Latest / Consumerpedia / 93 - The Home Insurance Crisis
Transcript
- 0:02This country is facing a growing insurance crisis, and that's not
- 0:05an exaggeration. Homeowners policies are
- 0:07skyrocketing, especially in high risk areas.
- 0:10This crisis is fueled by a combination of climate related
- 0:13disasters, ongoing inflation, and insurance company
- 0:16withdrawals from certain markets.
- 0:18Consumer advocates, including our guests, also blame a lack of
- 0:22strong regulation and corporate greed.
- 0:24The insurance industry claims it's reacting to skyrocketing
- 0:27costs and trying to stay solvent.
- 0:30Understand how unsettling it is to see insurance rates go up.
- 0:33Loretta Waters is with the Insurance Information Institute
- 0:36and industry trade group. Insurance rates have to reflect
- 0:38the real risk of loss in order to ensure that insurers can meet
- 0:41their promise to pay claims when disaster strikes.
- 0:44You know we can't pay claims if we're not solvent.
- 0:47I'm her Weissbaum, the Consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:50checkbook.org. Welcome to
- 0:52consumerpedia@checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:56consumers select services, avoid trouble and save money.
- 1:00Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 1:03any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 1:06completely independent and objective.
- 1:09Now here's the host of Consumer Pedia America's consumer expert,
- 1:13the consumer man Herb Weisspaum. In this episode, we're going to
- 1:18look at the home insurance market, where we are possibly
- 1:21ways to make improvements, and what you can do to avoid some
- 1:24bad decisions as you try to lower your premiums.
- 1:27You'll also meet Rosanna, a homeowner in Pasadena.
- 1:30Her house is filled with toxic chemicals following the Eaton
- 1:33wildfires earlier this year. She feels betrayed and
- 1:36mistreated by her insurance company, State Farm.
- 1:39I can't believe that they can market themselves as like a good
- 1:43neighbor, You know, I mean, they're the worst neighbor
- 1:46possible. You pay for 30 years and then
- 1:49when you have something that's no fault of your own, they will
- 1:53not live up to their promises. We have two.
- 1:55Experts on the subject. Doug Heller is director of
- 1:57insurance at the Consumer Federation of America.
- 2:00Hi, Doug. Hi, Herb.
- 2:01And Carmen Balber, executive director of Consumer Watchdog.
- 2:05Consumer Watchdog is a nonpartisan group that works to
- 2:07give American consumers an effective voice during a time
- 2:11when special interests dominate public discourse, government and
- 2:14politics. Hi, Herb, Good to be here.
- 2:16So I want to start with a look at a few data points and these
- 2:18come from a recent report that Doug helped co-author for the
- 2:21Consumer Federation of America. From 2021 to 2024, annual
- 2:26insurance premiums for a typical American homeowner increased by
- 2:29an average of $648. That's a 24% increase.
- 2:34During that same time period, inflation rose by 11%.
- 2:38And in some states the rate hikes last year were
- 2:41significantly higher. Utah 59%, Illinois 50%, Arizona
- 2:4748% and Pennsylvania 44%. And last year the average
- 2:51premium for a homeowner with mid range credit at a $350,000
- 2:55replacement value policy was $3300 per year or $275 per
- 3:02month. Doug, when you saw those
- 3:04numbers, what did you think? Well, we think that the stories
- 3:07that we've been hearing from homeowners all around the
- 3:09country are just the honest frustration of people who really
- 3:13can't afford to maintain the insurance that they need.
- 3:16And so many people are experiencing the kind of
- 3:18increases that you just described.
- 3:20And of course, we're looking at averages.
- 3:22For some people around the country, that premium is in the
- 3:2510s of thousands of dollars, especially in places like
- 3:28Florida and Louisiana and parts of California, but also parts of
- 3:32Nebraska and Oklahoma are facing these incredibly high insurance
- 3:36premiums. And if you want to have
- 3:38sustainable home ownership in America, you need to have a
- 3:41sustainable system of protection.
- 3:42Insurance used to be that, but it's no longer sustainable under
- 3:46the pressures that we've been facing.
- 3:48Just this summer, State Farm announced a 27% rate increase in
- 3:52Illinois. Illinois was already one of the
- 3:54states facing the highest increases.
- 3:56So all around the country, people are struggling to make
- 3:58payments on this critical but required insurance product.
