Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Investment Podcast #38 - Compartmentalised Investing
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with our sponsor, Innova Asset Management Pty Ltd, ABN 99141 597104, AFSL 509 578, and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:16Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:23Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice or services or endorse any
- 0:30If a PDS or IM exists, you should obtain a copy and review it thoroughly before making a decision.
- 0:38Hey guys, this is Ben Nash from Pivot Wealth and one of the Ensemble co-founders and I'm pumped to be involved in the investment podcast for Ensemble.
- 0:47Our advice business is built around younger, higher income clients where investments is a big part of the picture and the Ensemble crew have asked me to host this podcast where I'll be sitting down with some of the sharpest people in the market to talk about portfolio construction, asset allocation, the mindset and psychology side of investing and what's actually working right now.
- 1:10This podcast is proudly brought to you by Innova Asset Management, a leading provider of goals-based, risk-managed SMAs.
- 1:17Innova empowers financial advisors to align client portfolios with their natural behavior and long-term objectives.
- 1:23Their evidence-based approach combines dynamic asset allocation with a deep understanding of investor psychology, helping to reduce value-destructive behaviors.
- 1:31With a proven track record since 2012, Innova offers traditional and behavioral portfolios designed to deliver consistent outcomes across diverse market conditions.
- 1:40Learn more at InnovaAM.com.au.
- 1:43All right, guys.
- 1:43So welcome back to the investment series on the Ensemble podcast.
- 1:49Today, I'm chatting to Dan Miles.
- 1:51Dan is from Innova, where he's the co-chief investment officer and managing director over there.
- 1:58So we're going to get deep into investments, talk a bit about portfolios, a bit about human beings and their brains.
- 2:05So Dan, I'm keen to get into it, mate.
- 2:08Yeah, looking forward to it.
- 2:10Why don't we start?
- 2:10Why don't I very quickly, what's your background, Ben?
- 2:14You've got my bio there.
- 2:15What is your bio?
- 2:16Can I look it up and have a read of it?
- 2:18Oh, for sure.
- 2:19So look, a few people would be familiar with that from previous podcasts as one of the co-founders of Ensemble as well, but my business, PivotWell.
- 2:29We're city-based, work with higher income accumulators.
- 2:34This is our 11th year this year.
- 2:36predominantly we're sort of in that sort of Henry market-ish, 30s and 40s primarily.
- 2:42Increasingly, they have more and more assets to manage.
- 2:46And so we've got a team of 11 advisors as of today.
- 2:50And one of my sort of key functions in the business is working with our head of our delivery team and the head of the advice team to help,
- 3:01do things like, you know, structure portfolios.
- 3:04We just had a bit of an emergency session this morning around the, you know, the budget changes and all the fun stuff that the government have been so kind to throw into our laps over the last couple of weeks.
- 3:15And the investments was, you know, was a big chunk of that because, and I'm sure we'll get into it, but, you know, one of the things that I think is increasingly important at the moment is...
- 3:25Obviously, you want to be strategic within the rules that we've got, but now that basically the whole rule book has essentially shifted, I think that being selective with what you're investing into and where you're holding those investments, it's always been important, but I think it's increasingly important.
- 3:42I was saying to our guys that I think it's one of the biggest ways that we can add some really material value into our clients.
- 3:50Yeah.
- 3:50Absolutely.
- 3:51And in fact, that was one of the biggest things that advisors had done because of the amount of value it can add.
- 3:58And now it's even more poignant and needs to be reassessed and needs to be re-looked at.
- 4:02I couldn't agree more.
- 4:03Do you guys utilize, like we refer to the common strategic asset allocation portfolios, conservative balance, moderately conservative balance, et cetera, as traditional because that's traditional and what people have done.
- 4:16Mm-hmm.
- 4:16Do you guys ascribe to that and utilize those as some of the investment solutions for those high net worths?
- 4:26Is it more around trying to achieve a goal and therefore the portfolio might have a mix of that as a core with some other parts because of a certain requirement, whether it's growth or income?
- 4:39I don't like splitting things that way, but anyway, is that how you guys...
- 4:42Yeah, so we largely work around risk profiles, which is essentially the most important part is the split between your growth and your defensive investments and broadly follow the conservative balanced growth, high growth as ASIC tells us to do.
- 4:59But one of the things that we do quite a lot with our clients is to look at
- 5:04look at their global portfolio because clients will typically have, they've got maybe some investments in their own name, then they've got their superannuation, then they've got investment bonds, family trusts, as I jokingly said off camera, at least until last Tuesday, they had family trusts, investment companies as well.
