Latest / Ed & Red! / Ed & Red! - Epi 137 - Why are people most passionate about causes they are the least informed of?
Transcript
- 0:00The views expressed in the following program are those of the participants and do not
- 0:04necessarily reflect the views of Saga nine sixty am or its management. Hello,
- 0:16Leanna, how are you? Ah? It's the end of another week,
- 0:20and it is the end of the week. I'm now based on the weather,
- 0:23I'm at the stage how when people ask me or when people ask me,
- 0:28how are you doing? I say, it's one day closer to spring.
- 0:32Yeah, No, with me, it's just I don't know. I
- 0:37had three hours today where I wasn't exhausted. I'll take it. It's a
- 0:43start. Yeah, that's three more hours than I've had any other day this
- 0:47week. Yeah, you know, it's you work for the You work like
- 0:52crazy. You dedicate yourself to your peer counseling clients, and you work and
- 0:57work and you help them out, and you work out like your hours are
- 1:00crazy. Your dedication is off the charts, So understandable why you're exhausted.
- 1:07Lots of people that I know also are. I think it's the I think
- 1:11it's the oncoming winter, it's the shorter days. It just it seems to
- 1:17sap the energy from people. It's also there's a psychic drain out there.
- 1:25Right now that everybody. Everybody's feeling it one way or the other. I
- 1:30think that with the stuff in the news, but more the way people we
- 1:38used to see in a completely different light are behaving now. I think people
- 1:42are just they need it to all go away, and it's not going to
- 1:49and people are you know, normally I turn my nose up at the idea
- 1:53of I feel unsafe for most people, but it's real now, people,
- 2:00people are feeling a distinct lack of security in actual physical terms going out on
- 2:07the street now, and that's really I I don't know what to do about
- 2:14it. It's it's hard to to listen to person after person after person just
- 2:21feeling afraid to go out because they're going to be accosted by someone over some
- 2:25political thing that none of us can do anything about. You know, I
- 2:30think this is kind of the way many Americans have lived their lives for years,
- 2:36you know, the whole idea that we you know, it's okay even
- 2:38like gun controling. You're like, I understand wanting a gun to protect yourself,
- 2:44you know, m I always my thought has always been protect yourself from
- 2:46who, like where, get your neighbor, no matter where you live,
- 2:50you know, an affluent area, not affluent, you need a gun.
- 2:53It's it's a given that you should have a gun to protect yourself. And
- 2:57as a Canadian, my thought is protect yourself from who. I don't feel,
- 3:00you know, I've never felt to this up up till recently, like
- 3:04I needed to protect myself from anybody. And I think that the way people
- 3:08are feeling now, looking over their shoulder, not sure what the other person
- 3:13is thinking that when you thought you knew them before. I think that level
- 3:15of I'm not gonna call it paranoia, I'm gonna call it anxiety is something
- 3:21that Americans have been living with for generations. I don't entirely agree, because
- 3:25that's how I grew up, you know, I grew up being taught don't
- 3:30look someone in the eye. They may treat that as a challenge, right,
- 3:36especially Tom Cruise. It's not no, it's not just America. There
- 3:39are some neighborhoods in Canada that aren't as safe, and I think part of
- 3:46it is people are acting out because they're not upset about what they're screaming about.
- 3:53It's the cost of food, it's the fact that even a used car
- 3:57is unaffordable now, and and we keep hearing there's nothing we can do,
- 4:01there's nothing we can do, there's nothing we can do. And that might
- 4:05be true, but the people who can do something and it isn't. In
- 4:13many of these cases, it is not government. It is things like banks,
- 4:17it is things like businesses. They're not doing things that would help,
- 4:24and no one can make them. And so people are just they've had it.
- 4:30They've had enough. And I'm not saying it's right, it's weird ed.
- 4:35Lately, people have trouble distinguishing between saying this is human, this is
- 4:43the way humans' brains work, and saying this is morally correct or an ideal.
- 4:49People have lost the ability to separate those two statements. They ever have
- 4:56it, I don't know it's pribable. I think it was never put to
- 5:00the test, is the thing, And now it's put to the test,
- 5:02and hey, what do you know? They never had it? I don't
- 5:05know. I mean, during COVID, all things considered, Canada got through
- 5:10COVID pretty well. I think we're all just sort of exhausted from COVID and
- 5:15now it's, oh God, please not this. I don't know how all
- 5:20these protesters have the time or the energy or the money to do what they
- 5:28do. I'm so exhausted the idea of going and screaming and yelling at politicians
- 5:34for hours. I don't have the I don't have the stamina. I don't
- 5:40know how they do it. Yeah, there are those who suggest that it's
- 5:45because a great many of them don't have jobs. But I think that's actually
- 5:49just a way of dismissing them. I don't think that that's actually if you
- 5:54follow the data, I doubt that's true. But well, it does seem
- 5:59like the reason a lot the protests are on weekends. Yeah, well it's
- 6:02well, yeah, because during the week they're busy working. On the weekend,
- 6:05Hey, what do you want to do sport? I don't know,
- 6:08Dad, you want to go rail at people and call out death sentences review?
