Latest / Logistics With Purpose® I Building Better Supply Chains / Business as a Force for Good: The Power of Stakeholder Capitalism
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Logistics with Purpose presented by Vector Global Logistics in partnership with Supply Chain.
- 0:08Now we spotlight and celebrate organizations who are dedicated to creating a positive impact.
- 0:14Join us for this behind the scenes glimpse of the origin stories, change, making progress and future plans of organizations who are actively making a difference.
- 0:24Our goal isn't just to entertain you, but to inspire you to go out and change the world.
- 0:29And now, here's today's episode of Logistics with Purpose.
- 0:35Welcome, welcome, welcome.
- 0:37I'm delighted to be here with you again.
- 0:39A new interesting interview.
- 0:41I'm Enrique Alvarez with Logistics with Purpose.
- 0:43I'm with my co host, Kristi Porter.
- 0:46Kristi, how are you doing this week?
- 0:47I'm good.
- 0:48It has been really cloudy here in New Jersey, so the sun is out today.
- 0:53It's a little cooler, but I welcome the sun and got my buddy Great Dane sitting beside me.
- 0:59So it's a good day.
- 1:00It's a good day to be out here.
- 1:00It's a great day for an interview.
- 1:02Another interesting interview.
- 1:03I like the fact that we're trying this new software as well.
- 1:06So it's exciting.
- 1:07We have our guinea pig ready and we'll be, we'll be rolling in a second, but go ahead.
- 1:12Christy, why don't you just do us the honor of introducing our guest today?
- 1:16So I am delighted to introduce Nathan Havey, co founder of Stakeholder Business and writer and director of the podcast miniseries 10 things you should know about stakeholder capitalism, which sounds intriguing and the Beyond Zero film.
- 1:29Nathan, thank you so much for joining us.
- 1:31Enrique's had the pleasure of meeting you, but I am delighted to have the opportunity now as well.
- 1:36Likewise, Kristy, and it's my pleasure to be here.
- 1:38Yeah, thank you.
- 1:39We've got a lot to get into.
- 1:41You're doing a lot of really cool things, but first I want to ask you just some quick questions.
- 1:46We'll get you warmed up and answer with just the first thing that comes to mind.
- 1:50Sounds good.
- 1:51So what is one thing you can't live without?
- 1:53One thing I can't live without, I would say, you know, I'm a family person and so I'll just say that my wife and kids are something that I don't think I live without.
- 2:02They're pretty awesome.
- 2:03That's good.
- 2:03We'll make sure that they know you answered that well.
- 2:06Here.
- 2:06What is your favorite book?
- 2:07Yeah, favorite book right now is a book called Donut Economics, which turns a lot of sort of the classic assumptions that we have about economics on its head.
- 2:15And that gets us to really consider what is the true goal of commerce, of industry, of business.
- 2:20And it's really inspiring.
- 2:22Ooh, that sounds fascinating.
- 2:23Favorite place to be.
- 2:25You know, my family has a house in the mountains of Southern Colorado, and that is my favorite place to be.
- 2:30One thing you do to stay productive.
- 2:32If I haven't kind of thought about planning what I need to get done in a given week, I am not productive.
- 2:39And so it's planning.
- 2:40It's taking a minute to really think through what needs to happen, and laying that out on a calendar.
- 2:44Awesome.
- 2:45And one thing you do to relax at the end of the day, you.
- 2:48Know, that's in flux.
- 2:49I would have said, you know, have a drink, but I'm trying to do less of that.
- 2:53Okay.
- 2:53And so I think that it's more just a little bit of, like, a gratitude meditation is the thing that is working for me lately.
- 3:00That's good.
- 3:01Always good to be grateful.
- 3:02Thank you very much for your answers, and welcome again to the show.
- 3:05This is amazing to have you.
- 3:06As Christie was saying, we met each other a while back at the CEO Summit, and it's been a pleasure talking to you ever since.
- 3:13Taking a little bit of a quick deviation here to your background, like, when you were younger, some of the things that you actually remember from your childhood, something that you kind of grew up that you can share, that
- 3:24kind of shaped who you are now.
- 3:26Yeah.
- 3:26I was thinking about this, and I remember a moment.
- 3:30Whereas, you know, my dad was a photographer and a filmmaker also, and he had a production studio in downtown Denver.
- 3:36And it was always a treat, we lived in the suburbs to get to go into the city and hang out.
- 3:40And I don't know why we were there, but I do remember that the TV was on in the background, and it happened to be sort of the live news coverage of apartheid falling in South Africa.
- 3:50It sticks out in my memory because I feel like up until that point, I'd gone through public education, and we'd been taught that slavery and civil rights and, you know, all of that stuff were these big problems, but
- 4:03they were handled.
- 4:03That was all in the past, and now everything was good.
- 4:06And I think that as I was watching what was happening in South Africa, and my parents were doing their best to explain the context of apartheid and all that kind of stuff, I was like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa,
- 4:17whoa.
- 4:17This was happening while I've been here living my life, and I had no idea about that.
- 4:22And so it sort of was this formative moment of deciding that I wanted to have my life and career be about, I guess, continuing that march of progress for creating the world that we wish we had.
- 4:35You know, something that really is a world that works for everyone with no one and nothing left out.
- 4:40And I didn't know what the hell form that was going to take, but it was sort of looking back, the sort of moment that I had an awakening that there was work to do in the world, and I
- 4:49wanted to be part of that.
- 4:50Wow.
- 4:51It seems that we still don't know exactly how that's going to look out at the end years and years after you had that moment.
- 4:57It's true.
- 4:57But we continue with the work and we need to make sure that this happens one way or another, so.
- 5:02And what was the work?
- 5:03Did your dad do a documentary film?
- 5:05He fled the structures of very formal Catholicism in his youth and went out to the uncharted open west in 1974ish.
- 5:15Then met my mom.
- 5:16And he really wanted to live the life of an artist.
- 5:19He was an armchair philosopher and just wanted to kind of create things of beauty.
- 5:23And so he got really into photography, which turned into filmmaking.
- 5:27He liked stories, storytelling and creating films.
- 5:30And he was known as kind of the Ken Burns of Colorado.