- 4:02Carmen, what are some of the real life problems that you see
- 4:05related to skyrocketing insurance costs?
- 4:08I mean, I can't tell you how many consumers we've heard from
- 4:11who are struggling to pay their everyday bills because of the
- 4:15skyrocketing cost of their insurance.
- 4:18That runs the gamut from homeowners who are being forced
- 4:21to reduce the amount of coverage.
- 4:23We hear from people who have been essentially priced out of
- 4:27their coverage and have had to fall back on state insurance of
- 4:31last resort, which is sometimes cheaper but also covers much
- 4:35less. And we're hearing from consumers
- 4:38who are concerned they may not be able to pay their mortgage
- 4:42because their insurance cost is so high.
- 4:43It's unsustainable. So it's really a baseline
- 4:47pocketbook problem for more and more Americans.
- 4:51And you're also hearing in California from people who paid
- 4:54their premiums and can't get the insurance companies to pay their
- 4:57claims for the recent fires. What's with that?
- 4:59I think that is the most fundamentally outrageous example
- 5:03of what these high prices are doing to people who have paid
- 5:07their premiums diligently for years and sometimes decades.
- 5:13In the wake of the Los Angeles fires, we saw a trend develop
- 5:17where consumers who had recently seen massive rate increases also
- 5:23learned that their insurance company was trying not to pay
- 5:26them for their full losses in the LA fires.
- 5:29So for example, a coalition of fire survivors from the Eaton
- 5:34Fire in Los Angeles got together and learned that the number one
- 5:39insurer who wasn't paying the claims they owed with State Farm
- 5:42California, that company was simultaneously looking for a
- 5:46massive double digit rate increase that amounts to about a
- 5:49billion dollars every year for policyholders.
- 5:52So we have on one hand an insurance company looking for a
- 5:56billion dollar a year increase in premiums and at the same time
- 6:00low balling insurance claims to the tune of 1020 or 30% of what
- 6:06insured people thought they were owed.
- 6:09An example of that, one of the worst examples is consumers who
- 6:13suffered not a total loss of their home, but thought they
- 6:16were lucky that their home survived the fires, but they had
- 6:20smoke damage. Because of course, when a fire
- 6:22burns, things melt, ash accumulates, all sorts of
- 6:26contaminants end up left in your home and it needs to be at a
- 6:29minimum, clean. But often elements of your home
- 6:32need to be replaced because of toxins seep in and they're
- 6:35permanent. And State Farm is one of the
- 6:37number one culprits. Really low balling those claims,
- 6:41refusing to pay for testing and then offering consumers 30 grand
- 6:46when their private estimate is 150.
- 6:49And that's exactly what happened to Rosanna Valverde and her
- 6:52husband Sam. They survived the Eaton Fire in
- 6:55January, which destroyed more than 9000 buildings.
- 6:58They were lucky, if you can call it that, because their house
- 7:01didn't burn, but it's filled with toxic chemicals left behind
- 7:05by all the smoke. We have high levels of lead,
- 7:09arsenic and nickel and I was stunned.
- 7:12Rosanna told me she and her husband have been living with
- 7:14her son since the fire because State Farm won't pay to make the
- 7:18house safe. When the appraiser and inspector
- 7:20for State Farm came to her house shortly after the fire, Rosanna
- 7:23told me they concluded there was nothing more than smoke damage.
- 7:27And they had one of those tall boxes of Kleenex and he came in,
- 7:31he literally pulled one out in my entryway, wiped it on the
- 7:36wall with two fingers and said, oh, it's not bad.
- 7:38Do you have a cleaning lady? And I go, are you insane?
- 7:42And no, I don't have a cleaning lady.
- 7:44So then he went through the house Pooh poohing everything As
- 7:49my husband and I are getting more and more upset and really
- 7:53kind of stunned by this. He said, there's nothing bad
- 7:56here. You just basically need to
- 7:58vacuum it up and clean it up and that kind of thing.
- 8:00And I said, well, this guy from Servpro said we need to work
- 8:04with a certified industrial hygienist and we need to get a
- 8:06tested. And they said, oh, we never do
- 8:07that. Never.
- 8:08And the Surf Pro guy whispers in my ear.
- 8:11They do it all the time. But based on an independent
- 8:14appraisal, which Rosanna and Sam paid for themselves, the house
- 8:17is a toxic waste site. Everything must be removed.
- 8:20They were told to detoxify the house.