- 5:22And so we are, you know, we're looking for our high growth investors.
- 5:26We're 90% equities and we're, you know, sort of 60-40 Australian international.
- 5:32But, you know,
- 5:33Now, I think it makes even more of a difference where you're holding your Aussie versus where you're holding your international when you look at the return profiles of those investments and, you know, which have franking credits, which don't, which have higher incomes, which are higher growth.
- 5:49And there are different entities because our clients are more in that like sort of like $400,000, $500,000 plus income type level saving at a pretty solid clip.
- 5:57They're building their assets and their investments relatively quickly.
- 6:02And so we know that, you know, getting that structuring right, we still are very passive in our investment approach where, you know, 90 plus percent of our overall client investments would be in index type funds.
- 6:15But being strategic with those index funds and where we put them, yeah.
- 6:20I think makes a big difference, or at least we find makes a big difference overall.
- 6:25How do you guys think about it?
- 6:27How we think that portfolio construction could be probably reinvented or probably rethought of is, well, first of all, as an industry, we've done a terrible job of providing advisors with tools to deliver better advice.
- 6:42We just haven't done it.
- 6:43Everything has come from an investment or insurance institutional landscape and then tried to be slightly tweaked and then forced into an advisory framework.
- 6:52And we think we should be starting advisory framework to begin.
- 6:56There's no one answer to it.
- 6:58One of the solutions I hopefully will get a chance to discuss today is not just the investment component, but how those investments, as you mentioned, in regards to different structures, you might have different goals, different portfolio and different home horizons.
- 7:12how you can put portfolios together that are more relevant to the client and more understandable to the client.
- 7:19And nobody likes to talk about risk because they find it really boring, but clients, most clients who, you know, the majority of the wealth is in people over the age of 50.
- 7:30They're going to have experienced at least the GFC and some of them will remember the tech rack.
- 7:35So to them, losing money, even if it's just on paper, they may not be realized gains, can be very frightening and cause them to do silly things.
- 7:44So we think that one of the solutions that probably would fit better for advisors, not for every client, not for every advice firm, but portfolios that kind of say on the box what kind of risk.
- 8:00They are trying to manage to and not breach whilst always maximizing return.
- 8:07And I think that's probably a more meaningful conversation to the client when you can say, well, you know, they can't guarantee it, but this is because it's definitely not a guarantee, by the way, we're not talking about a guarantee.
- 8:16You know, for this pot of money or in this trust with this so-and-so, with this time horizon, you know, your tolerance, your sleep at night factor, you can't handle seeing a loss on paper of more than an amount.
- 8:28Yeah.
- 8:29For other components where you need to take on more risk because you need to grow some wealth, you need to build some wealth, or you might just want to even if you don't need it, it's this amount.
- 8:40And then for the really longer term stuff, the aspirational stuff, the more relevant risk is things like longevity risk, it's the ability to pass on a bequest, it's...
- 8:50leaving a legacy in its outliving your savings, which is longevity risk.
- 8:57If you want to, it might cause you to do something dumb.
- 8:59So this amount is kind of the threshold at which a portfolio is going to be, is going to try and not over, not breach, whilst always maximizing return.
- 9:10And I think, well, from, I talked to lots of advisors and have done ever since I was an early teenager,
- 9:17advisor generally resonates with a lot better because clients don't care what your asset allocation is.
- 9:22They just want you to get the result.
- 9:23The majority of them don't even know what the hell you're talking about with asset allocation.
- 9:27Most of them don't know why they own equity.
- 9:28They don't know why they own shares apart from, oh, they go up over time and you're like, give them more.
- 9:33How do they go up?
- 9:34That being the case, do what is relevant that they can understand and don't do something that isn't already on the box and spell it out clearly.
- 9:43And on top of that, I think from the institutional framework, institutions hated the idea of bucketing.
- 9:49They hated the idea of compartmentalizing assets and compartmentalizing goals.
- 9:54And so there's been this rhetoric, I think, in the last 15 years that has made advisors try to feel as if they're kind of too old school or inferior if they compartmentalize assets or compartmentalize gold with different assets.
- 10:09The reality is that that's nonsense.
- 10:12Compartmentalizing, having a suite of assets or a portfolio for a specific thing and having two or three or four of them.
