Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Is Messi A Great Value Investor?
Transcript
- 0:00So imagine a 39 year old athlete just, you know, casually
- 0:03strolling around a soccer pitch. Right, like he's on a Sunday
- 0:06walk. Exactly.
- 0:07His shoulders are kind of slumped, he is barely breaking a
- 0:10sweat, and he's just watching 21 other elite athletes literally
- 0:14Sprint until their lungs burn. Yeah, until their legs just
- 0:18completely give out. But here's the crazy part.
- 0:21That exact same guy, through that exact same leisurely
- 0:24stroll, is executing the precise mathematical strategy as a
- 0:29billionaire sitting in a quiet office in Omaha.
- 0:33Welcome to another deep dive. Glad.
- 0:35To be here. Today we are exploring what
- 0:37might be the absolute ultimate paradox of high performance.
- 0:41Like how does doing absolutely nothing sometimes lead to
- 0:45achieving absolutely everything? It's a it's fascinating because
- 0:48it challenges literally every core assumption we have about
- 0:51success. Right, because we're taught that
- 0:52output requires input. Exactly.
- 0:54From a young age, it's all about grinding.
- 0:56You want more results, you have to apply more effort.
- 0:58But the data we're looking at today points in the exact
- 1:01opposite direction. And it is a wild stack of
- 1:04sources. Today we've got a really
- 1:06fascinating mix for you. We're looking at official FIFA
- 1:09tracking data from the 2026 World Cup, some landmark
- 1:14behavioral neuroeconomic studies, and we're tying it all
- 1:17together with the foundational text of value investing from
- 1:20guys like Buffett, Munger, and Peter Lynch.
- 1:23It's a really eclectic mix, but the through line is just
- 1:26undeniable. It really is now before we jump
- 1:28in the material, I have an important housekeeping update
- 1:31for you to access more advanced researches applications at our
- 1:35latest personal D Value agents. Welcome to explore and join D
- 1:38Values APP track total market temperature.
- 1:41Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett Indicator from
- 1:45Apple App Store or Bubble Watch from Google Play.
- 1:47Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 1:51and may be subject to revisions or different interpretations.
- 1:55All contents from this channel is for research and
- 1:56entertainment purposes only and does not constitute any
- 1:59investment or financial advice or service.
- 2:01Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 2:03financial decisions. Always good to get the
- 2:05disclaimers out of the way. Definitely.
- 2:07OK, let's unpack this because it's wild that a 39 year old
- 2:10athlete walking around holds the same secret to wealth generation
- 2:15as a billionaire. Yeah, it really sounds like a
- 2:17philosophical thought experiment until you actually look at the
- 2:20raw number. All the numbers are staggering.
- 2:22Let's drop the FIFA data right away.
- 2:24So out of 618 outfield players with at least 90 minutes played
- 2:29in the 2026 World Cup, 39 year old Lionel Messi, ranked
- 2:34absolute dead last in distance, covered.
- 2:37Dead last #618. Literally last, depending on the
- 2:42metric, he spent anywhere from 64% to like 87 or even 95% of
- 2:47his time walking. Just walking or standing
- 2:49completely still, yeah. He averaged A measly 2.7 sprints
- 2:53per match. I mean literal goalkeepers
- 2:55probably covered more ground. Which, you know, paints a
- 2:57picture of a guy who is completely disengaged or just
- 3:00exhausted, right? To a casual observer, it looks
- 3:03like a student who isn't even opening his textbook, but he's
- 3:07somehow acing the final exam while everyone else is furiously
- 3:11writing until their hands cramp. Because despite all that
- 3:14walking, he tied for the Golden Boot.
- 3:16It's insane. Eight goals, 3 assists, and
- 3:19expected goals or XG of 1.09 per match.
- 3:24How was that mathematically possible?
- 3:25Well, to understand the math, you really have to understand
- 3:28the cognitive mapping going on. It isn't laziness, it's a highly
- 3:32deliberate spatial audit. E Spatial audit.
- 3:35Explain. That so former manager Pep
- 3:36Guardiola actually described this perfectly.
- 3:39He noted that Messi spends the 1st 10 minutes of a match
- 3:41basically ignoring the ball. Wait, really?
- 3:44Just ignoring it. Yeah, he just wanders around,
- 3:46but Cordiola says he's building a map in his eyes, he is
- 3:49constantly scanning the opponent's defensive structure,
- 3:52looking for geometric weaknesses.
- 3:54So he's not reacting, he's modeling the game.
- 3:56Exactly. He's calculating.
- 3:57You know if the ball turns over here, which guy steps out of
- 4:00position? OK, I get that.
- 4:02Conceptually, yeah. Why does he have to walk?
- 4:04Why can't he just map the field while jogging?
- 4:06That's where the bio mechanics come in and it's super cool.
- 4:08Walking keeps the heart rate incredibly low.
- 4:12When you Sprint, your body floods with lactic acid, right?
- 4:16And aerobic stress spikes. Right, you get exhausted.
- 4:18But more importantly, oxygen gets diverted away from your
- 4:21brain to your legs. So when your heart rate stays
- 4:23low, your prefrontal cortex, which handles complex spatial
- 4:28reasoning, is functioning at absolute peak capacity.
