Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP209: Missing: Gary McCullough and Lena Chapin
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Welcome back, everyone to another episode of
- 0:37Crimes and Consequences. I'm Tanya and this is my co host Talia. Hello,
- 0:42and before we get into today's episode, I would just like to ask
- 0:47everyone to hit the like or subscribe or follow button whatever app you're listening to.
- 0:52If you're here on YouTube watching us on True Crime Daily, if you
- 0:55could hit like, that would be wonderful. So have you ever heard about
- 0:59the disappearance Gary McCullough or Lena Chapin. I don't know, Okay, I
- 1:04mean I've read a lot of true crime. I'm going to get into it
- 1:08and it sounds bad, but I don't remember their names. I know.
- 1:12Sometimes when I see pictures, I'm like, oh, yeah, yeah,
- 1:15yeah, I know that one. Yeah. On May eleventh, nineteen ninety
- 1:19nine, Gary McCullough went missing, and he lived in Missouri in a town
- 1:23called Cassville. He was known as a hard worker and never missed a day
- 1:29of work, so when he didn't show up to work multiple times, the
- 1:32people that knew him knew something terrible had happened. At the time he disappeared,
- 1:38he was having troubles with his wife, Sandy, and there was an
- 1:42incident that happened. He owned a shotgun and he had taken it to a
- 1:47friend's house just within days before his disappearance, telling the friend that Sandy had
- 1:53taken it, and he she kind of like shoved it in his gut.
- 1:56Oh what and she pulled the trigger. What. But he kept his guns
- 2:00unloaded, thankfully, so you know, nothing happened in Yeah, it is
- 2:05a big incident. So he was a little scared, obviously, and that's
- 2:09why he wanted to take this shotgun to his friend's house. Who gets to
- 2:15his friend's house and the friend opens the shotgun and he noticed there is a
- 2:20shell that had misfired that was in it. So he thought it was empty.
- 2:24Yeah, but it wasn't. No, it was the shell was on
- 2:28it a bit. She was just you know, it was a really close
- 2:30call because, like I said, holy shit. So his friend takes some
- 2:35flyers and he goes to remove the shell and gunpowder comes spilling out, so
- 2:40it was a live shell. And this is at the point Gary realized that
- 2:45Sandy actually tried to kill him. Ye, not playing games, no,
- 2:49And he said, if it had been a good shell, I wouldn't be
- 2:52standing here right now, especially a shotgun. Yeah. Gary's friend said he
- 2:57never forgot the look on Gary's face when he made this realization, and that
- 3:01was the last time he ever saw Gary alive. Wow. After his disappearance,
- 3:07police went to Gary's house. Obviously that's the first place you're going to
- 3:09start looking, right, to start this investigation. When they got told how
- 3:14old was Gary, Gary, I'm guessing was probably in his forty somewhere.
- 3:16Okay. So when they got to Gary's house, they noticed that one of
- 3:21his cows had gotten out. Like he had a farm, he had farm
- 3:24animals. So the police are like, okay, we got to help get
- 3:29this cow back in the paddock. So weird, I know. So they're
- 3:31they're getting they're rounding the cow back up, and that's when Sandy and one
- 3:36of her daughters, Lena chapin. That's when they come home. Sandy asked
- 3:39the police, you know, what are you doing here rounding up your cow?
- 3:43Yeah, And that's when the police asked her, is there anything that
- 3:46we should know? No, and she said, wow, I have been
- 3:51meaning to call you because my husband, Gary has been gone for two days
- 3:54and I don't know where he's at. But she's been busy, she's been
- 3:58busy. She hasn't gotten an to it yet. So she tells him.
- 4:02You know, Gary had gone to Diamond, Missouri because he was going to
- 4:06buy some fighting roosters what and he just never came home. So is that
- 4:14illegal cock fighting? Yes? I believe so, and I believe it's very
- 4:18illegal cockfight. But I don't know that's I don't Maybe he just I don't
- 4:23know. I don't know. Are there fighting roosters that people just buy?
- 4:26I don't know anything about Ruth. I have no idea. Maybe. The
- 4:30police asked Sandy, well, do you want to make a missing person's report?
- 4:32And yeah, she said, yeah, I probably do need to do
- 4:35that. Gary then was officially determined to be missing. Police obtained a search
- 4:42warrant to search Gary's residence and Sandy was really unhappy about this, and obviously
- 4:46she didn't a search warrant. She didn't give consents, so they because he's
- 4:51missing, he's an adult. How do you get a search warrant? I
- 4:54don't know, but they did. They searched the house for quite some time,
- 4:57and they did notice some odd things while searching. They couldn't find any
- 5:01clothes that belonged to Gary in the house. That's because he took off.
- 5:05And actually there was nothing to suggest that Gary even lived in the house at
- 5:10all. Like everything that he owned, including his clothing, everything was gone.
- 5:15Then one interesting thing the police did find besides not finding anything anything that
- 5:21belonged to Gary, was there was a checkbook and it belonged to a man
- 5:25named Christopher Klemp. So we're going to circle back, okay to Christopher.
- 5:30Police then discover that Sandy and Chris were dating, and two days into their
- 5:38investigation, Chris moved in to Gary and Sandy's house. Wow, yep.
- 5:44Could she try to make it a little less obvious? I think a little
- 5:47less obvious. Everything of his is gone, everything is gone. There's a
- 5:53new guy. There's a new guy. Yep. So police ask Sandy to
- 5:56take a polygraph test because they're like, something's going on. Don't do it,
- 6:00Sandy, Sandy, don't do it? Well, yeah, she said,
- 6:02no, if you find a body, then I'll take a poll,
- 6:05is what she told us. What is wrong with her? It's not lower
- 6:10enough, but quick enough. And so police knew instantly that something was very
- 6:14wrong, like what do you mean find the body? Why? Why?
