Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow with Force: Chapter 8 - Feel of Flow
Transcript
- Catalyst - Feel of Flow: Have you ever been so absorbed in something that you completely lost trap of time? Have you ever had that experience disappear like in an instant? That happened to me recently. I was writing when my phone alarm suddenly went off and it startled me. I looked up and for a moment I felt, you know, completely disconnected from where was. The alarm was reminding me to turn on, of all things, the crock pot for dinner. Nothing dramatic here, but I had been sitting there for three hours and I honestly had no idea where the time went. I was in a flow state. Welcome to Catalyst, a podcast of thought. I'm Dr. G, and today I'm continuing my exploration of flow with force with a question that seems deceptively simple on the surface. What does flow feel like? I'm not asking how to achieve it or to measure it, but what does it feel like when I'm experiencing it? I'll explore that question through a few personal experiences, then connect them to what research has, learned about attention, self-consciousness, and performance. I believe there's a distinction here that matters beyond the writing or sports contexts. It's about how we experience ourselves while we're doing something and what happens when we become aware of ourselves actually doing it. When I write, I try to create the conditions for flow. I put on my headphones, play some instrumental music, and limit the distractions. There's a difference between creating the conditions for flow and forcing it to happen. I know I can prepare the environment. I also know I can't command the experience. That distinction is important. Flow can easily become another thing I try to control. I've read about it, learned its characteristics, developed a routine and If I'm not careful though, I'll start asking myself, am I in flow yet? That's when I would start evaluating the experience of flow while trying to experience it. Research generally supports the idea that certain conditions make flow more likely. Psychologist Mihai Chek Set Mihai, out of the University of Chicago, whose work established much of what we know about flow, emphasized the relationship between an activity's challenge and our ability to meet it. Clear goals and useful feedback can also help induce flow. Those are conditions for flow, but not guarantees of it. You can have the right challenge, the right skills, a quiet room, and a clear goal, and still not experience flow. A twenty twenty four paper in communications psychology by Oliver Durkin and his colleagues makes a related point. Researchers need to consider not just an activities challenge, but also how much autonomy people have while doing it. In other words, the activity itself matters, and so does the freedom to engage with it meaningfully. That makes sense to me. I can set up my writing environment, I can decide what I want to work on. I can remove a few of the distractions. I can't, however, dictate exactly what my mind will do when I sit down and write. Perhaps that's the first lesson for me. Prepare, but don't confuse preparation with control. When I'm really in it, in flow, I stop noticing things I normally notice. So it's not so much what I feel, but what I don't feel. My body almost disappears from my awareness. My fingers move along the keyboard, my Thoughts move through and I don't stop every few seconds to judge what I'm doing. That's a big part of flow for me. The research gives us a useful way to understand what I'm talking about. In another twenty twenty four study, this time from Frontiers in Psychology, researchers examined the apparent paradox of flow. Turns out we can be intensely engaged in an activity while becoming less conscious of ourselves and as the person performing it. They make an important distinction here. Flow doesn't mean we lose all awareness of ourselves. We still act, we still perceive what we're doing, we still make adjustments. What's reduced is more reflective self-awareness, the habit of stepping back mentally and thinking about ourselves as objects to be evaluated. And that distinction capture something I recognize in my own experience. I don't stop being the person writing when I'm in flow. I don't lose the ability to decide what belongs in the essay. I simply stop treating myself as a subject to be reviewed. I'm not standing over my own shoulder asking whether the next sentence is good enough. I'm just thinking about the next sentence. Those are two very different experiences. It's like two versions of me show up in these situations. One is the person who is actually doing the thing, and the other is the person imagining how others might judge it. The writer and the imagined audience, the golfer and the imagined spectators, the person doing the work and the person wondering whether the work is good enough. When I'm in flow, that second voice, the audience, the spectators, I feel it getting quiet. I'm not thinking about what the work says about me. I'm just doing the work. When that voice of judgment returns, I feel the tension. I feel the difference. I want to be careful here. I'm not claiming the imagined audience is always imaginary in in the sense that nobody is ever watching. Sometimes people really are evaluating us. We have bosses, clients, real audiences