Latest / Newcomer Pod / Travis Kalanick's Right-Hand Man Tells the Story of the Coup that Brought Them Down (w/Emil Michael)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome back on Sally. Hey everybody, Welcome to Dead
- 0:15cat. This is are newcomer and I'm
- 0:17here with Tom dote on. We've got a very exciting guest
- 0:21Emil, Michael the former Chief business officer Uber, and the
- 0:25right-hand man to Travis kalanick is joining us, meal was
- 0:30Uber's chief dealmaker. He was instrumental in the
- 0:32company's battle, in China and Emil had his hand in almost
- 0:36every potted Uber from 2013 to 2017.
- 0:40Helped it raise those billions and billions of dollars for sure
- 0:4515:15. Exactly certainly.
- 0:49It's like on the back of your baseball card, you know, like
- 0:52career stats, raise 15 billion, controversial figure, I think we
- 0:56can say portrayed as sort of a shady character on TV series
- 1:00super pumped, though, as you'll soon hear and probably have
- 1:03already picked up meal, is much more a chatty.
- 1:07Extrovert that I think the character in his show, we're
- 1:11going to talk about the Uber files.
- 1:13They'll latest sort of investigative journalism into
- 1:17Travis kalanick era, Uber, spearheaded by the guardian.
- 1:20And we'll talk a little bit about super pumped, but, you
- 1:24know, I think there's so much, like, sort of the real world
- 1:27Uber to talk about Emile, is a A Critic of both how the media has
- 1:32covered Uber over the years and some what I think, or definitely
- 1:36a Critic for the current CEO dark house or shaii.
- 1:38So, we'll talk about that Tom. And I have both spent so much
- 1:42time covering noubar, you know, me earlier and him later.
- 1:45And so this is this is a dream you know as talk to you sort of
- 1:49on the record. Thanks thanks for joining us
- 1:51here. In a way, the podcast was always
- 1:53headed towards this moment. Yeah.
- 1:56Okay. Controversial getting people,
- 1:58come back to that, Eric I just want to know, like what is like
- 2:03the Heyday of uber to you, or like, you know everybody.
- 2:06Listening is by guest knows Uber and sort of like, you know, the
- 2:11magic of it at the time, but just like, did you like raising
- 2:14all the money, the China thing, or like, what was to you like,
- 2:18what may like, uber so fun, or like, what was like, the good,
- 2:21what were the good old days of uber?
- 2:23You know, I joined in 2013, and that was before.
- 2:29Uber had raised the money from from Google.
- 2:32So, so before that Uber's market cap was like three hundred
- 2:35million dollars, right? And this was, it was still a
- 2:38small company. 200 people, 360 three to five cities, 14 was
- 2:46when sort of the whole thing accelerated, like almost
- 2:50vertically. We just joke that was almost
- 2:52vertical. That was bending back was
- 2:56growing. And that is what?
- 3:00We raised from the third this 17 billion dollar round which shook
- 3:04sort of fundraising for the first time right?
- 3:07At that time, two companies had raised these steel deck, the
- 3:11Unicorn, round Airbnb. And Dropbox have both been sent
- 3:15out of ten billion dollar around and when we were raising money,
- 3:18we used to call them compay and comp D.
- 3:20And we said like look how much better our businesses that
- 3:23company and Humpty we raised at 17 billion dollar round.
- 3:26Be launched in China, we launched in Russia.
- 3:29To, I think going into Susan 2015, we launched ubereats, we
- 3:34did successive rounds. That went from 17 billion to 40,
- 3:39to 50, to 70, to all between 2014 and June of 16.
- 3:45So, that 24 months was an insane amount of growth progress
- 3:52valuation increase. We did that at the end of 60 or
- 3:55August of 16. We sold the business in China to
- 3:58China, which at the time. That meant we went from, you
- 4:01know, we spent 2 billion in China turned into what was
- 4:03worth, 10 billion at the time. So those those were the good
- 4:06days and to give you credit for it here, like where it's do the
- 4:11fundraising and aggressive, you know, valuations structure and
- 4:16strategy. That's you're working, right?
- 4:18I mean that would really was something that you devised and
- 4:21led and kind of made your signature almost throughout your
- 4:24time at the company, right. That was the thing.
- 4:26I was most known for and spent the most time One and Travis and
- 4:32I sort of agreed on what we thought it's from your of a
- 4:36purist approach to this. You guys have been around
- 4:39fundraising for startups. For a lot of your careers, we
- 4:43did this thing that was actually characterized in the in the show
- 4:46a little bit called the home show, right?
- 4:48And, and what that meant to really, besides being the fact
- 4:51that it was at our office was, we never asked for a price, we
- 4:55never said, here's the valuation.
- 4:56We wants like a lot of companies.
- 4:58Do we said here's the data? How we're going to do three
- 5:01meetings a day for 10 business days.
- 5:04So we're going to meet 30 investors, right?
- 5:07And you are going to these investors.
- 5:10If you're interested, you put a bid in of how much you want to
- 5:12spend invest in at what valuation.
- 5:15And we decided only thing we decided is we want to raise a
- 5:18billion dollars or 1.5 billion. And we put a spreadsheet
- 5:21together and whoever bid above the price which yielded the
- 5:26amount of money we raised, that was it.
- 5:28We close the deal. Even if you like somebody, you
- 5:31didn't help people come to the right price ever.
- 5:34We've the whole idea of this was to have it be market-based and
- 5:40if you start doing this well this is a price.
- 5:43We want you get into a negotiation and everyone feels
- 5:46bad at the end because you feel like you left money on the
- 5:48table, they feel like they overpaid.
- 5:51So this was sort of a purist auction kind of thing you could
- 5:55imagine for a private company just what we're talking about
- 5:57pricing because it is fascinating like This Audi
- 6:00around this 69, 72, whatever, pre-post money like.
- 6:05Did they overpay, did you think they overpaid in with what we
- 6:09know now to they overpay because that question matters so much
- 6:12for evaluating Dara's leadership.
- 6:14Right, you Peg that price is fair.
- 6:16He looks really bad. If it was like an insane price
- 6:19to pay, he could look better. I mean, would ya, is that a fair
- 6:23price to Benchmark him against was it a reasonable price?
- 6:27Well, I mean tiger Global Pay. Price Capital recent way.
- 6:32I know, you know, I'm not telling you sort of the oh sure.
- 6:35Hey, that price, right. I think marks, tatted Dragon
- 6:38near pay that price. Like all the sophisticated
- 6:41Capital research, pay that price, BlackRock played that
- 6:44price like everyone that was one big round.
- 6:47That was the biggest round ever done.
- 6:48Five and a half billion dollars, three and a half weeks which
- 6:50Saudis and Saudis didn't price that the sophisticatedly stage
- 6:56Financial guys priced at Saudis joined it.
- 6:58There was sort of a follow on So based on where we were growing
- 7:02and now round was done in 16 that was a valid price.
- 7:06I think that price today had we had we continued and we could
- 7:10debate this more if you want. I think the company would have
- 7:13been worth to 300 billion today and that would have been a great
- 7:15price to pay right? And before we get to you know,
- 7:19where you know Uber is today and the Uber files and all the stuff
- 7:22we want to get into this episode.
- 7:24You know as we're in kind of the positive reminiscing of things I
- 7:28mean that's you is what you remember the most fun Lee of
- 7:30your time, you know at the top of uber is kind of the
- 7:33Rocketship fundraising experience being part of this.
- 7:36Once at the time thought of like once in a generation company and
- 7:39sort of accelerating its growth through fueling its fundraising
- 7:43all that stuff. I mean, is there anything else
- 7:44you kind of? Hang onto, yeah, do so.
- 7:47So the notion that America and American tech company could do
- 7:51business in China was incredible at the time.
- 7:55Yeah, I don't know if you remember, it was a lot of
- 7:56optimism us China relations and In 2013, 15, 16 Zuckerberg was
- 8:02going there, trying to convince president G to get Facebook
- 8:05launched. He was learning Mandarin, he was
- 8:08learning, Mandarin LinkedIn, had launched a subsidiary out there,
- 8:12Airbnb launches subsidiary out, there we work.
- 8:15All the companies were trying to get in and do burr was the most
- 8:18successful of that crowd and it was really exciting to be there
- 8:22at the time for that. So that was really mind-blowing
- 8:25experience as well and I mean working with Travis I mean just
- 8:29tribe that because I feel like the show.
- 8:31I mean a lot of people know, even sort of people are
- 8:34extremely critical of Travis say oh the Travis and Super Pump,
- 8:38doesn't really reflect any of his virtues like you worked so
- 8:43closely with him. I mean what-what was that
- 8:45working relationship? Like and what?
- 8:47What's he like like what sort of that, what's that style?
- 8:50I think he's one of the best. Entrepreneurs have this
- 8:54generation. And what his super power was and
- 8:58is was thinking globally from day one?
- 9:02And he was a, why not versus why, like why not try China and
- 9:07really? Well, Facebook fail, Google
- 9:09filled that I he said, but why are we going to fill their?
- 9:12And you didn't have a good answer and he was right, and
- 9:15here's the example of it. If you're a mayor and a big
- 9:18Chinese City and you had DD there, you didn't want him an
- 9:21opportunity. Polly on ride-sharing, you want
- 9:24a competition. So we would go there and the
- 9:26mayor's. Like we please keep you here in
- 9:29China and Chengdu. So we had this thing and he was
- 9:33right that we were just there and we were in a digital
- 9:36business and we didn't have the same sort of overhang on
- 9:38censorship and all that that some social media is it but we
- 9:41were on the ground business and he was right about that.
- 9:44So he was just incredibly ambitious.
- 9:46He was never a chest-beating ape-like, the show made it sound
- 9:50to be, he actually hate what? We sat in the office was the
- 9:53quietest part of the office because he didn't like noise.
- 9:56We're going like people yelling, so sort of really weird
- 9:59characterization of him. But he's also he's not Brian
- 10:03chesky wasn't the the soft and fuzzy, right?
- 10:07In this case is well into the Uber files stuff because I mean,
- 10:10I feel like the why not attitude, right?
- 10:13Is sort of the explanation for some of their you've referred to
- 10:17the early days mentality is almost like Pirates, you know.
- 10:20And obviously there was sort of an Press decision on the part of
- 10:24legal top rate in sort of gray areas following the experience
- 10:28with lift and others launching peer-to-peer ride cherien serum
- 10:31San Francisco. So that that's sort of an
- 10:34organizing principle to me. I mean, time, do you want to
- 10:36sort of frame up the Uber files real quickly?
- 10:39Yeah. Sure.
- 10:39The Uber files which came out a couple of weeks ago, our this
- 10:43massive Trove of documents 125,000.
- 10:47If you earned a numbers that were released by whistleblower
- 10:50to the UK In and the icij in a bunch of newspapers around the
- 10:55world. Not me that detailed essentially
- 10:58Ubers expansion into Europe. The Whistleblower turned out to
- 11:01be this guy Mark began, but basically the bulk of these
- 11:05files are internal Communications between
- 11:08high-level Uber execs including Travis, that explained Uber's
- 11:13policy strategy in. I mean, I would argue going to
- 11:16brute forcing its way onto the continent and you know, these
- 11:20files begat a series of articles.
- 11:22It's essentially, if I to boil them down the big reveals here
- 11:26were Uber use this tool like gray ball which essentially
- 11:31dupes Regulators. There's this kill switch, which
- 11:34wipes computers inside the, which I'd reported.
- 11:37You knew you're going to jump in with that.
- 11:38A lot of you over files have been report.
- 11:40We can talk about that but so there's the kill switch.
- 11:42You know, there's also very aggressive lobbying of officials
- 11:45in Europe like macron and France which was kind of funny to me,
- 11:49British officials. There is some pretty kind of
- 11:51arrogant emails Biden. I took the lobby news, like,
- 11:54uber is good at his job, right? Just one last thing to kind of
- 11:57frame it up for people who haven't read.
- 11:59All of these articles, too many articles by the way, is that,
- 12:01you know, these stories came out a couple weeks ago.
- 12:03I don't think they made the huge splash.
