Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Legal UFwOes
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:12Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, where I feel like we just need to add a preface
- 0:18to the start of these things now.
- 0:19The inane laughing at our own jokes is part of the entire process.
- 0:25We are very aware of it. If you're here because you like the person that we are making fun
- 0:30of or learning about, you're probably going to have a bad time. I'm just telling you that
- 0:35now.
- 0:36On an episode that doesn't have one specific person that we're talking about. So here we
- 0:40are laughing and namely laughing nonetheless, but laughing nonetheless.
- 0:46We are your hosts, Taylor and Chelsea laughing and namely, I'm sure at some point in this
- 0:50episode here today talking about I've kind of had a hard time describing my topic today,
- 0:57but I think the easiest way to describe it.
- 0:59With an article from the New York Post.
- 1:01Nothing but New York Post.
- 1:04But only if it's supported by the Epoch Times.
- 1:06I'll never make the mistake again.
- 1:08No, the topic today is I guess the best way to put it is space based or UFO based lawsuits.
- 1:15Oh, even better.
- 1:16And these aren't quite connected cases, but I felt like this would just be a fun thing
- 1:21to do.
- 1:22We haven't done a walk down law lane in a while.
- 1:24So I thought this would be a fun time.
- 1:26Okay, definitely sounds like a fun time.
- 1:30Strap yourself in.
- 1:31There are some interesting stories.
- 1:32We're definitely going to learn about some famous UFO cases, but at the same time, we're
- 1:38not going to look at that much into them because we're more so worrying about the lawsuit
- 1:42that comes about from it.
- 1:44We hate looking at anything in depth.
- 1:46On how you guys want us to look at it.
- 1:48We can vaguely cover it and move on.
- 1:50Perfect.
- 1:51Or allude to it for a couple years.
- 1:52Yeah.
- 1:53And then cover it at some point, maybe.
- 1:54Yeah, exactly.
- 1:55We covered it just cover it poorly in all the ways you wouldn't think of talking about
- 2:00it and then just alluding to it again.
- 2:03And without much more rambling because we just want to get into these stories.
- 2:08Chelsea, I think everybody's at least seen people claiming that the rocks on Mars are
- 2:12different things.
- 2:13Be it lizards, be it bagels, be it big foot way back in the day.
- 2:18But people are always claiming that yet they're taking no actions.
- 2:21How dare they?
- 2:22Well, somebody has in fact taken actions against NASA to force them to look into these issues
- 2:29that they found on the surface of Mars in the photos that they've taken.
- 2:33Interesting.
- 2:34This story comes from a law firm's website, Kahane Law, and it's about this man who's
- 2:38taken the step.
- 2:39So this suit comes from a scientist in California named Dr. Joseph.
- 2:44He is suing NASA for failing or refusing to investigate a rock found by the Mars rover.
- 2:49He claims that the rock is actually an alien life form, a fungus, that they were failing
- 2:53to do their duty by not investigating it properly.
- 2:56Joseph filed his suit in the U.S. District Court in San Francisco against NASA, as well
- 3:00as Charles Bolden, their administrator.
- 3:03In the petition he filed, he said, quote, the refusal to take close up photos from various
- 3:08angles, the refusal to take microscopic images of the specimen, the refusal to release high
- 3:13resolution photos is inexplicable, recklessly negligent, and bizarre, end quote.
- 3:18Joseph also believes that the object is growing since it was first spotted in earlier pictures,
- 3:23and NASA has a different explanation.
- 3:25They do not feel as though it is any type of alien life.
- 3:28They claim that it is merely a rock, although it has, quote, an unusual amount of sulfur,
- 3:32magnesium, and manganese, end quote.
- 3:35They also do not believe that it has moved at all, as others claim.
- 3:39Instead, they say that the rover must have bumped into the rock and moved it.
- 3:43Joseph is demanding that NASA release the high resolution pictures of the object, as
- 3:46well as 24 microscopic shots of the interior, and he wants all of this information made
- 3:52public.
- 3:53Naturally, he also wants the naming rights too.
- 3:55While it might seem outlandish, Joseph is very serious about this belief, and he has
- 3:59others who are backing him up in this.
- 4:01Even if you were right, which is unlikely, and it was an alien life form, the chance
- 4:06of that information coming out because of this lawsuit is pretty slim.
- 4:10It's important to note that this is not Joseph's only fringe type of theory.
- 4:14He's also written a number of papers and books covering the September 11th attack,
- 4:18as well as alien life.
- 4:19For many of these things, this credit is credibility as a scientist, and it is quite unlikely that
- 4:24this suit goes anywhere.
- 4:26Even though Joseph might not be correct about the alien fungus on Mars, which sounds like
- 4:29a 1950s B-movie title, it doesn't mean that others won't continually pursue NASA's images
- 4:34and videos looking for proof.
- 4:36That probably won't be the way that humans discover alien life, it does make for some
- 4:40fine entertainment.