- 4:31Oh wow, so he's protecting his computing power while the
- 4:35defenders are exhausting their brains just chasing the ball.
- 4:38He's effectively sitting in an air conditioned room playing
- 4:41chess. Exactly, and it actively
- 4:43manipulates the defenders too, because human threat detection
- 4:46is wired to react to rapid movement.
- 4:48Like a predator instinct. Right when an attacker sprints
- 4:51the defenders brain locks on. But when an attacker is just
- 4:54walking, that mirror neuron system relaxes.
- 4:57The defender subconsciously categorizes him as a non threat.
- 5:01So they literally dropped their guard.
- 5:02Yep, and by the time the ball arrives and the defenders brain
- 5:06reboots into panic mode, Messi is already a half step ahead.
- 5:10The sources bring up the round of 16 match against Egypt to
- 5:12prove this. It's such a perfect example.
- 5:14Argentina was down to nothing. The pressure was immense.
- 5:18And messy just strolls. For 5.2 kilometers he looked
- 5:21like a total passenger. People were probably riding his
- 5:23obituary. But then in the 79th minute he
- 5:27explodes. Goal, then an assist in the 83rd
- 5:31minute. They win 3 to 2.
- 5:33Because his legs were fresh and his neural map was perfectly
- 5:35calibrated, he outsourced the fatigue to everyone else.
- 5:38OK but I have to push back here. If walking and conserving energy
- 5:42is so mathematically superior, why isn't everyone doing it?
- 5:45I mean Imbabe ran 109 sprints compared to Messi 69 right?
- 5:50If walking is the ultimate hack, why did Imbabe Sprint over 100
- 5:54times? This raises an important
- 5:56question, and it takes us straight into behavioral
- 5:58economics. The reason everyone doesn't just
- 6:01stand still is a pathology called action bias.
- 6:04Action bias. Yeah, evolutionarily, we are
- 6:06wired to favor action over inaction.
- 6:09If you're a caveman and you hear rustling in the bushes, the guy
- 6:12who stood still to analyze the situation got eaten by a tiger.
- 6:15Right, the one who just bolted survived.
- 6:17Exactly. But in modern society, that
- 6:19instinct mutates into this massive reputational defense
- 6:23mechanism. Society rewards visible effort.
- 6:27Oh, I see. Yeah, the sources bring in this
- 6:29landmark 2007 bar Eli study on penalty kicks that just
- 6:34perfectly encapsulates this. Right, the goalkeeper's dilemma.
- 6:37So statistically, about 33.3% of penalty kicks go straight down
- 6:42the middle. Exactly 1/3.
- 6:43Which means if a goalie just stood perfectly still, they'd
- 6:46save a third of all shots. But what do they actually do?
- 6:48They dive 93.7% of the time. It's crazy they literally lower
- 6:53their own save percentage so the goalkeeper dives not to stop the
- 6:57ball but to protect their ego. 100% it's called norm theory.
- 7:01Like if they stand still and miss, they look foolish on
- 7:03tomorrow's headlines. He didn't even try.
- 7:05But if they dive and miss, at least they quote UN quote tried.
- 7:09They're optimizing for career risk, not objective success.
- 7:12They're optimizing for social standing.
- 7:14It's entirely at the expense of probability.
- 7:17So what does this all mean for our money?
- 7:19Because it sounds like Wall Street is just full of
- 7:21goalkeepers diving left and right just to look busy.
- 7:24No, it absolutely is. I mean, look at the financial
- 7:26sector. The average institutional
- 7:28portfolio has an annual turnover rate of like 75%.
- 7:32That's. Huge.
- 7:32They trade frantically to simulate productivity because a
- 7:36manager who just sits on a static portfolio during a market
- 7:40crash is going to get accused of negligence.
- 7:42Clients want to see you furiously typing on a terminal.
- 7:45Exactly. And this is where Warren
- 7:47Buffett's philosophy is so brilliant.
- 7:49He famously said inactivity strikes us as intelligent
- 7:52behavior, and he called his strategy lethargy bordering on
- 7:57sloth. Lethargy bordering on sloth.
- 7:59I love that. And the sources connect this to
- 8:01the Ted Williams baseball analogy, right?
- 8:03The 77 cell matrix. Yeah, Value Messers love this
- 8:06analogy. Williams batted .400 because he
- 8:10mapped his strike zone into 77 cells and he only swung at
- 8:14pitches dead center. The fab pitch.
- 8:16Right, he knew if he swung at the margins, his average would
- 8:19plummet to .230. He just waited.
- 8:22OK, here's where it gets really interesting.
- 8:25Buffett points out that the biggest advantage in the stock
- 8:27market and in Messy's game is that there are no called
- 8:31strikes. Exactly.
- 8:32No umpires calling you out. You don't have to swing at some
- 8:35crazy tech IPO because it's on the news and messy.
- 8:37Doesn't have to chase a 5050 aerial duel against a Giant
- 8:40Center back. You just wait for the structural
- 8:43gap. But waiting is incredibly
- 8:45painful on a neuroeconomic level.
