Latest / So That's Why / Why Do We Get Wrinkles and What Actually Causes Them?
Transcript
- 0:04Jen: Welcome to the So That's Why podcast, where we unpack the
- 0:07science behind everyday questions.
- 0:09I'm Jen.
- 0:10Chris: I'm Chris.
- 0:11Matt: And I'm Matt.
- 0:12Jen: Okay, so here's a question for you.
- 0:14When you spot a new line on your face in the mirror, what do you blame?
- 0:20Um, I mean, it's not something I experience, but hey.
- 0:22Matt: Obviously.
- 0:26Jen: Nearly all of us, though, we will blame aging, but the science
- 0:31says the calendar is mostly innocent.
- 0:33So why do we get wrinkles?
- 0:36Matt: Y- hang on, so the calendar is mostly innocent.
- 0:40Jen: Mm-hmm.
- 0:41Matt: You can't just say that and then carry on.
- 0:42I've spent my whole life assuming wrinkles are time doing its thing,
- 0:47or maybe stress caused by the kids.
- 0:49I don't know.
- 0:51Chris: Well, Father Time does play a part, it's fair to say.
- 0:54Uh, but when researchers try and pin down what actually causes the lines
- 0:59we see on our face, the biggest single factor isn't birthdays at all, um, it's
- 1:03sunlight, with estimates putting at least 80% of visible aging, uh, that we
- 1:09see on our faces down to sun exposure.
- 1:12Jen: Which actually means then that most of what we treat as inevitable is
- 1:17something happening to your skin, not just something ticking away inside.
- 1:23Matt: So you're telling me then, the thing that I've been passing off as just getting
- 1:27older, uh, is mostly the sun exposure with no cream on, convinced I was, you
- 1:32know, tanning or Captain Invincible.
- 1:34Chris: Mm. Well, looking like a spring chicken as you do, Matt, you clearly got
- 1:37away- … with all of that sun exposure.
- 1:39Matt: Oh, you smooth talker.
- 1:40Chris: Um I know.
- 1:42Uh, but yes, some of those hideous tanning rituals that people had back in the '80s
- 1:46and '90s, they've got a lot to answer for when it comes to premature aging.
- 1:51Jen: Okay, before we get into the how, it's worth knowing, like, the speed
- 1:56of the process, because it's actually a slower process than people picture.
- 2:01So from your late 20s, your skin's collagen, which is the main structural
- 2:05protein, that starts dropping by around one to 1.5% a year.
- 2:11Matt: It doesn't sound like a whole great deal though, does it, one to 1.5% a year?
- 2:14Jen: Mm.
- 2:15Chris: It doesn't when you look at it in a singular way, but that's one year.
- 2:18Uh, but of course it compounds, so if you're shedding a percent or
- 2:22so annually over, like, 30 years, that's a huge share of your collagen
- 2:26that you're losing in that time.
- 2:28Jen: Yeah, and that's just the slow background hum that happens to
- 2:31everyone, you know, whatever they do.
- 2:34But the reason, like, two people the same age can look a decade apart is mostly down
- 2:40to what's been layered on top of that hum.
- 2:43Matt: So I reckon then some people will feel a little called out here.
- 2:47Um, uh, maybe me.
- 2:49I… Lots of people think a fortnight frying on the beach counts as self-care.
- 2:53Jen: Mm.
- 2:53Chris: Yep.
- 2:54I'd say that applies to a large percentage of people.
- 2:56And let's be honest, there are benefits of, of going in the sun ain't th- And
- 2:58chilling out on holiday, but, um- Yeah,
- 3:00Jen: definitely
- 3:00… Chris: yeah, you gotta put the captain sensible bit on-
- 3:03and be careful.
- 3:04Um, but the, the good news, which we'll get into, is that the biggest
- 3:08lever in all of this is actually the easiest one to put right.
- 3:11Jen: We love, we love stuff like that, don't we?
- 3:14Matt: We do, Jen, we do.
- 3:15Absolutely.
- 3:16Jen: Okay, so let's go under the surface of the skin because this is where
- 3:22it gets scientifically satisfying.
- 3:24Matt: Love that phrase.
