Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E016: Alex Thorn – Bitcoin is King
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 0:12unaffected by the demand. If you want to preserve your
- 0:16wealth, you have. To convert.
- 0:18That currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable,
- 0:22portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:31Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom and I'm happy to welcome you to
- 0:34the 16th episode of Scarce Assets, a show that examines
- 0:37scarcity, the most fundamental driver of economics and markets
- 0:40and the scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 0:43My Co host, Jesse is traveling today, but he'll be back for the
- 0:46next episode. In the meantime, I'm happy to
- 0:49introduce my guest, Alex Thorne. Now Alex is Head of firm Wide
- 0:53Research at Galaxy Digital, where he leads a team of
- 0:56researchers covering the crypto ecosystem.
- 0:59Prior to that, he spent 12 years at Fidelity Investments where he
- 1:02Co managed Avon ventures, the early stage crypto VC fund
- 1:07affiliated with the parent company.
- 1:09And before that he was director of blockchain research at
- 1:12Fidelity Center for applied tech applied technology, excuse me,
- 1:16where he directed tech experimentation and also
- 1:19published research. Now I'm going to add my
- 1:21editorial here, which is that although it covers a wide space
- 1:24that many people would label as general crypto, I think Alex is
- 1:28one of the very best researchers in the field who gives Bitcoin
- 1:31the respect it deserves. And he also has a great podcast
- 1:35called Galaxy Brands. I listen to it all the time,
- 1:38including this morning when I heard his great interview with
- 1:40Richie Torres, and I'm sure we'll talk about that today.
- 1:44So Alex, thank you for the work you do and thank you for coming
- 1:47on Scarce Assets. How are you?
- 1:49I'm great, Andy, thanks for having me.
- 1:50I'm a big fan also of your work. And I, I think that's right.
- 1:54By the way, I, I look at the world through the crypto world
- 1:58through a Bitcoin lens, right? I'm a long time Bitcoiner.
- 2:02I think it's the most important project in crypto.
- 2:05I think it's very different from block chains and crypto as a
- 2:10segment. I think you're crazy if you're
- 2:12interested in this technology or the crypto asset class and you
- 2:16don't own Bitcoin, you're absolutely underweight.
- 2:19I think the most important digital asset that there is.
- 2:22But also, I mean, I think it it, there's a lot more to Bitcoin
- 2:26than its technology. And you know, we can long time
- 2:29followers of crypto will know that there's been literally
- 2:32dozens of attempts at creating a quote better Bitcoin.
- 2:36None of them have been better than Bitcoin and and most of
- 2:38them have outright failed. There's plenty of reasons for
- 2:42that, but I yes, I am interested in blockchain technology.
- 2:45I'm interested in in and what it can do.
- 2:49I'm interested in the segments like Defy and, and whether and,
- 2:52and I am interested in distributed networking and
- 2:54whether other types of block chains have other features.
- 2:57But I think Bitcoin is the most important.
- 3:00I think it's likely to be the most important for a long time.
- 3:03And it's very interesting. And we have a huge Bitcoin
- 3:07businesses at Galaxy. A giant portion of our company
- 3:10is focused on Bitcoin trading, Bitcoin lending, Bitcoin mining,
- 3:14right? Like we, so you know, Galaxy is
- 3:16involved in the whole of market. So of course we also do other
- 3:19things in the broader crypto space.
- 3:21But I think bitcoins, Michael, Michael Saylor says Bitcoin is
- 3:29the there is no second best, right?
- 3:31So I look, I'm interested in everything.
- 3:33I have a team of researchers. I mostly research Bitcoin and
- 3:36regulation and markets. I have other researchers who
- 3:40cover Ethereum and stuff. And I, I think it's perfectly
- 3:42valid to be interested in the broader crypto ecosystem.
- 3:46I think there's other interesting things happening,
- 3:47but there is, you know, you can't, you come at the king, you
- 3:50best not miss. There's something, there's
- 3:53something different and special happening with Bitcoin than the
- 3:55other things. Well, let's talk about coming at
- 3:57the king and let's talk about, you know, just throw you some
- 4:01red meat. Let's talk about politics.
- 4:04Oh, OK, yeah. For for a minute, so yeah.
- 4:06You. Recently published a thread on
- 4:08Twitter X discussing why a Kamala Harris administration, if
- 4:13elected, might continue with policies that are basically
- 4:18hostile to Bitcoin and crypto. Can you tell us about that?
- 4:23Yeah. And I and I, I think the big
- 4:24first caveat is we really don't know.
- 4:27We don't know. Kamal Harris has yet to speak
- 4:30after winning the nomination off the teleprompter, right.
- 4:34So outside of a few rallies with scripted remarks, we don't have
- 4:38any platform from her. We don't have any policy
- 4:41positions. You know, we have the Biden
- 4:43administration's positions of which she was the vice
- 4:46president, and we know that those were broadly negative.
- 4:49I mean, you know, Bitcoin doesn't have a lot of business
- 4:52before the government in the scheme of things, certainly not
- 4:54like crypto does, which is, you know, all entangled in questions
- 4:57of securities or commodities and various types of financial
- 5:01regulation questions. Bitcoins primary things I would
- 5:04say before, you know, from a legislative and regulatory
- 5:07standpoint, obviously the Bitcoin ETF was business before
- 5:11the SEC. They had to be drag kicking and
- 5:13screaming with the DC Circuit Court of Appeals ruling to even
- 5:16do that, but they have done it now.
- 5:18So I would say there's not much business for the for Bitcoin at
- 5:21the SEC level. There are possibilities that the
- 5:24CFT CS mandate could expand into spot markets, which could result
- 5:28in more regulation of spot Bitcoin trading.
- 5:32And then I would say the the the big questions that that by the
- 5:36way, Bitcoin and crypto share it still has right is self custody
- 5:41legal? Do blockchain nodes, even home
- 5:46nodes, lightning nodes, just straight up archival nodes that
- 5:49merely relay transactions. So they have to perform bank
- 5:52like compliance activities. The you know, should you have,
- 5:58what do they call it? The, the, the, the travel rule?
- 6:01Like should transactions have to be KYC?
- 6:03Should miners have to KYC the transactions in their blocks,
- 6:07Right. These these questions are big
- 6:10important questions that are in some cases existential in my
- 6:13view, for the legality of Bitcoin.
- 6:16I don't think, like, you know, Bitcoin could be outright banned
- 6:18in the US and I think in the long run Bitcoin will survive
- 6:21anyway, but that would be bad. And I think these questions
- 6:26overlap between Bitcoin and crypto.
- 6:28You know, the Etherium people are just as concerned about
- 6:30whether miners have to transact all their transactions the same
- 6:33way. Would would this prove mistake?
- 6:35Validators have to do that, right?
- 6:36So there's there is plenty of overlap.
- 6:38That's something I think the corners miss.
- 6:40Sometimes they say like, what do we care?
- 6:41Bitcoins not on the menu at the SEC.
- 6:43There's other stuff out there that's not good.
- 6:46We don't have any concrete policy positions from the
- 6:49Democratic presidential ticket yet.
- 6:51And as far as I can tell, neither Kamala Harris nor Tim
- 6:54Waltz have ever mentioned the word crypto or Bitcoin ever.
- 6:58I don't even think they've said the word blockchain, right?
- 7:00So we, we don't know. So what we look to for guidance
- 7:05on this is who is advising them on economic and, and financial
- 7:09regulatory policy. And again, it's still early.
- 7:12I mean, I'm, I, I think it's a lot of people are optimistic
- 7:15that it's possible we could get a slightly better outcome under
- 7:18a Harris Waltz administration than under a Biden Harris
- 7:20administration. We know that the Trump Vance
- 7:23ticket is extremely favorable. So, but I, I'm of the view that
- 7:28Bitcoin is nonpartisan. It's frankly apolitical.
- 7:31I think there are some aspects of it that are appealing to
- 7:35different political factions. For example, it's perfect
- 7:38scarcity, you know, aligns well with Austrian economic monetary
- 7:42theory. It's radical permissionlessness
- 7:46and self sovereignty, you know, appeals to people that want
- 7:48independence from government. Like there are some sort of I, I
- 7:52think like small lowercase P political aspects to the, the
- 7:56platform itself and the network itself.