- 10:20Whilst it makes the communication of the client a lot easier, it actually taps into a whole bunch of behavioral components of the brain that help clients increase their buy-in and their understanding of what they're doing and how they're doing it.
- 10:35But we as an industry have done a terrible, terrible job of trying to help advisors show that and demonstrate that to clients.
- 10:43And so they had to do it by themselves.
- 10:51portfolio has managed to risk the clients' consumer and compartmentalizing the right way is going to increase the likelihood of GM Gold.
- 10:59Yeah, that's what I was going to say.
- 11:00It's like whether the instos think that it's the right thing to do or not, that's how people think about their money and I'm sure that a lot of the advisors listening would be able to resonate with the fact that
- 11:10When you work with a client and you're building their financial models that often for us as the advisors that you're going, okay, well, they might come to you and they've got money in a savings account here or they've got some equities in different buckets there.
- 11:23But you just go, okay, well, they got this much cash and they got this much equities.
- 11:26And then you build your model and you plan around it.
- 11:29But the clients go, oh, but that money, I had that there for that purpose.
- 11:33Yeah, correct.
- 11:35It's baked into their brain.
- 11:36So it just makes so much sense to be able to do that.
- 11:39And look, I should have probably qualified that I think one of the things that makes our life a little bit easier at Kivot Wealth from an investment perspective is the fact that,
- 11:49Because our clients are all accumulators and they're all aspirational, that means that we haven't had to invest a heap of time in figuring out the right rules around generation.
- 12:00We have had a few clients that have got significant exits from businesses or really large inheritances and we create bespoke approach to generation.
- 12:12Not necessarily as much the investments, which of course we do, but more about like the cash flow management of it all.
- 12:18And, you know, what have we got from an income perspective?
- 12:21What do we've got in that growth bucket?
- 12:23And we probably haven't labeled it in exactly that way, but we absolutely do it.
- 12:29One question, sorry, just that just came to mind as you were saying that last bit, you're talking a bit about longevity risk there.
- 12:35What are your thoughts on the fact that,
- 12:38You see, we've got this business coach and he's right into tech and AI and, you know, all of this different stuff.
- 12:44Every year he goes to this conference and it's like, so they have some big ones in the States and they're talking about all this crazy stuff that happens in the medical space in particular.
- 12:53Yeah.
- 12:53How do you think about longevity risk when they talk about the nanobots are coming and then we're all going to live to where 195 or whatever?
- 13:01Does that factor into portfolios?
- 13:04Because I know for us with clients and particularly in the rare ones that we get in the older sense are like, well, sometimes people are looking to run down their assets.
- 13:12But I feel like that's increasingly risky with all of the advances that we're seeing.
- 13:16Yeah, absolutely.
- 13:17Absolutely.
- 13:17Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 13:19And it's kind of out of trend too.
- 13:21Like, correct me if you don't agree, but I remember the whole where it was kind of celebrated by people in retirement.
- 13:28The boom was going, oh, you know what?
- 13:30You know, spend the retirement savings.
- 13:32I remember seeing there was an ad for something showing the grey nomads and they're like, yeah, we're spending the kids inheritance.
- 13:37Whereas, I don't know, I've seen this distinct trend from feedback with advisors to me because I don't have a book of end clients.
- 13:46I often present in front of them and in groups, but I don't see them day to day.
- 13:50There's this trend that retirees now who have got grandkids, it's less about exhausting the inheritance and enjoying it.
- 13:59It's more about spending it now so they can see the benefit, particularly with their grandkids.
- 14:04And it's not about that exhaustion thing.
- 14:06Now, does longevity risk and the ability to live to 190 play into account?
- 14:11Yeah.
- 14:11Yes, I absolutely think it does.
- 14:14And it needs to be considered.
- 14:15But whether it's 190 or it's 100 or it's something else, the amount of money that somebody's got, the way that they invest...
- 14:22the behaviours that they display are going to always have an enormous impact on where the money can go.
- 14:30And there may be capacity constraints around how long it could last.
- 14:36So outliving your savings is absolutely a potential concern for a lot of clients, but
- 14:43I would say that the vast majority of retirees in Australia right now, and the majority of clients of advisors who are listening in on this at the moment are not in the bucket of, oh, they've got so much money that they don't need to take on risk because it'll last forever anyway.
- 15:01And more of them about, well, I mean, I've done, I've run, I don't know how many models we've done many, many Monte Carlo simulations of them, but you've got less than a million bucks.
- 15:12Yeah.
- 15:12You often have the very frugal, very good with money, very tight people and retirees that are just used to not spending a lot.