- 4:41Chelsea, this happened in 2014, actually, this case, and I did find the judge's decision.
- 4:46I just took a few quotes from it.
- 4:49Here Joseph requests that the court order NASA to quote, take 100 high resolution close-up
- 4:54in focus photos, end quote, of the specimen he has identified.
- 4:57Take a minimum of 24 microscopic in focus images, end quote, of the specimen.
- 5:03Supply the images to the public, allow Joseph to quote, act as an observer at the rover
- 5:07command facility, and appoint two NASA astrobiologists to rover team, end quote.
- 5:13Credit Joseph with discovering the organism and allow him to appear as first author on
- 5:18the first six articles relating to the discovery.
- 5:21So he petitioned the court for this?
- 5:23This becomes kind of important right here.
- 5:25Justice Joseph has not requested relief and his petition does not state any cause of action
- 5:31other than mandamus, which one sec, I need to actually be able to say what that word
- 5:35is and I don't know it.
- 5:37Not mandamus.
- 5:38Yeah.
- 5:39Oh, it's to make them do something that they're legally required to do.
- 5:42That would make sense.
- 5:44The court orders Joseph to show cause why his petition should not be dismissed for failure
- 5:49to state a claim.
- 5:50Joseph's petition raises only a generalized grievance shared with many citizens.
- 5:55With alleges that he is an astrobiologist and has published many papers in the field
- 5:59petition at 15 to 22.
- 6:01However, quote standing is not measured by the intensity of the litigants interest or
- 6:05the fervor of his advocacy.
- 6:07The only injury Joseph alleges is NASA's failure to investigate a specimen depicted
- 6:12in an image taken during a Mars rover mission.
- 6:15This is not an injury particular to Joseph.
- 6:18Joseph also suggests that he is standing because he is a taxpayer.
- 6:22Currently taxpayer standing is only allowed quote in a narrow range of establishment clause
- 6:26cases and quote because the establishment is a specific limitation on exercise of the
- 6:32power to tax and spend.
- 6:34In addition to not alleging a violation of the establishment clause, Joseph does not
- 6:38appear to have alleged a violation of any specific federal law.
- 6:42Accordingly, it is ordered that Joseph show cause why this case should not be dismissed
- 6:46for failure to state a claim and or for lack of standing.
- 6:49Those are some nice burns.
- 6:50Yeah, I really like when it's formal just telling a year and idiot go away.
- 6:55I also googled this guy and it turns out this is by no means the only ridiculous lawsuit
- 7:01he's filed.
- 7:02All of them he's a self-wrap.
- 7:04So Dr. Joseph sued Amazon in 2012 alleging that Amazon regularly quote publishes and
- 7:11copyrights defamatory and libelous statements about competitors including the plaintiff.
- 7:16He sued Springer Nature who he contends conspired to cover up his discoveries and defraud him
- 7:21as they retracted some of his papers about extraterrestrial life in 2020.
- 7:26And there was a criticism in the court case there.
- 7:28The complaint is at times difficult to follow.
- 7:30It is littered with speculation, confusing ramblings, conclusory legal assertions and
- 7:35personal attacks against the defendants.
- 7:37It got dismissed in 2021 with prejudice, which means he has to pay the other lawyer.
- 7:43And then he said that the judge who dismissed his case is a fraud who was bribed.
- 7:47He basically went out and made a statement.
- 7:49You have at least two crooked judges, Cronin who took bribes and Viscosell who is covering
- 7:55it up.
- 7:56Both judges have conspired with the defendants to commit fraud against the court and to pervert
- 8:00and obstruct justice.
- 8:01And they have ruled that a click through agreement is valid despite the fact that even the defendant
- 8:06admits it is fake and it is impossible for anyone to click, check, agree or sign.
- 8:11But that truth doesn't matter to these two Black Robes criminals because as Viscosell
- 8:16has admitted the case is fixed.
- 8:18Cronin belongs in a jail cell.
- 8:20Viscosell is not fit to serve on the bench and no, I don't expect you to investigate
- 8:25the two gangsters in Black Robes.
- 8:26I expect you and the Southern District to cover it up and blame the victim because
- 8:30I suspect there are a lot of judges who are taking bribes just like Cronin, which is why
- 8:34Viscosell is covering it up.
- 8:37If these two representatives of the Southern District then it's a cesspool of correction.
- 8:41Oh and sorry his name is Ron Joseph.
- 8:42Spell RHAWN.
- 8:45He then went on to suit the city of San Jose.
- 8:47Joseph was involved in a feud in 2018 with his next door neighbor over light infusions
- 8:52onto his property.
- 8:53Joseph has alleged that his neighbor hated him for quote his race, religion and sexual
- 8:58orientation.
- 8:59End quote.
- 9:00He also alleged that San Jose code inspector, Jacef Gabilisco, I'm sure that's how you
- 9:04say it.
