Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - Every now and then I stupid my way into smart
Transcript
- 0:07This is AV Superfriends Off the Rails,
- 0:10an almost regularly scheduled open
- 0:11discussion on audio and video in higher
- 0:14education.
- 0:15We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 0:16ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:18and everything in between.
- 0:19And because this conversation will almost
- 0:21certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 0:23we'll end up covering just about
- 0:24everything else.
- 0:25And now, the AV Superfriends.
- 0:31For February six, twenty twenty six,
- 0:33it's the best sounding and most ISE
- 0:35focused podcast in higher ed.
- 0:37This is the super friends off the rails.
- 0:39Episode number one hundred and thirty one.
- 0:42I want to say the number's wrong,
- 0:43but I'm going with it anyway.
- 0:44It seems right.
- 0:45It sounds right.
- 0:46That's right.
- 0:46It's close.
- 0:48It's fine.
- 0:49Broadcasting live across all four time
- 0:51zones.
- 0:52That's strangely phrased.
- 0:53It's that time of year where half the
- 0:54AV world is in Europe attending a trade
- 0:56show and the other half is quietly
- 0:58grateful they won't have to explain
- 0:59certain LinkedIn photos to a future hiring
- 1:02committee.
- 1:03We chose wisely.
- 1:04I'm Chris Benjamin.
- 1:05You're tuned in for another Friday
- 1:06afternoon podcast adventure.
- 1:07Hmm.
- 1:09I'm telling you, man.
- 1:10What happens when I'm out there?
- 1:11Something about bathtubs.
- 1:12And let's say hello to today's panel of
- 1:14AV super friends.
- 1:16Hmm.
- 1:18Our first panelist leads groundbreaking
- 1:20campus initiatives entirely from his
- 1:22office,
- 1:23proving innovation is possible without
- 1:25international airfare, per diems,
- 1:27or LinkedIn humblebrags.
- 1:29He's a director of domestic innovation and
- 1:31fiscal responsibility from Kansas City.
- 1:33Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:36Making new stuff with no dollars.
- 1:41Our next panelist generates industry
- 1:43insights, conference opinions,
- 1:44and strategic direction without ever
- 1:46leaving campus or pretending that missing
- 1:48ISE was a huge loss.
- 1:50He's a coordinator of remote thought
- 1:52leadership and sensible travel choices
- 1:54from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 1:55Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolobosinski.
- 1:57I'll have co-pilot with that all together
- 1:59in a nice little summary.
- 2:00I want you guys to submit your reports.
- 2:02Thank you.
- 2:03And submit reports.
- 2:05Our next panelist ensures all AV, IT,
- 2:08and human systems function despite
- 2:10sub-zero mornings, snow days,
- 2:12and morale dips caused by February lasting
- 2:14forty-seven weeks.
- 2:15He's a manager of WinterEye Systems and
- 2:17Cold Start Operations from Greensboro,
- 2:19North Carolina.
- 2:20Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:22My son has been remote from school for
- 2:24two weeks.
- 2:25This is nonsense.
- 2:26And Larry is out of wine.
- 2:31And our final panelist provides executive
- 2:33oversight by not attending overseas trade
- 2:35shows and instead approving budget
- 2:37staffing plans and reality-based
- 2:40technology decisions.
- 2:41He's a vice president for strategic
- 2:43presence, North America,
- 2:45from Bowling Green, Kentucky.
- 2:46Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:48Oh, North America.
- 2:48So I'm strategically not present at ISC
- 2:51because I can't leave North America.
- 2:54It's not your jurisdiction, sir.
- 2:55It's not your market.
- 2:56There's a whole other group who handles
- 3:00other parts of the world.
- 3:01That's fine.
- 3:01The contingent from Europe say their
- 3:04numbers are looking better than yours.
- 3:05That's fine.
- 3:05I don't have my real ID.
- 3:07I got a passport.
- 3:08It should be good enough.
- 3:09It's not.
- 3:10I think.
- 3:11You just jumped the line.
- 3:12It better be.
- 3:12It's a forty dollar fee.
- 3:14All right.
- 3:14Better not be.
- 3:15We're going to discuss rethinking our
- 3:17approach to camera deployments and the
- 3:19death of eight K. But first,
- 3:21some housekeeping.
- 3:22So if you're listening to this as a
- 3:23recording or just as a reminder,
- 3:24we do stream live on Fridays at about
- 3:26three fifteen Eastern twelve fifteen
- 3:27Pacific or whenever we get our act
- 3:29together.
- 3:29Today,
- 3:29we were debating what the actual news
- 3:31story was going to be.
- 3:33We just said it was going to be
- 3:33ISE news and we had to, like,
- 3:35figure that out.
- 3:36So, yeah.
- 3:38Anyway,
- 3:38you can join us live for that on
- 3:39YouTube, LinkedIn, Twitter, etc.
- 3:41I just noticed this.
- 3:42Don't put that there.
- 3:43All right.
- 3:43If you can't make that live,
- 3:45don't worry about it.
- 3:45Please connect with us on the same
- 3:46socials.
- 3:46You can follow us.
- 3:47Just follow AVSuperFriends.
- 3:48You'll find us on there on Twitter,
- 3:50LinkedIn, YouTube, Blue Sky.
- 3:51We're all over that stuff.
- 3:52So there's updates.
- 3:53There's clips.
- 3:53There's all sorts of fun things going on
- 3:55there.
- 3:56And the occasional reminder that
- 3:57meaningful work still happens even when
- 3:58you're not roaming the European exhibit
- 4:00halls collecting tote bags and bad
- 4:01opinions.
- 4:03As always,
- 4:04if you could please help spread the word,
- 4:05share this podcast with your friends,
- 4:06colleagues, enemies, department chairs,
- 4:07procurement officers,
- 4:09and anyone who's currently convinced the
- 4:11future of higher ed can only be discovered
- 4:12somewhere between Hall Seven and the
- 4:14closest open bar.
- 4:15If you want to continue supporting the
- 4:17show, please consider donating.
- 4:18Your contributions help keep this thing
- 4:20running, fueling honest conversations,
- 4:21bad jokes,
- 4:22and radical ideas that you don't need a
- 4:23passport to have an informed opinion.
- 4:26But I have a passport.
- 4:28Don't need that.
- 4:29Do you have an opinion?
- 4:30No.
- 4:30It's not informed.
- 4:32Correct.
- 4:32And thanks to you all for your support,
- 4:34because we couldn't do this without you.
- 4:37And now, how about some ISE news?
- 4:40Justin, you ready?
- 4:42Get it going, Justin.
- 4:42Sing along.
- 4:44Yeah.
- 4:44Yeah.
- 4:49There was more do do's in there.
- 4:51There was just a little bit more energetic
- 4:53back in the day.
- 4:55Tired.
- 4:56All right.
- 4:56So which which one of these two related
- 4:59stories that become one story?
- 5:00Are we storing here?
- 5:01I defer to Mark,
- 5:04we're gonna get through both.
- 5:05Because why have one when you'd have to
- 5:06at twice the cost?
- 5:08Let's jump off.
- 5:09Let's start with buy in.
- 5:10Chris.
- 5:11So buy amp is now reselling clear one.
- 5:13Oh, wait, not that.
- 5:15Not that one.
- 5:18That was piece of this was also in
- 5:20this it also in this news.
- 5:24It said it was that's the only part
- 5:25that I really pay attention to.
- 5:26Alright,
- 5:26so this comes from AV magazine at AV
- 5:29interactive.com.
- 5:30And the title is biamp workplace update
- 5:32biamp.
- 5:33Let me try it.
- 5:33Let me start again.
- 5:34The title is biamp workplace update heads
- 5:37raft of company innovations.
- 5:40Basically,
- 5:42Biamp's big push at ISE this year,
- 5:44and I think we're going to continue to
- 5:45see this throughout the year,
- 5:46is they're migrating.
- 5:47They're trying to collapse all their
- 5:49software into Workplace to be the place to
- 5:52go for live monitoring, for control,
- 5:55for system building, for configuration,
- 5:56for all of that stuff through Workplace.
- 5:59Well,
- 5:59we have been complaining that Biamp has
- 6:01too many software suites to do all our
- 6:04stuff.
- 6:04And now they have one.
- 6:05Is this better or worse?
- 6:07Well, it depends.
- 6:09Oh,
- 6:09and if all your stuff is on the
- 6:11network?
- 6:12Well, Q-SYS does it, right?
- 6:14They all do, yeah.
- 6:15But just because it's one platform,
- 6:19does it work well?
- 6:20That's the question.
- 6:21I haven't played with it yet,
- 6:22so I don't know.
- 6:22It's a Workplace Tools desktop app,
- 6:25which relieves the common pressures faced
- 6:27by AV installer on-site during
- 6:29installation and commissioning.
- 6:31An app?
- 6:32That sounds weird.
- 6:33Well,
- 6:33so they said there's the workplace tools.
- 6:36There's the workplace command.
- 6:37There's my workplace.
- 6:39There's enhanced floor plan views.
- 6:40I think that's part of workplace.
- 6:42That sounds more like Crestron's approach.
- 6:44And then there's workplace status.
- 6:45Like,
- 6:46here's a software suite with little
- 6:48modules in the suite.
- 6:49Yes.
- 6:50versus Qsys have, I don't know.
- 6:52I don't know that's, whatever.
- 6:55It's their attempt to bring all their
- 6:56stuff into one unified platform.
- 6:58And I get it.
- 7:00Like the Highlander.
- 7:01I get it.
- 7:02You have to one step at a time,
- 7:04Mark.
- 7:06You've got to start somewhere.
- 7:08I think that's where they're starting.
- 7:10This is their first step.
- 7:12Which is great.
- 7:14I had bad-mouthed it for a little while.
- 7:16I might bad-mouth it again in the future.
- 7:19As long as your little while is measured
- 7:20in years.
- 7:23I did attempt to spin up a workplace
- 7:28instance for myself.
- 7:30Did it fail?
- 7:31In order to badmouth it with intelligence,
- 7:35with experience.
- 7:36Use the word attempt.
- 7:38I found out that the devices that I
- 7:40wanted to do such things with did not
- 7:42qualify for said attempt.
- 7:44Yet.
- 7:44So I need to change my attempt strategy
- 7:48in order to attempt this product trial
- 7:51again.
- 7:52You've said the word attempt a lot.
- 7:54That's the way I felt going through the
- 7:56whole thing.
