Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 180- Authors David Fantle & Tom Johnson- "C'mon Get Happy The Making of Summer Stock"
Transcript
- 0:01Your listening you've Forgotten Hollywood with Doug Hess here on j L JBDIA. Hello
- 0:21everyone, and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcasts and memories of yesteryear.
- 0:25My name is Doug Hess, and if you're tuning in to Forgotten Hollywood for
- 0:28the first time, what I do on this podcast is take you on a
- 0:31journey back in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or
- 0:36may not know about. And in this episode, we have author David Fanto
- 0:42and Tom Johnson joining us today regarding their latest book that will be coming out
- 0:47in the middle of October called Come On, Get Happy The Making of Summer
- 0:52Stock. Gentlemen, welcome back to Forgotten Hollywood. Thanks thanks Doug. Great
- 0:57to be back. Yes, well, thank you for great to come back
- 1:00and enjoyed the conversations the last time. And we know we get you have
- 1:06a new book coming out, Come On, Get Happy The Making of Summer
- 1:08Stock. And first question just want to ask you is maybe provide a little
- 1:12overview of what the book is about for the listeners. Well, I'll jump
- 1:19in Tom so. Summer Stock is a nineteen fifty MGM technicolor musico. It's
- 1:26the third and final pairing of superstars Judy Garland and Gene Kelly. It also
- 1:33happens to be Judy Garland's final film at Metro Goldwin Mayor that she was there
- 1:38for fifteen years since nineteen thirty five, so it was her swan song.
- 1:44We really dive into the back story because there's been a lot of information and
- 1:49some misinformation on the back story, and that it was a tedious long production
- 1:55window. Judy was having some growing emotional problems, despendency issues, other things,
- 2:01and a lot of the misinformation is putting all of these delays at Judy
- 2:06Garland's feet. And I think we go this is about four years in the
- 2:09making of research, Tom and I go into great detail and say, yes,
- 2:13Judy's erratic problems were part of the problem, but they certainly were not
- 2:19the only reason the film took six months to finish. I think the other
- 2:24thing, Doug that's really important is summer Stock is not always on the tongue
- 2:30of people when they talk about the great MGM musicals, Even Judy, it's
- 2:34Easter Parade or Meet Me in Saint Louis or Wizard of Oz, or for
- 2:38Gene of course, Singing in the Rain or an American in Paris. But
- 2:42the reality is, and Tom and I have talked about this, we watched
- 2:45it last night as a matter of fact, again for the upteenth time.
- 2:50It's one of the greatest tap dance musicals ever made. One two for one
- 2:54hundred and eight minutes. While the plotline may be a bit trite, let's
- 3:00put a show on in the barn kind of thing, there's probably more quality
- 3:05musical numbers crammed into that one hundred eight minutes, arguably than most any other
- 3:10musical from the heyday of the forties and fifties. So there's so many compelling
- 3:15reasons that we thought this book needs, this film needs a spotlight book,
- 3:22This film needs a closer look and examination, and that's why we undertook this
- 3:27project. Yeah, very interesting, you know, And you mentioned there's a
- 3:31lot of myths or misinformation out there about a lot of these movies films that
- 3:38are out there, And that's one of the reasons that I've started this podcasting
- 3:42or really enjoyed talking to authors like yourself, because with social media out there,
- 3:49everybody just takes it as the gospel as the word, and I have
- 3:53really enjoyed talking to authors like yourself that really tried to do your homework and
- 3:59really bring to write some of the truth when it comes out to some of
- 4:03these misconceptions or miss around the film. And I really appreciate what you and
- 4:10others do to really try to set the record straight. Thanks, thank you,
- 4:15And you know, Douglas, you know, when you're talking about a
- 4:17film that's seventy three years old and we're interviewing people, we're getting opinions.
- 4:24In some cases we were getting memories, and sometimes they were conflicting memories.
