Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP197: The Tragic Death of Darcey Freeman
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Tanya and I'm Talia and we are Crimes and Consequences,
- 0:18a true crime podcast. Hi Talia, Hey Tanya. Welcome back. Everyone
- 0:37to come back another special episode of Crimes and Consequences. Before I begin,
- 0:44please hit the subscribe follow like whatever you know the drill, I mean,
- 0:48maybe this is your first episode. Maybe and if so, probably not.
- 0:52Whatever app you're listening to, please follow us. Yeah, I would do
- 0:58me too. I have a story today about Unfortunately, it's about a child
- 1:02death, so I'm just preparing everyone. If you're extrasensitive to that, you
- 1:06might want to skip it. But yeah, okay, okay, well I'll
- 1:11skip it. All right, I'll skip it. You're gonna stop listening.
- 1:18In the early hours of January twenty ninth, two thousand nine, kids across
- 1:23Australia, we're preparing for their first day back to school after the long school
- 1:27holiday break. By all accounts, this day would remain to be very average
- 1:33for many Australians. Children were struggling to wake up in the early morning after
- 1:38being able to sleep in for the last six weeks. So their holiday break
- 1:41is long, it's a lot longer than ours. Nice parents were pestering their
- 1:45children to wake up in order to get them ready for school while also preparing
- 1:49for their day of work. Little did many Australians know that an event that
- 1:53would transpire on this day would shake the country for years to come. Although
- 1:57the school holidays were over, the scorching weather of an Australian summer was still
- 2:04in full effect. I haven't been to Australia me either. I'm hoping to
- 2:07go there someday. But I bet it's hot. I bet it's hot.
- 2:09Will this day would reach temperatures above forty degrees celsius, which is one hundred
- 2:15and four fahrenheits. So it is hot, hot, hot, hot hot,
- 2:20And they've got that ozone problem, yeah, don't we all? Though?
- 2:23I wonder if it's a dry heat or if it's a humid heat,
- 2:27right, does it? But even though it was so hot, it wouldn't
- 2:30put a hold on the return to school. It's like, you gotta go,
- 2:34you gotta go. While some students wouldn't really be excited to go back
- 2:38to school. There was one little girl who was extremely excited for her very
- 2:43first day of school. She was four. Oh yeah, she's excited.
- 2:47Yeah, hell yeah, it's a little Darcy Freeman. And she was just
- 2:53she was over the moon about getting to finally go to her first day of
- 2:57school. She was born February eleventh, two thousand and four, to Arthur
- 3:00Freeman and Peta Barnes. Darcy was the middle child for this couple and the
- 3:06only girl in the family. She was described by family as a determined and
- 3:10strong willed girl. Her older brother Ben, who was six at the time,
- 3:15and younger brother Jack, who was two. She had two brothers.
- 3:20Like I told you, she was the only girl. She had an older
- 3:22brother, Ben, who was six at the time, and a younger brother,
- 3:24Jack, who was two. Darcy absolutely loved her brothers and she looked
- 3:29up to her older brother Ben. Her parents had her hands full. Oh
- 3:32my dad, really seriously. The children all loved playing together and they loved
- 3:38their parents very much. In June of two thousand and eight, Peta and
- 3:42Arthur separated, so the children had spent their school holidays split between their parents.
- 3:46The children had spent the end of their holidays with their father, Arthur,
- 3:51I mean the end of the holiday break with Arthur. The night before
- 3:53their first day of school, the Freeman children were staying with their grandparents.
- 3:58To get the kids to school on time, Arthur had to wake them up
- 4:01bright and early, as the drive to school was about one hundred and twenty
- 4:05eight kilometers away. But yeah, which is ok because they were at their
- 4:13grandparents. Oh, okay, that makes sense. You know the drive was
- 4:16gonna take him an hour and a half's dark, Yeah, that's long.
- 4:19It is eager for her first day and to see her mother at the school
- 4:24gates while she's dressed in her school uniform. Darcy jumped into the car with
- 4:28her brothers and they got their seatbelts on and they were on their way.
- 4:31The children were joking and playing in the backseat as Arthur was driving them.
- 4:35During the drive, Arthur seemed a little off. It was very apparent that
- 4:39something was on Arthur's mind, and the longer he drove, the more he
- 4:43was dwelling on whatever it was that was bothering him. The children didn't seem
- 4:46to take much notice in Arthur's behavior. They were just so distracted and occupied
- 4:51with each other that the strange behavior from their dad was the firstest thing from
- 4:56their mind. Little did they know that the day before, Arthur and Peter
- 5:00had attended family court to discuss custody arrangements. After much discussion back and forth,
- 5:06the custy arrangement went from equally shared fifty fifty custody to Arthur getting the
- 5:12children for three days every second weekend as well as the afternoon on a Thursday
- 5:17in the off week. That's pretty much minimum period of time here in our
- 5:23county. The verdict had really thrown Arthur for a loop. After being at
- 5:28the court, he made the drive back to his parents place and got there
- 5:30around midnight. Arthur had been really stressed out over the court issue with his
- 5:34ex wife, but he never would have guessed that he would have lost time
- 5:39with his children that he loved so much. He spoke to friends and told
- 5:42them he was really upset about not only the verdict but the way he felt
- 5:46he was treated throughout the proceedings. He told his friends that although he was
- 5:49very upset about the verdict, he was happy that it was all over and
- 5:53he could get back to his life without this heaviness being held over his head.
