Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Mini: Things are getting Dire
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, Chelsea, I have three different articles
- 0:02for you to choose from. Not all of them are necessarily
- 0:05Dooming Loom, so... Okay. How have you sorted
- 0:08them for me to choose? Well, I have three. I'm
- 0:10going to give you a vague idea of the topics.
- 0:12One is De -Extinction, one is Financial Times,
- 0:18and one is Astronomy. Well, I'm definitely not
- 0:21choosing anything financial. So let's go with
- 0:24De -Extinction. Did you hear about the dire wolf
- 0:28that was cloned recently? I did actually. Oh
- 0:32good. Because this is in line with it. Would
- 0:35you like me to tell you about it? This article
- 0:39is on that and kind of the things that weren't
- 0:41talked about when everything was pumped through
- 0:44the news system with it. So, this one comes from
- 0:47a site that we've used many a time, Live Live
- 0:50Science. We're never sure how to pronounce it.
- 0:52If only we were able to look into this at some
- 0:55time in our spare time, but we will not. This
- 1:00came out April 9th, 2025 by Sasha Pear. And it
- 1:04is titled, Colossal de -extincted direwolf isn't
- 1:07a direwolf and it has not been de -extincted,
- 1:10expert says. I love where this is going. In an
- 1:13announcement on Monday, April 7th, scientists
- 1:15revealed to the world that they have brought
- 1:17back long -extinct direwolves with genetic engineering.
- 1:21Researchers with biotechnology company Colossal
- 1:23Biosciences shared images of three adorable Snow
- 1:26White pups which they said marked the world's
- 1:29first de -extinction. I don't think that's necessarily
- 1:32true, but let's not get into this now. Okay,
- 1:34fair enough. Also, you're gonna think they're
- 1:36claiming that. Dire Wolves, which were made famous
- 1:39by HBO's television series Game of Thrones, went
- 1:42extinct at the time of the last Ice Age. By creating
- 1:44Lookalike Pops, Colossal CEO Ben Lam said that
- 1:48the company has, quote, made healthy dire wolf
- 1:50puppies, end quote, and resurrected these predators
- 1:53after more than 10 ,000 years of de -extinction.
- 1:56But many experts say the language used by Colossal
- 1:58to describe these creations is misleading, quote,
- 2:01what Colossal have produced is a gray wolf with
- 2:04dire wolf -like characteristics, end quote. Nick
- 2:07Rollins, an associate professor and co -director
- 2:09of the Otago Paleogenetics Laboratory at the
- 2:13University of Otago told the New Zealand Science
- 2:16Media Center quote this is not a de -extincted
- 2:19direwolf rather it's a hybrid end quote to make
- 2:21the pup scientists extracted DNA from two prehistoric
- 2:25direwolf fossils a 13 ,000 year old tooth discovered
- 2:28in Sheridan pit Ohio and a 72 ,000 year old ear
- 2:32bone from American Falls in Idaho Using this
- 2:35DNA, the researchers pieced together a partial
- 2:37direwolf genome, which they then compared with
- 2:40the genomes of the direwolf's closest living
- 2:42relatives including wolves, jackals, and foxes.
- 2:46Based on their results, the scientists selected
- 2:48the gray wolf as an egg donor to quote bring
- 2:51back end quote direwolves. Despite the two species
- 2:55not actually being that closely related, experts
- 2:57said. Quote, new information shows that the original
- 3:00direwolf itself was not really a wolf, end quote.
- 3:03David Mack, an adjunct professor specializing
- 3:06in wolf ecology and behavior at the University
- 3:08of Minnesota and senior research scientist with
- 3:10the U .S. Geological Survey, I guess that probably
- 3:13should say former at this point because he's
- 3:15probably been fired from that, told Live Science
- 3:17in an email. Evolutionarily speaking, direwolves
- 3:20split from wolves roughly six million years ago,
- 3:23forming an entirely separate group from modern
- 3:25-day gray wolves. Quote, Dire wolves are in their
- 3:29own genus, so a very different species." Philip
- 3:32Sedon, a professor of zoology at the University
- 3:35of Otago, told New Zealand Science Media Centre.