- 4:30So we as historians and authors can do nothing more than present both sides and
- 4:35let the reader make their own thoughts or opinions on what might be true or
- 4:41not true. Yeah. Well, I think a lot of times, because
- 4:45of Judy Garland's past, I'll just leave it at that, it's easy to
- 4:49throw a lot of dirt or negative towards her and use her as an escape
- 4:56goat because of our past history. Yeah, that's that's very true, and
- 5:01that's one of the major major myths we tried to debunk. As Dave spoke
- 5:06about that, you know, laying this all these delays, all these problems
- 5:11at the feet of Judy Garland is unfair. I mean, there were some
- 5:14delays and there, and she was at an emotional low level when she was
- 5:18filming this, But that was part of the reason that that really surrounded the
- 5:23casting of the movie. The casting. You know, they got Chuck Walter's
- 5:28directing, Jeane Kelly co starring Phil Silver's Eddie Brack and Glory to Haven.
- 5:32They were all people that loved and knew Judy and that she was comfortable with.
- 5:38So they were all these like strong shoulders of support to brack at her
- 5:42when she had these little doll periods during the film, and that, you
- 5:45know, I think made it maybe not easy to complete the film, but
- 5:48it really lent itself to getting the film done, you know, because there
- 5:54were a couple of times when Judy wanted to bail from the film. Jean
- 5:58never really wanted to be in it because it was sort of a you know,
- 6:01not really advancing the musical stuff that he was doing and was interested in.
- 6:06But he his love for Judy was so heartfelt and deep, and you
- 6:11can see that in the movie that he said I would wait, I'll wait
- 6:15a year if it takes to be stand by Judy's side and to get this
- 6:19movie made. I will not do anything, you know else, I will
- 6:24be there for Judy, which is really and all the rest of the cast
- 6:28felt that way too, which I think Judy really really appreciated. Well,
- 6:32yeah, and Doug as it pertained to the plot, you know, let's
- 6:35put on a show in the barn. I me know, a lot of
- 6:39conventional wisdom is that they were trying to get Mickey Rooney and you know,
- 6:43to reunite with Judy, and that really never had strong firm footing. In
- 6:48fact, I think his name may have been floated out here and there he
- 6:51was on the wayne as box office. Gene of course was on the ascension
- 6:56as being an even bigger star. And the reality is section of Summer Stock
- 7:00began in late November of nineteen forty nine, but the announcement of Summer Stock
- 7:06in the Hollywood Reporter came in December of nineteen forty eight, and Gene Kelly
- 7:13and Judy Garland were attached to it via that article as early as December of
- 7:18forty eight. Now, Judy's name went disappeared periodically through the months as being
- 7:25in the film, but Gene Kelly was attached to that film from the get
- 7:29go absolutely did anything surprise you during your research. Well, I would say
- 7:36a one big thing and this was another little you know, myth that we
- 7:42broke, well, a couple of things, and Dave can elaborate after I
- 7:46do that. It's always been said that Get Happy was the last number filmed
- 7:53of Summer Stock that Judy Garland came back from a hiatus. He had lost
- 7:58all this, all these pounds and film Get Happy, and that's and she
- 8:01was so trimmed down that everyone thought it was an outtake from another movie,
- 8:05which Dave can go into. But Geen filmed as the last number of the
- 8:11movie after principal photography was done. They figured they said he needed another solo.
- 8:16There wasn't a solo really for Gene. There was kind of the dig
- 8:20for Your Dinner. But so that's where he came up with the Squeaky Board
- 8:24in Newspaper Dance, which is his favorite number, favorite solo that he ever
- 8:28did, that he's attested to, and he that So that was filmed after
- 8:33Get Happy was filmed. And Dave can tell you maybe a little bit about
- 8:35Get Happy. Well, and yeah, you know, some people thought because
- 8:41Judy looked very healthy in Summer Stock, and in fact, in some earlier
- 8:46pictures. She didn't. She was almost too thin in the opinion of many
- 8:50people. So she came back ready to go with Summer Stock. And many
- 8:54people then saw Get Happy, which is sort of the finale of the film,
- 9:00and thought that this was a number cut from an earlier picture or something
- 9:03else, which of course is not true. It was actually, as Tom
- 9:07said, shot only a few weeks after Judy finished principal photography in February of
- 9:13nineteen fifty, she came back shot the film. She personally selected Get Happy
- 9:18as the songs. She wanted to do the Kohler Ireland song, and she
- 9:22showed and the costume was actually a holdover from a number that she shot and
- 9:31was cut in nineteen forty eight from Easter Parade, So there was that holdover
- 9:37as far as the costume was concerned. The other thing that if you read
- 9:41Vincent Minelli's memoir, he said the inspiration for that costume was a classical ballet
- 9:48artist is a Tamara deep GeV A. But in our research we discovered that
- 9:56the actual inspiration for that costume that was designed was from Marlena Dietrick. And
- 10:03the other thing that we from our research was and had with director Charles Walters