- 15:21But then you've got the others that believe that they can spend and the money will just always be there.
- 15:26$700,000, $900,000 for a couple.
- 15:30And their essential spending is probably $70,000, $80,000 a year, something like that, probably more.
- 15:36I don't know how me and my wife could live off that.
- 15:3870, 80 grand a year, even if our kids were independent, and I'd paid off the mortgage.
- 15:42I just can't see how we'd be able to do it.
- 15:47It puts the ask for standards into perspective.
- 15:49I look at those numbers and just think, how is that working?
- 15:53Well, to be honest, well, I'll come back to that because it's a good point.
- 15:58But then it's more about, well, your money on average will probably only last to $79.
- 16:03Give or take could be as soon as $74.
- 16:07It might last until $81, $82.
- 16:10And it's less about could you live to be $190 and we need to plan for that.
- 16:15because that's an unknown.
- 16:17It's an outside probability and it's not within your control.
- 16:22Planning for it is within your control, but it might not be possible.
- 16:25What is probably more relevant, more prevalent, is that whole, well, your money with current spending and how you're invested in your current behaviours, you're likely to run out a day before you turn 80.
- 16:37So the risk is that you live beyond 80, which is a very high probability.
- 16:40Right.
- 16:41or you live beyond age six or whatever.
- 16:43And so that should always be, I believe, incorporated into conversations because we kind of went down a path for a little while there where everything was about sequencing risk and people were trying to describe what sequencing risk was and drawdowns and therefore focused on the income and da-da-da-da-da-da.
- 16:57But sequencing risk and longevity risk are hand in hand because it might be all well and good that a glide path option that's out there puts you in more defensive, and I hate that word defensive, put you in defensive assets over time.
- 17:09Yeah, okay, fantastic.
- 17:10So when the market draws down, you don't draw down as much and you're not taking the money out or spending, it's not there to bounce back, fine.
- 17:27white bread and tin beans and the age pension, which is just not comfortable.
- 17:36It's just not a great outcome.
- 17:38And so the two of them should always be thought of and addressed together.
- 17:40And I think the – well, not I think.
- 17:43I know.
- 17:45This is rooted in science.
- 17:46The compartmentalization idea of having assets for golds that may be to focus on this in the shorter term, but this component, markets moving around, markets crashing, Donald Trump blowing things up and causing volatility.
- 18:02That's not the kind of risk you need to worry about.
- 18:04The risk is that you could outlive your money and always think about that.
- 18:08That's why that's there.
- 18:09So year on year on year, month on month, week on week, it's irrelevant what is going on inside there.
- 18:14The main thing is that it needs to grow enough so that if you are healthy and you do well, that you'll still have some money left over.
- 18:21And the age pension stuff, it's bizarre that you get, like I just cannot imagine people who are in the process of about to retire, people from Gen X and probably Gen Y, being able to live off anything close to the age pension.
- 18:33But I do know people that...
- 18:35And retirees who have grown up and learned to be quite frugal who don't spend enough and often advise that to convince them, no, you're going to be okay.
- 18:44You can spend this and enjoy this.
- 18:46There's no quite accumulating it.
- 18:48Yes, your family and offspring or whoever you decide are going to benefit from it.
- 18:54But you should still at least be able to enjoy the later years of your life.
- 18:58That's a very long-winded answer to your 190-year question.
- 19:01Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:02No, no, no.
- 19:02I get it.
- 19:03We see this a lot with clients where it's like – and I would agree with you that I think that the majority of people probably spend – they find it easier to spend money than to not spend money.
- 19:12But then you do have that subset that they need to really be pushed to do that.
- 19:16I find that with older people as well, sometimes younger people as well because like the –
- 19:21the fire movement and the people that get sort of swept up in all of that.
- 19:25And I think it's got a lot of great – there are a lot of great elements to that.
- 19:28But you see people that really take it to the extreme.
- 19:30And I know we've had conversations with clients who go, when you model things out, you go, your trajectory is so strong.
- 19:37Do you really want to only have a holiday every three years just so that you can get an even bigger number?
- 19:44Because sort of why?
- 19:45Why are you doing it?
- 19:47Yeah, why?
- 19:48And it comes in that –
- 19:49Yeah, look, I'll tie back to the compartmentalizing thing, how that works and how you can have that conversation with them and show them they'll be fine.
