Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E037: The Pensions Have Arrived with Sam Roberts & Glenn Cameron
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29in Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation. As we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:12having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class, we are halving all annual maintenance
- 1:18fees for clients that secure their wealth before the next
- 1:21Bitcoin epoch. What you're telling me is that
- 1:25music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:28the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:33history of governors 1974198792972000.
- 1:40And whatever we want to call this.
- 1:42It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:44We can't help ourselves. I say when we.
- 1:47Sell, I say when we sell. We've got a very unique setup
- 1:58for this show. Jesse and I are in Texas and
- 2:01Michael is over in London, joined by the Cartwright team,
- 2:06Glenn Cameron, who's been on the show before, and Sam Roberts,
- 2:09the CIO of Cartwright. Michael, I'll let you open this
- 2:12since you, Glenn and Sam have been hanging out and talking for
- 2:17the last couple days. What's going on over in London?
- 2:21You know, well, we took a red eye from Texas last night, you
- 2:24know, hopped over the pond and went to meet Glenn and Sam and
- 2:28had some good conversations, excited to roll into this.
- 2:32This is one of the ones that I think I need to say less of.
- 2:34And we have experts in the room, asset allocators that have been
- 2:37looking at Bitcoin for a very long time and excited to have a
- 2:40conversation with them. Time as well.
- 2:43And Sam, before you re entered the room, I couldn't see you
- 2:46before, but I was telling you, I I thought I was telling you.
- 2:48I was just telling Glenn and Michael that the first time
- 2:50Glenn was on, he explained how he joined Cartwright and the
- 2:56interview process he went through, which is essentially
- 2:59you making sure that Glenn understood Bitcoin and Bitcoin
- 3:03specifically. And I think for the purposes of
- 3:06this show and just building on the first episode we did with
- 3:09Glenn, really interesting to learn about your background, how
- 3:14you became so convicted on Bitcoin particularly.
- 3:18Yeah, sure. So brilliant to be here by the
- 3:20way, and good to be live with you guys.
- 3:25Obviously seen you in the past on previous podcasts.
- 3:28And yeah, that trick question I asked them was what do you think
- 3:31of crypto? And I'm pleased to say you
- 3:33passed, otherwise you wouldn't be here.
- 3:36So my background is I'll take a step back and then sort of take
- 3:40a run up into how I've ended up here.
- 3:46So I'm an actuary by career choice that's since started in
- 3:5198, so many years ago there. And I first started sort of
- 4:00having thoughts about if things aren't quite right in 2008 and
- 4:07that I was looking all over the place for answers to that, found
- 4:12myself going deep into the Austrian School of Economics.
- 4:17I think it's a natural step from there certainly in those days to
- 4:22then end up as some kind of gold bug.
- 4:25So I think that's a commonly treaded path.
- 4:33I was then focusing on my career for the next few years and then
- 4:37came back to I heard about Bitcoin in 2013.
- 4:42I did what I normally do, which is I dabbled.
- 4:45Obviously in hindsight, I wish I'd dabbled a lot more than I
- 4:48did, but sort of just tested out a little bit and then forgot
- 4:54about it. I didn't really understand it in
- 4:56reality in those days but then it rolls around to 2020 and
- 5:04obviously everything that was going on then central banks
- 5:08taking action as they want to do and into 2021 where I was then
- 5:14had the chance to to go a bit deeper into Bitcoin again and I
- 5:19took the took the path again. Pretty well trodden.
- 5:22I think I had a slight diversion into crypto, which I've I
- 5:31dabbled again. So again as an idea doesn't make
- 5:35any sense. I feel I have to test it out for
- 5:38myself, which is what I I then did.
- 5:41I then very quickly realized that it was a dead end,
- 5:46essentially to put it politely, which then helped me to come
- 5:51full circle back again to say, OK, so it's Bitcoin only.
- 5:55So that takes us to sort of late 2021 and then 2022.
- 6:02A key date in my mind was it was 24th of February 2022.
- 6:07So that was when that might have been when I can't remember the
- 6:11exact date actually saying that, but it was Russia had invaded
- 6:14Ukraine at that point and it wasn't so much that.
- 6:17It was more the event of the US and indeed other nation states
- 6:23confiscating Russia's treasury bonds.
- 6:29And for me that was that was a real inflection point.
- 6:33So I built up a Bitcoin only understanding at that point and
- 6:40understood about, you know, the lack of counterparty risk, if
- 6:44you hold it in the right way, etcetera.
- 6:46And for me that was it wasn't, you know, it wasn't about
- 6:48whether Russia was right or wrong or whatever thing.
- 6:50It was the fact that one Nation state had confiscated another
- 6:53nation states assets, just a stroke of a pen.
- 6:59And that for me was a turning point.
- 7:01So it was, it was a couple of days later I had a team meeting
- 7:05and I said OK, I think they were a little bit shocked, but I said
- 7:09OK, we now need to be thinking more carefully about Bitcoin as
- 7:14a serious option for our clients.
- 7:16My expectation, which I think I told you, Glenn, actually at
- 7:20that time was that it's going to take a couple of years for us to
- 7:24get to the stage where clients are going to be able to invest
- 7:27possibly a bit longer. So two years rolls on.
- 7:31We're almost at that to your point.
- 7:33And we're, you know, very close I think to to helping clients
- 7:38get into this asset class. So it's very exciting time.
- 7:42It's been a long time coming, but very pleased that we're here
- 7:45today. Yeah, it's it's crazy to think
- 7:50about somebody in your shoes, too, as the CIO of Cartwright.
- 7:54And you have this duty to your end.
- 7:57Clients may not be doing as deep of research into these subjects
- 8:01as you have to make sure that you're getting them the right
- 8:04information. So leaning into your personal
- 8:06journey and having to basically come to grips with the fact that
- 8:10crypto's noise and Bitcoin is signal, as you mentioned, the
- 8:14confiscation of treasury assets is a very large event that
- 8:19really highlights this counterparty risk exists
- 8:22throughout the system and Bitcoin is the solution.
- 8:25And then having the wherewithal and the foresight say, OK, we've
- 8:30got to go on this journey to develop a thesis and a process
- 8:35internally before we can go get our clients into this years down
- 8:39the line. How, like, how do you sort of
- 8:47pitch this to your clients now that you've spent this amount of
- 8:51time, 2 years building out a process, building out a thesis,
- 8:55finding the right counterparties to get you access and your
- 8:58clients access to Bitcoin? Have you been pitching Bitcoin
- 9:02along the way or is this a point now in time, February 2024,
- 9:06where it's like, all right, we have everything in order on our
- 9:09end. We can then go begin telling our
- 9:12clients about this. So we started seriously telling
- 9:15clients in October, Just gone. And that was in the context of
- 9:24an asset allocator portfolio construction.
- 9:28These are people. Our clients are people that look
- 9:31after other people's money. And I think that's a really key
- 9:34difference. Me personally or anyone else
- 9:36personally, you can dabble, right, You win some, you lose
- 9:40some maybe, but you can dabble and you can test things out to
- 9:43understand them better. That's fine.
- 9:46But that's not what our clients can do.
- 9:50In the same way, they need to be much more confident in what
- 9:54they're investing and much more confident they can get the
- 9:56advice and the proper analysis around that.
- 9:59So we very much pitched this as a small allocation to Bitcoin
- 10:06and Bitcoin only obviously, but the small allocation is also
- 10:12important and because it helps them to dip their toe in the
- 10:16water, I think also what helps the small allocation sort of
- 10:22from our point of view and maybe some we can dig into it deeper
- 10:25possibly. But in simplistic terms, I think
- 10:29we've got a couple of phases coming up.
- 10:31So we've got the monetization phase and then we've got the
- 10:38increasing in value in line with economic growth generally.
- 10:40So it's sort of what Gold has effectively done for for for a
- 10:46few 1000 years. You know, the old Roman Roman
- 10:50suit idea. So you've got two distinct
- 10:54phases and the advantage of that first stage is that you can
- 10:58justify putting a small amount in 2-3, four percent of a
- 11:03portfolio and you know what your downside is 2, three, 4%.
- 11:09But you've got this massive upside potential and I think
- 11:12that is what is extremely helpful at this stage because
- 11:17when you start plugging it into you know any kind of investment
- 11:21risk model, it looks very attractive.
- 11:26Yeah. To take a step back, I think
- 11:30it's always fascinating when Glenn first came on and Chris
- 11:33Kuiper and very senior professionals that are used to
- 11:37speaking the language of asset allocators, you guys have
- 11:40amazing positioning. There's a term inversion that
- 11:44Chris brings up. I was just talking the other
- 11:46day. It's not going to come off the
- 11:47top of my head, but there's this angle of being able to like flip
- 11:50like what would cause Bitcoin not to work or what would cause
- 11:52it to not, like appreciate, but to go backwards.
- 11:57We kind of glossed over the the, the, the, the question to Glenn
- 12:05about, you know, I think it was very transformative or very
- 12:09important to the whole process of you guys like finding a
- 12:12person to lead this unit. And I say that because as we're
- 12:17coming out East, we're gonna be in the UAE.
- 12:20There's folks that we're talking to in India and Dubai, Abu
- 12:24Dhabi, the Middle East. And this, this idea of
- 12:27counterparty risk is understood by them and they understand that
- 12:30the ETF may not be the solution, similar to what you're saying
- 12:33about the treasuries different angle, but similar concept of
- 12:36like who's your counterparty. And when we met Glenn, it was
- 12:40top of mind all the way up the stack.
- 12:42What do you what do you investor, what he offer was the
- 12:46counterparty the, the solution from a custody perspective?
- 12:49Do you, you know the delivery mechanisms, all these things
- 12:52that were important. And so going back to that clever
- 12:54question, you were either was a test there.
- 12:56But I'm curious, like, how did you think about why it mattered
- 12:59and how you had to find the right person for this whole,
- 13:01like, journey? Because I think that's like one
- 13:03of the most pivotal points to find the right person and then
- 13:06and the right counterparty to make sure that you could
- 13:08actually get the right, yeah, like solution.
- 13:12And we're fortunate. This is a growing area and
- 13:15therefore, these opportunities are more likely to come along
- 13:18than if it's a contracting area. And so Glenn's been fantastic.
- 13:24It was a bit of a coincidence in terms of the timing.
- 13:28So I mentioned February 2022, Glenn joined in May 2022.
- 13:34Obviously, we'd had some discussions before February.
- 13:37So that worked that, I mean that worked very well in terms of the
- 13:42timing. And I think that I think our
- 13:47clients are looking at it partly from a counterparty risk point
- 13:51of view and partly from inflation point of view.
- 13:56And they're not mutually exclusive scenarios, economic
- 14:00scenarios, but in some ways they can be simplified down to that.
- 14:05So you have an economic contraction that increases your
- 14:09counterparty risk, Increase your counterparty risk.
- 14:11If you own bonds, are they going to be able to pay the coupons?
- 14:15If you own equities, what their profits going to be like?
- 14:18If you're in property, are they going to pay the rent?
- 14:19So you've got there tends to be a correlation with higher
- 14:23counterparty risk in an economic contraction.
- 14:26And then of course, the flip side is that the central banks
- 14:30printing, creating inflation, the hard cap 21 million then
- 14:36really comes into its own. So you've got this fantastic
- 14:39combination of extreme scenarios where historically gold would
- 14:45have played that role. But of course now we're in, now
- 14:49we're in a new world and Bitcoin is I think gradually going to
- 14:52take over from gold in that role.
- 14:55Does that answer your question? Yeah, I think so.
- 15:00Yeah. You raise a really good
- 15:01distinction there that I don't think we talk enough about.
- 15:04In the space of, you know, people often fall into the trap
- 15:09of like well I if I'm going to hold a sound money asset, I
- 15:13might as well hold gold because it's proven and like that's
- 15:16going to be a better store of value and a more reliable.
- 15:19So if I'm going to do anything, I'll include a little bit of
- 15:21gold, but they're making this, this mistake, this fallacy, that
- 15:27of assuming that Bitcoin and gold are in a similar sort of
- 15:30point in their life cycle. And I think you're right to call
- 15:34out that, like you want that end state stability in in this
- 15:40asset, but that's not where we're at right now.