- 6:18Yeah? So, as they were investigating Gary's disappearance, police decided they wanted
- 6:25to interview Sandy's children, including Lena. Sandy had six daughters, six daughters,
- 6:30six daughters. There was more than me, yeah right, Brandy was
- 6:33the oldest, then Lena, then Robin, Jeanie, Rachel and Rosie.
- 6:40Were they all from the same man. No, they all had different fathers.
- 6:44I shouldn't say they all did, but they did have different fathers.
- 6:46Okay. At the time of Gary's disappearance, Lena was about fourteen years old,
- 6:53and when the police wanted to talk to her, she seemed really hostile.
- 6:57She was really close to her mind, and the police noticed that,
- 7:00and she was really defensive of Sandy and talking to the other girls. In
- 7:05learning about the dynamic of the family, the police found out that Lena was
- 7:10like Sandy's number two in terms of ruling the house. Like it wasn't necessarily
- 7:13the oldest daughter Brandy, it was Lena she was the one that would tell
- 7:16her sisters what to do and keeping them in line and making sure everybody did
- 7:20their chores like they should have. So, even though she's not the oldest,
- 7:25yeah, she's in charge. Yeah, she's in charge with Sandy.
- 7:29So she told them, if the police come to talk to you about Gary,
- 7:31don't say shit. Okay, that's a quote. The day Gary disappeared,
- 7:38Brandy remembers coming home. And Brandy's the oldest daughter. She remembers coming
- 7:42home after school with her sisters when their mother greeted them at the door.
- 7:46She told them there was a cat that had kittens on the farm and the
- 7:50girls needed to go look for them. So they got excited, because who
- 7:54doesn't love a little kitten. I love kittens, right, I love kittens.
- 7:57They go off to find these kittens, except for Brandy because she had
- 8:01chores. She had to milk the cows after school. But yours this nineteen
- 8:05ninety nine. Oh okay, yeah, So Brandy sat on the porch for
- 8:09a minute before going in the house to get the things that she needed to
- 8:11milk the cow. I can't get the dishes, let alone milk a cow.
- 8:16I know, And they like it, said they lived on this farm,
- 8:18and like I said, everybody had chores control. This is crazy,
- 8:22now, right, go have my kids milk it. Maybe that's what they
- 8:26need to do. I know, right, we need to take them to
- 8:28a farm and have them milk some cows to learn some hard work, really,
- 8:33right, because I'm sure this isn't easy. They need to learn some
- 8:35hard work. My daughter does too. We need to get all of them
- 8:37on a farm, on a farm. Okay. Anyway, when Brandy opens
- 8:41the door to go in the house, she saw Sandy on her hands and
- 8:45knees scrubbing the floor with what appeared to be bleach water. She probably could
- 8:50smell it too, Bleach has a very strong, old strong. She noted
- 8:54that her mom was wearing shorts and her hair was tied back, and she
- 8:58said that was really odd, like in her head because Sandy never tied her
- 9:01hair back. And that night Sandy sat the girls down and told them if
- 9:05anyone asks, Gary went to buy fighting roosters, and you guys had spaghetti
- 9:11that night for dinner. What and you haven't seen him since? Okay,
- 9:13mom? And if you say exactly what I'm telling you, everything will be
- 9:18fine. Oh okay, Lena was told by Sandy to make sure none of
- 9:22the girls got up and left their room that night. What is she like
- 9:26the enforcer? Yeah, because she's fourteen, so I don't know. Yeah,
- 9:30but Brandy was older. Mm hmm yeah. Okay. So that night
- 9:33of Gary's disappearance, after Sandy's been scrubbing the floor, Robin was having trouble
- 9:39falling asleep. And she's younger than Lena. Yauh. Something just didn't set
- 9:43right with her. So she's up and she's gazing out her bedroom window when
- 9:48she noticed Sandy and Chris, her boyfriend, struggling to pull something very large.
- 9:54Robin had a sinking feeling that it was Gary's body being dragged it was
- 10:00inside something, because his boots were sticking out one of the ends, and
- 10:05Robin was so scared seeing that. Oh yeah that your mom, Yeah exactly.
- 10:11She kept this information to herself for years, by the way, and
- 10:16she would later tell police that she could have sworn it was Gary in that
- 10:20some whatever they wrapped him allegedly up in Okay, allegedly. Allegedly, Lena
- 10:26had told the girls they couldn't talk about what happened to Gary because then the
- 10:31police would take them away from Sandy, they'd be split up and end up
- 10:35in like different foster homes, and so this was one of the reasons why
- 10:39Robin never said anything about what she saw. I mean, Mom, yeah,
- 10:45maybe he was dragging, but you want to stay with your sisters,
- 10:48probably, yeah, but now my mom might be dragging my dad's dead body
- 10:52around. Was some strange guy, yeah, okay. After Gary went missing,
- 10:56Sandy decided to move the girls to Saint Louis, where she married Chris.
- 11:01Then a year later they all moved again to Sligo or Sligo, Missouri.
- 11:05I'm guessing this is probably out in the country somewhere. So time's going
- 11:09by, time's going by. Yeah. Then Lena's sisters started noticing a difference
- 11:13in Lena. She had become quite distance. She seemed just kind of like
- 11:18on the edge most of the time, and her friends noticed a change in
- 11:22her behavior. She started going out to parties and drinking and using drugs,
- 11:28which wasn't like her personality before, But there was just something going on with
- 11:35her, that internal internal conflict. She would often stare into space, and
- 11:41when she was asked what's the matter, she would just pretend nothing was wrong.
- 11:46Brandy felt that Lena must be really lonely, like I don't know how
- 11:48she knew this, but she just said that Lena's keeping something battled up and
- 11:54keeping to herself and isolating herself, and just something's going on. Lena eventually
- 12:01confided in a boyfriend about what was troubling her. Oh no, and he
- 12:05convinced her to go talk to her former stepfather and Gary's brother, Albert.