- 6:12All right, let's go do that and then afterwards, maybe we'll go
- 6:15for ice cream. Like it's uh, it's a weird thing. And I
- 6:19think that people are looking and it's very deep, very deep. People are
- 6:25looking constantly for a sense of community. They will join a community that isn't
- 6:31necessarily uh something about their aux being gored if you understand that that expression,
- 6:40as long as if they can find some point of commonality or a group that
- 6:46will accept them. People are so desperate for a sense of community that they
- 6:50join up with things that they otherwise perhaps would not if that void wasn't present
- 6:58in them. And you know group dynamics. You get involved with something,
- 7:02you see the passion of other people, you want to join in it.
- 7:05You know, it feels like fun, you're joining in, the adrenaline rush,
- 7:08you're joining in, and so you'll get carried away. And I think
- 7:12they do and say things maybe they really deep down don't believe in, but
- 7:16they're in a community and it's a community that will accept them. What they
- 7:20need to recognize is the minute they say one word out of line, they're
- 7:27out of that community. Like the minute you express any questioning of anything that
- 7:32community says or it does, you're out. And not only are you out,
- 7:36you're the enemy. Like you're not just okay, you're out. You
- 7:40are now an active enemy. So it be careful when you get into this
- 7:44sense of community, because it's such a false connection to that community. That
- 7:49community will kick you out the minute it thinks you're not ideologically pure yeah,
- 7:56or the minute someone else wants your spot. Well, someone who's got connections.
- 8:01Yeah, that explains one thing you said there, possibly explains one thing
- 8:07I've been trying to figure out, which is why people are putting so much
- 8:11energy into things you know half a world away that we Canada has soft power
- 8:20in the world, but we don't have veto power. We don't. You
- 8:24know, we can't make any other country do anything. We're just not big
- 8:28enough. Our diplomatic influence comes from Canada generally being well regarded on the world
- 8:37stage, and we set an example. And you know, we can't do
- 8:45anything about really Ukraine or the Middle East or except offer moral support to somebody
- 8:54for whatever that does. But there are still not just indigenous communities, but
- 9:01definitely indigenous communities without clean drinking water right here in Canada. And I'd be
- 9:07much happier if we saw the kind of numbers we're seeing for Gaza for problems
- 9:16here, because we can do something about that. Yeah there, you know,
- 9:22it's I think there's something about people being afraid in a way to engage
- 9:30in something where they can actually make a difference. Well, like you said,
- 9:35they don't actually care that much. You know, as somebody who's been
- 9:39involved in stuff in I don't like to call myself an activist because I'm not.
- 9:48If I see something I can make better, I'm gonna make better.
- 9:52So maybe advocate, but not even not even then, I'm just a person
- 9:56who wants to leave this world slightly less bad then I found it. But
- 10:01when you do something locally, you have to make those compromises that these groups
- 10:09based on moral purity, excommunicate you for. And yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 10:16And like you said, you know, if they actually are joining groups
- 10:20just because they think they get a sense of belonging, they don't really care
- 10:26about the cause. That explains why they'd pick something very very far away,
- 10:31because the likelihood of them actually making an impact and therefore maybe making a mistake
- 10:37is very low. Yeah, and they don't. It isn't a cause that
- 10:43many of them research and understand. Every situation between people and in the world
- 10:52has there are nuances that are important, there are gray areas that are important
- 10:58that contribute to the formation of what's been going on. And when you parachute
- 11:03yourself in and take a snapshot visually of what's going on, you're not gonna
- 11:07get a real sense of what's really going on. So you're not gonna really
- 11:13be able to think about or suggest or be part of any solutions because you
- 11:18don't even know what the problem really is. And you know, there's a
- 11:22there's a lot of people, people I know, people you know, people
- 11:26listeners know, who want to feel like they're contributing to doing something good.
- 11:33And if they find something they think seems like contributing to doing something good,
- 11:39they're gonna do that and they don't want anything that tells them that. Hold
- 11:43on a second, This isn't the black and white you think it is.
- 11:46There's a lot of complications here, and the truth is somewhere in the middle.
- 11:52No no, no, no, no no. They need to feel
- 11:54good about what they're doing. They need to feel like they're contributing positively to
- 11:58the world because they genuinely would like to be a part of positive change,
- 12:05not enough to actually do something, but and so don't confuse them with facts.