- 12:05The outcome is sort of unclear. There is some talk of, maybe an
- 12:08inquiry of Micron and the French government, you know, there's a
- 12:11bit of blowback in London based on the way they forced their way
- 12:14in there but that's sort of been it but the whole episode kind of
- 12:17exhumed the messiest time. Maybe our Garrick would argue
- 12:21the - time of covering Uber. Right now we get to talk about
- 12:24that are of uber. Now, the tamils got enough
- 12:26distance that he's willing to be open about it.
- 12:28He's not paranoid that it just happened.
- 12:30So it's an excuse for us to re-litigate the old days.
- 12:33Which emile's just smiling. I'm ready to know what?
- 12:37He's is reaction. Alright, well and I know you'll
- 12:39smile the biggest at this part of it Emile.
- 12:40Because the last thing I'll say, is that boobers response to
- 12:43almost all of this stuff has been like, Kanye from 808 and
- 12:46heartbreaks. Like, I know I did some things
- 12:48but that was the old me. So that's it.
- 12:51That's the over. Else.
- 12:52I know Emile you have a lot to say about it here and I set it
- 12:55up a lot here. But what's what are you
- 12:58thinking? What's your mind?
- 13:00Actually, as you know, the Articles first come out and, you
- 13:02know, they end up being all about your time at the company.
- 13:06You know, the icij I think is an Inquisitor incredible
- 13:11organization, right? The things they did with the
- 13:12Panama papers, like, I mean, he's truly revolutionary
- 13:15groundbreaking stuff, I was surprised they took this on Five
- 13:20Years After It and it really. What if you end up with the
- 13:25opposition party in France, saying hey mccrone, you should
- 13:27not be talking to CEOs of companies that are trying to do
- 13:30business in France, and that's it.
- 13:31You know, that's the backdrop. That's what they did with 80
- 13:34journalists and all these unfounded argument, hundreds of
- 13:37thousands of documents. I just, it would seem to
- 13:39unimpressive. Now, I'm biased on that, but,
- 13:42you know, the example of Travis saying about the Biden thing
- 13:46like, oh, every minute he doesn't spend with, he's late
- 13:49isn't me? I guess humors lost.
- 13:51Wait, what? Say it again.
- 13:53There was this comment that. Oh yeah yeah that felt like a
- 13:57classic Travis where he's like he's going to get less time with
- 13:59me of like he's yeah. But you said it was a joke or
- 14:02you think it was a it was a joke.
- 14:04Yes. Okay.
- 14:05I was with Travis that I was with Travis as he walked into
- 14:08the bite of meat, but it's a joke as in, it's funny to people
- 14:12to think of Travis having so much Swagger that he would say
- 14:15that somewhat sincerely or a like that.
- 14:18Is that the type of joke? Or it's a joke that reflects
- 14:21level I'm really important to, you know, or he doesn't think
- 14:25you're. Yeah, explain the joke, explain
- 14:27the joke. It's in, choke them that we were
- 14:31characterized as these arrogant Bros, right?
- 14:35Oh, hey, every time he doesn't get this, you know, he he's
- 14:39lady, doesn't get spent a minute with me, right?
- 14:41It was that kind of thing, and then Dust by the way.
- 14:43Just for fact at to add to the fact he sat with Biden, I was
- 14:47there. And then by this, like wow, this
- 14:48was fun. You should stay for this
- 14:50meeting. I'm having with the chance.
- 14:52Mm, so on and Travis like awesome, I could stay with you,
- 14:54and they, they hung out for like two hours and did foreign policy
- 14:57meetings. Well, this wasn't, it wasn't
- 14:59like Charles. Like I'm out of here, buddy,
- 15:00right? You know, you've lost your time
- 15:02with me. It was a, it was a fun thing.
- 15:04So, which is such a classic media thing that everything
- 15:07comes across. So humorless, if it's like part
- 15:10of a headline story, I'll add to it though.
- 15:12That one of the things, I really struck me about the files
- 15:15themselves, as the relates to the politicians, is it spoke so
- 15:19much to the era of how much a lot of political School leaders
- 15:22wanted to be cozy with tech and it seems.
- 15:26We're the pendulum has swung, maybe not the full Direction the
- 15:29other way. But during the Obama era
- 15:31specifically and I guess this is also touching a woman to Trump.
- 15:33There was a real connection between politicians and Tech
- 15:37seeing it as this upstart Innovative socially Progressive
- 15:42industry, that they wanted to be attached to one because there is
- 15:45a lot of money but also is like okay I don't it's bad to Cozy up
- 15:48to Wall Street. But these Tech Guys and you
- 15:50know, San Francisco and Silicon Valley bad.
- 15:51I Do that makes me look cool. Let's all go work there after
- 15:55after Obama's done and and I think you could kind of see a
- 15:57little bit of that with, you know, macron maybe and to a
- 16:01lesser extent by didn't. But it just seemed generally
- 16:03there was like a warmth between politicians and and Tech that in
- 16:07retrospect seems a bit misguided.
- 16:09Are, you can see, ya, misguided is your word and your opinion,
- 16:12but I would say, like, when when Obama went down to Cuba to open
- 16:16up, he took Brian chesky with him.
- 16:18You know, he took with mccrone was Finance Minister his hole.
- 16:22Platform was we need more tech companies to be doing business
- 16:25in France, and to hire our own people, so that they can get
- 16:29experience in it. Dissolve, your Neil, all the big
- 16:32French industrialist from really wanted tech companies to
- 16:36establish in France, especially if they were on the ground tech
- 16:39companies not digital with they took all the money out because
- 16:42remember for Uber, 80% of the money went to drivers who are
- 16:45local, the employees were local and they were paid salaries
- 16:49there. So we weren't more as extracted
- 16:51like the Set of tech companies and politicians absolutely
- 16:55wanted to know us and other tech companies that was nothing new.
- 16:59So when they say aggressive lobbying I don't know.
- 17:02I mean there's does President Biden meet with foreign CEOs
- 17:05when they come to the u.s. of course he does.
- 17:07So this thing, wasn't. None of it was illegal.
- 17:11That nothing in the icij said, any?
- 17:14This was wrong. They said it was aggressive,
- 17:16right? And it was aggressive, we were
- 17:19growing aggressively. So, what's wrong with that?
- 17:23The lobbying is not like, oh, they are promising him a job or
- 17:26so it makes sense, Uber was a high-stakes sort of policy issue
- 17:29that politicians were campaigning on and against.
- 17:33And so, it made sense that you would go to the top, you know,
- 17:35the most powerful person you could to get them to weigh in on
- 17:39an issue? Yeah.
- 17:40That one doesn't resonate with me, but the fact is also that
- 17:43Uber did end up, please. Correct me if I'm wrong here
- 17:46because I'm not the expert on this are that you guys are but
- 17:48boober ends up going into a lot of these countries fairly Unless
- 17:52you know, with it not a ton of huge pushback that stops them
- 17:55from doing more or less what they wanted to do, right?
- 17:57They were kind of untrammeled entering into these places and
- 18:00ends up getting into, you know, a lot of spats with taxi unions
- 18:04in the country and there is, you know, one of the revelations in
- 18:08the Uber files is traversing pretty blithely.
- 18:10If there's violence in France, you know, between the Uber
- 18:13drivers in the taxi Union, that's good for us because, you
- 18:16know, violence, she puts the Union in a bad light.
- 18:18I mean, those sort of things seem like uber wasn't
- 18:20contravenes with Policy with regulation and with the you know
- 18:24the local taxi unions that I think a lot of people find
- 18:26pretty unsavory. I mean let's take a minute and
- 18:30talk about taxi organizations all over the world.
- 18:33These are government created monopolies where the taxi
- 18:38Medallion owners and most big cities around the world are cozy
- 18:41with politicians they protected the number of medallions so
- 18:45there was no competition, the taxi drivers themselves were
- 18:49essentially paid like indentured servants They took people right
- 18:53off the immigration lines and they said, you're going to rent
- 18:56this taxi for $800 a week and you don't make a single dollar
- 19:00until your Affairs exceed that we're not going to drop you off.
- 19:02In Harlem. We're not going to pick up black
- 19:04people there. I mean this was a corrupt nasty
- 19:08industry and almost every city in the world.
- 19:10So it is absolutely true that to go in and get your business
- 19:15model to be accepted. You couldn't ask like, hey can I
- 19:18we allowed to do ride-sharing here, guys like maybe you know,
- 19:22You had to really show consumers and drivers a better path.
- 19:27And there's a reason why By ignoring regulation, or there
- 19:31was a vacuum, a lot of places do was just no regulation, right?
- 19:36And some of the regulations were anti-consumer in Miami.
- 19:39For example, you could not price a ride for less than $50.
- 19:43If you weren't a taxi, couldn't do it.
- 19:46How's that pro-consumer? So yes, if that if we broke that
- 19:49regulation, who's benefiting, and Who's losing their I want to
- 19:53answer Tom sting because regular Ubers breaking regulations
- 19:56banking regulation breaker so Airbnb was breaking regulations.
- 20:00The taxi Union that taxi medallions themselves were
- 20:04antitrust they were violating antitrust laws you know in many
- 20:07states in the US the state can sue a municipality for antitrust
- 20:11behavior and they weren't enforced in that against their
- 20:14own taxi operations in these cities.
- 20:17So there was this this industry was ugly dark, it was Is really
- 20:22dirty and you had to do something.
- 20:26If you were on Roger due to exist and by the way two thirds
- 20:29of the world now has ride-sharing.
- 20:31And what would the world be like if no one ever tried to break
- 20:34the taxi and I trust Monopoly and it is a fair criticism that
- 20:38a lot of these Uber haters take boobers.
- 20:41Like I honestly some people try to roll their eyes it's like no
- 20:43you believe that the service is so essential that it was worth
- 20:47like fighting for I yeah, I know that not to be You know.
- 20:52Yeah, I agree with you bir people on that.
- 20:54Yeah, it's just so you can have your view as that no business
- 20:58should should break and unfair regulation in order to give
- 21:02consumers a taste of what it would be like to have a service
- 21:05that met their needs. That's an argument one can make
- 21:08and then but you have to make the same thing with your between
- 21:10B and lots of other businesses that do that on the on the kill
- 21:15switch thing that you wrote about Eric, almost all tech
- 21:18companies do this in foreign countries.
- 21:20And the reason why is that If they're connected to the main
- 21:24database of the company, they don't want anyone government
- 21:27raid to sort of expose all the company's data, inclusions their
- 21:30user data, which they get fined for have to disclose the FTC.
- 21:34So, we have a shutdown that's separate from a subpoena.
- 21:38If you got a subpoena, Uber or any company instead, we want
- 21:40these documents, they're entitled to them, and no one's
- 21:44ever accused Uber of not providing documents that any law
- 21:49enforcement agency asked for, and that's why would Eric It
- 21:52says is it was no consequences because they did was just
- 21:55nothing illegal about shutting down computers.
- 21:57If there's not a warrant that says, I need this that or the
- 22:00other. Well, let's not talk about
- 22:02shutting down computers. Oh, right.
- 22:03This is wiping of hard drives. I mean, this is like, oh, it
- 22:05wasn't but no one accused him or even Jill.
- 22:09His vicar statement saying, we know and nothing was ever wiped.
- 22:11Okay, read the stuff they're locking locking down stiffer
- 22:15than what. What, why does that old?
- 22:17Okay, that's that's slightly. Different than what companies do
- 22:19like in China. Say, where I think a kill
- 22:20switch, had been Fairly, you know, de facto for a lot of
- 22:23companies and that to me could be wrong here.
- 22:25And if I am, I'll cut it. I mean, that is wiping of drives
- 22:29to prevent the government from there.
- 22:30What? I began drives.
- 22:31A whole different ballgame, says destruction of evidence.
- 22:33Would you see legal almost anywhere?
- 22:35Right? But okay, okay, but but shutting
- 22:38down, so that you have a proper warrant and you're giving them
- 22:40exactly what they asked for is not illegal.
- 22:43I do think one of the bad things we did.
- 22:44A new Brew is naming things, terribly that the kill switch
- 22:49real Contrition there, ya know. Okay, and I guess you would
- 22:53probably include within that ghraib, although I don't.
- 22:55What is that even in? Referee ball?
- 22:56Hell, I was one of them. Yeah, War Room, hell great.
- 23:01I think these things were meant to be provocative but they took
- 23:04on a life of you guys leaned into the Pirates, Motif for
- 23:07sure. But since we're on the
- 23:08regulation side of things, I mean, looking back on this.