- 3:38Quote, the average acol might be more closely
- 3:41related to dire wolves, end quote. De -extinction
- 3:44requires egg cells from a living animal to hold
- 3:46and grow the genetic material of the animal scientists
- 3:49want to create. Having selected grey wolves to
- 3:51perform this step, colossal scientists then collected
- 3:54cells from grey wolf blood samples and modified
- 3:56them to resemble the cells found in dire wolf
- 3:59fossils. Using CRISPR gene editing technology,
- 4:02the team made a total of 20 edits in 14 genes
- 4:05that they identified as important in giving dire
- 4:07wolves their traits. Next, in a similar process
- 4:11as the one used to clone Dolly the Sheep in 1996,
- 4:14the scientists inserted the modified cell's DNA
- 4:16into a grey wolf's egg cells, whose own genetic
- 4:19material had previously been removed. At this
- 4:21point, the grey wolf egg cells contained all
- 4:23the genetic information required to build the
- 4:25wolves with some of the defining characteristics
- 4:27of dire wolves. The egg cells were then left
- 4:29to mature in the lab, and the resulting embryos
- 4:32were implanted into the wombs of domestic dogs,
- 4:34which are technically a subspecies of the grey
- 4:36wolf. Colossal's first direwolf puppies, and
- 4:39direwolf is in quotations, Romulus and Remus
- 4:42were born October 1st, 2024, meaning they are
- 4:45now 5 months old adolescents. According to Colossal,
- 4:48they are being held and continually monitored
- 4:50in a nature preserve surrounded by 10 foot tall
- 4:52fencing. That doesn't really sound like a nature
- 4:54reserve. They will live out their life in a luxurious
- 4:58preserve under human care." Bridget Von Holt,
- 5:01a professor of evolutionary genomics and epigenetics
- 5:04at Princeton University, who collaborates with
- 5:06Colossal on the project, told LiveScience in
- 5:08an email, Their health always remains unpredictable
- 5:15and of potential concern." A third pup, Khaleesi,
- 5:19was born on January 30th, 2025. It's unclear
- 5:22how dangerous these animals are, but their behavior
- 5:24is unlikely to differ dramatically from that
- 5:26of a captive gray wolf. Especially as they have
- 5:28been constantly surrounded by humans, von Holt
- 5:30said. Romulus, Remus, and Khaleesi will not be
- 5:45released into the wild, but in the future Colossal
- 5:47said it will consider options to introduce animals
- 5:49into, quote, secure and expansive ecological
- 5:52preserves potentially on indigenous land, end
- 5:55quote. But some experts doubt very much that
- 5:57these introductions would be successful, quote,
- 5:59any release of the wild would be fraught with
- 6:01negative PR and legal consequences, which would
- 6:04probably also be the case with any of the other
- 6:07types of newly created animals, end quote, Mech
- 6:09said. Regarding the direwolf specifically, Mack
- 6:12said there is a question mark over how they might
- 6:14fit into modern ecosystems. Quote, they occupied
- 6:17an entirely different ecological niche than exists
- 6:19today, end quote he said. Many experts have criticized
- 6:22Colossal's announcement, but some have also praised
- 6:25the technological breakthroughs the company made
- 6:28along the way. Quote, certainly this involves
- 6:30advances in genetics technology, and these might
- 6:33have applications for the conservation of existing
- 6:36species, end quote said and said. One species
- 6:38that is already benefiting from the Colossal's
- 6:40breakthrough is the Red Wolf, the world's most
- 6:43endangered wolf. The company announced the birth
- 6:45of two litters of cloned Red Wolves on Monday,
- 6:48boosting the number of Red Wolves held in captivity
- 6:50in the US and offering new hope to the species.
- 6:52But at the end of the day, Colossal's claim that
- 6:55it has resurrected the direwolf is spurious.
- 6:58Seddon and others have said, quote, Colossal
- 7:00compared the genomes of the direwolf and the
- 7:02gray wolf, and from about 19 ,000 genes, they
- 7:05determined that 20 changes and 14 genes gave
- 7:08them a direwolf, end quote Roland said. Moreover,
- 7:12Colossal's quote direwolves unquote. Aren't technically
- 7:15the world's first the extinction? Oh good, they
- 7:17answered that. In 2003, scientists in Spain cloned
- 7:20an extinct wild goat species known as the Picardo
- 7:22or the Pyrenean Ibix. A baby goat was born, but
- 7:26it died seven minutes later due to a lung defect.
- 7:29The announcement on Monday means that quote,
- 7:31we have GMO wolves and might one day have GMO
- 7:34Asian elephants. But for now, extinction really
- 7:36is forever. End quote, sad and sad. That's the
- 7:39end of the quote. That's the end of the article.
- 7:40Can I share my screen with you? Yeah, go ahead.
- 7:43I got to thinking while you were speaking. Oh,
- 7:46they got the puppies up there. Yeah. Oh, those
- 7:48aren't puppy. Those are full groans. This is
- 7:50like some crazy Jurassic Park. First of all,
- 7:53this is the most fancy website I've ever been
- 7:56on. It does really look like an advertisement
- 7:59for like Pacific Northwest Park or something
- 8:01like that. It is crazy. Okay, I just was taking
- 8:05a look through this website while you were talking
- 8:08and... It is I just have to go through it. Look
- 8:13at this I'm on I'm showing Taylor the colossal
- 8:16comm website actually and I'm on the heading
- 8:18for D extinction There's a few things that I
- 8:21wanted to point out to you on here because this
- 8:24is I mean I'm surprised that I don't see any
- 8:27t -rexes or Raptors on here. Look at this rebuilding
- 8:30extinct species for existence today Oh good.
