Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 60: A discussion about The New Parisienne
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening. To the new Paris It's been quite
- 0:11a few weeks over here. On July 7th, my second book, The
- 0:15New Parisian, was finally released into the world.
- 0:18I've been spending a lot of time discussing it with journalists
- 0:21who, like me, couldn't believe how timely it was.
- 0:25Not because I hadn't intended it to be topical, of course.
- 0:28Women's lives, rights and issues will continue to be important,
- 0:32just as they were before, but because it is entering a context
- 0:35in which there is a global conversation around many of the
- 0:38issues. Raised in the book around the
- 0:40themes of representation, discrimination, adversity and
- 0:43national identity, the parallels between important and fraught
- 0:47discussions around these themes in France and abroad are
- 0:50striking. And I can only hope that this
- 0:52means more people are open to having such necessary
- 0:55conversations. I've been delighted to dig into
- 0:57The Who, what, where and how of this book and the process to
- 1:01writing it, and have been participating in a number of
- 1:04virtual talks. On July 1st, I spent an hour
- 1:08talking to author Thomas Chatterton Williams about my
- 1:10book as part of the American Library in Paris's Author
- 1:13program. That's the conversation you'll
- 1:15discover in this episode. I hope both the book and this
- 1:19exchange inspires discussions in your own circles.
- 1:22One brief note, if you'd like to order a.
- 1:24Copy of the book you can visit thenewparisian.com That link is
- 1:28in the show notes and choose from a number of online
- 1:30retailers or you can ask your local bookstore for
- 1:33availability. An audio version is also
- 1:35available if you'd like to hear me read the whole book to you.
- 1:39And if you've picked up a copy, please consider leaving a review
- 1:42on Amazon, Goodreads, or wherever you can.
- 1:44They are a tremendous help. And now on to the show.
- 1:50Good evening, everybody, and welcome to the American Library
- 1:52in Paris's Virtual Zoom Events. Another edition of Evenings with
- 1:55an author featuring Lindsay Tremuda in conversation with
- 1:58Thomas Chatterton Williams about her latest book, The New
- 2:01Pahesian. I'm Catherine Oleen, programs
- 2:03manager at the American Library. Just a just to say a bit about
- 2:06the library, for those of you who are maybe joining us from
- 2:08the States or other where other places in the world may not be
- 2:11familiar with us. We're an independent, nonprofit
- 2:14institution. And so we don't receive funding
- 2:16from either the US or French governments.
- 2:18We are also the largest English language lending library on the
- 2:21continent, something we're very proud of.
- 2:23And importantly, this year we've been celebrating our Centennial.
- 2:26So we turned 100 in May and we've had a variety of.
- 2:30Events, most of which have taken place virtually, of course.
- 2:33And we'll be having our annual gala.
- 2:35It was postponed for October, but we'll be releasing more
- 2:38details about that soon. And you can stay sort of stay
- 2:41tuned for all of our updates on our Facebook page through Eli
- 2:44Bris, which is our biweekly enewsletter or our homepage.
- 2:48I should also say, since it's very, very current, that we've
- 2:50just broken ground for our expansion, that's one of the
- 2:53major ways that we're celebrating our Centennial as
- 2:55well. Where?
- 2:56Sort of refurbishing and adding a lot of space to the children's
- 2:59and teens section. So that's very, very exciting.
- 3:01And I know that there's a lot of work going on at the library as
- 3:05we're speaking. I should also say we're in the
- 3:08process of reopening. So we are open for members who
- 3:11would like to come in and browse.
- 3:13I think we've been open for about 3 weeks now and it's, it's
- 3:16all gone very well. So we're ensuring that you guys
- 3:18can come and get your books again.
- 3:20A lot of people are very eager to read after being confined for
- 3:23so long without them. So this evening again, I'm
- 3:25delighted to be joined by Thomas and who will be interviewing
- 3:28Lindsay. I'll introduce him first.
- 3:30So Thomas Chetterton Williams is the author of self-portrait in
- 3:33Black and White, Unlearning Race and Losing My Cool Love,
- 3:37Literature and A Black Man's Escape from the Crowd.
- 3:40He is a contributing writer at the New York Times Magazine, a
- 3:43columnist at Harper's, and a 2019 New America Fellow.
- 3:47He also hosts the podcast Americans in Paris for the
- 3:49American Scholar. Out of our library, actually.
- 3:52He's also a repeat evenings with an author, guest and moderator.
- 3:55So we're very happy to have him doing that again tonight.
- 3:58And of course we're very delighted to be joined by
- 4:00Lindsay Tramida. Lindsay is also the author of
- 4:04the best selling book, The New Paris and a regular contributor
- 4:07to the New York Times, founding Ass Traveler, Afar and Fortune
- 4:11magazine. She's also a repeat EWA guest
- 4:14and panelist. And I mean we've we've had her
- 4:16in for all sorts of events, so. We're delighted to be joined by
- 4:19her and very happy to welcome you both.
- 4:22I'll hand it over to Thomas now. Thank you guys for being here.
- 4:25Thanks so much. Thank you.
- 4:27Hi, Lindsay. How are you?
- 4:29Hey, I'm good. How are you?
- 4:30From I'm. Well, I just Did you want to
- 4:34read a little something short first, or do you want to get
- 4:36right into the? No, I think we can get right
- 4:38into it, and then we'll see what time allows.
- 4:41Cool. First of all I just want to say
- 4:44that you publish. Really, really beautiful books.
- 4:47I love to have them in my home and I like to read them and look
- 4:52at them. And your first book, The New
- 4:55Paris, was published in 2017. It's an amazing concept.
- 4:59Paris is the most visited city in the in the world.
- 5:02It's a geography that we're all really familiar with and many of
- 5:06us already feel we know it. Why did you sense that it was
- 5:10time for a reintroduction? Well, I've been here now almost
- 5:1515 years. And I think that what we
- 5:17noticed, and I'm sure you could attest to this too, is that
- 5:20there are certain stories that are recycled about Paris.
- 5:22There are certain narratives that are common, most likely
- 5:25because they're part of this sort of collection of stories
- 5:29and fantasies that we've been, we've been seeing and and and
- 5:33we've been fed for generations. And so it's a concept and it's a
- 5:36formula that works. Unfortunately, I have always
- 5:39found that to be very limiting and very much a, you know, a
- 5:43fraction of the full story. And so the first book was sort
- 5:47of an attempt to say that there are things that are happening.
- 5:49There are, there is a movement of change and there are people
- 5:53who are helping that change along.
- 5:56But it's worth focusing on because it makes a more complete
- 5:59or it offers a more complete picture of what Paris is.
- 6:02And similarly the, the, the new book is almost like a
- 6:06continuation of that. What happens when we continue to
- 6:09flatten a destination or flatten a whole set of people into
- 6:14caricature And you know, what does that do to our
- 6:16understanding of a place? What does that do to our
- 6:18understanding of of a people. And so that kind of is what
- 6:23inspired the the second, the second book, which was, you
- 6:27know, building off the momentum of the first one and saying that
- 6:30there are still some problems that are worth addressing here.