- 15:42But instead there's a huge asymmetric upside opportunity as
- 15:47we get to that eventual place for Bitcoin, which is many,
- 15:51many, many trillions away in terms of monetization in in, you
- 15:54know, total asset value. So you know, I I think that's a
- 15:58a unique lens that I haven't heard.
- 16:02And I think it's probably coming from your role in trying to
- 16:05communicate this opportunity to pensions of don't think about
- 16:10that end state, think about where you're at right now.
- 16:15And the end state is, is you know where you'll eventually
- 16:17get. But the the real exciting part
- 16:20is, you know, the monetization process that Bitcoin is still at
- 16:24the very beginning of. Yeah, that's right.
- 16:28I mean we've got, we've got a saying in the in the into the
- 16:32investment community which is very variations on it.
- 16:35But the the future is not necessarily a reflection of the
- 16:38past or you know something similar to that.
- 16:40So the idea that Gold's you know done what it's done over the
- 16:46last five, 5000 years, I mean it's obviously impressive,
- 16:49right. It should be given credit for
- 16:50that, but I can't invest in the past, I can only invest in the
- 16:54future and so I need to look at when advising clients what's the
- 17:00future, what's the likely future scenarios that we that we can
- 17:05foresee or test out or you know, envisage.
- 17:10And also if, well, Bitcoin in April is going to have a better
- 17:17stock to flow ratio than gold by a long shot, double the stock to
- 17:21flow ratio, right? So if you look historically at
- 17:26what's happened when a harder form of money into the society,
- 17:31well then all of a sudden that's slowly kind of eats away at
- 17:36everything else. So actually holding gold is a
- 17:40risk, right? Because if Bitcoin eats gold's
- 17:45lunch, if gold becomes demonetized, you certainly that
- 17:49argument of like, Oh well, if I'm looking for an asset that's
- 17:52a store of value, I'll just go with gold.
- 17:55What if in 20 years time it's been demonetized and now it's an
- 18:00industrial metal, right. So you definitely don't want to
- 18:04be making the mistake of saying I need a store of value asset in
- 18:09My Portfolio. It's obviously gold because that
- 18:13might be the worst thing that you can do.
- 18:15And then also, nobody's saying that the probability of Bitcoin
- 18:20doing that is 100%, right? But it's some percentage.
- 18:25I like to think it's a quite a large percentage probability
- 18:29that it's going to do that given bitcoins properties.
- 18:33And so if you give me, you know, 100 opportunities with high
- 18:42probabilities that they're going to come true and with huge
- 18:46upside, I'm going to take every single one of those baits, it
- 18:52will make an allocation to all of those things.
- 18:55The trouble with this is, is that you can't rely on the law
- 18:59of large numbers because you've only got this one bit right.
- 19:05But there's also the danger that like we discussed I think the
- 19:08last time is that because everything's denominated in
- 19:12this, these Fiat currencies that essentially I remember Marty
- 19:20joking about black hole insurance, right, like Bitcoin
- 19:25acting like a back hole and like sucking all the value out of
- 19:29these other assets because as it monetizes, that value has to
- 19:34come from somewhere, right? And as people and the biggest
- 19:38asset class where that's going to be the case is bonds, Another
- 19:42one is property probably the last one if it would have been
- 19:51would be equities because you know there you kind of I mean
- 19:58essentially because you're not your revenue is going up as the
- 20:04the inflationary nominal terms you kind of protected I mean
- 20:09equity has. Been a good long term like
- 20:15inflation, sort of protection kind of assets, bonds,
- 20:21definitely not properties overvalued, right.
- 20:25So it's, you know, the idea that, Oh well, if I want to
- 20:30store a value asset in My Portfolio, I'll just put gold in
- 20:33there. OK.
- 20:34So what are you expecting? A zero real return, right?
- 20:38That's what you're expecting. And at the same time it gets
- 20:43demonetized. And how much of your portfolio
- 20:46are you going to put in gold, right, Whereas you can put 2,
- 20:50three, 4% in Bitcoin, right? And it kind of it's going to
- 20:55have a material impact on the race of your portfolio, you
- 21:00know, so and you you especially like with different types of
- 21:05investors, right. You can't afford to be using
- 21:09huge chunks of your portfolio as kind of a long term store of
- 21:14value. You've got different objectives.
- 21:16You need to grow the capital or you need to hedge liabilities or
- 21:21something like that. Whereas with this thing, it's
- 21:23just kind of like the sprinkle of salt, you know that you put
- 21:27on top of the meal and you know you can get busy with everything
- 21:33else that you want to do with the portfolio and just have this
- 21:36thing there kind of. Yeah, it's it's so interesting
- 21:41that you guys marry this. You know the the first principle
- 21:46of thinking that is necessary to understand the value proposition
- 21:50of Bitcoin, but through an actual actuarial lens where you
- 21:54guys are evaluating this in terms of probabilities, numbers
- 21:57and how this works out in different scenarios.
- 22:01And then finally having to to filter that through the
- 22:03fiduciary obligations that you have providing advice to
- 22:08pensions because of and specifically with regard to the
- 22:12the mandates that those pensions have to take care of people's
- 22:15retirement money. And that combination is kind of
- 22:23unusual I think in the Bitcoin space.
- 22:24There's a lot of people who are in similar roles that we've yet
- 22:29to really see find Bitcoin. But you know maybe whatever
- 22:33circumstances it was that you guys in particular had that
- 22:36allowed that combination of three things to line up just
- 22:39right to to see it, to get it. And and I think to solve such a
- 22:44big problem in, in, in pensions of you want to have that sound
- 22:49money safety but you don't want to set aside a huge portion of
- 22:54the portfolio to provide that protection because because Glenn
- 22:58you're right with with gold you'd have to if you want to
- 23:00protect the portfolio. You got to have like 50% of the
- 23:03portfolio in this in this asset that's going to generate, you
- 23:06know, no real return versus 2, three, 4% in an asset that can
- 23:12provide the same function of protecting in you know, in terms
- 23:16of the sound money properties that it delivers.
- 23:19Because of the growth in this early stage in the NASCAR of
- 23:22monetization phase that that it also comes with.
- 23:27And you know that insight I think comes from the combination
- 23:31of those three lenses that you guys are bringing to the table
- 23:34and that every other pension, every, every pension allocator,
- 23:39every pension consultant sits in the same role and has yet to
- 23:45like really put together those dots.
- 23:48But I think that you know we're going to see a greater trend of
- 23:50that because once you once you really understand Bitcoin and
- 23:54that's the first principle heavy lifting that has to happen
- 23:57first, then the conclusion is this that like if you want you
- 24:02know it's the most attractive thing to include in any
- 24:05portfolio if you have the right position sizing and that's just
- 24:10two, three, 4%. Hence, so I think the built oh,
- 24:16sorry, Sam. I think there's something else
- 24:19that's needed as well as those three things you mentioned,
- 24:22which I agree with all those 3. It's willingness to think
- 24:27outside the box or if I put it another way, the willingness to
- 24:31see outside the bubble. I think we look across our
- 24:37industry in the UK and look at the actual profession and all
- 24:42that kind of stuff. And they're doing lots of hard
- 24:46work in lots of areas and some of it's quite useful, but it's
- 24:50within a bubble. It's and you need to get outside
- 24:54of that bubble and you see the bubble for what it is.
- 24:57I suppose another way to describe would be a Fiat bubble
- 25:00and all the things that go along with that that I'm sure you
- 25:03talked about before. You've got to step outside and
- 25:08see it for what it is and then realize that it's fine for that
- 25:12to be 98% of a portfolio, but you also need something outside
- 25:17of that bubble as well. And that's what gives you that
- 25:21diversification. Being out, having something, the
- 25:24exact potentially it almost doesn't matter, but having
- 25:26something outside the bubble. And to build on this line of
- 25:32thinking, I think I have a three-part, I do have a
- 25:34three-part question. How do we settle on this
- 25:39particular allocation, 2 to 4 to 5%, whatever it may be?
- 25:43What sliver of a portfolio allocation does it fall under?
- 25:48What bucket does it fall into? Then three, at which point do
- 25:52you think it becomes abundantly clear to everybody that this is
- 25:57the strategy that needs to be employed, Some sort of
- 26:01allocation towards Bitcoin? Maybe it's not even a decision
- 26:06that's made willingly. Maybe it's forced upon market
- 26:09actors via benchmark or something like that.
- 26:14So I mean it, it really depends on the type of client.
- 26:17So if it's a corporate treasury, if it's a pension scheme, if
- 26:22it's a charity, if it's a funeral trust, it depends where
- 26:25they are in the investment journey.
- 26:28Are they, do they have a short horizon?
- 26:30Do they have a much longer horizon?
- 26:34But initially, it's kind of like the first thing that you
- 26:38normally come across when you approach a client and you say,
- 26:41hey, I want to talk to you about this thing called Bitcoin, is
- 26:44that like, isn't it too volatile, right.
- 26:49So when you're thinking about the percentage you should put in
- 26:52a portfolio, you're thinking how much can I put in this thing
- 26:57without there being any sort of perceptible effect on the
- 27:03overall volatility of the portfolio, right.
- 27:06And what you find is you can kind of done do rolling sort of
- 27:144-5 year periods where you kind of put 2% in you back testing,
- 27:20right. And you're saying what I've
- 27:22noticed the volatility both from a kind of a standard deviation
- 27:28or normal volatility portfolio or from a maximum drawdown kind
- 27:33of perspective in the overall portfolio.
- 27:36And if you put 2IN, you, you can't, you can't even feel it,
- 27:41right? You can't see it.
- 27:42You can't feel it. It's like, you know, why
- 27:46wouldn't I do this, right? You put 3IN, it's kind of like
- 27:52again, not persist. Once you start getting to five
- 27:56right, then 'cause you know, you find that, like, so for example
- 28:02in March 2020 when they locked us all in our houses, right?
- 28:07They, you know, everything becomes correlated, even
- 28:13Bitcoin, right? So but bitcoins draw downs are
- 28:17like you know, 6070%, right? So if you got 5% in a portfolio,
- 28:25it's about, you know, it makes about 35 basis points difference
- 28:29to the draw down, something like that.
- 28:33If you put like, no, what? Sorry, what?
- 28:36No, it's about 3 1/2 percent of the drawdown if if you've got 5%
- 28:42in a portfolio, right, so that you start to kind of notice,
- 28:45whereas 2 percent, 1% extra drawdown takes no longer for the
- 28:50portfolio to recover to its previous high.
- 28:53It kind of feels like that point where you can kind of, you know,
- 29:00everybody stays calm. You know what I mean?
- 29:02You don't want people like if there's you when you're
- 29:06introducing an entirely new asset, an entirely new concept,
- 29:10all of these ideas and whatever you want it to be at a level
- 29:14where everybody's like, you know, I mean 2% is sort of like
- 29:19the allocation that a bank stock might have in a portfolio,
- 29:23right? Just one stock.
- 29:25So it's kind of like easy to introduce somebody at that kind
- 29:31of level, whereas if you stop talking about higher
- 29:33allocations, it's a more complicated conversation and you
- 29:38just want to kind of get people off 0 rather than asking them to
- 29:43do a lot more than that. I mean, this may be sacrilegious
- 29:46for this show, but the right allocation for some pension
- 29:48schemes is zero, yeah. And I think ultimately it comes
- 29:54down to normally it comes down to time horizon.
- 29:57So if they they're different types of pension schemes, you
- 30:01know you got DB and DC over in the states as well as you know
- 30:05we've got the same over here. So DB actually once it gets well
- 30:11funded enough, a final salary scheme or a defined benefit
- 30:15scheme, you can pass a whole lot over to an insurer.
- 30:17So actually your time horizon to invest is until you can afford
- 30:22to pass it to an insurer and for some schemes that might be, you
- 30:26know, might be 6 months. So actually they won't even have
- 30:30any, particularly with the rise in bond yields generally that
- 30:36has actually improved the funding position of a lot of fun
- 30:39and salary pension schemes. So a lot of them are in a good
- 30:42position that actually they just want to lock down as much risk.