sometimes, colleagues, competitors. Their judgments can have real consequences. We also carry those judgments into situations where nobody is actually evaluating us. We can anticipate criticism, we can imagine expectations. We start seeing ourselves through the eyes of an audience that may not even be present. It's that imagined audience that can change the experience before anyone else actually says a real word. Research on flow offers one way to understand this. Reduced self consciousness is one characteristic. Repeatedly associated with flow, attention that might otherwise go to monitoring ourselves becomes available for the doing of the activity. That doesn't mean all self-awareness is bad or self-evaluation is bad. We need to evaluate our work. We need to notice errors and learn and improve. The question is whether we're doing that at a useful moment. Or are we interrupting the activity to judge ourselves while we're still trying to do it? I've started to think about my experience with flow as three states that I move through. Hyper awareness, fractionality, and hyperacuity. These are my terms for describing what I notice. I'm not presenting them as scientifically sound observations or stages that everybody moves through. They're just a way of making sense of my own experiences. So hyper awareness to me is when I'm fighting myself. I'm staring at the cursor. And it's as if it's yelling at me, telling me to write something meaningful. I'm trying so hard to do something well that I can't seem to even get started. When I'm in a state of fractionality, this is when I notice the cursor blinking. I notice my breathing. I notice where I'm sitting. I start thinking about myself sitting there. Instead of thinking about what I'm supposed to be doing, I just notice that I'm there. To me, this is a transitional space, right? The works in front of me. My attention is with it, but I'm not evaluating myself anymore. When things come together, when the cursor stops being an accusation and is more of an invitation, and my ideas begin to arrive and my fingers can keep pace with my thoughts as I type, that's the next stage for me, hyperacuity. It's an intense focus, but not attention. I'm working hard, but I'm not fighting myself. I'm surely not evaluating myself. The interesting thing is that the work hasn't necessarily become easier. I may still be trying to make sense of a difficult idea and I may still be looking for just the right words. But the effort feels different because I'm no longer spending so much attention judging myself. And that difference between effort and strain matters. In a twenty twenty three study, also in Frontiers of Psychology, researchers examined cognitive control and work related flow. Across these studies they found support for relationships between flow and factors such as mindfulness, persistence, and people's belief about flow's usefulness. Their model treats flow as something that requires attention and effort, not something that simply happens when we stop trying. I find that helpful because we sometimes talk about flow as if it's effortless, but the experience can involve considerable effort. The difference is that the effort goes toward the activity and Rather than getting consumed by the monitoring of ourself. I can work hard without constantly asking myself whether I'm working hard enough. I can struggle with an idea without turning the struggle into a verdict on my ability. I can keep going without needing to narrate my own performance. Flow isn't limited just to writing. I experienced something similar in the gym. When I'm working through a difficult exercise or series of exercises, I can become so focused on the movement that the rest of the room disappears. I focus on my muscles that I'm working or my breathing or just the next rep. There's still a lot going on. I'm focused on the movement, adjusting to the exercises' demands. I'm aware of my body in a very practical sense, but I'm not necessarily thinking about what the workout looks like to someone else. Whether I look competent, whether anybody has noticed even what I'm doing. My attention is on the work, the effort. I recently was pushing through a particularly difficult series of exercises that I had struggled with in the past. I couldn't keep up with the digital trainer I was watching. and I was apparently expressing myself in language that wasn't suitable for a public setting. Cause I'd done it. I'd kept up with them every set, every rep. And I was proud of myself. So I celebrated in what turns out to be an appropriate inappropriate way. And employee walk had to walk into my view and break my focus and say, I'm sorry, but we can hear you. You know, and I had laughed and I was startled again, kind of like the crock pot alarm. but I but I wasn't embarrassed about what I had said really or the workout. I was proud of what I had done. What strikes me about that memory is how little I thought about the people around me. How little I realized I was even in a public setting. I wasn't trying to look a certain way. I was just so concentrated on getting through every set and every rep because I had failed so many times. And this time I did it. But I really had to focus and be intentional without being tense. And the world around me disappeared. When someone brought me back into that world, the