- 3:25Chris: There's no
- 3:26Jen: better satisfaction- Probably not one you've ever said before-
- 3:29… Matt: but hey.
- 3:30Scientifically
- 3:31Jen: satisfying.
- 3:31Okay.
- 3:32So wrinkles don't form in the bit of the skin that you see.
- 3:36They form in the layer beneath that, the dermis.
- 3:40Matt: So the visible crease, uh, is what I see, but the real
- 3:44action is, uh, a layer down.
- 3:46So what's actually going on there?
- 3:48Chris: Yeah, so there are three things mainly, and it's probably
- 3:50worth naming them properly.
- 3:52So as Jen mentioned, we've got collagen, which is the, the protein that gives
- 3:56skin its firmness and tensile strength.
- 3:58It's almost like the kinda scaffolding that holds the skin up.
- 4:01Then we have elastin, th- another well-known protein, and this is a separate
- 4:04protein that lets skin kind of stretch and spring back, hence the elastic part- Mm
- 4:09of the elastin name.
- 4:11And another one that's well-known is hyaluronic acid, and this
- 4:15is a molecule that holds water together into the cells and keeps
- 4:19the whole lay- skin layers plump.
- 4:21Jen: So in young skin, like ours, Those three are, like, dense, organized,
- 4:27and they're constantly renewed.
- 4:29So collagen is the one, like you said, doing most of the structural
- 4:33work, and it's actually the most abundant protein in the whole body.
- 4:37Matt: Okay, so firmness, stretch, and plumpness, which is a great word,
- 4:42plumpness- … um, are three separate jobs with three separate molecules
- 4:47Chris: Yep, and what makes and maintains all three is a single
- 4:50kind of cell called the fibroblast-
- 4:52Jen: Sounds tough, that, doesn't it?
- 4:53Chris: It does.
- 4:54I mean-
- 4:54Jen: Fibroblast.
- 4:55I,
- 4:56Chris: I don't know, it sounds a bit like a film, but Fibroblast 2-
- 4:58The Skin's Revenge.
- 5:03Um, again, I've lost my train of thought.
- 5:05Um, so- That's unlike you … in young skin, fibroblasts are productive, and
- 5:10what they're doing is they're laying down fresh collagen and elastin about
- 5:13as fast as the old stuff is wearing out.
- 5:15Jen: So two things change that as we age, and this is, like,
- 5:19at the heart of it really.
- 5:20So first is a growing share of fibroblasts, they become senescent, which
- 5:26means they largely, like, stop producing.
- 5:29They don't clear away, and they start giving off low-level inflammatory signals
- 5:34that degrade the tissue around them.
- 5:36I bet you've never said senescent before, have you?
- 5:38Matt: I was just thinking, it's just a word that I've not used.
- 5:40Senescent.
- 5:41Jen: Put that on your Scrabble list.
- 5:44Matt: I've said this before on previous episodes, I'm not
- 5:45playing Scrabble with you two-
- 5:46you cheat.
- 5:47Um, so the cells then that are meant to be maintaining the place sort
- 5:52of zone out, and then they seem to do a bit of harm on the way.
- 5:56Jen: Mm.
- 5:57Chris: They do, and then the second change is, um, a family of enzymes called MMPs.
- 6:04Matt: Military police?
- 6:05Jen: MPs? No, MMPs?
- 6:07Chris: I was, yeah, I was gonna try and get away with this one.
- 6:09MMPs are matrix metalloproteinases.
- 6:12But, but we'll call them- Bless you … MMPs for short, okay?
- 6:15Um, and the, the normal job of MMPs is useful because they clear
- 6:19out worn collagen so that fresh collagen can replace it, and in
- 6:23young skin, their activity is held in careful balance, but it's fair
- 6:27to say it's not the case as we age.
- 6:29Matt: Mm.
- 6:29Jen: So I'll give something for the fact fans.
- 6:31Chris: Yes.
- 6:32Jen: I did my PhD in snake venoms, and actually, a lot of snake venoms contain
- 6:38metalloproteinases, and when they get the, you know, a snake bites and the
- 6:43metalloproteinases get injected into the skin, they wreak havoc 'cause they
- 6:47just degrade everything, so you end up with, like, massive swelling, bleeding.