- 30:45They shouldn't be having equities, they shouldn't be
- 30:47having any growth, Which to your question Marty, that's where it
- 30:50fits if in the growth allocation for fun and salary schemes.
- 30:56And so you just want to move them across to insurance and low
- 31:00risk. And all you're trying to do
- 31:02though is make sure people get the pensions they've been
- 31:04promised. You're not looking to do
- 31:06anything fancier than that in a secure way as possible.
- 31:10However, there were other schemes where they might have
- 31:1310/15/20 years to go, in which case then they do have some
- 31:19equities, they do have a growth portfolio, in which case then
- 31:24some kind of allocation to Bitcoin within.
- 31:26That makes sense and I think that's probably the, that's the
- 31:31category where it's, it's, it makes sense to get off 0.
- 31:35That, that that's really, that's really interesting that two very
- 31:39notable things you include there that what the conclusion that
- 31:43you guys have come to is that this fits in the growth category
- 31:47of any portfolio. And and I think I certainly fall
- 31:51into this this reflex I guess at this point of oh it's you know
- 31:57it's a sound money asset, it's a scarce asset, it's a hard money
- 32:01asset. It it's its own thing really
- 32:04it's a 6040 zero like that zero should be higher.
- 32:08You know you have your your equities, your bonds, your hard
- 32:12money and everybody overlooks that category.
- 32:16It should be its own thing but you guys are cleverly putting it
- 32:19in a growth category. So you're thinking about it as a
- 32:24replacement for like a growth company stock and and that's
- 32:29very notable and informative for anybody who who's trying to
- 32:34think about how to justify where to include Bitcoin in their
- 32:38portfolio. And then the other thing that
- 32:40that I want to follow up on is so makes sense that you know six
- 32:45month timeline, six month horizon pension scheme, Bitcoin
- 32:50doesn't make sense. It's it's too volatile the the
- 32:52possibility of like a March 2020 event is non zero and you don't
- 32:57you can't have that 10 years plus there the the growth will
- 33:02bear out. You know if the thesis is right
- 33:04with Bitcoin. Where do you draw that line
- 33:06though? Is it?
- 33:06Do you? Do you, you know, subscribe to
- 33:11OK for your cycle Is what you need to live through or is it
- 33:16different in your minds? So we've said the minimum is 4
- 33:20years, right? So that, but obviously if it's
- 33:25longer, it's better. Ideally you'd want longer than
- 33:29eight years, so two cycles, right?
- 33:32But but four years at a minimum, I suppose it would also depend
- 33:37on where you started, right? So if we have a massive bull run
- 33:42now in the next 18 months, which is kind of what I guess we're
- 33:46all hoping and expecting, that's you know if then a client came
- 33:55to us then we'd probably dollar cost average in and we'd
- 34:02probably kind of do that you know put in.
- 34:07You know we would space the, the the kind of entries wider rather
- 34:13than kind of doing them quite quickly.
- 34:18And if it's going to take like 2 years to get them in and they've
- 34:21only got 4 years total horizon then it kind of doesn't make
- 34:25sense, right. So then you need a little bit of
- 34:28a longer horizon because definitely I mean I think it's,
- 34:34you know, it's we we talk a lot about investor behavior and
- 34:39psychology and stuff. And with an acid like this, it's
- 34:44definitely going to bring out the greed, right.
- 34:47So we're going to have that blow off top at some point and then
- 34:52it's going to you know crash to you know a level which is much
- 34:58higher than the last time it crashed, right.
- 35:00But nevertheless, if you get in at the top, it's not going to
- 35:05feel good and it's not going to be good for the portfolio.
- 35:09So I think you, you know, like now and we've even kind of said
- 35:15this in our communications to our clients, it's ideal.
- 35:19Nobody knows what the future holds, right.
- 35:21But it's ideal if you really like an asset and it's had a bit
- 35:25of a tough time, that's the time to kind of make an allocation.
- 35:30Not kind of. When everybody's going,
- 35:33everybody and their dogs saying I've got to get some Bitcoin,
- 35:37right, then it's probably the time to say OK, well, it's kind
- 35:41of, you know, get in, but very kind of gradually and slowly.
- 35:46We might be getting too much into the into the nuances
- 35:50possibly but I think it's it's not just what you think the time
- 35:55horizon will be. It's also how certain can you be
- 35:59that it will be at least say four years or or whatever number
- 36:02you pick. So there are, you know if you've
- 36:06got a a defined benefit scheme that's that's taking lots of
- 36:10investment risk. You think the time horizon is 10
- 36:14years, but actually you turn around 5 minutes later and
- 36:18equity markets have done really well and bond yields have shot
- 36:22up and they're, they're fully funded.
- 36:24They can go to the insurance market straight away or they're
- 36:27close and that the company suddenly has some cash and
- 36:30throws it in and and then you can go to the insurance.
- 36:33So if you've got these kind of uncertainties around the DB
- 36:36scheme, then it then creates uncertainty about the time.
- 36:40So it takes a lot of thought to make sure that it's right for
- 36:45each particular scheme and that's DB schemes in particular.
- 36:49And then there were other types of scheme as well where I think
- 36:51it also gets quite interesting and I think comes back to your
- 36:55point about sound money. So if we move to like define,
- 37:01define contribution, we call them over here or money
- 37:03purchase. So the company and the employee
- 37:08throw some money in a pot and the pension is whatever it buys
- 37:11whenever that member retires. In that scenario, a small
- 37:17allocation can make a lot of sense and in fact often they're
- 37:21not buying and annuity at retirement, they're continuing
- 37:24to invest it. So actually the time horizon
- 37:25could be not just the 20 years until they get to retirement,
- 37:30but maybe another 2025, thirty years after then.
- 37:34So we're talking about a really long time horizon there.
- 37:38Yeah, that's actually important part because you're referencing
- 37:42the the time horizon and whether it's explicit or implicit
- 37:45because you guys fundamentally understand what's happening.
- 37:47I feel like you're educating beyond any time horizon and and
- 37:51wanting them to think much longer than whatever is on their
- 37:53benchmark. Be curious like how you guys try
- 37:56to navigate that because historically like institutions
- 37:59have been effectively exit liquidity for the system, right.
- 38:01They see it running and then that's when they get in and then
- 38:04they're burned and they're like what did I do?
- 38:06And so that has to be at the, you know in the back of your
- 38:08mind as you guys have been educated and be curious how have
- 38:11you thought about that and try to get in the under the
- 38:14underside of something we think about a lot at on ramp.
- 38:18It's about these institutions are made-up of individuals and
- 38:22so it took you going through O eight took Glenn having his
- 38:25background we'll maybe save that one for for beers.
- 38:27I don't know if we need to discuss publicly how he got to
- 38:30be the way he is, but but this idea of it starts at an
- 38:35individual and it feels like as much as it's talking to the
- 38:38pension, it's also the individuals that are there and
- 38:40helping them see it. Anything you guys can share
- 38:42there I think is is helpful because there's a lot of people
- 38:45that listen that are having these conversations across the
- 38:48board, whether it's family members, their treasury and
- 38:51institutions, and they're all trying to figure out what is the
- 38:53right and there's no silver bullet, but you guys are
- 38:55navigating this in real time. So anything you can share there
- 38:59would be nice. Yeah.
- 39:01Sure. I mean, so it's always
- 39:03interesting, right? Because there's that moment
- 39:06where you say, OK, Bitcoin could be right for this client and now
- 39:10you've got to contact them and it's usually an e-mail, right?
- 39:17So you've got to kind of, you know, in this e-mail, say them,
- 39:22I want to talk to you about Bitcoin, right.
- 39:25And I've been pleasantly surprised, right?
- 39:30Because you, I would say 9 times out of 10, they're like, OK,
- 39:35let's have this conversation. You know, I think maybe maybe
- 39:40what it is, is that, like, intrigued, interested, you know,
- 39:45just curious. Want to learn more, right.
- 39:49There have been instances, like with the head of corporate
- 39:54treasury, where we contacted him and he sent us back a chart of
- 39:59Bitcoin. And said look at this thing,
- 40:02it's so volatile or whatever. So then we send them one with a
- 40:06logarithmic price axis saying actually you should think of
- 40:11this as like something in the adoption phase and that like you
- 40:17know, you want to look at percentage changes in the price
- 40:20and you can see in that logarithmic kind of price curve
- 40:24how it's slowly being adopted over time.
- 40:29And then he came back and he was like we don't want anything that
- 40:34isn't backed by anything or something like this, right?
- 40:37And so you don't always win, but nine times out of 10, they're
- 40:42willing to have the conversation right?
- 40:44Well, the important thing there is that he didn't just ignore
- 40:46your e-mail, he came back with questions.
- 40:48So I think that's where a lot of people are at.
- 40:52You know everyone goes to their own journey and learning about
- 40:55this and sometimes that'll be what do you mean it still hasn't
- 41:00died yet and that will that will get their interest.
- 41:06So it's it is quite interesting how different people will take
- 41:11different boots in there and I think whilst we're in the
- 41:13monetization stage, which I mean could be who knows, I mean a
- 41:19couple of decades maybe, could easily be, yeah but equally no
- 41:23one knows. So things could happen.
- 41:26Actually, I find quite interesting the, the impact
- 41:32something else can have on itself sort of in a circular
- 41:36way. So actually it might speed up
- 41:40the adoption of Bitcoin because it exists.
- 41:42I know that sounds a little bit circular, but that's sort of the
- 41:44point in that because there is an exit route, it means that
- 41:47people run faster towards it, which then leads more quickly to
- 41:51the collapse of the existing system into Bitcoin.
- 41:54So I've seen some people say we could take 3 generations and
- 41:59that's to do and it makes sense. It's about people, it's a
- 42:04psychological way that people think about these things and are
- 42:08they used to it and so on. But I suppose, yeah, I'd like to
- 42:15be alive for the end of it. So it's some ways quicker the
- 42:20better. I was thinking about the point
- 42:24Sam's making, about maybe happening, you know, like, like
- 42:29Parker, Lewis says. Gradually.
- 42:30Then suddenly. Right, right, right.
- 42:32You remember when it was like March last year when all the
- 42:39banks were kind of in trouble and Credit Suisse basically went
- 42:45to the wall. And I remember, I can't remember
- 42:50if it was on this podcast or one of the other ones, Marty, where
- 42:54you showed that chart where the bank stocks all like going down
- 42:59and then at exactly the same time Bitcoin going up, right.
- 43:03And we've been looking at like setting up corporate treasures
- 43:11with access to Bitcoin and actually having software to kind
- 43:16of plug into the normal corporate treasury systems and
- 43:19stuff. And the company that we're
- 43:21talking to, who's got the technology to do all of this
- 43:24stuff, like kind of told me without mentioning names,
- 43:28they've already got like companies with more than a
- 43:31billion pounds in Bitcoin, right.
- 43:34And so, like, I was thinking when that stuff was going down,
- 43:37like, imagine you're a big company and you've got like a
- 43:40few million in cash in the bank, right?
- 43:43How? How do you get it out when you
- 43:47know the proverbials hitting the fan?
- 43:49What do you do? Like go and say please give me,
- 43:52like, you know, big, you know, I don't know, briefcases or
- 43:58something full of cash? I want to get it out of the
- 44:01system because I'm afraid, right?
- 44:04But with these kinds of systems, you can just say, just buy
- 44:10Bitcoin with it and now you're entirely outside the financial
- 44:14system, right? There's no way that anybody can
- 44:18debase it. No one can.
- 44:20There's no con outside the bubble, outside the bubble,
- 44:22right? And so I wondered if that is
- 44:26what caused because there was also this VC.
- 44:31Silicon Valley Bank. Yeah, and he put out this note
- 44:34to all his investing companies, say, yeah, like you know, buy
- 44:39some Bitcoin for for situations like this so you can still make
- 44:44payroll. So I think so that's one of the
- 44:47things that quite interests me is this sort of escape route
- 44:50idea. So by and suppose you know, so
- 44:55in corporate treasuries for example, if they've got a small
- 44:58amount in but they've got the infrastructure set up to then
- 45:01make a quick allocation if they need to.