- 6:33Yeah, it's a it's like a fascinating approach.
- 6:35You went out and you interviewed more than 50 different women
- 6:39from a really diverse set of backgrounds and occupations.
- 6:44How did you go about choosing your subjects and and and how
- 6:49did you know? Like, how did you know that
- 6:51fifty was enough or not 60 or 40?
- 6:55Well, well, SO50 was actually my initial goal.
- 6:58And I quickly learned that everyone thought I was crazy
- 7:00because it was extremely ambitious.
- 7:03And, you know, you write for magazines.
- 7:05You know what it's like when you're approaching, you know,
- 7:08interviews with people. And it's basically like 50
- 7:11different, you know, magazine stories in a way, yeah.
- 7:14It's actually overwhelming. So I quickly realized that I had
- 7:18maybe gotten myself into something that I wasn't quite
- 7:21prepared for and certainly that the timing of the, you know, of
- 7:24the book process didn't really allow.
- 7:26So I managed to, I incorporated, I would say about 50 women.
- 7:30Not all of them are profiled, but I did want to incorporate
- 7:33their thoughts in some ways. But what I did was I looked at
- 7:36sort of my inner circle 1st and there are some really inspiring,
- 7:41really creative and sort of forward thinking women who are
- 7:46in just even my inner professional circle.
- 7:49And I started there and I and I thought, okay, are there stories
- 7:53here that I should I should be looking at and I should be
- 7:55celebrating in some way? And does this fit sort of the
- 7:58bigger picture of what I'm looking to do?
- 8:00And then it was quite easy to say okay, there's a whole host
- 8:03of other women whose work I follow, whether it's in media,
- 8:07whether it's in, you know, the books that they write or the,
- 8:10you know, articles that have been written about their work
- 8:12And and trying to get in touch with them to say this is what
- 8:15I'm trying to do. I think you are, you know, you,
- 8:18you exemplify what I'm trying to to describe and and what I'm
- 8:23describing is essentially more of a realistic picture of of the
- 8:26population. And then there were women who,
- 8:29you know, were recommended by some of the other women I
- 8:32interviewed. And that's kind of the best
- 8:33place to be because you, you know, there's who you know.
- 8:37And then you're introduced to a whole a whole host of women who
- 8:41might have been inaccessible in some way.
- 8:44And through the recommendation of someone else, that really
- 8:47helps you to build that pool of talents and ideas.
- 8:52And I really wanted a diversity of thought.
- 8:54And so this was sort of 1 surefire way to get that.
- 8:57Yeah, I mean you have a real mix of some very well known women
- 9:02and some that we haven't heard of yet until you've introduced
- 9:05us to them. How did you go about getting an
- 9:09Hidalgo or Sarah from Collette or Leila Simani?
- 9:12Was it? Was it just a matter of
- 9:14approaching them and they immediately saw your vision or
- 9:17so? Ann Hidalgo took months.
- 9:22She is the mayor of a very busy city and and she's become, quite
- 9:26honestly, probably just as solicited as you know, the
- 9:29president. I mean, honestly, she, she is
- 9:32very media active and she's got a lot of her on her plate.
- 9:36And unfortunately or unfortunately, I was writing
- 9:39this and preparing this during a time when Paris was undergoing
- 9:42quite a lot of upheaval, whether it was the yellow vests or you
- 9:45know, floods and you know, a whole host of other things.
- 9:49So it took months of chasing her team and I think that's the
- 9:53thing also when you're thinking about these projects is that
- 9:55yes, they're two years long, but the writing portion and the and
- 9:58the moment where you can actually, you know nail these
- 10:01people down for for time, for for conversation is it all needs
- 10:05to happen in a certain time frame.
- 10:07So that's very stressful. But it was it worked out and I
- 10:11think you just really need to persevere.
- 10:13And I think if I didn't have the experience of sort of chasing
- 10:17people for interviews, you know, as we've done you know, we've
- 10:20all had to do in this, in this field, I think it would have
- 10:23been. I probably would have given up.
- 10:26But for me her story and her work is too important.
- 10:31So for me it was like she needed to be in there.
- 10:33For Leila Slomani, that was actually for a mutual friend who
- 10:38who introduced us, who had previously interviewed her as
- 10:42well and made the introduction and and kind of gave her her
- 10:46like, stamp of approval on what I was doing.
- 10:48So she was able to say like, I know what she's going to do.
- 10:51I know she'll handle this with, you know, it'll be treated in a
- 10:54certain way. You know, talk to her, maybe see
- 10:57if you're willing to participate.
- 10:58And so that's how that happened. Other women, honestly, it was,
- 11:03you know, engaging with them on social media.
- 11:05I mean, honestly, if there's a reason to spend a lot of time on
- 11:07social, yes, it can be a super time suck.
- 11:10But it is an incredible tool to reach, especially women who are
- 11:15in activism. I mean that is where they're
- 11:17spending a lot of their time mobilizing.
- 11:19And so I also needed to be, you know, in that space to be able
- 11:23to understand how they're they're working and understand
- 11:26how best to reach out to them. So yeah, the the mix of women,
- 11:31you know, they're women who I think are going to become a lot
- 11:33more famous, women who should be more famous and also women who,
- 11:38for whom fame and attention is, is sort of irrelevant.
- 11:42It's about doing the work and, you know, making a difference in
- 11:46some way. So it might just be, you know,
- 11:48by showing other women that they're, they can be part of
- 11:51these fields and that they have a place.
- 11:53Or it's through, you know, being creative and just making sure
- 11:57that they're, you know, there's a community within Paris that
- 12:00embraces this kind of work. Yeah, I see what you and like.
- 12:05I guess we should talk a little bit about what was the idea of
- 12:10the Parisian and. Why did it need to be updated
- 12:14and in what ways has it changed? And and and what are we seeing
- 12:18now that's new and exciting? And so I I think all of us, even
- 12:24if you've never even been to Paris, you have some semblance
- 12:27of an idea of who she is. And that's thanks to pop culture
- 12:32and generations of stereotype building that make it very
- 12:35difficult for us to detach her from a certain set of
- 12:38qualifiers. So, you know, typically you're
- 12:41looking at someone who's white, heterosexual, affluent,
- 12:46bourgeois, so you know of a certain intellectual elite.
- 12:52Most likely, you know, she has a good job and and and really
- 12:59she's been. So this is another the whole
- 13:01shape of the woman, the way she looks, has been played out and
- 13:06recycled over and over again. And so I what I do in the book
- 13:09is I tried to understand like, where did this come from or
- 13:12where are some of the earliest mentions of any kind of
- 13:15depiction of a Parisian woman. And I look at, I trace that back
- 13:19to the 18th century and and John Jacques Rousseau and his work
- 13:22and how he was defining women who were, yes, tied to the
- 13:26court, but the the sort of a. Swiss guy.
- 13:30I'm sorry. This guy comes over and defines
- 13:32the Parisian woman for us. Right, right.
