Latest / Systems and Power / Is AOC the Future of the Democratic Party? - Joe Silverstein | Systems & Power #8
Transcript
- Moses Parente: Hello everyone. Welcome back to the Systems in Power Podcast. I'm your host, Moses Parente. Today I'm here with a very special guest. He is a recent graduate of Brooklyn Law School. He is also a published political commentator and has been on Fox News, Fox Business, Newsweek, The Wall Street Journal, and many more. Please welcome Joe Silverstein. Thank you for coming. Joe Silverstein: Hey, Moses, thank you very much for having me. You've had state assemblymen, you've had city councilmen, and I'm very honored to join that list, so thank you. Moses Parente: Now, thank you so much for coming. One thing I also loved about your background is that you also been trading in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu and you recently ran the New York City Marathon, right? Joe Silverstein: Yes, I ran the marathon in twenty twenty four and I did train jujitsu and I did a fight in Harlem for charity that summer, which I won. So I'm happy about that as well. Moses Parente: how did how was that like a entering a a fight for like even if it was for charity, like how how was that environment like? Because I I think that's absolutely super cool as someone who's an MMA fan Joe Silverstein: Yeah. Moses Parente: myself. Joe Silverstein: It it was a lot of fun. You have to be able to handle pressure. you don't want to fail. You don't want to look poorly in front of people, especially given that we're in an age where everything is recorded. So God forbid you lose. It doesn't look too good, especially down the road if you're in media or you're running for something. You don't want a video circulating of you losing. So I'm very happy the video was of me winning. And it wasn't my first time fighting. You know, I did a taekwondo fight at Cornell. Actually, it was at Princeton, but it was part of the Cornell Taekwondo team. And thankfully Moses Parente: nice. Joe Silverstein: I won that fight as well. so that was a great experience. And growing up, I did taekwondo for years. So probably dozens, if not a hundred sparring matches in Taekwondo. So I think it builds some foundational skills that I think are helpful to have through life, and it's a good experience to take with me, and I was happy to be part of it. Moses Parente: Do you think that mindset that you were able to build on in your early years in Taekwondo, it helped carry on to your later fights l later com com like jujitsu matches and your f fights and all of that? You think that also helped carry on with the mindset that you had earlier on? Joe Silverstein: So, I mean, I think it helps like the more experience the better. And I think just like comfort in that setting, and you don't have control over the outcome. You only have control over what you're willing to do. And in most cases, you're not worried so much about the the physical damage that could be done because it's just less of a concern, especially you're in a regulated environment. It is a competition, it's a match. you're worried more about not wanting to look bad. So thankfully Moses Parente: Mm-hmm. Joe Silverstein: I won. You know, I know Teddy Roosevelt. did a few boxing matches. I don't know whether he won the boxing matches, but I actually I would like to do an amateur MMA fight at some point in the relatively near future. But it really just depends because I have a busy schedule with work and stuff and with law school having just ended and the bar having just ended. So that is something I would like to do and hopefully either very late twenty twenty six or maybe twenty twenty seven, depending on how things work out. Moses Parente: You are a very busy man, Joe, and one thing that I all well one quote that I've always loved from Dan Gable is that once you wrestled, everything else in life is easy. And I I believe that applies to all sorts of combat sports because obviously you're not going to be like ro doing round kicks or jabs and crosses to your everyday task, but the mentality that you get from doing those those sports carry on into every other aspect of your life, whether it's I guess law law school or doing politics or or computer science or anything or anything like that. Every task that you or challenge that you have to overcome, it's the the same mindset and and principles that you carry on into your life. Joe Silverstein: Absolutely. Yeah, I think that's very true. Moses Parente: And especially since now now that I w I did want to go a bit into your your background. You also did a lot of wrote wrote a lot of articles for Fox and was featured in in the Wall Street Journal and and many things like that. How was it, how did you start getting into politics and all of that? Joe Silverstein: So getting into politics and getting into media for me were two different starts. in terms of politics, the first election that I was interested in was John McCain versus President Obama for the 2008 presidential election. And I Moses Parente: wow. Joe Silverstein: remember we took a we took a vote in class. And of course, I voted in that case when it was against Obama for McCain in the sort of class vote. but because it was a public school in Brooklyn, President then Senator Obama, ultimately who became President Obama, won that. class mock election that we had. but I remember being first interested in politics all the way back then, which was about third grade for me. And then throughout the Obama presidency, I got into listening to Glenn Beck and watched Fox News a good bit in that time period. And then in middle school ran for student government. I became the eighth grade president at IS 34 and we did some fundraising for the troops and some cool events. And then really in high school I played a big role in the student government there and ran and became ultimately served as grade president every year and then school president in the final year and we did a lot to fundraise for air conditioning at Tonville High School. Tonville High School is one of the biggest public high schools in New York State. And when I started there were virtually no air conditioners, very few. And I was a big part of the cool the school effort. so that's not necessarily partisan politics, but that certainly is local issues. so my start in politics and then over the years I went to the Brooklyn Young Republican Club meeting, probably when I was about 15 years old, maybe even a little bit younger, 14 years old. And I've just sort of always been into politics. and then obviously as I got older, I started to volunteer and occasionally work for some campaigns. And yeah, so I've sort of been involved in it throughout the years and gotten increasingly involved, but I never tried to make a profession out of it. You know, some people are staffers for different offices. I didn't do that. I went away to college. I worked in media. And I guess that gets to the second part of your your question, which was about sort of the media and how I got into media and how I got these publications under my belt. so it started, I would say. I wrote a letter to the I wrote a letter to the editor of the Stan Island Advance in 2018 and I self-published a book. There's so much stuff that honestly over the years you kind of forget. There's definitely been a lot of work that has gone into my my journey. But I self-published a book, Our America, when I was 17 years old, when I was a senior in high school. And I got local press for that because of how young I was at the time. and then I had a radio show that