Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The New Frontier E004: Bitcoin and Islam with Bitcoin Majlis
Transcript
- 0:16Welcome to The New Frontier, a Bitcoin centric podcast that
- 0:19bridges the gap between the transformative world of Bitcoin
- 0:22and the unique financial landscape of the Middle East.
- 0:25This podcast is brought to you by Onramp Mino and is Co hosted
- 0:28by Ralph Dobran, Managing Partner at Onramp Mino and
- 0:31Harris Irfan, CEO of Cordoba Capital Markets and advisor to
- 0:35Onramp Mino. Ralph and Harris have built
- 0:37their careers in traditional finance, accumulating extensive
- 0:40experience across capital markets, investment banking, and
- 0:43asset management. Each episode delves deep into
- 0:46how Bitcoin is reshaping finance, technology and
- 0:49investment within the region and beyond.
- 0:51From macroeconomic trends to real world applications, and
- 0:54from Islamic finance to sustainable energy practices,
- 0:57this show covers it all. In today's episode, we're
- 1:00thrilled to have two exceptional guests who are making waves in
- 1:03the Bitcoin community with their unique and powerful mission.
- 1:05They are brothers and also cofounders of Bitcoin Mesh List,
- 1:09a pioneering nonprofit organization dedicated to
- 1:11educating Muslims, Muslim owned businesses and Muslim scholars
- 1:15about the importance of Bitcoin from a sound money perspective.
- 1:18Their work is grounded in a deep conviction that Bitcoin offers
- 1:22the best pathway to escape the Reba based systems of
- 1:25traditional banking and Fiat currency.
- 1:27Abdullah, who's widely known as Muslim Bitcoiner on X, also
- 1:30hosts the popular Muslim Bitcoiner podcast where he dives
- 1:33deep into these crucial topics. We're honored to welcome
- 1:37Abdullah and Salaf to the show. Get ready for an insightful
- 1:40discussion that explores the intersection of faith, finance
- 1:43and Bitcoin. Hey everyone, welcome to the new
- 1:46Frontier. We have a few special guests
- 1:49today with us from Bitcoin Measureless, Abdullah and his
- 1:53brother Salah and as always my Co host Harry Serfan.
- 1:57How's everyone doing? Great.
- 2:00Fantastic. Great to have you guys.
- 2:02So we'll just jump straight into it.
- 2:05Abdullah Salah, could you start by telling us a little bit about
- 2:09Bitcoin Measureless, what it's all about?
- 2:11What's your mission and what inspired you to create this
- 2:15platform? Yeah.
- 2:17So I think Salah should probably start with how he got into
- 2:22Bitcoin and then how I got into Bitcoin because that eventually
- 2:25is what ended up leading us to create Bitcoin Measureless.
- 2:30Yeah, so. I think the journey started pre
- 2:34Bitcoin with me learning about Ron Paul.
- 2:38And this was during my college years trying to figure out
- 2:42politics. And, you know, out of listening
- 2:44to everyone, it sounded like Ron Paul was the one talking the
- 2:46most sense. And he was the only politician
- 2:49that was talking about the Federal Reserve and how much of
- 2:53an impact the Federal Reserve has and, and kind of
- 2:57manipulating the economy. And kind of that led to me doing
- 3:01a deep, deep dive on how Fiat money works and kind of having a
- 3:06deeper understanding there. And that primed me to kind of
- 3:11recognize, oh, OK, now we finally have a working
- 3:13alternative to to Fiat money. And then over next few years, I
- 3:18tried to get Abdullah interested as well.
- 3:21Of course, you know, he was like, yeah, that, that's
- 3:23interesting. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 3:24And, and nothing really kind of hit until I gave him a copy of
- 3:28the Bitcoin standard and I'll just let Abdullah take it from
- 3:31there. Yeah, yeah.
- 3:32So like, like Salaf said, I mean, Salaf has been telling me
- 3:34about Bitcoin since like 2014. And so, you know, he's he's he's
- 3:38really been trying to get me to kind of see it.
- 3:40But it wasn't until he gave me a copy of the Bitcoin standard.
- 3:43And once I read that, I, I was like, it kind of gave me a lot
- 3:47of food for thought. And then I started like, you
- 3:49know, consuming a bunch of other Bitcoin content.
- 3:51I started consuming podcasts and, you know, reading books and
- 3:55YouTube videos and stuff. And, you know, you kind of you
- 3:58get a hardware wallet and you start like, you know, buying
- 4:00some Bitcoin and messing around with it.
- 4:02And then next thing you know, you know, Salah is telling me,
- 4:05Hey, you know, you should, you should make a Twitter account
- 4:07and follow all of these toxic plebs.
- 4:09And I'm like, Oh, sure, that sounds great.
- 4:10So I make an account. I'm like, Oh, Muslim Bitcoin.
- 4:13I like, I didn't even put any thought into it.
- 4:15And then like, next thing you know, you know, it's just, it's
- 4:18really insane. Like I was not intending to
- 4:20having like a mass following or anything.
- 4:22But you know, that's, I guess that's just how it happened.
- 4:24I started researching it more and putting my thoughts out
- 4:27there. And, you know, my my brother and
- 4:29I were discussing further about like, how do we promote this
- 4:34Bitcoin thing to the general Muslim population?
- 4:36Because we found that like, yeah, there's some talk about
- 4:38Bitcoin among especially Islamic scholars, but like, it was never
- 4:42really framed in the right way. So like one of the things that
- 4:46kind of compelled us to actually create Bitcoin medulists as we
- 4:49listen to this podcast with Narman Ali Khan.
- 4:52And, you know, he was on a podcast with Mufti Farah's Adam
- 4:55and Islamic finance guru. And I love these brothers.
- 4:59I don't want to talk bad about them, but like the podcast or
- 5:01the the YouTube video was talking about it was like
- 5:03Bitcoin or something, something like, you know, Sharia compliant
- 5:07or whatever. So like Salah and I were excited
- 5:08like, Oh my God, guys, look not met.
- 5:10Ellie Khan is about to get orange built.
- 5:11So we fire up the video and like the 1st 10 minutes is about like
- 5:15Bitcoin and blockchain. And then the topic, the the
- 5:18conversation gets completely derailed talking about NFTS, web
- 5:233, metaverse and all this other stuff, which is like, like,
- 5:27like, it's, it's fine that, you know, if not mentally Khan
- 5:29wanted to learn about that, but it's like what?
- 5:32There wasn't even any mention of like the Federal Reserve or how
- 5:34Fiat works or like anything talking about the riba in Fiat.
- 5:38So like my brother and I were like, dude, we have to do
- 5:40something. So like, that's kind of like was
- 5:42like, let's just make a website and we're just let's come up
- 5:45with the name when we came up with Bitcoin Medulis and, you
- 5:47know, we registered it as a nonprofit.
- 5:49So all right, all it is right now is just a website that has
- 5:52educational material on there. And you know, we're, we're
- 5:55hoping to use this platform Inshallah to kind of help the
- 5:58general Muslim community understand this Bitcoin thing
- 6:01from a sound money perspective without all of the other added
- 6:05crypto noise attached to it. That's amazing, Abdullah.
- 6:09And. I can relate directly.
- 6:11So we had say for Dean on our podcast last time and you know,
- 6:15he was one of the 1st to get me into the Bitcoin rabbit hole.
- 6:18Before we transfer it over to you, Harris, quick question for
- 6:22you guys. Maybe you can translate what
- 6:25Bitcoin measures means to the non Arabic speaking community.
- 6:30It's like a committee, right? Yeah, that that's correct.
- 6:35So we kind of, you know, gave it some thought in terms of like
- 6:39what what do we call this? And you know, the, the name that
- 6:42just kind of popped into my head was, you know, Medulist, because
- 6:44we just want it to be like a gathering of, of Muslims that
- 6:47kind of discuss Bitcoin and we just want the the conversation
- 6:51to be about Bitcoin. And so it just makes sense to
- 6:54just go with Bitcoin Medulist. Amazing.
- 6:57Fantastic. I'm going to ask you the big
- 6:59question straight off the bat and that is how is Bitcoin anti
- 7:05riba? What is it about Bitcoin
- 7:08fundamentally that aligns it with Islam?
- 7:12Well, so you know, I, I think in before answering that question,
- 7:16it first to help frame what how, how riba is involved in the
- 7:21current Fiat monetary system, which you guys already went over
- 7:23in the last podcast was Saifuddin.
- 7:24But just to kind of recap, you know, the only way that Fiat is
- 7:28mined or the only way that new Fiat tokens are produced and
- 7:31distributed is through a proof of Reba algorithm.
- 7:35If, if, if, if I could use that term.
- 7:37So like anytime there's a new Fiat token that's generated,
- 7:40there has to be an interest bearing loan associated with it.
- 7:44So off the bat, anytime there's new money created in Fiat,
- 7:47there's already Reba attached to it.
- 7:49Now, like you could probably make the case that like, oh, OK,
- 7:52the, the, the, the money is, is already generated.
- 7:55So it doesn't have Reba involved in it.
- 7:57But I mean, at the end of the day, that money that you're
- 7:59using was only generated from Reba.
- 8:01So, and I think that kind of helps in framing the question
- 8:06and looking at Bitcoin and seeing whether it's anti ribbon.
- 8:08Now, you might look at this and just right off the bat, assume
- 8:11that, well, you know, if Fiat is completely entrenched in riba,
- 8:14then Bitcoin is like non Reba money.
- 8:17But we like to take it a step further and say, actually, no,
- 8:20we, we believe that Bitcoin is anti riba money.
- 8:23And we, we make the case that there's, there's three monetary
- 8:27properties associated with it being anti ripple money.
- 8:29First is it's fixed supply. So because it has a fixed
- 8:33supply, you can't really generate new Bitcoin.
- 8:39And you know, it's having a fixed supply already
- 8:42incentivizes people to save rather than go into debt.
- 8:46Because if you have a fixed supply, you're not, there can't
- 8:49be any new tokens that are created in order to help create
- 8:52a global debt based system on money.