- 12:13The world is it always has been a very complicated place. Human beings,
- 12:18human interactions have always been much more complicated than we know. There's usually
- 12:24things below the surface of the people we deal with that we have no idea
- 12:28and maybe never know until it may be surfaces one day when something comes up
- 12:31and relationships between nations. There are so many layers of things going on,
- 12:39so many layers of pressure, so many people who benefit from the chaos and
- 12:45say they'd like it to stop, but they actually don't want it to stop.
- 12:48Like there's you know, there's people who know what to say, what
- 12:52the correct thing is to say, and people who want to believe them will
- 12:58take those words and say, see, this is what this person wants,
- 13:01this is who they are. Then they ignore that that the person does something
- 13:03completely the opposite of what it was they said they wanted to do, because
- 13:07then they go back and if you if you criticize that person, they'll they'll
- 13:11highlight some quote, some kumbay, a quote the person made. And then
- 13:16if you actually find a quote that is a really horrible quote that somebody made,
- 13:22a quote that you would consider like evil, they find an excuse as
- 13:26to why it's okay that they did it and there's still a good person or
- 13:30the other way around. What's that no matter how many good things you show
- 13:35somebody that somebody did, oh they did one thing they disagree with, they're
- 13:39a monster. But it's the other problem with activism, and this is something
- 13:46that's driven me crazy. Back to It's funny. When I was in high
- 13:52school and the whole marriage equality debate was going on in Canada, that's when
- 13:56I first really got involved in stuff that and and violence against women awareness after
- 14:03the lakeal Polytechnique shooting. I've been very young when that one happened. Uh
- 14:09white ribbon that I was. I remember starting in the tenth grade with postering
- 14:20and stuff. But one thing we were taught, especially with marriage equality because
- 14:28gay gay right stuff back when we called it that and not LGTBQ plus or
- 14:33what is it LGTBQ two s I A, that's too much, But I'm
- 14:39seeing that as the standard thing now, which is kind of like, I
- 14:41don't know why they haven't settled on a word, because it's very difficult in
- 14:46speeches too. That's like saying mister Mix's Pidolic's name the Superman Antagonists, but
- 14:54instead of saying mister Mixus Podolic, you're saying mister m x y z pt
- 14:58LK like it's it is a it's a mouthful, yeah, which is why
- 15:03gay rights was way simpler, because, let's face it, the state does
- 15:09not need to give you permission to have a boyfriend or a girlfriend, but
- 15:13if you want legal recognition that matters, and that kind of legal recognition was
- 15:18very important, especially for people who were strained from their families and wanted their
- 15:24partners to have control over their medical decisions and not their families who didn't accept
- 15:30them for who they were. But what we were taught back then, because
- 15:35I got involved in it before it had majority support, it was legalized in
- 15:39Canada, before majority polling supported it. They went MP to MP and convinced
- 15:48people under I believe it was Kretan that this was the right thing to do.
- 15:56They made a human appeal because back then we recognized we are trying to
- 16:03advocate for something that is unpopular. Act accordingly, don't get aggressive, don't
- 16:11get in people's faces, don't give anybody any reason to harm you, because
- 16:18back then the cops, if you gave anybody remotely a reason, even though
- 16:25it was a hate crime, they wouldn't charge them because they said you provoked
- 16:30them. And so I look at these activists now doing everything wrong, because
- 16:38if you look at opinion polling, the only portion of the demographic that is
- 16:44actually on the side of the largest protests that we're seeing now, the only
- 16:49demographic is basically college aged students so twenty five and under slight majority in eighteen
- 16:59to five thirty four. Well, every other demographic very different. Well,
- 17:04okay, here's the thing. Two things on what you said. First of
- 17:07all, the under twenty five demographic have always been the loudest and always been
- 17:15the demographic that doesn't know their butthole from a hole in the ground to vote.
- 17:22Yeah, they rarely show up to vote. They I mean youth.
- 17:26They have lots of time. You know, we talked earlier about how much
- 17:29you know, where do people find the time. Youth have a lot of
- 17:32time, typically twenty five and under. They're not paying a mortgage, they're
- 17:36not raising kids. They have a lot of time, and they want to
- 17:41feel that they're you know that they're adults now, and part of being an
- 17:45adult is having adult opinions and getting involved in adult adult discussions. And they're
- 17:51very idealistic because life hasn't beaten the tar out of them yet. So that's
- 17:55the thing. Gen Z or gen Z isn't idealistic. They're nihilistic, and
- 18:03they actually do show up to vote. Gen Z are investing, they're they're
- 18:10those don't don't judge all of that generation by the mouthy you know, get
- 18:17in your face protesters. Gen Z has its eye on the ball, and
- 18:23I hope you're right because the attitudes that I'm seeing in gen Z, the
- 18:30things that I am seeing large numbers of them support publicly and in polls,
- 18:37are our positions that can only be supported if you have no real understanding or
- 18:44life experience. No understanding of the world and no life experience. They're still
- 18:48wet behind the ears. But listen, I was that aging of the understanding
- 18:53of history is in the toilet. But that doesn't mean they don't have it.