- 45:03If they start from scratch, you know it's not going to be 5
- 45:07minutes to to get their money out of the banking system or or
- 45:09some of it or you know just to reduce their reliance on certain
- 45:13banks or whatever it might be. So that escape route for
- 45:16corporates I think will be really important going forwards
- 45:20escape route for individuals. So in particular you know we're
- 45:22so we're investment advisors and employee benefit specialists.
- 45:26So we can, you know there's loads of interesting things
- 45:28going out there but we can only focus on what we're we can do
- 45:31what our skill set is. So on employee benefits, the
- 45:36what we're trying to set up is a Bitcoin employee benefit system
- 45:42or you know, ability to do that. And one of the reasons I like
- 45:47that is because it gives individuals an escape route.
- 45:52It also, you know if you've got no exposure to something, you've
- 45:56got limited interest in learning more.
- 45:58If you've got, even if it's only £100, a $100, whatever, you
- 46:03suddenly you're interested in it, disproportionately so, but
- 46:06you're more interested in it and therefore you'll see the
- 46:08headlines, you'll read more reports, you'll maybe read your
- 46:11book. Yeah.
- 46:13One thing just to anchor like this is common practice from
- 46:16business continuity. When that that Silicon Valley
- 46:21Bank I was with Marty that weekend when it was happening, I
- 46:23remember vividly thinking about like, holy crap, like they have
- 46:26to, they have to figure this out by Sunday because it was just
- 46:29going to be anarchy on Monday and they did that Sunday night.
- 46:33But it's this idea of like you gave enough people the time to
- 46:36think about what if I don't make payroll?
- 46:39Like what? What are all those things?
- 46:40It's almost negligent not to have some capital outside and
- 46:45everybody has their own balance sheet whether it's an individual
- 46:48or a business. And so to have those rails, even
- 46:50if it's a river account in the US or a coin corner account in
- 46:54the UK and maybe start playing around like you're like you're
- 46:56referencing. It's like this isn't a
- 46:58conspiracy that the banks just like have not given people their
- 47:01money. It's it's true they they shut
- 47:02them down. It's not a, it's no question
- 47:04about it. And so to not question or think
- 47:06about what is your options, whether it's a pension or an
- 47:08individual, it's almost just like you know, at your own risk
- 47:11at this point. We are seeing live the flipping
- 47:16of the previous view, which was I don't go anywhere near
- 47:19Bitcoin. It's too volatile, I've got
- 47:22fiduciary duty, I'm looking after other people's money.
- 47:24It feels like gambling and we're sort of in the process in the
- 47:28middle of flipping to a situation where it is actually
- 47:31irresponsible not to consider it.
- 47:34And I well, the quicker that spreads the the better I think
- 47:39because you know we want to protect our clients as best we
- 47:42can from these risks and they're, you know, they're big
- 47:45risks out there. We.
- 47:46We we we were talking to trustees of a funeral trust and
- 47:53what happened was they got into this sort of quite tech heavy
- 47:59equity fund at the end of 2021. It was kind of like the
- 48:02beginning of the investment journey, right?
- 48:04To peak. Yeah.
- 48:06And then they they, it literally like crashed like 40% on them,
- 48:11right. And then they're like kind of
- 48:13lay trustees. They're not like investment
- 48:16even, you know, investment savvy.
- 48:18So they were like like this is too much.
- 48:21Peloton peloton's like peak 2021.
- 48:23Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then they were like, OK, we
- 48:27want our money back. So they took it out, right?
- 48:29And then they put it in the bank.
- 48:32And which bank did they choose? Metro Bank and Metro Bank ran
- 48:37into trouble and had to get recapitalized, right?
- 48:41But there were a few days there where the money was in the bank
- 48:44and they didn't know if the bank was going to be OK.
- 48:48So that was kind of like their experience was.
- 48:52They took the 40% haircut and then they might have taken the
- 48:54rest of it if they didn't fulfill them.
- 48:56And it's like a whole Fiat adventure, right?
- 48:59Because you, like, put interest rates at 0 prints.
- 49:04A whole lot of money. Hand it all out, right?
- 49:08All these techs growth stocks goes through the roof, right?
- 49:12Then inflation roars, Then you raise interest rates, then they
- 49:16all come crashing down again, right?
- 49:18Then you have all these banking crises and whatever.
- 49:21It can be more obvious that you need something like Bitcoin.
- 49:24Glen, you got to be careful. You're going to get Marty all
- 49:26riled up. I'm thinking because I'm
- 49:30thinking, I'm thinking back to last March when this was all
- 49:33happening, we had a number of companies in our portfolio 10/31
- 49:37that were exposed. I mean the Bitcoin industry as a
- 49:41whole was probably the most exposed because of the lack of
- 49:44access to banking relationships and banking relationships that
- 49:48did exist. The the banks that failed at
- 49:51Silvergate Signature, Silicon Valley Bank, First Republic like
- 49:55those were top three banks, the 1st 3 for for the industry.
- 49:59And so people were moving quickly and a lot of them were
- 50:02buying Bitcoin and putting it in something like an Unchained
- 50:05vault or holding it on river. And I think it's important to
- 50:09highlight here too like yes you eliminate that third party risk
- 50:13as well. But diving back into like the
- 50:15long term strategy, there's also it's an exit from this third
- 50:19party risk. But if Bitcoin does what we what
- 50:22we think it's going to do, particularly in the context of
- 50:25something like a venture backed company, it could extend your
- 50:28runway into the future. So you start by allocating the
- 50:33Bitcoin to eliminate that third party banking risk that exists.
- 50:36You hold Bitcoin on your balance sheet and then the price runs
- 50:40and you wake up for eight years from now and like holy crap my
- 50:44balance sheet is 5X or the the Bitcoin portion my balance sheet
- 50:49is 10X which has allowed me to have significantly more runway
- 50:53and you can apply this to a pension or any type of fund for
- 50:56that matter in the future. Yeah, it goes from being defense
- 51:00to offense really quick. Yeah you get yeah you you get a
- 51:08lot when when you buy Bitcoin. You're not you're not just
- 51:11getting gold you're you're getting gold plus growth plus
- 51:17you know something that sits outside of the bubble outside of
- 51:20the system and and benefits in in the event that there's
- 51:23trouble in the system and you know and plus you're getting the
- 51:28you know you're buying a a stake in the Internet of value in the
- 51:32early days of the second part of the digital revolution in my
- 51:35opinion to complement the Internet of information that we
- 51:38already have and assume is is everything but it's actually
- 51:40half the story. There's so many things that you
- 51:43get when you make an allocation to Bitcoin and I think that's
- 51:47part of like when you guys are running through your actuarial
- 51:50tables and seeing like, you know, what if this is 2 to 5%?
- 51:55Not only is the volatility acceptable, but you get all this
- 51:59incredible performance out of it too.
- 52:01It becomes something that so long as your time horizon is
- 52:05long enough, it becomes a bit of a no brainer really.
- 52:10If not a no brainer, then at least a hugely asymmetric upside
- 52:15bet. Yeah.
- 52:16And what are we trying to achieve for our clients?
- 52:18We're trying to maximize the return for the same amount of
- 52:22risk or we're trying to have the same return and reduce the risk.
- 52:26You want assets with this kind of risk profile, not all, but
- 52:31you want a bit and that's exactly what we're talking
- 52:34about. Thanks for tuning in.
- 52:36If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 52:38further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 52:42a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 52:45our team at onrampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 52:49you on your Bitcoin journey. But Glenn, I don't invest in
- 52:53crypto. I don't invest in crypto.
- 52:56What do you guys say to that? Cuz that, obviously.
- 52:59Neither do we. Yeah, we don't either.
- 53:03Yeah, is I would imagine that's the response but can you expand
- 53:06on that because that's something we obviously get a lot when
- 53:08we're we're doing outreach we're having discussions is I don't
- 53:11invest in crypto and and. So right up front, whenever I
- 53:15talk to people, I say everything I'm going to be saying today is
- 53:21not about cryptocurrency, right? It's we.
- 53:26We need to make a distinction right up front so that you don't
- 53:29make the mistake of me talking to you about this asset and you
- 53:33going away and thinking I was talking to you about
- 53:36cryptocurrency, right. I was not talking to you about
- 53:39cryptocurrency right? I told them if you hear any of
- 53:44these terms NFT, Web 3, blockchain, crypto, right.
- 53:51I'm not talking about those things, and I suggest very
- 53:55strongly that you stay away from them because at best their
- 54:01sortof.com companies if you want to be generous and you know kind
- 54:07about them. But in reality, the very vast
- 54:12majority, if not all of them are scams or there's some kind of
- 54:23way that the banking system or whatever is going to kind of
- 54:29Co-op them and they you're just going to have the same thing
- 54:32over again. Right?
- 54:34With block chain, private block chains or whatever where they
- 54:39essentially like, Oh no, it's all safe because it's a digital
- 54:43Ledger and whatever. But there's only like 3 nodes on
- 54:47this Ledger, and when they get into trouble and they need to
- 54:51bail the system out, they'll just create a whole lot more
- 54:54digital tokens, you know? So I try and kind of separate.
- 55:02And then three hours later, we start the presentation.
- 55:07Yeah, yeah, but but, you know, it's it's like kind of making it
- 55:11clear that like there's always like to say to people that all
- 55:17of this other stuff is just people copying Bitcoin.
- 55:21That's all they did. Like, right?
- 55:23And then and so the only real thing here is Bitcoin, right?
- 55:31Yeah, and if if you view Bitcoin as far out on the risk curve
- 55:34already, just by looking at just a pure market cap comparison,
- 55:39you'd have to be even crazier to allocate to broader crypto.
- 55:44It's way further out on on the risk curve compared to it.
- 55:48Actually helps, actually helps Marty.
- 55:50It helps that our clients are more cautious as they should be
- 55:55because they're looking after other people's money because
- 55:57then it's you've got OK, crypto currencies and then you've got
- 56:02the one which is the well, I mean obviously they're ones that
- 56:06came before it sort of known as the first, isn't it, but there
- 56:09were ones that came before that. But it's the one that that works
- 56:13and has the press and the network affection all the rest
- 56:15of it. So if you combine that and then
- 56:19we can help them through the sort of what is money angle and
- 56:24then it's really, well, it's the perfect money as long as it
- 56:31doesn't get killed. So it's all about so it's like
- 56:36the perfect asset for someone to do it.
- 56:39OK, you got to assess what are the chances of it getting killed
- 56:44and if you get comfortable with that, I haven't found anything
- 56:49convincing myself yet, then it doesn't matter, nothing else
- 56:54matters. So that makes it a bit easier.
- 57:00Yeah in in that sense it's it's the perfect asset for for
- 57:03everyone to be holding in in pensions in particular.
- 57:06Sam, you touched earlier on on how I think this that my
- 57:12understanding of it is is correct that for defined
- 57:15contribution plans schemes it it can be a little bit easier to
- 57:20justify this type of asset versus defined benefit plans.
- 57:25And to me it's it's it's almost a shame because I I don't know
- 57:29if it's, I assume it's the same in the UK that here in the US we
- 57:34have a lot of underfunded defined benefit plans and the
- 57:41the US government in particular has a huge burden of of unfunded
- 57:46liabilities into the future. And from my perspective, I don't
- 57:51see any asset that helps close that gap except for Bitcoin.
- 57:55You know, and I think that that Bitcoin could be the only thing
- 57:59that saves a lot of these under underfunded defined benefit
- 58:05plans if they can wake up to it fast enough and see the value
- 58:09proposition, which most of them won't, but you know that the
- 58:12opportunity is there for for those who can.
- 58:16Any any thoughts on that? I think you're right.
- 58:18I mean, I think the underfunded schemes by their very nature
- 58:23will tend to have a long time horizon because you expect it to
- 58:26take a long time to pick up the returns from equities or or
- 58:30whatever the growth assets you've got.
