Latest / Family Twist: A Podcast Exploring DNA Surprises and Family Secrets / Unregulated Donation with Spermworld Documentary Director
Transcript
- 0:00Corey: How do I be professional in giving this person my sperm?
- 0:03Corey: Welcome back to Family Twist.
- 0:05Corey: I am one of your hosts, Corey Stoltz.
- 0:08Corey: And I expect this to be a very polarizing episode, so here we go.
- 0:12Corey: In it, I interviewed the director of a new documentary called Sperm World about men who meet prospective mothers on Facebook groups in order to donate, or in some cases, sell them their sperm.
- 0:23Corey: Family Twist has explored the topic of donor conception in several episodes, but this was a new and sometimes shocking avenue to go down.
- 0:31Corey: I interviewed director Lance Oppenheim the day after I watched the film, so my take on it was very fresh.
- 0:36Corey: I was honest in my reactions about the film to Lance, and he didn't push back even when I threw him some curveballs.
- 0:43Corey: There is a bit of an awkward exchange, and I left it in the edit, so let me know if you figure out which part of the episode I'm talking about.
- 0:50Corey: Sperm World is Lance's second feature flake documentary.
- 0:53Corey: This first is called Some Kind of Heasant about the Villages region of Florida, where coincidentally Family Twist has a big following.
- 1:00Corey: Alright, here's Lance.
- 1:04Corey: Well, Lance, welcome to Family Twist.
- 1:07Corey: Hey, thank you.
- 1:08Corey: Nice to be with you.
- 1:09Corey: So I I will let you know that I was just checking our analytics for the podcast last week, and we're very big in the villages.
- 1:16Corey: So hopefully that's a good sign for this episode.
- 1:20SPEAKER_02: Oh my god.
- 1:21SPEAKER_02: Wow, what a twist.
- 1:22SPEAKER_02: You put in the family twist in the name.
- 1:24Corey: That's uh I know.
- 1:26Corey: So congrats on the doc launching.
- 1:29Corey: I watched it and it's one of those um I love when a movie just like sticks with you.
- 1:34Corey: You know what I'm saying?
- 1:36Corey: You think about it day after day, and then that's definitely what what this doc is doing for me.
- 1:41Corey: But when people ask you, like, hey, what are you working on?
- 1:44Corey: What's your what's your new project?
- 1:45Corey: Like, what's your elevator pitch?
- 1:46Corey: Like, how do you describe sperm world?
- 1:48SPEAKER_02: I've been trying to hone it in for years, so I'll give you what I've been working with now.
- 1:53SPEAKER_02: I mean, but you know, the it it explores the world of unregulated uh sperm donation on Facebook groups.
- 2:00SPEAKER_02: So, you know, you're seeing people that have basically been by you know, life and luck and chance and socio economic economic forces have led people to trying to have children outside of the sperm banks and outside of relationships.
- 2:18SPEAKER_02: And so the movie drops you into a few different people's lives who are trying to have children with complete strangers, and in some cases with the men, they're trying to find meaning in their lives, and they think they've found or come close to it through the act of reproducing and giving their sperm to you know other people.
- 2:43Corey: Right.
- 2:44Corey: Right.
- 2:44SPEAKER_02: How is that?
- 2:45SPEAKER_02: Is that a good elevator pitch?
- 2:48SPEAKER_02: Would you give me$10 million,$10 billion?
- 2:51SPEAKER_02: I can make 10 sequels of this movie.
- 2:54Corey: Uh well, I'm sure you probably could, because I can only imagine how many subjects there are out there that you know you you you weren't able to focus on because you gotta had to hone in on just a few, you know, for a 90-minute talk.
- 3:05Corey: But I am curious like how the how Nellie's uh New York Times article went from that to becoming this documentary.
- 3:14SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's you know, I mean look, Nellie is an incredible uh journalist, and the article she wrote, I was fortunate enough, Nellie early on came to me and said, Hey, you know, I love your past movie.
- 3:27SPEAKER_02: What do you think of this?
- 3:28SPEAKER_02: I'm working on a story, you know, about unregulated sperm donation people meeting each other on Facebook.
- 3:34SPEAKER_02: What do you think?
- 3:35SPEAKER_02: And I started poking around.
- 3:37SPEAKER_02: I joined the groups, I saw the types of interactions that were going on there that were very poignant and then very kind of sometimes absurd, just the response that a man would have to a very emotional, poignant piece of writing about someone, you know, recipient's life, what led them, what circumstances of life brought them to the groups, and the guy would say, Nice, smiley face, I'm available.
- 4:02SPEAKER_02: There was something tonally that was interesting there, and Nellie kind of invited me into her process.
- 4:07SPEAKER_02: She said, While I'm writing this, why don't we kind of tag team different people you could talk to and I'll talk to and we'll trade notes.
- 4:15SPEAKER_02: What I love about what Nellie does is she turned what could be sort of this like investigative reporting piece into something very novelistic and very personal to her.