- 6:52Awful
- 6:53Matt: Awful
- 6:54Jen: Give you all that one for free.
- 6:55Matt: Thanks for that.
- 6:56Jen: So we- Dr. Jen.
- 6:57Yeah.
- 6:59To prove that I am a real doctor.
- 7:02Not a fake one as people think.
- 7:06So yeah, so with age, the balance of, um, what you talked about, Chris, that
- 7:12tips, so the MMP activity, it climbs, and that is often, like, switched on by
- 7:17the sun and by inflammation, so while new collagen production slows, um, so
- 7:24breakdown starts to outpace repair.
- 7:27Matt: So the skin suddenly doesn't fail then, uh, it just loses,
- 7:32uh, that repair, doesn't it?
- 7:34It, it, it doesn't, it doesn't work, so the one-sentence version being what?
- 7:38I don't know, collagen comes apart faster than the body can put it back together?
- 7:41Jen: Mm.
- 7:42Chris: That's it almost word for word.
- 7:43You're a biologist.
- 7:44Woo-hoo.
- 7:44We, we knew it.
- 7:45Matt: I'm getting so smart doing these podcasts.
- 7:46He's a
- 7:47Chris: graduate now.
- 7:48Absolutely.
- 7:48Um, so collagen and elastin get broken down and disorganized faster than the
- 7:53fibroblasts rebuild them, as Matt, you were saying very eloquently.
- 7:56Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 7:56And as a result, the dermis thins and loses its spring, and the
- 8:00surface above, which is no longer fully supported, settles into these
- 8:04kind of fine lines and wrinkles and
- 8:06Jen: crinkles.
- 8:06It sounds very gentle, that, doesn't it?
- 8:08Settles into lines.
- 8:10Chris: It
- 8:10Jen: does.
- 8:10Doesn't look quite as gentle on your face, but hey.
- 8:13Chris: No, I hope the, uh, the filters are good on these cameras.
- 8:17The soft effect filter.
- 8:20Jen: So we mentioned sunlight before, and this is where it comes in,
- 8:24because it dries the same imbalance, but harder than anything else does.
- 8:29Matt: So go on then, because I still can't picture really how
- 8:32sunshine reaches a whole layer down and does structural damage.
- 8:37Jen: Mm.
- 8:38Chris: Yeah, so when ultraviolet light hits the skin, it generates
- 8:41a burst of unstable molecules that are called free radicals.
- 8:45Matt: Great band name.
- 8:46Jen: Yeah.
- 8:47Is a great band name.
- 8:47The Free Radicals.
- 8:48Chris: Yeah.
- 8:48Matt: Ooh.
- 8:48I was thinking Unstable Molecules.
- 8:51That's a great band name.
- 8:52That, that's, that's
- 8:52Chris: the album name, The Free Radicals.
- 8:54You know, the, the tricky second album.
- 8:57Yeah.
- 8:57You know, the Unstable Molecules.
- 8:57I
- 8:57Jen: feel like we need to do this as a side hustle.
- 9:01Matt: I, you don't want me in a band.
- 9:03Not if you want people to listen to it, that's all I'm saying.
- 9:08Chris: So anyway, when these free radicals form, within minutes they
- 9:12switch on these MMPs, the very enzymes that break collagen down.
- 9:16So each unprotected sunny hour is a small spike of collagen loss.
- 9:23Jen: And it does a second thing at the same time, so it quietens the signal that
- 9:27tells fibroblasts to make new collagen.
- 9:29So the sun speeds up the breakdown and slows the repair in, like, one
- 9:34move, which is why it accounts for so much of what we see on the skin.
- 9:39Matt: Yeah.
- 9:39So the sun isn't aging our skin in some vague way, it seems to be
- 9:43driving the two exact processes you've both just described- Mm … at both
- 9:49ends, which kind of makes it feel, I guess, less like fate and something
- 9:53that we can actually deal with.
- 9:54Jen: Mm.
- 9:55Chris: Yeah, that's it, and of course it's cumulative, so no single afternoon
- 9:58matters much, but the damage banks up over decades, which is why heavily
- 10:03sun-worn skin looks the way it looks.