- 6:00We know how that goes, absolutely, we're divorced attorneys. Yeah.
- 6:02Unfortunately, when he got home, he was so distraught that he didn't want
- 6:09to speak to his parents about it. Arthur really couldn't think about anything else
- 6:13at night, and he continued to dwell on the fact that the court felt
- 6:15he was inadequate to look at Yeah, he's seething. He woke up in
- 6:20the morning to take his kids to school, and his father could tell he
- 6:24was still upset. He tried to talk to Arthur about it, but Arthur
- 6:29was just dismissive, and he was at the point he still didn't really want
- 6:31to talk about it. His father then asked if he wanted him to come
- 6:35along for the drive to keep him company, but Arthur refused his father's offer.
- 6:41As Arthur continued on the long drive to get the kids to school,
- 6:45it's now rush hour, rush hours started. Cars are starting to pile up.
- 6:49Oh my god, it's terrible. The traffic was causing the drive to
- 6:54Hawthorne to take a little bit longer, and Arthur continued to think about this
- 6:58verdict from the day before. He's Oh, he is pissed. As more
- 7:01and more time passed, Arthur became more and more frustrated with the situation,
- 7:05he should have hired us. He really needed someone to talk to, so
- 7:12he decided to call one of his friends and during this conversation he just poured
- 7:15his heart out. His kids are in the car. Yeah, while his
- 7:17kids are in the car. He started crying and telling his friends that he
- 7:23had lost his children. Oh that's nice, but he vowed to do whatever
- 7:27it took to get them back. After finishing this call, Peter called Arthur
- 7:30and Peter's the ex wife the kid's mom, to see what time she should
- 7:34expect to see him and the kids at school. Arthur once again felt as
- 7:39if his ex wife thought he couldn't look after his own children to get them
- 7:43to school on time, and he gives offended she's trying to control and trying
- 7:47to control him, so he started an argument with Peter. During the call,
- 7:50Arthur told her to say goodbye to her children and he hung off that
- 7:56stop. I know where you're going with this. Stop it. Scared of
- 8:01what was happening. Peter called Arthur back and tried to talk some sense into
- 8:05him. Arthur wasn't having it and told Peter, you know you're never going
- 8:09to see your kids again. And he hung up on her a second time.
- 8:11The kids are in the God yeah the car. Peter had no idea
- 8:16what to think at this point, and she called her lawyers to tell them
- 8:20what Arthur had said. As Arthur continued his drive, all he could think
- 8:24about was how he was going to get back at his ex wife for everything
- 8:30she had put him through. I don't want to know what he does.
- 8:33Arthur and the children came up to Melbourne's largest bridge, the Westgate Bridge.
- 8:39The bridge stretches across the Yarra River, connecting the city to the western suburbs
- 8:45of Melbourne. It stands about one hundred and ninety feet from the river at
- 8:48its highest point and can see up to two hundred thousand vehicles going across it
- 8:54every day. Wow. The bridge opened in nineteen seventy eight and it has
- 8:58seen some tragedy Before the bridge opened up in nineteen seventy eight and during the
- 9:03construction, because it took a few years. During the construction of nineteen seventy
- 9:07a section collapsed and killed thirty five were holy shit, Yeah, so what
- 9:13the It's already got a reputation holy shit. But because it was large,
- 9:20it quickly became the main road for many commuters as the years went on.
- 9:24Yeah you said, two hundred thousand, Yeah a day, that's a lot.
- 9:28The bridge was full from rush hour, giving Arthur more time to dwell
- 9:33on the situation with his ex wife. Arthur then pulled over to the side
- 9:37of the bridge, toward where it reached its highest point. How do you
- 9:41pull over on the side of a bridge, You know, there's gotta be
- 9:45some I guess, but I was feeling interrupting. I know, especially on
- 9:50a bridge. Bridge is terrifying, right, Yeah, and at the top
- 9:54I am, I get, I start to hyperventilate. Yeah, my mom's
- 9:58got a bridge full. Yeah. I managed to drive over it, like
- 10:01I drove over the Macana Bridge a few years ago, and I was like,
- 10:05you know, my mom goes, just close your eyes. I was
- 10:11driving anyway. Arthur pulls over and he turns on his car hazard lights and
- 10:18puts the car in park. He turned to his children and told Darcy to
- 10:22come up to the front seat while he unbuckled her seatbelt. Arthur then grabbed
- 10:26her and got out of the car. I know, brings yourself. Other
- 10:31commuters on the bridge saw Arthur take Darcy out of the car. But they
- 10:35didn't think too much about it at the time, as he had turned his
- 10:39Hanzards on. You know, they're thinking maybe something's up. Others thought that
- 10:41Darcy was a doll and she really didn't move and eventually didn't seem to struggle.
- 10:46Why is a grown man taking a doll out of a car? Yeah?
- 10:50I know? During morning rush hour, right, Arthur walked with Darcy
- 10:54to the side of the bridge and without hesitation stop it. He threw Darcy
- 10:58over the one hundred and ninety feet highbridge. Arthur then calmly went back to
- 11:07the car and started it up with the boys in the back seat and started
- 11:11to drive again like nothing had happened. What And they're like what what?