- 4:25SPEAKER_02: I feel like I've tried to do the same with the film.
- 4:27SPEAKER_02: You know, I don't consider the movie to be an adaptation of the article.
- 4:30SPEAKER_02: I feel like it's more inspired by, I think, some of the things that we both observed together while we were writing, but also Nellie has moved on and has written many more things, and I've sort of stayed in this universe for a little longer.
- 4:44SPEAKER_02: I'd say it was a starting off point, the article, and then you know, we went, took some wrong turns and right turns, and we kind of found ourselves with the movie after almost three years of making it.
- 4:57Corey: Well, I do love that both the article and uh the documentary both end with some unanswered questions.
- 5:04Corey: Not everything's cut and dry.
- 5:06SPEAKER_02: Yeah, no, certainly not.
- 5:08Corey: Now, I purposely did not watch the trailer.
- 5:10Corey: I just wanted to go in and and watch the dock as it premiered.
- 5:14Corey: I love the fact that it's not a talking heads doc.
- 5:17Corey: It is like a voyeuristic, like we're looking in on people's lives, we're flies on the wall watching what's happening here.
- 5:24Corey: And it's it I mean, it really set me through a lot of emotions as I'm watching it.
- 5:31Corey: It was it was heavy and it definitely sticks with you, so we're not gonna spoil everything, you know, in this interview.
- 5:36Corey: But couldn't you just sort of introduce us to the subjects of the doc a little bit?
- 5:42SPEAKER_02: The the film follows a few different stories.
- 5:45SPEAKER_02: We have of of donors and recipients that are trying to have children in this uh unregulated way.
- 5:50SPEAKER_02: One of them is the story of a man, Ari Nagel, who has a hundred, when we meet him in the film, 136 children, and we meet him as he declares that he wants to retire and he he no longer wants to be doing what he's doing, and he's tired and he's he's looking for an out to that lifestyle.
- 6:11SPEAKER_02: Uh, and we see that question, that desire get more complicated over the course of the film through his relationships with different women.
- 6:20SPEAKER_02: You learn you know later in the movie that he he doesn't actually have a physical one address.
- 6:26SPEAKER_02: He has been sued so many times for child support that he no longer can afford to have a house and he lives with each of his children, so every day he goes to a new home.
- 6:36SPEAKER_02: And his desire to stop donating is because he has a desire to become a father, to be a real parent.
- 6:43SPEAKER_02: And so you're watching this sort of Sisyphian task of trying, how do you be how are you a parent?
- 6:49SPEAKER_02: How are you how do you father a hundred and then the number keeps ticking throughout the movie ends up in 170 children?
- 6:55SPEAKER_02: And that's sort of the um the kind of screwball comedy that he sees his life to be.
- 7:00SPEAKER_02: That's what we try to inhabit in the film.
- 7:02SPEAKER_02: So you have Ari on the opposite side of the spectrum, you have a man named Steve who is by contrast to Ari, he's starting his donating career, he's just beginning, and he is a 65-year-old man, a divorcee, and he's sort of we meet him at a crossroads.
- 7:20SPEAKER_02: He doesn't know where his life is going.
- 7:22SPEAKER_02: He feels completely unmoored by everything in his life.
- 7:27SPEAKER_02: And the movie finds him as he meets a recipient named Rachel who has cystic fibrosis, and her biggest dream in life is to have a child, which is you know complicated, and the film gets into that.
- 7:40SPEAKER_02: But it ends up becoming really about these two people.
- 7:42SPEAKER_02: How do you navigate this very unstructured way of giving a complete stranger your sperm?
- 7:49SPEAKER_02: It's something that by default, maybe as humans, the way sperm emits uh sexual things need to happen.
- 7:57SPEAKER_02: And so it's this confusing thing for Steve, who doesn't really know how do I divorce the romantic parts of this?
- 8:04SPEAKER_02: How do I be professional in giving this person my sperm?
- 8:07SPEAKER_02: And of course, the relationship gets a lot messier and deeper and really in a weird kind of tragic way, really, you know, really beautiful.
- 8:15SPEAKER_02: Um, and then the last person you have is Tyree, who's his story I would say is more focused on his fiance, but this is a couple, Tyree and Atasha, who are um trying to conceive on their own, they're engaged.
- 8:28SPEAKER_02: Tyree's main preoccupation outside of being a good fiance to Atasha is uh is to donate his sperm to many other women who are reaching out to him.
- 8:37SPEAKER_02: And so their story ends up becoming a lot of a lot of things, and it goes to some unexpected places, but how do you manage to keep your relationship intact while you give yourself away to so many other people?
- 8:51SPEAKER_02: And so anyway, you know, it's kind of a melange of things, and you know, I'd say the movie ultimately is if it's about anything, it's really about people trying to be bigger than themselves to eke out some sort of purpose, legacy in their life, justify that they matter, and that their lives that maybe are more mundane, you know, that they feel that are mundane, and that they that they could be good at something, that they could do something for themselves.