- 10:06Jen: And this is probably a good moment to say that not all wrinkles
- 10:08are the same, because it explains why one fix never works for everything.
- 10:14Matt: I did wonder about that, actually.
- 10:16The lines on my forehead feel like a different thing from the ones
- 10:19maybe starting around my eyes.
- 10:21Chris: Yeah, and, and they really are.
- 10:23So some are what we call dynamic wrinkles, so they're made by muscles folding the
- 10:28skin every time you frown or smile, whereas others are static, so from a
- 10:33s- they're from a structural loss that we've been describing, and they sit
- 10:38there even when your face is still.
- 10:41Jen: And then there are sleep wrinkles, which are almost funny, so- But, you
- 10:45know, if you press your face into a pillow the same way for seven hours a night for
- 10:50years, those creases can eventually set.
- 10:54Matt: Yeah, so the pillow crease that usually fades by 11:00 in the
- 10:58morning, given enough time, will become permanent on my face, which is,
- 11:02if I'm honest, not great if you see my face first thing in the morning.
- 11:06Chris: Mm-hmm.
- 11:07I think you do yourself an injustice.
- 11:09I thought your camera filter really is quite good.
- 11:12Matt: Let's go with that.
- 11:14Chris: Now, as always, there's, um, there's real individual variation on top
- 11:18of all of this, so how much protective pigment your skin makes is largely
- 11:22down to genetics, but that protective pigment strongly affects how much
- 11:26UV gets through and does the damage.
- 11:29Jen: And hormones matter enormously, too.
- 11:31So around menopause, when estrogen falls, women can lose up to about
- 11:3630% of their skin's collagen in roughly the first five years.
- 11:41Matt: 30%, that's not 1% a year.
- 11:43That's a proper drop rate.
- 11:44Jen: I know.
- 11:45Chris: It really is, and it isn't talked about n- anywhere nearly enough, is it?
- 11:49Um, because by the age of 50, you can have lost nearly 50% of your collagen.
- 11:53And of course, as we just mentioned, a lot of it's accelerated during that,
- 11:56that kind of the early menopausal years.
- 11:59Um, and with- when it comes to estrogen, it directly supports collagen
- 12:03production, so when that estrogen falls away, a lot of that structural change
- 12:08arrives in that very short, small window, which is just not fair, is it?
- 12:12Jen: No, it's really not.
- 12:14And while we're talking about the popular stuff- Yeah … like
- 12:17menopause, can we talk about the thing that half the internet is currently
- 12:21drinking, collagen supplements?
- 12:23Matt: Dun, dun, dun.
- 12:24I was hoping you'd get to those because I'm betting there's a
- 12:28whole bunch of people with tubs of this stuff in their cupboards
- 12:31in houses up and down the country.
- 12:34So give it to us straight, guys.
- 12:36Chris: Yeah.
- 12:36So let's be fair to the, the kind of evidence out there, or lack of.
- 12:40Um, so for the kind of pre-made kinds that you swallow or, you know, the
- 12:45collagen drinks, a recent pooled analysis of 23, like, peer-reviewed, um, trials
- 12:53showed that the strongest independent studies don't actually show a clear
- 12:56effect on wrinkles or elasticity.
- 12:58Jen: And the reason, though, it's less damning than it sounds.
- 13:01Your gut can't absorb collagen whole, so it breaks it down into amino acids first.
- 13:08So r- you're really just taking in the building blocks the long way around.
- 13:12Matt: So it's less drink collagen, build collagen, and more drink
- 13:16collagen, break it into pieces-
- 13:18and let your body decide what to build.
- 13:21Jen: Mm.
- 13:21Chris: Yeah, and an important point here is that collagen is
- 13:24not always actually collagen.
- 13:26So when we talk about collagen drinks or supplements, they're usually or
- 13:30almost always hydrolyzed collagen, and that's because, as we mentioned,
- 13:34h- um, collagen itself can't be absorbed, so the hydrolysis breaks
- 13:37that collagen down into its amino acid components, which can be absorbed.
- 13:42So i- it's really important to understand what a collagen supplement actually is.