- 7:57I want this to be something,
- 7:59because I think they had bits and pieces
- 8:01in there,
- 8:01like the remote control pieces and some of
- 8:05this other stuff.
- 8:05I'm like, okay,
- 8:07I've been complaining about Canvas.
- 8:09I didn't like it was an app.
- 8:10I wanted to just be able to log
- 8:11in and do it.
- 8:12And now they say, oh, now you can.
- 8:15It's supposed to make firmware issues
- 8:16easier.
- 8:17Okay, I'll try.
- 8:20Wait, I haven't been successful yet,
- 8:22but mostly that's because my test bed was
- 8:24not optimum.
- 8:25Is this the project you started really
- 8:27late in the afternoon?
- 8:28No, no, that was completely different.
- 8:30Oh, yeah,
- 8:30Jamie decided to spin up a Zoom room
- 8:32twenty minutes before he was supposed to
- 8:32leave.
- 8:33That was like another procrastination
- 8:34thing.
- 8:35That's a different story for later on,
- 8:37but no, not the same project.
- 8:39Okay.
- 8:40because it will be off brand.
- 8:41If I didn't mention this,
- 8:42I am awfully curious of this alleged AI
- 8:46agent to help configure devices properly
- 8:48and streamlining deployment at scale.
- 8:56What?
- 8:57What type of configuration is this thing
- 8:58actually going to do?
- 8:59Is this wholesale across the board?
- 9:01Is this like launch on steroids?
- 9:03Let's go try it.
- 9:05It configures the devices so that they
- 9:06have an outbound IP outside the firewall
- 9:10so that they can hit all the monitoring
- 9:11systems.
- 9:12Love it.
- 9:13Sign me up.
- 9:14No, I'm curious about that.
- 9:16I assume it's something where it watches
- 9:17how you configure devices,
- 9:18and then it kind of, I'm guessing here,
- 9:21it snapshots that,
- 9:22and then you plug in another one.
- 9:23It says, hey,
- 9:23the last one you did this way.
- 9:24Do you want to do it the same
- 9:25way?
- 9:26So it's accountability?
- 9:27Well, you did it like this.
- 9:28You're doing it wrong again, sir.
- 9:30Keep deploying it.
- 9:31You don't think it's part of reading the
- 9:33room?
- 9:34I don't know.
- 9:35Or you think it's more of like an
- 9:36image PC thing?
- 9:38They have the AI-powered processing
- 9:41blocks.
- 9:42I think it's part of that,
- 9:43and I also believe that it's also going
- 9:45to be solely dependent on all of their
- 9:48own thing.
- 9:48Well, isn't it out?
- 9:49Maybe we should do more research before we
- 9:51talk.
- 9:51That's what I said.
- 9:52I was attempting to.
- 9:54Yeah, we're trying to.
- 9:55I did hit some roadblocks.
- 9:56Allegedly work with some other things and
- 9:57platforms.
- 9:58I mean,
- 9:59this is the trend and everybody's got
- 10:02their pane of glass.
- 10:03Speaking of trends.
- 10:04I do not want to...
- 10:06just let the light be focused on buy-in.
- 10:09So Chris,
- 10:09there's another story from a convening.
- 10:10There is.
- 10:11Is it this one right here?
- 10:12Is it this story?
- 10:13I don't know.
- 10:14Is it?
- 10:14All right.
- 10:15So our second related story comes from
- 10:18Rave Pubs.
- 10:19And the title for this one is Sennheiser
- 10:20launches new device hub.
- 10:23So they now have software to plug all
- 10:26your Sennheiser mics and network-enabled
- 10:28Sennheiser devices into to monitor and
- 10:30deploy and update firmware and all that
- 10:32stuff.
- 10:32This is kind of becoming a theme.
- 10:33It is.
- 10:34I don't like this theme.
- 10:38It's just a theme at large.
- 10:40I don't like all these separations being
- 10:41like,
- 10:41how am I going to get to this?
- 10:43Yeah, it's getting crowded.
- 10:45My islands can't talk to their islands is
- 10:48where we're at.
- 10:50I think he's just still upon some of
- 10:51my testbeds product problems is my island
- 10:55can't talk to their island.
- 10:58I think...
- 11:00I'm okay with like islands when it's like
- 11:02purely web.
- 11:04What I don't like is the localized
- 11:05application that then like,
- 11:08it's quasi web.
- 11:10It's locally served web.
- 11:11It's not real.
- 11:12It's but I'm not saying it all needs
- 11:14to be cloud.
- 11:14But it's now you're in like switching all
- 11:17of your stuff all the time to make
- 11:18it so that you can communicate with these
- 11:20things.
- 11:20And
- 11:21It was all done in the name of
- 11:22centralized management,
- 11:23but now you really can't.
- 11:24Right.
- 11:25And so, you know,
- 11:25you have to go boots on the ground
- 11:26to get over to your sneaker net world
- 11:27and blah, blah, blah.
- 11:28And you spend all the time doing this.
- 11:30So it's it is a step in a
- 11:32direction to bring all these different
- 11:34panes of glass
- 11:36But is it really just not more of
- 11:39a pain in the ass?
- 11:40I don't know.
- 11:41I find it doesn't really.
- 11:43Most of these don't solve the overarching
- 11:45problem that we've talked about multiple
- 11:47times.
- 11:48They're all panes of glass.
- 11:49But you have to have so many panes
- 11:51of glass.
- 11:53Or.
- 11:54You now have built a ten-story building
- 11:56with the panes of glass you've got to
- 11:58use.
- 11:59Or, Jamie, you just buy one manufacturer.
- 12:02Nah, that doesn't work.
- 12:04That's what they need to hear.
- 12:06That's what everybody assumes on this
- 12:07manufacturing side.
- 12:08It's like, oh, well, if we develop this,
- 12:10then people are going to buy our products.
- 12:12Well, it very much, Justin,
- 12:13you're not wrong.
- 12:13It very much is.
- 12:14From a manufacturing perspective,
- 12:15from a product development perspective,
- 12:16it's very much a- They're doing it.
- 12:18We have to do it, too.
- 12:18We have to do it.
- 12:19We need one of these.
- 12:20Get in our sandbox.
- 12:21We have white sand.
- 12:22It's nice.
- 12:22It's clean.
- 12:23Come get it.
- 12:24But I think for the application like raw,
- 12:28EXE, let me launch this thing.
- 12:32it feels weird to me because if we're
- 12:34all trying to get web-aggregated data and
- 12:36do all this stuff, it just feels adjacent.
- 12:38Well, that's what I want to know.
- 12:39On both of these systems,
- 12:41the new workplace from Viamp,
- 12:42the device hub from Sennheiser,
- 12:44do we get appropriate levels of outbound
- 12:47and inbound API access to have them talk
- 12:49to other said devices or said systems?
- 12:51Yes, you do.
- 12:52But then you can pay for that service,
- 12:53too.
- 12:54And it's probably limited.
- 12:55It's not just do whatever you want.
- 12:58Their query costs you eight cents.
- 12:59So, I mean...
- 13:02So like a dead, broken record here.
- 13:04Yes, though,
- 13:04the excites the unifies and all the other
- 13:06words,
- 13:07they do have their integrations to do that
- 13:09turn out site, whatever it is.
- 13:11So yes,
- 13:11they do have their open their API that
- 13:13does connect to these things.
- 13:14And they are an integrated partner to
- 13:15bring that data in.
- 13:17Fraser Cain, in Yes,
- 13:18we need to do it.
- 13:18But now you have like the secret machine
- 13:20running under your desk that's serving
- 13:22this stuff.
- 13:23And then it's also going to the cloud,
- 13:24right?
- 13:25So architecture is really important.
- 13:27Like,
- 13:28are you running this in a virtualized
- 13:31environment, a secure thing,
- 13:32when it looks like it's kind of deployed,
- 13:34like here,
- 13:34put this on your management laptop and see
- 13:37what happens.
- 13:39Oh,
- 13:39it needs administrator access to run them.
- 13:41Of course, yeah.
- 13:42Not you, somebody else.
- 13:44Well, as long as it's A-to-administrator,
- 13:46not just the everyday administrator.
- 13:49But these are the good conversations to
- 13:50have,
- 13:50and I think it is a step in
- 13:51the odd direction,
- 13:52and they're probably difficult.
- 13:54Mark,
- 13:54all you've got to do is just tell
- 13:55IT you want to put that .exe file
- 13:57on a VM in their server room.
- 13:59I don't know, whatever OS you've got,
- 14:00just run this.
- 14:01And then everybody can remote into that
- 14:02one instance, and everything's fine.
- 14:05All good.
- 14:05We've done things like that.
- 14:07I bet you have.
- 14:09I think this is a march into some
- 14:10direction.
- 14:12You're all in, right, Chris?
- 14:13Sign you up?
- 14:15Sure, yes.
- 14:17We did this with...
- 14:19I'm not doing the single pane of glass.
- 14:20I'm doing twenty-seven panes of glass on a
- 14:24video wall.
- 14:25Remember Mersive?
- 14:26Remember that company?
- 14:29Mersive?
- 14:29Remember that?
- 14:31Yeah,
- 14:31we did that a long time ago with
- 14:33them.
- 14:33We put their .exe on a VM server
- 14:35in the IT room and just had multiple
- 14:39people ask.
- 14:39Explain so many questions.
- 14:42That's all they had to manage.
- 14:43That was the only option.
- 14:46Mark's done it before.
- 14:48He said he was guilty.
- 14:49Well,
- 14:49I'm just going to have to make sure
- 14:51that I have a dedicated computer to open
- 14:53up a web browser with twenty seven tabs
- 14:56on it.
- 14:56See?
- 14:58That's all you need.
- 14:58That's the whole thing.
- 14:59You get one of those plug-ins.
- 15:00You should not be doing this on your
- 15:02tower under your desk.
- 15:03If it goes faster and faster and faster
- 15:04and faster,
- 15:05then it's real-time monitoring.
- 15:06Well, I figure with the price of RAM,
- 15:08I could also keep my house.
- 15:11All right.
- 15:13Any other thoughts on this trend for
- 15:15additional cloud services?
- 15:16Absolutely not.
- 15:18I like that people are I like that
- 15:20they're trying to do some of this.
- 15:21I just wish there was it just doesn't
- 15:23fit my needs most of the time.
- 15:25It's we'll keep seeing more of it for
- 15:27sure.