- 58:32So they would naturally fall into that category of having a
- 58:36long time horizon and therefore should naturally fall into the
- 58:38category of a small Bitcoin allocation makes a lot of sense.
- 58:43So I'd hope that a lot of them take up on that because we are,
- 58:50you know we are going from A1 era to another era I think for
- 58:57lots of different reasons. But one of those areas is moving
- 59:00and we have been doing it for the last 10-15 years or so is
- 59:05moving away from the defined benefit provision, pension
- 59:09provision. Certainly Uki don't know enough
- 59:11about the US, and in some ways that's quite sad because that
- 59:19industry provides a huge amount of certainty and benefits to a
- 59:24lot of people. It is not perfect by long shots
- 59:31and you're relying on sort of a lot of investment complexity to
- 59:36try and beat your bond returns, beat your inflation to provide
- 59:42those benefits. But then that's where Bitcoin
- 59:45slots neatly in. There's been a move to the money
- 59:50purchase again over a similar sort of period as employers stop
- 59:54providing DB and they start providing DC and that is a
- 1:00:01natural step, I think a flawed step, but I think a natural step
- 1:00:06because it's the company saying I can't take this risk anymore,
- 1:00:10I need to pass it on to the employees.
- 1:00:12The trouble then is the employees are taking on the
- 1:00:14responsibility of investing. So I like there's in fact I
- 1:00:20think there's a video with you sitting next to him.
- 1:00:22Marty, there's a great, I think he said it a few times safer,
- 1:00:25Dean has said, talked about how not having a proper savings, he
- 1:00:31says he's much better than me, by the way.
- 1:00:33But but it's along the lines of, you know, by not having a proper
- 1:00:39savings vehicle, it forces people to invest.
- 1:00:42I think it also forces people to spend because they don't know
- 1:00:44what else to do with their money.
- 1:00:48And people are then trying to understand stuff, which I mean,
- 1:00:55it's very, very complicated. It's complicated for a lot of
- 1:00:58investment professionals and the whole idea of you go to work,
- 1:01:01you do your job as a doctor or teacher or whatever it is, and
- 1:01:04then you've got to come home and you've got to be an investment
- 1:01:07professional in the evenings just to retain the money that
- 1:01:10you've earned. It is ridiculous.
- 1:01:14And that was, I guess there's a few things that I suppose really
- 1:01:18struck me. So I mentioned the bubble.
- 1:01:20I suppose I was thinking of Jeff Booth when I was thinking about
- 1:01:23that and say for Dean saying that about the investing and
- 1:01:29savings and having effectively you need to have two jobs to
- 1:01:33keep the money you earned. And I think that ultimately the
- 1:01:38truth will out. So if markets can be distorted
- 1:01:40for a long time, and I'm not just talking financial markets
- 1:01:44here, I'm talking about pension provision, markets can be
- 1:01:47distorted for a long time, but eventually the truth will out.
- 1:01:51And the truth is that if you've got an asset that is the perfect
- 1:01:57money and doesn't die, it's and particularly once we get to the
- 1:02:02second stage which is you know, just roughly obviously it's not
- 1:02:07perfect nothing, life is perfect of course it essentially tracks
- 1:02:12economic growth then that is like the perfect asset to have
- 1:02:19in a world of uncertainty that we all live in and we're never
- 1:02:22going to get away with that is life.
- 1:02:26So I can, I can see, you know we could be many decades away from
- 1:02:28that. But I can see a scenario where
- 1:02:31the truth comes out through you know of DB and DC and and some
- 1:02:35of the hybrids that have been created which are even more
- 1:02:38complicated than either DB or DC to try and mitigate some of the
- 1:02:41risk. And then you end up in a
- 1:02:42position where actually most employees they want to go to
- 1:02:46work. They want to just focus on doing
- 1:02:48a really good job. They want to take their salary
- 1:02:52and maybe some of that is in Bitcoin, maybe some of it is in
- 1:02:55the local currency. What, whatever, you know, that
- 1:02:58will depend on the situation at the time and that it could
- 1:03:03easily be where we'll end up. Now, there's a huge amount of
- 1:03:04vested interest to get through before we get to that stage
- 1:03:08because you don't need a lot of investment advice to be able to
- 1:03:14do that. But you know, as I say,
- 1:03:17ultimately the truth will out, and I'd much prefer to be on the
- 1:03:21right side of history than to try and artificially keep the
- 1:03:27existing system in place or be part of that.
- 1:03:32Yeah. And I, Sam, I think I agree with
- 1:03:35you. I think this is going to happen
- 1:03:36much faster than people imagine because you have all these
- 1:03:40forces at play, whether it's the macroeconomic headwinds that are
- 1:03:45going to just hit markets globally like the the.
- 1:03:49It's becoming abundantly clear that the Fed's rate hiking
- 1:03:54regime may be coming to an end. We had Jerome Powell on 60
- 1:03:57Minutes last night saying it's probably going to happen.
- 1:04:00It's definitely going to happen at some point this year.
- 1:04:03You have the increasing knowledge of Bitcoin and
- 1:04:06understanding of Bitcoin globally, and then you have
- 1:04:09these systemic problems that exist throughout pension
- 1:04:14systems, fund systems, whatever it may be.
- 1:04:17And once the cat's out of the bag, people realize this and
- 1:04:21they start flooding in, there's not going to be any turning
- 1:04:24back. And this gets back to the point
- 1:04:27at which Bitcoin becomes like a benchmark that forces pensions
- 1:04:31to allocate, which forces them to sell positions in other parts
- 1:04:36of their portfolio to buy Bitcoin, which hinders their
- 1:04:40performance, the the, the assets that they're selling.
- 1:04:44And I could see just a crazy feedback loop, sort of virtuous
- 1:04:48cycle to Bitcoin monetization happening rather quickly.
- 1:04:51And then on top of that you have all the social developments in
- 1:04:56terms of people being more aware of inflation than they have in
- 1:05:00in multiple generations. And understanding that the
- 1:05:04institutions that are supposed to have our backs and look after
- 1:05:08us, whether that's the government, the media, big
- 1:05:09pharma, the banking system are are are corrupt at their core.
- 1:05:15And I think there is this incredible culmination of events
- 1:05:18happening to produce an inflection point that sort of
- 1:05:23slingshots Bitcoin to the reserve asset of the world.
- 1:05:27I would say in less than 15 years.
- 1:05:31It's funny because Jesse, you said it's going to take decades.
- 1:05:34We're already a decade and 1/2 into this.
- 1:05:36I think from launch to reserve asset would take like 30 years,
- 1:05:41one generation that would be 15 years from now.
- 1:05:44And and Sam said three generations, which is also
- 1:05:46possible. I mean, anything in that range
- 1:05:49would be incredible. I mean, one thing to add though
- 1:05:54Sam alluded to is this idea of that you reference safe about
- 1:06:00people don't have a good form of money, so their habits.
- 1:06:02And that's like, that's the scary part and the pervasive
- 1:06:05part of it. It may take longer because
- 1:06:07that's like a psychological thing and the way it manifests
- 1:06:09now is you need your yield. So like getting somebody into
- 1:06:13bitcoins only like half the journey, right, Maybe a little
- 1:06:15more. But then there's this idea of
- 1:06:17like the the Bitcoin is the yield.
- 1:06:19You don't need to do anything with it.
- 1:06:20And we know how many people in 2022, in 2021 don't have any
- 1:06:25Bitcoin anymore. And that's gonna be a long,
- 1:06:27that's already a distant memory. So the next cycle we're gonna
- 1:06:30see, I think if we all probably agree, we're gonna see the
- 1:06:34animal spirits again. And so this idea is that it's an
- 1:06:38asset, but you're a sucker if you don't do something with the
- 1:06:41asset. And that's the concern of does
- 1:06:43it happen that fast Because there's an education that goes
- 1:06:46in and the thing that it's really like, it's kind of the
- 1:06:49annoying part of all this. And Sam, you alluded to, it's
- 1:06:51like this reality of getting to the other side of like you just
- 1:06:54do what you were supposed to do, whatever it is that you were
- 1:06:57given from a like skills perspective and the money just
- 1:06:59protects you from it is a is a very like long thing to pick up.
- 1:07:04And so most people like what do I do with it, what I got to go
- 1:07:07out, I got to trade it, even the even even Bitcoin like the
- 1:07:10whatever appreciation year over year.
- 1:07:12And so that's the kind of part that I don't know if it happens
- 1:07:14as fast as we want it to because it's still a psychological thing
- 1:07:18that you just like hold it. You don't go and do something
- 1:07:20else with it, cuz that's what, that's where you end up losing
- 1:07:23the asset. I think it's what it is, is it's
- 1:07:28not so much about Bitcoin, it's about the rest of the system.
- 1:07:31So, like, so in the UK we had like in the way the government
- 1:07:39likes to measure inflation 13%. I don't know if you guys have
- 1:07:44seen this website true inflation where they kind of like create
- 1:07:48their own inflation baskets, right.
- 1:07:51And they call it 20%. Actually there's no real
- 1:07:54inflation rate because it depends what you put in the
- 1:07:56basket, right. So it's different for everyone,
- 1:07:59but but The thing is everybody felt it in the US here, right?
- 1:08:06And so when those kinds of big systemic things happen, right,
- 1:08:13and everybody's like, hang on, what the Hell's going on here?
- 1:08:17That's what I think more of that can make it make the Bitcoin
- 1:08:23adoption happen faster, right? Whereas if they're just stealing
- 1:08:28kind of 2% or 3% a year, then it's going to take longer, you
- 1:08:33know, and I also think that because of the four year cycles,
- 1:08:38you're going to have these kind of waves of adoption, right?
- 1:08:42So I, you know, like with each new cycle you'll have like the
- 1:08:47people that kind of FOMO in at the top, right?
- 1:08:50And then it crashes and you know, half of them more and
- 1:08:55probably 80% of them don't stick around, right.
- 1:08:58But you got kind of the snakes. But I think what can really
- 1:09:02speed it up is if, because I think it is a real, a very real
- 1:09:07possibility like we were at a investment manager, an LDIA
- 1:09:13liability driven investment manager the other day.
- 1:09:16We were talking, we were getting, they were talking to
- 1:09:19us. And there was this one guy who
- 1:09:21all he does is, well, maybe not all he does, but he just looks
- 1:09:25at like interest rates and inflation rates and swap rates
- 1:09:31and all of this kind of stuff. And he was basically giving us
- 1:09:37his kind of analysis of where the government is and how many
- 1:09:46gilts or or UK government bonds they're going to have to issue.
- 1:09:50And I've seen similar analysis in the US and like the imbalance
- 1:09:56between demand and supply and you know, all of this kind of
- 1:10:01stuff. And I think we could see a huge
- 1:10:04it's kind of a financial crisis in the normal system, you know,
- 1:10:08And then it's sort of like the response to 2008, but this time
- 1:10:13Bitcoin exists and then all of a sudden it sort of bursts into
- 1:10:21the the consciousness of the masses.
- 1:10:24Yeah, we need to be careful there, don't we?
- 1:10:25Because we're not saying that Bitcoin is the reason for the
- 1:10:30existing system to explode or explode.
- 1:10:35It's going to do that anyway. What we're talking about here is
- 1:10:37how can the least number of people be harmed when it does
- 1:10:42blow? And whether it's productive
- 1:10:46companies or whether it's individuals, from a sort of a
- 1:10:52philosophical point of view, I want as many people to be
- 1:10:55unharmed as possible. And and the way to do that is to
- 1:10:58have some exposure to be gone. The way to do that is to have
- 1:11:02gonna escape route to have learned about that escape route.
- 1:11:06And yeah, no one knows the exact timing, but just be ready.
- 1:11:09But actually, so that goes back, let's go pre Bitcoin because
- 1:11:12this goes back to 8. Can you walk through like I
- 1:11:15think and correct me if I'm wrong, you came to this
- 1:11:17realization before Bitcoin about the system and inevitability.
- 1:11:22Can you walk through like I think most of us I mean we're at
- 1:11:26least on the the pod come on regularly.
- 1:11:28We were very young you know to like have a full obviously
- 1:11:32understood something was not right.