- 10:07when we were college students in nineteen eighty. He used different tricks to motivate
- 10:13Judy into amazing performances, and in the case of Get Happy, he said,
- 10:20think of yourself as Lena Horne, and so Judy was actually channeling Lena
- 10:26Horne and thinking Lena Horne when she shot the get Happy number. But as
- 10:31Tom points out, aptly, everyone assumed get Happy was an afterthought. It
- 10:35was the last thing shot. They tagged it on. But again Gene Kelly's
- 10:39amazing solo with the squeaky board in newspaper, and we go into great detail
- 10:43on how and the other people involved in helping him conceive that number. Now,
- 10:54Nick Castle Jr. All played a little role in developing that amazing and
- 11:01just to elaborate a little bit of that, one of the people that helped
- 11:05Jean that we talked to was his daughter, Carrie Kelly, who is now
- 11:11a world renowned psychotherapist, and she told us, how, you know,
- 11:16Jean to sort of include her into his little work when he could, they
- 11:20will. They would fold newspapers and she would fold them and do all this
- 11:24kind of origami stuff. Basically with these newspapers on the weekends when Jean would
- 11:30try and rehearse it and see how it would tear when he jumps on the
- 11:35paper and he tears it with his feet. So they had to do all
- 11:37this experimentation, and Carrie remembers that vividly, saying like, yeah, I
- 11:41was, I was part of that. I was constantly folding different you know
- 11:46newspapers, old newspapers, new newspapers, wetting them down, scoring them,
- 11:52just trying to figure out at the folds, trying to figure out how it'll
- 11:54care for my dad. And she said it was his really his way to
- 11:58kind include her into, you know, doing stuff on the weekend when he
- 12:03was trying to figure this number out with Nick Castle, the choreographer of the
- 12:09film. Very cool to think that he just wasn't in the other room working.
- 12:16He actually tried to include his daughter and make her part of that and
- 12:20spend time with her, I assume, and all that good stuff. Very
- 12:22that is a very neat story and very cool. And in terms of that,
- 12:26you talked a little bit about Jean and Judy's relationship. Can you just
- 12:33maybe elaborate a little bit more on that. Obviously you said he said he'd
- 12:37wait up to a year for her. What was it like on the set,
- 12:43Well, the set was one of a security blanket, and as Tom
- 12:46pointed out, producer Joe Pastornick and Louis B. Mayer, who was still
- 12:50at the studio at that time, he was not too far from his way
- 12:54out. They knew that Judy was in a fragile state. And my asterisk
- 12:58and it's in the book we write about Judy. People need to Some people
- 13:03don't quite have the empathy that we think we people should have. In the
- 13:07case of Judy, particularly at that time of her life, her marriage to
- 13:09Vincent Minelli was gone. It was on the rocks. She had a young
- 13:13toddler, which was Eliza, so she had, you know, her handsful
- 13:18to put it bluntly, so you know it was so. Jean and Judy
- 13:22first became acquainted when Jean was on Broadway in Pale. Joey and Judy went
- 13:28to New York to with Mickey to appear in some live performances to support one
- 13:33of her films, So Judy and Jean. Judy was able to rid herself
- 13:37of her entourage, and Jean and Judy went bar hopping in Manhattan together so
- 13:43they had that early relationship. Then when Jean got signed first by David O'selznick
- 13:48and then MGM bought the contract. His first film was nineteen forty two for
- 13:54Me and My Gale, who was the star of that show. Judy Garland
- 13:56was the star of that picture and showed Jean the ropes on how to make
- 14:03the transition from trying to project to the third balcony in a Broadway theater to
- 14:07how to project and act in front of the more intimate camera. So Jean
- 14:13was always indebted to Judy, and then in nineteen forty eight they made this
- 14:18ambitious musical sort of a cult classic called The Pirate. But again, if
- 14:22you look at what they do together in Summer Stock from a musical standpoint,
- 14:26arguably the best dance routine that Judy did and Judy did with Jean is the
- 14:31Portland Fancy Number from Summerstock. But a going back to your earlier question,
- 14:37Chuck Walters worked with Judy from nineteen forty two presenting Lily Myers. He would
- 14:41choreygraphed routines and meet me in Saint Louis. He did Easter Parade. He
- 14:46was the director of Easter parade, so he knew how to get a performance
- 14:52and motivate Judy. Jean by the time of Summer Stock was the security blanket,
- 14:58as was Chuck, as was as Tom mentioned, Eddie Bracken Glory to
- 15:03Haven Phil Silver's. There was true love and empathy on that set, and
- 15:07they were all bound and determined like a giant arms around Judy to get her
- 15:11to the finish line, which they did a funny thing about Eddie Bracken,
- 15:16who I think both Dave and I feel steal the movie as far as comedy
- 15:22goes from Phil Silver's who was probably the de facto comedian, but you know,
- 15:30Eddie Bracken is the Oliver Milk toast Orville wind Gate. Is just hysterical
- 15:35and one of the things that he brought to the film was that he would
- 15:39crack Judy up. Judy. All Judy had to do was look at him.