- 8:47Why, If the math is so clear, why is it so hard for us to just
- 8:51wait? Because of loss aversion,
- 8:53Kahneman and Chaversky proved that the brain feels the pain of
- 8:57a loss 2.5 times more intensely than a gain.
- 9:00So it's actual physical pain. Yes, your amygdala of the panic
- 9:04center is literally screaming at you to do something.
- 9:08The sources reference Sir Isaac Newton in the South Sea Bubble.
- 9:11Oh this story is wild. One of the greatest geniuses in
- 9:14history lost his absolute fortune because he couldn't
- 9:17handle his FOMO. Exactly.
- 9:19He couldn't regulate his amygdala.
- 9:21He watched his friends getting rich, the social pain became too
- 9:24much. He panicked, bought in at the
- 9:26peak and lost everything. But then contrast that with
- 9:30Buffett sittingoutthe.com bubble in the late 90s, right?
- 9:33He was mocked mercilessly. Called a dinosaur.
- 9:36Yeah, but he just stood perfectly still in cash because
- 9:40he didn't understand the tech, and he was completely
- 9:42vindicated. It's the same as messy
- 9:45suppressing panic when trailing against Switzerland, just
- 9:47trusting the cognitive map instead of chasing the ball.
- 9:50It takes immense psychological discipline.
- 9:53But you know, we should clarify. You can't just stand still
- 9:56anywhere. Right, You can't just stand in
- 9:58the parking lot and win the game.
- 9:59You have to know exactly where to stand, and you need a system
- 10:02to help you survive while you wait.
- 10:04Right, and that's Charlie Munger's circle of competence.
- 10:07How does that apply to Messi? Well, at 39, Messy's physical
- 10:11circle shrank. He couldn't run box to box
- 10:13anymore, so he hyper focused entirely on the inside right
- 10:17channel, the half spaces. The inverted the problem.
- 10:20Yes, Munger's philosophy of inversion.
- 10:22Instead of asking, how can I run faster to beat this guy, Messy
- 10:26asked. How can I stand completely still
- 10:29in a way that utterly defeats this defender?
- 10:32But wait, if he's just standing there, how does his team not
- 10:35just get crushed defensively? There has to be systemic
- 10:38leverage. Yes, the sources call it the
- 10:40asset leverage principle. The kinetic labor is outsourced.
- 10:44Outsourced dude. The midfielders, guys like
- 10:46Rodrigo De Paul and Enzo Fernandez, they execute the high
- 10:50intensity pressing the 7 second rule to win the ball back.
- 10:53They do all the grueling labor so the apex asset doesn't have
- 10:56to. So taking this back to finance,
- 10:59those hard working midfielders are basically the reliable fixed
- 11:03income or dividend generating core of a portfolio.
- 11:06Exactly like Berkshire Hathaway's GEICO and Jen
- 11:08refloat. The insurance premiums.
- 11:10Right. It's this massive reliable
- 11:12cushion of capital that absorbs volatility.
- 11:14It subsidizes the apex asset, the growth equity or messy to
- 11:18remain inactive until the perfect moment.
- 11:21That makes so much sense, but retail investors usually get
- 11:23this totally wrong, don't they? The sources talk about the Halo
- 11:26effect of Messy moving to enter Miami.
- 11:29Oh, this is the perfect example of retail versus smart money.
- 11:32When he moved to Miami, retail investors succumbed to pure
- 11:36action bias. They furiously bought up this
- 11:39tiny microcap licenser called MGO Global.
- 11:43Just swinging wildly at a terrible pitch because they
- 11:46needed to act. Exactly.
- 11:48But the smart money value investors like Aris Management,
- 11:51they did the equivalent of standing in the right space.
- 11:53They bought the structural assets.
- 11:55Right ticket prices, Apple TV broadcast rights, the
- 11:59compounding assets. They just stood still in the
- 12:01half space and let the value come to them.
- 12:03So, bringing it all together, the amateur believes that value
- 12:06is created by end. Frantic motion, the goalie
- 12:10diving, the day trader furiously typing.
- 12:12Because society tells us that motion equals value.
- 12:15But the master understands that motion incurs a massive
- 12:18metabolic and financial cost. True mastery is having the
- 12:21emotional discipline to endure the noise, map the environment,
- 12:25and just wait for the fat pig. It really is.
- 12:27So I want you to think about this in your own life.
- 12:30Where in your work or your investments are you just diving
- 12:33to the left to look busy for your boss instead of having the
- 12:37courage to stand perfectly still in the center of the goal?
- 12:40And you know, there is one final, really provocative thread
- 12:43here in a Mull over we are rapidly moving into a future
- 12:48where artificial intelligence and automation are going to take
- 12:51over all that relentless kinetic output.
- 12:54The AI is going to become the hard working midfield.
- 12:56Exactly. The machines will do the daily
- 12:59grinding tasks across almost every industry.
- 13:02So in that world, will the ultimate, most highly
- 13:04compensated human skill simply be the cognitive discipline to
- 13:08know exactly when and where to stand completely still?
- 13:12Now that is a thought to leave you with.
- 13:13Thank you for joining us on this deep dive.
- 13:15Until next time.