- 5:34And so he.
- 5:34He's the guy that did most of the historical films about Colorado and the Rocky Mountain West.
- 5:38So I grew up with that kind of an influence.
- 5:41Wow, that's a great nickname.
- 5:43That's impressive.
- 5:43That tells me already a lot about him.
- 5:45So a very cool lineage.
- 5:48And so I'm curious, obviously, now you followed in his footsteps in many ways.
- 5:51Is there something that when you.
- 5:53Maybe when you're making a film, a process or a moment or something, that comes to mind that you really think, I know exactly where I got this?
- 5:59Yeah, I think he, like I said, with the armchair philosophy thing.
- 6:03Right.
- 6:03He was really into a lot of, I guess what would have been called New Age, you know, more Eastern philosophy stuff.
- 6:09And one of his favorites was Joseph Campbell.
- 6:11Right.
- 6:12And so he wrote the book Hero with a Thousand Faces and a few others.
- 6:14And he had studied through his career all of these different myths and stories that had been told that had survived from antiquity from all cultures around the world, including indigenous cultures.
- 6:25And then he had sort of come up with this theory that there's this kind of central arc to the great stories of humanity and it can sort of help us to understand ourselves.
- 6:35And it's the hero's journey.
- 6:37And so I think a lot of folks probably familiar with that.
- 6:39It's definitely the map of 85, 90% of the movies that come out.
- 6:44Certainly all of the marvel Universe and Lord of the Rings and Star wars and all that stuff.
- 6:48And it's this call to adventure that we are greater than we dare to believe.
- 6:54And that if we are willing to, as Campbell said, enter the forest at the darkest point, the place where you can't see what is happening, then that is where you will find the true shape of your own self
- 7:04and you will come out of it changed, and you will live the journey that you were meant to live in this lifetime.
- 7:10And it's a pretty cool poetic thing, right.
- 7:12And so I really love to tell the stories of the people who have really, really done that and specifically done it in largely a business context, but have done it in service of the kind of work that needs
- 7:24to be done in the world.
- 7:25And so that's a lot of how that stuff comes together for me back in Colorado.
- 7:29And thanks for sharing that.
- 7:30About your dad, he sounds like an amazing person.
- 7:32What was his name?
- 7:33Jim Havey.
- 7:34Well, the culture to adventure and you mentioned it recently.
- 7:38So what was the call to you back in those days and what is the call for adventure now?
- 7:44Well, there were two sort of big moments.
- 7:45And so one of them was when I was a freshman in high school.
- 7:48I had this older boy that I had looked up to for years.
- 7:52He was a senior then.
- 7:53His name was Peter Nestor.
- 7:54And he had gotten an internship or something working with the mayor of Lakewood, Colorado, our little suburban town.
- 8:00And they were working on some policy initiative.
- 8:03It was even forget what it was, it was to repurpose an old mall to make it more of like a walking, work, live, community kind of a thing.
- 8:10And I head of its time.
- 8:11Well, right.
- 8:11I could.
- 8:12No, that's incredible.
- 8:13Did not care about the issue whatsoever.
- 8:15But Peter was working on this and I had heard at one point that he needed help organizing volunteers to do like a literature drop, you know, walking door to door through a neighborhood and dropping off campaign materials.
- 8:25And I was like, well, sure, I can.
- 8:27I can help.
- 8:27And you know, not knowing how it went or that it would be hard or whatever, I just organized like a ton of 13, 14 year olds to go and do this thing.
- 8:36None of them had ever been asked to do this before.
- 8:38And they all had a lot of free time.
- 8:40And so I got like a lot of people and I incentivized them by saying, hey, we're going to go walk a couple of precincts and then we're going to have a barbecue at my house.
- 8:46And they were like, sure.
- 8:47And so we covered like an insane amount of the city in one Weekend day.
- 8:52And word kind of spread that there was this army of like 14, 13 year olds around doing this thing.
- 8:58And the mayor ended up showing up at the barbecue.
- 9:01That is incredible.
- 9:02And I was like, what?
- 9:04Like, wow, that was easy and cool.
- 9:06And now, like, there's like, impact and like, this is neat.
- 9:11And so I sort of went the political route for a while and started to just do local politics and state politics.
- 9:16And by the time I was in college, I also was into theater and storytelling.
- 9:20So I had a double major in theater and political science.
- 9:23Called it the Ronald Reagan School of Success at the time, but then went for grad school and got a job working in the U.S.
- 9:29house of Representatives and was just trying to do the policy route because I thought that was how you drove change in the world.
- 9:35Right?
- 9:35You were active politically.
- 9:36I mean, I could see myself running for office and all that kind of stuff.
- 9:39And then I got into what it actually is to try to organize political change and policy change inside of the US House and hated it.
- 9:48Just thought it was the worst idea, like, bless the people that have the patience for it.
- 9:52But I just saw it as a deeply dysfunctional system and not effective.
- 9:56It's changed, right?
- 9:57It's very different, yes.
- 9:59Very different today.
- 10:00Well, but I gotta say though, that.
- 10:02Did it help the fact that you actually had that theater political science gumbo?
- 10:07I mean, how much?
- 10:07And I'm more curious about the.
- 10:09The theater portion of it.
- 10:10Is it easier, better for a good public policymaker from George Washington University, by the way, to be an actor?
- 10:18I think that the thing about theater, yes, there's the performative and public speaking aspects and all that kind of stuff.
- 10:24And yeah, that's very, very helpful.
- 10:25But the sort of, the narrative creation, the power of storytelling is something that is.
- 10:30I think we know it, but I don't know if we actually know how powerful storytelling is in shaping our ideas, the way we see the world, all that kind of stuff.
- 10:39It's a stat that I read recently is written language is maybe 4,000 years old.
- 10:44And like the forms of communication in argument, logic, case making, all that kind of stuff, it's about 4,000 years old in society, but storytelling is probably 100,000 years old.
- 10:55And so to say that humans really do think and understand the world in terms of story, it's an understatement.
- 11:02Right.
- 11:03And so if you're looking at policy, if you're looking at how to frame policy, how to get people organized, if you're not doing that with a really savvy creation of story, you're not doing it right.