- 9:17Corey: Yeah.
- 9:17SPEAKER_02: Um, so yeah.
- 9:18Corey: Absolutely.
- 9:19Corey: And and I appreciate your approach of you know, a non-judgmental look.
- 9:24Corey: This is again like fly on the wall, like we're just experiencing this, what's happening with these people in their lives.
- 9:30Corey: And I guess the challenge for somebody like me and and for Kendall and and for others who are getting educated about the whole fertility industry and like how the quote unquote legitimate f fertility industry doesn't have a lot of regulations, like we've already have our our strong opinions, like we've become allies for those um donor-conceive people who you know need to have a bigger voice, we feel, and then the need for more legislation.
- 9:58Corey: So like I was already going into this with like a an opinion, you know.
- 10:02Corey: So I do appreciate the fact that you, you know, you approach this with like not judgmental, and I I was really trying to watch this and and understand, and so I could definitely see all the different sides of the humanity, you know, on display here.
- 10:14Corey: But I mean there there are certainly elements of of this movie that are just heartbreaking, you know.
- 10:20Corey: Yeah, yeah.
- 10:21Corey: You know, I mean it's it's certainly um like I'm just like I I'm just you know, I'm like tears are streaming on my face, you know, watching her segments as like she, you know, she's she she's helping her partner along this experience of helping other women have children and she's struggling.
- 10:38Corey: One tiny little spoiler alert, but then all of a sudden a child ends up in their laps.
- 10:42Corey: Those segments are just like wow.
- 10:44SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 10:45SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 10:46SPEAKER_02: They are.
- 10:46SPEAKER_02: I mean, it when it was like that film filming, filming all of that, you know, and I I mean I think look, you know, I think the job of at least the filmmaker that I'd like to think I am is is I don't like when films are telling me how to feel about someone or something.
- 11:01SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 11:02SPEAKER_02: I love watching a movie, whether it be a documentary or a fiction film, and I'm seeing types of behavior that um initially may seem completely foreign to me.
- 11:11SPEAKER_02: Why would someone do that?
- 11:12SPEAKER_02: Why is that person acting the way they are?
- 11:15SPEAKER_02: And my the hope is is that you those questions are so absorbing that you completely forget about yourself and you're so engaged, and ultimately if the movie is done right, then you start to feel things and you feel for the people and someone that you maybe wouldn't be relating to at first, you can't help but relate to them by the end.
- 11:35SPEAKER_02: And so I think that you know, look, it's it's I think it's a tough movie in some ways because what you're seeing is is um it's controversial.
- 11:42SPEAKER_02: There's you could see, you know, Ari, he's selfish, you could see him as altruistic, you could see him as narcissistic.
- 11:49SPEAKER_02: It's all these things that sort of cancel themselves out.
- 11:52SPEAKER_02: The thing to me that I'm really like my North Star when I'm making this kind of thing and I'm following people who have trusted me to with their most vulnerable, you know, um, just at their most vulnerable, is emotions and and um expressions of that, you know, the feeling of longing for something.
- 12:08SPEAKER_02: You know, the women in the film are so just absorbed with this idea of chasing the dream of having a family.
- 12:16SPEAKER_02: And I think that's also one of the themes that just run through it.
- 12:20SPEAKER_02: I I don't have any children myself, so I can't I can't speak to this, but having observed and inhabited that sort of longing and that fantasy for the last like three years, I feel like there's something that's what the movie really is.
- 12:32SPEAKER_02: It's it's it's kind of this quicksiotic dream that people will spend most of their lives and put themselves in very at times compromising places to achieve.
- 12:43SPEAKER_02: I think the very fact that this exists and is happening, right?
- 12:46SPEAKER_02: And the system, which I think in a lot of ways is really fractured, you know, the ways in which people can have children are is it's very expensive at Sperm Banks.
- 12:56SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 12:56SPEAKER_02: And I think it says a lot about ourselves.
- 12:58SPEAKER_02: It says a lot about ourselves as a society, and it says a lot about ourselves as creatures on this planet that are desperate to find community and reproduce.
- 13:07SPEAKER_02: It makes me emotional too.
- 13:09SPEAKER_02: I think it's it's it it's you know the most existential, I feel like, uh, questions and topics you you can really ask for in a movie.
- 13:18SPEAKER_02: It's literally about existence and the desire to keep existing.
- 13:22Corey: Because I think that you know, people that are watching the film that don't know really anything about the fertility industry, like they're gonna see you know this the Sperm Kings universe is like the Wild Wild West.
- 13:34Corey: But the quote unquote legitimate fertility industry is also like the Wild Wild West.
- 13:38Corey: There's no real regulation there.
- 13:41Corey: I mean, the horror stories that we've been told are just unbelievable.
- 13:45Corey: So, like I and I absolutely empathize with you know anybody who's trying to like have that dream, have a child, you know, and they're and they're doing whatever they have to do to make it happen.