- 1:11:33But to know that it was a system that was, you know, born into
- 1:11:37and you're you have to pay taxes and go into, but explain like
- 1:11:40what your realization was in that.
- 1:11:43Yeah, So it was. So it's a realization that there
- 1:11:47was, there was, there was too much debt the way that money was
- 1:11:51created, you know faction was our banking but also from the
- 1:11:55central bank and sort of how that system operates creates
- 1:12:00certain vulnerabilities to the system as a whole, which is why
- 1:12:05we get business cycles and all the rest of it.
- 1:12:07So it was an understanding of that, and I suppose it was sort
- 1:12:15of realization that it didn't seem to be widely realized,
- 1:12:21which is why maybe why the whole system was kept relatively
- 1:12:26together. I suppose it was gold was the
- 1:12:35old obvious escape route in those days, and obviously it was
- 1:12:38fairly well publicized, but even then that didn't get, you know,
- 1:12:42huge inflows. What was the second part of your
- 1:12:48question? I was desperate for two parts.
- 1:12:50You know what it was for me, right?
- 1:12:52Was that it was like so you you're an investment
- 1:12:58professional, right? And back then, so at Carver we
- 1:13:03think very long term strategic. So we're not really thinking
- 1:13:07about tactical asset allocation or anything like that.
- 1:13:11We're thinking you know 20 years or whatever.
- 1:13:14If it's short horizons, well then we're basically not in
- 1:13:17growth, right? We're just matching liabilities.
- 1:13:22But back then I was working and I've worked at a number of
- 1:13:26firms. We were thinking more
- 1:13:27tactically, more kind of short term, right?
- 1:13:31And for me it was the realization that no matter what
- 1:13:34analysis we do, no matter, it's all meaningless because at any
- 1:13:40moment the central bank can just pull out a massive money bazooka
- 1:13:47and make all of our analysis meaningless, right?
- 1:13:50So it was like the right thing was not to be invested in this
- 1:13:55or that or whatever. And then all of a sudden they
- 1:13:57just make us look like idiots because all of a sudden
- 1:14:00everything goes, you know, rocketing up because they've
- 1:14:04just kind of debased the denominator.
- 1:14:09If the whole risk on, risk off depending on what each central
- 1:14:13bank said at that particular moment.
- 1:14:15I mean, it was a little bit silly.
- 1:14:19I mean, what? So I like Marty's optimism, if
- 1:14:23if I can call it that. The 15 years.
- 1:14:26I think the mistake I made in 2008 was that the financial
- 1:14:31system cared at all about what I thought or when I thought it.
- 1:14:38So the mistake I made was that I've just found out all this
- 1:14:41stuff. I thought, Oh my goodness me, I
- 1:14:44didn't realize this, how the system works.
- 1:14:45This is going to fall apart, is it?
- 1:14:47It feels like it should fall apart tomorrow, but of course
- 1:14:51it's clung together for well over 15 years actually.
- 1:14:59So will it cling together for another 15 years?
- 1:15:01So I think I'm a lot more skeptical about my own ability
- 1:15:04to predict timing on these things and hopefully get the
- 1:15:08direction roughly right. I mean, it's also like
- 1:15:12quantitative easing, right? That was kind of the first time
- 1:15:16that I. It's like, what is this thing?
- 1:15:19OK. I've got to figure out what this
- 1:15:20thing is. And then you figure out that
- 1:15:23they just creating money out of thin air and then, you know, and
- 1:15:28then buying. It's like, hang on, like, I
- 1:15:32spent four years at university and then another three becoming
- 1:15:36a chartered Financial analyst. Nobody told me this was going
- 1:15:40on. You know what I mean?
- 1:15:43And then you're like, you start to question everything that
- 1:15:46you've learned, right? You know, and yeah.
- 1:15:50Yeah, in the actual exams, no mention of the Austria economics
- 1:15:54at all. Yeah.
- 1:15:55And and no mention of the money bazooka that that changes
- 1:15:59everything. And and so you guys were living
- 1:16:01through this experience in 2008 of like wait a second, all the
- 1:16:04value investing that's based on like actuarial math and and you
- 1:16:09know actual numbers of like what our future cash flows and what's
- 1:16:12that worth in terms of you know, PE ratios.
- 1:16:16All of that goes out the window. If suddenly there's a money
- 1:16:19bazooka and and risk on, risk off, is all that then matters?
- 1:16:23Is the bazooka turned on? Is it bazooka turned off?
- 1:16:26That becomes all that matters for, for, you know, portfolio
- 1:16:31construction. Well that and that's only one
- 1:16:33facet of the manipulation is the money bazooka, which is a
- 1:16:36massive manipulation. But then like going back to O 8
- 1:16:40like another form of manipulation was rating
- 1:16:42agencies. Like you could make all the
- 1:16:45actuarial analysis that you want to based off the bond rating of
- 1:16:49the commercial backed mortgage or commercial backed securities
- 1:16:53you're buying. But at the end of the day, if
- 1:16:55you have one stakeholder in that flow, essentially lying, which
- 1:17:00the ratings agencies were, just completely borks your models, no
- 1:17:05matter how good of an actuary you are.
- 1:17:08Yeah, good film that The Big Short.
- 1:17:10Yeah, I remember going to an interview at SMV where so I'd I
- 1:17:18started my career as a bond trader and then I worked at a
- 1:17:23investment consulting and investment technology firm,
- 1:17:26American firm called Wilshire Associates.
- 1:17:29And then I wanted to leave there and I started interviewing
- 1:17:34around and one of the places I interviewed was at S&P to rate
- 1:17:39CD OS, right. And then this was before the
- 1:17:432008 financial crisis. And I always remember that
- 1:17:46interview because I would have been one of the guys at S&P
- 1:17:50rating these things full of subprime mortgages, AAA as AAA,
- 1:17:56you know, because we'd like basically kind of had all these
- 1:18:00tranches of and you know, they remember that CDO squared, so
- 1:18:05CDO's that held CDO's and just crazy stuff.
- 1:18:11I mean like how can you not look at all that?
- 1:18:16And you you got into this industry thinking, I'm a clever
- 1:18:20guy. I've learnt all of this really
- 1:18:23important stuff and like now I'm going to, you know, go and add
- 1:18:27value and kind of use my brain and all this knowledge and
- 1:18:31stuff. And then all of this stuff just
- 1:18:33makes a complete mockery of the whole kind of thing because
- 1:18:38basically just buy anything because it's better than having
- 1:18:44the money in cash, right? It's and.
- 1:18:47But it's but it's worse than that, isn't it?
- 1:18:48So I only know about the rating agencies from watching the big
- 1:18:51shorts. So I don't have any inside
- 1:18:53information there but if the big shorts correct then it was
- 1:18:56pretty awful. But it's more than that.
- 1:19:00It's, you know, by changing the interest rate you're you're
- 1:19:06manipulating everyone's economic calculations and creating these
- 1:19:10boom, bust, bust cycles and creating these periods of
- 1:19:14hardship and distorting. So we wrote AI say we wrote
- 1:19:22Glenn, we got someone else to write some of it, and Glenn
- 1:19:24wrote some of it. We're most of the way through a
- 1:19:28series that we're running through a series of articles
- 1:19:32called What is Money. So what we realized was that we
- 1:19:36could go out there and try and talk about Bitcoin.
- 1:19:38But actually we've missed the stage because most of our
- 1:19:42industry is very happy talking about equities and bonds and
- 1:19:45property and all the rest of it, but don't actually understand
- 1:19:48what money is. And so we felt that actually we
- 1:19:52needed some education there. So we had we've got ten articles
- 1:19:56in me, so seven. I think the 7th 1 comes out
- 1:19:59later this week, three more to come and it steps through
- 1:20:04various different things which you'd expect us to.
- 1:20:07I can't remember them all now, but one of them is the cancel on
- 1:20:09effect and I for me that was a. When I learnt about that however
- 1:20:15many years ago that I thought that was absolutely fascinating
- 1:20:19in terms of how that works and just another distortion of what
- 1:20:24happens when you mess with with the money and who benefits and
- 1:20:28who doesn't. And it's not a it's not a value
- 1:20:31judgement, it's for each individual person should.
- 1:20:35What's that? It's an essay on economic theory
- 1:20:38by Richard Cancelling. Cancelling.
- 1:20:40Very good. So it's, you know, each of these
- 1:20:45articles and and each of the underlying theory behind them.
- 1:20:49They're not value judgments, you know, it is for each individual
- 1:20:53reading them or you know, in their daily life to make their
- 1:20:56own judgments. We're not, we're not saying that
- 1:20:59they should be thinking in a certain way.
- 1:21:01What we're all we're trying to do is say, look, there's some
- 1:21:03information here which you may not be aware of.
- 1:21:06It is up to you what you then think about it.
- 1:21:09And some people may be happy with those distortions in or
- 1:21:13manipulation of money flows. Other people will not be.
- 1:21:18So we're going to have a variety of clients with a variety of
- 1:21:20views. The one we're putting out this
- 1:21:23week is how modern banking works, right?
- 1:21:27And so again, we're not telling people what to think.
- 1:21:30We're just telling them some stuff they might want to know.
- 1:21:32And then they can make up their own minds, right?
- 1:21:35So, you know, do you realize that when you put the money in
- 1:21:41the bank that they're not keeping that money, in fact they
- 1:21:45can give it to other people and they can create as much money as
- 1:21:52they want, subject to demand given interest rates because the
- 1:21:57reserve requirement is 0%. They there's no such thing as
- 1:22:03fractional reserve banking in the UK and the US, because that
- 1:22:07fractional reserve implies they've got to keep a fraction
- 1:22:11of the money that you put. They don't have to keep any.
- 1:22:15So just be aware of that. We're not telling you what to
- 1:22:21think about that. Maybe you think that's a good
- 1:22:23thing. Right.
- 1:22:25And and that change happened in March 2020 and and you know was
- 1:22:31a temporary fix to provide liquidity to the markets that
- 1:22:36four years later we still have. In in the UK they did it in the
- 1:22:41late 90s. Oh, really?
- 1:22:43It's been that way for that long.
- 1:22:46Wow. Do you guys feel like you're a
- 1:22:49little bit of a Canary in the coal mine then with everything
- 1:22:54that happened with the gilt market recently and the
- 1:22:57intervention that had to happen to stabilize things, a little
- 1:23:00bit more volatility over there? Yeah, well, it was like, so
- 1:23:04misreported that whole thing, right, Because it was like, oh,
- 1:23:08the pensions would have gone bankrupt, right.
- 1:23:12We were like, no, the base thing that can happen to a defined
- 1:23:15benefit pension scheme, which is the large majority of where the
- 1:23:19assets and liabilities are in the UK when interest rates, when
- 1:23:25yields on bonds go up like that, it's great for the defined
- 1:23:29benefit pension schemes, right? And actually because with
- 1:23:37liability driven investment funds, you're using leverage,
- 1:23:40right? So it's like when you're hedging
- 1:23:42the interest rate risk using leverage, you need to meet
- 1:23:49collateral calls as the price of the bonds falls and the yields
- 1:23:52rise, right. So that's where it's the issue
- 1:23:57came. But the thing was then the Bank
- 1:24:00of England kind of stepped in, right.
- 1:24:03So everybody got knocked out of their liability driven
- 1:24:06investment funds because they couldn't meet the collateral
- 1:24:09calls quick enough, right? And then once they'd all be
- 1:24:13knocked out, then the Bank of England comes in and buys all
- 1:24:16the bands and drives the yield that was the.
- 1:24:19Problem that was the problem would have been it been
- 1:24:22absolutely fine otherwise. Actually a lot of pension
- 1:24:25schemes were licking their lips saying this is awesome, I can
- 1:24:28buy bonds even cheaper and I want I want more bonds and the
- 1:24:33bank. If the bank could come in and
- 1:24:34said we're going to. I think yields were about 5%,
- 1:24:40maybe just under 5% at the point in time.