- 8:55And the second is going to be the the fact that it's proof of
- 8:57work. So because there's there,
- 9:00there's an energy expenditure associated with the creation of
- 9:03Bitcoin. This is inherently it already
- 9:07makes it resistant to kind of, you know, creating any any new
- 9:12Bitcoin in a in in a non proof of work way or in in a not not
- 9:18energy expenditure way. And lastly is the digital
- 9:21portability. So this is the advantage that
- 9:23Bitcoin has over gold is that you can actually hold the
- 9:26Bitcoin itself, like you can hold it on on on a smartphone in
- 9:30your pocket, as opposed to gold where like, you know, if you
- 9:33wanted to store all of your wealth in gold, you know, you
- 9:36would have to store it somewhere and secure it.
- 9:38But with Bitcoin, all you need is 12 or 24 words.
- 9:41So right off the bat you already have this incentive for people
- 9:44to hold on to their Bitcoin and not trust third party to
- 9:48fractionally reserve against that Bitcoin.
- 9:50So we believe that like having these three properties doesn't
- 9:53just make Bitcoin non riba money, but actually makes it
- 9:56anti riba money. Wonderful, thank you for that
- 10:01and I'm looking forward to your anti riba meme.
- 10:05When is that coming out? I've, I've, I've made quite,
- 10:10quite a bit of memes talking about it, But you know, I, I
- 10:13will go ahead and mention that Salah and I have started working
- 10:16on a book and we're, we're, we're hopefully trying to make
- 10:21the case that, you know, throughout this book, making the
- 10:24case that Bitcoin is anti Ribbo money.
- 10:26I actually, I, you know, thinking about it now, I don't
- 10:29have a working title for it, but we, we might end up calling the
- 10:32book anti Ribbo money just to try to get that idea of front
- 10:36and center to any Muslim that, that's, that's curious about
- 10:39learning about Bitcoin from the Muslim perspective.
- 10:41But I, I, I, I will say that like, we're not, you know, we're
- 10:45not even really halfway done. We're still trying to put hours
- 10:48into it. I, I didn't realize that writing
- 10:50a book would require a lot of work.
- 10:53So, you know, we're, we're still going through that and you know,
- 10:56inshallah maybe sometime early next year, we'll we'll have a
- 10:59rough draft to review and then and then release subsequently
- 11:03Inshallah. Yeah, we'd love to have you on
- 11:05the show once the book is ready for being promoted and pushed
- 11:10out. So please keep us in mind on the
- 11:12topic of gold, Abdullah and Salah.
- 11:15You know, in Islam, gold has, you know, been viewed over many
- 11:19years, millennia, as a store of value.
- 11:22You touched on a few comparisons, but do you think
- 11:26Bitcoin is the modern equivalent of gold, or it's a total
- 11:30different asset class and it's just something else?
- 11:35So I'll take this one. It's so yes, gold has been sound
- 11:40money for, for Muslims for a long, long time.
- 11:42And, and interestingly, when Satoshi developed Bitcoin, if
- 11:48you read, you know, his white paper and his, you know, early
- 11:51postings, he, he talked about how, you know, you know,
- 11:55bitcoins mines like gold. It like gold, it requires time
- 11:58and energy to dig out of the ground or dig out of, you know,
- 12:02the protocol. And he makes so many different
- 12:06analogies to, to gold. So, you know, it's, I think it,
- 12:11I think it does like it takes a lot of inspiration from gold.
- 12:17And I think that's kind of kind of how maybe Muslims, you know,
- 12:22used to think about things as like, you know, letting kind of
- 12:26God's, you know, you know, creation kind of inform us how
- 12:30to make, you know, systems that would be beneficial for mankind.
- 12:35And so, yeah, definitely the modern, modern gold.
- 12:39But I think it can also be, you know, much more as well.
- 12:45Yeah, I, I also kind of view it that way as well.
- 12:47I mean, I, I, I find that gold is actually very useful because
- 12:52explaining gold's properties actually helps to explain
- 12:54Bitcoin. So yeah, I do kind of consider
- 12:58it as kind of a step that humanity takes after gold.
- 13:03I mean, it's just kind of like if you read about the history of
- 13:06money, you see humanity converging on these different
- 13:08commodities and you know, eventually we converge on silver
- 13:11and gold. And then, you know, right now it
- 13:13feels like that process has been kind of reversed with this
- 13:16current Fiat Fiat system of what what HOPPA calls of a system of
- 13:21partial barter where you have like over 160 different Fiat
- 13:24currencies, which, you know, it's kind of like reverse that
- 13:27process. But I feel like Bitcoin is kind
- 13:29of putting us putting humanity back on track to try to actually
- 13:33find the best money that we all can converge on.
- 13:36And, and, and to kind of speak about the 160 different
- 13:40currencies, I mean, so, you know, you know, each country
- 13:44likes to have its own own Fiat money that they get to print and
- 13:48they get to lend into existence. And, you know, this is something
- 13:52that, you know, I, I, I'm kind of a little puzzled about why
- 13:55Muslims are not picking up on, you know, the, the enormity of
- 13:58the problem when it comes to Fiat and Reba.
- 14:02So it's so ingrained that, you know, you can look up the
- 14:06currency of any, any country and you have to also kind of figure
- 14:10out what's the interest rate that, you know, the central Bank
- 14:14of that country is setting for that currency.
- 14:16So, you know, right off the bat, you can kind of, you know, get a
- 14:19clear idea of like how ingrained Aruba is into Fiat currencies,
- 14:24even the currencies of Muslim countries.
- 14:28And, and you know, you know, we, we as Muslims, I, I think we
- 14:34kind of get excited if we get, you know, a large sum of, of, of
- 14:38Fiat money because it's just kind of been wired into us from
- 14:42from birth or since childhood. And I think we kind of need to
- 14:48figure out a way of, you know, elevating the discourse.
- 14:52But just before we get to that, just kind of have a reframing of
- 14:56what Fiat money is. And if, you know, like Abdullah
- 14:59explained some already, Fiat requires riba in order to be
- 15:04created. And it requires that the
- 15:06country, you know, issue bonds or hold bonds on its balance
- 15:09sheet. Or if it requires the setting of
- 15:12an interest rate, you know, in so many facets, it requires, you
- 15:17know, riba or riba contracts. So, you know, if you have that
- 15:22level of involvement of Reba into the money, then, you know,
- 15:27maybe it shouldn't be called just Fiat money.
- 15:29It should be called Reba money. And, you know, whenever I try to
- 15:32explain, you know, Bitcoin to anyone, I always try to first
- 15:36start with explaining how Fiat money is actually Reba money.
- 15:41And, you know, we, we try to make it a point to call Fiat
- 15:44money Reba money so that, you know, Muslims can get an idea of
- 15:47like, you know, this is something you should be
- 15:48disgusted with. You know, if, if, if someone
- 15:50gave you a leather wallet and then you're like, oh, wow, this
- 15:54is a nice wallet. And then and then they also
- 15:57tell, yeah, it's it's really nice, high quality pig leather.
- 15:59You know, all of a sudden you're gonna be like, I don't know if I
- 16:02really want this, you know, So I think that's kind of like the
- 16:05goal is to kind of just reframe it as like this, this money
- 16:08that, you know, people are using day-to-day.
- 16:10It's Ribbo money and you shouldn't be comfortable with
- 16:13it. I I I love this phrase.
- 16:15You guys use proof of proof of Ribbo algorithm?
- 16:18That's fantastic. Let let me go back to gold for
- 16:20one second. What do you say to Muslims who
- 16:25say gold is the only or bimetallic currency is the only
- 16:29money of Islam? And sometimes they thought this
- 16:31hadith would be 6 ribawi items. So you know, date, sweet barley,
- 16:35salt, gold, silver. What do you say to those guys?
- 16:40You know, I've, I've, I've also had, you know, people on Twitter
- 16:43that also mentioned that where they say like gold and silver
- 16:46are the only Islamic currencies. And they do mention that hadith
- 16:49talking about the six different commodities where, you know, you
- 16:53where Reebok could be charged on them.
- 16:56But you know, I like, I like to explain that nothing in that
- 16:59hadith says that gold and silver or any of the, the four other
- 17:03commodities that were mentioned, that hadith doesn't mention that
- 17:06those have to be used as money. That if, if you actually look at
- 17:10that hadith and study it, you realize that the, the hadith is
- 17:13showing you what items Reba can be charged on.
- 17:16And actually, I think it was Mahalia Tucker that did a very
- 17:20fascinating YouTube video about that hadith where like he, he
- 17:24kind of extrapolates from all these different sources about
- 17:28like, actually, if you look at all of these different
- 17:30commodities that were mentioned in the hadith, the issue or the,
- 17:33the property that they all have in common is fungibility.
- 17:36So really like the thing that you can actually charge interest
- 17:39on are commodities that are fungible in nature.
- 17:42So again, I, you know, there, there is, there is some, there
- 17:48is a precedent for, you know, Islamic societies to, you know,
- 17:52where they've actually used the gold standard.
- 17:54But again, it doesn't have to be that way.
- 17:56That was just the best money at that time.
- 17:58And we, we contend that we have a better money because I mean,
- 18:03if we go back to a gold standard right now, I feel like the same
- 18:07thing is just going to happen again, where you end up having
- 18:10to trust third parties that are going to fractionally reserve
- 18:12against it. And then that kind of introduces
- 18:15this attack vector for Reba in, in the, in the money.
- 18:18So like, I, I think it's, that's why it's, it's also good to look
- 18:22at the history of money as well, because that kind of gives you a
- 18:25clear picture of like, oh, OK, because of gold and silver's
- 18:29weaknesses in their monetary properties, as good as they
- 18:33were, ended up actually introducing Fiat banking at the
- 18:38protocol level. So again, there's not really any
- 18:42requirement for gold to be used as money.
- 18:45What about the intrinsic value argument they say?
- 18:57So this is also something I like to meme about because it is, I
- 19:01would say the intrinsic value thing is almost is the very
- 19:04first thing that a lot of Muslim scholars, they will look at
- 19:07Bitcoin and immediately the third, the very first argument
- 19:09they make against it is that it has no intrinsic value.