- 13:56Corey: Uh, how much did you know about the fertility industry and and like legitimate sperm banks before you got into this?
- 14:03SPEAKER_02: I knew practically nothing, really.
- 14:05SPEAKER_02: You know, I I knew from researching it the article and talking with people when I was with you know Nellie before we started shooting, that was very eye-opening to me.
- 14:15SPEAKER_02: I you know, I I had been interested in Sperm banks earlier in my life, just as a kind of setting for a story, just the fact that something so um, in some cases profane, you know, pornography and the magazines could be presented in such a um antiseptic way, you know, and and and um there was something interesting to me about that feeling.
- 14:36SPEAKER_02: But I had knew nothing really about the the financial constructs or even the way sperm is split into different vials and the price of you know insemination, the price of IVF, of IUI, I mean, all of those things, it counts and it it adds up.
- 14:51SPEAKER_02: It's amazing.
- 14:52SPEAKER_02: This is a way people are just taking the process back into their own hands, and I think that's one of the things that I thought would make for a compelling movie is each person has a very different way of enacting control or rules or structure over this sort of undefined arrangement.
- 15:12SPEAKER_02: Some people, like you see in the film, it's a parking lot handoff, and there's very few words exchanged, it's extremely transactional.
- 15:19SPEAKER_02: Other people in the film end up becoming the closest of friends to one another, and at times, you know, tinged with this kind of romantic uh feeling that maybe is unrequited or maybe it's shared, it's unclear.
- 15:32SPEAKER_02: You know, and and then one, you know, for Ari, it's this you you know, you can have a bunch of opinions about him, but the way he feels about his children you can't take away from him.
- 15:41SPEAKER_02: He loves them, and he's so compelled by this larger feeling that it takes him everywhere around the world in some cases to feel it.
- 15:51SPEAKER_02: And so that's that you know, I think um that's the thing that I'm always interested in is taking ideas of, you know, this is a societal issue, I think.
- 16:01SPEAKER_02: I think loneliness is a societal issue, but I think really the way in which people who are trying to get pregnant and come from a different socioeconomic background, they're not offered a lot of options.
- 16:11SPEAKER_02: And so I wanted to explore that without having to over-inform the audience or try and sell them of a point.
- 16:19SPEAKER_02: I wanted to just present the reality of what's happening and let everyone sort of sit in it and experience it and feel for the people in it and and love them or hate them or whatever, you know, take away their own uh feelings and project things onto the screen.
- 16:34Corey: Yeah.
- 16:36Corey: Yeah, uh, because I'm definitely torn with with all three guys, you know.
- 16:39Corey: As you said, I mean, you watch Ari interact with his children, it's just like it's it's beautiful.
- 16:45Corey: And then juxtaposed that with his ill mother, this might be her last Passover, and the decision he makes, I'm just like, oh, Ari.
- 16:56Corey: Yeah.
- 16:57Corey: You know?
- 16:58Corey: Um Yeah.
- 17:00Corey: And and something I I've got to share with you just because I'm a huge film fan, and um Kendall and I are both horror movie fans.
- 17:07Corey: So I and I I know this probably wasn't on purpose, but there's a scene in the dock where all right, so st Stefan um is clearly going through some very difficult emotions with this relationship with the potential uh, you know, person who's going to accept his sperm.
- 17:25Corey: You you do really feel like he, you know, the the feelings that he's having for this person are real, and then it's the next scene cuts away and it's him meeting a new potential, you know, person, and he's got this hat on that he's you know talking about.
- 17:42Corey: And I mean, I immediately went to the very last moment of Silence of the Lambs when Hannibal Lecter is about to stalk his prey, Dr.
- 17:52Corey: Chilton, uh, you know, after he escapes and everything.
- 17:56Corey: And I mean, that's just like a I just that that's where I went.
- 17:59Corey: And uh as I said, I'm sure it wasn't on purpose, but like that's where my mind went.
- 19:05SPEAKER_02: Interesting.
- 19:06SPEAKER_02: Well, you know, I mean, look, I think it's um yeah, I don't know, I don't know what to say.
- 19:10SPEAKER_02: I mean I think I think uh I think I think you know Steve is not uh you know a horror movie character in any by any means.
- 19:18SPEAKER_02: You know, he's he's a he's um I think he's a really sensitive and really sweet, sweet guy.
- 19:24SPEAKER_02: But I could see the maybe you're you're referring to the costuming, the choice of uh the hat and everyone.
- 19:29Corey: I don't know if you remember them, you know, the that moment in Silence of the Lambs, but Hannibal Lecter's disguise, he's got a wig on, uh he's got like a you know, he's got that similar kind of hat and sunglasses, like he's disguised himself because he's about to chase down his captor.
- 19:42Corey: And for whatever reason, like when you cut away from him with Rachel and then to meeting somebody else, and it's just it just kind of felt like, oh, here is somebody eyeing up their prey.
- 19:54Corey: Uh and that's just where my mind went.