- 1:24:43If they come in and said we're going to cap yields at 5% or 5
- 1:24:471/2 percent or something like that, then actually it would
- 1:24:51have been a right. It would apply for time because
- 1:24:52the problem was when you got any leverage fund, you call for call
- 1:24:56for cash, you need at least some time to get cash from A to B and
- 1:25:02that that was that was the the difficult bit.
- 1:25:05So if they just capped yields, they didn't, They just said
- 1:25:08we're going to come and buy some.
- 1:25:10So mass, as Glenn says, I mean it's so frustrating how you can
- 1:25:16have such a big player who does not understand the market or how
- 1:25:20it operates and think the worst thing is they think they're
- 1:25:23helping that unbelievable. So the proof that they were not
- 1:25:29helping define benefit schemes is that I'm trying to remember
- 1:25:32the numbers now something like they bought bonds in
- 1:25:38particularly in particularly in October 22 and they bought
- 1:25:44around £19 billion worth of of UK government bonds and that
- 1:25:50that drove the yields down by half percent or 1% or so.
- 1:25:56The plan stated by them, to be fair, was that they would
- 1:25:59always, they were short term, they would sell them back to the
- 1:26:02market. So they bought them for £19
- 1:26:05billion, they sold them for £23 billion, so they made a profit,
- 1:26:11which goes back to the UK government because of the way
- 1:26:13it's structured. So we've got to ask.
- 1:26:17Pensions. Where does that 4 billion come
- 1:26:20from? So they basically manipulated
- 1:26:22the market to take £4 billion from UK pension schemes.
- 1:26:26There'll be some other entities involved in that as well
- 1:26:29somewhere, but we're talking primarily UK defined benefit
- 1:26:33pension schemes and then they think they're helping.
- 1:26:37And then the newspapers. I don't know if who told them
- 1:26:44this or whatever their story is, the Bank of England saved the
- 1:26:48pension schemes. This is your life on central
- 1:26:52planning, yeah? Definitely the the headlines we
- 1:26:55got over here. It's almost as if when you're
- 1:26:59adding additional intervention into a market, it causes
- 1:27:02problems. Amazing, right?
- 1:27:04If any someone had thought of that before.
- 1:27:06Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, because you know like when
- 1:27:10the the Soviets that it in Vietnam, it clearly works very
- 1:27:16well. When you worked great.
- 1:27:18The more you do have it, the better things go.
- 1:27:23So yeah. And I wonder if I mean for the
- 1:27:27pensions that do come around and adopt Bitcoin and allocate a
- 1:27:31certain portion of their portfolios to it, does Bitcoin's
- 1:27:34performance give them ammo against the government that may
- 1:27:39want to stop Bitcoin or intervene to say, hey, either
- 1:27:43this is really helping us, you cannot ban this, this asset or
- 1:27:47try to prohibit with proliferation.
- 1:27:50It's literally helping us fund pensions of the individuals that
- 1:27:53live in this country. And then #2 like, hey, we don't
- 1:27:57need your help. We've we've found something
- 1:27:59that's doing really well for us. Just leave us alone.
- 1:28:03We've got this figured out. You central planners don't
- 1:28:05understand. I mean, I wish we.
- 1:28:06Don't need you. I wish that was true, but we're
- 1:28:10not at that point yet where they kind of like you know that
- 1:28:14that's my view. I know that's your view, Marty,
- 1:28:16but I don't think they're just thinking, oh, OK, well, we could
- 1:28:21get a really good return out of this thing, but they're not
- 1:28:24looking at it as a way to hold the government account.
- 1:28:28When you say, hey, if you keep doing this, then we're going to
- 1:28:31do that or. What what about the cousin of
- 1:28:34that in in the sense of like BlackRock in the the SEC and
- 1:28:37large bodies approving it, How is that influenced?
- 1:28:42Have you seen any movement or just interest?
- 1:28:45I mean, when I mentioned it to people, so we we've kind of we
- 1:28:50actually, so we have investment monitoring reports that got
- 1:28:54every quarter and in there we usually we call them hot topics,
- 1:29:01OK. So it's like 3 things that we
- 1:29:03want to get out to our client base.
- 1:29:05And in there, we did a piece just 200 words saying, you know
- 1:29:10that the landscape of investment has changed because of the ETF
- 1:29:14launches. And you know we mentioned
- 1:29:17BlackRock, Fidelity, Franklin Templeton, Why?
- 1:29:22Because these are brand names that they know and that they
- 1:29:26trust. And so it's sort of like and
- 1:29:30when I've had conversations with people and I've mentioned the
- 1:29:33ETFs, everybody that I've had a conversation with is aware that
- 1:29:39this happened, right. So I think that's kind of
- 1:29:44confusing people because it was like I every time I read about
- 1:29:49Bitcoin, it was used by criminals.
- 1:29:53It's bad for the environment. It's a Ponzi scheme.
- 1:29:56The government saying stay away from it, da, da, da.
- 1:30:00And now BlackRock and Franklin Templeton and Fidelity have just
- 1:30:04launched these ETFs. So it's like kind of like now I
- 1:30:07don't know what to think, right. So I think that's helpful
- 1:30:11because yeah. There is, there is, there will
- 1:30:14be an inflection point at some point in the future though I
- 1:30:16think to which is helped by the Black Rock ETFs and I think to
- 1:30:19to Marty's point as well. So each pension scheme, so each
- 1:30:25each pension scheme trustee board must think only of their
- 1:30:30scheme. They can't think about why than
- 1:30:31that it's looking at the investment advantage
- 1:30:35disadvantages of having small allocation etcetera, right.
- 1:30:37So that that's what they must be focused on, otherwise they're
- 1:30:42not carrying out their fiduciary duty properly.
- 1:30:46However, I think it's a wider point that the more pension
- 1:30:49schemes that do this for their own reasons, but the more
- 1:30:51widespread it is, the more it is difficult for then the regulator
- 1:30:57or the government to act well, intervene, I suppose in some way
- 1:31:04because they are hurting, they're hurting, whether it's
- 1:31:08the companies that sponsor those schemes or the members, they're
- 1:31:11hurting them by taking that kind of interventionist action.
- 1:31:17Which are affected with their constituents, people supposedly
- 1:31:19voting for. Them.
- 1:31:20Yeah. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:31:22So you'd hope that the voters would recognize that.
- 1:31:28And this ties back into the Bitcoin employee benefits,
- 1:31:32right? Because if you're a member of a
- 1:31:35defined benefit pension scheme and the scheme rules say you get
- 1:31:43inflation as the government measures it, or or they can
- 1:31:48stipulate it in the rules, they can say the retail price index,
- 1:31:52the consumer price index. You get that, but only up to 5%,
- 1:31:57right? If it's higher than 5%, you
- 1:31:59don't, You don't get the rest right?
- 1:32:02But also the 5%, is that even real right?
- 1:32:08So the defined benefit, the sponsor, the company behind that
- 1:32:13scheme is only on the hook for the rules of the scheme, right?
- 1:32:18But the members are relying on that for 30 years of retirement,
- 1:32:23right? And so if real inflation is 10
- 1:32:29or higher and they're only getting five of the sort of
- 1:32:37metric that the government's come up with or whatever, they
- 1:32:41could be 5% poorer every year. You compound that over 30 years,
- 1:32:47right, All of a sudden you're going to, it's very nice having
- 1:32:51a defined benefit pension scheme, right?
- 1:32:54But it's not near the end. It's not going to be nearly as
- 1:32:59good as it is in the beginning. And yeah, so even if we put
- 1:33:06Bitcoin in a portfolio, we're really only helping the company,
- 1:33:10the sponsor, because they're only on the hook for the rules
- 1:33:13of the scheme, right? So you want people to have
- 1:33:16access to this thing outside of their pension to make kind of to
- 1:33:22make up for what's going to happen?
- 1:33:24To think of it as a, think of it as a 2%, right.
- 1:33:27So let's go back to that 234 percent maybe if we end up in a
- 1:33:30position where they've got most of their pension provision at
- 1:33:36least over the next few years and most of their pension
- 1:33:38provision through DB or DC or whatever it is and then 234
- 1:33:43percent outside actually that's probably quite a healthy
- 1:33:47position for a lot of individuals.
- 1:33:51Agree. I think to your points about it
- 1:33:54accelerating or almost it's like it feels like it's accelerating
- 1:33:58the sense of like high net worth individuals.
- 1:34:00I think of my mother-in-law who retired and and I always like
- 1:34:03Egger on because every year I'm just like you have less
- 1:34:06retirement and like you can feel it, you go on vacation, it costs
- 1:34:09X, it's not and it's not 5%, it's 10 to 15 if not more.
- 1:34:13So you start to look at like, OK, I had this defined amount
- 1:34:15and it historically was enough because it was two to five and
- 1:34:18you felt it. Now you actually start and that
- 1:34:20goes across the board and that's not slowing down since 2020
- 1:34:24that's that's just exponentially increased given money printer.
- 1:34:29Exactly. I mean it's quite funny.
- 1:34:33Yeah. So the inflation linked gilts,
- 1:34:37yeah, they used to be linked to RP.
- 1:34:39Well, they still are linked to RPI, but I think it's what's a
- 1:34:432032 or 2030. They they're changing the thing
- 1:34:48that it's linked to, to CPIH, OK, which is consumer price
- 1:34:54index and housing. And then if you look at the
- 1:34:59level of RPI and the level of CPIH, of course CPIH is lower
- 1:35:04than RPI, right. So but it's like the story is
- 1:35:09no, CPIH is a better, more accurate measure of inflation.
- 1:35:14It just happens to be lower, right.
- 1:35:17You know what I mean? So it's like, you know, it's
- 1:35:22like you think about these things like a logical human
- 1:35:26being and you're like, come on. We just need to look at rib
- 1:35:28eyes, like whatever the rib. Eye is.
- 1:35:31It's a pretty good index. Oh, that's my basket.
- 1:35:37Yeah. It goes back to Glenn.
- 1:35:39What you were saying earlier of like the the four year cycles,
- 1:35:44it sort of caused people to go through their own steps of of
- 1:35:48the adoption process. You know, and maybe you get in
- 1:35:52at the top in one cycle, but you you learn and then the next
- 1:35:57cycle you DCA and and then suddenly you are building a
- 1:36:02position and you're becoming a Bitcoin adopter like in in
- 1:36:06earnest. And every individual goes
- 1:36:08through their own process. And that also extends to
- 1:36:13organizations and to, you know, to pensions who are made-up of
- 1:36:17individuals who are decision makers and folks like yourself
- 1:36:21who are, who are providing advice to these organizations.
- 1:36:24But everybody in the world is going through their own adoption
- 1:36:27process. And it's a series of steps where
- 1:36:30at first you ignore it in 2013, then, you know, 2017, you're
- 1:36:35like, Dang, I should have gotten some.
- 1:36:37And then 2020 happens. They print a bunch of money.
- 1:36:41You're like, I don't know this, this feels wrong.
- 1:36:44Or Sam, in your case, you know, Russia's foreign exchange
- 1:36:47reserves get seized and that becomes like, all right, there's
- 1:36:51something wrong here and and I need to take Bitcoin more
- 1:36:55seriously. And then of course, you know,
- 1:36:57going into the future, there's not only the guaranteed
- 1:37:01mechanics every four years of the next having causing
- 1:37:04increasing scarcity, causing the next price run or you know, the
- 1:37:09next supply demand, price disequilibrium that forces price
- 1:37:16discovery, that causes, you know, a price run and and people
- 1:37:20pay more attention to Bitcoin for that period because that's
- 1:37:23how human nature works. There's that guaranteed to
- 1:37:26happen every four years. But, but looking forward, what
- 1:37:29will be the macroeconomic events like Russia having its foreign
- 1:37:36exchange reserves seized like the banking crisis and and BTFP
- 1:37:42stepping into to save those banks like the COVID stimulus or
- 1:37:50or like you know, 2008 and and Occupy Wall Street's inefficacy,
- 1:37:56you know, and because of it not addressing real problems.
- 1:38:01What are the what are the events going forward?
- 1:38:04There's recently, there's been some major event every year that
- 1:38:09has awakened people like Sam to like, you know what this is?
- 1:38:12It's time to take Bitcoin seriously.