- 11:13And so that is a little bit of a understood superpower.
- 11:17But I'm not saying I have it, I'm just saying that is the way that it works.
- 11:20Right?
- 11:20That's what needs to happen.
- 11:21And the thing for me, I guess is that what I saw in Congress is that there was a game afoot by both parties that was about winning majority.
- 11:30And it was very short term.
- 11:32It was two year election cycles, right.
- 11:34And that everything that was happening there was really to try to score political points or deny political points to be able to win majority.
- 11:43And then in theory that's justified by.
- 11:45Because our agenda is important.
- 11:47And the only way we can get that through is if we have majority.
- 11:50But it's the same thing that happens in capitalism where if we're playing a really short term game, we do things that actually defeat the long term game.
- 11:57And that's.
- 11:58It's just the wrong game.
- 11:59And so when I saw that that is the game, I was like, I don't think this is how we get there.
- 12:04And so I got out of there.
- 12:05I met the woman who had become my wife and she was leaving for law school.
- 12:09We'd been dating for like three months and we had to have a conversation about is this worth me coming with you to law school?
- 12:14Or like, is this over?
- 12:15And we decided it was worth it.
- 12:17Anyway, I exited, but I did not know what the heck I was going to do.
- 12:20And back to your question, Enrique, about kind of the other aha moment or epiphany moment came in 2010.
- 12:25I didn't really know what I was going to do, so I thought, well, you know, nonprofits, nonprofits would be the other route to try to like, do the good work in the world.
- 12:32And so I got a job working for a new media company, we called it back then, doing social media and websites.
- 12:38And it was a for profit company, but it was serving nonprofits at the time.
- 12:41I didn't have any understanding about business and for profits and what that is really.
- 12:45And so I judged the leadership of that company very harshly for having me mark up the prices of the things that we would sell so that we could make a profit.
- 12:55Because to me at the time, it was like, wait a minute, we're doing this to try to advance the good here.
- 12:59Why are we charging them more than you know?
- 13:02So anyway, I just didn't.
- 13:03I was very naive and I did a great job of losing two of our biggest accounts in the same week and got good and fired.
- 13:10And so at that point I was really in a spot, not really knowing what to do.
- 13:13And it happened to be that I got a hold of Ray Anderson's book, Confessions of a Radical Industrialist.
- 13:19And in that book, he makes the case that at different points in human history, there have been different dominant institutions in the world that really organized the effort of humanity.
- 13:27Right.
- 13:27At one point it was the church, at one point it was state power.
- 13:30But really since the Industrial Revolution, and you could argue the exact timing on this, it's been for profit corporations that have really organized the effort of humanity around the world.
- 13:40And he makes the case that because it's the most powerful, best resourced institution in the world, it is really the one that must lead the change.
- 13:49And so that sort of idea of hit Ray Anderson when he read Paul Hawkins book in 1994 and set in motion what became the Interface Transformation Journey.
- 13:58And as I read that book, I saw a new, more effective pathway to do what I'd always dreamed I wanted to do, which was to really look at how business can be a very, very effective leader of the
- 14:10change that we need to see in the world.
- 14:11And since then, that was in about 2010, I got deep into the conscious capitalism movement and many similar groups.
- 14:17And now in recent years, increasingly all around the world, thanks to Beyond Zero, that is the work that engaged in now.
- 14:23That's wonderful.
- 14:24I'm curious.
- 14:25So, yes, huge shifts.
- 14:26I think it's still a perception today.
- 14:28I was actually talking to somebody about this yesterday.
- 14:30I think it's very common, not just coming out of working in government, but if you want to do good, you have to work in nonprofits.
- 14:36And for some reason, in 2025, that is still a prevailing theory, and I can't figure out why.
- 14:42And so I'm glad you made the recognition and the shift early.
- 14:45And so whenever you finally, I guess, forgave your bosses internally for trying to make a profit off of nonprofits, did you immediately see that?
- 14:54Oh, I want to go into this from a storytelling perspective or how did you see kind of your place in this new world?
- 14:59Yeah, I had no idea.
- 15:00And so this coincided with my wife got a clerkship after she finished law school with the Alaska Supreme Court.
- 15:08Wow.
- 15:08And so we moved up to Anchorage, where I knew absolutely no one.
- 15:11And I was trying to figure out how the heck I would do this thing.
- 15:14And the best I had at the time was to sort of work on higher purpose that companies, you know, if they.
- 15:19If they really were animated by a higher purpose, then that was sort of the first step toward them being impactful.
- 15:25And so I went around and knocked on doors of little mom and pop businesses in and around Anchorage and just started to do what I could do, which was some website social media, which evolved into communications consulting.
- 15:38Right.
- 15:38But trying to get them to talk to me about what their higher purpose was.
- 15:42And I had no idea how to do it.
- 15:44Right.
- 15:44It was pretty ridiculous in many cases early on.
- 15:46But I spent two or three years cutting my teeth, sort of understanding what it was and you know, flying back to every conscious capitalism conference and stuff like that that I could to sort become increasingly sophisticated still in
- 15:58a very like novice way, but learning, learning, learning and just trying it out, you know, learning by doing fast forward just a bit.
- 16:05I've been at it for four years when my wife's time in Alaska ends and we move to cutting out some of the story.
- 16:11But we moved to Northern Michigan, not the U.P.
- 16:14But as north as you can get.
- 16:15To a little teeny compared to Alaska.
- 16:17Yeah, well, I mean it's a similar kind of a thing, you know, tiny little small businesses.
- 16:21Again, I leave a community, I have no idea what's happening.
- 16:24Long story short, she wants to go on this camping trip to South Manitou island on the last weekend that the boats run.
- 16:31And I'm stressed trying to figure out how the heck I'm going to like network and build a practice of consulting or whatever.
- 16:37And I relent and I go and we are around a campfire ring where there's like one campfire ring for multiple camp sites.
- 16:44And so we show up and we start talking with these folks.
- 16:46And a lot of what I had been doing in the consulting world was just kind of telling people the stories of some of the cool conscious capitalism examples and Interface.
- 16:55And so I launch into that around this campfire not knowing who's there.