- 7:58There's also plenty though, that appealed broadly to, you know,
- 8:01more classic American liberal values, like, you know, no
- 8:05intermediaries, you know, you can't be redlined by your bank,
- 8:08right? It doesn't see race or gender or
- 8:10sexual orientation, right? All that stuff is very positive.
- 8:13So I think in general, it's mostly apolitical.
- 8:16It certainly should be nonpartisan in my view.
- 8:18And I think for the, for any industry or project or platform
- 8:22or asset to be, you know, have great success in America, it
- 8:26certainly shouldn't be seen as a Republican thing or a Democratic
- 8:30thing. So I, I'm very in favor of
- 8:32reaching out to the Democratic Party and trying to help them
- 8:36understand the promise of Bitcoin and, and that it could,
- 8:39it is positive and it can be positive for America.
- 8:43So I'm open and I'm hoping that we'll get better open to and
- 8:46hoping that we get better policies out of a Harris Waltz
- 8:50ticket and, and if they win a Harris Waltz administration than
- 8:53we currently have. But like I said, people are
- 8:57policy. And some of the people that
- 9:00apparently reported by both the Journal and Bloomberg are
- 9:03advising Vice President Harris include two notoriously anti
- 9:10crypto and Bitcoin people, Brian Deese and Bharat Ramamurti.
- 9:14Brian led the National Economic Council.
- 9:17Bharat was his deputy for two or three years.
- 9:21All around the time that the Biden administration did this
- 9:25executive order mandated survey of crypto, right?
- 9:27They looked at a whole bunch of stuff, including Bitcoin mining
- 9:29all across the government, and they have a very strong anti
- 9:34crypto bent and I and I would venture to say they were at the
- 9:37at the center of this operation choke .2 point O, which is which
- 9:43I'm happy to summarize for the audience, if if that is helpful,
- 9:46but we're we're pretty confident they were key architects of that
- 9:51And by the way, that which is this effectively the systematic
- 9:55coercive, either de banking or creating of roadblocks and
- 9:59barriers for just companies involved in Bitcoin and
- 10:02cryptocurrency to have bank accounts and for banks to deal
- 10:05with companies like this, which I think is a fundamentally UN
- 10:09American thing to do right for legal businesses, make it
- 10:12impossible for them to get banking.
- 10:15That's, you know, you can't pay employees very easily without a
- 10:18bank account. In the scheme of things, Sure,
- 10:19you can pay them in Bitcoin or stable coins or whatever, but
- 10:22you know it's pretty hard to exist in American capital
- 10:25markets without a bank account. So we don't know what they're
- 10:28doing for her. Again, we don't know a lot about
- 10:30this policy, but just sort of throwing up the red flag here
- 10:34that these are two people who who really don't like us.
- 10:37That's what that thread was about.
- 10:39And you know, but again, like I said, we should reserve
- 10:41judgement. It's I think the the question is
- 10:43if if they end up being central to a Harris Waltz
- 10:47administration's Financial Policy, that's bad for us.
- 10:50At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 10:53asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 10:57right. There are shortcomings with
- 10:59keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 11:02up your own self custody arrangement.
- 11:04On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 11:07Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 11:10minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 11:14remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 11:17inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 11:20well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 11:22for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 11:25for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 11:28set up. For more information, check us
- 11:31out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, no, I really appreciate
- 11:35that summary. I sort of it makes me feel about
- 11:39it makes me think about, OK, yeah, you know, there's more
- 11:41cards to be turned over in the poker game here.
- 11:44We don't know that much, but the cards that have been turned over
- 11:49are not great. You know, the flop, the flop has
- 11:51come and it it doesn't look fantastic.
- 11:54We've still got a couple more cards coming.
- 11:57I'm curious about the feels. I mean, you know, and I don't
- 12:01want you to speak for your boss, Mike Novogratz, but I think he's
- 12:04a pretty committed Democrat. I just wonder what the feeling
- 12:09is among, you know, among guys like him who are committed
- 12:13Democrats in terms of, you know, the, the educational effort.
- 12:18I know people on the Democratic side who are bitcoiners have
- 12:24reached out, you know, have made significant efforts to help
- 12:28educate the Democratic side. You know, I'm sure at any way
- 12:32they're willing to, you know, to accept, to accept help and
- 12:36information. I mean, is there a feeling of
- 12:39frustration kind of generalized at this point?
- 12:41Do you have any, do you have any sense not speaking for
- 12:44particular individuals, but just kind of the the group?
- 12:48Yeah, I think people are trying to get to them, right?
- 12:50I mean, there's there is a concerted effort to try to get
- 12:53in front of the Harris Waltz teams to educate them on on
- 12:59Bitcoin and why it's good and why it's not a threat to the
- 13:03country, right. And why you should you know why
- 13:05it's part of an innovation mandate, why there are jobs the
- 13:09Bitcoin brings, why it's good for the energy grid, right.
- 13:12Like there, there are a lot of efforts, I think from a lot of
- 13:14different people. My my sense is that it's the the
- 13:17message they're getting back is that the campaign is open to
- 13:21this, but we but we haven't seen a lot of engagement, right.
- 13:24I mean, even, you know, we're recording this on Thursday,
- 13:27August 15th, on Wednesday, last night, the 14th, there was this
- 13:30call crypto for Harris. And this is mostly organized, my
- 13:36understanding by, you know, Democratic activists in
- 13:40Washington who may work on crypto policy either for
- 13:43companies or lobbying firms or whatnot.
- 13:45And you know, there were some appearances from prominent
- 13:49Democrats, Chuck Schumer, but a lot of these were via video, pre
- 13:53recorded video. There was no, my understanding
- 13:57is appearance from any official from the Harris Waltz campaign.
- 14:02There aren't really that many officials yet.
- 14:05So it it seems sort of like the I, I would say I think people
- 14:09are are a little frustrated. I do think people are actually
- 14:12optimistic, though. One, the campaign is through
- 14:16channels officially signaling openness to this conversation.
- 14:19They're just not really engaging yet.
- 14:21I'm in it. And yeah, I mean, there is
- 14:24concern about like if if Brian Deese and Bharat Ramamurti are
- 14:28deeply involved in shaping the this campaign's economic policy.
- 14:33To be clear, like Bitcoin and crypto is like pretty low state,
- 14:36like low on the list of priorities for like American
- 14:38economic policy people. You know, things like inflation
- 14:42and global trade are higher on the list.
- 14:46But what I think people want is to get the candidates to care,
- 14:50right? Because if they care, then the
- 14:54policy won't simply be outsourced to these technocrats
- 14:57and bureaucrats. Because if it is, if it is
- 14:59brought Rahamurdi and, and no one gives him some other mandate
- 15:02on this issue, we know where he stands.
- 15:05And it's highly restrictive, combative to to the to Bitcoin.
- 15:09And so, yeah, I would say it's cautious optimism.
- 15:12I would also say that like, I think most of us believe that it
- 15:15can't really get worse than the Biden administration.
- 15:19They were extremely hostile, particularly the SEC,
- 15:22particularly Treasury. Another person who's been
- 15:25floated in those same articles and reported to be, you know, on
- 15:29a short list for Treasury Secretary is this guy Wally
- 15:31Adeyamo. And Wally is, he's not as bad as
- 15:35Barat. He doesn't appear to be as
- 15:37combative, but he's very aligned with the KYCAML on blockchain
- 15:42nodes on minors thing that really emanates from Elizabeth
- 15:45Warren, right? That's not great.
- 15:48So I would say it's cautious optimism.
- 15:51I think most likely, I mean, I've even said this straight up
- 15:53for Bitcoin price, like I think we're in a range, we're in the
- 15:5550 to 70 K range. I don't think we really go much
- 15:58lower than the 49 K dip we had on last Monday on the like
- 16:02Japanese yen carry trade on wine situation.
- 16:05But like, and I think you, you, you probably can't get worse
- 16:10than a hair, probably even a, a no engagement Harris
- 16:13administration might even be just slightly better because of
- 16:16some turnover. But I, I, I think that, you
- 16:20know, the potential upside is huge.
- 16:22I think a Trump victory is very supportive for Bitcoin.