- 12:11Okay, wait, oh yeah, I'm gonna I'm gonna explain this. Yeah,
- 12:15I know, you're blowing your mind for me or something. So Sandy
- 12:18met a man named Albert McCullough this is Gary's brother, in the early nineties,
- 12:22and they got married Albert and Sandy on November seventeenth, nineteen ninety four.
- 12:28Okay, and Albert turned out to be a great stepfather to Sandy's girls,
- 12:33and Gary was too, by the way, but Albert took on this
- 12:37role of raising the girls and giving them some stability. He put them in
- 12:41activities like gymnastics and other sports like to keep them active. I mean,
- 12:46there's six girls. This family has their hands full, Albert, you know,
- 12:52and look at me, look at me. I know. Albert had
- 12:56become really close to the girls. But at some point during his marriage to
- 13:00Sandy, he got the suspicion that something was going on with her, that
- 13:03she was hiding something, and maybe that she was cheating on him. But
- 13:07he never expected the person to be his brother, to be his brother's brother.
- 13:13Yeah, I know his brother. Stop it. When Albert found out
- 13:20about the affair between his wife and his brother, he confronted Gary and they
- 13:24got into a fist fight. Albert said, quote he beat the tara out
- 13:28of me, and I beat the tar out of him. End quote.
- 13:31During the fight, Albert had pinned Gary down and then he felt like whack
- 13:37on his back. Oh, that's probably from Sandy. Yeah, she was
- 13:39trying to break up the fight between the brothers and she hit Albert on the
- 13:43back with a stick or something. Why did she hit Gary? Albert was
- 13:48on top of Gary. Yeahert So he's like beating the shit out of Gary.
- 13:52So she's saving her new man, right, and knocked the wind out
- 13:56of Albert. So I don't think it was just like a little stick.
- 13:58I think it was something a little more hefty. After that happened, Albert
- 14:01just said he got up and he said to Gary quote man I'm done that
- 14:05girl ate nothing but trouble. You'd better leave it alone. But then he
- 14:09doesn't get to be a stepdad to the kid. No, isn't that sad?
- 14:13And then how do you do Christmas and Thanksgiving? You know, right
- 14:16sure your brother is with your wife and your brother who's now married to your
- 14:22ex wife. Yet like, what what is this? Okay? After this
- 14:26fistfight between the brothers, Sandy officially laughed Albert for Gary. And this happened
- 14:33on May twenty second, nineteen ninety six, so this is about three years
- 14:37before Gary disappears. Sandy had married Gary on December twenty first, nineteen ninety
- 14:43six, and the girls, the sisters said their lives changed whence Gary came
- 14:48into their lives because now I mentioned earlier Gary lived on a farm and Albert
- 14:54didn't live on a farm. So here they're now being thrust into this farm
- 14:56life. And and their uncle's now stepdad yea, their uncle stepdad? Hello?
- 15:03Yeah, So they were put to work working on the farm. There
- 15:07was chickens, cows, and horses that the girls had to take care of.
- 15:11They would chop wood that if they weren't used to it, that would
- 15:13be a big shock. I'm sure. Yeah, it's hard work. Yeah,
- 15:18chopping wood and taking care of it. I mean I haven't. I
- 15:20mean I've never done it. I've never done it. I have two Yorkis
- 15:24count I don't think that's quite as big as taking care of a horse.
- 15:28But work, No, But they're little, they're little hellions too, so
- 15:33as they keep you busy, yes they do. Gary made sure that each
- 15:37of the girls hit a chore that would keep them busy and off drugs.
- 15:41Yeah, you know, out of trouble, not out of trouble. But
- 15:43he was a great stepdad. When they were done with each day, he
- 15:46would take them into town and buy them ice cream. Oh that's nice.
- 15:50That's nice. And just like Albert, Gary grew connected to the girls and
- 15:54looked after them. Brandy says she's thankful for some of the lessons that Gary
- 15:58totter. That makes me feel good. Yeah, And she said, you
- 16:00know, she became more discipline and she doesn't depend on any man to do
- 16:06anything for her. And it's something these lessons that she learned is something that
- 16:08she values to this day. That's why we got to do it with our
- 16:11kids. You know, we got taken to a farm just find it for
- 16:15me. That's right. We're just gonna have to look for one. There's
- 16:17gotta be one out where you live. There's farms out there, isn't there
- 16:19just out the middle of the country there, okay. Unfortunately for her daughters,
- 16:25Sandy became bored with Gary my ber I told your and and Albert before
- 16:29him. She was now smitten with Chris Clamp. How'd you find in all
- 16:33these guys she's living in like bump fucky? Like why finding people? And
- 16:38bumpucky? And there was menda for these two too, So she got around,
- 16:42not trying to like shit on Sandy, but Candy got around. So
- 16:47Chris was younger than Gary, and she considered him more handsome, and he
- 16:52also came from some money and he owned some properties, so maybe he was
- 16:56a step up from Gary. Although Gary owns a farm, so he's owning
- 17:00property too. But so she starts having this affair with Chris. In March
- 17:03of nineteen ninety nine, Robin actually met Chris one time, and she instantly
- 17:07thought, oh, Gary's gonna whip his little butt, right. She thought,
- 17:11yeah, there's no Gary's Gary's gonna take him on. And Sandy felt
- 17:15no shame in showing off her boyfriend so weird, I know, in front
- 17:19of her kids, like, oh he's gonna Gary's gonna whip his butt?