- 9:05Joseph recently solicited an accepted money from and entered into a conspiracy with plaintiff's
- 9:08neighbor to commit hate crimes against plaintiffs based on plaintiff's neighbors perception
- 9:13of plaintiff's race, religion and sexual orientation.
- 9:16Joseph filed a lawsuit against the city of San Jose as well as he alleged they told him
- 9:20to strip eight of his cypress trees from their base up to five feet as they were in violation
- 9:25of certain municipal code provisions and he alleged that that would affect their aesthetic
- 9:29value and endanger their health and that the city did not provide him with a code violation.
- 9:34He argued that the first amendment should offer free speech protection to his cypress
- 9:39trees as they are a symbol of his religious beliefs.
- 9:42This guy just really wants to suit someone.
- 9:44Yeah, yeah he sure does.
- 9:45See a doctor ensuing people?
- 9:47No, cause he would be better at it by then.
- 9:49I think he might actually have a PhD in astrobiology.
- 9:52I didn't look into that part.
- 9:54There's too many lawsuits.
- 9:55What an interesting thing to speculate on.
- 9:59Astrobiology.
- 10:00Yeah.
- 10:01Cause then maybe it shouldn't be founded.
- 10:03Yeah.
- 10:04He alleged that the 12 cypress trees that he planted had a mythical and religious significance.
- 10:10Plaintiff suggested that he planted 12 cypress trees because he thinks the number 12 has
- 10:14both religious and cosmic significance citing the fact that there were 12 tribes of Israel,
- 10:1812 disciples of Christ, 12 hours in part of the day, 12 sons of the zodiac and 12 gods
- 10:23of Olympus.
- 10:24He claims that quote, 12 has been seen as a mystical, magical and religious symbol and
- 10:29again it has cosmological significance and quote.
- 10:32It's a 12 from like all different kinds of religions.
- 10:34All different kinds of religions and then also part of the day.
- 10:38Yep.
- 10:39This guy's nuts.
- 10:41He added that quote, as a reflection of my own beliefs, I planted 12 and I made sure
- 10:45it was 12 and then I put the Celtic cross as well as other religious symbols such as
- 10:50a Buddha because I shared Buddha's beliefs and those are right there in my front yard
- 10:54between those trees.
- 10:56In short, the plaintiff is quite adamant that this feeling towards his trees is not part
- 11:00of any set of religious beliefs and certainly not part of any organized or recognized religion
- 11:04instead to put it in his own words.
- 11:06He describes trees as such quote, they're still religious symbol while not religious
- 11:11spiritual.
- 11:12Let's not use the word religious.
- 11:15People would because it is a religious symbol.
- 11:17To me it's a spiritual symbol that happens have religious significance and quote end
- 11:21of that whole part.
- 11:23I will comment.
- 11:24I love that he planted 12 then made sure it was 12.
- 11:27Yeah.
- 11:28Hey, how many have gotten out?
- 11:30I think that was 12 just got a retallion make sure it was 12.
- 11:34You know, maybe he's a doctor of carpentry because like the first rule of carpentry is
- 11:38measure twice cut once.
- 11:40And maybe he planted the trees count twice plant once.
- 11:45Count then plant then count.
- 11:47I didn't say he was a good doctor of carpentry.
- 11:53The United States met not only do you see what we're everything but you like and this
- 11:58guy is like the epitome of it.
- 12:00You don't see people like this in Canada that often.
- 12:03You say that but I live in the same town as David Lindsay and my God, he's just he's
- 12:07a character.
- 12:08I don't know who that is.
- 12:09Oh, he's a guy who's going through a court case right now for assaulting a police officer
- 12:13during COVID.
- 12:14Oh, that guy.
- 12:15I didn't know him.
- 12:17Yeah, he made all his money telling people that they don't actually have to pay taxes.
- 12:21I remember that.
- 12:22Allegedly.
- 12:23And that note I wonder what the Queen of Canada is up to on a different note back to this guy
- 12:27we're talking about the doctor.
- 12:29So I love that he's suing everyone over everything.
- 12:32Love that.
- 12:33And then there's the typical like all of this stuff that I'm taking a stand against is for
- 12:39religious spiritual purposes.
- 12:41So yeah, well no, sorry, religion.
- 12:42What spiritual for religious people if they were.
- 12:46Remember, I am using it as a religious exemption.
- 12:49But it's just spiritual for me.
- 12:54The San Jose lawsuit got dismissed in 2023 from that judgment.
- 12:58Here there is no genuine issue of material effect because one, San Jose municipal code
- 13:02provisions requiring trees to be kept pruned and below a certain height are valid and neutral
- 13:06regulations of general application that do not constitute a constitutionally cognizable
- 13:11or otherwise substantial burden on the exercise of plaintiff's belief as he has described
- 13:15them in his deposition to plaintiff specifically disavows religion and claims that his connection
- 13:22to his trees is rooted in a vague and indeterminate concept of spirituality, quantum physics and
- 13:29cosmic mechanics.