next summer we got to interview great guests. so you know, this is a this sort of the question of how I got into it, definitely it's a it's been a long journey, full of adventure. and in terms of the articles themselves and how I got into the articles themselves, when I transferred to Cornell. so I transferred from St. John's to Binghamton, then Binghamton to Cornell. So it was two transfers, Moses Parente: Mm. Joe Silverstein: but it was upward mobility. And when I transferred to Cornell, I was interested in writing for the Cornell Review, which was our conservative publication there. And I found out that it had been inactive for a period of about five years, and I decided I wanted to relaunch it. So I got a group of students together and we relaunched the Cornell Review, and it's still going strong today. And then from that, I did couple of articles, handful of articles for campus reform. And then I wrote in a pretty dedicated way for a while for the college fix. the American spectators saw my college fix articles and reached out and offered for me to write For them. And then ultimately when graduation was approaching senior year, I reached out to Professor Jacobson, who is a professor at Cornell Law School. He does securities law. And I was interested in maybe working in financial services. So I reached out to Jacobson. I said, Do you know anyone in financial services that is hiring? And he No, but I know people at Fox and they're hiring. And given your Moses Parente: Mm-hmm. Joe Silverstein: your journalism background, I think you'd be good for it. One thing led to another, worked for Fox for a year, went to law school, and then you know, I've written op eds here and there since. Moses Parente: I mean you've you've definitely written a lot of I guess I I I don't w I don't wanna necessarily call them opsides, but you've written a lot of articles all across all ma many major publications. And one thing that Joe Silverstein: Mm-hmm. Moses Parente: I definitely wanted to bring up was your most recent article that you wrote about AOC comparing Hassan Piker to Joe Rogan. And I I wanted to get get your thoughts on that on o on the record if that if that was fine. Joe Silverstein: Yeah, absolutely. it was an article because I saw that AOC did an appearance on the the the ABC show, the weekend show, and she was asked about whether or not Hassan Piker should have a leadership role in the Democratic Party and in what they describe as the quote unquote progressive movement. And she dodged the question and she said that appearing on Hassan Piker's show is similar to appearing on Joe Rogan's show. And that was not the question she was asked. The question she was asked was not about Whether or not people should appear on his show and talk to him. The question she was asked was a very direct question about whether or not he should have a leadership role in her movement. And she dodged that question and instead compared him to Joe Rogan. And sort of the point of the article was to point out A, that she dodged that question, but then also B that there's no comparison between Hassan Piker and Joe Rogan. Hassan Piker is somebody who said that America deserved 9-11. He's somebody that said that a US senator should be murdered. He's somebody who is he talks openly about political violence, celebrates Mao, wears Mao's outfit, says that he wants to move to China. so also apparently abused his dog, which is, I mean, wherever you are on the political spectrum, I don't think that shocking your dog during a podcast is a normal thing to do. so Hassan Piker seems like I I don't know him as a person, but he seems like a pretty radical individual. And he also praises Hamas and says that. Hamas is someone that he would choose a thousand times over Israel. And whatever you think about the Israeli government one way or the other, in Hamas's founding documents, they explicitly talk about murdering Israelis and murdering Jewish people. And you know, it's really just very extreme. And he's someone who's openly Marxist. And AOC was asked about this individual and whether or not he should have a leadership role in her movement, and she dodged the question. So I think she's a coward as far as I'm concerned. And I think that that should be noted. I don't think I don't think that someone who says Americans deserve nine eleven should be a political leader in any context. Moses Parente: I mean that I mean a lot of well there was a lot of I guess the as as you saw in the Democratic primary, there was a lot of I guess people who you can say on the DSA or DSA aligned candidates who made a lot of statements similar to Hassan and you see Hassan Hassan Piker openly backing these these candidates who are who are running for office. Do you see that he that people like this is the and that people and influencers like this is kind of like the new face of the Democratic Party and this is the direction that where they're going. Joe Silverstein: Well, I think it seems to be, right? You see that with the election of Mamdani. Now Mamdani has not said some of the things that Hassan Piker has said, but nonetheless he certainly identifies himself as a socialist and was quoting from Karl Marx during his I guess you could call it his inauguration as New York City mayor, the speech that he gave. so I think that the DSA is taking the Democratic Party over, and I think that the Democrats really don't have any control over it. And I think part of the reason is the they haven't they haven't examined their own reasons for the beliefs that they have as a political party. And you have this movement that even though I think it's very incorrect and radical, it's it's certainly very sure of itself. And they've really stormed the gates and taken over the Democrat Party. And that's why Chuck Schumer is probably not gonna I mean, in addition to the fact that he's old, but even if he weren't so old, I think that even if he even with him being so old. if it weren't for the undercurrent shifting in the Democratic Party, I think it would be more likely than not that he would seek reelection. But you know, if AOC doesn't run for president, she'll probably run for Senate. And I think AOC would probably beat Chuck Schumer in a statewide Senate race. I could be wrong, but that's my perception. Moses Parente: I mean she was polling at tw at she was polling at the top at twenty two percent at a New Hampshire poll. And when you're polling that high on a poll like on a state like New Hampshire, you might as well take a stab at the presidency. I mean, I don't think she really wants to run again for Congress and stay there for another two years because at l like that that that's boring at at that sense. Like, why not take a shot at the top, you know? Joe Silverstein: Yeah, no, I think I think it's interesting that you say that because I'm of the impression that I think she will run for president. You never know. Maybe she won't. she didn't do too good in Munich. She was asked the question abroad about something pertaining to national security and she really didn't seem to have a good answer for it. And that's not that's not great. But I think that she probably will run for president because she's somebody who is a very well known House of Representatives member. So she has influence. And she could effectuate change if she wanted to in the House. And I'm not sure that she would have much more actual influence or power in the Senate than she currently does in the House. I know the Senate is generally looked at as being a promotion for politicians from the House, but that being