- 13:34Well, you know, but he was also very, very unamused and
- 13:43unimpressed by what he was seeing.
- 13:45And so that was really, that really tied into his work.
- 13:47So you're seeing women who are, you know, very obsessed with
- 13:50material things and superficiality and already the
- 13:53identification of of the the French woman as so French slash
- 13:58Parisian, because those get conflated even now as a sexual
- 14:02temptress and being, you know, excessively talented at
- 14:06seduction, all of that sort of started there.
- 14:09And when you think about how in those early literary works and
- 14:13how quickly they became popular and spread, those ideas become
- 14:17embedded in the national conversation.
- 14:21So that did a lot of the early work and then that, you know,
- 14:24trickled down into the ways that even more modest women were were
- 14:27described. And then you have the
- 14:29proliferation of prostitution you structured prostitution and
- 14:33brothels and and how this identity then gets sort of
- 14:36twisted but still connected very much to sexuality and and almost
- 14:40the objectification of the body. And then of course we we move
- 14:45on. You've got you can look at the
- 14:46American G I's and how that played a role in sort of
- 14:50bringing some of these ideas home back to America about about
- 14:53French women and then in in in film and branded the the sort of
- 14:59the commodified capitalistic society that we live in.
- 15:02And So what I'm the reason this was so important to me is
- 15:06because, you know, I've lived here and yes, seen it, but I
- 15:11didn't move, having been sort of bathed in these fantasies about
- 15:17about what the people were like. I actually came purely as a
- 15:21lover of language and didn't have any expectations of what I
- 15:24was going to see. But I came as a 21 year old who
- 15:28you know was in a transitional period in her life about to
- 15:32become a woman and becoming a woman and an adult woman in an
- 15:35environment that is very complicated.
- 15:38And I think it's very complicated for anybody who does
- 15:40not fit these you know this sort of checklist of of qualities.
- 15:45And so yes, OK, I'm I'm I'm a white woman from America.
- 15:48But there there are whole. You're thin.
- 15:51You're pretty thin, but I but there are a whole host of other
- 15:54ways that I did not fit that mold.
- 15:56And so, you know, we're talking about the this quality that
- 15:59can't necessarily be, you know, necessarily defined so neatly,
- 16:05but, you know, elegance and style and all of these these
- 16:08things that have been sort of like bunched together to to
- 16:11define this monolith. But she's not, it's not real,
- 16:16right? And it's not that.
- 16:17So it's not that she doesn't exist.
- 16:19So the one, you know, the people that we think about, we think
- 16:21about in Este d'afresange, we think about even Jane Birkin,
- 16:26who's British but has sort of like taken on the role of the
- 16:30adopted Parisian woman. You have Francois Hardy, you
- 16:33have all of these figures, and today you'd have Jean Damas, who
- 16:36sort of perpetuates the May 1968 kind of, you know, revolutionary
- 16:42body. All of that's.
- 16:46You've got her too, right? Right, right.
- 16:48So all of this exists. You you can find her.
- 16:51But is that the majority? No.
- 16:53And and I almost think that, you know, these women are also
- 16:57capitalizing on something that they know sells.
- 17:00So you know, the danger becomes this is the sole representation
- 17:04we see of per region women that he faces a whole, a whole
- 17:09massive set of the population who don't fit these these
- 17:12characteristics, who are from immigrant families, who are of
- 17:16all socioeconomic strata. They are, you know, bigger,
- 17:22smaller, taller, maybe not able bodied and and you never see
- 17:26them. And I think that just like we
- 17:29see this branded version of Paris that that plays out and
- 17:32you know, you could call it a museum city, you could call it a
- 17:34postcard. Paris, whatever it it, it's an
- 17:38incomplete story. And so my, my thing was this is
- 17:41an incomplete story. And it's problematic not only
- 17:43for the women who live here, obviously, because they are held
- 17:46to this standard that they can never meet, but for all the
- 17:48women who are looked, who who look to Paris and who look to
- 17:51France and they're all over the world.
- 17:53And that's because popular culture has told us we should be
- 17:56paying attention to what comes out of France.
- 17:58We should be reading books about how they don't get fat and how
- 18:02they, you know, they dress better and they do everything
- 18:04better. And you know that it's praying
- 18:07on our sort of rampant insecurities.
- 18:12And then what we're seeing and what we're given is the same old
- 18:14recycled image. And so I do think it's very
- 18:16damaging both for the place and for, you know, our sense of
- 18:20personal worth. So did you get some?
- 18:23Was there some gratitude when you started approaching Parisian
- 18:26women with this project? Were they happy that, like,
- 18:28somebody had noticed that their lives were different than this
- 18:32stereotype? Totally.
- 18:33I mean, I think some of them were like, oh, you're right, you
- 18:37know, and they hadn't actually like thought about it in those
- 18:39terms. And then many of them actually,
- 18:41you know, came out right and said, you know, finally we need
- 18:44to start changing the story. It's it's a, it's a narrative
- 18:47that really does very few people any real benefit.
- 18:51I'd say that the people who are benefiting the most are the
- 18:54people behind the big corporations who are, you know,
- 18:57leveraging this image to sell billions and billions of dollars
- 19:01of cosmetics and clothes and and ideas about Parisian myths
- 19:06without ever really concerning themselves about who it's
- 19:10reflecting. Yeah, I mean, so you get at a
- 19:13really fascinating discussion of multiculturalism here.
- 19:17Part of what makes these women new is that they are much more
- 19:22ethnically diverse than the traditional image would present.
- 19:26But diversity is done differently in France, right?
- 19:30What we think of as multiculturalism, what they call
- 19:32communatakism. There are different values
- 19:34ascribed and there's a different relation in the story they tell
- 19:37themselves about nationhood. I mean, can you speak a bit
- 19:41about how diversity is done here as opposed to back home?
- 19:45Yeah, I mean, one of the, the reason I go into this in the
- 19:47book is because someone, so many of the women in their stories
- 19:50talk about issues that I think needed clarification for a
- 19:53foreign audience. So, you know, yes, there's big
- 19:56discussions about race in in France right now.
- 19:59And the context that I mean there's certain parallels in the
- 20:03context of course, but there are ways that these issues are
- 20:06treated differently. So I think what makes the French
- 20:08context so unique is it's ideals of universalism, in which all
- 20:13citizens are meant to be equal under the.
- 20:15Public, you know, they like to believe themselves colorblind.
- 20:19And as a result, any emphasis on diversity, ethnicity or race is
- 20:24almost seem to be, or it seem to potentially undermine unity and
- 20:28social cohesion. So, you know, essentially
- 20:30they're threats to the Republic and that's what they would call
- 20:33a communalism or communalism. So the hyphenated aspects of our
- 20:37identity in the United States that are seen as valuable and
- 20:40quite positive qualities, You know, the things that we
- 20:42celebrate as multiculturalism, we can celebrate that in the US,
- 20:48celebrate all the ways that we're different and still feel
- 20:51part of the national American identity, but not here.