- 11:15I know? I'm sure they're freaking out. Did Darcy did right? Many
- 11:18commuters who witnessed this horrible acte started to flood the Triple zero That's Australia is
- 11:24nine one with calls, frantic about what they had just saw. Very confused
- 11:28at what just happened. Darcy's brother Ben asked if he could sit in the
- 11:33front. No, no, no, dude, no, no, you
- 11:35don't want to sit in the front. So Arthur pulled over and Ben got
- 11:39in the front seat, not fully aware of the severity of what just happened.
- 11:43Ben Ben is six, right, yeah, and Ben is six.
- 11:46Ben told Arthur he had to go back for Darcy because she couldn't swim,
- 11:50and you know she's in the water. We gotta go back. Arthur ignored
- 11:54his child's pleased to help his sister, and continued to drive to the Commonwealth
- 11:58Locke Courts building, where he had spent the previous day with his ex wife
- 12:03and courts. So we're no longer going to school. We're going to courts.
- 12:05We're going to court. Once he got there, he parked his car,
- 12:11paid for parking, and then grabbed his boys out of the car and
- 12:15made his way into the building. I love how he paid for parking.
- 12:18He doesn't want a ticket. He doesn't want to through his four year old
- 12:24over a bridge, over a bridge. We don't want that ticket. We
- 12:26don't want that ticket. Arthur, carrying his youngest in his arms and holding
- 12:31the hand of his eldest, tried to give his children over to the court
- 12:35security officer and said take my sons. The security officer refused, and then
- 12:39Arthur started to crumble, like what the fuck? Okay, let me take
- 12:43your sons. Yeah what? He became unresponsive to security and his children and
- 12:48he started to shake, whimper and cry. The boys told the security guards
- 12:52their names and the names of their parents. Arthur was then taken into a
- 12:56separate room to be interviewed, but a psychologist team that Arthur was not in
- 12:58the state at this point to be interviewed. Wait, they brought him into
- 13:01the court and there was a psychologist there. And did anybody say, hey,
- 13:07my sister Darcy. I don't know if the boys you would think that
- 13:09Ben would be like hey yet yeah, I thought these kids would be hysterical.
- 13:16As the calls made their way from police to news outlets like the emergency
- 13:20Calls, the story broke and left the citizens of Melbourne really confused. People
- 13:26who worked with the different news outlets thought it was fake. Police had gotten
- 13:28to the scene and after being in the water for fifteen minutes, Darcy was
- 13:33pulled out. She was still alive. What right? Oh my gosh.
- 13:37Officers who attended the scene performed CPR on little Darcy until the paramedics arrived,
- 13:43who then continued to perform CPR in the ambulance. Darcy was then taken to
- 13:48the Royal Children's Hospital. As emergency workers continued to try and do whatever they
- 13:54could to save her life. Police officers drove to the school to find Darcy's
- 13:58mom to tell her the horrible news about her daughter and take her to the
- 14:03hospital. Little Darcy hid and dirt head injuries, bruising and severe internal injuries.
- 14:09Yeah, it's like hitting cement right from that high up. Yeah.
- 14:13How she's still alive. I know, it's amazing. Right after five Yeah,
- 14:18I mean she'd have been in there a while. She's young. Yeah,
- 14:22she's just survived more. I'd be dead in a second. When Peter
- 14:26was at the hospital and she was informed how severe Darcy's injuries were, she
- 14:31had to make the hardest no, no for any parent to no. Yeah,
- 14:37she had to turn off Darcy's life support. I thought you were going
- 14:41to tell me Darcy surviving. No she didn't. I'm so sorry. I'm
- 14:46thinking she must have been brained at at this point. Right at one thirty
- 14:50five pm, Darcy Iris Freeman was pronounced dead while being cradled in her mother's
- 14:56army. I know this is terrible. After being arrested in the Commonwealth Law
- 15:01Courts Building, Arthur told police officers about what transpired When he was on the
- 15:07bridge. He told police he was worried about being late for school. As
- 15:11he approached the Westgate Bridge, he started to feel anxious and trapped, like
- 15:15he wasn't going to make it the school on time. While the traffic on
- 15:18the bridge. With the traffic on the bridge, his anxiety began to rise
- 15:22more and more and he started to feel right. I know, he started
- 15:26to feel frustrated. I get that too. Traffic gives me such anxiety.
- 15:30Instead of a normal road rage of yelling or even hitting the dashboard, Arthur
- 15:33decided he was going to grab Darcy out of the car and throw his only
- 15:37daughter over the side of the bridge. Can't he just beat obnatches and beat
- 15:41the horn at everybody, pip them off and flip them off and tell everybody
- 15:45like, let's fucking go right, No, this is a weird decision.
- 15:50As a news spread throughout Australia of Darcy's death, Australians were left just confused
- 15:54as to how a father could throw his own daughter off this undred and ninety
- 16:00foot high bridge to her death in the middle of rush hour. In the
- 16:04middle of rush hour, A consensus among the public was that the only reason
- 16:10was because Arthur was a psychopath. A reporter who was interviewed for TV series
- 16:14Crimes That Shocked Australia told them that when people would ask her what she was
- 16:18currently reporting at the time, she would tell them she was reporting the case
- 16:22of Darcy Freeman, and people would tell her that they couldn't talk or hear
- 16:26about the story. It was just too upset. Arthur's trial is getting ready
- 16:30to start because obviously he gets arrested. Australians who were tuning into the case
- 16:34were eager to see Peter Barnes. Many wanted to show her support as she
- 16:40would have to sit in court with her ex partner, who man Peter Lea.
