Latest / The Vegan Report / How Many People Are Really Vegan? | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:01Hi everyone, I'm Elise Hankins for The Vegan
- 0:04Report today. I'm here to explore the seemingly
- 0:07simple question, how many vegans are there? And
- 0:10is that number growing? Now, tucked away in this
- 0:14seemingly simple question is a minefield of inconsistent,
- 0:19conflicting and missing data. And I recently
- 0:22did my best to make sense of it. And you might
- 0:26be thinking, Elise, this is the most benign.
- 0:30or even, dare I say, boring topic to cover. But
- 0:33to be honest, I'm actually a little bit nervous
- 0:36to talk about what I found because I might be
- 0:39handing the anti -vegans some ammunition. So
- 0:43I'm hoping they haven't tuned in. But if that
- 0:47piques your interest, I hope you'll stay with
- 0:49me through the episode. Before I tell you about
- 0:52all that, though, again, my name is Elise Hankins.
- 0:55I'm a social researcher for Bryant Research.
- 0:58I also manage the company's social media, so
- 1:00if you see anything really cringy on there, you
- 1:03have me to blame. If you want to see any of that
- 1:07potentially cringy content, you'll find our social
- 1:09links in the episode notes, as well as my email,
- 1:12if you'd like to reach out. Anyway. Bryant Research
- 1:16is a research consultancy. We work with animal
- 1:20protection non -profits, alternative protein
- 1:22companies, and academics to help transform the
- 1:25food system into one that is kinder to animals.
- 1:29Essentially, we conduct research on others' behalf
- 1:32or in partnership with others, and sometimes
- 1:34we do our own independent projects as well. The
- 1:37project I'm going to talk about today is one
- 1:39I did with Phonolitics. the animal advocacy data
- 1:43gurus that you guys probably already know all
- 1:46about and don't need any introduction. So with
- 1:50all that out of the way, let's get into it. I'm
- 1:54going to take you back to 2015. A peer -reviewed
- 1:59study comes out looking at the diets of over
- 2:0115 ,000 Americans between 2007 and 2010. They
- 2:07found that nearly half of self -identified vegetarians
- 2:12ate red meat, poultry, or seafood in the last
- 2:1724 hours. Then animal charity evaluators comes
- 2:22in for the kill with another report. It's 2018
- 2:25now. Keep in mind between 2 and 6 percent of
- 2:29Americans at this point identify as vegetarian.
- 2:33What percentage of self -proclaimed vegetarians
- 2:37do you think ate meat in the preceding 24 hours
- 2:41this time? Okay, to be fair, participants logged
- 2:44their food choices on two separate days. So let's
- 2:47say how many self -identified vegetarians ate
- 2:50meat over the course of two days? If you guessed
- 2:5460%, you'd be right. I mean, a brutal finding,
- 3:01right? So there's clearly a difference between
- 3:03who people say they are and how they actually
- 3:07eat. But the data is pretty old at this point,
- 3:11right? And it only covers the US. So if we want
- 3:14to know the rate of vegetarianism or veganism
- 3:17and what vegetarian or vegan even means, we've
- 3:22got some gaps to fill. So, finalists put a call
- 3:25for research out and we answered with a systematic
- 3:29review of academic and gray literature covering
- 3:32837 sources, 10 years, and 58 countries. All
- 3:37of the findings I'll talk about today came from
- 3:40analyzing nationally representative data only.
- 3:44And within those 837 sources, we pulled out data
- 3:47about veganism, vegetarianism, and also flexitarianism.
- 3:51So not every source reported a veganism rate,
- 3:54for example. The first major finding I'll share
- 3:59is that veganism is rising globally. It's more
- 4:04of a crawl than a sprint. I'm talking an annual
- 4:07growth rate of about 0 .1 % since 2015, which
- 4:13sounds underwhelming, I know. But with headlines
- 4:16proclaiming the death of veganism, it's cool
- 4:20to see that they're wrong. We're on the up. And
- 4:23actually, if you look at the raw data before
- 4:26applying any sort of regression, you'll see that
- 4:29the global average rate of veganism shot up from
- 4:33less than 1 % in 2015 to about 2 .5 % in 2025.