- 19:55SPEAKER_02: Oh, well, yeah, that definitely wasn't uh intentional.
- 19:58SPEAKER_02: I mean, to me, it's you know, this is he he's talking about in the previous scene, you know, um, yeah, wanting to find that the relationship with Rachel is is a fantasy, it won't work, and so he's gonna he'll he'll find someone to spend time with on hinge, and so then it cuts to uh a new recipient, right, that he's donating to.
- 20:17SPEAKER_02: And um the idea that with the the associative edit there is is not um yeah, I mean it's not to imply that he's gonna he's sizing someone up to uh take them home or something, it's more just um it's more about him, it's another kind of moment of of an attempted sort of deeper attempt at a deeper connection and wanting to know someone, but ultimately after exchanging you know fluids, uh he gives her his sperm, not not sexually, just you know, he masturbates and gives it to her artificially, he's left alone again.
- 20:51SPEAKER_02: And it's this um it's this kind of just I think the the the cycle that ends up happening to a lot of the men.
- 20:58SPEAKER_02: And in some ways, it's kind of the reason I wanted to make the film in the first place, which is like you see, you know, women join the groups, they either stay to you know to find someone, eventually they either get pregnant or they don't and they leave.
- 21:12SPEAKER_02: And then you you're with these men who stay for long periods of time.
- 21:17SPEAKER_02: It's it's in this sort of liminal kind of purgatory place, and they achieve these great things for other people, and then they return back to their lives where they feel the same maybe feelings of loneliness or or um emptiness.
- 21:32SPEAKER_02: And so I wanted to sort of capture that in like a one one sort of fall false swoop where you where you see him sort of on the rebound, if you will.
- 21:42SPEAKER_02: You know, he's okay, that's not gonna, she's not interested in a romantic relationship, fine, I'll go to see someone else.
- 21:47SPEAKER_02: You think he's with a new romantic partner, but yet again, it's not.
- 21:51SPEAKER_02: He's he's he's sort of tying these two, this firm donation and right the hopes of maybe romance together, which leads to this lethal combination of nothingness, I think, at the end of the day when he's alone.
- 22:05Corey: Absolutely, yeah.
- 22:05Corey: No, and and I I just wanted to share that with you because that was what immediately came into my mind at that particular scene.
- 22:11Corey: But I think you know, your power as a filmmaker is showing multiple sides of people.
- 22:18Corey: And I mean, by by the end of the film, I have empathy for everybody, every character, every subject in there.
- 22:24Corey: I call them characters just because it almost it feels like you know a drama.
- 22:27Corey: It doesn't feel like a documentary because it's it's just you know, you're not narrating, we're watching drama unfold.
- 22:33Corey: Yeah, but yeah, I just wanted to share that because as a horror fan, it that just like immediately jumped into my mind.
- 22:41Corey: I I love when films challenge us, that we just don't walk away and be like, okay, I like I I love to watch a movie and go and sit down with somebody and have coffee and like, what do we just watch?
- 22:52Corey: And we need to unpack this.
- 22:54SPEAKER_02: And that this is definitely one of those movies.
- 22:57SPEAKER_02: Well, yeah, definitely thank you for saying that.
- 22:59SPEAKER_02: Yeah, no, I think that it's there's a lot there's a lot to unpack in it, you know, and and um not just of the reality that's being shown but then the formal dimensions to it and you know the ending of the film has has sort of uh you know an image in it that that I think you know if when you hopefully if it if if it sticks with you and you think deeper about it this idea of of a bird you know that's um delivering children stork that's sort of a childhood fascination uh where stories we tell children about where children come from there's this element to it too where you're seeing people try and situate themselves they're in this very unconventional way trying to place trying to have children and yet they're still sort of yeah they're they're sizing themselves up against the stories that we told ourselves when we were younger and maybe in some cases the men are probably the modern equivalent of the stork they they drop off the goods for people to get pregnant and they leave again and so there's this there's this feeling that image kind of wanted to you know I wanted this that that to stick with me yeah but yeah man there's a lot there's a lot in there yeah I mean it's a dense movie yes I mean as you mentioned that the that last those last moments and watching that through Rachel's eyes like I I got chills just like oh oh my goodness yeah it's yeah so have you heard from the subjects who who have watched the film oh yeah yeah I'm I'm in a group chat with Rachel and Steve and Lauren our producer it's very active we're talking like several times a day and Tyree Natasha same thing and Ari the same thing.
- 24:40SPEAKER_02: I had the opportunity to see the movie before it premiered and you know over the course of making the film over the last few years you know when we would go and shoot something and we'd return after being gone for a few weeks I would come with little clips of things we were editing.
- 24:56SPEAKER_02: And so you know the the whole process is it's it's almost like um it's hard to if describe easily but it's you know the same degree of trust and vulnerability that they're affording me as a filmmaker I feel like you know I think because we're making the film in this extremely collaborative way it allows for that trust and vulnerability to to just expand because in most cases throughout the movie you know there's not one image in it that the people involved in it aren't aware that is being captured right it's like every single moment there's a conversation that is that we ha I have with folks that lead to that moment um to us capturing it.