- 8:22It's called a pack out. Clean the whole house, clean the
- 8:25stuff off site and then bring it back so you don't cross
- 8:28contaminate. The attic insulation, carpets
- 8:30and hardwood floors will go to the dump.
- 8:32Special paint will need to be applied to the sheetrock to lock
- 8:35in the heavy metals. The clothes can be cleaned.
- 8:37The upholstered furniture must be destroyed.
- 8:40Estimated cost $300,000. State Farm settled the claim for
- 8:45about 70,000. What am I supposed to do with
- 8:48that? You know it's not even enough to
- 8:51start, so it still sits in the bank.
- 8:54How would you describe how you've been treated by your
- 8:57insurance company, State Farm? Disrespectfully, dishonestly,
- 9:01like we're stupid and just dragging it on forever.
- 9:07Now, Rosanna and Sam are considering the possibility of
- 9:10suing State Farm, as others have done.
- 9:12As they see it, it could take a year or more to move back into
- 9:15their house. All the while, there are
- 9:17mortgage payments to make and property taxes to pay.
- 9:20All of this, Rosanna tells me, has taken a toll on the family.
- 9:23We've been demoralized, defeated.
- 9:26We have panic attacks. We can't sleep.
- 9:28I've lost a lot of weight. We both have had to have
- 9:31medication for the panic attacks.
- 9:33I cannot believe these people sleep at night.
- 9:35Checkbook wanted to know what State Farm had to say about
- 9:38this, but the company did not respond to our multiple emails.
- 9:42Rosanna told me she wasn't surprised considering how she
- 9:45was treated. Doug, I know you're not
- 9:47surprised either. This is not just a problem that
- 9:50we're seeing in the wake of these fires in California.
- 9:52A few years ago, the Washington Post did an investigative
- 9:56reporting and found in the wake of Hurricane Ian, which
- 9:59devastated Florida, after the insurance companies would send
- 10:02their adjusters out to look at the homes and come up with a
- 10:05cost of repair. The insurance company executives
- 10:08or higher ups would look at those adjuster claims amounts
- 10:12and then send it back to be changed and reduced such that so
- 10:16many of the homeowners with legitimate claims In the wake of
- 10:20that hurricane, they found that their original claim that was
- 10:23supposed to be paid at about $100,000 would be reduced
- 10:26dramatically, often times below their deductible threshold.
- 10:30So people with serious damage and the insurance companies,
- 10:33adjusters having told them that they should get paid 100, $1000
- 10:37of for repair costs, we're suddenly getting nothing.
- 10:39This is a practice that the insurance industry uses in the
- 10:43wake of catastrophes in California, with the wildfires
- 10:46in the wake of the Hurricanes, but also when people report hail
- 10:50damage after a severe thunderstorm around the country.
- 10:53We see this time and again where the insurers who sell us this
- 10:56product with a contract to pay come up with excuses not to pay.
- 11:01Win, win for them. But homeowners around the
- 11:04country are paying for a product they're required to have and
- 11:06that they need to secure their home, and yet aren't getting the
- 11:10benefits of what they paid for. Really good point.
- 11:12This is a national problem, Carmen.
- 11:13I just want to go back. One last thing.
- 11:15In California, you talked about the emergency interim rate hike
- 11:18that the state granted State Farm in June, 17% for
- 11:21homeowners, 15% for renters and condos, 38% for rental
- 11:25dwellings. The company said it needed to
- 11:27rebuild its capital after the wildfires in Los Angeles County
- 11:30earlier this year. Your group opposed the rate
- 11:32hike. You said State Farm had not
- 11:33adequately proven the need for the increases.
- 11:36So why in the world is the state of California approving this?
- 11:39Unfortunately, the department went against our arguments and
- 11:43that interim emergency request that State Farm asked for was
- 11:47approved. However, ultimately the company
- 11:49did not explain or justify the reasons behind that increase.
- 11:54That interim increase is now up for review and the company has
- 11:59asked for even more money. Essentially, State Farm is now
- 12:02asking to increase the interim rate increase they got to 30%
- 12:06for homeowners, and that will amount to more than a billion
- 12:10dollar increase annually for State Farm policyholders.
- 12:14The company is claiming poverty, but the facts say otherwise.
