Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / American Idolatry: A Christian Against Christian Nationalism (with Andrew Whitehead)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feel so much more happiness. Truth, Usian
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast, hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:56I'm always talking about trying to find points of connection of shared values, and
- 1:03I have followed this guy for a long time, and so I just threw
- 1:07a feeler at hey, would you join me on the show. I know
- 1:11you're a believer, you're a Christian, but we have a lot in common.
- 1:14Can we talk? And he joins me here. Andrew Whitehead is Associate
- 1:19Professor of sociology and director of the Association of Religion Data Archives at the Center
- 1:26for the Study of Religion and American Culture at Indiana University, Purdue University,
- 1:33Indianapolis. Come on, you got to give me like a shorter intro man.
- 1:38Yeah, that's a lot of words, a lot of words. It's
- 1:41so impressior. I mean, how do you put that on a business card?
- 1:44And I don't even care him anymore. In the twenty nineteen he authored
- 1:49an article called make America Christian Again, Christian nationalism and voting for Donald Trump
- 1:56in the twenty sixteen presidential election. He's also author of a book that came
- 2:00out three years ago. It's called Taking America Back for God Christian Nationalism in
- 2:07the United States. And he's got a brand new book and the reason we're
- 2:09talking American idolatry, how Christian nationalism betrays the Gospel and threatens the church.
- 2:19You do a lot of data collection about belief or professed belief in the United
- 2:24States. People go to church, they leave the church. The demographic tides
- 2:29are shifting articles about politics religion, and I want to get to that.
- 2:34But beyond the data collection, can you sort of flesh out more about who
- 2:38you are? This is an introduction to my audience and the first time handshake
- 2:43for many. Who are you? Andrew? So, I'm a sociologist and
- 2:46I study religion in the US, and so it's been a little while I
- 2:52guess a little over a decade since I left graduate school, and so in
- 2:54that time I mostly study broad surveys of the US population, And so I'm
- 3:00fascinated with religion, especially in the US contexts, how it both shapes and
- 3:06is shaped by our culture and demographic change, different types of socio demographic change,
- 3:13and how that affects religion. And so that's really where my expertise on
- 3:15this subject begins. But then too, you know, as an American who's
- 3:20interested in living in a democracy and power sharing all of those things, and
- 3:24then too, yeah, identifying still as a Christian and having grown up in
- 3:30a particularly conservative Christian space, but then being on a journey sense growing up
- 3:35in that space. So would you say you deconstructed at least to a degree,
- 3:39Like you said, you come out of kind of a FUNDI religion?
- 3:42Did you have to sort of re examine? Right? You come out of
- 3:45the cocoon and you're like, wait a minute, maybe this isn't my flavor
- 3:49of belief or value. Did that happen to you? Yeah? Now,
- 3:52I think any Christian that is interested, and I think this is true for
- 3:55probably any world religion or for those that identify with no religious faith. We're
- 4:00all on a journey and to you know, really think through why we believe
- 4:04what we believe, it's going to involve self examination. And when you do
- 4:09that, there's going to be things that you find don't really work with how
- 4:13you view the world or want to view the world, or how you want
- 4:15to live within it. And so we set those aside. And so that
- 4:19happened with my faith journey that I'm still on and still you know, thinking
- 4:25through and wrestling with particular aspects of it. And I think other folks do
- 4:29that as well, and so I think that's a part of just being honest.
- 4:32If we're going to be with whatever deeply held beliefs we hold, I
- 4:36think holding them in such a way that we try to have some humility that
- 4:41this is where I am right now, and I understand that we may not
- 4:44be in the same place or drastically different places, but that doesn't mean we
- 4:47can't, like you said, value the humanity that we see in each other.
- 4:53Andrew, It's funny I think you and I might hear the same thing.
- 4:56Some people say, I sound sometimes like a preacher, a little bit
- 5:00of a minister thing going on there. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you
- 5:02ever heard that one before? I guess probably just being a teacher communicator kind
- 5:06of, I think, so, yeah, doing a lot of teaching and
- 5:10podcasting, communicating, and then too, like you know, in funny ways
- 5:14where I don't know, you know, how we try to label ourselves.
- 5:18It can be difficult for me sometimes to figure out, well, where do
- 5:20I really slot in? But I know that I was formed, you know,
- 5:24in the Evangelical Protestant tradition, and so no matter where I'm at,
- 5:29probably some of the cultural style, let's say, comes out. Yeah,
- 5:33maybe we do have echoes of that. You said that in your book,
- 5:38you said you used to listen to Christian music. Man, that's my wheelhouse.
- 5:41I was a Christian radio host for a lot of like ten twelve years.
- 5:45Come on, give me some of the artists, I mean, not
- 5:46necessarily the new ones that I can't connect with, but give me the old
- 5:49school. Some is back in the day music. Who'd you listen to?
- 5:53Yeah, So one that was really influential is five Arm Frenzy, So you
- 5:57know, the sky wave we all live through. But I think you know,
- 6:00their music still holds up. There are many that I don't didn't really
- 6:03like then, and certainly don't like now, but five Frenzy, I think
- 6:06holds up and funny story, I was been working on a four part Christian
- 6:12nationalism podcast, right and so as I was working on it, the sound
- 6:15engineer as someone who didn't grow up with that music at all, but I
- 6:19had talked about, you know, some influences and told him that band.