- 19:58And then also why I think managing a portfolio to risk and not having a single definition of risk, having multiple definitions of risk that are relevant for the client actually makes, I think, a lot more sense and should be easier conversations between an advisor and the client.
- 20:13Yeah.
- 20:14The compartmentalizing thing, if you want to, if you are dealing with someone who's retired, if you're not dealing with someone pre-retirement, but it's just as valid to them, I'll just try zero in and make an example that's useful for the listener.
- 20:29If you've got those clients that you have trouble getting to spend or they spend too much or they're nervous or they watch markets too frequently, by having assets there relevant to the goals they've got and the amount of risk they need to take,
- 20:45balanced with the amount they can tolerate, blocking them up into time horizons to match those goals taps into elements of the human brain that help reinforce it or potentially blow it up.
- 20:58So you'd mentioned that you had followed that and you'd been more focused on the cash flow management, complaining, etc.
- 21:05There hasn't been many scientific tools that have been provided to advisors and there hasn't been a huge amount of science that's published on this, but I think it's pretty easy to understand that
- 21:14You can't predict the future.
- 21:15No one can.
- 21:16Clients especially know and feel uncomfortable.
- 21:19That's why they're uncomfortable because they don't know what's going to happen in the future.
- 21:22If you provide them some form of structure, perceived or otherwise, if they get an idea of structure and that there's some kind of structure in amongst this chaos, they're far more likely to anchor to it and feel more comfortable and far less likely to run off and do their own thing because it's so uncertain.
- 21:40So that's what's called a framing effect.
- 21:43On top of that, as you mentioned, clients have goals and say, oh, but I've got those for that and I've got those for that.
- 21:48That's mental accounting.
- 21:50And it's just easy for us to think and go, that's linked to that.
- 21:54And if you combine the two together, framing, and you've got this suite of assets slash portfolio for these goals, you combine that strategy.
- 22:03structure in a world of uncertainty, which makes them more comfortable and increases buy-in with the fact that we think in terms of mental accounting and owning this to offset that, it's actually an embedded implied asset liability matching type thing that pension funds do for their own future liabilities, which humans do by accident without knowing that they do it.
- 22:27I always use the word hijacked.
- 22:30It's not hijacked.
- 22:31You can use that to your benefit by framing, okay, over these time horizons, you've got these requirements, may just be you need this much to live on.
- 22:42We need to generate that amount of income like you mentioned, and we need to do the cash flows around that.
- 22:49And that's a bucket, a compartment, a goal allocated to it.
- 22:55And if it is then managed in a way that is like, look, it's managed to this amount of market volatility, hold it for this period of time, get this amount of income, own these kind of assets that you can be secure about.
- 23:10That should theoretically be the main focus or that's what the advisor says, look, you just need to look at that and worry about that.
- 23:16But if the risk is longevity risk or it's the ability to pass on a request or a future tax at an event or whatever the case may be, this part, the risk is that we can't achieve that goal, not markets bouncing around.
- 23:30But I know that you'd freak out if we had less than X, Y, and Z.
- 23:34So, Orfolio has managed to that risk, to that market risk, and clients are...
- 23:39understand it.
- 23:40It's much easier to understand how much losses are than that is to understand volatility.
- 23:46And it's there to grow over time.
- 23:48That's the part that we worry about in the longer term.
- 23:52You've combined those things together in terms of goals, framing, referencing for the client, increasing the likelihood of their buy-in.
- 24:00and combine together not only human behavior, but hopefully decent asset management where people are managing two risks that are the type of things that cause clients to blow up and move and go and do something.
- 24:13For sure.
- 24:14I was just going to ask, what are the most common like buckets or goals that you say you're attaching your investments and all your buckets of money to particular goals?
- 24:26And you've mentioned some there around income, but like you see inside a lot of advice businesses, what are the most common ones or the ones that you think are most relevant that people should be thinking about?
- 24:35The most common is the short-term income requirement, often funded through cash or term deposits.
- 24:45Although since we had zero interest rate policy post-COVID and in Australia and pre-COVID overseas, and you've had the bond volatility of 2022, and TDs are not paying jackal.
- 24:58People are kind of a little bit hamstrung there, but generally just, like I say, cash,
- 25:02allocation bucket to say this will fund your income for however long.
- 25:06Then the other component, the simplest thing is that people just put it into another portfolio that in some way balances out a tolerance, et cetera.
- 25:14What I think is more relevant is not as popular.
- 25:19is to think about goals in terms of duration and importance.