- 13:30Three plaintiff has failed to demonstrate that any of the actions complained of in his
- 13:34SAC ever actually impinged on any of his beliefs and for plaintiff conceded that he was neither
- 13:41even made to cut his trees or that he was ever assessed any fine or penalty related to
- 13:47his trees.
- 13:48So he also sued NASA again in 2016.
- 13:52I never found out what he sued them for, but it was dismissed with prejudice.
- 13:56He yeah, it was NASA money.
- 13:58So yeah, that's the first one.
- 14:00I actually found him more interesting than the first lawsuit that he did.
- 14:03He might get his own episode at some point.
- 14:05It turns out he wrote a scientific paper that says plasma that lives in the atmosphere is
- 14:10living and that's what you have those are.
- 14:12The stuff that comes out of your nose at San's is the blood stuff.
- 14:17More like lightning, I think is a good way to put it.
- 14:19Why do we have so many words for plasma?
- 14:21I don't know many many things called plasma.
- 14:23Yeah, I don't like it.
- 14:24Okay, we're going to move on from our friend Ron Joseph to something that it's sorry,
- 14:32Dr. Ron Joseph, something probably a little more substantive than what he did.
- 14:37We're going to look at something called the Kecksburg incident, which shall see you might
- 14:40have an idea of what it is.
- 14:42But if not, I'm going to give an overview of it on the evening of December 9th, 1965,
- 14:47a large brilliant fireball was seen in at least six US states and Ontario and Canada
- 14:52as it streaked over the Detroit, Michigan, Windsor, Ontario area.
- 14:56Reports of a pot metal debris over Michigan and Northern Ontario, grass fires and sonic
- 15:00booms in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area were attributed to this fireball.
- 15:04Some people in the village of Kecksburg, which is 30 miles southeast of Pittsburgh reported
- 15:08wisps of blue smoke, vibrations and a thump and also that something from the sky had crashed
- 15:13into the woods.
- 15:14An early story in the Greensburg Tribune Review stated the following, the area where the object
- 15:20landed was immediately sealed off on the order of the US Army and state police officials
- 15:24in anticipation of a close inspection of whatever may have fallen.
- 15:28State police officials there ordered the area roped off to await the expected arrival of
- 15:33both US Army engineers and possibly civilian scientists.
- 15:36When state troopers and Air Force personnel searched the woods, they found quote absolutely
- 15:41nothing and quote, a subsequent addition in the Tribune.
- 15:44Or the headline quote, searchers failed to find the object.
- 15:48Authorities discounted proposed explanations such as a plane crash, air missile test or
- 15:52re-entering satellite debris and generally assumed it to be a meteor.
- 15:56Astronomer Paul Ineer said the fireball was likely to have been a meteor entering Earth's
- 16:00atmosphere.
- 16:01Geophysicist George Weatherillo.
- 16:02With the era, Weatherillo?
- 16:04Weatherillo?
- 16:05Yeah, Weatherillo.
- 16:06Discounted speculations that it was debris from a satellite and agreed that the report
- 16:10was probably due to a meteor.
- 16:12Former William P. Butt, Bittleman and Fred Hess said it undoubtedly was a meteor and
- 16:16a spokesman from the Department of Defense in Washington said first reports indicated
- 16:20that the reported fireball was a natural phenomenon.
- 16:23So that's the event.
- 16:24Happened in the 60s.
- 16:25Then I stumbled across a Vice News article on this which I'm going to read quite a bit
- 16:30from because it's great.
- 16:32It's written by Matthew Goh.
- 16:33I think we've actually used him before.
- 16:36New documents shed light on NASA's secretive project, Moondust.
- 16:39There's still no solid answers as to what crashed in Pennsylvania that night, but new
- 16:43documents tied to an old lawsuit against NASA have uncovered a few of the missing pieces.
- 16:49A Freedom of Information Act request from the Black Vault, a clearinghouse for declassified
- 16:53documents, has uncovered new documents related to the Air Force's project Moondust, a sustained
- 16:58effort to recover objects and debris from the spacecrafts that had crashed to Earth.
- 17:03Multiple people have been searching for these records for decades and NASA has long claimed
- 17:07they were either destroyed or lost.
- 17:09Journalist Leslie Keane hoped to uncover the truth in 2002 and went on the hunt for information
- 17:14about project Moondust and the Kexburg incident.
- 17:16A year later, she sued NASA claiming it was holding back.
- 17:19After previously promising to conduct an expedited search for files related to the 1965 Kexburg
- 17:25UFO crash, NASA had stonewalled and was withholding documents leaving no recourse but this one.
- 17:31Keane said in a blog post in 2009.
- 17:33In 2007, NASA finally relented and gave over the files and agreed to pay Keane's legal
- 17:38fees related to the lawsuit.