- 6:21So he went back and listened to it, and I was really pleased.
- 6:25Where he's like, you know, I was fully expecting to listen to some
- 6:28of this music and be like, how horrible is this? But five Iron
- 6:30held up like he was like it was, It's pretty good. And so
- 6:33that was one. I was really into the you know, pop punk Christian
- 6:39scene too. So MxPx was a big one, Gody Hook and some of
- 6:44those other smaller bands, but those it was basically like if if anybody knew
- 6:47about Cornerstone Festival in Illinois, that was where I was in the summer.
- 6:53Love that. So those are kind of I mean, if I made,
- 6:55they're kind of niche bands though. We mean it wasn't like Amy Grant,
- 6:59Michael W's myth White Hearts, Third Day, you know that kind of thing.
- 7:03You were a little hardcore, you were a little more niche if I'm
- 7:06in that's interesting. Yeah, and we pride in that, right, Yeah.
- 7:10I mean I work for an alternative Christian station for about a year and
- 7:15a half, and I remember we used to play a lot of bands and
- 7:16we were edgy man, you know, we were rocking for the rock kind
- 7:19of deal. So yeah, yeah, our paths have crossed in that way.
- 7:25Andrew. Let's say that Jesus Christ exists. Let's say you and I
- 7:28agree on this, and Jesus, I don't know. He takes an uber
- 7:32over the border from another place into the United States and he looks around.
- 7:39Jesus looks around at the US in the year twenty twenty three. What do
- 7:44you think he would have to say about everything that's been going on? Oh?
- 7:48Man, that is a huge question, and one that too, I
- 7:54guess I want to preface. And this is something that I truly believe and
- 7:57try to get across in this most recent book, is that there are a
- 8:00number of expressions of Christianity, and so to say that I would know exactly
- 8:05what Jesus I think different expressions would would highlight different things. But I think
- 8:09what I would want to do is encourage people to move towards one of those
- 8:13expressions of Christianity and those expressions of Jesus and his teachings that moves away from
- 8:20Christian nationalism. So I think one of the things that maybe a number of
- 8:24those expressions would say, Jesus would think is looking at this close intertwining of
- 8:30American identity with being truly that's how you be a true Christian, right,
- 8:35So to be a real Christian, we've got to be American. And if
- 8:37you're going to be American, you've got to be a Christian of a particular
- 8:41type. So I think he would obviously have some issues with that. I
- 8:43think the wealth of our nation would obviously come up, and that includes me
- 8:50in that. But then the treatment of those who are marginalized and oppressed,
- 8:54I think Jesus would have words to say on that. And I think that
- 8:58is something that you know, as I study Christian nationalism is something that gets
- 9:03overlooked and I think actively ignored. And there's a lot of kind of examples
- 9:09that pop up. You know, a culture that is obsessed with firearms,
- 9:13and you know there's you know, a picture of friend just sent me where
- 9:18it said one nation under God and then it had a skull with the American
- 9:22flag on it, and then two semi automatic rifles crossed behind the skull.
- 9:28And so thinking of this, like interplay of violence and guns and God and
- 9:33all of that, I think he would be troubled by that. And so
- 9:37that a moment I'm reminded of when there was a manufacturer of firearms for the
- 9:41US military and they were actually embossing scriptures on the weapon itself, which is
- 9:48weird. And aren't you are believers divinely protected? Like, aren't you divinely
- 9:54protected? So I don't know, I'll let you speak to that. No,
- 9:56I think you know. A lot of it is kind of holding beliefs
- 10:01and then how that actually gets lived out and the disconnect between some of those
- 10:05right, and so these are some of the questions that I think caused me
- 10:09to have to leave or walk out of some of the aspects of the faith
- 10:13that was handed where it's exactly that if we believe that God protects us and
- 10:18that our battle isn't against flesh and blood, this is another verse that folks
- 10:22will use, then why are we fighting wars? And why are we so
- 10:26easy to move into violence towards other people? Both interpersonally or collectively or you
- 10:33know, as we look at racial inequality too so quick to ignore some of
- 10:37that inequality. And so yeah, the divinely protected part, I think there
- 10:43are aspects where for those outside the faith looking at it, it's like,
- 10:46well, that seems hypocritical, right, you say God will protect you,
- 10:50but then you're more than willing to take up arms or act out in violence
- 10:54towards others no matter what. And so those are questions that I've had and
- 10:58that I have to wrestle with, and I hope other Christians wrestle with as
- 11:03we think about how to be Christian in relation with those who don't share the
- 11:07same beliefs as us. We have to find a way to live and work
- 11:11together towards a common future. I've noticed that the depictions of Christ have sort
- 11:16of become a little more badass over the life, Like he's just more buff.