- 23:11Now, everything that was explored in the Uber files and
- 23:14stuff that Mike Isaac wrote about with gray ball and Eric,
- 23:16we already talked about the kill switch.
- 23:18You think it was all Justified, you think there was no other way
- 23:21that boober could. Approached any of these
- 23:22countries entered a way that was maybe more in accordance with
- 23:26regulation wouldn't have seen as you know, well-funded Tech
- 23:31American tech company barging into these places up ending
- 23:34things and sort of letting the pieces fall where they may.
- 23:37You don't think it could have gone done any differently.
- 23:40I mean, yeah, I think in any one instance to probably could have
- 23:43been done differently but you didn't know ahead of time what
- 23:46the resistance was and what it wasn't and sometimes that pain
- 23:49depending on, who is in charge, what was the I meant, so you had
- 23:53to take bets on what it was going to be like.
- 23:56And and, you know, we were kicked out of Germany, South
- 23:59Korea. There's some countries that like
- 24:00were effective at resisting Uber.
- 24:06All you all, you could say, Tom, is that you like we could have
- 24:08gone slower and I think we just would have been in less places.
- 24:14Well, okay, slower, in that case, sort of sounds obviously
- 24:16bad as an investment, you know, it sounds like it's maybe not as
- 24:19pro-consumer or they'll maybe we can get into that.
- 24:21But It's also, you know, government and you know people
- 24:25deciding to have input on the way business is conducted in
- 24:28their countries is just fundamentally slower than a
- 24:31business. I mean, that's just the way
- 24:33large masses of people work. Yeah.
- 24:35So so if you want to do get pre regulated, Uber wouldn't exist
- 24:40today. I mean, it just it's, you can't
- 24:42have it both ways. Like you had, you had monopolies
- 24:47controlling the transportation systems donating to politicians.
- 24:51Protecting their Hide when you think monopolies, do you mean
- 24:53unions right? Even attacks a union Medallion
- 24:56system the medallions, okay? Okay.
- 24:58And they were, never going toward a lens, no matter how
- 25:01slow, no matter how lobbying, how much love you did, unless
- 25:04you showed consumers, something else that was better.
- 25:07And once you did, that consumers told their politicians.
- 25:11We want that. And that was a deliberate
- 25:14strategy. So there was no other way to
- 25:16break that Monopoly. Hmm, there's so many criticisms
- 25:20of uber some some worse. Just some last like I feel like
- 25:23a challenge with discussing all this has become such like a
- 25:27laundry list and I think we would all probably agree that
- 25:31the Public's sort of like the things they hate boober for the
- 25:36most are not necessarily like to me the best reasons at least to
- 25:41object to burrow the most viral thing that happened was like
- 25:45delete boober which had to do with like the tide of trump.
- 25:48It was like, super, super incoherent.
- 25:51You've said, Don other interviews that boober had some
- 25:53like, you know, it grew too fast and have good corporate culture,
- 25:56but there's certainly a degree to, which the lens was on, Uber,
- 26:00in a way that it wasn't on other companies.
- 26:01And if Oracle or somebody sustain the level of like, I
- 26:05don't know, corporate culture investigation.
- 26:07I would suspect that it would have had troubling stories to
- 26:11then there's sort of this sort of gray area, regulation, sort
- 26:15of fighting with governments area.
- 26:17I mean, I think how the drivers are treated to me is like the
- 26:20clearest, like real Sort of moral issue at play, some people
- 26:24would say like the independent contractor like system is just
- 26:28like unredeemable. I don't, I wouldn't say that
- 26:31the, like, the leasing program was something that I wrote about
- 26:34back in the early days where you got, there were cases where, you
- 26:37know, drivers and this is sort of Illustrated in the driver
- 26:40video where drivers get sort of like hooked or they're making
- 26:44money on Uber. They want to make it their
- 26:46career, they might lease a vehicle and then they're sort of
- 26:49basically you're offloading the capital.
- 26:51To the drivers and then, you know, they're they're sort of
- 26:56the ones taking the risk without necessarily knowing where Ubers
- 26:58business is going to go. I mean, do you think Uber has
- 27:02been good for drivers and do you agree that that's sort of the
- 27:06area where a sort of like the moral sort of criticism is, is
- 27:11the most significant. You know, it's a hard thing and
- 27:14I'll give you, I think the history of this is important,
- 27:18right? Uber started with black cars,
- 27:20the black card Driver. Who Loved Uber at the time, was
- 27:24one who had a two-hour job in the morning after our job at
- 27:27night, and they're like holy cow in the middle, I can make
- 27:30additional money and this was great and I could do the short
- 27:34trips and so on and the prices were high.
- 27:37It was geared toward the black car customer, right?
- 27:41And then, Uber started to say, like these drivers started
- 27:44saying, well, hey, why don't I just do this full-time have full
- 27:46control my schedule. I can make more money and so on
- 27:50and that whole thing kind of I worked and drivers were
- 27:52relatively happy. We're really.
- 27:54When you got to Uber acts that you started to have hard
- 27:59decisions to make because you had a black car driver, who's
- 28:02doing this for a living, right? And then you had an alternative
- 28:06that was half the price and they'd say this black car
- 28:09drivers, say well, hold on. My customers are now going to do
- 28:12this other uberX thing, and I'm going to lose them and they're
- 28:15they're half price. So you started to say, like,
- 28:18okay, we had different price points for different products.
- 28:22One was cannibalizing, the other.
- 28:24So, is that a, what is the the ethics for the morality of that?
- 28:27I don't know. It's a hard question because,
- 28:30you know, it was a better product that had more
- 28:32applicability and some people decided I'd rather pay half the
- 28:36price and being a less nice car. Right?
- 28:38That was that was one stage. The second stage were, was you
- 28:42had these bonuses come drive for Uber.
- 28:44You get 50 rides, you get a five hundred dollar bonus or
- 28:47wherever, and people, if they came to I think that that was
- 28:52going to go on forever. They felt really let down when
- 28:55that didn't last forever, but a lot of businesses do that, you
- 28:59get a free month of Spotify. You get a free this to entice.
- 29:02You to try it but that deal doesn't last forever.
- 29:06I think the hard part here is, if you quit your job to join
- 29:10Uber or you at least a car to join Uber with an expectation
- 29:14that you were going to make this much money over time, you felt
- 29:17bad. And there was, there is
- 29:18something there and an Uber to be clear.
- 29:20You know, I remember is 20, Routine or 2014, Uber was
- 29:23actively putting out stats. That were just unrealistic about
- 29:26the amount of money that a driver can make on the platform.
- 29:28And remember, there were stories saying that drivers in DC or
- 29:31some city were making ninety thousand dollars a year.
- 29:33In New York is New York. Yeah, bullshit.
- 29:36Right. I mean, how many drivers
- 29:38wherever making that much money in a way that could be
- 29:40justifiably promoted to people, as you know, an income you could
- 29:43make on this platform? Yeah, I think that that
- 29:46particular instance of the goober got fine for, for that
- 29:50piece, but it was, you know, For advertising that was 90,000 one.
- 29:54It wasn't the average. Like yes there was a definitely
- 29:56drivers who made a more than 90,000 but it wasn't the average
- 29:59and so give an impression that wasn't quite an Uber definitely
- 30:02did a lot of like hiding the ball on how much drivers were
- 30:06like full-time versus part-time and the messaging would be very
- 30:09aggressive about the part-time drivers.
- 30:12When they were certainly people who are making their career but
- 30:15what but what do go back to what changed, what's changed?
- 30:19And this is even before Dara's regime.
- 30:21To go over is the driver bass turned into 80 90 percent
- 30:26part-time, 10 hours a week or less because of food or no, it
- 30:30just beat it. Just burned through it, just
- 30:33people just didn't want to do it for a living.
- 30:36They had other things that they would do that were more
- 30:39full-time. But for whatever reason is, it
- 30:40turned into more of a. Hey, I didn't want to take my
- 30:43girlfriend out to dinner this Friday, I need to drive and make
- 30:46some money. I want to buy a Christmas gift,
- 30:48so it turned into a gap filler as opposed to Profession.
- 30:53And that's where it gets weird again.
- 30:55Because then you're like, okay, these people actually that
- 30:57you've seen the service didn't want to be employees.
- 30:59They want to be the one to do this for a little bit.
- 31:02They want to do doordash, they want to not work for three
- 31:05weeks, and so now it's ironic that we're trying to give
- 31:09employee go and some people are trying to giving employment
- 31:11benefits to people who don't want them because they're
- 31:13actually doing it. So, little time of their week
- 31:17that it doesn't make sense. It actually made more sense when
- 31:20the Black Card drivers were doing it full-time.
- 31:22Then they add, they were kind of closer to being employees
- 31:25because the amount of time in the Reliance they had on the
- 31:27system. So that's why there was
- 31:29different eras of how Uber treated drivers.
- 31:33And and what were the mistakes in each era.
- 31:35It's it's difficult I think, for drivers because the sense I get
- 31:39from talking to them, is that, you know, the union is so, it's
- 31:42a complicated concept for a lot of them.
- 31:45It doesn't really apply in the way unions are structured now,
- 31:47because so many of them are part-time because they drop in
- 31:49and out. And yet, what they really want
- 31:51is, Ability of income. And I actually disagree with
- 31:54you, I do think they want some sort of benefits.
- 31:56I think the system as its, you know, the broader us Healthcare
- 31:59System and other kind of insurance systems are set up.
- 32:02So poorly now that they just look towards some sort of
- 32:04company to providing for them, and you know, what exists?
- 32:07Now, with prop 22 is not very satisfying to a lot of people,
- 32:10but yeah, I actually don't think they don't want benefits.
- 32:13I do think they want something, they want some sort of security,
- 32:16and an Uber kind of sort of provides that but not in a way
- 32:19that's reliable. And I think the proof in the
- 32:20pudding, is that There is such high turnover, right?
- 32:23That no drivers sticks on the platform for more than a couple
- 32:26months. I mean, who Burr is just
- 32:27churning constantly through a driver base and it's never
- 32:31gotten better. I think this is necessarily a
- 32:35job function, that is a temporary filler in pids, become
- 32:40that way down. You can say, Uber made it that
- 32:42way or it's become that way regardless.
- 32:45It is that way I do think someone driving 40 hours a week,
- 32:48it has to be thought of differently than someone who's
- 32:50doing it eight hours. A week and then doing doordash
- 32:53and then going to school and that, you know, have a their
- 32:57income spread over a lot of different places.
- 33:00And yeah, there has to be some way.
- 33:02That's why frankly, I think Obamacare is a good broads
- 33:06change from the health care regime in the US before that.
- 33:10And so, yes. Could it could you conceptually
- 33:12say that this person is making 10 percent of their income from
- 33:15Uber? They should can contribute 10%
- 33:17toward the benefits that they would get.
- 33:20If there are full-time. Please.
- 33:21Yeah. There's There's something like
- 33:22that there that probably makes sense.
- 33:25That's fair. But what else?
- 33:27How what I was there's no perfect system here?
- 33:30Yeah, take a look fried you take a goober ride, you do doordash,
- 33:33you do your, do your home and Airbnb.
- 33:36It's like, people are just amalgamating a lot of different
- 33:39income streams. And how do you deal with that?
- 33:41That's a, that's a national problem, it's not just an Uber
- 33:43problem. Yeah.
- 33:45Actually, before we move fully off of the Uber files, I do want
- 33:48to get to the response that boober the company had to it.
- 33:52People can't see it. So she released a video but Emil
- 33:54is shaking his head and rolling his eyes.
- 33:56I mean, like I said, in my intro of it, basically, Uber says that
- 34:00isn't us anymore, that was that regime?
- 34:02They love throwing Travis and you and that whole era under the
- 34:05bus as a response to any sort of reminder of what you guys were
- 34:09doing. What do you think?
- 34:11I mean what a gaslighting. Like, I was stunned.
- 34:17They said you know, don't judge us by what we did five years
- 34:21ago, Justice. We did in the last five years,
- 34:23in the last five years, we were stock prices dropped in half.
- 34:26They've been sued by the doj for overcharging.