- 20:54So you're seen as sort of and if you think actually most recently
- 20:58about Mac Ho and how when he commented on the Black Lives
- 21:02Matter slash racial justice March from a few weeks ago, he
- 21:06didn't call them out specifically by name.
- 21:08But he said that any of these people who are gathering in this
- 21:11way are not only communatalities but they're separatists who are
- 21:15threatening to divide the nation.
- 21:17So you're. A strong word.
- 21:18I mean that's, I mean that's very, very strong language.
- 21:22And so you're talking about, you know, potentially people who are
- 21:25from immigrant, immigrant families, who are born on French
- 21:30soil, who, you know, go to school, who are identified as
- 21:34French. And yet the reality is, is
- 21:36they're not treated as French. So this whole idea of, you know,
- 21:41universalism under the Republic is really, really great in in
- 21:44theory, and it's a noble goal, but it falls short in practice.
- 21:48The other element that I would highlight is that that makes the
- 21:51French context quite different from the US is that it's illegal
- 21:54to keep racial, ethnic or religious statistics.
- 21:57So without data, it's it becomes very difficult to measure the
- 22:02discriminations that exist. And we do know that they exist.
- 22:06So in many ways, France wields this colorblind universalism as
- 22:10a kind of like tool for the denial of discrimination.
- 22:14And and then when race was removed from the Constitution in
- 22:172018, critics viewed it as further evidence of an overall,
- 22:22you know, great discomfort with discussing and addressing racial
- 22:25injustice. So you've got this long history
- 22:29of slavery and colonialism that has largely been eclipsed by
- 22:32this narrative of universal human rights.
- 22:34So I know you and I have talked about this.
- 22:37The idea of, you know, everyone being equal under the Republic
- 22:42surely sounds really wonderful in theory.
- 22:45But the fact that it falls short and the fact that it isn't
- 22:48playing out that way for a lot of people means that they don't
- 22:53feel like they can be part of this national, this national
- 22:57community, this national identity.
- 22:58So what happens when the images that you're seeing on TV and in
- 23:02the media and the journalists who are speaking on behalf of,
- 23:05you know, the collective are all white?
- 23:09So, you know, I would say that in the US, again, very hard to
- 23:13compare. But I do think in some respects
- 23:16the US has made more progress in terms of diversifying who is
- 23:21sharing these stories, who's getting access to tell these
- 23:23stories on TV and in film. And and that fight is still
- 23:27ongoing in France. So when you're a little girl who
- 23:29wants to be an actress and you're, you know, you're black
- 23:33or Arab and you see the way you're represented on television
- 23:37or in film, it doesn't look like a very possible or viable career
- 23:41path. You're presented as someone who
- 23:43is most likely, given the average type of, you know, the
- 23:46the, the types of stories that are often presented on
- 23:49television. You're probably portrayed as a
- 23:51caricature, you know, a thug, potentially someone in in in sex
- 23:57work, someone who's in trouble with the law.
- 24:00These kinds of representations matter, and they make a big
- 24:03difference in people's feeling of connectedness and belonging.
- 24:08Yeah, you have a really great quote early in the book where a
- 24:12woman says a woman's appearance is part of the country's source
- 24:16of national pride and therefore her body belongs to the national
- 24:20gays. And so if you're cut out of
- 24:21that, you don't participate in that pride.
- 24:23And it must who was pushing back against this in a really
- 24:26interesting way that you spoke with among these women and who
- 24:30taught you some things here? Oh God, I mean, honestly, I
- 24:33learned so much from every single one of them.
- 24:35I mean, obviously the activists are kind of the easiest people
- 24:38to talk to because they have so much they've already worked
- 24:41through and they've they've thought through.
- 24:44And even the person who said that was Alice Pfeiffer and I
- 24:47learned a lot from her as well. You know, I I think we need to.
- 24:53What they taught me was that it's about questioning what
- 24:55we're seeing and questioning what we've taken for as sort of
- 24:59standard, standard discourse. And and that's very hard to do
- 25:05in this country because a as a woman in general you are not
- 25:09listened to as much. It's very it's it's very
- 25:11difficult to be heard. All you have to do to to see
- 25:15that first hand is to see some of the women in the book who are
- 25:17often on television and who can barely get, you know, 10 seconds
- 25:21of a thought out before they're interrupted.
- 25:24And then you add on to that women who are, you know, of a
- 25:27different background and we're talking about, you know, really
- 25:31trying to fight to get a seat at the table.
- 25:34So if we look at Orokayed Yellow, for example, who's an
- 25:36activist who's, you know, very much in the spotlight, you know,
- 25:41she what what I've sort of blown away by in speaking with her was
- 25:46just how much she feels French. You know.
- 25:49So you can argue for the need for antiracial movements and you
- 25:53can fight for better representation and still feel,
- 25:58you know, at at your core that you are still part of this
- 26:02France. And she would say to me that
- 26:04there was never any moment she felt more French than when she
- 26:06traveled outside of France because of the way people would
- 26:08treat her. So one of the things that I know
- 26:10you and I have talked about is, is the experience of when you
- 26:13are a black American living in France or living in Paris and
- 26:19what that experience is like. And then for her being a black
- 26:24French woman and what the experience is like when she
- 26:26travels and how much she is treated like, oh, well, you're
- 26:29French, that's fine, you're French.
- 26:31But on on French soil she is everything.
- 26:35But I, you know, very clearly French.
- 26:38So I think, you know, with respect to that, that quote
- 26:41about being part of the national gaze, I think yes.
- 26:44I mean, you look at the symbol of the Mahayan who is the
- 26:47national personification of the Republic and arguably one of the
- 26:51most prominent symbols of the emancipated woman.
- 26:53You know her with her breast exposed and you know, on stamps
- 26:57and statues of her everywhere. But that ideal and the way that
- 27:02she's been portrayed over the years by, you know, mostly white
- 27:05women has fed into all sorts of political arguments for even why
- 27:11the veil in religious dress is antithetical to freedom and
- 27:15essential Frenchness. So you know, talking with Sarah
- 27:18Zwak who who runs the, the, the organization called Lalab, which
- 27:23is for, you know, giving a voice to Muslim women speaking with
- 27:28okayed Yellow. But a whole host of other women
- 27:31in the book who feel like they're just not seen, there's
- 27:34this the the, the, the the state of being invisible is no better
- 27:38than being discriminated against outrightly.
- 27:41So there's all sorts of ways that we are discriminating
- 27:44against, against women, men and women, but in this case speaking
- 27:47solely about women and and ways to feel that you're not
- 27:49connected to sort of the bigger community and and that does have
- 27:53long lasting problems. And so many of these women are
- 27:57working past those hurdles, working through them, working
- 28:00past them, whatever, and trying to, you know, make careers for
- 28:03themselves all the while. These oppressions are still very
- 28:08much a part of their daytoday. Yeah, it's it's fascinating to
- 28:12me how they navigate that. And it does have a lot of kind
- 28:15of. Echoes in the black American
- 28:19experience where you have James Baldwin or someone say that he
- 28:21never was treated as an American until he came to France, but
- 28:24then he saw that an African or an Arab was being treated, how
- 28:27he would be treated back home. And so it was a kind of
- 28:29complicated feeling. And I've heard others say that
- 28:32it's the same realization they have when they leave France and
- 28:34go to America, that they get to be finally just just French.