trainer, I I could acknowledge and laugh and move on and And that's the problem with focus sometimes and flow is you lose track of where you're at. So there's a useful connection here to sports psychology. Researchers spent decades you know studying what happens when athletes become overly conscious of their performance under pressure. A twenty twenty four meta-analysis, which is combines results from multiple studies on the same topic, examined findings from twenty nine articles on how athletes perform under pressure. The themes they found focused on task focused attention, confidence, preparation, the importance of where athletes direct their mental resources, actually where they look with their eyes. The research describes two related problems. Sometimes pressure distracts us with worries and irrelevant thoughts. Other times we start consciously monitoring movements that ordinarily work better when they're allowed to unfold without constant interference. I th if I think about that for a moment, as a golfer we practice all kinds of swings, but standing over the ball, I start thinking about all kinds of swing thoughts, my hands, shoulders, hips, club face angles, and the consequences of getting it wrong. That's my biggest hang up. I try to control the movement, but then I end up disrupting it. I'm not saying every thought about technique is harmful, but again, it's about timing. Deliberate practice requires attention to technique. But there's a big difference between working on a movement during practice and micromanaging it in the moment you're trying to execute it. The challenge is knowing when to analyze and when to act. And golf offers this lesson with every swing. I recently played more than half the round, hole after hole, without really thinking about my score. I was relaxed, enjoying the game with my friends. They then I noticed the ball I was playing with. It was Callaway, number six, the red dot. I realized I'd played the entire round up to this point with the same ball. Hmm, that's a big deal for me, right? Hadn't lost a ball. Suddenly I became aware not only of the ball I was playing, but of myself and of my score. I started thinking about all the things I wanted to protect. I had shifted from playing golf in the state of flow to forcing a protection. Of what I've already accomplished. I moved from flow to force. I wasn't simply responding to the ball, the course, and the shot in front of me anymore. I was thinking about the entirety of the round and trying to pret to preserve the success success I already had. In other words, I had introduced a new problem. I was trying not to lose something I had been enjoying. I interrupted myself. I was the crock pot alarm. I was the trainer. My own thoughts interrupted my state of flow. The moment I started protecting my performance, I was no longer fully present, no longer in flow. And that aligns with a central question in research on choking under pressures, which is what I did to myself. What happens when attention shifts from the task to worries about the outcome, from the process to the product, or to our conscious control of actions that normally happen more fluidly, right? We have to get out of our own way, as we've heard ourselves say. The answer isn't as simple as saying that pressure always hurts. Athletes sometimes perform exceptionally under pressure. research has distinguished choking from when pressure contributes to, downfall performance to clutch performance when an athlete meets a goal, even under severe pressure. The direction of attention matters. Am I attending to the task in front of me, or am I attending to what the outcome will mean later? How I will look to others. whether I can preserve the success I've already had. In my case, that little red dot in the golf ball pulled me out of my current experience, reminded me that I was having a good round, and the recognition changed to what I was paying attention to. I started trying to protect the experience instead of just living it. That's how quickly it can happen. The moment I start worrying about what the experience means, I can lose the experience myself. This whole meaning making thing I do in other parts of my life, right? I spend a lot of time making meaning of what happens and what doesn't. I evaluate interpret. I try to figure out what everything says about me. I used to, anyways, I'm trying to avoid doing it as much. That's not necessarily a bad thing. Meaning making is part of being human. And reflection lets us learn from experience. We see patterns, we decide what we want to do differently. I'm beginning to think timing is what may matter more. There's a time to reflect on the experience and a time to be in it. Those are not always the same time. Seldom are they? If I'm in the middle of writing, I can stop and ask whether the paragraph works. Sometimes that is exactly what I need to do, but if I interrupt every thought to judge his quality, I may never give an idea enough for him to develop. I can think about my swing technique during practice, but if I stand over every shot on the golf course and run a full analysis of my identity, ability, scorecard, all that. I may make it much harder to even execute a single shot. So maybe an experience deserves our attention first and then we can evaluate it afterward. What I need to remember is I don't have