- 11:20I mean, you notice that, like that we're in this sort of
- 11:22era of bravado. You know, it's like watching the NFTs or whatever,
- 11:28Donald Trump, and you know, and he's got a six pack, and
- 11:31he's seven feet tall, and he's you know, he's riding a tank and
- 11:35there's fire and eagles and stuff like that, and the Jesus of today seems
- 11:39to more and more be like that. I don't know, I thought that
- 11:41was interesting. Yeah, let's talk about patriotism. Now. This is something
- 11:46that you deal with in the book Patriotism, and I want to get into
- 11:50your definition. Maybe we should start there. Define for me your take on
- 11:56patriotism. Yeah. You know, different writers, you know that work within
- 12:01political science or political theory will distinguish between nationalism and patriotism. And so I
- 12:07like when they distinguish patriotism as love or feelings of care and warmth towards our
- 12:13fellow countrymen and women. So it's almost like when we watch the Olympics and
- 12:18we see somebody that we like. I watch the Olympics and I don't know
- 12:22that person who's running the eight hundred, you know, in track and field,
- 12:26but I see that they're from the US, and so all of a
- 12:30sudden I care about them. I want to see them do well and win,
- 12:33but not at the detriment or to push down other nations, but just
- 12:35because we happen to be from the same country by historical accident. And so
- 12:41I think patriotism in that sense is care for those around us who have lived
- 12:46around us, and wanting to do better and do well by them. Right
- 12:50by looking at our history and seeing where we've had issues, how can we
- 12:54do it better going forward? And again, not at the detriment to people
- 12:58from other nations. This isn't something where we have to be over and above
- 13:03them. But how can we care for one another and those who are even
- 13:07outside our group in such a way that we aren't trying to marginalize or push
- 13:11down other folks? And so I think patriotism in that sense resonates with me.
- 13:16Right, it's wanted to tell the truth about the group. It does
- 13:18seem to be a zero sum game for many people, like for us to
- 13:22be winners, everybody else has to be a loser, you know, for
- 13:28us all to succeed, we simply have to succeed more. And I find
- 13:31that very interesting. Yeah, I'm also struck by the people who say we're
- 13:35the greatest country on the face of the earth, and yet they can't give
- 13:37you a single metric or I wrote about this in Fox News Christian a few
- 13:41years ago. I'm like, well, cost of living, no, we
- 13:43lose healthcare, No, we lose violence, murder rate, no, you
- 13:48know, lifespan, Yeah, all of these. I mean, you're the
- 13:52sociologist, You've seen that kind of thing, right, Yeah, definitely across
- 13:56a number of different things. And I just saw today actually the life expectancy
- 14:01of the US compared to other essentially wealthy, western post industrialized nations is much
- 14:07lower, right, And they've all taken a little dip because of what we've
- 14:09lived through with the global pandemic, But the US is much further below other
- 14:13countries. And so when we look at that, I think that's where we
- 14:18should all be skeptical of anybody trying to say that, you know, we
- 14:22have it figured out, or the US is number one. I think there's
- 14:26so much work that needs to be done and can be done to make it
- 14:31a place where, yeah, like you said, it doesn't have to be
- 14:33a zero sum game that there can be there's enough for everyone if we're all
- 14:37committed to giving up what we feel is our right to be on top.
- 14:43I'm talking here with sociologist and author doctor Andrew Whitehead new book out called American
- 14:48Idolatry, How Christian nationalism betrays the Gospel and threatens the Church. I'm interested
- 14:56in the symbols of patriotism. Can be the worst person in the world.
- 15:01But you put a flag out in your yard, and you put the flag
- 15:05sticker on your car, or you're wearing the colors red, white or blue,
- 15:09boom, you are now a great American, Right, it's patriot plumage.
- 15:13I think. So there's a lot of flag waving, especially by the
- 15:16extreme right wing, by Christian nationalists. Let's talk about the symbols. What's
- 15:20your take. Yeah, I think symbols are key part of Christian nationalism because
- 15:26as we study it, we define as a cultural framework, and cultural frameworks
- 15:31are there's many different types, but essentially they contain narratives and symbols and value
- 15:35systems and beliefs and all those wrapped up together that help people make sense of
- 15:41their social worlds, what things mean, and what they should do, how
- 15:45they should act within it, who we are as a people or a country,
- 15:48and where we're going. And so with Christian nationalism, it's a very
- 15:50powerful cultural framework filled with powerful symbols, whether it's red, white and blue,
- 15:56different songs, different ritual holidays that we have throughout the year, and
- 16:00then Christian symbolism as well, and seeing those two intertwined can be really powerful.
- 16:06So as you know, I don't know if this will come up later,
- 16:10but as we look at let's say January sixth, right, this brought
- 16:12a lot of Americans and woke. I think a lot of Americans up where
- 16:17they see the symbols of Christianity crossed with or in relationship with the Confederate flag,
- 16:25or symbols of QAnon and conspiratorial thinking or nooses and other you know,
- 16:30weapons of war harm and so they were really surprised. And so the symbols
- 16:34are so key and are such an important part of this because they tell us
- 16:38something about ourselves and a lot of times do they motivate people to action.