said, she's a particularly well-known House member and she's already been there for close to 10 years. So I think for her it would be a it would really probably be a much bigger jump. I mean, for anyone, it would be a bigger jump to to be president of the United States. But I think in her case, uniquely, I'm not sure she would be much more powerful in the Senate than she would in the presidency. And I think that if she looks at the current landscape of the Democrat Party, despite her own flaws and radical ideology, who's she really gonna run against? I mean, Kamala Harris was not a great candidate, despite the fact that she wants to attribute her loss to the time period that the Biden administration was widely unpopular. I don't think for as liberal and progressive as Gavin Newsom is. It seems to me that the activist DSA types do not like him. so he has problems and he's also not particularly skilled. I mean, he could get attention for himself. And actually I read portions of a book about him, a book that was written by Eli Gardy. She's one of the editors of The American Spectator. And it's a good book about Newsom and it talks about his background. He's always been very good about getting attention for himself, but beyond that, I don't think he's he's that exceptional in terms of him as a political candidate that could win. So, you know, I mean if you're a AOC looking at the field, they're not the greatest field. So it who's to say she can't get the nomination on the Democrat side. Moses Parente: yeah, especially when you see a whole bench full of candidates that are just kind of scattered and there there's no real clear front runner. You might as well take a stab at it. And you and you especially see that as well on the on the de on the Democrat lead leadership in terms of the House and the Senate. Right now everyone's kind of disarrayed because the Democrats are out of power at the moment. Do you think that they will be able to how do you think that they will be able to manage a the new incoming members who just won their who just won their primaries and to be fair are most likely going to win their general elections in November for the for the midterms. Do you think that they will be able to maintain order in the Democratic Pri in the Democratic Party inside the House of Representatives and the Senate? I know Abdul Al Sayyid just won his his primary. Do you think that they will be able to kind of work together or it's all gonna continue to be a little bit of a mess, like they're kind of like how the I guess the Tea Party was back in the Obama days for the Republicans. Joe Silverstein: So I I think it's an important question and it's because it highlights an important opportunity for a distinction. And I know that you're not equating the Tea Party with the DSA, but this is an important note for everyone to look at. Like the insurgent wing, quote unquote, of the Republican Party in during the Tea Party, what did they want? They wanted lower taxes, they wanted to lower spending. it really wasn't that controversial of an agenda. These DSA candidates that are coming in as part of this caucus, many of them are to the left of of AOC, right? And that's kind of what some of the article was about is that even AOC almost has to appeal to her left flank because she lost the endorsement of the national DSA because they didn't think that she was critical enough of of Israel. Now, whatever you think of the conflict between Israel and Hamas and what's happening in Gaza, AOC has been very critical of Israel, but she hasn't come out like Hassan Piker said and says that he would support Hamas over Israel. And she hasn't made those radical statements. And to my knowledge, I think what they're unhappy about that she did is she didn't vote to remove the defensive weapon funding that we give or that weapons that we sell to Israel. and they wanted her to not do that. They they don't want any weapons being sold to Israel, including defensive. So she is someone who's been I I'm not sure liberal or not liberal is the right frame of analysis, but she is someone who's been very critical of Israel, but for the DSA, it's she hasn't gone far in as far as they would like her to. And that's sort of just an example in terms of in terms of how the Congress would run generally, you know, I think that there was like a liberal class of congressmen and politicians, like a Dan Goldman type, for example, that lost to I think it was Brad Lander in Moses Parente: Yes. Joe Silverstein: downtown Brooklyn. Right. And I think that Dan Goldman is sort of used to the old playbook from Trump One, where you're just like this liberal congressman that plays up criticism of Trump and they think that that's what's gonna get them elected by the Democrat base. But that doesn't seem to be the case. They they seem to be electing people that are not just like liberals, but true Marxists or at least very far left Democrat. Well, yeah, I mean, Democratic socialist is Marxist. So there you go. so I I think I think that I think the radicals are more likely to be running the caucus 'cause I think that's where things are heading. If if they take if they take control. Now they may not take control of the house, so we'll see what happens. Moses Parente: I mean I know that Daria Lisa Avila Chevalier, she recently said she wanted to join the both the Hispanic and the Black Caucus of the Democrat Party and the Black Caucus basically said from at least from like ru ru rumors that I heard from like o from social media that if you're not gonna support Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, upon like if we take back the House of Representatives, then don't don't bother joining us. And I I think it's also interesting the fact that there are people in the DSA lane of the Democratic Party that think that people like Zoran Mamdani or AOC are too conservative for them. Which when when w which is not not something that you hear ver very often. I was wondering your your your thoughts on that. Joe Silverstein: Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I mean, I think that it's crazy, right? 'Cause as we know, those are people that are very far on the left. So this idea that there's people to the left of them, and that's why AOC was trying to say, woke one was crazy. But in reality, certain places did try to defund the police. You look at Minneapolis and then crime surge, and then they had to bring them back. And having just graduated law schools, a lot of the professors on the faculty of the criminal law believe in prison abolition, which is crazy. So there's a lot of radical ideas out there. And even though mainst in mainstream America, AOC is very far to the left, in the context of the left wing movement itself, this is sort of what happens, is that they try to outflank each other and they lose control of the situation. It just goes further and further in that direction, unfortunately. And it's too bad because there's a lot of real problems that have to get solved, right? Like the country has a lot of problems, there's a lot of debt. P we would I would love to improve healthcare and get more people healthcare. people talk about affordability and the cost of of of housing and the fact that buying a home has been delayed and this these are decades long trends. This isn't recent. so there's a lot of real problems to solve, but it becomes, I think, more difficult when we sort of have to fend off these these attacks on our on our sort of way of life. Moses Parente: Affordability has been the top issue as of now, even even na nationwide. And