- 25:38SPEAKER_02: So you know in in that way I feel like um you know I've had experiences in the past where I've made movies that are just you know like uh completely fly on the wall completely observational and in the story is really discovered in the edit the people in the film never you know they they they they didn't really like it because they were like wait I I didn't know you caught that how you know and you're using that in this way and how right you know so most of the things I'm trying to do I've I've like I've recognized the limits of what you can accomplish just through observational fly on the wall filmmaking.
- 26:07SPEAKER_02: What I'm trying to do is something different I'm it's it's more of like the spirit of making a movie together with a small crew and inviting people into that and into the magic of it into the magic of trying to almost you know contribute artistically to something.
- 26:24SPEAKER_02: And so at all times you know it's like with Steve I bought him the Paul Schrader's Transcendental Cinema book right and we had sort of a watch along where I would watch a movie for inspiration he would watch it and I'd come to him I'd say let's go you know you're waiting outside someone's door and he knocked on someone's door and I said maybe we as we're waiting for her to answer can you can you send her a text just to maybe we'll have something to shoot with that and he'll say you know well I usually don't text and I'll say okay well then what do you do instead of texting he said well you should do voice to text and so they're then kind of like birthed the motif of even that in the movie right yeah so every moment every single thing that you're seeing everyone is aware of the camera's presence and I think because of that what I'm trying to do is not make you feel their awareness of the camera I'm trying to kind of bring you into their subjectivity into the trust that we fostered into that vulnerability into that you know rawness and and let this whole experience wash over you because it's it's coming not just from me and my crew it's coming from the people in the movie.
- 27:27SPEAKER_02: These are like the images these are the things that we all wanted you to see uh over the past few years that we were able to witness together.
- 27:36Corey: Right.
- 27:37Corey: So before I forget I want to ask us first and then I'm gonna jump into something else but um did you introduce him to David Lynch and Maholland Drive?
- 27:43SPEAKER_02: No that was another um that was a Steve uh Steve recommendation yeah he he messaged you know we the most of those messages were were um were captured like uh you know months after he sent them um but he he sent he messaged Rachel about Maholland drive there were a few other ones Cuckoo's nest um there was a a chef themed inspiration list there was uh jewels and gym there was uh the movie burnt um that they watched you know a lot of the movies they would watch together Rachel has told me too when we weren't present there was always like at least one steamy like sort of erotic moment uh in the movie and so I wanted to capture something was that one that was licensable but two um you know um yeah spoke to that it spoke to the desire that he has he's kind of using the opportunity to watch a movie together you know it's nice that they're doing it it's also him trying to figure out and test the boundaries like is she interested in me is she interested in this I don't know you know yeah yeah that's the that's why I feel like the scene uh for us was important to to to put in.
- 28:55Corey: Were there subjects that you approached that you would have loved to have but they just said no absolutely not I'm not gonna be filmed.
- 29:02SPEAKER_02: Yeah yeah of course but you know I think that in a way it it's sort of like that's the first conversation right in in in terms of casting and everything else it's like it and it's an invitation like this is what the process is like it's very involved it takes years in most cases it's invasive I'm going to be up in your grill all the time you know I'm gonna be with you I'm gonna be asking you uncomfortable questions but it's also going to be magical and there will be parts of this that you'll never forget and if we can do it the right way and we make this movie all together then it will feel like you're not just being observed but you'll feel like you're part of something and are you interested and if people say no then great you know that's that's less time for me to figure that out when we're you know spending money you know to on our shoot days then the next question's just like the sperm donations we're filming how are we sort of setting boundaries with each other what's and usually for me there's nothing off limits.
- 30:37SPEAKER_02: If someone asks me a question about myself or what I'm going through I they're you know it's very porous.
- 30:42SPEAKER_02: And so then we sort of figure out from there, okay, well, you know, I'm interested in something that you may not be interested in talking about.
- 30:50SPEAKER_02: Are you still interested in being a part of this film?
- 30:52SPEAKER_02: If they say yes we keep going and we keep pushing and that's that's really what you see you know with the people in the movie.
- 30:58SPEAKER_02: They all were willing to to to go down on that ride, that voyage you know with us and take us along for it.
- 31:04Corey: Now I read an article where you mentioned that there were some times when things got too sensitive and you cut the cameras and and stopped filming.
- 31:12SPEAKER_02: I mean without giving too much away or without exposing anybody is there a a a particular moment you can share that was like okay we gotta stop right now yeah I mean that you know there there was um I would say with with Atasha you know talking about her her miscarriage that was a really sensitive and extremely difficult thing for her to do and very brave of her to do in front of a lot of people because it's not a topic that she likes to talk about naturally and it's not a it's it's something that she feels a lot of guilt over.