- 16:25So you're meant to be cautiously protective on the downside and,
- 16:30and own like wingy upside or certainly be long in the face of
- 16:33that. I don't think so.
- 16:35I would say probably people aren't that worried, but we're
- 16:38not getting much back yet from that campaign.
- 16:41Yeah. No, I think that's really well
- 16:42said. And some of that, I'm sure,
- 16:43comes from long experience, you know, years in the space, which
- 16:46is there's always FUD. Well, so there's always FUD, but
- 16:49there's always, you know, I guess real substantive threats,
- 16:53at least potentially from government.
- 16:54And some days I wake up thinking, you know, they're all
- 16:59gonna come at us guns blazing. And then other days I wake up
- 17:02thinking, you know, this is, I don't know, for me, seven years
- 17:05in now. And it's like, you know, nothing
- 17:07really that bad has happened, nothing existential.
- 17:11And yeah, I like your framing of sort of Trump election, you
- 17:16know, probably big upside potential for Bitcoin Harris
- 17:19selection, you know, probably probably not much worse.
- 17:22So maybe hit, you know, heads I win, tails I don't lose or
- 17:26something, something along those lines.
- 17:29Oh, and also, by the way, you know, we're still at only a
- 17:32trillion in change of network value for Bitcoin, fraction of
- 17:35the value of gold. Yeah, To be clear, like all else
- 17:38equal, a Harris administration, assuming they're not like
- 17:40catastrophically worse than the current situation like you, you
- 17:43have to remain bullish on Bitcoin.
- 17:45It's not Bitcoin doesn't stay in that range forever.
- 17:47I think of that range as basically through the election,
- 17:49right? We sort of think about it that
- 17:50way. I don't see other major
- 17:52catalysts upside or downside between now and then.
- 17:55I think that probably is the main catalyst for the next few
- 17:59months. But I mean, again, in a Harris
- 18:00Waltz victory scenario, like it's probably not much more
- 18:04restrictive from a regulatory standpoint than it is now.
- 18:08And then you still have global macro conditions.
- 18:10You have, you know, the the perpetual, you know, degradation
- 18:14of the dollar. You have fed policy which is
- 18:18likely to turn to easing, which should be supportive for scarce
- 18:22assets. And so like, I mean, and you
- 18:25have the adoption curve, you have the ETF adoptions like you,
- 18:28you have plenty of longer term. All all those longer term
- 18:31Bitcoin catalysts remain. So I, I don't, you know, I, I
- 18:34think it's fine. I mean, I think This is why you
- 18:36saw like 49 K bought up like crazy when it went down to that
- 18:40level. Even I had a sub 20% down 20%
- 18:43limit by order set on river that I'd even forgotten about that I
- 18:46woke up to being filled on it like 50K to do 50.2 or
- 18:49something. Like.
- 18:50I think I think people are very constructive on the on the
- 18:53trajectory for Bitcoin. It's more of a question of and,
- 18:56and, and I think it is fair to point out like the, the risks,
- 18:59the regulatory risk broadly applies much more to other
- 19:02cryptos than it does to Bitcoin in general, right.
- 19:05I mean, so much of that risk is related to the securities laws,
- 19:08which bitcoins really immune to at this point.
- 19:10I mean, so there's no so I, yeah, I think Bitcoin in
- 19:13particular is, and I've said this, I was calling for EPTC to
- 19:17go much lower last fall. I continue, I would say it's
- 19:20pretty low now, like so I'm not I'm not I'm not necessarily
- 19:23calling. I haven't rewritten.
- 19:25I'm still basically in the like, it should go lower.
- 19:27But the main thesis there was just that like all of these
- 19:30regulatory rules are so much more damaging to the Etherium
- 19:34world than Bitcoin. There's custody rule stuff,
- 19:37there's the exchange definition, there's like AMLKYC stuff that's
- 19:42hits it more than Bitcoin, right?
- 19:44And it some of that has eased with like recent Supreme Court
- 19:47rulings and, and, and other things.
- 19:49But like the downside scenario of a Harris Waltz campaign
- 19:55victory in itself applies much more broadly to the broader
- 19:58cryptocurrency landscape than it does to Bitcoin anyway.
- 20:03But yes, that that's how I think about it.
- 20:05Well, that's awesome. So first of all, good on you for
- 20:07having the stink bid in for Bitcoin that you didn't even
- 20:11remember that you forgot. It's like finding the $20 bill
- 20:14in the couch cushions. It was, except Bitcoins much
- 20:17better than finding than finding Fiat.
- 20:19So I love that you brought up ETH in terms of BTC and you
- 20:24know, we're not an ETH podcast, but I got it.
- 20:26I am really actually interested in your take there.
- 20:29I look at a chart. You know, I look at a chart, the
- 20:31very long term chart ET BTC and I see sort of a giant, you know,
- 20:37triangle or narrowing range. Like since inception and lately,
- 20:41you know, the the upper edge of that narrowing range has been,
- 20:47you know, EPTC has been falling kind of sort of bleeding out
- 20:50over a significant period of time now and then it just dumped
- 20:54recently and it's it may have dumped out of, you know, the
- 20:58support edge of the range, the bottom edge of the range.
- 21:01So I'm just I guess I do want to ask you, I mean, you said you
- 21:04haven't published. So maybe you're sort of
- 21:06reserving judgment, but you know, is this, is this the
- 21:09failure of that, you know, of that cross or, you know, or or
- 21:15still could there be, you know, another alt season, who knows
- 21:19next year, God knows when. It's it's a it's a really
- 21:22interesting question. And and yeah, I mean, I think
- 21:24long term bit corners don't need to care too much about this one
- 21:27way or another. I also don't think it is a 0 sum
- 21:29game and in general and markets like wealth can be created.
- 21:33Look, the Etherium people can make money and that doesn't I, I
- 21:36don't view that as being negative to Bitcoin.
- 21:39Like that's, you know, they're different.
- 21:40I view them as different. I think they are obviously if
- 21:43you look at how these block chains operate and what they,
- 21:46what their purposes are, they are different.
- 21:49Some people have a different view on that.
- 21:50A lot of Bitcoiners that I'm friends with or say that it
- 21:53takes away investment from Bitcoin.
- 21:55But like, look, Bitcoin doesn't do the things that Etherium does
- 21:58most of them. And that's good.
- 22:00Like I think that's they should be different.
- 22:03Yeah. I mean, look it, it, it years
- 22:05ago in like 1617, EPTC was much higher briefly.
- 22:09It spiked huge. Then during that 18/19/20 bear
- 22:13market, it came down, which historically has been the trend,
- 22:18right? People fleet equality and they
- 22:19they would fleet a Bitcoin and it and it's initial spike was
- 22:23all in the ICO craze, which you had to buy ETH to do, right.
- 22:27So like, that's why it went up high.
- 22:30Then it rebounded The the it's it's more local.
- 22:32Last few years high was all on the merge, right?
- 22:35So this was all on there was a very boring summer in in crypto
- 22:39markets. This is like 2022, right?
- 22:43And like people got really excited.
- 22:45Traders got excited about the merge, like the when Ethereum,
- 22:48right, they changed out the engine mid flight, right?
- 22:50They changed from proof of work consensus to proof of stake.
- 22:54And so there's a huge run up then when people are like
- 22:56playing a trade around whether they should, whether this was
- 22:59bullish, right? And it peaks at the merch and
- 23:01it's been basically down only since.
- 23:03And that's like 2 1/2 full years of down only EPTC ratio,
- 23:09literally lower lows and lower highs pretty much the entire
- 23:12time in a pretty nice downward channel, right?
- 23:17I think this is this time is a little different, right?
- 23:21I mean, you're in a bull market historically these bull market,
- 23:24you think? I mean, Bitcoin's the only asset
- 23:27that made a new all time high so far, right?
- 23:29E has not. And I don't, I think even
- 23:33Solana, which you know, 10X from fall of last year till now or
- 23:39till recently or whatever, like still didn't make a new all time
- 23:42high yet either. I think the situation is kind of
- 23:45different. You haven't seen an alt season.
