dealers would specifically be interested in those things. Mm-hmm.
- 4:55And always when we think about how we can examine the success of suc- you know, the, the things that are working for these successful people, successful dealer groups, we can always take away a few things.
- 5:06And no, you will never be able to operate like them. There are no two dealers that are alike. I don't care if you're same, sell the same brand in a similar market, there's still differences- Right... in leadership style.
- 5:15There are differences in ownership structure. There are difference in market dynamics. Um, so never the same, but always something to learn.
- 5:22I also think that you're building a framework and it's almost like, I think of, like, practicing medicine or practicing law.
- 5:28Like, you practice, and you get these thoughts out there, and you start to m- look at them from different angles, and then you start to refine them a little bit.
- 5:35And I think with AI, the ability to take your thoughts and your, your information and your, like you say, you may agree, you may not agree, to take that and then use it to b- emphatically train an AI model and then ask the AI model to, like, can you interview me to ask me the, the pertinent questions to get the information you would need to start to develop insights between what Steve said and where I am right now, and how I can get there?
- 6:02Right. Right. And so I think, I think, I can't wait now. I'm super [laughs] excited. [laughs] Yeah. Good, good, good. Because I, I wanna see this as well. You know what, Nathan?
- 6:09Uh, let's make a note and we will link up Steve's, uh, keynote from last year in the show notes so you can go back and watch it- Mm-hmm. Oh, got it [laughs]...
- 6:15and you can kinda see and, um-And then you can get ready for this. If you haven't gotten your tickets, needless to say, you need to be at ASOTU CON. You can go to asotucon.com right now, see all the speakers.
- 6:24But by the way, let, let me just pitch you guys. So let- Yeah. Okay, sure... listen. Um, I, I'm gonna be very honest. This is feedback that I, I've given you, Paul and Kyle and Nathan in the past. So for...
- 6:32When, when did you guys first go to this venue, four years ago? Yes. That first year, my criticism of you guys, I'm being very honest here, was you didn't have enough dealers in the room. Mm-hmm.
- 6:43Um, and I was like, "You need to have..." The, the ratio for any, any show that we go to, any, any conference, the ratio's always challenging, deal- dealer to vendor ratio. Mm-hmm.
- 6:51Paul's now worried where I'm going with this. No, that's fine. [laughs] But, but, but listen, listen, it ends in a good place, in a, in a great place, actually.
- 6:57And, you know, you go to any of these, these, these shows now, and I'm not gonna name any names, but, like, you always look around, there's a lot of vendors and not a lot of dealers.
- 7:03I can tell you, like, over the last, like, three years, you guys intentionally have, have attacked that problem. Whether it was because I planted the seed or others or whatever. Mm-hmm.
- 7:11Um, I'm shocked at the number of dealer principals that show up. I'm shocked.
- 7:16There is no other conference in automotive that has as many dealer principals showing up, and anyone who shows up is gonna be shocked at, like, the proportion. Now, now this is a high bar. You guys gotta deliver.
- 7:29You know what? It's, it's... No. But it's, it's shocking. It's shocking. You guys have done such a great job. And I understand behind the scenes what you've done. I'm not gonna reveal your secrets.
- 7:36But you guys have done, like, a very intentional job of getting dealer principals to show up. And, like, I walk around that room and I'm like, I'm amazed at the quality of the dealers, attendees.
- 7:46And dealers come and they don't only bring, like, themselves. They're, they're bringing their management team because they're learning. Mm-hmm. So kudos to you guys. Thank you.
- 7:52But, like, there is not another conference out there that brings as many dealer principals. And if I'm a vendor out there, I'm like, "Dude, this is one conference you gotta be at." Man, thank you so much for that.
- 8:02And that is the- But it's true. 100% true. I mean, it's true, like, three, four years ago I was worried about you guys. But you guys have, like, rallied and it's, like, it's really amazing what you guys have built.
- 8:11Oh, man. That, that means so much. Thank you. And it really is the, the overall trajectory is like you need to get the dealer principal, but you also need to get the senior leadership team.
- 8:20Because one person can go to an event, and they come back, and everyone's had this experience where they come back and they, they're like, "Oh, I have this notebook full of ideas," or, "I saw this guy and he said something like this," and now you have to translate it, and then it never really translates.
- 8:33And so we try to be very holistic in our approach, which is why we think dealer principals, general managers find it so intriguing, is because we cover the spectrum of dealer operations with a cohesive thread through it saying the most successful dealers will be the ones that are aware of every area.