- 18:59They don't under understand how the world works. In other ways, this
- 19:02is a traumatized generation. And yes, you have to start acting accordingly.
- 19:07Yes, but there listen, I when I was their age, I thought
- 19:12I knew everything. Over I get and I look back and realized I didn't
- 19:17know anything. But sure, I sure was loud about what I thought I
- 19:21knew. And it happens to a lot of people. You know. The
- 19:25old saying was, if you're not NDP in your teens, you have no
- 19:30heart. If you're not a conservative when you're an adult, you have no
- 19:34brain. I don't believe that, but I understand what the point it's making,
- 19:40which is that life experience will temper or explain or give you context to
- 19:48things you don't have when you're younger, and you don't when you're younger,
- 19:52you don't know. You don't have context because you don't have context. What
- 19:56is that thing? What is that called? You don't know what? You
- 19:57don't know? Unknown unknowns. No, it's the there's something something something effect
- 20:04Dunning Kruger. Dunning Kruger. Yeah, they don't know what they don't know.
- 20:08But the the things these loud groups are supporting, well, you know,
- 20:15mind you, I'm thinking back to when I was younger and thinking about
- 20:18some of the passionate twits that I went to high school with. They didn't
- 20:22know their butt from a hole in the ground either, and they didn't wind
- 20:27up growing up in shaping the world the way they wanted to as teens.
- 20:32So, you know, it's entirely possible that this generation will be like every
- 20:37other generation before it, and as it gets older and incorporates life experience and
- 20:41like, huh, maybe I need to I need to take another look at
- 20:45that, as long as they don't maintain this current infection that people have against
- 20:52admitting that you were wrong, like you know, I just admitted. When
- 20:56I was younger, I was completely wrong. But nowadays people are very disinclined
- 21:04and discouraged from saying they were ever wrong about anything because if you were wrong
- 21:08about something, you didn't have a wrong opinion, you didn't have the wrong
- 21:11information. You were bad. And that's never a good way to carry on
- 21:18through life. Well, it's an ineffective way to persuade, that's for sure.
- 21:25I mean, that's what I was getting at is. Even when I
- 21:27was younger and thought, you know, was a bit more I these are
- 21:32easy problems to solve that I am now. We were still told don't go
- 21:37in and get in people's faces because you know, if you get your head
- 21:44put through a wall, that's what we want to avoid. Well and go
- 21:52on. Well, I don't know when that changed, and I do think
- 21:59that it it undermines a message of peace. You know, if you're getting
- 22:08aggressive, if you are escalating while chanting cease fire, people respond to the
- 22:18contradiction. There. It's not effective, and especially in Canada, the most
- 22:23successful protest movements, including women's suffrage in Canada, we're done with a sense
- 22:32of humor. People like to be able to go yeah, Okay, I
- 22:36can get behind that that I can agree with. That's what you're looking for.
- 22:40It's called interest convergence. See, that is what I've said for a
- 22:44long time that comedians like George Carlin and Richard Pryor and Lenny Bruce and on
- 22:51and on, people who tackled head on these things, these contentious issues that
- 22:56made people uncomfortable, did it with some level of huge humor and cleverness,
- 23:00and it allowed a conversation to progress in ways it may not have otherwise.
- 23:04Nowadays, comedians are either hiding from the mobs that will cancel them over one
- 23:11word, or they're stepping forward in ham handed ham fist in ways to try
- 23:18to show I'm still an independent voice. I'm an independent And the stuff they
- 23:22do isn't actually funny, it isn't actually clever, it isn't actually thought provoking.
- 23:26It's just them waving their penis around saying I'm not going to be scared
- 23:30by somebody, and that's not comedy. And we should go to a break.
- 23:37Okay, all right, we shall go to a bake a bake.
- 23:41Yes, we're going to have a bake sale during the break, So come
- 23:45by the church and there will be cookies. Stream us live at SAGA nine
- 23:56am. All right, we're back, We're back, well before the break.
- 24:06It's funny because I had an incident I don't remember when, you know,
- 24:11when something just stresses you out so much, you don't exactly remember where
- 24:15it happened, especially when it goes on a really long time. And you
- 24:18know, I run a discord for my online communities. It's a it's an
- 24:23app that you can talk to people while you're playing video games, but a
- 24:26lot of people just use it as a social media service. And the I
- 24:33have people moderating comments because I can't be there all the time, and this
- 24:40whole idea of censorship came came up. This guy blew up at the moderators
- 24:45because they, yeah, they removed a comment that I thought they'd made the
- 24:53right call because he was cracking a joke about the server rules and that you
- 25:02don't do that. You got to take the rules seriously. You know,
- 25:04you can't appear to be making fun of the rules, because if you let
- 25:07one person do it, everybody thinks they can do it. And it's not
- 25:11right that some people get to do that and other people don't. But this
- 25:17guy slipped out accused the mods of censorship and said to me, I didn't
- 25:26know you were running a church youth group here, And I said, dude,
- 25:33I'm not even Christian, but I it was. So this whole censorship
- 25:41thing has gotten way out of control because people are missing that it's I mean,
- 25:48if you want to call it censorship, go ahead, But that doesn't
- 25:56change the fact that if you are acting in a way that it group finds
- 26:00unpleasant, the group has the right to ask you to leave. Well.