- 34:29Disabled people have 20,000 civil rights laws, you know,
- 34:33disputes with a with with people, they just have 500 women
- 34:37sue them for sexual assault. I mean, come on like the private
- 34:41financial performance has been terrible.
- 34:43There's been ninety percent attrition, you know, all the doj
- 34:47has done things because this is a hard business.
- 34:49So give me a break. Number two, insanity is a lot of
- 34:54the people who are doing these things in Europe, with kill,
- 34:58switches and mccrone are still there.
- 35:00The Nelly crew Nelly crows, that wasn't like a Travis.
- 35:03Hey, let's create an Advisory board with all these European
- 35:06politicians. That was the policy team and the
- 35:09person who wrote that document was on the team running The
- 35:12Advisory board that got Nellie crows there.
- 35:14So it's sort of like, are you kidding me and Pierre to meet
- 35:18you? His quote, was like a hostage
- 35:20statement like Pierre Dimitri is the head of ubereats right now.
- 35:24So he's you know, who is you know, someone who crosses both
- 35:27both are has Uber and he's like I'm sorry I was just a young.
- 35:31I was young and immature and I was right.
- 35:33I was being led by unethical people.
- 35:35You're like this guy was a Goldman Sachs.
- 35:37Banker a hedge fund guy in his 30s at never apologized for
- 35:42since then and all sudden. Now it's the battle guys from
- 35:45seven years ago, who made this poor young Goldman, Sachs hedge,
- 35:48fund manager, do things, didn't want to do, like, give me a
- 35:50break. Well, there is an argument.
- 35:51And that strategically the thing that Travis was so bad at was
- 35:57Contrition or apologizing, whichever way you want to put it
- 36:00and dhara is obviously a professional at this point
- 36:04apologizer. I mean at the khashoggi incident
- 36:07suggests otherwise that was a that was a pretty bad one.
- 36:09But we were yes we dhara what? Yeah, don't you remember after
- 36:13deuber. Took money from the Saudis dhara
- 36:15has this interview without any sort of Leo's and they bring up
- 36:18like how do you feel about taking money from the Saudis
- 36:20when they just member? Shogi and they're just like, you
- 36:23know, we all make mistakes which you know they had to apologize
- 36:27for that. But yeah, why wasn't Travis able
- 36:29to like show you agree with that criticism, right?
- 36:32I mean, I know he's your friend but like, he's not very good at
- 36:36apologize. I mean, he pauses a lot in 2017
- 36:39but I think he has it. I but I think that I actually I
- 36:44do think and was some in some hindsight that it's okay to say
- 36:48we did things wrong and here's how we're going to do them
- 36:50better. And to and be accountable for
- 36:54for doing things better and we just didn't, I will say like you
- 36:59imagine being in the most important company in the world
- 37:02for some period of time, that was growing faster than any
- 37:05other company that ever grown. The problems you're seeing are
- 37:08coming non-stop because you have a real on the ground business.
- 37:12I mean, transportation is no joke.
- 37:14People people die in accidents, I mean, it is a real world thing
- 37:18and it's in big cities every day and everyone used to say that.
- 37:21Everything that Ben's in a city happens in an Uber, it's true.
- 37:23So the flood of what was happening was really intense and
- 37:27no one had ever done it before. There was no Playbook.
- 37:30So yeah, we made mistakes and probably should have said more,
- 37:33but not the mistakes that I think people talk about as much
- 37:37as they should. Well.
- 37:38Yeah. What are those mistakes?
- 37:40What are those mistakes? That you think I think.
- 37:42And I've talked about this before, the one thing I wish I
- 37:45had done differently and I'll take responsibility for.
- 37:47This is the revenue is growing like this, right 9 89 degrees.
- 37:52And the company building was growing at like 50 degree 45
- 37:55degrees and that's that causes a dissonance, you're not building
- 37:59guardrails and HR legal finance, that keep a company stable.
- 38:04Okay, I've heard you say, this is what I want to push back
- 38:06like, yeah, a lot of the key to Uber.
- 38:09I mean, you and Travis, especially we're good at really
- 38:14drilling down like some of the most flattering things people
- 38:16say about Travis, is when he has your attention, he's like,
- 38:19jamming with you and sort of saying, let's solve this.
- 38:22And, you know, I we can't go through every one of these
- 38:24controversies improve, the Travis knew what, but there's
- 38:27definitely a sense that Travis was definitely enthusiastic
- 38:30about Creative Solutions around whether it's like, geofencing
- 38:34with apple. Or, you know, these Technologies
- 38:36Travis was aware of them like it was sort of part of his sort of
- 38:40Ingenuity. Right.
- 38:41I mean, so wasn't just like to me the things that you guys were
- 38:44criticized. For besides, maybe the Susan
- 38:47Fowler category were sort of ideas where wasn't It wasn't a
- 38:52bureaucracy problem. It was a sort of judgment
- 38:55question. Well, I was I was, I was talking
- 38:57about taking charge instead of Fowler situations, like you need
- 39:02to have a system that deals with bad behavior inside a company.
- 39:07And most companies, the last five years, I've realized like
- 39:09their systems have been inadequate, right?
- 39:11And so, that was one thing. I wish we'd done better on the
- 39:14financial discipline thing, like that leasing cars out to
- 39:17drivers, it was kind of an experiment and it didn't work.
- 39:21You know? And so you had to, you know,
- 39:23should we have done more study and more pilots beforehand?
- 39:26Sure. When you talk about things like
- 39:27the geofencing, yeah, those were pure mistakes but the whole Tim
- 39:31Cook Serio thing was just this is where I get to my criticism.
- 39:35Either was just out of control, false, you're saying, the
- 39:39meeting as depicted in Mike, Isaac's, big, New York Times,
- 39:42story with Tim Cook, and Travis didn't happen as it would like
- 39:46he Travis met with Tim Cook but but not in the way that is
- 39:48described in the story. Yeah, I remember.
- 39:52Arguing through Jill with Mike, I said Mike, the only four
- 39:55people in the room, this is Jill Hazel Baker, the head of
- 39:58communications at the only four people in the room were me
- 40:02Travis, Tim Cook and Eddy. Cue only four of us.
- 40:06Me and Travis are telling you, that this never happens.
- 40:11Tim Cook didn't chastise us. He didn't, we never discussed
- 40:14the geofencing, it never happens.
- 40:16And I called Eddie. And I was like, Eddie can you
- 40:18guys tell? Also, please tell them he's
- 40:20like, we don't comment. On anything ever.
- 40:22So I was like, okay, so great. We're having an article written
- 40:25where the four people in the room.
- 40:27None of them. Two of them are saying it, never
- 40:29happened to them are not commenting, and yet, you're
- 40:30going to write a whole article about it.
- 40:32That turns into a whole episode on a show.
- 40:36It was, it was sort of Otherworldly.
- 40:38I was like, I don't know how to combat those.
- 40:40So what so what did happen then, what's the accurate as you see
- 40:42it? Representation of that meeting.
- 40:44Yeah, so there was the meeting with any Hugh and Phil Schiller
- 40:49about the Geo fencing stuff. Ins.
- 40:52But it wasn't Tim Cook was and it was us hat and hands.
- 40:56Coming down to Cupertino saying, here's exactly what happened,
- 41:00and why? We did it?
- 41:01We were wrong, we'll never do it again.
- 41:04And it was really about fraud, we're losing ten million dollars
- 41:07a week because of what was happening with the wiping of
- 41:11iPhones and stolen credit cards. And then we would love to work
- 41:15with you on fixing this problem. When for the next two years we
- 41:17work with apple and actually solving a fraud problem that
- 41:20that would happen. Worldwide on that Tim Cook.
- 41:23Had nothing to do with that. We went to Tim Cook.
- 41:25We were talking about driverless cars.
- 41:27Should we build Maps together? We would be the first customer
- 41:30to use Apple pay. It was a totally different, but
- 41:32he was insulated from that. So just, you know, the Tim Cook
- 41:36part of it. Never happens.
- 41:37I don't know what to tell you. I mean, we were talking about
- 41:39Jill and and obviously, I want to talk about, you know, Bill
- 41:42girly to the funny thing about all.
- 41:44This is I sort of enjoy all of your company.
- 41:47But yet you guys all, I mean, I wouldn't say, you know, there's
- 41:51a lot of Resentment all around. I mean isn't there?
- 41:54This is Bill girly. You know, the Benchmark partner.
- 41:57This is a why can't you guys all get along your all, you know, I
- 42:00mean, isn't there? I mean you and Travis had sort
- 42:04of a, there's a moral crusade in the, We Believe, Uber, we don't
- 42:07believe in this sort of the government regulation, but then
- 42:09I do think there is a certain like a morality and sort of like
- 42:14the regulatory, you know, it's sort of like they're gray zones,
- 42:17we can operate, we're making deals.
- 42:19Like people can make deals with us or not like The same sort of
- 42:22like if they decide, they think you guys have pushed it too far,
- 42:26it's hurting their reputation. They're going to make less
- 42:27money, like they can, like, try and push push you out.
- 42:31What do you think girly and crew?
- 42:33Did that was so wrong and like try, like the strategy makes
- 42:36sense to me that, if you're going to push out like, you guys
- 42:40got absolute control for Travis's part of this Audi deal.
- 42:43So then it became very hard for them to replace the CEO, which
- 42:46may be girly. Should have never agreed to, but
- 42:48like, it was a very high valuation of very good terms.
- 42:51And then so the only way to really push Travis out, was a
- 42:54total like surprise attack full-on War.
- 42:57Don't you as a tactician agree that their strategy there was no
- 43:00nice way to do it? Like they did it.
- 43:01The only way if you want to get rid of Travis, that's the only
- 43:04way to do it. Well, God, so many thoughts.
- 43:08So The Benchmark attack was premeditated and the shold the
- 43:13holder report was a vehicle for that.
- 43:15Premeditation. They knew ahead of time that
- 43:18their goal was to get Travis out.
- 43:19Girly said that said so, so and I'm sorry too.
- 43:21You have here, but the holder report was basically
- 43:23commissioned internally by the company to suss out the culture
- 43:26problems with an Uber, it was authored by Eric Holder, the
- 43:29former Attorney General and Travis signed on to that.
- 43:32Yeah. Isn't there public reporting?
- 43:34The Rachel Whetstone like said it was a bad idea and Travis
- 43:37still did it. Like he created some of the
- 43:40vehicle for his own demise there.
- 43:42Yeah right and well and also the conclusion of the report was
- 43:44also that you specifically should be fired.
- 43:47Yeah. So okay let me finish Falcons.
- 43:50Okay. Okay.
- 43:53This is just so people know we're talking about is the
- 43:55climax. What do you think?
- 43:56All right, so the whole report was not started to do culture
- 44:01investigation, was started to investigate.
- 44:03This isn't Fowler situation, girly, had it expanded to
- 44:06include culture, okay? And because he knew that was an
- 44:10Achilles heel. Know, a lot of people could say,
- 44:12whatever the whole report was was basically like let's talk to
- 44:15a bunch of people, get the the get their complaints and then
- 44:19we're going to decide what we want to do at the company.
- 44:21No one had. A chance to cross-examine no one
- 44:23ever heard what someone said about them that they did or
- 44:25didn't do wrong. So it was just it was just a
- 44:27vehicle for for that usage and had girly, honestly ahead of
- 44:32time said, I think Travis should go raise it in a board meeting,
- 44:35right? And there were other board
- 44:37members, therefore, get the dual class, whatever that only comes
- 44:40into play, Eric when there's a vote, right?
- 44:44You could say, hey, I think this company is doing poorly.
- 44:46We need to remove the CEO. After the holder report, the
- 44:50board unanimously agreed to let Travis take a leave of absence,
- 44:54right? Right.
- 44:55I think I broke the the leave of absence by like a second fun.
- 44:59The unanimous agreement Travis's mom died Benchmark.
- 45:03Went sent to people not girly didn't have the guts to go
- 45:07himself sent them the Chicago with two letters.
- 45:10One is smear letter saying if you don't quit.
- 45:12Now we're going to we're going to release all this information
- 45:16on you. That looks like a smear.
- 45:17Our or quit now. And by the way, you have no
- 45:19lawyer, there's no lawyer, there's no time.