- 16:59You know, somebody made the mistake of asking me what I did for work and story time.
- 17:03The guy was Mike McFall and I didn't know who he was, I didn't know what Bigby Coffee was, but he gives me his card on the boat on the way home and I look him up and I'm like,
- 17:11whoa, this is like $100 million franchise.
- 17:13That's by far the biggest company I'd had access to at that point.
- 17:16And long story short, they hired me.
- 17:18And over the next three years we did a giant culture and purpose transformation largely based on the way that Interface had done what they did.
- 17:27And so I don't know if see Mike here on the wall, he and Bob were put on the COVID of Conscious Company magazine.
- 17:33Because of that work and, you know, our relationship and the work that we do together continues to this day.
- 17:38But that sort of was the first, like, real, wow, I can do this.
- 17:42I do know how to do it.
- 17:43And so then that led to opening up a whole bunch of other opportunities.
- 17:46It was pretty cool.
- 17:47Well, I'm a blank slate when it comes to Alaska.
- 17:50I don't have any idea what it would be to like, just go door to door asking people and having these questions.
- 17:55Same thing in smaller towns in Northern Michigan.
- 17:57So you were doing it at a very grassroots, especially early on.
- 18:01What were the conversations?
- 18:02What were you hearing early on in the movement?
- 18:05I think that it gives some benefit because if you're a small business, you kind of do a lot of this naturally, and it's because you're so proximate to the people that are in your company.
- 18:15Right.
- 18:15And so at least from like, you know, again, speaking in the language of conscious capitalism, if you're looking at conscious culture, generally, folks do pretty well with that because they haven't been so abstracted that people are just numbers
- 18:27on a spreadsheet or line, items that need to be trimmed to drop more money down to the box, bottom line.
- 18:32And so you just don't have a lot of the more toxic expressions of hierarchy and capitalism at a small level.
- 18:39Similarly, though, you've got folks that are kind of just in it for whatever the business is, and they don't really consider the broader stakeholders, environment, community.
- 18:47They don't see that they have much agency to change those things.
- 18:51And in truth, they don't have agency to change the meta systems.
- 18:54Right.
- 18:54But they actually do have quite a lot of agency in terms of the decisions that they make for their own company.
- 19:00And so they're still constrained by like, like the available possibilities that supply chains and logistics afford and all that kind of stuff.
- 19:07But based on the choices they have, they have tremendous discretion to make those choices.
- 19:12Whereas at larger, larger levels of companies, the approval processes and the getting people on board and the, you know, all it.
- 19:18It's a lot harder to do change at that level than it is for smaller companies to do it.
- 19:23So I think it just gave a really, really good, I guess, experience and understanding of some of those dynamics that you wouldn't get if your consulting training was through a McKinsey or a Deloitte or something that.
- 19:34Right.
- 19:35So I don't have the other training.
- 19:36I've never done a McKinsey or a Deloitte.
- 19:38I've never been able to do a major consulting engagement inside of a Fortune 500 company.
- 19:43But it's an interesting perspective.
- 19:45You need both at the same time, right.
- 19:47In order for change to really be impactful and for change to actually be real.
- 19:51And you went on to found you're the co founder of stakeholder business.
- 19:56And before you tell us a bit more about that business, what does stakeholder mean to you?
- 20:00I mean, can you define the term for us in your own words?
- 20:03Not using maybe conscious capitalism lingo, but what does it mean to you as an individual?
- 20:08I guess for me, one way to think of stakeholders is the things and the people without whom you could not do your business.
- 20:16There's a book called the Spirit of the Glacier Speaks by a shaman from the Lakota and Andean native traditions.
- 20:24And in the Andean language there's a concept of ayni, I think is the way you say it.
- 20:28It's a Y N I.
- 20:29And it's basically this, I'll use the word covenantal relationship because it's not transactional.
- 20:35It's not that I'm going to sort of take care of the because you are giving me something I need, but it's deeper than that.
- 20:42It's kind of the recognition that we are in this together for better or worse.
- 20:46And I'm gonna take care of you because you're worthy of care, right?
- 20:50And then yes, you're probably gonna take care of me too.
- 20:53But I'm not doing it for the reciprocity, I'm doing it because you are worthy of care.
- 20:58Right.
- 20:58And so there's that kind of a thing.
- 21:00And so if you're looking at the systems upon which you depend, there is this, there's that kind of a covenantal relationship that I think ideally we would.
- 21:10That's the real essence of stakeholder.
- 21:13It definitely makes sense to me and I hope some more listeners find that rational and logical as well.
- 21:18But I think that that's just the essence of being a human, right.
- 21:21I think that you actually have that deep down and you want to care for each other because you know that if you do, everyone will be better off, everyone will be protected.
- 21:30And it's just frustrating some of these days when we find out kind of not being honest to that very universal law, I would say, right?
- 21:38And we're to trying, trying to get all these different things, shorter term gains as opposed to really thinking about like we are all in this world together, whether we like it or not, whether you want to call it
- 21:49one way or the other.
- 21:50And that's something that you very early on realized and then you also put in practice as you were telling all these different stories from all these different businesses before we go into the actual Beyond Zero movie, which I
- 22:03know everyone wants to get in and get a little more details about and tell us a little bit about the stakeholder business.
- 22:08But then also, as you progress, since you were in Colorado with your dad, I'm guessing you kept practicing this directing.
- 22:16I mean, I'm guessing filmmaking was still your passion.
- 22:18You still make all those personal videos that kind of led to the storytelling through film at the end of the day, right?
- 22:25Yeah.
- 22:26And it's weird, though, Enrique, because I literally just in the past couple of months, have I connected the dots on that.
- 22:33I've always made videos and films.
- 22:35I don't know if it was like sort of the don't want to follow and my father's footsteps, like, young man thing, but I have.
- 22:42You are correct.
- 22:43Ever since there was the ability for amateur people to be putting films and videos and stuff together, I've always done it, and I've done it just because I love it.
- 22:51It's a total passion area.
- 22:52But I didn't do it in earnest until Beyond Zero.
- 22:56And so that was, you know, 2017, I think, is when I met Aaron Mizan in Atlanta at a storytelling event that was brought to Atlanta in partnership with the Conscious Capitalism chapter there.