- 8:48And their teams are also aware of what's happening in the other areas of the business. Because like you said, even AI is bringing those areas much closer, much faster than we ever could have imagined.
- 8:58So thank you so much for that. Uh, we're working our tail off to make every year a little bit better than the last, and I don't think this year will be any exception. All right. Nice. So let's talk about some, some news.
- 9:07And I wanted to... I, I get your email. Um, Automotive Ventures, um, the Intel report every week. You should get it. Go to automotiveventures.com so you can download it, subscribe to it. I read it every week.
- 9:18Um, how many people do you have reading this thing every week now? It's a lot. Uh, almost seve- almost 17,000 now. 17,000. So just a couple, two, three. How many dealers are there? Oh, 16,000. That means...
- 9:27[laughs] Um, and so, no, but a lot of people pay attention. It's not just the auto industry, but also finance, uh, politics, leadership, global, global industry. And be- Yeah...
- 9:36we put an article in there this week that was, uh, a Rolling Stone article first and foremost. It was awesome to just see a Rolling Stone article at the top- Yeah. [laughs]...
- 9:43of your email because I feel like- Yeah, leadi- leading off too. Leading off with that... I, I, the lead off hitter is Rolling Stone. And, um, I forgot how much I actually enjoy Rolling Stone's writing style.
- 9:52Yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, very refreshing article. We have it linked up here in the show notes.
- 9:54But basically it's about legacy automakers staring down the perfect storm with EVs and software and Chinese competition shaping the industry.
- 10:01It's an in-depth article with Jim Farley, uh, Ford's CEO, who by the way I did not realize he was the first cousin of Chris Farley, the, the- It's crazy, huh?... the actor. Um, but now I can see it. I'll never unsee it.
- 10:12Um- Yeah, that's right. Exactly right. Once, once you see it you're like, "Oh, wow." I'm like, "Oh, now I just wanna see him pick up David Spade and, like, fall through a table." [laughs] Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:18Down by the river. But basically he's calling... Jim Farley's calling today a fitness test for EVs and software defined vehicles.
- 10:24Um, Chinese automakers have leapfrogged legacy OEMs and EV tech and speed to market and cost.
- 10:30And he says their early efforts, Ford's, missed the mark on cost and design, losing money despite the consumer interest that there was.
- 10:38He says, "The one thing that we have that is our strongest asset," he says, "dealers remain a strategic advantage because global competitors lack the distribution network needed to execute that."
- 10:49He said, "If we don't put all our chips on the right number, Ford maybe could not exist." So it was a very revealing and strong article. And if you,
- 10:58you know, if you're thinking about the whole, the whole breadth, I've see... I've s- saw things in that article that I've heard you say many times and people like Jim Dunn, um, Michael Dunn, I mean, talk about.
- 11:09And the fact that COVID came up, we thought we were a little bit ahead or even at least with the Chinese. COVID ended. We weren't traveling, we weren't seeing.
- 11:17And then all of a sudden there was, like, this shock moment that- Yeah... Jim, Jim Farley were like, "Oh, my gosh. What happened?" So, um, this conversation very, very high, uh, in the, in the public sphere right now.
- 11:29I actually have people asking me about this. Now, just, like, regular friends, not like the usual requests we get as car people. Oh, wow. [laughs] That's a re- No... it's, it's hit the mainstream now, huh?
- 11:37That's interesting. It really is. I was at church over the weekend- Yeah... and somebody said, "Hey, how about these Chinese EVs," right? Oh, wow. Not the question I was expecting to get in the church lobby.
- 11:44But, um, but- Fascinating... which, which is an indicator to me that, like, the, the general public is starting to pay attention to this conversation which has a lot of implications. Yep. Yeah.
- 11:55So what do you, what do you, why did you put that article first? And, and what do you see, how do you see it unfolding right now in public discourse?Yeah. Well, well, one is it's a, it's a great article.
- 12:03And, and for those that, uh, aren't subscribers, if you want a copy, I'm happy to send you a copy. So just ping me or Paul, and we'll send you a copy. Um, it's, it's, it's worth reading.
- 12:11Listen, um, you know, Farley's vilified sometimes in the press for talking too much, but I think we should all appreciate that one, one of the, one of the leaders of the Detroit Three is Jim Farley, and he's willing to open up and talk about what's- Yeah...
- 12:22on his mind. Because we're getting good insight into what all, all the automakers are consumed with right now, which is, as you said, it's like, how do we build cars faster?
- 12:31How do we bring down the cost to compete with the Chinese? How do we be more, like, forward with software for software-defined vehicles?