- 19:12And to me, it just demonstrates that like you haven't really
- 19:14done any work to actually understand it at all, especially
- 19:18from first principles. But so there's two ways to
- 19:22approach this. The first way is to understand
- 19:25that one value is not intrinsic. You can easily demonstrate this
- 19:30by any commodity that you value it, that that value ends up
- 19:36changing based on the situation that you're in.
- 19:38So like, you know, you just make a simple example of like right
- 19:41now I have a cup of water that I'm drinking from and I don't
- 19:44value it that much. But if I was stranded out in the
- 19:47desert and I didn't have any water and you know, and I, I
- 19:50eventually find some water, I'm going to value it very, very
- 19:52highly. Nothing inside the water.
- 19:55It's value did not change. It's subjectively evaluated.
- 19:59That's the important thing is that value is subjective.
- 20:02But also, you know, when people say that Bitcoin has no
- 20:04intrinsic value, they mean that it has no other non monetary use
- 20:07case. And to that we say actually,
- 20:10that's that's a good property that you want because you want
- 20:13your money to only be used as money.
- 20:15You don't want it to have these other non monetary use cases.
- 20:18So for you know, for for for gold, for example, it has other
- 20:23non monetary use cases. But primarily the reason why
- 20:26people hold gold isn't because, you know, someone is
- 20:31unexpectedly is going to need a gold tooth or is going to need
- 20:33some jewelry. You hold gold because of its
- 20:35monetary properties. So I think, you know, when
- 20:38you're talking about Bitcoin that, you know, untangling what
- 20:42that intrinsic value argument is, it kind of naturally leads
- 20:46to a discussion of phrasing the question of, OK, wait, what
- 20:50gives Bitcoin it's value or why is Bitcoin valuable?
- 20:53And I think that's a much better question or a much better
- 20:55approach to to answering that question instead of just off the
- 21:00bat saying, oh, it has no intrinsic value.
- 21:03The question that you should be asking is OK, what gives Bitcoin
- 21:05value? Yeah, great answer.
- 21:07I love that. Interesting.
- 21:08I'm gonna slightly change the subject and we're talking about
- 21:12Bitcoin as a, you know, as a form of money, as a store of
- 21:17value. But I want to talk about the
- 21:19financial system around a monetary system.
- 21:24Tell me a little bit about what role you think you see for
- 21:29Islamic finance and Islamic banking.
- 21:31I'm going to use the word banking very loosely, but an
- 21:33institution that, you know, essentially deals with money in
- 21:36some way. What do you think what, what
- 21:39role will they have in the adoption of Bitcoin?
- 21:41Do you see some kind of, you know, meeting of minds there or
- 21:45not? So I, I think, yes, I think
- 21:50they're, you know, that potential is there and, but you
- 21:55know, I think there has to be a discussion about, you know what,
- 21:59you know what, what's the base layer that's being used?
- 22:01You know, when we're talking about, you know, like Islamic
- 22:04contracts or you know what, what, what is an Islamic bank
- 22:07really doing? You know, it's, you know, it
- 22:12becomes, you know, an issue where you have to kind of like
- 22:15ultimately it leads to having to understand, you know, Fiat, Fiat
- 22:19at the base layer and you know it, you know it.
- 22:24You can have a lot of, you know, a lot of Islamic banking and
- 22:29Islamic finance contracts that are built on on Fiat, but you
- 22:33know, at at the root of it, at, you know, the soil is, you know,
- 22:38still still riba. And then, you know, when, when
- 22:41it comes to to Bitcoin, it requires you to kind of have a,
- 22:44you know, understanding of like, you know, this, this, this is
- 22:47the, the riba free option that, you know, can be used as a new
- 22:52way to build a new system that is more aligned Islamically.
- 22:57And do you don't have the issues of having to figure out, OK, we
- 23:01have the riba issue. How, how can we make a contract
- 23:04that emulates riba so that, but it's not technically riba in
- 23:07certain ways. And, you know, you just kind of
- 23:10get rid of that headache altogether when you're using
- 23:12Bitcoin. It's just, you know, when you
- 23:14have sound money, it just makes it so much simpler.
- 23:17Yeah, I also just want to mention real quick, you know, we
- 23:19don't come from like an Islamic finance or Islamic banking
- 23:22background. We Salah and I both studied
- 23:25engineering in college. But so you know, we're kind of
- 23:28coming at this from from an outsider perspective.
- 23:31But it, it does seem like, and you know, how does I think
- 23:34you've talked about this in other podcasts where you have to
- 23:37understand that having a sound money, especially one that has a
- 23:40fixed supply and with all of the other associated properties with
- 23:44Bitcoin makes it kind of a, a vehicle to allow people to be
- 23:49low time preference. So off the bat, you know, Fiat
- 23:52makes, makes people think in the short term and it makes people
- 23:56kind of like consume capital rather than accumulate capital
- 23:59for the long term. So I think like having a sound
- 24:02money will cause us to be more low time preference where we're
- 24:05thinking more about the future. And you know, as how that
- 24:08relates to Islamic finances. I think like Salah was saying,
- 24:11you know, I feel like a lot of the issues that are related to
- 24:14Islamic finance is just trying to make Fiat work in a, in a
- 24:19halal way. And I, I feel like a lot of time
- 24:22and a lot of ingenuity is wasted on trying to get that to work.
- 24:26But I feel like on a, on a Bitcoin standard, you know, you,
- 24:29you would actually be able to have true Islamic finance, like
- 24:32you would actually be able to have true like risk sharing
- 24:35contracts as, as, as, as opposed to like interest bearing
- 24:39contracts. And, and I think, you know,
- 24:42having having the the this anti riba property at the base layer
- 24:48will kind of help facilitate that and will help Islamic
- 24:51finance actually, like I think it'll, it'll help make it truly
- 24:55shine. So before I, I hand over to
- 24:59Ralph, I, I, I mean, it feels like you're saying that Islamic
- 25:04banking as it stands today, Islamic finance is just not
- 25:08compatible with Bitcoin as a monetary standard.
- 25:12It's just not going to happen. It's going to have to happen
- 25:14outside of the banking, the traditional Islamic finance
- 25:17system. Is that what you're saying?
- 25:20I mean, yeah, I don't, I don't see, you know, I think you
- 25:24actually talk about this in in your book.
- 25:26I think that that was actually when I, when I read your book
- 25:29Heavens Bankers, it kind of made me realize that like there's
- 25:31really no way to get Islamic banking to truly work within the
- 25:34Fiat system just because, you know, like, like we talked about
- 25:38before, I mean, it has the proof of riba algorithm in the base
- 25:42layer. So like there's there's just
- 25:45really no way to get any kind of Islamic finance contracts to
- 25:51actually work on top of a riba based layer.
- 25:56So yeah. Very interesting, I wanted to go
- 26:02back. I've been thinking about the
- 26:04term you use anti riba and please correct me if I'm
- 26:08mistaken but I think there's like a spectrum.
- 26:12So you have gold. If I were to put it on a
- 26:14pendulum it will be in the middle.
- 26:16It is halal. It's a Islamic form of money.
- 26:20To the left, I would put Fiat, which is exponentially more riba
- 26:25over time. And we've seen that with the
- 26:27proliferation of derivative markets, derivative markets of
- 26:31derivative markets, et cetera, where there's basically nothing
- 26:35really sound about. It's just fake money on top of
- 26:38fake money on top of fake money. And on the far right, the way I
- 26:42see it is Bitcoin, similar to the term Talib uses anti fragile
- 26:49and in this case it's anti riba. So over time on a Bitcoin
- 26:54standard money society and all that will become more moral and
- 27:00moral and moral because it's not just neutral, it is actually due
- 27:04to its fixed supply and it's certain criteria pushing the
- 27:08world into less usury, more transparency, more fairness in
- 27:12the system, more symmetrical distribution of, you know,
- 27:16outcomes when it comes to business dealings, etcetera,
- 27:18versus A1 sided play similar to what we have now with the
- 27:22banking system. Do you think that would be an
- 27:24accurate description? I mean, I'm just bandwagoning
- 27:27off of your turn. I've been thinking about it anti
- 27:29Reba and I thought about anti fragile and I found it such an
- 27:32amazing book because the more you attack Bitcoin, it seems the
- 27:36stronger it gets and the more people have control and it
- 27:40empowers the people at that level.
- 27:42And anti Reba seems to empower morality.
- 27:45Islamic finance, Muslims and not just Muslims.
- 27:48I'm a non-muslim, for example, but I am a Christian
- 27:50practitioner and a lot of the things that I am learning about
- 27:54through Islamic finance between you guys, Harris, Saifuddin,
- 27:57anyone who talks about if you were to replace the term Islamic
- 28:00finance, I would put in ethical and moral finance.
- 28:05I mean, that's what it is to me from, and I've heard that from a
- 28:09lot of my Christian friends that have been watching this.
- 28:11It just makes sense. It's just a more moral and
- 28:14ethical system. So the term antiruba is quite
- 28:17amazing. So is there something that I got
- 28:20off or something that you'd like?
- 28:21I think. I think you hit hit, hit, hit it
- 28:25on the head. I mean, it's, it's, it is kind
- 28:27of, you know, the, the anti the anti fiats, you know, on the
- 28:30opposite end where you know, with Fiat, you kind of have to,
- 28:34you're forced to kind of, you know, work the hamster wheel to
- 28:37try to keep the value of your money.
- 28:39Like you have to work, you know, an additional job to try to
- 28:42figure out how to invest your money so that you have value for
- 28:45the future. Whereas with Bitcoin, you just
- 28:47focus on your job and then you just save in Bitcoin and, and
- 28:51people that are new to Bitcoin, you know, would kind of take
- 28:54take a step back in like, whoa, you know, you're talking about
- 28:57this, this crypto stuff. And you know, that's that just
- 29:00is, you know, very speculative. And, you know, they kind of
- 29:04associate, you know, Bitcoin with cryptocurrency and they
- 29:07think, you know, high frequency, like trading or day trading.
- 29:13And, you know, and, and we're trying to explain that, you
- 29:17know, the, the high type preference activities of, you
- 29:20know, trading cryptocurrencies back and forth.
- 29:23You know, that's or NFTS or, you know, you know, launching a coin
- 29:28that you know, is, is, you know, interesting for, you know, a few
- 29:31months and then people forget about it.
