Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Mastermind] 1958 Warren Buffett to Partnership Letter
Transcript
- 0:001958 Letter Warren E Buffett 52O2 Underwood Ave., Omaha, NE
- 0:07The General Stock Market in 1958 A friend who runs a medium sized
- 0:11investment trust recently wrote. The mercurial temperament
- 0:15characteristic of the American people produced a major
- 0:18transformation in 1958, and exuberant would be the proper
- 0:22word for the stock market. At least I think this summarizes
- 0:26the change in psychology dominating the stock market in
- 0:291958 at both the amateur and professional levels.
- 0:33During the past year almost any reason has been seized upon to
- 0:37justify investing in the market. There are undoubtedly more
- 0:41mercurially tempered people in the stock market now than for a
- 0:44good many years. In the duration of their stay
- 0:47will be limited to how long they think profits can be made
- 0:50quickly and effortlessly. While it is impossible to
- 0:53determine how long they will continue to add numbers to their
- 0:56ranks and thereby stimulate rising prices, I believe it is
- 1:00valid to say that the longer their visit, the greater the
- 1:03reaction from it. I make no attempt to forecast
- 1:06the general market. My efforts are devoted to
- 1:09finding undervalued securities. However, I do believe that
- 1:13widespread public belief in the inevitability of profits from
- 1:16investment in stocks well lead to eventual trouble.
- 1:20Should this occur, prices, but not intrinsic values, in my
- 1:24opinion, of even undervalued securities, can be expected to
- 1:28be substantially affected. Results in 1958.
- 1:31In my letter of last year, I wrote our performance relatively
- 1:36is likely to be better in a bear market than in a bull market, so
- 1:39that deductions made from the above results should be tempered
- 1:43by the fact that it was the type of year when we should have done
- 1:46relatively well. In a year when the general
- 1:48market had a substantial advance, I would be well
- 1:52satisfied to match the advance of the averages.
- 1:55The latter sentence describes the type of year we had in 1958
- 1:59and my forecast worked out. The Dow Jones Industrial Average
- 2:03advanced from 435 to 583, which, after adding back dividends of
- 2:09about 20 points, gave an overall gain of 38.5% from the Dow Jones
- 2:14unit. The five partnerships that
- 2:16operated throughout the entire year obtained results averaging
- 2:20slightly better than this 38.5%. Based on market values at the
- 2:25end of both years, there gains range from 36.7% to 46.2%.
- 2:32Considering the fact that a substantial portion of assets
- 2:35has been and still is invested in securities, which benefit
- 2:39very little from a fast rising market, I believe these results
- 2:43are reasonably good. I will continue to forecast that
- 2:46our results will be above average in a declining or level
- 2:49market, but it will be all we can do to keep pace with a
- 2:53rising market typical situation. So that you may better
- 2:56understand our method of operation, I think it would be
- 2:59well to review a specific activity of 1958.
- 3:03Last year I referred to our largest holding which comprised
- 3:0710% to 20% of the assets of the various partnerships.
- 3:11I pointed out that it was to our interest to have the stock
- 3:14decline or remain relatively steady so that we could acquire
- 3:18an even larger position, and that for this reason, such a
- 3:21security would probably hold back our comparative performance
- 3:25in a bull market. This stock was the Commonwealth
- 3:28Trust Company of Union City, NJ At the time we started to
- 3:32purchase the stock, it had an intrinsic value, $125 per share,
- 3:37computed on a conservative basis.
- 3:39However, for good reasons, IT 4 paid no cash dividend at all,
- 3:44despite earnings of about $10 per share, which was largely
- 3:47responsible for a depressed price of about $50 per share.
- 3:51So here we had a very well managed bank with substantial 1
- 3:55earnings power selling at a large discount from Intrinsic
- 3:58value. Management was friendly to us as
- 4:01new stockholders and risk of any ultimate loss seemed minimal.
- 4:05Commonwealth was 25.5% owned by a larger bank.