- 15:27And these every manufacturer has it.
- 15:29I mean,
- 15:30these are not the only two guilty parties
- 15:31that I have as I literally think anything
- 15:33that modern AV at this point in time
- 15:35has their own little ecosystem of
- 15:36management software.
- 15:38And it's, you know,
- 15:38that's what we all asked for,
- 15:40I guess I can see this more in
- 15:41corporate world versus edu world.
- 15:44Like if a corporate building standardizes
- 15:47on one thing and they do it once,
- 15:49it's like, hey, spin up Sennheiser,
- 15:52whatever.
- 15:54All righty.
- 15:54Well, let's take a quick break.
- 15:55We'll come back and talk about our big
- 15:57topic on deploying cameras a little
- 16:00differently than we used to years ago and
- 16:02all that fun stuff.
- 16:03Jamie just realized your slate's going to
- 16:05be wrong for this one.
- 16:07Uh-oh.
- 16:09Do we need to restart the show?
- 16:11Already scramble for this one or just?
- 16:13Go with it.
- 16:16Right.
- 16:16Do it live.
- 16:17All right.
- 16:19Back in a sec.
- 16:22The AV Superfriends are sponsored by
- 16:23Computer Comforts,
- 16:25and they've got a brand new product
- 16:26hitting the lineup.
- 16:28And this one exists because not every
- 16:29classroom needs a full server rack hiding
- 16:31inside a lectern.
- 16:32Shocking, I know.
- 16:33Last year,
- 16:34CCI's Evolve lectern was a big hit.
- 16:37A push button power table combined with a
- 16:39super flexible AV cabinet.
- 16:40But let's be honest,
- 16:41not every room needs twenty four units of
- 16:43rack space.
- 16:44That's where the new AV Hub comes in.
- 16:46It's a lighter,
- 16:47more space efficient solution for
- 16:49classrooms that still need real AV
- 16:51infrastructure.
- 16:52That's right.
- 16:52You get eight units of rack space and
- 16:54the whole thing sits only about ten inches
- 16:56off the wall.
- 16:57Which makes it a great fit when you're
- 16:58pairing it with a sit-stand power table
- 17:00instead of building a massive lectern
- 17:01footprint into the room.
- 17:03And this wasn't designed in isolation.
- 17:05The AV Hub was developed in collaboration
- 17:07with Texas State University.
- 17:08So it's very much built around real higher
- 17:10ed classrooms and real deployment needs.
- 17:13Meaning fewer compromises,
- 17:14cleaner installs, and way less,
- 17:16why is this furniture the size of a
- 17:17refrigerator?
- 17:18If you want to see photos, specs,
- 17:20and all the details,
- 17:21head over to Computer Comfort's website
- 17:22and check out the AV Hub.
- 17:24You can find that at ComputerComforts.com.
- 17:26It's a smart,
- 17:27compact approach to classroom AV furniture
- 17:29from a company that's been doing higher ed
- 17:31for decades.
- 17:32That's the new AV Hub from Computer
- 17:34Comforts.
- 17:34Purpose-built, space-efficient,
- 17:36and designed for how classrooms actually
- 17:38work.
- 17:38And thanks again to Computer Comforts for
- 17:40sponsoring the AV Superfriends.
- 17:44I heard new voices.
- 17:46Yeah,
- 17:46and you talked right through it there,
- 17:47Chief.
- 17:48Yeah.
- 17:48You sound like somebody was talking.
- 17:52Like, where is that coming from?
- 17:55The other ABC preferred.
- 17:58Where is this person?
- 17:59The replacement.
- 18:01My replacement?
- 18:03We're going to spin and find out later.
- 18:07Let's get into it here.
- 18:13I forget about these things every time you
- 18:15play them.
- 18:15I'm like, oh yeah, there's that thing.
- 18:18You know how much that one cost?
- 18:21Five minutes.
- 18:23No, that's Jeffrey Tambor.
- 18:27All right.
- 18:27Okay.
- 18:31Whatever.
- 18:34Thanks.
- 18:34Sure.
- 18:34So first topic today is we were talking
- 18:36about this the other day.
- 18:37We were talking about cameras and cameras
- 18:39being as exciting as they can be.
- 18:41But we kind of suddenly realized we're all
- 18:44deploying.
- 18:45The endpoints are the same.
- 18:46The cameras are kind of the same.
- 18:47Capabilities are better.
- 18:48They have better processing on board.
- 18:49They have better lensing, better imaging,
- 18:50all that stuff.
- 18:51Yes.
- 18:51But.
- 18:52We're deploying them physically
- 18:53differently.
- 18:54We're thinking about how we set up our
- 18:56cameras, how we can cable them,
- 18:58where we're putting them, all that stuff.
- 18:59We're doing that differently now.
- 19:00And a lot of interest in,
- 19:04there's additional software processing out
- 19:06there,
- 19:07little processing boxes from a lot of
- 19:08companies that are now adding capability
- 19:10to the cameras you already have.
- 19:13And some of those are tied to room
- 19:14systems, some are not.
- 19:15But it's kind of a unique thing to
- 19:17think about that, yes,
- 19:18we put cameras in all our spaces because
- 19:20that's what you do.
- 19:21But we're doing it differently,
- 19:23different protocols,
- 19:24different cabling methods, you know,
- 19:26all that fun stuff.
- 19:28And even ways to potentially reduce the
- 19:32load of stuff we already have in the
- 19:33spaces to make,
- 19:34as Justin likes to put it,
- 19:35to get rid of one more box,
- 19:37one less digit in there.
- 19:39Do you think there was a common way
- 19:40we were approaching this?
- 19:41Do you think we've deviated from that?
- 19:44I think the common way was
- 19:46You're like, how many years ago?
- 19:50How far back are we going here?
- 19:54Prehistoric times, Justin,
- 19:55all the way back.
- 19:56Okay,
- 19:56so you're probably using two or three
- 19:58cables to another widget box by that
- 20:01manufacturer, and it's super expensive,
- 20:03like five grand.
- 20:04If there's another widget box,
- 20:05or if you're just hard running multiple
- 20:08cables back to a certain location.
- 20:09Maybe you've got a head end where you're
- 20:11doing a whole bunch.
- 20:11This cable's for power.
- 20:13This one's for control.
- 20:14This one's for video.
- 20:15Right.
- 20:16What the hell?
- 20:17That is like the prehistoric lanes of
- 20:18traffic, right?
- 20:19Yeah, like eight, ten years ago, right?
- 20:21Okay.
- 20:22So then we moved forward,
- 20:23and some people may say, oh,
- 20:24what did you do over the pandemic?
- 20:25Oh, you had a pandemic response.
- 20:27SDI.
- 20:28Nope, USB.
- 20:29Just USB,
- 20:29and I ran it thousands of feet.
- 20:31Just taped them all together.
- 20:33Got a bunch of passive extenders.
- 20:34Passive little barrels, just...
- 20:36And then you post it on all the
- 20:39message boards.
- 20:39Why does my USB keep flaking out?
- 20:42My webcam's not working.
- 20:45No, we didn't do that.
- 20:46But somewhere, some people did.
- 20:48A lot of people did.
- 20:49Some people did.
- 20:49A lot of them out there.
- 20:50And so I think you do have that
- 20:51camp where it's like,
- 20:53maybe I just want to take this lousy
- 20:55web camera or whatever.
- 20:57You paid whatever.
- 20:57I don't care.
- 20:58And extend it.
- 20:58But you're going to try to extend that
- 21:00USB.
- 21:00So you have this whole market of USB
- 21:02extension widgetry.
- 21:04out there that's, oh,
- 21:05just put this shoebox worth of shit
- 21:07underneath your desk and see if that
- 21:09extends it.
- 21:11OK, mileage may vary, right?
- 21:14And then you had the folks that I
- 21:17was probably in was like, oh,
- 21:17we're going to SDI and a network cable
- 21:19to all of our camera locations.
- 21:20And that worked.
- 21:23One conversion into the PC, USB, bang,
- 21:25we're off to the races.
- 21:25I'm still doing that shit.
- 21:26I'm saying so am I.
- 21:28But I think we're starting to see some
- 21:30desire to do it different.
- 21:31You want to do that whole intro again?
- 21:34Who's rethinking?
- 21:35You are right now.
- 21:35Jamie and I are rethinking this.
- 21:37Look at you.
- 21:37I can see in your face.
- 21:38You're like, hmm.
- 21:40You're still not to where I am.
- 21:41Got you fooled.
- 21:43no yeah we haven't gotten the jamie yet
- 21:44mark you also skipped over the um well
- 21:46let's do a whole bunch over um uh
- 21:49versions flavors and and types of hd based
- 21:52hd base t yep exactly some of which
- 21:54appropriately carry power some don't some
- 21:56of which appropriately carry control some
- 21:58don't some of which appropriately carry
- 21:59network some don't some of which after a
- 22:01while you give up and you have to
- 22:02run a second or third cable anyway and
- 22:04because i want to make i i want
- 22:06to be all inclusive on this
- 22:09We all were guilty of at least exploring
- 22:11this, so we're gonna be honest.
- 22:14We have the HDBase-T transmitter.
- 22:17I'm gonna throw my HDMI in.
- 22:19I'm gonna bring it back to the switcher
- 22:21of the system and then bring that out.
- 22:24You all have done it.
- 22:25I'll be honest, Mark.
- 22:27I have not done that dumb shit.
- 22:28I don't trust you.
- 22:29I've only done it when I was programming
- 22:31and consultants put that in.
- 22:33I haven't done that.
- 22:34It's okay.
- 22:35Justin, lean back from the mic.
- 22:37No.
- 22:39You got excited.
- 22:40You're getting crunchy.
- 22:41I'm getting accused of things that I
- 22:43didn't do.
- 22:45Justin, I've seen you do it.
- 22:46No, you haven't.
- 22:50I will back up Justin here.
- 22:51I have not done this,
- 22:52but I have inherited dozens of rumors this
- 22:56is the case.
- 22:57But you've thought about it.
- 22:59Yes,
- 22:59and how bad of an idea it is
- 23:01because why am I routing my camera around?
- 23:04Integrators love this approach.
- 23:05Oh, hell yeah, they do.
- 23:07Consultants do as well because it adds
- 23:09cost.
- 23:10Look how many card slots I can put
- 23:11in this chassis because you can run your
- 23:12cameras right in here.