- 45:22Your mom just died. You just agreed to take a leave
- 45:24of absence of the board agreed upon the whole board with you
- 45:28girly. Why didn't you say right then
- 45:29that you were gonna, you were opposed to this leave of absence
- 45:32you want him fired. So his deception on Deception,
- 45:35along the way we're, okay. When did you your, when did you
- 45:38first have an inkling? The Benchmark wanted to replace
- 45:41Travis's. See you, probably too late.
- 45:43I would say April 17, may have 17.
- 45:46So how far in advance Of that of the letter.
- 45:48Is that maybe a month? Oh wow.
- 45:51I mean, they've been plotting it for a while, at that.
- 45:53Yeah. Yeah, they have to, we just, we
- 45:55thought it was a little more honest.
- 45:56Because we had this subcommittee of the board that was Ariana.
- 45:59Banamine curly, who were managing the holder thing, and
- 46:02they're like, yeah, look. This is going to be an objective
- 46:04report. We're gonna make some
- 46:06recommendations. And then only later did I
- 46:08realize like actually God, I now I know what this whole thing was
- 46:11about and Tom. Yes, they're the holder report
- 46:16recommended that. I'd be fired because you know
- 46:18why? No, please tell me so that in
- 46:212014, one of my employees submit an expense report that I didn't
- 46:27approve but my assistant improved and he had asked for an
- 46:31extension to file that expense report and I said to the CFO.
- 46:35Can you give him more time goes didn't have an assistant to help
- 46:38them do an expense report and so therefore I'd approved somehow
- 46:41tacitly of 1000 our expensive should have been expense.
- 46:46What was the expense As a material.
- 46:48Yeah, it's the correct. Karaoke bar know what it was.
- 46:51It was a pretty karaoke bar is sort of, yeah, hooker situation.
- 46:55Yeah, it was a pretext and every board member every.
- 46:58And, and the way they structure, the vote on the holder
- 47:01recommendation, and this was a girly, Eric Holder genius thing.
- 47:05He had to vote all or not, she had to vote on every
- 47:08recommendation or not, which included firing me, right?
- 47:10So you could vote on the value change of step on toes and that
- 47:14was the equivalent of Letting Go someone on this ridiculous.
- 47:17Non-violation and every board member apologize to me after
- 47:21that including growing because they're like that was
- 47:23ridiculous. But basically they had to get
- 47:25rid of me to get to Travis right?
- 47:26It was stuff. I do the investors right.
- 47:28Who governance I was a lawyer. I'm all board members.
- 47:31I was I knew how to make sure Travis wouldn't get ousted and
- 47:35so they had to get me out of the way.
- 47:36That's why I'm saying this feels like a strategy that if you were
- 47:38on the other side you would respect.
- 47:39You're like, okay they play. I mean the Travis's mom and mom
- 47:43dying is obviously that you can't respect that.
- 47:45That is that is uncommon but they were probably We're
- 47:47pursuing this strategy way before that was like,
- 47:50uncomfortable for everybody, don't you think they timed it to
- 47:52them? Well, I even remember actually,
- 47:54when, you know, the news came out about his mom dying, I
- 47:57remember seeing Jill Hazel, Baker tweeting out, you know,
- 48:00her condolences to Travis during this period.
- 48:02It seemed like, people were caught in the very difficult,
- 48:04those who had moral pangs about it in this, like there was the
- 48:08momentum to push him out and eat at the same time, a horrible
- 48:10life event happened to him. How do we both manage that?
- 48:13But also, if you are on the side of the board or think Travis
- 48:16should be gone push towards something that That is maybe the
- 48:18for with they thought the best for the company, this is not
- 48:21accurate. So the there was no person
- 48:24besides Benchmark who wanted Travis to resign.
- 48:27Then there were all said, we you take a leave of absence, you
- 48:30need a leave of absence the the management Jill mantor credit
- 48:35and the management team who were saying, like, Travis needs to
- 48:38leave of absence. They weren't asking to resign,
- 48:39but the executive leadership team, including sort of a lot of
- 48:43these people Jill and other people were talking about wrote
- 48:45a letter saying they thought. Travis need To take this, leave
- 48:49take a leap. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 48:51So, so I'm giving her credit which is like, everyone agreed
- 48:54on the board. Now on the board and otherwise
- 48:58agreed to a leave of absence period and then he was ambushed
- 49:03after his mom died on purpose. Without representation without
- 49:08girly, doing it himself, had that in a moment.
- 49:10Not happens. I think he would have taken a
- 49:12leave of absence. Did you talk to him?
- 49:14It is mind-boggling, why did he agree?
- 49:16Why did he agree like that? Clearly in retrospect, he wishes
- 49:19he hadn't right? Like, yeah, it was look you
- 49:22Corner that I was his right hand man's.
- 49:25I was removed a week earlier on a pretext.
- 49:28He was alone, he didn't have counsel and Ariana does convince
- 49:32him to go along with it, right? She had been very aligned with
- 49:35you guys and then she turns on him right at the 11th hour,
- 49:39right? Yeah I but I think she turned on
- 49:41him. She was like once he decided she
- 49:43was helping him to write the statement or you know, whatever
- 49:47that it's a little. Augie exactly how that went
- 49:49down. But no, every single board
- 49:52member voted to approve. The leave of absence there was
- 49:54no vote to remove them. Can I just quickly say, one
- 49:57thing you did bring up, you know, the karaoke incident which
- 49:59you say was used as a pretext for pushing you out of the
- 50:02company. And, you know, I was a little
- 50:04bit closer to that one because I worked at the information at the
- 50:06time, which is a little, you know, the outlet that published
- 50:08the story about the incident with, you know, Gaby Travis's
- 50:11ex-girlfriend about it and you sort of played a part in it in
- 50:14that as the story said, you kind of were texting with Gabby
- 50:18Saying, let's put this behind us.
- 50:19Let's not, you know, let's not. You know, some would argue, is
- 50:24way to kind of cover it up and not embarrass the company.
- 50:26You do you regret the way you handle that situation at all?
- 50:30And do you think it could have been, you know, are you sorry
- 50:34for you? Sorry for what you said to Gabby
- 50:36and, and do you think that it's something, had you wish the
- 50:39whole thing never happened? You never went to that bar and
- 50:41can in South Korea. So, a couple things and I'll
- 50:44tell you, so we definitely should have never gone to that
- 50:47bar. That was 10.
- 50:48Why he's like that. And I apologize about that, by
- 50:51the way, that was in the Uber HR records at the time.
- 50:56Like, we knew that was bad at the time was like, hey, we
- 50:58shouldn't have done this with employees and by the way, I was
- 51:00at the most senior Garden Room Travis was there.
- 51:02Gabby was there was a 10 0 B, 10 employees, the local team took
- 51:06us there sound like we're like hey let's go to a karaoke bar
- 51:09regard. Regardless how was senior?
- 51:11And I should have said this is a dumb idea.
- 51:12We shouldn't do it all that happened in the karaoke bars.
- 51:15I sang a duet of Sweet Child. Mine with Gabby, the notion that
- 51:19she was unhappy to be. There is is not as not true.
- 51:23She actually was very excited. She was a good singer.
- 51:25She wanted to go there and so the local TV can be like, let's
- 51:29go sings, we went these places are shady that of shady elements
- 51:33of them. And I've said this many times
- 51:36said his to a mirror at the time.
- 51:38Gabby and my wife were best friends and this is after
- 51:41Travis, and she broke up best friends.
- 51:44And she was on public about her her eating disorder.
- 51:48Is and things like that and we care like not wife cared for her
- 51:51a lot. We were on watch.
- 51:53When Travis is a way to make sure she had people to talk to.
- 51:55So me calling her that day and this show gets this wrong.
- 51:58And I'm really upset about it. Actually, I called her say, this
- 52:01was happening. This is, by the way, all known
- 52:03in the HR department, new, but this was not a hidden thing.
- 52:06And if the Press knew what happens?
- 52:08Yeah, great. We went to a shady place.
- 52:10It was already reported to HR. We sang, we drank, we went home.
- 52:14Like, we're, you know, what do you want me to do?
- 52:15So what was a asking Gabby to do To hide what?
- 52:19There was nothing to hide, but wasn't the allegation that you
- 52:21were texting her saying, let's not talk about this, right?
- 52:24Like let's no, no, no God. I never texted her about this.
- 52:27I called her and said, hey, this is happening.
- 52:30She's like, I don't want anything to do with it as a
- 52:31look, I can't stop reporters from calling you about this.
- 52:35I'm sorry. She's a, please keep me out of
- 52:37his, like, I'll do my best to keep you out of it.
- 52:40And the only thing that was it. She said, and then she said, I
- 52:43said, tell people that we only had fun or something.
- 52:48That was right. Well, that sounds like a
- 52:50cover-up to, a lot of people cover above what of singing and
- 52:53drinking. Well, we only had fun versus
- 52:55this is a shady place in which, there are escorts there that,
- 52:58but it made her feel uncomfortable, right?
- 52:59I mean, that was the core of her completely untrue.
- 53:02They don't know. That's, that's just, that's
- 53:03crazy. Talk.
- 53:04It was, it was, it was going to be known.
- 53:07That was a shady place. So, having fun saying we had
- 53:10fun, how does that change? Whether the place for shady or
- 53:13not? Well, but clearly it looks.
- 53:14He must have felt aggrieved by it because she chose to speak to
- 53:17the Press and say I was put in a position that I shouldn't have
- 53:20been. And this was later said, we just
- 53:22had, you know, we were just supposed to be having a fun
- 53:24time. That's not the way she felt
- 53:25about it and that felt like a cover-up to her.
- 53:28I think you're maybe conflating someone being upset with a break
- 53:32up with someone who actually wanted to, go to the karaoke
- 53:37bar, sang songs had fun, and was using that situation in a way to
- 53:44hurt people who are she was previously closed to, right?
- 53:48That we exhume a relationship. But yeah.
- 53:50Well, I mean Travis is inability to like maintain a good
- 53:54relationship with her. Does end up her eye.
- 53:57Like I do think his relationship maintaining abilities hurt him.
- 54:01I think you think that's good. Psychoanalyzing, come on, come
- 54:06on, leave the show is. So unfair on this point they try
- 54:08to overlap the Angie relationship with the Gabby
- 54:11thing. Who's so unfair, it was very
- 54:13unfair to Angie they have choosen.
- 54:15I don't know how this person they broke up.
- 54:17Up in 2009. I don't think I was started
- 54:20dating cab until 2014 so wasn't overlap, and right?
- 54:25And human Angie still have a great relationship.
- 54:27So I don't. This relationship is he like
- 54:29when you break up with somebody, it's not happy for one or both
- 54:33parties generally. So you know, what do you do?
- 54:37What do you asking a human being to do?
- 54:39Let's talk about the media because I feel like we need to
- 54:42take some of the heat ourselves here.
- 54:44Yeah. I mean, I don't know what the
- 54:46media is. So many things in that like in
- 54:50the period, it's like all these scandals stories without a lot
- 54:53of context and then you get like, you know, I did the fall
- 54:57of Travis Troy there, these sort of magazine stories, there's
- 55:00very much like a mood in the media to given time, but like
- 55:03all the stories to me are sort of like, even when I would write
- 55:06them. It's like okay, it gives a
- 55:07little bit of what I understand about it were, but it's just
- 55:09hard in his story to convey it all then super pumped becomes
- 55:14like so defining and how most people People understand Uber
- 55:18and now the show, it has like 80,000 people on the finales.
- 55:22So it's small but it's still like a show, people are lazy and
- 55:24they're more willing to, you know, they watch the show.
- 55:27I don't know what is wisdom. Is there a piece in the media
- 55:30ecosystem that upsets you the most or or is there a you know
- 55:35it's such a you know it's not like a centralized organized
- 55:38Force which like the the area where you think is most flawed.
- 55:42I think that the biggest flaw is sort of trying to look Uber's
- 55:48faults in a vacuum as opposed to compared to other companies and
- 55:53what what was wrong and corporate cultures, generally
- 55:57speaking prior to me too, and how that's changed, how we look
- 56:01at the world and how much more diversity matter.
- 56:04All the things that in the last five years, people are looking
- 56:09across all companies and going like, holy cow, CNN, had
- 56:12problems. Pinterest had problem.
- 56:14Every company has some versions was just below.
- 56:17Below the radar for a while and sober became this poster child.