- 17:22What about? Oh mom? Is she not Gary? And I'm thinking like
- 17:26his oldest was probably somewhere around seventeen, maybe sixteen seventeen. It didn't take
- 17:33long for Gary to catch on well, yeah, and he's showing the kids
- 17:37right. And it culminated on March twenty fourth, when Gary was arrested for
- 17:44allegedly writing bad checks. He didn't do it, It's like I didn't do
- 17:49this. But after his arrest, he realized Sandy, of course was using
- 17:53his name and passing the bad checks. Of course. But at this point,
- 17:57you know, Gary's just had enough. She got this boyfriend, she's
- 18:00now doing this. She's gonna get him in twelve Yeah, she's gonna get
- 18:03him in trouble. So he contacted a family friend who was also an attorney,
- 18:07and he told him everything that Sandy was doing and had done. He
- 18:11told his friend, the attorney, that he was going to file for divorce.
- 18:15So remember I told you Lena had told her boyfriend what was Yeah,
- 18:21she confessed something, So I didn't tell you exactly what it was because I
- 18:23had to give you a little more background. Okay, So her boyfriend was
- 18:26urging her to go to Albert and tell him what was bothering her. She
- 18:32trusted Albert, like I told you know, he was a great step dad
- 18:34and she looked up to him. So on June twenty sixth, two thousand
- 18:37and three, Lena went over to Albert's house. And this is like almost
- 18:41four years I was going to say from year three now, yeah, and
- 18:45Lina's probably around eighteen at this point, yeah, because she was fourteen.
- 18:48Yeah, So she goes to Albert's and he could tell right away something was
- 18:52wrong. Lena ended up confessing to Albert that Sandy had killed Gary although years
- 19:00ago, and that she had been a witnessed part of it. Why would
- 19:03she let her kids I witnessed that. Albert had a recorder, like a
- 19:08recording device hidden, so he ended up taping what Lena told him. Wow,
- 19:15and she described what happened. She said Gary was sitting on the couch
- 19:18eating some scrambled eggs when Sandy walked out into the living room and shot him
- 19:23three times. What in the house and six girls? Yes, and this
- 19:29is I'm thinking, this is when they were at school, because remember they
- 19:30came home that day. She wasn't there for this part. Okay, but
- 19:34this is what Sandy, Yeah, this is what's allegedly sandy. Okay,
- 19:38okay. She then wrapped him in some plastic and hay strings and dragged him
- 19:42into their bedroom. Her daughters were home or do home from school soon,
- 19:48so she locked the bedroom door for safe measure. She's mom of the fucking
- 19:52year, isn't she right. She tried to hide Gary's body from Lena,
- 19:56but Lena looked through the door somehow, and she ended up seeing Gary's lifeless
- 20:02body lying on the bedroom floor. She couldn't believe it. And later that
- 20:07night, Sandy moved Gary's body to his truck. And then is she doing
- 20:11that? Well, Chris, I believe Chris, help, You can't.
- 20:15There's no way she's gonna move. You ever carried dead weight? Hell no,
- 20:18I haven't. Well, it looked like I have. I have,
- 20:21but we're dead a hospital for the record, and a very tiny older woman
- 20:26felt like a billion pounds really dead weight. There's a reason why they say
- 20:30dead weight. Yeah, yeah, so I'm yeah, she had to have
- 20:34had help, right, And remember Robin saw something through her bedroom. Yeah,
- 20:37I was right with Chris, right, and it was with Chris.
- 20:41And she's telling Albert this story. Lena is just shaking like a leaf the
- 20:45entire time. I mean, she's terrified. We asked her, well,
- 20:48where is Gary's body? And Lena told him there's nothing left of Gary.
- 20:53Did you have pigs on the farm. No, Oh, he had been
- 20:56burned in a burn pile and everything that was in the burn pile was then
- 21:02put in buckets and spread out all over the farm, so no one could
- 21:07really tell they were ashes or anything. There's still be teeths. Yeah,
- 21:11she said she helped spread the ashes, and so that's how she knew what
- 21:15happened. And she told Albert how she had burned her fingers picking up the
- 21:21ashes, and there was little bits of bone left, like you said,
- 21:23maybe there was teeth. That poor girl, That poor girl. And she
- 21:27was probably fourteen when this happened. Lena then said Albert, quote, I
- 21:33know this makes me look like a bad person, but what was I supposed
- 21:37to do? End quote. I'd be afraid my mom would kill me,
- 21:41yes, exactly. And so Albert told her, Yeah, he said,
- 21:45you were just a kid and you were doing what your mom told you,
- 21:48so he didn't blame her for what happened to Gary. And she's traumatized.
- 21:52I would be traumatized, right, and that kind of explains like her change
- 21:56and behavior and yeah, absolutely, you know, and she's probably drinking and
- 22:03forget what happened because they told you. Albert recorded, yes, and he
- 22:07ended up giving the recording to a family attorney. He told Albert, you
- 22:12really need to take this to the police. So Everett took it to the
- 22:15police in hopes that maybe something now was going to happen to solve Gary's disappearance.
- 22:22Officially, he's just missing at this and that's his brother. Yeah,
- 22:26so when police heard the tape, he thought, oh, they could finally
- 22:30start putting together a case that Gary was murdered. However, because the conversation
- 22:36was taped without Lena's knowledge, it's inadmissible in Michigan. Would be admissible,
- 22:41Yeah, in Michigan it would, but at the time there what Missouri.
- 22:45I guess. So this is a problem for the police. You know,
- 22:48they're they're trying to decide like can they even pursue charges against Sandy because they
- 22:55really have no evidence except this inadmissible recording that's where you go to lean yeah,
- 23:00and you start doing some pressuring. Yeah, because she's ready to crack.
- 23:03Yeah, she's ready to crack. Well, didn't quite happen that way,
- 23:07because Sandy found out that Lena confessed to Albert no no, and that
- 23:12a recording had been handed to the police. How did she find out.