- 23:06And so the book I read for Interface, right, stops in 20, because that's when Ray wrote it.
- 23:11And so I had been telling the story as of 2010, all the way up to, like, 2017.
- 23:16And in 2017, I heard what had happened over the subsequent seven years and what the plan was for the next few.
- 23:22And it blew my mind.
- 23:24As big as my mind had been blown when I read the book the first time.
- 23:27And I started to really get this understanding that there.
- 23:29I mean, people don't know this thing, they need to know it.
- 23:32And then the next year, I had a chance to meet Jim Hartsfeld, who was one of the original players in the Interface story.
- 23:37And he told me all this stuff that was not in Richard Ray's book about the early years.
- 23:41And I was like, holy smokes.
- 23:43And I saw in it I saw a hero's journey.
- 23:45I saw the whole thing.
- 23:46I was just like, somebody needs to make this into a movie.
- 23:49And I did not relate to myself as a filmmaker.
- 23:52I was a consultant, right?
- 23:54But I just could not put the notion away.
- 23:56And I approached my dad and said, you know, because I can't edit, I can't shoot at that level.
- 24:01You know, I might be able to write, but that was it.
- 24:03And so I said, would you and the team be interested in considering this?
- 24:07I mean, he's like, if you can put the budget and the deal together, we would totally consider that.
- 24:11And so I was like, well, I've never done that before.
- 24:13But I went and actually asked Mike and Bob from Bigby if they would be willing to put up some seed capital to help me get a first shoot under my belt and create a trailer that I could then
- 24:22go use to create other funding.
- 24:24And they said yes.
- 24:24And so then it's like, all right, we're off for the races on.
- 24:27And then, you know, one thing led to another, and by 2020, we had the movie done.
- 24:31Well, tell us about Beyond Zero.
- 24:33We now know a little bit more of the behind the movie and what led you there, but tell us more about it.
- 24:38What is it about?
- 24:39Clearly, you have a huge passion for it and a driving force, and we're going to get it done, but let's talk more about it.
- 24:46Yeah.
- 24:46So the way to understand it, I think, is that 1994, Ray Anderson had been this sort of.
- 24:52He had lived the entrepreneur's dream.
- 24:53He had founded a carpet tile manufacturing company, and he had worked in another big carpet company as a young man fresh out of college.
- 25:01He had seen the innovation of a carpet tile that had happened in the UK and was like, this is going to revolutionize the industry.
- 25:09We need to do this.
- 25:10But the company that he was working for didn't get it.
- 25:12And so he was like, well, I have to do this.
- 25:14And so he, you know, at great personal risk, founded Interface 1974 and had built it by 1994 into a fortune $500 billion or even more company.
- 25:26And, you know, had done it.
- 25:27And in 1994, he was sort of in a place of trying to figure out what was next when the company lost a massive order in California because they couldn't answer the question, what is Interface doing for the environment?
- 25:39And Ray remembered a Day in 1970 when he had all of his capital equipment set up, ready to go in a warehouse, in a factory, and not one order on the books.
- 25:48And so he remembered that every order, every order is like the next heartbeat for a company, right?
- 25:55And when he lost one, he took it super seriously.
- 25:58And so it sort of sent him into a little bit of a tailspin, asking all of his executives, what do they mean, we're not doing enough for the environment?
- 26:04We comply with the law.
- 26:05What else is there for business to do?
- 26:07What are you talking about?
- 26:08And so he doesn't know what to do.
- 26:09And then he creates a task force to go figure it out.
- 26:12And the task force says, okay, Rick, come tell us your vision.
- 26:15He's like, no, figure it out.
- 26:16We need your vision.
- 26:17And so finally he agrees to make this speech on August 31st of 1994 and a couple of weeks before that.
- 26:24He has no idea what the hell he's going to say.
- 26:26And serendipitously actually tell the backstory that's not in the movie on this.
- 26:29There was one of his right hand people was this woman named Joyce Lavalle.
- 26:33And her daughter had gone through a very early environmental science class in her college and they had read a book called the Ecology of Commerce by Paul, Paul Hawken.
- 26:44And she had been at her mother saying, you really need to understand what Carpet does in the world and what all of industry does.
- 26:53It is not good and you need to be accountable for this.
- 26:57And you need to get this book to your boss so that you guys can figure it out.
- 27:01Right?
- 27:02So that's going on in the background.
- 27:03Ray is having this moment and sure enough, Joyce is able to get that book onto his desk right in this moment.
- 27:10And he takes it home and he reads it and it blows his mind.
- 27:12He's an engineer by training.
- 27:14He's got a phenomenal, I guess just sobriety about the way that systems work.
- 27:19And Paul Hawken in that book lays out that all of the life support systems of the planet Earth were in decline in 1994, all of them.
- 27:27And Ray looks at it and has what he calls a spear in the chest moment, realizing that he is a plunderer of the Earth, that all of his success has come at the expense of the life support systems
- 27:39of the planet, as has the success of, of humanity at that point.
- 27:43Right.
- 27:44But he's not one who says, well, what we need to do is we need to stop all of this and we need to go back to a pre industrial way of living, because that's just not going to work.
- 27:53So we have to figure out how to get the Industrial Revolution to go through a second industrial revolution, to get all of the manufacturing processes that we use for everything in the world to reinvent themselves, to be in
- 28:07line with the life support systems of nature.
- 28:10And so he has all this hit him in one dark night of the soul.
- 28:13And he's shows up on August 31, 1994, and lays this all out to a team of about 18 business leaders from around the world for Interface.
- 28:21And they think he's gone crazy.
- 28:23They think he's totally lost it.
- 28:24And so, so begins the hero's journey.
- 28:26Right?
- 28:27You can hear it in the way that it happens.
- 28:29And so Ray is unrelenting.
- 28:30And 20 years later, Interface is recognized by the UN as one of the most sustainable companies in the world.
- 28:36This piece of carpentile actually is carbon sequestration.
- 28:40They have got that.
- 28:40It's so dialed in.
- 28:41The process is so efficient that when you add a little bit of bio based material into the backing, you actually get a negative carbon signature on this thing.