- 17:39But some of the files related to Kexburg and the project Moondust were allegedly lost forever.
- 17:44According to a NASA Public Affairs document, included in this latest round of the documents,
- 17:49NASA sent its files to the National Archives for safekeeping two years after the Kexburg
- 17:53incident.
- 17:54In 1996, the National Archives told NASA that the files had been marked as lost since 1987.
- 17:59Enter the Black Vault, which asks the government for all its documents related to the lawsuit
- 18:03with Keane.
- 18:04The documents were found 220 pages back, including some fragments of the project Moondust records.
- 18:09The file also detailed the reasons why they were so hard to find.
- 18:12NASA had destroyed many of them as part of a routine cleaning out of old records.
- 18:16The 220 pages are an interesting grab bag of NASA communications describing struggles
- 18:21to track down records and State Department communications about Project Moondust.
- 18:25The diplomatic cables are particularly interesting and paint a picture of NASA in the 1960s rushing
- 18:30around the world attempting to pick up every scrap that fell from the sky for study.
- 18:34For example, one diplomatic cable recounts the difficulty NASA had in collecting a piece
- 18:38of debris that fell in Zambia.
- 18:40Quote from this,
- 18:41Contacts says fragment measure 17 by 11 feet is made of aluminum and appears too large
- 18:46for pickup by Zambia Air Force Caraboo unless cut into.
- 18:50One cable said another quote,
- 18:51Took 12 men to carry fragment through difficult terrain to strip, but four men could lift.
- 18:57According to the documents, NASA later identified the Zambia fragment as a piece of the Apollo
- 19:01AS-203, an unmanned test craft NASA launched in 1966.
- 19:06The documents are full of the minutiae of the early days of America's foray into space
- 19:11when anything crashed to Earth could be part of someone's space program.
- 19:15What exactly landed in Kecksburg that night in 1965?
- 19:18In 2005, just ahead of the 40th anniversary of the incident, NASA announced it was a Russian
- 19:23satellite, but NASA couldn't prove its case because the records had been lost.
- 19:28Quote,
- 19:29As a rule, we don't track UFOs.
- 19:30What we could do, and what we apparently did as experts in spacecrafts in the 1960s,
- 19:35was to take a look at whatever it was and give our expert opinion.
- 19:39End quote, a NASA spokesperson said in 2005.
- 19:42We did that, quote.
- 19:43We did that, we boxed the case up, and that was the end of it.
- 19:47Unfortunately, the documents supporting those findings were misplaced, end quote.
- 19:51That however wasn't NASA's line in 1965, quote.
- 19:54Investigations of photographs and sightings of the fireball indicated its path through
- 19:57the atmosphere was probably too steep to be consistent with a spacecraft re-entering
- 20:02from Earth orbit and was more likely a meteor in a pro-grade orbit from the vicinity of
- 20:07the asteroid belt, and probably ended its flight over Western-like Erie, end quote.
- 20:12It's at an archive press release in 1965.
- 20:15NASA has steadfastly said that the Kecksburg was not the result of an extraterrestrial
- 20:19crash, but one of NASA's key goals is the search for life in the universe.
- 20:24To date, NASA has yet to find any credible evidence of extraterrestrial life.
- 20:28However, NASA is exploring the solar system and beyond to help us answer fundamental questions,
- 20:32including whether we are alone in the universe.
- 20:35We lead the US government's search for extraterrestrial life, be it close to home, on planets or moons
- 20:40of our solar system, or deeper into space.
- 20:42NASA does not actively search for UAPs and the lack of robust data is the central problem
- 20:47for scientific study of UAPs and to determine whether they are natural or human-made phenomena.
- 20:53There is no current data to support that UAPs or UFOs are evidence of alien technology,
- 20:58as is said by NASA to motherboard, which is the subsidiary of vice or the section of vice.
- 21:04I can leave out that last paragraph of this article just because I don't think it's that
- 21:07relevant, but NASA has also changed their position again and they don't think it was
- 21:11a Russian satellite since that time.
- 21:18So this is NASA's current position on this.
- 21:21There is some speculation that the reentry of the Cosmos 96 Vanara-type spacecraft was
- 21:25responsible for a fireball which was seen over southwest Ontario through from Michigan
- 21:30to New York.
- 21:31Investigations of photographs and sightings of the fireball indicated its path through
- 21:34the atmosphere is probably too steep to be consistent with the spacecraft reentering
- 21:37Earth orbit and was more likely a meteor in a prograde orbit from the vicinity of the asteroid
- 21:42belt.
- 21:43So they're back to, they've changed their minds again.
- 21:45Interesting.
- 21:46Is that a lawsuit or?
- 21:48No, that's just their position.
- 21:49Is there going to come a lawsuit?
- 21:51No, there's no documents.
- 21:53So it's kind of hard to do anything.
- 21:56Right, right.
- 21:57It's just kind of where we are.