- 23:47What we ended up seeing in crypto markets over the last
- 23:50year, a Bitcoin LED rally fueled in in large part, I think by
- 23:55hype around the ETFs. Think about this drum beat,
- 23:57right? Like we pretty much knew the
- 23:59market was pretty sure they would be approved as early as
- 24:03like late September. And you had months and months
- 24:06and months of like James Seyfart and Eric Balchunis, like
- 24:09updating us with new filings. I mean, it was a really fun
- 24:12market to be honest, because you had this drum beat.
- 24:14And like people that followed closely were pretty sure even in
- 24:17August when that ruling came out against in Grayscale's favor
- 24:21against the SEC, that like this ruling was the nail in the
- 24:24coffin for the SE CS denial arguments.
- 24:27So you have this giant, giant drum beat that of course did
- 24:29culminate with them launching in January on January 11th.
- 24:32And then you had about two weeks where people hadn't really
- 24:36figured out how to like buy these yet or whatever or like,
- 24:38you know, getting turned on. But Grayscale was out out
- 24:40flowing. And then after about two weeks
- 24:44in like from like mid to late January through March, you had
- 24:48just like unbelievable amounts of inflows into these products
- 24:51and Bitcoin just ran to new all time highs.
- 24:54Nothing else did right. And then you had you had
- 24:56basically the only the, the hot from a token standpoint, the
- 24:59other hot thing in crypto. And I'm gonna get to the
- 25:02question part of this 'cause I think it's relevant, but it was
- 25:04meme coins, right? There was all this meme coin
- 25:06frenzy. It was a point where 10,000 meme
- 25:08coins were being launched on Solana an hour every hour.
- 25:12One of the most successful crypto start-ups this year is
- 25:15Pump dot Fun, which literally like automates the process of
- 25:18launching a meme coin like from literally creation of the token
- 25:23to getting it listed on a Solana decks right so that it can trade
- 25:28and. Turn key solution for creating
- 25:30meme coins. That's exactly right and and now
- 25:33obviously meme coins by definition have no utility,
- 25:37right? They're not they're they are
- 25:38literally memes like to be clear, in case the audience is
- 25:41unaware, they have no purpose at all.
- 25:43That's the point. Separately, I think that like
- 25:47says something really dark about the state of the global economy
- 25:50and people's feelings of hopelessness of getting ahead
- 25:53that they, it's, it's, it's somewhat akin to the rise of
- 25:56like sports gambling, in my view, which is, and at least
- 26:00sports, like his teams playing sports.
- 26:02It's not. I mean, meme coins are the
- 26:05distillation of the most cynical way of trading, right?
- 26:09Like the literally trading it for no reason at all.
- 26:12It's the apotheosis of financial nihilism.
- 26:15It is. It absolutely is.
- 26:17It's extremely well said. I completely agree with that.
- 26:21And so you have this barbell of like the most iconic, you know,
- 26:26secure, scarce digital asset ever created, like having
- 26:31institutional adoption on one side, all of the crypto stuff in
- 26:36the middle, not that interesting to the market.
- 26:37Defy NFTS all doing like me, like I mean defy functioning
- 26:42successfully, but you know, it's not defy tokens not doing great
- 26:46and what not and like the story isn't defied I the traders, the
- 26:49institutional traders that trade crypto, not energized by it.
- 26:53NFT trading volumes still down a lot from where they were right.
- 26:56All these sort of other narrative web three like kind of
- 26:58going nowhere at the moment. A lot of that built on Ethereum
- 27:03and then on the far other end, this like apotheosis of cynical,
- 27:08you know, hopelessness of meme coins.
- 27:11So that's where we've been. And because of that, and now, of
- 27:14course, as a platform, Etherium effectively facing unprecedented
- 27:17challenge from Solana, like in all of the history of these
- 27:21networks, like Etherium's never faced such a compelling all L1
- 27:26as Solana. It's, it's also fundamentally a
- 27:29different technology than Etherium.
- 27:30So it's not just like previously all these Etherium killers,
- 27:33quote UN quote, were just sort of like clones of Etherium,
- 27:36right? With slight tweaks.
- 27:37Solana's fundamentally designed much differently, for better or
- 27:40worse. I, I think all of this has
- 27:42really weighed on that ETH BTC ratio and I mean, just if you
- 27:46want to look at the ETH soul ratio too to learn about that
- 27:49story, you'll see it there as well.
- 27:51So I, I, I think Ethereum is sort of getting squeezed on both
- 27:54sides. It had tried to be remember they
- 27:57had they, they have they altered the monetary policy yet again
- 28:00and started calling it ultrasound money, because the
- 28:04more it's used, the more deflationary it gets.
- 28:07Like, OK, it's it's an interesting, it's interesting to
- 28:09me. But again, like that, I don't
- 28:11think they understand what sound money actually means, which is
- 28:13that the line should be straight, like we should know
- 28:15what the line is, right, and should be unchanging, credibly
- 28:20transparent, right, which is what Bitcoins monetary policy
- 28:23is. Whereas there's this all over
- 28:25the place, right? And yes, it it sometimes is more
- 28:28deflationary than Bitcoin. Great, OK, But like, you know,
- 28:31the whole point to me of a sound monetary theory is even more
- 28:35than the fact that it that it that it's monetary expansion
- 28:38declines over the time, sure, and eventually decays to
- 28:40effectively nothing even more than that.
- 28:43It's that it's predictable. It's transparent, predictable,
- 28:46incredibly unchanging. It's inelastic.
- 28:49Like that's sound money to me. And of course, Ethereum is not
- 28:52that. So it's it fails at that.
- 28:54And I think smart people know this.
- 28:57Investors in Bitcoin because of its monetary policy, they know
- 29:00that Ethereum's not credible in that way.
- 29:03And then as a platform turns out like for applications and other
- 29:07types of crypto use cases, Solana has proven to be very
- 29:11competitive here, right? So in that sense, it's actually
- 29:14getting squeezed on both sides from a narrative standpoint.
- 29:17I think that's been a big part of that story.
- 29:21And and, and yeah, we just haven't seen the alt season
- 29:23where like ETH and a bunch of alts RIP.
- 29:25So like, I mean, I, I don't know if we will.
- 29:27I don't know that we won't. I do think Etherium will find
- 29:29its footing a little bit now that it also has ETFs, but also
- 29:34the recent drop. I mean it, it's pretty much
- 29:38widely used now as like a collateral currency and and not
- 29:41much more for the people that we talked to, right.
- 29:44So that's more about well, can I buy ETH and fund it with can I
- 29:47buy Solana and fund it with, with ETH, right?
- 29:49Like it's there, I would say. And this is does make me wonder
- 29:53about whether we are nearing a bottom in that ratio because I
- 29:57can just tell you broadly across the crypto trading, you know,
- 30:03like diaspora, I don't know like ecosystem community like that.
- 30:08We talked to just basically all of the biggest crypto trading
- 30:11funds who also trade Bitcoin. Obviously.
- 30:14I would say it's pretty unprecedented bearishness for
- 30:17ETH, at least on a relative basis right now.
- 30:20And so you kind of wonder also if you look at they have the
- 30:23same dynamic on a much smaller scale with the ETF's with
- 30:26grayscale outflows and you know, net inflows into others, it's
- 30:30much smaller scale. To be clear, like these things
- 30:32are trading $300 million of volume a day right now on it's
- 30:35like bad days. Bitcoin ETF's trade a billion,
- 30:37so it's like more than triple. And of course Grayscale like
- 30:41GBDC was 30 billion in assets and outflowed half, which is a
- 30:48huge amount and an absolute basis E ETF EE was 10 billion.
- 30:52And and so it's like it was a third, right.
- 30:54So you are seeing the ETH EE outflows recede.
- 30:58And so you, you, you probably do start to get to a net inflows
- 31:02situation cumulatively for the ETF at some point, which should
- 31:05then be more constructive for ETH.
- 31:07But right now they're experiencing unprecedented
- 31:09outflows with an issue or complex that frankly was
- 31:13unprepared to market them, right, because everyone thought
- 31:16they would be denied and they, they really did think that so.
- 31:20And most of them are focused on selling Bitcoin still.
- 31:22I think if you, I, I bet you, if you talked, if, if, if they
- 31:25would talk, you know, off the record or candidly, most of the
- 31:29ETF issuers that have both would have preferred that they weren't
- 31:31the ETH ones were not approved yet.