- 29:32You know, that those are the things that we're trying to get
- 29:35away from to kind of explain, you know, that all of that stuff
- 29:38tends to be, you know, that doesn't accrue value over the
- 29:43long term. It's it's 0 sum.
- 29:45You know, when, when you're day trading, you know what, not sure
- 29:47what the benefit is of, you know, day trading crypto
- 29:49currencies is really going to help with, you know, for the
- 29:51rest of society, Whereas, you know, if you just have a focus
- 29:55on Bitcoin, you know, just just focus on your job and, you know,
- 29:59if you need to save something for the future, you know, saving
- 30:01Bitcoin, yes, it can be painful, you know, seeing the, the
- 30:05volatility day-to-day. But, you know, you know, as
- 30:07Muslims, we we have this understanding of like, you know,
- 30:10we do things for the long term. You know, our long term is, you
- 30:13know, the afterlife of Afira. And, you know, it's like, OK,
- 30:17well, if we can plan for Afira, maybe we can also plan for, you
- 30:21know, you know, 1020, thirty years from now.
- 30:24And to try to, you know, envision a monetary system
- 30:27that's, you know, that that's anti riba.
- 30:31And yeah, that's yeah. Yeah, just to piggyback off of
- 30:35that, I mean, I, I love the, the, the pendulum that that,
- 30:38that you talked about there, Ralph.
- 30:39I mean, I think, I think that's a very good way to frame it.
- 30:41I, you know, I, I didn't mention this before, but you know, I, I
- 30:46think in trying to envision a Bitcoin standard, I think it
- 30:49makes sense that it would just naturally lead to more of a
- 30:54profit sharing type revenue generation rather than trying to
- 30:59get it through interest bearing loans.
- 31:01So you know, if, if, if you just look at like an interest bearing
- 31:05transaction on a Bitcoin standard, now, you know, for an,
- 31:09and anyone that's complaining, that's like, oh, bitcoins, not
- 31:11anti riba because you can actually, you know, make a, make
- 31:14a riba contract on, on Bitcoin. Like, duh, of course you could
- 31:17do that on money. But the reason why we say it's
- 31:20anti RIBA is because if you are going to make an interest
- 31:23bearing transaction, interest bearing loan on on Bitcoin, I
- 31:28mean, it's, it's a very risky thing because if you end up not
- 31:32being able to have the loan paid back to you, there's no like
- 31:36FDIC or any, any other bank that's going to be able to bail
- 31:39you out. So inherently doing an interest
- 31:42based loan is already very risky, as it should be.
- 31:45And I feel like it's going to be very risky on a Bitcoin standard
- 31:48where as you know, the the, the other, the other way to
- 31:52actually, you know, make or I guess make use of capital on a
- 31:56Bitcoin standard is you would actually engage in a profit
- 31:59sharing mechanism where you actually have to know what the
- 32:03investment is like. You actually have to know like
- 32:05you're not just putting your Bitcoin up and generating some
- 32:09revenue from interest. You're actually going to be
- 32:11putting Bitcoin into a project where you intimately know what
- 32:15that project is. And you're going to know whether
- 32:17it makes a profit or not. And if it doesn't make a profit,
- 32:20that's, that's higher than what would be if you had just
- 32:22accumulated that Bitcoin, then it's not going to be a
- 32:25profitable venture. Again, as it should be.
- 32:27I think you know what one, one thing that I've kind of realized
- 32:31about going on a Bitcoin standard is that initially
- 32:34you're, you're not going to have as many like just in investments
- 32:39that are going to be made because people are going to be
- 32:42more, more discerning in what they will give their Bitcoin to
- 32:47and what, what, what projects they want to fund.
- 32:50Because, you know, with, with Fiat, you're kind of
- 32:51incentivized to just throw your money here, throw it there.
- 32:54It's like, Oh yeah, this, this, this project sounds good.
- 32:56And especially in low interest rates environments where like
- 32:59you just kind of throw money at, at whatever because you're,
- 33:03you're on this hamster wheel where you're trying to beat
- 33:05inflation. So automatically you're in this
- 33:07high time preference thinking where like all, all you're
- 33:10thinking about, it's just the revenue that you can generate
- 33:12and you're more likely to be incentivized to go into interest
- 33:15bearing loans. Whereas on a Bitcoin standard,
- 33:18we feel like it's gonna naturally just just an
- 33:22environment is gonna emerge where you're you're gonna end up
- 33:25having more profit sharing contracts and more profit
- 33:30sharing agreements in in in order to make make use of
- 33:34capital or generate profits. So.
- 33:37Interesting. Yeah, I think before I turn it
- 33:38over back. Oh, sorry, there's a bit of a
- 33:41delay. Yes.
- 33:42Sorry about that, Harris. Yeah, I think many Muslims
- 33:45missed this point and, you know, in getting caught up in the FUD
- 33:50of Bitcoin. And you know, we'll talk about,
- 33:52we'll knock off the FUD later on.
- 33:54We'll talk about volatility and we've talked about intrinsic
- 33:56value and energy usage and all this kind of, so they come up
- 33:59with all these reasons why not Bitcoin.
- 34:02But when you explain to them what actually the investment
- 34:05decisions that we make today on a Fiat standard are dumb
- 34:09investment decisions because we're forced almost to throw our
- 34:13money away at bad projects because money is devaluing.
- 34:17So if you had a money that didn't devalue, you are
- 34:21incentivized to make long term sustainable decisions.
- 34:24So your investment process is a much higher quality.
- 34:28That's not to say they won't be rib eye if you have a Bitcoin
- 34:30standard as you say. I mean, you know, human beings
- 34:33are human beings, They'll find ways to to charge people
- 34:36interest and they may well throw money at bad projects.
- 34:39But you have a much higher degree of incentive to invest
- 34:43wisely when you think for the long term, when you're nudged in
- 34:47the direction of thinking in the long term.
- 34:49Anyway, sorry Ralph, back to you.
- 34:51Oh, no, no worries. That was quite interesting.
- 34:54Two points real fast and I'll flip it over back to you,
- 34:56Harris, I know you have a lot to talk about in this conversation.
- 34:59Two things. Your comment about profit
- 35:01sharing, one thing that you find in Bitcoin that you can't find
- 35:06in Fiat and that says a lot, at least to me, is you know you can
- 35:10hold your Bitcoin, but if you lose your Bitcoin or even you
- 35:13can take it with you to the grave, literally.
- 35:16And in doing so, you are benefiting everyone who holds
- 35:20Bitcoin, the ultimate charity case, because you're cutting
- 35:23down on why. So I mean, even if you don't
- 35:27have children or etcetera, you can just take it with you.
- 35:30And then everyone in the world that holds Bitcoin will see, you
- 35:34know, the benefit of that. So that's one thing that I find,
- 35:37you know, inherently good that you can do something like that,
- 35:41whereas you can take as many dollars as you want.
- 35:43The next day there's going to be a trillion of them that are
- 35:46printed newly and fresh and minted.
- 35:48You know, so that's that's very interesting thing to me.
- 35:53Question for you guys just to shift gears a little bit.
- 35:55So you know, the Bitcoin measure is you guys have your own
- 35:58community. You work with a lot of people, a
- 36:00lot of scholars unsure variety of ages and you've been working
- 36:05to kind of approach the scholars themselves.
- 36:08How do they approach the Islamic jurisprudence with regards to
- 36:13Bitcoin? Like how do they go about, you
- 36:15know, studying, viewing Bitcoin? Like where do they start off?
- 36:20Let's take a moment to talk about On Ramp Mino.
- 36:22As a driving force behind the new frontier On Ramp, Mino
- 36:26offers best in class education and advisory services for
- 36:29Bitcoin accumulation, strategy and custody.
- 36:31Our expert team specializes in crafting tailored Bitcoin
- 36:34strategies and providing recommendations that ensure your
- 36:37assets are both secure and accessible.
- 36:40Book a consultation with Anramina today to take the first
- 36:43step towards securing your financial future with Bitcoin.
- 36:46Visit ourwebsite@anramina.com to learn more and schedule your
- 36:50consultation. And now let's get back to the
- 36:53show. I mean, you know, I guess like
- 36:59in terms of looking at it through, you know, Islamic
- 37:01jurisprudence or fit, you know, they, they, they tend to look at
- 37:05it kind of, you know, they, they, they, they start out like
- 37:09looking at like what money is or like what, how, what, what money
- 37:13is supposed to be. I oftentimes feel like, you
- 37:17know, even using that approach, it doesn't really get at to the
- 37:21heart of the issue because I mean, like, you know, I don't
- 37:23want to downplay the role of fit because that's like super
- 37:27important. But I mean, you know, you don't
- 37:28need to have like that deep of an analysis to at least know
- 37:33that like the current Fiat system is based inherently on
- 37:36riba. Like, like, I think that's,
- 37:37that's a very easy thing to, to, to make, to make the case for.
- 37:41And, you know, I, I think, you know, in, in, in conversations
- 37:44that I've had with certain scholars, I was recently at a
- 37:48conference in, in Baltimore at the IGNA conference or the
- 37:52Islamic Circle of North America. I think that's what that stands
- 37:56for. And I've actually talked with a
- 37:58few scholars at that conference. I had a friend that like knew
- 38:01all of these different scholars and he like dragged me.
- 38:02He's like, hey, this guy wants to talk to you about Bitcoin.
- 38:05So like he dragged me like in front of a bunch of scholars.
- 38:07Some scholars were like very receptive.
- 38:09They were like, oh, like, you know, they had no idea that like
- 38:12Fiat was completely entrenched in riba.
- 38:14But I, I found that like most of, and I, I hate to say this,
- 38:18but I feel like most of the response that I got was just
- 38:22like, they didn't really care that like the current Fiat
- 38:25system is completely entrenched in riba.
- 38:27Like, and, and I, that makes me like really sad because like
- 38:31when you actually read the Quran and you know, you read the
- 38:34Hadith about riba, like it is a very serious grave sin.
- 38:37Like in the Quran, Allah declares war on the person that
- 38:41engages in riba. Like no other sin has this, like
- 38:44this is obviously something that's really, really heinous.