- 23:17I'm not sure exactly. I'm thinking Lena told her sisters, because I know
- 23:22at some point one of her sisters gets into a fight, but Lena couldn't
- 23:25have known because she didn't give permission, so it must have been Yeah,
- 23:27I think it. Eventually, it al came out. It all comes out.
- 23:30Oh, no, I know you're gonna tell me something bad. Well,
- 23:33Sandy got a lawyer for herself and for Lena, and this really solidified
- 23:38the fact that Sandy was guilty. And the lawyer that Sandy hired for Lena
- 23:44convinced Lena to take back her confession oh that she had made to Albert,
- 23:48which then again left the police with absolutely nothing. The officer was working on
- 23:52Gary's case really felt defeated because they felt like they knew exactly what happened to
- 23:57Gary, like who did it, how his body was disposed of? Like
- 24:02maybe they could even start searching the land. I was going to say,
- 24:03you right, I find she's got some twenty thirty three teeth? How many
- 24:07do I have? Write something like that. They don't burn and burn,
- 24:11But they couldn't do anything because knowing something and being able to prove it with
- 24:17evidence, as you know, is two different things. Before I tell you
- 24:22more, we're going to take a break. When Brandy found out, and
- 24:29Brandy's the oldest sister, found out about Lena's confession, she was just shocked
- 24:33beyond belief. Despite what she knew about her mom, she never thought that
- 24:37her mom was capable of hurting someone or even killing someone. And she had
- 24:41so many questions that she wanted to ask Sandy, but she kept them to
- 24:45herself for years. All these girls are feeling like something's going on. Well,
- 24:48I would be like to my sister, listen, you're gonna sit down
- 24:52and you're gonna tell me the truth, right nor bullshit? Right. One
- 24:57day, Brandy was hanging out with Lena, and that's when Lena finally opened
- 25:02up to her about what happened all those years ago. She told Brandy about
- 25:07how Sandy had killed Gary and disposed of his body. Brandy didn't know what
- 25:11to say. Really, what can you say? Right, It's go to
- 25:14the track place. Yeah. The next night, you let's leave mom.
- 25:18I don't want to see mom agat. I know they're staying. My kids
- 25:22don't talk to me sometimes, so I try to take their phone away.
- 25:25Let alone killed somebody kill like their stepdad. I know. The next night,
- 25:29Brandy and Sandy got into a massive fight. This is the one that
- 25:32I kind of referred to earlier. Brandy was calling Sandy names and eventually said
- 25:36to her, I'm going to call the police and tell them every single thing
- 25:40you did because I know. Oh no, no, no no. And
- 25:44that's when Sandy looked at her and said, you need to get in the
- 25:45truck right now. Oh fuck no, mom, not getting in that truck.
- 25:49Oh Brandy did no, and Chris was there. Oh shit, yeah,
- 25:55still got Chris. She still got Chris. Don't get in the truck,
- 25:59Brandy. She did, and they drove for a while, when eventually
- 26:03Chris pulls the truck over. He gets out, I know, he gets
- 26:07out, and Brandy starts looking around. When she looks to her right and
- 26:11she sees a gun. This is my right, see the guy When she
- 26:15looks her and she sees a gun like staring her right in the face.
- 26:18So she jumps out of the car screaming. She's just scared out of her
- 26:22mind because she's like, he's gonna kill me, right in front of Sandy.
- 26:26And she looked at Sandy and Sandy mom. Yeah, Sandy had no
- 26:30reaction because she's hoping Sandy will protect her. That's her mom, and in
- 26:34the hopes that Sandy would protect her. She gets back into the truck and
- 26:40she gets to where Sandy's in and she starts hugging her like just as tight
- 26:44as she can, and she said, please, don't let him hurt me.
- 26:45Please, don't let him hurt me. And then that's when Sandy says,
- 26:48don't hurt my baby. Oh good. So Chris lowered the gun.
- 26:52He got back into the car and they drove back to the house. Oh,
- 26:56oh my god, you have me on the edge girl. Oh I
- 26:57know Brandy survived it. But Brandy said, before that night, she would
- 27:02have never thought that her mom was capable of this, and now she was
- 27:06terrified. Yeah. Time to get a job, get out of mom's house,
- 27:10move away right. A few months after making her confession to Albert.
- 27:15Lena gave birth to her son, Coulter on November third, two thousand and
- 27:19three, and her whole world change after that. I feel like I kind
- 27:22of saw the story someplace. You may have. It was on Unsolved Mysteries.
- 27:27Okay, yes, it was an Unsolved Missy. I don't remember anything
- 27:32because I watched it religiously, and even the new ones that are on Netflix.
- 27:34I don't remember this from watching it. But it's an Unsolved Mysteries story.
- 27:40So she was absolutely in love with her son. She would do anything
- 27:44for him, and after giving birth, she didn't want to speak about what
- 27:48happened to Gary after that because she just wanted to like start this new life
- 27:51she had her son. She's still living with Sandy because she doesn't have enough
- 27:56money to move, so she starts working multiple jobs in order to provide for
- 28:00Colton and give him the life that she never had. Sandy would look after
- 28:04Culture when Lena went to her, I'm sorry, it's Culter. So if
- 28:08I said Colton, I'm sorry, that was a mistake. It's Culture.
- 28:11Yeah. Lena was doing really well for a few years after Coulter's birth.
- 28:17She stopped partying, she stopped all of that, like I said, he
- 28:18changed her life. And in two thousand and six, Lena had finally started
- 28:22to make a life for herself without Sandy and with culture. She met a
- 28:27man that she was looking forward to marrying, and they planned to settle down
- 28:32and have this family together. Her fiance was going to be a great dead
- 28:34to Coulter, and Lena was working to become financially independent from Sandy. You've
- 28:40set me up with a high Yeah, just take me. I'm sorry.