- 25:24And if it resonates with people, the way we've kind of talked about it, we've actually talked about it irrespective of what age you are.
- 25:31You can be 70 or you can be 45, but it's kind of safety, lifestyle, and future goals.
- 25:39or aspirational component.
- 25:41And the safety component is that income.
- 25:44It is that you need to get this sort of income.
- 25:47It is not negotiable.
- 25:49So that's what we need to do.
- 25:51And that'll be a function of how much you need and how much you've got to allocate to it.
- 25:55If we're talking in terms of finances, if we're talking in terms of somebody who's your or my age, it's safety is the ability to, depending on your own family dynamic, but it's the ability to put a roof over yours and your family's head and put food on the table or clothes on their back.
- 26:14The ability to earn a wage, right?
- 26:16Income protection.
- 26:17It's an insurance conversation.
- 26:19Then you've got lifestyle, which is we're comfortable.
- 26:21We like this kind of lifestyle.
- 26:24If our income is protected, say the whole safety thing, I can make sure that we don't starve.
- 26:29What do we do to maintain our lifestyle?
- 26:30Well, it's not necessarily about what you can do to maintain.
- 26:33It's what you prevent from destroying it.
- 26:36And that could be death, TPD, et cetera.
- 26:39Again, it's the insurance compensation.
- 26:40That's why you have insurance on the house.
- 26:43And then about the aspirations and the future component, that's probably their superannuation.
- 26:47But you can talk about those three buckets with someone who's retired.
- 26:51I've had advisors say, oh, they just, all they care about is their income, that they meet their income requirements.
- 26:56I'm like, cool, but they're 66.
- 26:58What if they live to 90?
- 26:59Like maybe not 190, but what if they live to 90, right?
- 27:02Yeah.
- 27:03So you've got very different time horizons.
- 27:06They would have no tolerance for volatility around their capital or their income in the short term, none whatsoever.
- 27:13However, they, like we're talking about before, longevity risk, may not have anywhere near enough to be able to lift to 90 if they just leave it all in cash.
- 27:21So we need to do something with that.
- 27:23You can talk about your safety bucket.
- 27:25You can talk about your lifestyle bucket, which is, you know, you can take some market risk because you're going to get
- 27:31over the longer term, so uplift, which will potentially improve your lifestyle and make things more comfortable.
- 27:37And then what do you want in the future in terms of managing longevity risk or passing something on or having some money left over, spending money on your grandkids, et cetera?
- 27:48That's how we've talked about it.
- 27:49It's not the most popular way to do things, but it just fits and feels kind of sensible to me because it doesn't matter what I do.
- 27:56That makes a lot of sense.
- 27:58Product relevant.
- 27:58There's no product relevance.
- 28:00It's client relevance and then you go and find what to solve the problem.
- 28:04Yeah, look, that's a similar approach and good to know that I'm hearing from the expert that it's sort of around the money.
- 28:09But in the cases where we've done it with clients, what we typically do is that we will have cash and defensive investments, which is that income, one to two years of income
- 28:21Then we typically have equities that were ideally in a perfect world that equity income is enough to replenish that year's worth money.
- 28:30And then if we hold two years of cash or cash-ish, and then we know that every year that the equities are giving us another year to top it up, then that means that you've got this constant cycle that keeps sort of filling up the bucket.
- 28:44We have only done it though with people where they had like significant money.
- 28:49So they probably weren't in that position where they were looking at it saying, well, we need to have some level that's going to sort of do more to cover off that longevity risk or whatever.
- 29:01But for us, we found that that makes practical sense and it's a model that seems to resonate for clients as well.
- 29:10One question, and I don't know, maybe the answer to this is that there isn't anything, but again, being someone that's seen inside a lot of businesses, any other tricks you have or interesting sort of approach that you've seen?
- 29:25Because I think, and I know that you're a big advocate for this as well, that one of the biggest destroyers of value and investment returns for clients is typically their own behavior and their behavior at home.
- 29:36I'm so glad you said that.
- 29:37Listeners, we did not have a pre-meeting and agree that's what we're going to talk about.
- 29:43Because I've been up talking about unidestructive behavior at every ensemble, everything I've ever been invited to.
- 29:49Good man.
- 29:49Sorry, keep going.
- 29:50I just, that's all.
- 29:51I was just going to say, do you, you know, any other, like I said, like sort of maybe trick is the wrong word, but, you know, hacks that you've used to maybe channel out clients to not make those dumb decisions that destroy the value in their referrals?