- 26:06Yes, And the how do I put this sent The thing that the thing
- 26:14that we're protected or want to be protected from censorship from, is the government
- 26:18editing our thoughts and editing public discourse. Now, first of all, there
- 26:22is always going to be some degree of quote unquote censorship because certain speech is
- 26:27detrimental to the public good. And yes, it's a slippery slope. Who
- 26:33determines what. So far in Canada we're doing all right with that as far
- 26:37as I'm concerned. But the idea that like, if you come into my
- 26:45house and everyone there's a wall where people can like, actually, I've been
- 26:49to clubs, comedy clubs, music apps where people musicians who go in sign
- 26:55the wall. Yeah, Now, If somebody comes in and puts a swashed
- 27:03on the wall or something generally understood as being offensive, and the person who
- 27:07owns the wall paints over it, that's not censorship. That person owns the
- 27:12fricking wall, and they decide what they want on that wall. You won't
- 27:18decide. And whenever you join any social media platform, any group, there
- 27:22are rules you agree to, and part of those rules are the stuff's going
- 27:27to be curated. It doesn't. You're not being censoriy. This stuff is
- 27:33curation. It is proper editing for the form and the place, you know,
- 27:38the time and place of the whatever medium you're using. It is not
- 27:45censorship. This idea that anytime you go somewhere and if you go let's say
- 27:51you go into Canadian tire, all right, and you start stomping and screaming
- 27:56out loud and screaming obscenities, if they remove, is that censorship? Are
- 28:03they censoring your free speech? Or are they kicking your ass out because what
- 28:07you're doing is inappropriate for where that place is. It's their premises and they
- 28:11don't want that there, and so that's not censorship. People have grown up
- 28:15with this idea that any curtailing of their commentary in places where it's been deemed
- 28:22inappropriate is censorship, and they stand up. They get this moral righteousness against
- 28:30censorship. Censorship. They don't even, like I was saying at the beginning,
- 28:33they don't even understand what the hell they're talking about. They don't understand
- 28:37what censorship is. They've latched on to a term that makes them feel empowered
- 28:41at the same time as it makes them feel victimized, and they go forward
- 28:45with this idealized and empty idea of what censorship is, and they think they're
- 28:53fighting the good fight when they really just be an idiots. Well, there's
- 28:59also a a trade off between having the power to influence people and accepting certain
- 29:07restrictions. Like I think there's a bunch of words that we've have said,
- 29:11and we'd have said in the last twenty minutes were this not on regulated radio
- 29:17airwives right, Oh yeah, there are words that the words that went through
- 29:22my head went through a filter and came out as something else. But there's
- 29:27it's gotten so bad now that I don't know if you've seen this. Hundreds
- 29:32of journalists have signed this open letter, accusing sites like The New York Times
- 29:38and things like that of biased coverage and censoring basically pro Palestinian voices. Now
- 29:48the for people who don't know, there's this thing called the AP style Guide.
- 29:52You've heard of that, right as Associated Press. Yes, yeah,
- 29:56and they recently updated certain sidelines about how to report on the war. And
- 30:04I read it and some of the demands in this open letter are actually violating
- 30:12AP style guide. And no one is required to use the style guide of
- 30:18the Associated Press is just generally seen as the standard. And I'm really surprised
- 30:26because you know, we were always taught if someone is charged with a crime
- 30:33but not convicted, you always say allegedly or is accused of You don't speak
- 30:40definitively you know that they committed a crime, because that's not factual. They
- 30:48can sue you for defamation. Also, it's wrong innocent until proven guilty.
- 30:52Well, also, there have not all of the particulars have been presented court
- 31:00case where all the particulars are presented. Yeah, and the media gets things
- 31:03wrong. That's the thing. If you spend enough time in the media,
- 31:08you have had a few things where you were just wrong, you were lied
- 31:12to, you were fooled. It happens to all of us. Which is
- 31:17why airing on the side of caution is always good. It makes you more
- 31:23persuasive. But for some odd reason now people think that screaming words like genocide
- 31:33and apartheid, both of which are crimes in the international Criminal Court, people
- 31:41think that's persuasive, and I just disagree. One of the things I was
- 31:45very fortunate was to have teachers who busted me down when I did things like
- 31:55that, and I was told they haven't been convicted yet. The only time
- 32:00you can actually use terms like that without it just being allegedly or accused of
- 32:07is if it's in a direct quote or if they have actually been convicted.