- 28:45Sandy of course felt very threatened. So if all this is true, right,
- 28:49that Lena knew this stuff about Sandy, she of course is now feeling
- 28:53threatened by her daughter's maturity, and she began to feel, you know,
- 28:59I no longer have Lena under my thumb. True that Lena might start talking
- 29:03about what she knew. Tensions began to rise between Sandy and Lena, which
- 29:08then escalated when a lawsuit was filed. And this lawsuit was filed by Gary's
- 29:14family for wrongful death. Oh shit, Yeah, his family felt that since
- 29:18no criminal charges were pending, and it didn't seem like criminal charges would even
- 29:23ever be a possibility, that seven years later or something. Yeah, it's
- 29:27like seven years later the only way they could get some satisfaction was to sue
- 29:32Sandy for wrongful death. It's not a criminal charge, but it also has
- 29:37a lesser burden right to prove. You don't have to prove beyond a reasonable
- 29:41doubt. It's clear convincing evidence. So I'm thinking that's like how oj got
- 29:45convicted, probably right her death, the more famous one that we know.
- 29:49So the preponderance of the evidence, is it a preponderance of the evidence or
- 29:52clear and convincing? I can't remember. I can remember preponderance, preponderance because
- 29:57the preponderance is below so reasonable, yeah, and clear and convincing is lesser
- 30:03than this. Yes. So they alleged in the wrongful death suit that sand
- 30:07and Chris were responsible for Gary's death and that Lena was an accessory. So
- 30:11Lena's part of this. Oh and they hope that including Lena in the lawsuit.
- 30:15Yeah, so here's finally the pressure that you talked about a little bit
- 30:18earlier, Like maybe they would put this pressure on and maybe now she would
- 30:22go to the prosecutor. Or it's a prosecutor that does it, So maybe
- 30:26get immunity somehow, like maybe trade her testimony against Sandy for some kind of
- 30:32lesser charge or some kind of immunity for herself. However, is where you're
- 30:37gonna get me sack. When the time came to serve the lawsuit to Sandy,
- 30:41Chris and Lena, they weren't able to find Lena and knew it.
- 30:45Yeah, to serve for the papers, they asked Sandy where Lena was because
- 30:49they need to deliver this summons and the complaint, and Sandy told them,
- 30:55oh, Lena ran off the Florida with some guy that she just recently started
- 31:00to sing, which seemed really odd because the guy wasn't her fiance and she
- 31:06son, and she didn't take Colter with her. No, No, he's
- 31:08with what Sandy right, something like that. Yes, I kind of remembered
- 31:12that. Now, Yeah, that's why I don't like Sandy Noney reasons No.
- 31:17Yes. On February fourteenth, two thousand and six, Robin stopped by
- 31:19Lena's house and this is when she finds out Lena's boyfriend fiance tells her,
- 31:25oh, your sister took off with some guy to Florida, and so Robin's
- 31:29like confused, like what what she knows? Lena would never leave? Of
- 31:33course, yeah, would never leave colder and the boyfriend Beyonce told Robin,
- 31:37well, that's what Sandy told me. Oh okay. So when Robin looked
- 31:41around the house, she noticed none of Lena's clothes were taken and all her
- 31:48photos were still there, and she knew Lena loved the photographs that she had,
- 31:53so Robin was convinced that if she had really laughed, she definitely at
- 31:56least would have taken these photos with her. So this seemed really weird to
- 32:00rap him, like, not only did she not take clothing, Jussel,
- 32:04didn't take these precious or her son? Yeah or her yeah, exactly.
- 32:08Yes. When Sandy told Brandy that Lena left with some guy, she was
- 32:12also confused. Brandy and Lena were hanging out often together. I mean,
- 32:16they were close and they would tell each other everything. So for Brandy to
- 32:20find out that Lena had left with some guy through Sandy, no, she
- 32:23would have known. No, Mom, call him bullshit. Sandy then told
- 32:28the rest of Lena's sisters that Lena had been saying bad things about them and
- 32:32she wanted nothing more to do with them. So they were like, they're
- 32:36hanging out with there, I know, and the girls waited a few days
- 32:39and hoped that Lena would show back up, but she didn't, so her
- 32:44sisters knew something was mom very, very wrong. When Albert was told that
- 32:50Lena was missing, he instantly he knew, he knew. He felt like
- 32:54Sandy had something to do with it. God, what an evil bitch.
- 32:58Yeah, he felt Lena knew too much. She would be able to get
- 33:01Sandy locked away for the rest of her life if she was able to tell
- 33:06everyone what she allegedly saw right. Robin later talked to police and said she
- 33:10believed her mother killed Lena to keep her quiet. All the sisters, who
- 33:15was Robin, I'd be scared to death to all of them. No.
- 33:19Robin put up missing person flyers around the neighborhood in hopes of getting information about
- 33:24Lena, and then Robin found out later that her mother was paying her little
- 33:29sister's five dollars a piece to take them down. Getting pissed Tanya, so
- 33:35Robin later called Sandy confronted her, and she said, I know that you're
- 33:38the reason that Lena's not here. You messed up this time. Now it's
- 33:42one of my sisters. I'm going to be the one that finds out.
- 33:45One way, or another, whether it's scary or Lena, I'm going to
- 33:49be the one that finds out and make sure that you rat. Well,
- 33:52that's pretty brave, considering you think your mom probably killed your sister and now
- 33:55you're telling your mom and her husband. Eventually, see, Andy got custody
- 34:00of culture oh home, and an officer that was investigating Lina's case is convinced
- 34:07that culter is one of the reasons Sandy had for making her daughter disappear.
- 34:13Allegedly, she wanted to raise Yeah, you know. Obviously one was to
- 34:16hide the fact that Lena knew stuff. But then Sandy's was supposedly reportedly obsessed
- 34:24with culter, like she always wanted to have a son, Yeah, because
- 34:28she had ten thousand daughters. Yeah, and she would even have culter color
- 34:31mom, oh, which is weird. And Lena was really bothered by that.