- 16:42Right, they see, this is what we're all about, and this is
- 16:45who we are, and those identities are are really powerful. Yeah, but
- 16:49I mean I got a all right, I'll just go here. If you
- 16:53look at the Bible, if we read the Bible, yeah, it's loaded
- 16:56with militarized language. You know, we are in God's army. The weapons
- 17:02of our warfare are not carnal. When I was a kid, we used
- 17:04to march, you know, we used to sing I'm in the Lord's army.
- 17:07We talk about the sword of the Spirit and the breastplate of righteousness,
- 17:12the helmet of salvation. We are going to battle. It's easy for me
- 17:17to see how some people could read those verses literally and say, you know
- 17:21what, it's war. It may be literal war. What's your take.
- 17:25Yeah, No, I think you're exactly right. I think there are definitely
- 17:29American Christians. And two, it isn't even just Christianity other world religions,
- 17:33or even just Christianity in the US, but other countries through Christianity's history,
- 17:40you know, drawing on and using these symbols to essentially baptize violence and fear
- 17:45of others, and being able to go out and commit really heinous crimes,
- 17:51you know, against whole people groups, whether we're talking about indigenous people that
- 17:56were on these shores before us, or enslaving Africans. All of these things
- 18:00were made possible through interpretations of the Bible and theologies that essentially said that God
- 18:06is on your side and has a particular demand on you to go and take
- 18:10control and to flourish and take these resources. Whether it's the doctrine of discovery
- 18:15or manifest destiny, all of these things were intertwined with theologies, and so
- 18:19I think some of the work that I need to do, continue to do,
- 18:23need to continue to do, and other Christians too, is thinking through
- 18:26some of those theologies we were handed and where they come from, and are
- 18:30they truly things that we need to continue to carry going forward, or do
- 18:34we need to set those aside and to see how closely they're intertwined with anti
- 18:40black racism or xenophobia or other types of isms that cause us to harm our
- 18:45neighbors. And so it's true that in the Bible there's their symbolism and words
- 18:52used that Christians throughout history have drawn on and interpret in such a way that
- 18:57allow them almost in some sense, they feel forced them to act in very
- 19:03violent ways towards other human beings. Yeah, but do you think that a
- 19:07benevolent deity would come down and say you got it wrong? Like everybody,
- 19:12you are interpreting these words incorrectly, or let me fix the words. I
- 19:17mean, you know, do you feel like that an involved personal God would
- 19:21come in and intervene in some way? You know, that's a really good
- 19:25question. It's a fair question. It's one that I definitely struggle with and
- 19:30have to think through. You know, in my personal life, stuff that
- 19:33I face, but then looking at all of the pain and suffering of the
- 19:36world, and I can say I wish, like I wish that would happen.
- 19:41I wish it would be that straightforward and easy. And I don't know
- 19:45that I have a great answer on most days for that. That is one
- 19:48of the most difficult parts, right, is thinking through that in the'm
- 19:53trying to put you on the spot, Andrew, But I mean you and
- 19:56I are just talking over now. No, it's fair. It's totally fair.
- 19:59Like I I totally empathize with that, and it's a completely fair question.
- 20:03Well all right, well, while we're here sort of talking about the
- 20:07faith itself. Interesting line in your book it said Jesus calls us to be
- 20:11a light, not a wildfire, and I think it's a great line.
- 20:15Being a former Christian, though, I was taught that God created Adam and
- 20:19then one of the next things he did was to give Adam dominion over the
- 20:23entire earth first Chronicles twenty nine. All that is in heaven and in earth
- 20:30belongs to the Christian God, Psalm twenty two. He rules over the nations.
- 20:34Matthew twenty eight. Has the great commission right, go yee into all
- 20:37the world and pretty much converts anybody. So it seems to me that the
- 20:42Christian dominionist, and I think that Christian nationalist is a dominionist. It seems
- 20:48like the Bible is a dominionist book. Would you agree disagree? Elaborates refuge.
- 20:55Yeah, well, I think there are definitely interpretations and expressions of christ
- 21:00Ristianity that will highlight or foreground those types of verses, but in such a
- 21:04way that it becomes yeah, you know, quote unquote, we're interpreting it
- 21:08literally, and this is what it means to go and do. But I
- 21:11do think there are expressions of Christianity that wouldn't read those passages or interpret them
- 21:17in the same way, or wouldn't necessarily think that we have to go and
- 21:22take dominion or force others into anything, or even just focus on, you
- 21:27know, quote unquote saving those people. So I think that's part of it
- 21:33is recognizing too, at least for me in my journey, the various expressions
- 21:37of Christianity, and for me moving towards some of those that don't demand others
- 21:42just fall in line, but are focused on a type of self sacrifice that
- 21:48will hopefully help others find flourishing and the common Good, and yeah, so
- 21:55I think there's a lot of variation within it. And those are the types
- 21:57of expression of the Christian faith that I want to move towards, that I
- 22:02hope others move towards, and that I think help confront and oppose some of
- 22:04the dominionus aspects of Christian nationalism. More with sociologist Andrew Whitehead about his book
- 22:12American Idolatry, How Christian Nationalism betrays the Gospel and threatens the Church. We
- 22:18continue next. Andrew Whitehead is a sociologist and a Christian, but he is
- 22:30an opponent of Christian nationalism, and he joins me for this conversation today.