- 23:13And you could just switch it through this
- 23:15and then switch it to a single.
- 23:16Well, you might need iMac.
- 23:18What if you need that up on?
- 23:20i need i need that on the screen
- 23:21get it out of here building wide switching
- 23:24yes thirty two by thirty two nothing less
- 23:26how many thirty two by thirty twos are
- 23:27they four seven one one per room sir
- 23:30the right way don't make me go into
- 23:33my inventory system again because i will
- 23:34okay so that we got there now let's
- 23:37let's settle on okay we have an sdi
- 23:38cable we have the cat no we're powering
- 23:40it i know jamie we're gonna get to
- 23:41the edge case in a moment listen pal
- 23:43but what happens when i have another
- 23:44camera
- 23:46I want a simple camera.
- 23:48You just put in more.
- 23:48A little Marshall SD switcher and you're
- 23:50good to go.
- 23:51The VLSW-SW-SW.
- 23:54Marshall?
- 23:55That's like two hundred dollars more than
- 23:57my seventy dollar special.
- 23:59Which is the same hardware.
- 24:00Sounds like Jamie wants to talk.
- 24:02That I was using eight years ago.
- 24:04You got something to say, Jamie,
- 24:06about your camera?
- 24:07But then we're still converting that to
- 24:08the same
- 24:09SDI to USB bridge.
- 24:10That's right.
- 24:11Prior to the compute, right?
- 24:13Yes,
- 24:13probably fair snapshot of the landscape
- 24:15we're at.
- 24:16No, we haven't got no me.
- 24:17Oh, yeah.
- 24:19Jamie,
- 24:19because I think this is like the edge
- 24:20now where we're going.
- 24:21We're gonna get up to the point where
- 24:23Jamie is now stepping into where the rest
- 24:25of us are now starting to tiptoe into.
- 24:27We're all just watching Jamie hover over
- 24:29that cliff.
- 24:30Every now and then,
- 24:32I stupid my way into smart,
- 24:34and I think I've done it this time.
- 24:35Even a broken clock is right twice a
- 24:38day.
- 24:38I don't think that's a thing.
- 24:41No, no.
- 24:41Every now and then,
- 24:42you do something so dumb and so out
- 24:44of line that it works out.
- 24:46usually when i do that i get hurt
- 24:47justin we talk about how you guys could
- 24:49just do nothing and at least once every
- 24:51eight years you're on the cutting edge
- 24:54that's where we are audio is a trend
- 24:58you know we're trying to find the positive
- 25:04in what we do every day i don't
- 25:05you know yeah he started with zoom rooms
- 25:09we all made fun of it now we're
- 25:10all trying to look at zoom rooms again
- 25:13Let's go.
- 25:13So anyway, so Jamie,
- 25:14we got into this whole like,
- 25:17NDI stream switching, yada, yada.
- 25:19And I think that's how this unraveled on
- 25:21us the other day,
- 25:21because we're I'm looking for certain
- 25:22products.
- 25:23And you're like, Oh, fuck,
- 25:23I can do that right now.
- 25:24What do we what are we doing?
- 25:27So explain,
- 25:27explain what we're looking for?
- 25:28Yeah.
- 25:29You know, several years,
- 25:30and even infocomm things,
- 25:33if you go back to some of the
- 25:34perspectives,
- 25:35I did one on a product that was
- 25:36going to help me out here.
- 25:37But years ago, I decided, like,
- 25:40I'm all I'm going to do NDI.
- 25:42I get PoE.
- 25:43I get VSCO over IP.
- 25:45I get an NDI stream.
- 25:46I decoded it in the desk and then
- 25:48ran it through a widget, right?
- 25:50So my big thing for years was can
- 25:52I find an NDI to USB UVC adapter
- 25:55thing?
- 25:57And there were many out there that
- 25:58purported to do it.
- 25:59And they're still out there.
- 26:00Yes.
- 26:01And more and more have come out.
- 26:03And the pricing is right.
- 26:06And so now I think more of,
- 26:08and I use NDI,
- 26:10but I've also used just RTSP streams off
- 26:14of some of the cameras or SRT streams.
- 26:16I mean, it doesn't have to be NDI.
- 26:17It was the IP one.
- 26:20I had some decent luck with that cheap
- 26:22little Magwell IP to USB thing.
- 26:29And so that's what I've been doing.
- 26:30And I run all the control and everything
- 26:32through the one network cable.
- 26:36It's just one network cable for all these
- 26:37cameras, wherever I put them.
- 26:40When you say control, what's your control?
- 26:43So, look, it's traditional control.
- 26:45And this is where we started falling apart
- 26:47the other day.
- 26:48This is where we fell apart the other
- 26:50day.
- 26:51There's the control through the software
- 26:53interface,
- 26:54which is what we would use
- 26:55troubleshooting, right?
- 26:56Just pull up NDI tools or pull up
- 26:58whatever you're going to use.
- 27:00The web page itself,
- 27:01move the damn camera and go about it.
- 27:04Or, you know, VSCO over IP is...
- 27:06pretty common.
- 27:07Almost all the cameras do it now except
- 27:09for Panasonic has their own version.
- 27:11Some don't document it well.
- 27:14Just because they don't like Sony.
- 27:16They don't want to deal with Sony stuff.
- 27:18And fine,
- 27:19there's a good protocol for those cameras
- 27:20too.
- 27:22And so you put it into your control
- 27:24system of choice.
- 27:26Um,
- 27:26and that could even be your control system
- 27:28of choice could be a stream deck directly
- 27:31to your computer.
- 27:32I mean, it didn't have to be,
- 27:34that's Larry's control system.
- 27:35All right.
- 27:36Uh, how about my companion app?
- 27:40Oh, better.
- 27:41There we go.
- 27:42How about that there?
- 27:44Uh, but yeah, so,
- 27:46so you had to use the API to
- 27:47get, to get it going.
- 27:48And I think, you know,
- 27:49we started to have this,
- 27:50you asked the question, the question was.
- 27:55fill in the blank mark.
- 27:57Question was, I so here's what Yeah,
- 28:00this is what I was looking for.
- 28:01And this is where the whole like,
- 28:02this is where I told you shut up.
- 28:04The leg wrestling match happened is that I
- 28:07wanted the NDI to expose itself as just
- 28:09raw UVC as all the control.
- 28:11Fraser Cain,
- 28:12with the control the UVC with,
- 28:12Fraser Cain,
- 28:13the control as ascribable as UVC.
- 28:17And then we got into speculation.
- 28:18Well,
- 28:18does that or does that does that not
- 28:20exist in the language around a lot of
- 28:21these manufacturers is vague at best?
- 28:25Correct.
- 28:25And it's we don't know.
- 28:26And so I don't want to need a
- 28:29third party control system,
- 28:31I want it to be flat and exposed
- 28:33at the UVC level.
- 28:35So I want NDI,
- 28:36whatever you want to call whatever your IP
- 28:38flavor is, and through my application,
- 28:40choose
- 28:42and also be able to control native with
- 28:44that application.
- 28:44You want your teams in Zoom rooms, Mark.
- 28:46Correct.
- 28:47That's what I'm looking for.
- 28:48Mark wants his peanut butter and his
- 28:49chocolate.
- 28:50And jelly.
- 28:50I want peanut butter and chocolate and
- 28:51jelly.
- 28:51Ew, gross.
- 28:53And fluffernutter, all of it.
- 28:54Put it all in there.
- 28:55That sounds delicious.
- 28:56Put it on potato bread.
- 28:58Why don't you just top it with eggplant
- 29:00while you're at it?
- 29:01What?
- 29:02Yeah, exactly.
- 29:03What?
- 29:05I was all in on this.
- 29:06Some Nutella.
- 29:08Yes, I forgot about Nutella.
- 29:09And some marshmallow fluff on sandwich.
- 29:13Oh, put a banana on there.
- 29:16We got there, guys.
- 29:16Pickles?
- 29:19No.
- 29:20Spicy mustard?
- 29:21You guys eat weird.
- 29:23I don't want to rely upon like that
- 29:25Viska injected by way of third party
- 29:27application,
- 29:28because that implies I have some other UI
- 29:30that's not native, right?
- 29:31And so I don't want to need to
- 29:33go down that road.
- 29:34And I think that's where it's like, well,
- 29:35how would you do this?
- 29:37And so I said, I believe you can,
- 29:40but it's the widget transversal thing,
- 29:43and I wasn't sure because I'm not doing
- 29:45that.
- 29:45But I do understand what you're saying,
- 29:47and I think there's, again,
- 29:49software download plugins in order to
- 29:51enable this,
- 29:53but it's all within the computer and
- 29:54you've got to be able to run it.
- 29:55Because I know there's OBS plugins will do
- 29:58it.
- 29:59Hold on, hold on.
- 30:00I just want to go out on a
- 30:02PSA right now.
- 30:04What?
- 30:05Never is the answer.
- 30:06OBS is the solution.
- 30:07No, no, no, no.
- 30:09I just want to make sure.
- 30:10In a classroom, OBS is never the answer.
- 30:12Didn't you say we should spin up OBS,
- 30:14run it in a VM,
- 30:15we could all remotely connect?
- 30:17That's for this nonsense.
- 30:19But that was for your house of cards
- 30:20crap.
- 30:21you're just i would never know it would
- 30:22work in a learning three people you're
- 30:25talking to two different phones to make
- 30:27this work like oh it would be great
- 30:28but i know i hear those words uttered
- 30:30a lot like people they call me you
- 30:31just do it with obs it's like well
- 30:33no i can do whatever i want with
- 30:34obs my example was there's a plug-in mark
- 30:38oh some nerd out there has written this
- 30:41transversal plug-in
- 30:44Jesus.
- 30:46Was it you?
- 30:46No, it was not me.
- 30:48I'm not that smart.
- 30:50It was Ben.
- 30:50Was it you plus AI?
- 30:51It was one of those open claw machines
- 30:53that did it for us.
- 30:54But I do believe there are nerdery plugins
- 30:59out there that will do what you're asking,
- 31:00but I don't think it comes native.
- 31:02And the more,
- 31:03after we got done arguing in the call
- 31:05the other day,
- 31:05I did kind of briefly plug in the
- 31:07system.
- 31:08I'm like, you know what?
- 31:09Maybe he's right, which hurt a little.
- 31:11I guess this is the phone call I
- 31:13missed.
- 31:13Yeah.