- 16:47I know right, I would have to kill on. Honestly, I
- 16:52don't know how anybody can keep their composure in times like this. Peter lived
- 16:56in Western Australia, so many people had no idea what she looked like,
- 17:00and she would have to travel from there for the court proceedings. When they
- 17:03began, people were eager to see Arthur because, I mean, what a
- 17:07freak, right, There was no hesitation in what he did. When Arthur
- 17:11turned up to court, people were shocked by the man who appeared before them.
- 17:17He looked disheveled and like a rest mutant, like mad Monk. The
- 17:21hair Woody Harrelson on a really bad day, a little like pell Collins too.
- 17:26Write a little bit, not to disparage them, but a little bit.
- 17:29His hair was a mass. Yeah, his hair was a mass.
- 17:33You'll see photos if you go on. Yeah, he's like bald, but
- 17:36it's with male pattern baldness and his long hair. Yeah, and it's just
- 17:40like over. His hair was a mess. And when he sat in court,
- 17:44he just sat there blankly, staring ahead, without any emotion. He
- 17:48pleaded not guilty by reason of mental impairment. The prosecution made their arguments,
- 17:53telling the court that Arthur wasn't insane. He very clearly knew what he was
- 17:57doing when he pulled over her. I mean he put on his hazard lights
- 18:02and then he grabbed Darcy and threw her over the bridge, and he told
- 18:06his wife. Yeah. Yeah. They said he did it as an act
- 18:10of revenge against Peta due to their bitter custody battle. Yeah. Peta sat
- 18:15through every moment of the court proceedings. She didn't want to let Arthur see
- 18:18that his actions had gotten to her, so she sat completely composed during the
- 18:23entire trial. God bless her. She eventually testified against Arthur, telling the
- 18:29court about the relationship and the reason for their divorce. The court reporter told
- 18:33Crimes That Shocked Australia that when Peta testified, she was very poised in articulate.
- 18:38She carried herself well given the circumstances. The defense finally had a chance
- 18:44to tell the court their version of what cause Arthur to throw his daughter over
- 18:48the bridge that day. They told the court that Arthur had disassociated from the
- 18:52event, that he acted robot like when he grabbed a little Darcy out of
- 18:57the car and threw her to her death. The prosecution didn't believe this.
- 19:00I like, this is fucking bullshit, said That's what the bron scuter said.
- 19:07This is fucking bullshit, your honor, that's our interpretation what he said.
- 19:11In fact, the prosecution had gone to five different psychologists to find some
- 19:17sort of reasoning as to why the events on January twenty ninth occurred. All
- 19:22of them he had agreed that Arthur fully understood what he was doing and he
- 19:26knew right from wrong when he did it. He knew full well that not
- 19:29only could he have hurt his child by throwing over the bridge, that he
- 19:33could also potentially kill her. Potentially, Yeah, one hundred nine drop in
- 19:37the water and she can't swim. Let's see you jump into that water from
- 19:41that point. Now, Oh, that's very high. That's giving me like
- 19:47anxiety just looking at it. One psychologist testified and said, quote, all
- 19:51the observations of witnesses regarding his behavior on the morning of Darcy Freeman's death suggests
- 19:56that he knew the nature and quality of his conduct. Mister Freeman continued to
- 20:00demonstrate that he was able to think purposefully about a situation and to continue to
- 20:06make reasoned judgments about both his own behavior and the behavior of others. Unfortunately,
- 20:11we do not know what mister Freeman was thinking at the time he threw
- 20:15his daughter over the rail of the Westgate Bridge. Nonetheless, there is minimal
- 20:19evidence to support a conclusion that at the time of engaging in conduct constituting the
- 20:23offense, mister Freeman was suffering from mental illness that had the effect that he
- 20:29did not know that his conduct was wrong. That is, that he could
- 20:33not reason with a moderate degree of sense and composure about whether the conduct,
- 20:37as perceived by reasonable people, was wrong. He knew it was wrong,
- 20:41and quote exactly, he knew it was wrong. The jury heard about the
- 20:45phone calls that Arthur was making during the drive. You know those phone calls
- 20:48that he made to Peter. He also made phone calls to his sister,
- 20:52telling her that he was worried about the kids lunches and getting Darcy to school
- 20:57on time, but not once it assist get the indication that something terrible was
- 21:02about to transpire. He then called his friend, who was living in the
- 21:06UK at the time, and told her about his court verdict previous day and
- 21:10how it felt like he had lost his children, but he was fully prepared
- 21:12to fight the court as he was treated unfairly. He's making all these weird
- 21:17ass phone calls. He claimed. The court was full of angry women who
- 21:19were against fathers, which was the reason why he lost custody. We hear
- 21:23that all the time. I'm lightly dude. Yeah, they hate men.
- 21:26It's not true. It's not true anymore. Maybe maybe they used to be.
- 21:30They hate bad man, yeah, but now it's not true now it's
- 21:36He made no indication to his friend that he was going to murder his daughter.
- 21:38Then he received the first call from Peta, who was becoming increasingly worried
- 21:42that Arthur was running late to drop Darcy off on her first day of school.