- 34:36Yeah, what is that? So she just was really possessive and obsessed
- 34:39with culture, and so they're thinking maybe this was another reason, a second
- 34:45reason. When Lena went missing, Sandy filed abandonment charges against Lena to obtain
- 34:51custody of culture, and since Lena didn't show up to court, the court
- 34:54had no choice. But to declare that Lena had abandoned her child, Lena
- 34:58has to get served. They might have done alternate service. That's true,
- 35:01that's true. In July of twenty thirteen, Judge car Woods heard the wrongful
- 35:07death lawsuit brought against Sandy and Chris for the murder of Gary. Lena's recorded
- 35:12confession wasn't played. It was not allowed to be used as evidence for reasons
- 35:15that I've said before. Yeah, you can't very verify it, right,
- 35:20but then if she's dead, that's I know, you can kind of get
- 35:24in. I mean, Albert could testify to it, but it's your say,
- 35:28you're right here say. Brandy and Robin had taken the stand to testify
- 35:32against their mom and implicate her in the murder plot against Gary. When Brandy
- 35:37took the stand, she testified about the night that Chris had threatened her with
- 35:42the god remember they were in the truck. Yeah, and that Sandy really
- 35:45didn't do anything to help her. Brandy never thought she'd be able to testify
- 35:50against her mom, but she knew she needed to do it in order to
- 35:53see some kind of justice for Gary's family. The verdict in the civil trial
- 35:59was that Chris and Sandy were found liable for knowingly taking the life of Gary
- 36:02McCullough. Sandy and Chris were ordered to pay seven million dollars to Gary's family.
- 36:07The family hasn't received any compensation. I'm sure they don't have any anything,
- 36:14probably not in their name. And they never had much in their name,
- 36:16even though Chris did have land and stuff like property and stuff, but
- 36:20I don't know he had time to get it out of his name, right,
- 36:22Yeah, I guess. In twenty fourteen, Chris and Sandy got a
- 36:27divorce. Oh oh, and Sandy remarried, oh for like the fortieth time,
- 36:34and all the wrong places, look the wrong places whatever that is.
- 36:39Yeah, and she married some guy named Joe and she still his custody of
- 36:44bold no, stop it, stop it. And for a while Culter was
- 36:47homeschooled because allegedly, Sandy's school didn't want him to find out anything about his
- 36:53mom. And that's another way to keep him under control. Yeah right.
- 36:58Lena's sisters have vowed to tell Coulter the truth someday because they don't want Sandy
- 37:02to get away with what they believe she did. Oh, I mean,
- 37:07it's just and Brandy's heartbroken I'm sure all her sisters are heartbroken over the fact
- 37:12that Sandy is raising and Lena didn't get a chance to do it and she
- 37:17adored her son, and Sandy, you get away with it. Well,
- 37:22where's Lena's body? Well, no one knows. It's known that Chris and
- 37:27Sandy had two properties when they were married. One was in Sligo or Sligo
- 37:30and one was an eighty acre ranch north of Salem. That's a lot of
- 37:36property. Brandy and Robin were given permission by the new owners of the property
- 37:40to search for Lena's remains, which is obviously difficult. When Brandy went back
- 37:46to that property, she recalled there used to be a well there, and
- 37:51the new owners had no recollection of a well being there, So Brandy believes
- 37:54maybe for some reason, Sandy filled it in before it was sold. And
- 37:59at the other property, Robin remembers that after Lena's disappearance, Sandy had pointed
- 38:06out, like there were four trees in front of the house and told Robin
- 38:08that's where I buried my dog Toby. I kind of remember that from the
- 38:13show, And Robin thought, well, this is kind of weird because Sandy
- 38:15had originally told Robin that she had buried Toby at the top of a hill
- 38:20under a tree at their old house. So this wasn't making sense, and
- 38:24she's changing her story about burying her pet. I can't believe she's even talking
- 38:29to her mom. I know, I think that might have happened before,
- 38:34yeah, but I mean it was obviously after Lena disappeared, and the police
- 38:38did conduct a ground scan of the area where Robin thought Lena could have been
- 38:44buried, but after searching with ground penetrating radar, there were no remains found.
- 38:50Anybody that knows that doesn't live in a city and knows property, eighty
- 38:53Eggers is a lot of land to go through, especially if you burned by
- 39:00That's what I'm thinking, because they got away with it once right again,
- 39:05right. Brandy and Robin obviously struggle every day with the loss of their sister,
- 39:08and they just really just want to know what happened to her. Robin
- 39:13told Unsolved Mysteries that she wants Lena to know that she loved her, is
- 39:16proud of her for keeping the girls all together, because she was like their
- 39:20rock when they were little, and if it wasn't for her, they wouldn't
- 39:23be together. Like they are now and there isn't a day that goes by
- 39:28her. She's not thinking of Lena. I bet what happened to Lena is
- 39:32a lot like what could have happened to Brandy. Yeah, and let's get
- 39:37in the truck. It's pretty I don't know, I know nothing. Allegedly.