- 31:44SPEAKER_02: There was a moment yeah while we were filming that where she's talking to her mom on the phone where we put the camera aside for a second and you know and there's a lot of things we did capture while she's having that conversation that aren't in the film too because it felt to me like um I don't know there's a certain degree at some point where it starts feeling you know I'm never I don't want what I'm doing to feel voyeuristic.
- 32:08SPEAKER_02: I want it to feel like reflective of the minds and the spirits and the fantasies in the head spaces of the people in the movie.
- 32:18SPEAKER_02: And so you know if at times you're seeing something that feels it pushes that you're like it crosses the line or it goes to a place that feels um just something like you really shouldn't be seeing at all then it shouldn't be in the movie and that's that's an instance of that.
- 32:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 32:33SPEAKER_02: You know and I think there were moments too with Steve and Rachel where there were moments where their conversations things were revealed to one another that we were present for you know about their sexual experiences in the past or just about um you know different things that they both would would um would say in confidence to us knowing that we were filming and then we would see them again together and you know they both knew they would say stuff to us but they weren't sure what you know that then that's another part of it like well how much then is really necessary to see that because ultimately it's it's um it's their relationship it's not ours to really get involved in it's it's ours to sort of be there and offer our thoughts and you know observe the relationship and and but it's not ours to to dictate or or kind of um offer explicit judgment about I really appreciate that because uh you know one thing that we do with guests on this podcast you know when people are telling their stories is like hey this isn't live you know we edit this if there's anything that's said either during this interview or after we hang up that you're not comfortable with we're not going to include because this is not expose this is not TMZ this is like you're you're you're bearing your soul and you're being very courageous about telling your story so we don't want to put something out there that you're not comfortable with.
- 33:53Corey: And I I think that's kind of a rare thing with journalists these days and I would consider you know you as a documentarian as a journalist it's like you know we're we're so you know put upon to like get everything out there that kudos to you for being willing to do that.
- 34:07SPEAKER_02: Well hey well you you too I mean I I think it's just sort of it's like look I'm not making a um I'm not an investigative reporter I'm not making a a documentary exposing a powerful person doing something unscrupulous.
- 34:22SPEAKER_02: These are average they're ordinary people and I feel like there's certain just lenses that I'm I'm you there's certain humanity that that everyone should be afforded and that's why I'm probably not the right person to make the you know hit piece or an expose I just don't believe in binaries if someone is good or evil.
- 34:41SPEAKER_02: I just think it's a it's a continuum right yeah and if you're if someone is being honest with you and trusting you you have to fall in love with them I think in order to tell a good story and you have to tell the story together.
- 34:55SPEAKER_02: So that's why even just you know it's like I feel very sensitive when you know and it's interesting to see how people react to things and I like that the movie ultimately is designed for people to have that kind of they'll have their own opinions and they'll bring and make associations and connections to it that that you know that we none of us really thought of we're all going about this very earnestly I think and so that's that's why it's always like I love the people in it so much and anytime I read or hear something that's that's um you know extremely judgmental of of Ari or whoever it's more it it's it's it's um I'm usually like okay well I understand that but that's and that's interesting uh but that's not necessarily the uh that wasn't the intention you know right right yeah you know when I first read about this doc I reached out to one of our former guests who who's definitely one of the people who's out there trying to you know fight the fight for exposing the fertility industry and and getting the truth out there and they came back and said well you know I have I I've read about it too I haven't seen it yet so let's just watch it and and and see what happens and you know make our own decisions but have you heard from folks who are like out there fighting that fight against the uh fertility industry I haven't really yet I mean the movie you know it's it it just came out so I I'd be very hopeful to you know I'm hopeful to hear from people what they thought that are of the the world in space you know I think that's that the thing that's interesting about the movie too is it's ultimately like uh you know it's it's a lot of the context you know you you get a little bit of it through the screen life posts you know the Facebook posts people what they're what they're talking about and you get a lot of the the bigger world the the what led you here sperm banks are really expensive how do you do this what are the you know uh what are the sort of the normal quote unquote ways that people go about this sort of thing you get it from those those posts but for the most part I just thought as a viewer you know it would be much more engaging to just drop people into these interactions knowing that they were brought here and letting the audience sort of associate and assume and glean information from each scene and each screen life sequence that that everyone is here for a reason.
- 37:05SPEAKER_02: And for some people it's by choice like Anika the first recipient in the film she's someone who sought this out she didn't want to go to a sperm bank and for others it's not really by choice it's by the circumstances they were dealt and so I think my hope is when someone sees it if someone's fighting it I uh fighting against the fertility industry and all the hedge funds that own all these sperm banks and stuff I think um I'd be curious to hear what their takeaway is I could see them think that this is a very sad film or a poignant film.
- 37:34SPEAKER_02: I could see other people saying it's a very hopeful film and that's kind of the thing that's been interesting.
- 37:39SPEAKER_02: I hear it from and seeing the movie out now and it's in the world it's it's um it's garnered a lot of different uh reactions which which is all very um yeah it's in it's it's encouraging to me that we made something that's hopefully will stick around for a while and uh stick with people.