- 4:39So again, very cool. When we analyze the data
- 4:44region by region though, we see that this growth
- 4:47story is mainly a European one. Europe is the
- 4:51only region with a statistically significant
- 4:53upward trend. Other regions show non -significant
- 4:57change or can't be estimated at all because there's
- 5:00simply not enough data to work with. Vegetarianism
- 5:04was also flat, both globally and in each region
- 5:08for which we had enough data. Flexitarianism,
- 5:12similar story, globally a plateau between 2015
- 5:15and 2025. But Europe breaks that mold, actually,
- 5:20growing by an impressive 1 .2 percentage points
- 5:23per year. Now, don't get too excited yet about
- 5:26flexitarianism, though, because I'm going to
- 5:28circle back to it. I might cast some doubt. So
- 5:32yeah, stay tuned. Okay, so veganism. Growing
- 5:37slowly and maybe exclusively in Europe. Vegetarianism
- 5:42not growing, but something wacky happens when
- 5:46we put them together. There's actually a massive
- 5:50pool of data from Statista's Consumer Insights
- 5:53Survey, but the only data they share publicly
- 5:56and for free is aggregated, so vegans and vegetarians
- 6:01are smushed together. They have data on dozens
- 6:04of countries at dozens of time points. The only
- 6:08catch, again, is that they report vegetarians
- 6:10and vegans as a single aggregated group. When
- 6:14we combine vegetarians and vegans, of course,
- 6:18we lose a lot of nuance, right? But through this
- 6:21status to database, we're able to capture a lot
- 6:24more countries than before. So we thought it
- 6:27was worth it. And we ran a new analysis together.
- 6:32vegetarianism and veganism are rising 0 .4 percentage
- 6:38points per year. And not just Europe this time,
- 6:42we saw a significant rise in six out of seven
- 6:45regions. So listen, the movement isn't booming
- 6:50per se, but it's definitely not dying either.
- 6:55And don't let people tell you otherwise. Moving
- 6:58on to the second major finding. I have a hard
- 7:03truth to share, and it's what we all expected,
- 7:06I think. More people identify as vegan or vegetarian
- 7:11than actually eat like it. And the gap can be
- 7:14quite wide. So in Europe, 1 .6 % of people identify
- 7:20as vegan, while just over 1 % actually follow
- 7:24a plant -based diet. If I had to make a judgment
- 7:27call on it, I'd say that gap, you know, isn't
- 7:30horrendous. But it's not great, either, compared
- 7:34to vegetarianism in North America, where over
- 7:38four times as many people identify as vegetarian
- 7:42than actually consistently abstain from meat.
- 7:46So I think most people hearing these stats are
- 7:49thinking, that's bad, right? The data is essentially
- 7:54calling us out as hypocrites on a global scale.
- 7:58It's rough. Or if we take the findings a little
- 8:02less personally, the takeaway is that different
- 8:05measurement methods can and do dramatically change
- 8:09the results. Asking people about their dietary
- 8:12identity is not the same as asking people to
- 8:15fill out a food frequency questionnaire or a
- 8:1824 -hour food diary. And since most research
- 8:23records people's identity and not their actual
- 8:26eating behaviors, we are potentially over counting
- 8:30by a lot. But there's also an opportunity here
- 8:35that I don't want to get drowned out. The fact
- 8:38that people are over identifying as vegan or
- 8:41vegetarian might indicate something really positive.
- 8:46To think that people view veganism as something
- 8:48worth aspiring to, as something socially desirable,
- 8:53something they want to be known as. is really
- 8:57cool. The work now lies in simply helping those
- 9:01over -identifiers close the gap between their
- 9:04identity and their plate. My third finding is
- 9:10something I've already been alluding to. There's
- 9:14quite massive geographical bias in the data as
- 9:17it stands now. 87 % of the data I collected on
- 9:23vegan rates came from either Europe, or North
- 9:26America. And it was usually Europe. Europe and
- 9:30North America hold about 16 % of the world population.
- 9:35All being fair, they should make up about 16
- 9:39% of the data, right? Not 87%. Even if we thought
- 9:45every global region deserved equal data representation,
- 9:49we definitely still haven't achieved that. Meanwhile,
- 9:53we have little to no nationally representative
- 9:55data on veganism for Sub -Saharan Africa, South
- 9:59Asia, Latin America, or the Middle East and North
- 10:02Africa. Of course, there could be lots of data
- 10:05out there that I simply couldn't scrape. I collected
- 10:09data from a select group of international polling
- 10:12organizations, data compilers, and other movement
- 10:15leaders. Think YouGov, Our World in Data, Good
- 10:19Food Institute, that sort of thing. So hey, very
- 10:22possible that there's lots more data out there
- 10:24and I just didn't see it, especially because
- 10:27most of my searching turned up English language
- 10:29sources. So take from that what you will. I still
- 10:33think the results are alarming. Now finally,
- 10:38before I leave you with my recommendations, I've
- 10:41got one more finding to share, and that's the
- 10:44widespread of definitions that I encountered.