- 12:19State Farm's parent company, which by the way is really on
- 12:22the hook for most of the LA wildfire losses, has $140
- 12:26billion in the bank in surplus funds that it could be using to,
- 12:31one, make California homeowners whole in the wake of the LA
- 12:35fires and stave off the supposed financial emergency that its
- 12:41local subsidiary is in. So State Farm crying poverty is
- 12:45a real joke. And it's a real slap in the face
- 12:49to California homeowners who have paid them for years and are
- 12:52now not getting their claims paid.
- 12:54I keep hearing the Jingle in my head like a good neighbor.
- 12:57Anyway, Doug, will the high cost of insurance, something as you
- 13:00said, is being experienced all across the country, Is that
- 13:02going to price people out of buying homes or condos or maybe
- 13:05keep builders from building land that affect landlords?
- 13:08Is this going to have a whole effect on the housing in this
- 13:10country? I'll tell you, I'm hearing from
- 13:12Realtors, developers, people who build affordable housing, and
- 13:16they're freaking out. They, we don't see a way out of
- 13:19this at these prices, because if people can't afford homes,
- 13:23people aren't going to build them.
- 13:24And that creates an economic cycle that can be really just
- 13:27tremendously painful for our whole economy.
- 13:29We are seeing already a significant and concerning rise
- 13:34in people who are going uninsured.
- 13:35So to go uninsured, you own your home outright.
- 13:38It's very dangerous to do that. The people who are going
- 13:40uninsured are not doing so because they have enough money
- 13:44in the bank in case something terrible happens.
- 13:45They're going uninsured because they can't afford the coverage.
- 13:48And right now we estimate there's about $1.6 trillion in
- 13:52market value of homes that are uninsured.
- 13:54We have a real crisis on our hands.
- 13:57I think that this is going to affect a whole range of aspects
- 14:00of our economy, including, as you suggest, the housing market.
- 14:03$1.6 trillion of uninsured property in this country, That's
- 14:07a lot of folks who if something happens, the worst happens,
- 14:10they're on their own. Yeah.
- 14:11That's right, Herb. And we do see concentrations in
- 14:13some cities, Miami, Houston, Detroit.
- 14:16So if those places sustain catastrophic kind of weather
- 14:20related events, you can imagine that it's not just going to be
- 14:23though all those individuals who are dealing with it, but you'll
- 14:26see community blight when you can't rebuild.
- 14:28And so there are two things happening, both the individuals,
- 14:31the families who are exposed to losing everything because of
- 14:36this insurance crisis of ever escalating prices and lower
- 14:40quality coverage, but also communities losing so much.
- 14:44It's just utterly clear that we have to take this seriously and
- 14:47engage public policy changes to address the problems.
- 14:50And there's one more dynamic going on here.
- 14:52Homeowners who live in hard hit areas such as California,
- 14:55Florida, North Carolina, where some of the insurance companies
- 14:58have decided not to issue new policies and not to renew
- 15:01existing ones. That's leaving these folks with
- 15:03fewer no options. Yeah, that's right.
- 15:04The market is not working. And I think that we tend to
- 15:08assume that, you know, every market is a perfectly free
- 15:10market and well, we just have to go and the supply and demand
- 15:14curves will match at some point. But the reality is on the demand
- 15:18side, US consumers, we're required to buy insurance by our
- 15:21lenders. So we always have to buy.
- 15:23So the insurance companies have incredible amounts of power.
- 15:25That's why we're seeing around the country, these regulators
- 15:29just kind of fall in line whenever the insurance companies
- 15:31make a demand because the companies have so much power.
- 15:34We really are facing a market for which the unregulated
- 15:38environment that we rely on in so many other types of markets
- 15:42just isn't working. And it just reminds us how
- 15:45important it is that we take the regulation of this, this
- 15:48industry, more seriously than we have because we've been letting
- 15:51the industry try to solve the problem and they've failed us.
- 15:54I hear so many times the insurance companies and their
- 15:57lobbyists say, well, it's so hard to be in this business.
- 15:59Why would anybody want to be in this business?
- 16:01And I think at a certain point, if the insurance industry keeps
- 16:04on telling us they don't want to serve our communities, we should
- 16:06take them seriously. We should believe them and start
- 16:09thinking about alternative ways to make sure that Americans can
- 16:12protect their homes and secure home ownership.
- 16:15And that's what we're going to talk about next.
- 16:17The influence that the insurance industry has on lobbying state
- 16:20lawmakers and regulators. And how does the little guy deal
- 16:23with that? I'm her Weissbaum, the Consumer
- 16:25man, and you're listening to Consumer Pedia powered by
- 16:27checkbook.org. At checkbook.org, we have the
- 16:31answers to your consumer questions 24/7.