- 37:58Corey: Yeah for sure well I'm I'm encouraging anybody who's listening right now to to watch it but without giving too much away can you share um where the subjects are today like what what what has happened in the meantime?
- 38:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah I mean you know everyone's everyone's uh more or less kind of where where we left them I mean Rachel's doing much better uh her health is has improved uh which is great and she's she's still looking for you know a lung transplant and she's had one previously and that's difficult and she's navigating a a different sort of very bureaucratic process there but she's doing better and Steve is good and you know Ari is still up to his old tricks.
- 38:36SPEAKER_02: So he's not retired did just pass away about two weeks ago okay and so that was I think um he's seen the movie a few times now and he brought his dad to watch it on the big screen on one of the screenings we did and I think he had a different reaction to it the second time around knowing that his mom was was gone.
- 38:54SPEAKER_02: Seeing her her preserved on screen I think was was a nice thing for him.
- 38:59SPEAKER_02: And Tyree and Tasha are doing great too and they're still in the process of of um of adopting Italy but it's it's uh from what I heard from them last yesterday it seems like it's only a matter of of uh a few weeks now when they can bring her home.
- 39:14Corey: That's awesome.
- 39:15Corey: That's great.
- 39:17Corey: Wow what has this whole process made you think about becoming a father?
- 39:23SPEAKER_02: I mean I'm excited for it honestly I think it's been interesting.
- 39:26SPEAKER_02: I think most of the people involved in the film have had the opposite reaction that it it's uh made them not want to have children I think uh just seeing the um I think seeing Ari you know go through his his life is just so stressful that I think it's um for most of my friends who you know have worked on the movie it's we're all so obsessed with work it's hard to imagine to have that kind of responsibility.
- 39:50SPEAKER_02: I derive so much self-worth and and uh purpose from from making these movies and these relationships I form with the people in them it can be unhealthy I think at times to just only have one way of self-definition.
- 40:04SPEAKER_02: And so not I guess I'm not interested in having a child just to justify myself worth I guess but I could see that um it would at least let me care about something that is bigger than myself and bigger than a film and not you know defined by what other people think of it.
- 40:20SPEAKER_02: And you know so that in that sense I I I really look forward to it.
- 40:24SPEAKER_02: I'm hoping to wait a few years before I do it.
- 40:28Corey: Well no I you know just watching the doc you know sort of got me thinking again like you know Kendall and I have been together for 19 years.
- 40:36Corey: We're not we're not young men by any means.
- 40:38Corey: We you know we've talked about it over the years and we've gone back we we have way too many animals let's let me put it that way but you know we've talked about you know fostering and you know Kendall is a is adopted so we've talked about that and you know Kendall's been told he has good swimmers.
- 40:52Corey: I you know I don't know it's it's got me sort of thinking about like oh well I'm the same age as Ari.
- 40:56Corey: We're much younger than Steve.
- 40:58Corey: Yeah you know who knows?
- 41:00SPEAKER_02: I mean you got hey you know this is what Steve says is look at all the older older fathers you know people are having kids up until Al Pacino into their 80s now.
- 41:09Corey: I know I was just joking with somebody about Tony Randall you know uh the when when I heard about this doc.
- 41:13Corey: Oh my God.
- 41:16SPEAKER_02: Wow yeah yeah yeah I mean it's fascinating it really is yeah yeah well you should do it you should do it if you guys are in love and you feel like uh you know I just yeah I mean we I we go back and forth you know all the time and we certainly have the love to give.
- 41:31SPEAKER_02: I think it's an interesting thing.
- 41:32SPEAKER_02: It's like what what else are we here for if it's not for that I mean I'm sure many people can find different answers to that question but I think the more personally the more I go through life I I um you know I've seen my parents were were amazing to my sisters and I and I want to take what they gave me and and if I can if I can live up to that uh then why not you know why not try?
- 41:58SPEAKER_02: You got plenty of time we'll see.
- 42:05Corey: Awesome Okay that's a wrap on Lance I've already reached out to some of our former guests from donor conception themed episodes to see what they think about Sperm World and I bet they're gonna have a lot to say.
- 42:18Corey: So we're open to following up this episode with another episode about their takeaways from Sperm World.
- 42:23Corey: In the meantime we want to hear what you think not just about Sperm World but about Family Twist in general.
- 42:29Corey: You might be a great guest or know someone who would be Kendall and I are so passionate about sharing your courageous stories relating to being an adoptee, an NPE, aka not parent expected or donor conceived person.
- 42:44Corey: Reach out to us today at FamilyTwistPodcast at gmail.com.
- 42:49Corey: We read every email.
- 42:51SPEAKER_00: Alright until next week remember family secrets are the ultimate plot twist the Family Twist podcast features original music by Cosmic Afterthoughts is presented by Savoir Fair Marketing Communications and is produced by How the Cow Ate the Cabbage LLC