- 28:38But I'm also interested in like your.
- 28:41Your experience here, I mean, you've been in the country and
- 28:44in the city for long enough that you can call yourself a kind of
- 28:47nouvelle Pakisi and you've mastered the language and this
- 28:51is really a place you've made your home.
- 28:54Do you feel yourself prison or is it not possible to actually
- 28:57immigrate into Parisian This not.
- 29:00I mean, I I do think, you know, I think 10 years ago I would
- 29:04have said no because I was still holding myself to some sort of
- 29:08set of standards that were impossible.
- 29:09They're not meant for me to aspire to or really anyone.
- 29:15Now I think after doing a lot of this work and coming to the
- 29:18realization that I was like, hoodwinked for a very long time
- 29:22by these very stereotypes that I am, I am like, you know, I first
- 29:29of all, I am a French citizen and I became French in 2014.
- 29:33But that's even separate. It's it's just this is my home.
- 29:36This is the city I'm devoted to. This is, this is where I became
- 29:40an adult. This is where I figured out who
- 29:41I was. So whether I was born here or
- 29:44not is sort of, you know, not irrelevant, but, you know, plays
- 29:49less of a role in whether I feel Parisian.
- 29:53And and I look at it as how New Yorkers, you know, look at where
- 29:56they all come from. I mean it is like the most, one
- 29:58of the most diverse cities on the planet.
- 30:01And eventually they consider themselves New Yorkers.
- 30:03And I think that for whatever reason, we've always allowed
- 30:06that for New York. But in Paris, you're not really
- 30:09Parisian unless, you know, you fit all these, you know, these
- 30:13criteria. I don't believe that anymore.
- 30:16And actually the women in the book are are not all born in
- 30:18France, You know, they're American, They're Lebanese,
- 30:21they're Moroccan. They are born in, you know, the
- 30:23suburbs of France, you know. And So what it means to be
- 30:27Parisian needed to be rethought and upended anyway.
- 30:31So yeah, I I would say I do feel, I do feel Parisian now.
- 30:35Rule of thumb in New York is 10 years, but I I feel like 10
- 30:38years is too short in Paris, right?
- 30:40Because. You can't really.
- 30:42Like, I've been here for almost 10 years, but I don't speak the.
- 30:45I don't speak the language of Gavale the way that you do.
- 30:49So I think that for me it's not gonna be 10 years.
- 30:51What's the what's the rule of thumb here?
- 30:54I think it's it's everyone you either know or you you know, you
- 30:58know when it hits. You you know what?
- 30:59You know it when you see it. So I know I'm not appreciating
- 31:01yet. I'm just an expat.
- 31:03No, I know. I mean, look, also the word
- 31:06expat versus immigrant is a whole nother debate.
- 31:08I'm constantly called an expat and I I haven't used that term
- 31:11to refer to myself in many, many years.
- 31:13I mean, first of all, I have no intention of moving home.
- 31:16So I think that removes the expat from the equation right
- 31:19away. But I don't know, maybe you will
- 31:22find that moment where you too feel like a Parisian.
- 31:25It's gonna come with some real improvement in my conjugation
- 31:28skills. I've got the knowledge of.
- 31:33It's a state of mind, that. Sounds are, but I don't have the
- 31:36conjugation skills. That's OK.
- 31:39So we could. So I I love your project.
- 31:41I love how you, you have like a very holistic approach to your
- 31:45career. You're a writer and a
- 31:48journalist, but you're also a podcaster.
- 31:50You also have like a well defined social media presence.
- 31:54And you integrate all of these things together.
- 31:56And even your books, they're not they.
- 31:58They do stand alone, but they're also part of a larger like.
- 32:02Cycle or project. So can you both speak to how
- 32:07you've kind of thought systematically about
- 32:10investigative and kind of exploratory work you're doing in
- 32:13France? And also will this be a trilogy?
- 32:15And will the brothers get some love the the the nouveau Parisi
- 32:20Parisi ends. I'm starting with you.
- 32:23If there is that book I'm starting with you, yeah.
- 32:26So it's interesting because I think I came, I came up in my
- 32:30career, which almost didn't feel like a career until very
- 32:33recently with social media, right.
- 32:37So I was on Facebook when it was rolled out to my university in
- 32:402004 or whatever. And that early adoption, even
- 32:45with Twitter too, because I got on Twitter when I had just
- 32:48finished grad school and I was feeling very lost and people
- 32:50were talking about Twitter. And I'm like, oh, I guess I'm
- 32:52going to spend some time here figuring out what this tool is.
- 32:56That being on those platforms early on really allowed me to
- 33:00get comfortable and understand how how they could be used to
- 33:05sort of connect me to other people, but also get certain
- 33:09messages out there and and and figure out how to weave it into
- 33:15my work. So whatever my work was going to
- 33:17look like. And then of course I saw as it
- 33:20took off and as other platforms were introduced and I was
- 33:24already comfortable playing around on those on those
- 33:26platforms. I realized that if I do have a
- 33:29certain message that that is important to me to get out or to
- 33:32share whether it's this or whether down the road it becomes
- 33:36something else that these tools are ways to to reach more
- 33:40people. But, you know, pure and simple,
- 33:42I mean a lot of some of what we're discussing and what we
- 33:45have just discussed, you know, finds its way into New York
- 33:49Times articles and investigative reports for Al Jazeera and
- 33:53Washington Post. But the.
- 33:54But not everybody's reading those, those publications.
- 33:58And so some people are getting a lot of their, their learning or
- 34:01their, you know, their news from podcast.
- 34:03Some of them are spending way too much time on social media,
- 34:07but that's also where they're doing a lot of their learning.
- 34:09And so I realized that if I want to sort of get these messages
- 34:13into more people than it can't be, my focus cannot be on on one
- 34:18sort of tunnel. And so I I kind of attribute it
- 34:22to coming up at the right time when I didn't have to like catch
- 34:27up and and learn how these platforms worked and and being a
- 34:31little bit more adaptable in that sense.
- 34:33And then also realizing that I can't put my eggs in one basket.
- 34:36And you know, the nature of our work is changing.
- 34:39COVID has certainly thrown everything for a loop.
- 34:42So you know, figuring out how I'm going to keep telling
- 34:44stories, you know is is sort of mutating.
- 34:48And so having my hand in all these different pots, I think is
- 34:51a way to make sure I can, you know, tell the stories I want to
- 34:55tell. Who?
- 34:57Who's your ideal reader? Because the obvious answer would
- 35:00be like I want like some young Parisian to to read this and to
- 35:04feel seen. But maybe your ideal reader is
- 35:06actually not that, and it's like a 55 year old guy who has never
- 35:10thought hard about some of his city's inhabitants.
- 35:14Or, I don't know. No, you're you're right.