- 21:59But yeah, because a lawsuit came about, we did at least learn about Project Moondust
- 22:03which is to collect anything coming down from space regardless of where it is, which is
- 22:08incredibly interesting.
- 22:09And that makes sense.
- 22:11A little more serious, kind of different, but you'll hear Kecksburg come up a lot because
- 22:15it is kind of weird and it was quarantined off.
- 22:18Like everybody agrees on that, just nobody actually knows what landed.
- 22:21Oh, I love, Bergs are good.
- 22:23I think it's a pair on as far as my favorite UFO.
- 22:26Yeah.
- 22:27And it's the one where people say there was like an acorn shaped thing leaving the site,
- 22:31correct?
- 22:32Yeah, that's the one that is theorized by some of the eyewitnesses that it was, I mean,
- 22:38I guess in the end it was speculation because it was supposed that the Germans had the bell,
- 22:45which was supposedly in that sort of shape, so they think it was around the right time
- 22:50for it to possibly have been one of the many theories, I'm sure.
- 22:55I'm just vaguely aware of that part of the story because it wasn't about the lawsuit.
- 22:58So I think I gave enough in the overview of that.
- 23:01The last one we're actually going to finish off with, it's a fairly famous story that
- 23:05came up actually in, what was I just talking about?
- 23:09Doctor.
- 23:10No, William English, I think was his name.
- 23:12He was in the first UFO casualty story, the British guy.
- 23:16Was he the casualty?
- 23:17No, he was the guy who uncovered it.
- 23:19Author or something, right?
- 23:21Yeah, this case came up in that story, so it's interesting that it's coming up again
- 23:25so soon.
- 23:26Can't be bothered to look up the guy's name though, unfortunately.
- 23:28So don't worry, doesn't have anything to do with the story.
- 23:31The record exists in our catalog.
- 23:32Yeah, it's somewhere out there.
- 23:33Catalog, catalog, not backwood, catalog.
- 23:36It's commonly known as the Cash Lundrum UFO Encounter.
- 23:40Oh, this is familiar.
- 23:41Yeah, I'm going to set up the story for everybody so they can see what actually happened a little
- 23:45bit or what has been alleged to happen, then we'll see what comes of it.
- 23:49On the evening of December 29th, 1980, Betty Cash, Vicki Landrum, and Vicki's grandson,
- 23:55Colby Landrum, together they are age 51, 57, and 7, are driving home to Dayton, Texas,
- 24:02and Cash is ultimately a cutlass after dining out.
- 24:04They later said that at about 9pm, they were driving on an isolated two-lane road in dense
- 24:09woods.
- 24:10They saw a light above some trees.
- 24:11At first, they thought it was an airplane approaching Houston Intercontinental Airport,
- 24:16which is about 35 miles away, and gave it little notice.
- 24:19A few minutes later, on the winding roads, they saw what they believed to be the same
- 24:23light as before, but thought it was now much closer and brighter.
- 24:27They said that it came from a huge diamond-shaped object that was hovering at about tree-top
- 24:32level, and its base was expelling flame and emitting a significant heat.
- 24:37Landrum told Cash to stop the car, fearing that they would be burned if they got closer.
- 24:40Landrum, who's a born Indian Christian, interpreted the object as a sign of the second coming of
- 24:45Jesus Christ, telling Colby, quote, that's Jesus, he will not hurt us, end quote.
- 24:50Outside of her firing at the UFO, I can't see a more American answer to that.
- 24:54No, there's only the two options.
- 24:57It's either Jesus or you shoot it.
- 24:59Sometimes you do both.
- 25:00Yeah, if you're American enough, and that's anybody in the south.
- 25:04So Cash says from here she was feeling anxious and considered turning the car around, but
- 25:08abandoned this idea because the road was too narrow and she presumed to get stuck in the
- 25:13dirt shoulders, which were soft from the evening's rain.
- 25:16Also she's driving an old tumble, so it needs like a 17-point turn at that point.
- 25:20Cash and Lundrum said that they got out of the car to examine the object, but that Colby
- 25:24was terrified, so Lundrum said she quickly returned to the car to comfort him.
- 25:29Cash remained outside, quote, mesmerized by the bizarre sight.
- 25:32The object intensely bright and dull metallic silver was shaped like a huge upright diamond,
- 25:37about the size of the Dayton water tower, with its top and bottom cut off so that they
- 25:42were flat rather than pointed.
- 25:44Small blue lights ringed the center and periodically over the next few minutes flames shot out
- 25:49the bottom.
- 25:50Flaring outward to create the effect of a large cone.
- 25:53Every time the fire dissipated, the UFO floated a few feet downward towards the road, but
- 25:57then the flames blasted out again.
- 25:59The object rose about the same distance.
- 26:02They said the heat was strong enough to make the car's metal body painful to touch.