JD Vance did did say that Republicans need to tackle the afford affordabil the affordability issue, especially for young people, or they're or they're doomed to lose both the the house and I also think it was the Senate. You can correct me if I'm wr if I'm wrong on that. But what do you think what do you think that Republicans will attempt to do or try to do to make sure that they at least give a give some sort of solution to the affordability crisis that everyone is facing right now, especially people who are our age. Joe Silverstein: Yeah, no, I think that a lot of this is longer term trends, right? Like the housing supply doesn't seem to be enough. And I think a lot of that's because of regulations in different cities and municipalities. some of the regulations discourage landlords from fixing up existing units within apartment buildings, and then those units are taken off the market, and then that further drives up costs. But you know, we we need to do more building. Trump was talking about building new cities during his presidential campaign. in twenty twenty four, I think that's something that would be a good idea. If you if you look at the inflation rate year over year, inflation is down compared to the Biden administration. It was at nine percent because inflation is measuring the rate at which things are getting more expensive, right? So it's like i if you say inflation month over month or year over year, depending on how you look at it, but inflation is lower. The rate at which the price of things are increasing is substantially lower under Trump than it is under Biden. So that's something that's a good thing. And I think that there has been economic gains, but obviously there's there's more that needs to be done. Moses Parente: Mm, okay. 'Cause at least from from everything that you you see on social media, everyone always has I guess complaints about both administrations, whether it's on like the right side or or or the left side. But one thing that we saw this this week is that social media doesn't always translate to real real votes. And we saw that in the Republican primary against Byron Donalds and James Fishback, with James Fishback going and amounting A viral social media campaign, kind of like I guess some people joked and said that he was like the Mamdani of the right, and he only ended up getting about 10% of the vote. I would love to get your take on I guess the rise of social media and how that affects campaigns nowadays, and what does it mean for does social media and attention that garnishes online affect what's going on in the real world? Joe Silverstein: Well, I think there's definitely a disconnect between social media and the real world. And the race you just mentioned is one example of that. I think social media is an important and powerful tool. And I it it when I say it always has been, it really has been the last what 10 years, a little bit more than that. But certainly from the time we were teenagers paying attention to the 2016 presidential race on social media has played a role. But you also need a ground game as a campaign. You also still need a a fair bit of fundraising. And I think it's also the candidates themselves and the things they say and the ideas they have matter. so I think all those things are important. Moses Parente: Hmm. In terms of c campaigning, I this is not too recent, but Zoran Mamdani did say that he will not be opting into the New York City's matching funds program. And I'm and I was so a bit surprised that pro that he didn't get a lot of progressive pushback from that because the whole point of the matching funds program is to basically keep outside money outside of local elections and st statewide elections. And the fact and when he said that I'm not going to opt into the matching funds program and accept outside money is because I'm going to be at least getting a whole bunch of challenges from basically the people who want to take me out. And what is your whole thoughts of Mamdani not opting into the matching program? And is that something that you think progressives are intentionally not speaking about because they fear Mamdani? Joe Silverstein: That's interesting. That's actually the first I'm hearing of that. I will say that the matching funds program drove h a lot of his success in this past election when he was not the incumbent because Cuomo had outraised him and the PAC supporting Cuomo had out had outraised him substantially. And it was through the matching funds and the public funding that Mamdani obtained a lot of his money, most of his money. And without that, without those public funds through the city's program, I don't think he would have been able to win. So the fact that he's now turning it down. is something that I think is interesting. In terms of my thoughts about the program itself, and in terms of the why people on the left haven't criticized him for that, I honestly, this is the first I'm hearing of him not taking it, but he certainly is someone who is a a powerful and influential figure on the left. So if people are hesitant to criticize him from his side of the aisle, that that would make sense as to being a reason why. about the matching funds program itself, I'm actually not the biggest fan of it. Because I think that there's a lot of local candidates that that are in districts that can't win. And if you look at the results, right? Some of these districts that are seventy, thirty or or you know, eighty, twenty, and we're spending a lot of public money to support these these races. And I that's something that in political circles people would have obvious reasons to push back against that viewpoint. But I just think from an efficiency standpoint, in a city where where potholes don't get fixed. Where it seems like the infrastructure is deteriorating, where we're being told we don't have enough money for police. I think that the matching funds program not existing or being scaled back in some form would probably be a better use of everyone's money. The flip side of it is that the city wastes so much money anyway, that are you are you really sure the money would go Moses Parente: Ha ha Joe Silverstein: to anything better? Who really knows? but when you walk through the lovely rain we have outside and you see that things are flooding and and the water is not properly draining. you know, it doesn't give you a lot of hope for what's supposed to be the greatest city of the in the world and how it's run. Moses Parente: I mean one n now that you you mentioned that, you d you did just to remind me of the now the new city controller Mark Levitt, he came up with some statistics and saying that like, hey, look, listen, with with if we're gonna keep putting a lot of taxes like this, a lot of the middle middle to high income families are going to keep leaving New York. And that's one thing that a lot of people are are talking about. I would love to get your opinion on that. Joe Silverstein: Yeah, it seems to be a problem. I think that Mamdani has adopted a very hostile attitude toward the middle class and toward the wealthy. And I think that Staten Island bears the brunt of some of that. If you look at the things that we don't get, whether it be snow snow plowing, whether it be 3K, there's a lot of things that Stan Island hasn't gotten that other parts of the city have. And maybe part of that is because Stan Island is disproportionately middle class. And also, frankly, there's people in the Mamdani administration that are on the record. That have made anti-white comments. One of Mamdani's top advisors said that it's