- 13:46Mm. Um, now we've taken this thinking into the volagen formula that we've
- 13:50developed, which it does the same thing.
- 13:52So we've got the amino acid components of collagen in the same structure and ratio,
- 13:58which is the same as hydrolyzed collagen.
- 14:00Um, just we do it from a plant source, not an animal source.
- 14:03Sorry for the little plug, but, you know, we've put a lot of research into it.
- 14:06Jen: Yeah.
- 14:07Matt: Plug away.
- 14:09Jen: We- and there's a, you know, the fair caveat is that raw materials are only ever
- 14:14part of it because the bigger lever is slowing the breakdown in the first place.
- 14:20Matt: Yeah, so the building blocks are worth having, aren't they?
- 14:22They're not just the whole thing.
- 14:24So what's the stuff then with really solid evidence?
- 14:29Jen: And here's where there's genuinely good news because- Yay … the
- 14:33single most effective anti-aging step is almost boringly simple.
- 14:39Matt: Boringly simple.
- 14:40Don't tell me it costs a fortune because the skincare aisle is
- 14:44already full of these psychological experiments at this point, isn't it?
- 14:47Mm-hmm.
- 14:48Chris: It's the opposite.
- 14:50Um, the best solution is a good daily decent SPF broad-spectrum sunscreen.
- 14:56Um, so there's a well-known controlled trial where people using such a sunscreen
- 15:01every day showed no measurable increase in skin aging over four years, whereas
- 15:06the comparison group which didn't apply the same sunscreen aged visibly.
- 15:11Matt: So the cheapest and most ignored bottle in the shop beats the 40 quid
- 15:15miracle serum sitting right next to it, which is, like, g- for me it's
- 15:19great news if you're paying, right?
- 15:20Chris: Like, 40 quid, that's- that's a bit, uh, generous, isn't it?
- 15:22That's cheap, isn't it?
- 15:22Yeah.
- 15:2280, 100 pounds thereabouts.
- 15:25Jen: Yeah, that really is the headline, and it's never too late
- 15:29to start because you're always preventing the next decade of damage
- 15:33even if you can't undo the last one.
- 15:36Chris: Yeah, and I think sticking with skincare, 'cause I- I do wanna be
- 15:39fair to skincare 'cause there are some good technologies- Mm … out there.
- 15:42The next tier down, um, with good evidence behind it is
- 15:47retinoids, so vitamin A creams.
- 15:50And these are interesting because they d- don't just sit on the surface of the skin.
- 15:53What they do or what, if they can be delivered properly, what they're trying
- 15:56to do is actually switch collagen-building genes back up in the deeper layers,
- 16:01the dermis, dermal layers of the skin.
- 16:03Matt: Okay, so a retinoid is actually going down into that layer and turning the
- 16:07collagen-making back up, not just kinda smoothing the surface like a polyfiller.
- 16:15Jen: It's probably a bit more elegantly than that, yeah.
- 16:17But it's more or less what they do.
- 16:19So, um, one other one to mention is topical vitamin C, which has
- 16:24got decent evidence too, and that's partly because it's an antioxidant
- 16:29against, like, the UV damage.
- 16:31Um, and also partly because collagen literally can't form without it.
- 16:36Chris: Yeah, vitamin C is amazing on, on so many levels, but it
- 16:40really is the collagen king- Okay … when it comes to vitamins.
- 16:43Matt: I'm learning lots, guys.
- 16:44So what about, uh, the lifestyle stuff?
- 16:46Or is … And I- here you go.
- 16:48Here's the bit where you tell me all the fun things are bad again.
- 16:51Chris: Well, it's fair to say that not smoking is one of
- 16:54the biggest levers, and, um
- 16:56but also protecting your sleep, um, because that lets
- 16:59your skin repair overnight.
- 17:00So for those sleep creases we talked about, position matters most because
- 17:04sleeping on your back keeps your face off the pillow altogether.
- 17:07Matt: Yeah,
- 17:07Jen: but it- Yeah
- 17:07… Matt: does increase the snore factor, doesn't
- 17:09Jen: it?
- 17:09Yeah, my husband would not be thankful if I slept on my back.