- 21:47The prosecution felt that this call was the catalyst for the events that transpired
- 21:52Next. Arthur started to feel the rage build up inside him and wanted pet
- 21:56to feel the pain he was feeling. Arthur gave the war to his ex
- 22:00wife about what was going to happen only moments later. This warning to the
- 22:03premeditation as exactly this warning to Peter showed the court that Arthur was clearly not
- 22:10mentally unstable and was fully aware of what he was about to do. And
- 22:12he just pissed talking to her. Yeah, like this fucking bitch, I'm
- 22:17going to get her. They believe that Arthur didn't want to murder Peta,
- 22:22as that wouldn't have the desire to fact he was going because her, Yeah,
- 22:26he killed one of their kids. It would cause tremendous pain to Peta
- 22:30for the rest of her life. Before I tell you more, we're going
- 22:33to take a break. Arthur continued to sit in court emotionless as countless witnesses
- 22:44and professionals all testified against him. When the coroner described the injuries Darcy had
- 22:48stained in the fall, Arthur finally broke down and cried as he listened to
- 22:53every single detail. This would be the only time Arthur would show any emotion
- 22:59during the So what were her injuries? She had damage to her heart,
- 23:04the traumatic brain injury, and she had a collapsed lung and the traumatic brain
- 23:10injury. Also she lost oxygen and she was brain dead, and that's why
- 23:15her mother had to shut the way of support off. A bit about Arthur's
- 23:21background came out during the trial. His childhood was really nothing to note.
- 23:25His father was a school teacher and his mother was a crossing supervisor. While
- 23:30he was in crossing Guard, Yeah, crossing Guard. While he was in
- 23:33primary school or elementary school, he had a hard time as he was bullied
- 23:37and he even received counseling because of it. As he reached high school,
- 23:42however, he was no longer bullied, so the remainder of his childhood seemed
- 23:47uneventful, like nothing to really suggest that he could have the potential to do
- 23:51this to one of his own children. He attended university where he studied aquatic
- 23:56science, but then he later transferred to a different school and studied computer science,
- 24:00where he eventually graduated with a bachelor's degree. Arthur married Peter in nineteen
- 24:06ninety nine, and it was reported that the couple was very happy. They
- 24:10would then move to the UK or They purchased an apartment in London's North area.
- 24:15They gave birth to Ben, Darcy and Jack in the UK. Peto
- 24:18was ready to move back to Australia so the children could go to school there,
- 24:22so they rented a place in Hawthorne. Peto went back to work and
- 24:26Arthur was a stay at home dad who looked after the children all day.
- 24:29Oh he was yeah. The Peta and Arthur became unhappy with their relationship eventually,
- 24:36and it ended in March two thousand and seven. Despite many attempts at
- 24:40counseling, they eventually divorced in June of two thousand and eight. Was he
- 24:44stay at home dad on purpose? Or are you just can't fund a job?
- 24:48Girl? I don't know. Okay. While these events may have been
- 24:51upsetting, nothing would have suggested to people who knew Arthur that he would murder
- 24:56his child just six months later. However, there are some things people didn't
- 25:00know about Arthur. No one knew what he was like behind closed doors.
- 25:04People described Arthur as a nice guy and he was put together well. However,
- 25:10little did anyone know that Peter had reported to three different doctors that she
- 25:14believed Arthur was harming her children. She told one doctor that she felt he
- 25:18was so vengeful that he was going to kill her children just to get back
- 25:22at her. Another incident that Peter talked about was when she went to leave
- 25:27the house with her youngest son, Arthur grabbed him out of her arms and
- 25:30acted as if he was going to smashim into the fireplace. What Peter's mother
- 25:36was at the house when this happened, and both Peta and her mother had
- 25:38to fight Arthur off when he wouldn't give his son over to Peta. Another
- 25:44instance of Arthur's aggression showed its ugly face when Arthur attended a social function in
- 25:48two thousand and eight, where he started to make threats against Peta if she
- 25:52tried to prevent him from having access to the children's whether there's some red flags,
- 25:56but no one ever thinks this would happen, Not this now. After
- 26:02nineteen days, the trial came to a close and the jury was sent to
- 26:06reach its verdict. It took the jury multiple days for them to come back
- 26:11with a decision because to them this didn't seem so cut and dry. Really,
- 26:15yeah, well, maybe they were arguing about second grievers. Maybe they
- 26:19came back multiple times to ask the judge questions, and it was obvious that
- 26:23the jury just couldn't grasp what they needed to decide. The judge then posed
- 26:29the question as to whether Arthur deliberately killed Darcy or whether he was insane.
- 26:34The jury really struggled with the fact that though they believed he wasn't insane,
- 26:41they then felt that would mean he deliberately killed his child, and nobody really
- 26:45wants to think that. Arthur claimed he had no recollection of what happened,
- 26:49but his actions caused the death of Darcy, so that left the jurors conflicted
- 26:53about reaching a verdict. They eventually came back and told the court that they
- 26:59were deadline and couldn't make a decision. There were women in the jury that
- 27:03were clearly upset when they informed the judge they couldn't come up with a unanimous
- 27:08verdict, and some were crying. It was evident to everyone in the courtroom
- 27:12that there was some tension among the jurists. This started to worry people in
- 27:17the courtroom who wanted to see Arthur found guilty. The judge wasn't having any
- 27:22of it from the jury. It was seven pm and most jurors go home
- 27:26at four thirty. When the judge told him, you're going to go back
- 27:29and you're gonna make a decision, as he believed they could come up with
- 27:33a final decision, the judge rephrased the question without any legal jargon to help
- 27:38the jury understand the question better, and they were once again sent to come
- 27:42to a verdict. Fourteen minutes later, they had a verdict. Okay.