- 35:17I mean, I think I really want. I wanted women specifically to
- 35:22feel like there are other women out there who are battling the
- 35:27same thing and who are trying to change the stories or the way
- 35:31that we are perceived and try to change that dialogue.
- 35:34But I really want this to be a conversation with men too.
- 35:36I mean, I've gotten some messages already of men who have
- 35:39preordered the book and who are engaged in these conversations.
- 35:42And I think that's honestly key. We're not going to make a lot of
- 35:47change if we're only having these conversations and silos
- 35:50and you know, in our little groups or with, you know, an All
- 35:53Girls book Club like it needs to be more mainstream.
- 35:58And and so that's who I'm hoping.
- 36:00I'm hoping this transcends, you know, any tiny little niche
- 36:03audience group and can be something that starts a
- 36:05conversation with as many people as possible.
- 36:08Yeah, because it's interesting the.
- 36:11We talked a bit about how women get spoken over here.
- 36:14And with that, at the risk of saying something that's too
- 36:19general, France is still a Latin, old Latin culture, you
- 36:24know, and it's interesting to compare with the United States
- 36:26because on the one hand, the French government provides such
- 36:31a great structure that women can be mothers and also quickly get
- 36:36back into the workplace and so are much more actually like.
- 36:39Liberated than American women who often make even highly
- 36:43educated American women who end up making choices between
- 36:46motherhood and and and career, but at the same time, you mean
- 36:52this has been widely reported women in France, even highly
- 36:56successful professional women, end up doing much more of the
- 36:58childcare, end up kind of still dealing with the very same
- 37:02things that you would think that they had transcended.
- 37:06Because they've made so much progress in other areas here.
- 37:08So it's a kind of fascinating conversation.
- 37:10It's a very timely one and very important one that you're
- 37:13bringing well. And I think there I certainly
- 37:15had certain notions about France early on, which was that it was
- 37:19a far more progressive country than it actually is.
- 37:22I mean they're progressive in certain key ways and certainly
- 37:25as a social system when you're comparing it to the US, you
- 37:28know, it's on a whole different planet.
- 37:31But in terms of of women's rights, it's not all, it's not
- 37:35all golden. And if you, if you consider even
- 37:38just with you know, reproductive rights, we're still fighting
- 37:42right now. The bill hasn't even passed for
- 37:44what's called Panama, which is medically assisted procreation.
- 37:49It's still illegal for single women or lesbian women to have
- 37:54access to IVF within France. That really shocked me when I
- 37:57read that. Yeah, yeah, it's.
- 37:58I mean, until the bioethics committee of France has said
- 38:01that there's no reason it shouldn't, you know, be allowed,
- 38:04but it still has to be voted upon.
- 38:05And because of COVID and all sorts of other things that's
- 38:07been delayed, you know, but these are women who you know
- 38:11have to go, who end up paying quite a lot of money to go to
- 38:13other countries to do this. So yes, OK, you can get
- 38:17contraception for free and there are a lot of other services that
- 38:22are are free and and super accessible.
- 38:25And no one is judging you for in France.
- 38:27But then there are other areas that where France actually lacks
- 38:31quite behind. So I think ultimately there's
- 38:34no, there's no country that is getting it right, 100% right.
- 38:37You know, if they're excelling in one area, they're perhaps
- 38:40behind in another. But these are issues that need
- 38:43to be talked about. And so where I would say that
- 38:46these issues sort of overlap is where you have the debate around
- 38:49Panama and you have men on television being the ones
- 38:53debating this on behalf of women.
- 38:56It's like where are the women? Don't tell me that you can't
- 38:58find, you know, women who are directly concerned by this issue
- 39:02to speak. They're there.
- 39:04You know, and doing a book like this tells me it doesn't take
- 39:08that much effort to find women to come and speak on these
- 39:11issues. They are there.
- 39:12It's the media being complicit and not wanting to change.
- 39:15You know whose voices they're allowing to be heard.
- 39:18Yeah, that makes maybe this is my last question before we open
- 39:21it up to the to the audience. So is like America is a crazy
- 39:28space at the moment, and it's hard to say that America is.
- 39:32Necessarily like woke, but But is France actually like a less
- 39:35woke, less kind of progressive space socially for women than
- 39:39America? On balance, is it safe to
- 39:42generalize like that or is it impossible?
- 39:44It's so hard. I mean, I would say I think my
- 39:47gut tells me that yes. I mean if you look at the way me
- 39:50too played out here, I mean it almost it almost was a non
- 39:53issue. Only only only Tariq Ramadan
- 39:57suffered any consequences. Only a Muslim man suffered any
- 39:59consequences. Oh, yeah, that's a whole, that's
- 40:01a whole other, you know, very heated, heated debate.
- 40:04But, you know, and unfortunately, in a way, it was
- 40:07starting to reach a fever pitch right as confinement hit.
- 40:10You know, we had the, the Roman Polanski film that was, you
- 40:14know, stirred all sorts of protest among women across
- 40:17France. And it was, it felt very, I
- 40:20don't want to say exciting in a positive way, but it was
- 40:22exciting to see this energy, really a sustained energy, you
- 40:26know, carry carry us through over many, many months.
- 40:30And then you know, obviously that's been derailed a bit, but
- 40:33I don't feel that France is as woke as it thinks it is.
- 40:38But but really is is anyone. I mean I think that's the thing
- 40:41you know every country right now is going through it sort of like
- 40:43learning process of how to become, you know, better and
- 40:47more equipped to handle these these serious issues that exist.
- 40:51But when it comes to certain key topics in France, I think it's
- 40:54they're it's not even that they're blind spots, it's that
- 40:57they're they're willfully brushed under the rug.
- 41:00And so until that changes, we're not going to see a whole lot of
- 41:04woke people, especially not in the public sphere.
- 41:08So when it comes to race and discrimination and, you know,
- 41:12sexism, I still think there's a huge fight to be to be had and
- 41:17to be led. Yeah.
- 41:20No, I agree with you, Lindsay. Thank you so much for thank you
- 41:24these. Wonderful answers, and I think
- 41:26we must have some questions from the audience now.
- 41:29Yes, thank you both. I'll invite the audience to
- 41:32submit your questions via the chat features we talked about.
- 41:35So go go ahead and make sure your mics are still off, but
- 41:38I'll be happy to read any questions that come in.
- 41:41Give you guys a couple seconds to to type and Lindsay and
- 41:44Thomas can have a drink of water or relax for 30 seconds while we
- 41:48wait. Thank you both.
- 41:52It's really a wonderful book. Bravo, Lindsay.
- 41:54Thank you, Thomas. And maybe while we're waiting
- 42:01too, we should just go over how to preorder Lindsay.
- 42:03Or do you want to tell us a little bit about the release or?
- 42:06Yeah, so it officially comes out next Tuesday, July 7th,
- 42:10everywhere in the world, I think.
- 42:13But if people want to preorder, they can visit
- 42:17thenewparisian.com and I can actually type that in the group
- 42:21perhaps, so that you see how it's spelled.