- 22:38The book title American Idolatry. You say Christian nationalism is idolatry. Explain that
- 22:45for me. Yeah, So, you know, within the Christian tradition,
- 22:49this idea of idols or anything that we place Christians or others place their hope
- 22:56and trust in other than God, and so idols we turn to these for
- 23:00protection and provision, but they require allegiance that cost us something. And so
- 23:04when we go to these things other than God for protection and provision, it's
- 23:10going to lead us down paths that are going to be inherently self centered and
- 23:14focused on protecting us to the detriment of others, I believe, and so
- 23:18I think Christian nationalism is idolatry, especially around this desire for power over other
- 23:23people, you know, in such a way that we want to their detriment,
- 23:27a fear and threat where we're you know, drawing up boundary lines against
- 23:32others and we're just afraid of them even having conversations or working with them,
- 23:36and then violence to protect those boundaries and protect our access to self centered power.
- 23:41And so you know, I try to I'm writing to a Christian audience
- 23:44to try to say, you know, when we turn towards these idols,
- 23:48right, we're turning away from what the Bible calls us to do, which
- 23:51is to trust in God and to leverage what we have to the benefit of
- 23:55those around us. Because Jesus, again in various expressions of the Christian faith,
- 24:00was focused on siding with the marginalized and siding with those who were broken
- 24:04and being oppressed. And so you know, as I write this book to
- 24:08Christians and even you know, for for your listeners who who aren't maybe even
- 24:15resourcing them to be able to talk to the Christians, they're near or in
- 24:18you know, they live life with or in their families, you know,
- 24:22to use the resources of the Christian faith to show a way away from Christian
- 24:26nationalism, because I do believe that there are expressions of Christianity that can live
- 24:32around and with and in harmony with those who don't share the same religious beliefs.
- 24:37Have you noticed how often many of the people, especially you know,
- 24:40I mean, are those people busting into the capital on January sixth, that
- 24:44they're holding up Jesus. He's suspiciously white. Yes, white, he's very
- 24:48American jay. Have you noticed that? Oh? Yeah, definitely. I
- 24:52mean, and there's some really interesting, you know, social scientific studies of
- 24:56how folks imagine Jesus, and the racialized aspect is very clear and has a
- 25:02lot of implications for how they see their social worlds. Yeah, I think
- 25:04a lot of cultures. I did a presentation years ago called the Changing Face
- 25:11of Jesus, and there's like a Native American Jesus, there's an Asian Jesus,
- 25:15there's an African American Jesus. It's interesting, how you know, Jesus
- 25:18seems to reflect we want to look at Jesus and see ourselves. I don't
- 25:22know, would you say it that way, Andrew, Yeah, I think
- 25:25that's one of the real, not necessarily desires. It's not as though it's
- 25:29like this. Well, for some folks might be explicit, but I think
- 25:33for many people, as they just imagine a person that you know, obviously
- 25:37they would never have a picture of or know what looks like or even God
- 25:41in their mind, it's so easy to impute, right what we see around
- 25:45us, or what we value the groups that we're a part of, to
- 25:49create God in our image, to think that God looks like or values us.
- 25:53And you know, the writer and LaMotte has a great quote where I'm
- 25:57going to get it wrong, but essentially what she's saying is for a lot
- 26:00of folks, they look around and you know, if you've created God in
- 26:03your image, if God hates everybody that you hate, and so if God
- 26:10just completely agrees with you, you know, the likelihood that you've created God
- 26:12in your image is pretty high. And I think a lot of American Christians
- 26:17have done that. Well. Let me, I mean, you brought up
- 26:19kind of the dark side, the hate, the bigot tree. Do you
- 26:22feel like you've mentioned white Christian nationalism, do you feel like the Christian nationalist
- 26:27movement in this country is a white power movement, you know. I think
- 26:32that there is overlap. So the Venn diagram, there's overlap. There are
- 26:36going to be white nationalists who would embrace Christian nationalism would talk in terms of
- 26:41saving. A lot of times they talk in terms of saving like Western civilization
- 26:45and Christendom, right, and so there's aspects of it. But I would
- 26:48I wouldn't say that many Americans that embrace Christian nationalism would actively or even implicitly
- 26:55embrace a lot of white nationalists viewpoints. But Christian nationalism in the US is
- 27:00fundamentally racialized. And by that, I mean this cultural framework operates in such
- 27:06a way that it perpetuates and sustains a society and social systems that tend to
- 27:11benefit white Americans as a group, right, And so it has less to
- 27:15do with the skin color of the person embracing it and more to do with
- 27:18the fact that it enforces and perpetuates whiteness, which again is a society that
- 27:23functions to benefit white people more and at the detriment to other racial and ethnic
- 27:29minorities. And so I think there's some overlap. But for most Americans who
- 27:33might embrace Christian nationalism, we do find over and over they're more likely to
- 27:37hold more racist views. But I wouldn't go so far as to say that
- 27:41it's broadly a white nationalist movement, or that these folks are white nationalists.