her goal to to impoverish the white middle class. And that's something that most of the mainstream press and the New York press hasn't picked up on. And I would just ask the question why? In the case of the in New York press, is that something that they're afraid to criticize? Is that a view that they're sympathetic to? and in terms of the national press, are they just is that something they're afraid to touch and cover? The anti white racism that has been made in statements by some of Mandani's top officials. I mean, the comments were are are publicly known. It's not a conspiracy as to whether or not they were said. It's not in dispute factually. Moses Parente: yeah, I think on honestly ha hatred against any sort of r race and gender is absolutely terrible. And I think that it's sad that people who are basically advising the leaders of our city have these radical beliefs and aren't necessarily held accountable to it. And speaking of people who are advising the the the mayor, the New York Post just came out with one of the DSA's co co co co le I believe it was a co the co chair, and He was a very big proponent of taxing the rich. However, his dad just s seemed to have him have a big multi million dollar house in Noam. I I believe it was Bushwick Brooklyn. And they say, Joe Silverstein: Hmm. Moses Parente: like, okay, tax the rich, but hey, they're bankrolled by the rich. A lot of these people are what a lot of people would call Nepo babies. And I would love to get your your thoughts on that and how we see a lot of people who disproportionally do not come from working class backgrounds. They don't come from they don't come from even middle meant like low income backgrounds or immigrant backgrounds where their parents had to work hard and then and they were just basically spoon fed wealth. What what is your take on this whole new breed of Democrats that are coming in and are basically completely coming from these wealthier backgrounds and saying stuff that are basically almost counterintuitive? Joe Silverstein: Right. Well, it it's sort of hypocrisy at its finest when you look at that DSA leader whose parents bought him a one point five million dollar house in Brooklyn, right? And that's why socialism has always failed, because they want socialism for everyone else, but they want the riches for themselves and they're not willing to give up their material benefit. And people tweet about socialism from the iPhone that was made by a company in a capitalist country. So Ultimately, there's important nuanced policy discussions to have about various aspects of the fiscal budget of of different government policies and programs, but all of that gets lost when we have to defend the civilization itself from Marxism, which has destroyed countries throughout world history. so it it certainly is. I mean, if you look at Mamdani himself, right? His father was an accomplished professor. I'm not sure I would say accomplished. I mean, I guess from a pure prestige standpoint, accomplished, but certainly I disagree with with the things that he said, which is what I'm getting to in this next comment. But the father was someone who it was an established, let's say, was an established professor who said that the that we should, this is his words, quote, destigmatize suicide bombers and instead look at them as soldiers, right? That's what one of his academic books said. And if you take a look at his mother, his mother worked in the entertainment industry, and she, I believe, did something pertaining to either Broadway plays or screenplays, but at a fairly high level. So Mamdani himself comes from very privileged background and his parents are very financially well off. And yet he's claiming to rein in socialism. And that was one of the points Cuomo raised about him during the not that Cuomo obviously Cuomo lost, although Curtis lost too. Curtis did fairly terribly and has since criticized the Trump administration, which is what he was doing prior to that race. Now he went back to criticizing the Trump administration. again. So I never thought Curtis was somebody who was a great representation of the Republican Party or conservatism. Moses Parente: He's definitely been a lot pro Mam Dani recently, I will say. Joe Silverstein: Well, he's been pro Mamdani, and it's not to knock Curtis Leewo, but it's just to say that when people made it an issue of quote unquote loyalty, I totally disagree with that. I think that the thing to do was to back who was most likely to win. And obviously the president of the United States, President Trump felt the same way, and that's why he endorsed or yeah, that's why he said people should vote for Cuomo. But nonetheless, they both lost and here we are. and Mamdani ultimately is the mayor. But yeah, no, it's unfortunate. And if you look at the people that drove Mamdani's electoral success, a lot of it does come from that sort of financial background and demographic that you're talking about. Whereas a lot of the people that are lower income actually were more inclined to vote for Cuomo. Moses Parente: Hm. Do you think that I I mean a lot of people probably will s say say the same thing, but do you think that a lot of people think that Mamdani and Sleawood they had like some sort of secret coalition behind to make sure that they worked together to that they ensured to beat Cuomo. Do you think that was actually a thing that was going on on in the back scene or or not really? Joe Silverstein: No, I don't think there was that, but I think it's the fact that it was self-interest. I mean, Sleewa wanted the attention. It's the job of the local parties to support the Republican candidate. And then at the individual level, different people were working for the campaign and wanted to get paid by the campaign and make the connections in politics. And that's one of the reasons that I'm glad I've always been an independent voice that that says how I feel and doesn't filter through the lens of whether or not this is good for some weird political standing. but if you look, the fact is that Curtis Lewa criticized IC. He said that he would not lock up people that Choplift if that's not what the public wanted. I mean, these were things that were videos of him saying these things. And then that's why it really didn't make sense because there was plenty of cli there was plenty of criticism to be had of Sleewa from the right. So this idea that he was like the champion of true conservatism as like a benchmark, I never understood that. on top of the fact that he really doesn't have a background to be mayor. I mean, obviously I would have voted for him over Mamdani, but this is not as Trump himself said, this was not exactly an ideal candidate. And hopefully this next time around, there's more competent politicians that that run on our side, on the Republican side. Moses Parente: No, I think that's actually very interesting that you mentioned that Curtis Lewa is that he mentioned that he wouldn't lock up shoplifters if that's quote unquote what the public wanted. And he ran as the person who kind of ran on a little bit on the law and order public safety side of of things. And there are many dem Democrats, even my side, I mean I'm a I'm now a Democrat a as well, but there are many Democrats who do believe that hey, we should have basic crime. Joe Silverstein: Maybe you'll be a Silverstein Democrat in the future. Maybe you'll be a Silverstein Democrat. Moses Parente: No i it it it's all good. I I make sure I'm very open minded and I am willing to talk to anybody and have them on on this show and I think that's one