- 31:14Yeah.
- 31:15This sounds very entertaining.
- 31:17This is why we didn't want to tell
- 31:18you what we're talking about.
- 31:21They can't hear your eye roll, buddy.
- 31:23They saw it.
- 31:25For those who watch, they saw it.
- 31:29On that tangent, Raul,
- 31:30I did have a guy that came to
- 31:32one of the trainings,
- 31:32and he said that in his institution,
- 31:34they do run vMix in some of their
- 31:36classrooms.
- 31:38Why?
- 31:39Which is the cousin of OBS.
- 31:41Yes, it's the paid-for cousin of OBS,
- 31:43and I went, huh.
- 31:46Is there a concert hall, a classroom?
- 31:48I don't know.
- 31:49I didn't get into it.
- 31:49Do they have a technical director?
- 31:51We use it on campus versus we use
- 31:52it in a classroom.
- 31:53Or we use it on campus to serve
- 31:54some needs of a classroom,
- 31:55but never shall the solution be it's
- 31:56installed on the classroom PC.
- 31:58There.
- 31:59And I believe that that was the solution.
- 32:01You guys don't run all new faculty through
- 32:02a three-day OBS course on how to operate
- 32:05the O. Well, we do.
- 32:06And then hand them vMix.
- 32:08We do.
- 32:08We do.
- 32:09No templates.
- 32:10They have to design it from the ground
- 32:11up.
- 32:11That's right.
- 32:12You start fresh every time you log in.
- 32:15We're going to teach you how to use
- 32:16OBS and then give you TriCaster.
- 32:18Here's TriCaster.
- 32:19Get after it.
- 32:21OBS TriCaster with a Stream Deck.
- 32:22That's how all the classrooms are as a
- 32:23standard build.
- 32:26Get those prices down.
- 32:27You said get those prices down.
- 32:28I did.
- 32:29So, Larry, how does that work for you?
- 32:30Yeah, it doesn't.
- 32:34What if the student experience is
- 32:35exceptional?
- 32:37It's not.
- 32:38I doubt it.
- 32:39Why are you trying to employ cameras in
- 32:42a new and unique way and get away
- 32:44from the standard baseband coaxial
- 32:46delivery method that has been rock solid
- 32:49for a hundred years?
- 32:50I'm not.
- 32:51I'm sticking to...
- 32:52You don't even have cameras, bro.
- 32:54He has a camera.
- 32:56I don't have any cameras in my Zoom
- 32:58rooms.
- 32:59Yeah,
- 32:59little doc rooms have no audio and no
- 33:02cameras.
- 33:03So I think there's two, two reasons.
- 33:05One is like the blatant like rooms
- 33:07scenario, right?
- 33:08Multi room and we want we don't want
- 33:10to have to have our rooms doing API's
- 33:12to other thing and widgetry and the house
- 33:14of cards and the Rube Goldberg thing to
- 33:16just make it as flat as possible.
- 33:18And there's also the elusive one cable
- 33:20installation.
- 33:21You know what else can do a one
- 33:22cable installation mark?
- 33:24dot cams, USB extender.
- 33:26Yeah, yeah.
- 33:29Oh, you have your shit in the USB?
- 33:31No.
- 33:33Do you have a trusted USB extender that
- 33:35is died in a war never fail?
- 33:38No, that's not the answer.
- 33:39That is not the answer is a normal
- 33:40form.
- 33:41extender is more expensive than the camera
- 33:43it's extending does not mean it's a bad
- 33:45answer.
- 33:46But it works.
- 33:47And when the transmit side dies,
- 33:48you have to buy a whole new set
- 33:49because they're paired together,
- 33:50and that receive side doesn't work with
- 33:52any other pair.
- 33:53It's beautiful.
- 33:54Hence why I do not recommend doing that
- 33:56type of thing.
- 33:56But your qualifications was one cable,
- 33:58though.
- 33:59Yes.
- 34:00So USB extenders have been there.
- 34:03You say one cable.
- 34:07So this is not an endorsement.
- 34:09This is not an endorsement.
- 34:10How do you define one cable differently?
- 34:13I love the installation of the Hudley
- 34:15L-One.
- 34:16I don't mind it.
- 34:17Simple that is.
- 34:18I do that a lot.
- 34:19For those of us who have not had
- 34:21the Hudley L-One.
- 34:22It's a standard cat.
- 34:23It's a fake USB extender.
- 34:24That's all it is.
- 34:25But you're buying the camera and it comes
- 34:27with USB extenders.
- 34:28It's one cable that's.
- 34:30But from an integration standpoint,
- 34:32it is extremely clever and very easy to
- 34:34deploy.
- 34:35Yeah.
- 34:36Yeah.
- 34:37I don't know.
- 34:37I agree.
- 34:38It was more readily available.
- 34:39Would we not see more cameras?
- 34:40More readily available.
- 34:42Yeah.
- 34:42Well,
- 34:42there's a lot of companies out there.
- 34:43But the important point I think that you
- 34:45blew past is that it's fundamentally
- 34:48extending USB with UVC control over a
- 34:51standard you-can-do-it-yourself cat cable.
- 34:54And that's where a lot of manufacturers go
- 34:56the wrong way.
- 34:57we made this box with this thing and
- 34:59the little adapter i'm not throwing shade
- 35:03over the the logic so yes the logitech
- 35:06rally kit you can you can extend that
- 35:07on one cable and do all that stuff
- 35:08too but i'm not saying it's not i'm
- 35:10just saying at large we don't see as
- 35:13much of this in the market where i
- 35:14think we would with it with as much
- 35:15prolification prolification of zoom rooms
- 35:18teamers and the like i don't what
- 35:20We're proliferating.
- 35:21I understood.
- 35:22I understood that word.
- 35:23Actually, he's speaking Kentucky.
- 35:25All right.
- 35:26See, we vote you off the island, Chris.
- 35:28You're done.
- 35:29I'm typing that in,
- 35:30and my autocorrect just changed the word
- 35:32to spell it correctly.
- 35:33You know how tough this is?
- 35:36That's fine.
- 35:37But I would be jumped up and said,
- 35:40I'm not sure that's what you're thinking.
- 35:42Right?
- 35:42And so I think it would be natural
- 35:45for us to assume we would see more
- 35:47of this, but I've seen the opposite.
- 35:49I don't see it.
- 35:50Now I do see more cameras saying, well,
- 35:51we now ship within di.
- 35:53srt and all the stuff and it's like
- 35:55that's easy you get me the poe one
- 35:57cable but i still have to do all
- 35:59this other at the last mile and so
- 36:01because you're just getting that you're
- 36:02just getting a straight video yeah well if
- 36:04i just wanted one thing no control okay
- 36:10but i think you can if i just
- 36:12wanted one big box surveillance camera at
- 36:13the back of the classroom yeah all day
- 36:15long it would work but surveillance is not
- 36:17distance education
- 36:19But I think you can get all that
- 36:22other stuff.
- 36:23Mark,
- 36:24is that substantive distance education?
- 36:25It's depending on which rule we're going
- 36:28to abide by.
- 36:29So I'm curious.
- 36:30I would love to see NDI with control
- 36:32in a widget that converts that and gives
- 36:34me as...
- 36:36selectable UVC independent camera streams.
- 36:39And I know somebody out there is
- 36:40screaming,
- 36:41but Zoom and Teams do NDI and you
- 36:42can do it.
- 36:43And good luck showing somebody how to do
- 36:45that.
- 36:45That shit doesn't work exactly right.
- 36:47You can subscribe to NDI and within Teams
- 36:50rooms.
- 36:50I know you can.
- 36:51I haven't quite got to the I'm yelling
- 36:53at you part, but I am skeptical that...
- 36:56that this is not currently possible.
- 36:58I believe it should be possible for sure.
- 37:00And somebody, please send the link.
- 37:01Put it in the comments right now.
- 37:03I think there is a widget out there
- 37:04right now that does exactly what we want,
- 37:06and it's not from any of the companies
- 37:07we think it should be,
- 37:09and we don't know what it is,
- 37:10so please write in and tell us what
- 37:11it is.
- 37:12What kind of, like, what are we... Oh,
- 37:14you're just...
- 37:15Okay, I got it.
- 37:16It's going to come from a place you
- 37:17don't you're like, it's this big,
- 37:19it can be USB power or PoE,
- 37:21it has to connect my managed network.
- 37:22I understand that.
- 37:23But it's going to take all of the
- 37:25available NDI streams or whatever your
- 37:26flavor of choice is,
- 37:28and expose them individually as a UVC with
- 37:32control at the actual compute level.
- 37:34So this company,
- 37:35you don't know who it is,
- 37:37and it's not one we've ever heard of.
- 37:39You're going to put on your managed
- 37:40network.
- 37:41Yes.
- 37:43Of course.
- 37:44I'm putting on your unmanaged island
- 37:45network, sir.
- 37:46Everybody's going to see it anyway.
- 37:48Hold on.
- 37:49You lost me at putting it on your
- 37:51managed network.
- 37:51Why the hell would you do that?
- 37:52What are you doing?
- 37:53How am I going to get these streams?
- 37:55It's got to get on the computer.
- 37:58Yeah.
- 38:00The way they're doing it,
- 38:01it's got to be out there.
- 38:02That's where they belong.
- 38:04Hmm.
- 38:06Yes, if this is a simple answer,
- 38:08why aren't you now if,
- 38:10if we could get to a world where
- 38:13our PCs were merged onto the same network,
- 38:17the our AV was on,
- 38:18and maybe we did have that NDI slash,
- 38:21that's what you have to do in your
- 38:22scenario that you're talking about.
- 38:25I know, and it can be done.
- 38:26That's what I was going for.
- 38:31But that's in that philosophical room
- 38:33scenario only.
- 38:34Now let's talk about the rest of the
- 38:36spaces that are not these room-centric
- 38:38spaces.
- 38:39We're still back to that drawing board.
- 38:40We still have to solve for that.
- 38:43island-to-island traversal.
- 38:45Do we need to take a half-step back
- 38:48and maybe explain why,
- 38:50for those who are not familiar with it,
- 38:51because I know there's a lot of people
- 38:52listening who this is not something to
- 38:53deal with,
- 38:54why NDI is of interest in particular,
- 38:56or SRT, or RSTP, as Jamie says it,
- 39:00but why subscribing and switching those
- 39:02streams that carries both video and UVC
- 39:05full control directly to the computer over
- 39:09a USB device is of interest?