- 27:47Well, if we talk about mag make America great again? Well, I
- 27:51always like to say, when were we great? Like, y, what
- 27:53is it you want to return to? Right? Yeah? And usually I
- 27:56have found and you tell me what your experience is in it's usually mid twentieth
- 28:02century, right, And everything on TV was sort of homogenized and sanitized,
- 28:07and you know, everything was amazing and pure, and you know, everybody
- 28:11had greater morals. And of course you do a cursory look at the mid
- 28:15twentieth century and you're like, well, wait a minute. We had white
- 28:18and colored water fountains, and women weren't welcome in the workplace, and kids
- 28:22are ducking under desks for nuclear bomb drills, and you know, I just
- 28:27think, whoa wait a minute. So when you hear the good old days,
- 28:33the myth of the good old days, what comes to mind? I
- 28:34know you wrote about it, tell me about it. Yeah, I think
- 28:37that's one of the key questions that we should be asking each other continually asking
- 28:41ourselves, is you know, anytime we want to kind of embrace or uplift
- 28:47nostalgia or thinking that, oh it was better when the key questions asked,
- 28:52well, better for who right and which groups? And so, yeah,
- 28:55as we look at make America great again, and many of those folks are
- 28:59thinking of the nineteen fifties. You know, it was a pretty good time
- 29:02for wide Americans, but especially those that were upper working class or middle class
- 29:07especially, But then, like you said, when we look at that time,
- 29:11it was a time of segregation and Jim Crow and lynching and sundown towns,
- 29:17and there were higher rates of in some quarters substance abuse and domestic violence
- 29:22was kind of hidden but was prevalent. And so there's all these aspects where
- 29:26it might have looked good to some or at least on the surface, there's
- 29:30a lot of suffering too, And so we have to think, well,
- 29:33why would we want to return to that or what was so great about that?
- 29:37And I think some of the nostalgia is just a fabricated history and past
- 29:41right where we think, well, this was a time that was good for
- 29:44everyone, but it wasn't And something I try to tell my students or show
- 29:48them consistently, is how much of an outlier decade in nineteen fifties was especially
- 29:53economically right where coming out of World War two and manufacturing is booming, and
- 29:57you could support a fam on one income with nothing more than a high school
- 30:03education, and folks did really well and had a pension and all those things.
- 30:07And not every American, but I think some of that is where folks
- 30:10think that was widespread. But before that decade and especially after that has just
- 30:15not been the reality for Americans. And so to want to return to some
- 30:18period and have a nostalgia for it that we can't recreate and is never coming
- 30:22back, is truly unhelpful. And I think in that way it serves to
- 30:26motivate folks to vote a particular way, but in reality, it's just nothing
- 30:30that's ever going to come again. Yeah, do you want to go back
- 30:33to a time when it enter racial marriage was illegal and you know, if
- 30:37your teenage daughter became pregnant, they send her away, kind of shun her
- 30:41off to a school for unwed girls, and blah blah blah. And I
- 30:45just think what exactly was great about that particular moment in our history. In
- 30:49the book, you talk a lot about the fear mongers, and I appreciate
- 30:53that because we talk about the power of the weaponization of fear language. So
- 31:00I'm going to throw some stuff out here and I'm just going to let you
- 31:03respond to it. Okay. Yeah, the fearmongers, usually white Christian nationalists,
- 31:07say those seculars or other religions or whatever, the atheists, the evil
- 31:12people. They have taken God in prayer out of our schools. This is
- 31:18what they say. How would you respond to that? Yeah, they haven't.
- 31:22First of all, like if we're talking about they, I would want
- 31:26to know who they is. But prayers still allow in school. In school,
- 31:30students can pray however much they want, and lead prayers. All that
- 31:33we ask is that adults and teachers employed there aren't leading prayers or asking students
- 31:41to join them in prayer. And so, yeah, it isn't as though
- 31:45God's not allowed in school. God is in schools. Okay, it's moral
- 31:49chaos. Andrew, it's great, we have to return to Judeo Christian values.
- 31:56I hear this one a lot. How do you respond to that term
- 31:59Judaeo Christian values? Yeah, well, this is another one where where those
- 32:02terms we really need to be clear of what that means. And a lot
- 32:07of times that's used to only refer to a very particular expression of Christianity,
- 32:12because again, they wouldn't want any sort of for instance, progressive Christian values
- 32:17to be a part of the discussion of overturning wealth or you know, Christians
- 32:22that would say we need to operate according to a different economic system, they
- 32:24wouldn't want that. So it's a very particular expression of Christianity. So it
- 32:29isn't this broad widely held belief or understanding of Christianity. It's one that they've
- 32:35defined in very particular ways, and in that sense to benefit a very particular
- 32:39group, which is generally, you know, white Christians and natural born citizens.