- 31:33And that they could spend the next year or two educating and
- 31:37marketing the Bitcoin ETFs and then move to the Etherium ETFs.
- 31:40Like they're really, there was not the like 5 month drum beat
- 31:43and like anticipation and then like massive explosion of
- 31:47interest right when they hit them.
- 31:48I mean, I think people are going to look back and really be, be
- 31:53really blown away when they, when they recall, like the, the
- 31:56drum beat of excitement for the Bitcoin ETFs was truly something
- 31:59you, you probably won't see again ever in markets.
- 32:03So all of that contributing to Bitcoin's outperformance.
- 32:06That's a phenomenal summary, by the way, for listeners who feel
- 32:09like digging back into the archive.
- 32:12There's a period of probably a couple years where I used to
- 32:16write articles. I did about a dozen articles for
- 32:18Coindesk, and my goal was just to write about Bitcoin, you
- 32:22know, basically just to get Bitcoin content, you know, into
- 32:26the broader cacophony of, you know, whatever gets published on
- 32:30Coindesk. But I did write one article
- 32:33about Etherium and the title was Sell the Etherium Merge.
- 32:40That's a good call. That's what happened.
- 32:43Yeah, I did not, I actually did not expect that trade at least
- 32:46in Bitcoin terms to to last as long as as long as it has, but
- 32:51but there you go. Well, you mentioned, Alex, you
- 32:54mentioned use as collateral. Maybe we could talk about
- 32:58another form of collateral which is wrapped BTCWBTC.
- 33:05You know, I hear there's some news about change in the
- 33:10structure of wrapped BTC. My guess is you're aware of
- 33:15what's going on there. Can you tell us a little bit
- 33:18about what's going on because this does affect the use of
- 33:23Bitcoin as collateral and therefore effects Bitcoin demand
- 33:27throughout the ecosystem? Yeah, so so RAP BTC is an
- 33:32Etherium token collateralized with Bitcoin 1 to one, right.
- 33:35So think of it like a stable coin, except instead of tracking
- 33:37the dollar and holding dollar like assets, bit go issues the
- 33:41RAP BTC token and holds Bitcoin in an equal amount and they have
- 33:45a good it is a good tool. If you're somebody who wants to
- 33:49use Bitcoin in other cryptocurrency ecosystems,
- 33:53primarily Etherium D5 right? You want to lend Bitcoin or
- 33:57borrow Bitcoin using Ethereum's platforms, then then rap Bitcoin
- 34:02is the main way that people do that.
- 34:05And to Bitco's credit, this is a pretty good product.
- 34:07It has daily cryptographic attestations of the proof of
- 34:10reserves of the Bitcoin Bitco, of course, a very old and and
- 34:14long time multi sig based and and promoting Bitcoin custodian
- 34:20in the scheme of things, one of the oldest and if I think if you
- 34:23go, I think it's WBTC dot network.
- 34:25Maybe is the dashboard so far. If anybody wants to let me just
- 34:28double check that so I give the correct URL dot network.
- 34:33I think this is the website. It is Yep.
- 34:37So they have a dashboard. So they have 154,000 Bitcoin,
- 34:41which is a lot. I mean, that's, that's that
- 34:43makes this product or whatever. And by the way, it looks like
- 34:47it's on several other networks too, not just Etherium, but it's
- 34:50154.265 BTC and that is then tokenized into an ERC 20 token
- 34:58on Etherium, right? That lets you just do Bitcoin
- 35:02on, on Etherium. Now obviously it there's, it's
- 35:05not, you know. Similar order magnitude, right
- 35:07to MicroStrategy or you know, the biggest Bitcoin ETFs?
- 35:12Just so that's right at. The stage for listeners like
- 35:14this is. A That's right.
- 35:15It's it. That's a lot.
- 35:16Ash, this is a major stack. Of coins yeah there's a if we
- 35:20look at where bitcoins currently are sitting on the network I
- 35:24think MicroStrategy is well over 200,000 Bitcoin at this point
- 35:27but they're they're may be the single largest holder probably
- 35:29at US some of it sitting with the US government a fairly large
- 35:34amount or other governments that seize them right this would
- 35:38remember Trump had announced in Nashville that he wouldn't sell
- 35:41those Bitcoin and that would form the basis of the national
- 35:44strategic Bitcoin stockpile. He said other governments have
- 35:48seized Bitcoin, right? Germany was selling all this
- 35:50Bitcoin down that they seized from a piracy website.
- 35:52Like of course, ETFs hold a lot of Bitcoin and then by the way,
- 35:57the plebs hold a lot of Bitcoin as well.
- 35:58Like the everyday person holds plenty of Bitcoin in that sort
- 36:02of capital stack. But one of the big ones is
- 36:04Bitco's wrap Bitcoin products. So it does matter.
- 36:08Obviously these WBTC tokens have different, I'll use the well
- 36:14overused term, trade-offs. They have different features
- 36:16than actually native Bitcoin, right?
- 36:18You're not inheriting the security of the underlying
- 36:21Bitcoin blockchain. You're relying one on the
- 36:24custody of Bitco, both their, their competence and their you
- 36:30know that they're not malevolent, they don't steal the
- 36:33Bitcoin or something, right? I think WBTC users know that,
- 36:37but that's it's not sovereign, right?
- 36:40Of course, you have smart contract risk related to both
- 36:42their contract that they issue it with and wherever you use it.
- 36:46If you put it in Ave. or Compound or one of these Defy
- 36:49applications on Ethereum, then you're taking risks there too.
- 36:51So it is different risk profile than native Bitcoin.
- 36:55But yes, native Bitcoin collateralizes it.
- 36:56My understanding of the story is that Bitco is now spinning it
- 37:00out into a joint venture with Bit Digital, which is a foreign
- 37:05company, I don't know exactly where headquartered somewhere in
- 37:07Asia that it involves Justin's son, right?
- 37:10And I don't know Justin's son, the founder of Tron and also, I
- 37:16believe one of the largest crypto traders in the world.
- 37:20And I think I don't know the motivation for that.
- 37:23I don't know what it really will mean, what it appears to mean.
- 37:27I, I, I saw Mike Belshi, the CEO of Bitco saying that it that
- 37:31there will be a multi jurisdictional multi sig now
- 37:34holding the keys for the underlying Bitcoin.
- 37:38I I don't know, but I think people are some people are
- 37:40concerned about Justin Sun's involvement in that right.
- 37:44So I think that's that's the story.
- 37:45I don't have much more information on it.
- 37:48I do know I did see that maker Dow, which is a decentralized
- 37:51stable coin and sort of lending platform on Ethereum, one of the
- 37:54oldest Defy apps they allowed and had a large amount of their
- 37:59stable coin die collateralized with wrapped Bitcoin.
- 38:03And there is a motion in their governance process to remove it
- 38:06as a thing in direct response to this.
- 38:10And I saw also that it appears Coinbase may be about to launch
- 38:13their own version of rap Bitcoin now CBBTC they said.
- 38:18So yeah, it's an interesting it look and I would step back to
- 38:22and broadly say, you know, people ask me, are the ETFs good
- 38:25for Bitcoin? Like, you know, like do we
- 38:26really want Bitcoin over there? It's not as good as, you know, I
- 38:29I personally self custody my Bitcoin and I'm not going to say
- 38:31how, but I believe in using actual Bitcoin and gaining the
- 38:37full sovereign benefits of holding Bitcoin myself.
- 38:40And it's hard. And if you can't figure out how
- 38:42to do it safely, there's a lot of great resources out there by
- 38:45the way, to help. But if not, I think that's OK.
- 38:47Like, but you know, I mean, I trust my stocks to Fidelity like
- 38:51I like, I get it, like I I but I also happen to believe that if
- 38:55you want Bitcoin to be extremely widely adopted as money, even
- 38:59just as digital gold. But let's even say money, if you
- 39:03believe in the concept of hyper bitcoinization, that it's going
- 39:05to be so widely available that you you might pay with it, you
- 39:09might save in it, Maybe you'll invest with it.
- 39:11Like it's going to be in every single system.
- 39:14Like, right, Like dollars in a bank account are different than
- 39:16dollars in a money market fund and dollars on in cash in your
- 39:19hand. Like they're all, they all are
- 39:21the same unit, They're all the same asset, but they have
- 39:24different properties. They have different, you know,
- 39:26cash under the mattress is more secure than cash in the bank in
- 39:29terms of having it literally stolen from you, right?