- 28:49So as they're doing their business now, it's actively sequestering carbon.
- 28:53And so that's one of many, many, many examples of the way that they figured out how to completely reimagine the way that they do their business in ways that were highly profitable.
- 29:03They're running laps around their competitors on this kind of stuff.
- 29:07They are the brand in the world for anybody that cares about SUST and interiors.
- 29:12And they've been able to have the company work great.
- 29:14Now is it a hockey stick kind of a growth?
- 29:16No, it's not.
- 29:17But you know, if you ask their chairman why that is, he goes because nobody cares about our stock.
- 29:21We're part of an industry portfolio.
- 29:23We rise and fall with carpet.
- 29:25Right.
- 29:25There just isn't differentiation in terms of the broader stock market.
- 29:29So you can't tell that story about Interface.
- 29:31But what you can were you to factor in the actual environmental costs that almost all manufacturers pass off as external.
- 29:39If you were to incorporate those into a balance sheet to look at the true performance of the company, including the value that is created or destroyed in terms of environmental and social.
- 29:50Right.
- 29:50If you were to put a dollar amount on that and include it.
- 29:52Most companies are actually in the red.
- 29:54They operate in the red.
- 29:55They're actively destroying value in excess of the financial value they're creating.
- 30:00If you looked at Interface's balance sheet on that, they're not doing that.
- 30:03If we had a different way of accounting for all of this, you would be able to see very, very clearly the way that a company like Inter is performing as a lighthouse to help guide the rest of industry
- 30:14for where we need to get.
- 30:15That's a very inspiring.
- 30:17And honestly, I think that's just going to be what companies need to do if they want to keep in business.
- 30:22Right.
- 30:22Which is something that I really appreciate from the movie.
- 30:25It's like this is we're not doing it because we're nice or because we are different.
- 30:29We're doing it because if we don't do it, we're going to go out of business.
- 30:33And I feel like that's something that we need to keep hammering in and we need to keep saying because some companies just don't see it, but that will be of the future.
- 30:41I was just trying to actually dig into some of the writing that you see all over right now talking about, you know, we need to put a stake in stakeholder capitalism, ESG is gone, good riddance, you know, stuff
- 30:55like that, which, you know, it's a, I'm trying to understand it.
- 30:58And the basic argument is that if you go to stakeholder capitalism versus the shareholder model that has really been dominant for the past 50 years, that has been very successful at creating a ton of, of financial capital, it's
- 31:11made a lot of people very, very rich.
- 31:13And if you look at the average quality of life, the length of life over the past 50 years, I mean, humanity is making phenomenal progress.
- 31:20And much of that is thanks to capitalism and for the last 50 years, shareholder Primacy capitalism.
- 31:27But if you then factor in things like inequity, the gross inequity that we've got, if you look at it certainly in terms of environment, it is pretty clear that it's very, very unsustainable.
- 31:38And the folks that are really propone of a shareholder capitalism model argue that companies will lose focus if they are trying to serve all of their stakeholders and if they're trying to drive environmental goals that are separate from
- 31:53their business and do DE and I and you know, that they're trying to serve too many interests and they'll lose focus and they won't do anything.
- 32:00Well, there's some truth in that.
- 32:02There is some truth in that.
- 32:03But the thing that they just don't deal with in any of these arguments is, okay, okay, then how would you suggest we solve the problem of the fact that we're killing the life support systems of Earth?
- 32:14And the closest that I've seen in any of those things is, well, it's just not the role of business, it's government that has to say that.
- 32:21But if you look at the way government works, as we've discussed, you know, business also actively flummoxes the effort of policymakers to try to address this problem.
- 32:30And so it feels either a little bit like blinders or a little disingenuous.
- 32:35And let's give people credit and let's just say that they're really focused on one thing.
- 32:39But it's just the level of complexity that we have to struggle with right now is something that is difficult.
- 32:43It is different.
- 32:44We are not wired to do this as human beings, our minds do not work this way very well, and we've got to figure out how to get there.
- 32:51Right?
- 32:52That's a thing.
- 32:52But the chairman of Interface argues that people are going to have to.
- 32:56They're going to have to transform.
- 32:58And what will likely come is it's like it'll happen gradually and then all at once.
- 33:03And so if companies aren't feeling an absolute necessity to do this right now, okay.
- 33:09But when the necessity gets here, if you're not already well positioned for it, it's going to be too late.
- 33:14So I guess.
- 33:15I guess we'll see.
- 33:15I guess we will see.
- 33:16But I think that, you know, there's a great New Yorker cartoon that is, you know, this sort of debate that looks like it's in Congress or the UN or something.
- 33:23And the one speaker says, so wait a minute, you're telling me if we invest in green jobs and we have all this economic growth and climate change isn't as dire as we thought, that we did all this for
- 33:34nothing?
- 33:34And the truth is, the way that companies have been pursuing some environmental goals, some de.
- 33:40And I has been from a place of a side project, and they haven't really done the work to figure out how you actually integrate that stuff into the way you do your core business.
- 33:50And then the critics have a point, but the way to do it, the way Interface did it, right, is that this wasn't a side project.
- 33:55This was absolutely core to their strategy.
- 33:58And when it's absolutely core to your strategy, it drives employee engagement, it drives innovation, it drives competitiveness in ways that actually create outsized returns.
- 34:07And so the way you do this is something that.
- 34:10I think there is a third kind of a way where you've got people that are saying, we need to.
- 34:13You've got people saying, no, no, no, it's going to be a distraction for business.
- 34:16But you can take both of those folks at their word and find the way that it becomes the core focus of the business.
- 34:22And that's where we find one of the things we say in the 10 things you should know about stakeholder capitalism is there's thesis.
- 34:27There's always antithesis, right?
- 34:29The things that are wrong with the thesis and that eventually there's something called synthesis where the proponents and the opponents are able to actually agree on something, and that's generally the right pathway forward.
- 34:39And that's where we got to get.
- 34:40I love that.
- 34:41Well, kind of along those lines can be.
- 34:44Obviously Interface is a great example, but there.
- 34:46It's really hard for Legacy companies, very large companies, to make that shift.