- 39:11Sure, tell us.
- 39:13I'm asking the crowd.
- 39:16But I was throwing that out to the
- 39:17panel.
- 39:17But yeah,
- 39:18I don't I don't I think the only
- 39:20reason it's of interest is because the
- 39:22manufacturers have made it zoom.
- 39:24The only reason is to teams and zoom
- 39:26rooms.
- 39:26That's it.
- 39:27It's they've required this us this USB,
- 39:30this USB handshake in order to make some
- 39:32of this crap work if it can be
- 39:34ingested directly.
- 39:35or dealt with directly, it is unnecessary.
- 39:38Unless I'm in a Teams room or Zoom
- 39:41Room branded room,
- 39:42this has no interest for me because I
- 39:45have other solutions that can do one cable
- 39:48and bring it into the computer.
- 39:49You still have a widget box.
- 39:50The box count is still the same.
- 39:52What's the name of that cable?
- 39:53What's it exposed as?
- 39:55cat six the name of the device is
- 39:57cat six you said what's the name of
- 39:59the cable no when it exposes itself in
- 40:01your computer your software what is the
- 40:04you bring it in us usb and what's
- 40:06it called when i choose my camera what
- 40:10am i selecting
- 40:13What are you talking about?
- 40:14Okay, I won't select a computer then.
- 40:15Okay, it's just going to be there.
- 40:17It's wireless, Mark.
- 40:20It's wireless.
- 40:21What do you mean you're selecting?
- 40:21You're missing the last six inches.
- 40:23How many cameras do you have?
- 40:25One or two or three or four?
- 40:27I was talking about one camera solution.
- 40:29Yes, any of the above.
- 40:31What does the software see this connection
- 40:33as?
- 40:34A camera.
- 40:36Protocol.
- 40:37Justin, what protocol?
- 40:38What protocol is it?
- 40:40What do you mean, what protocol?
- 40:43Are you talking like,
- 40:44is it NDI or is it some,
- 40:47what do you mean protocol?
- 40:49Yeah, it's just USB UVC.
- 40:51I said that multiple times.
- 40:52And you're like, what's the protocol?
- 40:53I was like, it's USB.
- 40:56But is it the actual camera or is
- 40:58it like widget company?
- 41:00usb thingy is it magical capture is it
- 41:03asia capture is it yes no matter what
- 41:07you say it's the same solution that we're
- 41:09trying to magically come up with on the
- 41:11ndi like i'm just not following it's one
- 41:15cable people can see foreign participants
- 41:19they could see i don't get it what
- 41:21are we trying to solve for what are
- 41:22we what are we out of curiosity mark
- 41:28You have, I'm assuming,
- 41:30you've set up a test bed where you've
- 41:31run multiple NDI streams and maybe used
- 41:36the NDI Tools USB
- 41:38thing where it does expose it as pick
- 41:41camera X, pick camera Y,
- 41:43and then it populates.
- 41:44See, we're talking about multiple cameras.
- 41:45That's different.
- 41:46It populates into your lists.
- 41:49It will show up there.
- 41:51Yes.
- 41:52And control.
- 41:53Right.
- 41:53Yeah.
- 41:54But you have to use the software.
- 41:55You have to use the software, right?
- 41:56And so now you have to have this
- 41:57other plugin running,
- 41:58and that's going to be problematic on your
- 42:00build and all that stuff.
- 42:01And then it has to stay in your
- 42:04managed networks.
- 42:04We're not going to spill expose NDI out
- 42:06onto the managed side.
- 42:07i thought i thought we were trying to
- 42:09solve the problem of one we don't have
- 42:11the luxury of of multicast across where we
- 42:14want to come so that's just a current
- 42:16so the problem is more than just solving
- 42:19two cables to one it's more than that
- 42:21well i think i i would like to
- 42:23go to the two cables to one because
- 42:24i think it does simplify a lot of
- 42:25infrastructure design i'm not i'm not
- 42:28saying oh the labor versus one over two
- 42:30i'm just saying just simplifying that is
- 42:31nice
- 42:32to do that.
- 42:33I think it is an area that can
- 42:35be developed.
- 42:36I'm surprised that we have not seen more
- 42:39development in.
- 42:40Now,
- 42:41am I solving for every little world
- 42:43problem?
- 42:43No, I'm not.
- 42:44But I think it's an interesting
- 42:46perspective of going from the SDI and the
- 42:48kind of
- 42:49switcher,
- 42:49which I'm still waiting for the new one
- 42:51Marshall that you've been promised me for
- 42:52four years.
- 42:52Where the hell is it?
- 42:53Like they've been the one that doesn't run
- 42:58over to?
- 42:59Yeah.
- 42:59The IP based?
- 43:01Where's my small for in one out IP
- 43:05based control?
- 43:06STI switcher?
- 43:07I think that it's it's
- 43:11It's obvious the difference between like a
- 43:15broadcast,
- 43:16let's go back to the OBS and vMix
- 43:17and TriCaster and, you know, a Pro AV,
- 43:21Zoom Rooms, Team Rooms, something, right?
- 43:24Because trying to ingest that into a
- 43:27production switcher software of some sort,
- 43:29it does carry through.
- 43:31It does do exactly what
- 43:32Because you have like this thing, right?
- 43:33You have this controller, you're like, Oh,
- 43:35I'm marrying it to this.
- 43:35Well,
- 43:36go ahead and push all these things over
- 43:37there.
- 43:37No,
- 43:37but even even within a software based one,
- 43:39you know, I mean, without a controller,
- 43:41you're just using, you know,
- 43:45just the local PC to do that.
- 43:48All those stream, that stream data,
- 43:49that connection data, the throughput,
- 43:51all the information,
- 43:52all the control information,
- 43:53all pops through that one gig or ten
- 43:55gig network cable into that machine.
- 44:00Where the hell is this conversation going?
- 44:02No, no, no.
- 44:03This is that difference between a
- 44:06production environment PC system and what
- 44:10we are typically dealing with,
- 44:11where in our systems,
- 44:13and the softwares that are built around
- 44:15that.
- 44:15So Zoom's not thinking of it that way.
- 44:17They're not saying, oh, well,
- 44:18let's take this whole list of things and
- 44:20make it available and expose it to the
- 44:21end user as part of their selection.
- 44:24They're like, oh, no, it's a USB hook.
- 44:27It's a Teams.
- 44:28It's a USB hook.
- 44:30We depend on that USB hook,
- 44:32which is what's causing some of these
- 44:33problems.
- 44:34And that's just that difference in that
- 44:35Pro AV,
- 44:35because I'm sure there's some of our
- 44:37brethren out there going,
- 44:39but I can do that with my...
- 44:42my black magic design stuff.
- 44:43Yeah, but it's not the same.
- 44:44Yeah.
- 44:45Yeah,
- 44:46how you how you doing broadcast versus how
- 44:47you do it, like in a room scenario,
- 44:49you can accomplish the same outcome
- 44:50outcome.
- 44:51But I think when we looked at all
- 44:52of the like,
- 44:53look at any standard zoom room or teams
- 44:55room build diagram,
- 44:56they're gonna give you on the site,
- 44:58they're all going to have these extended
- 45:00USB nonsense configurations.
- 45:02Like I think all of us consider I
- 45:03know and say, Yeah, don't do that.
- 45:05Do not do that.
- 45:06It's not going to work the way you
- 45:07want it to do.
- 45:07And that's why we're like, eh,
- 45:08I'm going to do that.
- 45:09But I do see the value in these
- 45:11more ecosystem-centric approaches.
- 45:13This would help make that more elegant.
- 45:17That's not my only point.
- 45:18I'm just shocked that we haven't seen this
- 45:20segment mature the way we would anticipate
- 45:22it maturing.
- 45:23But I think we made great... Look,
- 45:26it took five, six... I mean,
- 45:29how many years did we talk about that
- 45:30on the show?
- 45:31Since we've started this show that I've
- 45:32been screaming,
- 45:33I wanted an NDI to USB widget...
- 45:37and Matt Madgewell came out with one,
- 45:39and now,
- 45:40is it Iogeni just put theirs out there,
- 45:42and somebody else is putting one out?
- 45:43It's like, to your point, it's like,
- 45:45why has it taken this long to get
- 45:47that product?
- 45:49I suspect it's based on the chipset,
- 45:50but I think part of also is a
- 45:52lot of the cameras, even those,
- 45:54if you're called, even...
- 45:56Just a year or two ago,
- 45:57the cameras that are NDI was NDI capable
- 46:00if you had the license,
- 46:00and now a lot of them are just
- 46:01including that across the board.
- 46:03So I think that maybe that critical mass
- 46:06is there,
- 46:06but I suspect on the widgetry side,
- 46:08we're seeing it from a specific chipset
- 46:11that can actually do it.
- 46:13And they're all saying, Oh,
- 46:13we're doing we can do them teams.
- 46:15It's the USB,
- 46:16we have it out on the computer.
- 46:17It's already on the camera.
- 46:18It's right there.
- 46:18Just play.
- 46:18It's like, No, no, no, no, no, no,
- 46:19I understand.
- 46:20I need the just make the NDI carry
- 46:24all of that information.
- 46:26I think we'd be right in the pocket.
- 46:27And I think they're all right there.
- 46:29They're
- 46:30See, if I did the NDI thing,
- 46:32I'm going to hit the local switch in
- 46:34the lectern and then run another cable out
- 46:36of that switch to a doohickey anyway.
- 46:39So it's no different than what I'm doing
- 46:40today.
- 46:41It solves no problems.
- 46:42Yeah.
- 46:43And that's my,
- 46:43and that Larry can understand that.
- 46:45Yes.
- 46:46Yes.
- 46:47Yes.
- 46:47Yes.
- 46:48But if all your cameras,
- 46:49let's say I'm going to do four cameras,
- 46:50Justin, I'm not,
- 46:51I'm not changing the goalpost on you here.
- 46:52Okay.
- 46:53So now we're,
- 46:54now we're in a different world.
- 46:56What if they were built around the
- 46:58display?
- 46:59Wherever they were.
- 47:00Cool it.
- 47:00Cool it.
- 47:02Cool it.
- 47:05Those are coming in as,
- 47:06let's just imagine the world.
- 47:07Let me just weave this tapestry for you.
- 47:09Four cameras in the room, different zones.