- 1:38:14So what will be the next like series of events going going
- 1:38:19into the years ahead in addition to the halving that we have
- 1:38:22coming up in three months? You know, and and it all points
- 1:38:25back to Glenn, what you were talking, you know, earlier about
- 1:38:29about every cycle there's some incremental slice of the
- 1:38:33adoption curve that comes into Bitcoin or progresses to the
- 1:38:37next stage of their Bitcoin adoption process.
- 1:38:40And the culmination of that is this, like 3 generations of
- 1:38:43behavioral shift away from how things are today to eventually
- 1:38:49just save your money in Bitcoin so you can work on your career
- 1:38:53and don't worry about investing because it takes care of you
- 1:38:56because it's, you know, finite absolute scarcity and it tracks
- 1:39:00with overall GDP growth like that.
- 1:39:03You know, and we're in the early stages of this process.
- 1:39:06It's and then that's the end state.
- 1:39:08But, you know, it's exciting that Sam had this series of
- 1:39:13events move him into a position of adopting Bitcoin for
- 1:39:19professionally and who who will be, you know, coming down the
- 1:39:25Pike because BlackRock, you know, maybe that's the event
- 1:39:29right now that's happening, is suddenly Wall Street is
- 1:39:32switching from negative to positive on Bitcoin because of
- 1:39:34the marketing that comes with an ETF.
- 1:39:38And over the next year or two, there's going to be a lot more
- 1:39:41people pointing at that and saying, you know what?
- 1:39:44That was actually the start of me learning about Bitcoin and
- 1:39:47coming around to it. So there's this lag effect
- 1:39:50between events and then people becoming bitcoiners.
- 1:39:53Sam's a recent example, I guess, of the Russia event triggering.
- 1:39:58You know what? I'm going to go on a two year
- 1:40:00long search for? What's the right way to get my
- 1:40:03clients to take Bitcoin as an allocation?
- 1:40:07And you know Glenn was was the the instrument of making this
- 1:40:11all happen. What happens going forward?
- 1:40:14What's the two year lag from from the ETFs coming out now,
- 1:40:20the having coming in in April and who knows what macroeconomic
- 1:40:24series of events into the future?
- 1:40:27So you, you know what we've been hearing a lot about lately?
- 1:40:31It's kind of bizarre, right? Is so we had this government
- 1:40:37minister on Sky News like whether this very well known TV
- 1:40:45presenter here in the UK, Kate Burley or something like that,
- 1:40:52asking her, asking him about comments that the general of the
- 1:41:00whole British Army had been making about potentially needing
- 1:41:07to get ready for a major World War and that we need we may need
- 1:41:17to start conscription again. Right.
- 1:41:20And I was watching this and I was thinking what the hell are
- 1:41:25they talking about? Like, where's all of the sudden
- 1:41:28this coming from? You know, like, what are we
- 1:41:32getting ready for? Like all of a sudden?
- 1:41:35Like this is the plan, like. And he's saying, yes, we've got
- 1:41:38to get ready like as if it's inevitable, You know, like they
- 1:41:43come in like somebody's going together.
- 1:41:46Yeah. And then and I think what that's
- 1:41:51about right, is always when the system's collapsing, right,
- 1:41:57Because you mentioned the unfunded liabilities, right.
- 1:42:00We got the same problem over here.
- 1:42:02It's just kind of different numbers, but relative to, you
- 1:42:06know there it's like it's. Like 300 trillion.
- 1:42:09Trillion or your 300 trillion here, it's like only like 8
- 1:42:13trillion but relative to the side of the economy, right?
- 1:42:17And the given that the total dates only two trillion, right.
- 1:42:21It's like you realize that if I'm a political party or
- 1:42:27politician, right? There's no way out here because
- 1:42:31I can't tell people, oh, sorry, I know you put all that money
- 1:42:36into National Insurance or Social Security, but I can't
- 1:42:42give you what I promised you. Well, then, then then that's a
- 1:42:46next politician, you know? So you realize there's no kind
- 1:42:51of way out and the games kind of up, right?
- 1:42:56We're at that point now where the, the, the explicit
- 1:43:01liabilities are so high and then there's all the unfunded
- 1:43:04liabilities and whatever. And so you need to use a a, a
- 1:43:11World Economic Forum term, you need a great reset, right.
- 1:43:17And so, well, how did we have the last great reset, right,
- 1:43:21because what happened is we kind of the, the British pound was
- 1:43:26the global reserve currency in 1913 and they kind of did the
- 1:43:32stealth kind of QE to fund the First World War.
- 1:43:36Then because they lied to the public, they had to go back on
- 1:43:42the gold standard at the same rate they caused deflation,
- 1:43:46right. Then we had a worldwide Great
- 1:43:50Depression, right? And and then we kind of did the
- 1:43:53New Deal and all of these kinds of things and whatever.
- 1:43:57But the game was kind of up. And then we had a World War and
- 1:44:01then we had Bretton Woods, right.
- 1:44:04And then we ran that for 1970 till 1971, which was kind of a
- 1:44:08quasi gold standard, but really not a gold standard role.
- 1:44:13Then we went from 1971 to today on the sphere standard.
- 1:44:18But even the game with that is now up, right.
- 1:44:21So now we've got to like create some huge calamity where it's
- 1:44:26sort of we just erase all of that.
- 1:44:28And then at the on the other side in the rubble we'll kind of
- 1:44:33like create some new standard which will now be, you know,
- 1:44:38some CBDC or and you know it'll be, oh, because of cyber
- 1:44:47attacks. You have to have a digital
- 1:44:49identity. And you, you know all this is
- 1:44:52what it's starting to sound like because they saying that
- 1:44:56Vladimir Putin is like now a rest to the whole of Europe,
- 1:45:01right. But he's still stuck in Eastern
- 1:45:04Ukraine just fighting Ukrainians, right.
- 1:45:08So, like, how is he all of a sudden a threat to Europe?
- 1:45:12So when they say things like this on national TV and it's
- 1:45:17these very senior people and stuff, and they're absolutely
- 1:45:20illogical, they don't make sense, then I know there's a
- 1:45:24plan. So we're going to rename Glenn
- 1:45:27Glenn Jones. Glad I I'm picking up what
- 1:45:32you're putting down. Marty.
- 1:45:35'S there like, yeah, yeah. War is the greatest jobs program
- 1:45:39humanity's ever known. It's.
- 1:45:42I was going to go for something less extreme, but it sounds
- 1:45:44sounds quite weak now. No, I was going to I think
- 1:45:47there's a shorter term I I so I think the next, I think the next
- 1:45:51wave will come from the institutions.
- 1:45:54I think that is where it'll come from and that's sort of what I
- 1:45:57envisaged a couple of years ago that we needed to get ready for.
- 1:46:01I think they'll be crying out for, yeah, OK, not very much,
- 1:46:04but the small allocation we've talked about and I think and
- 1:46:07what will trigger that, I don't think it'll be the halving so
- 1:46:11much, although that might put it on the front pages a little bit
- 1:46:13more, which is helpful. I think it will be the next wave
- 1:46:20of inflation. So we, I mentioned earlier that
- 1:46:24one of the key risks that Bitcoin helps to protect against
- 1:46:28for institutions, it's counterparty risk and inflation
- 1:46:31risk. And we are obviously I've got no
- 1:46:37insider knowledge on this, but just sort of applying some
- 1:46:41Austrian School logic to it. We are coming to the point where
- 1:46:46the interest rate rises we've seen are going to lead to some
- 1:46:49kind of contraction, possibly serious contraction, you know
- 1:46:52that the tide goes out etcetera. And then the government and the
- 1:46:58Central bank and not just in the UK, but I guess in quite a few
- 1:47:02countries, is then going to be faced with the decision that
- 1:47:04it's been faced with quite a number times before, which is
- 1:47:07does it allow the economy to to, I was going to say collapse
- 1:47:12them, but sort of return to a more sustainable position really
- 1:47:19to unwind the excesses that that shouldn't have been, shouldn't
- 1:47:22have happened in the 1st place or does it print to push the
- 1:47:26future out a little bit further. And I think we'll probably see
- 1:47:31one and then the other. And so therefore we'll see a
- 1:47:37sort of a reminder of the counterparty risk that corporate
- 1:47:43treasuries, pension schemes, etcetera face, the institutional
- 1:47:48investors generally the counterparty risk that they face
- 1:47:50and also the inflation risk that they face.
- 1:47:53And we'll see them in fairly short succession because I think
- 1:47:57that's what I think that's why a lot of pension schemes and their
- 1:48:04companies were more willing to take action in 2023 to lock in
- 1:48:11some of those high, high interest rates that we saw on
- 1:48:14bonds is because 2022, when bond yields were very low, was recent
- 1:48:19in their memory. So I think it needs, it needs
- 1:48:24that, it needs for a general sort of awakening to a
- 1:48:28particular situation. It needs like 2 events within
- 1:48:33recent memory. And I think that's what there's
- 1:48:35a good chance that we'll get over the next, who knows, you
- 1:48:38know, but six, 1218 months maybe.
- 1:48:42And then hopefully that will mean that more people are
- 1:48:48thinking, OK, I think something doesn't feel right.
- 1:48:52It's going back. It's that feeling of uneasiness
- 1:48:57that well, I don't know if it's the same for you, but I think
- 1:49:00it's probably the I'd suggest. It's the same for everyone.
- 1:49:03To take action to do something, you need to feel uneasy about
- 1:49:07your current situation, and it's that which then forces you,
- 1:49:12subconsciously or otherwise, to take action in a certain
- 1:49:15direction, to try and ease that uneasiness, make yourself feel a
- 1:49:19bit better. And one way to do that is of
- 1:49:22course for these kind of things to learn more about Bitcoin.
- 1:49:25Yes. Do not be paralyzed by fear.
- 1:49:28Act simple act. Just be reading some information
- 1:49:33about Bitcoin to develop the confidence and then take another
- 1:49:36action which is gonna get on your personal or business
- 1:49:39balance sheet or pension balance sheet, whatever it may be.
- 1:49:42Yeah, and if you wanna learn more from Glenn's understanding
- 1:49:48of the system, you have to come to to the UK and visit him and
- 1:49:52take him out to dinner where I think we're getting kicked out
- 1:49:54of the studio but looking forward to eating steak and and
- 1:49:58hearing him expand on some of his Marty Jones.
- 1:50:04Kinder experience. Go with what Sam said.
- 1:50:07Know what I said. I I love Sam's pivot to the
- 1:50:11actionable. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:50:14There's the there's the short term and and maybe the long
- 1:50:17term, which are not incompatible between what you guys were
- 1:50:20presenting. But yeah, I would love to hear
- 1:50:23more about that over a pint of bitter with Glenn and Sam.
- 1:50:27I'm jealous. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:50:30I I think the key if if we're allowed to leave you with a sort
- 1:50:33of a key message from us, I think it's that this
- 1:50:38monetization phase that we've talked about that is what
- 1:50:41creates a huge opportunity for institutions to dip their toe in
- 1:50:47the water. It's not going to be around
- 1:50:48forever. So ACT.
- 1:50:54Because big Bitcoin is what it is and you can't stop it.
- 1:50:59So it is inevitable. And if it's inevitable, it's
- 1:51:03going to monetize. So we don't know how long over
- 1:51:07what period it might be. Five years might be 15, it might
- 1:51:11be 50. Doesn't really matter.
- 1:51:15No. And they're and they're not
- 1:51:17making any more of it. There's only 20.
- 1:51:19More than so. So.
- 1:51:20Well, they are still, but only very little, but yeah.
- 1:51:23Less, less, they're making less and less of it.
- 1:51:27Who's making them, Glenn? Well, I'm extremely jealous.
- 1:51:31Jealous. The FOMO is real right now
- 1:51:34across the pond. You gentlemen go enjoy your
- 1:51:37dinner and the conversation around that meal.
- 1:51:40And it was pleasure meeting you, Sam.
- 1:51:43Glenn, pleasure talking to you again.
- 1:51:45For everybody out there listening, we'll see you next
- 1:51:47week.