- 38:47And you know, like when I'm, when I'm trying to explain that
- 38:50to, to other, other Muslims, it's just regular Muslims or
- 38:54they don't have to be scholars. They don't really, they're not
- 38:58like they're not compelled to actually act on that.
- 39:01They're just like, oh, OK, that's that, that's interesting.
- 39:03I didn't know that, but like, I don't want their reaction to be
- 39:06that. I want them to like be panicked
- 39:07a little bit. I want them to be like, Oh my
- 39:09God, I didn't know that. What can we do about this?
- 39:11So you know, but ham did a lot like so when, when we were at
- 39:15the IGNA conference, me and our, our friends, Subhan, we gave
- 39:19this talk and I titled it Bitcoin, the anti Riba monetary
- 39:23protocol. I, I gave it a fancy title, then
- 39:26Masha Allah, like dude, we had like over 100 people show up to
- 39:29the room and the room only had like a 7080 people capacity.
- 39:32The room was jam packed. Like there were people that were
- 39:35like lining up outside to come in because I guess they really
- 39:37wanted to hear this talk. So, you know, I, I gave the talk
- 39:41and then like, after I gave the talk, there was a line of people
- 39:43that were coming up to me that wanted to ask questions.
- 39:46And the question, the main question that I got was
- 39:48Abdullah, how do I buy Bitcoin? Like, like I, I guess maybe I, I
- 39:53delivered the, the, the, the message in a very clear way.
- 39:55But sorry, that completely derailed to the original
- 39:59question you were asking about Phil.
- 40:00But I just wanted to mention that, like, it doesn't take much
- 40:03to understand. At the very least, just
- 40:06understand that the current Fiat system is completely entrenched
- 40:09in riba and that like, yes, you can use Phil to, I guess, you
- 40:14know, see if Bitcoin is halal or Haram, you know, in a technical
- 40:18way. But at the end of the day, we're
- 40:20really only left with two alternatives.
- 40:22We either go back to a gold standard or we use.
- 40:25This Bitcoin thing because like clearly, you know, this Islamic,
- 40:29this Islamic finance, Islamic banking circus that we've been
- 40:33trying to make work on a, on a Fiat standard is clearly not
- 40:36working. I mean that there are ways to
- 40:38make it work, but at the end of the day, it's just not something
- 40:41that's viable to do. So the only thing we could do is
- 40:43either go back to a gold standard or use Bitcoin.
- 40:45And I think that just kind of lays it out very plainly that
- 40:48like in order for gold to work, do you, you have the only way to
- 40:52really get gold to work is you like the, the, the Khalifa has
- 40:55to come back and he has to like institute gold for all of these
- 40:59Muslim countries to use it. That's going to be the only way.
- 41:01And to be honest, that just seems very unrealistic if you
- 41:03ask me. And compared to Bitcoin, that
- 41:06Bitcoin just seems like it just it just seems like the very
- 41:09common sense of approach to solving the 300 and something
- 41:13trillion dollar riba problem that we have going on in today's
- 41:16world. And, yeah, so like when I speak
- 41:20to Muslims, you know, they they say, yeah, that the system is
- 41:23definitely entrenched in riba. And, you know, there's not much
- 41:26we can do about it. You know, let's just, you know,
- 41:28sit, sit back and, you know, maybe wait for, you know, the
- 41:32the prophesized, you know, Mehdi, to return to, you know,
- 41:35set everything right. And you know, I'm listening to
- 41:37this and I'm like, you know, the, you know, this, this, this
- 41:40is not the Islam that I know. You know, we're not supposed to
- 41:43just, you know, oh, there's a problem and we're just gonna
- 41:45sit, sit back and wait for the problem to get solved by
- 41:47someone. You know what, what what are we
- 41:49doing to be proactive about, you know, taking down the system?
- 41:53And you know, it's it's I I tried to like draw an analogy
- 41:57from from history. So, you know, as long
- 42:02prophesized, you know, from Prophet Muhammad Sallalla audio
- 42:06said to them that the Muslims would, you know, one day conquer
- 42:09Constantinople. And I like to bring up this
- 42:13story because it it illustrates, you know, how did we had a
- 42:16certain mindset when you know, Muslims, you know, you know,
- 42:21they, they, they, they tried for centuries to, you know, fulfill
- 42:24the prophecy of, you know, taking over Constantinople.
- 42:26And, and you know, the, the, the, the ruler at the time was
- 42:32Mohammed Feta. The, the second he, you know,
- 42:37was very forward thinking. And he, you know, he like his
- 42:40forefathers, you know, they wanted to be the one to conquer
- 42:42Constantinople because, you know, they want to be the one to
- 42:44fulfill the prophecy. And and you know it, they
- 42:49couldn't, they couldn't takedown the the walls of Constantinople.
- 42:53So that's like for centuries, you know, they couldn't get past
- 42:56the walls of Constantinople. It was just, you know, the walls
- 43:00were too high, too thick, and you didn't have really a way of
- 43:03taking the walls down, laying siege never really worked.
- 43:07And you know that Mohammed the second the Sultan, he was
- 43:12approached by by a non-muslim. And I like to emphasize that
- 43:17this this man was non-muslim. His name was Orban.
- 43:20And he presented his idea for a new, new technology like it
- 43:28because the people are already playing around with, you know,
- 43:30gunpowder at this time. But he would want to take it to
- 43:33the next level and say, Oh, I have, you know, I have this
- 43:36design idea for cannons. And, you know, he he Orban
- 43:42initially brought the idea to the Byzantines at the time, but
- 43:45they were not really interested. They had other things to worry
- 43:47about. But then, you know, when
- 43:49Muhammad Sultan Muhammad saw the, you know, the plans and
- 43:54realizing, oh, you have you, you're bringing this to me.
- 43:57And you're he just want, he's just, you know, he's he's he's a
- 44:01technologist. You know, he or Bond just wants
- 44:03to build his cannons. And I'm at the second he is
- 44:07like, OK, I'll fund you. You're not getting funding from
- 44:10anywhere else, but I'm going to fund you and you're going to
- 44:12help me bring down these walls for Constantinople.
- 44:15And, you know, there was, you know, I don't know for certain
- 44:19because, you know, I'm not, I'm not a historian, but I'm sure,
- 44:22you know, the thought process was wasn't oh, is, is this is
- 44:27this halal? Is this compatible, you know,
- 44:29with, you know, the old times or anything like that?
- 44:32No, he just, he saw the best technology and he just went for
- 44:35it. And that's how he ended up
- 44:37taking down the walls of Constantinople.
- 44:40And you know, and even if it was developed by a non-muslim and
- 44:43other, you know, you know, FUD pieces, you know, well, you
- 44:47know, Bitcoin was maybe created by this Satoshi guy.
- 44:49We don't know who he is, probably a non-muslim.
- 44:51We don't know what his motives are.
- 44:53And you know, and you know, when I hear that, it's like, well, it
- 44:55doesn't really matter. You know, we as Muslims should,
- 44:59you know, be forward thinking. And if we see the best
- 45:01technology to bring down the walls of the Arriba system, we
- 45:05need to jump on it. So let's use it.
- 45:07Let's bring down these walls. I'm.
- 45:13Just we're coming back to, I mean, we're talking about
- 45:16actions rather than, you know, just pontificating about Bitcoin
- 45:21and hoping Muslims come around to it.
- 45:23I was interested the love that people came up to at the end of
- 45:26the session, Igna, and said, how do I get into it?
- 45:29So what do you tell Muslims who never come across this before?
- 45:33Maybe they say to you, wow, this looks like very techie.
- 45:36I'm not a techie person. I, it's very confusing to me.
- 45:39What do I do? What do you say to them?
- 45:43So you know, when, when people came up to me, luckily I had a
- 45:45few copies of the Bitcoin standard with me because I, I
- 45:48kind of anticipated something like that would happen, but I
- 45:50only had like 3 copies with me. But my, my, my first thing is,
- 45:55you know, I think it, it takes a lot of education because like, I
- 45:58think if you try to get Muslims to get into Bitcoin without
- 46:01understanding it, like Salah was saying, you know, they look the,
- 46:05the, the volatility is like hard to stomach if you don't actually
- 46:08understand what it is that you're buying.
- 46:10So at the very least, like you actually need to be educated on
- 46:13it. And unfortunately that education
- 46:15is like it, it, it requires reading, it requires like
- 46:19watching YouTube videos. I mean, right now that's, that's
- 46:21just that the only way to educate is to actually get down
- 46:25and, and actually learn it. So, you know, for, for those
- 46:28Muslims that were asking me like, how do I buy Bitcoin, I
- 46:31just tell them, look, go read the Bitcoin standard while
- 46:34you're reading the Bitcoin standard, like go open up an, an
- 46:37exchange, an account on an exchange.
- 46:39Typical, you know, you should try to go for a Bitcoin only
- 46:42exchange, which you know, I, I recommended in, in the US, we,
- 46:45we like to use coin bits because you know, one, one of one of
- 46:48the, one of our friends that we know here in the US is they,
- 46:52they these, these, these Muslim brothers, they opened up coin
- 46:57bits. So it's, it's, it's a Bitcoin
- 46:59only exchange. And you know, I, I, I tell them,
- 47:03open up an account on coin bits and just start like, you know,
- 47:07putting in a little bit from your paycheck.
- 47:08You don't have to like go all in on this.
- 47:10Like, I'm not asking for Muslims to completely like ditch their,
- 47:13their savings on their Fiat account and go completely into
- 47:17Bitcoin. I think this is going to be a
- 47:18gradual thing where as you're putting in, you know, a few
- 47:21dollars here and there, you're going to start looking at the
- 47:23Bitcoin price. You're going to start looking at
- 47:25seeing it's going up and down. You're going to be like, oh, why
- 47:27is Bitcoin going up and down? And then you're going to start
- 47:29reading about it. And then, you know, I tell them,
- 47:32like, while you're doing that, also read things like the
- 47:34Bitcoin standard, read the Fiat standard, read these books and
- 47:37watch these YouTube videos and, and, you know, consume these
- 47:40podcasts. And while you're consuming that,
- 47:42like it'll start to click. And then they'll, I, you know,
- 47:45that's, that's, that's how I got into it.