- 39:31Like if you're in, if you have your cash in a Cyprian bank And
- 39:34and like in the, you know, in the last decade, they took half
- 39:37of it, right? Like when the country was going
- 39:39bankrupt, like they, they did a haircut on it.
- 39:41This is what got Winklevoss twins interested in Bitcoin, by
- 39:44the way. They can't do that if your cash
- 39:46is under the mattress. Similarly, like if they try to
- 39:4919, you know, executive order 61 O2 your Bitcoin.
- 39:53If they just say they it's illegal to own Bitcoin the way
- 39:55that it once was illegal to own gold.
- 39:57Well, if you have the Bitcoin self custodied securely, like
- 40:00they're not going to be able to take it right, So it's going to.
- 40:02But if you have it at a third party custodian or exchange,
- 40:05maybe they can't. So there's, there's different
- 40:07trade-offs, but I believe that in the long run, like for
- 40:10Bitcoin to be hyper successful, it needs to.
- 40:12Be everywhere Bitcoin in your bank account, Bitcoin on your
- 40:14brokerage account, Bitcoin in your gold vault, Bitcoin perhaps
- 40:18on your Ethereum if Ethereum's going to exist like there are
- 40:21there. So I don't view that like rap.
- 40:24Bitcoin is like bad for Bitcoin the same way I don't really view
- 40:28the ETFs as bad for Bitcoin. I do think it's incumbent upon
- 40:31Bitcoiners to make sure that the values, the features and
- 40:35capabilities of Bitcoin that express its most important
- 40:39underlying values like permissionlessness, openness,
- 40:42credible monetary policy, self custody, unstoppable payments,
- 40:47those features that that enable those things do need to be
- 40:51protected in the protocol itself in the long run because that is
- 40:54important. So if all the ETF issuers were
- 40:57to band together and say we want a hard fork that makes Bitcoin
- 41:00KYC for every transaction, that has to be opposed, obviously,
- 41:05right? But I don't I luckily it's not a
- 41:07proof of stake system. So the amount of Bitcoin that
- 41:09you hold basically gives you no technical advantage in dictating
- 41:13the future of the protocol, unlike a proof of state network
- 41:16where capital literally controls consensus.
- 41:19So, but nonetheless, there's a giant pile of this Bitcoin and
- 41:21rap Bitcoin. And I don't know, I mean, it
- 41:23looks like Coinbase is planning to compete.
- 41:24It's possible others will as well.
- 41:26Does your Bitcoin custody set up keep you up at night?
- 41:29Maybe you still have coins sitting on an exchange worried
- 41:32about hackers. Or maybe you've set up your own
- 41:34self custody but don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings
- 41:37stashed on a little plastic device in your desk drawer.
- 41:40Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp and our multi institution
- 41:44custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 41:47On Ramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 41:50separate institutions each hold a key on ramp bit go and coin
- 41:54cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 41:58Instead, only you have control over your coins with on ramps
- 42:02multi institution custody. You'll sleep better at night
- 42:05knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class security on
- 42:08chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 42:11If you believe your Bitcoin is going to be worth a lot someday,
- 42:15don't jeopardize that future by exposing your coins to hackers
- 42:18on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks in the real world, or perhaps
- 42:22most importantly, the risk that you might screw something up
- 42:25with a highly technical self custody set up on ramps.
- 42:28Multi institution custody eliminates single points of
- 42:31failure, reduces your personal attack surface and technical
- 42:35burden, and provides access to financial services that allow
- 42:38you to confidently secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance
- 42:42planning, insurance backed warranties for all balances and
- 42:44transactions, low cost trading, and more.
- 42:48Bitcoin is a once in a species asset, secure it right.
- 42:51Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com. Yeah, No, I think it's really
- 42:55interesting. It's really well said with
- 42:57respect to, you know, the ethos in Bitcoin and the core, the
- 43:00core factors that must be protected on the main chain.
- 43:05You know, some of our listeners will be hardcore Bitcoiners,
- 43:09they understand these distinctions.
- 43:11Others are newer and and learning, you know, one of the
- 43:15things we're doing at onramp obviously is multi institution,
- 43:18multi sig Bitco, by the way, is one of the key holders.
- 43:22And so one one way to understand this is rapt BTC is and maybe
- 43:26this new instantiation. Likewise, by the way, on ramps,
- 43:30you know, doing multi jurisdiction custody.
- 43:32So these are sort of good ideas. There's they're, they make sense
- 43:37with respect to security, you know, for anyone who is willing
- 43:41to entrust, let's say a quorum of third parties to, to hold
- 43:45their Bitcoin. And of course, with the wrapped
- 43:48BTC having the extra layer, as you pointed out rightly of let's
- 43:53call it, you know, Ethereum risk or Tron risk or whatever,
- 43:57whatever, wherever that coin is wrapped, whatever wraps that
- 44:01coin is that other sort of additional, additional layer of
- 44:05risk which is worth being aware of and worth understanding.
- 44:09Absolutely. If you're playing in that space.
- 44:11And yeah, yeah, the reality of Bitcoin just being, if Bitcoin
- 44:15continues to succeed, people will do additional new and
- 44:19strange and sometimes terrible and sometimes wonderful things
- 44:23with their coins. And that's just gonna be the
- 44:27path that adoption takes as this thing gets bigger and bigger.
- 44:31Yeah, we're going to see weird stuff.
- 44:33I agree. Well, you've already seen.
- 44:37You and I both have already seen quite a bit of of weird stuff in
- 44:40our travels. You you probably more than than
- 44:42I have. That's why I like it.
- 44:44I mean, that's one of the main things that draw draws me to
- 44:47this to be a researcher in Bitcoin and in crypto is it's
- 44:50just so interesting. There's just so much interesting
- 44:52stuff happening. I of course, I believe in the
- 44:55long term future and, and importance of Bitcoin, but like
- 44:58also, I just think it's a fascinating industry to cover
- 45:01and work in. There's so much weird and
- 45:04exciting stuff happening and, and of course, at its best,
- 45:08right, like crypto, including Bitcoin can have such a massive
- 45:13change to the world, right? It can be such a positive at its
- 45:17best. At its worst, it's one of the
- 45:18most entertaining and terrible industries in the history of
- 45:21mankind, right? So like we've got such a broad
- 45:24thing, you know, we just try and you know, I try Galaxy tries,
- 45:27for example, to be on the right side of that and not be part of
- 45:30the fraud or scams that have plagued, you know, the high
- 45:33profile ones that have plagued us in the past.
- 45:35But yes, at dude at its best and in Bitcoin is certainly on the
- 45:40side of the spectrum of the best.
- 45:43I think it's, it's just such a fascinating and positive thing
- 45:45that it's just about, you know, you trying to bend that arc over
- 45:49time towards, you know, permissionlessness, scarcity,
- 45:52self custody and and good monetary policy.
- 45:55That's it, that's it. Never a dull moment.
- 45:57Very rewarding reminder by the way, people, people I
- 46:01periodically get inbound, you know, asking me, you know,
- 46:03should I come work in, in the Bitcoin industry and I say,
- 46:05well, just don't forget the downturns and don't forget the
- 46:10don't forget the cyclicality. Oh, it hardens you.
- 46:12It hardens you completely, right.
- 46:14I mean, we've got, I mean, it's like what there's all these
- 46:16memes, you know, they're like, Oh my gosh, the NASDAQ down 5%.
- 46:19Like, you know, stock guys, like, you know, despondent, he's
- 46:23freaking out, right? Bitcoin is going down 50%.
- 46:26We're like, do I have any more money to buy?
- 46:28Or like we're like laughing memes on Twitter and stuff.
- 46:31I mean, it's it's we've been through a lot the longer you're
- 46:34in this space. And by the way, just to be
- 46:36clear, I mean, volatility is going down over time.
- 46:38It has been right. I mean, you know, there was AI
- 46:41actually remember there was one of the scariest downturns that I
- 46:44saw and people don't talk about this lot was Labor Day 2017.
- 46:49Bitcoin was up around $4000, crashed to like 1400.