- 32:12And I think that's a good rule that journalists. Some journalists want to throw
- 32:17out now because they're angry because something has driven them to madness on this one.
- 32:25But here's the thing with commentary writing. It's not persuasive, like let
- 32:32me, let me try something with you, Okay, all right, I'm
- 32:36ready. Who are you more likely to listen to someone who accused you of
- 32:42a whole bunch of things you thought were unfair, or somebody who started off
- 32:46like, look, you're a reasonable person. I've known you for a while,
- 32:50you're a good guy who cares about people. Who are you more likely
- 32:52to listen to? Well, you know this is almost rhetorical. Second in
- 33:00person, the one who's not determining right off of the beginning that I am
- 33:04a horrible piece of crap? Right, And why not persuade people? Why?
- 33:13Because they're not giving used of something, they're not picted of something before
- 33:17there's even a discussion. Right, they're not giving you benefit of doubt,
- 33:22So why should they hear Why should you hear them? Out right? You
- 33:25give to get yes. When you're writing an opinion piece, you have to
- 33:31decide are you trying to just double down and throw red meat to your presumed
- 33:37base and like increase enthusiasm, or are you actually trying to persuade people who
- 33:45may disagree with you or be on the fence. Right, And most people
- 33:52used to consider persuasive writing, writing that changed people's minds to be the superior
- 34:00form. Not anymore. People like to share things that make them feel absolutely
- 34:07right, and for whatever reason, yelling the loud funny words makes them feel
- 34:15right. The thing is, if you're trying to appeal to a group that
- 34:21you think are bad people, you go in and tell them you're bad people,
- 34:28you're awful, you enjoy death and destruction. They're not going to listen
- 34:32to you when their self concept, their view of the thing is that they're
- 34:39acting in self defense. And so people have to choose when they speak.
- 34:49Are they looking to persuade or are they looking to get back paths from people
- 34:54who think exactly like them on this issue. But the minute they disagree,
- 35:00they are going to throw you under the bus for not being sufficiently morally pure.
- 35:02You have to choose, right, Yeah, why go on? And
- 35:08then I got something. Why professional journalists would be advocating for appealing only to
- 35:19extremists. I don't understand. It's such a sign of the times, Like
- 35:24some of these journalists are gonna get fired for signing that letter, and frankly,
- 35:29I think they should be because style guides exist for a reason and we
- 35:35may not understand them at the time, but there's a reason. They're standardization
- 35:40and you fight about it later. But if you're given an instruction from an
- 35:46editor, you do it or you get fired. That's that's the gig,
- 35:52right, Yeah, I mean, you know, looking at it if I'm
- 35:55going to look at it objectively, yeah, there it is. There's a
- 36:00bravery in These journalists, knowing that they may very well get fired and have
- 36:05their careers, can speaking up about something that they legitimately feel. Now I
- 36:12don't think they're thinking very much, but they're definitely feeling, and okay,
- 36:16taking away the cause or whatever they're they're advocating, there is something to be
- 36:23said for people who believe in a principle enough to take risks. I disagree,
- 36:30stand up to it. I disagree on this one because your job as
- 36:35a reporter is to report. You have to put your own opinions about what's
- 36:43going on aside. You have to report the facts. If you want to
- 36:47be an opinion writer, that's fine. But these are people claiming to be
- 36:52journalists, which is fact based, not opinion based. Yeah, but if
- 36:59they're saying that there are facts that are not being put in evidence, all
- 37:04right, that's a thing to be concerned about. Show me proof. But
- 37:08genocide and apartheid at this point are not facts. There's been no conviction.
- 37:15Now, See, the words don't even mean anything anymore. Reporting reporting that
- 37:22certain you an officials said those things totally fair, but referring to it in
- 37:29the article not as a quote, that is not being a journalist. At
- 37:34this point that is offering an opinion and keeping that straight matters. Yeah,
- 37:42this is a problem with with modern journalism. Though this is a modern journalism,
- 37:47isn't It's not well when you're in a race to beat the next guy
- 37:53to the clickbait. No, that doesn't allow the careful thought and vetting process
- 37:59that's actually journalism. But the other thing, the other way journalists get knocked
- 38:05and I'm not talking about these people signed the list. I'm talking about journalists
- 38:07in general, is that if a journalist or a news site publishes a quote
- 38:15by somebody who is involved in the news, there are people who will say
- 38:21that that news site is the one advocating or saying what is in the quote.