- 27:47They were like, okay, we're gone. It was like, we want
- 27:49to go home. I'm sorry. That's probably not true. It probably is,
- 27:52but it's probably not in the in the in the name of justice,
- 27:56it's probably not true. The jury found Arthur Freeman guilty of murdering his daughter
- 28:03and that he had no mental impairment. A reporter told Crimes That Shocked Australia
- 28:07that after the verdict was read, she got into a taxi and just cried.
- 28:11She felt the sense of relief that Arthur was found guilty after what he
- 28:15did to Darcy and that Darcy's family got the justice they deserved and Arthur was
- 28:19going to be punished for his crime. As the sentencing hearing came around,
- 28:23Peter read a victim impact statement. Oh Man, and this was the only
- 28:29time she allowed herself to show how much the loss of her daughter really hurt
- 28:33her. She didn't want to give Arthur the satisfaction of the pain he caused
- 28:37until after he was found guilty. The judge would later repeat parts of Peter's
- 28:41impact statement when the sentencing came as he wanted to reiterate to Arthur the magnitude
- 28:47of his crime. Quote. Where to start is a challenge, as this
- 28:49statement brings to the surface all of the raw emotions I live with daily since
- 28:55the loss of Darcy. I grieve on a daily basis and realistically do not
- 28:59see how it can ever change. The same time heals all wounds is not
- 29:03true for myself, and I don't ever expect it to be. Not a
- 29:06day goes by where I do not constantly think of Darcy, where I don't
- 29:08miss her and wish with all my heart that she was with me. I
- 29:12can feel her little hand holding mine when I walked down the street or drive
- 29:17in the car. I lie in bed at night and hold her in my
- 29:19arms. I talked to her and think of her daily, wishing she was
- 29:22participating the activities that were happening at the time. No words could ever truly
- 29:27describe the loss of a child to a parent, the emptiness that sits with
- 29:32you, the piece of you that no longer exists, the fact that you
- 29:34no longer go on in life as a complete person. Seeing little girls who
- 29:38have similar traits or looks to Darcy heightens my already active emotions. Holding myself
- 29:45back from giving the child a hug is always a struggle of self control.
- 29:51Not a day goes by where I don't flash back to the emotions I felt
- 29:53when I was told by my ex husband that I would never see my children
- 29:56again. The panic and fear these words oft inside me resonates within me even
- 30:02today. I feel and now an incidents of my daily life that would not
- 30:06have impacted me prior to Darcy's passing. I noticed that I have heightened anxiety
- 30:11in everyday situations and have to manage myself carefully to control this end quote just
- 30:15got those two boys got to take care, right? Don't I want to
- 30:19cry? Time heals all wounds. I don't think not losing a child.
- 30:23Now. Officers who were on the scene and found Darcy's body in the water
- 30:29have been diagnosed with PTSD and major depressive disorder, and many commuters that witnessed
- 30:34Arthur throw Darcy over the bridge had to receive counseling for the tragic event they
- 30:38witnessed. Many of those people wrote impact statements for the court to show the
- 30:44impact of Arthur's actions, like what it had on the community was crowded,
- 30:49crowded. You know, many of these people are just trying to get to
- 30:52work and they're just never going to forget this day because of what Arthur did.
- 30:56On April eleventh, two thy eleven, Arthur was sent to life in
- 31:00prison with a minimum sentence of thirty two years. The judge believe that Arthur
- 31:03was not beyond redemption but needed to be punished for his heinous act. Arthur
- 31:08will be eligible for parole in twenty forty one, when he will be sixty
- 31:12seven years old. Like many times we've seen before, this would not be
- 31:17the end for Arthur. Arthur, what's that mean? Well, Arthur set
- 31:21out to appeal his sentence, okay, believing that what he had been given
- 31:25was manifestly excessive. Once again, your core is just bringing him. Yeah,
- 31:32they're just you know, they're giving it to him. Once again.
- 31:36Unfair, unfair. Arthur's team felt that while the judge thought Arthur's depression at
- 31:41the time was moderate, he completely overlooked it and it should have been considered
- 31:45high. Okay, well, hi to your depression. Yeah, doesn't mean
- 31:48you're throw a kid, you know. They said, because he had high
- 31:52depression, his sentence should be reduced. He should have I mean, this
- 31:55sounds bad, but he could have killed himself, right, right, Yeah,
- 32:00why but it wouldn't hurt Peta if he killed himself, right. Arthur's
- 32:05appeal was ultimately rejected on multiple grounds. There was nothing provided to the court
- 32:09that could prove that Arthur was in such a depressive state that he was unaware
- 32:14of what he was doing. Is basically what the court decided the minished capacity
- 32:19right and wrong. The previous judge said during a sentencing quote, I except
- 32:23that your offending was not premeditated, but related to your increasing anger towards your
- 32:29former wife over the family court proceedings, exacerbated by you being late for Darcy's
- 32:35first day at school. It should be noted that Professor Burrows, who was
- 32:38the psychiatrist called by the defense, did not doubt that you were angry at
- 32:43the time you killed your daughter. Well, no, shit, I have
- 32:45no doubt that the resentment you bore your wife had been building for some time.