- 47:12It's a big room, right?
- 47:13Or a small room.
- 47:14Yeah, whatever.
- 47:15Or yeah, a really small room.
- 47:16One focus on... One managed switch,
- 47:19four connections, one output to the thing,
- 47:22one USB cable in.
- 47:23Yeah,
- 47:23you're describing my stuff right now.
- 47:24Right, and so you're there, right?
- 47:25And it's kind of where we are,
- 47:27but it's how we do it is a
- 47:30little bit more thing.
- 47:30Now, Chris,
- 47:31I would like you to explain how you're
- 47:32doing,
- 47:32because I think you have yet an
- 47:35ecosystem's worth of...
- 47:37stuff in the way you're doing it too
- 47:38well my interest in this is twofold one
- 47:40it's it's and justin brings us up a
- 47:42lot removing boxes it's it's reducing
- 47:44complexity it's getting rid of something
- 47:46so i'm already running the cameras into
- 47:48the switch that's there the managed switch
- 47:50now i can if if i gave move
- 47:52this over to our our mystical let's just
- 47:54say our mystical ndi to and to uvc
- 47:57converter or srt to uvc whichever we want
- 47:59to do it
- 48:01I can remove one cable to every camera
- 48:03because now I just need one cable.
- 48:04I'm already pulling PoE for control and
- 48:06power, so I can do that anyway.
- 48:08Okay, great.
- 48:09It's already running to the switch,
- 48:11but it's also running the parallel video
- 48:14stream to another switcher,
- 48:15and I can get rid of all of
- 48:16that,
- 48:16and then it comes out of that to
- 48:18a little converter box.
- 48:19So I'm still going to need a converter
- 48:20box,
- 48:20but that converter box now just goes to
- 48:22the network switch that's right there and
- 48:25converts to UVC with video and control.
- 48:30Great.
- 48:30So I've removed three or four things from
- 48:32my system.
- 48:33And what we haven't brought up yet is
- 48:36that as many of these systems now gain
- 48:38software systems,
- 48:40as many of these software applications,
- 48:41rather,
- 48:42gain access directly to the cameras,
- 48:44you get additional features.
- 48:46You get the intelligent director,
- 48:47the smart framing,
- 48:48all these things that are coming from
- 48:50software running either as a helper widget
- 48:52or in the case of a...
- 48:54of a room system that's running in that
- 48:55application or on a dedicated device.
- 48:57But you're adding capability that wasn't
- 49:00there previously to the cameras you
- 49:01already have or already buy.
- 49:03And that's my interest.
- 49:04It's like, hey,
- 49:05this cost me an extra hundred bucks over
- 49:07what I do.
- 49:08I removed a bunch of stuff that I
- 49:09had to install or pull or whatever that
- 49:12is.
- 49:13And I'm getting added features that
- 49:15weren't there before.
- 49:16How about this?
- 49:16How about one better?
- 49:17One better.
- 49:18Extend USB.
- 49:21So what if I remove the network switch
- 49:24altogether too?
- 49:25And we could buy a Hudley L-One.
- 49:27We're back to that.
- 49:29That's what I do a lot.
- 49:31So I'm going to plug three of those
- 49:32in and ask them to go in and
- 49:33switch which of the three cameras they're
- 49:34looking at?
- 49:35Well, no,
- 49:35they make a solution for that too,
- 49:37where it's one.
- 49:38Zoom Room is doing everything that I'm
- 49:41asking to do.
- 49:41Like, it can bring in the NDI.
- 49:43It does show up in the camera control.
- 49:44It's all there, right?
- 49:46Which makes it specific is outside of that
- 49:49scenario.
- 49:49It's the common classroom,
- 49:51where I'm not running the Zoom Room piece
- 49:53of that,
- 49:53and that maybe that PC is not sitting
- 49:55on the same network that all the control
- 49:56stuff is sitting on.
- 49:57That's where it starts to fall apart.
- 49:58That would be where this widget is going
- 50:00to span those two ecosystems.
- 50:02Because I know people are screaming, well,
- 50:03Zoom Room does it already.
- 50:04Teams, that room does it already.
- 50:05Yes, I know that.
- 50:06But it's it's,
- 50:07you have these specific architectural
- 50:10differences of how these these systems are
- 50:12landing and sitting on your network.
- 50:15Or are they?
- 50:17They don't have to,
- 50:17but that's now we're talking about other
- 50:19people's domain.
- 50:21Yeah,
- 50:21that's where a lot a lot of the
- 50:22question marks come in,
- 50:23because with mine running on this,
- 50:26that VLAN is is
- 50:29Fraser Cain,
- 50:30it's a self imposed problem for a lot
- 50:32of for a lot of us because of
- 50:33the way our organization structure is in
- 50:35our IT departments.
- 50:35And this is yes,
- 50:36we have to figure these kinds of things
- 50:37out.
- 50:38And you know,
- 50:38this is asking for a solution for a
- 50:40problem that shouldn't be anyway.
- 50:42Yes, or just extend USB,
- 50:44or just extend USB.
- 50:45Sorry,
- 50:46there's always that I forgot about that
- 50:47one.
- 50:49And we use we use the same cameras
- 50:52for like,
- 50:53that's how we get room views and things.
- 50:55So it's all exposed all the way.
- 50:58So if it was
- 51:00surveillance, Larry surveillance.
- 51:02Just saying that's coming.
- 51:02All right.
- 51:02Well,
- 51:08any any last thoughts on the the mystical
- 51:12new version of deployments of our cameras
- 51:14are removing cables and adapters and
- 51:16widgets and hoping for the best.
- 51:19More more widgets.
- 51:20More widgets, okay.
- 51:21We'll convert it back.
- 51:23I'm going to take my NDI stream out
- 51:24to UVC,
- 51:25convert that through the compute out to
- 51:27SDI, and then back in.
- 51:29But I think you're going to see that
- 51:31this becomes more a complicated problem
- 51:34when folks start doing more of the...
- 51:38I'm going to say a vision suite kind
- 51:40of thing where you're trying to multi,
- 51:42the AI switching the AI bull crap and
- 51:46to having it exposed.
- 51:47You need to be doing that when you
- 51:49can get ninety percent of the way there
- 51:50with stuff that now just shows up in
- 51:52Zoom and Teams and all the rest.
- 51:53Correct.
- 51:55But if it's just SDI to a converter,
- 51:58this is what I'm saying,
- 51:59like being able to expose all the
- 52:01individual cameras and streams and feeds
- 52:03and things to the
- 52:04the machine that's doing all the thinking
- 52:07is going to be more important,
- 52:08even if that machine doesn't reside in
- 52:11that rack.
- 52:11Maybe it resides somewhere else.
- 52:13Well, you're not wrong there,
- 52:14but that's my interest in this,
- 52:15is thinking about not necessarily the
- 52:17machine or the device, whatever it is,
- 52:19that may exist down the hall in a
- 52:20server closet.
- 52:22I'm not running stuff down in the IDF,
- 52:23but I have the computer in the room
- 52:27so why can't that be doing it so
- 52:28if i can expose these and gain let's
- 52:30say seventy five percent of those added
- 52:32features great that's that's that's a
- 52:35win-win for me because i ain't buying
- 52:37thirteen thousand dollar appliances for
- 52:38every room right
- 52:41And if you are, please reach out.
- 52:43I wish you would just waste money like
- 52:46the rest of us.
- 52:47How come you just won't fall in line?
- 52:49Higher ed's just wasting money on thirteen
- 52:51thousand dollar appliances.
- 52:53And if you're buying many of those for
- 52:54your new space,
- 52:56please write in and explain to us how
- 52:58often you go to therapy.
- 52:59I haven't seen one in a while.
- 53:01I have yet to see one actually grazing
- 53:03out there roaming the earth.
- 53:04No.
- 53:07Well, let's take a quick break,
- 53:08and we'll come back,
- 53:08and we're going to talk about another
- 53:10technology which never got off the ground.
- 53:18Are you ready for a desk job like
- 53:20no other?
- 53:20Get ready to experience forbidden passions
- 53:23and office romance like never before in
- 53:25the scintillating made-for-TV movie event
- 53:28of the year, hot desking.
- 53:31A sea of sleek,
- 53:32stylish desks designed for love,
- 53:35where every pencil holder,
- 53:36every slimline drawer,
- 53:38and every paperclip screams romance.
- 53:41Join us on a journey through the office
- 53:43corridors of desire as co-workers find
- 53:46themselves irresistibly drawn to each
- 53:48other and their oh-so-seductive desks.
- 53:52Sparks fly as deadlines loom and emails
- 53:55ping in the background.
- 53:56But amidst the chaos of the office,
- 53:59love finds a way.
- 54:00From the water cooler whispers to the
- 54:02steamy conference room encounters,
- 54:04Hot Desking will have you on the edge
- 54:06of your desk chair, craving more.
- 54:09If you're ready for a workplace drama
- 54:11that's equal parts steamy and hilarious,
- 54:15tune in to Hot Desking,
- 54:16where even the office furniture knows how
- 54:18to kindle forbidden passions.
- 54:21Hot Desking,
- 54:22coming soon to a screen near you.
- 54:25An independent, amalgamated production.
- 54:31I hear that's got good Rotten Tomatoes
- 54:33scores.
- 54:34That's something.
- 54:35Everyone loves hot desking, apparently.
- 54:38People keep coming up to me on show
- 54:39floor tours and yelling at me about it.
- 54:42All right.
- 54:42You don't need a little scheduler at every
- 54:44single desk in your office?
- 54:46I do.
- 54:46I schedule when I have to leave and
- 54:47all that.
- 54:48It's a whole thing.
- 54:48All right.
- 54:52So this next topic is on eight K,
- 54:55which nobody used.
- 54:57Shame.
- 54:58Show's over.
- 54:59I have seven eight K TVs in my
- 55:02house.
- 55:03with specialized eight K content that I've
- 55:06developed with watching seven,
- 55:08twenty P over streaming.
- 55:09Yeah.
- 55:09I created my own,
- 55:10like Smurfs cartoon in AK.
- 55:12Larry, you posted this in our,
- 55:14in our discussion board.
- 55:15Um, uh, and it was from a, uh,
- 55:17LinkedIn post.
- 55:18And then I dug up a, um,
- 55:19a new story on it,
- 55:20but the LinkedIn post basically says that,
- 55:22um,
- 55:23And links in the show notes here.