- 56:21I don't think it was that different from any other company
- 56:25in the problems that human beings have when they work
- 56:27together and they took, we took the brunt of it and is partly
- 56:31because I think after the Trump election people are angry and
- 56:37this notion of being able to delete to protest by deleting
- 56:40app and how this whole taxi JFK thing, got out of control and
- 56:46you said many times Credit Eric, that was incoherent but man,
- 56:51right? The issue there.
- 56:53So Travis have been on, you know, like Advisory board but so
- 56:56it a lot of other CEOs. But then Uber because of
- 57:00hurricanes, stopped implementing surge pricing during Crazy
- 57:04incidents. We don't turn on surge pricing
- 57:07during sensitive areas protest, hurricanes.
- 57:10There's a whole argument about whether that even make sense.
- 57:13I think you were initially resistant, not you specifically,
- 57:15but there was some resistance any way you could pitch.
- 57:17A tan that to please sort of the public mood even though it's
- 57:21perhaps irrational and then delete Hoover's sparked because
- 57:26you don't have surge pricing, which is then framed as a
- 57:29reason, that people won't come to the protest.
- 57:32So it is the ultimate irony that in giving up on your principles
- 57:36to satisfy the mob, the mobs still comes after you so I do
- 57:41find it like a truly perverse, but I blame the public.
- 57:44I mean, Twitter, I mean the New York.
- 57:46Mike Isaac did run a. About delete over that I thought
- 57:49was pretty credulous and the time, but but it was mostly a
- 57:53Twitter mob, sort of event. It was, but it led to delete
- 57:57noubar and that led to Travis stepping down from the Trump
- 58:01counsel that maryborough is on Elon Musk, you name it.
- 58:06And by the way, the tech CEOs were all going to see trauma and
- 58:09this was early 17, right? So so and then the drive, you
- 58:13know, this isn't our thing and then the driver video which you
- 58:15broke Eric, which ironically Akeley that driver wishes yet
- 58:19Travis back as CEO and Hunter. He said that the driver.
- 58:24That's another thing. He gets a very charitable, I
- 58:27obviously have an affection for him, but the kind of person
- 58:32who's going to argue with the CEO of the company.
- 58:34You work for spontaneously on a night is probably not as soft
- 58:37and fuzzy as presented on a TV show.
- 58:40But I mean, very I don't think I would have been this bravest him
- 58:43to confront problems. So it's my criticism the Press
- 58:47are different than they were. Back then were where I was just
- 58:50like, you know, defensive mat. Now, I'm just like it just
- 58:53wasn't proportional relative to what was happening in the rest
- 58:57of the industry. We had inside leakers.
- 58:59As you know, Eric who made it worse.
- 59:01So we didn't know what was coming when and I just think it
- 59:05was sensationalized through degree and I give you this Tim
- 59:09Cook example that we were just couldn't control it.
- 59:12And I think today, we would have been more Savvy about it.
- 59:16I think today, you would have had It would have just been
- 59:18another story amongst the other corporate stories and, you know,
- 59:22you would have fired this. And that Travis is the one who
- 59:25said boober, I honestly think the boober thing, like just the
- 59:30whole once the Bro e reputation was built and sort of it was so
- 59:33hard to like online that. Yeah, I've never understood the
- 59:37river thing. You could tell, you could
- 59:38explain that for a GQ Magazine was was interviewing him.
- 59:41I wasn't there at the time it was even before my time and he's
- 59:44like are you getting more dates? Is there goes made this boober
- 59:47joke. N.
- 59:48Okay, not a great joke, present joke.
- 59:51It was clearly a joke. I don't tell me you didn't you
- 59:53debated, whether the Biden thing was a joke.
- 59:55It was a joke, but this was definitely a joke.
- 59:58Right? Why, what was so incendiary
- 1:00:01abutting that or this is our take on the TV shows.
- 1:00:06I mean we said this before, what people hate the most like
- 1:00:09they're more forgiving of the fraudsters than people who
- 1:00:12remind them of like the guy who is like snide to them or
- 1:00:15whatever in high school or whatever, you know.
- 1:00:17I mean it's just sort of like, right Travis has like a chip on
- 1:00:20his shoulder. He's like, oh yeah I'm like
- 1:00:22getting all the girls off this and like sort of has this sort
- 1:00:25of combative Nur I feel like people just like he played into
- 1:00:28a personality type that people like no.
- 1:00:30Yeah, it also came about during this, you know, conception this
- 1:00:33media conception of the brogrammer and Silicon Valley
- 1:00:35was on the rise and it was kind of cool to work there, but they
- 1:00:38also they were nerd but they were programmers and so you
- 1:00:40know, Travis kind of was the king of that media creation any
- 1:00:44but just let me this what's ironic about it I was When I
- 1:00:48have to browse a 45 year old man and I did dated.
- 1:00:52My wife is I was dating a whole way through Travis had to
- 1:00:55long-term girlfriends. We're not club guys, he doesn't
- 1:00:58barely drinks. He also looks like such a dork
- 1:01:00in the Uber driver video to, right?
- 1:01:02And he's like we were just right nor like we brought we were
- 1:01:07doing probably just like we're doing keg stands in the office
- 1:01:09like give me a break like we did get tagged with the Bro thing
- 1:01:13and it's so mystifies me, you know what, how do you have a you
- 1:01:17live in? Miami.
- 1:01:18Now, you guys like going out? Yeah, I live with a two and half
- 1:01:21year old and my parents nearby like again live.
- 1:01:24If living Miami makes you a bro, then like anyway, I'm not I'm
- 1:01:28not ready. You went off by being a bro.
- 1:01:29I'm just trying to analyze and I agree.
- 1:01:32I mean that was always a funny thing with Travis where way he
- 1:01:34was like 44 must much of this and people treat him like he
- 1:01:37must have been like some 20 year old or something.
- 1:01:40Yeah. Right.
- 1:01:41And and the line that they need an adult in the room, right?
- 1:01:43Here's the thing. I want to ask you a meal because
- 1:01:45and maybe you as well. Eric, the thing that I The most
- 1:01:48from talking reading Mike's book, talking to Mike on the
- 1:01:51show, I barely watch The Uber show, it's really bad, but it's
- 1:01:55Bill girly, and the leakers inside Uber, and maybe you guys
- 1:01:58to a less effective degree, use the media as a tool to enact
- 1:02:01your agenda. I saw, you know, the reporters
- 1:02:04as very effective mouthpieces reported mouthpieces, but, you
- 1:02:08know, people, good sources leaked to the right people to
- 1:02:11get the things that they wanted to come across and it ended up
- 1:02:14being this very public, you know, display this very public.
- 1:02:18War, you know, through Anonymous sources in the media to kind of
- 1:02:21fight Travis and I guess potentially fight against Bill
- 1:02:25girly. Although again, you guys lost
- 1:02:26that battle. I mean, what did you learn
- 1:02:28through that process in the way that reporters, are utilized
- 1:02:32through selective leaks in order to push, you know, an internal
- 1:02:36agenda. I mean, Mike's even almost kind
- 1:02:37of upfront about this in the book saying, like, you know,
- 1:02:40before the letter comes out, he gets an anonymous call from
- 1:02:42someone. We makes Reuben seem like a huge
- 1:02:44character who, honestly, I didn't even talk to you.
- 1:02:46It was a very high bun, who's real I think that's like the
- 1:02:48high very high profile PR firm. It was like the crisis PR from
- 1:02:53yeah. That was hired by grilling.
- 1:02:55These guys, do you know, the pivotal point in the book is
- 1:02:58like who leaked him? That Travis was resigning Sokka?
- 1:03:01Yeah yes. Yeah I mean that's well it's a
- 1:03:08well-known amongst the know people because he could use the
- 1:03:12ideas. There was a cabal, you know,
- 1:03:14where was meant to be more organized and then sock is like
- 1:03:16fuck it. Like let's make Make sure this
- 1:03:18thing happens. Yeah I don't want to quickly one
- 1:03:21click within for say we're all buddies with Mike we love Mike I
- 1:03:24don't think he was like a tool in any sort of dumb way.
- 1:03:26He's a great reporter and and wrote a story that I think
- 1:03:29proved to be right an accurate version of certain person's of
- 1:03:32the truth. And Eric wrote a story
- 1:03:33corroborate but a good story is a good score story.
- 1:03:36Anyway, yah, mule look. I think I think Mike made a big
- 1:03:39mistake on the Tim Cook story that so that I will credit for
- 1:03:44being not accurate. I think a lot of stuff was
- 1:03:46accurate. He was like, I did get the
- 1:03:48letter from soccer before, you know, true.
- 1:03:50And I don't know if I have an opinion Tom on the leaking on
- 1:03:54leaking, but that guess that's just how the game is played.
- 1:03:56I think the thing I didn't expect is internally goes to be
- 1:04:00working against their management team to such a degree that it
- 1:04:06was, you know, it was sort of I just didn't expect and that kind
- 1:04:10of disloyalty to be that prominence.
- 1:04:14And now I've learned my lesson that I was like holy shit.
- 1:04:17This is This is what happens, I guess in political politically
- 1:04:21charged situations. Well, there is amazing, like,
- 1:04:24who is uber-like is just because he's is Travis like
- 1:04:28fundamentally Uber? Because he's CEO or if you think
- 1:04:32you know it you get these really like abstract.
- 1:04:35I mean it's it's been an amazing way for me to learn about
- 1:04:39business just because a company is not a singular person.
- 1:04:43As look at here's the thing, I would challenge you on this is
- 1:04:46why which Katie was on because I Katie I think was in late 17 and
- 1:04:51she was telling me that the Benchmark partners are saying.
- 1:04:53All you guys are going, you and Travis are going to jail and
- 1:04:56that's it. Companies going is zero.
- 1:04:57That's why we have to throw you out all these things.
- 1:05:01And I and Trav girl is running around saying, you're going to
- 1:05:05be on the right side of History by letting these guys go right
- 1:05:08side of History, this company is going to be worth a hundred
- 1:05:11billion dollars in two years. That's on Twitter.
- 1:05:13The company is worth half, that never made that no one's going
- 1:05:17to jail. Indictment and bet like, none of
- 1:05:19that stuff happened. And I tell people this, I think
- 1:05:23Benchmark made a huge mistake for their shareholders
- 1:05:25themselves. This could have been one of the
- 1:05:27most valuable companies in the world.
- 1:05:28He agreed to take a leave of absence.
- 1:05:30There was things that needed to be fixed and he'll regret it.
- 1:05:33He will regret it for the rest of his life and try to make it
- 1:05:36up. And because it's the only thing,
- 1:05:38you know, Stitch fix Open Table grub up.
- 1:05:40All those things were never going to be as important
- 1:05:42collectively as Uber, was to him and his reputation, and I like
- 1:05:46girly at the time, we talked multiple Today a day a day.
- 1:05:49We I talk too girly. I'm guessing more than he talked
- 1:05:53to anyone else in business is where you guys, you guys are,
- 1:05:56like, girly didn't have anything to do with the company.
- 1:05:58And then you're like, I talk to girly multiple times a day.
- 1:06:01I did. I didn't say it.
- 1:06:02Nothing to it. You know.
- 1:06:03I know in other interviews. I feel like there's been not
- 1:06:05nothing, but there's sometimes a never to downplay his
- 1:06:09significant. He was used very effectively to
- 1:06:12my blog posts to your speak at conferences.
- 1:06:16He and I talked strategy all the time.
- 1:06:17I'm we disagreed a lot. We agreed a lot.
- 1:06:20He and I both agreed on that. Thomas car division, stuff, that
- 1:06:23that was an over-investment. You're very skeptical.
- 1:06:26Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:06:27I do remember. I think, even at the time you
- 1:06:29being like, oh, this way mode, real, this is not my ideal.
- 1:06:32Yeah, I just knows, but I think he just he got scared.
- 1:06:37And, you know, I think that's something entrepreneurs have to
- 1:06:40worry about if you put thirty three million dollars in
- 1:06:42something that turns into 10 billion.
- 1:06:43And for years, you're not worried about 10 billion turning
- 1:06:46to 20, you're worried about losing Seeing the 10 billion.
- 1:06:48So it's like loss aversion. I did.