- 30:06That's the, that, that dovetails into why I think that portfolios manage to very specific market risk definitions are super relevant and super useful.
- 30:18They're just one way.
- 30:19I've got a whole bunch of techniques you can use because humans are subject to a whole bunch of things because of the way that our brains evolved.
- 30:27In fact, I'm going to be talking about that at the end.
- 30:29ALPD session in Queensland on the 28th of May about why people, in particular, when there's lots of concerning news and things going on, clients and often advisors feel like when they're told you don't need to do anything, that's like the worst answer.
- 30:49They're just not comfortable.
- 30:50They just feel they need to do something.
- 30:51That's actually embedded in the brain and embedded in a...
- 30:56a primitive component that has evolved over time.
- 30:59Well, our brain has not.
- 31:00Sorry, a primitive component that has not evolved over time was useful, but we have evolved in the situation as well.
- 31:06The most common value destructive behavior that I see and have asked and told advisors is not necessarily overconfidence.
- 31:15It's not necessarily FOMO.
- 31:18It's more loss aversion, which the academic literature backs.
- 31:22And that is when people freak out when things go down beyond the threat.
- 31:27But they haven't been told what threshold is.
- 31:29So the reason why I think – well, no, one of the reasons why I think a traditional approach to portfolio construction, just having reasonably fixed asset allocations, which, by the way, is not a requirement of ASIC,
- 31:42reasonably fixed asset allocations.
- 31:45It just doesn't make any sense because whilst they, on average, over the long term, might end up being bang on what the client's overall tolerance for risk is, the client's tolerance for risk is in the moment.
- 31:59What's happening then and there?
- 32:01telling and forcing and teaching a viable in the last 30 years that they have to try and talk people through it that's coming in the market and da-da-da, as opposed to actually building stuff that targets that and does everything it can within its power not to breach it while still maximizing returns.
- 32:17The first version is just the easy answer for instos.
- 32:20The second version is not easy.
- 32:21It's hard to do and you can't get it 100% right.
- 32:24But if it is done appropriately, you can tell the client what kind of threshold is there, what the likelihood of having a loss is, what the magnitude of a normal loss would be if it's not like a GFC or TechRate.
- 32:37If they're super technical, they're an ex-engineer, you can talk to them about volatility, though.
- 32:42I don't think there'd be a single advisor in the country that wants to sit around and talk about the explanation, volatility, or then even the derivation of semi-deviation.
- 32:50That would just be dumb.
- 32:51But if you do...
- 32:51I'm sure there'd be a couple.
- 32:52There's probably Warren Strybel, should I say, who'd be into that.
- 32:57I...
- 32:58Send a mile away to my team.
- 32:59They're going to absolutely have a conversation.
- 33:01We can talk about how semi-deviation downside volatility is not quite the same as the volatility of things when they're losing money.
- 33:09Anyway, but if you build the portfolio about those risk tolerances, nobody likes talking about risk.
- 33:16But if those are the most value-destructive behaviors, not doing them in the first place and telling clients in clear language this is what they're managing too,
- 33:28The vast majority of the time, the clients are more comfortable.
- 33:30It just, it kind of works.
- 33:32And it's why I think the SAA structure, even with a dynamic overlay, makes a whole lot of sense.
- 33:40And the maths has evolved and the testing has evolved and the evidence has evolved to show that we can manage to risk via asset allocation far more effectively effectively.
- 33:51In fact, if I could get anyone who knows and could get their head around it, whether it's at a licensee level or a PI insurer level and preferably treasury or ASIC,
- 34:03The whole idea of minimum and maximum bans in an SAA is to try to manage risk.
- 34:08But the actual asset itself is not the risk.
- 34:11The amount of risk associated with it changes based on price.
- 34:14This is just a ham-fisted way of trying to make sure the clients don't have too much risk by controlling the minis and maxes that they can allocate to.
- 34:24In reality, what you're trying to do is deliver a solution that does not take on more risk than the client said that they could.
- 34:31And no one's been sued for this, or no one's been called in front of us for this, but make sure you don't not take the amount of risk or the amount of capital market risk or inflation risk or whatever it is that they need to be able to achieve their goals in the future.
- 34:49But if you manage portfolios to those risk components so that you get an outcome that is managed within what it is you said, who cares what the min and max bands are?
- 34:58Who cares what the baseline anchored portfolio allocation to equities is?
- 35:05As long as you're managing that risk, it actually satisfies the crime and not putting in too much risk.