- 12:38And there's a, there's a lot of moving parts right now to, to running an automaker that they didn't have to worry about 25 years ago when there, when there wasn't this threat of the Chinese, and cars were much less sophisticated from a technology standpoint.
- 12:48So it's worth reading. Um, it does kind of reiterate a lot of the themes that we've talked about in the past, you and I, Paul. But, um, it's, it's very in- interesting times.
- 12:57I think m- my observation is that, um, you're, you're, you're seeing almost weekly this vacillation with Ford specifically. Are we talking to Chinese automakers about potential JVs or are we not?
- 13:08[laughs] Because you'll see two articles back to back from different news outlets. We are- It feels a bit whiplash-y. Yeah. Yeah. Well, well, listen, h- here's the deal, right?
- 13:15Um, think of the prisoner's dilemma, you know, where, you know, we are both brought in by the police and put into separate rooms, and they're trying to break us.
- 13:22And whoever breaks first, the other guy goes to jail for longer, right? [laughs] You remember that probably from economics class. Um, maybe we can put, have Nathan put a little graphic up here or something.
- 13:30[laughs] But, you know, it, it's, it's, this is a prisoner's dilemma.
- 13:33And what I mean by that is it's a really bad day for Farley if tomorrow morning GM announces publicly that they've got a JV with B- BYD and bringing them into the country. Yeah. And the converse is true, right?
- 13:44It's really bad for Mary Barra if Jim Farley structures the deal, right? Mm. So what, what we do know is, as, as Farley el- eloquently outlines in this article, that they're, they're, they've, they've been flat-footed.
- 13:56They, they haven't been able to keep up with Chinese in terms of cost of delivery.
- 13:59They haven't been able to keep up with Chinese about EV innovations, and they haven't been able to keep up with Chinese with just the speed, the speed of innovation, right? Mm-hmm. Never mind the software area.
- 14:08Yeah, time to market. So- Yeah... one, one thing could be neutralize the enemy. Like, it's, it's very, um, leading the witness to say, "Hey, we've got distribution."
- 14:16The, the Chinese won't come into the US without a dealer network. That's right. They're gonna rely on dealers.
- 14:21This is gonna be a unique once in a lifetime opportunity for some dealers to raise their hands and get the BYD franchise in their local city. Mm-hmm. Um, whether we like it or not, this is gonna play out.
- 14:31And I think that, um, you know, if, if, if, if Farley and, and Barra can structure these JVs in such a way that the economics are favorable to them, we protect American workers, and, um, they, they get the, uh, intellectual property, maybe most importantly, understand how are the Chinese building cars cheaper, faster, and, you know, bringing down the cost and, and, and software intellectual property they have, and, and try to neutralize, you know, the, the threat.
- 14:58Um, but all, all of that is very hard. It's a lot to unpack. Mm-hmm. And but I, I do think over the next, you know, 12 to 18 months, we're gonna see how this all plays out.
- 15:05And reading articles like this, why it's so important, it does give you insight into one of the, the global leaders of the legacy automakers and exactly how they're perceiving the threats and what they're thinking a- about potentially neutralizing the enemy.
- 15:18And I would, I would also add to that, that if you, all this Chinese coming to you, like, if all of this is a little bit, like, distant from you, this article actually summarizes very well the beginning of when we started paying attention to where we are now.
- 15:32So it's also a great little history lesson. Um, let's, let's talk about the next story, the only other story we have today, is a story coming out of the Beijing Auto Show.
- 15:39We talked yesterday about, uh, an American YouTuber from North Carolina going to the auto show and going around and, and bringing all this tech and featuring cars so that Americans are starting to pay a lot of attention what's happening.
- 15:51But also one thing very clear at the show, that their EV market is brutally cheap. Dozens of models under $25,000. The pricing gap versus the US is impossible to ignore.
- 16:02The average car in the US topping $51,000, while China offers 200 plus EVs under $25,000.
- 16:10Some of these in this article, Reuters article, are under $12,000, and the headline of the article is like, "You could buy these five Chinese EVs- Right [laughs]... for the same price as the average cost in the US."
- 16:21Um, they have the, the sub, sub $12,000 EVs, they have two, 300 miles of range. They have nice technology in them. You can even get lidar on these vehicles. Um, fast charging.
- 16:32And, uh, one of them that they announced it last year called the Seagull. You can see it in this article. Just very slick and savvy vehicles.