- 32:49Yeah, he did it because he's pissed and he's anxious. Yeah,
- 32:53for sure, he wanted revenge. He hated her, and she was taking
- 32:58away his kids, so he was going to take dar. She wasn't even
- 33:00taking away his kids, you know, she wasn't see his kids, and
- 33:04she didn't make the decision the court did. While Arthur is living out a
- 33:08sentence in a maximum security prison, it is reported that he was involved in
- 33:13a prison brawl where he sustained minor injuries. Apparently, other inmates were constantly
- 33:19tawning him, which eventually resulted in him exploding at them. This then caused
- 33:23the inmates to start a fight with Arthur, and it would be a minute
- 33:27before the prison guards stepped in to break up the fight. Arthur and the
- 33:30other inmates in the fight were eventually separated across the prison to prevent another altercation.
- 33:36An inquest was conducted from statements made by Peter Barnes. Was this tragic
- 33:40event preventable and is there anything we can learn from this? The focus of
- 33:45this inquest was mainly on Pete's appointments with her doctors, where she disclosed to
- 33:50them about the potential abuse her children were suffering, and whether the doctors acted
- 33:54responsibly by not reporting the allegations to authorities. But I don't think they have
- 34:00to report hypothetical Yeah, oh, you're not going to see your children again.
- 34:07Now if he said he was going to kill them, right, that's
- 34:09true, He didn't say that. He didn't say that. The inquest heard
- 34:13that the police did attend to domestic dispute between Pete and Arthur in two thousand
- 34:16and seven. The police were aware of some instances of concern, so the
- 34:21doctors felt that they didn't need to report the allegations to polices. They were
- 34:24already aware of them, and that's why he didn't get joint custody exactly right.
- 34:31The doctors felt there were no indicators at the time that would suggest that
- 34:35Arthur would hurt his children. One doctor said that even in hindsight, he
- 34:37had no idea what Arthur was going to do. He didn't threaten to throw
- 34:42a kid in a fireplace though, right, he didn't threaten it, he
- 34:45acted like he was going to do it. Yeah, Arthur always seemed to
- 34:47appear well put together and calm. So not in the pictures I saw them.
- 34:52They was during the trial. Though. After Darcy's death there were a
- 34:55spike in suicides off the Westgate Bridge. Yeah, could have been prevented.
- 35:00I guess if there was some talk of putting more barriers up on the bridge,
- 35:05but high, yeah, higher ones. The Westgate Bridge now has.
- 35:08They have nets. Oh right, they do down on like on a bridge.
- 35:14They would jump and then that catches you. Well, then you could
- 35:16always jump off the net. It's true. I think I'm kind of hard
- 35:21to get out of though. I'm just saying, yeah, there's a will,
- 35:23there's a way. It's true. The Westgate Bridge now has safety barriers
- 35:29to prevent anyone from jumping off the bridge or being thrown off. Many Australians
- 35:34still feel great sadness when they hear Darcy's name or see the Westgate Bridge.
- 35:38It is unclear how Darcy's family is currently doing, but I hope they're doing
- 35:43well. I did too, and they're able to remember Darcy for the beautiful
- 35:46little girl that she was, and not for her death. When when did
- 35:51this happen? This wasn't that long ago? Right? No? Ten years
- 35:53ago, two thousand and nine. Her poor brothers, I know. Ok
- 36:00how do you, I know, get over that? How do you get
- 36:04over that? I don't know? And that's my terrible, sad story about
- 36:08little Darcy Freeman. I don't like those kinds of stories. I know.
- 36:13I'm very very very sad and horrible. And it's just how can you do
- 36:19that? How anybody could do this? He snapped, Yeah, lost it
- 36:23definitely, Teliah. Before we get into our business, would you like to
- 36:28do some review the reviewer? Oh my gosh, we haven't done that in
- 36:30so long. Oh my god. Well we've gotten some who star reviews recently.
- 36:36Well, I have to go from sad to pissed off. Yeah,
- 36:37and they're mostly about me. So you're going to enjoy this. I'm just
- 36:40kidding you would enjoy it about you? Okay. This one was left on
- 36:50August seventh, twenty twenty three, by Chris Jesse Jake and it's two stars
- 36:54and the title is used to be a fan Oh. I used to love
- 36:59the show, but I feel like every time I listen it gets cornier corner.
- 37:02Tanya needs to go what all these he needs to fucking go all the
- 37:08oh my gods, and seriously, and she just piggybacks on whatever Talia says
- 37:14this. No, you are real. Like when I'm having a normal conversation
- 37:17with Tanya, she talks exactly the same. I have no idea how in
- 37:22the world she's an attorney. She seems to have like half a brain.
- 37:27What the mother fuck? Yeah, fuck this person. He needs to fuck
- 37:32off. Yeah, Chris jesse Ja gets one star. No, he gets
- 37:36no stars, and he gets a big fuck off Chris jesse Jay can lick
- 37:40my nuts. Okay, it's gracious, Well he's lucky he's not in front
- 37:45of me right now. Yeah, we have another one Okay, two stars.
- 37:50I don't like these. This was left July thirty, first, twenty
- 37:52twenty three by eight five eight Mia. Okay eight five eight Mia Mia.