- 34:51You've worked in consulting, you've done research in a lot of these other ways in your storytelling and talking to so many people in conscious capitalism and just otherwise.
- 35:01So even talking about making it the core thing and not stuck in a committee or, you know, a foundation or something like that, still a big process.
- 35:07So how would you recommend people, what are a few steps, what are a few questions to ask?
- 35:13How can we help people kind of begin to make this new mindset, Mindset shift?
- 35:18I think there's two really important things.
- 35:20So the first thing is that we need to sort of recognize that we as business people, but broader than that, in broader society, we exist within the systems that were created, that have the world work the way it
- 35:32works.
- 35:32And so we are all complicit, like Ray was, in being part of the problem.
- 35:37And there's nothing shameful about that.
- 35:39I don't believe in finger wagging and telling people that they're bad and wrong.
- 35:43Right?
- 35:43We are all in this, and we're all in these systems.
- 35:46And so the best that we can sort of see the systems that we're in, I guess, the better equipped we are to be able to make intelligent choices with the right information.
- 35:54Right?
- 35:54And so I want to, I want to say this in a specific way for business people in particular, is that if they've been to business school, they were taught a certain way of seeing the world, right?
- 36:01If they read business media, all of that is still framed in that way.
- 36:04Let's call it shareholder supremacy, right?
- 36:06The associations that they're part of, they all still work in that way, right?
- 36:10Enrique, I think you're part of eo, are you not?
- 36:12Right.
- 36:13So just not to blame eo.
- 36:15Ypo, there's lots of the local chambers of commerce, all of these associations, they are all still obsessed, obsessed with financial growth.
- 36:22And they don't have a lot of space for talking about the social and environmental performance of companies.
- 36:27There's some, there's some.
- 36:28But the people that are really held up as great exemplars are still the ones that are performing best in financial capital alone.
- 36:33Right?
- 36:34Okay, got it.
- 36:35Consultants, especially the bigger consultants, they're all attuned with those goals in mind.
- 36:39And so as a business person, especially as a CEO, all of the influences that you take in in a given day prime you for shareholder primacy.
- 36:48That's.
- 36:48That's the system, right?
- 36:49There's nothing wrong with that.
- 36:50But if you want to do something different, you need to consciously get yourself into a Community and to get other things in your space so that you can constantly start to see the systems as they work and begin
- 37:02to look for the alternative, which gives you a competitive advantage because you're looking at it a way that nobody else is looking at it, right?
- 37:08So that is one of the systems that's at play.
- 37:11So number one is consciously choose the influences that you're allowing into your space, right?
- 37:18And make sure that they're consistent with your goals and your aspirations.
- 37:21And that's a big deal.
- 37:22So that's the first thing.
- 37:23The second thing is you got to pick your thing, right?
- 37:26It's important to like be conscious of all the things and do what you can to not do active harm in some of these other areas.
- 37:33But there is a thing that you are uniquely suited, you personally and with your company to go after.
- 37:40And when you are able to make the shift on that, you make it possible for all of the rest of us to just do your thing.
- 37:47And so carpet as an example, right?
- 37:49Ray didn't go and try to just plant a bunch of forests all over the place.
- 37:53He focused on his core thing, which was carpet.
- 37:55And now it is possible for the rest of us to not have to go do a bunch of work and innovation.
- 37:59We can just buy the damn carpet.
- 38:01Okay, this one's solved.
- 38:02We got this one.
- 38:03And interestingly, the fiber, right, the nylon that's on here, it was technically impossible to recycle nylon.
- 38:10Nobody knew that you could do that when they decided that they needed to recycle nylon.
- 38:15And it was a decade long innovation journey, not by them, but by one of their suppliers, Italian company called Aquafill, that cracked the technological nut on this and made recycled nylon a thing.
- 38:25And so great, they solved that one.
- 38:27Now Gucci, Prada, Levi's, they can all use this fiber without having to go fix that, right?
- 38:33That's the way that this whole thing is going to go down is we all just have to figure out which one of those things we are going to solve and make available to the world, right?
- 38:41And you know what we call that business?
- 38:43So that's what we got to do.
- 38:45And like, there's another thing that Bigby is up to right now, just since we mentioned them, if you look at the way that the commodity market marketplace sources coffee, it's a wash in awful externalities that nobody wants to
- 38:57really talk about.
- 38:57So that's one of the new storytelling projects that I'm working on with them right now, is trying to have that same thing happen for coffee, right?
- 39:04Because we, I Don't know.
- 39:05You drink coffee?
- 39:06I drink coffee every morning.
- 39:07That's one of those things, right.
- 39:08And yes, you can go and have to do all of the homework to try to figure out how to be an ethical buyer of coffee.
- 39:14We're not gonna until somebody does the work and makes it easy.
- 39:17That's what they're up to.
- 39:18And that's the thing that all of us need to be engaged in right now is what is, is the thing that you are suited to be able to go do where you can just provide the solution.
- 39:27And once that solution exists, you know how much easier it's going to be for the Fortune 500s to be like, oh, we just buy this and not that.
- 39:33Yes, it has to be that simple.
- 39:35Right.
- 39:35And that I believe, is what's coming.
- 39:37And so if companies are not really ambitiously going for that right now, they might find themselves in a situation where somebody else says, no, no, no, don't buy that, buy this.
- 39:46And then they're toast.
- 39:48Well, and guess what, that kind of comes full circle back to the thing that you said at end the beginning.
- 39:53That is the only sustainable way to maximize shareholder value.
- 39:58So all my saying is all this argument between the stakeholder and shareholder, I think it just resolved by having a longer term, right?
- 40:05So if you look and your vision's longer term, the way you maximize shareholder value is by maximizing stakeholder value.
- 40:12If you are just narrow sighted and want to make a quick buck, even if it's great.
- 40:16Because sure enough, the way capitalism is understood these days definitely brings wealth to the world and certain communities.
- 40:24Not all of them clearly, but it could be even better.
- 40:27Right.
- 40:28So it just depends on what you're measuring up against.
- 40:31And yes.
- 40:31Are we better off?
- 40:32Sure, we have been even better off then certainly this has been great.
