Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How Treasury Buybacks Are Quietly Supporting the Debt Market
Transcript
- Lucas: So the Treasury is quietly becoming a buyer of its own bonds — and I don't mean the Fed's quantitative easing. I'm talking about the buyback program that's been ramping up over the past year, and yesterday Treasury Secretary Bessent hinted the next operation could top four billion dollars. Luna: Buybacks — that's a tool they haven't really used since the early 2000s, right? What's driving it now? Lucas: Exactly. The Treasury first experimented with buybacks back in 2000 and 2001, but they were small and then got shelved. Now they're back, and they're becoming a regular feature of how the government manages its debt. The idea is simple: the Treasury issues new bonds every month, but it also buys back older, less liquid ones — particularly those with high coupons from when rates were lower. Luna: So they're essentially swapping old debt for new debt. Why go through the trouble? Lucas: Partly it's about smoothing out the maturity wall — the Treasury has a lot of debt coming due in the next few years, and buybacks let them manage that more flexibly. But the bigger reason, according to officials, is liquidity. A lot of the older bonds, especially the thirty-year issues from the 2010s with coupons around two or three percent, have become harder to trade. Dealers don't want to hold them, and that makes the whole Treasury market a bit clunkier. Luna: And a clunky Treasury market matters because everything else — mortgages, corporate bonds — prices off those securities. Lucas: Precisely. And that's why the buyback program isn't just some accounting gimmick. It's a way to repurchase those off-the-run bonds, the ones that have fallen out of favor, and replace them with fresh, liquid issues at current market rates. The Treasury gets to tidy up its balance sheet, and the market gets a more active benchmark curve. Luna: But here's the thing — with the national debt now past forty trillion dollars, and the thirty-year yield sitting at five point two eight percent as of yesterday, isn't buying back bonds just adding to the government's own borrowing costs? You're taking on new debt at higher rates to retire old debt at lower rates. Lucas: That's the trade-off, and it's a real one. When the Treasury buys back a two percent coupon bond and issues a four and a half percent bond to fund it, the interest expense goes up. But the Treasury argues it's not purely about cost — it's about market functioning. If the buyback helps keep the Treasury market running smoothly, that can lower borrowing costs across the curve, at least at the margin. Luna: And Bessent said there's a 'very good chance' the deficit has peaked, which would be a big deal if true. Lucas: Yeah, that was the headline yesterday. But even if the deficit has peaked, we're still looking at a structural gap of around one point seven trillion dollars for the fiscal year that just ended. And the debt to gdp ratio is over one hundred twenty-two percent. So the buyback program is happening in a world where the government is already borrowing enormous sums every quarter. Luna: So what exactly did Bessent say about the buybacks? He mentioned a specific number, right? Lucas: He said the next operation could be more than four billion dollars. That's actually a decent size for a single buyback. To put it in context, the Treasury's been doing these regular buybacks since 2025, and they've been averaging around two to three billion per operation. So four billion is a step up, and it signals the program is gaining momentum. Luna: And how does this interact with the Fed's own balance sheet runoff? The Fed has been letting its Treasury holdings mature without reinvesting, which means more supply hitting the market. Lucas: That's exactly the tension. The Fed is reducing its holdings, so the private market has to absorb more Treasuries. The buyback program can help support that by providing demand for the older issues, which might otherwise be sold off in size. But it's not a huge offset — the Fed's runoff is like forty billion a month, while the buybacks are a few billion. Still, every bit helps in terms of liquidity. Luna: I'm curious about the actual mechanics. How does a Treasury buyback work? It's not like the Fed's QE where they just buy in the open market, right? Lucas: Right, it's different. The Treasury holds auctions where primary dealers can submit offers to sell specific securities back to the government. The Treasury then selects the ones that give it the best price — meaning the lowest yield it has to pay to buy them back. It's a reverse auction, essentially. And they've been focusing on bonds with relatively high coupons, which tend to be the ones trading at a premium and are less liquid. Luna: So they're targeting the most expensive bonds to service — the ones with the highest coupon — and getting rid of them. That makes sense from a debt management perspective. Lucas: It does, but there's a nuance. The Treasury isn't just trying to reduce interest costs; it's also trying to extend the maturity of its debt. By buying back short-dated notes and issuing longer-dated bonds, they can push out the average maturity of the debt, which reduces refinancing risk. That's been a stated goal of the Treasury for a while. Luna: But wait — isn't the Treasury also issuing a ton of short-term bills right now? The three-month yield is around three point eight six percent, but the two-year is four point one nine. That's a pretty steep curve, so short-term borrowing is cheaper. Why not just keep issuing bills? Lucas: Because too much short-term debt makes the Treasury vulnerable to rollover risk — if rates spike, the cost of rolling over that debt jumps immediately. That's why they aim to keep the average maturity of the portfolio around six years. Buybacks help them manage that balance without having to make sudden shifts in auction sizes. Luna: And in the meantime, the ten-year yield has actually ticked down a bit — it's at four point seven one percent as of yesterday, down from four point seven two. Not a big move, but the thirty-year is down to five point two eight from five point three one. So there's a bit of relief in long-term rates. Does that make buybacks more attractive? You're buying back old debt when yields are still relatively high, but if rates fall, you'd be locking in higher costs on the new debt. Lucas: That's a risk, but the Treasury's mandate isn't to time the market. It's to ensure the market functions smoothly. And in the context of forty trillion dollars in debt, even small improvements in liquidity can have a meaningful impact on