- 38:28They're reporting. They're just they're not saying it's true. They're not saying
- 38:30it's not true. Sometimes they say it's not true. But when you are
- 38:34simply reporting this is what has been said by this person, that is not
- 38:38you taking a position. But you get people freaking out about the CBC,
- 38:45especially because it's a conservative hobby horse. And you know, somebody showed me
- 38:51a headline then they said was promoting a new blood libel against Jews, And
- 38:57I looked at it and said that doesn't. All it says is this is
- 39:00what this guy said, and this is what this guy said. It took
- 39:04no position whatsoever. Yeah, but there are some people are like, if
- 39:07you report both sides and you don't say that one side is lying, then
- 39:15you're part of you know, you are biased. That's not and that's the
- 39:17thing that's not always the job of the media. I've been in situations like
- 39:23this where okay, it was over video games, but you ask the question,
- 39:29you get somebody on the record. You know, in this case,
- 39:31it was promises about certain elements of the game. So when the game comes
- 39:37out and it doesn't meet that promise, they can't claim they never actually promised
- 39:44it. You have them on the record saying these features would be there.
- 39:50That is the noble purpose of doing fact based reporting. It's very very important.
- 39:58Even if you can't stomach the people you're recording, it's very important to
- 40:04get somebody on the record, so if they reverse themselves, they can't gaslight
- 40:07the public. And at that we're gonna go to a break and come back.
- 40:13Okay, no radio, no problem. Stream is live on Sagay nine
- 40:22six am dot CN Early. I think we've we've chewed on that stuff a
- 40:31fair piece. Yeah, for the last do something where you want to say,
- 40:37I don't know, I have a particular This is particularly important to me
- 40:45as somebody who does do you know a lot of commentary stuff and people ask
- 40:50my opinion for things and then yell at me for offering it. But I
- 40:53mean, I was, I was. I've been blacklisted by a few different
- 41:00and in media's you know, the reporting we did on bontopack in the day
- 41:05was not very popular at the station we were at, and I did the
- 41:09bulk of that research and I stand by it. It was all true.
- 41:15Well it was all fact, yes, and you know that wasn't very popular.
- 41:21And then in video games, I thought it's important to get the side
- 41:25of groups of people that were considered undesirable at the time. And I got
- 41:30people saying you must agree with them, you're reporting on them. It's like,
- 41:35no, that's not the job. And I do think that it's very
- 41:42important to remember that it isn't the job of a reporter. You have a
- 41:47you have a duty if you think someone is just lying, either don't use
- 41:54them as a source or fact check their statements. That is, you know,
- 42:00you can't disseminate knowing lies. But if someone says this, I mean,
- 42:07there was that whole thing. I don't remember a while back where social
- 42:12media was freaking out because they claim that Justin Trudeau said that Israel bombed that
- 42:16hospital, and he actually didn't ye. He was asked a question and he
- 42:22just said bombing a hospital is a war crime. He didn't say Israel bomb
- 42:28the hospital and it's a war crime. He just said bombing the hospital as
- 42:30a war crime. And it's very important that you are able to go and
- 42:37find out exactly what he said, because otherwise, the first, the first
- 42:42casualty of war is truth. And it's amazing how many people have forgotten that
- 42:46with so many of these conflicts these days. Don't believe the most recent reporting.
- 42:54The breaking news is often wrong. Wait a bit, because you know,
- 43:01especially in areas that are too dangerous for reporters to cover, they're getting
- 43:06things second and third hand. They're doing their best, but ultimately other information
- 43:13comes to light. So it's okay to step away from the news for a
- 43:19day or two. It's okay to read it and go you know what.
- 43:22I'm going to wait for confirmation on this one because somebody getting it wrong doesn't
- 43:29mean nefarious intent. It just means you have to do the best with it
- 43:34you have and then there's a more thorough investigation. But most of the quotes
- 43:37they're getting are coming from official government channels. We're in a war. They
- 43:43both have reason to lie, you know, they both have motivation to lie.
- 43:46And you know, certain governments lie more than others, and certain governments
- 43:52have a free press holding them to account and others don't. Other places,
- 43:58you have to operate on the watchful eye of a government that actually does practice
- 44:04censorship, and some of that censorship means killing journalists. So you know,
- 44:09journalism is a tough job. But try to give people the benefit of the
- 44:13doubt. But a lot of people have been really forgetting what the purpose of
- 44:19the profession is lately, and right well, I think they think the purpose
- 44:24of journalism is to confirm what they already believe. And how dare you put
- 44:30any doubt in my mind? How dare you attempt to put any doubt in
- 44:34my mind? How dare you attempt to shake my certitude upon which my mental
- 44:38survival rolies? Because what doubt is good for you? No, people don't
- 44:44want people don't want doubt anymore. They don't want doubt. You know.