- 16:34That's checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 16:38can help you with select local service providers, avoid
- 16:40trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 16:43advertising or take money from any business, we recommend, you
- 16:47can rely on Checkbook to be completely independent and
- 16:49objective. Our advice is always free.
- 16:52Ratings of local services are available with a subscription.
- 16:56If you live in one of these seven metro areas and haven't
- 16:58joined Checkbook yet, check us out.
- 17:00Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 17:04Minneapolis, Saint Paul and Washington DC Get your free 30
- 17:08day subscription by going to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 17:14Insurance is primarily regulated at the state level, and
- 17:17insurance companies have a lot of clout with state lawmakers
- 17:20and regulators. Their influence stems from a mix
- 17:22of political spending, lobbying power and their perceived
- 17:25importance to the economy. So, Doug, how influential is the
- 17:29insurance lobby in this country today?
- 17:31It's an incredibly powerful lobby.
- 17:33They work every State House in the country and every Department
- 17:37of Insurance in the country every day.
- 17:38And they are huge contributors to the campaigns of politicians.
- 17:43And they also just have a legion of lawyers and lobbyists who
- 17:47show up advocating for their own interests.
- 17:50And the rest of us as consumers, we're just trying to get by.
- 17:53We don't have the kind of resources to be there every day.
- 17:56So what happens is the insurance industry becomes so close with
- 17:59the insurance regulators that you have that classic fox guard
- 18:03in the hen house. And we see this play out all
- 18:06around the country with premiums that are too high, with claims
- 18:10practices that are unfair, and with a market that is not
- 18:16meeting the needs of American consumers.
- 18:18And it stems from the incredible power that the insurance
- 18:21industry has in every State House.
- 18:23Carmen, what do you see when you try to work with state insurance
- 18:25commissioners? Everything Doug has said here is
- 18:27true and it factors into the fact that we're so often in a
- 18:32situation where the insurance companies excuses for their
- 18:36behavior become accepted as the baseline reality.
- 18:41And I think a perfect example of that is what we're going through
- 18:44right now, where the insurance industry points to climate
- 18:47change as the excuse for all abuses.
- 18:50Prices are going up because climate change, we can't help
- 18:53it. We aren't paying claims out
- 18:55because climate makes those things completely uncoverable.
- 18:59We have to exclude them from your policy or we can't cover
- 19:03whole swaths of your neighborhood or your state
- 19:07because climate change makes that place uninsurable.
- 19:10But what regulators need to do but and often don't, is remember
- 19:14that the insur currents industry is looking at their very short
- 19:17term profits. Their goal is not keeping your
- 19:21community or your state insurable.
- 19:23That their goal is their six month or year end profitability
- 19:27and how they can shift where they do and do not cover in
- 19:30order to maximize that profitability.
- 19:33And if that means dropping some of the, yes, riskier but not
- 19:37uninsurable homeowners in order to pad their bottom line,
- 19:41they're going to do that, Which is why that industry influence
- 19:45over regulators is so one of the reasons it's so troubling,
- 19:49because that makes the industry narrative where they start the
- 19:53negotiations. If we were talking about a
- 19:56product that wasn't critical to our lives, that wasn't required
- 19:59for us, maybe you could lifting prices go up and people would
- 20:03just decide not to buy it. But when people don't buy home
- 20:05insurance, they're putting the most important financial asset
- 20:09in their lives at risk. Yeah.
- 20:11Let me just add to that because I I think it's a really
- 20:13important perhaps positive development with the pressures
- 20:17of non renewals and rising costs in the home insurance market
- 20:22making more and more people unable to afford their coverage
- 20:26or unable to get it at all. Grassroots anger at the
- 20:30insurance industry is really growing at a phenomenal rate.
- 20:34And what that means is constituent anger is in some
- 20:38cases overwhelming lobbying power of the insurance industry
- 20:43to actually implement changes in state legislatures that perhaps
- 20:47because of the power of the industry in the past, were
- 20:50impossible. But as more and more people are
- 20:53either priced out or squeezed to the breaking point by their
- 20:56insurance costs, the possibility of reform in legislatures that
- 21:01have often been captured I think is increasing.