- 10:47Across our pool of data, we found dozens of distinct
- 10:52definitions for vegetarian, vegan, and especially
- 10:55for flexitarian. For vegan and vegetarian, most
- 10:59variation is essentially cosmetic, you know,
- 11:03different wordings of similar concepts. For flexitarianism,
- 11:07however, the variation was actually quite substantive.
- 11:11Some studies defined flexitarians vaguely and
- 11:14loosely, like having an awareness of how much
- 11:18meat is consumed and making choices to avoid
- 11:20it at times, while others define it as vegetarians
- 11:25who occasionally eat meat and fish, and others
- 11:28are more strict with it, such as consume meat
- 11:31no more than once a week. I'd argue that these
- 11:35definitions are not really describing the same
- 11:39people, and that complicates things. Like, how
- 11:43confident can we be that flexitarianism is rising
- 11:46or falling when every study is measuring a slightly
- 11:49different slice of the population? So that's
- 11:55what we found in a nutshell. Veganism is rising
- 11:59around the world with some caveats. There's a
- 12:02distinct difference between calling yourself
- 12:05a vegan and eating like one. The data is suspiciously
- 12:09European. and we haven't quite agreed on who
- 12:13it is we're even talking about when we measure
- 12:15dietary adherence. That's what we found. Now,
- 12:19I'll tell you what we should do about it. First
- 12:23off, if you're an advocate, treat self -identification
- 12:28prevalence statistics with caution. When citing
- 12:31vegan or vegetarian rates in campaigns or communications,
- 12:36be mindful that polls relying on self -identification,
- 12:39which is most polls, likely overestimate actual
- 12:44dietary adherence. This doesn't mean the numbers
- 12:46are useless. Just be aware of what you're citing.
- 12:50Number two, consider the aspirational upside
- 12:53of the identity behavior gap. More people claim
- 12:57a vegan or vegetarian identity than actually
- 13:00maintain a vegan or vegetarian diet. This gap
- 13:04may signal that these diets are increasingly
- 13:06seen as aspirational or socially desirable. Advocates
- 13:11can leverage this. People who over identify as
- 13:14vegan may be more receptive to messaging that
- 13:17helps them close the gap. And finally, don't
- 13:20assume European trends reflect the rest of the
- 13:23world. The growth story for veganism is, right
- 13:26now, a largely European story. Advocates operating
- 13:30in other regions should be cautious about assuming
- 13:32the same momentum applies locally, and should
- 13:35push for better regional data to inform their
- 13:37strategies. Now, if you're a researcher, first
- 13:42off, prioritize filling the global South data
- 13:45gap. Sub -Saharan Africa and South Asia together
- 13:48account for nearly 40 % of the world's population.
- 13:52Yet, nationally representative vegan and vegetarian
- 13:56data for these regions is effectively non -existent.
- 14:00Future research should actively pursue data collection
- 14:03in underrepresented regions. Local advocates
- 14:06should be directly involved in the translation
- 14:08of surveys into local languages as part of this
- 14:10research focus as well. This just ensures that
- 14:14the resulting data is not compromised by mistranslations
- 14:17or lost cultural context. Second, use dietary
- 14:22intake measures alongside self -identification
- 14:25wherever and whenever possible. Self -identification
- 14:29is a useful and practical tool, but our findings
- 14:33confirm it consistently overestimates adherence
- 14:36relative to dietary intake measures. So we recommend
- 14:40pairing self -identification items with a food
- 14:43frequency questionnaire or similar intake measure
- 14:45in future studies. This doesn't require abandoning
- 14:50self -identification, but rather treating it
- 14:52as one data point instead of the whole picture.
- 14:58And third, in lieu of standardized dietary definitions,
- 15:02just offer transparency. Our review surfaced
- 15:05dozens of distinct definitions for vegetarian,
- 15:09vegan, and flexitarian across studies, potentially
- 15:12making cross -study comparisons unreliable. This
- 15:16field would greatly benefit from a shared definitional
- 15:20framework, of course, as an established standard
- 15:23allows for meaningful comparison over time and
- 15:25across regions. But in practice, establishing
- 15:30and enforcing such definitions, especially worldwide,
- 15:34especially across languages, it's likely to be
- 15:36a losing battle. So where standardization can't
- 15:40be found, Researchers should clearly specify
- 15:43their definitions and acknowledge those definitions
- 15:46limitations. Okay, and that's where I leave you.
- 15:51Thank you so much for listening. If you made
- 15:53it all the way to the end, I really do appreciate
- 15:56you. And of course, feel free to reach out. You
- 15:59have my email. Okay, bye.