- 47:47Like I didn't go convert all of my Fiat into Bitcoin on day one.
- 47:51It, it, it takes a while. And that's what I recommend to
- 47:54Muslims that want to get into Bitcoin is just, you know, first
- 47:57of all, open up an exchange, start reading about it.
- 48:00Put again, a little bit of your paycheck into it every week or
- 48:03every month and just just go from there.
- 48:09By the way, just as an aside, you may have heard in the last
- 48:1324 hours or so that Coinbase has shut down the accounts of many
- 48:19Palestinian organizations. Binance it's.
- 48:22Quite Binance. Yeah, my apologies, Binance.
- 48:26Yeah. And, you know, this is so
- 48:29there's a bit of a buzz, again, in the Muslim community.
- 48:33And again, a process of education needs to take place.
- 48:36What do you say to Muslims who say, well, you know, your
- 48:38money's not safe, It can be hacked.
- 48:41You know, you are. You know, you're at risk of
- 48:44criminals or censorship or manipulation by third parties.
- 48:47What do you say to that? We say yes, that that is
- 48:52definitely the risk if you're not doing things properly.
- 48:55And you know, that kind of gets back to the education angle.
- 48:59You know, you, you know, want to be holding your own keys.
- 49:03So if you're using an exchange, once you get a, you know, a
- 49:06certain amount of Bitcoin, you know, let's say it's like, you
- 49:09know, 500 or $1000 worth. You know, you want to have
- 49:13regular intervals where you're moving funds off the exchange
- 49:17into a ideally like a hardware wallet.
- 49:21And you know, we want Muslims to understand that, you know, you
- 49:25know, with Bitcoin, you, you actually have censorship
- 49:28resistance. You, you don't, you're not going
- 49:31to be in a position where if you're holding your own keys,
- 49:34you know, your funds can be frozen or your funds can be
- 49:37confiscated. You, you'll always, as long as
- 49:40you have access to the Internet, you're going to be able to move
- 49:42your Bitcoin and do what you want with your Bitcoin.
- 49:46And yeah, so it's it, it was a sad story to hear that, you
- 49:49know, you know, the, the Palestinians don't have a lot
- 49:55already. And you know, this is something
- 49:57we didn't, didn't mention earlier, but you know, Abdullah
- 49:59and I, we, we, we grew up in Palestine.
- 50:02We grew up in Bethlehem and we lived there for a few years in
- 50:06our childhood. And, you know, Palestinians
- 50:10don't have much into here that, you know, finance just
- 50:12confiscated the funds of all Palestinians.
- 50:14I mean, that's that's really sad news.
- 50:18And, you know, we're we're, you know, that kind of just makes,
- 50:20makes it more imperative for us to educate Muslims.
- 50:23Like, you know, if you use an exchange, get your funds off the
- 50:26exchange, don't leave them on the exchange.
- 50:29And, you know, and, and we would say that also you don't want to
- 50:33use other things like, you know, Tether, if you can avoid using
- 50:38things like Tether and alt coins, you know, there's,
- 50:41there's always kind of room for those things to be censored and
- 50:47to, you know, be controlled by the developers.
- 50:50And you don't want to be in a situation where, you know, you
- 50:52get censored from that angle either.
- 50:54Like, like, if you want true censorship resistance, you know,
- 50:58go with Bitcoin, don't go with anything else that could be
- 51:02censored. And, you know, and I think,
- 51:04yeah, we really just have to educate them on it.
- 51:07Yeah, and I just just talking about the censorship resistant
- 51:10aspect. I mean, I think this is a a
- 51:12wonderful property that Bitcoin has especially is because like
- 51:16once once that transaction is sent and once it's confirmed, I
- 51:20mean there's there's no one that can like reverse that
- 51:22transaction. I mean Bitcoin is a truly like
- 51:25censorship resistant money. And I feel like, you know, as
- 51:29like if if you're if you know, if you're a Palestinian or you
- 51:32know, if you're, if you're Muslim in another place where
- 51:34you're being oppressed. I mean, this, this is a very
- 51:37good use case where you can actually like you, you can leave
- 51:41with your money by memorizing 12 or 24 words.
- 51:44And you you can take your money with you wherever you want.
- 51:47And no one can take that away from you.
- 51:49So, yeah, it was kind of sad hearing about by Nets just just
- 51:54completely just taking all the Palestinian funds.
- 51:57I mean, I guess they, they, they must have done it through like
- 51:59looking at their phone numbers or something, or like I, I, I
- 52:02don't know if they do KYC or whatever, but like, that's just,
- 52:05I mean, that's, that's like really evil.
- 52:08And that's, that's why I don't like using a lot of these crypto
- 52:11exchanges. I, I think that's, that's, you
- 52:13know, another reason why you should play it safe, use a
- 52:17reputable Bitcoin only exchange. And like Salah was saying, I
- 52:20mean once once you have an amount take it out, put it into
- 52:23your into cold storage and keep keep your keys safe.
- 52:29And just any. Recommendations.
- 52:32Sorry, any recommendations you can make for for making
- 52:37donations to Relief Aid on the ground in Gaza?
- 52:42Yeah, there's, there's so there his, there's this guy, his name
- 52:46is Yusuf Mahmoud. That's that's on Twitter and
- 52:50he's also on Noster right now, where you can actually send
- 52:54Bitcoin to someone that will receive it in Gaza and they will
- 52:58actually use the, that Bitcoin to, you know, they, they trade
- 53:01it for the local currency. But then using, using the local
- 53:04currency, which by the way, a lot of other people don't know,
- 53:07but like the local currency, the Palestinians is the Israeli
- 53:10shekel. So like using, using the local
- 53:13currency, he can actually buy food and water and other, other
- 53:17materials and supplies for, for any, anyone that's like lost
- 53:21their homes or is not able to feed themselves.
- 53:23So even right now, like you could actually use Bitcoin to
- 53:27help Palestinians. I mean, you know, we, we talk,
- 53:29you know, the, the main use case that I use Bitcoin for is
- 53:31obviously holding. I mean, I have 5 kids, I'm
- 53:34thinking about the future. But they're, you know, as, as a
- 53:37Muslim, you can actually use Bitcoin right now to help your
- 53:40fellow Muslims that are in Palestine by donating Bitcoin.
- 53:43You're not going to be able to do that from any, you know,
- 53:46crypto exchange that could censor you.
- 53:47You're not going to be able to do using Venmo or PayPal or
- 53:51whatever, but you can't do that using a censorship resistant
- 53:55permission list protocol that's called Bitcoin.
- 53:57So yes, you can actually send Bitcoin to Palestine right now
- 54:02and help the Palestinians. And we'll, we'll, we'll, we'll
- 54:05even put that on our, on our profile regularly.
- 54:08We'll, we'll actually retweet that.
- 54:11So, and, and, and the guy is really great because he like
- 54:13puts pictures and videos of like all of the food that, that he's
- 54:17acquired and he's passing them out to like all the hungry kids
- 54:19and all, all the hungry people there.
- 54:22So, you know, this isn't like some scam or anything like it's,
- 54:24it's, it's legit and it's happening on the ground and you
- 54:27can use your Bitcoin to make a difference now.
- 54:30Yeah, and and and to also, you know, extrapolate from there.
- 54:34It's not, you know, just helping Muslims in, in Palestine, but
- 54:38you know, any, you know, person in needs, you know, like, for
- 54:44example, if if there is an orphanage, you know, that needed
- 54:48funds and you want to, you know, give your charity to that
- 54:51orphanage. And if they accept Bitcoin, then
- 54:54you have the ability to send Bitcoin directly from your
- 54:57wallet to their wallet. And I know this is something
- 55:00that is something that kind of, you know, plagues the, the, the,
- 55:06the charity scene, You know, when it comes to Muslim
- 55:09organizations where, you know, the organization, they end up
- 55:12keeping egregious amounts of the charity they receive for
- 55:15themselves. And, you know, Islamically, I
- 55:19think you, you are allowed to keep a certain small percentage
- 55:22as, you know, someone who helps distribute charity.
- 55:25But, you know, I think last year there were reports of charity
- 55:29organizations that keep, you know, 20-30, forty, 50% of all
- 55:33the charity that they collect before they give it to the
- 55:36people in need. And you know, now, now with
- 55:39Bitcoin, so not just as a way of saving, it's not just savings
- 55:43technology, but now, you know, we have a way of sending
- 55:46directly to people in need. And you don't have to worry
- 55:48about a middle man that's going to take a big cut of your funds
- 55:52when that you're trying to give to the people in need.
- 55:55That's amazing. To add to that, we spoke about
- 55:58the custody component and how it's important to, you know, not
- 56:02your keys, not your Bitcoin. One factor or one idea I want to
- 56:07touch on as well, giving you guys are also based in the US
- 56:11and you talked to a lot of Muslims based in the US.
- 56:15What do you say to them when they look for easy exposure
- 56:20through the ETFs which are marketed non-stop?
- 56:23Do they confuse it with real Bitcoin?
- 56:26Because there's clearly a religious differentiation
- 56:30between direct ownership and non direct ownership?
- 56:33Is that something that comes up in your conversation?
- 56:35Do people just point at the ETF and say this is just the way I'm
- 56:37going to do? It's just much easier that way.
- 56:41Luckily, we, we haven't had that issue so far.
- 56:44But you know, I, I do want Muslims to understand that like
- 56:48owning the Bitcoin ETF doesn't mean you actually own the
- 56:51underlying Bitcoin. And you know that, that, that
- 56:54could, you know, that, that that could also be something that's
- 56:57actually UN Islamic where like you are buying something that
- 57:00you don't actually own because like property rights are like
- 57:03really, really super important in, in, in, in Islam.
- 57:06And you know, if you're buying the ETF and you don't actually
- 57:10hold or you, you don't have access to the underlying asset,
- 57:13then like you don't actually own anything.
- 57:15So like it's not really like a valid transaction.
- 57:18So, and, and The thing is, is like, I don't, I don't see the
- 57:22point of owning the ETF when you can actually own the asset
- 57:25itself. I mean, even if you're, if
- 57:27you're a company, and especially if you're not a very big one, I
- 57:30mean, there's nothing stopping you from like actually just
- 57:33buying Bitcoin and you know, it's adding it to your balance
- 57:37sheet. I mean, plenty, plenty of
- 57:39companies and organizations already do that even today.