- 42:24Let me see. And if you look at Catherine's
- 42:27e-mail that she sent with the details for this chat, there
- 42:30were some links in there as well.
- 42:32So that has links to the US and other countries where you can
- 42:39access the OR find the book. And so I see one question that
- 42:43is. Yeah.
- 42:45We have a question from Megan. I'm going to go ahead and read
- 42:46it so we can capture this in the podcast and on YouTube for
- 42:49people who won't be seeing this. So, and so Megan is saying thank
- 42:52you. Do you get the sense that the
- 42:53feeling of being invisible as a woman in Paris is the same
- 42:56across France? Or are there more opportunities
- 42:59for women in Dionne, Marseille, Bordeaux, etcetera, where the
- 43:02Parisian mystique is not there? That's a really good question.
- 43:08I can't speak specifically to what it's like being a woman in
- 43:11those cities. However, I would say that
- 43:13probably what does not help is the way mostly foreign media put
- 43:20Parisian women in the same sort of thought as French women.
- 43:24So I can tell you that women who are not from Paris and who live
- 43:27elsewhere does not, they do not identify with being Parisian.
- 43:32It's kind of like if a woman from, I don't know, Los Angeles
- 43:35is is conflated with being in New Yorker.
- 43:38They're they're, you know, they're different identities.
- 43:39There are different stories and and so I would I I think that's
- 43:45one of the bigger problems the the problem is constantly
- 43:48creating this monolithic French woman or Parisian woman and and
- 43:52pretending like somehow they're going to be the same or all
- 43:54across the country. But unfortunately I can't really
- 43:57speak to what it's like in terms of opportunities.
- 44:00I would say that most economic opportunities are in Paris and
- 44:04other large cities, but I would love for it to be better for
- 44:07women elsewhere. Okay, great.
- 44:11Thank you. So we've got a lot of questions.
- 44:13I'll do my best to get to as many as we can.
- 44:15The next is from Patrick. He says, How do you feel the
- 44:18treatment of women has changed since arriving in France?
- 44:21Till now? I guess that's since your
- 44:22arrival, especially interested in the workplace.
- 44:26So I can speak at least to the workplace question because I did
- 44:30work in a corporate environment for, you know, 5-6 years.
- 44:34And I know that many of the sort of like offhanded remarks that I
- 44:41was exposed to when I was in that environment, the sort of
- 44:44everyday sexism that sort of filtered into to casual
- 44:48conversation and and was made to feel normalized is most likely
- 44:53not, would not, would not pass quite so easily today.
- 44:56And that's that's really because there were certain cases
- 44:59actually in in especially in advertising and in specific
- 45:02companies where it was revealed that there was rampant sexism
- 45:06and sexual harassment and you know, the company needed to make
- 45:12make a change. And so they they you know laid
- 45:15off these these men and and actually made sort of concrete
- 45:20change where before they were barely you know reprimanded.
- 45:25I would say it's still a work in progress, but I know even in
- 45:27super conservative or traditional companies, big, big
- 45:31French, you know, large corporations have instituted
- 45:34sexual harassment and sort of me too style guidelines and
- 45:40discussions and and and really trying to discuss the issue of
- 45:45consent as well. And so that already is a big
- 45:47step in the right direction because before consent was you
- 45:50know, an abstract thought and didn't even really enter into
- 45:53the conversation And so now it's sort of front of mind.
- 45:56So there have been some changes. They may seem perhaps a little
- 46:00bit more subtle, but things are changing.
- 46:03Great, thank you. We've got a really good question
- 46:06from Marsha, she says. Lindsay, you touched on
- 46:08representation. How do you think your book will
- 46:10help young women seek out opportunities that they don't
- 46:13necessarily see themselves represented in?
- 46:16I mean, I sure hope so. You know, that was the whole
- 46:19reason behind including women from different professions.
- 46:22You know, I wanted to have a lawyer.
- 46:24I wanted to have someone who's an engineer, you know,
- 46:27especially in a very male dominated aspect of engineering,
- 46:31women who are trying to raise millions and millions of dollars
- 46:34for for startup projects. I think the more we see them and
- 46:40we hear their stories, the more we understand that it's
- 46:43possible. You know, I I'm not in a field
- 46:46that's particularly masculine. However, I know that I needed to
- 46:51see certain stories along the way to to make me feel like this
- 46:54wasn't just some, you know, lofty goal.
- 46:57So regardless, I think we all need to have these kinds of
- 47:00stories. And so if it helps a few young
- 47:02people feel like you know, there, there is a way forward
- 47:05and then then I've accomplished something.
- 47:09All right. The next question is from
- 47:11Heather Lindsay. Do you feel French men are also
- 47:13subject to the cultural expectation to be seductive?
- 47:16And how does that influence the relationship between men and
- 47:19women? Well, that's a very good
- 47:22question. I would assume so.
- 47:24I don't know that men are as. I don't know that their
- 47:29identities, in the way that they are presented with such
- 47:31stereotypes, are as I don't know that they permeate sort of pop
- 47:38culture in the same ways or to the same degree as the
- 47:42stereotypes around women. I I can say that, you know, the
- 47:48men in my life don't feel particularly hemmed in by these
- 47:51stereotypes. And I don't know if that's
- 47:54because simply they, you know, don't concern themselves with
- 47:57such things because, you know, it's maybe less egregious.
- 48:01But I would say that the dynamic between men and women and and
- 48:05the idea of traditional gender roles and, you know, division of
- 48:09Labor, all of those things are still very much an issue in
- 48:11French couples, as as Thomas said, even about, you know, how
- 48:15you can be ascending in the workplace and still end up as a
- 48:18woman and still take on much of the role, much of the work at
- 48:21home. So I think that, you know, no,
- 48:24they're not. Maybe they're not hemmed in by
- 48:25these stereotypes, but there are certain traditional roles that
- 48:28are not changing. Absolutely.
- 48:33OK, so Nicole is saying, as a black American woman in France,
- 48:36I was horrified by Macron's response, which I haven't heard
- 48:39until you just stated it. Do you foresee this attitude of
- 48:43quote not challenging French unity and quote evolving as the
- 48:46US evolves and confronts its painful history and its effects?
- 48:51So that's a very good question. Also, sorry, you might hear a
- 48:53cat meow. So that you actually raise a
- 48:58very interesting point, which is this idea of, oh, there's a
- 49:02tale, you raise an interesting point, which is sort of, you
- 49:06know, as America is doing this work, will that influence
- 49:09France? And France is very reluctant to
- 49:13follow another country's lead, especially not the US And so a
- 49:17lot of the last three weeks have been, you know, French pundits
- 49:21going on TV and saying, you know, pointing out all the ills
- 49:24of of US culture and and sort of the US racial divide and saying
- 49:30we are not like them, let's stop trying to Americanize French
- 49:33politics. So I don't know.