- 39:40I guess when Unsolved Mysteries was doing was doing their episode, they reached
- 39:46out to Sandy and Chris for interviews, but they got no real I have
- 39:50no comment, no comment. Unsolved Mysteries later released footage of some unseen interviews
- 39:55from some of the episodes that didn't make it into the documentary. One of
- 40:00the interviews was Lena's description on the night Gary was allegedly murdered. I think
- 40:05maybe they played the tape. Lena had told police that she took a ride
- 40:08in Gary's truck before he died, and it seemed odd to police because when
- 40:13they chucked to Gary's truck, they discovered you couldn't sit on the passenger side,
- 40:17like the floor was covered in litter. So one of the police officers
- 40:21said, I found it ironic because in the one interview I did get with
- 40:23Lena, she said that on the night Gary left. She rode with him
- 40:27in the truck but didn't want to be seen with him, and she sat
- 40:30on the floor of the truck. And it just seems like, so they're
- 40:34not sure. Maybe that with some bullshit story, I don't know. Another
- 40:37interview that was missed in the documentary came from Chris Klemp's wife at the time,
- 40:42because he was married when he met Sandy. He was married. He
- 40:45was married married, that's so cute. Yeah, So he was cheating on
- 40:49her with Sandy, and Sandy was cheating on Gary with Chris. So everybody's
- 40:52cheating, okay, And apparently Chris's wife, Jennifer, they got into a
- 40:58screaming match one night. So they're having screaming match. And he said something
- 41:01to the effect of, I can't worry about the stuffy now, I've got
- 41:06to worry about killing a man. Oh. Oh, I don't know,
- 41:09you know what fish to fry. Yeah, I really can't deal with your
- 41:14bullshit at this moment. I've got Yeah, I've got other important things on
- 41:16my mind. The fuck is wrong with people? Yeah, And she took
- 41:22Chris to Gary's house and dropped him off. The night of Gary's disappearance,
- 41:25she said, and she said, Chris was scared and she believes like that
- 41:30was the night because she had up picking him up later that night and she
- 41:32said he was scared, and she believes that's the night that Gary's body was
- 41:36burnt. I don't know, Okay, it's her recollection, Okay. When
- 41:40police opened the case into Lena's disappearance, they talked to Lena's boyfriend at the
- 41:45time, and yes fiance, and he told police he left Lena it was
- 41:50Valentine's Day. Now, they kissed and they had made plans for the day,
- 41:53but when he returned home, Lena wasn't there, but Sandy was,
- 41:58and she was cleaning out of Lena's belongings from their apartment. And he said,
- 42:02you know, so they live together, Lena and her mom and her
- 42:05boyfriend. Oh, Lena and her boyfriend fiance, oh, fyance, and
- 42:08then mom is there. They're cleaning out Lina's belongings like that same day,
- 42:15so that was weird. He said. He never saw Lena again after that,
- 42:17so that was kind of odd. I would be like, what the
- 42:21hell are you doing here? No, right, like, what are you
- 42:23doing? And that's when she told him, Well, Lena ran off with
- 42:25another guy. So I'm just here to get her stuff, probably is what
- 42:29she said. This where I'm gonna end the story, Okay, And it's
- 42:31unsolved, and I'm sorry, I hate this obviously with unsolved mysteries. I
- 42:36mean, you all got a clue a little bit earlier that it was not
- 42:38solved. But I kind of know what happened. We know it happened.
- 42:43It's just there's no there's not enough evidence to bring charges against anyone. And
- 42:49the same with Gary. There's no criminal charges pending or anything. But if
- 42:53you know anything regarding the disappearance of Lena Chapin, please contact the Dent County,
- 43:00Missouri Sheriff's office at five seven three seven two nine three two four one,
- 43:07or you can go to unsolved mysage. I mean, I'm sure you
- 43:08would have already went to unsolved you're listening to. Yeah, So if anyone
- 43:15has any information, it would be nice to have some closure. But and
- 43:19you guys some real pissars here. I'm just saying, I'm sorry everyone,
- 43:22Can you just give me like solved one? I know, but this was
- 43:25a really interesting story and it needs to be told because Lena's family needs some
- 43:30kind of closure. Too bad. There's not more information that somebody knows.
- 43:34I mean, somebody does know everybody, and there's only two people allegedly they
- 43:38know Chris saying and I'm thinking even though they're divorced, they're not saying anything
- 43:45anything because they could, you know, they could. They're both in trouble.
- 43:47Yeah, then they're both in trouble. So if a legend, I'm
- 43:52not saying anything, I know, I wasn't there. I wasn't there,
- 43:54so but I have an idea. But thank you, thank you anyone watching
- 44:00and listening. Well, first of all, I want to thank my lovely
- 44:02co host Tanya. You're welcome, an LN Marie Jane. You guys can
- 44:07check us out on our website, Crumbsonconsequences dot com. We have some merchandise,
- 44:13some cool merchandise. Does we have new like Christmas themed things on our
- 44:19website too? Yeah? Yep, bucket, fuck you fuck off? Ye
- 44:27yeah, I'm sure to say what I'm dead inside hardcore true crime. Don't
- 44:32kill each other, don't kill each other. There's also what there's in a
- 44:38lot of our episodes. I say, what the fuck, Tanya, Yeah,
- 44:43you probably felt that way about this one because it's unsolved. I know
- 44:46she swears too, though she's actually had a really bad don't let this little
- 44:52school teacher Sunday school teacher act fool anybody. So you can go to our
- 44:59website, Crime Consequences. You can listen to us on it, you can
- 45:01listen to us on any of the podcast apps you subscribe to. Subscribe to
- 45:08True Crime Daily's YouTube, and like us, please don't say anything mean because
- 45:13if you do, we are probably going to pick out your comment and insult
- 45:15you. Unless unless you're into that, but you know, go ahead.
- 45:22And then we also have what's called Patreon where you can subscribe. It's patreon
- 45:25dot com slash TNT crimes, and that is where Tanya and I release once
- 45:31a week audio for our paid subscribers, and we also release the audio for
- 45:38this audio slash video early and they're all ad free and we have over two
- 45:44hundred episodes. And yeah, what else. Check it out Patreon dot com
- 45:50checkt crimes. But you have our website, Oh, social media. We
- 45:53haven't done that in a while though, our social not really there's good stuff
- 45:58on there if you're into true crime. I mean, we do feature some
- 46:00other cases and stuff that we've never covered, and it's at hardcore true crime.
- 46:05And that's about it. That's it until our next episode. Don't kill
- 46:09each other. Bye bye