- 26:06Cash said she had to use her coat to protect her hands from being burned by the door handle
- 26:11when she finally got back in the car.
- 26:13When she touched the dashboard, Lundrum claimed that her hand pressed into softened vinyl,
- 26:17leaving an imprint that was evident weeks later.
- 26:20Investigators cited it as proof of their account.
- 26:23Video evidence of this was shown in UFOs, what's going on in 1885, HBO documentary.
- 26:28They said that the object then ascended from the treetops and rose higher in the sky, and
- 26:33then a group of helicopters approached it, surrounding it in tight formation.
- 26:37Surrounding it in tight formation.
- 26:38Cash and Lundrum counted 23 helicopters and later identified some of them as Handemroeder,
- 26:43Boeing CH-47 Chinooks, used by military forces worldwide.
- 26:47More specifically, Cash claimed that they had United States Air Force markings.
- 26:52And with the road now clear, Cash says she drove on, claiming to see glimpses of the
- 26:57object and the helicopters receding into the distance.
- 26:59From first sighting the object to its departure, they said the encounter lasted about 20 minutes
- 27:04based on the description giving.
- 27:05It appears that they were southbound on Texas State Highway when they claimed to have been
- 27:09seen the object.
- 27:10So that's the actual story itself.
- 27:13From there though, and this is where it gets the most interesting, I think.
- 27:16Like it's a pretty bizarre case because you never hear flames.
- 27:19I'm interested to see where this goes, and no, you don't usually see flames even from
- 27:25like military vehicles.
- 27:26Yeah, you do see black helicopters they come up.
- 27:29I think it's an episode we've always actually kind of had on the list to do.
- 27:34It seems like a very specific time frame where they kind of happen.
- 27:38But that's enough because I want to continue on with the story, the real juicy part that
- 27:42we get into and it's the health problems that start to arise.
- 27:44So the witnesses claim after the UFO and helicopters left, Cash took the Lundrum's home and then
- 27:50went home herself.
- 27:51That night they apparently all experienced similar symptoms.
- 27:54So Cash to a greater degree.
- 27:56The claim was that they all suffered from nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, generalized weakness,
- 28:01a burning sensation in their eyes, and a feeling as though they were suffering from sunburns.
- 28:06Over the next few days, Cash said her symptoms worsened, with many large painful blisters
- 28:11forming on her skin.
- 28:12When taken to a hospital emergency room on January 3rd, 1981, Cash could not walk and
- 28:17had lost large patches of skin and clumps of hair.
- 28:20She was released after 12 days though her condition was not much better.
- 28:23And she later returned to the hospital for another 15 days.
- 28:27In the HBO documentary from 85, Cash's hair was shown in pictures and she claimed doctors
- 28:32switched from treating her for burns to treating her for radiation sickness after realizing
- 28:36she had been exposed to radiation.
- 28:38Later she was treated for cancer.
- 28:40The Lundrum's health was somewhat better though reportedly both suffered from weakness,
- 28:44skin sores, and hair loss.
- 28:46In an April of 1981, Vicki was found to be developing a cataract in one eye and Betty
- 28:51was first treated for breast cancer in 83.
- 28:54Neither condition was known to have been present prior to their UFO encounter.
- 28:58That's what this one gets known for.
- 29:00There's actual symptoms coming from this encounter.
- 29:02At least it seems to be from that.
- 29:04That doesn't prove that it's extraterrestrial though.
- 29:07No and that's actually where this goes.
- 29:10During their Bergstrom Air Force Base interview 8 months post incident, when asked to sketch
- 29:14a picture of what they saw, if it had a discernible shape, Betty drew and signed what she described
- 29:19as a diamond.
- 29:21Betty Cash and Landren contact their US Senator Lloyd Benson and John Tower and they suggest
- 29:28that the witnesses file a complaint with the Judge Advocate Claim Office at Bergstrom
- 29:33Air Force Base.
- 29:34In August of 1981, Cash, Lundrum, and Colby are interviewed at length by Bergstrom Air
- 29:40Force Base and are told that they should hire a lawyer and seek financial compensation
- 29:44for their injuries.
- 29:46So they find a lawyer, Peter Gersten, who takes this case on pro bono and the case ends
- 29:52up going through the US courts for several years.
- 29:55Cash and Lundrum sued the US federal government for $20 million and testimony of officials
- 30:00from NASA, the Air Force, and Army, and Navy are all given.
- 30:04I do have a few excerpts just from, I couldn't find the original documents unfortunately because
- 30:09they're too old, but there's a few things from that those documents that still kind
- 30:13of are out there.
- 30:14All here with are the sworn affidavits of Robert Somers, NASA, US Air Force, just all
- 30:20the people that are involved.
- 30:21The affidavits established that the UFO allegedly seen by plaintiffs and which is alleged was
- 30:26proximate cause for their asserted injuries is not and was not owned, operated, or in
- 30:31the aircraft inventories of the United States of America, nor was it such an object under
- 30:35the control of the United States or its employees.