- 15:43And we talked to Eddie years and years and years ago, and he's
- 15:46passed away now, but he said she couldn't even look at him, and
- 15:50she started, you know, dying laughing. And they would do practical jokes
- 15:54with each other on the set, and he was always this huge, huge
- 15:58book for her. As far as keeping her you know, laughing and in
- 16:04a humorous, good mood. So he was one of like, as Dave
- 16:07said, one of those strong shoulders, you know, along with Phil Silvers
- 16:11who knew her real well from they would go to Kelly's house on weekends.
- 16:15He had these famous parties at seven twenty five North Rodeo where he lived for
- 16:21years and years with his wife, and Phil Silvers would be there all the
- 16:26time. Judy would be singing at the piano. So they knew each other,
- 16:29you know, socially for years, and he was he was a big
- 16:32help too well. And what's kind of said it is, you know,
- 16:37here we are in twenty twenty three, and I don't know if the stars
- 16:41would have that same relationship today that they had back then, And probably they'd
- 16:47be selling each other out, trying to see who could be in the next
- 16:51edition of X y Z magazine or newspaper or TikTok or whatever the keats might
- 16:56be. And I think we've lost a little bit of that detection or that
- 17:02crimarity that some of the older stars had with one another. Well, it
- 17:07was also you know, that was a sort of a signature the studio system,
- 17:11like in Hollywood back in the you know, forties and thirties and even
- 17:15in the early fifties, it was a real company town. Everyone knew each
- 17:19other, they all worked for different studios, they all socialized together, and
- 17:25you know, they were contracted to these studios, so you know, it
- 17:27wasn't so much of a dog eat dog. I mean, they did.
- 17:32They were presented with projects that they either did or maybe they didn't want to
- 17:36do, and they might be put on suspension, or if they had enough
- 17:40power that they you know, they were given a pass. But you know,
- 17:44it's just very, very different now. You know, the whole the
- 17:48whole entertainment business is sort of changed in probably not a good way from from
- 17:53that regard, you know, Doug, there's we've all heard the stories and
- 17:57this up until current times that there are really happy sets, everyone gets along,
- 18:03and sometimes there are unhappy sets. And I look at Summer Stuck a
- 18:08little bit like it was a happy set in the supportive aspect that we're discussing.
- 18:15But I also use the analogy making art is a little bit sometimes can
- 18:19be a little bit like making sausage. It's not always pretty, but the
- 18:25end result can be really tasty. And I think in the case of Summersock,
- 18:29that sort of holds true. But I go and say that, you
- 18:33know, Chuck Walters as the director really probably was the brunt of most of
- 18:37the strain, most of the stress, as he points out in the interview
- 18:42we had with him in other places that you know he was you know,
- 18:45do you know, one cigarette after another and the film gave them an ulcer
- 18:49and this look like we're having fun. I think Gene and the people in
- 18:55front of the camera seated the reality that they did not have the same level
- 19:00of responsibility as Charles Walters as the director. Well, gentlemen, thank you
- 19:07for coming on and spending a few minutes with us with Come On, Get
- 19:11Happy. They're making a summer stock which will be out in the middle of
- 19:15October. But I understand and correctly gentlemen if I'm wrong, but we have
- 19:18a code for our listeners to get thirty percent off through the end of this
- 19:23year December thirty one, twenty twenty three. You have to go out to
- 19:27the University Press of Mississippi and order to order the book, and the code
- 19:33is in all caps, get Happy three zero or thirty Get Happy three zero.