- 55:25LG stopped making AK panels.
- 55:27Sony doesn't make AK panels.
- 55:28TCL doesn't make AK panels.
- 55:31The AK Association went from.
- 55:33Well, there's an AK Association.
- 55:35Eight thousand.
- 55:36There was an AK.
- 55:37It's down to sixteen people.
- 55:41It's just,
- 55:41it never seemed to get anywhere.
- 55:42And we saw this with four K as
- 55:44well.
- 55:44Four K,
- 55:44like how long have four K displays been
- 55:47around?
- 55:48And we're still kind of baby stepping into
- 55:50four K in specialized applications because
- 55:53at the end of the day,
- 55:53it really doesn't matter.
- 55:55And I think that's what they're seeing
- 55:56with eight K is the level of processing,
- 55:58the level of quality control.
- 56:00And Justin, to your point,
- 56:00the specialized content you need to
- 56:02actually
- 56:04Just isn't there.
- 56:05Now,
- 56:05someone out there is yelling they just
- 56:06built some visualization suite or
- 56:08whatever.
- 56:08Okay, I get it.
- 56:08Yes, there are specialized uses for this.
- 56:10But the general gist of we're buying eight
- 56:13KTVs, it never got anywhere.
- 56:15And then I have another article from Ars
- 56:18Technica just kind of basically saying the
- 56:20same thing,
- 56:20and I'll link in the show notes there,
- 56:21but that these have been around for like
- 56:23almost fifteen years.
- 56:25If you don't know that,
- 56:26because it was the twenty twelve Olympics,
- 56:28I think that they were talking about.
- 56:29They were broadcasting in eight K and all
- 56:31these like specialized things.
- 56:32It was crazy.
- 56:33They just never got anywhere.
- 56:34Capturing.
- 56:37yeah no they weren't no it wasn't japan
- 56:39who was doing that i mean wasn't the
- 56:40biggest problem is just sending the signal
- 56:43uncompressed i mean it's then you have to
- 56:44compress ak anyway then what's the i mean
- 56:47it's like i mean for broadcast right and
- 56:49transmission i mean we're really not i
- 56:51mean netflix four k isn't really four k
- 56:54and so see what i'm saying so what's
- 56:56the point right
- 57:01Yes, and I think at the size,
- 57:03the size to pixel count didn't matter
- 57:05either.
- 57:07Better than the human eye kind of thing.
- 57:09For the residential market, just...
- 57:12It's silly.
- 57:13And now,
- 57:14if you're doing large displays that have
- 57:16that many pixels,
- 57:17you're already running a processor in
- 57:19custom-built pixel configurations.
- 57:24Yeah,
- 57:25when you get into that type of material
- 57:27to do that...
- 57:30it's never going to add up exactly clean
- 57:31the way you want it to.
- 57:32And so you're always going to need that
- 57:33processing.
- 57:33You're always going to,
- 57:34you can fill those pixels and make it
- 57:37be what you want,
- 57:37but it's never easy that way.
- 57:39It's not clean.
- 57:39Because I even,
- 57:40I was reading an article the other day
- 57:42that people were bitching about, oh,
- 57:45the new ATSC-III.
- 57:47Oh, I heard that's supposed to save lives.
- 57:49I heard that's supposed to be the bee's
- 57:51knees.
- 57:51But it's like, well, it's going to,
- 57:54over the air,
- 57:57But they're just going to upscale the
- 57:58seven twenty from, you know, Fox Sports.
- 58:01Well, it does more than that, though.
- 58:03No, no, no.
- 58:04They've been scaling it up.
- 58:06But the the the base delivery of the
- 58:08video is just that.
- 58:09No, it does a lot.
- 58:11It does a lot more than just mostly
- 58:14mostly copyright protection.
- 58:17Awesome.
- 58:17Oh, joy.
- 58:18We really need more of that shit.
- 58:20Thanks, lawyers.
- 58:21Yeah.
- 58:22So, no, that is the problem.
- 58:24And you will have to deal with it
- 58:25soon.
- 58:25But that was one of the things.
- 58:29No, I won't.
- 58:30Watch TV is the problem.
- 58:33Broadcasters are still going to produce
- 58:35content for ATSC One,
- 58:37and they're just going to upscale it,
- 58:38and it's not really ever going to get
- 58:40there.
- 58:40So I think AK kind of fell on
- 58:41that.
- 58:42Well, now we've got to triple it.
- 58:45Now we've got to quadruple it,
- 58:46whatever the math is on that.
- 58:48Math it out.
- 58:50I can check.
- 58:51NHK was broadcasting eight K for the
- 58:54twenty twelve summer Olympics.
- 58:56Twenty twelve.
- 58:58Yes.
- 58:58Twenty twelve in London.
- 59:00They broadcast eight K.
- 59:02I wonder how many people actually saw it
- 59:04in eight K. How do you really know?
- 59:07I'm broadcasting right now in eight K
- 59:09pools.
- 59:10What?
- 59:11What about it?
- 59:12Only a handful of people in Japan.
- 59:13That's all the new.
- 59:15It was just the tech director who then
- 59:16scaled it.
- 59:17They just derezzed it down.
- 59:18He broadcast it right from that router
- 59:20right into this monitor that he had
- 59:22locally.
- 59:22It didn't go anywhere else.
- 59:23The tech director was Chris's brother who
- 59:26said, ah, seven-twenty's good enough.
- 59:28Yeah.
- 59:30I'll give you four eight all day long.
- 59:35Why do you need more than that?
- 59:35What are you doing?
- 59:36It's HD, technically.
- 59:38So is this the last few minutes that
- 59:40we're going to waste on eight K forever?
- 59:43I highly doubt it.
- 59:44This is the first few minutes as well.
- 59:47I'm sure we'll talk about it.
- 59:48I think it'll be resurrected.
- 59:50Are we going to see it?
- 59:51Oh,
- 59:51but eight K could be four K stereo.
- 59:55Three to eight four K. Right?
- 59:59No.
- 1:00:00Don't give these engineers any ideas,
- 1:00:02Jamie.
- 1:00:02You don't need glasses because it's AK,
- 1:00:04so you can get two full K rasters
- 1:00:06on it,
- 1:00:07run that sucker up to a hundred and
- 1:00:08twenty Hertz, watch three D.
- 1:00:10I don't think physics works like that.
- 1:00:13Oh, it does.
- 1:00:13Oh, it does.
- 1:00:15It doesn't have to.
- 1:00:16You just got to convince enough people
- 1:00:17that it does.
- 1:00:17You just go talk to any marketing
- 1:00:19department on Earth, buddy.
- 1:00:20This is going to work.
- 1:00:21Exactly.
- 1:00:22It's not a physics problem.
- 1:00:23It's a marketing problem.
- 1:00:24How many AIs are in there?
- 1:00:26How many do you need in there to
- 1:00:27sell it?
- 1:00:28Seven.
- 1:00:29It needs seven.
- 1:00:31It's the AI to rule them all.
- 1:00:34It's kind of like the United Nations of
- 1:00:36AI so that Claude can talk to chat
- 1:00:38that can talk to,
- 1:00:39I don't even know all of them,
- 1:00:40but they're going to talk to each other.
- 1:00:42IMAX, yeah, okay.
- 1:00:43Specialized, sure.
- 1:00:46Special content.
- 1:00:48So, yeah,
- 1:00:50and AK displays themselves are not going
- 1:00:52away.
- 1:00:53You're going to see them in niche
- 1:00:55specialized markets, and, you know,
- 1:00:56you can build them out as video walls
- 1:00:58or whatever.
- 1:00:58So if you need that for your specialized
- 1:01:01content displays, yes,
- 1:01:02but you're not going to see Best Buy.
- 1:01:03We're not removing the pixel count.
- 1:01:04It's still going to exist.
- 1:01:06I'm saving a pixel for every display.
- 1:01:08You're just skipping over that number
- 1:01:10like, nope.
- 1:01:11If it's not eight point one,
- 1:01:12I don't want to talk about it.
- 1:01:15Well, they may need to dial back.
- 1:01:16They'll just do seven K. But so anyway,
- 1:01:18so this will go the same way as
- 1:01:21we saw with three D and all the
- 1:01:23rest.
- 1:01:23It was all the next big whiz bang
- 1:01:25thing.
- 1:01:26And we're still going to Spain.
- 1:01:27Is that what we're talking about?
- 1:01:29With VR, we can go to Spain.
- 1:01:31Get a tent.
- 1:01:32I see.
- 1:01:33I'm not using VR again until it's twenty
- 1:01:35one by nine.
- 1:01:38I you're saying a lot of nonsensical
- 1:01:41things, Jamie.
- 1:01:41You want this thing constrained, right?
- 1:01:44I don't like this nonsensical Jamie.
- 1:01:46Hey, he's making a lot of sense.
- 1:01:49I don't know why.
- 1:01:49I don't know.
- 1:01:50All right.
- 1:01:51Well,
- 1:01:52for those of you who have AK displays
- 1:01:54and AK televisions, great.
- 1:01:55Hang on to them.
- 1:01:56I'm sure you'll have trouble listening to
- 1:01:57them soon.
- 1:01:58Please call us.
- 1:01:59We'd like to know.
- 1:02:01um all right any last thoughts on uh
- 1:02:04eight k and uh it's uh wide proliferation
- 1:02:07no we just need to move on to
- 1:02:08sixteen k oh so yeah what is it
- 1:02:12okay birth of sixteen you learn nothing
- 1:02:13from me is anyone doing sixteen k i
- 1:02:15don't know probably somebody is isn't it
- 1:02:17out you can buy shit that's sixteen k
- 1:02:19right didn't i see that from some
- 1:02:21marketing place oh good lord back next
- 1:02:24week with more nonsense
- 1:02:28Well,
- 1:02:28we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:02:30of AV Superfriends Off the Rails.
- 1:02:32You can contact us with questions,
- 1:02:34topic ideas,
- 1:02:34or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:02:36avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:02:38If you complain loud enough,
- 1:02:39we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:02:44Nice work, everyone.
- 1:02:46Sharp broadcast.
- 1:02:47Really good.
- 1:02:48Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:02:50Really a lot of hustle.
- 1:02:51I liked it.
- 1:02:52The opinions expressed by the AV
- 1:02:53Superfriends are solely those of the
- 1:02:54individuals and do not represent their
- 1:02:56respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:02:58companies, or clients.