- 46:53It's a big drop, bigger than the 50% drop.
- 46:55This is during what we know now was a massive bull run.
- 46:59It ended up like almost 20 exit from there and in just a few
- 47:03months, right? But like people didn't know that
- 47:05was going to happen. They didn't know it was going to
- 47:07go to 20 K in December 2017. Only three months before it was
- 47:11down like 65% in the middle of what was supposed to be a bull
- 47:14market, right. We just saw what a 25% drawdown
- 47:18in in pretty aggressive recovery too.
- 47:20I mean, we're still in like the high 50s and low 60s.
- 47:24So we're not like back at all time highs, but like, I mean
- 47:26that this is a that was a huge market move.
- 47:30Bitcoin had last week, last Monday and the weekend before,
- 47:32right? Like down 25% is a lot of money.
- 47:35You had a $10,000 red candle. Like on that chart, that's a big
- 47:39decline, but it's only like 25%. Like we've seen 60 plus percent
- 47:44drawdowns during Blair bull markets, right?
- 47:47So like, if you've been in this space a long time, like it and
- 47:50it's good because like the same people, you know, we, we, if you
- 47:53look at the long term Bitcoin price chart or you, you explain
- 47:57and teach the fundamentals of Bitcoin.
- 47:59Smart people understand that and see the long term potential,
- 48:03right? But yet still a lot of these
- 48:05smart people are then like, Oh my gosh, is it going to 0?
- 48:07And I'm like, wow, how are you still asking that?
- 48:09Of course it's not going to 0. What is this?
- 48:12A correction? A correction for ANTS 25.
- 48:14I'll. Tell you how exactly Alex, my
- 48:17first Bitcoin that I bought was literally the day after the hard
- 48:21fork August 2nd 2017, and it's not because I was waiting to see
- 48:26like how the the hard fork would shake out no, it's because I
- 48:29couldn't like fund my Coinbase account faster.
- 48:32Yeah right. Because I just discovered it and
- 48:35Bitcoin was going to take over the world and you know and and
- 48:38and yeah, I also viscerally remember because I made then
- 48:42subsequently a sizable buy right around call it 5K and it
- 48:48immediately went to 3K in like right three days and I was a
- 48:53little bit shocked and stunned and so yes, every new
- 48:58participant that comes into the market, you know, maybe it's
- 49:00guys buying in the ETF if they haven't owned it.
- 49:04Well, it's like my dad used to tell me, you don't understand
- 49:08taking losses until you viscerally understand it, which
- 49:11is literally in your gut as it's happening to you.
- 49:15And so yes, it's just, it's just, I think human nature that
- 49:18may just just be the way it goes.
- 49:20Yeah, it really is. You know, it's like that.
- 49:22There's that meme of like the two, the two information desks
- 49:26and one of them says like Bitcoin AT70K and it's totally
- 49:29empty. And then one or sorry, it's
- 49:31Bitcoin at 50K and it's totally empty.
- 49:33And then the other one says Bitcoin AT70K and the line's out
- 49:35the door. And it's like, you know, if you
- 49:37love Bitcoin at 73 K, you should love it at 50K.
- 49:40Like it's, isn't it cheaper? But it's just people just they
- 49:43can't do it, you know, but more people are, are, are getting
- 49:46good at doing it. More people are owning Bitcoin
- 49:48every day. The IT is also, I mean, I think
- 49:50this was very evident in Nashville, but, and actually an
- 49:53Etherium person wrote an interesting thread about this
- 49:56that was like a very focused Etherium like ecosystem person
- 49:59was at the conference in Nashville and they wrote a whole
- 50:01thread being like, I just need to explain to the Etherium world
- 50:04that like what is happening in Bitcoin is completely different
- 50:08than what is happening in Etherium from a, from a movement
- 50:11standpoint. Like Bitcoin in a lot of ways is
- 50:14a movement even more than a money.
- 50:16And well, movements may have monies and it certainly is a
- 50:19money, it's certainly a commodity type of asset as well.
- 50:24But the, the more and more people everyday are owning
- 50:27Bitcoin and buying Bitcoin, and so that volatility does go down.
- 50:30So those people are learning and, and, and the, you know,
- 50:33dude, I'm literally backing up the truck.
- 50:35I mean, I bought, I did. Another one was when BSV was
- 50:38forking from BCH, Bitcoin had literally like like a like a
- 50:42dying patient had still the echoes coming down from the 2017
- 50:47drawdown. So it's now like November 2018,
- 50:50almost a full year later and it's still just like lower low,
- 50:53like kind of flat, though around six is the bottom, but just
- 50:56lower highs over and over again. And then it literally like
- 50:58flatlines at like 6K for like a month.
- 51:01And I'm like, all right, this is the bottom.
- 51:02We're at the bottom. I'm going to buy.
- 51:03And then, and then I think probably because Roger Veer or
- 51:07like Craig Wright had some Bitcoin and when they launched
- 51:09BSV, they decided to dump the remainder of their Bitcoin
- 51:12immediately nuke to 3K, like 50% additional drawdown from 6:00 to
- 51:163:00. And then that of course ended up
- 51:17being the actual bottom. And I was literally buying like
- 51:21I was like, oh, it went below 6. It's been at six for a month.
- 51:24It was like 5950. I'm like buying like you, you
- 51:29just get burned with that. I mean, you have a long and
- 51:31again, I, I was buying the whole time anyway, probably all the
- 51:33way down. I still now just I tell people
- 51:36I've been dollar cost averaging for five years now weekly, which
- 51:41is great because now I just know, look, did I, I, I can tell
- 51:46you for a fact that I bought every top and bought every
- 51:48bottom. Why?
- 51:49Because I'm just always buying like, and this is also the
- 51:51mindset that I, I tell institutional investors.
- 51:54I try to like, I'm not saying they have to think like that,
- 51:56right? They've got professional
- 51:57investors. They're going to do position
- 52:00sizing and portfolio strategy and maybe time try to time the
- 52:04market because they're good at investing, right?
- 52:06Not everybody is and I get that, but like, you know, I think I
- 52:12know that I bought every bottom because I'm just buying.
- 52:14And I think, and I try to explain to them that like this
- 52:16is a mentality, like they're try to explain the movement to the
- 52:19investors who see it as an asset or an asset class.
- 52:23And it is. But I'm like, there's also, you
- 52:25know, 10,000 people standing in a room to talk about Bitcoin
- 52:29now. Like you just don't fully get it
- 52:33unless you learn a little bit and get involved in Bitcoin
- 52:36culture. Like we're kind of built
- 52:37different at this point. And yeah, I mean, dips are for
- 52:41buying. That's it, man.
- 52:43I'd probably put that on my grave.
- 52:44Buy the dip. So it's funny you mentioned that
- 52:46story because I did essentially exactly the same thing.
- 52:49I went in with Ira money in the like the low sixes thinking
- 52:53exactly what you thought. Like, OK, this is the poor we're
- 52:56we're done here. And then gut wrenching puke
- 52:59downward. And that that was and then
- 53:01December stayed down and it was in January, OK, January, the
- 53:06following month that I started writing.
- 53:09Why buy Bitcoin? Partly because it was a test of
- 53:12the thesis. I was there was part of part of
- 53:15me was saying was screaming. Part of my brain was screaming,
- 53:17Andy, what if you're wrong? You better really make sure you
- 53:21understand this asset that that you've put a substantial amount
- 53:26of your net worth into. And so, yeah, that was the
- 53:29genesis for me of the research paper, you know, the test of the
- 53:33thesis, like, oh God, I. Hope I love it Well.
- 53:36And then by by June of 2019, so just nine or seven months after
- 53:43that drop from six to three at the end of 2018, Bitcoin traded
- 53:47over 13,000 during the first Bitcoin conference in San
- 53:50Francisco. And I recall that well.
- 53:52So we we went from in just six months, you went from three to
- 53:5613 and just like, I mean what you're kind of like, well,
- 54:01alright, so then you're 5K buy or my 5500 K buy look or 5500
- 54:06buy looks good. I think I'm pretty much I think
- 54:10Jesse has put out content on this before himself actually,
- 54:14but there's very few times historically where you could
- 54:17have bought Bitcoin and lost money.