of the things that I really, really stand on is that everyone should have a platform to project their voice. Now you can of course talk to them, disagree with them, challenge them, but as long as you do it in in a respectful manner and have an on ongoing conversation. I felt always that there were at least like in in terms of the way how he was moving, that he was kind of pandering a little bit to the Mumda to the Mumdani fans and especially to I guess like the young Gen Z vote once he started getting a lot of the social media fame from all the memes back in twenty twenty five. And especially I guess he was getting love from the transplants for not being like Cuomo or or whatever. Joe Silverstein: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I mean, either way, he lost. I knew he was gonna lose. I had been saying that from the beginning. I took some flap for it online, but I turned out to be a hundred percent correct. He got eight percent of the vote, and a majority of Republicans voted for Cuomo. Not that Cuomo's great. I mean, obviously I criticized Cuomo more strongly than anyone else did, both when he was governor. Actually, my first like quasi-viral video was I was Moses Parente: Mm-hmm. Joe Silverstein: meeting with Joe Borelli when I was in middle school. And this was when Joe Barelli was a state assembly minute. I had sort of criticized Cuomo because this was when Cuomo said that if you're a Republican and you believe in the Second Amendment and you know, all these other things, you're not welcome in New York State. There's no place for you. And I sort of made an offhand comment to Borrelli. This was when I was like the eighth grade z president of thirty four that that I guess I'm not welcome in New York State because I'm a Republican, 'cause this had just happened. and Barelli liked that I said that and they they posted it on on Barelli's Facebook at the time. So yeah, you know, I mean, obviously Moses Parente: man. Joe Silverstein: none of the candidates were great. I mean, you have Adams going around now and God knows what he's doing. Moses Parente: he's selling data centers in Wisconsin. Joe Silverstein: Right, yeah. So yeah, he's a real a real popular person there too. So it kind of is what it is, unfortunately. But I guess on to the next, right? There's a lot of things happening in the city council, there's a lot of things Mamdani's doing, there's lot to pay attention to. So I think more important than rehashing what went wrong in the last election, I think it's more important that we take steps in the immediate future to continue to advocate for what's right at a city level and stay engaged with city politics. Moses Parente: Yeah, I think that f funny enough that that you you you just mentioned that in twenty twenty nine most of the New York City Council seats on at least on the Queens level are all going to be vacated, except for I believe it's three seats, Phil Wong's seat, Tyro Ty Hankerson's seat, and Chanel Thomas Henry's seat, I believe. So it's all open game and especially with the rise of how well the DSA has done in these primaries. You know that they're they're looking and scouting out for more seats that they can take that they can take over in a democratic primary, especially in Queens. W with Joe Silverstein: Mm-hmm. Yeah, no, I think I think that's true. I also think that if you look at some of the legislation and the laws that have been passed from the city councils, you can't tell the difference between the DSA and a Democrat in terms of the New York City Council, because the New York City Council current law saying I did an op ed about this last summer and I reached out privately to a couple of city council people, some of them Democrats, to try to get some legislation to change this. And I did not hear back from the Democrat that I reached out to about this. And I won't say who it was, but I was a little not I wasn't surprised, but I I thought that would have been someone that would have taken the initiative on this because he's actually otherwise an ice person. But the fact is that the current New York City Sanctuary City Law actually prevents the NYPD from turning over people to ICE. So when we talk about ICE going into cities, the current New York City law is not protecting random people on the street from. from detention and deportation. What it's doing is it's making it illegal and effectively all cases for people who are being charged with murder, with rape, with various different types of felonies, it actually prevents the NYPD and other city law enforcement agencies, Department of Prisons, from turning those people over to ICE. And it creates a phantom judicial warrant requirement that's just not the way that the warrants are issued at a federal level. The the warrants are signed by the Department of Homeland Security, Government officials. They're not signed by judges because there's no way you could process. I mean, you look at the estimates are maybe like 11 million people came in illegally under President Biden's administration. If you want to call him President Biden, but under his administration, 11 million people came in illegally. There's no way to process. People say, do process. There's no way to process that number of people through regular judges and the judicial system. You can't have 11 million separate trials. For these people that came in over a four-year period. So the warrants, the deportation warrants, are issued and have always been issued. This isn't just under the Trump administration by the actual ICE agents. And the New York City legislature and the sanctuary city policies, as it relates to turning over people convicted of felonies. I'm not talking about people who have no interaction with the criminal justice system, and I'm not even just talking about misdemeanors. I'm talking about people convicted of serious felonies are legally prohibited in New York City. From being turned over by these city agencies to ICE. So if you want to talk about a radical policy, and this is something that Councilman Borelli, when he was in the city council, and also Bob Holden tried to overturn. They introduced legislation trying to to to repeal that law and and get rid of that. And the city council said no. So, in terms of the abolishment of borders, they wanna they wanna abolish prisons, they wanna abolish borders. And when you look at the New York City Council of legislation, it looks like they already have done everything they can, the Democratic city council members to abolish borders. And that's why they also tried to make it legal for illegal immigrants to vote in New York City elections. And that had to be struck down in a court. so it really is a frontal assault on the notion of a nation state itself. And to anyone who's paying attention to the ideological underpinnings of this, it's very obvious what they're trying to do. Moses Parente: Mm. One thing that I always at le at least thought I was I was always a little bit more, I guess, on the a a little bit more on the li a little bit on the liberish liberalish side on im on immigration. I always was fairly pro amnesty because I always felt in giving a second chance to to people. And but overall I think that the the the the fact that it's it's making it a lot harder to T h to turn in criminals who happen to be un undocumented o over it, I thought that was like a little bit too far to at least to my liking. Joe Silverstein: Right. And and you and I may not completely agree on the issue of immigration. That's fine. That's one of the reasons to have these conversations. But Moses