- 40:36And I really appreciate you kind of like turning the whole thing back to its origins and questioning the way that we conduct business today.
- 40:44That's very important.
- 40:44Yeah.
- 40:45And I guess I would just say one other thing.
- 40:46Back to one of the questions, right.
- 40:48Of this donut economics book that's my favorite right now.
- 40:51You know, we really need to start from a place, place of what really is the goal.
- 40:54Because we conflate GDP growth and business growth with the goal.
- 40:59And the theory, right, is that GDP growth and business growth is the thing that creates wealth.
- 41:03And with wealth, people can have the things that they need at an individual and societal level to be able to pursue happiness.
- 41:10Right?
- 41:11That is true.
- 41:12However, it does seem to have a bit of an upper boundary where actual happiness Right.
- 41:17And wealth seem to decouple somewhere around $100,000.
- 41:22And I'm not saying that you cap wealth and nobody more than that.
- 41:25No, no, no, no, no.
- 41:25I'm just saying that after that we're chasing wealth for its own purpose and no longer because it's serving the true goal, which I think would be something like a world that works for everyone with no one and nothing
- 41:37left out.
- 41:37Right.
- 41:38And so GDP does the same thing where even the person who created GDP said that this would be a horrible single measure of the performance of an economy.
- 41:46You cut down trees and that's good for gdp.
- 41:48You have more sick people, that's good for gdp.
- 41:50The incentives are misaligned.
- 41:51And so we have to have a slightly more sophisticated outlook at how we measuring the actual performance of companies and economies.
- 42:00And I believe that the goal of that performance, as Kate Raworth says in Donut economics, needs to be helping all people meet the basic needs of a thriving life.
- 42:09And we have to do that within the environmental constraints of the ecosystem.
- 42:13Right.
- 42:14It's not a zero sum game.
- 42:15Right?
- 42:15I mean, some people think that in order for me to have more, someone else has to have less.
- 42:19And that's just dumb.
- 42:20Now, I don't know how else to put it.
- 42:22That's just dumb.
- 42:22Technologically speaking, that might have have been true until about 1940, 1860, depending on what you're looking at.
- 42:29But by the 70s, it had been demonstrated again and again that there literally is enough that human beings are efficient enough that we can create more with less.
- 42:39Such that the needs of even the 8 billion people on Earth today and the 9 billion people that are going to be here in another 15, 20 years, there is enough for everybody to be able to meet their
- 42:50needs and then some.
- 42:52And so yes, it was once true that it was a relative zero sum game because of the limits of our technology.
- 42:58But we've already crossed that threshold.
- 43:00We did it 50 years ago, similar with supply chains.
- 43:03We had the pleasure of interviewing Annie Angle the other day from Cotopaxi, and she actually said something that really stuck with me, which is that we have enough textiles in this world to make clothing for nine generations of
- 43:15humans already in stock.
- 43:17We have enough textiles in stock today to just.
- 43:20Isn't that mind boggling?
- 43:21It's incredible.
- 43:22Honestly.
- 43:22I think companies are starting to realize this.
- 43:24This is not a movement.
- 43:25I think that's starting to become a very economic strategy for a lot of corporations like of course, Interface and some others out there.
- 43:34So thank you so, so much, Nathan.
- 43:36How can our listeners connect with you and of course learn more about not only stakeholder business, but then also about the movie and some of your future projects, which I know are plenty great.
- 43:46Yeah.
- 43:46Thank you, Enrique.
- 43:47So stakeholder businesses, I mentioned that CEOs need to find a place where the influences that are coming at them are the ones they need, not the default.
- 43:55And so stakeholder business is a community for CEOs that are seeking to build companies of consequence.
- 44:02And so if anybody's interested in that, they can go to stakeholderbusiness.com and if you're not a CEO, or even if you are, I am just a couple weeks away from launching, somewhat begrudgingly, Nathanhavey.com but the thing that I'm
- 44:14excited about is that I'm starting to very deliberately play a game that is in line with everything that we've talked about here.
- 44:20And I call it the Best World Game.
- 44:22And the goal of the game is to see how we create the best world and to see how many points we can rack up each month, each quarter, each year.
- 44:29And it's a cool game.
- 44:30And so if you want to come check that out, I don't know when we're releasing this, but nathanhavey.com there will be a a spot to sign up for updates or you'll get, if you like the kinds of stuff
- 44:40we're talking about here, lots more where that came from and that's how to get that.
- 44:43I have no doubt.
- 44:44Lots more to come from you by just you dropped a lot of great books here, a lot of great ideas.
- 44:49I can tell the person who you're the kind of person who is actively reflecting and learning how to get better and trying to figure out what's next.
- 44:56So yeah, I'm sure lots more exciting projects on the horizon.
- 45:00And of course, where can people go to watch Beyond Zero if they want to do that?
- 45:03Well, right now they need to be on Cathay Pacific or on JetBlue or on Canadian Airline, whose name I keep forgetting, that just got the movie.
- 45:12I don't have it.
- 45:13Anyway, that's where it's publicly available.
- 45:15We do work with companies to bring private screenings of BMW zero in to train teams.
- 45:20Educators can get it for free to use in their classrooms.
- 45:24All of that is beyond zero film.com and we are hoping to have an announcement that the film will be available on a streaming platform this summer, but I do not yet have confirmation on that.
- 45:33So we've been working on that for a long time.
- 45:35But in the meantime, Beyond Zero Film.com is where to go for information on Beyond Zero.
- 45:40That's a good teaser.
- 45:41Thank you.
- 45:41Thank you so much for this conversation.
- 45:43This has been a lot of fun.
- 45:44I know I've learned a lot.
- 45:45I know our listeners will, too.
- 45:47And thank you so much for your time.
- 45:49I can tell there's always a number of things going on in your brain.
- 45:52So thanks for pausing for a minute to be able to talk to us.
- 45:55Thank you.
- 45:56Of course, to our listeners who are diligent about tuning in with us to hear these incredible stories.
- 46:00We appreciate the community that you're building here with us.
- 46:04And if you want to hear another terrific conversation, then we've got one ready for you in two weeks.
- 46:08So we'll see you then.
- 46:09Thanks, everybody.
- 46:16Sam.