- 32:45And so I think that's what needs to be made clear, is that
- 32:49this isn't the only representation of Christianity. There are many different expressions, but
- 32:53this is only a very particular one that wants the privilege and power. And
- 32:57so Kevin Kruse in his book One Nation Under God has a great chapter where
- 33:02you know, they're talking about wanting to get the Bible quote unquote back in
- 33:05schools and the big question is and that these Christians that wanted to put Bible
- 33:09back in schools couldn't agree on is which Bible? Right? So you ask
- 33:14well which translation, and all of a sudden you'll have Christians disagree with one
- 33:17another. Or put prayer back in schools, Well which prayer? And all
- 33:22of a sudden they're all going to be disagreeing. And so I think that
- 33:23shows the inherent weakness of thinking that there's some monolith of Judeo Christian values because
- 33:30Christians themselves differ on a lot of these things. Oh man, you and
- 33:32I I'm telling you, I just want to like when we talk about expressions
- 33:37of the faith and all the things that people are confused about. I'm just
- 33:40waiting for the curtain of this guy to open and the great clarifier to show
- 33:45up and just solve the mystery. Because right now, if I ask an
- 33:49expert in Christianity about anything, you know, literal creation, how do you
- 33:54baptize? What's the nature of heaven? And how you know all those things?
- 33:59You get the Holy Spirit of salvation? Is that a separate prayer?
- 34:02Miracle speaking in tongues blob you know? The end Times? It's thunderdome and
- 34:07really totally and and the fact that even the experts can't agree is extremely frustrating
- 34:14for someone like me. I mean, that's understandable, right, that's a
- 34:16reasonable frustration. Oh yeah, totally. And I think in some ways that
- 34:21points to this idea or belief that somehow we have it settled and can now
- 34:27you know, shape and bring that out and everybody needs to fall in line
- 34:30with it. I think should raise some humility and some hopefully taking a step
- 34:37back right and taking a beat, because there's a lot that we can't agree
- 34:40on. And too, you know, something that you mentioned earlier and I
- 34:44thought maybe we would go here, but you know, as Christians want to
- 34:47run the world, as we look at some influential denominations, they can't even
- 34:52really run their congregations well, you know, and when we look at the
- 34:55abuse crisis. So in that sense, I'm like, you know, there's
- 35:00the whole kind of parable or saying of Jesus, the you know, spec
- 35:06someone else's I and the log in your own eye. I think I would
- 35:09want Christians to kind of embrace a little bit more humility in that there's a
- 35:14lot of things we differ on, and we have a lot of problems internally
- 35:17too. To think that we now can go out and just easily take control
- 35:22and do whatever we want, I think for many reasons, but especially for
- 35:28this one is a bit problematic. Yeah, do we really want the Southern
- 35:31Badtist convention running the rest of the world right now? Probably not. I'm
- 35:36just probably not a couple more of the this is right out of Fox News.
- 35:40As far as scaring people, the immigrants, what a great scapegoat,
- 35:45right, especially on the southern border. We're not too worried about the Canadians.
- 35:47They're busy curling and watching hockey and all that stuff, right, But
- 35:52a southern border, they're coming. I've heard, I was raised hearing this.
- 35:57They're coming for your jobs, They're coming for you, your money,
- 36:00for your opportunity, for your children. You know, how do you address
- 36:05this sort of outhing of everybody else, especially those outside our national border lines?
- 36:12Yeah? Well, I think one thing that I try to write in
- 36:14the book is that immigration, you know, especially in a nation this large
- 36:19and this complex, is an incredibly complex issue. And to think that we
- 36:22can just turn to the Bible or a couple verses to figure out all the
- 36:25policy that we need to help our nation function and take in those that are
- 36:30either fleeing here as refugees or coming here as immigrants. I think is an
- 36:36exercising futility. But I do think there are fundamental values that Christians could use
- 36:42as we think about those in need, and immigrants and refugees are those in
- 36:45need to think through how we treat them, how we talk about them.
- 36:49And I think one of the really, you know, really sad aspects is
- 36:52religious leaders with a lot of sway and a lot of poll and a lot
- 36:55of followers really embracing this demonizing language to those in need, whether it's immigrants
- 37:01or refugees. To the fact that when we gather data Americans that embrace Christian
- 37:06nationalism, they're even less likely to want to admit refugees who come from majority
- 37:10Christian nations who are probably have a greater likelihood of being Christian than they're fellow
- 37:15Americans. But it has little to do with any share religious faith, and
- 37:20everything to do with the fact that they are being identified as other right outside
- 37:25American identity and who is actually American or and that's racialized as well, and
- 37:30so all those aspects I think should be troubling to Christians and I hope increasingly
- 37:36it is. But like you said, the voices that kind of embrace this
- 37:40rhetoric are really loud and really powerful, and I think that makes it really
- 37:45difficult. You've been very generous with your time. I'm going to link the
- 37:47book in the description box, but before we go. Yeah, the increasing
- 37:53amount of I don't know, violent language. I don't even know if they're
- 37:59dog whistles anymore. They seem to be more and more overtly saying we want
- 38:02to brutalize our enemies. They're not coming after me, they're coming after you.
- 38:08I worry that all it takes is one spark and it's bullets in the
- 38:15streets, a jihad in this country, especially going into twenty twenty four.