- 8:34Yeah, just wait. Oh, they got some holy mammoths
- 8:37Wow. This is fully just PR. It is. And I'm not
- 8:43seeing any mention of meatballs at all. by the
- 8:48way oh you got to get to the food cart part of
- 8:50this yeah because jurassic park had a food court
- 8:52so down here when i scroll on see we're right
- 8:57here we're in the human causation section yeah
- 9:00there's one where we can go to all the species
- 9:04that are about to go extinct that they would
- 9:07like to eventually replace here we're in the
- 9:10extinction stats Anyhow, I think I lost it, but
- 9:13I just wanted to show you how beautiful this
- 9:15website was, first of all. Oh, right here! That
- 9:19is... Endangered Animal Backup. Oh, good. That
- 9:22doesn't sound like one of the problems we talked
- 9:24about with the extinction. Nope. It seems like...
- 9:28Is that Kathy Bates? It does look a lot like
- 9:31short -haired Kathy Bates. That was just a lot
- 9:36of you listening to us scroll through a website.
- 9:39You couldn't even hear the scrolling. Poor guys.
- 9:42I just really want to emphasize that this website
- 9:44really seems to downplay the fact that we talked
- 9:46about in the extinction episode. If you want
- 9:48to go learn more about it, go listen to it. But
- 9:50basically, if we think we can clone or bring
- 9:53a species back from extinction or not have to
- 9:55worry about an endangered species because we
- 9:57can clone them, it takes away the impact of people
- 9:59having to worry about other species. huge impact
- 10:03because we can just clone them back and that
- 10:05website worried me a lot with how they're just
- 10:07kind of downplaying that or at least using it
- 10:10for advertising yeah it's like don't worry science
- 10:12but the other worrisome thing like how about
- 10:16like reintroducing these kinds of things back
- 10:19into our environment because nature like evens
- 10:22itself out and then you're just like dire wolves
- 10:25yeah and I just because I found this article
- 10:28on reddit I was reading through it it's not on
- 10:30this but it's on another one the Dire Wolves
- 10:32post found a really good comment from somebody
- 10:35named Saint Ulvaman was posted 23 days ago which
- 10:39would be April 7th from when we're recording
- 10:41and they said I'm a geneticist myself though
- 10:44I have different specialty I've never done any
- 10:46work like this but I'm paid to know a lot about
- 10:48this one thing they don't seem to have done anything
- 10:52specific to account for is that Dire Wolves weren't
- 10:55wolves they were about as separate from wolves
- 10:57as chimpanzees are from humans jackals and african
- 11:00wild dogs are more closely related to wolves
- 11:02than dire wolves that makes sense it's just like
- 11:05a mammoth like you can't recreate a mammoth in
- 11:08itself no exactly so there were definitely more
- 11:12than 20 differences between what they actually
- 11:15sampled in the wolf genome they used. Change
- 11:1820 genes in a human and you might get something
- 11:21that looks like a chimpanzee if you've done a
- 11:23really good job of picking the right 20 genes.
- 11:26But you're still going to get something that
- 11:28is very genetically different from a chimpanzee
- 11:31because you started from a human and most of
- 11:33its genes were human. The same applies here.
- 11:37So although this is very interesting work, that
- 11:40helps us observe the effect of old genes from
- 11:43a popular understanding, it's really important
- 11:45to note that these are actually not real dire
- 11:48wolves yet. Their wolveshoof's genes have been
- 11:51edited to be a bit more like dire wolves. But
- 11:53that's scary though, isn't it? That feels like
- 11:56a horror movie starting. It's like weird. It
- 11:59really does. Yeah, and it could go horribly wrong.
- 12:02Well, the fact that they even say these will
- 12:04never be released into the wild because they
- 12:06don't really know how loaning will impact anything
- 12:10when they do it because it can just go so horribly
- 12:12wrong and I misspoke it's not like the mammoth
- 12:16at all because they had mammoth DNA to create
- 12:19those meatballs and What they're doing with the
- 12:22entire wolf is they they're trying to recreate
- 12:25its DNA They don't have any actual DNA from it.
- 12:28No, they did have DNA two samples Yeah, and then
- 12:32they cloned it through the genetics of a wolf.
- 12:34So where's the company with the direwolf meatball?
- 12:37That is a great question, but there's no evidence
- 12:40that a direwolf's gonna be more delicious than
- 12:42a wolf, and we don't make wolf meatballs. You
- 12:44know, I don't eat meat, but I would fully imagine
- 12:48that a wooly mammoth meatball would be way better
- 12:51than a direwolf. It's gotta be worth it. I mean,
- 12:53who's trying it, though? No one, so... Great
- 12:56question. I know. I'm full of them. But yeah,
- 12:59I mean, you guys got 48 hours now. Go explore
- 13:01that website. See how our major issues that we've
- 13:06caused this planet have no impact on the future
- 13:08because we can just bring everything back. Don't
- 13:10let them rope you in. Bye.