- 57:42So I, I think owning something like the ETF, it's just a way
- 57:46of, of like it's, it's really no different than Fiat where like
- 57:50you actually don't own the underlying asset.
- 57:53And it's, it's just, it's just like a, a claim to, to, to
- 57:58nothing basically. Amazing.
- 58:02One thing before I transition it back to you, Harris, since we're
- 58:05talking about the custody component, you know, self
- 58:09custody, multi signature custody, all these nice custody
- 58:13models, you know, they are relatively complex for the
- 58:18average individual. And there's a problematic
- 58:21aspect, which is the inheritance, because one
- 58:23individual will spend hours, hundreds of hours trying,
- 58:27testing, and then the expectation is that their
- 58:30children would inherit the Bitcoin.
- 58:33What are your views on that? For starters, I think
- 58:36inheritance is important in all cultures, especially within the
- 58:41Middle East as well. But do you perceive a world
- 58:46where institutions will self custody, where high net worth
- 58:49individual will self custody? Or do you perceive a different
- 58:52form of custody that might come out?
- 58:56So I, I think, I think you're going to have a mixture.
- 59:00I mean, I think you'll have, you know, Muslims that, you know,
- 59:02self custody, but I think there is also, you know, definitely a
- 59:09lot of opportunity to offer different custody solutions.
- 59:13So when Abdullah was talking about, you know, the ETF, you
- 59:16know, you, if you buy into the ETF, you know, you don't know
- 59:22which specific amount of Bitcoin on the blockchain is yours.
- 59:26And you know, and you don't know if ET the ETF company in the
- 59:30background is, you know, lending that out to someone else to, you
- 59:35know, do you know, leverage trading, you know, involving
- 59:39RIBA, you know, and your funds being are being used to, you
- 59:42know, help fund, you know, activities that you're not
- 59:45really, you know, want to participate in.
- 59:48Whereas you know, if you have a multi sig solution or you know
- 59:52you have multiple keys controlling a certain amount of
- 59:54Bitcoin, you can have you know, you can have the situation where
- 1:00:00you have your amount of Bitcoin visible on the blockchain and
- 1:00:04you can have those keys distributed among various
- 1:00:08institutions. And that that provides a
- 1:00:10powerful way for you to have like a direct legal agreement
- 1:00:14with each of those companies where you have this, this kind
- 1:00:19of legal contract in place like I'm trusting you to hold.
- 1:00:23This one key of mine and you have this same legal contract
- 1:00:28with other entities and that way and and at all times you can see
- 1:00:32the Bitcoin on the blockchain. So you kind of know which which
- 1:00:35address is holding your Bitcoin and you know you know what
- 1:00:38specific amount of Bitcoin is yours.
- 1:00:40So like, you know, you're expecting the property rights
- 1:00:42where you know, like this amount of Bitcoin is, is for Ahmed and
- 1:00:46you know, he can, he can have the security of multiple
- 1:00:49organizations securing his funds.
- 1:00:51Especially, you know, if you're, if you're dealing with an
- 1:00:53organization, a family office or high net worth individual, you
- 1:00:58know that that that can be a very good solution.
- 1:01:02And you know, if something you know when, when, when it's their
- 1:01:04time to when they pass, they can pass, they can have that
- 1:01:09solution, you know, work in their favor in terms of offering
- 1:01:12like making sure that Bitcoin gets handed down to their heirs.
- 1:01:16Full disclosure, Salah doesn't work for on ramp because you
- 1:01:21just described that. You just described multi
- 1:01:24institution custody by on ramp. Like maybe we should work for on
- 1:01:28ramp. Yeah, but I totally agree.
- 1:01:34And Harris and I have been working through the region here
- 1:01:38to try to bring that to the region because, you know, the
- 1:01:41risk sharing, the reduction of counterparty risk, removing
- 1:01:45single points of failure, all that aligns with Muslim
- 1:01:51traditions, Islamic traditions and just common sense
- 1:01:54traditions. I mean, it's kind of crazy that
- 1:01:5780 to 85% of all the ETFs are custodied by a single custodian,
- 1:02:02which is coin based prime. This is a recipe for disaster.
- 1:02:07It's like we haven't learned from FTX, we haven't learned
- 1:02:09from Mt Gox. So hopefully in the future we'll
- 1:02:13see these multi institution, multi jurisdictional custody
- 1:02:17models become more prevalent. And that's why we're here and
- 1:02:21that's why we're working towards that.
- 1:02:24I did this. I did a survey of about 2000
- 1:02:28client net worth investors and wealth managers about 3-4 years
- 1:02:32ago in the Middle East, actually globally, but the Middle East
- 1:02:35was a large segment of that survey.
- 1:02:39And it was very interesting that one of the biggest issues, one
- 1:02:45of the big most important factors for these high net with
- 1:02:49individuals and family offices, succession planning and
- 1:02:53inheritance. And I'm sure we've all heard
- 1:02:55multiple occurrences in the Middle East where a in a large
- 1:02:59merchant family, the patriarch has passed away.
- 1:03:04And, you know, the next thing you know, the siblings are
- 1:03:06squabbling over, you know, who gets what.
- 1:03:08And there's no clear plan in place.
- 1:03:10And so I think that this will be a sort of a new phenomenon now,
- 1:03:16this idea that, you know, where is the Bitcoin and how will it
- 1:03:19be split up? I, I think that's going to be
- 1:03:22doubly important in the Middle East where you have these
- 1:03:24specific issues, especially in the Gulf.
- 1:03:27Anyway, changing the subject slightly, I appreciate that we
- 1:03:30are, you know, some way into our podcast and you know, we, we
- 1:03:34could talk all, but I, I want to just try and focus on a few
- 1:03:37quick, quick fire issues. And Bitcoin modulus, of course,
- 1:03:42is, you know, one of its primary aims is education of the
- 1:03:45community. And let's address some of the
- 1:03:48FUD, right? We've already talked about
- 1:03:52intrinsic value. We've talked about sort of
- 1:03:55digital property. Is it real?
- 1:03:57Is it not real? These are things that we've
- 1:03:58addressed through that particular hadith that you
- 1:04:01mentioned, Abdullah. And let's talk about fixed
- 1:04:04supply. What do you say to Muslims who
- 1:04:05say, oh, you need to have a variable supply so you can deal
- 1:04:08with crises? Yeah, that's, that's definitely
- 1:04:12more of a, of like, I guess I would classify it as economic
- 1:04:16FUD because I, I find that a lot of this type of FUD really kind
- 1:04:19of stems from a lack of understanding of economics,
- 1:04:22which like, by the way, I mean, if you open up like any Islamic
- 1:04:26economics textbook, I mean, one of the things that like I, I
- 1:04:29just, I'm, I'm kind of actually too scared to go like really
- 1:04:33deep in this rabbit hole. But like, if you open up any
- 1:04:35like modern Islamic economics textbooks, you find that it's
- 1:04:38just like littered with Keynesian propaganda, which is
- 1:04:41like really worrying. But I, I didn't know like how
- 1:04:44bad it was until like, I, I had just like, you know, opened up a
- 1:04:47few textbooks And I've, I've, I've made a few posts about it
- 1:04:50on, on my Twitter account. But like you know concerning the
- 1:04:53fixed supply, I think it it stems from that same.
- 1:04:56Leading voices, I mean, some of the people that everybody looks
- 1:04:59up to and say, oh, this is the greatest economist and this is
- 1:05:02really important Islamic theologian in this subject.
- 1:05:06And they're repeating, repeating the same propaganda.
- 1:05:09It's just amazing to me. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:05:11And it's, it's, it's really quite worrying because I mean,
- 1:05:14I, I, I like to think that, you know, Islamic economics is like
- 1:05:17a thing that makes sense because it is Islamic, but it just seems
- 1:05:20like as, as, as a modern concept, it's been completely
- 1:05:23hijacked by, by Keynesianism. And there's like no other way to
- 1:05:26view economics unless it's from that Keynesian viewpoint.
- 1:05:30And you know, this fixed supply thing is, I feel like it's a
- 1:05:32downstream issue of that Keynesianism being in Islamic
- 1:05:36economics where, you know, people will make the fun that
- 1:05:39like, oh, Bitcoin has a fixed supply.
- 1:05:41So you know, it's, it's, it's not going to be able to
- 1:05:43lubricate the economy or, or whatever other like buzzword
- 1:05:47they use. But like underneath all of those
- 1:05:50buzzwords, like their contention makes no sense.
- 1:05:52You do not need to increase the supply of the money in order to
- 1:05:56have more goods to be created. Like it's, it's just, what do
- 1:06:00you think about it? Logically, creating more
- 1:06:03monetary units is not going to is not going to make things come
- 1:06:07into existence. Now, you know, there is the
- 1:06:11issue of divisibility. So like you might need more
- 1:06:13monetary units if you have something that's not very
- 1:06:17divisible because you actually need to have enough units for
- 1:06:20people to transact in. But the thing with Bitcoin is
- 1:06:23that it has a fixed supply, but it's perfectly divisible because
- 1:06:26it's digital. So I, I, I think, I think a lot
- 1:06:30of, a lot of Muslims that kind of engage in that flood really,
- 1:06:33really missed that point because they've been already
- 1:06:36automatically programmed to think like, oh, the, the supply
- 1:06:38needs to increase in order in, in order to have like, you know,
- 1:06:42all, all of these different investments.
- 1:06:44But really, if you take a step back, realize that actually
- 1:06:49having the supply be fixed is probably is actually the optimal
- 1:06:53way to have a monetary system, provided that it's perfectly
- 1:06:56divisible, because creating new monetary units does not make new
- 1:07:00goods. Yeah.
- 1:07:03It's just. Max and just exactly, exactly.
- 1:07:09And another aspect is historically, you know,
- 1:07:13governments have, you know, always been involved in money.
- 1:07:16So not just, you know, Fiat bring about money, but we're I
- 1:07:19was talking about like gold and silver.