- 21:03Well, clearly insurance rates are already more than some
- 21:05families can afford. So the question is, how are we
- 21:08as a country going to deal with this and what can you do to get
- 21:10the most for your premium dollar?
- 21:12That's straight ahead. I'm her wise bomb, the consumer
- 21:14man. And this is Consumer Pedia
- 21:16powered by checkbook.org. Consumer Pedia.
- 21:20Fast Facts The concept of homeowners insurance began
- 21:24hundreds of years ago, but according to the Insurance
- 21:27Information Institute, the first modern multi apparel policy was
- 21:31written in 1950 and included coverage for fire, theft,
- 21:34liability and more in a single package.
- 21:37According to Money Geek, property damage resulting from
- 21:40extreme weather, primarily wind and hail, is the most common
- 21:43reason for homeowners claims, followed by water damage and
- 21:46freezing, and then fire and lightning.
- 21:49Fire and lightning are the most expensive claims, averaging
- 21:52nearly 8, $84,000 per incident. According to a recent report
- 21:58from the Federal Reserve, 7% of the homeowners in this country
- 22:01didn't have homeowners insurance last year. 19% said it wasn't
- 22:05worth the cost, 43% said they couldn't afford a policy.
- 22:09Doug, all this creates an opportunity for some predatory
- 22:12practices that homeowners need to watch out for.
- 22:14You're absolutely right. And we're really concerned about
- 22:16what we're seeing in the market. So there have been some changes
- 22:19over the last couple of years in which insurance companies are
- 22:22really hollowing out the policies.
- 22:24They're offering slightly lower prices for a product that really
- 22:28can't be recommended. So one of the things that we
- 22:31urge people to look out for when they're being told, hey, well, I
- 22:34can give you a discount is a policy called an actual cash
- 22:37value policy. Typically when we buy insurance,
- 22:40we're looking for replacement costs.
- 22:42So if our roof were to be blown off, the insurance company would
- 22:45put a new roof on our house. We'd have to pay our deductible
- 22:48still, but they would pay for the rest.
- 22:50Under these actual cash value policies, policies.
- 22:53The insurance company is going to use a depreciation factor on
- 22:57the value of your roof. So if you had a 15 year old roof
- 23:00that wasn't leaking, that was working perfectly, that was
- 23:02blown off, instead of them paying for the whole repair of
- 23:05the roof, they would depreciate that.
- 23:07And a 15 year depreciation on a roof which may be as graded for
- 23:1120 or 25 years means you're going to get almost nothing,
- 23:14certainly a very small percentage of what you need,
- 23:16which leaves you having to rebuild your roof almost by
- 23:20yourself completely undermined the purpose of insurance.
- 23:22But it's the way insurance companies are trying to pitch
- 23:25people on a product which is just getting too expensive for
- 23:29them. So I want people to make sure
- 23:31they ask any agent or insurance company if this is an actual
- 23:34cash value policy or if it's doing what they would expect,
- 23:37which is replacing with a replacement cost value.
- 23:39So that's one thing. We are seeing companies push
- 23:42higher and higher deductibles. You have to remember that if you
- 23:45have a higher deductible, you're taking some of that risk of loss
- 23:48back onto your own wallet and you need to make sure that
- 23:50you're going to have enough money in hand.
- 23:52So you want to be careful that. And then there's one other thing
- 23:54we're seeing grow at that's really concerning and it's the
- 23:57growth of so-called surplus lines or non admitted insurers.
- 24:01These are insurance companies that aren't regulated by the
- 24:03state. They'll sell you a homeowner's
- 24:05insurance product, but nobody, nobody in government, no
- 24:08regulator is looking at the contract that they're giving you
- 24:10the policy. They're not looking at the rates
- 24:13they're charging you. So you could be paying too much,
- 24:15you could be getting a product that is insufficient.
- 24:18And then most importantly, unlike most of the insurance
- 24:21companies that we buy from them now, these non admitted
- 24:24insurance companies, they don't participate in what's called the
- 24:27guarantee fund of the state. That's the system that ensures
- 24:31if in one insurance company goes belly up and can't pay their
- 24:34claims, the rest of the insurance market will pay the
- 24:37claims for them. It means that we can trust that
- 24:41our policy will be there if a disaster puts our insurance
- 24:44company out of business. But with these non admitted
- 24:47companies, they're not part of that system and if they go belly
- 24:50up, there is nobody to pay our claims.
- 24:52So we want people to be very careful about the product that
- 24:55they're buying and the company they're buying it from.