- 17:13Matt: Okay.
- 17:14Well, talking about sleep then, the silk pillowcase that everyone
- 17:17seems to be swearing by, does the fabric itself actually do anything?
- 17:20Chris: I'd say less than the adverts suggest, if I'm honest,
- 17:22which may or may not surprise you.
- 17:24Uh, but it's probably fair to say they tug on the skin a little
- 17:27less than collagen, and they maybe hold moisture slightly better.
- 17:31So it is something low risk to try, but the evidence that it actually
- 17:35prevents wrinkles is pretty thin, and I'd say the kind of sleeping position's
- 17:41Jen: there's a, there's a, a kind way of framing, um, wrinkles as well,
- 17:46which is that some of what we call aging is really just evidence of a
- 17:52life with a lot of laughter in it.
- 17:54Matt: Yeah, that's me.
- 17:55Absolutely.
- 17:55I love that.
- 17:56My crow's feet aren't structural decline.
- 17:59No, no, no.
- 18:00They are a memorial of good times I've had.
- 18:02Jen: Yeah.
- 18:03Chris: No, totally.
- 18:04When you speak to people in their 80s and 90s, do you think they
- 18:06care about their crow's feet?
- 18:08They, they're looking back with amazing memories, so- Yeah.
- 18:10Mm. No, good on them.
- 18:11So onto treatments that people always ask about, and these are injectables
- 18:17and lasers, and this is where I have to be Captain Sensible for a
- 18:21moment, which won't surprise you.
- 18:22Jen: Go on, Captain Sensible.
- 18:24Chris: Yep, I'll take it.
- 18:25Someone's gotta wear the hat.
- 18:27Um, so very briefly, when it comes to the muscle relaxing injectables, they work
- 18:31on the dynamic expression lines, so the ones we talked about that from the kind
- 18:36of thin skin, and fillers replace lost volume, and lasers are there to kinda
- 18:41coax the skin into making new collagen.
- 18:44Now, these things can genuinely work, but this is the Captain Sensible bit, when it
- 18:49comes to the invasive treatments, please do consult a qualified practitioner,
- 18:54because there are some absolute cowboys out there, and it's far better to do
- 18:58it properly than just look for a, a kinda cheap treatment and low price.
- 19:01Yeah.
- 19:01Jen: Yeah.
- 19:01Yeah, I think we've all seen the horror stories, haven't we?
- 19:04Matt: We have, and I, I, yeah, I… Let me echo Captain Sensible for a
- 19:09brief second, and of course, the big takeaway is that for wrinkles we've
- 19:13technically been blaming the wrong thing.
- 19:15Jen: Yeah, and that's the twist, isn't it?
- 19:16So we look at a wrinkle, we blame the calendar, but the calendar is only
- 19:21doing a slow, quiet share of the work.
- 19:24Chris: It is, and as we explained, the largest share is sunlight speeding up the
- 19:27breakdown of collagen, while the skin's own repair slows, which is why the one
- 19:33habit that actually moves the needle f- is protecting your skin from that sun damage.
- 19:39Jen: Okay, so why do we get wrinkles?
- 19:42Chris: So we get wrinkles because in the deep layer of your skin, the cells that
- 19:46make collagen and elastin slow down with age, while the enzymes that break those
- 19:50proteins down keep going, and sunlight tips the balance hard towards breakdown.
- 19:56The surface, no longer firmly supported from beneath, unfortunately settles
- 20:00into lines, wrinkles and crinkles.
- 20:03Matt: And the good news is that the biggest cause, uh, is the
- 20:08one most within your control.
- 20:10The calendar you can't argue with, but the sunscreen is right there, and it's handy.
- 20:16Jen: So there you go.
- 20:17That is why you get wrinkles.
- 20:20That is it for this week.
- 20:21Hit subscribe wherever you're watching or listening, because we unpack a new
- 20:26everyday question every single week.
- 20:29And drop the things that you've always wondered about in the
- 20:32comments for us to answer.
- 20:34Thanks so much for geeking out with us.
- 20:36That's it from me.
- 20:37Matt: That's it from me.
- 20:38Chris: And that's it from me.
- 20:40Jen: Bye for now