Parente: yeah. Joe Silverstein: what I will say is that like that point that you just said about turning over people that are charged with and convicted of violent felonies, right? Like that's something we should all be able to agree on. And that's actually what my op-ed called for. Because I said, even if We can't get them to overturn all of the sanctuary policies. And the sanctuary policies really do ch pertain to people convicted of crimes. It's not, it's it because if you think about it, like the the the sanctuary city policies, they really offer no protection for people that are just like going about their business that don't have interface with the criminal justice system. It more pertains to people that are in the custody of the city agent the various city agencies. But if the city council is unwilling to support a secure border generally, at the very least, they should be able to get behind the idea of not refusing to turn over people convicted of violent crimes to the federal government when it requests them. Moses Parente: One of the biggest, I guess, campaign platforms that I've seen a lot of people on the on the Democrat primary run on was abolish ice. And realistically, at least from my understanding, ICE is a part of Homeland Security. There's no way you have the power to abolish ice. The best thing that they could do was sign a bill that was at least trying to abolish ice. But as in my first episode of with Councilman Jimmy Vaca, he would say that a lot of legislators would just they would just sign a bill and they would go back to their constituents and say, by the way, guys, I signed a bill. So that makes them like a hero back in their district. But really, in reality, you got nothing done. And at le and and for me, at least the way how I saw it was that the whole abolish ice pro platform was cheap tactics. Do I agree with everything that I Do I agree with the way how ICE is doing things now? Not necess no, I don't, but saying abolish ICE, at least from what I thought that they were trying to get at, that was just way that was just pure delusion. It's basically they're saying, Hey, I stand on this and I signed and I signed a bill. Okay, and then what did that accomplish? They're they're s they're they're campaigning on a wish list. And you can't camp and you shouldn't be able to campaign on a wish list, but I guess right now that's what's working. For them and their constituents. Joe Silverstein: Well, the problem is some of them really do mean it. And this gets back to the conversation about the DSA taking over and just like the the left word shift generally, even during the Biden administration. And I think Biden was incorrectly understood as a centrist. I don't think he was a centrist at all. I think that he was gonna end up being and did end up being one of the most radical politicians in in the history of the country, in terms of left left wing radicalism for sure. But Biden intentionally stopped deportations and I mean by the way. Because people may fact check. I'm not saying that no deportations happened under Biden, but I'm saying Biden very intentionally changed the way that these things were processed and flung open the borders. And that was why there was such a mass migration of people into the United States illegally during that time, during his administration. And if you if you look at the academic literature, some of these like left wingers really don't think we should have a border and would like to abolish him. As a legal matter, of course the city council has no power over that, but Congress does. And Congress, some people on the left would like to, and if they had the votes for it, they certainly would defund it and stop giving funding to it. And I think that's a risk that is possibly run if the Democrats take back the House. Moses Parente: I always thought that Obama, at least when he was when he was on r running immigration, he did at and you can agree disagree or agree with me if if you want on this, but I I always felt that at least when he was doing the hey, let's go target criminals, that was the effective way and making sure that they effectively got were running I guess what we we we would call deportations and saying and ma managing the whole im immigration crisis, but and back then I guess a lot of even Democrats who are further to the left, they would just not do anything about it because if they spoke up about it, then they would lose their constit th they would lose their districts and they don't want to be facing a primary for someone who would oppose who would like I guess go against their beliefs. And but now that like I guess Obama was gone and then Trump he came in and then he started make making putting on I guess his immigration platform. And then they all just kind of went a little bit more berserk on that end. Joe Silverstein: I really think that this has been a longer term trend if you look at the the immigration policy of the country and if you look at the academic literature of what a lot of these people that are on the left think. Like I think they really do have no issue with a borderless world. And I think that what gets lost in that is real economic concerns, national security concerns, concerns about the pace of change in the country and and whether the change is good in terms of beliefs belief systems. so, you know, I mean, I I think that this is something that is part of a ideolog a very ideological push on the left. And I think that President Obama was operating in a different ecosystem where he had to play more to the center because the country was more to the center. And I think that now over the years, the decades, because if you think even like Obama was elected in two thousand eight. That's almost twenty years ago, the first time he was elected. I think that the effect of a lot of these people going to colleges and becoming sort of indoctrinated without a lot of the other views being represented. I I think it's I think it's had an impact on on the country. And I think that the left of the country has moved more left. And unfortunately you're seeing that with tolerance for political violence as well. Moses Parente: Mm. You you were mentioning so I guess i in indoctrination in colleges. How how what where did I guess like did you did you see that coming like when when you were in college? And you can talk about like I guess your time in underg undergrad or your time in law school from a conservative perspective. Joe Silverstein: Yeah, I mean in law school, like a lot of the criminal law professors believe in prison abolition. Like they don't think there should be prisons, which is a crazy idea. And then when you look and you read the New York Post and you see that someone with 88 prior arrests and five recent felonies went and pushed someone on the tracks in the subway, you shouldn't be surprised that that's happening, right? Because there's no there's no punishment and there's no holding people for periods of time. I mean, people commit really violent crimes and then are out the next day with no bail. And there's some judges that are ideologically opposed to even setting bail at all. And if you look at the quote unquote bail funds and if you look at what Kamala Harris promoted during 2020, like that sort of gives you an idea of what's done. There's there's a professor at Brooklyn Law School who writes about court watchers and this idea that people go on to courts That are for prison abolition, they go into courts with an eyeball on their t-shirt to represent them as court watchers. And the message is to the ADAs and to