- 44:46Part of the reason they don't want doubt is because so many things, like
- 44:50I said earlier, are actually so nuanced and there's so much detail to them
- 44:55that they don't want it. They don't want They just want to They just
- 45:00want to pick black or white and don't tell them anything else, because they
- 45:05need to believe that black is black and white as white. If they don't
- 45:07believe black is black and white as white, then it opens up a world
- 45:12of great complications, and they don't want to believe that the world isn't easily
- 45:15digestible. Okay, here's the two things we know about war. Okay,
- 45:22one sucks well. One, you don't make peace with friends, you make
- 45:27peace with your enemy, right, yes. Two When peace is more expensive
- 45:34than war, there's war. When war is more expensive than peace, there's
- 45:38peace. And the mistake people are making with the Middle East is instead of
- 45:45making peace less expensive for the two sides, they're trying to make war more
- 45:51expensive in terms of global opinion. And they've priced themselves so out of the
- 45:55market already that that's it's not gonna work anymore. They need to bring the
- 46:01incentives for peace up instead of the punishments for war going up. Because they've
- 46:08already thrown the book at both sides. They're not listening anymore, all right,
- 46:14and at that we need to go to a break and come back for
- 46:16very short segments. All right, stream us Live at SAGA nine to six
- 46:27am dot CA. All right, really short amount of time left, so
- 46:36it's time for us to just wrap it up. We didn't talk about one
- 46:40thing that you I said now we're gonna talk about. Just moments before we
- 46:45started recording, we had things we said we're gonna talk about, and that's
- 46:50what tends to happen. Yeah, we didn't talk about one single thing we're
- 46:53going to talk about it. I started trying to bring one thing up and
- 46:57then it sort of veered in another direction. But that's okay. I'm good
- 47:00with that. Yeah, it's just the I don't even know why we bothered
- 47:05talking before a show about what we're gonna talk about. I don't like doing
- 47:07it. You're always what are we going to talk about? I'm like,
- 47:10just start, just start going. We'll figure it out. And you're the
- 47:14way to talk about topics and other just say no, we don't just go
- 47:17listen. I got my dedication to having a topic from Bob and Doug McKenzie.
- 47:23All right, the McKenzie brothers of s E TV. I got to
- 47:30start go ahead because I got my aversion to planning from talk radio. Well.
- 47:35They they would open the show with cuck cuck cuckoo, look cuckoo,
- 47:38cuckoo, and then they would spend the next couple of minutes, uh,
- 47:43talking about what they're you know, trying to pick a topic and then picking
- 47:46a topic. By the time they picked the topic, they didn't have time
- 47:50to talk much about the topic. But the importance of a topic came to
- 47:53me from Bob and Doug McKenzie. And as far as I'm concerned, they
- 47:59are the Canadian equivalent of climbing a mountain in Nepal to talk to a sage.
- 48:06They are the pinnacle. So Bob and Doug McKenzie tell me something is
- 48:09important, I believe that that is important. Therefore discussing what is the topic
- 48:15is important. Yeah. I got my aversion to topics from working in talk
- 48:22radio and the producers always coming down on me instead of you, because you
- 48:27were the talent. I was just the sidekick. And they told me to
- 48:30never say the word topic. They never corrected you. Oh, they never
- 48:35corrected you. Never. They kissed your butt up one cheek and down the
- 48:39other. And they always were like, don't do this, don't do this,
- 48:43stop him from doing that, don't do this. And one of the
- 48:45things they said is don't say the word topic. I don't even understand the
- 48:50reasoning behind it. Masseners want it to be a conversation and if you talk
- 48:54about the topic, it sounds too clinical or academic. They never said these
- 49:00things to you. They always expected me to control you, which, first
- 49:07of all, that's treating you like a child. But I'm not your keeper.
- 49:12It drove me crazy. Well, the thing is that thing about don't
- 49:16use the word topic that reeks of highly paid radio con Yeah, because the
- 49:24radio consultants. It's a great scam. Radio consultants, huge scam, because
- 49:30people are coming to you. Radio stations are coming to you because they feel
- 49:35like they don't know something. They're like, they feel that they're doing something
- 49:37wrong. They want they want advice from the experts. So because they're already
- 49:42coming to you and saying they don't know anything, anything you give them,
- 49:45they're gonna say, I think is wisdom, but it They want to get
- 49:50things that back up what they already believe. But they want an outside source
- 49:53to point to and to give them magic words or magic on words like topic.
- 50:00But we we gotta go. Yeah, all right, Leanna can be
- 50:05heard on It's Not Therapy, very incisive, fun, in depth, helpful
- 50:09podcast about mental health challenges and so on. It's available on all podcast platforms,
- 50:15A series, XM APP and I'm on ninety four nine in the Rock
- 50:20in GTA Monday to Friday, midnight till morning, also The Rock dot FM
- 50:25and the Rock App. Okay, Leanna, do your thing? Can I
- 50:29just think topic one more time? Say it Topic? Bye bye, no
- 50:45Radio, No problem. Stream is live on Sagay nine six am dot c a