- 16:39Uh, analyst Felipe Munoz says when you get in these vehicles, you don't feel like you're in a small car. So I think this is just another example of the affordability issue.
- 16:47Have, um, you've driven some Chinese vehicles before, haven't you? Uh, driven them, been in them. Dri- driven around, like Europe and such. Yeah, but not driven them.
- 16:56So, so I mean, this is just a little bit of a continuation on the conversation. Have you been paying attention to the Beijing Auto Show? Yeah. I, I mean, I was gonna, I was planning on going over there.
- 17:04I didn't get to g- go over there this year. Yeah. But it's o- overwhelming hearing from folks, et cetera. But yeah, I think it's very interesting.
- 17:09You think of like, you know, when was the last time you bought a laptop, Paul? Uh, about 18 months ago. And what'd you do with the previous one? Uh, I gave it to my kids. And your laptop was, was how much? Three grand?
- 17:23Four grand? Yeah. No, it was about 2,800. Okay. So we've conditioned consumers for this, like, planned obsolescence, right? Mm-hmm.
- 17:29And if the, the cars can get cheap enough, then you could literally see people say like, "Oh," you know, at the end of like the five-year hold period- Yeah, usable life. Right... so it- Use your phone...
- 17:37it doesn't really matter what has... Like, yeah. Yeah. Work out, work out what your lease pay, your amortization is over five years for like a $12,000 car. Yep.
- 17:45And you're like, okay, well, at the end of it, if there's any salvage value whatsoever, if they can reclaim the battery, or I can pass it on to my kids or whatever.
- 17:52Um, so I think we might be entering a new era where it's like it's just a different way at looking at, like, mobility and transportation. Mm-hmm.
- 17:58Especially if these devices become autonomous and we're sitting in the backseat. Mm-hmm. You're kind of like thinking like, "Well, what's the monthly cost to have transportation?"
- 18:07And it's a different, different equation- For sure... entirely, right? So- For sure. It's just a- Um-... it's, it's the, the conversation I have with people when they're considering a lease first purchase. Right.
- 18:15Like, do you ever plan on having a lower quality car?If the answer is no, then just understand that your monthly expense for a car of that level is going to be this, factor it in, lease the car, and don't worry about it.
- 18:26Right. Right? And, and so I, I agree with you. If they get cheap enough, more and more people play that game, because it's a much easier game to play.
- 18:32I was reading an article yesterday about a, someone who makes this a regular trip from, like, Nashville to Atlanta or something like that, and they said, "I decided to take my Tesla with full self-drive instead of flying like I usually do, and I liked it way better."
- 18:44Right. "It took the exact same amount of time, except I had peace, I didn't have all the brain damage, I ate what I want, I stopped when I wanted, and I had my car when I got there." Yep.
- 18:51So I think this, the, the affordability issue is a big one. You know, I've been hearing some conversations. Obviously you're talking about these dark factories, uh, you know, energy and AI running things.
- 19:01And, and so naturally speaking, that's gonna drive costs down lower and lower and lower to the part where maybe a car does become, as weird as it is to think about, uh, like a consumable item instead of something people look at as a hard asset.
- 19:12And this, this, you know, we use this a lot because it's true. This is likely the second-largest or first-largest purchase that every American will make. Yep.
- 19:21And if that changes fundamentally, obviously the business model can change fundamentally. I think they can do a lot for, uh, unit sales too. Yep.
- 19:28Yeah, I mean, if, if we start offering cheaper cars, this is one of the things I, I wanna think, think through, is, you know, what does SAR go to, you know, new, new car sales- Yeah...
- 19:36if we did have cars that were $12,000? Sure. You're gonna... Well, you're gonna cannibalize used car sales to some degree. People who would've otherwise had to buy used will start buying new.
- 19:44But you could see SAR going up to 20, 22 million simply because, hey, you know, if they're available at a price point I can afford, why wouldn't I buy new versus used?
- 19:53And, um, you know, we might be selling a lot more new cars than we ever have in the past. Yeah. Or this is America, Steve, and you know we buy garages to store the stuff we don't use. [laughs] Right?
- 20:03I mean, why wouldn't I have two or three of these things then? Right. Right. And why not- Buy five... bu- why not five? I would love five cars. I know a lot of people with five cars, but I'm not one of them.
- 20:11[laughs] There you go. [laughs] Steve, thank you again for joining us on the show and getting our brains going, giving us something to think about. Uh, keep adding sticky notes to that.
- 20:18We are anxiously- I'm working on it... awaiting your keynote. Go get your tickets at asotocon.com. [upbeat music]