- 4:09Commonwealth had assets of about $50 million, about half the size
- 4:14of the first National in Omaha, which had desired A merger for
- 4:17many years. Such a merger was prevented for
- 4:20persona one reasons, but there was evidence that this situation
- 4:24would not continue indefinitely. Thus we had a combination of one
- 4:29very strong defensive characteristics, 2 good solid
- 4:33value building up at a satisfactory pace, and three,
- 4:37evidence to the effect that eventually this value would be
- 4:39unlocked, although it might be one year or ten years.
- 4:44If the latter were true, the value would presumably have been
- 4:47built up to a considerably larger figure, say $250 per
- 4:51share. Over a period of a year or so,
- 4:54we were successful in obtaining about 12% of the bank at a price
- 4:58averaging about $51 per share. Obviously, it was definitely to
- 5:03our advantage to have the stock remain dormant in price.
- 5:06Our block of stock increased in value as its size grew,
- 5:10particularly after we became the second largest stockholder with
- 5:14sufficient voting power to warrant consultation on any
- 5:17merger proposal. 1 Commonwealth only had about 300 stockholders
- 5:22and probably averaged 2 trades or so per month.
- 5:25So you can understand why I say that the activity of the stock
- 5:29market generally had very little effect on the price movement of
- 5:33some of our holdings. Unfortunately, we did run into
- 5:36some competition on buying, which railed the price to about
- 5:39$65 where we were neither buyer nor seller.
- 5:43Very small buying orders can create price changes of this
- 5:46magnitude in an inactive stock, which explains the importance of
- 5:50not having any leakage. Regarding our portfolio
- 5:53holdings, late in the year, we were successful in finding a
- 5:57special situation where we could become the largest holder at an
- 6:01attractive price. So we sold our block of
- 6:03Commonwealth obtaining $80 per share.
- 6:06Although the quoted market was about 20% lower at the time, it
- 6:10is obvious that we could still be sitting with $50 stock
- 6:13patiently buying and dribs and drabs and I would be quite happy
- 6:17with such a program. Although our performance
- 6:19relative to the market last year would have looked poor, the year
- 6:23when a situation such a Commonwealth results in a
- 6:26realized profit is to a great extent fortuitous.
- 6:30Thus, our performance for any single year has serious
- 6:33limitations as a basis for estimating long term results.
- 6:37However, I believe that a program of investing in such
- 6:41undervalued, well protected securities offers the surest
- 6:44means of long term profits and securities.
- 6:47I might mention that the buyer of the stock at $80 can expect
- 6:50to do quite well over the years. However, the relative
- 6:54undervaluation at $80.00 with an intrinsic value $135 is quite
- 7:00different from a price $50.00 with an intrinsic value of $125
- 7:05and it seemed to me that our capital could better be employed
- 7:08in the situation which replaced it.
- 7:10This new situation is somewhat larger than Commonwealth and
- 7:13represents about 25% of the assets of the various
- 7:17partnerships. While the degree of
- 7:19undervaluation is no greater than in many other securities we
- 7:23own or even in some, we are the largest stockholder and this has
- 7:27substantial advantages many times in determining the length
- 7:31of time required to correct the undervaluation.
- 7:34In this particular holding, we are virtually assured of a
- 7:37performance better than that of the Dow Jones for the period we
- 7:40hold it the current situation, the higher the level of the
- 7:43market, the fewer the undervalued securities and I am
- 7:46finding some difficulty in five securing an adequate number of
- 7:50attractive investments. I would prefer to increase the
- 7:53percentage of our assets in workouts, but these are very
- 7:57difficult to find on the right terms.
- 7:59To the extent possible, therefore, I am attempting to
- 8:02create my own workouts by acquiring large positions in
- 8:06several undervalued securities. Such a policy should lead to the
- 8:09fulfillment of my earlier forecast and above average
- 8:13performance in a bear market. It is on this basis that I hope
- 8:16to be judged. If you have any questions, feel
- 8:19free to ask them. Warren E Buffett February 11th,
- 8:2359 Six.