to make every experience a demonstration of my competence. I can write because I want to write. I can exercise because I want to exercise. I can have a conversation because I'm interested in the person and the ideas we're exploring. The experience doesn't have to prove anything about me. I can feel safe in it. And when I'm in flow, I have that emotional safety, that social security. When I focus too much on the product, I lose the joy, the feeling of joy in the process. Flow is a process. When I stay with the process, the product often follows. It has to. I want to be precise about that too. I'm not saying that good results always follow from flow or that a satisfying process guarantees a good product, but writing still needs editing and athletic performance still needs, skill and training, coaching. Some work simply doesn't turn out the way we hoped. But if I focus exclusively on the result and constantly monitor it and judge myself, I can sacrifice the experience of flow, that feeling of freedom and autonomy, of judgment free work that made everything worthwhile in the first place. The idea that an activity can be rewarding in and of itself does have a long history in flow research. Psychologists sometimes use this term audio. Psychologists use the term autotelic to describe an activity that's worth doing for its own sake. Children do activities autotelically, just for the sake of doing it. The satisfaction isn't dependent entirely on an external reward, a score. Compliment or even recognition that you did it. I find that idea especially relevant as I think about how I spend my time. Not every worthwhile activity needs to produce something measurable or something to show someone else, not every hour needs to justify itself through productivity. Sometimes the value is in the engagement itself, the satisfaction of solving a problem, the chance of completing a crossword puzzle, the pleasure of becoming absorbed in idea that I can then record. For a podcast. And perhaps that matters because so much of our lives involved being evaluated. At work, we have performance reviews, deadlines, targets. In sports we have scores and rankings. Social life, we can become preoccupied with whether we're liked, respected, or seen as successful by the measures of our group. those things are just part of life. And I'm not suggesting we ignore any of them. I'm suggesting we also need experiences where we can stop performing for an audience, real or perceived, and simply participate. And I'm not suggesting that we can live in a state of flow and kumbaya our way through the day. We can't. And I'm it's not every difficult experience is an opportunity to find flow either. But we can learn to recognize the difference, the difference in feeling. Because I know what it feels like to force something. I know what it feels like to try too hard, get preoccupied with the outcome, and imagine an audience that may not even be there. And now I'm learning to recognize flow, the focus, the quiet, the feeling that I'm free of constant internal commentary. If I make flow another performance target, well, then I risk recreating the self-consciousness that makes it hard to experience in the first place. So I try to recognize when it happens without demanding that it stay. When flow ends, I can appreciate what happened and move on. If it returns, I welcome it. If it doesn't, I don't have to chase it. I don't force flow, I flow with force. And maybe that's the point. I have some agency over how much attention I give to the imagined audience. the imagined judgment and the pressure to make every experience mean something. I can't control every interruption, I can't eliminate every judgment, and I don't want to abandon reflection. I want to become more intentional about when I evaluate and when I participate. For me that's a small but meaningful shift. It gives me permission to do something without constantly turning it into a statement about who I am. It lets me enjoy the process before I I assess the product. And it reminds me that I can be fully engaged without needing to watch myself being fully engaged. So when things feel tight, rushed, overmanaged, I notice the contrast more clearly now. That's not a definition of flow. It's just difference in feel. Next time you find yourself fully immersed in something, resist the urge to step outside the experience and evaluate it. Just stay with it for a while. Notice what happens when you give your attention to the activity itself. You don't have to tell yourself that you're doing well. You don't have to turn the experience into a lesson while it's still unfolding. You don't have to decide what it means about you. Just be there. And if you notice you've lost that feeling, you may not need to force it back. You can simply recognize the difference and keep going. Maybe the more useful question isn't how do I get into flow? Maybe it's what am I doing when I interrupt it? Am I concentrating in the work or am I worrying about how the work reflects on me? Am I participating in the experience or am I watching myself participate? Those are questions I'm still exploring. I don't have a formula and I'm not sure a formula is the point. Join me next time as I wrap up the Flow with Floor series in the final episode. I'm Doctor G. Those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.