- 38:20Has your research spoken to this and have you tell me about what the book
- 38:24has to say about this sort of rising tide of jihot. Yeah. Well,
- 38:30violence, I think empirically we see, and as I talk about in
- 38:34the book, is a key element of Christian nationalism and a comfort with authoritarian
- 38:37rules and rulers that under the threat of violence or through violence, will kind
- 38:43of, in their hope, restore order according to this moral hierarchy that they
- 38:46believe should be enacted. And so we do see evidence of a greater acceptance
- 38:52of political violence if folks feel that the democratic process or election didn't turn out
- 38:58the way that they wanted. Americans that strongly embraced Christian nationalism are more likely
- 39:02to see political violence as an acceptable outlet for that. And we also see
- 39:09too, you know, a redefinition of what we saw in January sixth where
- 39:14Americans that strongly embrace Christian nationalism are more likely to say that those folks shouldn't
- 39:19be caught and prosecuted. All right, I'm going to finish with kind of
- 39:22a I don't know, a freshman college term paper question here, forgive me,
- 39:28but what is the like, what's one of the most surprising things that
- 39:32you discovered in writing the book. I mean, I know when you were
- 39:36doing your research you probably had some Eureka moments, But I mean, what
- 39:39did you learn yourself on your journey through Christian nationalism in the book? Yeah?
- 39:45I think really the big thing that I learned is is that exact word
- 39:50is journey. So as I kind of weave in some of my personal journey,
- 39:54you know, throughout the past couple decades of growing up in a very
- 39:59conservative religion community to now wrestling with Christian nationalism, and even since I finished
- 40:04the book, and obviously there's this big lag before it appears and then it
- 40:07appears. Just recognizing the journey that I'm still on and that others are on,
- 40:13and so while it can be at times frustrating, where you know,
- 40:16we would hope others might see what we see as the truth really quickly and
- 40:21easily, I think I'm trying to have empathy for those wherever they're at on
- 40:24the journey, you know, raising questions and issues to them and allowing them
- 40:30time to wrestle with it and begin the journey wherever they're at, because I
- 40:32know that I still have more to learn, and there are folks in the
- 40:36community that you're coming from or your listeners are in, that have helped me
- 40:39see where I can do better, right, and for those that have empathy
- 40:44with me that I'm hopefully learning and doing better, and then for me with
- 40:49others or for them with those that they're around, I think, yeah,
- 40:52recognizing that it's a journey, that it isn't a straight line, that it
- 40:55does take time, it can be difficult, it can be frustrating, but
- 40:59I think that's one thing that I've learned, and I guess it too is
- 41:01a note of you know, my hope as we go forward is that we
- 41:06continue to challenge each other, but recognize that folks are on the journey and
- 41:09it does take time. I came out of a type of activism where I
- 41:15was going hard all the time at every flavor of christian and I got nowhere,
- 41:20and I was frustrated, and I found that I was unnecessarily dividing much
- 41:23more than I was uniting. I mean, some people still blanche when I
- 41:28say that I'm more interested in your values than beliefs, although your values can
- 41:31inform your beliefs. But I mean, you're someone who you want to share
- 41:35this world, right, there's room in the world for you and for me
- 41:38and people across the color and culture spectrum. Yeah, you know, as
- 41:43long as you're not trying to strip me of my rights and equality and humanity,
- 41:47you know, maybe there's room on the planet for all of us,
- 41:51right, And yeah, Yeah, that's my hope, and that's my belief
- 41:54And it doesn't mean that it'll be easy or straightforward, but I do hope
- 41:59that, yeah, those values of shared humanity and then in our country a
- 42:02democracy where voices are heard, we have a seat at the table. I
- 42:07think those are the things that I hope we can rally around and confront those
- 42:12forces that want to take that away and hopefully finding a shared future together.
- 42:15Well, it's been an honor to have you on the show, and honestly,
- 42:19I'll I get a chance to shake your hand in person one of these
- 42:22days, because I do I follow your your Do you still I call still
- 42:25call it Twitter? I don't call it X. Yeah, I know I
- 42:30said we're done, But do you struggle with weather to stay on? I
- 42:34do? I really do, because part of me is like I just can't
- 42:38anymore. But then I don't want to abandon the platform. Yeah, I'm
- 42:43the same way you have that argument with yourself. Yeah, there's books there
- 42:46I still connect with and the voices I want to be connected to and hear
- 42:51and learn from. So yeah, I'm trying to, you know, figure
- 42:53out exit strategy with Substack and you know other Blue Sky and yeah, yeah,
- 43:00threads and I'm waiting for a dominant platform to if one ever emerges on
- 43:05it, And I've been watching anyway forgive me Doctor Andrew Whitehead. He is
- 43:08author of the new book American Idolatry, How Christian Nationalism betrays the Gospel and
- 43:15threatens the Church. You're terrific. Thanks for talking to me, man.
- 43:19Yeah, thanks so much for the time. I do really appreciate the conversation,
- 43:22and yeah, I look forward to hopefully our past cross in the future.
- 43:25Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts
- 43:30and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo,
- 43:36links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and
- 43:40conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.