how smoothly the Treasury can roll over its obligations. And with the debt to gdp ratio at one hundred twenty-two point six percent, every basis point matters. Luna: So, is the buyback program a sign of stress, or a sign of maturity? I mean, it's a tool that was used in the early 2000s, but then it was discontinued. Why bring it back now? Lucas: I think it's a sign that the Treasury is being more proactive about managing the debt portfolio. In the early 2000s, the budget was actually in surplus, so the buybacks were a way to reduce the outstanding debt. Now, we're running deficits, but they still see value in buying back high-coupon bonds to smooth out the maturity profile. It's a different rationale, but it shows they're thinking long term. Luna: Speaking of long term, what does this mean for taxpayers? If the Treasury is swapping higher-coupon debt for lower-coupon debt, that could actually save money in interest costs over time. But if they're issuing new debt at higher yields, that could cost more. Which way does the net effect go? Lucas: It's hard to say definitively because it depends on the future path of rates. But let's take a concrete example. Suppose the Treasury buys back a thirty-year bond issued in 2020 with a coupon of two percent. That bond still has twenty-four years left, and the Treasury is paying two percent on it. If they buy it back and issue a new thirty-year bond at five point two eight percent, they're increasing the interest expense on that specific bond. But the buyback price would be at a discount, because the coupon is so low relative to current rates. So they might actually pay less than par to retire that bond. Luna: So they're buying back the bond at a discount and then issuing new debt at a higher coupon, but the total cost over time might still be lower because they're reducing the premium they'd have to pay at maturity? Am I getting that right? Lucas: Not exactly. The Treasury pays the market price for the bond, which is below par because the coupon is low. But then they issue a new bond at par with a higher coupon. So the immediate cash outlay is lower, but the ongoing interest payments are higher. The net present value depends on the discount rate. If the yield curve is steep, it might not be worth it. But the Treasury isn't doing this to save money directly; it's for liquidity and managing the maturity profile. Luna: Got it. So it's more about market mechanics than cost savings. That said, the buyback program has been growing, and Bessent's comment about the deficit peaking suggests that maybe the fiscal situation is stabilizing. Do you think that's realistic? The deficit for fiscal 2025 was one point seven seven trillion, which is actually slightly down from the year before. Lucas: It's possible that we've seen the peak in nominal terms, but structural pressures remain. Interest costs are now the fastest-growing line item in the budget. With the thirty-year yield above five percent, the average interest rate on the debt is rising. That's going to keep pushing deficits higher unless spending is cut or revenues grow significantly. So I'd take Bessent's optimism with a grain of salt. Luna: And that's where buybacks come in as a tool to manage the debt, but they're not a magic bullet. They're a drop in the bucket compared to the overall issuance. The Treasury is selling trillions of dollars of new debt every year, and buybacks are just a few billion here and there. Lucas: Right. But sometimes it's the small tools that keep the machine from seizing up. The Treasury market is the biggest and most liquid in the world, but it's not immune to dysfunction. We saw that in March 2020 when everything froze. Buybacks are a way to add a bit of lubrication to the system, especially for the older, less-traded bonds. Luna: And if the buyback program helps keep the Treasury market functioning smoothly, that benefits everyone who borrows, from homebuyers to corporations to state governments. So it's not just about the government's own debt; it's about the entire economy's cost of credit. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a good point to bring up something that's been on our minds lately. If you're finding this kind of conversation useful — like, it's making sense of the fiscal world in a way that helps you navigate your own financial decisions — then maybe today is a day to consider supporting the show. We keep it ad-free, and that's only possible because of listeners who chip in when they can. If today's walk through the economy was worth a coffee to you, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a thought. Luna: Yeah, we really do appreciate it. It keeps the lights on and helps us keep doing deep dives like this. Lucas: But back to the buybacks — one more angle that I find interesting is how this interacts with the Treasury's cash balance. They've been holding a fairly large cash buffer, which has been a topic of debate. Buybacks essentially use some of that cash to retire debt, which reduces the outstanding stock. But if the cash balance is drawn down too much, the Treasury might have to issue more short-term bills, which could reintroduce some of the maturity risk they're trying to manage. Luna: So it's a balancing act. They're using cash to buy back bonds, but they also need to maintain a prudent cash buffer for unexpected needs. How do they decide how much to use for buybacks versus holding in the Treasury General Account? Lucas: That's a good question, and it's something the Treasury has been refining. They've set a target for the cash balance, and they don't want to go too far below it. The buybacks are funded from new issuance, not from the cash buffer, actually. They issue new debt and use the proceeds to buy back old bonds. So it's more of a swap than a drawdown. Luna: Ah, that makes more sense. So they're not reducing the overall debt; they're just changing its composition. It's a portfolio management tool, not a way to pay down debt. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the buyback program is best understood as a way to improve the efficiency of the Treasury market, not as a step toward reducing the debt burden. The debt is still there, and it's still growing, but at least the market can trade it more effectively. Luna: Which, in the long run, might make it easier for the government to manage its forty trillion dollar mountain of debt. And that's something worth keeping an eye on as the program expands. Lucas: Absolutely. And with the Treasury signaling more buybacks on the horizon, we'll be watching how the market absorbs them and whether they start to have a measurable impact on liquidity. That's a story we'll continue to follow.