the judges that we're watching you. And they go and they tweet at the private accounts, the private Twitter accounts of the ADAs. This is according to the prison abolitionist professor who's in support of prison abolition, her book. they tweet at the private Twitter accounts of the ADAs, and the ADAs end up deleting their own private Twitter accounts as a result of that. unwanted online harassment. And this is something that the professor celebrated as a good thing and celebrates the court watching as a good thing. I don't think that kind of extra j judicial pressure on the legal system is a good thing. And I don't think it's appropriate. so in the law school setting it certainly is very far left. we tried to relaunch the Federal Society at Brooklyn Law School and we did successfully relaunch the Federalist Brooklyn Law School and we had a alumni dinner and we had two debates and we had general body meetings and there's a very robust group and led by a great e-board that's taking it over this year. I had just graduated. but we faced an uphill battle with the SBA. when Charlie Kirk was killed, there was a student who put up a poster that was sort of a vigil or remembrance to Charlie Kirk and somebody defaced that poster and essentially said he deserved to die and you reap what you sow. That's what the left winger put. And then the school sent out an email condemning the fact that someone put up an author an unauthorized poster but said nothing about the totally inappropriate defamation of it. So the and you know, I'll say it too. And my friends said, should you say about the DOJ? But I think I should say the the man that just got confirmed to be the attorney general, right? Todd Blanche, is a Brooklyn Law School alumni, and the law school didn't post a congratulations to him and I Let it be known within the law school community that I thought that was too bad, that I thought they should have congratulated him publicly, because that's an alumni that has accomplished the awesome feat of becoming attorney general of the Department of Justice in the United States, and the school did not make a post for him. And part of the reason the school didn't make a post for him is because all of the controversy at the school, the left-wing controversy, they get them to cancel speakers. They don't like one of the student groups putting an ultimatum saying that the school better not congratulate. Todd Blands for becoming attorney general. I myself was visited to the White House to meet with a Brooklyn Law School alumni in January, which I was very grateful to be invited, and it was an excellent experience. I got to go to the Eisenhower Executive Office Building. I got to visit the West Wing and it was really Moses Parente: Mm. Joe Silverstein: an incredible experience. And I took a picture with the Brooklyn Law School alumni outside the White House and the school posted that picture to celebrate the fact that one of its students and student leaders Because I am president of or was president of first generation professionals and was president of FedSoc, our chapter, one of the school students and leaders got to go to the White House to meet with an alumni. And I thought that was an incredible thing. And the school posted it. And then people started commenting, some left-wing people from the school saying that they they shouldn't post me at the White House, that it's wrong to platform the White House. And I thought, A, the White House is doing a lot of excellent things, and B, the idea that we as a law school are platforming. The most powerful institution in the country is a little crazy. but they pressured the school into taking down the Instagram post, which I thought was an even bigger insult because why did the school take down the Instagram post of us meeting of two Brooklyn Law School, one an alumni, one at that time a current student, me at the White House. That's something that I think is an incredible thing, regardless of politics. And I let I emailed the school to express my strong dissatisfaction. as they became familiar with over the years. my strong dissatisfaction with the fact that they took down the post and ultimately they said it was an error and they put back up the post. And I will say the dean of the law school is a very nice man, but it's not just it's not just him. I mean, there's a whole cohort of people running it. And there's also the pressures that they face from current students and alumni. And my point to the administration was that you can't cave to the pressures from the left wing students and alumni because it really sets an inappropriate environment where people are afraid to express their views. And if you don't want the if you don't want the and that's okay because I see that but yeah I get I get noise here too, Moses. It's okay. But it that that's that's that that's that's Moses Parente: That's all right. There there there were sirens at the back. Don't don't mind me. Joe Silverstein: filming a podcast in New York City. That's what happens. So everyone from New York City that's watching this, they understand, you know. Moses Parente: Gotta love New York, right? Joe Silverstein: But but my my point was that if the school's afraid to even post one of its students and alumni at the White House then how are the students expected to feel free to speak up in their classes? And that was one of the reasons I thought it was important to launch the Federalist Society on campus was because people are afraid of speaking their minds. And it it really is that bad on the law school campus. And even in undergrad, I mean, you know, Cornell had its issues too. Binghamton, there was a turning point USA event that got shut down. A speaker, Art Laffer was a economist that advised Trump and also advised Clinton. so it's not like he's necessarily even the most controversial speaker, but there were mass protests to shut it down, and there's still litigation against the university ongoing about that because it was free speech implications. So to answer your question, there's a lot of problems in academia, and I think that's a really big part of what's going on because academia has been held captive for decades. And I think that it's now bled over into the real world. And it's it's very sad in many ways. But I think that more people need to be courageous at the individual level and join and start organizations. And really put themselves out there in their classes to express their opinions. Moses Parente: Mm. Thank you so much for tell telling about telling us about your time in in law school and we we really do appreciate the time that you came to come on this podcast and express your opinions. One thing again that I always want to tell to everybody it is like you should be able to talk to everyone regardless of what their political beliefs are. We've had progressives, conservatives and this is a place where we can all come together and discuss ideas freely. So tha thank you again, Joe, for coming. And one last question before we do wrap up. Where can we find you and what's next for you? Joe Silverstein: Well, you can find me at Joe Silverstein underscore and what's next is I'm gonna work as a lawyer for a few years and then see what happens next. So I look forward to updating everyone at the appropriate time. Moses Parente: Awesome. Thank you so much, Joe. Joe Silverstein: Thank you, Moses. I appreciate it. You're doing a great job with the podcast. And it's always nice to talk to you. So I'll talk to you soon. Moses Parente: Thank you, Joe. Really appreciate it. Joe Silverstein: All right, bye.