- 54:19It's if you if you hold for X number and and micro strategy at
- 54:22their conference in Vegas I was at, they had a good chart on
- 54:25this to forget. I think it's somewhere we can
- 54:27find. But like again, similar idea,
- 54:29like if you held Bitcoin for like more than X number of days,
- 54:32then it literally hasn't ever mattered when you bought it
- 54:35basically, you know? Yep, the cycles.
- 54:38If you can hold the hold through four or five year cycle,
- 54:41historically you've been in the green.
- 54:43There's also the corollary, which I think is unfortunate,
- 54:45which is if you buy the top, you will be underwater for a long
- 54:49time. Yeah, historically speaking,
- 54:52that's true. Bitcoin spends most of its time
- 54:56well below the previous high price it does.
- 55:00People should just just get used to and try and remember, well,
- 55:06we're getting up close to time here.
- 55:07But I do want to ask you one more thing about volatility
- 55:10related issue is I think we're still waiting for approval of
- 55:16options on the Bitcoin ETF products.
- 55:21And by historical standards it's taking longer than usual,
- 55:26although that's been the story of all Bitcoin products at least
- 55:30anything that you can hold in a, in a brokerage account.
- 55:34Do you have any thoughts on the timing there?
- 55:36What's what's going on as well as you know, will that have a
- 55:41significant effect do you think on dollar price volatility, you
- 55:46know, once they are approved? I don't have a good update.
- 55:50It is irregular for it to take this long.
- 55:54Pretty much any other ETF can get options.
- 55:57So it's not clear exactly what the issue is to me.
- 56:02You know, I mean, there is no court case forcing them to
- 56:05approve options at the SEC. And we know that we have an SEC
- 56:09that is hostile to digital assets including Bitcoin.
- 56:12You know, technically they bitcoins the only asset they've
- 56:16said is a commodity. But I mean, like I said, they
- 56:17had to be drag kicking and screaming by the federal court
- 56:21just to approve the ETFs. Nobody really knows why.
- 56:24I mean, I don't really know why do they just hate it?
- 56:26I mean, look, everyone knows bitcoins volatile.
- 56:29There are a ton of volatile equities out there.
- 56:31Like nobody. It's not illegal for an asset
- 56:34for investing to be volatile, right?
- 56:35No risk, no reward. Like everybody knows that.
- 56:38Like there's nothing. I can't think of another reason
- 56:41why they would be delayed. I do think that it would be
- 56:44positive. It should make the market more
- 56:46liquid in general. It should help.
- 56:48It'll certainly help institutional traders and people
- 56:51that work in Bitcoin, everybody from minors to the APS that
- 56:54create and redeem shares in the ETFs to other types of traders,
- 56:58macro traders, right? I mean, options are very useful.
- 57:01They are also useful for gaining leverage or hedging, which are
- 57:04kind of opposite. I think you should get them.
- 57:07I think you will get them at some point.
- 57:09I think 1 interesting thing people don't talk about is that
- 57:11it will, it'll, it'll result in some changes in the Bitcoin
- 57:15market structure. And in that like, you know,
- 57:19Galaxy's one of the biggest options market makers in
- 57:22Bitcoin. We do tons of options trading.
- 57:25And again, like, you know, everyone like Galaxy that does
- 57:30from GSR and Wintermute and Cumberland and whomever else
- 57:33like these big institutional options desks, they'll they'll
- 57:36be impacted by, by the launch of this because there are plenty of
- 57:40we'll still be doing it. And I don't want to speak to
- 57:43Galaxy's future strategies in this area.
- 57:45But like, let's say you're a traditional hedge fund or that
- 57:48wants to trade Bitcoin options. Like you can go to a today, you
- 57:53basically have to go over the counter to firms like Galaxy,
- 57:56right? And yeah, I mean, you could try
- 57:58to, you can trade on dare a bit if you can figure out how to
- 58:00trade in an offshore, offshore options exchange, right?
- 58:04Many can't, we don't really have listed spot options.
- 58:09Not really. I think they're, I think there,
- 58:11there are, there are a couple like, but they're all that's not
- 58:14where the volume is. I think you will see significant
- 58:16volume on the ETF options, which because the Bitcoin ETFs are
- 58:20commodity based trusts that have one job, which is to hold and
- 58:25track the price of Bitcoin. Like it's from a pure exposure
- 58:27standpoint, it's identical. I mean basically to trading an
- 58:31option based on the physical quote UN quote spot Bitcoin.
- 58:35So I think you'll see some disruption in the Bitcoin
- 58:38exchange institutional trading world as these are approved.
- 58:42There's also other opportunities, like I said that
- 58:44I don't want to speak to, but that's one of the things we
- 58:47won't talk about a lot. I think it it could dampen
- 58:49volatility. It doesn't need to.
- 58:51It does help institutionalized the the options, the trading
- 58:56capabilities that that Americans would have access to.
- 58:59And look, Bitcoin is real. It's here to stay.
- 59:02You can buy it in trusts that are offered by the world's
- 59:05biggest asset managers. There's no reason you shouldn't
- 59:07be able to trade options on it like any other asset like.
- 59:12Yeah, absolutely, absolutely makes sense to me.
- 59:14It's a little bit of head scratcher, but but yeah, the
- 59:17lesson, one of the many lessons learned in Bitcoin has been that
- 59:21things take longer than you might expect if there's any
- 59:25involvement of the SEC or or other government agents fees.
- 59:30Well, Alex, this has been a phenomenal conversation.
- 59:34Really appreciate it. I do highly recommend people
- 59:38follow you. Your Twitter X account is at
- 59:41Intangible coins. Galaxy Brains.
- 59:44A great name, by the way. Thank you.
- 59:46Podcast, like I said, I listen to it all the time.
- 59:50I get a lot of value out of it out of it.
- 59:52So highly recommend that to people.
- 59:54What else you know, any place else you want to tell people
- 59:58that they can find you? Or any anything else you want to
- 1:00:00close with? I mean, I love the podcast.
- 1:00:03I, I'm really, I love multi sig in general.
- 1:00:05So I love that you guys are trying to and, and working to
- 1:00:07bring multi sig to institutional and, and institutional
- 1:00:11investors, retirement investors. I think it's really powerful.
- 1:00:15I think multi sig is one of the most.
- 1:00:17And by the way, Bitcoin has multi signature custody as a
- 1:00:21native feature, right? Is not a native feature on
- 1:00:23Ethereum. It has to be done with smart
- 1:00:25contracts and sort of generalized can be done, but
- 1:00:28it's, it's not a native feature. So I encourage people to look
- 1:00:31into multi sig technologies from providers themselves, whatever.
- 1:00:35In general, I think it's really powerful.
- 1:00:38You can read our stuff too at galaxy.com/research.
- 1:00:40We write a lot about Bitcoin, a lot about policy, about other
- 1:00:42cryptos too, if you're interested.
- 1:00:45I really tell my team, our focus is to not just tell you what's
- 1:00:48happening, but to offer a viewpoint.
- 1:00:50So you can obviously disagree with the view, but I feel that
- 1:00:53it turns out, fortunately, people are lazy.
- 1:00:55They like to be told how to think.
- 1:00:57We'll always offer a view, right?
- 1:00:59We're not just like, here's an overview of XYZ.
- 1:01:01We'll always be like, This is why it's matters or doesn't
- 1:01:03matter. Maybe it, we don't think it
- 1:01:05matters or this is the way to think about it.
- 1:01:07So we try to be offer a little bit more insight than some of
- 1:01:10our sort of other friends in the research world.
- 1:01:12So check us out galaxy.com/research.
- 1:01:15I love it. And just in case anyone had any
- 1:01:17doubt about whether Alex Thorne has a view on things, he
- 1:01:21definitely does. That's one of the things I most
- 1:01:24appreciate about you so. Yeah, my views are not scarce,
- 1:01:27I'll tell you that, Andy. Well said.
- 1:01:30Well, we'll close on that one. And thank you, Alex, for coming
- 1:01:33on scarce assets. Thank you, Andy.
- 1:01:35Great to be here. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:01:38week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:01:40valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:01:43rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:01:45All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:01:47notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:01:50reminder that On Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:01:52entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:01:55investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:01:58your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:02:01Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:02:05one of our private Client advisors.