- 1:06:51I mean, that's his incentives. I just don't feel like it's
- 1:06:54easy, and I don't want to fall into this myself.
- 1:06:57Now the Travis is gone to be like, oh, you know, maybe it
- 1:07:01would have been different. But like the thing is, I don't
- 1:07:03see. Travis wasn't giving any sort of
- 1:07:05Escape valve, to all sort of the public anger, the sort of
- 1:07:09internal criticism like there was no path, like it really, it
- 1:07:13felt, I mean, it was the leave of absence or nothing if you
- 1:07:17that didn't work, if you didn't take that time to come back with
- 1:07:22a different modality, then that would happen later.
- 1:07:26Just so, you know, not sooner. But I think he genuinely was
- 1:07:29going to look, remember your mom dies, your best, you know, one
- 1:07:33of your best friends and lieutenants gets popped for a
- 1:07:35totally unfair. Reason, you're criticizing the
- 1:07:38media like more than any other person has been criticized at
- 1:07:40the moment. Taking a leave that as kind of
- 1:07:43makes some sense, right? And everyone agreed.
- 1:07:46Why didn't he have a chief operating officer like, you
- 1:07:49know, ironically he was, we were in a process with diverse of
- 1:07:53Partners to hire one and he was in Chicago, interviewing one, if
- 1:07:56you want to play, just like, alternate history on all of
- 1:07:59this, you know, Travis does take his leave of absence.
- 1:08:01He doesn't get, you know, cop owed by girly and he comes back.
- 1:08:05And like you say, a different modality is that even possible?
- 1:08:08Do you think Travis really had a different way of running things
- 1:08:11that could have been? Been fundamentally different for
- 1:08:13the company and I ask because Insider reported a piece.
- 1:08:17I did not report it that you know in Cloud kitchens which is
- 1:08:20Travis is current company. He sort of continued a lot of
- 1:08:23the cultural and business leadership strategies that a lot
- 1:08:27of people found problematic. A tuber seems like he's trying
- 1:08:29to do things again and I mean the conclusion of that story was
- 1:08:32like he didn't learn anything. I'm sure you're going to say you
- 1:08:35don't think that story was accurate or was unfair blah blah
- 1:08:37blah but knowing what you do about Travis is there a version
- 1:08:40of him that could have come back and actually Different.
- 1:08:43Like I think cloud kitchens is going to be bigger than Uber.
- 1:08:46He's got the people who went there went for him.
- 1:08:49Well, that bar keeps lowering. So that's good.
- 1:08:50That's good for him. No nobody.
- 1:08:53But people who went to clown kitchens wanted to work with
- 1:08:57someone like that, right? And they love the values and by
- 1:09:02the way, the values that were changed from the Travis of
- 1:09:05drawer just, you know, besides the, you know, we do the right
- 1:09:08thing period, which was the number one thing that Derek came
- 1:09:11in with No, Russ were were largely sort of interchangeable.
- 1:09:14Like most corporate values are, but I think we used to talk
- 1:09:18about this. I remember having conversations
- 1:09:20with Travis in 2016, and we were talking about when you're, when
- 1:09:25you get this read Hoffman's thing as pirate to.
- 1:09:28I forget what the other thing is you move to, but we were talking
- 1:09:31about how we move the company to be much more of a civilization
- 1:09:36than a, than a tribe, you know, which is one way to think about
- 1:09:38Pirates to sort of a captain of a ship and we I knew that you
- 1:09:42have to change some of these things.
- 1:09:44Even if you don't want to, you don't think the company is going
- 1:09:48to be as successful or successful fast because the
- 1:09:51world can't handle it. There's too many stakeholders.
- 1:09:54When you get to be a 20,000 person company cities all over
- 1:09:57the world, Regulators investors. You just have to be a little
- 1:10:02more moderate and this is what this is where I give dark credit
- 1:10:07card, is a great diplomat. He is kind of calm the waters
- 1:10:11that allowed the company to go public.
- 1:10:14Those are all things that would have had, we would have had to
- 1:10:18do after a leave of absence to actually make the come to
- 1:10:22censor. And of course it's possible if
- 1:10:23you believe in the mission enough and, you know, that's
- 1:10:25what it takes to succeed in the mission.
- 1:10:27You do that. We just didn't do it soon
- 1:10:29enough. But that what seems to be the
- 1:10:31problem though, is that there weren't there were seems to be a
- 1:10:33significant contingent of people that didn't think Travis could
- 1:10:36do that. Could be that person.
- 1:10:37It was benchmark. Mark, well, now, there are
- 1:10:41people inside the company that we're leaking.
- 1:10:42I mean, you said so yourself, sure.
- 1:10:44People know that, when they know that they're the same people now
- 1:10:46who cut the stock price in half and 90% of the people of a
- 1:10:51treated and they have the same level of Investigations and
- 1:10:54scrutiny just with the nicer guy on top.
- 1:10:57Who's more likeable? Yeah.
- 1:10:58I was sort of going to go into the valuation.
- 1:11:00Yeah. The path to Uber being like a
- 1:11:02200 billion dollar company like to some degree dhara has done
- 1:11:06some of the things you wanted. He's Spun off, you know,
- 1:11:11self-driving spun off some of the some of the stuff that
- 1:11:15wasn't working. Isn't it possible that like he
- 1:11:19just inherited a business that had sort of a ceiling for how
- 1:11:21much money it can make? I mean, Uber pool.
- 1:11:24When you guys were, there was like a big part of the future of
- 1:11:28the company and driving down prices to increase.
- 1:11:30Him was so huge. The Mission Pool is basically
- 1:11:34failed to some degree. Obviously, you were extremely
- 1:11:37right on food. I know you're going to say,
- 1:11:39invest more and more in food, but like, he basically to build
- 1:11:44the business you wanted had to move outside of ride sharing and
- 1:11:47sort of jump from the business. You build to other things.
- 1:11:50Or you think there's some magic trigger on ride-sharing that
- 1:11:53he's failing failing to monetize.
- 1:11:56Yeah. So so couple things losing to
- 1:11:59doordash the market. Share lead in the US was a
- 1:12:03thirty billion dollar mistake and that happened from 2018
- 1:12:072020. Earned our has, you know, tenure
- 1:12:11that was, you know, there were 30 billion dollars today.
- 1:12:15They're twice as big as ubereats and that lead was inverted when
- 1:12:19the company was handed to him big mistake.
- 1:12:22That's number one. Number two, I think selling
- 1:12:24southeast Asia to grab was a mistake, the selling the to
- 1:12:27selling China and Russia. You had to do in the long term
- 1:12:31because ultimately, the government's were not going to
- 1:12:32let a local company lose. They let us be second place, but
- 1:12:37they never let us be first place.
- 1:12:39Southeast Asia was a different ball game but and he could be
- 1:12:42Kareem also. So instead he paid three billion
- 1:12:44dollars for green, he paid three point seven billion dollars for
- 1:12:48Postmates. Holy cat is going to go down as
- 1:12:50one of the worst deals of this decade.
- 1:12:54All those things are going to be right down.
- 1:12:55Jump by well, they wanted GrubHub, right?
- 1:12:57I mean, they basically, you know, got second prize in this,
- 1:13:00you know, the sweepstakes to buy us as second prize, was a booby
- 1:13:04prize because, yeah. It's like not even a set of
- 1:13:07steak knives. Yeah.
- 1:13:09Like that should have been coming to his on bankruptcy.
- 1:13:13Watch. Right right.
- 1:13:14Well there's an argument that your propping up food delivery
- 1:13:17evaluations by giving you know, there's a valuation game there.
- 1:13:20You don't want to. If you let Postmates go
- 1:13:23bankrupt, you might have lost more money in sort of the
- 1:13:26personal. You don't think so good?
- 1:13:28No, no, no. No over was still consolidating
- 1:13:31their financials at that time. You couldn't tell rides from
- 1:13:33food delivery. They weren't splitting it out.
- 1:13:35Those Acquisitions were just terrible and that and that
- 1:13:38dilution Ocean, by the way, and the debt Uber has now, or
- 1:13:42really, like, uber has more depth and cash right now, it's
- 1:13:45the only one of these companies that has that ratio.
- 1:13:47That's inverted, so the food delivery mistake, but the
- 1:13:49ride-sharing thing is there are prophecy made in that business.
- 1:13:52You just have to do it efficiently and there's
- 1:13:55companies now that are called bolt in Europe.
- 1:13:58And yes year in North Africa and in driver who are newer, Roger
- 1:14:03companies who've just built their systems cheaper and
- 1:14:06they're doing less commissions to drivers and Eating Uber rides
- 1:14:10alive in these places and you're going to see that in 1224
- 1:14:14months, they're going to have lift size competitors and all
- 1:14:17the regions where they were dominant, but it would involve
- 1:14:20cannibalizing their existing business, right?
- 1:14:22Let's commissions paid by drivers, right there, giving
- 1:14:25drivers more of the Prophet. The give them more of the
- 1:14:27prophets. Okay, which is a very even
- 1:14:29harder business. No, no, but been doing it
- 1:14:32because they're do a lower cost structure there.
- 1:14:33Being more efficient and how they work.
- 1:14:35Rudra. Yeah, you think there's an
- 1:14:37efficiency in? In a dry chair business that can
- 1:14:40allow drivers to make more money.
- 1:14:41Consumers not to pay more and boober is not able to do that.
- 1:14:45Yes. Interesting.
- 1:14:47They're doing no layoffs right now.
- 1:14:48No Rifts that Uber right now. 28,000 employees none.
- 1:14:52Right now literally right now and we'll see, we'll see what
- 1:14:55happens. That is surprising.
- 1:14:56I mean, 28,000 by the way, you don't need the city teams as
- 1:14:59much as it did back in the day you needed City teams because
- 1:15:01you were handing drivers phones to use in their cars and so you
- 1:15:05know you were doing signing them up now all the stuffs online
- 1:15:08they're To be bloated. And that's a, that's an anchor.
- 1:15:11It's a boat anchor. You can't be doing twenty five
- 1:15:14billion dollars in revenue and making no profits.
- 1:15:17None forget the Investments up and down but you guys I mean the
- 1:15:21Travis era was certainly not the prophet Sarah, right?
- 1:15:24I mean no no no it's not like you guys were like about to hit
- 1:15:27a switch and suddenly there was going to be cash flow coming out
- 1:15:29the windows. Sure.
- 1:15:30But we were also weren't public for a reason.
- 1:15:32We're like we're gonna get to a place where you have the right
- 1:15:35market, share and right discipline and then we'll go
- 1:15:37public. Do you think it?
- 1:15:38He's good like the American economy, I mean, interest rates
- 1:15:41were low. Investors want to invest in
- 1:15:42growth? You are a natural outcropping in
- 1:15:45some ways of the economic environment that existed.
- 1:15:47But like, do you think the American economy should be run
- 1:15:50in such a way that a company like, uber is given such a Long
- 1:15:54Leash to burn through billions to try and sort of figure
- 1:15:58various things out? I mean, Big Ideas are always
- 1:16:01going to cost a lot of money. I mean, you know, SpaceX is
- 1:16:04raised four billion dollars Tesla's raise 15 billion.
- 1:16:09Are you that these things aren't Innovative and additive to the
- 1:16:13world you can? But you could I could argue the
- 1:16:15Counterpoint to which is like billions of dollars went into
- 1:16:18driver, right? Or subsidies.
- 1:16:20And is that really that's not a Space Racer.
- 1:16:22I heard we're not building, you know?
- 1:16:24So it is amazing. How much people resent noubar
- 1:16:27when like drivers and Riders? Both got a bunch of free money
- 1:16:31that is. I feel like nobody gives you
- 1:16:33credit for that. It's like, who got people
- 1:16:35talking about on the on the Riders side, sort of the
- 1:16:37millennial subsidy. But nobody really wants to
- 1:16:40acknowledge that there was like money given to drivers that
- 1:16:42like, didn't make sense long term, how much do you do?
- 1:16:45You know what is the number for how much Uber has burned through
- 1:16:48and enslave time? Do you have a guess?
- 1:16:50Take the total pay. The total capital is like 25
- 1:16:54billion when you include the debt, you know.
- 1:16:56So debt has to be paid back but that's the money used to finance
- 1:17:00the business. It's - 25 billion right now.