- 19:41We'll make sure we put this in the show notes, but please go
- 19:45out and get a copy of the book. Come on, get happy.
- 19:48They're making a summer stock. I don't think you're going to be disappointed.
- 19:52But gentlemen, before I let you go, I believe for those in the
- 19:56Indiana Chicago, Illinois area, you're going to be making in some appearances and
- 20:00here in the Midwest, and would you like to just kind of share where
- 20:06and when people can come and get a copy of the book and maybe speak
- 20:08to you guys as well. Sure, we are Midwesterners, so it's home
- 20:14for us to be doing a Midwest tour. And just as an asterisk to
- 20:18the thirty percent off, we understand that's at the University Press of Mississippi site.
- 20:22I know a lot of people just like to click right away on Amazon.
- 20:26So the book is available in the usual places Barnes and no About Amazon
- 20:30and pretty much all the indies, so I always want we want to give
- 20:33a plug to those indie booksellers as well, because there's not as many as
- 20:37they're used to be. But we actually have two Chicago area dates and one
- 20:42at the Great America Songbook Foundation in Carmel, Indiana. So the first date
- 20:49in the Chicago Land area is on Monday, October sixteenth at seven pm at
- 20:57the Northbrook Jewish Community Center, Northbrook JCC at seven pm. It's free.
- 21:04Then on the pre prior to that, I should say I'm going backwards.
- 21:08Saturday the fourteenth of October eleven am. We're going to be in the city
- 21:15of Chicago with our longtime friend and former Minnesota Daily colleague Mike Phillips, who's
- 21:21the film critic at the Chicago Tribune. We're going to be introducing Summer Stock
- 21:26at the music Box Theater. It's going to be shown the thirty five millimeter
- 21:30print will be shown in its entirety on the fourteenth of October at the music
- 21:34Box at eleven am. Will do a short introduction and then following the film,
- 21:40we will have a discussion in book signing. So we have those two
- 21:42dates and then on Tuesday the seventeenth, hopefully I have my dates right in
- 21:48my head. Tuesday, October seventeenth at seven pm, another free event,
- 21:52and that will be at the Great American Songbook Foundation. And also kudos and
- 21:56special thanks to the originator of the organization, which is wonderful Michael Feinstein,
- 22:03because Michael Finstein deserves high praise not just for his compliments about our book,
- 22:07but also for taking the time to contribute really meaningful content to the book as
- 22:11well. So we'll be at the Great American Songbook Foundation and Carmel on Tuesday
- 22:18the seventeenth at seven pm as well. All three excellent. If you're in
- 22:22the area of the Chicago or the Carmel, Indiana area, please get out
- 22:26and especially in the Chicago area, get out of October of the fourteenth,
- 22:32eleven am and get a chance to watch the film, talk to these two
- 22:37authors, these great individuals, David and Tom, and get a copy of
- 22:41the book. I know they would appreciate it, and I think you're going
- 22:44to enjoy it as well and not be disappointed. And again be sure to
- 22:48go out and worry your copy if you can't make it. University of Press,
- 22:51Mississippi. That thirty percent off to the end of the year. Gentlemen,
- 22:55again, thank you so much for spending some time with us today.
- 22:56We wish you nothing but the best on success your book. Right thanks to
- 23:02hope to see you in person in October. Yeah, absolutely forward to it.
- 23:06Ye, yes, absolutely, I'm gonna do my best to make the
- 23:08Carmel event and be able to meet you guys in person and and forget the
- 23:15zoom recording and be able to talk in person, so actually look forward to
- 23:18it. Yes, well, thank you again for listening to this episode of
- 23:22Forgotten Hollywood. Just search for Doecast for Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find
- 23:26me on Twitter, Instagram at hes doug fourteen. If you listen to this
- 23:29podcast on iTunes and another podcast service, please subscribe, rate, and review
- 23:33this episode. Tune in next time for the latest edition of Forgotten Hollywood.
- 23:37Thank you for listening and we will see you then.