- 37:58I've been listening for a long time, but the past five or so episodes,
- 38:00I've had to stop them midway. I can't finish. It. Sounds
- 38:04like they are reading directly from a script and it's their first read through.
- 38:07Sometimes it is the constant, Oh my god, and seriously throughout the story
- 38:14are obnoxious and they and they saw first in fake, they're not worse in
- 38:19fake. They're definitely not fucked sake. Oh my god. Right, Like,
- 38:22what what is your reaction when you hear a horrible story like she's getting
- 38:28thrown off the bridge? Oh my god, Oh my god. All right,
- 38:31I'm gonna have to think of something else. I'm gonna have to have
- 38:35new natural reaction. It's me and not you. So it's like the host
- 38:38give up, are no longer into true crime. So they're just going through
- 38:42the motions. I don't know what happened, but I have to stop listening.
- 38:45Oh okay, well you can also fuck off. Yeah, you can
- 38:47also fuck off and fuck off some more. When you're done fucking off,
- 38:52fuck you. Then there's a five start, so we're gonna do some good
- 38:57ones, okay or something nice. So July twenty fourth, JBT Mom said,
- 39:02addicted five stars to what. I really love this podcast. Great host,
- 39:07chemistry, lesser known cases, and victim focused checks all the boxes for
- 39:12true crime junkies. Then August fifth, wait, I love her, Oh
- 39:16yes, I love her. She's five stars, five stars across the board.
- 39:20Ye right, we love you, we love you JBT mom. Yeah,
- 39:23absolutely absolutely, it was very nice of you to leave a nice review.
- 39:27Yeah, oh my god, oh my god. So seriously. Then
- 39:32in August fifth Jazzy Girls sixty six, she gave us five stars. She
- 39:37said, I came across you recently and have been binging from episode one.
- 39:43I love it exclamation point, exclamation point. I'm with Tanya. I hate
- 39:46people, and none of the killers deserve a second chance. Whoa shit.
- 39:51I know I'm kind of hard on it. I mean, I hate people,
- 39:52but sometimes redemption love the fact that you ladies can talk honestly and you
- 40:00don't care about what anyone has to say. No, we don't give a
- 40:04fuck except her. I like what she had to say. We're very sweet.
- 40:07We love you, we love you. You don't need to fuck off
- 40:09because we like you. We do lovely. The other two star people can
- 40:16go fucking kiss my ass, kiss lin too, and go find a different
- 40:22podcast. I mean, honestly, yeah, go go. If you don't
- 40:24like the way I talk or the things I say, Sorry for being real.
- 40:30Would you rather me sit here like a robot? You know who scripted?
- 40:32Oh, I'm not gonna say. I'm not gonna say their name,
- 40:37but maybe she could listen to them. Yeah, at least they don't say
- 40:39oh my god. And seriously, seriously, do I really say it that
- 40:43much? We both do it all times? Sometimes do we say seriously at
- 40:46the same time? Seriously seriously? I know? Just sorry? Well,
- 40:51you know what, Like I said, now, I'm pissed. I'm really
- 40:53pissed about those two stars, especially the one that's trying to hurt my friend,
- 40:59because Honey is my friend. I know, you know, it doesn't
- 41:01hurt we're feeling. If I knew where he was at our slashes tires and
- 41:05run really fast away and maybe keys car, I don't know, maybe maybe
- 41:09maybe we could do together my dog shit on his mirror or windows or whatever
- 41:15or yeah, but I won't I wouldn't do that. It's illegal, but
- 41:17I might do it. If I wouldn't fantasize about it, I could,
- 41:22you know, you never know if I had enough alcohol, right, what
- 41:24I might do. So that was our segment review the reviewer. Yes,
- 41:30well I don't like those people. Yeah, those people can fuck right off.
- 41:34But I love the other two so absolutely. And there's lots of other
- 41:37really great ones. You know, we do review the reviewer usually when there's
- 41:39a bad review that comes by because because we hate them. Because we hate
- 41:44them and I need to vent a little bit somebody, you know, if
- 41:46I need to go to Leah really doesn't want to do the show with just
- 41:50on her own. Oh yeah, hey, I'll be like, hey,
- 41:52so then she jumped off, you know, I got thrown off a bridge.
- 41:54Maybe Oh my god, you could do both? Yeah, like it
- 41:58just what, no fucking way to Leah. Yeah no, it doesn't work
- 42:05that way. Yeah, no, fuck them anyway, before we go,
- 42:09We'll just do the business now. You can find our website Crimes and Consequences
- 42:15dot com. You can find out information there about becoming a Patriot member,
- 42:20or you can go to Patreon dot com slash t NT crimes like Dynamite and
- 42:25becoming a patreont member means that if you sign up for the highest level,
- 42:30you can get an extra episode every week that's unreleased to the public. You
- 42:34also get ad free an early release of our normal weekly episodes. Yes,
- 42:39if you want to check that out, go to either our website or patriot
- 42:43dot com slash TMT crimes Crime. You can find us on social media and
- 42:49hardcore true crime, hardcore crime on Facebook and Instagram. Even though we haven't
- 42:52been active all I haven't. One day we will. I'm sorry, but
- 42:57life has been horrible these past pisser. Yes, so I'm sorry. Life's
- 43:00a real big pisser and I think that's everything. So until our next episode,
- 43:07don't kill each other. Bye bye,