- 30:38On the basis of those affidavits, the United States moves this court for an order dismissing
- 30:42the complaint of plaintiffs with prejudice or on the alternative finding that there exists
- 30:46no genuine issue of material fact.
- 30:48In response to this, we have a letter from the Department of Air Force.
- 30:52The appeal of your client's claims of personal injuries allegedly caused by an overflight
- 30:57of an identified flying object and unidentified helicopters on December 29th, 1980 have been
- 31:01considered under 10 USC 2733 and are denied.
- 31:05The reason for this decision is the fact that as alleged by the claimants, they'll
- 31:09to establish that their injuries were caused in any way by the US government or in any
- 31:13of its agencies or its surreptilities and you should not consider the acceptance and
- 31:16subsequent denial of the claim as an admission of the truth of any facts alleged by your
- 31:20clients.
- 31:21Our investigation has revealed no evidence of involvement by any military personnel
- 31:25equipment or aircraft in this alleged incident and the arguments you presented to establish
- 31:29liability of the government are not supported by any case or statutory law.
- 31:33This is the final administrative action that can be taken on your client's claims.
- 31:37This denial also satisfies the administrative filing requirements of the Federal Tort Claims
- 31:41Act.
- 31:42Based on this denial, your clients have the right to file suit against the government
- 31:44and an appropriate United States District Court not later than six months from the date
- 31:48of the mailing of this letter.
- 31:50And it finishes off.
- 31:51There is an order of dismissal.
- 31:52It is hereby ordered that the above noted cause of action is dismissed pursuant to the
- 31:56federal government's civil procedures rules.
- 31:58So unfortunately, it doesn't go anywhere, but at least they tried to sue the US government
- 32:03and I find it an interesting argument.
- 32:05We don't own it so we don't owe you any money.
- 32:07Can you know what kind of reminds me a little bit vaguely?
- 32:11Not exactly.
- 32:12Of United Kingdom one.
- 32:14Oh, Randallson Forest.
- 32:15Yeah, and then they have a whole bunch of health problems and they can't get it covered
- 32:20because the incident never...
- 32:21Yeah, that part of their profiles were dacted and unfortunately they never sued for it.
- 32:26So they didn't make the list.
- 32:28I actually specifically looked that up to see if it did.
- 32:33That gives you something to think about.
- 32:34I mean, they suffered a lot of health problems and where do you see compensation from for
- 32:39that?
- 32:40Yeah, and they all kind of suffer the same one.
- 32:42So it's an interesting case.
- 32:44They tried to sue the Pledgeirans.
- 32:46They could.
- 32:47And I'm saying that with complete seriousness, notice my lack of maniacal laughter.
- 32:53Inane.
- 32:54Inane, sorry.
- 32:55I know, I keep using different ones.
- 32:56It is inane though.
- 32:57Yeah, I don't know.
- 32:58Could Beam actually do that on their behalf?
- 33:01Would they need to get a lawyer or would he just channel the lawyer?
- 33:04No, he would be able to go directly to the source, Pledgeiran.
- 33:08If anybody actually, no, they're not going to listen unfortunately, but it did seem like
- 33:12somebody who listened to us at one point, they'd have a connection to Beam.
- 33:15So if they could get us in touch, that would be great.
- 33:17We could see if they have anything to do with this.
- 33:20And what their tort system is like.
- 33:21But yeah, Chelsea, that was...
- 33:23I had a hard way of describing it.
- 33:25It all made sense to me as the category, but it's weird cases of in-arc parameter that
- 33:29had lawsuits attached to them.
- 33:31It's the legal woes of UFOs.
- 33:34But that first one with NASA on Mars doesn't quite fit that.
- 33:38No UFOs.
- 33:39Maybe a mushroom, but I doubt it.
- 33:42I really doubt it.
- 33:44It'll come to us.
- 33:45Okay.
- 33:46But yeah, anything you want to add before we wrap this up?
- 33:48No, because I have not myself sued anybody.
- 33:52I've not myself yet seen a UFO and needed to sue, nor have I been tracking what NASA
- 34:00is up to so carefully as if when they slip up, I will sue them.
- 34:05And hey, we at least know about Project Moondust, which is an interesting thing.
- 34:10We'll probably never know more about it, but it is a super cool little project.
- 34:13Like they had to go to Africa and get a spaceship, just one we made.
- 34:17Just because it didn't fit with the country isn't well equipped to be able to retrieve
- 34:22it.
- 34:23Oh.
- 34:24But with that, I think that's a good place to stop.
- 34:27I have been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 34:29We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 34:30Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 34:36Bye.
- 34:38Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 34:41If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow,
- 34:47depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 34:50Also, please, if possible, leave a five star review, as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 34:56If you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 35:01I bet you we are there.
- 35:03And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 35:07us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 35:14For now, I'll see you in the next episode.