- 24:58Make sure that you know that you're getting the replacement
- 25:01cost that you need and you're getting it from a company that
- 25:04is licensed and admitted to do business in the state.
- 25:06So you're getting the kind of protection you expect.
- 25:09If you're not sure, check with the insurance Commissioner's
- 25:11Office and make sure that company is licensed to do
- 25:13business in your state. Carmen, anything you want to
- 25:16share based on your experience dealing with all the problems
- 25:18you see? I mean, there's two conflicting
- 25:20problems here for consumers. 1, you want to make sure your home
- 25:24insurance policy will actually make you whole, but two, you
- 25:28want to figure out how to make it as affordable as possible on
- 25:31the affordability side. It's almost a wrote answer, but
- 25:35we have to give it every time. And that is, you can always try
- 25:38shopping around. In some markets that's harder
- 25:41than others, but it is always worth seeking out other
- 25:45companies to see if you can get a better deal elsewhere because
- 25:48they're all targeting different people.
- 25:50That can be harder in the home insurance market.
- 25:52So we often recommend folks seek out a broker who might want your
- 25:56new business and help you look around at different companies
- 26:00you might not be thinking about. So that shopping around is
- 26:04important, even though it can be frustrating, very time
- 26:06consuming. And then on the flip side, one
- 26:09thing that we're seeing more and more of across the country is
- 26:13people being underinsured. So they think they avoided that
- 26:17actual cost value trap that Doug was talking about.
- 26:20They bought a replacement value coverage policy, put that
- 26:24replacement value coverage low, balled the actual cost of
- 26:28rebuilding their home because insurance companies are using
- 26:32standard algorithms across the country to estimate what it
- 26:35might cost to rebuild your home, and those algorithms are
- 26:39underestimating that cost. So one thing we urge consumers
- 26:42to do is confirm with their agent that they know the details
- 26:47of the home that they live in. Make sure they have all of the
- 26:51specifications of your home and that you know the form wasn't,
- 26:54for example, auto filled with the wrong information.
- 26:56Because that has left a lot of folks in the wake of some of
- 26:59these Los Angeles, Northern California, other fires here in
- 27:03California finding out too late that they were insured for up to
- 27:07500,000 when a rebuild is really going to cost 750,000.
- 27:12Well, we've covered a lot of ground here, but just scratched
- 27:14the surface. So I'm going to put links to
- 27:16much more information in the show notes for everybody
- 27:18listening. Want to thank our guest, Doug
- 27:20Heller. He is director of insurance at
- 27:22the Consumer Federation of America.
- 27:23Doug, is there a website where people can go to find more
- 27:26information about insurance issues?
- 27:27Absolutely. We always love people to visit
- 27:29consumerfed.org. And Carmen Balver is executive
- 27:32director of Consumer Watchdog. Carmen, it was great to talk to
- 27:35you. Where do folks reach you?
- 27:37Come to consumerwatchdog.org. Individual complaints?
- 27:40Can they contact you as well? Absolutely.
- 27:42We are collecting complaints, trying to both help folks out
- 27:46where we can and tell their stories when we can't so we can
- 27:50drive policy change. Well, that was a fascinating
- 27:52discussion. Before we go a related Consumer
- 27:55PD episode you might want to check out #40 Insuring Your
- 27:58Home. It's loaded with tips and advice
- 28:01on buying homeowners insurance. We found that it's possible to
- 28:04save $1000 or more a year simply by shopping around.
- 28:09And with that, we've come to the end of another episode.
- 28:11We hope you'll rate this and follow us on Apple Podcasts,
- 28:14Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 28:17And remember, we release new episodes every other Thursday.
- 28:21Another way you can support this show is to follow us at
- 28:23Consumerpedia on Facebook and Instagram, at consumerpedia.org
- 28:28on Blue Sky, and at My Consumerpedia on X.
- 28:31You'll find me at consumerman.com.
- 28:34I'm her wise mom, always looking out for you.
- 28:37Until next time, be smart and shop wisely.
- 28:41Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 28:44We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 28:47smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 28:49help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 28:53ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 28:55If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 28:59Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 29:03Minneapolis, Saint Paul, Seattle, San Francisco and
- 29:07Washington DC. To get your free 30 day
- 29:09subscription, go to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia
- 29:13Consumer Pedia. Empowering consumers to save
- 29:16money and make smarter choices.