- 1:17:03If you look in the I think the paid-in capital line on the
- 1:17:06balance sheet and something like 25, 26 billion.
- 1:17:09Yeah, I mean in certain ways, I kind of feel like, you know, the
- 1:17:12Travis Emil era of uber are especially now we're in a kind
- 1:17:15of enviable position to analyze. A lot of this stuff and you can
- 1:17:18kind of play, what would have happened if Travis had stayed
- 1:17:21because you know it you're not there, right?
- 1:17:23If the stock price was a hundred bucks, we wouldn't have it as
- 1:17:27conversation, I'd be on a boat. I feel like, guys what you're
- 1:17:32doing, okay, I'm doing just fine, but I'd be like.
- 1:17:35This company is a gem and in my view, it's being It's being
- 1:17:39Yahoo fight. Yeah, and that's my, that's why
- 1:17:42Expedia fide. And they think that I'm doing
- 1:17:45this because I have a grudge or am angry, I don't care.
- 1:17:47I'm a bigger shareholder that entire management team combined.
- 1:17:50I wanted to do cluding dhara including Dora and so I care
- 1:17:54about it doing well, I hate when it makes mistakes for the first
- 1:17:57two years. I was in the background giving
- 1:17:59door advice when he wanted it. I was do nothing but suppose you
- 1:18:04did you go to Bill Ackman and say let's take it over.
- 1:18:07I went to every And the planet and be like, what does it take
- 1:18:12to put pressure on a company to do better?
- 1:18:16And I think, you know, that's still a possibility, you'll see
- 1:18:18out there, but who knows with you affiliated or look?
- 1:18:22I don't the Notions of what one of the things that were said in
- 1:18:25the super files released. They did.
- 1:18:28It's like they make actually a big deal about 90% of the Uber
- 1:18:30employees are different. Now, that's a 90%, which is
- 1:18:33like, for a tech company were like, hello, that's a bad thing.
- 1:18:41Other people have been feasting on Uber Talent, like, give me a
- 1:18:44break. So the notion of going back in
- 1:18:46there and doing anything like trying to reform the culture.
- 1:18:49So, it's somewhere in between where it was and where it should
- 1:18:51be, is, is my the I don't think, I don't think I could do it.
- 1:18:56What are you still in this space?
- 1:18:57I honestly, what happen with yours back or is that could be
- 1:19:01closing in ten days, which company did you buy?
- 1:19:03Or we bought a Quantum Computing company called d-wave?
- 1:19:06Oh yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:19:10Community like, last two questions on this.
- 1:19:12We gotta bring this plane of your Landing, I know.
- 1:19:14Yeah. Do you know how it's going to
- 1:19:15land? Because I don't, I do, I do I
- 1:19:17know what I want to ask. You don't think these losses are
- 1:19:19an overhang from Ubers aggressive entry into these
- 1:19:22places that suddenly are having some blowback.
- 1:19:25And what's your statue of limitations, Tom have, how many
- 1:19:27years is it? Not my false 10 years from now
- 1:19:3120? I don't know.
- 1:19:33Where when is it when is the buck stopped at DARS desk when
- 1:19:38You're not doing your the activists phase is sort of a
- 1:19:42you're like I don't want to, that's not happening.
- 1:19:44Do you have another I mean after this back?
- 1:19:47Yeah I mean I'm sitting on three other.
- 1:19:49No I'm done with this backstage I'm sitting on three other
- 1:19:52private company boards. I'll be on the public company
- 1:19:54board with d-wave and Quantum through a lot in the background
- 1:19:58and Ma and helping companies. Raise money, work with Breck's.
- 1:20:02Go puff revolute, some new younger companies that I think
- 1:20:06can be huge one called Cal she The archon called Dandy Dental.
- 1:20:10So I got a lot of I'm trying to play this bill Campbell role as
- 1:20:14a chief outside advisor, when I'm not on the board but I can
- 1:20:18take a young CEO and Mentor them a little bit.
- 1:20:21Help them with fundraising strategy.
- 1:20:23I mean, a learn from my mistakes navigate.
- 1:20:26The kind of world is it is your public reputation, your
- 1:20:28reputation among like uber people?
- 1:20:31I do think, like, within Uber world you're seen as.
- 1:20:33Yeah. It's sort of a mentor.
- 1:20:34Someone who's been really good at like looking after your ex
- 1:20:38employee. Why he's, I am willing to say
- 1:20:41that. I do think the sort of contrast
- 1:20:43between the public and private reputation especially when it
- 1:20:47comes to mentorship is pretty, pretty strike.
- 1:20:49And I would actually add to that, you know, one of the
- 1:20:52things I've been most struck by and Reporting on Uber over the
- 1:20:54last year. Is that, I find that a lot of
- 1:20:56current and former employees have very mixed opinions on
- 1:20:59Travis. Even if they like the era and
- 1:21:01reminisce about the era they're conflicted over you know the
- 1:21:04things that they think he's responsible for and they can
- 1:21:07whatever work that out with her therapist.
- 1:21:08Yes. But but I don't get that about
- 1:21:11you almost universally. The people that worked with you
- 1:21:15feel. Very fondly about your
- 1:21:16leadership and, you know, your advisor them Post company and I
- 1:21:19think that is, you know, a testament to maybe what you've
- 1:21:23done since you've left over and maybe them just putting all
- 1:21:25their negative feelings about that era on, Travis, it, not on
- 1:21:27you, but, but I it's consistent. I can tell you that a man.
- 1:21:31Well, one thing is important to me to mention is I had one of
- 1:21:34the most diverse teams that Uber the women and who were worked on
- 1:21:37my team and our partners, H + VC, firms CEOs.
- 1:21:41I mean, I really now was that me taking care of them, that was
- 1:21:44just, they were great people. I never had complaints about my
- 1:21:48leadership. It was very, it was the most
- 1:21:50racially and diverse group in the company, had the highest
- 1:21:54rating as a leader and I was proud of that and yeah, I think
- 1:21:58me being, you know, I criticize Travis in private not in public
- 1:22:02that's just my style and it did you criticize Travis enough did
- 1:22:07you push back on Travis? Or did he like having people who
- 1:22:10are sort of, like, that's not a yeah.
- 1:22:12I mean so I didn't say that word.
- 1:22:14But yeah, but he doesn't want anyone to say no.
- 1:22:16I mean, that's really what. Yeah, so, I would, at least say
- 1:22:21this on a relative basis, I did more than anyone else in history
- 1:22:25of giving him feedback, whether was investors or other leaders,
- 1:22:30whatever. Because we had a relationship
- 1:22:32that allowed for that. And I cultivated that on purpose
- 1:22:34because I wanted to be someone who is able to be A voice there
- 1:22:39and he listened to me. I remember just, I know this is
- 1:22:42hard to imagine. I remember you telling people.
- 1:22:44It was 28,000 people in my group.
- 1:22:46I had 300 employees so I didn't have the bulking please.
- 1:22:49I didn't run HR operations, legal Finance.
- 1:22:52I'm in business and corporate development.
- 1:22:54So I read about gray ball in the New York Times.
- 1:22:57I didn't know about it. I was just not involved in a lot
- 1:23:01of, I didn't know what a kill switch was until I read about it
- 1:23:04in one of your articles. So I was just not involved in
- 1:23:08lots of Those parts of the businesses that gotten rid
- 1:23:10about, I was involved in Korea. I was wrong.
- 1:23:14Hello. I went to a karaoke bar and
- 1:23:16saying, you know, Sweet Child of Mine, that was me, but I was in,
- 1:23:19and I was involved in fundraising and Ma and and
- 1:23:23unfortunately, I was involved in the press and I shouldn't have
- 1:23:26been. I was not a good, I don't have a
- 1:23:27good Instinct on press and so obviously like yeah, I was but
- 1:23:36but everything else like I worked hard.
- 1:23:38On unconvincing us to spend as little as we could in the
- 1:23:42autonomous car stuff. I worked hard and trying to get
- 1:23:44us to buy lift. I worked hard and tried selling
- 1:23:47us the deed selling our operations in DD something, our
- 1:23:49business Russia. So I didn't succeed on the lift
- 1:23:52one. I wish I would I didn't succeed
- 1:23:53on buying doordash. I wish I succeeded.
- 1:23:55My last question then reflecting as you can on all of this.
- 1:23:58I mean, do you think Uber even though you think the company is
- 1:24:01not particularly well run right now and it's value isn't what it
- 1:24:03should be blah, blah, blah has it been a good thing for the
- 1:24:06world. Do you think?
- 1:24:07Because I really do think Burr is responsible for the Giga
- 1:24:10fication and and the whole uberX thing exists and will probably
- 1:24:13never go away because it's a very attractive model one way or
- 1:24:16the other. Do you think it's been a good
- 1:24:17thing? I mean, do you think the world
- 1:24:19is a better place because Uber exists because, you know,
- 1:24:21contract labor is become de facto and a lot of companies II.
- 1:24:24By the way, I'm not taking a stance on it, I believe it or
- 1:24:27not, I do not have a stance on this Mister you say no like your
- 1:24:30tone belies. Your stance.
- 1:24:32Tom says, so of course, it's a good thing.
- 1:24:35Look, the I think over time, if you did a longitudinal study,
- 1:24:38Buddy, ten years from now, the number of drunk driving deaths
- 1:24:41that boober has helped avoid and ride sharing.
- 1:24:44It will be dramatic the ability for people to live in the outer
- 1:24:48boroughs of cities and reliably get two jobs is going to be how
- 1:24:53you measure, that would be incredible if you ask any person
- 1:24:56of color in New York City, what the taxi system was like for
- 1:24:59over and how and you say we're going to take away ride-sharing
- 1:25:01from you, you will get like some visceral responses of how
- 1:25:06discriminatory the system was not only in our country.
- 1:25:08Three but around the world. So there are lots of good things
- 1:25:11that when you talk about the labor peace in the gig of
- 1:25:13vacation, peace, I don't know people, work differently, is it
- 1:25:16because of uber that Uber cause beautification.
- 1:25:19And we're all that seems kind of nuts.
- 1:25:21Like, it just seems like one of the things that happened and by
- 1:25:25the way, it's not like these taxi jobs were great.
- 1:25:28It's like you're displaced a shitty just like a really shitty
- 1:25:32job with something that was less back.
- 1:25:34And so yes, net net, it was better for the world for sure.
- 1:25:38Great strong says, I love it. I love it.
- 1:25:41Well right, thank you, this is so much.
- 1:25:42This is I'm glad. So now I need to find a way to
- 1:25:45you know. After a big we had Parker Conrad
- 1:25:48on our first one which was also like one of my foundational
- 1:25:50skin. I do think like, yeah, people in
- 1:25:52scandals, you should just come on in the moment.
- 1:25:54I feel like it's better to like, don't just let the headlines.
- 1:25:57Destroy you, your don't you wish you'd been out there more like
- 1:26:00during this period. I do.
- 1:26:02But I do wish on the career thing.
- 1:26:04The crazy thing was such a garbage that I wish I was just
- 1:26:07like, look, here's what happened.
- 1:26:08I made a mistake. Admitted at the time it wasn't
- 1:26:10what it just you know if you want to crucify me for that you
- 1:26:13better not live in a glass house because anyone who dismisses in
- 1:26:16Korea goes these things. And you know if you want to
- 1:26:20judge me judge everyone else the same right, right.
- 1:26:23But I do think this one thing for you Eric because I know your
- 1:26:26your best buds would girly. Was he on the right side of
- 1:26:29history or not? And the same question you asked
- 1:26:31me, Tom is like oh it's easy to look back in hindsight and so
- 1:26:33you go down better ask him the same question.
- 1:26:35Well yeah, he's just like great to me the the The fundamental
- 1:26:39model of things are the criticisms that will stand the
- 1:26:42test of time where I'm on the more Tom's not going to say what
- 1:26:45do you think's. But clearly I'm more defender of
- 1:26:47the model and have have sort of been more open about that post
- 1:26:51Bloomberg, but I've just in favor of the great story, but
- 1:26:53anyway, meal, don't don't believe yourself.
- 1:26:55You are very good at talking to the media.
- 1:26:57I hope you continue to do it. Thanks so much.
- 1:27:00Okay guys good talk to you. Thanks see ya.
- 1:27:15Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 1:27:18goodbye. Goodbye.