- 35:10I think that the clients probably shouldn't care, but I think it is drilled into advisors so much and largely coming down the line from ASIC, obviously, that it's like, that's how you do it.
- 35:22That's what you're supposed to do.
- 35:23The licensees are all doing the same.
- 35:25Even for self-licensed companies like ours, it's like you've still got the compliance people that it's like that is the safe path, but 100% it's not.
- 35:33I heard a personal question last week where there was a whole bunch of stuff from an ex-ASIC member who was saying a lot of the stuff that you're getting from compliance is not a requirement of ASIC.
- 35:44It's an overreaction by compliance, but it's actually restricting the tailorability of results to clients.
- 35:51And this is a perfect example.
- 35:53It does come from the institutional landscape.
- 35:55That's exactly where it comes from because that's what is built for the pension funds and has been since the 60s to deliver a result that kind of works on average for the most things they can.
- 36:08And so advisors have been drilled into it and told that's what they need to do and that's how to go about doing it because that's what happened at the institutional level.
- 36:16No institution set up, no pension fund, no sovereign wealth fund, no whatever.
- 36:21was ever set up to deliver a result that is client-specific to their circumstances sitting down in front of them.
- 36:28That's exactly what advice is and what they do every day.
- 36:31And so it needs to be written there.
- 36:32We'll start from the beginning.
- 36:34I agree.
- 36:34It's an interesting conversation to have with our compliance team, for sure.
- 36:38Dan, my last question for you, and thank you for sharing all those insights.
- 36:43But last question is, obviously, there's a lot going on in the world at the moment.
- 36:46And you sort of touched on it a little bit before.
- 36:49What are some of the trends that you're seeing?
- 36:50And what do you think advisors should be thinking about as they're helping their client?
- 36:55Obviously, you know, bucketing and psychology and, you know, being smart with how we're guiding things.
- 37:00But particularly with where the world is and investment markets are today, what do you think, you know, should be most front of mind for advisors right now?
- 37:07This is a hard one because the common modeling tools advisors have don't take this into account.
- 37:14Very simple concept.
- 37:15Any asset you buy is worth something in the future.
- 37:18The problem is you don't know what it's going to be worth.
- 37:20Everyone has a guess and some people are better than others.
- 37:22No one knows.
- 37:23That being the case, if you pay more for it today, then the amount you're going to earn is less.
- 37:28If you pay less for it today, the amount you're going to earn is going to be more, right?
- 37:33Okay.
- 37:33The best proxy you've got for that, given you can't predict the future, is valuation.
- 37:37And by the way, do not use price to earnings, whether it's price to forecast earnings or price to last year's earnings or utilized earnings.
- 37:44I don't use PE when I talk about valuation.
- 37:47But the price being paid at the moment for most assets or for a lot of assets, especially the big markets in the equity markets, is not cheap.
- 37:54So the forecast returns are lower.
- 37:57Bonds, people think that 4% or 5% bond yield is really high.
- 38:01Anyone with lots of gray hair would look back and think bonds at 6% or below is the outlier, not the norm, because they just were never had a yield that low.
- 38:13credit's not paying an enormous amount unless you take on way too much risk.
- 38:17And so that being the case, your future returns are lower and asset consultants or researchers or whatever come out and say it all the time, just keep it in mind when you're talking to clients about realistic assumptions and strategies.
- 38:30Even like a debt recycling strategy might say, this is hugely valuable and beneficial to you, but the interest cost versus how much we could potentially earn might not be the best trade-off right now.
- 38:41perfect strategy.
- 38:42It'll be excellent for you.
- 38:44But now's not the best environment in which to do it.
- 38:47That's me trying to use a practical example, not being an advisor, but hoping that it makes some sense.
- 38:53That's what I think is a serious concern.
- 38:55That and Trump won't be in power forever.
- 39:00both sides of the coin doesn't mean that it'll be written in the stone where people are acting like it is yeah yeah it's definitely it's interesting times out there and i think it sort of highlights the fact that it's more important you know that the the uh the government over here throwing us some curveballs around our uh you know our rule book for clients as well so mate i'm i'm uh i'm excited to to see the alpd and and dive even deeper fantastic awesome
- 39:25Thank you, Ben, and appreciate the questions, and hopefully I made sense to the listeners and they enjoyed it and it was engaging.
- 39:32That's great.
- 39:33Well, cheers, guys.
- 39:35Enjoy and be safe, happy investing, and we'll see you at the ALPD.