- 49:36I think that there's a, there was a lot of backlash to
- 49:39Macron's comments about, you know, the people who are
- 49:42mobilizing, being separatists. I think that stunned a lot of
- 49:45people, although it really just highlights that he's pandering
- 49:48quite heavily to the right. But there are more young people
- 49:53who are engaged and who are shocked by some of this rhetoric
- 49:57and who I think are going to be much more engaged and involved
- 50:00in a way more than they were before.
- 50:02So will it change? I don't know.
- 50:04But I do think we're not going to be so quiet.
- 50:06About it All right. The next question is from
- 50:10Jeanne, who writes. Have you thought of doing
- 50:12something in France aimed at the younger audience?
- 50:14So young girls and boys know that there are these from whom
- 50:19to learn. You know what?
- 50:22I I, I would love to do something like that.
- 50:25I have seen one sort of young young adult children's book to
- 50:30come out recently in French with some of the women in the women
- 50:36of color who have been influencing French society over
- 50:39over history. So certainly there's.
- 50:42I'd be excited to work on something like that for a
- 50:44younger audience. I think we've seen a lot of the,
- 50:47you know, the rebellious women, the the bad women of history.
- 50:50I think we also need to be careful about how we're framing
- 50:53these kinds of stories. You know, we women are not
- 50:56always, you know, rebellious. I mean, we can refer to them as
- 50:59having, you know, been disruptive and disrupted the
- 51:02norm. But there's a lot to be done,
- 51:04certainly for a young audience. I have seen a lot of very
- 51:06interesting children's books come out of Paris or sorry out
- 51:09of France though, that I think are trying to tackle this very
- 51:13topic. Okay Great.
- 51:17Barbara's question is a quick one.
- 51:18Can we expect a version in French for a translation?
- 51:22All, I really hope so. Apparently it's in German.
- 51:25The German edition came out at the end of April.
- 51:29Again, thank you COVID for screwing up the timeline of
- 51:31that, but I would really love for this to be in French.
- 51:36It's not up to me. It's a publisher or publisher
- 51:39publishing rights decision. A part of me worries that
- 51:44because of the sensitivity of some of these issues, they may
- 51:47opt against it. But I would hope that they they
- 51:51see the potential in in getting these stories out there, even to
- 51:53their own, you know, their own country.
- 51:57So fingers crossed, I would love for it to be translated.
- 52:00Okay, Great. I think we've got time for a
- 52:02couple more questions here. I'll go to Yvonne's, She says.
- 52:06How much of A role do you think language plays in racial
- 52:09discrimination in France? Are certain dialects and French
- 52:12harshly judged? And in other words, is code
- 52:15switching as prevalent in France as in the US probably?
- 52:19I mean again, I can't speak from my, from personal experience,
- 52:23but I would imagine there's sort of like, you know, switching
- 52:27identities as you go through different contexts here in
- 52:30French society, especially given how elitist it tends to be When
- 52:34you think about the the people who are, you know, allowed to
- 52:37represent France, it's based on how palatable they are to sort
- 52:40of like, you know, the the the white national identity.
- 52:45So I I do think that that plays a role and you know language
- 52:51regardless of the culture is is one one way for people to be
- 52:55judged. But from from personal
- 52:58experience I haven't necessarily felt that.
- 53:01Although even just purely, as someone who is not a native
- 53:04French speaker, I have felt, you know, sort of uneasy in certain
- 53:09situations because I I knew that I was being judged based on on
- 53:13that and based on my ability to express a certain idea.
- 53:16So you can only imagine how that might play out if you're, you
- 53:19know, speaking a dialect or you're from a, you know, W
- 53:22African French speaking or Francophone culture where there
- 53:27are differences in terminology and phrases and you know, the
- 53:30French are just, they're just very judgy of everyone.
- 53:34And so I do think that that plays out, you know, for for
- 53:37someone who you know isn't a native French speaker and for
- 53:40someone who speaks, you know, a dialect or or even Quebecois, I
- 53:44mean, they're highly judged when they come to come to France and
- 53:49speak. So I'm sure that plays a role.
- 53:52Yeah, thank you. Sarah's question is how
- 53:55difficult is it for French women, especially those of non
- 53:58stereotype backgrounds, to obtain private investment for
- 54:01building companies? How difficult is it for French
- 54:04women? But it's time.
- 54:07I mean so the the funding exists but one of the women in the book
- 54:12who's named and Ravinona and has a company called Global Investor
- 54:16talks about the funding gap for women.
- 54:18So across the board and and this is true in France but also
- 54:23around you know an issue elsewhere in Europe.
- 54:26Just the access to funding is very, very difficult partially
- 54:29because when women in general undervalue what they the amount
- 54:33of money that they need, they're afraid to ask for more and men
- 54:37tend to overestimate the amount of money that they need.
- 54:41But in terms of so that would be private investment government
- 54:44aid is is readily available. So I, you know luckily that
- 54:47doesn't seem to be as much of a problem.
- 54:49It's about how do we unlearn some of these unconscious biases
- 54:55that make men less likely to invest in women funded or women
- 55:00women's businesses? And how do women get the
- 55:04confidence to ask for what they deserve and what they need?
- 55:10Okay, great. Thank you.
- 55:11We'll take one last one here from Liz.
- 55:14If there are no statistics taken based on ethnicity, how does the
- 55:17women, How do women in France define themselves?
- 55:20Is there an emphasis on correctly identifying people
- 55:23such as there is at least growing in the US?
- 55:26How does the French woman define herself versus how does society
- 55:29define her in terms of pronouns etc?
- 55:32I don't think we are yet to the point as we are in the US where
- 55:39we've just seen, you know, black indigenous people of color that
- 55:43acronym come out, which has also been heavily debated in the US.
- 55:47There have been stories just this week from people of color
- 55:50who disagree with using that term.
- 55:54You know, I don't know. I think I think there are are in
- 55:58my friend group here, there are women who would refer them
- 56:00further. The refer to themselves as
- 56:03queer. They would refer to themselves
- 56:04as, you know, black what a Muslim.
- 56:11I mean, honestly, I don't think they.
- 56:13I think there's less labeling because they're resisting the
- 56:17overarching culture of putting people in boxes and labeling
- 56:20them. So I think they're more likely
- 56:22to say bashing fam or what ashing fam too cool and and
- 56:28that's it. But I don't get the sense that
- 56:32there is this sort of like heightened political correctness
- 56:37around the pronouns and the terms.
- 56:40It's starting, but I don't think it's it doesn't take off like it
- 56:44does in the US, which happened like that.
- 56:47Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. All right.
- 56:49Well. We're just about coming up to
- 56:51time here, so I wanted to thank Thomas and Lindsay again so, so
- 56:54much. Thank you also for asking all of
- 56:56those wonderful questions and Lindsay for your responses.
- 57:00So thank you guys so much for being here.
- 57:03You can check out our past events as well on YouTube or our
- 57:06podcast Evenings with an Author Podcast.
- 57:08It's available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever
- 57:11else you like to get your podcasts.
- 57:13So thank you all for being here again.
- 57:15And thank you, Lindsay. Thank you Thomas so much.
- 57:18Thank you.