- 1:07:21You kind of needed a neutral or as neutral as can get party to,
- 1:07:26you know, standardize the coinage and to, you know, put
- 1:07:30their stamp and say, you know, this is this many grams of of of
- 1:07:34gold or silver in a coin and have it uniform and standardized
- 1:07:38so that it can be used for trade.
- 1:07:40So I think, you know, there's also this kind of historical,
- 1:07:45you know, bias, like where you kind of have an idea of like the
- 1:07:48government has to be involved with money.
- 1:07:49And in the past, I think maybe that was necessary for
- 1:07:52standardizing the coins of gold and silver.
- 1:07:56The, the awesome thing about Bitcoin is that it's, it's
- 1:07:58already standardized out-of-the-box.
- 1:08:00So, you know, the government does not need to play a role in,
- 1:08:03in, in, in the money supply. That was just an artifact of
- 1:08:07kind of needing to standardize gold and silver.
- 1:08:09But now with Bitcoin, it's already standardized.
- 1:08:12Don't need a third party or government to involved in the
- 1:08:15process. Yeah, yeah, that that's the
- 1:08:18government saying, saying minting and verification.
- 1:08:20That's not a government saying This is Money and we say so.
- 1:08:23So it's a complete 2 completely different things.
- 1:08:25OK, next FUD energy usage, you know, Muslims will say, oh, you
- 1:08:30big pointers are destroying the environment and you know, you're
- 1:08:34not sustainable. And what is what is this proof
- 1:08:37of work? Why do we need it?
- 1:08:39Explain. Well, so I, first of all, I, I,
- 1:08:42I like to say, you know, if, if you think Bitcoin uses too much
- 1:08:45energy, I, I like to ask the question back.
- 1:08:47Too much energy compared to what?
- 1:08:50Because if you compare it to the Fiat system, Fiat actually
- 1:08:52requires massive amounts of energy.
- 1:08:54And it so happens that it requires actually, I would say
- 1:08:59it requires human lives. I mean, the fact that we have
- 1:09:01like all of these wars that that have happened since the creation
- 1:09:05of the Federal Reserve is no coincidence, as Ron Paul
- 1:09:08famously said. But you know, the, the once,
- 1:09:12once you understand what actually backs Fiat money, it's
- 1:09:15it's this monopoly over issuing riba based loans.
- 1:09:19And in order to keep control of that monopoly, you have to go to
- 1:09:22war with other countries. And you know, it inherently it's
- 1:09:26going to be very destabilizing. But another thing that I like to
- 1:09:29bring up is that like, look, we, we believe that Bitcoin has a
- 1:09:33chance of bringing down the riba based monetary system that's
- 1:09:37global. We're talking about a 300
- 1:09:39something trillion, $1,000,000 RIBA problem.
- 1:09:42I'm not sure what the global amount of debt is, but like if
- 1:09:46you think that like it's not going to use a lot of energy to
- 1:09:49dismantle that, I don't know what to say.
- 1:09:51I think you're incredibly naive. I mean, if you want to take down
- 1:09:54the global RIBA based financial system, it's going to have to
- 1:09:57use a lot of energy and you're going to have to be okay with
- 1:09:59that. And another aspect is, you know,
- 1:10:02just kind of ask, ask someone, you know, you worked, you worked
- 1:10:05for so many years at your job, you know, you spent so much time
- 1:10:09and energy, you know, building up your wealth.
- 1:10:13Wouldn't you want a vehicle that also requires, you know, time
- 1:10:18and energy to store your wealth in?
- 1:10:20I mean, if, if if you put your, you know, wealth in a system
- 1:10:24that's, you know, didn't require much time and energy to, to
- 1:10:27make, then it it, you know, that that means you just can make
- 1:10:31another one and another one and another one.
- 1:10:32So you're, you're going to be storing your wealth in something
- 1:10:34that's not, not scarce at all. So, yeah, it's you definitely
- 1:10:38need, you want time and energy in, in, in, in a money system
- 1:10:43that you know, for you, you want that.
- 1:10:45That's how you can preserve your your wealth over time.
- 1:10:49Right, so we've got energy means security and proof of stake
- 1:10:54leads to perpetual war. Now next FUD volatility, Muslims
- 1:11:00will say, oh, but this is Macey or it's gambling or it Qatar,
- 1:11:04it's uncertainty. You know you're just gambling on
- 1:11:07an exchange with these magic money coins.
- 1:11:10Bit of that. I mean, I think there's
- 1:11:13different approaches to attacking that, but I think at
- 1:11:15at the at the very start of it, you kind of have to realize that
- 1:11:18you're measuring that volatility against something that's
- 1:11:21inherently volatile, which is the dollar.
- 1:11:23So like you're, you're inherently using Fiat to measure
- 1:11:26the volatility, but that measurement stick that you're
- 1:11:29using is actually very volatile. So like it, it, it, it doesn't
- 1:11:32really make sense when you talk about it being volatile.
- 1:11:35But you know, there's also this other approach where, you know,
- 1:11:42you have to understand that Bitcoin is this new emergent
- 1:11:45money that's, that's, that's monetizing from zero.
- 1:11:48Like of course it's going to be volatile.
- 1:11:50I mean, new technologies don't come in and you have a, you have
- 1:11:53a steady adoption curve that goes up like this.
- 1:11:55I mean, any new technology that comes on the scene is inherently
- 1:11:59going to have a very volatile adoption process.
- 1:12:02A new money is going to be no different.
- 1:12:03Actually, I would say a new money would would inherently be
- 1:12:06a very volatile process for adoption.
- 1:12:09So of course you're going to have it going up and down.
- 1:12:11The fact that it's going up and down shows it's giving you
- 1:12:14information that people are buying and selling it.
- 1:12:16I mean, if, if you didn't want volatility on the Bitcoin
- 1:12:19network, you would have to have a third party that controls who
- 1:12:22can buy and who can sell. And that's not any different
- 1:12:25from what Fiat is. And we see the, the, the
- 1:12:27destruction that Fiats caused when central banks attempt to
- 1:12:30suppress that volatility that manifesting down the line in
- 1:12:34huge in, in, in bigger boom, boom, bust cycles.
- 1:12:37So those those are those are the two points I like to bring up to
- 1:12:40to people that bring up that volatile volatility fund.
- 1:12:47And good. OK.
- 1:12:49So we can conclude there's two? Types of Vol.
- 1:12:52Oh yeah, just wanted to add to that.
- 1:12:53So there's two types of Vol too, right?
- 1:12:55There's good Vol and there's bad Vol.
- 1:12:57Well, Bitcoin is asymmetrically leaning towards the good fall.
- 1:13:02So the volatility is actually a feature because as the price
- 1:13:06goes up, more eyes are on it, it collapses new entrants and then
- 1:13:13cycle rinses and repeats constantly.
- 1:13:15So every wave of adoption is followed by a collapse and at
- 1:13:20that point new entrants go in and then you know you have more
- 1:13:23wealth created for those people. So I think when you look at this
- 1:13:27volatility metric from portfolio point of view, it's really
- 1:13:31asymmetrical to the upside and that's a feature.
- 1:13:36It's not normally distributed like other traditional assets.
- 1:13:40It's really to the far right. So there is no better bet in
- 1:13:45terms of you know long term store of value when it comes to
- 1:13:48asset classes. Well, I think we've hit the
- 1:13:51mark. Is there something Harris you
- 1:13:54want to touch on before we start closing the slide?
- 1:13:56No, that's good. I think we've touched on a lot
- 1:13:58of things there and I'm looking up to looking forward to
- 1:14:01following up with you guys. I think there's there are some
- 1:14:04fantastic things that you're going to come out with.
- 1:14:07Yeah. And before we wrap it up, just,
- 1:14:10you know, point us in the right direction, tell us what you're
- 1:14:12working on. We know there's the book that's
- 1:14:15on the horizon. We're excited about that.
- 1:14:17But is there something specific that you'd like to share with
- 1:14:20our audience? And please, we'll have
- 1:14:23everything in the links and in the description.
- 1:14:25So anything you can think of, just send them our way.
- 1:14:28But is there something specific other than the book that you're
- 1:14:31working on that you'd like to share?
- 1:14:34So it's, it's, it's still a work in progress.
- 1:14:37But you know, this goes back to the earlier question of, you
- 1:14:40know, how do we engage, you know, scholars and kind of get,
- 1:14:47get more eyes, more eyes from the Muslim community focused on
- 1:14:50Bitcoin. So one of the things that we're
- 1:14:52working on is going to be a grants program where, you know,
- 1:14:58we offer a grant to a scholar or a student of knowledge or, you
- 1:15:03know, one of the Muslim thought leaders, you know, if they are
- 1:15:09interested in Bitcoin, they can apply to our grant program.
- 1:15:13And, you know, we're working with many other Muslims within
- 1:15:18our organization to try to get funds raised.
- 1:15:21And this would be a way for us to, you know, provide them with
- 1:15:24educational material, a hardware wallet and some Bitcoin to get
- 1:15:28started. And, you know, I think that
- 1:15:31would be a very good way to kind of make, you know, get get more
- 1:15:35of the Muslim community looking at Bitcoin, studying Bitcoin and
- 1:15:39seeing what it's really about. And I think, you know, we can
- 1:15:42get more people, you know, into the Bitcoin movement this way
- 1:15:47through the Muslim community. That's amazing.
- 1:15:49Please make sure to share the details on that one.
- 1:15:51That's ready both. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:15:53That's coming out hopefully in next week or two.
- 1:15:56Amazing. That's pretty close by the time
- 1:15:58we launch this episode. So perfect timing maybe so well,
- 1:16:01that's it guys. I have nothing else to add.
- 1:16:03I just want to say thank you to the both of you.
- 1:16:05This was such a good conversation.
- 1:16:08Really appreciate you guys being here.
- 1:16:11Yeah. Thank you.
- 1:16:13Yeah, it's been great. Thank.
- 1:16:14You pleasure to have you. Thanks for listening.
- 1:16:33If you found the content valuable, please make sure to
- 1:16:35share with a friend and subscribe on your favorite
- 1:16:37podcast platform. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:16:40reminder that the content provided is for informational
- 1:16:43and entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed
- 1:16:47as investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:16:50your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you Onramp Mina com
- 1:16:55schedule a consultation.